Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Constantine
“Dino” Kiritsis
Strategic
Business Leader
2018-2019
Webinar series
“100”
1. Introduction - Strategic Business Leader - SBL
KEEP NOTES!
2 23/08/2018 Title of presentation - enter in the Header & Footer field ©ACCA
3 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis ©ACCA
1.1 The aim of the exam
Professionalism
©ACCA
1.5 Managing the time
©ACCA
1.6 Managing the time - summary
©ACCA
1.7 Managing the time
©ACCA
Sample exhibits from Specimen 2*
*NOTES:
We will be using Specimen 2 in the webinars so make sure you become familiar with it!
I will ask you to read Specimen 2 and annotate the information after the completion of
webinar 1, so as to be more effective when handling the questions!
©ACCA
1.8 Similarities in the Strategic Business Leader exam
Role of student
Format
Audience
Verb used – task based
Mark allocation
Professional skills marks
1.9 Key points when reading the requirements
14 23/08/2018 ©ACCA
1.11 Key words to help identify theories and models!
Address the requirements as written, taking particular notice (again!) of the verbs used
Make sure you include the most important, relevant and crucial points relating to the
requirement.
Only make relevant points and try not to include superfluous information or make
unsupported points.
Show deep/clear understanding of underlying or causal issues and integrate or link
different sources of information from various parts of the scenario or different exhibits to make
points
Avoid repeating points already made.
Show your ability to prioritise and make points in a logical and progressive way, building
arguments rather than using a random or ‘scattergun’ approach to answering the question.
Structure and present your answers in a professional manner through faithfully simulating
the task as would be expected of the person being asked to carry it out and always have a
clear stakeholder focus in mind when constructing the answer.
Level 3
Synthesis and evaluation requires demonstration of the • Create new
following capabilities: insights
Creation of new ideas from, or new insights into, • Compare
existing knowledge • Evaluate
Generalisation, comparison, and discrimination using • Infer
complex and unstructured information • Make a
judgement
Assessment and evaluation of complex information
• Justify
Use of reasoned argument to infer and make • Recommend
judgement
Presentation and justification of valid
recommendation
©ACCA
1.17 Professional skills – 20% of exam, but embedded!
©ACCA
1.19 Commercial acumen
©ACCA
1.20 Analysis
©ACCA
1.21 Scepticism
Probing deeply into the underlying reasons for issues and problems, beyond
what is immediately apparent from the usual sources and opinions available.
Question facts, opinions and assertions, by seeking justifications and
obtaining sufficient evidence for their support and acceptance.
Challenge information presented all decisions made where this is clearly
justified, in a professional and courteous manner; in the wider professional,
ethical, organisational, or public interest
©ACCA
1.22 Evaluation
©ACCA
1.23 Dealing with the volume of information – the case
©ACCA
1.24 Methods of controlling the information
REPORT/MEMORANDUM/BRIEFING PAPER
To:
By/From:
Title/about or RE:
Date:
Introduction
.
Paragraph 2 title
.
Paragraph 3 title
.
Conclusion/recommendations/further action etc.
29 ©ACCA
1.26 Layout for letters
Letters
Should start with (fake) name and address of sender, name and address of
recipient, date,
Dear Mr X/Dear Sir
Concerning / What the letter is about
Letter – divided into paragraphs but not usually numbered
Finish of with something like “If you need any further information please do not
hesitate to contact me”
If the letter starts ‘Dear Sir’ it is usual to end it ‘Yours faithfully’ If it starts Dear M.
X/Ms Y’ it is common to end it ‘Yours sincerely’.
Press release:
Company name
“Press release”
Signed: PR office
33 ©ACCA
1.30: Writing tips 2
Avoid harsh or ‘definite’ language; After all, you are a candidate and
you cannot be “sure” in many cases - especially in business– on what
will work for a company. Examples of words to avoid: “surely”,
“definitely”, ”of course” etc.
80/20 principle: The above point implies that there are NO CORRECT
answers, and you are free to write your own assessment.
34 ©ACCA
1.31 Answer Plan (brief)
35 ©ACCA
1.32 The good points to mention!
Corporate Governance – Why? Board of Directors - Role Risk Management Internal Controls – “sound” IC
Agency theory Composition & committees Dynanic Risk Internal Audit – objectives?
o Accountability Unitary vs two tier boards (+/-) Monitor Code of Ethics & Professional Values
o Fairness NED’s and role Types of risks (Strategic / Tucker’s 5 step model - ethical
Operational Risk) decisions
o Judgement Induction & CPD
Risk Mapping Social Responsibility of Accountants
o Probity Diversity
Risk Strategies (TARA) Professional Codes of Ethics (i.e.
Stakeholders Disclosure (mandatory – voluntary) IESBA)
ERM – COSO
Stakeholder Mapping BoD effectiveness (how?) Conflict of Interest, Ethical threats &
Safeguards
Related & Correlated Risk
Normative vs Instrumental Rules vs Principles & limitations of
governance Corruption
Risk culture & Risk appetite
Institutional Investors
Public sector governance & 3 E’s criteria Integrated Reporting & Value
Role of risk manager
Contribution of codes?
6 capitals of an integrated report 6ICyber – security (methods) SAF – Suitability, Acceptability, PID
Feasibility
Environmental & sustainability accounting E-business (types, pros & cons) - full
Business Structures Project manager vs Project
Vision & Mission
Disruptive technology & examples Sponsor
PESTEL (environment) Outsourcing pros & cons & Harmon’s
’s theory Matrix Elements of a project Plan
5 Forces (competition)
Marketing Mix in the digital era Shared Services Post implementation review
Diamond (national comp. advantage)
Market Segmentation Collaborative working
Scenarios Post audit review
Supply chain management / e- Business process redesign
Capabilities, Resources & Competencies procurement Leadership / Leadership Traits
Change Management
CSF’s & KPI’s Entrepreneurship /
SWOT analysis
Balanced Scorecard Lewin’s model Intrapreneurship
Organizational Culture - Web
Baldrigdge Balogun Hope Hailey model Financial Analysis
Ansoff’s growth matrix
Benchmarking POPIT model Short & Long term financing
Growth methodologies (common)
Generic Strategies Resistance to change
Franchising
Forecasting & Budgeting
BCG matrix
Project Management
Internal growth Variance Analysis
Value Chain
Project Constraints
Big data (3 V’s theory) Mergers Investment appraisal
Business Case, CBA & Risks
Cloud Systems (pros & cons) Acquisitions Ratio Analysis
Data Analytics & Business Intelligence Joint Ventures Costing
Why governance?
©ACCA
Area 7/100 – What is agency relationship and what are the costs
associated?
Why? Separation of ownership & control, especially after businesses
were growing and required people that were not ’family’
You have been asked to prepare a briefing paper for the Rail Co Trust Board
which:
(a) Identifies and explains the agency relationship of the parties involved in Rail
Co and discusses the rights and responsibilities of those parties. (8 marks)
Professional skills marks are available for demonstrating communication skills
in clarifying the agency relationships involved in Rail Co. (2 marks)
(b) Assesses the role and value of non-executive directors on the board of Rail
Co, as a public sector company. (6 marks)
Professional skills marks are available for demonstrating evaluation skills in
assessing the role and value of non-executive directors in a public sector
environment. (2 marks)
Total: 18 marks
This is the main difference with “responsibility” in the sense that you can
be responsible without a contract.
48 23/08/2018 ©ACCA
Area 9/100: What is a “Stakeholder”?
©ACCA 49
Example of stakeholders
Pressure Competitors
groups Media
Inner circle
Outer circle
Customers Suppliers
Board
Employees Shareholders
Talent
– Individuals who can make a difference to organisational performance through their
immediate contribution or, in the longer term, by demonstrating high future potential.
Talent management
– The attraction, identification, development, engagement, retention and deployment of
individuals who are of particular value to an organisation.
– It is critical for Rail Co to develop, manage and retain individuals as part of a planned
talent management strategy.
Notes:
The definition of talent emphasises that these are individuals who can make an impact
on the performance of Rail Co. This is of utmost importance in the near future as Rail Co
attempts to turn around its business performance.
Importantly, talent management should be seen as a key strategic management activity
which sits alongside and indeed underpins the whole corporate strategy.
Many organisations consider the ‘talents’ of all their staff and work on ways to develop
their strengths. Talent management programmes may include a range of activities such
as formal and informal leadership coaching, networking events and board-level and client
exposure. It can also include ensuring that all staff are adequately and effectively trained
and motivated at all levels of the business
Slide 2:
The contribution of the chief executive in talent management
– Important that talent management strategy is led from the top
– Senior management team must assess the human talent needs of the change programme
– Driving force in attracting talent and building a high performance workplace
Notes:
Ensuring that the talent management strategy is closely aligned with the corporate strategy must be a priority. The
CE must lead the senior management team in understanding the main priorities of the change programme in Rail
Co which should then be used to develop a human talent forecast, which can help shape Rail Co’s talent
management strategy.
Visible senior-level support for talent management is critical, and this is best done by the CE.
The ability to attract external talent depends upon how potential applicants view Rail Co. The creation of an
attractive employer brand is an important factor in recruiting external talent. Again, the CE will be a driving force in
this, as the figure head and mouthpiece of the organisation he will be integral in creating the employer brand which
will attract talent to Rail Co.
Normative view:
We have a moral duty towards others
We need to act in general sense of what is right
©ACCA
Area 12/100: Key Stakeholder: “Institutional investors” –
Why are they important?
Example: Goldman Sachs Institutional shareholder intervention – How? – When?
Types Strategy
©ACCA
Area 13/100 – What is the board of directors?
©ACCA
Possible exhibit to check:
Website page
©ACCA
Area 14/100 – Types of boards?
Advantages? Disadvantages?
©ACCA
Area 15/100: What is a Non Executive Director? (NED)
©ACCA
Area 17/100 – Why is board Diversity important?
The concept of diversity encompasses acceptance and respect of visible and nonvisible
differences that exist between people
Race
Ethnicity
Gender
Sexual Orientation
Socioeconomic
Status
Age
Physical Ability
Religious beliefs - Political beliefs
Experience - background
Other issues:
Women on boards
Diversity of NEDs
©ACCA
Area 18/100 Why split the role of Chairman & CEO?
Reasons for:
Representation
Segregation of duties
Accountability
Avoid possible abuse of power
Reasons against:
Unity (Since there are 2 leaders)
Ability
©ACCA
Possible exhibits - CV
©ACCA
Possible exhibits – Board meeting minutes
©ACCA
Area 19/100 What are the components of a Director’s
remuneration package?
Reason for rewards: ATTRACT, RETAIN & MOTIVATE!
Needs to be Legal, Ethical, Competitive, Regulatory
Basic Salary
Pension
Benefits
Share options
Termination
Performance – related (Advantages? Disadvantages?)
PRPs
Bonus
©ACCA
Area 20/100 Why is Induction & CPD required for
Directors?
©ACCA
Area 21/100 How can we evaluate a board? (its
performance)
Why & How boards are appraised
Performance appraisal (Board as a whole and
as individuals)
Decisions
Agenda
Expertise
Participation
©ACCA
Area 22/100 Why do we have Board
Committees? What is the best practice?
Why?
How many?
Which ones?
You need to know their role & their composition (i.e.
based on Sarbanes Oxley):
Audit (100% NEDs)
Remuneration (100% NEDs)
Risk (Majority NEDs)
Nomination (Majority NEDs)
©ACCA
Example: Audit committee duties: Internal & external
©ACCA
Area 23/100 – Why Disclose?
Of what? (statements, environment reports, other reports, profit warnings,
stakeholder meetings etc.)
Aim: To improve public understanding of the firm, attract capital, increase
investor confidence, attract new investors etc.
It is part of “good corporate governance”
Voluntary vs Mandatory?
Advantages of Voluntary?
Transparency
Attracting investors
Reputation
Useful information about company for all Stakeholders
©ACCA
Possible exhibits
©ACCA
Area 24/100 – Rules vs Principles
74 23/08/2018 Title of presentation - enter in the Header & Footer field ©ACCA
Area 25/100 – Public Sector Governance
Public sector – delivering goods or services not provided by “for profit” entities
©ACCA
Important: Stakeholders in Public Sector Governance
©ACCA
Area 26/100 – What are the contributions of Governance Codes
and what are their limitations?
Reactionary process Stressed governance importance
Impact varies Highlighted dangers
Restricts individual decision-making Provided benchmarks
power
Emphasised accountability and
Bureaucracy transparency
Harms competitiveness
Cannot stop fraud
©ACCA
Area 28/100 – Dynamic Risk
Dynamic Risk: This means that Risk is not static. It changes over time and
between situations, therefore risks are DYNAMIC.
©ACCA
Area 29/100 – The ALARP Principle
The ALARP level is reached when the time, trouble and cost for further reduction
measures become unreasonably disproportionate to the additional risk reduction
obtained.
Risk can be categorized in two main broad categories to help managers analyse
the probability that the risks will materialise and the hazard if they do materialise.
Strategic Risks: Those that arise from the fundamental decisions that directors
take concerning an organisation’s objectives.
Organisations need to decide on how to ‘deal’ with each risk. As noted in the Risk Management
Process, TARA can be used to help remember strategies:
Transfer
Avoid
Reduce
Accept
The role of the board, apart from crafting the strategy of the organisation is to also
set the “Risk Appetite” of the organisation; or how much risk is the organisation
willing to accept as well as its attitude towards risk (Risk Attitude).
This is usually based on the organisation’s overall Risk Strategy and influenced by
the Risk capacity (how much risk the business can accept).
Draft a section of the report to identify and briefly discuss THREE main risks
which DCS Company currently faces and plot them on a heat map,
recommending appropriate strategies to manage those risks using an
appropriate risk management framework. (6 marks)
The potential risks which the company could face whether or not it re-aligns its business are
as follows:
(Note: Candidates only need to discuss any three of these to gain maximum marks)
Strategic risk, business risk, financial risk and environmental risk.
(Note: Markers can give additional credit for any reasonable risks identified from the case
information and give a Professional Skills mark for a reasonable positioning of the risks in the
heat map)
Strategic risk
The key strategic risk which DCS faces is the increased competition in the data communications components manufacturing
market, the reduced margins and potential decline in the future. At the same time DCS faces the risk of missing an opportunity to
use its competencies to develop the potentially more profitable area of its business. DCS currently faces lower market share and
declining shareholder value and this is projected to be a 10% decline year on year for the next three years. To reduce or avoid these
risks, DCS could re-align its business towards the more profitable domestic market by investing in the network support business
in terms of increased R&D, fixed asset investment and improvements in policies relating to staff retention and recruitment to support
this potential growth area. This would also reduce its general cost base.
Business risk
As already explained in the five forces analysis, apart from heavy dependence on its main business sector of data
communications (65% of its total turnover), DCS is facing economic risk from overdependence on key customers (one of the OEM
customers accounts for 40% of its sales). DCS is also overreliant for its supplies of data communications sub-components on two
large multinational suppliers from which it currently faces serious supply shortages. It also risks further losses of staff and greater
recruitment difficulties caused by poor staff morale and due to the unattractive location of DCS’s headquarters. Under the TARA
framework, it is advisable to reduce these risks by widening the supplier and customer base. From a supply perspective, the benefits
of this strategy would be to spread the risk of a disruption to the supplies from one or both of the two current suppliers. The strategy
would also help DCS in terms of bargaining power, particularly if it is not getting favourable terms from them. Similarly, widening the
customer base, or concentrating on a higher value strategy will reduce its dependence on the data communications business and also
the bargaining power of their main OEM customer and help their profitability. DCS can reduce the staff retention and recruitment risk
by adopting tactics and implementing policies to improve the culture of the organisation and the morale of their key staff. This could be
achieved through offering greater empowerment and devolving more authority to middle managers. An improvement in intrinsic
rewards and in pay and conditions, or allowing staff to relocate, or work from other geographical locations which are more attractive to
them, may also help to mitigate this risk.
Financial risk
The main risk is the devaluing currency in the main market into which DCS sells
a significant proportion of its data communications components. A weakening
currency in the economic community from which customers settle their
payments means that DCS is facing a currency translation exposure as monies
received in the devaluing currency will effectively reduce the turnover collected
from customers in these markets. Under the TARA framework, the risk could be
reduced or transferred by using foreign currency hedging instruments or by
taking out loans in the denomination of the weaker foreign currency, using the
payments from the continental customers to offset the liability. The other main
financial risk is the high level of gearing and the risk of breaking bank covenants
and of default. This risk could be mitigated by either converting some of the debt
into equity or by repaying or redeeming loans from DCS’s considerable cash
reserves, or by issuing more shares.
Environmental risk
DCS is not itself at risk of potential environmental impact, but is facing a risk of
creating an increased carbon footprint or environmental impact which it is not
effectively managing and which may itself create environmental costs and incur
a carbon tax liability. This risk could be transferred through carbon offset
strategies, avoided by ceasing to manufacture or distribute goods in a way that
creates such a significant carbon footprint, or reduced through pursuing tactics
or strategies to avoid waste and reduce emissions.
©ACCA
Area 40/100: What are “Sound” Internal Controls?
All employees, at all levels, have a responsibility to ensure they follow the controls.
Information is required at all levels of the organisation and it is important for this information to
‘flow’ effectively so that management can have timely information & data to perform their tasks.
Management requires information from external and internal sources in order to monitor the
performance of the organisation.
Information needs to have the following characteristics (ACCURATE):
Accurate
Complete
Cost-beneficial
User-targeted
Relevant
Authoritative
Timely
Easy to use
Familiarity
Self Interest
Advocacy
Self-review
Intimidation
Internal Auditors should not accept accept explanations without checking, ignore
issues, fail to report an issue and/or turn a blind eye.
A few days later Alex Reed called you into his office to discuss Rail Co’s governance and internal
controls. During that meeting he referred to the transport report in the Beeland Herald newspaper (Exhibit
2) and handed you a copy of the minutes of the latest board meeting held by Rail Co (Exhibit 4).
Required:
Alex has asked you to draft a letter to be sent to the chairman of the Rail Co Trust Board which:
(b) Reviews the effectiveness of the internal controls at Rail Co using evidence from the minutes of
the latest Rail Co board meeting and any other suitable source and justifies that the chief executive of
Rail Co is failing in his fiduciary duties to the trustees of Rail Co. (8 marks)
Professional skills marks are available for demonstrating scepticism skills in questioning the opinions
and assertions made by the chief executive at the recent board meeting. (2 marks)
(24 marks)
A further internal control weakness could be seen as the lack of investment in online booking systems. Several other
national train operators offer online booking facilities and evidence suggested that this had positively impacted upon
revenue growth and customer satisfaction in all of these businesses (Appendix 3). Lack of focus upon IT investment and
development in key strategic information systems could be seen as an internal control weakness and could hamper the
long-term performance of Rail Co.
A further internal control weakness could be the current pay structure. Poorly paid staff who are dissatisfied will leave or
may take strike action. HR policies on fair pay could be considered to be weak if they are not commensurate with the
expected pay rate.
Throughout the board meeting, there is evidence of the chief executive’s inability to react to these key internal
weaknesses effectively and it would seem that in some cases, this reluctance and inactivity could have seriously
damaging consequences for Rail Co. In a number of cases, there is evidence of a failure to achieve his fiduciary duty to
the trustee of Rail Co.
First, his comments in relation to Rail Co’s performance are inaccurate and reflect his own opinion, based on historic
performance and not the actual performance in 2016. Clearly, some narrow aspects of performance have improved, but it
is not in line with competitors and customer expectations in the current climate. His comment that the target for punctuality
set by the Trust Board was unachievable and not relevant is highly inappropriate and shows a breach of his fiduciary duty
to the trustees. It is his role as chief executive to ensure that these targets are achievable and they cannot simply be
ignored. Also, his statement that customers do not understand value for money demonstrates his lack of understanding of
the customers’ perception of this critical measure. It is wrong for him to make such a sweeping and unjust statement and
could seriously damage the reputation of Rail Co if these views were made public.
His response to the investment in ticket barriers is unfounded and demonstrates a lack of understanding of a key internal control
weakness in relation to the potential level of fraud in Rail Co. He had made a significant judgement founded upon no evidence of costs
outweighing the benefits and his assessment that most fraud being unpreventable is ill-judged and incorrect. Again, his lack of
understanding of such an important issue is a failure of his fiduciary duty. His comment that there is no evidence to suggest that staff
morale is low is incorrect, as staff turnover is increasing, strongly indicating low morale. He pointed to evidence in the customer survey
report which indicated an annual growth in customer satisfaction levels in relation to staff helpfulness and attitude but this is not linked
to staff training in any way. His logic is flawed and his attitude towards staff and adequate training could be seriously damaging to Rail
Co.
The CE also commented that online ticket facilities went against the traditional values of customer service focus of Rail Co. His
reluctance to invest in such technology could prove to be seriously damaging to Rail Co’s performance. It is clear that customers are
not happy with ticket buying facilities and should this continue more will use other means of transport. To delay this decision could be
damaging to Rail Co, should customers continue to choose other forms of transport to commute.
The chief executive’s attitude towards the unions could be severely damaging to Rail Co, should the unions decide to take strike
action. The CE commented that the unions were merely taking advantage of the latest survey results to put the board under pressure
to increase levels of pay for its members. Although Rail Co must negotiate with the unions, to take an aggressive stance could be
counter-productive. His comment relating to the media as an unimportant stakeholder is incorrect as adverse media reports about Rail
Co are a potential reputational risk to the organisation.
In conclusion, my overall opinion is that the comments made by the chief executive demonstrate a number of serious failures and
weaknesses in his fiduciary duty to the principals and trustees of Rail Co. I have grave concerns regarding his awareness of the
current situation facing Rail Co and his abilities to respond effectively to the changes which will be required in the coming months.
Yours sincerely
Assistant auditor, NAA
©ACCA
Area 46/100 What is a Profession and what is
Professionalism?
Profession is a body of knowledge & theory Independence
Professionalism is taking action to support Must be seen to be free from
the public interest. One needs to have outside guidance, influence or
professional competence to act control
professionally, follow a set of rules and
values (i.e. ACCA code of ethics) Managing potential threats:
Integrity Fees not too high % of income
Objectivity Gifts/hospitality must be
insignificant
Professional competence
No financial involvement in clients
Confidentiality
Avoid close relationships between
Professional behaviour senior staff and client
©ACCA
Area 47/100 – What is a code of ethics?
©ACCA
IESBA Code of Ethics
IFAC
Objectives for accountancy profession:
Committed to protecting the public interest:
Highest standards of professionalism high quality international standards
Highest levels of performance strong ethical values
Meet the public interest requirement quality practice requirements
worldwide development support
Underpinning needs:
Creates standards (ISAs, IESs, IFRSs, etc):
Credibility Advocates convergence in financial reporting
Professionalism Provides best practice guidance
Quality of services Implements a membership compliance program
Members must implement similar (or stricter)
Confidence ethical codes
©ACCA
Some examples of ethical threats
©ACCA
Area 48/100 – Tuckers 5 question model - Ethical conflict
resolution
©ACCA
Area 49/100 - What is Corruption?
©ACCA
Possible exhibits – analysis of fraud
An analysis of fraud
©ACCA
Strategic Business Leader - Specimen exam 2 Q4a
Required:
You have been asked by the chair of the audit and risk committee to review the
findings of the financial controller and present a report which requires you to do the
following:
(a) Analyse the information presented in the spreadsheet produced by the financial
controller, questioning any assumptions he may have made, and explain the
implications of the findings for Rail Co. (8 marks)
Professional skills marks are available for demonstrating scepticism skills in
considering the information presented in the spreadsheet and reflecting on the
impact on Rail Co’s revenues. (2 marks)
©ACCA
50/100 - Economic Activity
Companies need to ensure that take into consideration 3 areas that they ‘affect’
through their operation/activities:
ECONOMIC
SOCIAL Footprint
ENVIRONMENTAL & Sustainability Footprints
©ACCA
Area 52/100: Social and Environmental Reporting –
Why?
Stakeholders want to know about performance and potential risk
Because the ethical performance of a business is a factor in some
investors' decision to invest.
Because employees may use ethical performance as a criterion in
their choice of potential employer
Because consumers will not always buy goods or services from
unethical companies
Because it assists good corporate governance practice.
©ACCA
122 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis ©ACCA
Area 53/100 - What is Vision and What is Mission?
Strategy is the direction and scope of an organisation over the long term: which achieves advantage
for the organisation though its configuration of resources within a changing environment, to meet the
needs of markets, customers or clients and to fulfil stakeholder expectations.
Know the term strategic drift as well ( when companies depart from their initial deliberate strategy)
Strategy Lenses:
EXPERIENCE
IDEAS
DESIGN
Business
Marketing R&D
Functional
125 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis Operations ©ACCA
Strategy
Legal Legal?(L)
Economic (E)
Social (S)
Environmental (E)
Technological (T)
PwC
Area 56/100 – Competition – How can I analyse it? The
5 Competitive forces
©ACCA
Example - real-life
Apple’s iphone
Can you analyse the competitive environment of Apple in the USA?
How would you do this?
Which model would you use?
The answer will help you “Assess the profitability of the industry” and help you
shape strategy
129 ©ACCA
Strategic Business Leader - Specimen exam 1 Q1
From the information you have collated, draft a section of the consultancy report
for the directors of DCS Company to include the following:
(i) An analysis of the industry and market which DCS Company is competing
in, using an appropriate model. (15 marks)
(ii) An evaluation of the overall performance of DCS Company between 2012
and 2015 from an integrated reporting perspective. (12 marks)
Professional Skills marks are available for demonstrating evaluation skills relating
to DCS Company’s environment and performance. (4 marks)
Threats from new entrants DCS is operating in an industry where the costs of entry are significant because it is
capital and knowledge intensive. Economies of scale compel new entrants to enter at significant output levels or
suffer a cost disadvantage. Furthermore, the need to offer comprehensive aftersales support, although a problem
for DCS, does also create a significant barrier to new entrants. Finally, the exit costs and barriers such as industry-
specific knowledge, skills and assets, reduce the attractiveness of the marketplace to new entrants.
Threats from substitutes There is evidence that large, successful, high technology companies are particularly
vulnerable to ignoring the challenge from disruptive new technologies which can replace the need for certain high
technology products and services overnight. However, the relatively small size of DCS may give it a competitive
advantage in its ability to respond quickly and flexibly to change, as long as it can attract the right calibre of
expertise to achieve this.
Rivalry amongst competitors Very different levels of competition are being experienced in the two market places
DCS is operating in. It is clear that the high volume, low-margin component business offers intense competition with
buyers who are able to use their size to extract favourable prices. DCS only has 1% of this market. The ability of
DCS to generate better market share and volumes through product innovation in this market seems highly unlikely.
The intensity of rivalry in the network management systems sector is significantly less in this specialist market. DCS
is dealing with a smaller number of large and medium-sized users, designing products specific to their needs. In
Porter’s terms, DCS is adopting a focused differentiation strategy. In these low-volume high-margin markets, the
emphasis has to be on increasing the volume side of the business, but at the same time making sure that they have
the resources to attract and support new customers.
©ACCA
Area 57/100 –
Analysing the National FAVOURABLE
Competitive FACTOR CONDITIONS
Advantage - Porter’s
Diamond
DEMAND RELATED AND
CONDITIONS SUPPORTING
INDUSTRIES
FIRM STRATEGY,
STRUCTURE AND
RIVALRY
©ACCA 134
Example
135 ©ACCA
Area 58/100: Other methods to analyse the environment
Linear regression
You will not necessarily be asked to undertake the mathematics of any of the
techniques, but you will have to focus on the principles, evaluations and consequences.
©ACCA
Area 59/100: How can I assess the resources of an
organisation? Through a Resource Audit (Ms model)
An organisation's resources can be organised into the following categories:
Men
Money
Markets
Materials
Management
Make-up
Manufacturing/Machinery
©ACCA
Area 60/100 – What is Critical Success Factor Analysis?
and what is a Key Performance Indicator? (KPI)
Definition: Those areas that the company must do well in order to succeed!
Usually there are only a FEW areas (i.e. 3 – 4)
The company must have capabilities in these areas!
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) used to measure attainment of CSFs
KPIs need to be SMART (Specific Measurable Achievable Realistic and Timely)
©ACCA 138
Example - Critical Success Factor Analysis and KPIs
For a restaurant
Music
Quality food
Customer service
Clean
Prices
Furniture
Parking
Location
Live events
Wi-fi
©ACCA 139
Area 61/100 - Balanced Scorecard – Based on CSFs
PwC
Example of an airline - Lufthansa
What are the CSFs in the airline industry and Lufthansa specifically and why?
Safety – KPI?: # of accidents
On-time - % of flights NOT on time: i.e KPI = less than 5% - SMART!!!
Customer service – Survey
141 ©ACCA
Area 62/100 M. Baldridge Model
©ACCA
Key points from the Baldridge model
©ACCA
What each area means
©ACCA
Area 63/100 - Benchmarking
©ACCA 145
Example – What is benchmarking?
©ACCA 146
Area 64a/100: Competitive Advantage Generic Strategies – How to
compete
Example
TOYOTA & LEXUS (owned by the same company)
Emirates & Fly Dubai (owned by the same company)
149 ©ACCA
Area 64b/100 - Strategic Clock (Bowman) – Based on the same logic as
Generic strategies
High
Differentiation
4 Focussed
Hybrid differentiation
3 5
1 7
8 Strategies
destined for
No frills
ultimate failure
Low
Low Perceived price High
BCG Matrix –
High
Analysing the
performance of Market growth STAR PROBLEM CHILD
Products, rate (%) Cash generator Cash in balance
(Note 2)
Services or SBUs
Low
©ACCA 152
Example: BCG matrix - VW
Used for Subsidiary analysis, portfolio analysis and for product analysis
In essence, it helps us understand the performance of a product line, our divisions
etc.
VW cars example
153 ©ACCA
Possible exhibits – spreadsheet
©ACCA
Area 66/100: What is the Value Chain?
156 ©ACCA
Area 67/100. The Value System and the supply chain
The
Organisation’s
value chain
©ACCA 157
Supply chain management
(Key terms: Upstream and Downstream)
©ACCA
Area 68/100 Big Data
The issue of Big Data is a phrase used to mean a massive volume of both
structured and unstructured data that is so large it is difficult to process using
traditional database and software techniques.
Characteristics of Big Data: 3 Vs
Volume
Velocity
Variety
Cost
Regulation (i.e. GDPR)
Loss and theft of data
Incorrect Data
Employee monitoring
Hacking / Security
SPECIMEN 1, Q1c)
Under the Strategy and resource allocation heading in the October board report, the
possibility of DCS Company supplying and supporting such technologies as cloud
computing and big data analytics is referred to. To accompany the consultancy
report a presentation is needed about the exploitation of such new
technologies.
REQUIRED
Prepare information for two presentation slides to be presented to the DCS
Company board, including relevant bullet points and supporting notes, highlighting
the key benefits and identifying the main opportunities presented by big data
analytics to DCS Company and its customers. (6 marks)
Professional Skills marks are available for demonstrating communication skills in
highlighting the key points to include in the slides and for clear supporting notes.
(2 marks)
©ACCA
Inefficient and Ineffective answer?
Why and how Data management can become a capability if analysed effectively
(managing knowledge).
Managing, securing and sharing knowledge can also be done through the “cloud” (i.e.
Google Drive, Dropbox, AWS etc.)
Benefits:
Sharing
On demand
Updated at real time
Cost effective
Back – up
Security
Why innovate?
From ideas to “innovation”
Examples of failed companies & products/services
Innovation as a requirement for sustainability
Lots of innovation sources from technology & the internet (hence the use of e-
methods, apps and continuous improvement through ‘open’ innovation methods)
Benefits of e-business + dangers
©ACCA
Innovation and Disruptive Technologies (continued)
Using Big Data to transform your business model & innovate (i.e. Amazon)
Data Analytics & Business Intelligence
Disruptors: UBER, Skype, itunes, Airbnb etc.
Cloud & mobile computing
©ACCA
Area 72/100 – What is Organisational culture & the Cultural Web?
The concept of the cultural web is a useful model for mapping out areas of change and it helps
identify the elements of culture in an organisation.
7 ELEMENTS
Organisational culture may be defined as
THE WAY THINGS ARE DONE AROUND HERE
1. Power
2. Controls
3. Structure
4. Stories & Myths
5. Routines & rituals
6. Symbols
7. Values (Paradigm)
©ACCA
168 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis ©ACCA
Marketing
Customer analysis
Market Research
Advertising, promotion
Marketing Mix
Digital Marketing
©ACCA 169
Area 73/100 - Market Segmentation
©ACCA 170
Area 74/100 The Marketing Mix
PRODUCT
Design/sizes colors
Materials PRICE
Specification List price
Quality Discounts PLACE
Packaging Payment terms Location
After-sales service Service/spares prices Retail/wholesale
Mail/telephone order
Delivery methods
PROMOTION PEOPLE
Advertising Skills
Competency
Brochures/data sheets PROCESS
Personal selling & networks Capabilities
Time saving
Exhibitions Resources
Customer focused
Gifts User friendly
Social Media
PHYSICAL EVIDENCE
Dress code
Building, premises
Vehicles
©ACCA 171
Area 75/100 – Pricing Considerations
Pricing Strategy:
Remember Generic Strategies here (cost vs differentiation
New Product and Market, New Product/ Existing Market, Existing Product.
General Factors:
Capacity, Costs, Quality, Rivalry, Bargaining Power, Perceived Value.
Pricing Techniques:
Cost Based, Demand Based, Competition Based, ABC
©ACCA 172
Area 76/100 - E-marketing
©ACCA
Area 77/100 - 6 Is
•Independence of location
•Integration
•Interactivity
•Individualisation
•Intelligence
•Industry structure
Selection
Acquisition
Retention
Extension
©ACCA
Customer relationship management
©ACCA
Area 79/100 - Principles of e-business
Benefits
Cost reduction in procurement and headcount needed to handle customers
Capability – increase penetration in new countries; help reduce inventory
levels held
Communication – improved, more interactive communication with customers
Control – better monitoring and control
Customer service enhanced – basic enquiries can be dealt with via a
website
Competitive advantage – will be dependent on competitors’ use of e-
commerce.
©ACCA
Area 80/100 - SWOT Analysis – Position Analysis
Based on assumption an effective strategy derives from a sound “fit” between a firm’s
internal resources and its external situation
Opportunities Threats
A major favorable situation in A major unfavorable situation in a
a firm’s environment firm’s environment
Strengths Weaknesses
A resource advantage relative A limitation or deficiency in one or
to competitors and the needs of more resources or competencies
markets firm serves relative to competitors
©ACCA 178
Area 81/100 - Directions for Growth - Ansoff
Products
Existing New
penetration development
©ACCA
Area 82/100 Means and Methods for growth – You need to know
the theory behind these methods!
©ACCA 180
Area 83/100: Evaluating Strategic Options
©ACCA 181
182 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis ©ACCA
Area 84/100 Organisational structures
Everyone else
©ACCA
Functional Structure
Strategic Apex
Mintzberg argues that
structure exists to
coordinate the
activities of different Techno- Support
individuals and work structure
Middle
Staff
processes. Line
Operating Core
BY MINTZBERG
©ACCA 187
188 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis ©ACCA
Area 85/100: Centralisation & Decentralisation
Relative terms
Classic views see decentralisation with a degree of distrust
(control and empowerment reasons)
Neither “good or bad” (contingency view)
Information, delegation, morale, quick responses, coordination
and ability is required
Advantages and Disadvantages?
©ACCA 189
Area 86/100 Boundaryless Organisations
©ACCA
Area 89/100 - What is change?
Quasi-stationary equilibrium
©ACCA Lewin: Force-Field
193Model
Main points on change
©ACCA
Area 90/100: The Change Process
©ACCA
Processes of Managing Change: revolutionary change
Altering
Enhancing the behaviour Managing
Driving forces resistance Institutionalising
Disturbing the change
equilibrium
Moving
Unfreezing Re-freezing
The status quo
Weakening the
Restraining forces
Gathering and Making the
Giving feedback Change
Creating awareness
permanent
of the need to change
©ACCA 196
Area 91/100: Contextual Features of change –Check them prior to
any change
©ACCA
Area 92/100: POPIT™
What is the business motivation?
Business Models Business Information Models
External Business Environment Information Standards
Organisational Capabilities Technical Architecture
Organisational Memory Application Architecture
Organisation
Roles and Job Descriptions Value Propositions
Skills and Competencies Value Chains
Information
Management Activities Core Business Processes
&
Culture Business Services
Communication Technology
People Processes
Evolution Adaptation
Revolution Reconstruction
Big Bang
©ACCA
What is a business process?
©ACCA
Business Processes example
©ACCA
Area 94/100: Project Management and Constraints
Project Constraints:
TIME
COST
SCOPE
©ACCA 202
Area 95/100: The business case
©ACCA
Projects should have benefits - Examples of benefits:
Strategic
Productivity
Management
Operational
Functional
Intangible
Emergent
©ACCA
Area 96/100: Financial analysis and decision-making
Types of costs
Capital investment
Consultancy
Resources
Disruption
Types of appraisal methods (advantages and disadvantages)
Accounting rate of return
Payback period
NPV
IRR
©ACCA
Area 97/100: Project Initiation Document (PID)
©ACCA
PID sample
Typical contents:
©ACCA
Project Management Tools
©ACCA
Area 99/100: Finalising the project
Project completion and Project audit
Post project review
Post implementation review (PIR)
Benefits review
Lessons learnt review
©ACCA
Area 100/100 Leadership
The act or process of influencing, inspiring and guiding people so they will
strive willingly toward the achievement of group objectives through common
effort
©ACCA 215
Leadership traits
Intelligence
Scholarship
Dependability
Social participation and Interest
Socioeconomic status (in comparison with non - leaders)
Emotional intelligence (social skills, judgement, maturity and
emotional control)
©ACCA 216
Leadership styles
Authoritarian
Democratic
Laissez faire (free reign)
©ACCA 217
Situational theories of leadership
©ACCA 218
Entrepreneurship - Intrapreneurship
©ACCA
IMPORTANT: Extra area 101: Remember your financial knowledge from
the Applied Knowledge and Applied Skills exams!
©ACCA
Analysing Financial performance and position
(for tables in the case)
©ACCA 221
222 23/08/2018 Dr. Constantine “Dino” Kiritsis ©ACCA
Thank you!
© ACCA PUBLIC