"he had the feeling that he was being watched" What are your feelings right now? Are you happy to be here or not? How do you feel about your crush? How would you feel • Feelings can also influence ethical judgments because we being lied upon? can also express our strong Are feelings approval or disapproval of different acts. NECESSARY in • Being good can also involve decision-making? both thinking and feeling Feelings and Moral Decision-Making Feelings and emotions can impede ethical judgments.
Two prevailing theories
• Ethical Subjectivism • Emotivism Ethical Subjectivism • Opposed to objective norms of morality • Truth or falsity of ethical propositions are dependent on feelings, attitudes, or standards of a person or group of persons • Moral judgments simply describe our personal feelings Emotivism • Improved version of Subjectivism • Moral judgments express positive or negative feelings • Moral statements are meaningless • Moral statements only express the speaker's feelings about the issue. • By expressing the speaker's feelings about a moral issue moral statements may influence another person's thoughts and conduct. Errors of Subjectivism and Emotivism: 1. What we like is not necessarily good. 2. We are infallible as long we honestly express our feelings on moral issues. 3. Both can’t account for disagreements in Ethics 4. Dangerous because they teach us to simply follow our feelings and emotions. 5. Suggests that in ethical disputes we appeal to emotions, not to reason Conclusion What can we learn from Subjectivism and Emotivism? • Feelings and emotions are not always wrong • Feelings, taste, emotions, etc. are also helpful in many situations. • They can also help us in making decisions that can give meaning to life. • Subjective feelings sometimes matter in deciding right and wrong • Feelings and emotions should be anchored on careful consideration of right goals, including altruistic ones. • What makes you different from animals? • What makes you different from plants? • What are your similarities with both? Reason and Impartiality Significance of Reason in Ethics: • Humans just like animals are sentient, only humans are rational. • Reason – basis/motive for an action, decision, or conviction. • As a quality, it refers to the capacity for logical, rational, and analytic thought; for consciously making sense of things, establishing and verifying facts, applying common sense and logic, and justifying, and if necessary, changing practices, institutions, and beliefs based on existing or new existing information. • Reason – indicate the difference of moral judgments from expressions of preferences. • Moral Truths – defined by good reasons that are objective and are always true no matter what we might think or want. Impartiality Are your personal interests and point of view important in moral decision making? However, impartiality is far more important. A principle of justice that holds that decisions should be based on objective criteria, rather than on the basis of bias, prejudice, or preferring the benefit to one person over another for improper reasons. • We give equal/adequate consideration to the interests of all affected persons. • Assumes the basic equality of all human persons. Caution!!! This principle is not absolute because in our society today there are individuals that might demand more moral attention or better treatment than others. Ex. Who should be prioritized for covid 19 testing? 7-Step Moral Reasoning Model proposed by Scott B. Rae, Ph.D. This model may not automatically generate the perfect answer to an ethical problem, however, it offers a guideline in ascertaining that all the right questions are asked in the process of ethical deliberation. 1. Gather the facts – first indispensable step prior to any ethical analysis and reflection on the case. 7.
It is important to understand that at some point, we
must stop deliberating and make a decision, no matter how hard/uncomfortable/unpleasant it is. Activity Pay attention to the news from print, tv, socmed and determine which of the suggestions/plans/decisions made/to be made by the authorities follow the 7 step model in confronting the challenges brought about by COVID 19.
Stay safe and healthy!
Let us pray for each other that the Lord will keep us all safe!