Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Mammalian cells depend on glucose as a major substrate for energy production. Glucose is
transported into the cell via facilitative glucose transporters (GLUT) present in all cell types. Many
GLUT isoforms have been described and their expression is cell-specific and subject to hormonal
and environmental control. The kinetic properties and substrate specificities of the different
isoforms are specifically suited to the energy requirements of the particular cell types. Due to the
ubiquitousness of these transporters, their differential expression is involved in various disease
states such as diabetes, ischemia and cancer.
The majority of cancers and isolated cancer cell lines over-express the GLUT family members
which are present in the respective tissue of origin under non-cancerous conditions. Moreover, due
to the requirement of energy to feed uncontrolled proliferation, cancer cells often express GLUTs
which under normal conditions would not be present in these tissues. This over-expression is
predominantly associated with the likelihood of metastasis and hence poor patient prognosis. This
article presents a review of the current literature on the regulation and expression of GLUT family
members and has compiled clinical and research data on GLUT expression in human cancers and
in isolated human cancer cell lines.
Key terms: GLUT, glucose transporters, expression, cancer, estrogen, progesterone, cell lines
INTRODUCTION
Most mammalian cells depend on a continuous supply of glucose not only as a
precursor of glycoproteins, triglycerides and glycogen but also as an important
source of energy by generating ATP through glycolysis. Glucose is a hydrophilic
compound; it cannot pass through the lipid bilayer by simple diffusion, and
therefore requires specific carrier proteins to mediate its specific transport into the
cytosol. There is an energy-dependent Na+/glucose co-transporter in the polarized
epithelial cells in the lumen of small intestine and in the proximal tubules of the
kidney. Exclusively in the aforementioned cells this protein uses the movement of
Na+ down its electro-chemical gradient to drive the uptake of glucose.
A ubiquitous glucose transport system also exists. All mammalian cells contain
one or more members of the facilitative glucose transporter gene family named
GLUT (Table 1). These transporters have a high degree of stereoselectivity,
providing for the bidirectional transport of substrate, with passive diffusion down
its concentration gradient. GLUTs function to regulate the movement of glucose
between the extracellular and intracellular compartments maintaining a constant
supply of glucose available for metabolism.
As any cell divides and grows the demand for energy increases, this is no less true
for cancer cells. Normal mammalian cells use oxygen to generate energy from
glucose, and other substrates, through oxidative phosphorylation. Although
tumors induce formation of new blood vessels to deliver nutrients and oxygen to
the growing tumor, angiogenesis does not keep pace with the growth of the
neoplastic cells. This results in large hypoxic areas throughout the tumor.
TABLE 1
Tissue-specific expression of the GLUT family members.
GLUT2 has a very low affinity for glucose with a Km for 3-O-methylglucose of 40
mM (Gould , 1991). Since normal circulating glucose concentration is 3.9-5.6
mM, the rate of transport will be directly proportional to glucose concentration.
Therefore, in the postprandial state, when circulating glucose levels are high, there
is a net flux of glucose into hepatocytes and pancreatic ß-cells. In contrast, when
circulating glucose levels are low, intracellular glucose concentration will increase
as a result of glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis. When the intracellular glucose
concentration exceeds the plasma concentration GLUT transports glucose from
the liver into the circulation. GLUT2 also functions as a low-affinity fructose
transporter, which is consistent with the liver being the primary site for fructose
metabolism (Gould , 1991). GLUT2 is further involved in the anterior
transport of glucose supplied by choroidal circulation from the early stages of
retinal development (Watanabe , 1999).
The localization, expression and regulation of the GLUT family are tissue and
often cell-specific. New GLUT isoforms are continually being discovered and
characterized in various cell types. Their involvement in disease states is also
continually under review. In cancer cells, which have broken free from the
normally tight global regulation, aberrant expression of the GLUT family
members provides the energy source required for further uncontrolled
proliferation and metastasis. As every cell contains the genes for each GLUT
family member we observe in cancer cells the expression of certain GLUT
isoforms which, under normal conditions, would never have been expressed in
these tissues (Table 2 and 3). The review will place emphasis on the best
described models of GLUT expression and regulation. These are GLUT1 and
GLUT4 in adipose and muscle tissue. GLUT1 is thought to play a constitutive
role, and is responsible for basal glucose uptake. GLUT4 is the inducible
transporter and is classically referred to as the "insulin-responsive" transporter.
This nomenclature has arisen due to its translocation from the intracellular
membrane compartment to the plasma membrane, which was originally described
in response to insulin (Slot , 1991; Kraegen , 1993).
TABLE 2
GLUT PHYSIOLOGY
One of the most important, and well established, models of GLUT regulation is
the stimulation of GLUT expression and translocation in adipose and muscle
tissue by insulin (Birnbaum, 1992; James & Piper, 1994; Slot , 1991). It is
this process that provides the regulation of whole-body glucose homeostasis and,
when dysfunctional, plays a vital role in diabetes mellitus. GLUT4 is almost
completely responsible for insulin-stimulated glucose transport. In rat adipocytes,
the most studied cell system for insulin action on glucose transport, more than
95% of GLUT4 and 30-40% of GLUT1 is associated with intracellular
membranes, and are thus non-functional. These GLUTs are translocated to the
plasma membrane in response to insulin, where they are able to facilitate the
transport of substrate (Suzuki & Kono, 1980). GLUT4 is constantly recycled
between the plasma membrane and intracellular storage pool with two discrete
first-order rate constants, one for internalization (kin) and one for externalization
(kex). Insulin causes transporter translocation by reducing kin and increasing kex
approximately 3-fold each (Jhun , 1992). Impaired GLUT activity is in part
responsible for insulin resistance in human diabetes and obesity (Ismail-Beigi,
1993).
The rate of glucose utilization in the rat heart is greater than in many tissues such
as skeletal muscle, adipose and lung (James , 1985). Cardiac muscle glucose
transport and utilization is vital for normal function, a fact illustrated in GLUT4
cardiac knockout mice which show cardiac hypertrophy and other major
morphologic heart changes (Katz , 1995). Moreover, a high rate of cardiac
glucose metabolism becomes crucial during ischemia when oxidative
phosphorylation is limited. Under basal conditions glucose transport is the rate
limiting step in glucose metabolism, however, the element of control shifts to
phosphorylation by hexokinase in the presence of insulin (Kashiwaya , 1994).
TABLE 3
Glut Over-
Gastric Associated Noguchi , 1999
2 expressed
Pancreatic Glut Reduced Not Seino , 1993
2 Associated
Nagamatsu ,
Brain Glut3 No Change NR
1993
Glut Over-
Brain Associated Boado , 1994
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Breast NR Binder , 1997
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Gastric NR Noguchi , 1999
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Gastric NR Younes , 1997b
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Head and Neck NR Reisser , 1999
3 expressed
Glut Over- Not Mellanen ,
Head and Neck
3 expressed Associated 1994
Glut Over-
Lung Associated Kurata , 1999
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Lung NR Ito , 1998
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Lung Associated Younes , 1997a
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Lung NR Younes , 1997a
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Meningiomas NR Glick 1993
3 expressed
Ovarian Glut Over- NR Younes , 1997b
3 expressed
Glut Over-
Breast NR Binder , 1997
4 expressed
Glut Over-
Gastric NR Noguchi , 1999
4 expressed
Glut Over-
Lung NR Ito , 1998
4 expressed
Pancreatic Glut Reduced Not Reske , 1997
4 Associated
Glut Over-
Lung Associated Kurata , 1999
5 expressed
There are two main glucose transporters present in cardiac tissue. Under un-
stressed conditions approximately 60-70% of GLUT1 and 10-20% of GLUT4 is
localized in the plasma membrane (Zorzano ., 1997). In cardiomyocytes,
GLUT4 and GLUT1 account for approximately 60% and 40% respectively, of
total glucose carriers (Fischer , 1997). A number of different stimuli, such as
ischemia, insulin and lactate, have been shown to cause translocation of GLUT1
and GLUT4 to the plasma membrane (Brosius , 1997; Egert , 1999;
Montessuit , 1998, Fuller , 2001; Medina , 2002). These effects may
be crucial in the overall metabolism of glucose since, as mentioned above, under
many conditions; transmembrane transport is the limiting step in glucose
breakdown in the heart (Doenst & Taegtmeyer, 1998; Manchester , 1994;
Nguyen , 1990). In addition to increased translocation of GLUT4 in response
to acute myocardial ischemia, chronic ischemia increases GLUT1 protein content
by enhancing GLUT1 mRNA expression (Brosius , 1997).
Fasting and diabetes cause a repression of cardiac GLUT1 and GLUT4 protein
levels in the rat heart (Kraegen , 1993) and cardiac sarcolemmal vesicles from
diabetic rats show decreased glucose transport (Garvey , 1993). These results
suggest a decrease in glucose transporter number at the cell surface and indicate
that both fasting and diabetes alter the expression and distribution of glucose
transporters. Therefore, it is possible that GLUT depletion and diminished glucose
transport across the cell surface of cardiomyocytes in diabetes could limit glucose
availability and lead to myocardial dysfunction.
Many tissues types can utilize a variety of substrates, such as glucose, lactate and
fatty acids, as an energy source. In contrast, the adult central nervous system relies
on glucose as its sole source for ATP production. In order for glucose to reach
neurons within the brain it must first cross the endothelium of the blood brain
barrier into the interstitial space. From this compartment glucose must be
transported across the neuronal plasma membrane using the ubiquitous GLUT1
and GLUT3 isoforms. Brain GLUT1 is a multiple-molecular-weight species
ranging between 45-55 KDa (Olson & Pessin, 1996). The larger-molecular-weight
species are present in microvessels (Maher , 1994), the smaller species are
present in vessel-free preparation on brain membranes (Pardridge , 1990) and
an intermediate species is present in the choroid plexus (Kumagai , 1994).
The differences in molecular weight are due to differences in N-linked
glycosylation. The functional effect of the different glycosylation states is not
clear although there is evidence suggesting that they are involved in GLUT1
trafficking (McMahon , 2000) and substrate affinity (Onetti , 1997).
GLUT3 is highly expressed in the brain (Nagamatsu , 1992), specifically in
neurons (Maher , 1993). Its relatively low Km indicates that glucose transport
via GLUT3 is near maximal at normal plasma glucose concentrations (Gould
, 1991). GLUT1 and GLUT3 expression is regulated by developmental stage and
by metabolic state. Fetal and neonatal rat mainly express GLUT1 in all brain
related cell types, but neurons change to the expression of GLUT3 at about 10
days after birth (Nagamatsu , 1994). GLUT3 mRNA levels are up-regulated
by hypoglycemia in mouse brain in an apparent protective mechanism against
energy depletion (Nagamatsu , 1994a). In accordance with the neural tissue
having a preference for GLUT3 mediated glucose uptake, it is the detection of
immunoreactive GLUT3, but not GLUT1, in the high grade gliomas which
suggests that GLUT3 isoform may be the predominant glucose transporter in
highly malignant glial cells of human brain (Boado , 1994), (Table 2 and 3).
The same observation is apparent in the choroid plexus where GLUT1 is down-
regulated while GLUT3 levels remain unchanged (Kurosaki , 1995). As an
example that each cancer is different, Boado and colleagues (1994) observed that
GLUT1 was over-expressed in malignant glial cells. Although GLUT1 is the
consistently over-expressed isoform, the presence of GLUT3 tends to be a major
factor in tumour progression. GLUT3 over-expression in lung cancer cells confers
a higher probability of metastasis and thus worse prognosis than GLUT1 over-
expression alone (Younes , 1997a ,b). In accordance with this report, Zhang
and colleagues (1996) observed reduced GLUT1 expression in lung cancer cells
that metastasized to the brain (Table 2)
The small intestine and kidney express the isoforms GLUT1, GLUT2, GLUT3,
GLUT5 and the Na+-dependent glucose transporter. GLUT2 is the primary
isoform responsible for transport across the basolateral membrane of intestinal
epithelial cells (Thorens , 1990) while GLUT5 mediates fructose uptake from
the intestinal lumen and efflux from the intestinal epithelia (Blakemore ,
1995). GLUT2 can also transport fructose but with a six-fold lower affinity than
GLUT5 (Colville , 1993). Human digestive tract cancers (gastric and
colorectal) show a distribution of GLUT over-expression with GLUT1, GLUT 2
and GLUT4 over-expressed. As a means of studying GLUT signaling, numerous
gastric and colorectal cell lines have been established which express one or more
of the isoforms GLUT 1-GLUT5 (Table 4).
TABLE 4
Glut
Tissue Origin Denomination Source
Expression
Studies in adipose, heart and skeletal muscle have shown that insulin-induced
translocation of GLUT4 is mediated by phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase (PI3K), as
has been shown using wortmannin, a potent inhibitor of the enzyme (Lee ,
1995).
TABLE 5
Regulators and signaling pathways involved in glucose transport.
Czech&Corvera,
Insulin IR, PI3K GLUT4 Muscle, fat
1999
IGF-IR,
IGF-I GLUT4 Muscle, fat Jullien et al, 1995
PI3K
IGF-IR,
IGF-II GLUT4 Muscle, fat Burguera et al, 1994
PI3K
GLUT4,
Contraction AMPK Skeletal muscle Hayashi et al, 1998
GLUT1?
Ischemia AMPK GLUT4 Heart muscle Russell et al, 1999
Hypoxia AMPK? GLUT4 Skeletal muscle Zierath, 1998
Presumed
Nitric oxide cGMP Skeletal muscle Young et al, 1997
GLUT4
Presumed
Phorbol ester PKC Skeletal muscle Hansen et al, 1997
GLUT4
a-Adrenergic
Gs protein GLUT4 Brown fat, muscle Shimizu et al, 1996
agonists
Presumed
b-Adrenergic agonist Gi protein Heart muscle Fischer et al, 1996
GLUT4
Bradykinin Gq protein GLUT3 Skeletal muscle Kishi et al, 1998
Thrombin Gi protein GLUT3 Platelets Heijnen et al, 1997
White and brown
Adenosine Gq protein GLUT4 Smith et al, 1984
fat
Sexual dimorphism exists in glucose metabolism. The role of sex hormones in this
metabolism is apparent in the fetal rat where males demonstrate delayed lung
maturation. This delay is speculated to be in part due to the predominantly female
sex hormone estrogen causing an increase in GLUT1, and consequently an
increase in glucose transport, in the female rat lung in comparison to the male
(Hart , 1998). Additional work in the rat model has demonstrated that glucose
uptake is impaired by the absence of estrogen or by the presence of progesterone.
This suggests that estrogen increases metabolic activity and this process is finely
regulated by the balance between estrogen and progesterone (Campbell and
Febbraio 2001). In the aforementioned study, progesterone decreased GLUT4 in
skeletal and adipose tissue, yet interestingly in another study of rat adipose tissue,
physiological doses of estrogen or progesterone did not alter GLUT4 expression,
while higher than physiological doses or the simultaneous co-addition of
physiological doses of both hormones reduced GLUT4 (Sugaya , 2000;
Sugaya , 1999). This indicates the complex interaction between signaling
pathways can produce differing responses to steroid hormones in the same tissue
or cell line. At any given time, the presence, absence or the activation level of
stimuli, such as insulin-like growth factor (IGF) and insulin, is different. Thus the
observed paradoxical results in response to sex steroid hormones may demonstrate
that cross-talk with other growth factors can differentially regulate the GLUT
family members.
In the Rhesus monkey brain, GLUT3 and GLUT4 expression is observed in the
corticol neurones and GLUT1 in the capillaries and glial cells. Estrogen
administration increased GLUT3 and GLUT4 expression and increased
paranchymal if not vascular GLUT1 expression (Cheng , 2001). In this same
study estrogen also increased the production of the IGF, suggesting that this
growth factor plays a co-regulatory role in glucose uptake. In support of this
argument, in mouse oocyte maturation the estrogen increase in GLUT1 expression
was significantly lower in the absence of IGF (Zhou , 2000). The breast
cancer drug Tamoxifen which possesses both estrogenic and anti-estrogen
activities depending on both the target gene and tissue, also increased GLUT3 and
GLUT4 in the Rhesus monkey brain, perhaps suggesting that the protective
estrogenic effect in the brain is connected to GLUT regulation, and that
Tamoxifen and other selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) could
confer some of these protective effects on the human brain (Cheng , 2001). In
agreement with this hypothesis, estrogen was shown to increase GLUT1 and
protect against brain capillary endothelial cell loss in reduced glucose conditions
and anoxia (Shi , 1997) and reduce glucose transport inhibition in
synaptosomes from the rat cerebral hemisphere (Keller , 1997).
To further dissect the mechanism of estrogen action Welch and Gorski (1999)
demonstrated that in the rat uterus, estrogen increased glucose uptake in what
appears to be both a transciptionally-independent and dependent mechanism.
Estrogen causes an increase in glucose uptake in less than two hours and
continues beyond eight hours. This early timeframe appears to suggest
transcriptional independence, a theory that is confirmed by insensitivity to
cyclohexamide and the observation that estrogen does not increase GLUT1
mRNA levels or GLUT1 and GLUT4 protein levels until after four hours of
treatment. Presumably after eight hours, when levels of GLUT1 and GLU4 are
elevated in response to estrogen, these proteins translocate to the membrane and
augment glucose uptake. The possibility that at less than two hours estrogen
induced glucose uptake was via translocation to the membrane was ruled out by
the demonstration that both GLUT1 and GLUT4 localization was unchanged.
This suggests that a GLUT1 and GLUT4-independent pathway is responsible for
glucose uptake or that estrogen treatment causes a modification in the membrane
localized GLUT proteins, thus facilitating glucose uptake. A conclusion from
several publications is that hormone regulated glucose transport is not solely
mediated by glucose transporters. In breast cancer biopsies no positive
relationship was found between glucose uptake, determined by FDG, and
expression of GLUTs (Avril , 2001). In comparison of two cell lines Aloj
, (1999) reported that higher levels of glucose transporter protein do not
guarantee increased glucose uptake. Marom , (2001) demonstrated that
GLUT1 and GLUT3 transporter expression did not demonstrate a statistically
significant correlation with FDG uptake in potentially resectable lung cancer.
These results could be explained if it is the glucose phosphorylation, by
hexokinase, and not the glucose transport which is the rate-limiting step in
glucose uptake.
The breast and uterine endometrium are two of the classical target tissues for sex
steroid hormone action. GLUT1, which is expressed in mammary tissue under
normal conditions, is over-expressed in breast cancer tissue and has a high
association with metastasis. As breast cancers are predominantly estrogen-driven,
this suggests a correlation between GLUT expression and estrogen. Although
aforementioned work in the rat and monkey has demonstrated such a relationship,
Avril and colleagues (2001) reported that there was no correlation between
estrogen receptor status and GLUT expression. The role of estrogen in GLUT
over-expression remains elusive especially since it has been observed that in
many advanced breast cancers estrogen receptor expression is lost. Both breast
cancer biopsies and isolated cell lines have been shown to express GLUT5
(Zamora-Leon , 1996). GLUT5 is not expressed under normal conditions in
the breast and is only expressed by a few tissues in the body, thus suggesting that
breast cancers are utilizing fructose as an energy source in uncontrolled
proliferation.
SUMMARY
For this it requires specific facilitative transport proteins which are subject to
hormonal and environmental control.
The fact that glucose, and possibly fructose, is the only utilizable substrate
available for energy production to ischemic cancers suggests that GLUTs have
great therapeutic potential in combating this disease. This potential is not solely as
prognostic markers, through their association with metastasis and thus poor
patient prognosis, but also as direct targets of clinical intervention. Further
therapeutic potential may be derived from a better understanding of the
coordination between signaling pathways such as IGF, insulin and hormones, and
with this knowledge the design of drugs to exploit this interaction for patient gain.
To better understand this signaling pathway association, numerous cancer cell
lines exist which express the GLUT1 through GLUT 5 family members (and
potentially other members, Table 1). These cell lines (Table 4) will provide useful
experimental models in which interactions can be dissected, prognostic markers
characterized and potential drugs designed, before their transference to the clinic.
REFERENCES
AGUS DB, VERA JC, GOLDE DW (1999) Stromal cell oxidation: a mechanism
by which tumors obtain vitamin C. Cancer Res 59: 4555-4558
BROWN RS, LEUNG JY, KISON PV, ZASADNY KR, FLINT A, WAHL RL
(1999) Glucose transporters and FDG uptake in untreated primary human non-
small cell lung cancer. J Nucl Med. 40: 556-65
BURGUERA BE, ELTON CW, CARO JF, TAPSCOTT EB, PORIES WJ,
DIMARCHI R, SAKANO K, DOHM GL (1994) Stimulation of glucose uptake
by insulin-like growth factor II in human muscle is not mediated by the insulin-
like growth factor II/mannose 6-phosphate receptor. Biochem J 300: 781-785
CHAN JY, KONG SK, CHOY YM, LEE CY, FUNG KP (1999) Inhibition of
glucose transporter gene expression by antisense nucleic acids in HL-60 leukemia
cells. Life Sci 65: 63-70
CHANG S, LEE S, LEE C, KIM JI, KIM Y (2000) Expression of the human
erythrocyte glucose transporter in transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder.
Urology 55: 448-52
COLVILLE CA, SEATTER MJ, JESS TS, GOULD GW, THOMAS HM (1993)
Kinetic analysis of liver-type (GLUT2) and brain-type (GLUT3) glucose
transporter in Xenopus oocytes: substrate specificities and effects of transport
inhibitors. Biochem J 290: 701-706
GERMAN MS (1993) Glucose sensing in pancreatic islet beta cells: the key role
of glucokinase and the glycolytic intermediates. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:
1781-1785
GOULD GW, THOMAS HM, JESS TJ, BELL GI (1991) Expression of human
glucose transporters in Xenopus oocytes: kinetic characterization and substrate
specificities of the erythrocyte, liver and brain isoforms. Biochemistry 30: 5139-
5145
HARRIS DS, SLOT JW, GEUZE HJ, JAMES DE (1992) Polarized distribution of
glucose transporter isoforms in Caco-2 cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89: 7556-
7560
JAMES DE, PIPER RC (1994) Insulin resistance, diabetes, and the insulin-
regulated trafficking of GLUT4. J Cell Biol 126: 1123-1126
JHUN BH, RAMPAL AL, LIU HZ, LACHAAL M, JUNG CY (1992) Effects of
insulin on steady state kinetics of GLUT4 subcellular distribution in rat
adipocytes: evidence of constitutive GLUT4 recycling. J Biol Chem 267: 17710-
17715
KAYANO T, FUKUMOTO H, EDDY RL, FAN YS, BYERS MG, SHOWS TB,
BELL GI (1988) Evidence for a family of human glucose transporter-like
proteins. Sequence and gene localization of a protein expressed in fetal skeletal
muscle and other tissues. J Biol Chem 263: 15245-15248
KRAEGEN EW, SOWDEN JA, HALSTEAD MB, CLARK PW, RODNICK KJ,
CHISHOLM DJ, JAMES DE (1993) Glucose transporters and in-vivo glucose
uptake in skeletal and cardiac muscle: fasting, insulin stimulation and
immunoisolation studies of GLUT1 and GLUT4. Biochem J 295: 287-293
MCMAHON RJ, HWANG JB, FROST SC (2000) Glucose deprivation does not
affect GLUT1 targeting in 3T3-L1 adipocytes. Biochem Biophys Res Comm 273:
859-64
NGUYEN VTB, MOSSBERG KA, TEWSON TJ, WONG WH, ROWE RW,
COLEMAN GA, TAEGTMEYER H (1990) Temporal analysis of myocardial
glucose metabolism by 2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose. Am J Physiol 259:
H1022-H1031
PHAY JE, HUSSAIN HB, MOLEY JF (2000) Cloning and expression analysis of
a novel member of the facilitative glucose transporter family, SLC2A9 (GLUT9).
Genomics 66: 217-220
VERA JC, RIVAS CI, ZHANG RH, FARBER CN, GOLDE DW (1994) Human
HL-60 myeloid leukemia cells transport dehydoascorbic acid via the glucose
transporters and accumulate reduced ascorbic acid. Blood 84: 1628-1634
lolguin@abello.unab.cl