Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I -«
In considering new and promising methods to calibrate radar, it is worth remembering some of the
old and perhaps forgotten methods that were used over the last half century.
D
uring the Radar Calibration Workshop at the shop. While formalizing these remarks in writing I
81st Annual Meeting of the American Meteo- thought it would be useful to elaborate upon them and
rological Society in Albuquerque, New Mexico, discuss some newer approaches. Thus this paper at-
in January 2001,1 was surprised at the relatively little tempts to synthesize a range of techniques. A com-
attention given to some of the simplest and proven mon thread that runs throughout is the calibration of
methods. This stimulated some extemporaneous re- the overall system by use of standard or well-defined
marks that I presented toward the end of the work- targets external to the radar.
In part, I was troubled by the apparent lack of fa-
miliarity of some of the younger generation with early
A F F I L I A T I O N : ATLAS—NASA Goddard Space Flight Center,
activities in this realm. I was also reacting to the re-
Greenbelt, Maryland
C O R R E S P O N D I N G A U T H O R : David Atlas, Distinguished Visiting
cent findings of the variability in the calibrations of
Scientist, N A S A Goddard Space Flight Center, C o d e 910,
the Weather Surveillance Radars-1988 Doppler
Greenbelt, MD 20771 (WSR-88Ds) around the nation that have been uncov-
E-mail: datlas@radar.gsfc.nasa.gov
In final form 22 May 2002 Above: In the early 1970s, Atlas used BBs to cali-
©2002 American Meteorological Society brate the vertically pointing frequency modulated-
continuous wave ( F M - C W ) radar.
A M E R I C A N M E T E O R O L O G I C A L SOCIETY SEPTEMBER
Unauthenticated 2002 01/25/21
| Downloaded B A I T S ' I07:49
1 3 1 3 AM UTC
ered by comparison with the radar measurements of tenna. These frequencies are readily distinguished
precipitation by the radar on board the Tropical Rain- from ground clutter and precipitation echoes. It is an
fall Measuring Mission (TRMM); (Bolen and excellent calibration device because it is always avail-
Chandrasekar 2000). The remarkable stability of the able regardless of the weather.
TRMM precipitation radar has made it a traveling
standard against which ground-based weather radars 88s. We first used BBs fired vertically from a BB pis-
can be calibrated. tol as standard targets to calibrate the vertically point-
There were a few papers presented at the work- ing frequency modulated-continuous wave (FM-CW)
shop that resorted to the more traditional methods radar at the Naval Electronics Laboratory Center at
such as calibration with a standard target. David Point Loma, California (Stratmann et al. 1971). After
Brunkow of Colorado State University spoke about having failed to support a calibration sphere from a
the use of a metal sphere. Ron Rinehart of the Uni- balloon in a stable position on the axis of the radar
versity of North Dakota used an oscillating dihedral beam we searched for another approach. In a joking
corner reflector. Also Isztar Zawadzki recounted his manner I suggested the use of a BB gun. Although
work with rain gauges and a Joss-Waldvogel (J-W) there was no prior literature on the subject it was
disdrometer. Surely, few of the participants were cheap, straightforward, and worth a try. We were very
aware that the early workers in Canada (Stewart pleased by how well it worked. If enough BBs are used
Marshall, Bob Langille, and Walter Palmer) and in (one at a time), the statistics of echo strength mimic
my group at the Air Force Cambridge Research Labo- the radiation pattern of the beam. The maximum echo
ratories (Vernon Plank, A1 Chmela, and I) used fil- corresponds to the antenna gain on the beam axis.
ter papers powdered with Gentian violet dye (which When using a conventional radar, one should tilt the
left purple stains on our clothes and teeth) to mea- beam close to the horizon outside the region of
sure the sizes of tens of thousands of drops by hand ground clutter. With Doppler radar, the Doppler shift
in the late 1940s and early 1950s (Hitschfeld 1986). can be used to distinguish the moving BBs from
Oh what a blessing it was to display the drop size dis- clutter.
tribution in a comfortable laboratory , while the J-
W disdrometer was observing the size of each drop Metalized Ping-Pong balls. T h i s is a n e x t e n s i o n of t h e
automatically outdoors. BB method. One can fly a light aircraft across and
Historically, it was the Weather Radar Group at the above a fixed radar beam and drop the balls sequen-
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), under tially at about 10-15 m intervals so that only one tar-
the leadership of Alan Bemis and the seminal work get is in the beam at any time. The metalized balls
by Polly Austin and Ed Williams (1951), that found are good targets of known radar cross section. The
the large underestimates of the radar echoes from successive echoes present a quantitative measure of
gauge measurements of rain in comparison to the the antenna pattern. Tracking of the aircraft and
then-available theory. It was this difference that mo- timing of each drop positions each target relative to
tivated Richard Probert-Jones (1962) in England to the maximum echo on the beam axis. The Ping-
formulate the proper radar equation for meteorologi- Pong balls are cheap and nonhazardous. One may
cal scatterers (Hitschfeld 1986). For almost a decade also use metalized wiffle balls (with holes in them).
we all struggled to understand the source of this dis- The idea is to prevent either type of ball from falling
crepancy. And here we are today still struggling with fast enough to create a hazard. Note that either of
the optimum methods of radar calibration. these types of balls may be within the Mie region
depending on the radar wavelength so that their
C A L I B R A T I O N METHODS. Frequency shift re- cross sections should be computed carefully. It is also
flector (FSR). The FSR was invented by John Chisholm possible to release such targets sequentially from a
(1963). It has been used mainly as a ground-based bucket carried on a constant-level balloon moving
target for precise locations on airports and geographi- with the winds perpendicular to the fixed radar
cal siting. It employs a parabolic reflector with a horn beam. A similar method was used to measure the
at the focus that is shorted by a diode at a frequency/ cross section of a free-falling artificial hailstone re-
(e.g., 30 or 60 MHz). The frequency/is generated by leased from a balloon and measured by a tracking
a battery-driven modulator. The echo from the tar- radar (Willis et al. 1964).
get is returned at F ±/, where F is the transmitted fre-
quency. The echoes at ±f are exactly 6 dB below that Airborne modulated target. This approach combines the
corresponding to the known cross section of the an- concepts in the frequency shift reflector (FSR) and