Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C C B Basnayaka MBA/2015/004
Impulsive and Compulsive Buying Behavior
Introduction
The marketing concept of business behavior focuses on consumers, their preferences,
wishes, needs and expectations that need to be met and exceeded so that the company can
achieve business success quantified by the levels of revenue, profit, market share and
loyal customer basis. Marketing as a science, with all its derived disciplines, has been
striving ever since its emergence to investigate the causes, factors, action mechanisms and
consequences of consumer behavior, and despite the fact that much has been discovered
and achieved in this aspect, marketing theory and practice are still far from having
explained all the aspects of consumer behavior.
Consumer behavior is the most complex issue of marketing theory and practice, due to its
marked heterogeneity and a multitude of factors exerting a combined impact on it, in
more or less diverse ways, depending on the occasion. One of the highly specific
manifestations of consumer behavior on the market is impulsive behavior resulting in
unplanned purchases. Marketing researchers have been trying to ascertain all the aspects
of consumers’ impulsive buying behavior, for decades now, during which period the
research focus was redirected from researching the types and categories of products
inducing impulsive buying and defining the companies’ marketing offer accordingly, to
current research into the broad range of factors affecting and shaping consumers’
impulsive buying behavior and setting marketing strategies based on these findings.
Impulsive and compulsive buying are considered some of the most persistent and
idiosyncratic phenomenon in consumer lifestyle. This distinctive nature of impulsive and
compulsive buying has increased the attention from consumer researcher and theorists in
these phenomenon (Rook, 1987; Rook and Fisher, 1995). Historically, research on
impulsive and compulsive buying behaviors have been focused on; its definitional
elements distinguishing and differentiating them from other form of buying behaviors
(Cobb and Hoyer, 1986; Rook, 1987). Moreover, theorists have traditionally focused on
providing theoretical frameworks for examining impulsive and compulsive buying (Rook
and Fisher, 1995). Lately, many studies have been conducted to develop and validate
scales to measure the tendency of consumers to display impulsive and compulsive buying
behaviors. There is still a lot of work that needs to be done to identify and examine the
factors that affect impulsive and compulsive buying.
Compulsive Buying
Research on the phenomenon of compulsive buying was presented into the consumer
behavior literature by Faber et al. (1987) and other works have extended those first
findings (Faber and O'Guinn, 1987; O'Guinn and Faber, 1989; Valence et al., 1988;
d’Astous and Tremblay, 1989). This abnormal form of consumer behavior is
characterized by chronic buying episodes of a somewhat stereotraited fashion in which
the consumer feels unable to stop or significantly moderate the behavior. Although
compulsive buying may produce some short-term positive feelings for the individual, it
ultimately is disruptive to normal life functioning and produces significant negative
consequences (O'Guinn and Faber, 1988).
Compulsive behavior is defined as “repetitive and seemingly purposeful” acts that are
“performed according to certain rules or in a stereo traits fashion” (American Psychiatric
Association, 1985: 234). In marketing, manifestations of compulsive behavior include
purchasing behaviors that cannot be controlled, are excessive, time consuming, and/or
patterned in nature. Although compulsive buying can be associated with emotional
attachment to objects, it is more likely that the pleasure derived from the act of buying is
the primary motivation (O’Guinn and Faber, 1989). It is distinct from impulsive
behaviors because compulsive buying involves an “inability to control the urge” (Faber et
al., 1995: 297). A theoretical framework of compulsive buying is presented, incorporating
constructs/data themes from previous research in psychiatry, psychology, sociology, and
marketing. Personality antecedents and short and long term consequences describe the
addictive consumer disease.
Impulsive Buying
Impulsivity is a personality trait defined as a tendency towards acting without
forethought, making quick cognitive decisions, and failing to appreciate the
circumstances beyond the here and now (Barratt, 1993). It is one of those dimensions of
individual differences that are frequently associated with the biological bases of
personality; a state involving non-specific physiological activation and the non-
directional component of alertness (Anderson and Revelle,1994). Impulse buying is an
outcome of a sudden consumer’s irresistible urge to buy an item spontaneously (O’Quinn
and Faber, 1989).
Impulsive buying has been described as making unplanned and sudden purchases, which
are initiated on the spot, and are accompanied by a powerful urge and feelings of pleasure
and excitement (Rook, 1987). In response to this definitional problem, researchers began
to focus on identifying the internal psychological states underlying consumers’ impulse
buying episodes (Rook, 1987; Rook and Gardner, 1993; Rook and Hoch, 1985). Impulse
buying was redefined as occurring “when a consumer experiences a sudden, often
powerful and persistent urge to buying something immediately. It is important to note that
although diverse literatures have historically focused on the negative outcomes of
impulsive and compulsive human behaviors, thus serving as a warning to rational humans
to “think before they leap,” marketers have traditionally been interested in encouraging
“leaping before thinking” consumption behaviors, where purchases are made swiftly
and/or repeatedly before deliberation of possible alternatives and consequences is given
more time. Selling additional goods to more consumers is, after all, one of the major
objectives when the goal is to increase market share and generate increased profits.
Millions of dollars each year are appropriated by corporations to discover additional
effective tactics that encourage rapid and repeated consumption behavior.
For a long time, the basic starting tenet of economic science was Homo Economicus, i.e.
the economic consumer, whose behavior is expressly cognitive and rational, and whose
shopping habits are always guided by their interests and consideration in order to achieve
maximum benefits with minimum invested resources. Reality, however, has refuted such
a narrow view of consumers, as they very often buy products and services not only to
satisfy their physiological and other rational needs, but also to satisfy some personal
psychological needs and desires that other consumers may find irrational. A purchase
decision can be and very often is prompted by aesthetic and symbolic motives, or simply,
desire for entertainment. Such deviation from standard and rational consumer behavior is
referred to as impulse buying. Generally, there are numerous examples of various
products and services that can ascribe their sales levels to such shifts away from rational
consumer behavior. It is therefore not a rare occurrence; on the contrary, impulsive
buying is a unique, but ubiquitous phenomenon, one that might even be classified as a
routine form of consumer behavior.
Dholakia (2000) argues that impulsive buying behavior is a moment during the shopping
trip occurring at the retail outlet, so that the greatest interest in the study of this
phenomenon and the initial body of knowledge about it originate from retailing sources,
where factors such as shelf arrangement, product packaging and point-of-sale promotion
significantly increased the consumers’ impulsive buying behavior.
Researching the relationship between gender and material symbols in relation to
impulsive buying, Dittmar, Beattie and Friese (1995) argue that the level of impulse
intention characterizes every individual consumer, different from one consumer to the
other, but directly determine the real impulsive purchase. Although it is the consumers
that manifest impulsive behavior, it is triggered by products and services, i.e. the latter
two are the main marketing stimulus of impulsive buying behavior available to
companies. Products such as clothing and accessories, music, and product categories that
imply social and personal visibility and involvement, as well expressing one’s personal
image, tend to encourage consumer impulsive buyer behavior.
One of frequently cited authors dealing with consumer impulsive behavior, Rook (1987)
defines it as unexpected purchases unplanned before entering a retail outlet, resulting
from rapid purchase decision, preceded by sudden and strong urge to possess a noticed
product or service. Impulsive purchase is an unplanned purchase decision made at the
point of sale, which is, in most cases, a consumer’s emotional, or cognitive, or combined
response to a sudden stimulus.
Tendai and Crispen (2009) devote the most attention to researching the element of point
of sale on consumers’ impulsive buying behavior, underlining that it is, basically, a
purchase decision made at the retail outlet, so that it is necessary for marketing theory and
practice to constantly investigate which retail outlet elements may produce impulsive
buying behavior and satisfy the consumers’ need innovatively. Product display,
packaging design, relaxing interior and atmosphere at the retail outlet make a positive
impact on consumers’ impulsive buying behavior. Tendai and Crispen (2009) specify that
the retail outlet ambience and atmosphere have two positive impacts on impulsive buying
(p. 103): promotion effect, as a combination of information and economic effect produced
by stimuli such as price reductions, coupons, gifts, etc. involvement effect, where the
atmosphere causes a high level of customer involvement, positive agitation and pleasure
by means of appearance and interior decoration, music, sales promotions, sales staff
attitude, etc.
Solomon (2002) defines consumers’ impulsive buying behavior as behavior that “occurs
when a consumer a sudden irresistible urge to buy” (p.301). Most frequently, impulse
purchases occur in situation when the consumer deems impulsive buying behavior totally
appropriate, such as buying a present for someone else. Salomon further categorizes
consumers according to the degree of manifestation of impulsive buying behavior
(p.303): planning consumers, who always decide in advance what, how much and which
brands they will buy; partially planning consumers, who either choose only the category,
or only the amount of product to buy; and impulsive buyers, without any prior shopping
plan. Hanna & Wozniak (2001) opine that consumers’ impulsive buying behavior is a
common occurrence on the market, and consider it to be within the consumer’s non
programmed problem resolution pattern during the purchase decision making process.
Impulsive behavior and purchases imply very little time used for decision-making, limited
presence or total absence of cognitive effort in decision making, where emotional appeals
make a decision-making impact on the consumers.
Mowen (1993) defines impulsive purchases as “hedonically complex impulses to buy that
may stimulate emotional conflict.” (p. 381). Impulsive purchases tend to appear in
situations when the consumer’s consideration and the significance of consequences of
these purchases diminish. Impulsive purchases occur when consumers have no prior
perception of any problem or consequences of these purchases, or prior intention to buy.
Mowen claims that between 39 and 67% of purchases are completely unplanned and
impulse-driven. Impulsive buys happen automatically and without control, but always
entail strong affective conditions in consumers.
Maričić (2011) regards what he terms affects as specific acts of manifesting consumer
buying behavior. An affect or emotion refers to consumers’ feelings, whereas cognition or
consideration refers to consumers’ planned behavior, and both these extremes are, in fact,
consumers’ psychological responses to stimuli and events in the environment. Affects are
almost always responsive behavior, which means that they reflect the consumers’
immediate and automatic response to stimuli they are exposed to. Maričić (2011) lists the
following types of consumers’ affective responses, their effect on behavior, and
characteristics of response to it (p.133): Types of consumer’s affective responses:
emotions; specific and subjective feelings; moods; assessments. Effect of affects on
consumer behavior: positive mood accelerates the consumer education process and
shortens the decision-making time when choosing products or services; invigorated mood
favors products with positive connotations; emotions activate consumers’ motivation to
buy. Characteristics of affect-driven response: affect is always an immediate and
automatic response to an external stimulus, which cannot be planned; affect-driven
responses are either beyond or under negligible control of the consumer; intensive
affective conditions also include consumers’ physiological responses; most affect-driven
responses are learnt.
Maričić (2011) argues that consumers’ affective and cognitive systems are mutually
dependent and related, and continuously influence each other, which often results in
unplanned and impulsive purchases. These purchases are characterized by sudden
spontaneous urge to buy, which can be completely contrary to the consumer’s earlier
behavior, followed by a state of psychological imbalance and loss of control over the
consumer’s own behavior, occurrence of psychological conflict caused by the analysis of
satisfaction and consequences, decrease in the consumer’s cognition, and finally,
manifestation of impulse-driven behavior. There are five types of impulsive purchases
(Maričić, 2011, p. 143): pure impulsiveness; suggestion effect ; planned impulsiveness:
recall effect; and planned purchase of a category, but not also a brand of product and
service.
Making an impulsive purchase requires certain mood, i.e. excitement, and the consumer’s
positive attitude. The most common impulsive purchases are those caused by hedonic
urges and comprise the so-called hedonic consumption; these purchases, however, also
cause emotional conflict, so that impulsive purchases are often also termed ‘emotional
purchases’ (Maričić, 2011, p. 144). Although impulsive purchases include a situation
where the consumer cannot resist the marketing stimulus, this does not mean that im-
pulsive purchases do not also include cognitive consumer behavior. On the contrary;
often a cognitive analysis of, for instance, excellent offer in a retail outlet is the trigger of
impulsive purchase.
Conclusion
The competition in every industry is getting fiercer. Even minor differences between
shoppers are becoming important for firms in their efforts to get target consumers.
According to the literature there are many factors influencing the impulse buying of
consumers in both in-store and online. This shows that there is a lot of scope for further
research in same direction related to impulse buying.
Impulse purchasing does not match with rational decision making model of a consumer:
when need emerges, a consumer buys impulsively and does not search for alternatives.
Various factors such as consumer characteristics, store characteristics, situational factors,
and product characteristics have strong influence on consumer’s impulse purchasing
behavior. Although recently impulse buying is considered to be an unethical appeal to the
consumers, in perspective of marketers, it brings revenues rather than blame. In
perspective of consumers, it should not be that much negative aspect, because who have
purchasing power, can spend their money according to their wish. But post purchase
dissonance should not be occurred due to impulse purchase. In fact consumers sometimes
love to purchase impulsively. So we have to consider both sides of impulse purchasing.
References
Rook, D. W., & Gardner, M. P. (1993). In the mood: impulse buying’s affective
antecedents. Research in consumer behavior, 6(7), 1-28.Rook, D. W., & Hoch, S. J.
(1985). Consuming impulses. Advances in consumer research, 12(1), 23-27.
Rycroft, C. 1968. A Critical Dictionary of Psychoanalysis, 2nd printing. New York: Basic
Books.
Scherhorn, G. 1990. “The Addictive Trait in Buying Behavior.” Journal of Consumer
Policy, 13 (March): 33-52.
Scherhorn, G., L. A. Reisch, and G. Raab. 1990. “Addictive Buying in West Germany:
An Empirical Study.” Journal of Consumer Policy, 13(4): 355-387.
Schiffman, L.G. & Kanuk, L.L., 2007. Consumer Behavior 9th edn., New Jersey: Prentice
Hall.
Shahjehan A., Qureshi J.A., Zeb F., Saifullah K., (2012.), “The Effect of Pesonality on
Impulsive and Compulsive Buying Behaviors”, African Journal of Business Management,
Vol. 6., No. 6., pp. 2187-2194.
Tendai M., Crispen C., (2009.) “In-Store Shopping Environment and Impulsive Buying”,
African Journal of Marketing Management, Vol.1., No.4., pp.102-108.
Tifferet S., Herstein R., (2012.), “Gender Differences in Brand Commitment, Impulse
Buying, and Hedonic Consumption”, Journal of Product and Brand Management, Vol.
21., No. #., pp. 176-182.
Valence, G., d'Astous, A., & Fortier, L. (1988). Compulsive buying: Concept and
measurement. Journal of Consumer Policy, 11(4), 419-433.
Winchell, R. M., Stanley, B., Guido, M. A., Jones, J. S., Posner, K., & Stanley, M. (1989,
December). An open trial of fluoxetine for trichotillomania. Paper presented at the
American College of Neruopsychopharmacology Meeting, Nashville, TN.
Yang D.J., Huang K.C., Feng X., (2011.), “A Study of the Factors that Affect the
Impulsive Cosmetics Buying of Female Consumers in Kaohsiung”, International Journal
of Business and Social Science, Vol. 2., No. 24., pp. 275-282.