You are on page 1of 56

Best Employers

Study 2016
Country Report: India

In partnership with

Best Employers Study 2016 1


Table of Contents

Foreword

About the Best Employers Study

India Best Employers 2016: Study Insights

• Section I: High Employee Engagement

• Section II: Compelling Employer Brand

• Section III: Effective Leadership

• Section IV: High Performance Culture

• Section V: Effective HR Function

Imagineering the Future: The Journey to Being a Best Employer

1 Best Employers Study 2016


Foreword

Best Employers Study 2016 2


Foreword

We are proud to present the ninth edition of Aon Hewitt’s (including 2,300 in the region) supports the striking
flagship study in Asia: Best Employers India 2016. evidence: having a high level of Employee Engagement,
a Compelling Employer Brand, Effective Leadership and
Through our research, we know that high employee a High Performance Culture translates into a committed
engagement not only delivers greater shareholder value, and productive workforce that delivers stronger business
but it also reduces staff turnover and improves customer results.
satisfaction. Aon Hewitt began the Best Employers
research in Asia in 2001 to provide insights into how This report provides a deep-dive into our observations,
organizations can create real competitive advantage supporting practices and outcome on the Best Employers
through people and explore the contours of what makes a construct in India.
workplace of choice.
We know that the journey to becoming a Best Employer is
Our 16 years of Best Employers studies in Asia, backed with a unique experience for each organization, and we hope
engagement research of over 6,400 global organizations you continue successfully on this journey.

Best Employers 2016 Asia Pacific


Covers 700,000 employee opinions (representative of a total
employment in excess of 2 million) across 570 organizations from
12 countries
• Aon Hewitt’s premier study for building better places for • Employee opinion coverage has doubled since 2011
work since 2001
• Participating companies crossed 500+ in the
• Expansive insights across the Asia Pacific region 2013 edition

• ANZ, China and India contribute ~50% to the participation

No. of Participating Organizations No. of Participating Employees (‘000)

570 700
+16%

490

2011 2016 2016

Definitions
Mkt. Average Scores – Average scores Best Employer Scores Participant Average Insights
of all organizations in the India market – Average scores of all Scores – Average scores
in 2015-16. This includes non-Best Best Employers in the of only Best Employers
Employers participants as well India market in 2015-16 participants in the India
market in 2015-16

3 Best Employers Study 2016


Best Employers 2016 Asia Pacific
Study construct focuses on 4 master and 12 sub indices

High Employee Engagement

Say Stay Strive


The employees consistently The employees have The employees exert
speak positively about an intense desire extra effort and engage
the organization to to be a member of in work that contributes
co-workers, potential the organization to business success
employees and customers

Compelling Employer Brand

Reputation Internal Brand Credibility


The organization is well- Employees are proud Employees believe that
known and has a good to be part of the the organization delivers
reputation in the market organization, and can on the promises it
explain what makes makes to employees
working here different
from other organizations

Effective Leadership

Future Vision Valuing People Business Excellence


Leaders show clear Employees experience that Employees trust their
and compelling future leaders are appropriately senior leaders to be open
vision to the members visible and accessible; treat and honest; and believe
of the organization them as organization’s they make good business
most valued asset decisions to drive the
organization to success

High Performance Culture

Accountability & Trust Reward Growth


Managers set clear Rewards and recognition Organization prepares
goals and expectations, for high performance are for future challenges
and employees know clearly understood and by offering interesting
how they can best transparent to employees careers for high potential
contribute to business employees and learning
opportunities

Best Employers Study 2016 4


Best Employers 2016 India
The jury

From Right to Left


Prof. Rajen Gupta: Professor at MDI | Mr. Raman Roy: BPO Industry Pioneer and Chairman & Chief, Quattro | Mr. Shiv Shivakumar: PepsiCo India, CEO |
Ms. Renu Sud Karnad: Managing Director, HDFC Limited | Dr. Santrupt Misra: CEO, Carbon Business and Director, Group HR, Aditya Birla Group

Aon Hewitt Study Team and Partner:


Mr. Tarandeep Singh: Partner, Talent & Performance Consulting, Aon Hewitt India | Mr. Annurag Batra: Chairman and Editor-in-Chief, BW Businessworld
| Ms. Yamini Maheshwari Sapra: Senior Consultant & India Leader – Aon Best Employers Study

As we talk about businesses being capable and we talk


about Make in India, it is important that all organizations
learn to leverage the best out of their Human Resources.

Dr. Santrupt Misra


CEO, Carbon Business and Director, Group HR,
Aditya Birla Group
I was struck by the following 4 innovations that the
companies are doing in the area of 1-Recruitment,
2-Development of Leadership as Capability,
3-Identifying top 10 or 100 managers in the companies
and design-specific inputs for their capabilities so that
they fit into senior roles, 4-Diversity, though there’s
Happy to see that this year other than the IT,
still a long way to go in this area.
ITeS, BFSIs, a lot of Mining, and Manufacturing
companies are coming in and that’s where Mr. Shiv Shivakumar
India’s growth will pick up. PepsiCo India, CEO

Ms. Renu Sud Karnad


Managing Director, HDFC Limited

5 Best Employers Study 2016


Best Employers 2016 India
The winners

Best Employers 2016


(in alphabetical order)
AAPC
India Hotel AGS Health
Management Pvt. Ltd.
Pvt. Ltd.

Bajaj Allianz
Bajaj Finance Becton Dickinson Bharti
General Insurance
Ltd. India Pvt. Ltd. Infratel Ltd.
Co. Ltd.

Hewlett Packard
Blue Dart DHL Express Godrej Consumer
Enterprise Global
Express Ltd. India Pvt. Ltd. Products Ltd.
Soft Pvt. Ltd.

InterGlobe METRO Cash Reliance Saint-Gobain


Aviation Ltd. Lupin Ltd. and Carry India Capital Asset India Pvt. Ltd.-
(IndiGo) Pvt. Ltd. Management Gyproc Business

Starwood
SKS Tata Autocomp Tata AIA Life
Hotels &
Microfinance Systems Ltd. Insurance
Resorts India
Ltd. (TACO) Company
Pvt. Ltd.

Tata WNS Global


The Oberoi Whirlpool of
Tata Chemicals Ltd. Communications Service Pvt.
Group India Ltd.
Ltd. Ltd.

Marriott
YASH Teleperformance
International
Technologies India (Global
India (Global
Pvt. Ltd. Program)
Program)

Best Employers Study 2016 6


Best Employers 2016 India
The winners – myth v/s fact

It is MNCs that
make it to Best
Employers
51% of the Best Employer
winners have been
Indian companies

Only large
organizations can
become Best Employers
30% Had less than
2,000 employees

Had been in
existence

20%
An organization needs to
have a rich history to
<10 years
when they
make it as a Best Employer
became a
Best Employer

Manufacturing
43%
Best Employers are
service-oriented firms companies that
were Best Employers

7 Best Employers Study 2016


2016 India Trends

Best Employers Study 2016 8


India: Overview & Highlights
9 out of 10 participants projecting fast/steady growth

• India continues to lead the world GDP growth (as per the IMF projections of April 2016, growth in India is projected
to notch up to 7.5% in 2016-17)

• 9 out of 10 participants projecting fast/steady growth

Getting Back on Track (GDP Trends)

India

Emerging Economies

Developed Economies
06

18
12
20

20

20
A Positive Business and Hiring Outlook Indicates an All Round Sentiment of Cautious Optimism
• 7 out of 10 businesses foresee an improved business outlook in 2016-17

• 7 out of 10 businesses will increase hiring in 2016-17

Business Outlook Hiring Forecast


1%
6%
12% 14%
27%
18%

67% 55%

Improving Significant Increase


Stabilizing Somewhat Increase
Declining Neutral
Somewhat Decrease
Significant Decrease

Source: IMF (April 2016 projections), Aon Hewitt India SIS 2016, Aon Hewitt India Hiring Study 2016

9 Best Employers Study 2016


India: Overview & Highlights
Talent risks and emerging talent imperatives

Rising salaries continues to be the biggest talent risk in India. According to the latest Aon Hewitt Salary
Increase Survey (SIS), the increase in salary for key talent is expected to be at an average of 14% to 16%.

Key Talent Risks


High

CONCERN ZONE
Rising
salaries
Impact of Talent Risks on Business

Inability to retain
Critical skills
employees
shortage
Poor external Inadequate leadership
talent selection pipeline

Low employee
Capability of productivity
current leaders
Inability to CAUTION ZONE
attract talent

Poor labor
relations
Medium

Likely Near Certain


Likelihood of Talent Risks

How do Best Employers manage talent risks?


On an average only 33% of the organizations feel they are prepared to tackle these risks. Best Employers leverage the 4 key
pillars as defined earlier, to derisk themselves against the talent risks.

1 Rising talent costs


Emerging Talent Imperatives

2 Critical skills shortage


High Employee Compelling Employer
Inability to retain Engagement Brand
3
employees

Inadequate
4 leadership pipeline

Low employee
5 productivity Effective Leadership High Performance Culture

Best Employers Study 2016 10


2016 Best Employers
Insights

11 Best Employers Study 2016


India: Overview & Highlights
From 2013 to 2016, Best Employers maintain their lead across all the
study indices
• Best Employers achieve 38% higher growth in • Positive shifts across all the Best Employers indices,
income* than market average but the widest shifts have been in the Effective
Leadership and the Employer Brand pillars
• Best Employers filled 30% more openings internally
compared to the participant average

High Employee Engagement Compelling Employer Brand


87%
77% 79%
68%

1%
4%

81%

70%
79%
66%

4% 1%

Effective Leadership High Performance Culture

Best Employers Gap Shift 2013-16 Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

*Growth in pre-tax income over FY2014

Best Employers delivered sustained growth ahead of macroeconomic indicators

Best Employers Study 2016 12


India: Overview & Highlights
High business performance is a given for Best Employers

Best Employers register 2.6X shareholder returns compared to the rest of the market

409
372

2.6X
shareholder
return
187 198

136
125 172
100 157

121 123 127


100 98

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Indexed Growth of the NSE


(Jan 2010-2016) To qualify for the analysis, a Best Employer
should have beeen recognized in 2 of the
Indexed Growth of Best Employer Stock last 5 studies
Prices Calculated at Average Stock Price
Growth YoY (January 2010-January 2016)

Source: Best Employers India Study 2016

In addition to registering a significant lead on average shareholder returns, Best Employers also:

• Stayed ahead during tough times; and

• Leverage “better” times to create disproportionate distance with the others on NSE

13 Best Employers Study 2016


Section 1: High
Employee Engagement

Best Employers Study 2016 14


High Employee Engagement
Best Employers register 9% points higher employee engagement

• Overall engagement for Best Employers shows a 1% point increase over 2013, even though the market has improved
by 3% points over the 2013 scores

• The ‘Say’ and ‘Stay’ pillar scores are marginally lower for Best Employers in comparison to 2013, however, the Best
Employers have improved on ‘Strive’ by 5% points since 2013

Employee Engagement Index 68% 77%


1%

SAY: The employees consistently 77% 84%


speak positively about the
organization to co-workers, potential
employees and customers
-2%

STAY: The employees have an 59% 67%


intense desire to be a member of the
organization
-1%

STRIVE: The employees exert extra


effort and engage in work that
73% 81%
contributes to business success
5%

Best Employers Gap Shift 2013-16 Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

• “What’s in it for me” is getting stronger by the year

• Employees are willing to strive hard in a Best Employer environment, given the strong leadership and
compelling brand connect

• However, there is a growing need to create a rewarding culture as a retention measure

15 Best Employers Study 2016


High Employee Engagement
Gap between Best Employers and market engagement scores
has reduced substantially in this year
The gap between the engagement scores has reduced this year indicating that the market is slowly, but surely making
efforts towards improving engagement

Engagement Scores Over the Last 16 Years


88%
83%
83%
77% 77%
78% 76%
76%

71%
67% 67% 68%
66% 65% 66%
62%

2003 2006 2013 2016

What helps Best Employers sustain their lead?

Best Employers Sustenance Drivers

Health & Well-being 84% 89%

Supervision 72% 81%

Collaboration 72% 80%

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

External collaboration with broader ecosystem has increasingly become a desired capability for Best
Employers and the market

Best Employers Study 2016 16


High Employee Engagement
Career opportunities and rewards & recognition continue to be top 2
engagement drivers
While the top 2 engagement drivers remain the same, variations across the top 3-5 are defining experiences. Best
Employers manage this multi-dimensional complexity through specific programs that address the different needs of
different employee segments

Top Engagement Drivers in India - Ranked by Demographic

Best
Engagement Rank 2016 Sr. Mid.
Employers GenY Women Leadership
Drivers in India (Mkt. Avg.) Mgmt. Mgmt.
2016

Rewards &
1 1 1 1 1 4 1
Recognition

Career
2 2 2 2 1 2
Opportunities

Brand 3 3 4 4 1 3

Senior Leadership 4 4 5 2

Work Tasks 4 4 4 3

Trust in Action 4 5

Collaboration 2 5 4

Work-life Balance 3 4

Enabling
1
Infrastructure

Learning &
5
Development

• Diverse mix of focus areas for varied demographic profile. Interestingly, work-life balance is key for leadership, and
senior management has indicated need for better enabling infrastructure

• Collaboration is key across all levels of management

Best Employers manage multi-dimensional complexity through specific programs that address different
needs of employee segments

17 Best Employers Study 2016


High Employee Engagement
Best Employers sustain consistent engagement levels across
employee segments
Engagement Levels by Tenure Within the Organization
• Best Employers maintain a consistent engagement level across the tenure of an employee; they outperform the
market specially after employees are sufficiently tenured

• This tenure duration is critical as it lays foundations of a career for an employee within the organization

80% 80%
76% 76%
75%

72% 73%
67% 66%
65%

< 6 months 6 months-1 year 1-2 years 2-10 years 10+ years

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Best Employers create a consistent employee experience across tenure groups

Best Employers Study 2016 18


High Employee Engagement
Best Employers work to sustain consistent engagement levels across
employee segments
Engagement Levels across Generations
84%
80%
76%

76%
72%

65%

Baby Boomers GenX: GenY:


1965-1978 1979-1990

Best Employers v/s Market

Specific talent programs* targeted towards GenY


55% 63%
*Godrej case study on Gen Y specific initiatives on Page 23

57% of GenY feel their future career opportunities at


their organization’s look good

53% of GenY feel they are paid fairly for the


contributions they make to the organization’s success

• Gen Y scores are the lowest for the Best Employers as well as the market

• However, Best Employers show 11% points higher Engagement for GenY at 76% when compared to the market at 65%

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores Participant Average Scores

Best Employers engage GenY through differentiated and focused talent programs

19 Best Employers Study 2016


High Employee Engagement
Measuring engagement is the norm; acting on opinions is how the
Best Employers drive results
Practice Prevalence

97% 100%
Measure engagement on a regular basis (at least annually)

Communication of engagement results is followed up with


team or focus group meetings that lead to a structured 83% 92%
action plan

Communication of engagement results is followed up with


71% 79%
regular employee communication on action plans

People manager and senior leaders own implementation of


64% 75%
action plans more than HR function

Progress on action plans is reported to employees 69% 75%

Engagement is linked to manager’s performance scorecard 62% 83%

Best Employer Scores Participant Average Scores

Best Employers hold leaders and managers equally accountable for employee engagement

Best Employers Study 2016 20


High Employee Engagement

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

McThai
Operating in the food and beverage industry as part of the McDonald’s brand, McThai Co. Ltd. is a fast
Thailand food restaurant that was founded in 1985 and has 8,000 employees.

The Challenge The Outcome


To attract 400+ future
The Approach
leaders to the company
each year by hiring McThai annually reviews
and engaging external and develops a 3-1-Q plan
Net Promoter Engagement
talent while at the same (3 year strategic outlook Score – Score –
boosting engagement – 1 year target – quarterly
through a variable pay
program.
execution), where goals and
targets of each employee
89% 92%
are tied to an annual
performance bonus scheme
and a variable pay program.

21 Best Employers Study 2016


High Employee Engagement

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

Starwood Hotels & Resorts


Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc. is an international hotel and leisure company. It is a fully
India integrated owner, operator and franchisor of hotels, resorts and residences with internationally renowned
brands such as The St. Regis, The Luxury Collection, W, Westin and Le Meridien, operating 39 hotels in
India with 3,400 employees.

The Challenge The Outcome


How to double • Attrition dropped well below
The Approach
manpower in order to the market average to less
achieve high growth • Developed a holistic than 10% in 2012-13
(100 hotels in India by integrated talent
2015) in the face of • 80% of senior management
management program
paucity of talent. and 90% of middle
‘Starwood Careers’
management openings were
• Talent development filled internally
was organized into 3
• Employee perception on
distinct career tracks:
“Starwood helps me reach
the executive, the mid-
my potential” in an internal
management and the
survey increased from 75% in
entry-level tracks
2009 to 86% in 2013
• Career paths mapped
for each track by
profiling the critical
job responsibilities and
competencies required
for each role. This helped
build transparency
about the competencies
required to grow in the
organization

Best Employers Study 2016 22


GenY Specific Initiatives

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

Godrej
The Godrej Group is an Indian conglomerate headquartered in Mumbai, India, managed and largely
India owned by the Godrej family. It was founded by Ardeshir Godrej and Pirojsha Burjorji Godrej in 1897,
and operates in sectors as diverse as real estate, consumer products, industrial engineering, appliances,
furniture, security and agricultural products.

The Challenge The Outcome


How to create a campus • This initiative helped Godrej
initiative to identify
The Approach see substantial improvement
some of the most • Godrej LOUD was created in their campus connect
passionate and creative with the objective of building interest levels, really helping
individuals and the kind Godrej brand at campuses Godrej re-brand themselves
that would be the next as an employer of choice for
generation of Godrej • Media tie up with CNBC GenY
employees? TV18 for a 7-part series on
Godrej LOUD; introduced a • This year, Godrej received
LOUD anthem contest where over 2,300 applications, a
shortlisted student bands 500% increase from 2012,
were invited to perform with the year LOUD was launched
Indian Ocean
• In 2014, Godrej also received
• The program introduced requests from B-schools,
a Campus Dream other than the ones that they
competition – students visited, to allow participation
were invited to share their in the program
dreams for their campus and
Godrej sponsored (` 5 lacs)
for the winning dream

• Godrej introduced a LOUD


journal for the students as a
toolkit to help them discover
themselves and their dreams

23 Best Employers Study 2016


Section 2: Compelling
Employer Brand

Best Employers Study 2016 24


Compelling Employer Brand
Best Employers score 8% points higher than the market on the
employer brand index
• Market is closing the gap on the “Compelling Employer Brand” index from 12% in 2013 compared to 8% now

• Best Employers have shown healthy improvement across all sub indices as compared to 2013 with the maximum
movement on the credibility sub-index (7%)

Employer Brand Index 79% 87%

4%
REPUTATION: The organization
is well-known and has a good 76% 85%
reputation in the market
2%

INTERNAL BRAND: Employees are


proud to be part of the organization,
81% 87%
and can explain what makes
working here different from other
organizations 3%

CREDIBILITY: Employees believe


74% 82%
that the organization delivers on its
promises it makes to employees
7%

Best Employers Gap Shift 2013-16 Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

• Best Employers displayed renewed focus on building their brand differentiator

• Best Employers go beyond words to deliver their brand promise through practices, policies and
organizational culture

25 Best Employers Study 2016


Compelling Employer Brand
Best Employers lay focus on effectiveness measurement of the
defined brand
As Employee Value Proposition (EVP) relevance and importance increases, there is increasing pressure for
organizations to deliver on their promises
The Top 6 EVP Effectiveness Measures

Attrition Statistics Rank

Number of employee referrals 1

Attrition statistics 2

Length of service statistics 2

Employee satisfaction on EVP driver (through employee surveys) 2

Employee feedback through exit interviews 5

Cost of recruitment statistics 6

Percentage of offers accepted 6

Number of visits to organization’s career site 6

The outcome of practices and measuring effectiveness is the opinion… Does the organization
keep the promises it makes?

84%

76%

73%
72%

66%
65%
63%
62%

2009 2011 2013 2016

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Best Employers Study 2016 26


Compelling Employer Brand
Best Employers clearly define their ‘value proposition’ and effectively
‘walk-the-talk’
Careers and Collaboration are among top EVP differentiators among Best Employers

Practice Prevalence: Employer Brand

We have formal documentation, implemented the EVP in all HR policies and


19% 29%
programs, and we measure the effectiveness of our EVP regularly

This organization offers exciting careers and provides great


36% 46%
learning opportunities

In this organization there is a great sense of teamwork and camaraderie 22% 33%
amongst co-workers; employees are challenged and empowered

Employee Experience

Defining an EVP is not enough, reinforcing it through communication, delivery and content is

84%
77% 75%
75%

64%
60%

I can clearly explain what makes This organization offers excellent There is effective cooperation
working here different from career opportunities to employees between different groups/
other organizations who are strong performers departments in the organization

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores Participant Average Scores

• Best Employers clearly define “what’s in it for me” for employees

• Providing an empowering environment and clarity on individual growth paths, sets Best Employers
apart from the market

27 Best Employers Study 2016


Compelling Employer Brand

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

IndiGo
IndiGo commenced operations in August 2006, as a low-cost airline in a competitive and highly regulated
India Indian aviation space and today, is the largest airline in India with the highest market share and a fleet of
104 aircrafts.

The Challenge The Outcome


To ensure employees IndiGo was adjudged an Aon
The Approach
truly live their brand Best Employer and is considered
promise and to extend • Ensuring employee one of the best companies to
the guiding principles experience, leadership’s work for in the Indian aviation
of “on time”, “courteous vision and design of industry.
service/hassle-free” people programs,
and “low fare” to the practices and policies
internal customers. are aligned to bring
alive a customer grade
experience for its
employees across all
touch points

• Introduced 8 types
of flying patterns and
associated work contracts
for pilots to ensure hassle
free flexibility in their
flying schedule

• Gives pilots an earning


potential compounded
incentive up to 20% on
the average base pay

Best Employers Study 2016 28


Compelling Employer Brand

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

Reliance Capital
Reliance Capital Asset Management Limited (RCAM) is the asset manager of Reliance Mutual Fund
India (RMF) and subsidiary of Reliance Capital Limited (RCL). As a leading and fast-growing company in
India, RCAM has 902 employees, 703 of whom are homegrown talent.

The Challenge The Outcome


To build a strong • 70% of RCAM’s talent
The Approach
Employee Value comes from outside the
Proposition (EVP) to • RCAM introduced an AMC (Asset Management
enhance the internal innovative initiative of Company) industry and 38%
employee experience, sourcing talent from from outside BFSI (Banking,
and develop an diverse industries to Financial Services, and
employer brand that promote learning and Insurance)
strengthens RCAM’s innovation
credibility to attract, • 90% of CXO talent is grown
retain and groom high- • These diverse industries in-house & 75% of next-in-line
quality future leaders. are carefully identified leaders are also developed
basis the business in-house
challenge or opportunity
• Employee attrition rate is at a
at hand. For example,
low 5%
to penetrate India’s
hinterland and rural
markets, RCAM sourced
a Chief Marketing
Officer with an FMCG
background

29 Best Employers Study 2016


Section 3: Effective
Leadership

Best Employers Study 2016 30


Effective Leadership
Best Employers have an 11% higher effective leadership index
than the market
• The overall index score has shown positive movement with both the Best Employers and the market showing a 4%
and 2% point improvement respectively over 2013 scores

• The Best Employers register improvement across all sub indices with a substantial 6% point improvement on the
valuing people sub index

Effective Leadership Index 70% 81%

4%

FUTURE VISION: Leaders show clear


and compelling future vision to the 68% 79%
members of the organization
3%

VALUING PEOPLE: Employees


experience that leaders are 69% 79%
appropriately visible and accessible;
treat them as organization’s most
valued asset 6%

BUSINESS EXCELLENCE : Employees


trust their senior leaders to be open 70% 80%
and honest; and believe they make
good business decisions
4%

Best Employers Gap Shift 2013-16 Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

• Best Employers use leaders to drive culture, reinforce organization values and create an engaging
environment

• Leaders create a strong personal connect with employees and thereby instill a strong sense of purpose

31 Best Employers Study 2016


Effective Leadership
An engaged senior leadership is an effective leadership

Senior leadership engagement has dipped for Best Employers and remained steady for the market

Engagement Scores of Top Leadership

93%

87% 86%

82% 83%
80%

79%
77% 76% 76%
75% 74%

2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2016

Market is registering a positive upswing in employee opinion on Senior Leadership, and while Best Employers scores
have dipped, they still maintain an 11% points lead

Employee Opinion Scores on the Leadership Pillar

87%
84% 84%
81%
77% 78%

74%
70%
68% 68%
67%
65%

2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2016

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Top leadership in Best Employers is significantly more engaged, resulting in a better perception of their
effectiveness across the organization

Best Employers Study 2016 32


Effective Leadership
Best Employers understand what engages leaders the best

Best Employers adopt multi-modal interventions to develop their leaders

Practice Prevalence

Formal process to identify and develop successors


72% 83%
and successor list is regularly reviewed

Internal training (classroom-based) 81% 96%


Practices adopted for leadership development

External training (i.e. executive training courses) 76% 83%

External coaching 40% 38%

Rotational assignments (formal process


to move leaders through a series of 59% 67%
departments or regions)

Developmental assignments (job


assignments matched to specific 60% 67%
development needs of leaders)

Increased access and interactions with senior


64% 79%
executives/ top management (e.g. shadowing)

Participant Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Coaching is just one of the ways for Best Employers to develop the leadership pipeline

33 Best Employers Study 2016


Effective Leadership

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

Whirlpool of India Ltd.


The Whirlpool Corporation is an American multinational manufacturer and marketer of home appliances.
India Whirlpool entered India in the late 1980s as a part of its global expansion strategy. The company owns
three state-of-the-art manufacturing facilities at Faridabad, Pondicherry and Pune, and has 1,625 full time
employees.

The Challenge The Outcome


To inculcate and Their effective leadership index
The Approach
ensure employees truly is at 80% which is 7 percentage
embrace leadership The fundamental objective points ahead of their industry
behaviors, Whirlpool was to de-mystify leadership benchmark.
worked towards and make it a part of everyday
ensuring the culture of lingo for all employees through
the organization, and several inventive methods:
not a part of the culture,
centered around • Designed and developed
leadership. mass customized learning
content

• Created change champions


to train employees on the
leadership model

• Leadership evangelism
through the leadership team

• Employees allowed to chart


and select their personal
leadership journeys

• Integrated leadership model


into people processes

Best Employers Study 2016 34


Effective Leadership

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

Tata Communications Ltd.


Tata Communications Ltd. (TCL) is a global telecommunications company. As the sixth largest mobile
India service provider in India, TCL is renowned for its cutting-edge, one-of-a-kind innovation – including the
world’s only, wholly-owned fiber ring around the world and Ethernet ring serving the Middle East.

The Challenge The Outcome


• The metrics to measure
TCL launched Develop The Approach
MINT to create a success have been divided
pipeline of business • After a rigorous selection into the following three
leaders for the future procedure, 30 finalists were categories: quality, cost
with a horizon of 3-5 selected. Development and time
years. Objectives was based on the 70:20:10
• The program is currently
include: learning model
underway and the
• Build a strong bench- • An advanced business leader participants are undergoing
strength of business competency development their first job rotation
leaders for the future training program was
organized in Frankfurt,
• Enhance capability Germany. The CEO set
of leaders who expectations and extended
understand the support
business and have
the right DNA • Candidates were assigned
a Group Coach who
• Focus on a ‘Build helped them create their
over Buy’ strategy for IDPs, identified areas of
talent expansion development, identify the
roles for the candidates over
the next 3-6 years

35 Best Employers Study 2016


Section 4: High
Performance Culture

Best Employers Study 2016 36


High Performance Culture
Best Employers have a 13% point lead on the high performance
culture index
• Best Employers show a 1% increase in overall index scores over 2013, however, the market has dipped by 3% points
in comparison to 2013

• Both the market and Best Employers register a noticeable dip in the reward sub index with a 4% and 7% point
respective drop over 2013

High Performance Index 66% 79%

1%

ACCOUNTABILITY & TRUST


74% 82%
Managers set clear goals and
expectations, and employees know
how they can best contribute to
realize their business strategy 1%

REWARD: Rewards & recognition


for high performance are clearly 59% 70%
understood and transparent to
employees
-4%

GROWTH: The organization prepares


for future challenges by offering
interesting careers for high potential
employees and learning opportunities 70% 79%
for all employees 5%

Best Employers Gap Shift 2013-16 Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

• Managerial capability building has enabled Best Employers to create transparency and trust

• However, with the advent of new-age industries, one needs balanced focus on rewards &
recognition too

37 Best Employers Study 2016


High Performance Culture
Best Employers distinguishing and rewarding for performance

Best Employers ensure appropriate recognition and differentiate rewards based on performance to push high
performers further

Practice: We combine Practice: Keeping average performers as a Outcome: Employee


structured, formal benchmark, how much does the variable opinion
recognition programs pay differ by performance?
with manager-driven
recognition

Employees 102
132
Top Leadership 53%
128 Appropriate
145 Recognition
66%

46% 47% Average 100


Performers 100
60%
Employees 18 Performance
21 Impact on Pay
74%
2016
Top Leadership
19
15

High Performers

Under Performers

Participant Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Best Employers Study 2016 38


High Performance Culture
Manager development focus continued

Best Employers develop, coach, assess and reward their people managers to become engaging managers

Practice Prevalence: People Manager Development

We have a formal approach to improving people management skills


93% 96%
Practices to drive People Manager

People managers get coached to


provide career advice and to explain 59% 71%
Development

rewards successfully to their people

People managers receive effective feedback on


78% 79%
how their leadership style influences their team

People managers’ performance ratings


60% 71%
reflect their teams’ engagement levels

People managers are measured


on their quality of people
55% 63%
management and are rewarded for
managing their people effectively

Participant Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Continued focus on managers assisted Best Employers on:

• Driving accountability of team engagement through managers

• Creating individual development plans to help them become engaging leaders

39 Best Employers Study 2016


High Performance Culture
The focus on outcomes

Best Employers are far ahead of the market in planning, communicating and providing abundant career opportunities to
their employees

Practice Prevalence: Career Development


We have a formal career development
60% 79%
framework

We have a campaign to communicate


57% 67%
the framework to our employees
Practices to support career development

Structured succession planning 59% 71%

Assessment of behavioral capability 64% 71%

Opportunity of cross department assignments 64% 83%

Career planning portal


(an online tool that helps
22% 38%
managers and employees
manage careers)

One-on-one coaching for


employees on managing 50% 63%
their careers

Opportunity for internal and


67% 83%
external learning programs

Career development goals integrated


55% 71%
into performance management

Participant Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Employee Experience on Career Opportunities


81%
77% 75% 72%
67% 69%

Organization offers excellent career There are sufficient opportunities Organization strongly supports the
opportunities to employees who within the organization for me to work learning and development of its
are strong performers on assignments to gain new skills employees
Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores Participant Average Scores

Technology adoption is low even for Best Employers in an increasing complex area of career opportunities

Best Employers Study 2016 40


High Performance Culture

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

Bajaj Finance Ltd.


Bajaj Finance is one of the few NBFCs in the country to be awarded a rating of FAAA/Stable for Fixed
India Deposits and have a network of over 115 branch offices throughout the country. They have been in
operation for 29 years and have a workforce exceeding 4,400 full time employees.

The Challenge The Outcome


To shift the onus of The success ratio of the Auto-
employee growth (up
The Approach
promotion policy will be to
to a certain level) to lie • The auto-promotion policy is ensure that at least 70% of
with the employee. An a unique initiative to create employees completing the
employee can growth a strong career progression required tenure get promoted in
in their current role program at Junior to Middle the system.
after a specified period management levels on
of time provided they achievement of a pre-defined
meet the defined set of set of performance metrics.
metrics. The intent being:

- To grow in-house talent and

- Ensure job enrichment for


an employee

• The review period of the


auto-promotion policy is
quarterly and promotions are
automatically initiated basis
tenure and performance

41 Best Employers Study 2016


High Performance Culture

The Best Employers Circle


Lessons from the trenches

DHL India Ltd.


DHL is present in over 220 countries and territories across the globe, making it the most international
India company. DHL India has been operation for 37 years and has a workforce exceeding 1100 employees.

The Challenge The Outcome


DHL targeted to Linking Performance Pay with
achieve the following The Approach “3 bottom lines” has shown
3 bottom lines, i.e. to tremendous results:
be an: • Each employees performance
appraisal carries weighted • Transit time over 96%
• Investor of choice linkage to the 3 bottom lines (provider of choice)

• Provider of choice • All employees irrespective • Active Leadership scores


of their grades have the improved by 16% in last 3
• Employer of choice years (employer of choice)
following 2/3 collaborative
targets:
• Customer Promise scores
- EBIT improved by 8% in last 3
years and currently at 95%
- Transit time (provider of choice)

- Active leadership

• The weightage for


collaborative target is higher
for management employees as
they are decision-makers and
their variable component can
go as high as 70%

Best Employers Study 2016 42


Section 5: Effective
HR Function

43 Best Employers Study 2016


An Effective HR Function
The Best Employers’ business expectations

What the CEOs of winner organizations expect from Best Employers?

R.S. Subramanian, Aditya Ghosh, CEO, Vikram Oberoi, CEO, Arvind Uppal, CEO,
CEO, DHL IndiGo Oberoi Hotels Whirlpool

HR partners with the HR is a very The competitive Increasingly, the


key stakeholders to important and advantage of the success of businesses
ensure that people strategic function group stems from our depends on the ability
strategy and policies in my organization. single minded focus on of its employees to
are aligned to the We are obsessed with creating memorable execute their business
business requirements our own people and experiences for our strategy. For us, the
and in line with our HR is a key partner guests. To do this, the ability of our employees
ambition to be the to implement our HR function drives our to enable business
employer of choice. culture. A lot of what ability to attract the transformation is termed
HR further helps the our customers see of best talent, provide as ‘People Excellence’.
organization develop us and our product is a them with learning and Enabling, nurturing
key measures that track reflection of who we are growth in an enabling and sustaining people
the people dimension internally. Therefore, environment that excellence and thereby
that impact the business HR is a key partner supports and empowers driving business strategy
and develop actions to for our leaders to them to do their best for is where our HR function
ensure high quality drive excellence. our guests… plays a pivotal role.
work environment
and ethic. HR helps
the business leaders
to look ahead and stay
people focused to
ensure that decisions are
taken with the people
aspect in mind and the
organization is future
ready. HR is the voice
of the employee in the
leadership team and
help ensure that talent
and skill development
remains a key focus area
at all times.

Best Employers Study 2016 44


An Effective HR Function

Best Employers don’t spend more on HR. They focus on doing the right things and doing them well

Actual spend on people practices initiatives (annual HR budget) expressed as a % of annual revenues in 2015-16

3.0%

1.0%

2016

Areas of strength for Best Employers (% reflects selection in the Top 3)

75%

64%

50%

42%
38% 38% 38%

26% 26%
22%

Employee Learning & Defining/ Employer Branding HiPo


Engagement & Development Aligning Development
Motivation Organization Succession
Culture Planning

Participant Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Data Representation: Actual spend on people practices initiatives (annual HR budget) expressed as a % of annual revenues in 2015-16
Source: Best Employers India Study 2016

Best Employers spend 1/3rd of market spend on people practices/initiatives

45 Best Employers Study 2016


An Effective HR Function

Best Employers don’t just articulate HR strategy, they ensure accountability and governance around it

The HR strategy was developed in partnership with multiple


76% 79%
business stakeholders
Practice Prevalence

The CEO is measured based on organization’s HR KPIs (e.g.


74% 79%
employee engagement, attrition)

HR collaborates with the business to identify HR KPIs and then


83% 88%
monitor, assess and report performance against those HR KPIs

Our organization participated in an HR benchmarking


71% 79%
process in the last 2 years

Design new
60% 71%
people programs
The use of benchmark data and

Build a
differentiated 34% 46%
EVP
insights

Include in our HR
43% 63%
reporting

Set our HR KPIs 47% 58%

Validate practices 71% 79%

Participant Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Best Employers go beyond articulation of HR strategy. Their HR co-owns the outcomes and metrics

Best Employers Study 2016 46


What’s in Store for
the Future

47 Best Employers Study 2016


Best Employers: Delivering on the Now,
Imagineering for What’s to Come
Is India Inc. Future Ready?
Businesses today are experiencing breakthroughs faster than ever; lifecycles for innovation are shortening, the East is
gradually becoming the new West and more importantly, technology is the new fuel disrupting and enabling businesses.
Leading firms are leaving behind the traditional models of market access; instead they are creating new markets and
controlling consumer experience like never before.

With close to 7 connected devices per human being on earth by 2020 and the average human spending close to 2.5 hours
on mobile devices surfing daily, one does not really need to underscore the pace of change both subliminal and actual.
Besides increasing connectedness, mobility and social media are also making organizations transparent to the outside
world. Current and prospective workforce is impacted by an employer’s stated purpose of existence (or rather, lack of it),
more so when income inequalities are rising and awareness for social issues are high.

The purpose of this report is to identify emerging trends around the below 3 shifts and visualize a journey that prepares
organizations for the future.

Megatrends Impacting the Business and the Workplace

• Businesses are experiencing breakthroughs faster than ever

• Nature of work is shifting dimensions faster than ever

• Connectedness is redefining talent expectations faster than ever

Business Workforce

• Disruption becomes a norm • Demographic and


psychographic shifts
• Changing sources of
competitive advantage • Consumer mindset

• Technology and internet of • Social connectedness


everything
• Highly informed
• Interconnected trade and
talent flows • Life long learner

Best Employers Study 2016 48


Best Employers: Delivering on the Now,
Imagineering for What’s to Come
What Does India Inc. Need to be Future Ready?
Faster than ever

Businesses are experiencing Nature of work is shifting Connectedness is redefining talent


breakthroughs faster than ever dimensions faster than ever expectations faster than ever

Speed Agility Innovation On- Constant Man & Transparent Experience Purpose
Demand Learning Machine

Keeping Pace with the Fast Changing Business and Workplace


Landscapes
Given the above mentioned external and demographic shifts, businesses now have to focus on three critical imperatives
to keep pace with the fast-changing workplace and business landscape.

1 2
Design Create work
organizations for culture to deliver
Innovation, Agility 10X impact
& Speed

3
Manage the young, the
old and the
connected

49 Best Employers Study 2016


Best Employers: Delivering on the Now,
Imagineering for What’s to Come
Where do the Best Still Need Improvement?
Dimensions to Imagineering the Future

1 Collaboration Takes Center-stage: Collaboration at the workplace is amongst top 3 sustenance drivers for Best
Employers. However, it is not the top most, which points towards the future journey for Best Employers.

2 Balance Work & Life: Work-Life Balance is an improvement driver for Best Employers despite its high scores.
This represents employees’ rising expectations towards better work-life integration enabled through omnipresent
technology.

3 Inspirational Leaders and Stellar Reputation Count: Brand and senior leadership are amongst top 4
improvement drivers for the market. Incidentally, senior leadership was a sustenance driver for Best Employers last
year, but no longer now. This corroborates our hypothesis of the task cut-out for inspiring leaders and organization’s
reputation.

4 Rewards & Recognition Matters: Best Employers have created the highest gap against the market average on
rewards & recognition (13%) validating the positive experience created for the employee. The same however is still
their top most improvement driver, which signifies hurdles of the journey yet to be traveled. Best Employers are
seemingly more prepared for this.

5 Raise the Bar of ‘Delivery of Promise’: Market average scores have interestingly improved across all engagement
drivers, with the maximum increase on brand and career opportunities. This indicates market is catching up with key
differentiators of the past. Hence, Best Employers need to raise their “delivery of promise” and focus on creation of
purposeful organizations.

Rewards & Recognition Rewards & Recognition

Career Opportunities Career Opportunities

IMPROVEMENT
DRIVERS
Brand Work-Life Balance

Supervision Health & Well-being

Learning & Development Supervision

SUSTAIN
DRIVERS Performance Management Collaboration

Market Best Employers

Best Employers Study 2016 50


Best Employers: Delivering on the Now,
Imagineering for What’s to Come
Challenges That Emerge for HR
The future will always remain the future; organizations that acknowledge the fact that they need to be prepared for the
same will continue to seize opportunities and create exponential advantages. In our view, HR will face the following 3
critical challenges in the readiness, and their ability to influence and lead change during this journey will determine their
success.

Pre-empt

1
• Organizations of the future will work in smaller and diverse teams
and solve
the TEAM • Team inability to work cohesively will impact the desired business
conundrum! outcomes of speed, agility and innovation

78% 71% 81%


84% 65%
72%

Diversity & Inclusion Career Opportunities Collaboration

The Best are at 84% on Career opportunities is Collaboration at the


Diversity & Inclusion, the second most critical workplace is amongst
ensuring they provide an improvement driver for the top 3 sustenance
open work environment the Market as well as the drivers for Best Employers.
that respects individual Best Employers. This only However, it is not the
differences. The market reaffirms the criticality of top most, which points
definitely has ground to this driver for employees towards the future journey
cover here as employee across organizations at for Best Employers.
expectations are both ends of the maturity
constantly rising. spectrum.

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

51 Best Employers Study 2016


Best Employers: Delivering on the Now,
Imagineering for What’s to Come
Challenges that emerge for HR

• Future of work revolves around one’s ability to learn and adapt


Enable the

2
new-age • Solving problems will be hugely dependent on quicker
WORK & decision-making and iterative learning techniques
LEARNING
• Technology will be omnipresent, and work processes will alter
techniques! significantly owing to automation and artificial intelligence

81% 83%
69% 73% 71% 79%

Basics (Enabling Infra, Empowerment & Work-life Balance


Talent & Staffing) Autonomy (Integration)

The Best are 12% points The Best are at 83% Work/Life Balance is an
ahead on the market when it on Empowerment & improvement driver
comes to providing the basics Autonomy, which goes for Best Employers
i.e. the requisite people to show that in addition despite high scores. This
and material resources and to providing an open represents employees’
an enabling infrastructure. work environment, they rising expectations
Considering that these are are also empowering towards better work-
foundation elements for their employees to take life integration enabled
any organization, delivering decisions and learn from through omnipresent
on these is critical for all their mistakes. technology.
employers.

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

Best Employers Study 2016 52


Best Employers: Delivering on the Now,
Imagineering for What’s to Come
Challenges that emerge for HR

• Future of managing talent will be driven by individual choices -


Relearn the art

3
traditional control & command practices will lose favor
of MANAGING
Brand and • Employee experience will be paramount, and leadership style will
People! need to be inspirational

88% 74%
83% 78%
70% 58%

Rewards &
Inspiring Leadership Employer Brand
Recognition

Senior Leadership was a Brand is the third most critical Best Employers have created
sustenance driver for Best improvement driver for the the highest gap against the
Employers last year, but no Market. Organizations are Market Average on Rewards
longer now. Leadership style expected to live and deliver & Recognition (16%).
will need to be inspirational the employer brand in However, it also is their top
to drive positive energy and thought, speech and action. most improvement driver,
a sense of purpose within the The Best Employers are 10% which signifies hurdles of the
workforce. points ahead of the market, journey yet to be traveled.
and definitely better prepared Best Employers are seemingly
to deliver on employee better prepared here.
expectations.

Mkt. Average Scores Best Employer Scores

53 Best Employers Study 2016


Imagineering the Future
Dimensions to Imagineering 2020

How to become a Best Employer

Collaboration Takes
Centerstage

Inculcate the ability for teams to


work cohesively to drive speed,
agility and innovation

Balance Work & Life

Enable better work-life


integration through
omnipresent technology

Inspirational Leaders and a


Stellar Reputation Count

Build towards an inspirational


leadership and a stellar reputation
to set up for future-readiness

Rewards &
Recognition Matters

Differentiate, reward
and recognize effective
performance and efforts

Raise the Bar on


‘Delivery of Promise’

Raise the bar on “delivery of


promise” and focus on creation
of purposeful organizations

Best Employers Study 2016 54


About Aon
Aon plc (NYSE:AON) is a leading global provider
of risk management, insurance and reinsurance
brokerage, and human resources solutions and
outsourcing services. Through its more than
72,000 colleagues worldwide, Aon unites to
empower results for clients in over 120 countries
via innovative and effective risk and people
solutions and through industry-leading global
resources and technical expertise. Aon has been
named repeatedly as the world’s best broker,
best insurance intermediary, reinsurance
intermediary, captives manager and best
employee benefits consulting firm by multiple
industry sources. Visit www.aon.com for more
information on Aon andwww.aon.com/
manchesterunited to learn about Aon’s global
partnership with Manchester United.

© Aon plc 2016. All rights reserved.


The information contained herein and the statements
expressedare of a general nature and are not intended to address
thecircumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although
weendeavor to provide accurate and timely information and
usesources we consider reliable, there can be no guarantee that
suchinformation is accurate as of the date it is received or that it
willcontinue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on
suchinformation without appropriate professional advice after a
thoroughexamination of the particular situation.

aonhewitt.co.in

Vikrant Khanna
Senior Consultant
Insights & Innovation
Aon Hewitt, APAC
vikrant.khanna.3@aonhewitt.com

Kanika Manchanda
Consultant
Culture & Engagement
Aon Hewitt, India
kanika.manchanda@aonhewittcom

Powered by- Insights & Innovation, Aon Hewitt

Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources.

55 Best Employers Study 2016

You might also like