Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2-Dimensional CFD Simulation of The Air Flow Insid
2-Dimensional CFD Simulation of The Air Flow Insid
net/publication/266057791
CITATIONS READS
2 667
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
determining the physical properties of liquids using interferometric method View project
Comparative evaluation of production processes for liquefaction of natural gas View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Suhaila Hussain on 12 March 2015.
Abstract :
This paper presents the results obtained from a computational fluid dynamics simulation of the cooking process
of a Malay delicacy called lemang inside a specially made oven. The normal way of cooking lemang is by
putting it in open fire for more or less 2 hours. By using the lemang oven, the cooking time was reduced to
about 1 hour and 20 minutes. A 2-dimesional CFD simulation was done to look at the hot air distribution inside
the oven and how it affects the conditions inside the oven and the lemang during cooking. Results for velocity
profile, as well as turbulence kinetic energy were obtained. It was found that the turbulence which carries with it
energy was highest at the bottom of the lemang which would mean that that part of lemang would cook the
fastest as it receives greater amount of energy compared to other parts of the lemang. This was why the lemang
was overcooked at that part as evident from the experimental results. These results would be used to further
improve on the existing lemang oven. .
Keywords: computational fluid dynamics, heat transfer, lemang, oven.
1. Introduction
Lemang is a Malay traditional food and is made of a mixture of glutinous rice and coconut milk placed inside a
bamboo stalk. It is cooked by placing it near an open fire until it is fully cooked. This usually takes about 2
hours and it is required that the bamboo stalk be turned alternately every 10-15 minutes to ensure that all parts
of the lemang is evenly cooked. The long time required as well as the laborious task of looking after the lemang
warrants a more practical method to cook lemang. Due to this, a specially developed oven was fabricated in the
hopes of eradicating these problems. It was found that the cooking time of lemang was able to be reduced to
about 1 hour and 20 minutes when it was cooked in the oven. The quality of the lemang cooked inside the oven
does not differ much from the ones traditional cooked in terms of taste and texture.
Computational Fluid Dynamics has been used by various researchers to simulate the processes involved in
food products especially ovens. Therdthai et al used CFD to study the temperature distribution inside an
industrial continous bread baking oven [1]. Saxena et al studied the contribution of each heat transfer modes
inside a tandoor oven during the baking of roti [2]. Boulet et al, used CFD to model a bakery pilot oven in order
to study all three heat transfer mechanisms combined with the effects of turbulence [3]. Hitesh et al used CFD to
model a 3-dimensional, unsteady, natural convective flow-thermal field coupled with radiative heat transfer
inside an electric oven [4]. Mostly, the researches here used CFD to either design a new oven or to improve on
existing ovens so that a better quality of food is obtained.
The purpose of the CFD modeling and simulation presented in this paper is to understand the air flow
profile inside the lemang oven and hence the heat distribution. Possible problems with the existing lemang oven
arrangement and ways of improving it to obtain a better quality of lemang can be known.
2. Simulation Procedure
from the side and above. The lemang oven is 215 mm in length and width and 685 mm in height. There are 4
cylindrical trays of 530 mm in height wherein the lemang is cooked. Three heating elements are located on the
sidewalls as shown in Figure 1. A fan is also located on the wall for the purpose of generating forced convection
inside the oven.
For this simulation where heat transfer is involved, Fluent code solves for all three governing equations of
conservation; mass, momentum and energy. For a two-dimensional, turbulence, unsteady state flow, the
equations are [5]:
x v y (1)
t x y
Momentum conservation (Navier–Stokes equation):
P
vx v x vx y x xx yx g x (2)
t x y x y x
P
v y vx v y y y xy yy g x (3)
t x y x y y
Energy conservation:
T T T 2T 2T 2 y 2 y
2
C p x vy k 2 2 2 x
x
(4)
t x y x y x y y x
As the problem also involves turbulence, the additional two transport equations for turbulent viscosity and
length scales are also solved.
The simulation was completed with full convergence at the set time step of 4800 seconds corresponding to
the time it takes for the lemang to cook in the experiment. At this point there was not much variation in the
temperature inside the oven as the temperature was maintained at 150oC using a thermostat. This particular
temperature is the temperature at which the lemang is estimated to fully cook based on the initial experiment.
Based on Figure 2, the velocity of the hot air is higher near the bottom of the lemang. The velocity is higher
there as it has the contribution of both forced convection from the fan on one side and natural convection from
the heating element on the other side. Both opposing the paths of one and the other.
(a) (b)
The velocity of air further up the lemang decreases possibly due to loss in energy as shown in Figure 3 and the
effects of gravitational forces.
(a) (b)
Figure 3: Turbulence kinetic energy (a) side view (b) top view.
Based on the turbulence results, much energy is concentrated at the bottom of the lemang. This results
in this part getting warmer faster than the other parts of the lemang. This can be seen from the experiment
conducted whereby the bottom part of the lemang had a harder texture than the upper part (Refer to Figure 4).
The upper part is still in its semi –solid state where as can be seen from Figure 3, not much energy reaches there.
There was also not much heat concentrated in the area near the fan as it was possibly be convected away by the
fan due to its close proximity. Figure 3(b) suggests that the sides of the lemang which are facing the middle
section of the lemang oven will be cooked faster due to the high concentration of turbulence kinetic energy in
this region. Furthermore, most of the energy seems to be concentrated at the bottom of the lemang near the
heating element. So, there is an imbalance of heat distribution inside the oven. This is clearly shown in Figure 4.
Based on these results, some improvements can be made to the arrangement of the lemang oven. The height of
the lemang tray can be shortened to a length that would enable heat to reach it. The lemang tray can also be
lowered down a bit. Another point to consider is the relative distances of the heating element, fan and lemang
tray to each other. It could be possible that the hot air is ‘trapped’ underneath the lemang because of the small
relative distances of the aforementioned elements and the opposing directions of convections from the heating
element and the fan.
Another possibility is the strength of forced convection in terms of the speed of the fan. Increase in fan speed
might be able to overcome the congestion of heat at the bottom of the lemang. This however, might well
distribute the heat to one side of the lemang (the one near the heating element) but not the side which is near the
fan.
Finally, based on the simulation results, having a large fan size does not necessarily mean that the flow of hot air
can be spread through a large area. The size of the fan can be reduced but this would be relative to the
arrangements of the oven decided.
The feasibility of these suggestions would require further simulations and study.
4. Conclusion
A 2-dimensional air flow simulation inside a lemang oven was conducted. The purpose of the simulation is to
determine the conditions inside the oven during the cooking process of lemang in terms of heat distribution.
Some interesting findings regarding the effects of the lemang oven arrangement on the air flow pattern were
obtained. Based on the simulation results, some possible suggestions to improve the lemang oven arrangement
in order for it to produce better quality lemang has been given.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia for funding this project.
References
[1] N. Therdthai, W. Zhou and T. Adamczak. 2-D CFD Modeling and Simulalation of an Industrial Continous Bread Baking Oven.
Journal of Food Engineering 60 (2003): 211-217.
[2] D.C. Saxena, P. Haridas Rao, and K. S. M. S Raghava Rao, Analysis of Modes of Heat Transfer in a Tandoor Oven. Journal of Food
Engineering 26 (1995) 209-217.
[3] M. Boulet, M. Bernard, M. Dostie and C. Moresoli. CFD Modeling of Heat Transfer and Flow Field in a Bakery Pilot Oven. Journal
of Food Engineering 97 (2010) 393-402.
[4] H. Mistry, G. Subbu, S. Dey, P. Bishnori, J.L. Castillo. Modeling of Transient Natural Convection Heat Transfer in Electric Ovens.
Applied Thermal Engineering 26 (2006) 2448-2456.