Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Maternal and Fetal Well Being
Maternal and Fetal Well Being
Pregnancy outcomes can be improved by following modern recommendations for personal health
maintenance. Adequate caloric intake, reflected by a weight gain of about 10 to 12.3 kg (22 to 27 Ib)
for women of average build, is associated with the lowest rate of perinatal mortality. Maternal
dietary protein supplementation should generally be avoided because it may be associated with
low-birth-weightpregnancies. Abstinence from social drugs offers the greatestpositive opportunity
to modify the health of a fetus. Serious perinatal infection can be prevented by preconception
immunization (rubella), food hygiene (toxoplasmosis) and attention to the expression of virus in the
mother (herpes simplex). Available data do not correlate exercise programs begun before preg-
nancy and continued during pregnancy with adverse fetal effects. Athletic capacity need not
diminish postpartum. Most employment may safely continue until delivery. Routine recommenda-
tions for prolonged maternal disability leaves are not medically warranted.
(Shy KK, Brown ZA: Maternal and fetal well-being, In Personal health maintenance [Special
Issue]. West J Med 1984 Dec; 141:807-815)
Americans are caught up in a new wave of health con- 27 weeks had infants with little reduction in birth weight.
sciousness. The importance of personal health main- Proper caloric support and nutrition returned immediately
tenance is enhanced during pregnancy by virtue of the respon- after the embargo was lifted. Follow-up studies of 125,000
sibility for a new life. Frequently coupled with health men 19 years later did not show an alteration in the mental
consciousness is consumer awareness that does not allow phy- performance of children born during the famine.' Because of
sicians to rest on tired dogma in response to new, or old, the severity of the famine, it is not possible to generalize the
questions. On a daily basis, patients are confronted with con- birth-weight effects of famine to contemporary diets, which
cerns about diet and nutrition, drug exposure, perinatal infec- may lack certain recommended vitamins and minerals3 but
tious risks and the advisability of exercise and employment otherwise provide sufficient caloric support.
during pregnancy. Pregnancy outcome can be influenced sub- Subsequent experimental4'5 and nonexperimental6 caloric
stantially by the patterns of response to these concerns. supplementation trials have indicated a beneficial birth-
Diet and Nutrition weight effect only for the pregnancies of women who are in a
negative energy balance or who are underweight and by infer-
Energy Requirements (Calories) ence underfed at the time of their pregnancy. Net caloric
During the past two decades, follow-up studies and con- supplementation of about 425 calories per day beginning
trolled trials of nutritional supplementation have better clari- during the 16th week of pregnancy resulted in a mean birth-
fied the influence of caloric restriction on pregnancy outcome. weight increase of 224 grams in Gambian women during the
Food shortages during World War II, because oftheir severity wet season, a period of food shortage and high work load.
and abrupt onset and resolution, became in effect a natural During the dry season, a period of ample food and positive
experiment on severe dietary restriction.' A famine was in- energy balance, the tendency was for a negative effect of
duced by a Nazi embargo during the 1944-1945 winter in the supplementation on birth weight.5 A similar experimental
western urban regions of Holland. The famine lasted six trial of Asian mothers at the Sorrento Maternity Hospital in
months. Overall, at the height of the famine, mean birth Birmingham, England, yielded the same results.4
weights were reduced about 300 grams. Pregnant women North American studies indicate that the apparent adverse
exposed to the famine throughout their entire third trimester effect of dietary supplementation to adequately fed mothers is
had infants of considerably lower birth weights, whereas probably greatest when the caloric supplementation is given
those pregnant women exposed to famine only during the first as protein.6-8 In an experimental trial of high-protein dietary
From the Department ofObstetrics and Gynecology, University of Washington School of MNedicine, Seattle.
Reprint requests to Kirk K. Shy, MD, MPH, Dept ofObstetrics and Gynecology, RH-20, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195.
gram to increase the likelihood that they will be able to abstain studies have failed to show any adverse pregnancy effect
during pregnancy.42 associated with maternal coffee consumption.i1 In spite of
Tobacco the paucity of information on women showing adverse preg-
nancy effects of caffeine use, some pregnant women may
The adverse effects of maternal smoking on human repro- wish to reduce their consumption. These women should be
duction are extensive.43 One of the most common neonatal made aware of the significant amount of caffeine found in
findings in cases of maternal smoking is symmetric growth tea, cocoa and other foods and beverages.
retardation.451 4 These children remain smaller as adolescents Marijuana
and have significantly more behavioral problems, learning
disabilities and poorer school performance.47-49 Many other Data regarding the impact of smoking marijuana during
obstetrical complications are also increased in smokers. In- pregnancy are difficult to interpret due to the small size ofthe
cluded are selected congenital malformations,'5-` abortion,50'52 reported series. However, there are no findings to suggest that
placental abruption and a substantial overall increase in peri- marijuana is teratogenic in animals or humans.35'P269'6' Several
natal mortality rates.53 These untoward effects are produced, studies have suggested that marijuana consumption during
in part, by nicotine, which stimulates the sympathetic ganglia pregnancy leads to intrauterine growth retardation, premature
and releases catecholamines from peripheral nerve endings labor, meconium staining, dysfunctional labor and features
and the adrenal medulla. The increased maternal catechol- suggestive of the fetal alcohol syndrome.62'" However, lack of
amines reduce uterine blood flow that in conjunction with satisfactory control for potentially confounding factors (mul-
elevated levels of carboxyhemoglobin produces a fetal state of tiple drug use, socioeconomic status and the like) makes inter-
chronic oxygen deprivation and stress.54'55 Indirect evidence pretation of these results difficult.65 In mice, prenatal exposure
suggests that the carcinogenic substances in tobacco smoke to cannabinoids results in alterations of endocrine function
may act as transplacental carcinogens, increasing the liability and brain amine levels in adulthood. These effects, which are
of the offspring of smokers to tumors in adulthood.56 Pregnant not evident at birth, become apparent only when the offspring
women should discontinue smoking at least for the duration of themselves begin reproducing.66'67 Unless substantial
pregnancy.57 long-term studies exonerate maternal marijuana consumption
from untoward effects on fetal growth and development, pa-
Caffeine tients should be strongly advised against consumption during
The Food and Drug Administration has recommended that pregnancy.
pregnant women avoid or minimize intake of caffeine be-
cause animal studies indicate it causes birth defects in ani- Perinatal Infection
mals. This warning has been criticized because safe levels of Concerns about the risks of infection are heightened for
caffeine were not defined,58'59 and properly designed human women during pregnancy. Although serum immunoglobulin
810 THE WESTERN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE
MATERNAL AND FETAL WELL-BEING
levels are decreased68 and cell-mediated immune responses TABLE 2.-Methods forPreventing Maternal Toxoplasmosis *
are suppressed in pregnancy,69'70 the clinical significance of Cook meat to > 66°C (150°F), smoke it or cure it in brine
these findings remains conjectural, and pregnancy data do not Avoid touching mucous membranes of the mouth and eye while handling raw
support a substantially increased incidence of viral infection.7' meat
Nonetheless, the proportion of women with an infection that Wash hands thoroughly after handling raw meat
may have direct adverse consequences on a fetus is impres- Wash kitchen surfaces that come into contact with raw meat
Wash fruits and vegetables before consumption
sive, about 14% for the TORCH complex alone.72 (TORCH is Prevent access of flies, cockroaches and so forth to fruits and vegetables
an acronym for toxoplasmosis, other [syphilis, chickenpox, Avoid contact with or wear gloves when handling materials that are po-
hepatitis B and the like], rubella, cytomegalovirus and herpes tentially contaminated with cat feces, such as cat-litter boxes, or when
simplex virus.) Further, approximately 15% of women are gardening
colonized with group B Streptococcus73 and as many as 5 % to Disinfect cat-litter box for 5 minutes with nearly boiling water
10% harbor Chlamydia trachomatis in the cervix.74 *Modified from Wilson and Remington.80
For members of the TORCH complex, the general mea-
sures for diagnosis and for maternal therapy are similar. The
major health risk is confined to the fetus and infant. Maternal susceptible women (Table 2). Routine serologic screening
signs and symptoms that suggest infection should be immedi- may prove to be efficacious in the future, but, at this time,
ately reported to a physician; symptoms alone are not reliable quality control is apt to be haphazard and screening is not
for diagnosis, however. Instead, maternal infection must be recommended.80 For women known to have a primary infec-
documented by serology or by viral isolation of the herpes tion during pregnancy, antimicrobial treatment appears to be
simplex virus. Generally, accurate serologic diagnosis of effective in reducing fetal susceptibility.8I
current infection requires the finding of a significant rise in Herpes simplex virus acquisition by a fetus is rare (less than
antibody titer. Serum should be obtained immediately when 0.05 % of live births), occurring predominantly during birth
there is a suggestion of infection. A rise in antibody titer is through the vagina.72 Disseminated and localized central ner-
usually found in a second sample obtained two to three weeks vous system disease affects most cases and severe central
after onset of infection. Except for cases of syphilis and nervous system damage is common among survivors.
toxoplasmosis, maternal therapy is supportive with no special Pregnant women with a history of genital herpes or those
therapy available. If maternal infection is documented, at with an undiagnosed genital lesion should notify their physi-
present, techniques are not available to diagnose the presence cians. Whenever possible, in women without a history of
or absence of corresponding fetal infection. Amniocentesis genital herpes, viral cultures should be taken from all genital
for viral recovery is not predictive of an affected fetus. At lesions. During pregnancy, suppression of recurring genital
birth, infant serology and culture will verify a microor- herpes with oral acyclovir is not indicated.82 Women with
ganism, if present. Except for neonatal herpes simplex infec- recurrent genital herpes can expect the recurrences to increase
tions that produce high mortality and morbidity, infection as pregnancy progresses.83 Asymptomatic viral shedding can
with other TORCH agents does not generally result in ap- occur from the cervix and vulva without a visible lesion.84
parent neonatal disease. However, late sequelae to these This has prompted recommendations for viral screening cul-
infections can result in damage to the perceptual organs and tures during the last month of pregnancy.85 However, this is
the brain, which would not be recognized until later in life.72 controversial because the cost is great and estimates are that
Infectious control should be directed at prevention by immu- with current techniques a maximum of only a fourth of infant
nization and minimizing exposure, if possible. infections could be averted.86 At the onset of labor, all pa-
Maternal cytomegaloviruses, the most common cause of tients should have a careful inspection for herpetic lesions of
intrauterine infection, occur in about 13 % of pregnancies75 the vulva, vagina and cervix. Because of the risk of asymp-
and 0.5 % to 2.5 % of live births.76 Less than 5 % of infected tomatic viral shedding and ascending herpetic infection, vag-
infants have classic cytomegalic inclusion disease (hepato- inal examinations and instrumentation should be kept to a
splenomegaly, microcephaly, chorioretinitis and so forth); minimum in women with a history of genital herpes. Patients
however, subtle learning disorders and auditory deficits may in labor who have a definite herpetic lesion (or an undi-
be more common." Much remains to be known about the agnosed lesion suggestive of genital herpes simplex virus)
means of transmitting cytomegalovirus between adults. The should have a cesarean delivery, even in the absence of a
occupational contact of pediatric health-care workers does positive viral culture, regardless of the duration since the
not appear to confer greater risks for infection.78 At this rupture ofmembranes.
time, screening for cytomegalovirus at the initial prenatal Cases of maternal and fetal rubella are rare, occurring annu-
visit appears to be of negligible value.79 The eventual devel- ally in fewer than 50 infants in the United States. More than
opment of an effective vaccine is the most promising avenue 30% of infants from pregnancies infected during the first
for reducing risk. trimester are seriously affected with a wide range of defects,
Toxoplasmosis, an infection caused by the protozoan para- including congenital deafness, cataracts and blindness and
site Toxoplasma gondii, is rare but potentially preventable severe heart defects.72 From 10% to 20% of reproductive-age
during pregnancy. Congenital toxoplasmosis is associated women are seronegative for rubella antibodies. Seronegative,
with chorioretinitis, hydrocephalus and intracranial calcifica- nonpregnant women of childbearing ages should be immu-
tion plus a wide range of less severe manifestations.72 80 nized and warned to avoid pregnancy for three months fol-
Exposure to the parasite is by ingesting uncooked meat con- lowing vaccination.87 Opportune settings include routine gy-
taining tissue cysts, or from oocysts in cat feces. Proper food necologic and family planning facilities and during hospital
handling and treatment of cat feces will avoid infection in stay after childbirth or abortion.
DECEMBER 1984 * 141 * 6 811
MATERNAL AND FETAL WELL-BEING
At present the recommendation is not to screen routinely for seven pregnant women after jogging on a total of 30 separate
prenatal group B Streptococcus or C trachomatis. This relates occasions.'05 At this time, limited studies do not support any
to uncertainty regarding the proper timing for screening due adverse effect of maternal exercise on a fetus. 106
to high maternal recolonization rates and the potential adverse Maternal exercise and physical fitness may be associated
effects from treatment of many pregnant women or infants with a reduced duration of labor. Pomerance and colleagues
who were colonized, but in whom disease would not have found shorter labors for physically fit multigravid women, but
developed. not for fit nulliparous women. '07Erkkola noted shorter spon-
taneous labors among women with above-average work ca-
Exercise pacity.'08 Collings and co-workers"'0 detected no differences
Estimates are that 25 million Americans, or 10% of the in the duration of labor of 12 women who engaged in a regular
population, jog regularly.88 Pregnant women who jog or en- aerobic exercise program compared with 8 other women who
gage in other regular strenuous exercise are justifiably inter- did not exercise. The positive association between maternal
ested in its effects on their health and that of their fetus. exercise and shortened labor must be interpreted cautiously.
Further, some competitors who become pregnant plan to con- Studies have not detected a reduction in the length of the
tinue strenuous sports and are interested in the effects that second stage, that part of labor dominated by voluntary mus-
should be anticipated in their performance. Little is known cular activity which would appear most responsive to phys-
about the effects of exercise on any of the specific pregnancy ical conditioning. Further, these studies did not control for
outcomes. However, insight into the potential consequences analgesic use, which may be different in women who exer-
of exercise can be gained by considering its effects on ma- cise.
ternal physiology. This subject has been recently reviewed by Exercise conditioning can advance with training during
Lotgering and co-workers. 89 pregnancy; postpartum, athletes should not expect a reduction
Maternal oxygen consumption by organs other than the in their athletic abilities. During pregnancy, exercise elicits
uterus is not increased substantially during pregnancy. Al- the same metabolic and cardiovascular responses as it does in
though maternal oxygen consumption near term increases by the nonpregnant state.'09 Erkkola noted a significant increase
16% to 32% ,90,91 most of the increase is related to uterine in the physical work capacity of randomly selected pregnant
mass. Thus, exercise in the sitting position does not increase women who engaged in regular strenuous activity compared
oxygen consumption more than with similar exercise in the with nonexercising controls. 10 Olympic athletes who had had
nonpregnant state.89 Because of the increased oxygen require- children judged their physical and functional condition to be
ments of weight-bearing (the pregnant uterus) for treadmill better after childbirth than before pregnancy.111
exercise, however, increases in oxygen consumption are
greater during pregnancy.92 These data suggest that exercise Work
efficiency is not altered substantially by pregnancy. Newly pregnant women who are employed outside the
Blood flow to a pregnant uterus decreases immediately after home are confronted with a decision: Should I stop working
the onset of exercise.93 94 Decreases as great as 36% have before the end of the pregnancy and, if so, when? Considering
been reported.95 However, the implications of reduced ox- that nonsalaried housekeeping and child rearing can be just as
ygen availability to the fetus may not be valid. The hematocrit strenuous as other salaried employment, rational solutions are
increases during exercise in association with a fall in plasma difficult. Available data and advice from physicians have
volume and increased glomerular filtration.96 Further, in been conflicting. Federal disability legislation has added new
sheep, blood flow under the influence of catecholamines is financial considerations that temper medical advice. This con-
redistributed from the myometrium to the placental site,97 and fusion is superimposed on prevalent societal expectations that
a reduction in oxygen availability has not been noted.95 Some have held sway for previous generations and vary widely
studies of pregnant ewes95 96 have indicated a significant fall across cultures.'12
in fetal oxygenation during maternal exercise. However, in Available information is difficult to interpret for three rea-
these studies blood gas values were not corrected for the sons. First, there are considerable differences in the kinds of
raised temperature that accompanies exercise.89 In other work women do. Second, studies carried out in different
studies in which a raised temperature was corrected for, only countries at different, times would be expected to have dif-
a small reduction in fetal oxygenation was found.99 ferent results. Third, employed women vary from nonem-
Fetal heart rate studies have provided no consistent evi- ployed women in several aspects such as education, parity and
dence of fetal distress during or after jogging or other exer- the use ofhealth services. 113
cise. Whereas some investigators noted modest fetal heart rate More recent studies"4""16 have not supported an associa-
increases with maternal exercise,100"101 others found fetal tion between employment during pregnancy and adverse
bradycardia with exercise.'02 Although exercise can induce pregnancy outcomes that was found with earlier data." 7.118
fetal heart rate patterns that are consistent with fetal distress, Stewart noted more prematurity, low-birth-weight infants
the abnormal fetal heart rate patterns are not directly caused and perinatal deaths among the pregnancies of British women
by the exercise. Instead, the exercise "unmasks" another con- who were employed in Northamptonshire during their preg-
dition such as nuchal cord,103 placental insufficiency103'104 nancy."17 If work ceased before 28 weeks' gestation, adverse
and the like that has compromised the fetus. This has outcomes were less frequent among the women who were
prompted some clinicians to suggest that the response of a employed. Naeye and Peters presented compelling data from
fetal heart rate to maternal exercise could be used as a test of the Collaborative Perinatal Project of the National Institute of
fetal well-being.103'104 Hauth and associates detected no dif- Communicative Disorders and Stroke that suggested a signifi-
ference in the incidence of fetal heart rate abnormalities in cant progressive effect on birth weight by duration of employ-
812 THE WESTERN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE
MATERNAL AND FETAL WELL-BEING
ment when it continued past the 28th week of gestation.'18 TABLE 3.-Guidelines for Continuing Various Levels of
The pattern of low birth weight suggested reduced uteropla- Work During Pregnancy *
cental blood flow. Murphy and associates had opposite results Week of
and different conclusions"' using British data from the Car- Job Function Gestation
diff Births Survey. Adverse pregnancy effects were all more Secretarial and light clerical . . . . . . . 40
common for nonemployed mothers, and the increase in pre- Professional and managerial . .. . . . . . 40
mature births for prepregnancies of nonemployed mothers Sitting with light tasks
Prolonged ( > 4 h) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
was statistically significant. Among employed mothers, the Intermittent.. .....
. .
40
nature of the work (sedentary, nonsedentary) and time of Standing
stopping work did not significantly affect the results. A recent Prolonged ( > 4 h) . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
French national birth survey"3 had findings similar to the Intermittent
British study. Two hypotheses have been advanced to explain ( > 30 min/h) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
( < 30 min/h) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
the superior pregnancy performance of the employed mothers Stooping and bending below knee level
in these two studies. First, by virtue of their ability to be Repetitive
employed, working mothers generally should be expected to ( >1O times/h) . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . 20
be healthier and have less adverse pregnancy outcomes. Intermittent
Second, social contacts are enhanced for working women and (< 10 > 2 times/h) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
(< 2 times/h) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
their access to medical care is greater. Climbing
These relatively sparse and conflicting findings make it Vertical ladders and poles
difficult to arrive at specific recommendations for the continu- Repetitive
ance of work during pregnancy. In addition to the medical (>4 times/8-h shift) . . . . . . . . . 20
Intermittent
consequences of work during pregnancy, the greater partici- ( < 4 times/8-h shift) . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
pation of women in the work force and passage of the Preg- Stairs
nancy Discrimination Act (PL 95-555) magnify the economic Repetitive
impact of physicians' recommendations about whether or not ( 4 times/8-h shift) . . . .. . . . 28
to continue employment during pregnancy. Intermittent
(<4 times/8-h shift) . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
The basic principle of the Pregnancy Discrimination Act is Lifting
that pregnancy and related conditions must be treated in the Repetitive
same nondiscriminatory fashion as any other disability or > 23 kg (50 lb) . . . . . . . . . . .20
medical condition. Basically, the law prohibits employers < 23 > 11kg (25 lb) . . . . . . . .24
<11kg.. ... 40
from illegally eliminating pregnant women from certain jobs Intermittent
and protects pregnant women's disability insurance benefits if >23kg.. ... 30
the company has a disability plan and the pregnant worker is <23 >11 kg . . . . . . . . .40
medically disabled. Because the law does not define disability <11kg.. .. 40
or place time limits on the benefits, physicians will be asked *Modified from The Journal of the American Medical Association (1984:251:1995-
to certify the extent and duration of the pregnancy-related 1997), Copyright 1984, American Medical Association.
disability.
As part of a physician's (and employer's) responsibility to has been acknowledged by most large firms, this may not be
minimize the effects of a pregnancy-related disability, every the case in small companies and a physician may be thrust into
effort should be made to ensure that the specific job is safe and a new role as patient advocate.122
its environment is nontoxic to a mother and her fetus. When in
doubt, regional consultants are available at the National Insti- Comment
tute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and the Health maintenance in pregnancy extends beyond the high-
Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). "9 lights discussed in this article. Personal health maintenance,
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists broadly interpreted, begins with preconceptual contraceptive
(ACOG) has drafted a principle applicable to most women planning and continues through to the choice of a site for
during their pregnancies: "The normal woman with an un- delivery. The fundamental aspects of personal health mainte-
complicated pregnancy and a normal fetus in a job that pre- nance are generally simple, but the effects of disease preven-
sents no greater potential hazards than those encountered in tion and peace of mind may be substantial. Obstetricians
normal daily life in the community may continue to work should embrace these concepts to achieve optimal outcomes
without interruption until the onset of labor and may resume for their patients.
working several weeks after an uncomplicated delivery." 119 REFERENCES
The principle is consistent with the traditional six- to eight- 1. Smith CA: Effects of maternal undernutrition upon the newborn infant in Holland
(1944-1945). J Pediatr 1947 Mar; 30:229-243
week window of per se disability (beginning two weeks be- 2. Stein Z, Susser M, Saenger G, et al: Nutrition and mental performance. Science
fore delivery and continuing until six weeks' postpartum) that 1972 Nov 17; 178:708-713
3. Committee on Dietary Allowances, Food and Nutrition Board: Recommended
surrounds the time of delivery for most normal pregnancies. Dietary Allowances, 9th Ed. Washington, DC, National Academy of Sciences, 1980
Each situation should be interpreted individually. Guide- 4. Viegas OA, Scott PH, Cole TJ, et al: Dietary protein energy supplementation of
pregnant Asian mothers at Sorrento, Birmingham-II: Selective during third trimester
lines for continuing various levels of work during pregnancy only. BrJ Med 1982 Sep4; 285:592-595
have been established by NIOSH and ACOG (Table 3). 120,121 5. Prentice AM, Whitehead RG, Watkinson M, et al: Prenatal dietary supplementa-
tion of African women and birth-weight. Lancet 1983 Mar 5; 1:389-492
For most employment, these guidelines support the concept of 6. Rush D: Nutritional services during pregnancy and birthweight: A retrospective
continued employment until delivery. Although this concept matched pairanalysis. Can Med AssocJ 1981 Sep 15; 125:567-576