Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/337355022
CITATIONS READS
0 76
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Pemodelan Kombinasi Grid Bambu dan Tiang Beton Sebagai Pendukung Timbunan pada Tanah Gambut View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Aazokhi Waruwu on 04 December 2019.
Abstract – This study presents the effect of pile length and connection with the performance of
the nailed slab system as supporting embankment load on peat soil. Various times-settlement
performances that have reflected different piles length and connection have been observed. The
consolidation settlement behavior at several models has been simulated using Asaoka method in
order to obtain the coefficient of consolidation. It has been obtained that the nailed slab system is
able to decrease the stress distribution in the soil foundation. This can have a significant effect on
the stability embankment, and hence, the type of connections pile with the slab will specify for the
embankment load on peat soil. The addition of the pile element under the slab can contribute to
the resisting forces, reducing consolidation settlement, increasing slab stiffness, and hence the
overall stability of the embankment. Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights
reserved.
Keywords: Peat, Nailed Slab System, Embankment, Pile, Influence Factor, Correction Factor
Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved https://doi.org/10.15866/irece.v10i5.15757
243
A. Waruwu, H. C. Hardiyatmo, A. Rifa’i
most widely used methods of retrofitting under the embankment. This paper discusses the coefficient of
embankment are the ones reinforced with geogrid. It is consolidation value, the analysis of consolidation
effective for heaps due to soil liquefaction [13], settlement, the influence factor of stress distribution, and
geosynthetic reinforcement of pile on soft clay soil the correction factor of settlement. A careful analysis
foundations [6], geogrid and supporting piles of highway shows how variations in pile length and connections
over soft clay soils [7], embankments supported by grids affect the performance of the nailed slab system in
and bamboo piles [8], [9], and reinforced of the bamboo support of the embankment load on peat soils. This paper
grid in order to increase the modulus of subgrade and is part of a research on the compression behavior of peat
shear modulus of peat soil [19]. Installation of bamboo soils with the reinforcement of the nailed slab system.
piles combined with bamboo grids can reduce the The data in this paper use the results of tests on the
deflection, can reduce the deflection of the bamboo grid peat soil layer. The results of other studies still leave
and can ultimately maintain stability. Retrofitting can some interesting parts to be published in between the test
contribute to improve the stability of the embankment, results of embankment loads in the peat and clay layers,
strengthening the peat shear that will withstand the lateral the effect of dimensions and pile distance on behavior
force [12]. Slab without piles affects only the top layer of peat soil. Several methods for estimating the settlement
the surface with a depth generally not higher than the in this paper include using the finite element method to
width of the foundation slab [15]. Another alternative to be developed in the following papers.
the use of piles on soft soils is the nailed slab system [5], The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section
[2]. Nailed slab systems are developed with simple, easy- II describes the analysis of settlement as a phenomenon
to-install, and cost-effective hardening systems, where of consolidation, stress distribution in soil, and time-rate
pavement slabs will be connected to mini piles that work of Settlement. Section III presents the research methods.
as a system. This nailed slab system cannot only Section IV discusses the result of study. Finally, Section
strengthen the clay layer, but it can also effectively resist V presents the conclusions.
the uplift force of expansive clay [2]. Piles are installed
under slabs and connected monolithically by using slab-
thickening connections on soft clay soil [11]. Some of II. Settlement
the advantages of using a pile in support of the The total settlement can be caused by embankment
embankment are the implementation of the embankment loading. The phenomenon of consolidation occurs in soft
construction can be completed in a short time, the pile- soil because the excessive initial pore water pressures
backed pile can reduce the total settlement, and cannot be dissipated immediately owing to the low
differential settlement significantly [7]. Supporting slab permeability [4].
using mini piles has a significant effect on slab motion
reduction. The nailed slab system with monolith piles can
reduce displacement 30% better than the pile of II.1. Consolidation Settlement
unsupported slab. While the non-monolith pile, the The consolidation settlement of embankment (Sc) can
reduced rate is only 20%. The soil around the pile and the then be given as:
interaction between the ground-pile-slab makes the
system more rigid [2]. Initially, this proposed system is a e
rigid pavement with slab thickness between 12-20 cm Sc H (1)
1 e
and a diameter of 15-20 cm [5]. In general, the prototype
of the nailed slab system as the pavement has good Cc H ' '
performance, according to differential settlement and Sc log o (2)
1 eo o '
effective in reducing the upward movement [20], [21].
The nailed slab systems can also be used to support where Cc = compression index from slope of the e-log
embankments on peat soils. The installation of piles on plot, H = initial height of soil layer, eo = initial void ratio,
slabs has been able to reduce the settlement of slabs and o = effective pressure at the middle of the layer, and ’
to increase the modulus of subgrade reaction. Piles can = vertical pressure increment.
reduce the settlement and deflection of the slab. Slab
with monolithic piles is more stable and stiffer than non-
monolithic piles under loading [17]. Piles length and II.2. Stress Distribution in Soil
connection system with slabs have also affected the Stress in soil is caused by self weight and by the
compression behavior of peat soil. Longer and embankment loading at the surface. The vertical stresses
monolithic piles have generated smaller settlement. Piles at any depth z in soil (Δσz) under embankment loading
installed on the embankment-supporting slabs could are calculated by Eq (3):
increase the modulus of sub-grade reaction [18]. This
system is still not applied for some projects in any z qI (3)
country but it is limited to test models in the laboratory.
For this reason, continuous research is needed so that where q = pressure of embankment loading and I =
this system can be applied as a support for future influences factor.
Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Civil Engineering, Vol. 10, N. 5
244
A. Waruwu, H. C. Hardiyatmo, A. Rifa’i
II.3. Time-Rate of Settlement of the settlement from dial gauge installed in the middle
of the slab and some other points. A photograph of the
Time-rate of settlement depends on drainage
embankment model testing is shown in Fig. 2.
conditions. The total thickness if the soil layer is drained
on one side, or half the layer thickness have to be drained Reference beam
on double drainage. The time of consolidation can be Concrete pile
Embankment d 2 cm Lp 15 cm Dial gauge
estimeted from Eq. (4): load and 35cm Concrete
slab t 2 cm
Sand h 2 cm
TH2 50 cm
t v t (4) Peat
Cv
100 cm Solid layer
where Tv = time factor, Tv = -0,933 log (1-U) – 0,085, Ht
= length of the drainage part, and Cv = coefficient of
vertical consolidation.
350 cm
The peat soil used in this study has been taken from
Bagansiapiapi - Riau. The peat used has been the same as
the research materials of [16]-[18]. The test results of
properties of peat soil have been specific gravity Gs =
1.34, bulk density b = 10.75 kN/m3, natural moisture
content wc = 970.86%, organic content Oc = 99%, fiber
content Fc= 35.21%, ash content Ac = 1%, eo = 9.04, Cc =
5.65, Soil sample tested has been fibrous peat because it
had an organic content of > 75% and a fiber content of >
20%. The peat samples have been compacted the test
boxes with the thickness of each layer 0.1 m. Each layer
has compacted close density b = 10.49 kN/m3 and wc =
699 %. The sand layer rests on top of the peat soil before
embankment loading is started. Fig. 1 illustrates the
model of embankment test over peat soil. Embankment
load test with a small-scale model has used box testing
sized 7 m × 3.5 m × 1.5 m. The embankment load has
been modeled from iron bar material sized 19 mm × 19
mm with the lengths of 40 mm placed on the surface of
peat soil. The unit weight of iron bars has been Fig. 2. Photographs of embankment model test
approximately 71.62 kN/m3. The embankment load has
TABLE I
been modeled from iron bars material in order to produce VARIATION OF TEST MODELS
a significant settlement [18]. The thickness of the peat No. Type of test Length of the pile (Lp) [cm]
layer is H = 50 cm, and the rest has been filled with the 1 Slab without pile -
solid layer. Cross sections and testing plan can be seen in 2 Slab with monolithic piles 15
Fig. 1. Five different tests have been conducted, 3 Slab with non-monolithic piles 15
4 Slab with monolithic piles 35
including slab without pile, slab with monolithic and 5 Slab with non-monolithic piles 35
non-monolithic piles with a length Lp = 15 cm and 35 cm
(Table I). Slab and piles have been made of concrete
materials, where the slab had a thickness t = 2 cm and an IV. Results and Discussion
area of 70×120 cm2, while the piles had a diameter of d =
2 cm cast monolithically or non-monolithically on the The result of embankment loading on peat soil with
slabs with a distance between center to center of s = 10 the nailed slab system can be seen in Fig. 3. The tests
cm. Stage load with the loading-unloading system was have been performed on the slab without piles, slab with
conducted by increasing the load for 24 hours, to be has monolithic piles (M), and slab with non-monolithic piles
been added to the second layer, followed by unloading (NM). The piles lengths are 15 cm and 35 cm.
stage and reloading of the third and fourth layers. The The results of the embankment load test are supported
height of embankment for a layer has been of 57 mm by slabs with and without pile groups accompanied by a
equivalent to the pressure (σ) of 4.08 kPa at each load coefficient of consolidation, analysis with Asaoka’s
stage. The total height of embankment for four layers method [1], estimated consolidation settlement, influence
was a h of 228 mm equivalent to the pressure (σ) of factor of stress distribution, and the correction factor of
16.32 kPa. Each loading and unloading required reading settlement.
Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Civil Engineering, Vol. 10, N. 5
245
A. Waruwu, H. C. Hardiyatmo, A. Rifa’i
Coefficient of consolidation,
The first step is to choose settlement observations 0,6
Lp 15cm (M)
generated by a constant duration from a series of Lp 15cm (NM)
observed data. 0,5
Lp 35cm (M)
Cv (m2/day)
The relationship between the Si and Si-1 can be plotted 0,4 Lp 35cm (TM)
as in Fig. 4. From this, it can be seen whether all these
point lines are on a slope of a straight line curve as β1. 0,3
The process of applying one of the Asaoka Methods 0,2
may be repeated for the different increment of
embankment using the time-settlement curves obtained in 0,1
each model for the slab with and without piles. The
0
coefficient of consolidation (Cv) can be determined by
subtracting β1. 0 4 8 12 16 20
In this study, the Δt is 2 hours or 0.08 days, and the Ht Pressure (kPa)
is 0.5 m. This was done by assuming that it was single
Fig. 5. The relation between pressure and coefficient of consolidation
drainage.
The relationship between pressure and coefficient of
consolidation calculated is presented in Fig. 5. It can be IV.2. The Result of Time-Rate Settlement
seen that the value of a coefficient of consolidation
The settlements at each time (St) are calculated at each
obtained has been essentially decreasing with increasing
U × final settlement (Sf). The Sf is estimated from the
pressure and pile length.
observed settlement at each model in the laboratory. It
The connections pile with slab had no influence on the
has been also attempted to derive a simplified method in
coefficient of consolidation.
order to estimate the consolidation settlement of peat soil
30 due to the embankment load supported by the nailed slab
system. By using Eq. (4), where all the values of Tv, Ht,
h (cm)
-30
the loading of embankments on peat soils.
-40
-50 Time (day)
Slab
Lp 15 cm (M) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
-60
Lp 15 cm (NM) 0
-70 Lp 35 cm (M)
Consolidation settlement (cm)
Lp 35 cm (NM) 1
-80
2
Fig. 3. The observed settlement at the center of an embankment [17]
3
4
5
Observed (slab) Calculated (slab)
6 Observed (Lp 15cm-M) Calculated (Lp 15cm-M)
Observed (Lp 15cm-NM) Calculated (Lp 15cm-NM)
7
Observed (Lp 35cm-M) Calculated (Lp 35cm-M)
8 Observed (Lp 35cm-NM) Calculated (Lp 35cm-NM)
1
IV.3. Stress Distribution
The influence factor of the nailed slab system (Ins) can
be determined from the ratio of the vertical pressure
Fig. 4. The relation between Si and Si-1 increment of the nailed slab system (Δσ=Δσns) with
Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Civil Engineering, Vol. 10, N. 5
246
A. Waruwu, H. C. Hardiyatmo, A. Rifa’i
vertical stress due to embankment (q). The relationship The addition of the pile element under the slab can
between the ratio of the length of the pile to the width of contribute to the resisting forces, reducing total and
the slab (L/B) and the influence factor of the nailed slab differential settlement, increasing slab stiffness, and
system is presented in Fig. 7. The pressure at the slab hence the overall stability of the embankment. The nailed
with monolithic piles is smaller than the one at the slab slab system is commonly more rigid than the slab
with non-monolithic piles on the same pile length. Thus, without piles. The rigidity of the nailed slab system is an
for the pile length of 35 cm, the pressure is smaller than important factor which affects the settlement of peat soil
the one at the pile length of 15 cm. It can be that the under an embankment load.
nailed slab system can reduce stress distribution. The
influence factor of stress distribution is very useful in Sc ns Sc s (5)
geotechnical engineering practice, especially in the
determination of the soil mass contributing to the
settlement of an embankment on peat soil. where α is the correction factor, Sc(ns) is the settlement of
slab with piles, and Sc(s) is the slab without piles.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the head and the
technicians of the Soil Mechanics Laboratory of Gadjah
Mada University for their help during the experimental
work. Great appreciation is also given to the Ministry of
Research, Technology and Higher Education of the
Republic of Indonesia for financial support.
References
[1] Asaoka, A., Observational Procedure of Settlement Prediction,
(1978) Soil and Foundations, 8(4), pp. 87-101.
Fig. 8. The relation between ratio Lp/B [2] Diana, W., Hardiyatmo, H. C., & Suhendro, B., Effect of Pile
and correction factor of settlement Connections on The Performance of The Nailed-Slab System on
Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Civil Engineering, Vol. 10, N. 5
247
A. Waruwu, H. C. Hardiyatmo, A. Rifa’i
The Expansive Soil, (2017) International Journal of Geomate, Reinforcement above Buried Pipes on Surface Settlement, (2018)
12(2), pp. 134-141. International Review of Civil Engineering (IRECE), 9 (2), pp. 86-
[3] Gruen, H. A., & Lovell, C. W., Use of Peats as Embankment 90.
Foundations, (1983) School of Civil Engineering, Purdue doi:https://doi.org/10.15866/irece.v9i2.13721
University West Lafayette, Indiana.
[4] Hardiyatmo, H. C., Soil Mechanics II, (2010) Gadjah Mada
University Press, Indonesia (in Indonesian). Authors’ information
[5] Hardiyatmo, H. C., Method to Analyzethe Deflection of The
Nailed-Slab System, (2011) International Journal of Civil & 1
Department of Civil Engineering, Institut Teknologi Medan, Indonesia.
Environmental Engineering, 11(4), pp. 22-28.
[6] Hinchberger, S. D., & Rowe, R. K., Geosynthetic Reinforced 2
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Universitas
Rmbankments on Soft Clay Foundations: Predicting Gadjah Mada, Indonesia.
Reinforcement Strains at Failure, (2003) Geotextiles and
Geomembranes, 21(3), pp. 151-175. Aazokhi Waruwu born in Sitoluewali, August
[7] Liu, H. L., Ng, C. W., & Fei, K., Perfomance of a Geogrid- 27, 1973, received his Bachelor of Engineering
Reinforced and Pile-Supported Highway Embankment over Soft degree in Medan Institute of Technology (1998)
Clay: Case Study, (2007) Journal of Geotechnical and and Master's Degree in Department of Civil and
Geoenvironmental Engineering, 133(12), pp. 1483-1493. Environmental Engineering, Faculty of
[8] Maulana, Azwar, Susanti, R. D., & Waruwu, A., Potential of Engineering, Gadjah Mada University, Indonesia
Bamboo Pile as Reinforcement of Peat Soil under Embankment, (2003), and Doctor Degree in Department of
(2018) ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Civil and Environmental Engineering, Faculty of
13(1), pp. 52-56. Engineering, Gadjah Mada University, Indonesia (2018). He joined
[9] Waruwu, A., Maulana, A., Halim, H., Settlement Estimation of with Medan Institut of Technology in 1998. He is currently studying
Peat Reinforced with Bamboo Grid Under Embankment, (2017) doctor at Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia. He has experience
International Review of Civil Engineering (IRECE), 8 (6), pp. research, designing and education. He has published many papers in
299-306. National Conferences, National / International Journal. He has
doi: https://doi.org/10.15866/irece.v8i6.13130 published in the field of Civil Engineering, Geotechnical Engineering,
[10] Porbaha, A., Hanzawa, H., & Kishida, T., Analysis of a Failed Peat Soil, Clay Soil, and Foundation. Mr Waruwu joined with
Embankment on Peaty Ground, (2000) Slope Stability 2000, (pp. Indonesia Society for Geotechnical Engineering (ISGE/HATTI) - ID.
281-293). No. : 15.2223.OR.
[11] Puri, A., Suhendro, B., & Rifa’i, A., Effect of Vertical Wall
Barrier on The Rigid Pavement Deflection of Full Scale 1-Pile Hary Christady Hardiyatmo born in Solo,
Row Nailed-Slab System on Soft Sugrade, (2017) International October 18, 1955, received Undergraduate, Civil
Journal of Geomate, 12(32), pp. 25-29. and Environmental Engineering Department,
[12] Rowe, R. K., & Li A. L., Geosynthetic-Reinforced Embankments Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia (1981) and
over Soft Foundations, (2005) Geosynthetics International, 12(1), Master Engineering, Asian Institute of
pp. 50-85. Technology Bangkok, Thailand (1990),
[13] Sasaki, Y., Kano, S., & Tsuji, T., Embankment Reinforcement by Diplome d’Etude Approfondies (DEA),
Geogrid to Reduce Its Settlement During Earthquakes, (2004) Universite de Grenoble I, France, Doctor
13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering Vancouver, Degree, University Joseph Fourier Grenoble, France (1995), and
B.C., Canada, Paper (No. 642). Profesor (2013). Research Interest are Cakar Ayam System For Rigid
[14] Susanti, R. D., Maulana, & Waruwu, A., Bearing Capacity Pavement, Nailed Slab System For Rigid Pavement and Patent
Improvement of Peat Soil by Preloading, (2017) ARPN Journal of P002007001, Cakar Ayam System For Pavement, Universitas Gadjah
Engineering and Applied Sciences, 12(1), pp. 121-124. Mada, 04/2007. He has published some papers in National/International
[15] Vakher, M., Load-Deformation Performance of Peat Soil Under Conferences, National/International Journal. Prof. Hary Christady
Large Concrete Plates, (2000) In Geotechnical Measurements: Hardiyatmo joined with Indonesia Society for Geotechnical
Lab and Field (pp. 44-55). Engineering (ISGE/HATTI).
[16] Waruwu, A., Hardiyatmo, H. C., & Rifa’i, A., Compressive
Behavior of Bagansiapiapi-Riau Peat in Indonesia, 2016 Ahmad Rifa’i was born on July 12, 1969. In
Electronic Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 21(16), pp. 1988 he continued his civil engineering
5217-5227. education at the faculty of Engineering,
[17] Waruwu, A., Hardiyatmo, H. C., & Rifa’i, A., Behavior of Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia. He
Nailed-Slab System on Peat Soil under Loading, (2017) achieved his bachelor's degree in 1993. In 1994
Proceedings of the 1st Warmadewa University International he continued his Master's, Geotechnics, Institute
Conference on Architecture and Civil Engineering, Bali, Teknologi Bandung, Indonesia and earned his
Indonesia, (pp: 101-107). master's degree in 1996. His doctorate was
[18] Waruwu, A., Hardiyatmo, H. C., & Rifa’i, A., Deflection obtained in 2002 at The Swiss Federal Institute of Technology of
Behavior of The Nailed Slab System-Supported Embankment on Lausanne (EPFL), Switzerland. Research interest in soil mechanics,
Peat Soil, (2017) Journal of Applied Engineering Science, 15(4), tunneling, and foundation has resulted in several publications in the
pp. 556 - 563. form of international journals. Dr. Ahmad Rifai is a member of
[19] Waruwu, A., Halim, H., Nasution, T., & Hanova, Y., Bamboo Indonesia Society for Geotechnical Engineering (HATTI) and ISSMG
Grid Reinforcement on Peat Soil under Repeated Loading, (2018) (International Society for Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical
Journal of Engineeering and Applied Sciences, 13(8), pp. 2190- Engineering).
2196.
[20] Puri, A., Hardiyatmo, H.C., Suhendro, B., & Rifa’i, A.,
Differential Settlement of Rigid Pavement of 3-Pile Row Nailed-
slab System on Soft Clay Sub Grade Due to Monotonic and
Repetitive Loadings, (2016) International Conference on
Technology, Innovation, and Society, (pp: 377-388).
[21] Diana, W., Hardiyatmo, H.C., & Suhendro, B., Small-scale
Experimental Investigation on the Behaviour of Nailed Slab
System in Expansive Soil, (2016) AIP Conference Proceedings,
(Vol. 1755, No. 1, p. 060002), AIP Publishing.
[22] Fattah, M., Hassan, W., Rasheed, S., Effect of Geocell
Copyright © 2019 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Civil Engineering, Vol. 10, N. 5
248