You are on page 1of 40

Antenatal and postnatal care service utilization in southern Ethiopia:

a population-based study
*Regassa N

Institute of Environment, Gender and Development, Hawassa Univerity, Hawassa, SNNPR, Ethiopia

Abstract
Background: Access to antenatal care (ANC) and postnatal care (PNC) services has a great deal of impacts on major causes
of infant death and significantly affects trends of mortality in a population. Antenatal care may play an indirect role in
reducing maternal mortality by encouraging women to deliver with assistance of a skilled birth attendant or in a health
facility. In most rural settings of Ethiopia, there are challenges in increasing such health care service utilization mainly due to
the fact that the decisions that lead women to use the services seem to occur within the context of their marriage , household
and family setting.
Objective: Examining the prevalence and factors associated with antenatal Care (ANC) and Postnatal Care (PNC) service
utilizations.
Methods: This was a cross-sectional population based study undertaken in 10 rural villages of the Sidama zone, southern
Ethiopia. The data were collected from a representative sample of 1,094 households drawn from the study population
using a combination of simple random and multistage sampling techniques. Two dependent variables were used in the
analysis: The ANC, measured by whether a woman got the service (at least once) from a health professional or not during
her last pregnancy and PNC which was approximated by whether the last born child completed the required immunization
or not. Household and women’s characteristics were used as explanatory variables for both dependent variables.
Results: The study revealed that the level of ANC and PNC service utilizations is 77.4 % and 37.2% respectively. The
predicted probabilities, using logistic regression, showed that women who are literate, have exposure to media, and women
with low parity are more likely to use both ANC and PNC services.
Conclusion: Antenatal care service utilization was generally good while the postnatal care given to new born children was
very low compared to other population groups in the region. Promoting women’s education and behavioral change
communication at grass root level, provision of the services at both home and health facilities, and improving the quality
and capacity of the health providers are some of the recommendations forwarded.
Key words: Antenatal Care, postnatal care, service utilization, complete immunization, Sidama Zone, Southern Ethiopia
African Health Sciences 2011; 11(3): 390 - 397

Introduction
Inadequate access and under-utilization of modern of mortality and morbidity among populations3, 2.
healthcare services are major reasons for poor health It is also possible that antenatal care may play an
in the developing countries. This inequality in the indirect role in reducing maternal mortality by
health and wellbeing of women in the developing encouraging women to deliver with assistance of
world is a growing concern1. Improving maternal skilled birth attendant or in a health facility4. As one
and newborn health requires strengthening of existing major component of the PNC, immunization
interventions in ANC and PNC2. Studies have shown remains to be one of the most effective health
that ANC and PNC have a great deal of impacts interventions and has been proven to prevent up to
on major causes of infant death and shape trends 24% of the 10 million yearly deaths of children under
five years5.
* Correspondence author In Ethiopia although access to health care
Nigatu Regassa services is improving, the country has faced challenges
Institute of Environment, Gender and in increasing health care utilization6. For example, the
Development proportion of women who give birth with the
Hawassa University assistance of skilled attendants is among the lowest
P. O. Box 679 in sub-Saharan Africa7.
Hawassa, SNNPR A number of individual, household and
Ethiopia institutional characteristics affect women’s decisions
Phone 251-46-2203801 to seeking care, which includes education, income,
Email: negyon@yahoo.com
390 African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011
accessibility, age, organization and functioning of the 5.51% are urban inhabitants and a further 0.18% are
health care system and services, interaction between pastoralists11. A substantial area of the Sidama land
parents and health workers, waiting time and clinical produces coffee, which is the major cash crop in the
practice8. Mengistu and James, in their study in the region. ‘Enset’ (enset ventricosum) is the single most
Arsi zone of central Ethiopia, found maternal age, important root crop grown in the study area and
parity, lack of time, education, marital status, and the bulk of the population depends heavily on it for
women’s economic status to be significant predictors survival.
of utilization of maternity care9. A study in Yirgalem
town and in the surrounding Southern Nations, Sampling
Nationalities, and People’s Region (SNNPR) of The 1,094 households were selected from two agro
Ethiopia showed that women’s education, inadequate climatic zones; highland and low land areas of Sidama
household income, and unwanted pregnancy were zone of Southern Ethiopia using appropriate
important predictors of antenatal care utilization10. statistical estimation. The two agro climatic zones
In general, despite the fact that ANC and have nearly equal number of population/villages (38
PNC services are made accessible to nearly all villages and 36 kebeles) ,and hence, the sampling was not
(in most instances at lower or no cost), the decisions weighted.
that lead women to use the services seem to occur Probability sampling in a form of simple
within the context of their marriage , household and random and two-stage sampling methods were used
family setting. It is thus important to examine the for selecting the required size from the study areas.
extent to which women are making use of the Since the two sub-districts (the low and high land)
services and answer why many women do not use were decided upon in advance, the first stage of the
the services. To the best knowledge of the author, sampling was started by selecting five kebeles (small
the very few studies conducted in the region are either villages) from each of the two sub-districts using
based on small sample or single out only one aspect simple random sampling. At the second stage, a
(ANC or PNC or sub parts) or are based on random sample of households with a child less than
secondary data available in health facilities. This study 24 months was selected from the available list, giving
therefore aims at examining both the utilization of a total of 1,094 households.
Antenatal and Postnatal care (ANC and PNC)
services in one of the most populous zone of Data collection
Southern Ethiopia, the Sidama. It tries to test three The data for this study were generated through a
major hypotheses a) educated women are more likely structured interview schedule. Prior to the data
to use ANC and PNC service than their counterpart collection, the checklists/schedules underwent
uneducated ones b) older women are more prone intensive review and pre-testing on a small sample
to using ANC and PNC compared to the younger of subjects from all categories of respondents.
ones. c) higher parity mothers are more likely to use During the interview, the enumerators went through
ANC and PNC. all the items where wives and husbands were
interviewed separately in view of avoiding any
Methods discomfort for mothers/women.
The study setting The two most important variables forming
The study was conducted in Sidama, one of the most the main response variables, ANC and PNC, were
populous zone of Southern Ethiopia. Sidama is framed using universally accepted survey questions.
located in the SNNPR.The Sidama zone is bordered For ANC, a dichotomous variable was asking created
in the south by the Oromia Region except for a short whether woman had visited a skilled health care
stretch in the middle where it shares a border with provider (such as doctor, nurse, midwife, or any
Gedeo, on the west by the Bilate river which separates other prescribed and trained health professional) at
it from Wolayita, and on the north and east by the least once during the last pregnancy. The measure is
Oromia Region. The administrative center for Sidama adopted from the World Health Organization’s
is Hawassa town. According to the recent census 11, definition of ante natal care12. The unit of analysis in
the total population of the zone was 2,954,136. With this case is the mother. The second dependent
an area of 6,538 square kilometers, Sidama has a variable, PNC, was measured by the level of
population density of 452/km2 with an average immunization of the last child. Attempt was made
household size of 4.99 persons. Of the population, to follow the immunization factors recommended

African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011 391


by the World Health Organization12 : The Bacillus Results
Calmette Guerin (BCG) which protects the child Table 1 presents the background characteristics of
from tuberculosis and given at birth; the Polio and respondents. The age distribution of the women
Diphtheria pertussis and tetanus (DPT) vaccination shows that a larger proportion of them ( 47.7%)
(given at six , ten and fourteen weeks) and measles were in the early adulthood (age 25-34) followed by
vaccination which is administered at nine months. those in the age group of 15-24 (39.4 %). With
The unit of analysis in this case is a child below the regards to the number of children born, larger
age of 24 months. proportions of women had given birth to 1-3
(46.3%) and 4-7 children (35.5%). Protestant
Data Processing and analysis Christians account for the highest proportion in the
The data processing and analysis has started with religious distribution (73.5 %) followed by Catholic
computing the percentages of mothers who got and Muslim (10.8 and 9.4 %) respectively while the
antenatal care services from the health professional remaining religious groups contributed small
which formed the first dependent variable, and also proportion of the respondents. The large majority
computed the proportion of children less than 24 of the respondents ( 60.6 %) of the study households
months with complete immunization per WHO have 4-7 members and 22.1 percent of them had
definition which formed the second dependent greater than 7 members. The average household size
variable (PNC). for the study population was 5.87. The analysis
Both bivariate and multivariate analyses were used showed that 15.3 percent of the women were
to examine the association between the study engaged in polygamous marriage arrangement (i.e
variables and selected household and individual husbands having two or more wives during the
characteristics. In the bivariate analysis, Pearson’s chi- survey).
square test of independence was performed to test The distribution of the respondents by
the existence of significant association between educational status revealed that majority of the
categories of ANC/PNC status and selected respondents were illiterate (56.3 %) followed by
predictors. Due to the fact that the chi-square elementary level (27.9 %) while the remaining
bivariate analysis indicates effects or associations of respondents accounted for a smaller proportion of
variables without controlling for the confounding the respondents. The majority (47.1%) of the
effects, the net effects of each independent variable respondents were farmers, and 39.9 percent were
were further examined using multivariate (the logistic self employed while the remaining employment
regression) analysis. categories contributed smaller proportion of the
In the logistic regression analysis, the first respondents. Land ownership by households in the
response variable (ANC) had two outcomes; study area was quite small and fragmented. It is seen
whether a woman got the service (at least once) from from table 1 that about 95 percent of the households
health professional or not during her last pregnancy. owned land size less than one hectare.
Similarly, the second dependent variable was framed Table 1: Background characterstics of
to have two outcomes; whether the last born child respondents, Sidama zone, 2011 (n= 1,094)
completed the required immunization or not. Since
the interest is in identifying the probability of facing Characteristics Number Percent
the outcome variable, the dependent variables were (n= 1094)
coded as 1 if the event happens and coded as 0 if Age of women
not. 15-24 431 39.4
The odds ratios, which were determined 25-34 489 44.7
from the logistic regression coefficients, tell us the 35-49 174 15.9
increased or decreased chance of ANC/ PNC given Religion
a set of level of an independent variable while Orthodox Christian 28 2.6
controlling for the effects of the other variables in Catholic 118 10.8
the model. Estimates of odds greater than 1.0 indicate Protestant 804 73.5
that the probability of the event happening is greater Muslim 103 9.4
than that for the reference category. Estimates less Traditional 25 2.3
than 1.0 indicate that the risks are less than that for Others 16 1.5
the reference categories of each variable.

392 African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011


Continuation of table 1 Table 2: Percentage distribution of respondents
by ANC service received and reported type of
Characteristics Number Percent immunization given to the last child (born
(n= 1094) during the last 24 months), Sidama zone, 2011
Household size (n = 1,094)
1-3 persons 189 17.3
4-7 persons 663 60.6 Type of ANC and PNC Yes No
Greater than 7 persons 242 22.1 services
Marital Form Received ANC services 77.4 22.6
Polygamous 166 15.2 (from trained health
Monogamous 928 84.8 professionals)
Educational Status of the women Type of immunization
Illiterate 616 56.3 TB Immunization 65.9 34.1
Elementary (1-6) 305 27.9 Immunization of Polio 0 66.6 33.4
Junior secondary (7-8) 69 6.3 Immunization of DPT 1 60.1 39.9
Secondary (9-12) 44 4.0 Immunization of DPT 2 57.7 42.3
College diploma 14 1.3 Immunization of DPT 3 56.9 43.1
Others 46 4.2 Immunization of Polio 1 65.4 34.6
Usual occupation Immunization of Polio 2 66.5 33.5
Self employment 437 39.9 Immunization of Polio 3 62.6 37.4
Civil servant 13 1.2 Immunization of Measles 71.4 28.6
Farmer 515 47.1 Fully immunized 37.2 62.8
Petty trader 60 5.5
Others 69 6.3 As part of the preliminary analysis, the results of
Land size owned by the household the bivariate analysis for ANC and PNC indicated
Landless 31 2.8 that six variables had a significant association with
> 0.5 hectare 459 42.0 ANC utilization and these included age of women,
0.5-1 hectare 579 52.9 pregnancy reaction, usual work status, children ever
> 1 hectare 25 2.3 born, religion and literacy status. Similarly, seven
Children ever born variables (age of women, usual work status, children
No children born 50 4.6 ever born, religion, literacy status, marital form and
1-3 children 506 46.3 educational status of the husbands) have shown a
4-6 children 388 35.5 significant association with PNC service utilization
7-10 children 150 13.6 (tables not shown).
Since the chi-square (bivariate) analysis
Table 2 shows the percentage distribution of women
indicates effects or associations of variables without
respondents by ANC and PNC status for the last
controlling the confounding effects, multivariate
child. About 77.4 percent of them reported getting
analysis using logistic regression was applied in view
ANC service from trained health professionals. The
of further examining the predicting variables. As
immunization coverage for specific vaccination type
clearly seen in table 3, two independent regression
was generally good. However, the full or complete
models were used (for the ANC and PNC) using
immunizationwas far below the expected standard.
nearly similar types of independent variables. The
The World Health Organization (WHO) suggested
variables included in the two models were: age of
that complete vaccination coverage should reach at
women, children ever born, religion, radio listening
least 90% of children at the country level and 80%
frequency, reaction to previous pregnancy, usual
in sub-areas 13 . Among the study population,
work, experiencing infant death, marital form and
complete immunization is only 37.2 percent.
women’s literacy.

African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011 393


Table 3: Results of logistic regression (odds ratio) for ANC and Immunization, Sidama zone, 2011
(n = 1094)

Variables ANC Immunization


Model 1 Model 2
Age of women B Exp(B) B Exp(B)
Age 15-24 (RC) - - - -
Age 25-34 -.563 .570* -.374 .688
Age 35-49 -.982 .374*** -.199 .820
Children ever born
1-3 children - - - .-
4-6 children -.182 .834* -.809 .445**
7-10 children -.231 .794 -.721 .486
Religion
Orthodox Christian (RC) - - - -
Catholic -.091 .913 .301 1.352
Protestant -.883 .414 .233 1.262
Muslim -.013 .987 -.295 .745
Traditional .111 1.118 .897 2.453
Others -.312 .732 .900 2.461
Radio listening frequency
Almost every day (RC) - - - -
Twice a week -.717 .488 .268 .307
Once in a fortnight -1.314 .269** .495 .640
Not at all -.670 .935* .563 .757*
Pregnancy reaction
Wanted RC - - Na Na
Wait -.772 .462*** Na Na
Never wanted -.709 .492** Na Na
Usual work
Self employment (RC) - - - -
Civil servant .674 1.963* .339 1.404
Farmer -.626 .535 1.989 7.308
Petty trader .229 1.258 .481 1.618
Others -1.309 .270* .420 1.522
Experienced Infant death
Yes RC - - - -
No -.369 -1.446 -.082 -1.086
Marital form
Polygamous (RC) - - - -
Monogamous -.334 -.716 - .437 -1.548*
Women’s literacy status
Literate (RC) - -
Illiterate -.327 .721* -.284 -.753*
Constant .125 .133 .673 .960
-2 Log likelihood
*=p<0.05, **=p<0.01, ***=p<0.001 1047.566 1328.488a

394 African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011


In model 1, which presents the results for ANC, six compared to other populations in southern Ethiopia.
variables had significant associations with the ANC However, this figure should be interpreted cautiously
service utilization. These are; age of women, previous due to two reasons: first, the study collected
pregnancy reaction, usual work status, children ever information on service utilization in relation to the
born, radio listening frequency and literacy status. For most recent birth during the 24 months preceding
the PNC, four variables established significant the survey, and hence, it is difficult to look into
associations with the dependent variable, which consistency in the use of these services between
includes; children ever born, radio listening frequency, successive births. Secondly, most women might have
marital form and literacy status. Therefore, the study visited the service to get treatment for their health
revealed three common denominators/ variables problem instead of deliberately seeking the ANC
predicting both outcome variables: children ever services.
born, radio listening frequency and literacy status. The utilizations of professional assisted
Women in the age groups 25-34 and 35-49 delivery care and PNC among the study population
are 43 and 62.6 percent less likely to use ANC services wasvery low. With regards to the level of PNC, the
compared to the reference category (younger finding documented that the proportion of the
mothers aged 15-24). Women who gave birth to 4- sample households/children who got complete
6 children were 15.6 % less likely to use the service immunization is very low (only 37.2%) compared
compared to the reference category. Similarly, for to many population groups in Ethiopia. The poor
PNC, those who have 4-6 children were 55.5 % less utilization of delivery and postnatal care service has
likely to attain full immunization. Radio listening often been attributable to the unpredictable onset
frequency (which is presumed to measure exposure of labor, making it difficult for women to travel
to media) has become a significant variable for both long distances as well as some factors associated with
ANC and PNC service utilization. Accordingly, for cost of delivery of care.
ANC service, those who reported listening to radio In view of addressing the second objective,
once in a fortnight and not at all are 73.1 and 6.5 attempt was also made to examine the associations
percent less likely to use the services respectively. between various explanatory variables and the two
Similarly, those who never listened to radio were main study variables (ANC and PNC). The study
24.3 percent less likely to use PNC services. identified six variables for ANC and four variables
Women were asked the reaction they had for PNC with strong significant associations. Three
towards their last born child when they were explanatory variables have become common
pregnant. Accordingly, those who reported “wanted variables influencing both ANC and PNC in the study
to wait” and “did not want to become pregnant at area, namely; literacy status, children ever born, and
all” were 53.8 and 50.8 percent less likely to use the radio listening frequency.
ANC services compared to those women who The age of women and children ever born
wanted the pregnancy to happen. Women who are have followed similar patterns in influencing the ANC
working in formal employment (such as in civil service utilization i.e older and high parity women
services) were 1.96 times more likely to use the ANC are less likely to use the ANC service compared to
services. The literacy status was significantly associated their respective reference categories. The possible
with ANC and PNC service utilization. Illiterate explanation for the low utilization of the services
women were 27.9 and 24.7 percent less likely to use among high parity older women are twofold: such
the ANC and PNC services respectively compared women usually tend to develop confidence due to
to their counterpart literate women. Finally, it was the experience and knowledge accumulated from
seen that those who were engaged in monogamous previous pregnancies and births, and may believe
marital relations were 1.55 times more likely to use that modern health care makes very little difference
the PNC services compared to polygamous ones. in the outcome. Secondly, more difficult labor and
associated complications are believed to occur
Discussions among younger women who are to become
The study was aimed at demonstrating the coverage pregnant for the first time compared to the older
of ANC and PNC, and also examine the key factors and high parity women, and hence, the latter become
predicting the utilization behavior in the study area less motivated to go through the formalities in the
The study has revealed that the level of ANC service health institutions. This result is consistent with
utilization is relatively higher (about 77.4 percent) Mekonnen and Asnakech 14 , Mekonnen 15 and
Sommerfelt16.
African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011 395
The significant relationship between the exposures are the prime determinants of both ANC
women’s reaction to their pregnancy and likelihood and PNC service utilization among the study
of utilizing the ANC service is an important findings population. The implication of this finding is that
of this study. When women feel that their pregnancy unless the local government puts pressure on
is somewhat unwanted or untimely, there is a women’s education and work on behavioral change
likelihood that they develop little motivation to get communications in rural areas, it will be difficult to
ANC and professional delivery assistance. Part of attain the targets for ANC and PNC.
their decline to utilize the services may emanate from The study realised that the rate of complete
denial of the fact that they are pregnant. immunization is far below the WHO’s
There are certain reasons to believe that literate recommended standard. In view of the fact that
women are more prone to using both ANC and immunization is provided free of cost and is usually
PNC. Education is likely to enhance female accessible, failure on the part of the women to use
autonomy and help women develop greater the services can be explained by women and
confidence and capability to make decisions about household level factors discussed above. This calls
their own health. It is also likely that literate women for policymakers and program implementers at
seek out higher quality services and have greater ability grassroots level to consider providing PNC services
to use health care inputs that offer better care14. Kwast at both health facilities and at home to overcome
and Liff 17, in their study of maternal mortality in financial, psychological and cultural barriers to care-
Addis Ababa, showed that women who did not seeking outside the home during the early postnatal
receive maternity care were often poor, illiterate, and period. Finally, it is needless to say that the quality
unmarried, with limited knowledge of maternity care and capacity of the health providers should be
services17 improved overtime through refreshment training
Finally, it is important to mention some of opportunities.
the strengths of the present study so as to clarify the
contexts under which the study was conducted. The Acknowledgement
major strengths are: first, the study was based on a This research is part of the post-doctoral research
large sample (1,094 households/women) selected fellowship, fully sponsored by the third phase
randomly from Sidama zone, Southern Ethiopia, and Norwegian government supported fund. The author
hence its findings can be generalized to the entire would like to express his heart felt gratitude to
population seeking ANC and PNC. Second, unlike Hawassa University-NORAD Project for the
many other previous studies, it has brought both financial support.
factors (ANC and PNC) onto the board and dealt
with the levels and common factors affecting them. References
In view of the fact that many of the studies are 1. Bibha Simkhada, Edwin R. Van Teijlingen,
either national or regional level secondary data analysis, Maureen Porter & Padam Simkhada .Factors
this study is believed to give better insight into the affecting the utilization of antenatal care in
problems at population level. developing countries: systematic review of the
literature. Journal compilation; 2007. Blackwell
Conclusion Publishing Ltd 244-266
On the basis of the information collected from the 2. AbouZahr C. Improve Access to Quality
1,094 eligible households and taking into account all Maternal Health Services. Presentation at Safe
the methodological pitfalls of cross sectional study Motherhood Consultation in Sri Lanka, 18–23 October
design , the present study has come up with the 1997. 1997.
following two plausible conclusions and policy 3. UNICEF State of the World’s children 2006. New
implications; York. United Nations Children’s Fund; (2006).
While women’s utilization of ANC service 4. Peter C. Rockers, Mark L. Wilson E. Godfrey
seems to be good ( about 77 %), a large majority Mbaruku Margaret E. Kruk. Source of
(more than 86 %) of the women are not getting Antenatal Care Influences Facility Delivery in
professional delivery care and instead exercise home Rural Tanzania: A Population-Based Study.
delivery. In relation to this, it is important to Matern Child Health J (2009) 13:879–885
emphasize that educational status and media 5. AbouZahr C, Wardlaw T. Maternal mortality at
the end of a decade: signs of progress? Bulletin
396 African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011
of the World Health Organisation. 2001; 79:561– 11. Central Statistics Authority, CSA. Summary and
568. Statistical Report of the 2007 Population and Housing
6. Ministry of Health (Ethiopia) Health and Health Census Results. Addis Ababa.
Related Indicators, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: Ministry 12. World Health Organization. Health information
of Health. (2007). packages. Geneva; (2003)
7. Central Statistical Agency (CSA) and ORC Macro. 13. World Health Organization (WHO). World report
Ethiopia Demographic and Health Survey 2005, on knowledge for better health: Strengthening health
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: Central Statistical systems. Geneva: World Health Organization;
Agency; and Calverton, MD, USA. (2006). 2004; 1-162
8. Aboubakary Sanou, Seraphin Simboro, Bocar 14. Mekonnen Y, Asnaketch M. Utilization of Maternal
Kouyaté, Marylène Dugas, Janice Graham, and Health Care Services in Ethiopia. Calverton,
Gilles Bibeau. Assessment of factors associated Maryland, USA: ORC Macro; 2002.
with complete immunization coverage in children 15. Mekonnen Y. Barriers to the utilization of
aged 12-23 months: a cross-sectional study in maternity care services in southern
Nouna district, Burkina Faso 2010. Ethiopia:Analysis of the service and user
9. Mengistu M, James J. Determinants of antenatal factors,. 1998. (Unpublished M.Sc. thesis).
care utilization in Arsi Zone, Central Ethiopia. 16. Stewart K, Sommerfelt AE. Utilization of maternity
Ethiopia Journal of Health Development. 1996. care services: A comparative study using DHS data.
(3):171-178. Proceedings of the Demographic and Health
10. Belay T. Correlates of antenatal care attendance Surveys World Conference, Washington, DC.
among women in Yirgalem town and Volume III. (1991); pp. 1645-1668. Columbia,
surrounding peasant associations, Southern Maryland
Ethiopia; 1997 (unpublished M.Sc. thesis). 17 Kwast BE, Liff JM. Factors associated with
maternal mortality in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
International Journal of Epidemiology 1988;
17(1):115-121.

African Health Sciences Vol 11 No 3 September 2011 397


CHAPTER 2 III

Antenatal Care
Ornella Lincetto, Seipati Mothebesoane-Anoh, Patricia Gomez, Stephen Munjanja

Antenatal care (ANC) coverage is a success story in Africa, since over two-thirds
of pregnant women (69 percent) have at least one ANC contact. However, to
achieve the full life-saving potential that ANC promises for women and babies,
four visits providing essential evidence based interventions – a package often
called focused antenatal care – are required. Essential interventions in ANC
include identification and management of obstetric complications such as pre-
eclampsia, tetanus toxoid immunisation, intermittent preventive treatment for
malaria during pregnancy (IPTp), and identification and management of
infections including HIV, syphilis and other sexually transmitted infections (STIs).
ANC is also an opportunity to promote the use of skilled attendance at birth and
healthy behaviours such as breastfeeding, early postnatal care, and planning for
optimal pregnancy spacing.

Many of these opportunities continue to be missed, even though over two-thirds


of pregnant women receive at least one antenatal visit. How can we strengthen
ANC to provide the priority interventions, especially given Africa’s current
critical shortage of human resources for health? Are there particular
barriers or challenges to increasing coverage and quality that could be
overcome? How can the multiple programmes that rely on ANC –
malaria, HIV/AIDS, tetanus elimination, control of STIs – be integrated
and strengthen the “vehicle” of ANC, rather than adding to the current
overload?

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 51


Problem
Good care during pregnancy is important for the health of the mother and the development of the unborn
baby. Pregnancy is a crucial time to promote healthy behaviours and parenting skills. Good ANC links the
woman and her family with the formal health system, increases the chance of using a skilled attendant at
birth and contributes to good health through the life cycle. Inadequate care during this time breaks a
critical link in the continuum of care, and effects both women and babies:
Effects on mothers: It has been estimated that 25 percent of maternal deaths occur during pregnancy,
with variability between countries depending on the prevalence of unsafe abortion, violence, and disease
in the area.1 Between a third and a half of maternal deaths are due to causes such as hypertension
(pre-eclampsia and eclampsia) and antepartum haemorrhage, which are directly related to inadequate
care during pregnancy.2 In a study conducted in six west African countries, a third of all pregnant women
experienced illness during pregnancy, of whom three percent required hospitalisation.3 Certain
pre-existing conditions become more severe during pregnancy. Malaria, HIV/AIDS, anaemia and
malnutrition are associated with increased maternal and newborn complications as well as death where
the prevalence of these conditions is high. New evidence suggests that women who have been subject to
female genital mutilation are significantly more likely to have complications during childbirth, so these
women need to be identified during ANC.4 Gender-based violence and exposure to workplace hazards
are additional and often underestimated public health problems. Rates of depression may be at least as
high, if not higher, in late pregnancy as during the postnatal period.5 Some African societies believe that
grieving for a stillborn child is unacceptable, making the death of a baby during the last trimester of
pregnancy even harder to process and accept.
Effects on babies: In sub-Saharan Africa, an estimated 900,000 babies die as stillbirths during the last
twelve weeks of pregnancy. It is estimated that babies who die before the onset of labour, or antepartum
stillbirths, account for two-thirds of all stillbirths in countries where the mortality rate is greater than 22
per 1,000 births – nearly all African countries.6;7 Antepartum stillbirths have a number of causes, including
maternal infections – notably syphilis – and pregnancy complications, but systematic global estimates for
causes of antepartum stillbirths are not available. 8 Newborns are affected by problems during pregnancy
including preterm birth and restricted fetal growth, as well as other factors affecting the baby’s
development such as congenital infections and fetal alcohol syndrome.
The social, family, and community context and beliefs affect health during pregnancy either positively or
negatively. Some cultures promote special foods and rest for pregnant women, but in others, pregnancy is
not to be acknowledged. In these cases, women continue to work hard, and nutritional taboos may deprive
them of essential nutrients, adding to nutritional deficiencies, particularly iron, protein, and certain vitamins.
In one tribe in Nigeria, pregnant women cannot say they are pregnant, and if they feel unwell, they have to
say that they have “swallowed a cockroach.”
This chapter will outline the ANC package, highlighting the shift to a four-visit model of focused antenatal
care for the majority of women. We describe the current coverage and trends in Africa and explore
opportunities to strengthen antenatal care at the health facility, through outreach and in the community.
Finally, we suggest practical actions to help address key challenges in providing quality care to mothers and
babies during the critical time of pregnancy and integrating the multiple interventions and programmes
targeting this time period.

The package element in this continuum of care is effective ANC. The


goal of the ANC package is to prepare for birth and
Preventing problems for mothers and babies depends on
parenthood as well as prevent, detect, alleviate, or manage
an operational continuum of care with accessible, high
the three types of health problems during pregnancy that
quality care before and during pregnancy, childbirth, and
affect mothers and babies:
the postnatal period. It also depends on the support
• complications of pregnancy itself
available to help pregnant women reach services,
• pre-existing conditions that worsen during pregnancy
particularly when complications occur.9 An important
• effects of unhealthy lifestyles

52 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


and not all developed complications; at the same time, III
some low risk women did develop complications,
particularly during childbirth. Focused or goal oriented
ANC services provide specific evidence-based
interventions for all women, carried out at certain critical
times in the pregnancy. The essential elements of this
package are outlined in Box III.2.1.13;14

ANC also provides women and their families with


appropriate information and advice for a healthy
pregnancy, safe childbirth, and postnatal recovery, BOX III.2.1 The essential elements of a
including care of the newborn, promotion of early, focused approach to antenatal care
exclusive breastfeeding, and assistance with deciding on
future pregnancies in order to improve pregnancy • Identification and surveillance of the pregnant woman
outcomes. An effective ANC package depends on and her expected child
competent health care providers in a functioning health
system with referral services and adequate supplies and • Recognition and management of pregnancy-related
laboratory support. complications, particularly pre-eclampsia

ANC improves the survival and health of babies directly • Recognition and treatment of underlying or concurrent
by reducing stillbirths and neonatal deaths and indirectly illness
by providing an entry point for health contacts with the • Screening for conditions and diseases such as anaemia,
woman at a key point in the continuum of care. A new STIs (particularly syphilis), HIV infection, mental health
analysis done for this publication using previously problems, and/or symptoms of stress or domestic
published methodology 10 suggests that if 90 percent of violence
women received ANC, up to 14 percent, or 160,000
more newborn lives, could be saved in Africa. (See data • Preventive measures, including tetanus toxoid
notes on page 226 for more details) Compared with other immunisation, de-worming, iron and folic acid,
components of maternal, newborn, and child health intermittent preventive treatment of malaria in
(MNCH) packages such as childbirth and postnatal care, pregnancy (IPTp), insecticide treated bednets (ITN)
the additional lives saved is fewer, partly because ANC • Advice and support to the woman and her family for
already has relatively high coverage and saves many lives developing healthy home behaviours and a birth and
already, so the gap between current coverage and full emergency preparedness plan to:
coverage is smaller. However, the benefits of ANC are
greater than mortality reduction alone, and given the o Increase awareness of maternal and newborn
relatively low cost of ANC, this package is among the health needs and self care during pregnancy and the
most cost effective of any public health package.10;11 postnatal period, including the need for social support
during and after pregnancy
ANC indirectly saves the lives of mothers and babies by
promoting and establishing good health before childbirth o Promote healthy behaviours in the home,
and the early postnatal period – the time periods of including healthy lifestyles and diet, safety and injury
highest risk. ANC often presents the first contact prevention, and support and care in the home, such
opportunity for a woman to connect with health as advice and adherence support for preventive
services, thus offering an entry point for integrated care, interventions like iron supplementation, condom use,
promoting healthy home practices, influencing care- and use of ITN
seeking behaviours, and linking women with pregnancy o Support care seeking behaviour, including
complications to a referral system. Women are more likely recognition of danger signs for the woman and the
to give birth with a skilled attendant if they have had at newborn as well as transport and funding plans in
least one ANC visit.12 case of emergencies
Which ANC? While research has demonstrated the o Help the pregnant woman and her partner prepare
benefits of ANC through improved health of mothers emotionally and physically for birth and care of their
and babies, the exact components of ANC and what to baby, particularly preparing for early and exclusive
do at what time have been matters of debate. In recent breastfeeding and essential newborn care and
years, there has been a shift in thinking from the high considering the role of a supportive companion
risk approach to focused ANC. The high risk approach at birth
intended to classify pregnant women as “low risk” or
“high risk” based on predetermined criteria and involved o Promote postnatal family planning/birth spacing
many ANC visits. This approach was hard to implement Source: Adapted from references15;16
effectively since many women had at least one risk factor,

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 53


How many visits? A recent multi-country randomised more likely to keep follow up appointments, ask
control trial led by the WHO17 and a systematic review13 questions about their health, and feel in control of their
showed that essential interventions can be provided over pregnancy. In designing their own ANC records,
four visits at specified intervals, at least for healthy countries should ensure that all essential information is
women with no underlying medical problems.18 The readily available to the caregiver. A prototype form is
result of this review has prompted WHO to define a new included in the new WHO model of ANC, together with
model of ANC based on four goal-oriented visits.13;14;17 the relevant information for implementing quality ANC
This model has been further defined by what is done in services.17 In most sub-Saharan African countries, the
each visit, and is often called focused antenatal care. The ANC record is part of a complete pregnancy record that
optimum number of ANC visits for limited resource covers childbirth and postnatal care as well as family
settings depends not only on effectiveness, but also on planning.
costs and other barriers to ANC access and supply. A
The role of the community: Family and community
recent study from southern Tanzania found that health
involvement is crucial for healthy home behaviours
workers spent an average of 46 minutes providing focused
during pregnancy and has been shown to be a major
ANC to a first time client, and 36 minutes for a revisiting
determinant of use of ANC services. Establishing links
client. This was thirty minutes more on average than the
between the community and the facility can increase
current practice and poses challenges for service delivery.19
utilisation of services, including ANC, and impact
When? For many of the essential interventions in ANC, maternal and neonatal mortality as well as stillbirths.23
it is crucial to have early identification of underlying The male partner or the mother or mother in law should
conditions – for example, prevention of congenital be welcome to attend an ANC session with the woman.
syphilis, control of anaemia, and prevention of malaria Their support can help the woman follow the ANC
complications. Hence the first ANC visit should be as recommendations, encourage shared decision making,
early as possible in pregnancy, preferably in the first and improve the health for both mother and newborn.
trimester. The last visit should be at around 37 weeks or Unsupported pregnant women, especially adolescents,
near the expected date of birth to ensure that appropriate need services that are specifically targeted to their needs.
advice and care have been provided to prevent and Service providers should do all they can to seek out
manage problems such as multiple births (e.g. twins), women unable or unwilling to attend a clinic and take
postmaturity (e.g. birth after 42 weeks of pregnancy, the services to them. Community health workers (CHW)
which carries an increased risk of fetal death), and can play a key role by identifying all pregnant women in
abnormal positions of the baby (e.g. breech, where the the community and provide counselling on healthy
baby’s head is not the presenting part at birth). lifestyles, birth planning, complication readiness, and the
need for ANC and skilled care at birth. This helps create
What? The first assessment in ANC is to distinguish
links between the community and the healthcare system,
pregnant women who require standard care, such as the
and reinforcing these health messages can take some of
four-visit model, from those requiring special attention
the burden off service providers in ANC clinics.
and more visits. Depending on the setting, approximately
25-30 percent of women will have specific risk factors
which require more attention. These women need more
than four visits. Table III.2.1 contains an overview of the
interventions at each ANC visit based on the four-visit
model as applied in focused ANC. Most of the
interventions recommended in the table are supported by
scientific evidence, are low cost, and can be implemented
in first level facilities in all countries in Africa. The
research model used urine dipsticks to check for
bacteriuria at every visit, but this intervention is currently
not included in WHO Pregnancy, Childbirth, Postpartum,
and Newborn Care: a guide to essential practice, which
presents recommendations applicable at the first level of
care.20 In referral hospitals or settings with additional
capacity, however, this intervention may be considered
because of the effect on reducing preterm birth and
neonatal sepsis.10
Records held by women: A number of studies have
shown the benefits of home-based ANC records,
including the plan for birth and emergency
preparedness.21;22 Women who hold their own records are

54 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


TABLE III.2.1 Focused antenatal care (ANC): The four-visit ANC model outlined in WHO clinical
III
guidelines

Goals
First visit Second visit Third visit Fourth visit
8-12 weeks 24-26 weeks 32 weeks 36-38 weeks
Confirm pregnancy Assess maternal Assess maternal and Assess maternal and
and EDD, classify and fetal well-being. fetal well-being. fetal well-being.
women for basic ANC Exclude PIH and Exclude PIH, anaemia, Exclude PIH, anaemia,
(four visits) or more anaemia. multiple pregnancies. multiple pregnancy,
specialized care. Give preventive Give preventive malpresentation.
Screen, treat and give measures. measures. Give preventive
preventive measures. Review and modify Review and modify measures. Review and
Develop a birth birth and emergency birth and emergency modify birth and
and emergency plan. plan. Advise and plan. Advise and emergency plan.
Advise and counsel. counsel. counsel. Advise and counsel.

Activities
Rapid assessment and management for emergency signs, give appropriate treatment, and refer to hospital if needed
History Assess significant Assess significant Assess significant Assess significant
(ask, check symptoms.Take symptoms. Check symptoms. Check symptoms. Check
records) psychosocial, medical record for previous record for previous record for previous
and obstetric history. complications and complications and complications and
Confirm pregnancy treatments during treatments during treatments during
and calculate EDD. the pregnancy. the pregnancy. the pregnancy.
Classify all women (in Re-classification if Re-classification if Re-classification if
some cases after test needed needed needed
results)

Examination Complete general, and Anaemia, BP, Anaemia, BP, Anaemia, BP, fetal
(look, listen, feel) obstetrical fetal growth, and fetal growth, multiple growth and
examination, BP movements pregnancy movements, multiple
pregnancy,
malpresentation

Screening and Haemoglobin Bacteriuria* Bacteriuria* Bacteriuria*


tests Syphilis
HIV
Proteinuria
Blood/Rh group*
Bacteriuria*

Treatments Syphilis Antihelminthic**, ARV if eligible ARV if eligible


ARV if eligible ARV if eligible Treat bacteriuria if If breech, ECV or
Treat bacteriuria if Treat bacteriuria if indicated* referral for ECV
indicated* indicated* Treat bacteriuria if
indicated*

Preventive Tetanus toxoid Tetanus toxoid, Iron and folate Iron and folate
measures Iron and folate+ Iron and folate IPTp ARV
IPTp ARV
ARV

Health Self-care, alcohol and Birth and emergency Birth and emergency Birth and emergency
education, tobacco use, nutrition, plan, reinforcement of plan, infant feeding, plan, infant feeding,
advice, and safe sex, rest, sleeping previous advice postpartum/postnatal postpartum/postnatal
counselling under ITN, birth and care, pregnancy care, pregnancy
emergency plan spacing, reinforcement spacing, reinforcement
of previous advice of previous advice

Record all findings on a home-based record and/or an ANC record and plan for follow-up
Acronyms: (EDD=estimated date of delivery; BP=blood pressure; PIH=pregnancy induced hypertension; ARV=antiretroviral drugs for HIV/AIDS;
ECV= external cephalic version; IPTp=intermittent preventive treatment for malaria during pregnancy; ITN=insecticide treated bednet)
*Additional intervention for use in referral centres but not recommended as routine for resource-limited settings
** Should not be given in first trimester, but if first visit occurs after 16 weeks, it can be given at first visit
+Should also be prescribed as treatment if anaemia is diagnosed

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 55


skilled providers (particularly in rural and remote areas),
lack of standards of care and protocols, few supplies and
drugs, and poor attitudes of health providers. An
assessment conducted in Tanzania found twice as many
poorly qualified health workers in rural facilities than in
urban facilities.27 In addition, there is not wide consensus
on the indicators for quality of ANC care. Possible
indicators include assessment of the coverage of four or
more ANC visits and measurement of the coverage of
essential interventions delivered through ANC, with
attention to missed opportunities – a gap between those
attending and those receiving key interventions for
example syphilis treatment. These are considered in more
detail at the end of this chapter.
Barriers to the access and uptake of ANC are financial
Coverage and trends and cultural. Women and their families incur substantial
In terms of global coverage, ANC is a success story. opportunity costs when ANC requires travel and waiting
Currently, 71 percent of women worldwide receive any long hours. Knowledge about community needs and
ANC; in industrialised countries, more than 95 percent behaviours as well as formal links with the community via
of pregnant women have access to ANC. In sub-Saharan gatekeepers, such as village health committees, is critical,
Africa, 69 percent of pregnant women have at least one especially for strengthening the household-to-hospital
ANC visit, more than in South Asia, at 54 percent. continuum. Replacing user fees with alternative financing
Coverage for ANC is usually expressed as the proportion mechanisms should be seen as an effective first step
of women who have had at least one ANC visit. towards improving access to health care for pregnant
However, coverage of at least four ANC visits is lower at mothers (Section IV). In South Africa, ANC
44 percent, as shown on the country profiles. Trends consultations increased by 15 percent in the years
indicate slower progress in sub-Saharan Africa than in following the removal of user fees on all primary health
other regions, with an increase in coverage of only four care services.28
percent during the past decade.1;24
Inequity in ANC persists. In Africa, 80 percent of women Opportunities to strengthen ANC
in the richest quintile have access to three or more ANC to save mothers and newborns
visits, while only 48 percent of the poorest women have
the same level of access. A similar disparity exists between The high coverage of ANC and repeated contacts
urban and rural women. Within the continuum of care, between the woman and the health services offer many
however, there is a smaller gap between the rich and opportunities for providing evidence based interventions
the poor in ANC than in skilled attendance during likely to affect maternal, fetal, and neonatal health and
childbirth, which is available to only 25 percent of the survival.
poorest women in sub-Saharan Africa, while reaching 1. ANC represents an important entry point for
81 percent of the richest.25 different programmes and provision of integrated care.
Coverage of four or more ANC visits as well as the Pregnancy often represents the first opportunity for a
number of visits disaggregated by trimester is important woman to establish contact with the health system. As
to assess, because the effectiveness of certain ANC Figure III.2.1 illustrates, there is a large gap between a
interventions such as tetanus vaccination, IPTp for single antenatal visit and optimum ANC, which would
malaria, and prevention of mother-to-child transmission require follow up visits and several preventive
(PMTCT) of HIV depend on repeated visits and the interventions. Several conditions that are prevalent in
trimester in which they occur. In Africa, the proportion Africa, such as malaria, STIs, maternal and neonatal
of pregnant women who attended the recommended four tetanus, HIV, tuberculosis (TB), and some nutritional
or more visits increased by six percent over 10 years. deficiencies, can be addressed during ANC care. If not
Similarly, the proportion of women who received ANC in effectively managed, most of these conditions interact
the first six months of pregnancy increased by 10 percent during pregnancy and may worsen pregnancy outcomes,
over 10 years, faster than the increase of overall ANC especially HIV and malaria (Section III.7, 8). Thus,
coverage.26 ensuring the integration of ANC with other programmes
can be particularly beneficial, both for the woman and
Measuring coverage alone does not provide information her baby, who can receive better care, and for the health
on quality of care, and poor quality in ANC clinics, system, as missed opportunities and programme costs can
correlated with poor service utilisation, is common in be reduced.
Africa. This is often related to an insufficient number of

56 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


3. ANC visits provide opportunities to promote lasting III
Missed opportunities to save
FIGURE III.2.1
health, offering benefits that continue beyond the
lives and promote health through antenatal
care in sub-Saharan Africa pregnancy period.
This includes birth preparedness, but also extends to
cover health information and counselling for pregnant
100%
women, their families, and communities. Relevant
information, education, and advice regarding appropriate
75% nutrition and rest, promotion of early and exclusive
breastfeeding and feeding options for HIV-positive
women, smoking cessation, avoidance of alcohol and
50%
drugs, and parenting skills should be made available to
missed
opportunity the woman and family. Guidance on family planning and
25% pregnancy spacing, seeking necessary care, and caring for
the newborn baby are also important components of
69% 54% 58% 10% 1% 1%
0%
ANC.
ANC ANC TT2+ IPTp PMTCT PMTCT
(At least (4 or more (mother) (baby) These interventions integrate prevention and detection of
one visit) visits)
some direct and indirect causes of maternal and newborn
death that begin during pregnancy. Other key areas for
Acronyms: ANC = antenatal care; TT2+ = two or more doses integration are discussed in Box III.2.2. The effectiveness
of tetanus toxoid vaccine given to pregnant women; IPTp = of ANC in reducing mortality depends on successful
intermittent preventive treatment for malaria in pregnancy; PMTCT
= prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV/AIDS integration of services as well as addressing challenges
Source:This figure is part of the profile for sub-Saharan Africa (See such as the availability of a functioning referral system
dates notes on page 226). Country-specific data is available on the and emergency obstetric care services.
46 country profiles.

2. ANC offers an opportunity to develop a birth and


emergency preparedness plan.
WHO recommends that all pregnant women have a
written plan for dealing with birth and any unexpected
adverse events, such as complications or emergencies that
may occur during pregnancy, childbirth, or the
immediate postnatal period. Women should discuss and
review this plan with a skilled attendant at every ANC
assessment and one month before the expected date of
birth.16;17;20 A birth and emergency preparedness plan
includes identification of the following elements: the
desired place of birth; the preferred birth attendant; the
location of the closest appropriate care facility; funds for
birth-related and emergency expenses; a birth companion;
support in looking after the home and children while the
woman is away; transport to a health facility for the birth;
transport in the case of an obstetric emergency; and
identification of compatible blood donors in case of
emergency. Although little evidence exists to show the
direct correlation between birth preparedness and
reducing morbidity or mortality for mothers and babies,
small-scale studies show that there is considerable benefit
to be gained from this intervention. For instance, the
adoption of new practices associated with planning
(such as setting aside money for the birth, transport
arrangements, and the use of a birth plan) at family and
community levels is encouraging. The presence of a
person of the woman’s choice to provide social support
during childbirth has also been shown to have a positive
effect.16;29

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 57


BOX III.2.2 Antenatal care is a vehicle for multiple interventions and

programmes

Prevention of maternal and neonatal tetanus (Section III chapter 9) Tetanus kills an estimated 70,000
newborns in Africa every year (about six percent of all neonatal deaths) and is the cause of an unknown
number of maternal deaths each year. In Africa, neonatal tetanus deaths have been halved during the
1990s, partly due to increased tetanus toxoid immunisation. Seven countries in sub-Saharan African have
eliminated neonatal tetanus. ANC services provide an opportunity to vaccinate pregnant women with the
recommended two doses of tetanus toxoid vaccination. Where ANC coverage is low, or misses certain
populations mass immunisation of women of childbearing age is an alternative option.
Prevention and case management of maternal malaria (Section III chapter 8) In Africa, at least 25 million
pregnancies are threatened by malaria each year, resulting in an estimated 2-15 percent of maternal
anaemia. In areas of high and moderate (stable) malaria transmission, adult women acquire immunity, and
most malaria infections in pregnant women are asymptomatic. Nevertheless, these asymptomatic
infections of the placenta result in anaemia for the mother and contribute to low birthweight (LBW) and
preterm birth, which lead to higher infant mortality and impaired development of the child. Maternal
malaria infection accounts for almost 30 percent of all the causes of LBW that can be prevented during
pregnancy.
In most settings, coverage of intermittent preventive treatment in pregnancy for malaria (IPTp) at
10 percent and insecticide treated bednets (ITN) at 5-23 percent are both significantly lower than
coverage of at least one antenatal visit (see profile for sub Saharan Africa). Hence ANC offers a “vehicle”
to increase coverage of these key interventions. ITN and IPTp are more effective and cheaper than case
management of malaria in pregnancy. However, women should be made aware of the danger signs of
malaria, and ANC providers need the knowledge and skills to treat women with uncomplicated malaria
and refer those with complicated malaria.
Prevention of maternal anaemia and malnutrition (Section III chapter 6) Anaemia affects nearly half of all
pregnant women in the world and is a risk factor for maternal morbidity and mortality. For the mother,
anaemia during pregnancy increases the risk of dying from haemorrhage, a leading cause of maternal
death. Anaemia in pregnancy is also associated with an increased risk of stillbirth, LBW, prematurity, and
neonatal death. In addition to health promotion activities, the strategies for control of anaemia in
pregnancy include iron and folic acid supplementation, de-worming for intestinal infestations, malaria
prevention, improved obstetric care, and management of severe anaemia. Antenatal services can integrate
advice on nutrition including supplementation in settings with micronutrient deficiencies, and can
encourage breastfeeding practices.
Prevention of Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs) and Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV (Section III chapter 7)
Reproductive tract infections such as syphilis, gonorrhoea, and chlamydia can be identified and treated
through ANC. Although estimates vary, at least 50 percent of women with acute syphilis suffer adverse
pregnancy outcomes. The more recent the maternal infection, the more likely the infant will be affected.
Most sub-Saharan African countries have high rates of syphilis infection.WHO recommends that all
pregnant women should be screened for syphilis at the first ANC visit in the first trimester and again in
childbirth. Women testing positive for syphilis should be treated and informed of the importance of being
tested for HIV infection. Their partners should also be treated, and plans should be made to treat their
babies after birth.
Syphilis control in pregnant women through universal antenatal screening and treatment of positive cases
has been established as a feasible and cost effective intervention – syphilis complications are severe, yet
therapy is cheap and effective. Nevertheless, many women attending ANC are not screened or treated for
syphilis, resulting in avoidable stillbirths and neonatal deaths. One important constraint is the lack of

58 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


III
supplies for testing. Simple and effective screening tests for syphilis are now available, which can be used
on site at even the lowest levels of service delivery.30
ANC is the key entry point for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV (PMTCT) services,
though the missed opportunity between the two services is quite large, as shown on the country
profiles in this publication and in Figure III.2.1. To increase the number of women who are tested, many
countries have adopted the “opt-out system,” whereby all pregnant women are offered counselling and
testing during ANC. Despite current low levels of coverage, strong political commitments, increased
resources allocated to PMTCT, and increased focus on integrated care from the same provider all
represent good opportunities for strengthening ANC, particularly birth preparedness, use of skilled
attendants at birth, and information and counselling on infant feeding options.
Additional ANC interventions Other effective interventions that can be added to ANC require a higher level
of health system complexity but have been shown to improve maternal and/or neonatal health and
survival. These include calcium supplementation in settings with low calcium intake, treatment of
bacteriuria, antenatal steroids for preterm labour, and antibiotics for prolonged rupture of membranes.
These are becoming available in teaching hospitals and private ANC clinics.

Challenges staff in the absence of incentives. Additionally, lack of


up-to-date standards and protocols, poorly defined roles
To respond to the needs of pregnant women, ANC must
among programmes or staff, and weak monitoring
address multiple conditions directly or indirectly related
systems contribute to low quality ANC. Poor regulatory
to pregnancy, including malaria, nutrition deficiencies,
mechanisms or insufficient capacity to enforce regulations
STIs, HIV, and TB. ANC should also provide required
contribute to the difficulty in assessing quality of care in
information and advice on pregnancy, childbirth, and the
public and private ANC clinics. Establishing and
postnatal period, including newborn care. The most
sustaining a functional health system that can provide
effective way to do this is through integration of
universal coverage of quality ANC (at least four visits at
programmes and availability of health care providers with
the correct times during pregnancy) is a challenge for
a wide range of skills. But integration is easier to say than
many countries in Africa.
to do and adding more interventions has implications for
this programme which is often already overloaded and Human resources are a major challenge. Deployment of
under funded (See Section IV). staff to rural areas can be a real difficulty, particularly
where there are not economic or career incentives to
While lack of infrastructure affects ANC less than other
deploy and retain staff in less favourable conditions. Staff
services along the continuum of care, ANC shares with
may not have the required skills to provide all
other components overarching challenges that are
components of ANC or may not receive the support they
influenced by supply and demand: general health system
need. ANC can be the platform to support special groups
weaknesses and social, economic, and cultural barriers.
such as adolescents, female victims of domestic violence,
Supply factors and single mothers, among others, as these groups have a
Many countries are struggling to achieve quality ANC higher risk of stillbirth, preterm birth, low birthweight
provision, particularly in rural and peri-urban areas. (LBW), and child abandonment and neglect. However,
Competition for staff and money as well as poor this is difficult for a lot of already overburdened ANC
communication with other programmes or components providers, who often struggle just to provide the basic
(malaria, HIV, emergency obstetric care) can be found at health promotion messages with limited resources and
different levels of the health system, particularly where heavy caseloads. A recent study found that providing
policies are ill defined. National and sub-national level focused ANC was thirty minutes more on average than
health budgets may be too small and heavily dependent the current practice.The time required for each focused
on donor funding. As a relatively low-profile service, ANC visit has implications for staffing levels and
ANC may not receive enough funding. Low managerial opportunity costs for both clinics and the women
capacity is common at district level, and poorer districts attending.19 Some practical steps to anticipate and avoid
may face difficulties in raising the funds for conducting this overload are detailed below.
essential ANC activities or in attracting and retaining

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 59


Shortage of supplies, drugs and basic equipment can and communities may underestimate the importance of
compromise the quality of care, motivation of staff, and ANC. In addition, many may simply lack knowledge
the utilisation of services. Weak health referral systems to about danger signs in pregnancy and will not know how
support case management of complications of pregnancy to seek care when a complication occurs during
inevitably reduces the overall impact of ANC. pregnancy. Finally, a lack of awareness exists about the
extent and impact of traditional household and
Social, economic, and cultural barriers
community beliefs and customs, such as suboptimal
ANC coverage is lower among women who need it the
maternal nutrition and infant feeding practices. The
most: those who are poor, less educated, and living in
attitudes and behaviours of health care providers in ANC
rural areas. An important barrier is the inability to pay for
clinics compound this problem by failing to respect the
ANC or the treatment prescribed in ANC, where user
privacy, confidentiality, and traditional beliefs of the
fees are in place and safety nets for the poor do not exist.
women. This may negatively influence the use of ANC as
Conflict or poor communication among formal health
well as MNCH services at large.
care providers, traditional birth attendants (TBA) and
other CHWs may be the cause of low utilisation of ANC Box III.2.3 gives the example of Tanzania moving
services in certain communities. As pregnancy is forward to strengthen ANC.
perceived as a natural process of life, women, families

BOX III.2.3 Scaling up focused antenatal care within the health system in Tanzania

Tanzania, with support from partners has developed a national package of essential reproductive and child
health interventions as a part of health sector reform to strengthen maternal and newborn health. One key
component is focused antenatal care (ANC) such as intermittent preventive treatment for malaria in
pregnancy (IPTp), nutritional counselling and supplementation, and screening and management of syphilis.
Over 90 percent of pregnant women in Tanzania attend at least one antenatal visit, yet coverage drops for
the essential interventions that can be delivered with more ANC visits and continuity of care. A number of
partners are working together to address the multi-sectoral task of increasing availability and demand for
focused ANC services. Three strategies used to reduce maternal and newborn morbidity and mortality are
policy and advocacy, capacity building, and quality and performance improvement.
Policy and advocacy: A collaborative process was undertaken to develop and disseminate necessary
guidelines outlining key reproductive and child health activities, necessary inputs to undertake these
activities, and expected outputs for each level of the health services delivery system. These provided the
foundation to define desired performance and quality targets. Registration forms used during ANC visits have
been adapted, and in-service training and pre-service education curricula have been standardised to develop
the ANC skills of a core group of trainers.
Capacity building: Capacity building was undertaken including development of educational materials and
building the capacity of pre-service faculty and in-service trainers to update student and provider knowledge
for the skills necessary to provide ANC services.
Quality and performance Improvement: Factors affecting performance were identified within facilities
and by community partners in four Tanzanian districts early in 2001. These findings guided interdisciplinary
teams of key stakeholders, including district and regional health management teams, to identify service gaps.
Based on the gaps identified, priorities were agreed and targeted interventions implemented focusing on a
range of performance factors such as supervision; knowledge and skills; motivation; and availability of key
resources, supplies and equipment. Facilities meeting quality standards will ultimately receive accreditation,
thereby generating greater community demand for their services. Ongoing in-service training and replication
of this initiative will ensure sustainability and long-term results.
These activities are currently supported by the ACCESS program, led by JHPIEGO
Source: Adapted from reference 31

60 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


Practical steps for strengthening 4. Harmonise activities by multiple partners through III
antenatal care effective partnership
A number of regional and national strategies offer
Given the challenges outlined above, efforts to strengthen opportunities to strengthen programmes in countries.
ANC in order to achieve better maternal and newborn Professional associations and non-governmental
health are listed below. organisations involved with women and children should
1. Establish or strengthen national policies be sensitised on the importance of ANC within the
A national policy and locally adapted guidelines must be continuum of care.
in place to protect the rights of all women, regardless of 5. Reduce barriers to accessing care and reach out to women
their socioeconomic status or place of residence, to access without access
ANC services. There is a need for evidence-based Utilisation of ANC services should be encouraged by
guidelines at the national level detailing the essential reducing barriers to access, such as user fees, limited
minimum components of ANC, in line with the country opening hours, long travel distances and waiting times,
epidemiological profile and country priorities and based and dehumanisation of care.
on WHO guidelines and recommendations.
Strategies should be developed for empowering
2. Strengthen the quality of ANC services communities to overcome obstacles to care and reach
This includes promoting evidence based guidelines and the missing 30 percent of women not receiving ANC.
standards for focused ANC: These may include using community channels to identify
• Training should be reviewed to incorporate focused pregnant women, targeting those more likely to be non-
antenatal care protocols and new competences (on-site users, such as adolescents and women who are poor and
RPR tests for syphilis, IPTp and ITN, ARVs, single, and making the services more responsive to the
counselling skills, setting and auditing standards). Staff needs of women.
should rotate between services. The attitude and 6. Use data effectively to monitor and improve ANC
motivation of health care providers is crucial. coverage and quality
• Time for service delivery. In some countries where many Data do exist, particularly from Demographic and Health
women attend ANC more than four times, the visits Surveys, and health management information systems,
saved by reverting to four visits would allow for longer, but it is not always effectively used by policy makers and
high quality content at each visit. In addition, some programmers to improve quality of care (See Section I).
tasks could be delegated to other cadres, for example, The country profiles in this publication indicate such
paperwork and weighing could be delegated to more missed opportunities in ANC as the gap between
administrative staff, saving the time of more senior staff pregnant women receiving one and four ANC visits.
for skilled, higher impact tasks. Such delegation may Citing other missed opportunities, such as the gap
require some policy changes. In addition, women’s in access to care between the rich and poor can
groups and CHW can be valuable in giving this supply evidence to advocate for more resources and
counselling in the community, along with regular input, improve care.
supervision, and appropriate referral services from
skilled care providers at the health care facility level.
• Supplies and logistics are an important aspect of
effective ANC, including regular availability of syphilis
and HIV testing kits and essential drugs and
equipment.
• Quality improvement approaches and tools help
identify and overcome local constraints to providing
client-orientated, effective ANC and ensure that women
return after their first ANC visit.
3. Improve integration with other programmes
To maximise opportunities for pregnant women, ANC
services should take advantage of existing programmes,
especially those with outreach activities targeting women
of childbearing age. This is especially important in
settings where ANC coverage is low. National strategies
for malaria, HIV, syphilis, and nutrition need to be better
integrated into ANC.

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 61


BOX III.2.4 Indicators for antenatal care

• Proportion of pregnant women who have at least one antenatal clinic visit #
• Proportion of pregnant women who have at least four ANC visits
• Tetanus protection at birth*
• The percentage of pregnant women who receive IPTp for malaria according to the national protocol of IPTp
• Antiretroviral course for PMTCT of HIV*
• Prevalence of syphilis in pregnant women#
• The proportion of pregnant women with a written birth and emergency plan by 37 weeks of pregnancy
*Key newborn and child indicators in Countdown to 2015 Child Survival process
#
Core WHO reproductive health indicators
For complete list of indicators, see Section IV.

Possible indicators to improve programmatic monitoring


of ANC are highlighted in Box III.2.4 and include
coverage of four or more ANC visits and coverage of key
ANC interventions (tetanus vaccination, IPTp, testing
and treatment for syphilis, and PMTCT, iron and folate
supplementation, de-worming). Process indicators will
vary with the specific programme but may include the
competency of the staff to treat maternal complications
and perform newborn resuscitation, availability of basic
equipment, laboratory test, drugs and supplies,
implementation of health promotion activities, clinic
open hours, record keeping; respect of privacy and
confidentiality, and implementation of infection control
procedures. Process indicators should also assess the
quality of communication, such as the proportion of
pregnant women with a written birth and emergency plan
by 37 weeks of pregnancy. Priority actions for strengthening
antenatal care
Conclusion • Improve quality of ANC services
ANC in Africa has reached more than two thirds of
o Revise in-service and pre-service training for
pregnant women, with reported increases in the coverage
ANC providers to include the essential
of the recommended four ANC visits and increases in the
coverage of a first trimester ANC visit. Multiple vertical components and new competencies required
programmes rely on ANC to deliver their interventions, o Improve supplies and logistics
representing both a challenge and an opportunity. As a
critical link in the continuum of care, ANC offers • Develop linkages with other programmes,
tremendous opportunities to reach a large number of especially traditionally vertical interventions, such
women and communities with effective clinical and as malaria and HIV
health promotion interventions. However, inequity exists,
• Harmonise activities through effective
and young, rural, poor, and less educated women may
not benefit from ANC services or may drop out due to partnership
access barriers and low quality services. Efforts to • Reduce barriers to accessing care and reach out
strengthen ANC should focus on universal coverage by to women not accessing care
addressing financial and cultural barriers to reaching
vulnerable groups, quality improvement to increase • Make better use of data to monitor and improve
women's satisfaction and reduce drop out, and ANC coverage and quality
integration of programmes to maximise the contact
between the woman and the health services.

62 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


12
Understanding Intranatal Care
through Mortality Statistics
Marjorie Tew

A fund of statistics on perinatal mortality and place of birth, reliable by any


standards, is provided by national perinatal surveys of 1958 (Butler and
Bonham, 1963) and 1970 (Chamberlain et ai., 1978), which were conducted
under the aegis of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, and
the official annual returns on stillbirths of the Registrar General and Office of
Population Censuses and Surveys. They make it possible to evaluate
objectively the basis for the official policy for the maternity services, the aim of
which is that all births should take place in the larger obstetric hospitals.
The proportion of births taking place in hospitals has been increasing
ever since the British College of Obstetricians was formed in 1929.
Recommendations in 1959 and 1970 by the Cranbrooke and Peel Committees,
whose most influential members were obstetricians, and in 1980 by the House
of Commons Social Services Committee, whose most influential advisers
were obstetricians, merely gave authoritative endorsement to the existing
trend.
As justification for the recommendations, obstetricians claim not simply
that the risk of death for infants and mothers is much lower in obstetric
hospitals than anywhere else, but indeed that this advantage is so great that it
should without question override any disadvantages, such as the distress it
may cause to mothers or the postnatal morbidity, physiological or psycho-
logical, which mothers or infants may sutTer as a result.
To any disinterested and open-minded observer this would seem a
surprising claim, for crude mortality rates for mothers and infants have
always, with an exception which will be considered later, been much higher in
obstetric hospitals than in general practitioner maternity units (GPUs) or at
home. However, to explain this apparent paradox, obstetricians have
successfully propagated as established fact several convenient assumptions
which, on investigation, prove to be invalid.

L. Zander et al. (eds.), Pregnancy Care for the 1980s


© The Royal Society of Medicine 1984
106 Pregnancy Care for the 1980s

EXCESS IN HOSPITAL OF BIRTHS AT HIGH RISK

One such assumption is that the excess mortality in hospital can be more than
accounted for by the fact that births there include most of those at highest risk.
However, this explanation does not survive the test of simple arithmetic, for
the mortality rate of any group of births is the sum of the contributions of its
subgroups, each of which is the product of two factors-its specific mortality
rate and the proportion of all births included in it. To test the validity of the
alleged explanatory assumption, both these factors in each subgroup have to
be quantified. If realistic figures are used, it is not arithmetically possible to
account for the actual difference observed between mortality rates in obstetric
hospitals, on the one hand, and GPUs and home, on the other.
For example, one category of risk relates to certain maternal characteristics
known during pregnancy. In the 1970 survey (Chamberlain et al., 1978) births
at each place of delivery were classified according to an antenatal prediction
score which quantified the cumulative effect of all such predicted risk factors
(Tew, 1979). Births at high and moderate risk made up 9 and 44 %,
respectively, of those in hospital, but only 3 and 30 %of those in GPUs and
home together. Overall the perinatal mortality rates (PNMR) in the low-,
moderate- and high-risk groups were in the ratio 1: 1.69:2.84. Assuming that
these ratios obtained in each place and given the actual PNMR per 1000 births
of 27.8 in hospital and 5.4 in GPU /home, the implicit specific rates for each
risk group must have been over four times higher in hospital (table 12.1). Since
the specific PNMR for low-risk births in hospital was itself much higher than
for high-risk births in GPU /home, no excess of births at high predicted risk,
however great, could possibly explain the excess in the hospitals' overall
PNMR.

Table 12.1. Perinatal mortahty rates by predicted risk group (1970 Perinatal Survey)

Predicted Hospital GPMUjhome


nsk group
Proportion PNMRjlOOO Proportion PNMRjlOOO
of births births Product of births births Product

High 0.09 53.7 4.8 0.03 12.1 0.3


Moderate 0.44 32.0 14.1 0.30 7.2 2.2
Low 0.47 18.9 8.9 0.67 4.3 2.9

All 1.00 27.8 27.8 1.00 5.4 5.4

Similar conclusions result from a corresponding analysis of the 1970 survey


data on infant birth weight (Tew, 1981). With 9 %of births in hospital and 3 %
in GPU /home weighing 2500 g or less and with the overall PNMR for these
low-weight births 25 times that for normal-weight births, the implicit specific
PNMR in hospital in both the high-risk (220.0) and low-risk (8.8) groups
Original Contribution

Practice of Intranatal Care and Characteristics of Mothers in a Rural


Community
*Saklain MA,1 Haque AE,2 Sarker MM3

In Bangladesh due to limited number of maternal and child health (MCH) based family planning
(FP) facilities located in rural area and other socio-economic factors, practice of intranatal care at
home is still higher than institutional based. This descriptive study was carried out with the
objective of exploring the practice of intranatal care and its associated factors in Puthia Upazilla
under Rajshahi district. Data were collected from 418 respondents residing in different villages of
Puthia Upazilla. Simple random sampling technique was adopted to select the respondents. It was
found that majority of the respondents (46.9%) were in age group 20-24 years and majority
(50.5%) respondents had home delivery and 49.5% had hospital delivery during their last child
birth. It showed that institutional delivery is higher (49.5%) than that of other parts of the country.
It indicates people became aware about the need for safe delivery, thus utilize MCH care from the
nearby health care facility. The study revealed that in case of home delivery, 92.4% literate women
was attended by trained traditional birth attendant (TBA) during their last delivery. On the other
hand among the illiterate group, it was only 6.6%. About 71% respondents told that hospital
delivery is better but 86% respondents told it is costly for them. To achieve health related
millennium development goal (MDG's) there is need to develop skilled health personnel related to
antenatal and intranatal care with giving value on socio cultural practice of intranatal care in rural
areas. Effective supervision and monitoring of the on going programme and active participation of
people can improve the MCH based FP service in rural area.

[Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4 (2):71-76]

Key words: Antenatal care, intranatal care, birth attendant, home delivery, hospital delivery

Introduction one quarter to one half of total death among

M ore than half a million (5,29,000)


women in the world die every year
from causes related to pregnancy and
child birth.1 Global observation shows that in
the women of reproductive age group. Most
of the deliveries in rural Bangladesh are
attended by untrained TBA and relatives at
home. National figures indicate that only 13%
developed regions maternal mortality ratio of the deliveries are conducted by trained
averages at 13 per 100000 live births; in TBA or midwifes.2 With the view, for
developing regions the figure is 440 for the reduction of maternal and perinatal mortality
same number of live birth. Between 11 to 17 and morbidity in recent years different
percent of maternal death happen during child strategies were developed, these are training
birth itself. Bangladesh is a country of 140 of birth attendants, improvements of MCH
million people. Among them 24 million are service, risk approach, emergency obstetric
women aged 15 to 49 years. The number of care (EOC) and the need for community
pregnant women at any point of time is participation an idea of a new strategy has
around 3.8 million and currently 21,000 been evolved. The strategy is called Meeting
women die every year due to causes related to the Community half way.3
pregnancy and child birth which contribute
1. *Dr. Md. Azam Saklain, Lecturer, Department .of Pathology, Dinajpur Medical College.
2. Dr AKM Enamul Haque, Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine, Jessore Medical College.

Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4(2) 71


Original Contribution

3. Professor Dr. Md. Abdul Mukit Sarker, Department of Community Medicine, Rajshahi Medical College.
*For correspondence
In February 1987, the Safe Motherhood face interview using a designed questionnaire.
Conference was held in Nairobi, Kenya gave Data were analyzed by using SPSS programme.
rise to a global programme "Safe Motherhood Result
Initiatives". Its goal is to reduce maternal About the distribution of respondents by age,
death to at least half by 2000. Safe it was revealed from the study that the
Motherhood Initiative place special emphasis majority of the respondents [196 (46.9%)]
on the female education and improvement of were in age group 20-24 years. Another
the status of women and the need for better important age group was 25-29 years that
and more widely available maternal health constituted 32.3% of total respondents. The
services.4 proportion of respondents aged 40years and
above (0.5%) was not significant (Table I).
Now MCH and FP viewed as an essential Regarding age of the respondents it was
component of primary health care. The study calculated that the mean age was 24.35 years,
regarded as a vital step towards achieving the median 24 yrs and mode 20 yrs. SD of age of
goal to improve maternal health by reducing the women was 4.2
maternal mortality three quarters between
1990 and 2015 according to health related Table I: Age distribution of the respondents
MDG. Most of the problems suffered by the
women particularly during pregnancy and Frequency
Age in years
childbirth are preventable. This descriptive N %
15-19 35 8.4
study was carried out with the objective of
20-24 196 46.9
exploring the practice of intranatal care and 25-29 135 32.3
its associated factors in a rural community in 30-34 40 9.6
Bangladesh. 35-39 10 2.4
≥40 2 0.5
Total 418 100.0
Methods
It was a cross-sectional type of descriptive
study carried out among the mothers who
have at least one child aged one year in
different villages of Puthia Upazilla under Table II: Respondents’ educational level
Rajshahi district. Puthia Upazilla consists of
Frequency
six Unions. The respondents were selected Educational status
N %
from all Unions for the present study. Sample Illiterate 52 12.4
size of the study was 418. A sampling frame Primary 154 36.8
was prepared for each Union and it included Secondary 166 39.7
all the mothers of the respective Unions who SSC 18 4.3
HSC 19 4.5
had given birth to baby in the previous year. Graduate and above 9 2.2
The researcher took help from Health Total 418 100.0
Assistant (HA) and Family Welfare Assistant
(FWA) in preparing the sampling frame for Regarding educational status of the
each Union. Simple random sampling respondents in the study area, it was revealed
technique was applied to select respondent that majority [154 (36.8%)] had primary
from each Union using the Union sampling education and 166 (39.7%) had secondary
frame.The data were collected through face to education. The literacy rate was 87.6%. The

Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4(2) 72


Original Contribution

number of illiterate respondents was 52 statistically significant. (x2 = 10.16, P = 0.001,


(12.4%) (Table II). df = 1).

Table II: Respondents received ANC in last Table V: Distribution of respondents by place
pregnancy and their educational level of delivery and received ANC

Educational level Antenatal Care


Total
Received ANC Illiterate Literate Place of Not Total
Received
N % N % N % delivery received
Yes 39 10.3 341 89.7 380 90.0 N % N % N %
No 13 34.2 25 65.8 38 9.1 Home 186 88.2 25 11.8 211 50.5
Total 52 12.4 366 87.6 418 100.0 Hospital 194 93.7 13 6.3 207 49.5
Total 380 90.9 38 9.1 418 100.0
x2 = 18.19 P = 0.000 df = 1
x2 = 3.920 P = 0.048 df = 1
Regarding receive of ANC in last pregnancy
and level of education of the respondents in In the context of distribution of respondents
the study area, it was revealed that most of the by received ANC and place of delivery, it was
respondents [341 (89.7%)] who received found that out of 418 respondents, 211
ANC were literate. Among the illiterate (50.5%) had home delivery and 207 (49.5%)
mothers, 39 (10.3%) went for ANC. The had hospital delivery. Compared to hospital
relationship between receive of ANC among delivery, the proportion of women was 11.8%
the women and level of education was who had home delivery did not receive ANC
statistically significant (Table III). and in case of hospital delivery majority [194
(93.7%)] women received ANC (Table V).
Table IV: Distribution of respondents by The association between received ANC by the
place of delivery and education of the mothers women and place of delivery was statistically
significant (x2 = 3.92, P = 0.048, df = 1).
Place of Educational level
Total
delivery of Illiterate Literate Table VI: Distribution of respondents by birth
last baby N % N % N % attendant at home with educational level
Home 37 17.5 174 82.5 211 50.4
delivery
Educational level
Hospital 15 7.24 192 92.7 207 49.5 Birth Total
Illiterate Literate
delivery attendant
N % N % N %
Total 52 12.44 366 87.55 418 100.0
Trained 5 7.57 61 92.42 66 31.27
x2 = 10.16 P = 0.001 df = 1
TBA
Untrained 32 22.06 113 77.93 145 68.72
About the relationship between place of TBA
delivery of respondents and education Table Total 37 17.53 174 82.46 211 100.00
IV shows that 211 (50.4% women had home
delivery. Among them 174 (82.5%) were x2 = 6.58 p < 0.05 df = 1
literate and a good number of respondents 37
(17.5%) were illiterate. 207 (49.5%) Regarding distribution of respondents by birth
respondents had hospital delivery. Most of attendant at home and education it was found
them [192 (92.7%)] were literate and a few 15 that majority of women (92.42%) who
(7.24%) were illiterate. From this study, it preferred trained TBA as their birth attendant
was found that the association between place were literate. Among illiterate women
of delivery of the women and education was majority birth attendants were untrained TBA

Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4(2) 73


Original Contribution

86.48% (Table VI). In this study, relationship that the hospital service is poor in quality.
between birth attendants at home of the There is lack of medicine and hospital staffs
women and education was statistically behave improperly complained by the
significant. (x2=6.58 p < 0.05 df = 1). mothers (Table VIII).

Discussion
Table VII: Distribution of respondents by The total number of respondents was 418.
birth attendant at hospital with educational Regarding age distribution of the women in
level the study area, it was revealed that majority
(49.9%) were in the 20-24 years age group.
Educational level The mean age was 24.35 years and standard
Total
Birth attendant Illiterate Literate
N % N % N % deviation ± 4.2 and age distribution of women
Doctor 6 5.3 107 94.7 113 54.6 aged 15-49 years (Table I). In this study
Nurse 8 9.0 81 91.0 89 43.0 respondents in 20-24 years age group was
Others 1 20.0 4 80.0 5 2.4 higher because of in our country this group
Total 15 7.2 192 92.8 207 100.0 women is more fertile.
x2 = 2.243 P = 0.326 df = 2
Regarding educational status of the
respondents, it was found that proportion of
Regarding distribution of respondents by birth
literate women was higher 87.6% than that of
attendant at hospital and education, it was
other parts of the country. It does not coincide
found that majority of women [107 (94.7%)]
with our national level of literacy rate
were attended by doctor as their birth
(68.3%) in 2004.5 It is quite encouraging
attendants were literate. Among the illiterate
because education plays a vital role in a
women, in hospital delivery nurses were
society to have 'healthy mother and healthy
higher in proportion (9%) as birth attendants
baby’.
(Table VII).
Practice of intranatal care was related with
Table VIII: Distribution of reasons for not
ANC in every respect. It was revealed that out
preferring hospital delivery (n =122)
of 418, 90.9% women received ANC and
Frequency
9.1% told that they did not go for ANC in last
Reasons not prefer hospital delivery pregnancy. It was due to fact that people were
N %
Costly 105 86 more conscious about the safe delivery and
Lack of medicine supply 23 18.8 motivational work by the family planning
Female doctor not available 41 33.6 workers was satisfactory in the study area and
Hospital service poor 25 20.4
health complex was nearer to the people.
Do not behave properly 3 2.45

Among the mothers who received ANC, most


Opinion was sought from the respondents
(89.7%) of them were literate. It indicated that
regarding hospital ‘not better for delivery’. It
literate people were more conscious about
was found that out of 122 respondents
health care and receiving ANC. The
majority (86%) respondents told it was costly
relationship between education and receive of
for them to go for delivery in the hospital. A
ANC by the pregnant women was statistically
good number of respondents (33.6%) did not
significant (x2 = 18.19, P = 0.000, df = 1) in
choose hospital for delivery due to non-
the study. (Table III).
availability of female doctors as attendants. It
was also found that 20.4% respondents told

Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4(2) 74


Original Contribution

It was revealed that 90.9% respondents The respondents who had their delivery at
received ANC and only 9.1% did not receive hospital and several other institutes, almost
ANC. Among the ANC receiver, most were (93.7%) all of the women received ANC. On
primi (95.2%). It proved that the primigravida the other hand compared to hospital delivery,
mothers were more conscious about their 11.8% women had home delivery who did not
health. receive ANC (Table V). The relationship
between place of delivery and receive of ANC
The chief objective of the study was to find in this study was statistically significant (x2 =
out the practice of intranatal care by the rural 3.92, P = 0.048, df = 1). It indicated that the
women. Among the study group majority of pregnant women who received ANC
the respondents (50.5%) had home delivery perceived well about the safe delivery at
and rest (49.5%) of female took hospital hospital and thereby preferred institutional
delivery. delivery.

There is a relationship between the place of There is a scope to counsel the pregnant
delivery and level of education. From the women about need for safe delivery at
present study it was found that among the hospital during ANC visits. The high
respondents who took hospital delivery, percentage of utilization of hospital service at
92.7% were literate and 7.24% were illiterate the time of delivery among the ANC
where as in case of home delivery. 82.5% recipients indicates the effectiveness and
were literate and 17.5% were illiterate. justification of ANC for the pregnant women.
Relationship between two variable was
statistically significant (x2 = 10.16, P = 0.001, There is a strong association between level of
df = 1) (Table IV). It contains the evidence education and birth attendants. In case of
that home deliveries were more prevalent home delivery, 68.72% women were attended
among illiterate people. The educated people by untrained TBA and among them 77.93%
prefer institutional delivery. As the level of were literate where as 31.27% women were
education progress the rate of institutional attended by trained TBA in which 92.42%
delivery increases. In another study conducted were literate (Table VI). The relationship
by Lubna Ahmed in 1995, a case study in between birth attendant at home with level of
London on Bangladeshi immigrants showed education in this study was statistically
that out of 88, one was delivered at home and significant (x2= 6.58, p < 0.05, df = 1).
rest 87 delivered in hospital. This report is not
mimic with the reports of present study.6 Regarding hospital delivery, 54.6% women
were attended by doctor and large number
From the study, it was revealed that the (94.7%) of them was educated (Table VII).
people of higher socioeconomic condition According to study it showed that educated
preferred institutional delivery to home people were more interested to be attended by
delivery. Large number of people of this doctor. In order to perform safe delivery and
country can not bear the expenditure of reduce the MMR by 2015 at 1.43% people
institutional delivery. It is one of the causes of should be motivated to report to the hospital
high rate of home delivery in this country. at the time of delivery. In developing
Unsafe home delivery is responsible for high countries maternal mortality ratio is 20 times
maternal death. So the socioeconomic higher than developed countries. The life
condition of the rural people to be improved. time risk of dying from the pregnancy related
complications for a women of developing

Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4(2) 75


Original Contribution

country is one in 11 compared to one in 500 6. A study on the "Attitude of pregnant


in developed countries.7 women regarding hospital delivery in a
PHC- intensified thana; NIPSOM. 1996
Conclusion 7. D. C. Dutta, Text book of obstetrics;
The objective of the present study was to Safe Motherhood, Epidemiology of
explore the practice of intranatal care and Obstetrics. Sixth edition – 599.
associated factors of mothers in a rural
community. It was revealed form the study
that out o 418 respondents, majority 50.5%
delivered their baby at home. Among them
88.2% received ANC and 82.5% were literate.
From the study 49.5% respondents who had
institutional delivery, 93.7% received ANC
and 92.7% were literate. Regarding birth
attendants at home delivery out of 211
mothers, majority (47.9%) were attended by
relatives and 28.9% by trained TBA. Trained
TBA was higher (92.4%) as birth attendant
among literate population. It indicates that
education has positive influence on taking
help from trained health personnel. Regarding
hospital delivery out of 207 respondents study
showed that educated people (94.7%) were
more conscious to be attended by doctor. It is
expensive to have delivery at hospital
mentioned by 86% women. It indicated that a
fixed amount of financial support or medicine
for the women during hospital delivery would
make them interest to go to hospital for safe
delivery.

References
1. Maternal Mortality: the Global Fact
book. The global picture. Geneva.
WHO.1991 6-10
2. Statistical pocket book of Bangladesh
2006 (BBS)
3. Emergency Obstetric care, obstetrical
and Gynecological Society of
Bangladesh. UNICEF. Sept. 1993.
4. Safe Motherhood from Advocacy to
Action. Finance and Development, issue
7, Nov 1991.
5. Statistical pocket book of Bangladesh
2006 (BBS)

Dinajpur Med Col J 2011 Jul; 4(2) 76


CHAPTER 4 III

Postnatal care
Charlotte Warren, Pat Daly, Lalla Toure, Pyande Mongi

Every year in Africa, at least 125,000 women and 870,000 newborns die in the
first week after birth, yet this is when coverage and programmes are at their
lowest along the continuum of care. The first day is the time of highest risk
for both mother and baby. The fact that 18 million women in Africa currently
do not give birth in a health facility poses challenges for planning and
implementing postnatal care (PNC) for women and their newborns.
Regardless of place of birth, mothers and newborns spend most of the
postnatal period (the first six weeks after birth) at home.

Postnatal care (PNC) programmes are among the weakest of all


reproductive and child health programmes in the region. How can we
increase the coverage of integrated maternal and newborn care in the
postnatal period? What does PNC include, when and where can it be
provided, and by whom? How can we operationalise, improve, and sustain
linkages between homes and hospitals? How can PNC be integrated with
existing strategies and programmes, especially childbirth care, Integrated
Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI), nutrition promotion, prevention of
mother-to-child transmission of HIV and immunisation?
Problem
The postnatal period – defined here as the first six weeks after birth – is critical to the health and survival
of a mother and her newborn. The most vulnerable time for both is during the hours and days after birth.
Lack of care in this time period may result in death or disability as well as missed opportunities to promote
healthy behaviours, affecting women, newborns, and children:
Effects on women: Half of all postnatal maternal deaths occur during the first week after the baby is
born, and the majority of these occur during the first 24 hours after childbirth.1 The leading cause of
maternal mortality in Africa – accounting for 34 percent of deaths – is haemorrhage, the majority of which
occurs postnatally. Sepsis and infection claim another 10 percent of maternal deaths, virtually all during the
postnatal period.2 HIV-positive mothers are at greater risk of postnatal maternal death than HIV-negative
women.3 Access to family planning in the early postnatal period is also important, and lack of effective PNC
contributes to frequent, poorly spaced pregnancies (Section III chapter 1). This is a stressful time for new
mothers, so emotional and psychosocial support should be available to reduce the risk of depression.
Effects on newborns: Sub-Saharan Africa has the highest rates of neonatal mortality in the world and has
shown the slowest progress in reducing newborn deaths, especially deaths in the first week of life. Each
year, at least 1.16 million African babies die in the first 28 days of life – and 850,000 of these babies do not
live past the week they are born.4 Asphyxia claims many babies during the first day, and the majority of
deaths due to preterm birth occur during the first week. Thirty-eight percent of babies in sub-Saharan
Africa die of infections, mainly after the first week of life.5 The majority of these deaths are low birthweight
(LBW) babies, many of whom are preterm. In addition, long term disability and poor development often
originate from childbirth and the early postnatal period.
Effects on children: At least one in four child deaths occur during the first month of life. These deaths
often take place before child health services begin to provide care, usually at six weeks for the first
immunisation visit. Low coverage of care in the postnatal period negatively influences other maternal,
newborn, and child health (MNCH) programmes along the continuum of care. For example, the lack of
support for healthy home behaviours, such as breastfeeding, can have ongoing effects for the child in terms
of undernutrition. (Section III chapter 6). Additionally, newborns and mothers are frequently lost to follow
up during the postnatal period for prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) of HIV. 6 (Section III
chapter 7).

The period following birth in Africa is often marked by countries, it is said that if a newborn baby dies, ‘the baby
cultural practices. Understanding these beliefs and has gone back and the baby has not been born yet.’
practices is an important part of ensuring effective and
timely care. Many communities throughout Africa Some cultural practices hinder the health and survival of
observe practices that keep mothers and babies indoors the newborn, and young first-time mothers are often
for the first month after birth – a period of seclusion. most likely to follow these practices. Giving newborns
Families are wary about visitors coming in close contact cold baths, discarding colostrum, and providing food
with newborns. 7;8 If mothers or babies become ill during other than breastmilk soon after birth can be harmful.
the period of seclusion, seeking formal health care is often Applying butter, ash, or other substances such as cow
delayed. Yet, sick babies often die within a few hours and dung to the umbilical stump increase the risks of
delays can be fatal. Delays also affect maternal outcomes. infection.
Three crucial delays are outlined in the previous chapter This chapter will outline the package for PNC and
on childbirth care – delay in recognition of describe the current coverage and trends for PNC in
complications, delay in reaching appropriate care, and Africa. Then we will explore opportunities to strengthen
delay in receiving appropriate care. PNC at the health facility, through outreach, and in the
When a baby dies, the women – not the men – of the community, and suggest practical actions that will help
family perform the burial. It is often taboo to moan and address key challenges relating to providing quality care
cry during the burial of a newborn or for relatives and to mothers and babies during the critical postnatal
friends to inquire about newborn deaths. In some period.

80 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


Package analysis) The impact on maternal survival and well being III
would also be significant.
It has been estimated that if routine PNC and curative
care in the postnatal period reached 90 percent of babies There is now more consensus on the content of PNC
and their mothers, 10 to 27 percent of newborn deaths (what),10;11 but questions remain about the best timing (when)
could be averted. In other words, high PNC coverage and place (where) for postnatal visits, and who can deliver this
could save up to 310,000 newborn lives a year in Africa.9 package. Box III.4.1 outlines the current consensus regarding
(See data notes on page 226 for more information on this the what, when, where, and who of routine PNC.

BOX III.4.1 Routine postnatal care (PNC): What, when, where, and who?

WHAT is routine PNC?

Preventive care practices and routine assessments to identify and manage or refer complications for both
mother and baby including:

Essential routine PNC for all mothers


• Assess and check for bleeding, check temperature
• Support breastfeeding, checking the breasts to prevent mastitis
• Manage anaemia, promote nutrition and insecticide treated bednets, give vitamin A supplementation
• Complete tetanus toxoid immunisation, if required
• Provide counselling and a range of options for family planning
• Refer for complications such as bleeding, infections, or postnatal depression
• Counsel on danger signs and home care

Essential routine PNC for all newborns


• Assess for danger signs, measure and record weight, and check temperature and feeding
• Support optimal feeding practices, particularly exclusive breastfeeding
• Promote hygiene and good skin, eye, and cord care
• If prophylactic eye care is local policy and has not been given, it is still effective until 12 hours after birth
• Promote clean, dry cord care
• Identify superficial skin infections, such as pus draining from umbilicus, redness extending from umbilicus to
skin, more than 10 skin pustules, and swelling, redness, and hardness of skin, and treat or refer if the baby
also has danger signs
• Ensure warmth by delaying the baby’s first bath to after the first 24 hours, practising skin-to-skin care, and
putting a hat on the baby
• Encourage and facilitate birth registration
• Refer for routine immunisations
• Counsel on danger signs and home care

Extra care for low birthweight (LBW) or small babies and other vulnerable babies, such as those born to
HIV- infected mothers (two or three extra visits)
The majority of newborn deaths occur in LBW babies, many of whom are preterm. Intensive care is not needed
to save the majority of these babies. Around one third could be saved with simple care,9 including:
• Identify the small baby
• Assess for danger signs and manage or refer as appropriate
• Provide extra support for breastfeeding, including expressing milk and cup feeding, if needed
• Pay extra attention to warmth promotion, such as skin-to-skin care or Kangaroo Mother Care
• Ensure early identification and rapid referral of babies who are unable to breastfeed or accept expressed
breastmilk
• Provide extra care for babies whose mothers are HIV-positive, particularly for feeding support (Section III
chapter 7).

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 81


WHAT is routine PNC? (continued)

Early identification and referral / management of emergencies for mother and baby
Appropriate detection, management, or referrals are necessary to save mothers and babies in the event of
life-threatening complications

Danger signs for the mother


• Excessive bleeding
• Foul smelling vaginal discharge
• Fever with or without chills
• Severe abdominal pain
• Excessive tiredness or breathlessness
• Swollen hands, face and legs with severe headaches or blurred vision
• Painful, engorged breasts or sore, cracked, bleeding nipples

Danger signs for the baby


• Convulsions
• Movement only when stimulated or no movement, even when stimulated
• Not feeding well
• Fast breathing (more than 60 breaths per minute), grunting or severe chest in-drawing
• Fever (above 38°C)
• Low body temperature (below 35.5°C),
• Very small baby (less than 1500 grams or born more than two months early)
• Bleeding

WHEN and how many postnatal visits should occur?

The optimum number and timing of PNC visits, especially in limited resource settings, is a subject of debate.
Although no large-scale systematic reviews have been carried out to determine this protocol, three or four
postnatal visits have been suggested. Early visits are crucial because the majority of maternal and newborn
deaths occur in the first week, especially on the first day, and this period is also the key time to promote
healthy behaviours. Each country should make decisions based on the local context and existing care
provisions, including who can deliver the PNC package and where it can be delivered. The following are
offered as a guide:
• First contact:
If the mother is in a facility, she and her baby should be assessed within one hour of birth and again
before discharge
Encouraging women to stay for 24 hours, especially after a complicated birth, should be considered
If birth occurs at home, the first visit should target the crucial first 24 hours after birth
• Follow up contacts are recommended at least at 2-3 days, 6-7 days, and at 6 weeks
• Extra contacts for babies needing extra care (LBW or those whose mothers have HIV) should have two or
three visits in addition to the routine visits

WHERE should PNC be provided and WHO can provide it?

There are a number of possible strategies for delivery of PNC and many of the routine tasks can be delegated,
although supervision and linkages are crucial:
• At a facility: This is more likely if the mother gives birth in the health facility, but even then women and babies
do not necessarily receive an effective PNC contact before discharge from the health facility, and even if
mothers initially come to facilities for birth, they may not return in the first few days after discharge from a
facility
• Through outreach services: A skilled provider can visit the home to offer PNC to the mother and baby
• Home visits from a community health worker (CHW): Where health systems are not as strong and human
resources are limited, certain tasks can be delegated to CHW, linking to health facilities for referral as required
• Combination of care in the facility and at home: PNC may be provided in the health facility following childbirth, at
the home during the first crucial two to three days, with subsequent visits to the facility after six to seven days
and six weeks, when the mother is better able to leave her home

Sources: Adapted from references11;12


Note: This information is not intended to be a detailed clinical guide.

82 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


Current coverage and trends According to DHS data in Ethiopia, 90 percent of III
mothers did not receive any PNC within the first six
The postnatal period is a neglected period. Despite the
weeks. Of the few who did have a PNC contact, more
fact that the majority of maternal and newborn deaths
than half gave birth in a health facility, where crowds and
occur within the first week of the postnatal period,1
the practice of early discharge often hinder mothers from
health care providers across sub-Saharan Africa continue
receiving proper PNC. In Eritrea, 92 percent of women
to advise mothers to come back to the facility for a first
giving birth at home received no PNC within the first six
check-up only after six weeks. This is a visit for survivors.
weeks. Similarly, 85 percent of women giving birth at
The void of comparable, relevant data for programmes home in Mali and 70 percent of women giving birth at
reveals the lack of systematic implementation of this home in Rwanda received no PNC at all, according to
package. There are no consistently measured indicators the most recent DHS country data. Aside from
of effectiveness of national PNC programmes.8 The measuring the number of births that take place at home,
definitions for monitoring PNC are sometimes the PNC indicator in DHS gives no information on the
problematic, including the assumption used in some content or quality of the visit. This is in contrast to the
surveys that all women who have facility births more comprehensive information provided by questions
automatically receive PNC. Based on an analysis of 23 on antenatal care (ANC), where women are asked if they
Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS), two thirds of received a variety of interventions, such as tetanus toxoid
women in sub-Saharan Africa give birth at home, and injections and blood pressure measurements.
only 13 percent of these women receive a postnatal visit
within two days of birth.

Postnatal care within two days of birth in facilities (assuming all facility births
FIGURE III.4.1.
receive postnatal care) or at home, according to Demographic and Health Survey (DHS)
data in 12 countries (2003-2005)
100
Facility births (DHS assumes PNC) PNC within 2 for home births, applied to all births

75
Coverage(%)

50

25

0
Burkina Faso Ghana Kenya Madagascar Mozambique Nigeria Cameroon Lesotho Malawi Tanzania Guinea Senegal
2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 2004 2004 2004 2004 2005 2005

Source: DHS data for surveys from 2003-2005. DHS assumes that all facility births receive PNC. See data notes on page 226 for more information on this indicator.

A lack of PNC affects the coverage of several essential


interventions. Although healthy home behaviours such as
breastfeeding are well described, only 30 percent of babies
in sub-Saharan Africa are exclusively breastfed. Many
newborns are also found to be too cold after birth, even
in tropical countries,13 and skin-to-skin care after
childbirth is not widely practiced.
Family planning is an important missed opportunity in
the postnatal period. Focus group discussions in Kenya
revealed that virtually all women thought that family
planning information could be given during postnatal
visits or before a woman leaves the hospital after
childbirth.14;15 The lactational amenorrhoea method
should be the first method of choice for early family

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 83


planning among mothers with new babies, also health systems, the level of decentralised decision making,
considering condoms to provide dual protection against and common cultural practices, particularly cultural
HIV/AIDS as well as pregnancy.16 Family planning practices regarding seclusion that may reduce care
technologies for the early postnatal period, such as seeking.
insertion of an intrauterine contraceptive device within
Even with agreement on the main content of a global
the first 48 hours after childbirth, should be considered.17
package for PNC, the who, where, and how should be
adapted to the relevant health and social context.
Opportunities to strengthen PNC Approaches for scaling up PNC include different
possibilities for women giving birth in a health facility
Across Africa, policy and programmatic opportunities and women giving birth at home. Given that over half of
exist to strengthen PNC, given widespread recent women and their newborns remain at home during and
recognition that this is a key gap in the continuum of immediately after birth, integrating care for both mother
care. PNC contact maintains continuity of care between and newborn outside the formal health system is crucial.
maternal and child health services, supporting healthy
behaviours that should have been introduced during Four possible approaches to provide PNC are listed in
ANC visits and continued during labour and childbirth. Table III.4.1, based on the place of birth and the place(s)
In addition, PNC contact is crucial to ensure a seamless and providers for PNC. The expected acceptability and
continuum of care from home to hospital. Improvement challenges of these possible approaches for the mother
of PNC depends on the capacity and accessibility of local and the provider and the health system are also detailed.

TABLE III.4.1 Postnatal Care (PNC) strategies: feasibility and challenges to implementation

Possible strategies Mother-friendly Provider-friendly Challenges for implementation

1 Mother and baby go to G GGG Requires mother to come to the facility within
facility for PNC a very short time following birth. More likely
following a facility birth.

2 Skilled provider visits the GGG G Conditional on sufficient human resources,


home to provide PNC for which is challenging and may not be highest
mother and baby priority for skilled attendants in settings where
skilled attendance at birth is still low. May be
possible where rural health facilities are quiet
during afternoons.

3 Community Health Worker GGG G Requires training for CHW and management,
(CHW) visits home to see supervision, and logistic support.
mother and baby

4 Combination: Facility birth GG GG Requires team approach with facility and


and first PNC visit in the CHW, sufficient human resources, good
facility, then home visit management and supervision, good referral
within two to three days, systems, and an efficient information and
with subsequent PNC visits tracking system so that mother and baby are
at the facility not lost to follow up.

Key: •Low ••Moderate •••High Source: PNC working group composed of chapter authors and editors.

With a supportive policy environment, these strategies ask the mother who has given birth in a facility to return
can be implemented and integrated within the to the facility for PNC.7 In sub-Saharan Africa, a high
continuum of care, linking with other services at proportion of women attend at least one ANC visit,
the facility, home, and community levels. Serious when providers can counsel pregnant women in their last
consideration should be given before commitment is trimester on the importance of having a skilled attendant
made to an approach that would necessitate the scaling at birth and an early check-up for mother and baby.
up of a new cadre of worker. Evidence suggests that women are more likely to have a
skilled attendant at childbirth if they receive good ANC,
1. PNC at the facility level
and if they have a skilled attendant at birth, they are
The most common model used for PNC in Africa is to
more likely to return for PNC.18;19

84 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


Women who give birth in a health facility could ideally the CHW remit and training would have a high impact III
be encouraged to stay for at least 24 hours before at relatively low cost. Health facilities serving certain
discharge. This allows the health facility staff to observe geographic areas can strengthen linkages between formal
the mother and the newborn to ascertain whether the health workers and community health extension workers,
preferred feeding option is established and to make sure CHW, and other cadres, such as traditional birth
any maternal or neonatal complications are detected and attendants, to improve both the knowledge base and care
managed. If specific risk factors are identified in the baby, for the mother and baby pair immediately after birth.
the mother and baby should be kept another two days to CHW who are tasked with providing PNC should be
enable feeding, warmth, and care for complications, and connected to the health facility through supervision and a
the mother of a LBW baby can be taught Kangaroo functional referral system. If a CHW visits a mother and
Mother Care (KMC). Before discharge, mothers should newborn and finds a complication, she should refer the
be advised to bring their newborns back if they notice patient and accompany her to the health centre, if
any danger signs. They should be given a specific date to possible. Experience of home-based PNC is available
return for PNC, which will increase the likelihood of from several studies and pilots in Asia.24;25 Currently there
them attending with their newborns.20 In many settings, is less experience in Africa, although a number of studies
however, even if the woman has a facility birth, she will are in process to test adapted approaches for home-based
not return for care in the first two days after birth, when care, linking to the health system.
the risk of dying is highest for herself and her baby.
Where feasible, timely home visits should be arranged
and scheduled, or a combination approach can be
considered as discussed in the fourth strategy below.
Is there a role for
BOX III.4.2
2. PNC as outreach: Home visits by a skilled community health workers (CHW)
attendant in postnatal care?
Postnatal follow up of new mothers and their newborns
can also be provided through outreach visits by a skilled According to a number of recent reviews, with
attendant. The attendant can examine both mother and proper training and support, CHW can:
baby, provide essential maternal and newborn care, and
identify complications, which can either be managed on • Increase healthy behaviours for the baby such as
the spot or referred appropriately. Successful outreach exclusive breastfeeding, ensuring warmth (for
visits for PNC have already occurred in limited resource example, delayed bathing and skin-to-skin care),
settings. In Madagascar, 15 percent of women receive a and hygienic practices
postnatal visit by a health professional in their own
• Provide extra care for the low birthweight
homes. In one pilot study in rural Kenya, retired
(LBW) baby
midwives facilitate childbirth at home and visit the
mother and baby two or three times in the first week.8 A • Reduce newborn deaths through early
study in Zambia showed that midwives who educated identification and case management of
mothers in their homes on newborn health enabled them pneumonia where referral is not possible26
to identify danger signs and take action more frequently,
resulting in a reduction in the prevalence of health • Provide information and services for the mother
problems in newborns.21 In general, however, there are especially for birth spacing and family planning,
not enough midwives to provide care during childbirth in giving vitamin A to mothers
much of Africa, and adding two or three home visits may
be expensive and challenging with current human • Identify danger signs for both mothers and
resource limitations. Additional time and expense for newborns and support referral for management
travel to undertake home visits must also be considered. of maternal and newborn complications
Childbirth care does require a skilled attendant and may • Promote the use of other services such as birth
be the priority for the midwife’s time.
registration and vaccination
3. PNC at the family and community level
Source: Adapted from references 25-29
Since the postnatal period is often characterised by
seclusion for the mother and baby, community health
worker (CHW) visits to the home offer an opportunity
to reach the woman and baby with care and build specific
health messages into this culturally sensitive time.22;23
Certain tasks in routine PNC could be delegated to a less
skilled cadre, where feasible and appropriate (Box III.4.2).
In countries where CHW programmes are being scaled
up nationally, adding home PNC for mother and baby to

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 85


4. PNC through linking facility care with outreach mothers and babies at home. Another important obstacle
and community care is lack of information. Women may not seek care because
Instead of a facility-only strategy or a community-only they do not recognise complications or know the service
strategy, it may be possible to develop a linked approach, is available to them.7 If care does exist, they may not
with a skills mix in the team. This is particularly true in perceive any benefits in attending, even though they
countries or settings where access to primary level would welcome information on caring for their new
facilities is good and referral links between primary level baby, breastfeeding, and family planning, either before
and referral level are functional. For example, the woman becoming pregnant or during pregnancy.33 Women
may give birth in the facility, go home, have a CHW or perceive childbirth as a major event but may view the
extension CHW visit her at home on the second day, and postnatal period with less concern.
then return to the facility after one week and six weeks.
Community involvement is crucial for shortening delays
A referral slip can be designed to facilitate these linkages.
in seeking care after birth because family members can
Where maternity waiting homes are available, the new
significantly influence behaviours. In many areas where
mothers and their infants could perhaps stay for three
husbands work away from home, women may wait for
days to ensure all is well before travelling the long
the ‘decision maker’ to return to give permission and pay
distances home. Referral links, however, continue to
for visiting a facility. Additionally, many societies in sub-
remain the weakest point in many maternal and newborn
Saharan Africa acknowledge that grandmothers play an
health care programmes.30 One programme that trained
influential role in supporting the young women (their
CHW to give key messages was successful in improving
daughters and daughters-in-law) in their community
healthy home behaviours and increasing postnatal
during pregnancy, childbirth, and throughout the care of
attendance among village women of childbearing age
the newborn (Box III.4.3). Sometimes harmful practices
in a remote area of Uganda.31
are endorsed by grandmothers, but given the wide-
Targeting specific groups for additional PNC ranging role they play, their influences, and their intrinsic
Whether births occur at facility or at home, health commitment to promoting the wellbeing of women and
workers should be able to identify specific risk factors in children, they should be viewed as key actors in the
women and in newborns (LBW, preterm birth, feeding provision of PNC. The influence of other community
problems, illness and history of prolonged and difficult gatekeepers such as local leaders, traditional birth
labour, mother with HIV) and follow up. Extra care is attendants, CHW, and support groups and their potential
specifically needed for LBW babies and preterm babies. for channelling information and swaying behaviour offer
Where the birth is in a facility and specific risk factors are both opportunities and challenges.
identified, the mother and baby can be kept in the facility
Improving the supply of PNC
longer to enable extra support for feeding, warmth, and
Many countries have some sort of postnatal policy (even
care for complications. If appropriate, the mother can be
if it only exists as a six week check-up), but generally at
taught KMC. If the birth is at home and a CHW or
the national level, there is a lack of guidelines, standards,
extension worker is being used for routine PNC visits,
protocols, and most importantly, human resources for the
extra visits should be considered for LBW babies and
management of the mother and baby in the early
others requiring special care, such as babies of HIV-
postnatal period.34 Moreover, there is often insufficient
infected women. For PMTCT programmes, the postnatal
coordination between the different health providers, weak
period provides opportunities for increased support,
links between programmes, and inappropriate use of
particularly for alternate feeding choices.32 Integration of
information. In many countries, unless she decides to
PMTCT with MNCH programmes would strengthen the
seek family planning, a woman may never receive a
linkages in this crucial handover period to enhance the
check-up until she becomes pregnant again. The majority
continuum of care
of countries do not have a postnatal register, so even if a
nurse has a check-up with new mothers, she cannot
Challenges record her efforts. To deal with this problem, the
Ministry of Health in Kenya has recently designed and
There is a major gap in the continuum of care due to low instigated a register for three targeted postnatal visits: one
coverage of PNC. There is limited available research to visit within 48 hours, the next within one to two weeks,
identify the optimum timing and delivery approaches, and the third visit at around six weeks.
and in any case, these may be situation-specific. The
challenges may be considered in terms of demand and The quality of care around the time of childbirth will
supply of services. influence newborn care during the postnatal period.
Where skilled care is lacking, there are very few providers
Increasing demand for postnatal care trained in essential newborn care or care of the sick
There are many delays in seeking care, especially during newborn and very few courses for nurses and midwives to
pregnancy, childbirth, and the postnatal period (Section extend their skills.34 Where skilled care is available,
III chapter 3). Delays in seeking care in the postnatal providers are often too busy to think about giving
period often occur because of the restrictions that keep information about the importance of having a postnatal

86 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


check-up for new mothers and their babies.35 The III
immediate postnatal period is often a time of uncertainty
for programme planners, who question whether PNC is BOX III.4.3 Wisdom from grandmothers
the responsibility of those looking after the mother on newborn care
through a safe motherhood programme or those caring
for the newborn through a child survival programme. In Mali, one programme engaged grandmothers to
There is rarely a systematic handover between those who educate communities about making simple changes
care for the mother and those who care for the baby and to protect the heath of mothers and babies.
child; thus, a disconnect occurs in the continuum of care. Grandmothers discussed better nutrition,
Limited health management capacity as well as referral preventing and treating infections, keeping
and communication failures have also been identified at newborns warm and dry, and early breastfeeding.
various service levels.36 One study from Tanzania suggests As a result, there were fewer newborn deaths and
that midwives need more support to provide PNC. a decrease in harmful practices such as high
Factors that may affect health workers in providing PNC workload for pregnant women, bathing within six
include the gap between classroom theory and practice, hours after birth, application of cocoa butter on
political awareness, and involvement in policy making. In the baby’s umbilical cord, and giving coffee to
addition, lack of confidence in management and referral newborns. Husbands were more willing to pay for
of women with complications and limitations in dealing medical services and nutrition supplementation
with job stress were also highlighted.35 during pregnancy and even accompanied their
Innovative solutions exist in other regions where PNC wives to health services for consultation.
packages have been adapted, and Africa should build on
One mother’s thoughts: “the shame wall between
these experiences. One project in Nepal aimed to improve
the mother and newborn’s access to basic, acceptable mother-in-law and daughter-in-law falls gradually;
PNC through a network of CHW delivering home-based money is given by the husband because permission
care. The results showed that it is feasible for trained was given by his father, who was influenced by his
volunteers to provide effective home-based PNC of wife.”
reasonable quality and coverage. The project has also
Source: Adapted from reference 38
shown high rates of identifying health problems and
referring both mothers and newborns, although these
results should be interpreted with caution given the low
sample size of mothers and newborns with health support to adapt their PNC package based on existing
problems.37 policy, including who can deliver PNC and where it can
be delivered.
Establish leadership at various levels to review, adapt,
Practical steps integrate, and implement a PNC package. Based on
There are a number of practical steps that can be taken individual country situations, high level government
by governments and partners in order to scale up PNC officials, donors, and other advocates can collaborate to
services. These include developing an evidence based champion PNC for the mother and newborn. It is
PNC package, building and reinforcing links between the important for Ministries of Health to coordinate,
community and health facility, and improving available integrate, and strengthen the PNC component within
information to guide programmatic decision making. existing programmes such as IMCI, child survival, safe
motherhood initiatives, emergency obstetric care, and
1. Develop an evidence based PNC package
early childhood development.
Standardise timing and frequency of care. The timing,
frequency, and exact content of PNC visits require further
testing and harmonisation. Many countries in Africa
have adopted or partially adopted the World Health
Organization (WHO) 1998 model of care, which
suggests postnatal visits within six hours after birth,
three to six days, six weeks and six months (6-6-6-6).10
However, the most important time period for PNC is the
critical first 24 hours, when most maternal and newborn
deaths occur (Box III.4.1). If possible, the next contact
should be on the second or third day of life, and, if
resources permit, a third visit during the first week should
be included. The routine visit during the sixth week is
important for the baby’s immunisation and the mother’s
family planning counselling. Countries may require

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 87


Provide for supervision, management, and
accountability. For various community-based
programmes, supervision and quality assurance are the
weakest links and failing points. Programme managers
as well as outreach and health extension workers should
be supported in routine supervision of CHW and
volunteers. Performance-based remuneration of CHW
should be considered in order to keep CHW motivated
and hold them accountable for delivery of services.
Consider the use of maternity waiting homes.
Maternity waiting homes linked to health facilities with
emergency obstetric care services may help reduce deaths
for mothers and babies, especially for those who live far
from the facility and who have known risk factors, such
The leadership team should assess the pre-service and as a previous neonatal death. The new mother and baby
in-service training curricula for all cadres of health can stay in these maternity homes for three or four days
providers so that essential PNC is included.21 to make sure they are healthy before going home.
Furthermore, they should adapt, disseminate, Bridge the gap between PNC and family planning.
institutionalise, and implement evidence based PNC Family planning programmes should increase outreach
policies.39 Guidelines, training materials, job aids, and and bring community-based workers to coordinate efforts
postnatal registers for both mother and newborn are with health providers at facilities (and vice versa).
available but are not yet combined to make an integrated Programmes must recognise and respond to the cultural
package for systematic implementation within the region. and physical immobility of the mother in the postnatal
Where focused ANC has been successfully introduced, period as well as the receptivity of mothers and their
coverage can extend smoothly along the continuum of husbands, grandmothers and other influential family
care to deliver a targeted PNC package. Key messages for members to advise and support. Counselling strategies
PNC can also be developed to match other MNCH should be redirected to include all aspects of newborn
messages. After implementation, Ministries of Health care 40 (Section III chapter 1).
and stakeholders should plan to review programmatic
operations, such as supplies and logistics issues, as well as Establish and nurture key partnerships. Use creative
lessons learned. ways to recognise and support new and existing
partnerships between government, donors, non-
2. Integrate programmes: Build and reinforce governmental organisations, women’s groups, traditional
linkages between community and facility health practitioners, and local faith-based organisations.
Connect MNCH services at every service delivery level. Consider:
PNC requires coordinated care for both mother and baby
wherever services are offered (at the health facility, • Recruiting the support and cooperation of religious
community, and home) and referral linkages to both figures, who are often prominent figures in community
maternal and child health services. In many instances, the health
same health worker is providing care for the mother and • Recognising the influence of traditional birth attendants
baby, yet protocols and standards for combining maternal and other community health promoters and providers
and newborn care have yet to reach peripheral health and inviting them to join the ‘community health team’
facilities, or a child health worker is assessing a newborn to educate parents and grandparents on positive
but has not been trained to do so. It is therefore practices
imperative to bring national level guidelines to those
who deliver services – the health workers. • Expanding formative research on knowledge, attitudes,
and behaviours, and negotiating change for practices
Empower family and community members. Use birth that are harmful while encouraging those that are
planning programmes and PNC to inform mothers, helpful
family, and community members on good maternal and
newborn care practices at home. Simple communication 3. Improve available information to guide
and counselling materials can guide families from cultural programmatic decision making
practices to evidence based essential newborn care, Strengthen monitoring of PNC. Data on PNC coverage
including timely recognition and referral of maternal and are lacking. Standardised monitoring indicators must be
newborn danger signs. When suggesting a change in developed to promote PNC as an important MNCH
behaviour, it is important to negotiate this change and programme and to evaluate cross-country comparisons.41
ensure that community gatekeepers are included in the Routine health management information systems should
process. also include PNC indicators (Box III.4.4). For example,

88 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns


future DHS and Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys III
(MICS) should ask women who have recently given birth
about the quality and use of PNC they received, BOX III.4.4 Key indicators for postnatal
including when, where, and with whom. Compound care (PNC)
indicators for essential newborn care are under discussion,
such as the percentage of newborns dried after birth, • Mother/newborn receiving PNC within three
breastfed within one hour, and kept close to the skin of days* and subsequent visits
the mother or caregiver.
• Place where care is provided and type of care
Conduct relevant operations research. Many questions provider
remain about the who, where, and how of providing PNC,
particularly for poor and underserved populations, and • Timely initiation of breastfeeding within one hour
how to provide PNC in varying settings whilst linking to after birth*
the health system. Most of the studies so far have been in • Sick newborns taken for treatment
Asia and there is a dearth of information for PNC
programming in Africa. Some of these research gaps • Health facilities where skilled or trained health
include: care providers are competent in essential
newborn care and management of maternal
• Who can provide care in various settings? How do
programmes locate pregnant women and new mothers and newborn complications
who do not access antenatal and/or childbirth care? • Case fatality rate of newborn complications
Who can do what for the mother and baby? (by cause if possible)
• Where is care best provided? Where do women and *Newborn and child indicators in Countdown to 2015 child
families want to receive PNC – at home or in the survival indicator list .42 See Section IV for complete list.
facility? Can services be provided in facilities and homes
and linked? How can referral systems be strengthened?
• How frequently should services be delivered for routine
PNC and for extra care for small babies? How can PNC
services be better integrated with PMTCT and other
programmes?
• What is the impact and cost of varying models of PNC
delivery?

Conclusion
Many African women and their newborns do not have
access to health care during the early postnatal period,
putting them at an increased risk of illness and death.
Each year, 310,000 fewer newborns would die in Africa
and many maternal lives would be saved if the coverage
of PNC reached 90 percent of women and babies.9
Yet PNC programmes are among the weakest of all
reproductive and child health programmes in the region.
Advancing PNC policy and programmes is crucial, as is
implementing and testing the feasibility, sustainability
and cost effectiveness of what we do know. There is an
incredible opportunity to adapt PNC to varying settings
to reach women and their newborns, especially for the
18 million African women who give birth at home.

Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns 89


Priority actions for strengthening postnatal care
Develop and implement an evidence based PNC package
• Attain global agreement on timing, frequency, and content of care
• Establish or revitalise a national working group to develop and operationalise a national PNC package,
for example, one that is linked to the national Road Map
• Adapt programmatic protocols and key messages for use in PNC
• Train/retrain health workers
• Address supply and logistics issues
Strengthen the programme
• Bridge key gaps in implementation at the family/community, outreach and facility level between family
planning, ANC, childbirth, and PNC
Improve the information available to guide programmatic decision making
• Improve and standardise monitoring indicators for PNC
• Conduct relevant operations research

90 Opportunities for Africa’s Newborns

You might also like