You are on page 1of 20

8

Sacred Landscapes and Imperial Ideologies:


The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru
Katharina Schreiber
University of California at Santa Barbara

ABSTRACT
Expanding empires not only establish political and economic bases of control as they consolidate their occupation
of new territories, but they also create or modify ideological bases of power in each region. Evidence from the
Sondondo Valley suggests that the Wari Empire manipulated local belief systems in order to express its power and
legitimate its domination. Wari imperial ideology was expressed through an iconography of power and an imposing
style of architecture. Local belief systems can be reconstructed through the use of modern and historic observations
combined with archaeological remains, and I identify one and possibly two major shrines that were in use during
the Middle Horizon. Among the sites established by the Wari in the Sondondo Valley was Leqles Pata, located
in proximity to local shrines in such a way as to exert control over their access and experiential nature. It is not
unlikely that Wari strategies of ideological control were tailored to each region, much as were their economic and
political reforms. The use of local belief systems as a form of resistance cannot be seen clearly in the case of the Wari
occupation, but I cite the Taki Onqoy movement as an example of 16th-century resistance by the people of Sondondo
against the Spanish. I conclude that Wari used ideological power as an important component of its imperial project.
Keywords: Wari Empire, sacred landscapes, ideology, Sondondo Valley, huacas/shrines

Empires mess with people’s minds. and categories of meanings imposed on the physical world,
—Susan E. Alcock (2002:36) norms of appropriate behavior, and ritual practices; ideolog-
ical power results from the ability to manipulate, control, or

P ower derives from a multitude of sources, and in the


complex interactions between dominant and subjugated
cultural groups, multiple forms of power come to the fore.
change these meanings, behaviors, or practices. Following
DeMarrais et al. (1996:15), ideology is a source of social
power, which involves the capacity to manage or control the
Political power is seen in the establishment of new forms activities of others. The materialization of ideology may in-
of political hierarchy and control over new territories. Eco- clude both physical and/or experiential phenomena, such as
nomic power is manifest in the economic reorganization shared forms of ritual or feasting events, iconographic sym-
of a region and the extraction of tribute. In this chapter I bolism, objects with particular social meanings, and public
should like to consider the role of ideology in the negoti- monuments. It may also include the bestowing of meaning
ation of power relations between conquerors and their sub- upon and sometimes physical alteration of places on the land-
jects. While my specific case study involves the Wari Empire scape thus providing order and domesticating natural space
of Middle Horizon Peru (A.D. 750–1000), I shall also draw (DeMarrais et al. 1996:16–19). The landscape is continu-
on other Andean examples temporally and culturally distinct ally encultured, to use Tilley’s (1994:67) terms, transforming
from the Wari. physical reality into meaningful, socialized forms.
I conceive of ideology as a series of mental constructs Ideology is a crucial component of the imposition of
that provide meaning and significance to aspects of the ma- imperial power. Initially, ideological beliefs may be a pre-
terial world, as well as to human actions and interactions. text for conquest (Lumbreras 1974:165; Sinopoli 1994:167–
Following Mann (1986:22–23), ideology includes concepts 168), but they may play an especially crucial role in

Archaeological Papers of the American Anthropological Association, Vol. 14, pp. 131–150, ISBN 1-931303-20-7.  C 2005 by the American An-

thropological Association. All rights reserved. Permissions to photocopy or reproduce article content via www.ucpress.edu/journals/rights.htm.
132 Katharina Schreiber

reinforcing imperial power during conquest and after control their own political centers in regions lacking a centralized
has been established. For newly conquered, recently assim- political structure (Menzel 1959). Craig Morris, in his stud-
ilated groups who may have conflicting agendas amongst ies of the Inca center at Huánuco Pampa, in northern Peru,
themselves, ideology can be a source of unity and stability and its environs, likewise concluded that the Incas adapted
(Carneiro 1992:193–194). their political strategies to the particular circumstances they
Perhaps more crucial for our purposes here, as we con- encountered in each region (Morris 1972, 1998). More re-
sider the foundations and relations of power in the Andes, is cently Terence D’Altroy has undertaken a careful analysis of
the notion that ideology serves as a basis of power for both the Inca occupation of the Yanamarca Valley in central Peru,
indigenous groups and the polities that come to dominate teasing out aspects of Inca political and economic power
them: “Materialization of ideology is . . . a strategic process (D’Altroy 1992). He and Christine Hastorf, along with sev-
in which leaders allocate resources to strengthen and legit- eral colleagues, have devoted productive efforts to under-
imate institutions of control” (DeMarrais et al. 1996:16). It standing domestic economies under Inca domination in this
therefore stands to reason that altering the material nature of region (D’Altroy and Hastorf 2001). Complementing this
extant symbols of indigenous ideology may be a most effica- emphasis on political and economic power, during the past
cious strategy employed by an intrusive, dominant political decade or so an increasing number of researchers have be-
order in order to shift that legitimation to themselves. Ideol- gun to include considerations of the role of ideology in the
ogy may also serve to justify imperial occupation (Conrad Inca expansion (Conrad 1992; Morris 1998) and in the case
1992; Demarest 1992) by attempting to conceal exploitation of other cultures (e.g., Kolata 1992).
or otherwise misrepresenting elite objectives (Joyce 1997; In this chapter I will attempt to address the articula-
Kolata 1992; Patterson 1986) and thus masking the asym- tion between imperial ideologies and local belief systems,
metry of state institutions and hierarchies (Shanks and Tilley as well as the negotiation of social power, in the case of one
1982). In time, once relations of social dominance have been particular occupation within the sphere of the Wari Empire.
established, ideology can be used to sustain those relations
(Tilley 1984), to centralize and consolidate political power
(DeMarrais et al. 1996), and to resolve tension and conflict The Wari Empire
(Anders 1989; Liverani 1979). Given the prominent role that
ideology plays in the negotiation of social power, it is a cru- In the second half of the first millennium A.D. the city of
cial focus of study in the examination of imperial expansion. Huari emerged in the central highlands of what we today call
In the Andes our clearest example of an imperialist state Peru.1 Bigger than anything before seen in the central Andes,
is the Inca Empire (A.D. 1476–1532), and our archaeologi- this urban site indicated a qualitative change in the cultural
cal knowledge and understanding of this culture is greatly history of the Andes and its rise marked an abrupt transition
enhanced by a large body of textual evidence consisting of to a new form of political dominance: an Andean empire
Spanish historic documents. Many Colonial Period docu- (Schreiber 2001). Wari control spread north in the highlands
ments, written as they were by parties not uninterested in the to what is today Cajamarca and south nearly to the Titicaca
Spanish conquest of the Incas, are concerned with details Basin; there were also Wari occupations at various locations
of Inca political and economic organization. Others concern along the central and south coasts of Peru, including Nasca
themselves with Inca and other indigenous Andean religious (Schreiber 1999) (Figure 8.1).
practices and form part of Spanish efforts to eradicate these The distribution of Wari-style architecture, roads, and
practices. artifacts of the Wari style in Peru, combined with those of the
Archaeological treatments of the Inca expansion, espe- Tiwanaku culture of Bolivia, form the basis of the definition
cially Inca occupations of particular provinces, have tended of the time period termed the Middle Horizon. John Rowe
to focus on political and economic manipulation of the cul- (1962) based his “master sequence” of Andean chronology
tural landscape. Dorothy Menzel, in her seminal study of on events taking place in the Ica Valley of the south coast
the Inca occupation of a series of valleys on the south coast of Peru. In his terms the Middle Horizon technically begins
of Peru, followed two lines of evidence: changes in local when Wari “influence” reached the Ica Valley and ends sev-
material culture, especially ceramic styles, reflecting Inca eral centuries after the collapse of Wari, when new cultural
influence, and changes in political control of each region. innovations appeared in Ica. Based on a handful of early ra-
Basing the latter part of her study on the presence or absence diocarbon dates, the Middle Horizon was tentatively fixed
of large local centers and/or intrusive Inca centers or other between about A.D. 550 and 1000, with the period of Wari
features in each region, she concluded that the Incas made expansion falling between A.D. 600 and 800 (see Menzel
use of local centralization where it existed but had to build 1977). As our inventory of radiocarbon dates has increased
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 133

Figure 8.1. Map of Peru showing locations of Huari and Wari sites mentioned in the text.
134 Katharina Schreiber

and advances in the technology have permitted these dates gue that maize production was greatly increased under Wari
to be calibrated to greater accuracy, it is now apparent that control (Schreiber 1992).
the Wari expansion occurred at a slightly later date, closer to
A.D. 750, and that it lasted perhaps until about A.D. 1000 (see
Schreiber 1992; Williams 2001). Following Rowe’s defini- A Consideration of Ideology
tion sensu stricto, the initial appearance of Wari influence in
Ica in about A.D. 750 provides our best current estimate of A noticeable lacuna in my own work to date is a lack
an absolute date for the beginning of the Middle Horizon. of explicit attention paid to ideological power and its role in
Because they shared certain distinctive elements of their Wari provincial occupations, such as that of the Sondondo
iconography, the Wari and Tiwanaku cultures were confused Valley. Wari specialists do not have the added resource of
for the first half of the 20th century, with Wari seen as a written documents to flesh out reconstructions of Middle
coastal component of a Tiwanaku expansion (Uhle 1903). Horizon societies, which are necessarily based on purely
Extensive research since the late 1940s has clarified the dis- archaeological data. This chapter is an attempt to partially
tinction between these two cultures, and Wari, with its capital address the bias toward the study of political and economic
at Huari, is now seen as an expansive state in its own right power and to bring to the fore a consideration of ideology
(see Lumbreras 1974:151–152; Schreiber 1992:72–79). and ideological power in the colonial situation. I shall con-
Wari research can be conveniently divided into three sider archaeological manifestations of imperial ideologies
general areas: material culture, the capital, and provincial in the case of the Wari Empire in general and evidence of
sites or occupations. Menzel’s (1964, 1968) detailed work local belief systems in the Sondondo Valley of south-central
on Wari ceramics provided the definition of several differ- Peru. Along the way I shall also provide illustrative examples
ent styles, a relative chronology for the Middle Horizon, and from other Andean situations, especially where the Wari data
the basis for later studies of iconography (Cook 1983, 1987, are weak or inadequate. My purpose is as much to suggest
1992, 1994, 1996; Isbell and Cook 1987; Knobloch 2000). fruitful lines of inquiry as it is to offer evidence in specific
Distinctive forms of Wari architecture have also received Andean cases.
comparative study (Cook 2001; Schreiber 1978; Spickard This discussion takes its inspiration from a series of
1983). Results of excavations at Huari, from the 1930s to questions posed by Carla Sinopoli in her 2001 article
the present, have been only sporadically published (e.g., “Empires” (Sinopoli 2001:458–459). In the case of empires,
Isbell et al. 1991; González Carré et al. 1996). Due in part she notes that ideology may be used to justify and legitimize
to terrorist activity in the 1980s and 1990s, this site has not imposed or altered political structures and reformulation of
yet received the level of intensive research that it deserves. social relations. She asks,
Investigations outside the Wari core have been aimed pri-
marily at specific Wari sites in provincial regions, includ- How are preexisting belief systems of various incor-
porated areas affected by imperial imposition: Are
ing Honco Pampa in the north (Isbell 1991), Azángaro near
they incorporated into imperial ideologies, suppressed,
Huari (Anders 1986), Jincamocco in the south (Schreiber or do they become media for resistance to empire?
1992), Pikillaqta near Cuzco (McEwan 1987), and Cerro How are imperial ideologies expressed materially . . . :
Baúl in the far south (Moseley et al. 1991; Williams and Isla in monuments . . . iconography, prestige goods or ritual
2002), among others. Several of these sites have been re- practices? How are these beliefs and their material cor-
gionally contextualized with the addition of archaeological relates expressed at the imperial center and in various
subject territories? Are regional practices, practitioners,
surveys designed to clarify their roles within local regions or deities brought to the imperial center . . . ? Are dis-
(e.g., McEwan 1987; Schreiber 1987, 1992; Williams 2001). tinctively imperial sacred monuments and iconography
Paralleling some of the research cited above in the Inca imposed upon or adopted in incorporated territories?
case, much of my own work on Wari has been devoted to un- [Sinopoli 2001:459].
derstanding aspects of political and economic manipulation
in the provinces. On the basis of my excavations of the Wari I would rephrase these questions as follows: (1) How are
site of Jincamocco in 1976–77 and a regional survey under- imperial ideologies expressed materially at the imperial
taken in the Sondondo Valley in 1981,2 I concluded that the center and/or within the culture of the dominant society?
Wari occupation was one of relatively direct control, involv- (2) How are local belief systems expressed materially and
ing heavy investment in an imperial infrastructure including how can we identify them? (3) How are imperial ideolo-
a major administrative center, several satellite centers, and a gies materially expressed in conquered territories? (4) How
road. Local settlements were relocated to lower elevations, are local belief systems affected by imperial conquest? (5)
and the valley was extensively terraced, leading me to ar- How do imperial ideological strategies change in conquered
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 135

territories? (6) How can local belief systems be used as a space and architecture have also been identified at Huari,
form of resistance to imperial control? especially in the form of D-shaped temples (Cook 2001;
I advise the reader at the outset that it is not my intent to González Carré et al. 1996). The Templo Mayor at Huari has
explore every permutation of and possible answer to these an interesting history that indicates a progression from open
questions; rather I shall strive to proceed along lines of evi- access to restricted use. Initially (and perhaps long before
dence that seem most fruitful in my specific case study. My the founding of the city of Huari), a large U-shaped mound
response to the first question lies in citing the work of others was built in this place. The D-shaped temple was built within
and will therefore be brief. Much of the focus of this chapter the wings of the U, thus reorienting and restricting the focus
lies in attempting to address the next three questions. The of activity. At some later date the open side of the U was
fifth question probably cannot be satisfactorily answered us- walled off, thus limiting access to the temple; finally a large
ing data from the Wari occupation of Sondondo or of any compound wall with a single entrance was erected around
other region within the Wari sphere, but I do think we can the temple complex, restricting access even more.
anticipate a general answer to it. Finally, there is a very in- Also within Huari’s ritual precinct are found complexes
teresting example to be taken from the Sondondo Valley, of underground galleries, whose function remains unclear,
although from a later time period, that partially addresses and a series of stone slab structures that may represent funer-
the final question. ary structures of high-ranking individuals (Cook 2001:162).
Isbell has recently argued that many architectural forms here
and at Conchopata, a nearby Wari site, are tombs that con-
How Are Imperial Ideologies Expressed Materially at the form to a variety of types (Isbell 2004).
Imperial Center and/or Within the Culture of the An interesting and notable aspect of Wari feasting, or rit-
Dominant Society? ual drinking, has been brought to light by Patricia Knobloch
(2000). She has identified many depictions of the hallu-
Sinopoli (2001) suggests a wide range of evidence in- cinogenic plant Anadenanthera colubrina in both Wari and
cluding portraiture and inscriptions, ritual space and archi- Tiwanaku iconography. It is seen on ritually smashed vessels
tecture, prestige goods, and iconography that might inform on which are depicted Wari elites, perhaps shamans, in elab-
us on this topic. DeMarrais et al. identify materialized forms orate dress. Unlike at Tiwanaku, where the plant was ground
of state ideology, including Moche burial practices, sym- into powder and snuffed, she suggests that in Wari culture
bolic objects, and monumental architecture (DeMarrais et al. A. colubrina was added to chicha (corn beer) to enhance its
1996:24–27), plus Inca feasting, symbolic objects, and ar- effect in Wari rituals.
chitecture of power (DeMarrais et al. 1996:27–30). Much of the architecture at Huari may be said to be an
In the case of Wari we can identify a clear iconography architecture of power and intimidation (see DeMarrais et al.
of power (Cook 1994), expressed in a figure usually called 1996:29 for a discussion of Inca architecture of power). Im-
the staff deity. The staff deity is typically depicted in a full- mense, imposing rectangular compounds, up to three stories
bodied frontal view; he wears an elaborate headdress and tall and with few entrances, were designed to keep people
tunic, his arms extend out to either side, and he holds a long at a distance rather than to welcome them in. This is an in-
vertical staff in each hand. Secondary beings are often de- teresting contrast with Tiwanaku, where state iconography
picted as well, viewed in profile and combining human traits is displayed in open, accessible areas; no open public areas
(head, body, arms, legs) with avian traits (wings, beaks). have been identified at Huari.
Although the best-known example is seen at the so-called
Gateway of the Sun at Tiwanaku, the staff deity has great
antiquity in the Andes extending back at least as early as How Are Local Belief Systems Expressed Materially and
the Chavı́n culture of the Early Horizon (800–200 B.C.). The How Can We Identify Them?
use of this symbol by a dominant society evoked memories
of times past and would have left no doubt in the mind of As in the case of imperial ideologies, we can look to
any Andean native that it represented social and/or political monuments, ritual spaces, architecture, iconography, and so
power. Wari iconography is depicted on media such as ce- on to seek evidence of local belief systems; in the present
ramics and textiles, prestige goods that could be transported case I propose to look to places that might form components
around the empire. of a local sacred landscape. Here I find it useful to follow
While Wari portraiture is not yet well defined, if indeed Tuan and make a distinction between space and place. Space
it existed, Anita Cook (1992, 1996) has been able to identify is abstract physical space, defined by location and configura-
canons of royal dress and hierarchy in Wari imagery. Ritual tion, while places have meaning, based on experience (direct
136 Katharina Schreiber

or indirect) and/or knowledge (intimate or conceptual) (Tuan only any god or idol, but also all places of worship, such as
1977). While it is unlikely that we shall ever know precisely temples, graves, and any other place that was venerated and
what meanings were ascribed to particular places by people where sacrifices were made” (Cobo 1990:10).
of the distant past, we can attempt to identify places that Contemporary ritual life in the Sondondo Valley in-
were meaningful, based on characteristics that differentiate volves indirectly or directly particular and significant places
them from other sites or locations in a region, as I discuss in on the landscape, beyond the boundaries or architecture of
more detail below. individual towns (Figure 8.2). Public rituals often include the
At this juncture I should like to consider evidence of making of offerings to significant mountain peaks (catego-
indigenous sacred landscapes in the Sondondo Valley, pro- rized as apus) in the surrounding mountains, including snow-
ceeding from the recent to the distant past. My purpose in capped Qarwarazu to the east of the valley, snow-capped Sara
considering sacred landscapes in the Sondondo Valley is not Sara to the south, and a three-tiered rock formation called
to project contemporary or historic landscapes onto the past Usjunta on the puna to the west of the valley. On rare oc-
but rather to open our eyes to the richness and vibrancy casions offerings are also offered to Coropuna, an immense
of the native landscape and to consider that even in times snow-capped mountain lying a much greater distance to the
perhaps beyond our grasp the landscape was replete with south. These apus are revered by members of multiple com-
special places and meanings. I begin with the contemporary munities in the Sondondo Valley and sometimes by groups
use of the landscape and places revered as special or sacred. in other regions as well. It is notable that these mountains
I then consider the 16th century, for which Spanish docu- are not visible from any of the communities within the valley
ments present a wealth of data on huacas—sacred places or and can only be seen when one climbs to higher elevations.
things—in this region. Finally I turn to archaeological data The points at which these features become visible as one as-
informed by recent theoretical approaches to landscapes and cends may also be characterized as special places. Along the
monuments to identify possible prehispanic huacas. I should old trail from Andamarca to Cabana lies a pair of chapels,
note that huaca is a term used at present, but it was also used one abandoned, the other recently built, located at the point
in the past. Cobo, writing in 1653, defines a huaca as “not at which one can see Qarwarazu. Each shrine is a small

Figure 8.2. Map of the Sondondo Valley and environs showing modern towns and sacred
peaks.
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 137

(roughly 3 × 3 meters), single-chambered, roofed structure, Sondondo Valley, discovered a nativistic movement called
with an open side facing the trail; a Catholic cross hangs on Taki Onqoy. Roughly translated as “dance sickness,” this
the back wall of the newer chapel. was an indigenous form of rebellion against the Spanish
In addition to the apus, each contemporary commu- and in particular the Catholic Church. Beginning in 1570,
nity in the Sondondo Valley reveres a particular place on the cleric Cristóbal de Albornoz made a series of journeys
the landscape that is not shared with other groups; these through the regions involved in the movement, including the
places are generally referred to as wamanis. Most of these are Sondondo Valley, in an effort to exterminate pagan idolatry
smaller peaks, such as Huachuaycerca (Aucará), Jampatilla once and for all. He produced a series of reports listing the
(Huaycahuacho), and Larigoto (Cabana Sur), and each oc- practitioners of the cult and their punishments and then listed
cupies a prominent position on the landscape as viewed from many of the places and objects of pagan worship, termed
its particular community (i.e., those indicated in parenthe- huacas (Albornoz 1990a, 1990b). He also wrote an essay
ses). In the case of the village of Sondondo (which gives its explaining how to discover native huacas so that other priests
name to the valley), the place that is revered as significant might carry on the work as needed (Albornoz 1967).
is a large cave, high above the village, called Pukamachay In the case of the valley of the Soras, lying just to the east
(“red cave”). Unlike the other wamanis, Pukamachay is not of the Sondondo Valley, Albornoz listed some 480 named
visible from the village that reveres it. sacred places—huacas and pacariscas (origin places; see
Certain places on the landscape are demarcated by built Hyslop 1990:107)—along with a summary of some 560
stone features. Large piles of accumulated small stones are idols of various types (Albornoz 1990b:264–278). In the
found adjacent to major trails leading out of the valley at case of the Sondondo Valley, then called the province of
high passes along the route; these heaps of stones are called Apcara, he provided the total number of huacas (708) but
apachetas. Travelers walking along a trail carry with them a did not name them nor distinguish between places and idols
small stone, which they leave on the apacheta as they pass; it (Albornoz 1990b:292–294). If, based on comparison with
is said that in so doing one leaves one’s fatigue behind. Other Soras, we calculate that at least one-third of these huacas re-
stone features called saywa mark sacred ground. Saywa are fer to places, then we can conservatively estimate that there
rather precarious columns of medium-sized stones made by were well over 200 named sacred places in the Sondondo
carefully setting one stone on top of another until the column Valley in the 16th century. Each huaca was owed service,
attains a height of one to one and a half meters. One cluster possessed lands, animals, and clothing, and had a particular
of saywa can be seen near the old Inca road as it ascends out set of sacrifices and offerings that were made to it (Albornoz
of the Sondondo Valley toward the southwest; in this case 1967:20). From this brief summary we can surmise that the
there are a dozen or more saywa scattered over a low rise. 16th-century landscape was alive with meaning, with a mul-
Several saywa are also present on the highest tier of Usjunta. titude of huacas, each playing a role in the ritual life of the
Other features on the landscape are defined as huacas, people of Sondondo.
or places with special meaning. Between the villages of Albornoz’s documents also tell us that the apus revered
Huaycahuacho and Ishua is an odd tract of land measuring today were worshipped in the 16th century and earlier.
about two square kilometers in extent that is relatively level Qarwarazu is listed among the huacas of two villages in
with a series of small low hills covered with thorn bushes. the Soras Valley, Usjunta was also worshipped, and Sara
Unlike most other tracts of land at moderate elevations within Sara was sacred to the Parinacochas (Albornoz 1967:28–29,
the valley, none of this zone is under cultivation. According 1990b). Apachetas accumulated then much as they do to-
to local oral traditions, this zone and its atypical appearance day (Albornoz 1967:19). He also noted that the Incas often
were the result of a major landslide that buried an ancient re-edified the major huacas, especially snow-capped peaks
city. The source of this landslide can be seen in the sheer and volcanoes of the western cordillera, providing them with
cliffs on the south face of the nearby ridge, although there servants, animals, and gold and silver vessels. In this con-
are no archaeological traces of a buried city. Within this zone text he mentioned specifically Sara Sara and several peaks
are a large boulder and a nearby pond, both of which are re- to the south, including Coropuna and Ampato (Albornoz
garded as huacas today, and on the ridge above is an oddly 1967:20–21). Inca human sacrifices have been located on
formed boulder that is revered as a huaca by the residents of the summits of each of these peaks (Reinhard 1992) as has
Huaycahuacho. Inca ritual activity on Coropuna (Reinhard 1999). To date no
Proceeding back in time to the 16th century, we have a investigations have taken place on Qarwarazu, but we might
wealth of data pertaining to sacred places and objects in this entertain the possibility that it follows the pattern of the other
region available to us. In 1564 or 1565 a Spanish cleric in snow-capped peaks in the western cordillera and may have
Parinacochas, the province immediately to the south of the an Inca human sacrifice on its summit.
138 Katharina Schreiber

Turning to archaeological investigations of the late pre- site at any given time may increase or decrease. The creation
hispanic period in the Sondondo Valley, there is evidence of a monument may make a place more visible, in a very lit-
that the Incas established an imperial presence at Usjunta; eral sense, or it may add layers of symbolism to an existing
an Inca-style platform of finely cut stone was placed on the sacred place.
lowest tier of the three-tiered formation. In 2003 another As we have seen in the preceding discussion of huacas
Inca platform was discovered at Qorihuayrachina, a peak in the Sondondo Valley and its environs, such meaningful
on the continental divide between Sondondo and the Pa- places may be natural places or monuments, using Bradley’s
cific watershed (Ccencho 2004). Two other Inca features in terms. Both are sacred locations, but monuments are dis-
the valley may be located relative to meaningful points on tinguished by having been modified in some physical sense
the landscape. A cut-stone platform was placed along the by human activity. Unmodified boulders, lakes, mountain
Inca road adjacent to a natural spring; this platform may peaks, and even the badlands near Huaycahuacho are consid-
be an usnu, a symbol of Inca power. Usnus were often lo- ered huacas locally and would fall into Bradley’s category of
cated in proximity to water features such as canals or drains natural places. Monuments include the apachetas and saywa
(Hyslop 1990:100–101). A single Inca building situated of the present, Inca platforms situated on sacred peaks, and
within the local town of Apcara (old Aucará) was placed the Inca usnu near Apcara. In attempting to identify huacas
next to a very large, prominent stone (Schreiber 1992:92– in the more distant past I would add several other criteria to
98). Stones were often regarded as huacas by the Incas (van those elaborated by Bradley. First, evidence of repeated use
de Guchte 1999:156), and the idiosyncratic form of this un- of a huaca may have significant time depth. That is, while
worked stone conforms to what van de Guchte has identified site locations and settlement patterns may change radically
as an “aesthetic of alterity,” being a sort of anomaly in the as a result of changes in political or economic organization
natural order (1999:166). of a region, the veneration of a huaca may transcend or be
As we continue our way into the pre-Inca past, we can immune to such changes. Second, huacas may show artificial
no longer rely on contemporary observations and historic modification in patterned and consistent ways. Third, huacas
documents. Moreover we cannot project what we know of may be located in places that have good views of significant
the recent past directly on the distant past. Rather, we might other places or may be placed in prominent locations where
attempt to develop some methodologies for discerning what they can be seen from many places and by many people.
sorts of places might have been meaningful, even sacred, in Following Bradley (2000:106), significant natural places in
the past. Bradley’s (1993, 1998, 2000) elucidation of mon- prominent locations may become even more visible when
uments and their significance (and not least of all their ar- transformed into monuments. And fourth, huacas may be
chaeological identification) in prehistoric Europe provides marked in some way by later or intrusive groups, or even
us with some potentially fruitful avenues of inquiry. He empires, as we have seen above in the case of the Incas.
points out that there exist numerous “natural places” on the Turning again to archaeological data from the Sondondo
landscape, in various cultural contexts, that held particular Valley, and considering pre-Inca periods, several features or
significance for people of the distant past (Bradley 2000:35– sites stand out as having had special significance. Several dis-
36). Such natural places are not construed as monuments tinctively modified boulders have been documented in the
because they are not physically altered by human action, but Sondondo Valley and its two southern tributaries. Carved
they do “have an archaeology because they acquired a signif- on these stones are miniature agricultural terraces and/or
icance in the minds of people in the past” (Bradley 2000:35). water channels (Figure 8.3). Some stones show only water
Archaeological evidence of such significance may include channels, other only terraces, but some combine both into
the presence of offerings associated with the place or alter- elaborate models of agricultural systems. While the carv-
ation of nearby areas, including through the use of rock art ing of the stones cannot be precisely dated, the association
(Bradley 2000:37–39). Such places might also be oriented of these stones with particular sites or places in the valley
to local topography, footpaths, cardinal directions, or with suggests that they date to the Late Intermediate Period (LIP)
respect to some sort of ritual axis (Tilley 1994:123–136, (A.D. 1000–1476). Six stones are located in or very near to
159–166). the town of Apcara, which was occupied through the LIP and
Over time such natural places might be altered in subtle then served as the Inca base of operations in the Late Hori-
(or not so subtle) ways by human activity such that they be- zon (A.D. 1476–1532). One stone is located across the valley
come monuments, in Bradley’s (2000:104–107) terms. The adjacent to another LIP site. Three such stones are found
construction of a monument alters the ways in which a place in the Mayobamba tributary of the valley, an area devoid
is experienced. Access to the site, as well as movement within of occupation until the LIP (Ccencho 2004). Some small
it, may be more constrained; numbers of people using the terrace-like carvings in the Negromayo tributary may be
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 139

Figure 8.3. A carved boulder, probably a prehispanic huaca, on the east flank of the Sondondo Valley.

associated with the LIP occupation there. The carved boul- Ccencho (1991); we were both struck by the unique features
ders are similar in many respects to maquetas (models) stud- of the site.
ied by van de Guchte (1990) in Cuzco and virtually identi- In a flat area just below the south flank of the mound
cal to those studied by Brooks (1998) in the Colca Valley; the excavation of an irrigation ditch has exposed a dense de-
Brooks (1998:287–292) cogently argues that the maquetas posit of ceramics, lithics, ash, and bone. The artifacts range
of Colca date to the LIP. in style from the earliest to the latest ceramic periods; we
In addition to these carved boulders and various large find it significant that this is the only site in the valley at
unmodified stones like the one adjacent to the Inca building which ceramic artifacts of all prehispanic periods are found.
at Apcara, there is at least one archaeological site that also It is possible that the artifacts are the result of offerings of
stands out as having had special meaning. The site of Piru- smashed ceramic vessels being made at the site. However,
ruyoq (“place of spindle weights”) is located on the crest of a the presence of lithics along with ash and bone suggests that
ridge that rises gradually up the valley side; above the site the food was prepared and consumed at the site. I suspect that
ridge rises precipitously to a major promontory called Tuqsa. ritual feasting activities took place at this site repeatedly over
Piruruyoq is a roughly circular mound with stone retaining the years.
walls around portions of its perimeter (Figure 8.4). This site The unique nature of this site, considering its form, lack
appears to be a natural hill modified by human efforts giv- of domestic architecture, and evidence of repeated ritual use
ing it a somewhat stepped profile. There are traces of curved over many centuries, if not millennia, is evidence that it
walls and perhaps one or more tombs on its summit. There is carried some special meaning (see Bradley 2000:37) and
no evidence of domestic architecture at the site. The site was served as a local shrine of some sort. But what was the na-
recorded in 1981 during my regional survey of Sondondo ture or source of its special meaning? Here I consider three
(Schreiber 1992) and again in 1991 by archaeologist José possibilities. First, the site itself may have been considered
140 Katharina Schreiber

Figure 8.4. The site of Piruruyoq seen from above, along the trail to Tuqsa. Note the circular plan and traces of architecture on the
summit of the mound. The site of Leqles Pata can be seen in the distance, as can the trail the follows the crest of the ridge.

intrinsically sacred. It may have begun its sacred life as a raised platforms, encircled by retaining walls and separated
revered natural place, later modified in shape with the cre- by a depression; 120 meters to the east, occupying the rest
ation of a stepped profile and the addition of perimeter re- of the ridge above this point, is a large defensive LIP site.
taining walls. The raised platforms may be associated with that site and
Second, the location of the site with respect to views thus LIP in date. However, a collection of surface artifacts
of other sacred places may have imbued it with meaning on and around the platforms yielded ceramics dating to the
(Figure 8.5). The site is located on a ridge with clear views Middle Horizon and earlier, suggesting that the Tuqsa plat-
to the north, west, and south. It overlooks the odd tract of forms formed part of the cultural landscape in those earlier
land said to have resulted from a landslide, discussed above, times. Tuqsa has the earmarkings of a shrine or huaca.
as well as the boulder and lake that are regarded as huacas To reach Piruruyoq from the valley below, one follows
today. Also visible from Piruruyoq, and located farther down a well-marked trail along the crest of the ridge; the trail
the same ridge, is the oddly formed boulder revered today as curves around the south side of the site. The site can also
a huaca. be reached by climbing the steeper north side of the ridge,
A third possibility is that Piruruyoq is not a sacred site in although no trails ascend this side in the direction of the
and of itself but rather a monument to another sacred place site; the southern flank of the ridge is too steep to climb in
farther up the same ridge: Tuqsa. When viewed from the most places. Above Piruruyoq the ridge rises precipitously
north or south, Tuqsa appears simply as a high flat ridge that and one begins a painfully steep climb to reach the summit at
suddenly drops off steeply to the west. However, viewed Tuqsa. The only way to climb to Tuqsa is to follow this ridge,
from the west, Tuqsa is a prominent high, pointed peak and one cannot make the ascent without passing adjacent to
(Figure 8.6). From any point on the ridge below, including Piruruyoq. The positioning of Piruruyoq may have trans-
from Piruruyoq, Tuqsa maintains this imposing profile. On formed access to Tuqsa, changing and restructuring the
what appears from below to be its summit are two large ovoid movement of people and so altering the character of the
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 141

Figure 8.5. The Sondondo Valley with Wari sites and other places mentioned in the text.

experience (see Bradley 2000:104). Feasting activities at ology to a large audience, and it has been proposed that
Piruruyoq may have been part of the rituals involved in mak- one of the most effective ways to do so is to give ideolo-
ing a procession to Tuqsa. gies concrete form—that is, to materialize them (DeMarrais
Regardless of which of these interpretations, if any, ex- et al. 1996). Ceremonies or rituals, symbolic objects, iconog-
plains the special nature of Piruruyoq, it is clear to me that raphy, and writing can all convey ideological information,
it was an important place within the sacred landscape of the providing leaders with an effective suite of tools for broad-
Sondondo Valley, a local shrine of sorts, and that it main- casting and legitimizing social power. The manipulation of
tained this role for a very long time. symbols and ceremonial activities is an important element
of the maintenance of ideology and the expression of power
How Are Imperial Ideologies Materially Expressed in (e.g., Brumfiel 1998). When examining the expression of
Conquered Territories? imperial ideologies in conquered territories, a number of
categories of material culture, including ritual architecture,
For the conquered, imperial expansion generally results iconography, portable sacred objects, and site location, must
in the imposition of new political and economic structures, be considered.
and the propagation of a state ideology is one way for an em- In some instances, objects sacred to a conquered people
pire to legitimize and maintain these new hierarchies. Those may be brought to the imperial capital. While this might
in power must devise a means of communicating their ide- serve to integrate the rituals of provincial areas into imperial
142 Katharina Schreiber

Figure 8.6. Photograph of Tuqsa, viewed from below, showing imposing profile.

practices, it can also be seen as an act of hostage-taking, Wari, the replication in conquered areas of the ritual features
compelling conquered groups to submit to imperial control. known from the heartland of the empire is likely an indication
Although we have no direct evidence of such a practice in that ideology was being used to bring those areas under state
the case of Wari, we do know from documentary sources authority. D-shaped temples have been identified at Huari
that the Incas appropriated sacred objects from conquered and at sites in its immediate environs, including Conchopata
groups and removed them to Cuzco (Cobo 1990:7). and Ñawimpuquio. Outside the Wari heartland they have
Wari iconography often communicates information been identified in a number of regions subsumed under Wari
about hierarchy, both sacred and secular, and ideologically imperial control: sites with D-shaped temples include Honco
imbued images disseminated to provincial areas could serve Pampa in the north, Yako in the Soras Valley just to the east of
as both models for and sanctions of Wari government (Isbell the Sondondo Valley, and Cerro Baúl in the far south (Cook
and Cook 1987). Moreover, iconography can help to mark the 2001:150–154).
political boundaries of the empire and to mask earlier stylis- In the case of the Sondondo Valley (Schreiber 1992),
tic affiliations (Cook 1983). The adoption of the imperial five Wari sites have been identified to date,3 four of which
iconographic pantheon in provincial areas under Wari con- seem to have played roles in the political dominance of
trol suggests that ideology was being used to integrate these the valley and its economic reorganization (see Figure 8.5).
areas (Cook 1987). There is ample evidence for the distribu- Jincamocco, centrally located and built first, probably served
tion of Wari imperial iconography in the form of portable me- as a regional capital. A secondary political center is found at
dia, especially ceramics and textiles (see Schreiber 2001:92). the site of Era Mocco, to the north. At the northeast extreme
Ritual architecture, as a materialized manifestation of of the valley, where a major road enters from the north, lies
ritual practice, can provide information about ideology and the site of Mamacha Corral4 ; this site may have been placed
the nature of social power (Moore 1996). In the case of the to control access into and out of the valley and perhaps to
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 143

exploit the small Jampatilla obsidian source located near the pretation necessarily moves beyond aspects of Wari political
site. On the east side of the valley, across from Jincamocco, and economic power. It is clear to me that it played a role in
is the site of Culluma, which probably served to store agri- the ritual life of this valley in ways that the other four sites
cultural produce. Middle Horizon ceramics of Wari and local did not. Moreover, its location with respect to Piruruyoq and
styles have been found at all these sites, and excavations at Tuqsa may be especially significant, reinforcing the posited
Jincamocco have produced ceramics with images of a Wari ritual nature of the site, as I will discuss below.
iconography.
Jincamocco, a 3.5-hectare rectangular enclosure, fol-
lows the same canons as the compounds at Huari, and I How Are Local Belief Systems Affected by Imperial
argue that this imperial style can be characterized as an ar- Conquest?
chitecture of power. There are very few entrances to the
probably multistoried enclosure at Jincamocco, and once Imperial ideologies and rituals must be conceived so
inside one must take a circuitous route, blindly following as to work in concert with existing beliefs and prac-
long corridors, to reach open spaces and patio activity areas tices (Carneiro 1992), which, consequently, are frequently
(Schreiber 1978). The sites of Era Mocco, Mamacha Corral, co-opted or transformed to meet the needs of the state
and Culluma also appear to be built in this style, although (Conrad 1992; Joyce 1997). It is clear that conquest often
their current state of preservation precludes mapping them in results in changes in local belief systems, but the changes
detail. Wari architecture is a complete departure from local brought about by imperial occupation may take a variety of
Sondondo-style architecture, which consists of single-unit forms. An empire may attempt to suppress or eliminate lo-
round houses. Wari architecture is thus distinguished by its cal beliefs, it may co-opt local beliefs, or it may incorporate
form, control of movement into and within the complex, and local beliefs into imperial ideologies.
imposing nature, and I would argue that it forms one material Given the potential power inherent in local belief sys-
element of Wari ideology in conquered territories. tems, an empire may deem it necessary to suppress them or
A fifth site, Leqles Pata,5 is distinguished from the other to attempt to eliminate them altogether. If certain beliefs or
Wari sites by virtue of unique aspects of its architecture and practices are threatening to or inconsistent with those of the
its location (Figure 8.7). Like the other sites in this valley, it empire, they might have to be eliminated completely. Such a
appears to have a compound built in Wari style, although this strategy also would permit an empire to standardize behavior
compound is by far the smallest, measuring only 30 × 50 across its territory and to give a common ritual vocabulary
meters. However, unlike the other sites, traces of Wari ritual to newly conquered groups with differing and potentially
architecture, in the form of at least two D-shaped temples and conflicting beliefs.
three or more stone slab tombs, have been identified at this Eradicating local practices and beliefs and replacing
site. To date no such stone slab tombs have been located at them with new ones can be a costly strategy, in both eco-
any other Wari provincial sites, although there are a number nomic and social terms. An empire might choose instead
of them at Huari, as discussed above. The presence of these to co-opt existing local beliefs and to manipulate them for
tombs at Leqles Pata has led Isbell to suggest that the site their own benefit. This would permit an empire to take ad-
might be “the estate of a Huari monarch whose relatives were vantage of the legitimizing power of traditional beliefs while
eventually buried there” (2004:18). Such an interpretation, lessening the imperial investment required to establish con-
based solely on the presence of the stone slab tombs, must be trol. At Ingapirca in Ecuador, for example, a large boulder
approached cautiously, considering our current knowledge that may have been sacred to the Cañari was encapsulated
of Wari provincial occupations. At present we cannot discern by a major Inca construction, suggesting to Dennis Ogburn
any pattern in the location or context of such structures in the (personal communication, 2004) that the Incas may have
provinces, since they only occur at a single site; additionally, been co-opting an existing Cañari shrine.
there is yet no evidence that Wari monarchs had royal estates Many researchers have noted that states commonly
like their later Inca counterparts. appropriate or manipulate the deities, beliefs, and ritual
When we consider this site in its spatial and cultural practices of conquered populations (e.g., Conrad 1992;
context in the Sondondo Valley I think we can arrive at a Joyce 1997; Sinopoli 1994). Previous research on empires,
more tenable interpretation. Temples and tombs have not and on the Wari Empire in particular, has established that
been identified at any of the other Wari sites in this valley, al- existing political and economic structures in the area of
though a Colonial Period document reports stone slab tombs conquest were frequently co-opted by the empire (Schreiber
near Jincamocco. Leqles Pata is unique among the Wari sites 1987, 1992, 2001), and we might expect that belief systems
in this valley by virtue of its ritual architecture, and its inter- would have been subject to a similar strategy of co-option.
144 Katharina Schreiber

Figure 8.7. Photograph of Leqles Pata, taken from above. The Wari compound and the locations of D-shaped temples and stone slab
tombs are noted.

As the Wari conquered new territory, local practices were I suspect, however, that the establishment of Leqles Pata
often adjusted to suit the imperial agenda (Cook 2001; in this location was intended to disrupt or alter the indige-
Lumbreras 1974). nous use of their sacred landscape. The ritual experience of
Returning to the Sondondo Valley and to the ridge on using the shrine at Piruruyoq would have included not just
which Piruruyoq is located, we find that Leqles Pata is also feasting activities and perhaps the making of offerings there
located on the same ridge, along the trail that ascends the but also the ascent and descent of the ridge by groups of
crest of the ridge, and that the sites are positioned within people. The presence of Leqles Pata on the ridge below the
sight of each other (see Figure 8.4). The simple presence of shrine thus significantly altered the experiential nature of the
ritual architecture at Leqles Pata may suggest that the Wari ritual use of the shrine. In order to reach Piruruyoq from the
placed their constructions on a meaningful place or huaca. valley below one ascends a long trail along the spine of the
It may have been an existing huaca that Wari co-opted, or ridge, a trek of a little less than one hour. Ascending from
the Wari may have newly defined this place as sacred. Al- Piruruyoq to Tuqsa requires at least another hour or so. Af-
ternatively, we might regard the spatial relationship between ter the establishment of the Wari site at Leqles Pata, about
Piruruyoq and Leqles Pata as representing not just the phys- 15 minutes from Piruruyoq, individuals had to pass through
ical articulation of two places but also the articulation of a the Wari site to reach either Piruruyoq or Tuqsa. While the
Wari imperial ideology with the local belief system. Like Wari site did not block access to those sites, as evidenced
Piruruyoq, Leqles Pata has an excellent view of Tuqsa, as by the presence of Middle Horizon local ceramics at both
well as of huacas below, so in one sense it mimics the set- sites, it may have delayed or detoured peoples’ ascent of
ting of the local shrine. Perhaps Wari was simply sharing the ridge. The need to pass through the imperial site might
in the use of a local sacred landscape, adopting local belief have been intended to send the message to the people that
systems. their activities, even religious activities, were subject to the
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 145

control of the empire. As Cooney (1994:33) notes, the con- ple of conquered provinces. For example, in the Inca case,
trol of sacred actions may be a key component of social in southern Peru the Incas co-opted the sacred snow-capped
power, and I believe that this is just such a case. peaks by placing their own human sacrificial offerings on the
summit of each one (Reinhard 1992). An empire may reinter-
pret the local landscape in its own (imperial) terms, as well
How Do Imperial Ideological Strategies Change in as exploit the ways in which it differs from region to region.
Conquered Territories? Certain landscapes or landscape features may be considered
special, and empires may seek out those places. Spiritual or
Strategies of control and the imposition of economic, ideological power may be thought to exist at certain places
political, and ideological power change along two dimen- on the landscape, and control of those places may allow lead-
sions, temporal and spatial. As Cobo states, regarding the ers to capture that power and to use it to legitimize their own
case of the Incas, “from the beginning of their empire the authority (Allsen 1996; Arnold 2002). The Incas considered
Incas were not always steadfast in their religion, nor did certain natural features, including mountains, rock forma-
they maintain the same opinions and worship the same tions, and springs, to be sacred, and they often placed their
gods. . . . They were prompted to make . . . changes because sites near these places (Hyslop 1990:125–128, 142–145; van
they realized that in this way they improved their control de Guchte 1999). As we have seen above, in the Sondondo
over the kingdom and kept it more subservient” (1990:5). Valley we find cut-stone platforms on or near sacred peaks,
Most empires vary their strategies of conquest and con- an usnu platform near a natural spring, and an Inca building
trol as they are faced with different problems in different placed adjacent to a unique rock formation. These are con-
parts of the empire, and resulting forms of political and eco- structions adapted to unique and specific places in the local
nomic control are tailored to specific local circumstances landscape.
(Schreiber 1987, 1992). Although imperial ideologies may Given these examples it seems entirely likely that the
be imposed with little modification, it is also possible that Wari adapted forms of ideological control to specific situa-
their ideological strategies change as empires expand into tions, much as they did their exercise of political and eco-
conquered territories, much like their political and economic nomic power. Once we have availed ourselves of suitable
strategies. Ideological forms of power may have been modi- data from other provincial contexts we may be able to begin
fied to accommodate, incorporate, or eliminate local beliefs, to address this question more directly.
depending on local circumstances.
Paralleling arguments I have made before regarding po-
litical hierarchies, an imperial ideology may simply be im- How Can Local Belief Systems Be Used as a Form of
posed wholesale, with no alteration. In this case, the imperial Resistance to Imperial Control?
ideology would not undergo any formal change at all. If an
empire chooses to co-opt local beliefs, however, the imperial At present I do not believe that we have enough data on
ideology as well as the local belief system might be subject local belief systems to be able to suggest how they might have
to some degree of modification or transformation. As lo- been used as a form of resistance to Wari control, although I
cal and imperial beliefs articulate, imperial ideology might have great hopes that we may be able to begin to address this
change to incorporate the new belief systems of conquered issue in the future. But rather than leave this question com-
areas. As the Incas conquered new groups, for example, they pletely unanswered, I would like to return to the Taki Onqoy
incorporated important local places and landscapes into the movement of the 16th century in the Sondondo Valley.
sacred geography of the empire (Niles 1992). Taki Onqoy presents us with a clear case of native re-
Imperial ideologies might also be added to the local sistance against Spanish rule using elements of local be-
belief system. Local belief systems may have been insuffi- lief systems (Millones 1990). After the successful capture
ciently institutionalized to be a significant challenge to im- of the Inca emperor in 1532 and the subsequent collapse
perial control, and these local practices may simply have of much of the Inca Empire, the Spanish found themselves
been supplemented with the ideology of the empire. In the by the second half of the 16th century faced with overt,
Andes, for example, the Incas allowed conquered groups to physical resistance on the part of the remaining Incas in the
continue to worship their own deities but required that the Vilcabamba region north of Cuzco. The Spanish perceived
Inca god be placed at the apex of the pantheon (Van Buren this as a military threat and responded accordingly. Unbe-
2000). knownst to them, however, there was a very different kind
In turn, imperial strategies may be modified to address of rebellion brewing in what are today parts of southern
specific local circumstances and practices unique to the peo- Ayacucho and adjacent provinces, including the Sondondo
146 Katharina Schreiber

Valley. Practitioners of the Taki Onqoy movement (many of the result of a collaboration between myself and one of my
whom were women) were mobilizing the ancient Andean graduate students, Jade Gibson. Jade also presented the pa-
huacas to wage war with the Christian god. Through ritu- per in that venue. All subsequent drafts and revisions have
als involving trances, speaking in tongues, and wild dancing been my responsibility alone, and the final result bears only
(which gives the movement its name: dance sickness), the passing resemblance to the original. I wish to thank Jade
huacas spoke to the people and prepared to fight the Chris- for her efforts and her useful input as I was thinking about
tian god. Here we are confronted with a clear case of the use some of the ideas presented here; however, all comments
of local ideological beliefs to resist imperial control. or criticisms should be directed to me. Figures 8.1 and 8.5
This movement came as quite a surprise to the Spanish are based on maps originally drawn by David Lawson of the
when it was discovered in the 1560s, as they were unfamiliar Anthropology Graphics Laboratory at UCSB. I also thank
with the waging of wars on a supernatural level. They put Drs. Christina Conlee, Dennis Ogburn, and Kevin Vaughn
a stop to it and then sent the cleric Cristóbal de Albornoz for inviting me to participate in the symposium that led to
to root out any last traces of the cult, to severely punish all the creation of this volume and for their exceptional levels of
its practitioners, and to document all the objects and places professionalism in creating the final product. It was an inter-
that still had sacred meaning to the people (Albornoz 1990a, esting turn of events, as they all were once my own students,
1990b), as I have discussed above. It is Albornoz’s written and so we found our roles reversed in some interesting ways;
record, including his lists of sacred places and objects, that I do appreciate the extreme gentleness of their prodding as
provides us with some of our best clues to reconstructing deadlines neared. I thank the AP3A review committee, Jay
local Andean belief systems. I find it somewhat ironic that Johnson, the series editor, and especially Dennis Ogburn for
these useful data are the result of the efforts of an imperial their useful comments on an earlier draft of this chapter; the
society in responding to indigenous ideological resistance final product has certainly benefited from their collective
and its efforts to eliminate local belief systems. wisdom. Many of the ideas presented here were developed
while I was on a year’s sabbatical in Santa Fe, and I must ac-
Conclusions knowledge my boon companions of that year, Lynn Meskell
and Norm Yoffee, and thank them for many hours of fruitful
In this chapter I have argued that it is useful to move discussions. I would also like to thank the Department of
beyond considerations of economic and political forms of Anthropology at the University of New Mexico for appoint-
power in order to arrive at a sense of some of the ways ing me as adjunct faculty for the 2002–03 academic year, thus
that ideology forms a basis for relations of power in impe- providing me with access to many useful resources there.
rial settings. I have used contemporary observations, his-
toric documents, and archaeological remains to try to recon- Notes
struct and understand features of the sacred landscape of the
Sondondo Valley at different points in time. I concluded in 1. In this chapter I use the spelling “Huari” to refer to
earlier publications regarding the Wari Empire’s conquest the site and “Wari” to refer to the culture and empire.
of the Sondondo Valley that they expended great efforts to 2. Prior to about 2000 I referred to the Sondondo Valley
establish a political hierarchy in the valley and reorganize in publications as the Carhuarazo or Carahuarazo Valley.
economic production (Schreiber 1987, 1992). This chapter In about 2000 the valley was officially dubbed the valle de
has moved in a different direction, considering the articu- Sondondo, so I follow this usage here.
lation between Wari ideology and local belief systems. An 3. José Ccencho and I have recently extended the survey
anomalous Wari site, Leqles Pata, seems to have been lo- into the three main tributaries of the Sondondo Valley. No
cated with respect to one or two local shrines in such a way additional Wari sites were located in any of these tributaries.
that it impeded access to those local sacred places. I have 4. This site was called Willkaya in Schreiber 1992.
argued, based on these data, that the Wari used ideological 5. This site was called Anta in Schreiber 1992.
power as a means to control the local populace, much as
it used forms of political and economic control. Wari did References
indeed “mess with people’s minds.”
Albornoz, Cristóbal de
Acknowledgments 1967 [1584] Instrucción para descubrir todas las guacas
del pirú y sus camayos y haziendas. Pierre Duviols,
The original draft of this paper, prepared for presen- ed. Journal de la Société des Américanistes (Paris)
tation at the AAA meetings in New Orleans in 2002, was 56(1):17–39.
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 147

1990a [1584] Información de servicios (Cuzco, 1584). In Brooks, Sarah Osgood


El retorno de las huacas: estudios y documentos 1998 Prehistoric Agricultural Terraces in the Rio Japo
sobre el Taki Onqoy siglo XVI. Luis Millones, ed. Basin, Colca Valley, Peru. Ph.D. dissertation, Uni-
Pp. 203–253. Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos. versity of Wisconsin, Madison.
1990b [1584] Relación de la visita de extirpación de idola-
trı́as. In El retorno de las huacas: estudios y docu- Brumfiel, Elizabeth M.
mentos sobre el Taki Onqoy siglo XVI. Luis Mil- 1998 Huitzilopochtli’s Conquest: Aztec Ideology in the
lones, ed. Pp. 254–296. Lima: Instituto de Estudios Archaeological Record. Cambridge Archaeologi-
Peruanos. cal Journal 8(1):3–13.

Alcock, Susan E. Carneiro, Robert


2002 Archaeologies of the Greek Past: Landscapes, 1992 Point Counterpoint: Ecology and Ideology in the
Monuments, and Memories. Cambridge: Development of New World Civilizations. In Ide-
Cambridge University Press. ology. A. A. Demarest and G. W. Conrad, eds. Pp.
175–204. Santa Fe: School of American Research
Allsen, Thomas T. Press.
1996 Spiritual Geography and Political Legitimacy on
the Eastern Steppe. In Ideology and the Formation Ccencho Huamanı́, José E.
of Early States. Henri J. M. Claessen and Jarich G. 1991 Informe de los estudios arqueológicos del proyecto
Oosten, eds. Pp. 116–135. Leiden: E. J. Brill. “El Periodo Intermedio Tardı́o en la margen
derecha del Rı́o Sondondo, Lucanas–Ayacucho.”
Anders, Martha B. Final report submitted to the Instituto Nacional de
1986 Dual Organization and Calendars Inferred from Cultura, Lima, Peru.
the Planned Site of Azángaro: Wari Administrative 2004 Informe final del proyecto Valle de Sondondo tem-
Strategies. Ph.D. dissertation, Cornell University. porada de 2003. Final report submitted to the Insti-
1989 Evidence for the Dual Socio-Political Organization tuto Nacional de Cultura, Lima, Peru.
and Administrative Structure of the Wari State. In
The Nature of Wari. R. M. Czwarno, F. M. Med- Cobo, Bernabé
dens, and A. Morgan, eds. Pp. 35–52. BAR Interna- 1990 [1653] Inca Religion and Customs. Roland Hamil-
tional Series, 525. Oxford: British Archaeological ton, trans. and ed. Austin: University of Texas
Reports. Press.

Arnold, Bettina Conrad, Geoffrey W.


2002 A Landscape of Ancestors: The Space and Place 1992 Inca Imperialism: The Great Simplification and the
of Death in Iron Age West-Central Europe. In The Accident of Empire. In Ideology. A. A. Demarest
Space and Place of Death. Helaine Silverman and and G. W. Conrad, eds. Pp. 159–174. Santa Fe:
David B. Small, eds. Pp. 129–143. Archeological School of American Research Press.
Papers of the American Anthropological Associa-
tion, 11. Arlington, VA: American Anthropological Cook, Anita G.
Association. 1983 Aspects of State Ideology in Huari and Tiwanaku
Iconography: The Central Deity and the Sacrifi-
Bradley, Richard cer. In Investigations of the Andean Past. Daniel
1993 Altering the Earth: The Origins of Monuments Sandweiss, ed. Pp. 161–183. Ithaca: Cornell Latin
in Britain and Continental Europe. Society of American Studies Program.
Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph, Series 8. 1987 The Middle Horizon Ceramic Offerings from Con-
Edinburgh. chopata. Ñawpa Pacha 22-23:49–90.
1998 The Significance of Monuments: On the Shaping 1992 The Stone Ancestors: Idioms of Imperial Attire and
of Human Experience in Neolithic and Bronze Age Rank among Huari Figurines. Latin American An-
Europe. London: Routledge. tiquity 3:341–364.
2000 An Archaeology of Natural Places. London: 1994 Wari y Tiwanaku: entre el estilo y la imagen. Lima:
Routledge. Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú.
148 Katharina Schreiber

1996 The Emperor’s New Clothes: Symbols of Royalty, Isbell, William H., Christina Brewster-Wray, and Lynda E.
Hierarchy, and Identity. Journal of the Steward An- Spickard
thropological Society 24(1-2):85–120. 1991 Architecture and Spatial Organization at Huari.
2001 Huari D-Shaped Structures, Sacrificial Offerings, In Huari Administrative Structure: Prehistoric
and Divine Rulership. In Ritual Sacrifice in Ancient Monumental Architecture and State Government.
Peru. Elizabeth Benson and Anita Cook, eds. Pp. William H. Isbell and Gordon F. McEwan, eds. Pp.
137–163. Austin: University of Texas Press. 19–53. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks.

Cooney, Gabriel Joyce, Arthur


1994 Sacred and Secular Neolithic Landscapes in Ire- 1997 Ideology, Power and State Formation in the Valley
land. In Sacred Sites, Sacred Places. David L. of Oaxaca. In Emergence and Change in Early Ur-
Carmichael, Jane Hubert, Brian Reeves, and ban Societies. Linda Manzanilla, ed. Pp. 133–168.
Audhild Schanche, eds. Pp. 32–43. London: Rout- New York: Plenum.
ledge.

D’Altroy, Terence N. Knobloch, Patricia J.


1992 Provincial Power in the Inka Empire. Washington, 2000 Wari Ritual Power at Conchopata: An Interpre-
DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. tation of Anadenanthera colubrina Iconography.
Latin American Antiquity 11(4):387–402.
D’Altroy, Terence N., and Christine A. Hastorf
2001 Empire and Domestic Economy. New York: Kluwer Kolata, Alan
Academic/Plenum. 1992 Imperialism in the Andes: Economy, Ideology, and
Imperialism in the South-Central Andes. In Ideol-
Demarest, Arthur A. ogy. A. A. Demarest and G. W. Conrad, eds. Pp.
1992 Ideology in Ancient Maya Cultural Evolution: The 65–86. Santa Fe: School of American Research
Dynamics of Galactic Polities. In Ideology. A. A. Press.
Demarest and G. W. Conrad, eds. Pp. 135–158.
Santa Fe: School of American Research Press. Liverani, Mario
1979 The Ideology of the Assyrian Empire. In Power
DeMarrais, Elizabeth, Luis Jaime Castillo, and Timothy and Propaganda: A Symposium on Ancient Em-
Earle pires. Mogens Trolle Larsen, ed. Pp. 297–317.
1996 Ideology, Materialization, and Power Strategies. Copenhagen: Akademisk Forlag.
Current Anthropology 37(1):15–31.
Lumbreras, Luis G.
González Carré, Enrique, Enrique Bragayrac Dávila, Ciri- 1974 The Peoples and Cultures of Ancient Peru. Betty
lo Vivanco Pomacanchari, Vera Tiesler Blos, and Máximo J. Meggers, trans. Washington, DC: Smithsonian
López Quispe Institution Press.
1996 El Templo Mayor en la ciudad de Wari: estudios ar-
queológicos en Vagachayoq Moqo. Ayacucho: Uni- McEwan, Gordon F.
versidad Nacional de San Cristobal de Huamanga. 1987 The Middle Horizon in the Valley of Cuzco,
Peru: The Impact of the Wari Occupation of the
Hyslop, John Lucre Basin. BAR International Series, 372.
1990 Inka Settlement Planning. New York: Academic. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.
Isbell, William H.
1991 Honcopampa. Expedition 33:27–36. Mann, Michael
2004 Mortuary Preferences: A Wari Culture Case Study 1986 The Sources of Social Power, vol 1. Cambridge:
from Middle Horizon Peru. Latin American Antiq- Cambridge University Press.
uity 15(1):3–32.
Menzel, Dorothy
Isbell, William H., and Anita G. Cook 1959 The Inca Occupation of the South Coast of Peru.
1987 Ideological Origins of an Andean Conquest State. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 15(2):125–
Archaeology 40(4):27–33. 142.
The Wari Empire in Sondondo, Peru 149

1964 Style and Time in the Middle Horizon. Ñawpa Rowe, John Howland
Pacha 2:1–105. 1962 Stages and Periods in Archaeological Interpre-
1968 New Data on the Huari Empire in Middle Horizon tation. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology
Epoch 2A. Ñawpa Pacha 6:47–114. 18(1):40–54.
1977 The Archaeology of Ancient Peru and the Work
of Max Uhle. Berkeley: R. H. Lowie Museum of Schreiber, Katharina J.
Anthropology, University of California. 1978 Planned Architecture of Middle Horizon Peru: Im-
plications for Social and Political Organization.
Millones, Luis, ed. Ph.D. dissertation, SUNY Binghamton.
1990 El retorno de las huacas: estudios y documentos 1987 Conquest and Consolidation: A Comparison of the
sobre el Taki Onqoy siglo XVI. Lima: Instituto de Wari and Inka Occupations of a Highland Peruvian
Estudios Peruanos. Valley. American Antiquity 52(2):266–284.
1992 Wari Imperialism in Middle Horizon Peru. An-
Moore, Jerry D. thropological Papers 87, Museum of Anthropology.
1996 Architecture and Power in the Ancient Andes: Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.
The Archaeology of Public Buildings. Cambridge: 1999 Regional Approaches to the Study of Prehis-
Cambridge University Press. toric Empires: Examples from Ayacucho and
Nasca, Peru. In Settlement Pattern Studies in the
Morris, Craig Americas: Fifty Years since Virú. Brian R. Billman
1972 State Settlements in Tawantinsuyu: A Strategy of and Gary M. Feinman, eds. Pp. 160–171. Washing-
Compulsory Urbanism. In Contemporary Archae- ton, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press.
ology. Mark P. Leone, ed. Pp. 393–401. Carbondale: 2001 The Wari Empire of Middle Horizon Peru: The
Southern Illinois University Press. Epistemological Challenge of Documenting an
1998 Inka Strategies of Incorporation and Governance. Empire without Documentary Evidence. In Em-
In Archaic States. Gary Feinman and Joyce Marcus, pires. Susan E. Alcock, Terence N. D’Altroy,
eds. Pp. 293–309. Santa Fe: School of American Kathleen D. Morrison, and Carla M. Sinopoli,
Research Press. eds. Pp. 70–92. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Moseley, Michael E., Robert A. Feldman, Paul A. Goldstein,
and Luis Watanabe Shanks, Michael, and Christopher Tilley
1991 Colonies and Conquest: Tiahuanaco and Huari in 1982 Ideology, Symbolic Power and Ritual Communi-
Moquegua. In Huari Political Organization: Prehis- cation: A Reinterpretation of Neolithic Mortuary
toric Monumental Architecture and State Govern- Practices. In Symbolic and Structural Archaeol-
ment. William H. Isbell and Gordon F. McEwan, ogy. Ian Hodder, ed. Pp. 129–154. Cambridge:
eds. Pp. 121–140. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Cambridge University Press.
Oaks.
Sinopoli, Carla
Niles, Susan 1994 The Archaeology of Empires. Annual Review of
1992 Inca Architecture and the Sacred Landscape. In The Anthropology 23:159–180.
Ancient Americas: Art from Sacred Landscapes. 2001 Empires. In Archaeology at the Millennium. Gary
Richard F. Townsend, ed. Pp. 347–357. Chicago: M. Feinman and T. Douglas Price, eds. Pp. 439–
The Art Institute of Chicago. 471. New York: Kluwer/Plenum.

Patterson, Thomas Spickard, Lynda


1986 Ideology, Class Formation, and Resistance in the 1983 The Development of Huari Administrative Archi-
Inca State. Critique of Anthropology 6(1):75–85. tecture. In Investigations of the Andean Past. Daniel
H. Sandweiss, ed. Pp. 136–160. Ithaca: Cornell
Reinhard, Johan University.
1992 Sacred Peaks of the Andes. National Geographic
Magazine 181(3):84–111. Tilley, Christopher J.
1999 Coropuna: Lost Mountain Temple of the Incas. 1984 Ideology and the Legitimation of Power in
South American Explorers Journal 58:5, 26–30. the Middle Neolithic of Southern Sweden. In
150 Katharina Schreiber

Ideology, Power and Prehistory. Daniel Miller and van de Guchte, Maarten
Christopher Tilley, eds. Pp. 111–146. Cambridge: 1990 Carving the World: Inca Monumental Sculpture
Cambridge University Press. and Landscape. Ph.D. dissertation, University of
1994 A Phenomenology of Landscape: Places, Paths, and Illinois, Urbana-Champaign.
Monuments. Oxford: Berg. 1999 The Inca Cognition of Landscape: Archaeology,
Ethnohistory, and the Aesthetic of Alterity. In Ar-
Tuan, Yi-Fu chaeologies of Landscape: Contemporary Perspec-
1977 Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience. tives. Wendy Ashmore and A. Bernard Knapp, eds.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Pp. 149–168. Oxford: Blackwell.
Uhle, Max
1903 Pachacamac: Report of the William Pepper, M.D., Williams, Patrick R.
LL.D., Peruvian Expedition of 1896. Philadelphia: 2001 Cerro Baúl: A Wari Center on the Tiwanaku
University of Pennsylvania Press. Frontier. Latin American Antiquity 12(1):67–
83.
Van Buren, Mary
2000 Political Fragmentation and Ideological Continuity
in the Andean Highlands. In Order, Legitimacy, and Williams, Patrick R., and Johny Isla C.
Wealth in Ancient States. Janet Richards and Mary 2002 Investigaciones arqueológicas en Cerro Baúl, un
Van Buren, eds. Pp. 77–87. Cambridge: Cambridge enclave Wari en el valle de Moquegua. Gaceta Ar-
University Press. queológica Andina 26:87–120.

You might also like