You are on page 1of 16

Int J Appl 

Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Int J Appl Earth Obs Geoinformation


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jag

Remote sensing data in lithium (Li) exploration: A new approach for the T
detection of Li-bearing pegmatites

Joana Cardoso-Fernandesa, Ana C. Teodoroa,b, , Alexandre Limaa,b
a
Dep. of Geosciences, Environment and Land Planning, Faculty of Sciences, University of Porto, Rua do Campo Alegre, Porto, Portugal
b
ICT (Institute of Earth Sciences) – Porto pole, Portugal

A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Remote sensing has proved to be a powerful resource in geology capable of delineating target exploration areas
Lithium for several deposit types. Only recently, these methodologies have been used for the detection of lithium (Li)-
RGB combinations bearing pegmatites. This happened because of the growing importance and demand of Li for the construction of
Band ratio Li-ion batteries for electric cars. The objective of this study was to develop innovative and effective remote
PCA
sensing methodologies capable of identifying Li-pegmatites through alteration mapping and through the direct
Alteration halos
ASTER
identification of Li-bearing minerals. For that, cloud free Landsat-5, Landsat-8, Sentinel-2 and ASTER images
Landsat-5 with low vegetation coverage were used. The image processing methods included: RGB (red, green, blue)
Landsat-8 combinations, band ratios and selective principal component analysis (PCA). The study area of this work is the
Sentinel-2 Fregeneda (Salamanca, Spain)-Almendra (Vila Nova de Foz Côa, Portugal) region, where different known types
of Li-pegmatites have been mapped. This study proposes new RGB combinations, band ratios and subsets for
selective PCA capable of differentiating the spectral signatures of the Li-bearing pegmatites from the spectral
signatures of the host rocks. The potential and limitations of the methodologies proposed are discussed, but
overall there is a great potential for the identification of Li-bearing pegmatites using remote sensing. The results
obtained could be improved using sensors with a better spatial and spectral resolution.

1. Introduction (e.g. Rowan and Mars, 2003) and volcanogenic massive sulfide ore
(VMS) deposits (e.g. Berger et al., 2003). The potential of the use of
It is impossible to ignore the current growing importance and de- Sentinel-2 images for geological applications has also been documented
mand of lithium (Li) for several industrial applications among which (van der Meer et al., 2014). Only recently, the first steps on the appli-
the production of rechargeable Li-ion batteries stands outs, mainly for cation of remote sensing to Li mineralizations were made: Perrotta et al.
the construction of electric vehicles in the pursuit for more environ- (2005) used ASTER images for a trial mapping of Li-bearing pegmatites
ment-friendly means of transportation. To address that demand, the in Vale do Jequitinhonha region, Brazil; and Mendes et al. (2017) ap-
identification of new Li deposits is crucial and less expensive and faster plied a similar methodology in the identification of Li minerals’ spectral
exploration methods (when compared with classic techniques) are in signatures in future identification of unknown ore deposits. Cardoso-
order. Fernandes et al. (2018), in a preliminary stage of this work, presented
Remote sensing could be the answer to this problem, since it has the potential of Sentinel-2 in Li-mapping. There are then several de-
already proved itself as a powerful resource to delineate target ex- velopments to be made in the field of remote sensing applied to Li-
ploration areas for several deposit types. Worldwide, remote sensing bearing pegmatites.
has been used in mineral exploration since the 70′s. Most of the studies The possible detection of Li-bearing pegmatites using remote sen-
concern the application of remote sensing in hydrothermal gold ex- sing can be of great interest to exploration and mining companies, since
ploration (e.g. Moradi et al., 2014). Other publications detail the use of they could lead to a decrease of the impacts of the early stages of ex-
remote sensing in other deposit types, such as: epithermal gold deposits ploration on the populations and an increased efficiency and sustain-
(e.g.Crósta et al., 2003), porphyry copper deposits (e.g. Pour and ability of mineral exploration. Taking this into account, the main ob-
Hashim, 2015), brine deposits (e.g. Sabins and Miller, 1994), Carlin- jective of this study was to develop a new methodology considering
type gold deposits (e.g. Rockwell and Hofstra, 2008), skarn deposits remotely sensed data, capable of identifying Li-pegmatites. This


Corresponding author at: Rua do Campo Alegre 687, 4169-007, Porto, Portugal.
E-mail address: amteodor@fc.up.pt (A.C. Teodoro).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jag.2018.11.001
Received 4 October 2018; Received in revised form 31 October 2018; Accepted 1 November 2018
Available online 13 November 2018
0303-2434/ © 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 1. Location of the studied area which includes the Bajoca mining concession and the Feli and Alberto mines where important Li-bearing pegmatites outcrop.
Image source: Google Earth (Google Earth Pro, 2018). Map projection is Universal Transverse Mercator zone 29 N from the WGS84 datum.

recognition was made based on two approaches: the identification of as NNE-SSW sinistral strike-slip faults resultant from late-Variscan
hydrothermally altered zones associated with the pegmatites (through brittle deformation (Ribeiro and Silva, 1994; Silva and Ribeiro, 1991).
the discrimination of iron oxides and clay minerals) and the direct In the study area, the majority of the metasediments belongs to the
identification of Li-bearing minerals. For that, a set of well-known “Complexo Xisto-Grauváquico” (CXG) (Costa, 1950; Teixeira, 1955)
processing methods were applied using well-established and also in- which corresponds to a monotonous pre-Ordovician pelitic-sandy flysch
novative remote sensing algorithms. The methodologies allowed to series, mainly composed of pelitic schist with interbedded meta-con-
predict the occurrence of iron oxides and clay minerals, and to dis- glomerates and meta-graywackes, ranging in age from the Upper Pro-
criminate between hydrothermally altered zones and non-altered zones. terozoic to the Lower Cambrian (e.g. Díez Balda et al., 1990; Rodríguez
Self-proposed RGB (red, green, blue) combinations for ASTER Alonso et al., 2004). The phyllitic-quartzitic formations from the Or-
(Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer), dovician lie above the CXG (Ribeiro and Silva, 1994; Silva and Ribeiro,
Landsat-5 and 8 were capable of discriminating the Li-bearing pegma- 1991).
tites from the host rocks. Self-proposed band ratios and selective prin- Several granitoid rocks intruded the CXG (Fig. 2), most of which are
cipal component analysis (PCA) were also able to highlight the Li- two-micas granites: in the south of the study area outcrops the granitic
bearing minerals in ASTER, Landsat-5, Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 complex of Mêda–Penedono–Lumbrales (the majority of the lithofacies
images. is syn-D3, with exception of some granites of fewer expression which
are late-D3 (Ribeiro and Silva, 1994; Silva and Ribeiro, 1991); at
2. Materials and methods northeast outcrops the Saucelle granite (late-to-post-D3 Ribeiro and
Silva, 1994); and the non-outcropping granite of Feli (3050 ± 3,3 Ma
2.1. Study area Vieira, 2010), detected by drilling holes between the Riba D’Alva
(Portugal) mine and Feli mine (Spain). The syn-D3 granites of Mêda–-
The study area (Fig. 1) includes the Fregeneda-Almendra aplite- Penedono–Lumbrales complex as well as the Saucelle granite are in-
pegmatite field which spreads from the Almendra-Barca D’Alva region stalled in antiforms formed during the Variscan orogeny (Ribeiro and
(Vila Nova de Foz Côa and Figueira de Castelo Rodrigo towns) to La Silva, 1994; Silva and Ribeiro, 1991).
Fregeneda and Hinojosa del Duero towns (Salamanca, Spain). Situated Roda (1993), Roda et al. (1999) and Vieira (2010) defined and
in the transition between Beira Alta and Alto-Douro regions, the aplite- characterized eleven different types of veins in the Fregeneda-Almendra
pegmatite field is delimitated at north by the Douro river, at east by the aplite-pegmatite field, most of which intruded the metasediments from
Vilariça’s fault valley and is divided in two by the Águeda river (ma- the CXG. Among the eleven types, four correspond to Li-bearing veins
terializing the border between Portugal and Spain). (Fig. 2): (i) petalite-bearing aplite-pegmatite veins – T7; (ii) spodu-
The study area belongs to the Iberian Massif, a complex fragment of mene-bearing aplite-pegmatite veins – T8; (iii) spodumene- and lepi-
the European Variscan Belt, which outcrops in the western part of the dolite-bearing aplite-pegmatite veins – T9; (iv) lepidolite-bearing
Iberian Peninsula. The Iberian Massif is divided in several geotectonic aplite-pegmatite veins – T10. All these vein types (7, 8, 9 and 10) be-
zones with different paleogeographic, structural, magmatic and meta- long to the LCT family, REE-Li subclass and Complex type of the Černý
morphic characteristics. The Fregeneda-Almendra pegmatite field and Ercit (2005) classification Vieira (2010). T7 and T8 veins are
(Fig. 2) is part of the Central Iberian Zone (CIZ) (Farias et al., 1987; clearly discordant from the host rocks, with a N–S to N30 °E trend and
Julivert, 1972; Lotze, 1945) which mainly consists of autochthonous sub-vertical dip, and are over a meter thick Vieira (2010). Miner-
pre-Mesozoic metasediments, intruded by rare pre-Variscan granites alogically, they are mainly composed by petalite (T7) or spodumene
and various Variscan granitoids (Dias et al., 2000; Martínez Catalán (T8), quartz, albite and potassium feldspar Vieira (2010). T9 veins are
et al., 2004). also sub-vertical and discordant with N–S to N30 °E trend Vieira (2010).
In the region, the three Variscan deformation phases (D1, D2, D3) Quartz, feldspars, Li-bearing muscovite (lepidolite) and spodumene
defined by Noronha et al. Noronha et al. (1979) were recognized as well occur as major phases and the veins often present an internal banded

11
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 2. Simplified geological map of the Fregeneda-Almendra


aplite-pegmatite field (adapted from Vieira (2010)). Type veins:
(1) intra-granitic - T1; (2) quartz with andalusite - T2; (3) apo-
physis - T3; (4) simple discordant -T4; (5) with potassium feldspar
- T5; (6) simple discordant- T6; (7) with petalite - T7; (8) with
spodumene - T8; (9) with lepidolite and spodumene - T9; (10) with
lepidolite - T10; (11) quartz with cassiterite - T11. (12) Syn- to
late-D3 granites; (13) metasediments (CXG); (14) Ordovician for-
mations; (15) quartz veins; (16) granitic/rhyolitic porphyry and
faults. Isograds: (17) sillimanite; (18) andalusite; (19) biotite.

structure Vieira (2010). T10 veins are sub-vertical and aligned ac- Landsat-5 TM images were acquired on 02/09/1990 (path 203, row
cording to a N10° to N40 °E direction, discordant from the host rocks, 32), Landsat-8 OLI images on 04/09/2014 (path 203, row 32), ASTER
and are lesser than 3 m thick Vieira (2010). Mineralogically, the images on 28/06/2004 (path 203, row 31) and Sentinel-2 on 27/10/
dominant phases are quartz, feldspar and lepidolite Vieira (2010). 2017 (tile number T29TPF). All the images cover the study area. The
Overall, in the Fregeneda-Almendra field the sterile veins are em- images map projection is Universal Transverse Mercator zone 29 N,
placed in the D3 tectonic foliation which presents a N100°-N120 °E WGS84 datum. ASTER Level 1 T products are already corrected for the
(WNW-ESE) general trend and can be intra-granitic or outcrop near the cross talk effect (Meyer et al., 2015).
granites (Vieira, 2010). The Li-bearing aplite-pegmatite veins outcrop Sentinel bands have better spatial resolution (10 and 20 m) than the
further away from the granites and are emplaced in late-tectonic NNE- other sensors, which is very important to better detect pegmatites of
SSW and NE-SW sinistral strike-slip faults (Vieira, 2010). smaller dimensions; but because it is a recent mission, long term
The existence of different known types of Li mineralization, the comparative studies are impossible to make. In opposite, the continuity
large number of mapped aplite-pegmatites veins and the fact that these of Landsat missions allows a comparison between Landsat-8 and
veins often difficult the growth of vegetation, make the Frejeneda- Landsat-5 images and consequently, a spectral evolutionary study of the
Almendra region an ideal target area for remote sensing exploration. Li-bearing pegmatites before and during their exploitation. On the other
hand, ASTER products have a higher number of bands in the SWIR
2.2. Materials region, making it the most used sensor for geological studies (e.g.
Crósta et al., 2003; Moradi et al., 2014; Rowan and Mars, 2003).
For the digital image processing and interpretation, Landsat-5,
Landsat-8, ASTER and Sentinel-2 multispectral images were used be- 2.3. Image pre-processing
cause their spectral range is more adequate for geology purposes than
other missions’ products. This is due to important absorption mineral The pre-processing steps were carried out using the Semi-Automatic
features in the near infrared (NIR) and short-wave infrared (SWIR) that Classification Plugin (SCP) (Congedo, 2016) version 5 for QGIS (QGIS
must be covered by the specific band’s spectral ranges. In particular, Software, 2018).
images with a cloud cover less than 10% were downloaded. To obtain
better results, only the images with fewer vegetation coverage were 2.3.1. Atmospheric correction and surface reflectance conversion
considered. To minimize scattering and atmospheric absorption effects, both the
Landsat-5 Thematic Mapper (TM) data records data in seven spec- Landsat and ASTER digital numbers (DNs) were converted to top of the
tral bands: three bands in the visible, one in the NIR and two in the atmosphere (TOA) reflectance. In the case of ASTER images, the ori-
SWIR, all with a 30 m resolution; and one band in the thermal infrared ginal information corresponded to radiance. The conversion used the
(TIR) with a 120 m resolution (The Thematic Mapper, 2018). information contained in the metadata files downloaded with the
Landsat-8 has two different instruments onboard: the Operational images. Sentinel-2 images are already provided in TOA reflectance.
Land Imager (OLI) and the Thermal Infrared Sensor (TIRS). The re- A DOS1 (Dark Object Subtraction 1) atmospheric correction
sultant product is composed by: (i) nine spectral bands with a spatial (Chavez, 1996) was applied, to convert TOA reflectance to surface re-
resolution of 30 m for bands 1–7 and 9 (five bands in the visible and flectance. This conversion is not performed on the thermal bands.
NIR, and two in the SWIR) and 15 m for band 8 (panchromatic); and (ii) In the case of the Sentinel-2, the conversion of TOA reflectance to
two thermal bands (10 and 11) collected at 100 m, and resampled to surface reflectance in SCP does an automatic rescale of the images:
30 m (Anon, 2018). pixels of 20 m bands are split in 4 pixels of 10 m whose values are the
The ASTER sensor acquired information in three bands in the visible same as the original 20 m pixel.
and NIR with 15 m of spatial resolution; six bands in the SWIR with a
spatial resolution of 30 m; and four bands in the TIR with 90 m (ASTER, 2.3.2. Sub-setting
2018; ASTER: Mission, 2018). Firstly, all images were cut to contain the study area and its sur-
Sentinel-2 Multispectral Instrument (MSI) has 13 spectral bands roundings. Secondly, a spectral sub-setting was also made because not
from the VNIR (ten bands) to the SWIR (three bands): four bands at all the bands of the different satellite products are adequate for geo-
10 m, six bands at 20 m and three bands at 60 m spatial resolution logical applications. In this study, Landsat-8 deep blue (1), panchro-
(Missions, 2018; User Guides, 2018). matic (8) and cirrus (9) bands were excluded from the further analysis.

12
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

However, the panchromatic band was used as a sharpening band (see


below in Section 2.3.4.). In the case of Sentinel-2, coastal aerosol (1),
red edge (5, 6 and 7), water vapour (9) and cirrus (10) bands were also
excluded.

2.3.3. Masking
In order to reduce spectral variability and noise contamination,
vegetated areas and main water bodies were masked out from the
further image analysis. The mask was created using the information
resulting from Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) com-
putation. For ASTER and Sentinel-2 images, the mask assigns the value
0 for water and typically for regions where NDVI is higher than 0.2
(value that indicates the presence of vegetation according to Weier and
Herring (2018)). In the case of Landsat images, the NDVI threshold
considered was 0.25 for Landsat-5 and 0.3 for Landsat-8, mainly be-
cause the previous value (0.2) masked a big part of the image.

2.3.4. Pan sharpening


Since some pegmatites present relatively small dimensions, a higher
spatial resolution, is better suitable to identify them in the satellite
images.
To overcome this problem, in Landsat-8 images, pan sharpening was
employed. In this specific case, it was applied the Brovey Transform
according to the method proposed by Johnson et al. (2012). The final
product is composed by bands 2–7 with a 15 m of spatial resolution.

2.4. Image processing methods Fig. 3. Schematic diagram of overall workflow.

The image processing methods were applied considering two ap- Table 1
proaches: (i) the recognition of hydrothermally altered zones (based on RGB combinations tested for the ASTER product.
the identification of associated alteration minerals) which is essential in RGB Feature Reference
mineral exploration (Pour and Hashim, 2015); (ii) the direct identifi-
cation of Li-bearing minerals. The methods employed in this study 621 Gossan, alteration, host Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
were: RGB combinations, band ratio and selective PCA. rock
631 Hydrothermal gossans Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
For the application of the image processing methods ArcMap
742 Enhancing structures Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
(ArcMap Software, 2018) and the Sentinel Application Platform (SNAP) 1613 Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed
(SNAP Software, 2018) were also used as complementary tools of SCP. 2113 Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed
The overall workflow for the image analysis, which includes the pre- 492 Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed
5114 Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed
processing and the application of the image processing methods, is
13149 Silicate minerals Self-proposed based on (Pour and Hashim
schematically represented in Fig. 3. (2015); Ali and Pour (2014)

2.4.1. RGB combinations


RGB combinations are an image enhancement technique that com- 2004). To evaluate the content and distribution of silicate minerals,
bines different multispectral or thermal bands to produce a color RGB13149 combination was proposed based on the combination used
composite that should enhance hydrothermally altered rocks and li- Landsat-8 by (Ali and Pour, 2014; Pour and Hashim, 2015). Based on
thological units at regional scale (Pour and Hashim, 2015). In this work, mineral spectra (Kokaly et al., 2017) and by trial and error, the RGB
the bands were chosen based on laboratory spectra of the Li-bearing combinations 1613, 2113, 492 and 5114 were proposed to identify Li-
minerals and of minerals related to hydrothermal alteration (Kokaly mineralizations.
et al., 2017). For example, clay and carbonate minerals have absorption In the case of Landsat-8, some of the known RGB combinations
features from 2.1 to 2.4 μm and reflectance from 1.55 to 1.75 μm (Ali tested were: (i) to identify hydrothermally altered rocks, 567 (Pour and
and Pour, 2014); silicate minerals present high emissivity in the region Hashim, 2015), 573 and 5710 (Mia and Fujimitsu, 2012); (ii) to identify
between 10.30 and 11.70 μm (Ali and Pour, 2014); iron oxides and iron oxides and clay minerals, 257 and 657 (Ali and Pour, 2014); (iii) to
sulphate minerals commonly have a strong reflectance near red and low identify silicate minerals, 10,117 (Ali and Pour, 2014; Pour and
blue reflectance (Han and Nelson, 2015). On its turn, Li-bearing mi- Hashim, 2015); (iv) to identify lithological contrasts, 674 (Mwaniki
nerals have important absorption features around 2.2 μm; lepidolite has et al., 2015). Self-proposed RGB combinations capable of differentiating
another absorption feature between 0.5 and 0.6 μm. If the bands that Li-mineralizations included: 327, 3211 and 7311.
contain these specific mineral absorption and reflectance features are Based on some of overlap/equivalence between Landsat-8, Landsat-
included in the RGB combinations, the latter should be capable of 5 and Sentinel-2 bands, it was made a correspondence between the
discriminating the minerals in question. bands used in Landsat-8 RGB combinations and Landsat-5/Sentinel-2
Self-proposed as well as known combinations from the literature bands to create similar combinations. In the case of Sentinel-2, the
were then tested (Tables 1 and 2). For the ASTER image, RGB621 correspondence between bands was only made for visible, NIR and
combination was tested to discriminate between gossan areas, altera- SWIR because this sensor has no bands in the TIR region.
tion zones and host rocks (Kalinowski and Oliver, 2004); RGB631
combination was applied to enhance hydrothermal gossans (Kalinowski
and Oliver, 2004) and RGB742 combination was tested in order to 2.4.2. Band ratio
identify and enhance geological structures (Kalinowski and Oliver, The band ratio is an information extraction technique that results

13
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Table 2
RGB combinations tested for Landsat-8, Landsat-5 and Sentinel-2.
RGB combination Feature Reference

Landsat-8 Landsat-5 Sentinel-2

257 147 2812 Iron oxides and clay minerals Ali and Pour (2014)
567 457 81112 Hydrothermally altered rocks Pour and Hashim (2015); Cardoso-Fernandes et al. (2018)
573 472 8123 Hydrothermally altered rocks Mia and Fujimitsu (2012)
5710 476 − Hydrothermally altered rocks Mia and Fujimitsu (2012)
657 547 11812 Iron oxides and clay minerals Ali and Pour (2014)
674 573 11412 Lithological contrasts Mwaniki et al. (2015)
10,117 − − Silicate minerals Pour and Hashim (2015); Ali and Pour (2014)
327 217 3212 Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed
3211 216 − Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed
7311 726 − Li-bearing minerals Self-proposed

from the division of one band for another with the aim of highlight 2.4.3. Selective principal component analysis
certain spectral differences. The ratios are based on the peaks and Principal Component analysis (PCA) is a multivariate statistical
troughs of a reflectance curve: usually, the band with higher reflectance technique used to enhance and separate certain types of spectral sig-
is divided by a band with low reflectance. This method is useful for natures from the background (Gabr et al., 2010; Moradi et al., 2014).
highlighting certain features or materials that cannot be seen in raw This technique reduces the redundancy of correlated data by applying a
bands (Ali and Pour, 2014; Sabins, 1996). It also eliminates shadowing linear transformation (Ali and Pour, 2014; Mia and Fujimitsu, 2012).
and topographic effects making it appropriate for complex terrain The PCA selects uncorrelated linear combinations (eigenvector load-
(Mwaniki et al., 2015). ings) of variables in such a way that each successively extracted linear
According to Sabins Sabins (1999), there are two groups of minerals combination, or principal component (PC), has a smaller variance
associated with hydrothermally altered rocks: (i) alunite and clay mi- (Singh and Harrison, 1985). The eigenvalues provide information based
nerals, like illite, kaolinite, and montmorillonite, and (ii) iron oxides on the magnitude and sign of about which spectral properties of ve-
and sulfates. Therefore, band ratios that discriminate these minerals getation, rocks and soils are responsible for the statistical variance
should highlight hydrothermally altered zones as bright pixels. mapped into each PC (Loughlin, 1991; Mia and Fujimitsu, 2012). The
Taking this into account, some well-known ratios from the literature result is a set of uncorrelated bands.
were tested during this work in order to identify and enhance hydro- In this work, PCA was applied in a selective mode, that consist in
thermally altered rocks (Tables 3 and 4). To identify Li-bearing peg- selected subsets of the sensors’ bands. Two techniques were then used:
matites and based on the Li minerals reflectance curves peaks and (i) the application or adaptation of the “Crosta technique” (Loughlin,
troughs (Kokaly et al., 2017), several band ratios were also proposed 1991), in which the PCA is applied to a subset of four bands; (ii) the
(Tables 3 and 4). application or adaption of the technique proposed by Chavez & Kwar-
In order to enhance the band ratio results, a primary method of teng (Chavez and Kwarteng, 1989), where PCA is applied to a subset of
classification -density slice - was applied. This method consists in the two bands.
analysis of the ratio image histogram and in the attribution of a color to The subsets chosen for the selective PCA and the target information
each histogram segment. A color ramp was applied in which cold colors to extract are presented in Table 5. Similar to the aforementioned for
represent the lower values and hot colors the higher values (see Section RGB combinations, a correspondence between the bands used in the
3.2). The resultant images emphasize subtle grey-scale differences that Landsat subsets and Sentinel-2 were performed.
may be imperceptible (Sabins, 1996).
3. Results
Table 3
Tested band ratios for the ASTER product. From all the tested RGB combinations, band ratios and subsets for
selective PCA, only the best results in alteration mapping and in the
Band ratio Feature Reference
identification of Li-mineralizations will be presented.
1/3 Spodumene Self-proposed
2/1 Ferric iron Kalinowski and Oliver (2004) 3.1. RGB combinations
4/3 Ferric oxides Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
4/5 Silicate alteration Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
4/6 Montebrasite Self-proposed 3.1.1. Alteration mapping
4/8 Cookeite Self-proposed The RGB combinations that better identify hydrothermally altered
4/10 Halloysite; montebrasite Self-proposed rocks are 573 for Landsat-8 (Fig. 4-a), 472 for Landsat-5 (Fig. 4-b) and
5/3 Goethite Self-proposed 8123 for Sentinel-2 (Fig. 4-c). All these combinations contain a NIR
5/10 Heulandite; illite Self-proposed
band in the red channel, a SWIR band in the green and a visible band in
5/13 Goethite Self-proposed
6/2 Lepidolite; cookeite Self-proposed the blue channel.
7/5 Kaolinite Kalinowski and Oliver (2004) In the three sensors, urbanized areas and ploughed fields present a
7/6 Muscovite; lepidolite; Kalinowski and Oliver (2004); self- bright white color; water bodies are represented in black and are par-
(spodumene) proposed for Li-minerals
tially masked; vegetated areas are fully masked; the metasediments
8/5 Amblygonite; montebrasite Self-proposed
11/10 Silica Kalinowski and Oliver (2004) from the CXG present purple color; and the granites are represented in
11/12 Silica Kalinowski and Oliver (2004) light- to medium-green color. In order to identify the cause of intense
12/6 Lepidolite Self-proposed green areas, specific spectral indices (see Supplementary materials) that
12/9 Lepidolite Self-proposed discriminate between burned and unburned areas were applied (Key
12/10 Lepidolite; cookeite Self-proposed
and Benson, 2006; Martín, 1998). The burned areas were mapped (S1-
13/10 Silica Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
14/12 Quartz rich rocks Kalinowski and Oliver (2004) S2), and a correspondence between these areas and the intense green
zones is clear (Fig. 4).

14
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Table 4
Tested band ratios for Landsat-8, Landsat-5 and Sentinel-2.
Band ratio Feature Reference

Landsat-8 Landsat-5 Sentinel-2

3/2 2/1 3/2 Goethite, halloysite Self-proposed


3/5 2/4 3/8 Spodumene Self-proposed
4/2 3/1 4/2 Iron oxides Ali and Pour (2014); Sabins (1999)
4/3 3/2 4/3 Ferric iron Self-proposed based on Kalinowski and Oliver (2004)
4/7 3/7 4/12 Lepidolite; (cookeite; amblygonite; montebrasite) Self-proposed
6/5 5/4 11/8 Ferrous minerals Ali and Pour (2014); Mia and Fujimitsu (2012)
6/7 5/7 11/12 Alunite and clay minerals Pour and Hashim (2015); Ali and Pour (2014); Sabins (1999)
10/7 6/7 − Heulandite Self-proposed

In the Fregeneda-Almendra aplite-pegmatite field, open pit mines ploughed fields present a bright white color and granitic rocks appear in
appear with a bluish tint probably indicating some hydrothermal al- blue or blueish grey color while the metasediments from the CXG ap-
teration. In the Landsat-5 image (Fig. 4-b), the pegmatites from Bajoca pear in yellow. Known Li-areas also appear in yellow, making it im-
and Alberto were not being exploited at that time, and no sign of hy- possible to distinguish between potential and non-potential zones with
drothermal alteration is visible. A deep analysis of Fig. 4 allows to lithium.
identify other areas in the metasediments that present a bluish color.
The burned areas present a color that also indicates hydrothermal al- 3.2. Band ratio
teration, but different from the one identified in Li-bearing zones.
3.2.1. Alteration mapping
3.1.2. Li mapping To map ferrous minerals band ratio 6/5 was applied to Landsat-8
The self-proposed RGB combinations that best highlight Li-miner- images (Fig. 7-a, -b, -c), ratio 5/4 to Landsat-5 (Fig. 7-d, -e, -f) and 11/8
alizations are divided in two sets. The first is composed by a SWIR band ratio to Sentinel-2. The resulting images are very similar to ASTER band
in the red channel, a visible band in the green one and a thermal band ratio 4/3 image which identify ferric oxides.
in the blue one: 5114 for ASTER (Figure S3-a), 7311 for Landsat-8 A color density slice version of band ratio 6/5 for Landsat-8 (Fig. 7-
(Figure S3-b) and 726 for Landsat-5 (Figure S3-c). c) is shown in Fig. 7-a, with color assignments shown in the histogram
In the three sensors, urbanized areas and ploughed fields present a presented in Fig. 7-b. Yellow and red areas correspond to the highest
bright white or yellow color, the metasediments from the CXG present surface reflectance values (yellow ≈ 1.61; red ≥ 1.82) and therefore
in general a blue or bluish color; and the granites are represented in should indicate altered rocks. Fig. 7-d is a color density slice version of
purple. Burned areas show an intense purple color, especially in the Landsat-5′s 5/4 band ratio (Fig. 7-f), whose color intervals were at-
Landsat-5 image (Figure S3-c). Li-bearing zones appear in a yellowish tributed based on the histogram showed in Fig. 7-e. Yellow and red
green or green color but only where Li-bearing pegmatites have a good areas correspond to the highest surface reflectance values (yellow ≈
exposition: in the Landsat-5 image (Figure S3-c) there is no distinct 1.51; red ≥ 1.8) and therefore should also indicate altered rocks.
signal in the Bajoca or Alberto mines. In all cases, there is a clear difference in the iron content of granites
The second set that better highlights Li-mineralizations is composed and metasediments from the CXG: granitoid rocks present a higher
by two visible bands and a thermal band: 2113 for ASTER (Fig. 5-a and content of ferrous minerals/ferric oxides. Burned areas present the
Fig. 6), 3211 for Landsat-8 (Fig. 5-b and Fig. 6) and 216 for Landsat-5 highest contents even when compared with the granites. The ratios did
(Fig. 5-c and Fig. 6). Since Sentinel-2 does not have available a band in not highlight ferrous minerals/ferric oxides in the known Li-miner-
TIR region, the thermal band was replaced by a SWIR band – RGB alized areas. Red colors near Feli mine in the Landsat-5 image (Fig. 7-d)
combination 3-2-12 (Fig. 5-d and Fig. 6). are due to fire exposure (the open-pit area presents light blue color).
For ASTER, Landsat-8 and Landsat-5, urbanized areas and ploughed Other minerals associated with hydrothermal alteration are alunite
fields present a bright yellow or yellowish white color, while water and/or clays (like kaolinite, montmorillonite and others). To map these
bodies are represented in black. Known Li-bearing areas also present a minerals band ratio 6/7 was applied to Landsat-8 images, ratio 5/7 to
bright yellow color, except for the Bajoca and Alberto mines in the Landsat-5 and 11/12 ratio to Sentinel-2 (Fig. 8-a, -b, -c). In the ASTER’s
Landsat-5 image (Fig. 5-c). There is no clear distinction between the case, band ratio 7/5 was applied to map kaolinite (Fig. 8-d, -e, -f).
metasediments and the granites. The respective density slice versions of each ratio (Fig. 8-a and -d)
In the case of the Sentinel-2 image (Fig. 5-d), urbanized areas and should highlight altered rocks in hot colors: for ratio 11/12, red colors

Table 5
Chosen subsets to the application of selective PCA and respective target mineral information.
Target mineral information Subset Reference

ASTER Landsat-8 Landsat-5 Sentinel-2

Alunite 1, 3, 5, 7 − − − Crósta et al. (2003)


Illite and muscovite 1, 3, 5, 6 − − −
Kaolinite and smectite 1, 4, 6, 9 − − −
Kaolinite 1, 4, 6, 7 − − −
Ferric iron − 2, 4 1, 3 2, 4 Chavez and Kwarteng (1989)
− 2, 4, 5, 6 1, 3, 4, 5 2, 4, 8, 11 Loughlin (1991)
Hydroxyl minerals − 6, 7 5, 7 11, 12 Chavez and Kwarteng (1989)
− 2, 5, 6, 7 1, 4, 5, 7 2, 8, 11, 12 Loughlin (1991)
Li-bearing minerals 1, 3 3, 5 2, 4 3, 8 Self-proposed
1, 3, 11, 14 2, 3, 5, 11 1, 2, 4,6 2, 3, 8, 11 Self-proposed

15
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 4. RGB combinations to highlight hydrothermally altered areas with a water and vegetation mask: a) RGB 573 for Landsat-8; b) RGB 472 for Landsat-5; c) RGB
8123 for Sentinel-2 (Cardoso-Fernandes et al., 2018); d) detailed information for the 3 mines. The granites appear in light green while the metasediments are showed
in purple. Hydrothermally altered rocks are discriminated in deep green and deep blue colors, but deep green colors appear to correlate to burned areas. Known Li-
bearing areas present a blue color indicating hydrothermal alteration, apart from Bajoca and Alberto mines in the Landsat-5 image. Map projection is Universal
Transverse Mercator zone 29 N from the WGS84 datum (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of
this article).

correspond to reflectance values higher than 1.82 and yellow areas difference in the alunite and/or clay content of granites when compared
present values near 1.65; in the 7/5 ratio image the yellow colors in- with the metasediments from the CXG; the fluvial terraces from the
dicate reflectance values around 0.96 and red areas present reflectance Quaternary present yellow to red color, which indicates high- to very-
values higher than 1.1 high content in alunite or clays. Known Li-mineralized areas present
In the case if Landsat (5 and 8) and Sentinel-2, there is no marked very low- to -medium contents.

Fig. 5. RGB combinations to highlight Li-mineralized areas: with a water and vegetation mask a) RGB 2113 for ASTER; b) RGB 3211 for Landsat-8; c) RGB 216 for
Landsat-5; d) RGB 3212 (with a SWIR band instead of a thermal band) for comparison. Known Li-bearing areas appear in yellow. In a) to c), some urbanized areas and
ploughed field also appear in yellow. In d), due to the lack of a thermal band, there is no distinction between Li-mineralized areas and the metasediments. Burned
areas present intense blue color (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article).

16
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 6. Detailed information about the target areas of Fig. 5 (zoom images): Bajoca, Feli and Alberto.

The results obtained by ASTER’s band ratio are very different from areas correspond to zones with high vegetation coverage.
the results obtained for the other sensors: Figs. 8-d and -f indicate that Another self-proposed ratio to discriminate Li-mineralizations,
known Li-bearing areas present high- to very-high contents in kaolinite mainly based in the spectral behavior of spodumene, is 3/5 for Landsat-
unlike the results presented in Fig. 8-a and -c. It should be taken into 8 (Fig. 10-a, -b, -c), 2/4 for Landsat-5 (Fig. 10-d, -e, -f), 1/3 for ASTER
account that ASTER’s 7/5 ratio is used to discriminate only kaolinite images (Figure S4-a, -b, -c) and 3/8 for Sentinel-2 (Figure S4 -d, -e, -f).
and not a wide range of clay minerals. As it can be seen by the gray-scale images (Figs. 10- and S4-c, -f), the
proposed ratios highlight in bright color the Li-mineralized areas, but
also several other zones. However, the colored density slice images
3.2.2. Li mapping (Figs. 10- and S4-a, -d) based on the respective histograms (Figs. 10-
Band ratio 7/6 for ASTER images is used to discriminate areas and S4-b, -e) allow to successfully differentiate Li-bearing rocks: these
where muscovite is present. However, in this work, 7/6 ratio is pro- areas present the highest reflectance values and are mapped in red color
posed to highlight Li-mineralizations due to a similar behavior of le- (surface reflectance values ≥ 0.59 for Landsat-8, ≥ 0.77 for Landsat-5,
pidolite and spodumene in the referred bands. The fact that petalite and ≥ 0.71 for Sentinel-2 and ≥ 0.86 for ASTER).
spodumene veins usually have a low mica content increases the con- A comparison between Landsat-5 images (before the opening of
fidence that this ratio highlights Li-minerals and not muscovite. A co- Bajoca and Alberto mines) and the other ratio images, shows that no
lored density slice version of band ratio 7/6 (Fig. 9-c) is shown in Fig. 9- signal is detected in these areas before exploitation. Very low (dark
a, with the respective color assignments shown in the histogram of blue) to low (light blue) reflectance values correspond to densely ve-
Fig. 9-b. Yellow and red areas correspond to the highest surface re- getated areas.
flectance values (yellow ≈ 1; red ≥ 1.06) and should indicate Li-
bearing rocks. Known Li mineralized areas are correctly identified in
yellow and red colors in Fig. 9-a. Urbanized areas and agricultural fields 3.3. Selective principal component analysis
also present high reflectance, as can be observed in Fig. 9-c and
therefore present equally yellow and red colors. Light and dark blue In order to try to isolate target spectral signatures, PCA was applied

17
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 7. Ferrous mineral mapping through band rationing: a) Landsat-8′s ratio 6/5 image with density slice (high ratio values shown in red); b) histogram for Landsat-
8′s 6/5 image; c) Landsat-8′s ratio 6/5 image; d) Landsat-5′s ratio 5/4 image with density slice (high ratio values shown in red); e) histogram for Landsat-5′s 5/4
image; f) Landsat-5′s ratio 5/4 image (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article).

to selected subsets of the satellites’ bands. This is the base of the “Crosta overall scene brightness or albedo and is therefore mapped in PC1. To
technique” (Loughlin, 1991). determine which PC maps alunite, we need to examine the eigenvector
The magnitude and sign (positive or negative) of the eigenvectors loadings for bands 5 and 7 (Table 6), in both of PC3 and PC4: the PC
depend on which spectral properties of vegetation, rocks, and soils are that has a moderate or strong loading from both bands, with opposite
responsible for the statistical variance mapped into each principal signs is the one that maps alunite. In this case, PC4 maps alunite in
component (PC) (Loughlin, 1991).The eigenvalues give an indication of bright pixels (Fig. 11-a). PC3 eigenvector loadings (Table 6) is domi-
decreasing variance in successive PCs (Loughlin, 1991). To aid in the nated by vegetation due to the high loading in band 3: the positive sign
eigenvalue interpretation, they can be expressed in percentage (ac- indicates that vegetation is mapped in bright pixels.
counted variance). In the same way, in the subset 1, 3, 5 and 6 the PC1 mainly maps the
albedo while PC2 shows the contrast between the visible and the SWIR.
Moderate to strong loadings from both bands 5 and 6, with opposite
3.3.1. Alteration mapping
signs indicate that PC4 points out illite and muscovite in dark pixels due
In the ASTER’s case, the four subsets proposed by Crósta et al.
to negative input of band 5. To map these minerals in bright pixels, PC4
(2003) in an adaptation of the “Crosta technique”, were used to map the
was multiplied by -1 the (Loughlin, 1991).
following alteration minerals: alunite, illite and muscovite, kaolinite
For the 1, 4, 6, 9 band subset, PC1 mainly maps the albedo and PC2
and smectite, and kaolinite, respectively. According to Loughlin (1991),
display the contrast between the visible and the SWIR. Moderate to
the strong correlation between the different image channels is due the

Fig. 8. Alunite and clay mapping through band rationing: a) Sentinel-2′s ratio 11/12 image with density slice (high ratio values shown in red); b) histogram for
Sentinel-2′s 11/12 image; c) Sentinel-2′s ratio 11/12 image. Kaolinite mapping through band rationing: d) ASTER’s ratio 7/5 image with density slice (high ratio
values shown in red); e) histogram for ASTER’s 7/5 image; f) ASTER’s ratio 7/5 image (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is
referred to the web version of this article).

18
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 9. Li-mineralization mapping through band rationing (ASTER): a) ASTER’s ratio 7/6 image with density slice (high ratio values shown in red); b) histogram for
ASTER’s 7/6 image; c) ASTER’s ratio 7/6 image (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this
article).

Fig. 10. Li-mineralization mapping through band rationing: a) Landsat-8′s ratio 3/5 image with density slice (high ratio values shown in red); b) histogram for
Landsat-8′s 3/5 image; c) Landsat-8′s ratio 3/5 image; d) Landsat-5′s ratio 2/4 image with density slice (high ratio values shown in red); e) histogram for Landsat-5′s
2/4 image; f) Landsat-5′s ratio 2/4 image. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article).

19
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Table 6 Table 7
PCA for alunite mapping (ASTER): Eigenvector and eigenvalues matrix. PCA for ferric iron mapping (two Landsat-8 bands): Eigenvector and eigenva-
lues matrix.
PC1 PC2 PC3 PC4
PC1 PC2
Band 1 −0.59661 −0.41752 −0.6835 0.050736
Band 3 −0.53339 −0.42121 0.728957 0.081806 Band 2 0.68521 −0.72835
Band 5 −0.43797 0.471264 0.037655 −0.76464 Band 4 0.72835 0.68521
Band 7 −0.40956 0.652815 0.006021 0.637224 Eigenvalues 4123921 415821
Eigenvalues 6335.479 186.9639 69.64581 24.79689 Accounted variance 99.00175 0.99825
Accounted variance 95.74714 2.825558 1.052547 0.374752 Cumulative variance 99.00175 100
Cumulative variance 95.74714 98.5727 99.62525 100

maps the albedo; PC2 describes the difference between VNIR and SWIR;
strong loadings from both bands 4 and 9, with opposite signs indicate and ferric iron is mapped in PC4 due to moderate to strong loadings
that PC4 maps kaolinite and smectite in dark pixels due to the negative from band 1 and 3, with opposite signs. Because of the positive loading
input of band 6. Multiplying PC4 by -1, these minerals are mapped in of band 3 in PC4, ferric iron appears in bright pixels. The same prin-
bright pixels. ciples were applied to Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2: in both cases PC4 is the
Also, for the 1, 4, 6, 7 band subset, PC1 mainly maps the albedo and PC that maps ferric iron.
PC2 describes the contrast between the visible and the SWIR. Kaolinite In the case of the two-band subset, the process is even simpler: the
is mapped in bright pixels in PC4 due to moderate to strong loadings target spectral information is usually mapped in PC2, and the ex-
from both bands 4 and 6, with opposite signs (Fig. 11-b). amination of the eigenvector sign allows to find if the target informa-
For Landsat-8, Landsat-5 and Sentinel-2 two approaches were used: tion is mapped in bright or dark pixels. Table 7 presents the eigenvector
(i) the application or adaptation of the “Crosta technique” in which the and eigenvalues matrix for Landsat-8 and based on the analysis of the
PCA is applied to a subset of four bands; (ii) the application or adaption eigenvalues we can predict that ferric iron is mapped in bright pixels in
of the technique proposed by Chavez and Kwarteng (1989) where PCA PC2 (Fig. 12-a).
is applied to a subset of two bands. Each one of these methods was In the case of Landsat-5, due to the negative loadings of band 3 and
applied to the three sensors in order to map ferric iron and hydroxyl to present ferric iron in bright pixels, it was necessary multiply by -1
bearing minerals. PC2. The resultant images for Landsat 5 and Sentinel-2 are shown in
In the four-band subset, the process is similar to the described be- Fig. 12-b and -c.
fore: for Landsat-5, PC1 showed in Table S1 (Supplementary materials) The two-band method appears to be more selective since fewer

Fig. 11. Alunite (a) and kaolinite (b) images where the respective minerals appear in bright pixels. The Bajoca mine presents a strong signal for alunite and kaolinite.

20
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 12. Selective PCA on 2 bands to highlight ferric iron in bright pixels: a) PC2 from the Landsat-8 subset; b) -PC2 from the Landsat-5 subset; c) PC2 from the
Sentinel-2 subset. Feli mine presents a lower ferric iron content than Bajoca and Alberto mines. Before the opening of the Bajoca and Alberto mines (b), no sign of the
presence ferric iron is visible.

areas were discriminated with bright pixels. Both methods indicate that Table 9
ferric iron is present in the Bajoca and Alberto mines except in Landsat- PCA for lithium mapping (two ASTER bands): Eigenvector and eigenvalues
5 images (before the opening of the mines). Only the four-band subset matrix.
appears to discriminate ferric iron in the Feli mine. PC1 PC2
In the four-band subset to discriminate hydroxyl bearing minerals,
for Sentinel-2 PC1 presented in Table S2 maps the albedo; PC2 de- Band 1 −0.74511 0.66695
Band 3 −0.66694 −0.74511
scribes the difference between VNIR and SWIR; and PC4 maps hydroxyl
Eigenvalues 4123.30400 69.76079
minerals in bright pixels due to the positive loading from band. The Accounted variance 98.33628 1.66372
same process was applied to Landsat-5 and 8, and in both cases PC4 is Cumulative variance 98.33628 100
the one that maps hydroxyl minerals.
In the case of the two-band subset, PC2 for Sentinel-2 showed in
Table 8 maps hydroxyl minerals in dark pixels. Multiplying PC2 by -1 matrices for Landsat-5/8 and Sentinel-2 are presented in the Tables S4-
allows to present these minerals in bright pixels. S6. In all cases PC4 is the one that maps Li-bearing minerals. PC4 of
The image results from the two-band subset are presented in Figure Sentinel-2 was negated (multiplied by -1) to show Li-minerals in bright
S5. In Landsat-5, known Li-mineralized areas do not show any distinct pixels. The resultant images from the four-band subset are shown in
signal from the host rocks. For the other satellites, both methods in- Figure S6.
dicate a very low to moderate in hydroxyl minerals in the open-pit In the case of the two-band subset, PC2 of Table 9 (ASTER) maps Li-
areas. bearing minerals in bright pixels. The correspondent matrices for
Landsat-5/8 and Sentinel-2 are presented in Tables S7-S9. To show Li-
bearing minerals in bright pixels, PC2 of Landsat-5 and 8 were multi-
3.3.2. Li mapping
plied by -1. The results from the two-band subset are presented in
To discriminate Li-bearing minerals an adaptation of the previously
Fig. 13.
mentioned techniques was performed for all the sensors.
In the four-band subset, known Li-mineralized areas in Landsat-5
In the four-band subset, for ASTER, PC1 presented in Table S3 maps
(Figure S6-c) do not show any distinct signal from the host rocks. The
the albedo and PC4 maps Li-bearing in dark pixels due to the positive
two-band subset appears to be more sensitive the signature of Li-mi-
loading from band 3. Multiplying PC4 by -1 shows the target minerals
nerals because the Feli mine is highlighted in the correspondent
in bright pixels. The correspondent eigenvector and eigenvalues
Landsat-5 image.
For the other satellites, both methods discriminate correctly known
Table 8
Principal component analysis for hydroxyl mineral mapping (two Sentinel-2 Li -bearing areas in bright pixels. Some urbanized/agricultural areas are
bands): Eigenvector and eigenvalues matrix. also highlighted in bright pixels, which reinforces the need to exclude
these areas from the image processing.
PC1 PC2
Due to the importance of the green and NIR bands in the identifi-
Band 11 0.82901 −0.55924 cation of Li-bearing pegmatites, ASTER and Landsat-8 respective bands
Band 12 0.55924 0.82901 were resampled to the Sentinel-2 spatial resolution using the nearest
Eigenvalues 8222452.87800 24945.17472 neighbor method, in order to establish a comparison between these
Accounted variance 99.69750 0.30250
bands for the three sensors. The same analysis was made for all open-pit
Cumulative variance 99.69750 100
mines. Fig. 14 shows the resultant scatterplots for the Bajoca mine.

21
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

Fig. 13. Selective PCA on 2 bands to Li-bearing minerals in bright pixels: a) PC2 from the ASTER subset; b) - PC2 from the Landsat-8 subset; c) -PC2 from the Landsat-
5 subset; d) PC2 from the Sentinel-2 subset. Before the opening of the Bajoca and Alberto mines (b), there is no distinctive spectral response from the Li-bearing veins.

4. Discussion to the formation of minerals that are also formed through hydrothermal
alteration processes or that it can induce geological changes which
As mentioned before, the recognition of mineralized areas is mainly present similar signatures to hydrothermally altered areas. Either way,
performed through the identification of the associated alteration halos. detailed compositional and spectral studies are needed to understand
The most common minerals associated with these alteration zones are these results.
iron oxides and clay minerals (Sabins, 1999). So, several known image RGB combinations are the most difficult technique to interpret be-
processing methods were applied in order to identify hydrothermally cause a mixture of signals from distinct minerals generates a mixture of
altered zones in the studied area. colors often quite different from the results reported in the literature.
RGB 573 (Landsat-8), RGB 472 (Landsat-5) and RGB 8123 (Sentinel- Band ratio were also applied to highlight hydrothermally altered
2) were able to identify hydrothermally altered rocks (Fig. 4). In the zones, through the discrimination of minerals normally associated to
Fregeneda-Almendra aplite-pegmatite field, Bajoca, Feli and Alberto these areas. Band ratios 6/5 (Landsat-8), 5/4 (Landsat-5) and 11/8
open pit mines appear with a bluish tint indicating hydrothermal al- (Sentinel-2) were applied to discriminate ferrous minerals (Figs. 7 and
teration. The burned areas present a green color that could also indicate 8). Ratio 4/3, that was employed to map ferric oxides in ASTER images,
hydrothermal alteration. This may indicate that fire exposure can lead presented similar results. All the ratios reflect the compositional

Fig. 14. Scatterplots between ASTER, Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 green and NIR bands for the Bajoca mine, obtained by spatial resampling of the products to 10 m
resolution. Warmer colors represent a higher density of points. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web
version of this article).

22
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

differences between the granitoid rocks and the metasediments. The presence of the thermal band is the key to effectively highlight Li-
high iron content in the granites can be explained by the alteration of bearing areas: since Sentinel-2 does not have available a band in TIR
biotite (which is a ferromagnesian mineral) to iron oxides. The altera- region, the thermal band was replaced by a SWIR band and the re-
tion of the biotite in the granites forms a superficial alteration cap while sultant combination is not able to discriminate the Li-pegmatites from
in the metasediments iron oxides tend to concentrate in zones of the host rocks. The thermal band is important in the discrimination of
weakness such as fractures. These ratios also highlight the burned areas Li-bearing pegmatites because silicate minerals like spodumene and
as the zones that contain the highest content in ferrous minerals. Sev- petalite have distinctive emission bands in thermal region (Spatz,
eral authors reported the physical, chemical and mineralogical changes 1997). On the other hand, the similar response between Li-areas and
in soils due to wild fires, and one the of the common changes is the urbanized zones and agricultural fields observed in these RGB combi-
formation of iron oxide maghemite (e.g. Clement et al., 2011; nations is a clear obstacle to its use. Spectral studies should be con-
Jordanova, 2016). Residual ash from forest fires can also present sig- ducted to understand these similar responses.
nificant amounts of iron oxides (Lu et al., 2000). In what concerns the Li-bearing pegmatites were also highlighted through band ratios.
open-pits of Bajoca, Feli and Alberto, no ferrous minerals were identi- Density slice versions of band ratio 7/6 for ASTER (Fig. 9) and of ratio
fied, although iron oxides have been described in these areas especially 3/5 (Landsat-8; Fig. 10), 2/4 (Landsat-5; Fig. 10), 3/8 (Sentinel-2;
associated with fault zones. In the Bajoca mine, Almeida (2003) de- Figure S4) and 1/3 (ASTER; Figure S4) successfully differentiated Li-
scribed the formation of iron oxides and clay minerals associated with bearing areas from the host rock. These ratios were proposed con-
fault zones. This shows the incapacity of the used band ratios to cor- sidering the spodumene spectral behavior, but both petalite and spo-
rectly map all the Fe-bearing areas. dumene veins were highlighted. It is important to refer that there is no
To map alunite and/or clays such as kaolinite, montmorillonite, reference spectrum for petalite. Nonetheless, because the elements that
band ratios 6/7 (Landsat-8), 5/7 (Landsat-5) and 11/12 (Sentinel-2) constitute petalite and spodumene are the same, the spectral behavior
were considered (Fig. 8). In all cases, these minerals appear to be dis- of the two minerals should be similar. In the first case (ratio 7/6), ur-
tributed near to the water lines and associated with some geological banized areas and agricultural fields also present a similar response to
faults. In general, no clay minerals are identified in the known Li-mi- Li-bearing areas. To overcome this obstacle in the future, these areas
neralized areas. However, the application of band ratio 7/5 to ASTER could be excluded. Nevertheless, it is essential to understand why these
bands (Fig. 8-d, -e, -f), in order to map kaolinite, produced very dif- different areas present similar spectral behaviors and how it is possible
ferent results: according to this ratio, kaolinite is present in the Bajoca to separate the two signals. It is also clear the importance of the density
and Alberto mines. These incongruent results can be explained by the slice method, without which the discrimination of Li-bearing areas from
fact that ASTER has several narrower bands in the SWIR while Landsat the background was impossible.
(5 and 8) and Sentinel-2 present only two broad bands. The higher Selective PCA proved to be a powerful resource capable of isolating
spectral resolution of ASTER results in a higher efficiency in mineral the spectral inputs of Li-bearing pegmatites for both two- and four-band
mapping and discrimination. Agricultural fields also are highlighted as subsets (Figs. 13 and S6). In addition to the Li-bearing areas, some
kaolinite-bearing areas. This could mean that the soils used in agri- urbanized/agricultural areas were also highlighted in bright pixels,
culture present high clay content. which emphasizes the need to exclude these areas from the image
Overall, the applied band ratios failed to identify minerals asso- processing. Overall, the two-band subset appears to be more sensitive to
ciated with hydrothermal alteration near the open-pits of Bajoca, Feli the signature of Li-minerals and present fewer noise because only the
and Alberto which emphasizes the need to study and characterize the target bands were used. It is essential, to define a threshold value from
alteration associated in the Li-bearing pegmatites in order to develop which only the Li-bearing minerals are being mapped. In the future, to
more adequate remote sensing algorithms. aid visual interpretation, density slice could be applied. The selective
Selective PCA proved to be more efficient than band ratio in iden- PCA can also be applied to other bands containing the target spectral
tifying iron oxides (Fig. 12). Both the four- and the two-band subsets information of Li-bearing minerals.
allowed to discriminate iron oxides/ferric iron in the Bajoca and Al- In general, a comparison between Landsat-5 images (before the
berto mines. It is also worth mentioning that no presence of iron oxides opening of Bajoca and Alberto mines) and the other images shows that
was detected in Landsat-5 images (before the opening of the mines). no distinct signature is detected in these areas before exploitation. In
On the opposite, selective PCA either in the two- and four-band the region, spodumene veins can reach 4 to 15 m of thickness while
subsets for Sentinel-2 and Landsat-5 and 8 was incapable of high- petalite veins can go from 5 up to 30 m (Roda-Robles et al., 2010).
lighting hydroxyl minerals in the open-pit mines (Figure S5), but it Considering that the exposition of the pegmatites (and thereafter of Li-
shows a clear signal difference before and after the opening of the bearing minerals) before the opening of the mines was very small when
Bajoca and Alberto mines. Selective PCA on ASTER was more effective compared to pixel size, these temporal spectral differences indicate that
and highlights more alteration minerals (like alunite, illite and kaoli- the signals obtained in Landsat-8, Sentinel-2 and ASTER images are in
nite) in the Bajoca mine than in the other two mines (Fig. 2). fact due to the Li-bearing pegmatites. Moreover, taking into account the
Analyzing all the results obtained, they indicate that in fact some high vegetation coverage over Bajoca and Alberto mines at the time of
alteration process is related to the Li-bearing pegmatites. Nonetheless, acquisition of the Landsat 5 images, we think that the any existing al-
other tested algorithms from the literature (which were defined to other teration/metasomatic halos are concealed due to the interference of
mineral deposits types) did not work well in this study. This emphasizes vegetation.
the need to develop specific algorithms for Li-mineralizations even The successful application of the proposed image processing algo-
more because so far only image classification algorithms were applied rithms in order to highlight Li-bearing pegmatites is proof of the remote
to select target Li areas (Mendes et al., 2017; Perrotta et al., 2005). sensing potential to delineate target areas in the near future.
With that goal in mind, and based on the known spectral curves of
Li-bearing minerals (Kokaly et al., 2017), some new approaches were 5. Conclusions
proposed.
Two of the self-proposed RGB combinations were able to success- In this study, we presented an innovative methodology capable of
fully highlight Li-bearing areas and distinguish them from the host detecting the spectral signatures of Li-bearing pegmatites as well as
rocks: the first comprises a SWIR, a visible and a thermal band (Figure well-known remote sensing algorithms to identify alteration halos re-
S3), and the second two bands in the visible and one thermal band lated to these pegmatites bodies. For that Landsat-5, Landsat-8,
(Fig. 5). The SWIR band in the first case combination allows to dis- Sentinel-2 and ASTER images were used. The applied remote sensing
criminate the granites from the metasediments. In both cases, the methods included RGB combinations, band ratios and selective

23
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

principal component analysis. The methods were able to evidence some Infrared Spectral Data in Mineral Exploration: Application to Northern Patagonia
hydrothermal alteration associated with the Li-bearing pegmatites that Mountains, Arizona. Econ. Geol. 98 (5), 1003–1018.
van der Meer, F.D., van der Werff, H.M.A., van Ruitenbeek, F.J.A., 2014. Potential of
needs to be characterized. RGB combinations and selective PCA prove ESA’s Sentinel-2 for geological applications. Remote Sens. Environ. 148, 124–133.
to be more effective than the band ratios at highlighting the altered Perrotta, M.M., Souza Filho, C.R., Leite, C.A.S., 2005. Mapeamento Espectral De Intrusões
areas. Band ratios were a good strategy to identify and map the com- Pegmatíticas Relacionadas a Mineralizações De Lítio, Gemas E Minerais Industriais
Na Região Do Vale Do Jequitinhonha (MG) a Partir De Imagens ASTER. Anais Do XII
positional differences between different lithologies. Band ratios could Simpósio Brasileiro De Sensoriamento Remoto 1855–1862.
also be used to study the geochemical changes in the soils induced by Mendes, D., Perrotta, M.M., Costa, M.A.C., Paes, V.J.C., 2017. Mapeamento espectral para
wild fires. All new RGB combinations, band ratios and subsets for se- identificação de assinaturas espectrais de minerais de lítio em imagens ASTER (NE/
MG). Anais Do XVIII Simpósio Brasileiro De Sensoriamento Remoto 5273–5280.
lective PCA were capable to differentiate the spectral signatures of the Cardoso-Fernandes, J., Lima, A., Teodoro, A.C., 2018. Potential of Sentinel-2 Data in the
Li-bearing pegmatites from the spectral signatures of the host rocks. The Detection of Lithium (Li)-bearing Pegmatites: a Study Case. SPIE Remote Sensing,
higher spectral resolution of ASTER allowed for a better mineral dis- SPIE, pp. 15.
Google Earth Pro, Available online: https://www.google.com/intl/en_uk/earth/desktop/
crimination. On the other hand, the lack of a thermal band from
(Accessed 3 August 2018).
Sentinel-2 prevented the discrimination of Li-bearing pegmatites using Lotze, F., 1945. Zur gliederung der Varisziden der Iberischen Meseta. s.n. Berlin. pp. 15.
only RGB combinations. Despite the mentioned limitations, there is a Julivert, M., 1972. Mapa tectónico de la Península Ibérica y Baleares Escala 1:1.000.000.
great potential for the identification of Li-bearing pegmatites using Ministerio de Industria y Energía, Servicio de Publicaciones, Madrid p 1 mapa.
Farias, P., Gallastegui, G., González Lodeiro, F., Marquínez, J., Martín-Parra, L.M.,
remote sensing. Martínez Catalán, J.R., Pablo Maciá, J.G., Rodríguez-Fernández, L.R., 1987.
In the future, to improve the proposed methodology, other remote Aportaciones al conocimiento de la litoestratigrafía y estructura de Galicia Central.
sensing techniques such as spectral unmixing and image classification Mem. Museu Mineral. Geol. Fac. Ciências Univ. Porto 1, 411–431.
Martínez Catalán, J.R., Martínez Poyatos, D., Bea, F., 2004. Coords.) Zona Centroibérica:
algorithms can be tested. The validation of the obtained results in the Introducción. In: Vera, J.A. (Ed.), Geología de España. Geol. España/Inst. Geol. Min.
field and the collection of mineral spectral signatures is also required. España (SGE-IGME), Madrid, pp. 68–69.
To increase the efficiency of the tested algorithms, sensors with a better Dias, G., Noronha, F., Ferreira, N., 2000. Variscan Plutonism in the Central Iberian Zone,
Northern Portugal. Eurogranites 2000, Field Meeting, Guide Book. pp. 1–15.
spatial and spectral resolution will be used to highlight other Li-bearing Noronha, F., Ramos, J.M.F., Rebelo, J.A., Ribeiro, A., Ribeiro, M.L., 1979. Essai de
pegmatites. corrélation des phases de déformation hercynienne dans le Nord-Ouest Péninsulaire.
Bol. Soc. Geol. Portugal 21 (2-3), 227–237.
Ribeiro, M.L., Silva, A.Fd., 1994. Notícia Explicativa da folha 15-B Freixo de Espada à
Funding Cinta. Instituto Geológico e Mineiro. Departamento de Geologia, Lisboa, pp. 48.
Silva, A.Fd., Ribeiro, M.L., 1991. Notícia Explicativa da folha 15-A Vila Nova de Foz Côa.
The authors would like to thank the financial support provided by Serviços Geológicos de Portugal, Lisboa, pp. 52.
Costa, J.C.Sd., 1950. Notícia sobre uma carta geológica do Buçaco, de Nery Delgado.
FCT– Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia with the ERA-MIN/0001/
Serviços Geológicos de Portugal, Lisboa.
2017 – LIGHTS project and to FEDER through the operation POCI-01- Teixeira, C., 1955. Notas sobre geologia de Portugal o complexo xisto-grauváquico ante-
0145-FEDER-007690 funded by the Programa Operacional ordoviciano. [s.n.]: Lisboa. pp. 48.
Competitividade e Internacionalização – COMPETE2020 and by Díez Balda, M.A., Vegas, R., Lodeiro, G., 1990. Central iberian zone: structure. In:
Dallmeyer, R.D., Martinez Garcia, E. (Eds.), Pre-Mesozoic Geology of the Iberian
National Funds through FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia Peninsula. Springer Verlag, Berlim, pp. 172–188.
within ICT, R&D Unit (reference UID/GEO/04683/2013). Rodríguez Alonso, M.D., Díez Balda, M.A., Perejón, A., Pieren, A., Liñán, E., López Díaz,
F., Moreno, F., Gámez Vintaned, J.A., Gónzalez Lodeiro, F., Martínez Poyatos, D.,
Vegas, R., 2004. Domínio del Complejo Esquisto-Grauváquico: Estratigrafía. La se-
Conflicts of interest cuencia litoestratigráfica del Neoproterozóico-Câmbrico Inferior. In: Vera, J.A. (Ed.),
Geología de España. Geol. España/Inst. Geol. Min. España (SGE-IGME), Madrid, pp.
The authors declare no conflict of interest. 78–81.
Vieira, R., 2010. Aplitopegmatitos com elementos raros da região entre Almendra (V.N.
de Foz Côa) e Barca d’Alva (Figueira de Castelo Rodrigo). Campo aplitopegmatítico
Acknowledgments da Fregeneda- Almendra. PhD thesis. Faculdade de Ciências da Universidade do
Porto, Porto.
Roda, E., 1993. Distribución, Caracteristicas y Petrogenesis de las Pegmatitas de La
The authors would also like to thank two anonymous reviewers for
Fregeneda (Salamanca). PhD thesis. UPV, Bilbau.
their helpful comments and suggestions. Roda, E., Pesquera, A., Velasco, F., Fontan, F., 1999. The granitic pegmatites of the
Fregeneda area (Salamanca, Spain): characteristics and petrogenesis. Mineral. Mag.
63 (4), 535–558.
Appendix A. Supplementary data
Černý, P., Ercit, T.S., 2005. Classification of granitic pegmatites revisited. Can. Mineral.
43, 2005–2026.
Supplementary material related to this article can be found, in the The Thematic Mapper. Available online: https://landsat.gsfc.nasa.gov/the-thematic-
online version, at doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jag.2018.11.001. mapper/ (Accessed January 2018).
Anon, 2018. What Are the Band Designations for the Landsat Satellites? Available on-
line:. (Accessed December 2017). https://landsat.usgs.gov/what-are-band-
References designations-landsat-satellites.
ASTER: Mission. Available online: https://asterweb.jpl.nasa.gov/mission.asp (Accessed
December 2017).
Moradi, M., Basiri, S., Kananian, A., Kabiri, K., 2014. Fuzzy logic modeling for hydro- ASTER: Instrument Characteristics. Available online: https://asterweb.jpl.nasa.gov/
thermal gold mineralization mapping using geochemical, geological, ASTER ima- characteristics.asp (Accessed December 2017).
geries and other geo-data, a case study in Central Alborz, Iran. Earth Sci. Inform. 8 User Guides: Sentinel-2 - Overview. Available online: https://sentinel.esa.int/web/
(1), 197–205. sentinel/user-guides/sentinel-2-msi/overview (Accessed January 2018).
Crósta, A.P., De Souza Filho, C.R., Azevedo, F., Brodie, C., 2003. Targeting key alteration Missions: Sentinel-2 - Overview.Available online: https://sentinel.esa.int/web/sentinel/
minerals in epithermal deposits in Patagonia, Argentina, using ASTER imagery and missions/sentinel-2/overview (Accessed January 2018).
principal component analysis. Int. J. Remote Sens. 24 (21), 4233–4240. Meyer, D., Siemonsma, D., Brooks, B., Johnson, L., 2015. Advanced Spaceborne Thermal
Pour, A.B., Hashim, M., 2015. Hydrothermal alteration mapping from Landsat-8 data, Sar Emission and Reflection Radiometer Level 1 Precision Terrain Corrected Registered
Cheshmeh copper mining district, south-eastern Islamic Republic of Iran. J. Taibah At-Sensor Radiance (AST_L1T) Product, Algorithm Theoretical Basis Document;
Univ. Sci. 9 (2), 155–166. 2015-1171; Reston, VA. pp. 50.
Sabins, F.F., Miller, R.M., 1994. Resource assessment—Salar uyuni and vicinity. Congedo, L., 2016. Semi-Automatic Classification Plugin Documentation. https://doi.
Proceedings of Tenth Thematic Conference on Geologic Remote Sensing 9–12. org/10.13140/RG.2.2.29474.02242/1.
Rockwell, B.W., Hofstra, A.H., 2008. Identification of quartz and carbonate minerals QGIS Software. Available online: https://www.qgis.org/en/site/ (Accessed 12 July
across northern Nevada using ASTER thermal infrared emissivity data—implications 2018).
for geologic mapping and mineral resource investigations in well-studied and frontier Chavez, P.S., 1996. Image-based atmospheric corrections - revisited and improved.
areas. Geosphere 4 (1), 218. Photogramm. Eng. Remote Sensing 62, 1025–1036.
Rowan, L.C., Mars, J.C., 2003. Lithologic mapping in the Mountain Pass, California area Weier, J., Herring, D., 2018. Measuring Vegetation (NDVI&EVI). Available online:.
using advanced spaceborne thermal emission and reflection radiometer (ASTER) (Accessed October 2017). https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/
data. Remote Sens. Environ. 84 (3), 350–366. MeasuringVegetation/.
Berger, B.R., King, T.V.V., Morath, L.C., Philli, J.D., 2003. Utility of High-Altitude Johnson, B., Tateishi, R., Hoan, N., 2012. Satellite image pansharpening using a hybrid

24
J. Cardoso-Fernandes et al. Int J Appl  Earth Obs Geoinformation 76 (2019) 10–25

approach for object-based image analysis. ISPRS Int. J. Geoinf. 1 (3), 228–241. (6), 883–896.
ArcMap Software. Available online: http://desktop.arcgis.com/en/arcmap/ (Accessed 12 Loughlin, W.P., 1991. Component analysis for alteration mapping. Photogram. Eng. Rem.
July 2018). Sens. 57, 1163–1169.
SNAP Software. Available online: http://step.esa.int/main/ (Accessed 12 July 2018). Chavez Jr, P.S., Kwarteng, A.Y., 1989. Extracting spectral contrast in Landsat Thematic
Kokaly, R.F., Clark, R.N., Swayze, G.A., Livo, K.E., Hoefen, T.M., Pearson, N.C., Wise, Mapper image data using selective principal component analysis. Photogramm. Eng.
R.A., Benzel, W.M., Lowers, H.A., Driscoll, R.L., Klein, A.J., 2017. USGS Spectral Remote Sensing 55 (3), 339–348.
Library Version 7; 1035. Reston, VA, pp. 68. Key, C.H., Benson, N.C., 2006. Landscape Assessment: Ground Measure of Severity, the
Ali, A., Pour, A., 2014. Lithological mapping and hydrothermal alteration using Landsat 8 Composite Burn Index; and Remote Sensing of Severity, the Normalized Burn Ratio.
data: a case study in ariab mining district, red sea hills, Sudan. Int. J. Basic Appl. Sci. RMRS-GTR-164-CD: LA 1-51; Ogden, UT. .
3 (3). Martín, M.P., 1998. Cartografía E Inventario De Incendios Forestales En La Península
Han, T., Nelson, J., 2015. Mapping hydrothermally altered rocks with landsat 8 imagery: Ibérica a Partir De Imágenes NOAA-AVHRR. PhD Thesis. Universidad de Alcalá.
a case study in the KSM and snow field zones, northwestern British Columbia. Clement, B.M., Javier, J., Sah, J.P., Ross, M.S., 2011. The effects of wildfires on the
Geological Fieldwork 2014, British Columbia Ministry of Energy and Mines Vol. magnetic properties of soils in the Everglades. Earth Surf. Process. Landf. 36 (4),
2015-1. British Columbia Geological Survey Paper, pp. 103–112. 460–466.
Kalinowski, A., Oliver, S., 2004. ASTER Mineral Index Processing Manual. Geoscience Jordanova, N., 2016. Effects of wildfires on the magnetism of soils: possible application in
Australia. soil science and paleoenvironmental studies. In: Jordanova, N. (Ed.), Soil Magnetism:
Mia, B., Fujimitsu, Y., 2012. Mapping hydrothermal altered mineral deposits using Applications in Pedology, Environmental Science and Agriculture, pp. 419–420.
Landsat 7 ETM+ image in and around Kuju volcano, Kyushu, Japan. J. Earth Syst. Lu, H., Liu, T., Gu, Z., Liu, B., Zhou, L., Han, J., Wu, N., 2000. Effect of burning C3 and C4
Sci. 121 (4), 1049–1057. plants on the magnetic susceptibility signal in soils. Geophys. Res. Lett. 27 (13),
Mwaniki, M.W., Moeller, M.S., Schellmann, G., 2015. A Comparison of Landsat 8 (OLI) 2013–2016.
and Landsat 7 (ETM+) in Mapping Geology and Visualising Lineaments: a Case Study Almeida, C.M.Pd., 2003. Estudo do filão aplitopegmatítico da mina da Bajoca, Almendra:
of Central Region Kenya. ISPRS - International Archives of the Photogrammetry, contribuição científico-tecnológica. MsC thesis. Faculdade de Ciências da
Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, pp. 897–903 XL-7/W3. Universidade do Porto, Porto.
Sabins, F.F., 1996. In: Freeman, W.H. (Ed.), Remote Sensing Principles and Interpretation, Spatz, D.M., 1997. Remote sensing characteristics of the sediment- and volcanic-hosted
3rd ed. pp. 494 New York, p XII. precious metal systems: imagery selection for exploration and development. Int. J.
Sabins, F.F., 1999. Remote sensing for mineral exploration. Ore Geol. Rev. 14 (3), Remote Sens. 18 (7), 1413–1438.
157–183. Roda-Robles, E., Vieira, R., Pesquera, A., Lima, A., 2010. Chemical variations and sig-
Gabr, S., Ghulam, A., Kusky, T., 2010. Detecting areas of high-potential gold miner- nificance of phosphates from the Fregeneda-Almendra pegmatite field, Central
alization using ASTER data. Ore Geol. Rev. 38 (1-2), 59–69. Iberian Zone (Spain and Portugal). Mineral. Petrol. 100 (1), 23–34.
Singh, A., Harrison, A., 1985. Standardized principal components. Int. J. Remote Sens. 6

25

You might also like