This document summarizes and critiques statements from two sources - a 2008 study on consumer protection in French and British credit markets, and a 2005 study on consumer overindebtedness in France and the US. It finds that some statements from the 2008 study are contradicted by data from the 2005 study. Specifically, the 2005 study shows that the percentage of French consumers seeking legal relief from debts between 2001-2003 was nearly three times higher than the less than 1% repayment problem rate claimed in the 2008 study. It also shows the debt burden on US consumers was about twice as heavy as on French consumers, contrary to a statement in the 2008 study. The document suggests establishing credit policies and collection procedures is important for businesses as they expand and
This document summarizes and critiques statements from two sources - a 2008 study on consumer protection in French and British credit markets, and a 2005 study on consumer overindebtedness in France and the US. It finds that some statements from the 2008 study are contradicted by data from the 2005 study. Specifically, the 2005 study shows that the percentage of French consumers seeking legal relief from debts between 2001-2003 was nearly three times higher than the less than 1% repayment problem rate claimed in the 2008 study. It also shows the debt burden on US consumers was about twice as heavy as on French consumers, contrary to a statement in the 2008 study. The document suggests establishing credit policies and collection procedures is important for businesses as they expand and
This document summarizes and critiques statements from two sources - a 2008 study on consumer protection in French and British credit markets, and a 2005 study on consumer overindebtedness in France and the US. It finds that some statements from the 2008 study are contradicted by data from the 2005 study. Specifically, the 2005 study shows that the percentage of French consumers seeking legal relief from debts between 2001-2003 was nearly three times higher than the less than 1% repayment problem rate claimed in the 2008 study. It also shows the debt burden on US consumers was about twice as heavy as on French consumers, contrary to a statement in the 2008 study. The document suggests establishing credit policies and collection procedures is important for businesses as they expand and
According to the study on Consumer Protection in French and British Credit
Markets, “For France, consumer credit is perceived as a useful tool of household finance, but one that risks to aggravate rather than to reduce social and economic exclusion. High interest rates charged to highly risky consumers are perceived as a transfer out of the lower classes. Consumer protection is understood at least in part as protection from credit itself.” This statement of the author contradicted his claim in the article that says, “Indeed, it seems likely that the strict enforcement of debt contracts in France might have reduce consumer demand for credit.” It is because as what the statement implies it would be conducive to the part of consumers even if they only have few consumer credits companies circulating around. Another statement from the article says, “In any case, the actual repayment experience of French and American lenders was similar: in each case fewer than 1 percent of loans faced nonpayment problems.” This statement is being contradicted by the study of La Responsibilisation de L’economie: What the United States can Learn from the French Law on Consumer Overindebtedness. This study stated that, “Between 2001 and 2003, nearly 450,000 French consumer sought legal relief from the debts. In other words, three-quarters of one percent of the entire French population declared themselves unable to deal with their debts over the last three years. During the same period, over 4.6 million U.S. consumers declared bankruptcy. This represents 1.6% of the total U.S. population”. Consistent with these figures, the debt burden of U.S. consumer is about twice as heavy as the weighing on French Consumers. This statement from the study says otherwise about the statement written in the article.
Gunnar Trumbull. February 2008. “Consumer Protection in French and British
Jason J. Kilborn. La Resposibilisation de L’economie: What the United States
can Learn from the New French Law on Consumer Overindebtedness. Volume 26 Michigan Journal of International Law. 619 (2005). Available at: https://repository.law.umich.edu/mjil/vol26/iss2/3 Supra note 320. (reporting total filing of 448, 833 from 2001-2003). CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY. THE WORLD FACT BOOK, France, People. (estimating total French population at just over 60 million as of July 2004). Available at http://www.odci.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/fr.html Supra note 99. (reporting total filings of 4,616,349 from 2001-2003). The U.S. Census website reports a total U.S. population of just under 294 million as of June 2004. See http://www.census.gov c. Establishing appropriate credit policies and collection procedures is vital to the success of any small or big businesses. Many business owners put off creating a credit and collection policy until they absolutely have no other choice. As their customer base builds, and more and more customers want to pay by credit, they realize that they need to open up a credit card account or offer credit terms. Or they ignore those few customers who don't pay their bills, until the few grow into many, and suddenly they realize that they need to spend time collecting overdue accounts. This is like what happen in the U.S that they extend consumer credit during a period in which this sort of lending was relatively unprofitable. However, in France the banks were larger, fewer, and focused on supporting government-defined goals for economic development. This circumstance left consumer lending in the hands of dedicated consumer loan companies. With the invention of profitable, indeed lucrative,and consumer lending these differences in the engagement of banks continued to matter in the industry.