Professional Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2014
CSCXXX10.1177/1532708614548134Cultural Studies <span class="symbol" cstyle="symbol">↔</span> Critical MethodologiesFinley et al.
Article
Cultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies
Abstract
This article demonstrates the pedagogy and performance of a radical ethical aesthetic. It emerges from a mural-making
project that exists in the confluence of critical arts-based research and emancipatory and transformative educational
practices. Critical arts-based inquiry is a methodology for ethical research that is futuristic, socially responsible, and useful
in addressing social inequities. The critical arts-based research that is demonstrated here was constructed to be deliberately
transformative of repressive social structures, and to inspire its participants and its audiences to both, reflection and
ethical, political action.
Keywords
arts-based research, critical pedagogy, arts and learning, public art
be disassembled and each of its individual four panels of the AHAS program. In addition to teacher educa-
exhibited as independent artworks. Its theme is “Food tion, students from English, Political Science,
Justice” and its panels depict the sub-themes that organized Human Development, Digital Technology, Public
our 2013 summer curriculum: (a) Healthy Eating, (b) Affairs, and Environmental Science have completed
Community Food Systems, (c) Urban Gardens, and (d) internships and independent study projects with
Food Heritage. In addition to the project’s function in teach- AHAS.
ing a variety of artistic concepts, content about food and 3. AHAS is a setting for research about teaching and
nutrition, community, collaboration, and so forth, the com- learning.
pleted project is intended as a mobile exhibit and teaching
tool to be displayed in urban farmer’s markets, food banks, The title of the AHAS program is a tad unfortunate
and schools. It will also be used in educational workshops because it sometimes leaves false impressions that the pro-
when displayed at local food banks and it will be used in gram has something to do with homeschooling or full-time,
teacher education workshops. In these workshop models, separate schools for homeless students. These are not the
the mural will present talking points for performance-dia- case. The name is, however, important to the program. The
logues with viewing audiences. program title was chosen during a group discussion by the
first 25 or so students who enrolled. During that conversa-
tion, students talked about their experiences of being out-
Context, AHAS siders in their schools, of being treated differently than their
Beginning in 2002, the AHAS program has operated as an classmates who were not economically poor or homeless,
arts-integrated, out-of-school time academic support pro- and of the lack of empathy and understanding they some-
gram for students who are homeless, sheltered, and unshel- times faced over the need for adjustments to be made to
tered. After the first two years, the population expanded to homework and some other assignments. The tenor of the
include students who are immigrants, children of incarcer- discussion became one of advocacy. Students were assured
ated parents, students living in foster care, and other preK- that they had rights to full educational access and that their
12 students who face systemic barriers to educational inferior status in schools was something they might need to
equity. In 10 years, AHAS after-school and summer pro- resist. Indeed, they (and their families) were encouraged to
grams have enrolled more than 1,200 K-12 students. Nearly actively claim their educational rights—to insist on trans-
half are racial minorities (in a county with a less than 25% portation to keep them in their homeschools; to assure
minority population), and nearly one fourth are non-native proper placements in appropriate grade levels, college-pre-
English speakers. AHAS serves three primary functions: paratory courses, and special education; as well as access to
materials, supplies, and teaching support for their unique
1. AHAS improves educational possibilities for home- learning needs. The conversation took a turn toward how
less, high poverty, and immigrant K-16 students and claiming their rights to equal educational opportunity could
their families through arts-based curriculum and actually improve their social standing, such that they would
instruction. feel at home at school. In truth, I cannot recall who first
2. AHAS functions as a “lab school” to prepare future uttered the phrase, but it became something of a refrain; the
teachers and principals to teach in culturally diverse name was put to a vote and so it has been ever after—At
public schools and to transform those schools into Home At School or AHAS.
models for 21st century education. All pre-service The first primary function of AHAS is to advance the
bachelor’s and master’s in elementary teaching and educational skills of our K-12 students and their families.
candidates for principal certification have inte- Improving individual educational opportunity implies much
grated, credited course work that takes place as part more than tutoring or “catching-up” with missed work due
Finley et al. 621
to transience and absenteeism, important as those educa- the movement to organize communities, to educate and
tional purposes might be. To that end, we create individual- reunite people with their cultural histories, to reclaim land,
ized learning plans for addressing student’s personal and to resist dominant capitalist culture. She explained the
learning needs that we include in an electronic portfolio importance of iconography to the success of the movement.
used to facilitate communications among students and their Her workshops highlighted, among others, the works of
peers, AHAS faculty, tutors, mentors, teachers, and fami- Diego Rivera and Judith Baca. In her biography, Baca (n.d.)
lies. The goal of advancing educational opportunity must references her process as being “transformative” wherein
also be the performance of emancipatory education: so, we she engaged more than 400 youth and provided inspiration
teach students how to be advocate for themselves and their for a “new wave of art” and a symbol of inclusiveness and
community, we teach critical thinking skills, and we use democracy (www.judybaca.com). Carmen encouraged the
service learning projects such as mural painting as a forum teacher candidates who participated in the project to follow
for challenging social determinism. It is our challenge at Baca’s lead in working with youths in creating transforma-
AHAS to encourage students to write their own futures, to tive, political, public art. Carmen consistently integrated
use their critical and creative skills to shape their own lives. her workshops with the Teachers as Cultural Workers
Personal reflection and autobiographical narratives are key (Freire, 1998) text the students had been assigned as a com-
to the AHAS curriculum. For example, Carmen Vonk (co- mon reading. Says Vonk (2011),
author of this article and former AHAS intern) has created
individualized, electronic murals with high school students Murals have long been a source of identity for individuals and
who have been expelled from area schools in which the stu- communities throughout the country. In Toward a People’s Art
dents tell their life stories in images while they also learn Cockcroft and her coauthors state that “murals are primarily
visual editing and other software applications. intended for the community that lives with them, so it is
important that the muralists live in or have some strong bond to
In the project described in this article, Carmen and Susan
the community” (Cockcroft, Weber, & Cockcroft, 1998, p. xi).
collaborated with about 50 AHAS students on the design of This strong bond provided artists and community members
a four panel, From Garden to Table mural. Madeleine with a basis from which to tell their story since “behind each
Finley drew the design in charcoal on gesso-primed ply- painted wall lies a story—not just a narrative depicted, but a
wood boards and (with Susan) instructed students on the art composite of all the stories, the debates and the ideas that
and mechanics of mural painting while organizing groups preceded and now underlie the completed images.” (p. xi)
of between 3 and 10 late elementary, middle, and high
school students as they painted the mural. Several of the From her emphasis on storied texts and her demonstra-
participating students had been involved in previous mural tions of personal, autobiographical murals, her design for a
painting projects through AHAS. diversity mural at Washington State University Vancouver
(WSUV), and her design for a separate, larger AHAS his-
torical mural, Carmen encouraged the teachers to produce
Teacher Education
lessons for K-12 students that involved narrating their art-
We initiated the project with a teacher education compo- works and storying their examples of artworks for inclusion
nent. About 30 university students enrolled in Diversity, in the Garden to Table mural.
Social Contexts, and Arts-Integration courses participated
in some phase of the project. In one example of the teacher
K-12 Student Education
education curriculum, Amber Heckelman, a doctoral stu-
dent in environmental science, volunteered her time to We began the project with the K-12 population with six,
share her research that centers on restoring food security three-hour workshops during Spring-semester AHAS Art
and sovereignty in the Philippines. “Essentially, food sover- Saturdays, on campus at WSUV. During these sessions, we
eignty ensures the rights to use and manage lands. presented curricula to introduce our four themes, as well as
Territories, water, seeds, livestock, and biodiversity are in the history and educational purposes of murals and other
the hands of those who produce food, and not in the hands community art forms. Supplementary example lessons
of the private sector,” says Heckelman. She also led the uni- included playing non-competitive games such as Rivers,
versity students through activities and discussions about Rails, and Roads in which students assemble an unformed
food deserts and controversy surrounding genetically modi- puzzle by connecting transportation systems from a series
fied foods (GMOs). Teacher candidate participants created of photographs and drawings. We included investigations of
posters and designed curriculum devoted to these topics for salmon habitats and collection of indigenous plants that
K-12 students. could be eaten, as well as turned into dyes and stains for
Carmen Vonk facilitated multiple workshops for educa- various student art projects. They visited murals virtually
tors on the history and pedagogical significance of murals. and they learned about the history of murals as educational
Her focus was Chicana/o Murals and political resistance, projects. Several events were held that included field
622 Cultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies 14(6)
activities and nutritional food educational stations in which Marling (1982) discusses matters of popular culture and
the students were the community educators for peers who taste—local and regional—in an examination of art and cul-
visited and participated in the events. During summer ses- ture as they played out in the 1930s New Deal post office and
sion, students visited a farmer’s market, planted container courthouse murals that began the “mural renaissance” in the
gardens, and took field trips to Heritage Farms where they United States. He writes about how interests of the parties to
harvested vegetables and prepared their lunches. the creation of the murals—the patron, the painter, and the
Working up the mural included students’ creations of public—overlapped and conflicted. According to Marling, the
mini-murals, topical posters, and the conceptual beginnings patron was governmental staff who were “experts in the fine
of an art installation for the Respect Park horticulture proj- arts” and held among them a collective notion of “good”
ect that depicted the many fruits and vegetables the students mural art—“good, that is, for the progress of American art and
were experiencing. Students composed and produced a the improvement of American taste . . . as well as a conduit for
radio broadcast on genetically altered foods, food justice, transmitting the often inchoate preferences of the public to the
and the politics of health and nutrition. In one fascinating painter” (p. 11). The painter, then, was put in a squeeze
exercise on food heritage, students were asked by a teacher between the patron and the public, while also exercising his or
candidate in very broad terms to use a new painting tech- her own responsibilities and preferences as an artist. Although
nique to “portray a food that is traditionally eaten in your we appreciated the New Deal contribution of murals to
family. Something that is well-liked and considered special Americana and traditions in mural painting, we certainly did
by multiple generations of family members, you, your par- not intentionally emulate any of their patterns of conflict.
ents, your grandparents.” Within minutes, she realized that Nonetheless, the Garden to Table Mural group had a
almost all students had produced an artifact on pizza— patron to please—our partner in this project was an organi-
which then turned into a dialogue on nutrition, advertising, zation that touts organic food production, local farms and
and the proliferation of pizza as a cultural construction of food purchases (100 miles) and advocates food justice pri-
the U.S. diet. Students left the session with an emerging orities, as well as our own acclamation of social justice
understanding of social construction and the social, eco- issues and interest in advancing the use of murals for the
nomic, and political processes it involves. purpose of public education. Together, the patron-partners
had determined the themes for the mural, with input from
the AHAS Youth Advisory (a committee of middle and high
Critical Arts-Based Research school students). Carmen probably felt the pressure of being
By its integration of multiple methodologies used in the arts in the middle more than the rest of us. Our process had us
with the post-modern ethics of participative, action- collecting preferences from our public—children and
oriented, and politically situated perspectives for human youths—and Carmen would pull the images children cre-
social inquiry, critical arts-based research has the potential ated, lesson plans, and input from the patrons into an elec-
to facilitate critical race, indigenous, queer, feminist, and tronic design. At one point, real debate ensued over
border theories and research methodologies. As a form of Carmen’s inclusion of ghostly figures of native Americans
performance pedagogy, arts-based inquiry in this example in the fourth panel, on the theme of “food heritage.” First,
addresses issues of social inequity. Participants in this work the youth participants rejected the notion that the figures
identify and confront systemic oppressions, targets sites of represented their heritage or even their lack of claim to the
resistance, and map possibilities for transformative praxis. land. For them, the figures didn’t tell the immigration story
Critical arts-based research is the dialogical performance many of them shared, but that also was very different
of critical theory using art-making as method (with refer- depending on whether they had immigrated as refugees,
ence to the complete works of Conquergood; see also undocumented, or by relationships to families in the United
Kincheloe & McLaren, 2000; Madison, 2005). “Dialogical States and in countries of origin. For me, as patron, I was
performances” are the ongoing conversations that occur concerned that we would be politicizing local tribal con-
among communities of individuals—in this instance, mar- flicts and that we didn’t have sufficient understanding of
ginalized students, teacher candidates and other educators, their issues to make informed choices of how to depict the
and researchers/art-teachers/community activists—and the area’s indigenous peoples. Furthermore, the whole project
audience(s) to the project. At AHAS, we consider the pro- broke down when both children and youths revolted against
cess of art-making to be at least as important as the product the process of creating the design because the photographic
of art-making because it is during the process that we method used was “too realistic” and would be difficult to
exchange information. The product is only useful as a dia- paint. Equally unacceptable to those stakeholders was a
logic performance of research when we make opportunities design with cartoonesque landscapes and figures. A great
for opening the dialogue to audiences of the performance, deal of effort by Carmen went into her assurances that the
so that the audience members themselves enter the dialogi- design and the actual mural would be remarkably different,
cal performance of art. and that literal translation was not the goal. Repeatedly,
Finley et al. 623
Figure 2. Panel 1: Healthy eating/abundance. The conflict between patron expectations and public is
captured in the depiction of Dragon fruit and compromise
was called for; the fruit stayed.
The public, our students, who were also the painters,
held an expectation that the concept of painting murals at
AHAS included the ethics we have promoted in the pro-
gram from the beginning—if these paintings were to be
consistent with our educational practices, then they were
also an opportunity for the “I” story. Here, we were even in
conflict thematically, with one of our themes being respect
for “local and indigenous” foods and another being “food
legacy.” One of the difficulties we know to exist for many
immigrants in this area of the Pacific Northwest is the lack
of availability of traditional foods and ingredients. In the
example of the New Deal murals, sometimes alterations to
content were required when iconography depicted ideas and
sentiments outside the range of the patron’s purpose—such
as one example “under fire for its ‘pessimistic attitude.’”
Still, the notion of place is important to considerations of
mural work. Quite a bit has been written about the role of
murals in establishing a sense of place for outsider popula-
tions. Yet, Lippard (1998) writes “Murals are not often
enough considered in the context of their specific urban
Figure 3. Panel 2: Community food production. landscapes.” Regionalism was an important consideration
in constructing the New Deal murals. Specifically, the
patrons required mural artists to include “factual content
Carmen revised the electronic mural design until it was, derived from the local scene.” Yet, Marling (1982) also
finally, acceptable to patrons and public. notes that history has not recorded any clear mechanisms
Even so, when Madeleine converted the mural landscape for the production of New Deal murals “whereby a Section
from its electronic vision to actual charcoal on board, she was artist was commissioned for service; betook him or herself
averse to laying in detail that would render the work of the to Anyplace, USA; mingled with the natives; and painted a
student artists to “paint by number.” For instance, at her insis- mural that local tastemakers deemed satisfactory, abhorrent,
tence, the entire area of the first panel “abundance” that con- or ignorable” (p. 84). Artists were primarily from urban
sists of fruits and vegetables was left open for students to centers like New York and California and regionalism was
624 Cultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies 14(6)
Declaration of Conflicting Interests Vonk, C. (2011). The physical expression of diversity on uni-
versity campuses. Unpublished report, Diversity Council,
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
Washington State University Vancouver.
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
article.
Author Biographies
Funding Susan Finley is a professor at Washington State University. She bases
her pedagogy and inquiry in arts-based approaches to understanding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research,
social and cultural issues in educational contexts. She is a community
authorship, and/or publication of this article.
activist who has implemented educational efforts with street youths
and economically poor children, youths, and adults, housed and
References unhoused. In 2010, she and Marcelo Diversi co-edited a special issue
Baca, J. (n.d.). Biography. Available from www.judybaca.com/ of Cultural Studies↔Critical Methodologies devoted to critical home-
Cockcroft, E., Weber, J. P., & Cockcroft, J. (1998). Toward a peo- lessness. Her chapter about critical arts-based research in the Sage
ple’s art: The contemporary mural movement. Albuquerque: Handbook of Qualitative Research inspired this special issue.
University of New Mexico Press.
Carmen Vonk is an independent mural consultant who has partici-
Conquergood, D. (2002). Performance studies: Interventions and
pated in several mural projects in Oregon and Washington and who
radical research. The Drama Review, 46, 145-156.
has extensively photographed murals in the United States and
Freire, P. (1998). Teachers as cultural workers: Letters to those
Mexico. She has provided mural design and educational support to
who dare teach. Boulder, CO: Westview.
the At Home At School (AHAS) program and Back on Track in the
Kincheloe, L. J., & McLaren, P. (2000). Rethinking critical
Vancouver, Washington, public schools. She is the author of a white
theory and qualitative research. In N. K. Denzin & Y. S.
paper The Physical Expression of Diversity on University Campuses,
Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (2nd ed.,
prepared for Washington State University Vancouver, Diversity
pp. 279-313). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Council.
Lippard, L. R. (1998). Foreword. In E. Cockcroft, J.P. Weber &
J. Cockcroft (Eds.), Toward a people’s art: The contempo- Madeleine L. Finley is a high school student at Vancouver School
rary mural movement (pp. xi-xv). Albuquerque: University of of Arts and Academics (a public school). With her mother, Susan
New Mexico Press. Finley, she has participated in 13 summer sessions of the AHAS
Madison, D. S. (2005). Critical ethnography: Method, ethics, and program. She has exhibited her artwork at the Sixth Street Gallery in
performance. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Vancouver, WA, and other venues. Her volunteer work for the
Marling, K. A. (1982). Wall-to-wall America: A cultural history National Honor’s Society includes painting and mural projects with
of post-office murals in the Great Depression. Minneapolis: AHAS and theatre workshops for Vancouver Public Schools ele-
University of Minnesota Press. mentary school students.