Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thackeray, in his earlier writings, has shown his feeling of piety towards the
Charterhouse School, where he was educated, by calling it Slaughterhouse.
Altogether, it cannot be said that the boys who afterwards proved themselves to
have been the most highly-gifted, shone with much lustre at school, or found them
selves in happy harmony with their school environment.
The record of the doings of genius at college is not greatly different. No doubt a
number of the ablest men have won university distinctions. In a few cases, indeed, a
thoroughly original man has carried everything before him. Thus, among the senior
wranglers we find the name of Paley, the eminent theologian. The mathematician, Sir
W. Rowan Hamilton, is said to have " completely mastered " the mathematics of his
college at the age of fifteen. The metaphysician, Sir William Hamilton, won high
distinctions both at Glasgow and Oxford. Among famous names that distinguished
themselves by winning honours in classics (including English verse) may be mentioned
Cowley, Coleridge, and Macaulay.
At the same time it may safely be said that a very small proportion of the men of
genius who have visited our universities have presaged their after fame by high academic
distinction. Thus it has been computed that, though Cambridge has been rich in poets,
only four appear in her honours lists.1 Not only so, we know that some of the ablest
men have proved signal failures at college. Goldsmith was quite as famous at college
as at school for incorrigible stupidity, and only just managed to scrape through his
degree, the lowest down in the list. Swift disputes with Goldsmith the distinction of ,
greatest dunce, seeing that he could not even obtain his degree, breaking down in the
definition of a syllogism. A third distinguished member of the same college, Edmund
Burke, was a very irregular student. He had spurts of study, or, as he calls them,
" sallies of passion," but, unfortunately, the direction of these crazes did not coincide
with that of the prescribed curriculum, so that he would be diving deep into natural
philosophy when he ought to have been giving his mind to logic. Among other
desultory learners at college, we may include Gibbon. The fourteen months he spent
at Oxford, he writes, "proved the most idle and unprofitable of my whole life."
Southey's is a very similar case. He was so dead to the advantages of college lectures
that his tutor advised him to discontinue attendance on his course.
In many cases we have too clear signs of a disposition to rebel against the
discipline and routine of college life. Milton was a most indocile undergraduate, and,
according to rumour, kicked so vigorously against either the discipli ne or the exercises
of his college, that he brought on himself a flogging. Dryden must have been a bit
of a rebel at Cambridge, for we read of his being discommoned and gated for a
fortnight for disobedience and contumacy, and he afterwards wrote of his alma mater in
the lines :—
" Oxford to him a dearer name shall be
Than his own mother university."