Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A THESIS
BY
DONA P. ARITONANG
REG.NO.110705103
DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH
MEDAN 2017
vi
NIP.196008051098703100
Board of Examiners :
Dr.Deliana,M.Hum. .........................................
NIP. 19571117 198303 2 002
vii
Head, Secretary,
viii
Signed :
DEPARTMENT : ENGLISH
Signed :
vi
Firstly,I want to thank to God,Jesus Christ because His bless and mercy I
could finish this Thesis.His love that he proof in the cross has made me fell blessy
and gifted.I also wants to thank for whom that helped me to compile this
Aritonang as the best booster in my life.Thanks for your guidance for the entire of
my life,without both of you I can not finish my education.Thanks for both of you.The
Sahat Aritonang, and Ruth Aritonang.Thanks for the brotherhood and sisterhood that
have been given to me.May the God always bless you.My bestfriends,Innovative:
There so many people I can not mention,I’m sorry for that.Whatever is that,I want to
thank you for all of those who has helped me to finish my lecturing.My our Lord
(Dona P.Aritonang)
vii
This thesis entitled ”An Analysis ofAffectime Meaning on Article in Jakarta Post
Daily”. This thesis discusses about the application of affective meaning that the
writer found in Jakarta Post Daily.Threre are positive and negative aspects that the
writer found in The Jakarta Post Daily, one example about the defamation case as
Jakarta governoor done has raises many critics from Muslims.They felt shirty about
his action to make blamesphy of Islam.This thesis uses library research which take
the data from written form one.This thesis objective are to find the examples of
affective meaning in Jakarta Post Daily and to find the application of affective
meaning in politic article news in Jakarta Post Daily
Keyword :meaning,affective,applied
viii
Skripsi ini berjudul “An Analysis of Affective Meaning on Article in Jakarta Post
Daily”.Skripsi ini membahas tentang pengaplikasian dari affective meaning yang
ditemukan penulis di Harian Jakarta Pos.Terdapat aspek positif dan negatif yang
ditemukan di Harian Jakarta Pos,salah satu contohnya adalah tentang Gubernur
Jakarta yang melakukan kasus penistaan yang menuai kritik dari dari umat Muslim.
Mereka merasa tersinggung dengan penistaan agama Islam.skripsi ini menggunakan
kajian pustaka yang datanya diambil darisumber tertulis.Adapun tujuan dari
penulisan skripsi ini adalah untuk menemukan contoh-contoh dari affective meaning
dalam Harian Jakarta Pos dan untuk menemukan pengaplikasian dari affective
meaning yang ditemukan di dalam Harian Jakarta Pos
Kata kunci :makna,sikap,diaplikasikan
ix
AUTHOR’S DEDCLARATION...........................................................................v
COPYRIGHT DECLARATION...........................................................................vi
ACKNOWLEDGMENT........................................................................................vii
ABSTRACT............................................................................................................viii
ABSTRAK...............................................................................................................ix
TABLE OF CONTENTS........................................................................................x
CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION
2.7 Presupposition................................................................................19
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................ 43
xi
INTRODUCTION
How the language over comes has been researched for a long time by the
emerged unknown. Eventhough the scientists has researched the developing of the
baby born language. The process of baby language untill they can talk with the other
gives us the comprehension about language, the best and the only one
regarded language as walking or breathing they do not pay attention to it. In his
when a thing is need based on the special characters or it is just consensus. That
dialogue gives us one debate that lasted for almost in a century, the dialogue about
The Analogues believe that language can be researched from its form that
they call it etymology. For example the word blackbird that consist of the word black
and bird. That animal was named because it is an animal and it is black that make
Phonology, Morphology, Syntax, Pragmatics and Semantics. All of five parts of this
pure linguistics cannnot be separate each other. Five of them talk about language,
whether how the word sounded, how the word became one and another of it, how the
word stuctured in a sentence, how the word meant in unparticular sentence and how
in a sentence or words. Muchtar (2011:3) says for almost half of century, semantics
is the is the subject of history studies. But it has changed in 1930 because semantics
has oriented in descriptive semantics. In that time there were two views about
descriptive semantics. First view regarded word as asign and the second views
field. Muchtar (2011:3) says first, semantics starts to be interested by the linguist
since the publication of Leonard Bloomfield’s book, Language that was very
interested in linguistics field in 1933. Second, needs to notice for the developing of
semantics it has to develop its balance of field study. The third, semantics has
five of them are included in associative meaning. There are conceptual meaning,
determine our reactions to something that are talking about. After determine our
reaction the next step that need to do is planning. It means our attitude towards
something also important in aim get the bigger benefit. In this paper the writer wants
to discuss about affective meaning that I analyse and take from Jakarta Pos Daily.
The writer chose that kind of meaning because it is the most interesting one and very
valuable to disscuss and analyse. And about that newspaper, the writer chose it
because that newspaper is published every day that means the news is the newest
Problem of the study contents about what the paper disscuss about that
written in the interrogative form or question one.In this paper the problems of study
are :
1.What are the examples of affective meaning found in articles in Jakarta Post
Daily?
2.How are the affective meaning applied in politic articles news in Jakarta Post
Daily?
Objective of the study is the aim that the writer compile that paper in the
1.To find out the example of affective meaning applied in politic news article in
2.To explain the use of Affective meaning app;lied in politic news article in the
Scope of study is the limitation of the disscussion of the paper by the writer.
In this paper, the writer will discuss the using of affective meaning in the Jakarta
Post Daily. The writer will limit the research about the affective meaning by Leech
The Sifnificance of study contents about the utility of the research writing or the
paper.
1. The readers will know much about the study of meaning of a word,especially
2. The readers will much know how to take a decision based someone
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Review of literature is the review about the paper that include the current
knowledge about the paper and it is in the methodological theory about particular
topic. Literature review uses secondary sources and do not report new or original
experimental work.
the meaning can be vague, unimportant and hard to understand that it is impossible to
come to any clear, concrete and tangible conclusion about it. The words that we use
can be a concrete meaning depends on what our aim when we use that words or
Chaer (1994:292) says makna denotatif ialah makna asli, atau makna yang
In this point, denotative meaning is the real meaning of the word or can be
said that the denotative meaning is the lexical meaning of the word itself. Denotative
meaning is the pure meaning of that word not the implicature meaning that the word
has in it.
via language is the refference of the spoken language of the semantic meaning of the
word.
Nowadays we know that semantic changes in the form of language is just the
changes of the use of the language that systematically relates each other.
through language. The basic of the semantic as showing how people communicate
meanings with pieces of language. Clearly, if a speaker can make up new sentences
and these sentences are understood, then they obey the semantics rules of the
language. So the meanings of the sentences can not be listed in a lexicon like the
often describe this by saying that the sentence meaning is is compositional. This
terms means that the meaning of an expression is determined by the meaning of its
These three terms are used to describe different levels of language. The most
language.
utterances.
caused by pitch level between women and children, style in accent and phonetics
irrelevant.
Both sentence are true, propositions need to make the sentences fair and correct
at all. If the first sentence is true then the same with the second sentence. The
soon leads us into some difficult and theory-laden decisions ( . The basic instinctions
seem a common sense one, distinguishing between instances where the speaker
speaks in neutral, factually accurate way, and instances where the speaker
special effects. This is happened when you missed your lunch, sentence 1 happened
1. I’m hungry
Non-literal uses of language are traditionally called figurative and are described
hyperbole and litotes. For one thing, one of the ways language change over time is
the speakers shifting the meanings of words to fit new conditions. One such shift is
more familiar. Such people as an integral part of human categorization : a basic way
of organizing our thoughts about the world. Here below the identifications of
In this cluster,the time is equal with the money,because there is proverb ‘time
Word is defined in parts by its relations with other words in language. The
word meaning or lexical semantics aims; to represent the meaning of each word in
language and to show how the meanings of words in language interrelated. Word
meaning is the accepted meaning of a word. Word meaning has played a somewhat
concerned with the structural features of sentences and showed less interest in the
compositional processes.
Nowadays,it is well estabilished that the way we account for word meaning is
bound to have a major impact in tipping the balance in favor or against a given
overview of the way issues related to lexical meaning have been explore in analytic
The referential theory holds that a linguistics sign derives its meaning from it
refers to something in reality. This suggests that language is a system arbitrary vocal
symbols used for human communication. For example, word like a fish,man are
10
are only an icon (or representation) from an actual thing or form is being symbolised.
The distinction between sense and reference was an innovation of the German
believed a singular term may have meaning. The reference (or "referent") of a proper
name is the object it means or indicates , its sense is what the name expresses. The
reference of a sentence is its truth value, its sense is the thought that it
For example, the name "Odysseus" is intelligible, and therefore has a sense,
even though there is no individual object (its reference) to which the name
corresponds.
2. The sense of different names is different, even when their reference is the
the identity sign must have a different meaning or sense. But clearly, if the
statement is true, they must have the same reference. The sense is a 'mode of
2.2.1 Sense
follows that the sentence will have the same significance if we replace a word of the
11
value of the sentence The reference of the whole is determined by the reference of
the parts. If 'the evening star' has the same reference as 'the morning star', it follows
that 'the evening star is a body illuminated by the Sun' has the same truth value as
'the morning star is a body illuminated by the Sun'. But someone may think that the
first sentence is true, but the second is false, and so the thought corresponding to the
sentence cannot be its reference, but something else, which Frege called its sense.
Second, sentences which contain proper names that have no reference cannot
have a truth value at all. Yet the sentence 'Odysseus was set ashore at Ithaca while
sound asleep' obviously has a sense, even though 'Odysseus' has no reference. The
thought remains the same whether or not 'Odysseus' has a reference. Furthermore, a
thought cannot contain the objects which it is about. For example, Mont Blanc, 'with
its snowfields', cannot be a component of the thought that Mont Blanc is more than
4,000 metres high. Nor can a thought about Etna contain lumps of solidified lava.
Frege's notion of sense is somewhat obscure, and neo-Fregeans have come up with
‘number of planets’ is a function that maps any possible world to the number of
2.2.2 Reference
12
to.For example, when we he hear I played some Chopin on the piano, we can infer
I saw a strange guy last night.He was wearing T-shirt with the Wikibooks logo.I tried
The anaphora expressions he and the guy both refer back to the strange guy.
It is how meanings relate to each other. There are a number of different types
a. Homonymy
homophones,senses of the same spoken words. Here we will generally just use the
1..lexeme of the same syntactic category, and with the same spelling,for example lap
‘circuit of a course’ and lap ‘part of the body when we sitting down’
13
wring.
b. Polysemy
polysemy. Both deal with multiple senses of the same phonological word, but
polysemy is invoked if the senses are judged to be related, This is an important for
polysemy. These criteria include speakers’ intuitions and what is known about the
from Collins English Dictionary where shows various senses of hook are terated as
1. hook(hʊk) n.1.a piece of material, usually metal, curved or bent and used to
suspend, catch, hold, or pull something 2.short for fish hook 3.a trap or snare
blow delivered from the side with the elbow bent.8.Cricket.a shot in which the ball is
hit square on the leg side with the bat held horizontally.10.Surfing.the top of
breaking wave,etc.
14
Synonyms are different phonological words which have the same or very
d. Opposites (Antonymy)
general label of opposition. There are number of relations which seem to involve
words which are at the same time related in meaning yet incompatible or contrasting
Pass/fail (test)
Hit/miss(target)
e. Hyponymy
15
hyperonym). Much of the vocabulary is linked by such systems of inclusion, and the
Some taxonomies reflect the natural world,like 1. Where we only expand a single
1.
bird
16
lexical items. Thus cover and page are the meronyms of book.We can identify this
part of book, or book has pages. Meronymy reflects hierarchical classification in the
1. car
g..Member of Collection
This is a relationship between the word for a unit and the usual word for
17
Tree fleet
Fish shoal
Book library
Bird flock
Sheep flock
Worshipper congregation
h. Portion- mass
This is the relation between a mass noun and the usual unit of measurement
or division. For example in 2.16 below the unit, a count noun is added to mass noun,
Drop of liquid
Grain of salt/sand/wheat
Sheet of paper
Lump of coal
strand of hair
18
be known to the hearer before she or he makes the utterance. Such semantic
someone utters (a) then he or she must presuppose (b); otherwise he or she utters
Geoffrey Leech (1936-2014) wrote his book that was influencing ,Semantics
in 1974 and in his book he proposed the seven types of meaning. Five of which are
associative meaning.
Conceptual meanings are the essential or core meaning while other six types
19
hierarchical structure.
E.g. Boy=+human+male-adult
Conceptual meaning is the literal meaning of the word indicating the idea or concept
communication.The conceptual meaning is the base for all others types of meaning.
above its purely conceptual content. It is something that goes beyond more referent
of a word and hints at its attributes in the real world. It is something more than the
conceptual meaning is not like that.It can be codified in terms of limited symbols.
The meaning conveyed by the piece of language about the social context of its
is used.
expression.For example,some dialectic words inform us about the regional and social
background of the speaker.In the same way,some stylistic usages let us know
something of the social relationship between the speaker and the hearer.
21
The line tells us about the speaker is probably a black American,underprivilaged and
uneducated.
the geographical region social class of the speaker.Style helps us to know about the
period,field and status of the discourse.Some words are similar to the others as far as
.But they differ in style and so have various social meaning.’Steed’ is used in
listener or to the subject matter of this course.For Leech affective meaning refers to
what is convey about the feeling and the attitude of the speak though use of language
For example : “ You are a vicious tyrant and a villanous reprobation and I hate
you”
22
We are left with a little doubt about the speakers feelings towards the
listener.Here the speaker seems to have a very negative attitude towards his
For example : “ Iam terribly sorry but if would be so kind as to lower your voice
a little”
politeness.Intonation and voice quality are also important here.Thus the sentence
above can be uttered in bitting sarcasm and the impression of politeness maybe
reversed while- “Will you belt up?” can be turned into playful remark between
lexical level of the language,reflected meaning arises when a word has more than one
to one sense of the word we partly respond to another sense of the word too.Leech
says in church service’the comforther and the Holy Ghost’ refer to the third in
23
sounds awesome or even ‘dreadful’.One sense of the word seems to rub off on
certain words.Words collocate or co-occur with certain wordd only for example Big
because of its usual or habitual co-occurance with certain types of words.’Pretty’ and
However,they slightly differ from each other because of the collocation or co-
verbs ‘wander’ and ‘stroll’ are quasy-synonymous-they may have almost the same
menaning but while ‘cows may wonder into another farm’,they don’t stroll into that
farm because ‘stroll’ collocates with human subject only.Collocative meanings ned
24
different from passive through its conceptual meaning is the same.Various parts of
statements in active and passive voice have same time conceptual meaning but
In the first sentence “who gave away the prize” is more important but in the
second sentence “what did Mrs. Smith gave is important”.Thus the change of focus
change the meaning also.The first suggests that we already know Mrs.Smith (perhaps
example :
25
The Jakarta Post is a daily English language newspaper in Indonesia. The paper is
owned by PT Bina Media Tenggara, and the head office is in the nation's capital,
Jakarta.
The Jakarta Post was started as a collaboration between four Indonesian media under
the urging of Information Minister Ali Murtopo and politician Jusuf Wanandi. After
the first issue was printed on 25 April 1983, it spent several years with minimal
began to take a more vocal pro-democracy point of view. The paper was one of the
few Indonesian English-language dailies to survive the 1997 Asian financial crisis
The Jakarta Post also features both a Sunday and Online edition, which go into detail
not possible in the daily print edition. It is targeted at foreigners and educated
for being a training ground for local and international reporters, The Jakarta Post has
26
The Jakarta Post was the brainchild of Information Minister Ali Murtopo and
politician Jusuf Wanandi. Murtopo and Wanandi were disappointed at the perceived
bias against Indonesia in foreign news sources. At the time, there were two English-
language dailies, the Indonesia Times and Indonesian Observer. However, due to
negative public perception regarding the existing papers they decided to create a new
one. In order to ensure credibility, the two agreed to convince a group of competing
Protestant-owned Sinar Harapan, and the weekly Tempo) to back the nascent paper.
Times in Singapore, the Bangkok Post in Thailand, and the New Straits Times in
Malaysia.After founding PT Bina Media Tenggara to back the paper, Wanandi spent
their cooperation, Kompas requested a 25 percent share in the new newspaper, for
which it would handle the daily business operations, such as printing, circulation, and
share, while Sabam Siagian of Sinar Harapan was hired as the first chief editor, for
which Sinar Harapan received stock. The establishment of the paper was further
for his role in acquiring a license. In total, the start-up cost Rp. 500 million
who formerly reported for Antara, became the newspaper's first general manager.
Further details, including the matter of Sinar Harapan's share of stock and the
27
month, on 25 April, the first edition — totalling eight pages — was published. The
first newsroom of the new paper were located in Kompas's former laundry room, a
one story warehouse; the first employees had to do the layout by hand, using pica
poles as straight edges. During the first few months, the writers translated and
recycled previously published stories from Indonesian media, which were later
picked up by foreign wire services. Original reporting was rare as the editors at first
did not want to deal with the censorship of Suharto's New Order government.
During the early years of publication, The Jakarta Post had difficulty attracting
advertisers, to the point that some editions ran without ads. However, circulation
originally hoped that the paper would begin to turn a profit within the first three
years, the recession in the early 1980s led to the start-up funds being depleted.
Eventually, in 1985 the paper took out an interest-free loan and received Rp. 700
million from its owners. After advertising increased, The Jakarta Post was able to
turn a profit by 1988, and was considered "one of the most credible newspapers" in
Indonesia.
28
METHOD OF RESEARCH
field of study
In the method of research there are three kinds of them,they are library
.To compile this thesis,the writer use library research,by reading some book or
written data that needed to make or compile this thesis.The research is about
consulting the book or source which has relationship with the thesis and they are in
the written one.This method do not need to focus on other method because the
framework that has been created to seek answers to research questions. In this thesis
the writer plans to make a research of the affective maning,one from seven meaning
The writer attempts to observe the applying of the affective meaning in the
Jakarta Post Daily. The step that will be done by the writer is select the data that
29
For data analysis the writer will get a newest Jakarta Post Daily ,read the news
and then translate the news in Indonesia,and then analyse them.The writer trying to
observe the using of affective meaning in this newspaper and then make or compile it
In computing, data is information that has been translated into a form that is
more convenient to move or process.The data that will be discuss in this thesis are
In this thesis the data was taken from newspaper the Jakarta Post.The writer
taken the data from Jakarta Post Daily edition 31 October 2016, 9 November 2016,
and 19 November 2016. The writer taken the data from column news and business
In this process writing of the thesis,the writer collect the data from
books,internet,magazine and newspaper .The books which borrow from the library
and the data which searching from the internet were utility and benefit to give the
30
For analysis the data,the writer take the data from The Jakarta Post Daily and
then analyse them one for one in the process to make the final conclusion.
31
4.1. The analysis and the examples of affective meaning on the article in Jakarta
Post Daily
”On Oct.11, the MUI concluded that Ahok had insulted both the Quran and
ulemas in his statement, in which he cited Al Maidah verse 51, during a visit to
Thousand Islands regency on Sept.27. This act had legal consequences, the
council said.”
promptly to investigate Ahok about the defamation case. The citation of the Qoran
which by Ahok in his speech while he visiting the Thousand Islands had caused
would be done by the National Police about the citation that blamesphy Quran
espeacially Muslims in Indonesia and the speaker is Ahok that affected himself also
Muslims in Indonesia .In this case, Ahok might be undeliberated to insulted Muslims
by cite Al-Maidah that leads they react to report Ahok and investigate this case. If
only Ahok knew this ,he would not embarrased himself with this case and tried to
country.
32
Protests against Ahok developed after part of his speech, in which he cited a
verse from the Quran, was uploaded by Buni Yani, a communications lecturer,
who later admitted that he had made errors in transcribing the video he
In the news above, the citation of a verse from Quran that has done by Ahok has
increasingly discussion that peaked to the Nov. 4 rally. His sentiment has raises
critics and pro-contra between Ahok followers and FPI. In this news,the affective
meaning appear in the Nov.4 mass rally by Islamic organizations that affected by the
speech by Ahok in which he cited one verse from Quran which raises the pro-contra
from any side of religion.Ahok should not do that action,because its speech had
caused demonstration that could be change the ideology and institutions in Indonesia
dangerous,because massive people could do such threating action like destroy the
would say and for most important respect our religious tolerance.
demand.
“I doubt there will be any significant increase from 2017 to 2018, because most
of the power plant projects need two to four years before the commercial
33
the demand of the coal increasingly due to the effectively using of coal as
electrification. The affective meaning arise in the careful of the company to produce
the coal due low price and the using of the coal that is not sufficiently. The
speaker,as the coal company doesn’t have to raise their production because of the
crisis in the coal market in Indonesia. In this news, the affective meaning that acted
produce their coal between crisis they will have loss the money.
When civilians flee their homes to escape conflict, militias operating under the
said.
From the news above the unpaying attention of the reign to the trouble that
happened in the Myanmar Karen’s state had affected in the loss of the land and the
resident of the farmer.They loss their land and didn’t have rights to have it back
because after they (the farmers) flee their homes,their land automatically owned by
the militia.And untill now they has not had the way out to solve it.
their meal, and not giving a tip is considered rude. Not paying a tip is
considered as bad as robbing the waiter because they do not get paid much. The
34
From the news above,the service of the waiter requires tipping from the
customer.Here,the affective meaning appear in the good service of the waiter that
needed some higher or lower tipping that doesn’t usual in Indonesia.If the customer
didn’t pay tipping for the waiter it could be categorized rude action,and we don’t
want it happened.So,if you go to USA,pay some tipping between 15-20 from the
But recent events seem to have prompted Indonesia to increase its defensive
posture in the region. Several Chinese fishing boats — backed by armed coast
guard vessels — have encroached into Natuna waters, and clashed with
The claim of the owning Natuna Land in South China Sea by China has made
Indonesia delegate TNI to defense area in there .In this news the affective meaning
shows in the delegation of the force to keep the national asset in Indonesia that
be safe now because the Military has keep operate in the Natuna Island to keep away
the strange boat that trying to take advantage in Indonesia’s sea area.
35
shares the same concept with their mind-bending movie Doctor Strange.
In the news above,the affective meaning of the paintings of the pencil drawing art
Studios.Here,the speaker as Marvel Studios feel that Veri’s works is matching with
the character that they looking for.His works has made him succeded as an artist in
Indonesia that influencing foreign country and company,Marvel studios that coming
from USA that has produce many cartoon and movie that inspired from the comic.
The agreement, which was discussed by Iran along with the United States, the
United Kingdom, France, Russia, China and Germany, allowed Iran to continue
developing its nuclear program as long as it was for peaceful civilian purposes
allow nuclear programs for safe condition.The affective meaning shows in the
for peaceful of Iran and Indonesia take part with joining with the agreement of iran’s
country.
36
affective meaning appears in the amending of death sentence caused by the study that
conducted by International Centre for Law and Legal Studies that give positive signs
The evictees in Pasar Ikan believe that incumbent Jakarta Governor Basuki
“Ahok” Tjahaja Purnama is responsible for their misery because he was the one
The evicted that Ahok done causes many loss for evictees where they lose their
job and home.In this news the affective meaning causes the evictees did not give
their vote for Ahok because the evicted that he had done for a part of Jakarta area.
“This debate will be the final chance for voters to see all candidates on one
stage, imparting their solutions, visions and missions, regarding the city’s woes.
We hope that through this debate, voters will be able to single out the person
who will lead the city for the next five years,” Jakarta General Elections
Commission (KPU Jakarta) member Betty Epsilon Idroos told The Jakarta Post
on Thursday.
37
the last debate that will win voters for the three candidates for Jakartans governoor.If
every candidates prepare themselves to face the debate they will win this election.
The shelter has several parks where social workers take the children to play
various games and teach them to read books every day accompanied by
psychologists to ensure that they are in a stable psychological state and have not
The shelter in Bambu Apus,Jakarta has made in the reason to avoid terrorism in
Indonesia through IS.They have to live separate with Indonesian people,wich they
come from Japan,Turkey and etc.They did not allow to have an internet or other
communication tools.It is done to change their miund not to do terrorism before they
4.2.Finding
In this thesis,the writer found different using of affective meaning in the news
of Jakarta Post Daily.There are positive and also negative meaning that the writer
analyse from different news.In this thesis the writer find the using of affective
meaning that could be dangerous to the future and other people,could help people to
keep their asset,to keep the force of one country,one culture and one fantastic
38
peace keeping in your area. Respect the other if you want respected by
them.Affective meaning gives us understanding that one action can reacted different
feedback,it is our duty to keep it safe and secure.Affective meaning gives feedback
and the attitude towards them,as democratic country we have to respect them.The
annihilation of the affective meaning can make our lifes felt empty and meaningless
39
5.1 Conclusion.
every people is really vary and different around the world inspite of the variational
meaning between them.It is Geoffrey Leech who has been giving the cluster of the
conveyed about personal feelings or attitude towards the listener. Affective meaning
gives comprehension about the effect of a speaker towards the listenener.In this
thesis the writer found that every meaning gives different reaction to them.The
blashphemy of religion for example has made the Nov. 4 rally eventhough it is just
the citation of one verse in the Quran by one one of Indonesian leader.It has made
many critics and expossed towards that leader.The governoor should not do this.This
positively into this news (the speech of Jakarta Governoor ) and keep in the peace
40
we don’t have to judge him or her,give improvement and lead him or her to the right
way.It is good if we active and beneficial to our environment,but if our action just
worse the condition it is better stop that and keep away.Remember,keep positive
41
...........Press.
Leech,Geoffrey.1974.Semantics.
...........Pragmatik.Jakarta:Irama Widya.
42
..........Technology.London:Longman.
43
The National Police are set to question Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) leader
Ma’ruf Amin as an expert witness in their investigation into religious blasphemy
allegedly committed by Jakarta Governor Basuki “Ahok” Tjahaja Purnama.
“We are scheduled to question the MUI chairman today [Monday],” National Police
spokesperson Brig. Gen. Agus Rianto said at the Criminal Investigation Department
(Bareskrim) office in the police’s headquarters in South Jakarta.
He said Ma’ruf would be questioned at the MUI office in Menteng, Central Jakarta.
On Oct.11, the MUI concluded that Ahok had insulted both the Quran and ulemas in
his statement, in which he cited Al Maidah verse 51, during a visit to Thousand
Islands regency on Sept.27. This act had legal consequences, the council said.
The police questioned Islam Defenders Front (FPI) leader Habib Rizieq as an expert
witness in Ahok’s blasphemy case on Thursday. As of Monday, the police had
summoned 12 expert witnesses comprising religion, language and criminal law
experts, in their investigation into the case.
The police have also questioned 13 witnesses, including Ahok, Thousand Islands
residents, and people who have reported the governor to the police.
Agus said Ahok’s questioning on Monday was to complete the information related to
his case. (ebf)
Guntur said anti-Ahok sentiments, which peaked at the Nov.4 rally by Islamic
organizations against the governor’s alleged blasphemous speech, were only political
maneuvers amid the Jakarta gubernatorial election campaign but these would destroy
diversity in the country if ignored.
"Several groups out there aim to change our Constitution, which upholds our
religious harmony, into a Khilafah Islamiyah [Islamic caliphate]," the activist told
The Jakarta Post on Monday.
"Tolerant Muslims as the majority must no longer keep silent. Our Constitution has
opened the opportunity for anyone to compete in elections regardless of their
religious and racial backgrounds," he said.
Protests against Ahok developed after part of his speech, in which he cited a verse
from the Quran, was uploaded by Buni Yani, a communications lecturer, who later
admitted that he had made errors in transcribing the video he uploaded on his
Facebook page.
The video went viral and sparked public outrage, which eventually led to Nov. 4’s
mass rally by several Islamic organizations, which called on the police to conduct a
transparent legal process against Ahok over his alleged blasphemy. (ebf)
Despite rising coal prices and new research indicating that the country’s coal
production will begin to increase, coal miners are still doubtful the rise in demand is
enough to significantly boost domestic production in the near future.
BMI Research, a unit of Fitch Group, has predicted that Indonesia—which is among
the five largest thermal coal producing countries— will see its coal production
increase by an average 7.5 percent per year from 2017 to 2020, after suffering from a
15 percent year-on-year (yoy) decline this year.
Publicly listed Bumi Resources will remain the largest coal miner in Indonesia,
according to the report.
“Through its two coal subsidiaries, Kaltim Prima Coal and Arutmin Indonesia, the
company produced 60.0 million tons of coal in the first nine months of 2015, down
7.7 percent yoy,” it said.
The report also said that India and Russia were set to increase their market shares in
thermal coal production as well, with only Russia’s additional output destined for the
seaborne market.
Other large producers, including China and the US, will slowly lose market share.
Although the report paints a pretty picture, the Indonesian Coal Mining Association
(APBI) casts some doubt on any significant increase in production for the next
couple of years.
APBI deputy director Hendra Sinadia said the electrification project was not enough
to spur production for domestic coal miners, because many power plants would not
begin operations until 2019.
“I doubt there will be any significant increase from 2017 to 2018, because most of
the power plant projects need two to four years before the commercial operation
date,” he told The Jakarta Post.
According to data from the association, coal demand for electrification stands at
around 80 million tons per year and has the potential to double by the time the
government’s electrification program is completed.
However, progress in the 35,000 MW project has been slow, and by September, data
from state-owned electricity company PLN show, that less than 1 percent of the total
35,000 MW has gone into commercial operation since the program was launched in
late 2014.
The APBI acknowledges that there has been a sudden increase in coal prices after the
coal market was badly hit for the past two years.
Reuters reported that the Asian benchmark Newcastle thermal coal price reached
US$105.81 per metric ton at the end of last month, almost 109 percent higher than at
the end of last year.
However, the trauma of low prices might be enough to discourage mining companies
from boosting production too much, Hendra said.
“The volatility of coal prices has made companies more cautious. They are now more
psychologically hesitant, which leads to more conservative production plans despite
high prices,” he said, adding that companies that had shut down some of their mines
due to low coal prices would need several months before the mines could start
operating again.
Government data reveal that Indonesia had around 32.2 billion tons of coal reserves
in 2014.
These reserves will most likely be depleted within the next two decades, forcing the
country to start importing coal by 2030.
Despite the process of democratic transition, farmers in Myanmar's Karen state are
being pushed off their land and face arrest and prison for standing up for their rights,
an international watchdog reported Thursday.
A report by Human Rights Watch shed light on land confiscation in Myanmar, which
has escalated in recent years with the military and armed groups driving people from
their land. Eastern Karen state, on the border with Thailand, has been engulfed in
conflict between Myanmar's troops and ethnic rebels for more than half a century,
resulting in massive displacements of villagers.
The Southeast Asian nation's 70 percent of the population live off agriculture and
depend on land for survival.
The Assistant Association for Political Prisoners, a pressure group, said that more
than 40 farmers were on trial while three have been sentenced to three to five years'
imprisonment on charges of protesting usurpation of their land rights.
Aung San Suu Kyi's government, which took office more than five months ago
following five decades of military rule, has not responded to any of the particular
cases, Human Rights Watch said.
The state government in Karen did not immediately return phone calls seeking
comment on Thursday.
"The authorities has not been able to solve any of the land grab issue in Karen state
until now, because they have no powerful influence on the military or any armed
groups and this is a great loss for many farmers," said Naw Ohn Hla, a prominent
human rights defender and land rights activist.
When civilians flee their homes to escape conflict, militias operating under the
central government, police or local authorities usually confiscate the land, he said.
Coming from a culture where tipping is less demanding, the American tipping norm
is something new for me. In fact, my first culture shock in the US was when I
received a bill with a tip calculator telling me how much to tip based on my meal
purchase.
Taylor Smith, a waiter at a restaurant in Boulder, Colorado, argues that customers tip
because they receive good service from the waiters. She thinks that customers will
tip more if the waiter does a good job. She further explains that young people like
herself tend to tip less than older people because they normally do not have much
money. She believes that tipping involves a lot of human psychology. Everyone
wants a different kind of service, and they have different criteria for what constitutes
good service. Their tips will vary regardless of the waiter’s performance.
In his research, Lynn also found that good service and high-tipping have a weak
relationship. That is, customers do not give good tips to waiters just because they get
good service. He further explains that the quality of serving has the same effect with
what the weather looks like and how the customers feel that day. Even if a server
makes a mistake like spilling water on the customer’s table, he will still likely get a
tip of at least 15 percent of the meal price.
Tipping is unpredictable. Common sense suggests that the better the quality of
service, the higher the tip. Although this fact is true to a certain degree, according to
the study, the quality of the service is not comparable to feelings of guilt. A very
important takeaway from the study is that waiters should always do their jobs at their
best and be grateful when they get high tips. On the other hand, they should not be
discouraged when they get low tips because it does not necessarily mean that they
provided poor service.
Most recent discussions of regional security in Southeast Asia center on the ongoing
tension in the South China Sea. China’s apparent assertiveness in expressing its
claim to this region has raised concerns with Southeast Asian countries bordering
this strategic spot.
Indonesia, which controls the Natuna Islands in the southern end of the sea, keeps its
distance from the dispute and tries to serve as an honest broker to keep the area
peaceful and secure.
But recent events seem to have prompted Indonesia to increase its defensive posture
in the region. Several Chinese fishing boats — backed by armed coast guard vessels
— have encroached into Natuna waters, and clashed with Indonesian security and
military boats. In response, President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo inaugurated an
expansion of Natuna’s airbase at the Indonesian Military (TNI) anniversary event last
month.
Thanks to the improvements, Natuna can now host a larger contingent of military
forces when security tension escalates. Such forces may include soldiers and
marines, with support from naval ships, aircraft and helicopters, to patrol the islands
and its surrounding battle space.
Despite building the infrastructure, a question remains. At the strategic level, what
would be required of TNI to respond to challenges given the country’s geographical
Utilizing this concept, TNI could deploy its tri-service assets along the string of
islands in the archipelago. These combined sea, air and ground operations would
entail deployment of surveillance, patrol and strike forces, as well as transportation
assets that would sustain the operations.
Using the Natuna Islands as an example, the army and marine elements would
defend the island from an amphibious assault force and man artillery and missile
batteries to harass an approaching naval fleet. The navy ships would conduct patrols
against surface combatants and submarine intrusions. Aircraft would comb the
horizon for any incoming force and would deny any attempt at air supremacy in the
area.
The ships and planes could be based in either Pontianak or Batam, where there is
more support capability for naval and air operations. In turn, these two bases would
be supported by reinforcement from the main bases in Java or Sumatra.
Such patterns could be replicated for securing the Strait of Makassar from Nunukan
and Tarakan, and similarly for the defense of the Moluccas from the hub in Morotai.
These interlocking forces in the islands, though, are just one of the necessary pillars
to successfully implement the archipelagic defense. The other essential pillar for this
to be effective is the military capability — also known as expeditionary capability —
to move and sustain those combat forces, especially for soldiers on the ground in
those outermost islands.
Although all military operations are directed from the TNI headquarters as joint
operations by utilizing various forces from the three services, seamless tri-service
combined operations could be very challenging due to a lack of regular joint training
among TNI’s units.
The challenge is especially compounded for the expeditionary units as their training
regimen mostly depends on all-arms exercises rather than specific exercises for them.
A robust and sustainable train of reinforcement and logistics is essential for the
archipelagic defense to be effective.
The naval amphibious vessels are the primary means for TNI’s expeditionary force.
From these ships, marines assault beaches and sustain them for the fight. They also
maintain logistical train to reinforce and resupply the troops on the ground. The
bigger ships also can launch helicopters for expanding the marine’s operational area.
Currently, if using all its ships at one time, the Indonesian navy can deliver about
one-and-a-half marine or army brigades with their associated tanks and artillery.
Considering operational cycles, the most that the ships can transport at any one time
is around one brigade of 2,000 troops.
As this capacity must be divided to allow for support of at least three outposts in the
sprawling archipelago, the navy could move only about a battalion to a theater. That
is indeed only a limited reinforcement for the island defenders.
From the air, the mainstay of TNI’s airlift is provided by 15 Hercules medium
transport aircraft. They can drop paratroopers from their bases in Java into the
outposts even with only a rough landing strip.
Another critical airlift and logistical asset is the helicopter fleet, which can be
stationed in forward bases –such as Pontianak – for reinforcement of logistical
sustenance of troops in the outpost. The air force depends on Super Puma for this
purpose, and the army utilizes the Russian-made Hip helicopter. Both are of the
medium-lift type.
Their limited lift capacity and operational endurance, however, hamper the necessary
reach to maintain the interlocking quality of archipelagic defense. For this critical
purpose, TNI needs heavy-lift helicopters with greater payload and range capability.
Moreover, as these helicopter fleets would be the main artery in this strategy, their
operational readiness must be at the highest level, which can be obtained through
extensive crew training, proper maintenance and reliable supply of parts. Our
soldiers and marines depend on this logistical train as provided by the expeditionary
force. They are the critical link in erecting Indonesia’s archipelagic defense chain.
We need those ships, aircraft and helicopters now.
Exhibited for one week at Kota Kasablanka shopping mall in South Jakarta, Height
Ways portrays multiple Veri who is walking on a tightrope above a city, almost
similar to one of the scenes in the movie. In front of the drawing there is a replica of
the tightrope made out of iron, where people can walk on it as if they are strolling
above a city. “People can try it so they can experience the sensation,” Veri told The
Jakarta Post on Saturday.
Indonesian contemporary artist Veri Apriyatno is seen trying out a tightrope replica
in front of his artwork, 'Height Ways' at Kota Kasablanka shopping mall in South
Jakarta.(JP/Ni Nyoman Wira)
When creating Height Ways, taking around two months, Veri asked his friend to take
photos of him walking on a railroad. “Everything was drawn by pencil in a detailed
way,” he said, adding that the one being displayed was actually a resized print
version since the actual piece was around 2 by 1 meters.
Later on, Veri, who is also a Marvel enthusiast, met with the representatives of the
company. “As far as I know Disney Marvel likes to collaborate with local artists.
They are looking for artists whose artwork resembles their concept,” he said. “Height
Ways was chosen because it is closest to their concept among others.”
The artwork has a quite interesting philosophy. “I want to feel like I can be in many
places, but I have to split myself in two,” Veri said. “The point is we need to delegate
[our tasks] to other people, that is how we [actually] split ourselves, therefore we can
do as many tasks as we want.”
Unlike other artists who are usually shy to put themselves in the spotlight, Veri often
features himself as the object of his drawing series. “I found a philosophy [from
there] that if we want to know God, we have to know ourselves first. It means that
you don't need to search for God everywhere, but inside of you,” he said.
As for his forthcoming object, Veri plans to create encaustic (hot wax) paintings and
post the tutorial on his YouTube channel. (kes)
Iran celebrated its 38th anniversary of the victory of the Islamic Revolution of 1979
by rejoicing in what it called a new era of Iranian development, following the lifting
of unilateral sanctions against the Gulf power.
The agreement, which was discussed by Iran along with the United States, the United
Kingdom, France, Russia, China and Germany, allowed Iran to continue developing
its nuclear program as long as it was for peaceful civilian purposes in return for a lift
of economic sanctions on the country.
Meanwhile, Agrarian and Spatial Planning Minister Sofyan Djalil, who represented
the government of Indonesia, delivered a keynote speech highlighting the
possibilities of closer cooperation between the two countries.
Sofyan noted weakening trade relations between the two partners over the past few
years, but resolved to find opportunities to reverse the trend in key areas of
cooperation, including in energy, oil and gas, electricity, technology and agriculture.
“I’m optimistic that the trade volume could be increased in the coming years, since
the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action has been reached by the P5+1 countries,”
Sofjan said at the reception.
Indonesia and Iran’s trade balance stood at US$221.31 million between January and
October last year, roughly $10 million lower than that recorded in the same period in
2015, and still below $273.09 million — the total twoway trade in 2015.
In December, President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo met with Iranian President Hassan
Rouhani and a number of business delegates during his two-day state visit to the
Persian Gulf country.
Among the luminaries spotted at the reception were envoys to Jordan, Morocco,
Afghanistan, as well as a number of ambassadors from European and Asian
continents.
(1/2)Malaysia is one step closer to amending the mandatory death sentence, Minister
in the Prime Minister’s Department Nancy Shukri said.
Nancy told the World Congress Against The Death Penalty in Oslo, Norway,
recently that a government-backed study on the death penalty had been completed
and a paper is being readied by the Attorney General’s Chambers.
“There are positive signs in Malaysia and a steady momentum towards possible
change in the death penalty legislation,” Nancy said.
The study was conducted by the International Centre For Law and Legal Studies (I-
CeLLS). The consultant was then Roger Hood, Professor of Criminology and
Emeritus Fellow of All Souls College Oxford.
Currently, in Malaysia, the death penalty is mandatory for 12 offences while 20 other
offences are punishable with discretionary death penalty.
Murder, drug trafficking, and offences related to security are instances of offences
which are punishable with death.
However, Nancy said empirical studies showed that the death penalty had not led to
“the deterring effect that such a penalty was created”.
The global anti-death congress was the sixth edition. Nancy expressed her “deepest
appreciation to Norway” for inviting Malaysia to participate.
For Teddy, 57, the forced eviction he experienced in Kampung Akuarium, also
known as Pasar Ikan, in North Jakarta, in April last year was unforgettable and
changed the course of his family’s life for the worse.
The evictees in Pasar Ikan believe that incumbent Jakarta Governor Basuki “Ahok”
Tjahaja Purnama is responsible for their misery because he was the one who ordered
the forced evictions.
Pasar Ikan residents say that in the 2012 Jakarta gubernatorial election, President
Joko “Jokowi” Widodo, then campaigning for the position of governor, and his
running mate Ahok won an overwhelming majority of votes there. Jokowi-Ahok
signed a political contract with the residents promising them several things including
upgrading the on-site slum, a process labelled geser bukan gusur, meaning “move a
little, not forced evictions.”
In the geser bukan gusur scheme, residents would agree to move a few meters away
from the river to make way for the inspection road.
For Pasar Ikan residents, the forced evictions have changed their feelings about Ahok
completely. Teddy, who has four children and is now unemployed, said he had
planned to send his children to university using the money he had gradually saved up
over the years. However, the eviction destroyed his dream.
The city administration evicted 596 families in the poor fishermen’s neighborhood in
April last year to clear the area of what Ahok called illegal squatters and a hotbed of
tuberculosis.
Jono, who like Teddy still remains in the evicted neighborhood, said relocation was
not an option for him and many of the residents who worked around Pasar Ikan. He
said he once checked out an apartment in Marunda but later decided to come back
and live in a makeshift shack because the apartment was too far away from Pasar
Ikan where he works as a boat porter.
Since the eviction, the community of Pasar Ikan has been one of the most organized
in its animosity toward Ahok.
When The Jakarta Post visited the area on Wednesday, Anies Baswedan banners, the
rival of Ahok in the Jakarta gubernatorial election, and the flag of the Gerindra Party,
were everywhere to be seen.
Teddy said Anies had visited the area during a recent campaign stop and personally
met with residents along with Gerindra Party chairman Prabowo Subianto.
Teddy said, however, that residents did not expect much from a politician like Anies,
noting that they had already been betrayed by politicians in the past.
“If a political contract is betrayed, how can we trust a [mere] promise,” Teddy said.
In 2012, Jokowi-Ahok also made a contract with Bukit Duri residents in South
Jakarta. One of the points was geser bukan gusur. In 2012, Jokowi and Ahok also
won a majority of votes in Bukit Duri.
In September 2016, however, Ahok ordered the forced eviction of residents in the
area and told them to move to apartments in Rawa Bebek.
Besides Anies, rival Agus Harimurti Yudhoyono has also taken a different stance
from Ahok in regards to forced evictions. He has tried to woo voters with promises
that he will not evict them. He also used the term geser bukan gusur while
campaigning in the area.
Ahok’s camp, on the other hand, has campaigned on continuing to develop the city.
Ahok and his supporters have mocked Anies and Agus, saying that they are all talk
and that it is impossible to develop the city without forced evictions.
On social media, memes mocking Agus’ geser bukan gusur proposal are circulating
with Ahok’s supporters calling it a “ridiculous theory.”
The third debate on Friday evening will be the last showdown for Jakarta
gubernatorial candidates to win over swing voters amid a tight race, in which
pollsters have difficulties predicting the winner.
The debate, which will address population and quality-of-life issues, will take place
two days before the campaign period officially ends.
“This debate will be the final chance for voters to see all candidates on one stage,
imparting their solutions, visions and missions, regarding the city’s woes. We hope
that through this debate, voters will be able to single out the person who will lead the
city for the next five years,” Jakarta General Elections Commission (KPU Jakarta)
member Betty Epsilon Idroos told The Jakarta Post on Thursday.
Betty also urged the three candidate pairs, Agus Harimurti Yudhoyono and Sylviana
Murni, Basuki “Ahok” Tjahaja Purnama and Djarot Saiful Hidayat and Anies
Baswedan and Sandiaga Uno, to use the finale debate as a medium to woo more
voters.
“The debate may not only help undecided voters make a decision, but could actually
influence voters that have already made up their minds to switch to candidates they
deem as having presented better and concrete ideas,” she said.
Friday’s debate, which will cover the topics of women’s empowerment, child
protection, drug eradication and the protection of residents with disabilities, will be
moderated by CNN Indonesia news anchor Alfito Deannova.
Betty said KPU Jakarta selected Alfito because he had long experience as a
television host.
Betty said just like the second debate on Jan. 27, the final one would run for 120
minutes and be divided into six segments. There will also be four panelists. KPU
Jakarta has yet to divulge the names of the panelists.
The election commission has engaged Transmedia, Kompas TV, SCTV and JakTV
as host stations for the debate, which will also be broadcast by 10 other television
stations, including Aljazeera TV.
Candidate Agus, who surveys and analysts say did not benefit from the previous two
debates, said there were no special preparations for the final debate.
“In preparing myself for the upcoming debate, I delved into the issues to be
addressed in between my daily campaign activities,” Agus said.
Agus said he was optimistic that he and Sylviana could convince Jakarta voters to
cast their votes for the pair in the remaining time before voting day, believing that, if
elected governor, the ticket’s programs “could further develop” the capital.
Agus’ rivals, Ahok and Anies have until now gained most from the debates, with
survey results showing their electability had received a boost after each debate on
Jan. 13 and Jan. 27.
The Ahok-Djarot camp said it had prepared nothing special and would again
elaborate on what it had accomplished during its tenure. In the past debates Ahok and
Djarot took advantage of their incumbent position and many voters said they were
the most knowledgeable pair.
“They don’t need to get too fancy,” Ahok-Djarot campaign team secretary Ace
Hasan Syadzily said.
Meanwhile, the Anies-Sandiaga ticket is also confident going into the final debate,
hoping that the issue of improving Jakarta residents’ quality of life, which has been
the focus of its campaign, could give them an edge in the final debate.
On women’s issues, Anies said he had plans to make life more comfortable for
women in Jakarta, including by providing “labor emergency units” in all community
health centers (Puskesmas), as maternal deaths continued to occur on account of a
lack of medical access in Jakarta.
The Bambu Apus shelter in East Jakarta looks like any regular rehabilitation center
where children can be seen playing without a particularly heavy security presence.
But that does not mean visitors can simply drop into the shelter, which currently
houses 75 people deported from Turkey, Singapore and Japan for allegedly trying to
join the Islamic State (IS) terrorist group in Syria.
“I’m sorry, entry to this place must be approved by the National Police’s
counterterrorism squad Densus 88,” a man holding a walkie-talkie told The Jakarta
Post at the shelter’s gate.
Of the 75 people housed in the shelter, which has a total capacity of 130 people, 17
are men, 24 are women and 34 children.
Many of them are related to each other. The last batch of alleged IS supporters sent
to the shelter includes former Finance Ministry official Triyono Utomo, 40, his wife
Nur Khofifah, 55, and three children aged 12, 7 and 3.
Unlike neighboring Malaysia, which has charged a number of people with trying to
join IS in Syria under its penal code, Indonesia does not regard such attempts as
crimes.
The National Police have said supporters can only be charged with terrorism if they
are found to have actually joined and fought with IS.
Despite having been exposed to radical ideologies for years that inspired them to
migrate to Syria to join IS, the deported IS supporters, particularly the 41 adults, only
undergo a one-month deradicalization program at the shelter before being sent back
to their respective hometowns.
The 17 men are held in separate buildings away from their wives but they can still
interact with each other during breaks and before bedtime.
The children are also separated from their radicalized fathers and housed in the same
buildings as their mothers. One of the 34 children is a three-week-old infant and
some others are toddlers.
The shelter has several parks where social workers take the children to play various
games and teach them to read books every day accompanied by psychologists to
ensure that they are in a stable psychological state and have not been exposed to
radical ideology by their parents.
Children only return to their parents during breaks and when they want to go to sleep
with their mothers, Bambu Apus shelter head Sulistya Ariadhi told the Post over the
phone.
Activities start at 5 a.m. when they wake for dawn prayers at the shelter, after which
they are required to attend daily sessions from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.
Many of the deportees, who are not allowed to have access to cellphones or the
internet during their stay, refused to talk in the first days after their arrival at the
shelter, Sulistya said.
“But after three days or so they start to communicate with social workers. That’s
good progress. Social workers will ensure that they are ready to communicate with
other people before they are sent to their respective hometowns,” he said.
At the end of the program, Sulistya said, Bambu Apus officials will meet with
Densus 88, the BNPT and Social Affairs Ministry officials to conduct an assessment
of each of the deportees to determine whether they are ready to go home.
Society must embrace the families after they return home because to leave them
alienated and stigmatized will only push them back into radicalism, BNPT chief
Suhardi Alius said.
Critics, however, question the law enforcers’ decision to let the adult IS supporters
go despite their attempts to join the terrorist group. “The fact that they already
arrived in Turkey to enter Syria shows that they were acting on their intentions. That
should be subject to prosecution,” terrorism expert Al Chaidar said.
He further argued that the problem could be because Indonesia has yet to draw up an
official list of foreign terrorist organizations that could be used as a legal reference
by the police in their investigation of deported IS supporters.
“The Attorney General’s Office has to move to draw up such a list so our law
enforcement agencies have a reference list on which organizations are labeled as
terrorist groups,” he said.