Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GUIDELINES
Guidelines for treatment of onychomycosis
D.T.ROBERTS, W.D.TAYLOR* AND J.BOYLE
Southern General Hospital, Glasgow G51 4TF, U.K.
*James Cook University Hospital, Middlesbrough, Cleveland TS4 3BW, U.K.
Taunton and Somerset Hospital, Taunton TA1 5DA, U.K.
Summary These guidelines for management of onychomycosis have been prepared for dermatologists on
behalf of the British Association of Dermatologists. They present evidence-based guidance for
treatment, with identification of the strength of evidence available at the time of preparation of the
guidelines, and a brief overview of epidemiological aspects, diagnosis and investigation.
confined to one side of the nail or spread sideways to and further cuticular detachment, i.e. a vicious circle.
involve the whole of the nail bed, and progresses Infection and inflammation in the area of the nail matrix
relentlessly until it reaches the posterior nail fold. eventually lead to a proximal nail dystrophy.
Eventually the nail plate becomes friable and may Distal nail infection with Candida yeasts is uncom-
break up, often due to trauma, although nail destruc- mon and virtually all patients have Raynaud’s phe-
tion may be related to invasion of the plate by nomenon or some other form of vascular insufficiency.
dermatophytes that have keratolytic properties. Exam- It is unclear whether the underlying vascular problem
ination of the surrounding skin will nearly always gives rise to onycholysis as the initial event or whether
reveal evidence of tinea pedis. Toenail infection is an yeast infection causes the onycholysis. Although
almost inevitable precursor of fingernail dermatophy- candidal onychomycosis cannot be clinically differen-
tosis, which has a similar clinical appearance although tiated from DLSO with certainty, the absence of toenail
nail thickening is not as common. involvement and typically a lesser degree of subungual
hyperkeratosis are helpful diagnostic features.
Chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis has multifacto-
Superficial white onychomycosis
rial aetiology leading to diminished cell-mediated
SWO is also nearly always due to a dermatophyte immunity. Clinical signs vary with the severity of
infection, most commonly T. mentagrophytes. It is much immunosuppression, but in more severe cases gross
less common than DLSO and affects the surface of the thickening of the nails occurs, amounting to a Candida
nail plate rather than the nail bed. Discoloration is granuloma. The mucous membranes are almost always
white rather than cream and the surface of the nail involved in such cases.
plate is noticeably flaky. Onycholysis is not a common Secondary candidal onychomycosis occurs in other
feature of SWO and intercurrent foot infection is not as diseases of the nail apparatus, most notably psoriasis.
frequent as in DLSO.
Total dystrophic onychomycosis
Proximal subungual onychomycosis
Any of the above varieties of onychomycosis may
PSO, without evidence of paronychia, is an uncommon eventually progress to total nail dystrophy where the
variety of dermatophyte infection often related to inter- nail plate is almost completely destroyed.
current disease. Immunosuppressed patients, notably
those who are human immunodeficiency virus-posit-
Diagnosis
ive, may present with this variety of dermatophyte
infection; conditions such as peripheral vascular dis- This section follows the criteria set out by Evans and
ease and diabetes also may present in this way. Gentles.6 Treatment should not be instituted on clinical
Evidence of intercurrent disease should therefore be grounds alone. Although 50% of all cases of nail
considered in a patient with PSO. dystrophy are fungal in origin it is not always possible
to identify such cases accurately. Treatment needs to be
administered long-term and enough time must elapse
Candidal onychomycosis
for the nail to grow out completely before such
Infection of the nail apparatus with Candida yeasts may treatment can be designated as successful. Toenails
present in one of four ways: (i) chronic paronychia take around 12 months to grow out and fingernails
with secondary nail dystrophy; (ii) distal nail infection; about 6 months. This is far too long to await the results
(iii) chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis; and (iv) sec- of therapeutic trial and, in any case, treatment is not
ondary candidiasis. always successful. If the diagnosis is not confirmed, and
Chronic paronychia of the fingernails generally only improvement does not occur, it is impossible to tell
occurs in patients with wet occupations. Swelling of the whether this represents treatment failure or an initial
posterior nail fold occurs secondary to chronic immer- incorrect diagnosis. Although the cost of diagnostic
sion in water or possibly due to allergic reactions to some tests may be deemed high at times of budgetary
foods, and the cuticle becomes detached from the nail constraint, the cost is always small relative to inappro-
plate thus losing its water-tight properties. Microorgan- priate and unnecessary treatment.
isms, both yeasts and bacteria, enter the subcuticular Laboratory diagnosis consists of microscopy to
space causing further swelling of the posterior nail fold visualize fungal elements in the nail sample and
culture to identify the species concerned. The success Such dystrophies, notably psoriasis, regularly yield
or otherwise of such tests depends upon the quality of Candida yeasts on culture but they are rarely causal in
the sample, the experience of the microscopist and the aetiology of fungal nail infection.
ability of the laboratory to discriminate between
organisms that are likely pathogens, organisms grow-
Reasons for treatment
ing in the nail as saprophytes, and contamination of
the culture plate. Although dermatophyte onychomycosis is relentlessly
Given that dermatophyte onychomycosis is primarily progressive there remains a view among some practi-
a disease of the nail bed rather than of the nail plate, tioners that it is a trivial cosmetic problem that does not
subungual debris taken from the most proximal part of merit treatment. In the elderly the disease can give rise
the infection is likely to yield the best results. In DLSO to complications such as cellulitis and therefore further
material can be obtained from beneath the nail: a small compromise the limb in those with diabetes or periph-
dental scraper is most useful for this purpose. If the nail eral vascular disease. While these complications may
is onycholytic then this can be cut back and material not be common they are certainly serious. The high
can be scraped off the underside of the nail as well as prevalence of the disease is the result of heavy
from the nail bed. As much material as possible should contamination of communal bathing places7 by infec-
be submitted to the laboratory because of the relative ted users; disinfecting the floors of such facilities is very
paucity of fungal elements within the specimen. In difficult because fungal elements are protected in small
SWO the surface of the infected nail plate can be pieces of keratin. It is therefore logical to try to reduce
scraped and material examined directly. PSO is rare the number of infected users by effective treatment and
and again should be scraped with a scalpel blade. thus reduce disease prevalence. Finally, onychomycosis
However, punch biopsy to obtain a sample of the full is a surprisingly significant cause of medical consulta-
thickness of nail together with the nail bed may be tion and of absence from work.8
necessary. Some of the material obtained is placed on a Onychomycosis should not therefore be considered a
glass slide and 20% potassium hydroxide added. Fifteen trivial disease, and there is a sound case for treatment
to 20 min should be allowed to elapse before examin- on the grounds of complications, public health consid-
ing the sample by direct microscopy. The addition of erations and effect on quality of life.
Parker’s blue ⁄ black ink may enhance visualization of
the hyphae. An inexperienced observer may very well
misdiagnose cell walls as hyphae and care should be Treatment
taken to examine all of the specimen as fungal elements
Introduction
within the material may be very scanty.
The remaining material should be cultured on Both topical and oral agents are available for the
Saboraud’s glucose agar, usually with the addition of treatment of fungal nail infection. The primary aim of
an antibiotic. The culture plate is incubated at 28 C treatment is to eradicate the organism as demonstrated
for at least 3 weeks before it is declared negative, as by microscopy and culture. This is defined as the
dermatophytes tend to grow slowly. primary end-point in almost all properly conducted
Direct microscopy can be carried out by the clinician, studies. Clinical improvement and clinical cure are
and higher specialist training includes teaching of this secondary end-points based on a strict scoring system
technique. However, nail microscopy is difficult and of clinical abnormalities in the nail apparatus. It must
should only be carried out by those who do it on a be recognized that successful eradication of the fungus
regular basis. Fungal culture should always be carried does not always render the nails normal as they may
out in a laboratory experienced in handling mycology have been dystrophic prior to infection. Such dystrophy
specimens, because of potential pitfalls in interpretation may be due to trauma or nonfungal nail disease; this is
of cultures. It must be remembered that the most particularly likely in cases where yeasts or nondermat-
common cause of treatment failure in the U.K. is ophyte moulds (secondary pathogens and saprophytes,
incorrect diagnosis, which is usually made on clinical respectively) are isolated.9
grounds alone. This should not be further compounded Invariably mycological cure rates are about 30%
by incorrect laboratory interpretation of results. better than clinical cure rates in the majority of studies,
Histology is almost never required and its use is the clinical cure rates often being below 50%. Publi-
usually confined to other causes of nail dystrophy. cations of clinical trials in onychomycosis are often
criticized for quoting mycological cure rates and thus to achieve clinical and mycological cure with topical
overemphasizing the efficacy of treatment. While it is nail preparations, these cure rates do not compare
understood that the patient is more concerned with favourably with those obtained with systemic drugs.
improvement in the clinical appearance of the nail Currently, topical therapy can only be recommended
rather than eradication of the organism, questions for the treatment of SWO and in very early cases of
regarding patients’ satisfaction at the end of a study DLSO where the infection is confined to the distal edge
usually mirror very closely the mycological cure rate. of the nail.
This suggests that eradication of the organism does A combination of topical and systemic therapy may
restore the nail to its previous state prior to infection improve cure rates still further or possibly shorten the
even though that state may not be completely normal duration of therapy with the systemic agent. Thus far
as defined by a scoring system. the results of such studies are inconclusive. A study
Systemic therapy is almost always more successful comparing terbinafine and amorolfine with terbinafine
than topical treatment, which should only be used in alone produced somewhat idiosyncratic results12 and
SWO, possibly very early DLSO or when systemic was not properly blinded, so further evidence from
therapy is contraindicated. well-controlled double-blind studies is required before
combination therapy can be advocated.
Although there are no studies comparing one topical
Topical therapy
preparation with another in a properly controlled
There are several topical antifungal preparations fashion, it is likely that amorolfine nail lacquer (Loce-
available both as prescription-only medicines and on ryl) is the most effective preparation of those avail-
an over-the-counter basis. The active antifungal agent able.
in these preparations is either an imidazole, an allyl-
amine or a polyene, or a preparation that contains a
Systemic therapy
chemical with antifungal, antiseptic and sometimes
keratolytic properties such as benzoic acid, benzyl The three drugs currently licensed for general use in
peroxide, salicylic acid or an undecenoate. Products onychomycosis are listed in Table 2. The two other
that are specifically indicated for nail infection are systemic agents available for oral use, ketoconazole and
available as a paint or lacquer that is applied topically. fluconazole, are not licensed for nail infection. Ketocon-
There are four such preparations (Table 1). azole may be used in some recalcitrant cases of yeast
There are no published studies on the efficacy of infection affecting the nails but cannot be prescribed for
salicylic acid (Phytex; Pharmax, Bexley, U.K.) and dermatophyte onychomycosis because of problems with
methyl undecenoate (Monphytol; LAB, London, U.K.) hepatotoxicity. The use of fluconazole thus far has
in fungal nail infection and their use cannot be concentrated on vaginal candidiasis and systemic yeast
recommended. infections although it is active against dermatophytes.
Amorolfine (Loceryl; Galderma, Amersham, U.K.) There are some published studies of its use in nail
nail lacquer has been shown to be effective in around infection but the dose and duration of treatment are
50% of cases of both fingernail and toenail infection in not yet clear and it is not licensed for this indication in
a large study where only cases with infections of the the U.K., nor does it appear likely to be so in the near
distal portion of the nail were treated.10 There are future.
several published studies examining the efficacy of
tioconazole (Trosyl; Pfizer, Sandwich, U.K.) nail solu- Griseofulvin. Griseofulvin (Fulcin; Grisovin; Glaxo-
tion, with very variable results ranging from cure rates SmithKline, Uxbridge, U.K.) is weakly fungistatic, and
of around 20% up to 70%.11 While it is clearly possible acts by inhibiting nucleic acid synthesis, arresting cell
Table 1. Topical agents for onychomycosis, with strength of recommendation and quality of evidence grading
Agent Strength of recommendation and quality of evidence
Amorolfine (Loceryl; Galderma, Amersham, U.K.) nail lacquer Strength of recommendation B, Quality of evidence II-ii
Tioconazole (Trosyl; Pfizer, Sandwich, U.K.) nail solution Strength of recommendation C, Quality of evidence II-iii
Salicylic acid (Phytex; Pharmax, Bexley, U.K.) paint Strength of recommendation E, Quality of evidence IV
Undecenoates (Monphytol; LAB, London, U.K.) paint Strength of recommendation E, Quality of evidence IV
A–I
A–I
B–I
no suspension formulation;
No U.K. licence for children;
greater. Although it is generally felt to be a fungistatic therapy. The first compared terbinafine 250 mg daily
agent it can achieve fungicidal concentrations, for 16 weeks with four pulses of itraconazole 400 mg
although its MFC is about 10 times higher than its daily for 1 week in every 4 weeks for 16 weeks and
MIC.25 also with terbinafine 500 mg daily for 1 week in
Both terbinafine and itraconazole persist in the nail every 4 weeks for 16 weeks.30 As only approximately
for a considerable period after elimination from the 20 patients were recruited in each study group, this
plasma.26 This property has given rise to a novel was a very small study; the regimens used were not
intermittent (pulsed) treatment regimen using itrac- those of the U.K. product licences, and the results
onazole in nail infection. comparing the groups were not significantly different.
A more recent and much larger study has been
Terbinafine vs. itraconazole in dermatophyte onychomyco- completed comparing terbinafine 250 mg daily for
sis. Both of these drugs have been shown to be more both 3 and 4 months with itraconazole 400 mg daily
effective than griseofulvin in dermatophyte onychomy- for 1 week · 3 and 1 week · 4. One hundred and
cosis and therefore the optimum choice of treatment twenty patients were recruited to each group and
lies between terbinafine and itraconazole. the follow-up period was 72 weeks.31 The study
Terbinafine is licensed at a dose of 250 mg daily for was carried out in double-blind, double-placebo fash-
6 weeks and 12 weeks in fingernail and toenail infec- ion and demonstrated terbinafine 250 mg daily for
tion, respectively. Itraconazole is licensed at a dose of both 3 and 4 months to be very significantly superior
200 mg daily for 12 weeks continuously, or alternat- to both three and four pulses of itraconazole (Strength
ively at a dose of 400 mg daily for 1 week per month. It of recommendation A, Quality of evidence I; see
is recommended that two of these weekly courses, Appendix 1).
21 days apart, are given for fingernail infections and The 151 patients in the Icelandic arm of this study
three courses for toenail disease. were further studied for long-term effectiveness of
There have been numerous open and placebo-con- treatment during a 5-year blinded prospective follow-
trolled studies of both drugs in dermatophyte nail up study.32 At the end of the study mycological cure
infection. However, historical comparisons of such without a second therapeutic intervention was found
studies do not provide evidence of equivalent quality in 46% of the 74 terbinafine-treated subjects but in
as that achieved by directly comparative double-blind only 13% of the 77 itraconazole-treated subjects.
trials, as even in properly conducted studies the results Mycological and clinical relapse was significantly
can be influenced by variation in the criteria for higher in the itraconazole group (53% and 48%) than
mycological or clinical cure, or by the period of follow- the terbinafine group (23% and 21%) (Strength of
up. It is generally accepted that patients entered into recommendation A, Quality of evidence I).
such studies should be both microscopy- and culture- The superiority of terbinafine has recently been
positive for fungus and that mycological cure should be supported by a systematic review of oral treatments
defined as microscopy and culture negativity at com- for toenail onychomycosis;33 this reference documents
pletion. Clinical criteria for cure are difficult to interpret many additional studies and also the varied and often
as the appearance of the nail prior to infection is incompletely presented criteria that have been used to
generally unknown and, especially in the case of describe a clinical cure.
toenails, because trauma can affect their appearance.
Short follow-up periods after cessation of therapy are
Treatment of yeast infections
unlikely to allow interpretation of which is the superior
drug; a follow-up period of at least 48 weeks (prefer- Most yeast infections can be treated topically, partic-
ably 72 weeks) from the start of treatment should be ularly those associated with paronychia. Antiseptics
allowed both in order to allow the most effective can be applied to the proximal part of the nail and
preparation to become apparent and to identify relapse allowed to wash beneath the cuticle, thus sterilizing the
as far as possible. subcuticular space. Ideally, such antiseptics should be
There are various published studies comparing ter- broad spectrum, colourless and nonsensitizing. They
binafine with continuous itraconazole therapy,27–29 require to be applied until the integrity of the cuticle
most of which demonstrate terbinafine to be the more has been restored, which may be several months. An
effective agent. Thus far there are only two studies imidazole lotion alternating with an antibacterial lotion
comparing terbinafine with intermittent itraconazole is usually effective.
Itraconazole (Sporonox) is the most effective agent Cure rates, both short- and long-term, may be
for the treatment of candidal onychomycosis where the influenced by correction of associated orthopaedic
nail plate is invaded by the organism.34 It is used in the and podiatric factors to avoid, as much as possible,
same dosage regimen as for dermatophytes, i.e. trauma that particularly affects the great toenails.
400 mg daily for 1 week per month repeated for
2 months in fingernail infection. Candida infection of
Summary of conclusions
toenails is much less common but can be treated as
above using three or four pulses. 1 Treatment should not be commenced before myco-
logical confirmation of infection.
2 Dermatophytes are by far the commonest causal
Treatment of nondermatophyte moulds
organisms.
Many varieties of saprophytic moulds can invade 3 Culture of yeasts and nondermatophyte moulds
diseased nail. Scopulariopsis brevicaulis is the common- should be interpreted carefully in each individual
est of these and may be a secondary pathogen. Its case. In the majority, yeasts are likely to be a
response to systemic antifungal agents is variable, secondary infection and nondermatophyte moulds to
although terbinafine is probably the drug of choice in be saprophytic in previously damaged nails.
that the primary nail disease is quite likely to be a 4 Topical treatment is inferior to systemic therapy in
dermatophyte infection that is masked by the Scopu- all but a small number of cases of very distal
lariopsis. There is little categorical evidence to support infection or in SWO.
the choice of one drug.35 In the U.S.A. and Europe 5 Terbinafine is superior to itraconazole both in vitro
cyclopirox nail lacquer has its advocates but it is not and in vivo for dermatophyte onychomycosis, and
available in the U.K. Nail avulsion followed by an oral should be considered first-line treatment, with itrac-
agent during the period of regrowth is probably the best onazole as the next best alternative.
method of restoring the nail to normal. 6 Cure rates of 80–90% for fingernail infection and
70–80% for toenail infection can be expected. In
cases of treatment failure the reasons for such failure
Treatment failure
should be carefully considered. In such cases either
Although terbinafine is demonstrably the most effective an alternative drug or nail removal in combination
agent in dermatophyte onychomycosis a consistent with a further course of therapy to cover the period
failure rate of 20–30% is found in all studies. If the of regrowth should be considered.
most obvious causes of treatment failure, notably poor
compliance, poor absorption, immunosuppression, der-
Audit points
matophyte resistance and zero nail growth are exclu-
ded, the commonest cause of failure is likely to be 1 Has a positive culture been obtained before com-
kinetic.36 Subungual dermatophytoma has been des- mencing systemic therapy for onychomycosis?
cribed37 and it is likely that this tightly packed mass of 2 Has an appropriate agent been chosen, based on the
fungus prevents penetration of the drug in adequate type of organism cultured?
concentrations. In such cases partial nail removal is 3 Are arrangements in place for adequate duration of
indicated. It is been demonstrated that cure rates of treatment to be supplied from hospital or general
close to 100% can always be achieved if all affected practitioner?
nails are avulsed under ring block prior to commence- 4 Has immunosuppression been considered in cases of
ment of treatment. However, this is neither feasible nor PSO?
necessary in most cases and the best approach is to try
to identify those individual nails that are likely to fail
Declaration of interest
and to remove the offending area.
Reports of long-term follow-up of treated patients David T.Roberts is a member of the Dermatology
have recently been presented, suggesting that positive Advisory Board of Novartis Pharmaceuticals Ltd. He
mycology at 12 and 24 weeks after commencement of has given advice to almost all other manufacturers of
therapy are poor prognostic signs and may indicate a antifungal agents and has spoken at symposia organ-
need for retreatment or for a change of drug. However, ized by a number of these companies. The other
this work remains to be confirmed. authors have no conflict of interest.