Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Madalyn Carter
21.SU.ENG.1201.5B3
26 July 2021
Opinions are varied and facts can be twisted about a baby's life or as some refer to a
fetus; however, the evidence speaks volumes. How does abortion exactly affect someone's body
mentally and physically? Abortion is a horrific practice that is both mentally and physically
damaging to the life of the mother while also taking the life of an innocent unborn child. The
effects that abortion has on a mother have been researched for many generations and the research
refers to the fact that abortion is harmful and can be life-altering. There are many medical and
scientific opinions on when life begins and what effects abortion has on the body. Does it begin
when a heartbeat is detected or when the baby takes its first breath of oxygen? Is abortion
morally wrong and what part does it take in the health of the mother and the baby? Is abortion a
relevant topic to discuss? Is it an epidemic like the pro-life movement would want people to
believe? “Conservative estimates reveal that approximately one-third of American women have
had (or will have) an abortion. (Platt.) “Based on the latest state-level data, approximately
879,000 abortions took place in the United States in 2017. Down from approximately 892,000
abortions in 2016 and 913,000 abortions in 2015.” (Abort73.com, par. 7.) For the pro-life
organizations, this is a welcoming set of statistics to view that the number of abortions in the
United States is decreasing as more people are being educated about the facts of abortion
procedures. Although abortions seem to be on a decrease in America, the harrowing fact is that
Carter 2
about 115,000 abortions are performed every single day across the world. Many abortions are for
social reasons and are not performed for medical reasons. “The vast majority of all abortions
performed today are done for social, not medical reasons -- because a woman doesn’t feel ready
for a baby at the time, because her partner wants her to have an abortion, etc. Approximately
93% of all induced abortions are done for elective, non-medical reasons such as these. (Torres
and Forrest.)
According to the website South Carolina Citizens For Life, they give information and
good credible sources about abortion. “The term "abortion" actually refers to any premature
induced, as in a surgical or chemical abortion. Today, the most common usage of the term
famous Roe v. Wade seems to be one of the most controversial judicial decisions in the twentieth
century. “Roe brought suit against Wade, a state official, claiming a Texas law restricting her
right to an abortion was unconstitutional. The court discussed the different types of interests a
state may have at different stages during the pregnancy, specifically the interests in protecting
the life of the mother and the unborn fetus. The United States Supreme Court held, that the law
was unconstitutional because a woman has a right to an abortion protected under the fundamental
right to privacy.” (Roe v. Wade.) Public opinion was split almost in half during this court
session. “The January 1972 Gallup poll showed fifty-seven percent of respondents favored
leaving the decision on abortion to the pregnant women and her physician.”(H. and Hoffer.) This
attitude of Americans became popular during the Great Depression of 1922 – 1939. Families in
the United States had to adjust for the diminishing income and chose to have abortions instead of
another mouth to feed. Social class and race did not matter in the statistics poll. “Ironically, as
Carter 3
birth control, supposedly the alternative to abortion, emerged as a respectable public cause,
economic crisis drove many American women to seek abortions and authorities to warn of a new
abortion epidemic.” (H. and Hoffer.) Handing out birth control did not take care of the abortion
problem, it continued. The number of illegal abortions was innumerable. Ruth Barnett, of
Portland, Oregon, was a female physician who practiced abortions on thousands of patients from
the period of 1929-1953. She was cheaper than the male physicians but because she charged very
little, less than forty dollars, she became very prosperous from all of the women that came to her.
Barnett eventually was convicted, in 1952, because of Oregon’s strict law on abortions, besides
when the mother’s life was in danger. However, Barnett performed abortions with disregard of
the law. “Before she went to jail, Barnett worried, “God almighty, what would my women do
without me?” As another abortionist arrested in the 1951 Portland raids told reporters, “Many of
these girls who get into difficulty beat a path to my door for help… I felt it was my duty to help
these girls. I believe in every community there must be someone to do the work that I have
Over the years abortion has been a continuing controversial debate between the states.
Texas and California have always been very vocal in the case of abortion study, reform, and
legalization. The California Committee to Legalize Abortion argues that Texas laws imposed
servitude on women, forcing them to bear children. They went on to insist that was a violation of
the Thirteenth Amendment against slavery.” When the Planned Parenthood League of
Connecticut birth control clinics were closed at the end of the 1930s, the birth control advocates
sought a doctor who would allow himself to be named as a defendant in a case to challenge the
statute.” (H. and Hoffer.) Planned Parenthood has always pushed for the woman to have an
The legal matter of abortion in the United States has been going on for nearly half a
century. Abortion probably will never be resolved because if the pro-life advocate's fight to make
abortion illegal, then the pro-choice advocates will certainly fight to make it legal again.
Individual states are constantly proposing new laws about abortion. There are also very many
different trends that are changing the pro-life movements. It used to be when you heard the term
‘Pro-life movement’ it was a group of people that lobbied for the rights of the unborn, but now
the movement is no longer a religious group of people that was mostly dominated by older white
men. “In recent years, young, secular ( non-religious) millennial women have stepped forward to
create pro-life originations. Many of these originations are committed to preventing not just
abortion, but all forms of violence - a view that sometimes differs from the pro-life views of the
past, when some groups were accused of not caring about helping a person after they were
born.”(Green.)
(Mouadex1.)
Ohio lawmakers passed a "Heartbeat Bill” in the Senate and the bill was signed into law
by Governor Mike DeWine on April 11th, 2019. “The law would ban abortions in that state from
the moment the heartbeat of a fetus can be detected -- which usually occurs about six weeks into
a pregnancy. The state's current law generally bans abortions after a fetus has begun its 20th
week of gestation unless a doctor determines that the fetus isn't viable outside the womb.
Carter 5
Exceptions are made if the pregnancy puts the woman's health at serious risk.” (Hanna et al.)
This is a huge victory for the fight against the unborn. Eleven states have already passed the
Heartbeat bill, and it has been introduced into five other states and is currently pending in one
state.“The election of Donald Trump as president has also had an impact on the abortion debate.
Trump stated during the 2016 debates that he is pro-life and would like to see Roe v. Wade
overturned and the decision left up to individual states.” (Green.) Trump continues to be an
advocate for the pro-life movement and has declared that he wants to stop funding Planned
Parenthood because they support abortion. There has been a rise in pro-life decisions in
When does life begin, at fertilization, at birth, or somewhere in between that? Those who
believe life starts at fertilization are reputable scientists. To say life starts at fertilization means
that when the male sperm unites with the female egg it creates life. According to “Dr. Jerome
chromosome pattern of Down's Syndrome, and Nobel Prize Winner, in the Report,
Subcommittee on Separation of Powers to Senate Judiciary Committee S-158, 97th Congress, 1st
Session 1981, he said, "After fertilization has taken place a new human being has come into
plain experimental evidence.”.(Alcorn.) Some would argue that this professor is pro-life, but
other scientists are not pro-life that also believe life begins at fertilization. Professor Ashley
Montague, who is a geneticist and professor at Harvard and Rutgers, who is unsympathetic to the
pro-life cause, was quoted as saying, “The basic fact is simple: life begins not at birth, but
conception.”(Alcorn.) Although some continue to argue that life does not begin at fertilization,
In the first trimester when most abortions happen, according to the U.S. CDC, 66% of
legal abortions occur within the first eight weeks of pregnancy, the baby is developed already. In
the first trimester the baby’s bones, skin, heart, intestines, and neurological system are
developed. The baby’s heartbeat can be heard at 6-8 weeks. At week 10 the baby's face now has
taken on a more developed look. His or her intestines are in the stomach. During the second
trimester, the baby’s bones begin to become hard and their skin becomes stronger and thicker.
Week 12 red blood cells are beginning to form in the baby’s spleen and the parents will be able
to find out the sex of the baby. At week 14 the baby can hold its head up and move it’s eyes.
Their movements are becoming more put together and can be caught by an ultrasound. However,
these movements are still too small to be felt by the mother. The baby's ears start to stick out on
their head. The baby might begin to hear. The digestive system has also started to work at week
16. The mother might be able to feel her baby's movements. The baby is regularly sleeping and
waking up at week 20, the halfway mark in the pregnancy. At week 23 the baby will start to
respond to someone’s voice with movement. The baby’s lungs are starting to form at 25 weeks.
During the third and final trimester of the pregnancy, the main system of the nerves can control
the baby's breathing.At week 29 the baby has finished most of their major development and will
now start putting on weight. To prepare for birth, the baby's head might start moving into the
pelvis at week 36. At week 37 the baby's chest is becoming more noticeable. At week 40, the
Abortion is when a pregnancy is terminated by other means besides a natural ending such
get an abortion in the first and second trimester of her pregnancy in any state but during the third
trimester, most states will not perform an abortion. Of course, when you read any scientific
Carter 7
documents concerning these procedures, it will refer to the baby as a fetus instead of a baby. In
an early stage abortion, up to nine weeks, a little tube is entered into the cervix and the baby is
taken out. This procedure is called “menstrual extraction”. However, if all the baby’s body parts
are not taken out, infection can take place, demanding complete dilation of the cervix and is
taken out of the mother. Most people will say that a heartbeat is required for life. So if a
heartbeat can be detected at six weeks then there is life in that womb that is being extracted.
Some people will argue that the baby cannot feel what is happening to them during an abortion,
which is false. Since the neurological system has already been developed at the very beginning
stages of life the baby can feel what is going on during an abortion. At the end of the first
trimester at around twelve weeks of pregnancy, general or local sleeping medicine is given to
the mother and she is dilated fast. A suction curette which is a hollow tube with a knife-edged tip
is put into the sac with the baby. It is then connected to a vacuum machine by a tube. The
vacuum suction then tears the baby and placenta into tiny pieces which are pulled into the
Starting at four months and continuing to six months, Dilation and Evacuation and Saline
Injection are used. Dilation and evacuation is used when a pair of forceps are put into the womb
to hold part of the baby. The jaws of the forceps twist and pull apart the bones of the unborn
baby. This action is repeated until the baby’s body is no longer attached and taken out of the
womb. Normally, the spine has to be broken and the skull mashed up to be able to take the baby
out.. Saline Injection happens when a lengthy sharp needle is inserted with a powerful salt mix
inside the mother's stomach and enters the baby's sac. The baby then consumes the salt mixture
and is poisoned.. It also reacts as an abrasive, burning off the surface of the baby's skin. It
usually takes somewhere over an hour and a half for the baby to pass away. Within a day birth
Carter 8
will normally start to take place and the mom will give birth to a baby who is dead or is in the
process of dying. There have been a significant amount of times where the aborted baby has been
born alive. They are usually left somewhere alone to die. However, in several cases a baby has
survived this and has later been put into an adoptive home and has told their testimony of how
they survived.
During the last three months of pregnancy, a Caesarean Section can be performed.
Caesarean Section is when surgery is performed to enter the mother’s womb through the
stomach. The method is close to Caesarean delivery, besides that the umbilical cord is normally
cut while the baby is still in the mother’s womb. It cuts off the baby's oxygen supply and causes
the baby to suffocate and die. Sometimes the baby is removed alive and just left in a corner to die
of neglect or exposure to chemicals and other things. During the third trimester in some states,
partial-birth abortion is legalized. Partial-birth abortion is when lead by an ultrasound, the doctor
takes the baby's legs with forceps and then the baby's leg is pulled out into the birth canal. Then
the doctor delivers the baby's entire body, besides for the head. The physician then jabs scissors
into the baby's skull. The scissors are then opened to enlarge the skull. The scissors are removed
and a suction catheter is inserted. Then the baby’s brains are sucked out, causing the skull to
collapse. The dead baby is then removed from the mother. These procedures mentioned above
How do abortions affect women’s physical and emotional well-being? Of course, every
woman is different in how they react to any medicine or surgical procedure. Having an abortion
can put a toll on any mother’s physical and mental health. Although statistics say that lide
threatening issues happen in fewer than one out of a hundred first trimester abortions and
approximately one out of every fifty late-term abortions, it is important to be aware of the
Carter 9
following risks that can happen. Some complications can include heavy or constant bleeding,
infection or blood poisoning, cervix damage, scarring of the uterine lining, perforation of the
uterus, damage to other organs, and the mother could even die during the process. These are
hospital facility. Complications are far more dangerous in ‘back alley’ abortion clinics. Even
though the above compactions are listed by the physician that performs the abortion, this list
does not mention other physical complications that could happen like severe contractions during
the abortion. For instance, a Prostaglandin Chemical abortion is when they use mixtures that
cause the uterus to shrink strongly, pushing out the baby who is still forming and developing..
The mother’s contractions are more severe than originally, natural contractions, so the baby is
often killed by them. Some babies have even been beheaded and some babies were born alive.
due to the low prevalence of contraceptive use in Pakistan leads to a huge burden of induced
abortions. These abortions are a major cause of concern, as a majority of these abortions are
and mortalities.” (Baig et al.) Unsafe abortions are a very big factor in a women’s physical harm
to her body. “Unsafe abortion is one of the major causes of maternal mortality that accounts for
approximately 4.7%–13.2% maternal deaths every year. In developing countries, every year,
nearly seven million women get admitted to hospitals for the treatment of complications related
to unsafe abortion. Some of the complications that can occur as a result of unsafe abortion
include hemorrhage, infection, uterine perforation, and injury to the genital tract and internal
organs that can be life-threatening to women. (Baig et al.) Many of the techniques they use for
Carter 10
abortion are unsafe. “Significant morbidity and mortality have occurred following the use of
Far more serious complications occur emotionally than physically. The women who have
had abortions feel hatred and bitterness towards themselves or their partner after abortion
because they have gone through a loss that they cannot explain. When a woman cannot explain
what she went through when she had the abortion she has not experienced any healthy grieving.
Healthy grieving is necessary for anyone who has gone through a loss of any kind. Many women
do not realize that they are responding to the loss of a baby when they have had an abortion.
After they have realized that they have indeed lost a child through a decision of their own
making they are left with feelings of confusion, fear, shame, and guilt. Such feelings must be
dealt with. “Working through grief requires confronting one's loss, admitting the loss, grieving
the loss, learning to live with the loss, and working through the grief to find a renewed sense of
meaning or purpose beyond the loss. Each of these processes must be completed to resolve one’s
grief.” (Burke and Reardon.) Many women find their selves wanting a replacement baby after
they get an abortion; they feel emptiness in their soul that they cannot describe. Many women
feel depressed and ashamed after they have an abortion. Some of the side effects of an abortion
are remorse, irration, at fault, humiliation, the feeling of being alone, becoming self conscious,
loss of sleep or nigh terrors, relationship complications, thoughts of killing themselves, eating
As mentioned, nightmares are a common side effect and many women suffer from
repeated nightmares. One woman who suffered from nightmares after an abortion shared her
desperation to get rid of this nightmare: “The dream usually had a little girl crying for Mommy. I
hear her crying out to me. I can’t get to her and I have a panicky sense that she is in danger. On
Carter 11
some nights I see a tiny helpless rabbit. I reach out to the struggling form and then it vanishes
into a sinking lagoon tinged red with blood. Sometimes I try to call out—but nothing comes out
of my mouth. It’s like I’m trying to scream but nothing comes out. Then the little thing plunges
and comes up again with an urgent gasp of air. With each step I take forward, I go backward as
blood swirls around, like waves coming in and out against the shore. I keep trying to save the
rabbit… as I reach out there is only sand, scarlet sand, slipping between my fingers.”(Burke and
Reardon.) It is a long and traumatic process for those women who have had the abortion to get
back to stable and mental health. For some women, they will never be able to get back to that
place. For many women who do get abortions it can be unsafe and can leave them scarred for
life, “I found a doctor in my community. I told him about my situation and he decided to “help”
me. It was a risky situation for him, and I didn’t have the large sum of money he asked for. He
said he would reduce the price if I had sex with him. Scared, I accepted. After I “paid” him, he
inserted an injection and pills into my uterus. It was painful, like cramps, but worse. I couldn’t
tell anyone, and I was worried because through the course of the night I hadn’t even bled. I was
afraid it wouldn’t work and that I’d wind up with a sick baby. I went to the doctor first thing in
the morning. He examined me and said that I was so early into the pregnancy that my body
Some may argue that it is better to have an abortion than an unwanted child. Dr. Nada
Stotland used this argument in her medical discussion in the Journal of the American Medical
Association, entitled “The Myth of Abortion Trauma Syndrome.” She uses in her case study of
treating women with post-abortion psychological problems that “women who are at high risk of
psychological problems after abortion are at equally high or higher risk if they continue their
pregnancies.”(Burke and Reardon.) She refused, however, to give proof to her research or her
Carter 12
perspective. If a person is going to make a statement such as this then they need to be able to
support their conclusion with facts instead of personal opinion. Labor and abortion will forever
change a women’s life. Stotland cannot claim that a woman who carries her child to term can be
equally at danger of encoutering the same signs ohumiliation, and remorse that are attached with
an abortion. Studies have proven that women who choose to have their babies, even an unwanted
pregnancy, are less likely to attempt suicide and experience depression than a woman who
chooses abortion.
Every single human being has an opinion. Opinions based upon facts and coming from
intellectuals bear much more weight than the person with no education. Physicians, Scientists,
and Theologians all have varied opinions in the individual fields. Gregory Koukl an author and
apologetics theologian said, “If the unborn is not a human person, no justification for abortion is
necessary…If the unborn is a human person, then no justification for abortion is adequate.”
(Platt.) Many people say that social services have too many kids and it’s better to get an abortion
than to put more kids into the system. There are other ways instead of abortion. There are private
Physicians have different opinions on the effects of abortion on a woman’s body even
though they have attended the same medical classes and have passed the same boards to become
a doctor. “The impact of abortion on the body of a woman who chooses abortion is great and
always negative. I can think of no beneficial effect of a social abortion on a body."(Martin.) Even
though there has been plenty of research and personal testimonies from women that have
experienced abortions to verify the negative impact on a woman’s physical and emotional well-
being after an abortion, there are still physicians that have the opinion that abortions are not
The scientific debate on abortion has changed drastically over the years because of
advancements in this field. The science of Ectogenesis (the creation of life outside the uterus),
has dramatically impacted the views of scientists and physicians on the topic of life and abortion.
In April 2017, scientists at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia announced that they had used
an artificial womb to gestate a lamb fetus for four weeks. The womb looked like a large plastic
bag full of a liquid similar to amniotic fluid, with attachments so the lamb could be fed
nutrients.” (Green.) Because of this development of artificial wombs, some pro-life advocates
feel like this is a possible solution to the problem of unplanned or unwanted pregnancies.
However, this procedure would be very costly to perform on every baby whose mother intended
an abortion. Scientists would need to decide when to remove the baby from the mother’s body.
Would physicians be able to remove a zygote from a woman’s body or would she be required to
carry the child until a later date when the baby can better support life? The Philadelphia research
team “ insists it is not looking to replace mothers or extend the limits of viability – merely to find
a better way to support babies who are born too early.” (Green.) Artificial wombs will probably
Pro-Choice advocates and organizations such as Planned Parenthood would like people to
believe that medical science is on their side of the debate, however; this is far from being true.
Many physicians are not pro-life that will give the medical facts in the same manner as the pro-
life physician. Dr. Beverly McMillan is an OB/GYN and in 1975, she became the first woman to
open an abortion clinic in Mississippi. She ceased doing abortions in 1978 when she became
convinced that the abortions she was performing were causing everyone involved far more harm
than good. “Women who have had abortions also experience more ectopic (tubal) pregnancies,
infertility, hysterectomies, stillbirths, miscarriages, and premature births (the leading cause of
Carter 14
birth defects) than women who have not had abortions. Abortion has also been linked to
No matter what the outcome of Roe v. Wade was or the laws that get passed today,
abortion has harmful effects on everyone involved. Abortion is taking a life, which is murder,
even if it is legalized. “Currently in 38 states if a criminal kills a woman who is pregnant the
criminal gets charged with two counts of murder” (Skinner and Garcia.) But if the mother
chooses to have the babies life terminated by abortion, it is not considered murder. How can the
law justify a criminal killing a pregnant woman as two counts of murder but abortion does not
count as one count of murder? The debate of when life begins will vary in opinion from
conception, to the final trimester, and to when the baby takes the first breath of oxygen.
However, when people are educated about the developmental stages of the baby and see a
sonogram, there is a realization that there is life unfolding. A pregnant woman, who has been
informed of choices other than abortion, and still chooses abortion as the way out of the
pregnancy will deal with emotional guilt as well as possible physical side effects from the
abortion. Physicians and Scientists all disagree within their field of expertise on abortion, but the
opinion that will matter in the end is one of the mothers who will be the one to live with the
consequences of the action. Abortion and its harmful effects should require long hours of
consideration.
Carter 15
Works Cited
Alcorn, Randy. " Scientist Attest To Life Beginning At Conception." NAAPC. Available at:
https://naapc.org/when-does-a-human-being-begin/why-life-begins-at-conception/
Aultman, Kathi, et al. “Deaths and Severe Adverse Events after the Use of Mifepristone as an
Abortifacient from September 2000 to February 2019.” Issues in Law & Medicine, vol.
Addressal.” British Journal of Midwifery, vol. 29, no. 2, Feb. 2021, pp. 94–98.
Burke, Theresa Karminski, and David C. Reardon. Forbidden Grief: The Unspoken Pain of
Erik Skinner, Alise Garcia. State Laws on Fetal Homicide and Penalty-Enhancement for Crimes
Carter 16
H., Hull N E, and Peter Charles Hoffer. Roe v. Wade the Abortion Rights Controversy in
American History. Lawrence, KS: U of Kansas, 2021. Print. [Accessed 9 July 2021].
Hanna, Jason, Dominique Debucquoy-Dodley, and Max Blau. "Ohio Passes 'heartbeat' Abortion
Bill; Leader Cites Trump's Election | CNN Politics." CNN. Cable News Network, 07 Dec.
Martin, Daniel J. M.D. , "The Impact of Legal Abortion on Women’s Minds and Bodies," paper
presented at the "Human Life and Health Care Ethics" national conference, April, 1993.
Green, Meghan. Abortion: A Continuing Debate. New York, NY: Lucent, 2018. Print.
McMillan, Beverly. "How Safe Is Abortion? Dr. Beverly McMillan, Former Abortionist."
http://afterabortion.org/1999/how-safe-is-abortion-dr-beverly-mcmillan-former-
Platt, David. A Compassionate Call to Counter Culture. Carol Stream, IL: Tyndale House, 2015.
"Roe v. Wade - Case Summary and Case Brief." Legal Dictionary. 16 Apr.
Sedgwick, Josephine. "'I Couldn't Tell Anyone': Women Around the World Reveal Intimate
Stories of Abortion." The New York Times. The New York Times, 09 July 2018.
Available
at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/09/reader-center/abortion-around-the-world.html
Torres, Aida, and J.D. Forrest, "Why Do Women Have Abortions?" Family Planning