Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2. 2. 1. Controlled practice
The first sub-stage aims for practice under controlled conditions, in which the students are
asked to repeat examples of the structure correctly via a variety of oral drills. The teacher,
who has full control over the language practised, focuses on accuracy and uses immediate
correction. The predominant type of interaction is Teacher –> Students. The typical drill
activities are:
a) Repetition drills
The aim of repetition is to reinforce the structure in terms of pronunciation and word-order.
The drills should replay the MS (Marker Sentence) from the presentation, e.g.: He’s been
living in the mountains for two months. The marker sentence is repeated first with the
whole class – choral repetition – then by individual students – individual repetition. One
useful repetition technique is back-chaining, in which the students are helped with difficult
areas by repeating one item at a time, starting from the end of the sentence, and adding a new
item each time until the whole sentence is reconstructed. Repetition drills should be done at a
fast pace – speed is important since drills are inherently boring. To maintain interest, the
teacher should also be unpredictable in selecting individual speakers.
An interesting and entertaining alternative to classical repetition drills are Jazz Chants, a
concept developed by Carolyn Graham, a musician, teacher and teacher trainer who adapted
structural drill practice to short, repetitive, structure/function-bound poems to be chanted on
jazz rhythms (see Graham: 1978, 1979, 1986, 1993, 2000, 2006). These poem-like, jazz-beat
chants make for a highly enjoyable way of practising structures and functions which alleviates
the inherent boring effect of repetition drills. Alternatively, these chants can also be used as
examples for the presentation stage.
b) Substitution drills
Substitution drills consist of graded variations on the marker sentence. The students are asked
to generate new sentences with the target structure by substituting various items in the marker
sentence. Substitution drills can be done chorally or individually. There are several types:
i. Simple substitution (vary 1 item in the MS):
She‟s living in the mountains two months
They‟ve camping in the forest ten weeks
Tom‟s drinking fresh water almost a month
My sister‟s been watching the bears for a fortnight
My friends sleeping in a tent several days
Mary and Bob have looking at the stars nearly a year
I‟ve climbing the mountain
We‟ve cooking on an open fire
fishing trout
washing in the river
The substitution of one item for another is based on cues or prompts offered by the teacher.
We can use verbal prompts (word/phrase spoken by the teacher or written on the blackboard
or prompt cards) or visual prompts (drawing, picture, mime and gesture, words on).
Further examples:
Single-word prompts
E.g.: Let‟s + verb
T: Cinema
SS: Let‟s go to the cinema.
T: Pizza
SS: Let‟s eat a pizza.
Picture prompts
E.g.: Can + verb
The value of the above exercise resides in what Adrian Doff calls meaningful practice, i.e.
practice which requires personalization and adds some personal meaning to the activity (Doff
1988).
Below is a list of other types of drills used at the controlled practice stage, mainly
variations on Substitution or Question and Answer drills, which also involve such operations
as transformation, replacement, restatement, completion, expansion, contraction of items, etc.
i) Transformation Drill
Language learners are required to change sentences from negative to positive, from positive to
interrogative, or from simple present tense to simple past tense, depending on the instructions
from the teacher.
E.g.:
T: The book is new.
SS: Is the book new?
j) Replacement Drill
Language learners replace a noun with a pronoun. It is the same drill as substitution drill but it
involves with a replacement.
E.g.:
T: I like the book
Student: I like it
k) Response Drill
Language learners respond to somebody‟s sentence. In this drill this answers are patterned
after the questions. This drill may involve “wh-” questions or “yes/no” questions.
E.g.:
T: Alice is at school.
T: Where is Alice?
SS: At school.
l) Cued Response Drill
In this drill language learners are provided with a cue before or after the questions.
E.g.:
T: What did the man buy? (A book)
SS: The man bought a book.
m) Rejoinder Drill
It is similar to the cued response drill, but in this drill language learners are given instructions
of how to respond in terms of style/register.
E.g.:
T: come to my house (be polite)
SS: Would you like to come to my house?
n) Restatement drill
Language learners rephrase an utterance and address it to somebody else, according to the
content of the utterance.
E.g.:
T: Ask your friend what he has for breakfast
SS: What do you have for breakfast?
o) Completion Drill
Language learners are told to supply a missing word in a sentence or statement.
E.g:
T: I bring my cakes and you bring….
SS: I bring my cakes and you bring your cakes.
p) Expansion Drill
Language learners build up a statement by adding a word or phrase.
E.g.:
T: Mathematics
SS: We study mathematics
T: everyday
SS: We study mathematics every day.
q) Contraction Drill
Language learners replace a phrase or clause with a single word or shorter expressions.
E.g.:
T: I didn‟t mean to hurt the dog
SS: I didn‟t mean it.
r) Integration Drill
Language learners combine two separate statements.
E.g.:
T: I know that lady. She is wearing a blue shirt
SS: I know the lady wearing a blue shirt.
s) Parallel writing
This exercise offers controlled writing practice based on a model text. Students have to
rewrite the text by making certain structural changes, e.g. change the subject from I to he/she
so as to use the Present Simple form for the 3rd person singular (hurries, goes, tries), put
Present Tense verbs into the Past Simple or simply personalise the text content by writing
about themselves.
2. 2. 2. Semi-controlled practice
This stage consists in structural practice based on a wide range of exercises, commonly found
in most grammar books. These exercises are less teacher-controlled, but do not offer complete
student control over language, as students have to use the structure correctly in a given
sentence or text, without actually producing language themselves. They have the advantage of
also being suitable for individual independent study, in class or at home, orally or in writing,
for reinforcement or consolidation purposes. The most common semi-controlled exercises are:
a) Bracketed verbs/adjectives
This is one of the most frequently used exercise type, extremely useful for tense practice,
adjective comparison forms, etc. Students operate with such categories as Tense, Aspect,
Voice, Infinitive/Gerund complementation, Subjunctives, having to choose between two
alternative forms – Simple/Progressive tense forms, Gerunds/Infinitives, etc, which always
involves a compare and contrast approach.
b) Dual/Multiple choice
This exercise offers two or four items to choose from: verb forms, prepositions,
singular/plural nouns, modal verbs, time adverbs, etc.
c) Gap-fill
These consist in sentences or texts containing gap or blank spaces to be filled in. It is used for
practice with verbs, prepositions, determiners, adverbial modifiers, etc.
d) Cloze passages
A cloze is a text from which every 5th or 7th word has been removed so that the students will
fill in the blanks. A grammar cloze devised in this way is a good way of testing general
grammar (and vocabulary) knowledge. Alternatively, teachers can tailor a cloze for practice in
a specific structure, by removing only the items related to the target structure
(infinives/gerunds, prepositions).
e) True/False statements
These can be organized as pairs of statements or sentences (a, b) to choose from, referring to
the meaning or use of a structure (tenses, modal verbs).
f) Matching items
The items to be matched are arranged in two columns, in random order. They can be verb
tenses + adverbs, main + subordinate clauses, verbs + gerund/infinitive complements, etc.
g) Error correction
Students are required to discriminate between correct and incorrect forms, and make
corrections where necessary. These exercises have an important formative value, as thinking
of and evaluating structural accuracy helps in developing the students‟ ability for self-
correction.
Below are illustrated two game-like activities based on error correction, which, by
adding an element of fun and even excitement, can render dull correction exercises more
enjoyable.
h) Grammar auction
The students work in pairs or groups. They are told they are going to participate in a sentence
auction, for which each pair/group have £1,000. Some of the sentences are correct, while
others will contain grammar mistakes. Of course, the students are supposed to bid for correct
sentences. The winning pair/group has the largest number of correct sentences at the end of
the activity.
i) Grammar gamble
This is a variation on the game above, but instead of buying correct sentences, the students
will bet on their own correction of sentences containing mistakes. Each group (3 or 4
students) is given 1,000 and a list of incorrect sentences with mistakes in grammar, word
order, etc. These can be taken from the students‟ mistakes in their written work. According to
the degree of difficulty, each sentence will be assigned different odds. In their groups,
students discuss the corrections they think necessary. The teacher calls out one sentence at a
time and asks students to place their bets on their corrected versions. On the board, the teacher
draws two columns headed Bet and Total, writing each group‟s stakes and earnings. The
winning team will have the largest sum at the end of the activity (see Gates, 1994).
j) Jumbled words ordering
These exercises are particularly focused on word order, but they can also raise awareness of
such issues as cohesion, linking words, emphasis/fronting, inversion.
Rewrite/Rephrase sentences
Beside target structure practice, these exercises also raise awareness about meanings,
functions, polysemous structural or syntactic forms, as they require reformulating a sentence
in such a way that its meaning remains unchanged. In order to rephrase a given sentence,
students are provided with cues which can be either a different beginning or a word to be
included in the new sentence.
k) Dictogloss/Grammar dictation
The teacher reads a short text at a reasonable, normal speech speed and students listen first, to
get a general idea of the content and grammar of the text. For the second reading, the students
are required to take as many and as detailed notes as they can of what they hear – sentence
chunks, key phrases/words. In groups of three or four, the students are required to put their
notes together and try to reconstruct the original text as accurately as possible. It can also be
done as a competition, in which the winning team ends up with a text which is the closest to
the original and the most grammatically accurate.
Teacher roles
T as presenter T giving T organising activities so that
of new language SS chance to practise language SS can use language meaningfully
Teacher-centred Learner-centred
Aims
ACCURACY FLUENCY
/
T ss ss
ssss ss T ss
ssss ss ss ss
ss ss ss
Of course, communicative activities for free oral practice commonly presuppose pair
work and group work. In order to motivate students to work together in pairs/groups, the
activities have to be task-based – if students know what they have to achieve, they will have
a purpose to work towards, i.e. solving the task. Of course, communicative grammar
activities must have a grammar focus – a structure/function they have learnt/revised recently.
Of course, task-based communicative activities require careful preparation on the part of the
teacher, who has to plan the activity well in advance, to organise the class and provide the
students with the necessary materials, such as handouts or visuals. Basically, the most
common communicative activities are of two types – Information Gap and Role Play – but
the range is in fact much wider. The most productive communicative grammar activities for
free oral practice are described below.