BEPORC

THE HON BLP UTY CV1L COUR

MOMBAL

O.s No -

2020
TN THe MATTeR

PARENTS . .. Plainli

POICENOm Com PANY AND

koLA RASPORT SERUCE S DEen DANT

ON SOBMISS1ON
10 HE C11Y 1V12 (oURT MOMBA

ORI1TEN SUBMISSIDN ON BE HBLP Of PLAIN TIEP

 TABLE OF CoRJ E A

ABB REVIATIONS, -.. .

ONDEX DF AuTHoRITeS, 2

STATE MENT OF JURISDICTIOAN .

STATEMEN DF FACTS

STATE MENT Of TssES.,..

SUMMARY 0f ARGU MENTS . . 8

ARGUMENTS ApvA NCED, . -Jo

Css OE ONE

TwO

OSsUE THRE E.

PRAYER 20

MEmORIAL OM BEHALF Of PETITIONER

 LIST OF ABGREVATIONS

SC Sua Cowd
HC Hugl Cgus
gou4 Cnga nwed
V
AR
AICadia aere
How'ble Hon o ab Le
St Sale
Alc AccPding
apP appiahOn
Sec SecHon
0SS OHhes
GPS

MEMORIAL ON BEHALA DF
PETITIO0ER
 TNDEX Au THORIt1eS

Coses
Bhim Hamdal Magoa (ov
Clnd OvYS AIR 1961 Pat 21
2 Jagon Roma MouoU V hadag
Pvasod Salnu (1903) LR 34 (al 743
3. MokoOY bihaa v. Dha Tmccdo hase
LR (19o3) 30 cal 539 (PC
Sadhu lax w Sundon Cuunin VSaclh

Swyananaoa AR 195o Mad 2

SS. Somi}a Gupta v
Jrder eet sig
(2011) SC lo P 2t3
6. Fiborosa V fa bau w 1942 UKHL
ALL EY 122

KalyQn Pur nn U Sto Buhc

A1R 19SY SC 6S
B Moses v Mac ferlon
9 Toulok dhand Mochand v
DmuSO men o Salas Tax

197o AiR 698

Aril
CBuAventaues
o Dwied stales

MEMORIA DN BE HALP OFPANSISE

Books
Auatan Singl dia Comvad
4H Eoi io
2 AK Jeu n Couhact la
3 ulla Comtyac lCud

loqd databose
1 SCO Onine
2 Re o
3 Tmdicn Konoo (om

Lgislabiow
cicun Consadk Ad, 1872

MeMoR192 D BEHA)F DF PLAINTIF

 STATEMENT of 30RISD1 CT ION

The Plakw HP mwbly Aubni s

emoYcucluu en Hhe u t u d ujor
Hs Ho ble put The u t Comw
H e Cohad Vauc oub- inio'" is iud
intho ud of G ivl Cosd,
Auwwbu i ocBrdaun i Ha cion b,
Sechon 9 CLnc Sechon 20 e Hhe Goil
Pouecaduad Codo, Hhe C9wt has Hhe
yuusditHoy o Hhe atHos
doude all ho
o i+ derision

memoRiAL Ono BEHALPOf PLAlDnff

 &79TE meN Df PACTS

Pohe- (ath was&dhoangtobl gamang app

okich ue baatd on viotuas-uol inluac
Owolaus He o n a choxocler (allsd
Loi uabo ooaou
Pok&noms
4e u s
4e has t6 Stat Hhur PS in orday to
hacR Hhe PokoMous iu Hue upholo u
2 Kola app was a oladt (ab Aewius
to L aola app h uLt has
oleuat
4enab Hhev 6PS amd Hhou Hy
AL thl utulouble (oub in Huiv uty
33 Porenbm aud Kola Compam satd a ioiud
Kola ahp e uDs
Uadne PoRemowm -

Honeugh Hus e bo H (abs amd pokunond

ihn Ha Sume wap md seloct He (ab te
(atdh he pokuvoms
Lould awcu Ha dowi cas by dpusvlodig
cwiP H abs
S Panmet s ( bo madlo Hengl,
Vi aal
6 agumls down Lsacled Hhe
pokl- (afeh apb
by wakuug CM Glsus poy md abter Hhod
Ricd wacla a ONOhadl in- onb aunclokk
Ond toka a dude to (oftl a pokmom by
h (ab
(ab und He p AT Dos acds

BE HRLF DF PLAN FF
MEMORIAL
 6
Hoog Ha Oudit (ad and no by

aap Rundhase amel ca

Se -
Ju ces C8sts H a Hngusands

ubee s
Paret ud t Comblaant G
Civil Dut Hun bos

MEMORIAz ON BEHALF OF fIANTIFF

 S70CMe N Of

DSsUe I:
o he Hhern
Agatmnd s
valid 0 ot
TSsuE
Dke Han Hhe Po humom
amd Kola
ompo
Droms pov (Bp0
is abl , wnjust

ME MOR1A OO BEHALFOP PLAn iPF

 SomMAAy OF ARCOMeNTS

1Ss0f

Lohe tHo Ha AgpuaAd i ualid o

wot ?

ww.by uhubutd bone Hhe

row'bla CBwd Hhod He.agputmad
ooouow lsadiue He apb usuali
but
bud H hea iM- obb edaak
clHerend aguunald ad
Haed us Uoie- ab- iuio 0s H
dhildw us uo lomas let te lobad
Alc to A 1 of te oiec Bepd
Act, 18712 Omd On CucLed&
Saml Uulief Sougd
JSsUE

whe Hhe Pha PoRuno wn Cambamy d

Kola LSmpam Gable BhoY
un just MYI Chnuud ?

umab ly huubiHecl ha e He
hon' bo C8t Hhad Hopo keno m
(orpa Cund Rola Comp ad
MEMORIAL OD BEHALf OF PLAINnfF
 iabla o umjus udh
ot cs H amou

elpt kno u ohad H u

Hhe Comp o uwyou y
deonq Ha pont on ho iu-opp
erchao Cund Aeupal cab-Ju das
wudh as to bo talet on vual
CugnU tmd
Come Joief us sougld

meMORIAL ON BEHALF OF P1A)N?I Ff

 10

ARGUM¬NTS ADUAN CED

TWHETH ER AReeMENT IS VALID oR

NOT ?

i s hubly Jubu thd by he Plainli

hat hore Mo Valic agtenaat baluaeen
He omepay and ha kid. e volian
ohacd A Dulf leanly Atodes hak o
pntnaut dnfoud wih HuinoY (ad he
Om forceel Dnnc ho valid s Doiel aub
indioit Wsonq un pa Stoke The
agrue mt HOt mauntable.

.Conhaed wih a monoy us Voiel abinio

The plaindh ff uwwbe ubuk be oxe s

(Ot hact Phe wiau e n hals
e valid lonhad us Hhe Couupe lence
he par fis oa p haed Seclon 1l
Undian (onpad Act 1812, slales
hot e lohauo lonhat toaiulividual
aspect
who usof Aa age o
E w huon s (oumpelt lo (oeprecd und wko us af
May Ak to H l a le olich e, us Jubyut
sotdwind, and s nel disqualbbiednan tuhocing by any
lau te uwluth a Aub d (Secion t)
MEmORIA O 3EHALF Of PLAiT1FP
 11

u b by kubmi Hhed Ho A or H
aclian HajoviAt 1875, he age ob mepviy
in Gnelia s heufed as 18 yans. Euei a
day shorB of Hs shaiied ag o nderung in
Confrad disquali ies h iedioi duas hen
baing apao 4oi As pu udicun louo,
minor'saguimmt staucs Voi, wid
mas Hhat it has no &tomel whakome
M Hhe yes of laus. So a Couroct u i t
uno standds wll amd voicl inu aHe
pa-y (anot imhseit

t h o r aed ut p umauy
Uwalon e eldiug & mnor's agõee naont yoid
s Hat okexa aagroLmct Hoongh whid
Hat
a nuveY iMcudos a hremuse u hs pa-t
brhis pronise s n enkd pant o He
agwlmet, it oucls voic nce a
us wet ualsed fo makt a proul imhosim
a legal pblgafion

1:2 o iabih on Jouor ouhact wet

ntorab
The plaiut huuublt &ke Rnt is
i s
2 AR 1961 Pa 21

MeMORIA2D BE HALF Of PLAINTIf

 12

Cleany oid in 3gon Rama Manoeni V.

Moha olto Praknel Suu 3
Hot non
Omders inlo CAA Ogumimd utho vno
inlenFionally 0x uwwn.lem
lenhonalyt
us is nustakRe amd he Caannot dac
Hhe clabt rovm He tild Eutn p
Child ejanaians imuulf a wmajov
at
at he Fil oh He conad. e
dlodrut oh astoph wilaJsp t ba
olepli cab in hat

The plointf huwubby subats baou His

Coust Hot hare o (aAQ oCombacd

the anued CoR cenauo becou

ApP hiq wnd by
was eicls vet
he pants Cundhenc h w0 aics
w not at
Aoil bosou h snhad itkel
Mot vaicl cmd @ntoCRalle ct all.

&ubuts Ht h
(pwo wc fact
hat he us tomos with who hay
ao oleauli nq o uOYS (a h Saud
AcausR H pp okEnOM- Cateh as a

3. Ug09) 12R 36 Cal 68 V.

Mohovi bbet
1LR (1903) 30 (al Ss9 P
Dhon moda) bhoSe

MEMoRIAL ON BA HAP Of PLAIN TIPP

u g oel ctdes inngin an dasoulos
(alled'Pobivewk' uobad dssvd uven
xist i Hh esl ubevld dmd obvicu
ah o gowns oi b Plag
by eils ou

Tha ploisP Her Aubrads Hrod

peko m p o mlera ug fato pud
ntune kola ap a a uaal
plamneel o a jo boost pe ounpa
ngs tegeHo bacaul p4 haeu
Vey u ect i he m ege boH A
tha ids unencuoingy w toh
He vuelas te (afch Hhose pokomowd
The odR ids Hhey dont hoa
umdastandin Hat what H doing
DOYOn
13 ens liabla e ay o iM-pp
Puchase&

The plain k hwby &ubmis Hhot

poun 3 vot make
p mts in god to in- ap Jeuulolt

MEMORIAL O BEHALP DF P1AIN 1FP

 bacauuk& he (onbhat anesd by patnls
oa Gab o h olgow loodliny pa ends
eh He aph ud wot on He in-ap
uwnchalUs, honc0 Hho you6us iM-op
Jawndhos ado by ha kid os a
li pPoet agtoAdk aud ús not valid
wunoY

us ubui Heed b He plainli hat

in He (L e Sad ha laxni Sund cuene
V. Sad ha Swueunaray cumaa dan ues
Dunby nel oy Ues
aqunst a ak o
a wuoY md H faPur ob te nunoy
(Omuot ba Lald asu aly i o uuov
has Hhe nov (am b
helel fe ba ablo.

H e ubuittecel by He plaik f
he a agrec to o Comrod
he end undered b h
wws
pavns
Hhe
uned ot
douomloacitg He a
Ha ucles ohich H: Hhev
id ook unhvow inguy A uclend
Mam l l
is
CUM
a9RMAR ohore ho ay hau
S AiR 1950 Mad 244

MEMoRIAL ON BEHALP OF PLAINTIff

 1S

o (atc ma sony au mal Omd fahe

( a b lowiasfan His

salso CBnlonlecl Hha it us

clea Om Hu ats hod he
Lompo ha ogly thanged a
peount o H hid or He dudo whic
has 4abun by H kied widh wb

&ubaokd lo a paid hoough vinuod

Cuwvunay bu Ha acu ay dhaaps
o e oucdit (and

MeMOR1AL ON BEHALF OF PLANTIFP

 6

L WHE THER POKEND M CoMPAN AnND KOLA

Com PANy LABLE FOR DDTUSTENRICHMENT?

i s hww.buy submi Hed Hhade in he

resent (ase AonD om He auound of
plainds daduceel uwnlauofly wihouk
a laufal CDnprot DoLccoptamt herefore
pokouonn CompaCndl Kola Dramspov
Avwias e o
yoMH uabQJo Dajult
WnJuchMent against plaunH

saHe ubwi thed botone i s

louwt ha wyust wudhmen vas boem
definte ousA hanet ebtaiuecd om
OmePher, not in teucled ous a qufL omd
not gulyusable o which H
honeua nust make sH ufiou 0
UwLommhmsalion A daim or Uust
nidh e n uuses when heu hos bOM
an wwju&t Jatenion e a banet o
ho Loss o Onmothon he utenion
0 Money pro fey oOmothor against
Ho Ln damen tol ainaplas o qusice

I Soita Guspda V ndojeed Singl

2011) sc 1o P2 8
 17

eguiy O good lonsuene 12 Sudic

Docuine of Uajus ayicdhwed sCodipiecd

M Maclens Auch os nciun CDntral
At , 18t2 (Sec 68-42) Gmbal Excise
Cunck Custom lou 1991.

os hunbby kubmu-tleol in he hxond

CusR where hefty Omowmt h a b e
Chongtagainst He iM-ahþ ondhoils
and obd udles te ald poromom
wihou he araher Compact bumly
Gacs to am ut wwudhment On port
boH daendants Compomies (as
e PibYosa V. ainboin wlerin land
Wught Stale hat CU Cumuseck
g o lau s bowmd to rovioda
vwmedius
emeclus has
Cuses(ues ofwha
,
beem
Callec nsjust vudhnendt mjuAt
benepit, Hhat is, te awndt Ma
Prom
om Wtainng he mon o on some
heneft lvid ron amo Hho whidh us
aganst (nsuen ha e ghould kup"

rhen porthen 8ubu Heel hact Alc

Sec lion 72 0f Dneicn (om ha ct Ac&
2 Blade Lawis DiciBMad
3 1942 0KHL 4 AL Er 122
 1872 Libiuly o oonson who
money us baid b mistahe 0 umd
Caercio ohith p a honson to
ohom mony has bo0M puid o u
oleli ue d by isak A hepao

2.1 BoHh Panes ndor Micake

s hummbly Aubiteel hat in Joud
(ae Lohore bo pantos Oru wndu mistaka
o act mahes it void-ab -iuio
Thert for 4o pali it as one eh Pue
w8enial dechon 42 n Kalyam Pur
ne V St oBha SC eld
kive pa Anung COmact n mistake
ocks maks ik voel Some
Pous cwvud In eeLt (ak0 whwe
iwno t cildsen Hhe Aakl of Lime
V y u t wmin enhenally
pdhasl D the alp De foncda-t
ob Ligaed by he as o atunal ushice
9pty 8 e Jwwa the S
mone

H.191 scR 9S8 AR 195 SC 16 S

5. Moses . Mac janle

MEMoRI AL ON BEHALF of PLAIN 71fF

 19

O s her ubited iu Hhe laned wrask

(asL o Glok chancl Hok chancd V
Coummi ss iemen of Sales Tax 6 a wm
paud salag tax a moYe Hhom ua
un
Six Hhosmdd Rpha M Jwptut of
sale in ousidle He stale 0 Bombay
annc ohich CUe not Uasle to
tax he amout was derad e
poy y
he
uun dad by sc
SC
frofound lauoyeyuust & phlospher
Joseph SHo stoaled Hhad" ugui tab le
uu spuclanes wwre obla te
mampulak
Comsthuios doices o as to wADwe
wnjut Uwudh wmend.7
Amd last 4 nhes bikd Hal
H Cpmaes has uaiad unjust
Dbiclwnet by Collabra inq t ophs
Ganel luige dild dntH in -abb
unhole

6 1570 A1R 898

Cpmutarues Cemsk ion oOnied stales

MEmORIA2 On BEHALF Of PLAwafe

 20

PRAVER

On ligut ha ocls of (o
uLsu taisecl ay gudnk ad vouncac
Ond cuA Hhbau tus ud He
ansel p
bo nal
oh leik6n hunbly pro
boo He How'b swt B
umb u to bo
holcd
pland to
adjudya
wnd dadn

. hed Ha Agsmund s
2. Thet
voi
HhY is a mvudnoud
Cuud Hhe
ploin HH should be
vupaid beuuk H Ounb d wud
uswons
dhenged by Hh
(9mpcmies
AND OR

Pass dty had i cland dit iu

Hho inteo Jusku, £qJuaucl
qcod Cn Suento Avd is, H
reiioma ab i duy bouno shall
huvabl PY
CDONSEL DP PLAINSIFF

MEMORIA ON 3EHAP Of ANTFP