Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Char B1
Place of origin France
Service history
Used by France
Germany
Production history
Designed 1921–1934
No. built 405 (34 Char B1, 369 Char B1 bis & two
Char B1 ter)
Specifications
Mass 28 tonnes
Crew 4
Fuel capacity 400 L
Contents
The SRA was the heaviest vehicle at 19.5 tonnes. Its length was 5.95 metres, its height 2.26m
and its width 2.49m. It had a 75 mm howitzer in the right side of the hull and a cast, 30 mm
thick, turret with two machine-guns. It was steered by an epicyclical transmission combined with
hydraulically reinforced brake disks, which failed to provide the desired precision during tests.
Seen from the front it was very similar to the final model, but its side-on profile was more like
that of the British Medium Mark D, including the snake track-system, with the drive wheel
higher than the idler in front. The suspension used leaf springs. A Renault six-cylinder 180 hp
engine (a bisected 12V aircraft engine) allowed for a maximum speed of 17.5 km/h; a four
hundred litre fuel tank for a range of 140 kilometres.
The SRB
The SRB, also using leaf springs, was a somewhat larger vehicle, six metres long, 2.28 metres
high and 2.5 metres wide. It was nevertheless lighter at 18.5 tonnes, a result of having a smaller
47 mm gun—it thus was the antitank version. Using the same engine, its speed was accordingly
slightly higher at 18 km/h. More limited fuel reservoirs holding 370 litres decreased the range to
125 kilometres. It used an advanced hydraulic suspension system and the hydraulic Naeder-
transmission from the Chaize company combined with a Fieux clutch and Schneider gear box. It
used modified FT 17 tracks. The upper track run was much higher, creating enough room for a
side door on the left.
The FAHM prototype
The FAHM prototype was 5.2 metres long, 2.4 m high and 2.43 m wide. It used
a hydropneumatic suspension. Despite a weaker Panhard engine of 120 hp it still attained a speed
of 18.2 km/h. Fuel reservoirs of just 230 litres limited its range to a mere seventy kilometres. The
75 mm howitzer was placed in the middle of the hull and steered by providing each snake track
with its own hydraulic Jeanny transmission. On top there was a riveted machine-gun turret with
25 mm armour.
The FCM 21
The lightest prototype was the FCM 21 at 15.64 tonnes. It resembled a scaled-down Char 2C, the
giant tank produced by the same company. It was very elongated with a length of 6.5 metres and
width of 2.05 metres. A rather large riveted turret with a stroboscopic cupola, adopted from the
Char 2C, brought its height to 2.52 metres. Like the superheavy tank it had no real spring system
for the twelve small wheels per side. Separate clutches for each snake track enabled it to
horizontally point the 75 mm howitzer in the middle of the hull. It used the same Panhard engine
as the FAHM type and its speed was the lowest of all at 17.4 km/h. However, its 500-litre fuel
tanks allowed for the best range at 175 kilometres.
In March 1925, Estienne decided to base the future production type on the SRB, as regarded the
general form and mechanical parts. However, it would be fitted with the 75 mm gun, a Holt-track
to be developed by FCM, which company had completed a special research programme aimed at
optimising weight distribution, and the FAMH-suspension (later this would again be discarded).
Estienne also had some special requirements: a track tension wheel should be fitted, adjustable
from the inside, and a small gangway from the fighting room should improve the accessibility of
the engine compartment. Furthermore, the front armour should be increased to 40 millimetres.
Prototype No. 101, here in its original state with a small machine gun turret
Testing on the first prototype had already begun before the other two were delivered, or even its
main armament was fitted. At 24,750 kg (24.36 long tons) the weight was more than specified
but could nevertheless reach a top speed of 24 km/h (15 mph). From 6 May until August 1930
the Commission d'Experiences des Matériels de Chars carried out a further test programme on
what was now officially called the Char B—the "B" not referring to Bataille but to a general
classification code. The commission was largely satisfied with the vehicle, though many smaller
problems were detected that had to be improved. The FCM prototype featured several alternative
technologies: a Winterthur transmission, a Citroën clutch and a Sulzer diesel engine, later
replaced by a Clerget diesel. All of these systems would prove to be more unreliable than the
original concept and were ultimately rejected.
The three vehicles were not only used for technological, but also tactical experimentation.
Together with the Char D1 pre-series, they represented the only modern tanks in France and the
Army was naturally very interested in what lessons could be learned from them about future
warfare, outlining the concept of a Char de Manoeuvre. Neither Char de Bataille nor Char de
Manoeuvre are official type designations; they refer to the tactical concepts only. In October
1931 a small unit was formed, the Détachement d' Experimentation in which the prototypes were
united from December, using the Camp de Châlons as a base to see how they could be used in
winter conditions. Afterwards, they drove on their own power to the Atelier de Rueil for repairs.
In September they took part in the summer manoeuvres in Champagne as a Détachement
Mécanique de Combat; from 4 May 1933 No. 102 and 103 together formed a Détachement
d'Engins Blindés to perform tactical experiments in the army bases
of Coëtquidan and Mourmelon as part of a motorised light division, followed by comparable
experiments in April 1934 at Sissonne. Technical aspects were not forgotten during these tests
and it was established they could attain an average road speed of 19 km/h, cross a trench 2.4 m
(7.9 ft) wide, and wade through a 105 cm (41 in) deep stream.
The prototypes were again extensively altered to meet changes in specifications. On 6 April
1934, the first order was made for seven tanks of a Char B1. The "B1" refers to the fact that there
were other simultaneous projects to develop improved types: the Char B2, B3 and B B.
The Char B1 was manufactured by several firms: Renault (182), AMX (47), FCM (72), FAMH
(70) and Schneider (32). Although it was the main producer, Renault had not exclusively
designed the tank. Therefore, the official name was not Renault B1 as often erroneously given.
[citation needed]
It was a very expensive tank to build: the cost per vehicle was about 1.5 million French
francs. In France at the time two schools of thought collided: the first wanted to build very strong
heavy tanks, the other a lot of cheap light tanks. Both sides managed to influence procurement
policy to the end that not enough tanks were built of either category, to the exasperation of men
like Colonel Charles de Gaulle, who wanted to build more of the medium Char D2 at a third of
the cost of the Char B1 bis, but with the same 47 mm anti-tank gun.
Tactical function[edit]
This section does not cite any sources. Please help improve this
section by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be
challenged and removed. (January 2021) (Learn how and when to remove this
template message)
B1 bis, No. 323, Var captured in Belgium after being abandoned because of a broken steering mechanism. Var was from
the 3rd Platoon, 2nd Company of the 37th BCC, 1re DCr
B1 bis, No. 401, Bearn II after being destroyed by its crew, one of the two 37th BCC replacement vehicles, earlier
named Vaux
General Walther von Reichenau inspects a destroyed Char B1 bis (No. 236, Le Glorieux), May 1940.
The outer appearance of the Char B1 reflected the fact that development started in the twenties:
like the very first tank, the British Mark I tank of World War I, it still had large tracks going
around the entire hull and large armour plates protecting the suspension—and like all tanks of
that decade it had no welded or cast hull armour. The similarity resulted partly from the fact that
the Char B1 was a specialised offensive weapon, a break-through tank optimised for punching a
hole into strong defensive entrenchments, so it was designed with good trench-crossing
capabilities. The French Army thought that dislodging the enemy from a key front sector would
decide a campaign, and it prided itself on being the only army in the world having a sufficient
number of adequately protected heavy tanks. The exploitation phase of a battle was seen as
secondary and best carried out by controlled and methodical movement to ensure superiority in
numbers, so for the heavy tanks also mobility was of secondary concern. Although the Char B1
had a reasonably good speed for the time of its conception, no serious efforts were made to
improve it when much faster tanks appeared.
More important than the tank's limitations in tactical mobility, however, were its limitations in
strategic mobility. The low practical range implied the need to refuel very often, limiting its
operational capabilities. This again implied that the armoured divisions of the Infantry,
the Divisions Cuirassées, were not very effective as a mobile reserve and thus lacked strategic
flexibility. They were not created to fulfill such a role in the first place, which was reflected in
the small size of the artillery and infantry components of the divisions.
The one-man turret[edit]
Another explanation of the similarity to the British Mark I lies in the Char B1's original
specification to create a self-propelled gun able to destroy enemy infantry and artillery. The main
weapon of the tank was its 75 mm howitzer, and the entire design of the vehicle was directed to
making this gun as effective as possible. When in the early 1930s it became obvious that the
Char B1 also had to defeat counterattacking enemy armour, it was too late for a complete
redesign. The solution was to add the standard cast APX-1 turret which also equipped the Char
D2. Like most French tanks of the period (the exception being the AMC 34 and AMC 35) the
Char B thus had a small one-man turret. Today this is typically seen as one of their greatest
flaws.[1] The commander, alone in the turret, not only had to command the tank, but also to aim
and load the gun. If he was a unit leader, he had to command his other tanks as well. This is in
contrast with the contemporary German, British and to a lesser extent[a] Soviet policy to use two
or three-man turret crews, in which these duties were divided amongst several men. The other
nations felt that the commander would otherwise be over-tasked and unable to perform any of his
roles as well as the commanders of tanks with two or three-man turret crews.
Whether this left the Char B1 less-formidable in actual combat than a review of its impressive
statistics suggests, is difficult to ascertain. In 1940, the vast majority of Char B1 combat losses
were inflicted by German artillery and anti-tank guns. In direct meetings with German tanks the
Char B1 usually had the better of it, sometimes spectacularly so as when on 16 May a single
tank, Eure (commanded by Captain Pierre Billotte), frontally attacked and destroyed thirteen
German tanks lying in ambush in Stonne, all of them Panzer IIIs and Panzer IVs, in the course of
a few minutes.[2] The tank safely returned despite being hit 140 times. Similarly, in his
book Panzer Leader, Heinz Guderian related an incident which took place during a tank battle
south of Juniville: "While the tank battle was in progress I attempted, in vain, to destroy a Char
B with a captured 47 mm. anti-tank gun; all the shells I fired at it simply bounced harmlessly off
its thick armour. Our 37 mm. and 20 mm. guns were equally ineffective against this adversary.
As a result, we inevitably suffered sadly heavy casualties."[3]
The French favoured small turrets despite their shortcomings, as they allowed for much smaller
and thus cheaper vehicles. Although the French expenditure on tanks was relatively larger than
the German, France simply lacked the production capacity to build a sufficient number of
heavier tanks. The Char B1 was expensive enough as it was, eating up half of the infantry tank
budget.[4]
Variants[edit]
Char B1[edit]
The wreck of the last surviving Char B1 at Fort de Seclin, Seclin, France (2007)
The original Char B1 had frontal and side armour up to 40 mm thick. The vehicle had a fully
traversing APX1 turret with a 47 mm L/27.6 SA 34 gun. This had a poor anti-tank capability: the
thirty Armour Piercing High Explosive (APHE) rounds among the fifty the tank carried had a
maximum penetration of about 25 mm. In addition, it was armed with a 75 mm ABS 1929 SA 35
gun mounted in the right-hand side of the hull front and two 7.5 mm Châtellerault M
1931 machine guns: one in the hull and the other in the turret. The 75 mm L/17.1 gun, able to
fire both a High Explosive and the APHE Obus de rupture Modèle 1910M round, had a limited
traverse of only one degree to the left or the right. It was laid onto target by the driver (provided
with the gun sight) through the Naeder hydraulic precision transmission.[b][5] The traverse had been
made possible only in order to align the gun barrel precisely with the sight beforehand. The
75 mm gun had its own loader—the remaining two crew members were the radio operator and
the commander, who had to load, aim and fire the 47 mm gun while commanding the vehicle
(and in the case of platoon leaders, command other vehicles as well). The fighting compartment
had the radio set on the left and an exit hatch in the right side. All vehicles had the ER53 radio
telegraphy set, which used Morse code only. A hatch in the rear bulkhead gave access to a
corridor (under which nineteen 75 mm rounds out of a total of eighty were stowed) in the engine
room to the right of the engine, which was officially rated at 250 hp (190 kW), but had an actual
output of 272 hp (203 kW). Each tank had its own team of three mechanics; in battle some of
these might join the regular crew.
The suspension was very complex with sixteen road wheels per side. There were three large
central bogies, sprung by a vertical coil spring. Each central bogie carried two smaller ones. The
three vertical springs moved through holes in a horizontal beam, to both extreme ends of which
road wheels were attached by means of leaf springs: three at the front and one at the back. The
high track run gave the tank an old fashioned look, reflecting its long development time. It had a
maximum speed of 28 km/h and a weight of 28 tonnes. The range was about two hundred
kilometres. A total of 34 vehicles were built from December 1935 until July 1937. They had
series numbers 102 to 135. Chassis number 101 was kept apart to build the Char B1 ter
prototype.
Char B1 bis[edit]
The Char B1 bis was an upgraded variant with thicker armour at 60 mm maximum (55 mm at
the sides) and an APX4 turret with a longer-barrelled (L/32) 47 mm SA 35 gun, to give the tank
a real anti-tank capacity. It was the main production type: from 8 April 1937 until June 1940 369
units were delivered out of a total order for 1144, with series numbers 201 to 569. Before the
war, production was slow: only 129 had been delivered on 1 September 1939. The monthly
delivery was still not more than fifteen in December; it peaked in March 1940 with 45.
The Char B1 bis had a top speed of 25 km/h (16 mph) provided by a 307 bhp (229 kW) petrol
engine. The first batch of 35 Char B1 bis used the original engine but from 1938 to May 1940
they were slowly re-equipped. Its weight was about 31.5 tonnes. The operational range was
about 180 km (110 mi) which was similar to other tanks of the period. At 20 km/h (12 mph) the
three fuel tanks (total capacity of 400 l (88 imp gal)) would be exhausted in six hours. To
improve matters, at first, trailers with an 800-litre auxiliary fuel tank were towed but this practice
was soon abandoned. Instead Char B1 units included a large number of fuel trucks and TRC
Lorraine 37 L armoured tracked refuelling vehicles specially designed to quickly refuel them.
The last tanks to be produced in June had an extra internal 170 l (37 imp gal) fuel tank. To cool
the more powerful engine the Char B1 bis had the air intake on the left side enlarged. It is often
claimed[citation needed] this formed a weak spot in the armour, based on a single incident on 16 May
near Stonne where two German 37 mm PAK guns claimed to have knocked out three Char B1s
by firing at the intakes at close range. The air intake was a 6-inch (150 mm) thick assembly of
horizontal slits alternately angled upwards and downwards between 28 mm thick armour plates,
and as such intended to be no more vulnerable than the normal 55 mm side plates.
Over the production run the type was slowly improved. Tanks number 306 to 340 carried 62 47-
mm rounds (and the old complement of 4,800 machine gun rounds); later tanks 72 and 5,250.
However the B1 bis had fewer 75 mm rounds compared to the earlier B1 : 74 instead of eighty,
normally only seven of which were APHE ammunition. Early in 1940 another change was made
when the ER53 radio was replaced by the ER51 which allowed spoken wireless communication.
The company and battalion command tanks also had an ER55 for communication with higher
command. The crews of the 1re DCR kept their old sets however, preferring them because the
human voice was drowned by engine noise.
Char B1 ter[edit]
Development of the Char B1 ter was started at the same time as production funds were given
for the bis with the intention of providing a tank armoured to 75mm.[6] A design with sloped and
welded 70 mm armour, weighing 36.6 tonnes and powered by a 350 hp (260 kW) engine was
meant to replace the B1 bis to accelerate mass production, a change first intended for the summer
of 1940 and later postponed to March 1941. In the course of the redesign, space was provided for
a fifth crew member, a "mechanic".[6] Cost was reduced by omitting the complex Neader
transmission and giving the hull gun a traverse of five degrees to each side instead. The first
prototype was shown in 1937.[6] Only three prototypes could be partly finished before the defeat
of France. In May 1940 it was agreed to deliver nine Char B1s each month to Britain in
exchange for a monthly British production of the "H 39". The three prototypes were lost after
having been evacuated on 17 June 1940, their ship the Mécanicien Principal Carvin being
bombed by the Germans in the Gironde on 21 June.[7] However, some believe that another
prototype was obtained by Italy.
Operational history[edit]
French service[edit]
The Char B1 served with the armoured divisions of the infantry, the Divisions Cuirassées (DCr).
These were highly specialised offensive units, to break through fortified positions. The mobile
phase of a battle was to be carried out by the Divisions Légères Mécaniques (mechanised light
divisions) of the cavalry, equipped with the SOMUA S35. The First and Second DCR had 69
Char B1's each; the Third 68. The 37th Bataillon de Chars de Combat, serving with 1DCR, was
at first equipped with the original B1; these vehicles were refitted with the longer SA 35 gun in
the spring of 1940 and the turret renamed to APX1A. The battalion was re-equipped with the
Char B1 bis and in May reinforced by five of the original tanks.
A Char B1 bis disabled in 1940 in Northern France
A Panzerkampfwagen B-2, showing the additional frontal armour above the hull gun. This example was Number 114
of Panzer-Abteilung 213. It is now owned by Bovington Tank Museum and shown on display at the Jersey War Tunnels.
After the German invasion several ad hoc units were formed: the 4e DCR with 52 Char B1s and
five autonomous companies (347e, 348e, 349e, 352e and 353e Compagnie Autonome de Chars)
with in total 56 tanks: 12 B1s and 44 B1 bis; 28BCC was reconstituted with 34 tanks. The
regular divisions destroyed quite a few German tanks but lacked enough organic infantry and
artillery to function as an effective mobile reserve.
German use[edit]
A number of Char B1s (161) were captured by the Germans during the Fall of France. These
were later pressed into service as second line and training vehicles under the name
of Panzerkampfwagen B-2 740 (f), and were often used as turretless Munitionspanzer supply
vehicles. Sixty became platforms for flamethrowers as Flammwagen auf Panzerkampfwagen B-2
(f). Sixteen were converted into 105 mm self-propelled artillery, armed with the 10.5 cm leFH
18 light howitzer. Ordinary tank versions were also frequently modified. For example, additional
armour was placed above the main gun, and a winch mechanism was added behind the turret.
One unit, Panzer-Abteilung 213, was equipped with the Char B1 bis and deployed on
the Channel Islands from 1941 to 1945. One of their tanks is displayed by the Bovington Tank
Museum, though repainted in French colours. In German service, the tank saw action in
the Balkans Campaign and the Eastern Front, initially during Operation Barbarossa, the
flamethrower version from 1942 onwards.[8] Some Char B turrets were removed and installed on
German bunkers defending Normandy beaches at the time of D-Day (6 June 1944).[9]
Panzer-Kompanie 224, a training unit, was outfitted with several flamethrower-equipped B2s.
[10]
They were stationed in Arnhem during Operation Market Garden, losing six tanks to anti-tank
weaponry when they were sent to attack the Oosterbeek perimeter on 20–21 September 1944.[11]
German designations[edit]
A 10.5 cm leFH18/3 (Sf) auf Geschützwagen B-2(f). It is equipped with the 10.5 cm leFH 18 light howitzer and lacks the
75mm hull gun on the original Char B1.
Panzerkampfwagen B-2 740(f)
The Char B1, re-designated after capture, in use by German armed forces.
Panzer-Brigade 100
Panzer-Regiment 100
Panzer-Ersatz-Abteilung 100
Panzer-Abteilung (F) 102
Panzer-Abteilung 213
SS-Panzer-Abteilung "Prinz Eugen"
Panzer-Kompanie z.b.V. 12
Panzer-Abteilung 223
Beutepanzer-Kompanie 223
I./Artillerie-Regiment 93 of 26.Panzer-Division
II./Panzer-Regiment 1 of 1.Panzer-Division
Panzer-Regiment 2 of 16.Panzer-Division
I./Panzer-Regiment 36 of 14.Panzer-Division
Panzer-Abteilung 205
Panzer-Kompanie 206
Panzer-Kompanie C (ND) 224
Panzerjäger-Abteilung 657 (PK 224)
Italian use[edit]
Italy independently from Germany captured eight Chars B1 bis when in October
1940 an Italian worker disclosed to the Italian Armistice Commission that they
had been hidden in a cave near Les Baux-de-Provence in July 1940. These
vehicles, six of which lacked the turret, were tested, but probably not used
operationally by Italy.[15]
The Italian armour historian Nicola Pignato in contrast stated in 1989 that some
twenty B1 bis, in various stages of preparation and construction, along with a
single 36-ton B1 ter prototype were directly recovered from the FCM factory, of
which an unknown number were to be destined for Italy.[16] Six vehicles in Italian
service were known as Semovente B1-bis, and lacked turrets, but were used in
trials until 1943, after which they were used as target practice, and ammunition
carriers.[17]
Post-war French use[edit]
Surviving vehicles[edit]
B1
bis Rhin (formerly F
landres)
at Rétromobile 2018
Today eleven
vehicles survive,
one Char B1 and
ten Char B1 bis.[22]
The last surviving
Char B1 can be
seen at the Association pour la Sauvegarde du Patrimoine Historique et
Militaire (ASPHM), near Strasbourg, in France. It was previously at the Fort de
Seclin. It is in a bad condition, with parts like the main gun missing. It was
salvaged from a firing range, and will be restored by the owner.
Ten Char B1 bis can be seen in various places in Great Britain and in France: