Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Perfect competition
.9
rl explain the
E nl distinguish between
firm in perfect
p HL explain how
.9
HL explain and
competition
HL explain and
HL explain and
perfect competition
xl define and illustrate
xl define and illustrate
xl explain and
and long run
Quantity
Quantity Quantity
103
Figure 71 The demand curves for the industry and the llrm in perfect comPetition
!!!!! 7 . perfect competitron
The industry
Quantity Quantity
We can see that the lirm takes the price P from the industry and,
because the demand is perfectly elastic, P:D =AR:MR. Profit is
maxirnised where MC:MR, which is at the level oI output q. We
must remember that although the scale of the price axes is the same
for the firm and the industry, this is not the case for output. The
quantity q is very small in relation to the total industry output, Q,
and it would not even register on the output axis for the industry. II
it could, then it would be large enough to shift the supply cuwe and
thus alter the industry price.
t04
7 s. perfect competit'on l!!E
Possible short-run profit and loss situations in
perfect competition
In the short run in perfect competition, there are two possible profit/
loss situations:
Quantity Quantity
Quantity Quantity
c
D:AR:A,ilR
0 q,q
Quantity Quantity
Figure 75 The movement from short-run abnormal profit to long-run normal profit
Some firms in the industry will, after a time, start to leave the
industry. At first this will have no real effect, because the firms are
relatively small. However, as more and more firms leave the industry,
unable to achieve norrnal profit, the industry supply curve will start
=
d
to shift to the left.
8
f
As the industry supply curve starts to shift from S towards S,, the o
3
industry price will begin to rise from P towards Pr. As the firms in -
the industry are pdce-takers, the price that they can charge will stafi
to rise and their demand curves will start to shift upwards. This
means that the losses that they had been making begin to get
smaller.
The industry
a Sr
g
t-),:AR':MR,
"1
P
qi-o qq,
Quantity Quantity
Figure 76 The movement from short-run losses to long+un normal profit
This process will continue as long as there are losses being made in the
industry. Eventually the industry supply curve reaches Sy, where the
price is Pr. At this point, the firms are "taking" the price of P1 and
the demand curve is Dr=ARr=MRr. We now find that the firms are
making normal profits, with the price per unit equal to the cost per
unit, i.e. Pr=Cr. Now the entrepreneurs of the firms in the industry
are satisfied, because they are exactly covering all of their costs,
including their opportunity costs. There would be no reason to leave
the industry as the firm could not do better elsewhere. However.
there is now no abnormal prolit to attract more firms into the
industry and so the industry is in a long-run equilibrium situation.
No one will now enter and no one will now leave. The outcome will
be a smaller industry producing only Q1 units, with slightly larger
firms, each producing qr units.
Ihe industry
Allocative efficiency
This measure o{ efficiency is sometimes also called the socially
optimum level of output.
Allocative efliciency occurs where suppliers are producing the
IOA optimal mix of goods and services required by consumers.
7 :r, Perfect competition llIE
Price reflects the value that consumers place on a good and is shown
on the demand curve (average revenue). Marginal cost rellects the
cost to society of all the resources used in producing an extra unit of
a good, including the normal profit required for the lirm to stay in
business. If price were to be greater than marginal cost, then the
consumers would value the good more than it cost to make it. If both
sets of stakeholders are to meet at the optimal mix, then output
would expand to the point where price equals marginal cost.
Similarly, if the marginal cost were to be greater than the price, then =
d
society would be using more resources to produce the good than the
value it gives to consumers and output would fall.
3_.
The cost
tt _ The
-
valLre
to producers to consurners
Output Output
In Figure 7.9, we can see the allocatlvely efficient level of output for
a firm with a normal demand curve and for a firm with a perfectly
elastic demand curve. In both cases we are looking for the output
where MC:AR -q, for the firm with a normal demand curve and
q2 when the demand is perfectly elastic.
t09
!!!! t . Perfect competition
The industry
tE
D=AR=l\ilR
E
o Quantity
Quantity
.9
Figure 710 Productive and allocative e{ficiency with short-run Profits in perfect comPetition
In the same way, if a firm is making losses in the short run in perfect
competition, we can see from Figure 7.1 1 that although they are
producing at the profit-maximising level of output, q (where
MC=MR), and the allocatively efficient level of output, q, (where
MC:AR), once again the firm is not producing at the most efficient
level of output, qr (where MC=AC).
The industry The firm
Quantity Quantity
Figure 7ll Productive and allocatjve efficiency with short-run losses in perfect competition
ll=AR:MR
Quantity Quantlty
Quantity
I l0
Figure 712 Productive and allocative efficiency in the long run in perfect competition
7, Perfect competit'on !l!E
Also shown in Figrre .12 is the fact that all oI the profit-rnaximizing
7
firms in the long run in perfect competition are also producing at the
allocatively efficient level of output, because they produce where
MC=AR.
@ffi@ryry
Short run
LonS run
3.
EXAMINATION QUESTIONS
Paper l, part (a) questions
t With the help of a diagram, explain how it is possible for
a firm in perfect competition to earn abnormal profits in
the short run. [10 morks]
2 With the help of a diagram, explain how it is impossible
for a firm in perfect competition to earn abnormal profits
in the long run. [to morks]
5 Explain whether or not a firm in perfect competition earning
abnormal profits is productively and allocatively efficient. [lo morks]
lll