Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A N E X P L O R AT I O N O F
U R B A N C O M M U N I T Y- B A S E D R E S P O N S E S T O
M A S S D I S P L AC E M E N T I N AT H E N S
Tahir Zaman
Introduction
129
TAHIR ZAMAN
130
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
131
TAHIR ZAMAN
notion that people on the move harbour little desire to be incorporated into
Greek society - a point conceded by Rozakou (2016:196). Nonetheless, it
says little of situations where pressing and palpable material needs persist,
and the prospect of onward movement recedes. Arguably, the breaking
of the “gift taboo” itself in turn produces a latent “egalitarian tension”
wherein a principled solidarity risks being eclipsed and overcome by a
gradual descent into dependency and clientism (Rakopoulos, 2016:148).
Expressions of solidarity and hospitality have become increasingly blurred.
Under the rubric of hospitality, the responsibility of who welcomes
into the community is transferred away from the state and centred on
societal responses. Many residents of the autonomous housing collectives
under consideration in this chapter make no demands from the state other
than to allow them to transit freely across into northern and western Europe
and await a decision from the state permitting them to do so. During this
interim period where refugees and migrants await an opening for onward
movement, material support for residents of the autonomous housing
collectives or squats is made contingent on practices of philanthropy and
hospitality afforded by those already present. Yet, the context as established
earlier is of a besieged and disenchanted middle class learning to cooperate
with an equally discontented working class in formulating an alternative
response to state austerity measures - one anchored in communities of self-
reliance rather than a reliance on the state.
This point needs closer attention. Far from being dependent and passive
recipients of aid as hegemonic modalities of humanitarianism demands,
residents of the refugee-led squats are actively re-calibrating their own roles
in relation to the material circumstances of so-called hosts to navigate their
journey. In the process they negotiate, contest, and re-iterate their rights
along with resident “host” others as a set of expectations and entitlements
they are due - producing new socialities.
Citizenship thus ceases to be viewed solely as a legal category but is
given meaning through acts that disrupt the status quo (Isin and Nielsen
2008) and calls out to those who are in place. Peter Nyers (2015) puts
into conversation the autonomy of migration literature (Mezzadra, 2004;
Mitropoulos, 2006; Papadopoulos, Stephenson & Tsianos, 2008) with
132
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
133
TAHIR ZAMAN
134
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
135
TAHIR ZAMAN
136
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
137
TAHIR ZAMAN
138
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
139
TAHIR ZAMAN
140
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
141
TAHIR ZAMAN
with a sociable space attached to them are more likely to attract volunteers
and therefore resources to their squat. Both the Fifth school squat and
the Acharnon school squat have large concrete playgrounds which afford
refugees and migrants the opportunity to take on the role of host, and
volunteers the role of guest. Here, refugees are able to reciprocate in a
limited fashion by giving up their time to be with volunteers.
It is also important to acknowledge here that relationships of mutual
responsibility and care are being fostered intra squat (see figure 1 below).
Surplus donations are distributed to other less well-resourced squats. There
have been attempts to better coordinate the distribution of resources between
the SSH-affiliated squats but these efforts have proceeded slowly and been
sporadic. Facilities available at one squat, for instance a doctor’s surgery, is
open to residents of other squats within the SSH network. Following the
firebombing of the Notara 26 squat on 24 August 2016, suspected to have
been perpetrated by fascists, the residents of the nearby Oniro squat arrived
quickly on the scene to help extinguish the blaze. In the days that followed,
residents from the squats combined efforts along with Greek volunteers to
help repair the fire-damaged storeroom. Long-term residents of the squats
also help locate and establish new squats to welcome new arrivals to the city.
142
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
143
TAHIR ZAMAN
144
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
145
TAHIR ZAMAN
have sex any more, the state fucks us each and every morning we get up,
and then one more time before we go to bed - so we are with you [the
refugees and the migrants]”. It is in this “particular constellation of social
relations” that migrants and refugees have been afforded space to insert
themselves. In so doing, they attract another set of networks and relations
which append themselves to the existing infrastructure. Most notable
among these relations are those with informal humanitarians.8
While it is perhaps facile to say that sites of resistance such as Exarcheia
offer a counterbalance to the hegemonic, I am making the case that there is
a pressing need to consider the different trajectories of actors located in sites
of resistance. For many of the activists in Exarcheia, inspired by principles
of anarchism and autonomism, there has been a conscious political journey
which has seen them gravitate towards the district. Activists choose to be
there and to be part of an anti-establishment milieu. In so doing, a space of
belonging is produced and shared with like-minded others. On the other
hand, there are people fleeing from arenas of war and conflict for whom
stability is much sought after: people who have little choice other than to be
in state-controlled camps which, by and large, have been declared “unsafe
and unsanitary” for human habitation (Human Rights Watch, 2016).
Often overlooked in discussions on solidarity are the myriad ways in
which those who identify as belonging to spaces like Exarcheia engage in
practices of “territoriality” to produce social control; delineating what action
is permissible and who the legitimate actors are (Sack, 1986; Agnew, 2007).
The counter publics in Exarcheia, through their everyday interactions and
material practices, impose their rules of the game such to organise spatial
practices. In so doing, they generate the production and reproduction of a
habitus in accordance with anarchist and autonomist ways of being.
The identity of Exarcheia, as with any place, is a social construct made
and remade through struggle and contestation. These struggles have long
been contested, often violently, with the state. As we have seen, Exarcheia
is a site for political mobilisation. Exarcheia evokes certain emotions,
dispositions, and values concerning what the appropriate way of being
ought to be: “This is an anarchist place!” “NGOs not welcome!” “Fuck the
146
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
147
TAHIR ZAMAN
148
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
and looks like rise to the fore as participants in the new game bring to
bear their own personal histories and trajectories to differentiate their work
from the official humanitarian field. As Brown and Yaffe (2013:8) observe,
“solidarity actions can face in more than one direction and seek to intervene
at more than one scale simultaneously”. How the politics of propinquity is
managed is integral to any project of solidarity.
The prioritisation of some activists’ agendas over and above the concerns
of migrants and refugees echoes paternalistic attitudes of humanitarians
who are adamant in knowing what is best. The same attitude is prevalent in
some of the squats where any discussion of NGO involvement is ruled out
by some activists as a matter of principle. This was captured in an exchange
between a self-identified anarchist and the director of a small NGO9 who
had offered to provide mattresses for residents in one of the squats, and
was told: “they can sleep on the floor - they don’t need mattresses”. Absent
in this exchange were the residents of the squat themselves. Given the
complex web of relations between local activists, international volunteers,
and refugees, the following section interrogates the notion of host-guest
relationships. It considers the degree to which hospitality presents an
obstacle in encountering the migrant and refugee other through modalities
of egalitarian solidarity.
149
TAHIR ZAMAN
150
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
not stupid, they see this. They see that volunteers come in and
provide the security they need. It is not uncommon to see young
children affectionately hugging volunteers. The volunteers end
up becoming the parents.
151
TAHIR ZAMAN
152
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
Aside from the efforts of the refugees, there has been little in the way
of attempts to integrate the refugees into the wider social and solidarity
economy that has emerged in Athens in response to austerity. There have
been two notable exceptions. The first was a theatre performance put
together by residents of the Acharnon School Squat. Here, they made use
of the Nosotros community space in Exarcheia for rehearsal purposes every
afternoon over a period of six weeks and performed a play on two occasions
at a newly established community day centre for refugees and migrants.
The second was a promotional event organised by the residents of Oniro
squat with the assistance of a Greek activist and international volunteers.
Here, they raised money from a group of Spanish volunteers to prepare
knafeh, a popular Levantine dessert, which they distributed to passers-by
at Exarcheia Square along with details of the location of the squat. They
also set up a sound system and introduced the local neighbourhood to the
joys of dabkeh. The event was successful in attracting the attention and
resources of local activists and international volunteers.
153
TAHIR ZAMAN
154
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
fully spaces of solidarity, arguably follow more in the tradition of the camp.
That is to say, they are spaces for filtering, segregating, and administering
care - albeit spaces where the retreat of the state and the limited presence of
humanitarian agencies and international NGOs has made way for a diverse
group of non-institutional actors to engage.
I would suggest that the squats are not fully abject spaces for three
reasons. In the first instance, the state has not corralled refugees and
migrants into such spaces - but it is through their own initiative along with
support from local activists that they have opened the squats.10 Secondly,
the state, despite its attempts to render the squats invisible and inaudible,
has not been fully able to curtail their access to rights and social networks.
Lastly, the squats have emerged from space provided by civil society actors.
The squats have been established on the basis of filoxenia or hospitality. This
is most marked in the guises of the City Plaza and the Oniro squats that
have been transformed from spaces of market framed hospitality (hotels)
into a community welcome where “guests” do not pay.
155
TAHIR ZAMAN
Conclusion
156
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
Bibliography
157
TAHIR ZAMAN
158
WHAT’S SO RADICAL ABOUT REFUGEE SQUATS?
159
TAHIR ZAMAN
Zaman, T. (2016) Islamic Traditions of refuge in the Crises of Iraq and Syria.
New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Zaman, T. (2016a) “A Right to Neighbourhood: Re-thinking Islamic
Narratives and Practices of Hospitality in a Sedentarist World”.
in L. Mavelli and E. Wilson (eds.) The Refugee Crisis and Religion.
London: Rowman and Littlefield pp. 157-174.
Notes
1 Here I take sociality to be “a dynamic and interactive relational matrix
through which human beings come to know the world they live in and
find their purpose and meaning within it” (Long & Moore 2013:2).
2 The Prosfygika of Alexandros Avenue carries immense resonance for
refugee solidarity in Athens. The site was constructed by the Greek state
for refugees following the population exchange between Greece and
Turkey. Today it is comprised of several squatted communities comprised
largely of anarchists and Maoists. It is also home to several Afghan and
Syrian refugee families who make up a quarter of the total number of
inhabitants.
3 WELCOMMON: A Model Center for Housing and Social Inclusion”,
http://anemosananeosis.gr/en/aboutwelcommon/ available [online],
accessed 3 March 2019
4 Among the 29 founding members of the Platform are the Islamic
Community of Lisbon, National Confederation of Solidarity Initiatives,
and the European Anti-Poverty Network (Portugal). See http://www.
refugiados.pt/sobre/#membros available [online], accessed 7 January 2017.
5 City Plaza promotional video available [online]: https://www.youtube.
com/watch?v=DKuHLSJuNGI (accessed 4 November 2016).
6 The arrival of the winter season meant that the roof terrace bar closed and
moved into the space formerly used by refugees.
7 A small number of individual refugees with a modicum of English have
developed friendships with local Greeks.
8 I choose the label informal humanitarian to describe those who are outside
the formalised humanitarian system. This includes. amongst others. people
161
TAHIR ZAMAN
162