You are on page 1of 6

Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-018-3558-1

BRIEF REPORT

Brief Report: Postural Balance and Daily Living Skills in Children


and Adolescents with Autism
Aubrey Fisher1,2,3 · Courtney Engel1,2,3 · Robyn Geist1,2,3 · Kristin Lillie1,2,3 · Sagui Lutman1,2,3 ·
Brittany G. Travers1,2,3 

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2018

Abstract
The current study investigated the relation between postural balance and performance of daily living skills (DLS) in youth
with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Fifty-two youth with ASD (6–17 years; IQ ≥ 67) completed standardized balance
testing and parent-reported DLS measures. Results showed a positive association between balance and DLS that was specific
to youth with below-average IQ. While balance challenges were evident across the IQ spectrum, youth with above-average
IQ did not exhibit an association between balance and DLS, perhaps suggestive of compensatory strategies implemented to
offset balance challenges during daily-living tasks. These results underscore the need to better understand the contributions
of motor challenges to DLS in youth with ASD within the context of broader cognitive and environmental factors.

Keywords  Autism spectrum disorder · Daily living skills · Balance · Motor

Introduction may affect the performance of DLS tasks such as grooming,


dressing, and household chores. Of these motor challenges,
Daily living skills (DLS) are a major challenge for indi- postural balance may be particularly difficult for individuals
viduals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) (Liss et al. with ASD (Ament et al. 2015), and it is often assumed that
2001; Perry et  al. 2009). The ability to complete basic balance challenges impact DLS in this population. Indeed,
DLS allows individuals to participate independently in the everyday tasks such as stepping out of the shower, cooking
home and community, making it is essential to understand at the stove, or dressing become substantially more complex
the factors that contribute to DLS challenges in ASD. Cur- if one cannot consistently rely on steadiness during standing.
rent evidence suggests that age, executive function, symp- However, no study has directly examined the link between
tom severity, and IQ are associated with DLS challenges postural balance and DLS in youth with ASD. The present
(Bal et al. 2015; Duncan and Bishop 2015; Pugliese et al. study addressed this gap by examining the relation between
2016; Smith et al. 2012), but factors such as atypical motor standardized measures of balance and DLS in children and
skills may additionally contribute to poorer DLS perfor- adolescents with ASD, while accounting for factors such as
mance. Many individuals with ASD exhibit motor impair- age and IQ.
ments (Fournier et al. 2010), and these motor challenges Only a handful of studies have examined motor contribu-
tions to DLS in ASD, but the findings suggest that a number
of motor features may be associated with DLS performance
* Brittany G. Travers in this population. Sensory features, fine motor, and gross
btravers@wisc.edu
motor performance were associated with DLS in preschool-
1
Occupational Therapy Program, University of Wisconsin- ers with ASD, with the strongest relation existing between
Madison, 2185 Medical Sciences Center, 1300 University fine motor skills and DLS (Jasmin et al. 2009). Similarly,
Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA motor coordination problems were associated with poorer
2
Department of Kinesiology, University DLS in school-aged females with ASD and school-aged
of Wisconsin-Madison, 2185 Medical Sciences Center, 1300 females with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder, even
University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA
when accounting for performance IQ (Kopp et al. 2010).
3
Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1500 Longitudinal research by Travers et al. (2017) found that
Highland Avenue, Madison, WI 53705, USA

13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders

manual motor skills (i.e., grip strength and finger-tapping disability, a known medical cause of ASD (i.e., fragile-X),
speed) significantly correlated with current and future DLS hypoxia–ischemia, seizure disorder, or other neurological
in individuals with ASD from childhood to mid-adulthood, disorders. The sample was representative of the racial com-
even after accounting for age and IQ. Taken together, it position of the USA, per the 2011–2015 estimates of the
appears that fine motor and motor coordination challenges U.S. Census Bureau (http://facti​finde​r.censu​s.gov): 65.4%
relate to DLS in ASD, but there is little evidence regarding White, Non-Hispanic; 11.5% Black/African American; 7.7%
the role of balance. Given that many DLS tasks inherently Asian; 7.7% White, Hispanic, and 7.7% more than one race.
involve standing and weight-shifting, it is important to deter- See Table 1 for additional demographic information.
mine if balance impairments are affecting DLS performance
in this population. Understanding this relation could aid in Measures and Materials
the development of appropriate motor interventions for chil-
dren and adolescents with ASD in order to promote greater Bruininks–Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency—2nd
independence in the home and community. Therefore, the Edition (BOT‑2) (Bruininks and Bruininks 2005)
aim of the present study was to examine the association
between postural balance and DLS performance in children The BOT-2 short form and balance subscale were used to
and adolescents with ASD. Based on the theoretical con- assess overall motor percentiles and balance. The BOT-2
tributions of balance to DLS as well as evidence that other is a standardized assessment of motor abilities that meas-
motor domains relate to DLS in ASD, we hypothesized that ures manual coordination, body coordination and balance,
participants with poorer balance would have poorer perfor- strength and agility, and fine motor skills. The balance sub-
mance in DLS, above and beyond the effects of age and IQ. scale uses two-footed and one-footed postures under various
conditions (eyes open, eyes closed, and balance beam) to
evaluate static and dynamic motor skills essential for main-
Methods taining posture while standing and walking. Balance scores
range from 0 to 37, with higher scores indicating better bal-
Design ance. The BOT-2 is normed for ages 4–21 years and has
demonstrated strong test–retest reliability, strong internal
To examine the relationship between balance and DLS reliability, and high interrater reliability. Within our lab, all
in children with ASD, a standardized measure of balance BOT-2 assessments were live coded by two separate raters,
and a standardized measure of DLS were combined across who used videos of administration and consensus coding to
three concurrent studies within our lab (i.e., two studies that reconcile any discrepancies.
examined a biofeedback-based balance training and one neu-
roimaging study that examined brain-motor relations). These Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale, Second Edition (VABS‑II)
measures were collected as part of the intake for all three (Sparrow et al. 2005)
studies. All measures, regardless of study, were administered
and scored by the same research team and were adminis- The VABS-II was administered as a parent/caregiver
tered prior to any balance training. The current analyses report, and the Daily Living Scale was used to assess
were consistent with the aims of all three studies, as the age-normed DLS. The Daily Living Scale specifically
overarching goal was to better understand motor skills in
youth with ASD.
Table 1  Demographic characteristics of the sample
Participants
N = 52 participants with
ASD (90% male)
All three studies were approved by the University of Wis-
Mean (SD) Range
consin-Madison’s Institutional Review Board. All parents
provided written informed consent, and all children provided Age (years) 12.60 (3.34) 6.41–17.85
informed assent. Fifty-two children and adolescents with Full scale IQ 103.25 (14.29) 67–135
ASD (6–17 years old; 90.4% male) completed the meas- VABS-II daily living skills standard 90.40 (15.98) 66–117
ures. To be included in these analyses, all participants were score
required to have a previous diagnosis of ASD that was sup- BOT-2 balance score (0–37 range) 27.50 (5.88) 9–37
ported by meeting criteria for ASD on Modules 3 or 4 of the BOT-2 percentile 14.04 (13.01) 1st–62nd
Autism Diagnostic Observation Scale-2nd edition (ADOS-
ASD autism spectrum disorder, BOT-2 Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of
2) (Lord et  al. 2012). Individuals were excluded from motor proficiency, 2nd edition, VABS-II vineland adaptive behavior
the study if they had a previous diagnosis of intellectual scales, 2nd edition

13
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders

measures age-normed performance of daily living tasks Results


such as household chores, dressing, and grooming. DLS
standard scores were used, with higher scores indicating The overall multiple regression predicting DLS as a func-
stronger DLS. The VABS-II has shown strong internal tion of balance, IQ, and age was significant, F(5,46) = 6.77,
consistency and test–retest reliability. p < .001, R2 =. 424 (95% confidence interval: .248–.599),
adjusted R2 = .361. The unstandardized beta coefficients,
their 95% confidence intervals, standard errors, and t-tests
Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence‑2nd Edition are shown in Table 2. Contrary to our predictions, there
(WASI‑II) (Wechsler and Hsiao‑pin 2011) was not a conditional (“main”) effect for balance. How-
ever, we found a significant interaction between balance
The WASI-II is an abbreviated measure of intelligence and IQ and a main effect for age and a­ ge2. The main effects
for ages 6–90 years with strong reliability and validity. for age and ­age2 suggest that DLS standard scores showed
The WASI-II includes four subtests (block design, vocabu- a slight decrease (with an inverted U-shape) as a function
lary, matrix reasoning, and similarities) to assess verbal of age within this ASD group. The interaction between
comprehension, perceptual reasoning, and general intel- balance and IQ is shown in Fig.  1. While the interac-
lectual ability (full scale IQ). Full scale IQ also has been tion between balance and IQ in the regression model was
shown to be reliably assessed with the two-subtest version between two continuous variables, Fig. 1 simplifies this
of the WASI-II (block design and vocabulary), although interaction by showing the relation between balance and
verbal comprehension and perceptual reasoning cannot be DLS scores in those with above-median IQ and those with
assessed with two subtests. In the present sample, 75% below-median IQ (median = 104).
(39) of participants received the four-subtest version of From Fig. 1, we see that there was a positive relation
the WASI-II (used by two of the three studies). The other between balance and DLS performance in individuals with
25% of participants received the two-subtest version (used below-median IQ but not in those with above-median IQ.
by one of the three studies). Follow-up partial correlational analyses (controlling for
age) confirmed that those with below-median IQ (< = 104)
demonstrated a significant, medium-to-large, positive rela-
Procedures tion between balance and DLS, r = + .44, p = .02, whereas
those with higher IQ (> 104) did not exhibit a relation
The intake session was similar across all three studies. between balance and DLS, r = − .09, p = .68. To examine
Specifically, after informed consent and assent forms were if balance scores differed between the below-median-IQ
signed, the participant completed the ADOS-2, WASI-II, group and the above-median-IQ group, we performed an
and BOT-2. While the participant completed these assess- independent-samples t-test. Similar balance scores were
ments, parents completed the VABS-II. observed in both the below-median-IQ group (M = 26.59,
SD = 6.25) and the above-median-IQ group (M = 28.48,
SD = 5.42), t(50) = 1.16, p = .25, Cohen’s d = 0.323.
Data Analysis

Data analysis was completed using R version 3.2.2 (R Core


Team 2015). To examine DLS as a function of balance, we
fit a standard multiple regression model. Because IQ and
age are known to affect DLS (Liss et al. 2001; Smith et al.
2012), age, a quadratic term for age (­ age2), IQ, and their Table 2  Summary of unstandardized beta coefficients from multiple
interactions were included alongside balance as poten- regression analysis examining predictors of daily living skills (DLS)
tial variables in the regression model. The leaps package standard scores (n = 52)
(Lumley 2017) was used in an exhaustive search to find b 95% CI SE t value p value
which subset of these variables accounted for the most
Intercept 96.88 91.06, 102.71 2.89 33.48 < .001
variance, using adjusted R2 to account for the number of
Balance 0.44 − 0.21, 1.08 0.32 1.36 .18
predictor variables in each model. This procedure led to
IQ 0.22 − 0.05, 0.49 0.12 1.64 .11
the final model: DLS standard scores ~ intercept + balance
Age − 1.98 − 3.09, − 0.88 0.55 − 3.62 < .001
scores + IQ + age + age2 + balance*IQ. To reduce the like-
Age2 − 0.57 − 0.98, − 0.15 0.20 − 2.76 .008
lihood of multicollinearity, all independent variables were
Balance X IQ − 0.04 − 0.08, − 0.00007 0.02 − 2.02 .04
mean-centered. All regression assumptions for the final
model were examined and met. Significant effects are bolded

13
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders

Fig. 1  Daily living skills (DLS) standard scores as a function of and plotted the relation between balance and DLS in those with
balance and full scale IQ. Balance was found to significantly inter- higher and lower IQs. However, we also used color to demonstrate
act with IQ to predict DLS, suggesting that balance and DLS were individual differences in IQ, as IQ was used as a continuous variable
related only in those with lower IQ scores. To illustrate the nature of in all of the analyses. The points on the scatterplot are adjusted for
this interaction, we performed a median split for IQ (median = 104) the main effect of age, as age was a significant predictor in the model

Discussion IQ scores, even though the relation between balance and


DLS was observed only in the youth with lower IQ scores.
The present study is the first, to our knowledge, to investigate One possible explanation for this pattern of results is that
the relation between postural balance and DLS performance individuals with higher IQ may have developed strategies or
in youth with ASD. Our results suggest that poorer balance routines to compensate for balance challenges during DLS
was associated with poorer DLS performance (above-and- (i.e. sitting down while dressing, using structural supports to
beyond the effects of age) but only in individuals who had lean on while completing daily tasks, etc.). In other words,
below-average IQ (IQs of 67–104). In those with above- children and adolescents with ASD with higher IQ may be
average IQ (IQs of 105–135), there was no relation between finding ways around relying on balance during daily tasks.
balance and DLS performance. These results extend upon While our current measure of DLS did not provide informa-
previous motor research to suggest that in addition to manual tion on compensatory strategies, past research has found that
motor skills (Travers et al. 2017), sensorimotor features (Jas- youth with developmental coordination disorder (Missiuna
min et al. 2009), and motor coordination (Kopp et al. 2010), et al. 2008) and cerebral palsy (Klotz et al. 2013) use cogni-
balance challenges may contribute to difficulties with DLS tive and behavioral strategies to manage motor challenges
in individuals with ASD. However, in contrast to previous during DLS. However, future research is needed to directly
research, the relation between balance and DLS was spe- test this possibility in ASD either by inquiring about poten-
cific to those who scored lower on the IQ assessment, even tial strategies used during DLS performance or by observing
though no participant in this study had a diagnosis of co- DLS performance in naturalistic environments.
occurring intellectual disability. It is unclear whether other These results have important implications for interven-
motor skills, such as fine motor skills, also interact with IQ tions that target DLS performance in youth with ASD. The
to predict DLS. However, this is a key avenue for future present results suggest that based on cognitive and motor
research, as the present results suggest that cognition may be profiles, different DLS interventions may be warranted for
an important factor to consider when examining the impact different individuals. Therefore, assessing both motor and
of motor skills on DLS, even in youth with ASD without cognitive skills prior to any DLS intervention may inform
co-occurring intellectual disability. the best course of action for teaching DLS to an individual
Notably, the results suggest that those with lower IQ with ASD. Specifically, for youth who are found to have
scores had similar balance challenges to those with higher both balance challenges and lower IQ scores, it is possible

13
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders

that targeting the balance challenges through balance prac- factors will enhance the design and efficacy of interventions
tice, physical therapy, or occupational therapy, may have that target DLS challenges in youth with ASD.
cascading benefits on DLS. Moreover, balance training in
conjunction with teaching and rehearsing DLS may lead to Acknowledgments  This work was supported by the Brain and Behav-
ior Research Foundation’s NARSAD Young Investigator Award [to
the greatest gains in DLS in this group. In contrast, youth BGT], the Hartwell Foundation’s Individual Biomedical Award [to
with ASD who have higher IQ scores may be strategically BGT], and the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child
compensating for balance challenges in DLS. Therefore, Health and Human Development [P30 HD003352 and U54 HD090256
we likely need to develop and implement different inter- to the Waisman Center]. The content is solely the responsibility of
the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of
vention strategies, as balance interventions are unlikely the National Institute of Child Health & Development or the National
to improve DLS performance in individuals who already Institutes of Health. We thank Sarah Brill, Sarah Crook, Olga Dadalko,
have methods for accommodating their balance deficits. Ashley Dinges, Dana Dobbe, Nikki Erickson, Isabelle Gallagher,
For this group with higher IQ scores, teaching further Andres Gomez, Larissa Hacker, Lauren Hoover, Sarah Jacquot, Brooke
Koehn, Jenna Lent, Nicole Marczak, Rachel Matz, Kristine McLaugh-
behavioral strategies to manage balance challenges may lin, Claire Melin, Molly Pearcy, Carli Peters, Kirstin Peters, Katie Phil-
be a more efficacious approach to improving DLS perfor- lips, Jenna Radke, Kailey Sabel, Rachel Samz, Sean Sekelsky, Michele
mance than trying to enhance balance itself. Severson, Olivia Surgent, Elise Suttner, Josh Tarnoff, Desiree Taylor,
A limitation of the present study is that the parent- Jake Tenaglia, David Turner, Amin Tmimi, Caitie Van Sloun, Matthew
Walczak, Shannon Wittel, and Oskar Zarzycki for their contributions
report DLS measure assessed performance across a num- to this project. We sincerely thank all the families who participated in
ber of daily tasks rather than assessing tasks that might this study.
specifically require balance. This may have led to an
underestimation of the role of balance in daily living tasks. Author Contributions  All authors participated in the conception,
Future research that links balance challenges to specific design, coordination, analysis, and interpretation of the data. All
authors assisted in drafting the manuscript. BGT oversaw all aspects
daily living tasks will be critical to inform intervention. of the study and finalized data analysis, interpretation, and the drafting
Therefore, there is a need to develop and utilize func- of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
tional assessment tools that measure motor skills during
daily tasks such as upper and lower extremity dressing or Compliance with Ethical Standards 
bringing a utensil to the mouth for feeding. An assess-
ment that measures balance and other motor skills during Conflict of interest  All the authors declares that they have no conflict
a functional task would provide the specificity needed to of interest.
understand the underlying causes of the observed deficits Ethical Approval  This project was approved the University of Wis-
in both balance and DLS in ASD. Further, a functional consin-Madison Education and Social/Behavioral Science Institutional
assessment may be able to exhibit if and how individuals Review Board (protocol #2014-1248) and Health Sciences Institutional
are compensating for balance challenges during functional Review Board (protocols #2014-1499 and #2016-0441).
tasks, which our current measure of DLS was unable to do.
The use of more comprehensive, functional assessments
could assist in tailoring specific motor-based interventions References
for this population.
In all, while postural balance is often assumed to impact Ament, K., Mejia, A., Buhlman, R., Erklin, S., Caffo, B., Mostofsky,
DLS performance in youth with ASD, the present results S., & Wodka, E. (2015). Evidence for specificity of motor impair-
ments in catching and balance in children with autism. Journal
suggest that balance challenges relate to DLS performance of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 45(3), 742–751. https​://
only in youth with ASD who have below-average IQ scores. doi.org/10.1007/s1080​3-014-2229-0.
This finding suggests a potential interaction between cog- Bal, V. H., Kim, S.-H., Cheong, D., & Lord, C. (2015). Daily living
nition and motor skills that should be accounted for when skills in individuals with autism spectrum disorder from 2 to 21
years of age. Autism: The International Journal of Research and
trying to understand the underlying causes of poorer DLS Practice, 19(7), 774–784. https​://doi.org/10.1177/13623​61315​
performance in ASD. These findings raise the question of 57584​0.
how motor challenges in ASD combine with other factors Bruininks, R. H., & Bruininks, B. B. (2005). Bruininks-Oseretsky
known to be associated with DLS, such as executive function test of motor proficiency, (2nd ed.) Minneapolis, MN: Pearson
Assessment.
and symptom severity. Further, these results from individu- Duncan, A. W., & Bishop, S. L. (2015). Understanding the gap between
als without a history of co-occurring intellectual disability cognitive abilities and daily living skills in adolescents with
raise the question of how balance skills relate to DLS perfor- autism spectrum disorders with average intelligence. Autism: The
mance in individuals with ASD and co-occurring intellectual International Journal of Research and Practice, 19(1), 64–72.
https​://doi.org/10.1177/13623​61313​51006​8.
disability. Most daily living tasks require some type of motor Fournier, K. A., Hass, C. J., Naik, S. K., Lodha, N., & Cauraugh, J. H.
involvement. Thus, understanding the contributions of motor (2010). Motor coordination in autism spectrum disorders: A syn-
skills in combination with other cognitive and environmental thesis and meta-analysis. Journal of Autism and Developmental

13
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders

Disorders, 40(10), 1227–1240. https​://doi.org/10.1007/s1080​ Perry, A., Flanagan, H. E., Dunn Geier, J., & Freeman, N. L. (2009).
3-010-0981-3. Brief report: The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales in young
Jasmin, E., Couture, M., McKinley, P., Reid, G., Fombonne, E., & children with autism spectrum disorders at different cognitive
Gisel, E. (2009). Sensori-motor and daily living skills of pre- levels. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 39(7),
school children with autism spectrum disorders. Journal of 1066–1078. https​://doi.org/10.1007/s1080​3-009-0704-9.
Autism and Developmental Disorders, 39(2), 231–241. https​:// Pugliese, C. E., Anthony, L. G., Strang, J. F., Dudley, K., Wallace,
doi.org/10.1007/s1080​3-008-0617-z. G. L., Naiman, D. Q., & Kenworthy, L. (2016). Longitudinal
Klotz, M. C. M., Kost, L., Braatz, F., Ewerbeck, V., Heitzmann, D., examination of adaptive behavior in autism spectrum disorders:
Gantz, S., et al. (2013). Motion capture of the upper extremity Influence of executive function. Journal of Autism and Develop-
during activities of daily living in patients with spastic hemiple- mental Disorders, 46(2), 467–477. https​://doi.org/10.1007/s1080​
gic cerebral palsy. Gait & Posture, 38(1), 148–152. https​://doi. 3-015-2584-5.
org/10.1016/j.gaitp​ost.2012.11.005. R Core Team. (2015). R: A language and environment for statistical
Kopp, S., Beckung, E., & Gillberg, C. (2010). Developmental coor- computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. https​
dination disorder and other motor control problems in girls with ://www.R-proje​ct.org/.
autism spectrum disorder and/or attention-deficit/hyperactivity Smith, L. E., Maenner, M. J., & Seltzer, M. M. (2012). Developmental
disorder. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 31(2), 350–361. trajectories in adolescents and adults with autism: The case of
https​://doi.org/10.1016/j.ridd.2009.09.017. daily living skills. Journal of the American Academy of Child and
Liss, M., Harel, B., Fein, D., Allen, D., Dunn, M., Feinstein, C., et al. Adolescent Psychiatry, 51(6), 622–631. https​://doi.org/10.1016/j.
(2001). Predictors and correlates of adaptive functioning in chil- jaac.2012.03.001.
dren with developmental disorders. Journal of Autism and Devel- Sparrow, S. S., Cicchetti, D. V., & Balla, D. (2005). Vineland adaptive
opmental Disorders, 31(2), 219–230. behavior scales:(Vineland II), survey interview form/caregiver
Lord, C., Rutter, M., DiLavore, P., Risi, S., Gotham, K., & Bishop, rating form. Livonia, MN: Pearson Assessments.
S. (2012). Autism diagnostic observation schedule–2nd edition Travers, B. G., Bigler, E. D., Duffield, T. C., Prigge, M. D. B., Froe-
(ADOS-2). Los Angeles, CA: Western Psychological Corporation. hlich, A. L., Lange, N., et al. (2017). Longitudinal development of
Lumley, T. (2017). Leaps: Regression subset selection. http://CRAN.R- manual motor ability in autism spectrum disorder from childhood
proje​ct.org/packa​ge=leaps​. to mid-adulthood relates to adaptive daily living skills. Develop-
Missiuna, C., Moll, S., King, G., Stewart, D., & Macdonald, K. mental Science. https​://doi.org/10.1111/desc.12401​.
(2008). Life experiences of young adults who have coordina- Wechsler, D., & Hsiao-pin, C. (2011). Wechsler abbreviated scale of
tion difficulties. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy. intelligence (WASI-II) (2nd ed.). San Antonio, TX: The Psycho-
Revue Canadienne D’ergotherapie, 75(3), 157–166. https​://doi. logical Corporation.
org/10.1177/00084​17408​07500​307.

13

You might also like