THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs.
TEODULO ROGADO, ET AL., defendants-appellants.'
Solicitor General Edilberto Barot and Solicitor Jorge R. Coquia for
appellee. Alfredo G. Fernando for appellant Teodoro Rogado. Angel C. Facundo for the other appellants.
SYLLABUS
1. CRIMINAL LAW; MURDER; OBEDIENCE TO AN ORDER OF A
SUPERIOR; ORDER MUST BE FOR A LAWFUL PURPOSE TO JUSTIFY AN ACT. — The well-settled rule is that obedience to an order of a superior will only justify an act which otherwise would be criminal if the order is for a lawful purpose. 2. ID.; ID.; ID.; WHEN THERE IS NO PRESSURE OF UNCONTROLLABLE FEAR. — Where an accused, who was ordered by his superiors to kill a person, had not only the means with which to protect himself from any retaliation on the part of his superiors if they should threaten to punish him if he disobeyed their order, but also the opportunity to escape with the intended victim to avoid the ire of said superiors, yet did not do so, but instead carried out the order, it cannot be said that he acted on the matter involuntarily or under the influence of uncontrollable fear. he acted on his own free will and with the desire to collaborate with the criminal design of his superiors and was, therefore, a co-principal by direct participation. 3. ID.; ID.; NO COMPLEX CRIME OF REBELLION WITH MURDER; WHEN MURDER IS NOT ABSORBED BY REBELLION. — There is no complex crime of rebellion with murder because the latter offense is absorbed by the former (People vs. Hernandez, 99 Phil., 515, 52 Off. Gaz., No. 12, p. 5506). However, if the killing is inspired by personal motive such killing is not absorbed by the rebellion but may be the subject of separate prosecution (People vs. Geronimo, 100 Phil., 90, 53, Off. Gaz., No. 1, p. 68).
DECISION
BAUTISTA ANGELO, J : p
On September 25, 1956, Teodulo Rogado, alias Commander Sulit,
Eddie White, Sr. v. Vernon L. Pepersack, Warden, Maryland Penitentiary, The Hon. Thomas B. Finan, Attorney General of The State of Maryland, 352 F.2d 470, 4th Cir. (1965)