GE1712

Names: Saen, Anna Marie E. Section: BSBAOM

Date: September 25, 2021 Score:

Directions: Complete the Comparative Matrix table below. (100 points)

Historical Source Author Event Date Event Objective Persons Involved Main Argument Bias
Santiago Marso25,1897 The main Magdiwang A conflict has It is the time when
, Alvarez, general objective of the council: begun between the Tirona chooses Mr.
for the Katipunan Secretary Jacinto magdalo members Jose Del Rosario as
assembly is to
Lumbreras, and the secretary of the
choose new Supremo Andres magdiwangmembe interior rather than
leaders of the Bonifacio, rs because the the supremo
Tejeros Convention
(Manuscript) Katipunan. Messrs. Mariano magdalo wanted to Andres Bonifacio,
(Primary Source) M. Alvarez, change the because Tirona
Pascual Alvarez, government believes thatthis
Ariston officials at the position should not
Villanueva, moment where be entrusted to the
Mariano C. Trias, election became Non-lawyer, which
A meeting had taken Santiago V.
March 27, 1897 the main agenda it ashamed of
at the Tanza Parish Alvarez, Artemio
house. instead of the Supremo Andres
Ricarte, Santos original which is to Bonifacio.
Nocon, Luciano talk about
San Miguel, Pablo strengthening the Andres Bonifacio
Mojica, Severino defenses. was the one
de las Alas, at managing the
Santiago The newly elected convention, he
RilloMagdalo proposed the idea of
peopleto the office revolutionary
council: where undergoing government rather
Messrs Baldomero oath-taking
than monarchy or
Aguinaldo, ceremonies where democratic
Daniel Tirona, at AndresBonifacio is republican
Cayetano Topacio. not present and the government.
Other person's troops of the
involved: magdalo where
Kapitan Heneral strictly ordered
Apoy, that no magdiwang
Heneral Vibora, G.
01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI
Page 1 of 2
 GE1712

Jose del Rosario underdogs where

to be seen nearby
otherwise they
would have been
annihilated then
and there.
December 1896 Andres Bonifacio
left Cavite to meet
Teodoro A. Agoncillo the Supremo and
Seeds of Discontent Filipino Historian his entourage
(Published materials) together with his
(Secondary Source) wife and two
brothers, Ciriaco
and Procopio
Bonifacio.

01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI

Page 2 of 2
 HISTORICAL SOURCE ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Source Material 1 It was the beginning of democracy for the The people of the Philippines had no real say in
Philippines. who become president and vice president which
has become a trend in Pilipino politics.

Source Material 2

Conclusion and Implication

Which is the better or credible version of the Tajeros Convention or the election that happened? For me, the most credible version was the "The
Katipunan and the Revolution" article. All though it is not detailed enough to understand what happened even before and even after the Tejeros
Convention, the explanations of the events that transpired during the said convention were short and brief but clear. It expresses what needs to be
conveyed without unnecessary words. The Seeds of the Discontent article, however, has a great explanation too of what happened but for me, it
focuses more on Andres Bonifacio's story, his journey with the presidency. For me, It was a long and detailed version of what happened in the past
in a way that tackled every part of the event. For example, the history of the two factions, Magdalo and Magdiwang. When Cavite led by the two
factions, successfully rose in their revolt, disputes arises between the leaders of rival factions for their desire to control the other faction. But neither
side would bow nor allow the other faction to rule the other faction, and this led to rebel's defeat at the hands of Polavieja and the Spaniards.

For the Comparative Matrix: For the Advantages and Disadvantages:

CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS
Provided the correct information with pieces of evidence and supporting Provided a sound argument with pieces of evidence and supporting
Content 12 Content 20
details. details.
Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1 Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1
Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the
6 8
of Ideas paragraph. of Ideas paragraph.
Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1 Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1
TOTAL 20 TOTAL 30