Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Kinetics of diffusion of chloride ions in hardened cement
pastes have been investigated. For Portland cement pastes
of fixed type, made with various water-cement ratios (w/c),
activation energies for the diffusion process have been
measured and the results have been related to the pore
structures of the materials. The influence of certain
other factors, including the curing conditions~ the
presence in the samples of interfacial zones of segregation
and the use of several other types of cement, have also
been examined.
395
396 Vol. I I , No. 3
C.L. Page, et al.
TABLE 2
UPV Determinations
Cement w/c UPV (km s -1)
OPC 0.4 3.66±0.05
OPC 0.5 3.40±0.05
OPC 0.6 3.17±O.O3
OPC/30% PFA 0.5 3.18±O.01
OPC/65% BFS 0.5 3.31±O.01
SRPC 0.5 3.17±O.O5
From the central regions of each of the cylinders at least four, but normally
five or six, circular discs of convenient thickness (~3mm) for subsequent study
were cut by means of a diamond saw, the blade of which was lubricated with
distilled water. The surfaces of the discs were then lightly ground on
Grade 600 emery paper, rinsed with distilled water and dried with lens
tissue before being fitted into diffusion cells of the type shown in Fig.l.
Vol. I I , No. 3 397
CHLORIDE, DIFFUSION, CEMENT PASTES, WATERCONTENT, CURING
Fig. 1
Diffusion Cell
For series (ii) experiments, OPC pastes of w/c 0.5 were cast into PVC moulds
fitted with flat PTFE base-plates. They were compacted and rotated for 48
hours as described previously, but thereafter the pastes were allowed to remain
o
in their moulds and were stored for 60 days at 22 C in saturated alr. At the
end of this period of curing, the specimens were demoulded and discs, 3mm thick,
were cut both from the central regions of the cylinders and from the ends which
had been separated from the PTFE plates. The cut surfaces were lightly ground,
washed and dried in the usual way before the discs were mounted in diffusion
cells; the 'as-cast' interfaces were then in contact with compartment 2 of the
cells.
The experimental arrangements under which diffusion of chloride ions was
studied are depicted fully in Fig. i. For every set of conditions examined,
four to six replicate cells were placed in a water bath, the temperature of
which was adjusted to values within the range 7 to 47°C for series (i)
experiments and fixed at 25°C for series (ii) and (iii) experiments. The
concentrations of chloride ion in compartment 2 of the cells after various
diffusion times were determined by withdrawing IOOul aliquots of the solutions
and analysing them by a standard spectrophotometric technique ( 7 ) . Samples
were tested in this way over a period of up to 3 weeks, depending on the rate
of diffusion. Their combined volume was negligible in comparison with the
total volume of solution in compartment 2 of the cells and so no
corrections for errors arising from this source were required in subsequent
calculations.
On completion of each set of diffusion measurements, the thicknesses of the
discs of cement pastes were determined by means of a micrometer gauge.
Specimens were then dried in vacuo and subjected to differential thermal
analysis (DTA) or dried in an oven at iO5°C and subjected to mercury
intrusion porosimetry (MIP). The results were compared with data obtained
for similarly cured cement pastes which had not been exposed to the effects
of chloride diffusion. In all cases, the MIP results showed that no
significant alterations in pore structure had occurred during the diffusion
periods. Certain changes in the DTA traces were, however, recorded and
these will be referred to in subsequent discussion.
Results and Discussion
A typical set of results from a diffusion experiment is shown in Fig.2.
After an initial delay ( t ) , during which chloride diffusion becomes
established across the thickness of the disc, there is a linear increase with
time in the chloride concentration (C 2) of the solution in compartment 2 of
398 Vol. I I , No. 3
C.L. Page, et al.
14 I I I I l I I
DISC T M I C K N E S S
- 12 • 301 mm
• 313ram
E
E ~o
G
I I J I
2 4 6 10 12
11M| t ~ x lOJ|
Fig. 2
Chloride diffusion through OPC paste of w/c 0.4 at 25°C
j = Z dC 2 = £ (~-Cl-C
2-
A 1
dt
wh~relD is the effective diffusivity of chloride ion through the disc in
cm s (assumed to be independent of concentration), V is the volume of
3 2
solution in compartment 2 in cm , A is the cross-sectional area in cm , 1 is
the thickness of the disc in cm and C 1 and C^, the solution concentrations,
are3assumed to be equal to the surface activities of chloride ion in moles
cm
Hence : [ ]
log e l+ C2 DA(t-t )
Cl-C----
~ = V--~ o
TABLE 3
Effective Diffusivlties of Chloride Ion in OPC Pastes
w/c 0.4 w/c 0.5 w/c 0.6
Temperature Dx~091 Temperature Dx½091 Temperature Dx½091
°C cm s °C cm s °C cm s-
8.94 18.6 58.2
11.88 22.0 56.4
7 14.15 7 22.3 7 5O.9
8.17 20.3 46.5
12.02 20.2 47.5
The correlation coefficients for the lines obtained at w/c 0.4, 0.5 and 0.6
were calculated to be -0.97, -0.97 and -0.98 respectively and the slopes
corresponded to activation energies (U) of magnitudes ShOWn with 95%
confidence limits in Table 4.
1 0 -a J I J I I 1 I
W/C
• 06
• 05
: 04
0 4 Ref 8
10.7 FIG. 3
U
u.. Arrhenius plots
u.
Z
_o
p.
9
10.11 - -
30
I
-3.1
~
3.2
]
3.3
1
3.4
I
3.5
RECI~OCALOFABSOLUTETEMPERA~RE(xl~)
1
3.6
1
3.7 3.8
I
TABLE 4
Activation Energies for Diffusion of Chloride Ions
in OPC Pastes
0.4 41.8±4.0
0.5 44.6±4.3
O.6 32.0±2.4
diffusion of chloride ions in mature Portland cement pastes of w/c 0.4 have
been plotted in Fig. 3. The closeness of these points to the corresponding
line obtained from the present work is notable, bearing in mind that the
results had been acquired by an independent technique (based on a solution
of Fick's second law applied to unsteady diffusion) and with somewhat
different materials.
Since each set of effective diffusivities could be fitted to a unique straight
line on the Arrhenius plots (Fig.3) it is clear that, for a given paste,
diffusion kinetics were under the control of a single dominant process over
the temperature range considered. The activation energies recorded in
Table 4 are all considerably in excess of values characteristic of the
diffusion of chloride ions in normal electrolyte solutions, which are
typically in the region of 17.6 kJ/mole ( 9 ) . This therefore indicates that
the rate-limiting process governing the diffusion of chloride ions in mature
Portland cement paste involves some form of surface interaction, as others
have suggested (8). The precise nature of this interaction is, however,
uncertain as desorption of the diffusing ions from binding sites on the pore
walls and/or structural rearrangements necessary to accommodate ion
migration through surface-bound water may be involved. Essentially similar
considerations apply as for the interpretation of activation energies for
ionic transport in clay/water systems - see for example (iO, ii).
Vol. ] l , No. 4 401
CHLORIDE, DIFFUSION, CEMENT PASTES, WATERCONTENT, CURING
0.3
I I
WlC
o
FIG. 4
0.2
Pore size distribution
curves for OPC pastes. o
o>
z
4(
0C
z o.1
10 J 10 a 10
PORE G4AMETERInm)
The results given in Table 4 indicate also that whilst the activation
energies for chloride diffusion in pastes of w/c 0.4 and 0.5 were not
significantly different one from another, they were higher than the value
obtained for specimens of w/c 0.6. This interesting trend in behaviour
is probably a consequence of differences in pore structure of the three
materials. According to the classic model of Powers et al (12, 13), all
capillary pores in 60 day-old cement pastes of w/c 0.4 and 0.5 would be
expected to have become subdivided by gel, whilst in similar paste of w/c 0.6
a residue of capillary pores might still be expected to remain unsegmented.
Some indication of the relative pore size distributions for the three pastes
investigated in the present work may be obtained from the MIP data presented
in Fig.4.
Series (ii)
Values of effective diffusivity of chloride ions obtained at 25°C for discs
cut from the central (D-bulk) and PTFE interface (D-interface) regions of
pastes of w/c 0.5 which had been cured in saturated air were as follows :
-7 2 -i
D-bulk = 1.14xlO cm s
D-interface = 4.27xlO-8cm2s -1
Comparison of D-bulk with the result obtained for paste of the same w/c, which
had been cured in saturated Ca(OH) 2 solution (see Table 3), indicates that
curing in air led to a markedly higher effective diffusivity.
The fact that D-interface was substantially lower than D-bulk is in accordance
with suggestions made previously by one of the present authors (4, 14) that
the portlandite-rich interfacial zone of segregation formed between Portland
cement paste and embedded materials (15, 16) may constitute a significant
diffusion barrier which tends to stabilise the passive oxide film on steel
reinforcement. This finding is paralleled by the results of independent
investigations, which have shown that the rate of diffusion of dissolved
oxygen through water-saturated concrete is considerably lower for specimens
with 'as-cast' surfaces than for similar ones with cut surfaces (17).
Series (iii)
In Table 5 are recorded values of effective diffusivity of chloride ions
measured at 25°C for pastes of w/c 0.5 manufactured from various types of
cement.
TABLE 5
Effective Diffusivity of Chloride Ions at 25°C
in Various Cement Pastes of w/c 0.5
Type of Cement D ~ !~ 9
Cm s
OPC 44.7
OPC/30%PFA 14 .7
OPC/65%BFS 4.1
SRPC iOO.O
0.3
O~ °°'*°
o~c . ~ ~s .....'~__
......... 0~¢ 3o~ PfA x:~""
~ 0.2 ......-" i ~
FIG. 5
Pore size distribution
curves for cement
pastes of w/c 0.5
io,
10' 10 m 10
P O l l [ [ X 4 M k ' T ~ (rim)
FIG. 6
3~C
! DTA curves for
OPC pastes of
ilg
w/c 0.4.
5
BEFORE DIFFUSION
SAMPLE TEMPERATURE
Examination of the pore size distribution data shown in Fig. 5 for the blended
cement pastes suggests that, in these cases, a quite different interpretation
is required of factors governing chloride diffusion kinetics. Pastes
containing OPC/30% PFA are substantially more porous than plain OPC pastes of
the same w/c, yet the effective diffusivity determined for the blended paste
has a value of approximately one-third that for the OPC paste. This suggests
that different mechanisms of diffusion rate control are applicable to the two
materials. Likewise in the case of the slag cement paste, the fact that the
effective diffusivity was an order of magnitude lower than that of the
corresponding OPC paste does not appear to be explicable purely in terms of
differences in the pore size distributions of the two materials.
Conclusions.
The investigations have shown that the relatively simple techniques used in
this work for study of chloride diffusion kinetics in hardened cement
pastes yield reproducible effective diffusivity values that compare well with
similar data obtained independently by alternative methods. The assumptions
inherent in the approach are therefore validated and its practical
advantages, in terms of speed, non-destructive nature and small specimen
requirement, may be exploited with reasonable confidence.
For diffusion of chloride ions in mature OPC pastes, the activation energy
was shown to be substantially higher than that for diffusion of the ions in
normal aqueous solutions. Its magnitude was practically constant for pastes
of w/c 0.4 and 0.5 but at w/c 0.6 a significantly lower value was obtained.
This is thought to be associated with the availability in pastes of w/c 0.6
of relatively large unconstricted capillaries which were absent from the
pastes of lower w/c.
Curing conditions had a marked effect on the transport properties of mature
cement pastes, the effective diffusivity of chloride ions being dependent
Vol. I I , No. 3 405
CHLORIDE, DIFFUSION, CEMENT PASTES, WATER CONTENT, CURING
on whether the material had been cured in saturated air or limewater. It was
also found that specimens, in which one surface had been cast against an
unreactive substrate to form an interfacial zone of segregation rich in
portlandite, limited diffusion of chloride ions more effectively than
specimens with two cut surfaces.
Investigations with various types of cement confirmed that diffusion of
chloride ions is strongly influenced by cement composition. Blended
cement pastes containing PFA or BFS sustained lower diffusion rates at 25°C
than OPC pastes of the same w/c and these differences could not be ascribed
simply to variations between the pore structures of the materials, The
effective diffusivity obtained at 25°C for the particular SRPC paste studied
was higher than that for OPC paste of the same w/c. In this case, however,
the difference appeared to be explicable mainly in terms of the coarser
pore structure of the SRPC paste and there was no clear evidence that the
lower C A content of the material had significantly affected chloride
diffusion kinetics.
The range of conditions that could be examined within the limited timescale
of the research reported in this paper is being extended by further work.
It is hoped that this will lead to conclusions of greater general
applicability and more detailed understanding of the mechanisms of chloride
diffusion in hardened cement pastes.
Acknowledgements
We wish to thank Professor A. W. Pratt for the provision of laboratory
facilities and Mr. C. Thompson for his excellent technical assistance.
References.
i. O. E. Gj~rv and ~. Vennesland, Cem.Concr.Res. 9, 229 (1979)
2. B. Ost and G.E. Monfore, J.PCA Res. and Dev. Lab. 8. 46 (1966)
3. M. Collepardi, A. Marcialis and R. Turriziani, Ii Cemento 69, 143 (1972)
4. C.L. Page, Bulletin of the Institution of Corrosion Science and
Technology 77, 2 (1979)
5. K. Tuutti, Cement-och betonginstitutet Research Report 4 77, 107pp.,
Stockholm (1977).
6. W. Jost, Diffusion in Solids, Liquids, Gases, p.139.
Academic Press Inc., New York (1952).
7. A.I. Vogel, A Textbook of Quantitative Inorganic Analysis,
4th Ed. revised by J. Bassett, p.754. Longman, London (1978).
8. M. Collepardi, A. Marcialis and R. TurriZ[ani, J.Am. Ceram. Soc. 55,
534 (1972).
9. R. Parsons, Handbook of Electrochemical Constants, p.79.
Butterworth, London (1959).
iO. P.F. Low, Clays and Clay Minerals, Vol. 9, ed. A. Swineford,
Proc.9th Natl.Conf. on Clays and Clay Minerals, Lafayette,
Indiana, 1960, pp.219-229. Pergammon, Oxford (1962).
ii. L. K. Porter, W.D. Kemper, R.D. Jackson and B.A. Stewart,
Soil Sc±.Soc.Am. Proc. 24, 460 (1960).
12. T.C. Powers and T.L. Brownyard, PCA Research Department Bulletin 22 (1948)
13. T.C. Powers, L.E. Copeland and H.M. Mann, J. PCA Res. and Dev. Lab.
1 (2), 38 (1959).
406 Vol. I I , No. 3
C.L. Page, et al.