You are on page 1of 5

1

Long Range Nuclear Radiation Monitoring System


using LPWAN Technology
Jitendra Goyal, Arpit Khandelwal

Abstract—A nuclear radiation monitoring system with a trans-


mission range of 10 km is developed and validated. The designed
system can be used for remote monitoring of nuclear radiation
and collecting the data at ground stations located far apart from
active site. It can be used to interface any wireless nuclear
radiation sensor and has 10 years of operating lifetime. The
transceiver is implemented using novel Low Power Wide Area
Network (LPWAN) technology which is specially designed for
applications requiring long range transmissions at low data rate.
The experimental testing of designed system shows that dose
rate information can be transmitted upto 10 km in rural and
7 km in urban environment. Moreover, there is possibility of
creating a network where number of different sensors located
geographically apart can transmit to the same base station, thus
providing simultaneous data analysis.
Index Terms—Wireless radiation monitoring, LPWAN, WSN,
CC1310, RSSI.
Fig. 1: Block diagram of proposed nuclear radiation monitoring
I. I NTRODUCTION system

T HE amount of radioactive materials being emitted in


the environment has increased recently due to increasing
nuclear activities for power generation and weapon purposes. low cost operation [8]–[10]. In this technology, long range
Continuous monitoring of radioactive levels in the environ- communication is achieved by using sub-1 GHz frequency
ment has become extremely essential to avoid accidents such band which offers robust and reliable communication at low
as Fukushima - Daiichi and Chernobyl [1]. Radiation sensors power budgets. While traditional non-cellular technologies
are deployed in the active areas to measure the concentration such as XBee, ZigBee and WiFi operate at 2.4 GHz band, their
of radioactive substance and their information is transmitted communication range is limited because of higher operating
to the nearest base station for further analysis. Recently frequency. They also suffer from latency and interference and
aerial vehicles have been used to monitor the radiation levels number of devices operating in this range are quite high. In LP-
at remote locations [2]. Both manned and unmanned aerial WAN, narrow band and spread spectrum techniques are used
vehicles with radiation sensors mounted on them have been to improve the security and link budget of the system. Simple
deployed [3]. Apart from these, IoT based solutions have also and light weight medium access control (MAC) protocols
been proposed for radiation monitoring [4]. Although, such are used to minimize the power consumption and extend the
a system makes it easier to measure radiation in seemingly operating lifetime of the transceiver. Currently there are several
inaccessible areas, transmitting the measured radiation dose competing LPWAN technologies such as LoRa, SigFox, NB-
to the base station remains a critical issue. With the current IoT etc. using different techniques to obtain long range, low
available transceivers in non-licensed spectrum such as XBee power operation [11].
and ZigBee, the maximum achievable transmission range is In this paper, an indigenously developed nuclear radiation
upto few meters [5]. This requires either the base station to sensor is interfaced with an LPWAN module developed by
be located very close to the radioactive site or use of multiple Texas Instruments to achieve long distance transmission of
transceivers as repeaters in order to increase the transmission the measured dose rate. The experimental evaluation proves
range. that dose rate information can be successfully transmitted
LPWAN is a wireless network designed to allow long upto 10 km in rural and 7 km in urban areas. Other qual-
range communication at low bit rates among connected ob- ity metrics of the system such as received signal strength
jects [6], [7]. LPWAN technologies are especially designed indicator (RSSI) and packet loss ratio are also measured.
for the applications that require long range, low power and Such a system eliminates the need of having the base station
close to radioactive site or installing multiple repeaters to
Jitendra Goyal is with Defence Laboratory, Jodhpur e-mail: increase the communication range. The paper is organized as
(goyal.8@iitj.ac.in).
Arpit Khandelwal is with Department of Electrical Engineering, Indian follows: section II describes the proposed system design with
Institute of Technology Jodhpur, India. detailed hardware specifications and software programming

978-1-7281-4842-7/20/$31.00 ©2020 IEEE


Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on November 04,2020 at 08:20:10 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
2

Fig. 2: Nuclear radiation sensor DELRAD developed by Defence


Labs Jodhpur (DLJ)

Fig. 4: Setup for testing the functionality of designed system.

4 R/hr is kept to avoid confusion between the detectors at the


time of switching.
The input dose rate is represented as counts per second
(CPS) and their typical values for a small area detector are
shown in Table I. This CPS value is converted into a data
packet by the transmitter module for wireless transmission.
This data packet contains 1 byte of device address, 1 byte
Fig. 3: Output of DELRAD sensor when exposed to nuclear radiation of hardware status, 2 bytes of CPS values and CRC field.
The transceiver module used in this case is CC1310-90 mi-
crocontroller unit (MCU) developed by Texas Instruments Inc.
steps; section III discusses the experimental results in rural It is a cost-effective, ultra-low-power wireless MCU capable
and urban environment and section IV concludes the paper of handling sub-1 GHz RF frequencies. Complete technical
with future scope of the work. details of CC1310 -90 can be found in [12]. For interfacing of
the wireless sensor, the MCU is programmed using the Code
Composer Studio (CCS) integrated development environment.
II. P ROPOSED S YSTEM D ESIGN
As the first step of programming, the RF parameters of the
The proposed system consists of a nuclear radiation sensor module are set to achieve optimum communication range at
interfaced with a transceiver module to transmit and receive moderate data rate. The list of parameters and their corre-
the dose rate information. As shown in Fig. 1, the transceiver sponding values are shown in Table II.
module with nuclear sensor attached to it acts as transmitter
while the one with display acts as receiver. The dose rate III. E XPERIMENTAL R ESULTS
information transmitted by the sensor is displayed on the LCD
screen continuously. Two types of tests are performed to verify the working of the
The sensor used in our case is DELRAD, which is de- designed system. Firstly, the functionality of radiation sensor
veloped by Defence Labroatory Jodhpur, India and shown in is tested using a setup shown in Fig. 4. The DELRAD sensor
Fig. 2. This semiconductor sensor when exposed to gamma is mounted on testing kit and probing is done on analog and
radiation gives digital pulses at the output whose frequency is digital output pins. Tektronix MSO 4054 oscilloscope is used
proportional to the dose rate as shown in Fig. 3. The sensor for recording various waveforms. A voltage divider circuit is
has 2 detectors, a large area detector measuring dose rate upto used to reduce the amplitude of digital pulses from radiation
5 R/hr and a small area detector for dose rate greater than sensor output to 3.3 V. These pulses are then fed to DIO23
5 R/hr. Based on the incident dose rate, the sensor switches pin of launch pad kit, acting as transmitter, for counting. To
between the 2 detectors. As shown in Fig. 3, a hysteresis of power up radiation sensor, mounting kit and transmitter kit
dual output power bank is used. The digital pulse at the output
TABLE I
Relation between Gamma dose rate and CPS for DELRAD TABLE II
Set of RF parameters for programming of sensor module
Dose Rate
Counts/Sec
(R/h) Frequency 867 MHz
1 64 Deviation ± 5 kHz
2.5 167 Data Rate 5 kbps
5 338 Symbol Rate 20 kchips/s
10 704 Modulation GFSK
50 3260 DSSS 2
100 6350 Rx BW 49 kHz
500 26440 Tx Power 26 dBm

Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on November 04,2020 at 08:20:10 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3

Fig. 5: Output waveform of DELRAD sensor when irradiated with


dose of Gamma radiation.

Fig. 8: Result of range test in rural environment

aim to maximize the achieved range. Two transceiver modules


(one programmed as transmitter and other as receiver) fixed
on an elevated platform as shown in Fig. 7 are used for the
range test. The transmitter is fixed over the top of a building,
at a height of about 11 m. The receiver is mounted on the roof
Fig. 6: Final output of the designed system showing the radiation of a car and is moved around. Different locations having line-
dose and equivalent CPS values.
of-sight communication are identified and total of 500 packets
are transmitted from each location. Based on the number of
packets received at the receiver, packet loss is calculated. In
rural environment, a communication range of about 11 km was
obtained as shown in Fig. 8, when the transmitter was fixed
on the top of Electrical Department building at Indian Institute
of Technology, Jodhpur and receiver was moved around in a
vehicle till the Toll Plaza. This range is obtained for a data
rate of 2.5 kbps where no packet loss is observed till 9.5
km. However, packet loss starts increasing from 9.5 km and
it reaches to 15.15% at a distance of 10.8 km and 46% at 11
km. For increasing data rates, the achievable range steadily
decreases as shown in Fig. 11.
The achievable communication range is found to be depen-
dent on number of parameters such as transmitter power, data
rate, environmental noise floor etc. For the experiments in rural
Fig. 7: Setup for range testing experiment showing transmitter areas, environmental noise floor was calculated as -120 dBm.
connected to the power bank and receiver connected to laptop. The achievable communication range is found to decrease with
a decrease in transmitted power as shown in Fig. 10.
Similar experiment was performed in densely populated
of radiation sensor when it is irradiated is shown in Fig. 5. urban environment inside the Jodhpur city. The transmitter was
DELRAD sensor is a hybrid micro circuit that has detectors kept at the top of Ratanada Palace and receiver was moved in
for radiation detection and front end electronics to process the a vehicle to obtain a range of about 7 kms as shown in Fig.
signal from the detector. The analog waveform shown in Fig. 9. At data rate of 5 kbps, no packet loss observed up to a
5 is the output of detector and the digital waveform is the distance of 3 km. However, packet loss increases to 2.2% at
final output of signal processing circuit. These pulses are then 4.5 km, 15.69% at 6.5 km and 46.72% at a distance of 7.34
converted into CPS values by the MCU and displayed as the km. After this distance receiver was not able to receive any
final output as shown in Fig. 6. packets from transmitter. Moreover, RSSI was also measured
The developed prototype is tested for achievable commu- at different distances from the transmitter as shown in Fig.
nication range in both rural and urban environments with an 12. As expected, RSSI is found to decrease with distance and

Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on November 04,2020 at 08:20:10 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4

Fig. 11: Variation in achievable communication range with respect to


transmitter data rate showing decrease in range with increase in data
rate.

Fig. 9: Result of range test in urban environment

Fig. 12: Variation of RSSI with distance in urban environment

geographically spaced LPWAN sensors and one receiver at


the base station can be created to effectively monitor a large
area. Such a system and its analysis with respect to reliability,
scalability etc. would be the topic of further research.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to thank Mahaveer Prasad, A.K.
Fig. 10: Variation in achievable communication range with respect
to transmitter power showing decrease in range with decrease in Yadav and Ravindra Kumar, Defence Labs Jodhpur for their
transmitter power. valuable technical inputs.

R EFERENCES
reaching minimum value at around 7 kms. The abrupt rise in
RSSI at 5.5 kms was due to sudden decrease in environmental [1] R. J. Nemzek, J. S. Dreicer, D. C. Torney, and T. T. Warnock, “Dis-
noise floor owing to lesser crowded area. tributed sensor networks for detection of mobile radioactive sources,”
IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, vol. 51, no. 4, pp. 1693–1700,
2004.
IV. C ONCLUSION [2] Y. Sanada, T. Sugita, Y. Nishizawa, A. Kondo, and T. Torii, “The aerial
radiation monitoring in japan after the fukushima daiichi nuclear power
A wireless nuclear radiation monitoring system is developed plant accident,” Prog. Nucl. Sci. Technol, vol. 4, no. 7, 2014.
and experimentally tested in rural and urban environment. [3] Y. Sanada and T. Torii, “Aerial radiation monitoring around the
fukushima dai-ichi nuclear power plant using an unmanned helicopter,”
The designed system consists of a PIN diode based Gamma Journal of environmental radioactivity, vol. 139, pp. 294–299, 2015.
radiation sensor interfaced with a transceiver system working [4] A. Tocchi, V. Roca, L. Angrisani, F. Bonavolontà, and R. S. L. Moriello,
on LPWAN technology. The radiation dose measured by the “First step towards an iot implementation of a wireless sensors network
for environmental radiation monitoring,” in 2017 IEEE International
sensor is transmitter wirelessly over a secured and reliable link Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference (I2MTC).
upto 10 km in rural and 7 km in urban areas. The achieved IEEE, 2017, pp. 1–6.
transmission range is much greater than those obtained from [5] R. Gomaa, I. Adly, K. Sharshar, A. Safwat, and H. Ragai, “Zigbee
wireless sensor network for radiation monitoring at nuclear facilities,”
other non-cellular technologies such as XBee, ZigBee and in 6th Joint IFIP Wireless and Mobile Networking Conference (WMNC).
WiFi. A wireless sensor network (WSN) consisting of several IEEE, 2013, pp. 1–4.

Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on November 04,2020 at 08:20:10 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
5

[6] U. Raza, P. Kulkarni, and M. Sooriyabandara, “Low power wide area


networks: An overview,” IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials,
vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 855–873, 2017.
[7] R. Oliveira, L. Guardalben, and S. Sargento, “Long range communica-
tions in urban and rural environments,” in 2017 IEEE Symposium on
Computers and Communications (ISCC). IEEE, 2017, pp. 810–817.
[8] K. Mekki, E. Bajic, F. Chaxel, and F. Meyer, “A comparative study of
lpwan technologies for large-scale iot deployment,” ICT Express, vol. 5,
no. 1, pp. 1–7, 2019.
[9] D. F. Carvalho, A. Depari, P. Ferrari, A. Flammini, S. Rinaldi, and
E. Sisinni, “On the feasibility of mobile sensing and tracking applica-
tions based on lpwan,” in 2018 IEEE Sensors Applications Symposium
(SAS). IEEE, 2018, pp. 1–6.
[10] W. Guibene, J. Nowack, N. Chalikias, K. Fitzgibbon, M. Kelly, and
D. Prendergast, “Evaluation of lpwan technologies for smart cities:
River monitoring use-case,” in 2017 IEEE Wireless Communications
and Networking Conference Workshops (WCNCW). IEEE, 2017, pp.
1–5.
[11] B. Vejlgaard, M. Lauridsen, H. Nguyen, I. Z. Kovács, P. Mogensen,
and M. Sorensen, “Coverage and capacity analysis of sigfox, lora, gprs,
and nb-iot,” in 2017 IEEE 85th vehicular technology conference (VTC
Spring). IEEE, 2017, pp. 1–5.
[12] T. Instruments, “Cc1310 simplelink ultra-low-power sub-1 ghz wireless
mcu,” Texas Instruments: Dallas, TX, USA, 2016.

Authorized licensed use limited to: Carleton University. Downloaded on November 04,2020 at 08:20:10 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like