Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history: Background: Minimally invasive Q3 repair has been proposed for acute Achilles tendon rupture with low
Received 10 April 2013 rate of complications. However there are still controversies about optimal technique. In this study we
Received in revised form 15 May 2013 aimed to describe Endobutton-assisted modified Bunnell configuration as a new Achilles tendon repair
Accepted 25 June 2013
technique and evaluate its biomechanical properties comparing with native tendon and Krackow
technique.
Keywords: Methods: 27 ovine Achilles tendons were obtained and randomly placed into 3 groups with 9 specimens
Endobutton
ineach. The Achilles tendons were repaired with Endobutton-assisted modified Bunnell technique in
Achilles tendon
Acute
group 1, Krackow suture technique in group 2 and group 3 was defined as the control group including
Rupture native tendons. Unidirectional tensile loading to failure was performed at 25 mm/min. Biomechani-
Repair calproperties such as peak force to failure (N), stress at peak (MPa), elongation at failure, and
Minimally invasive Young’smodulus (GPa) was measured for each group. All groups were compared with each other using
one-wayANOVA followed by the Tukey HSD multiple comparison test (a = 0.05).
Results: The average peak force (N) to failure of group 1 and group 2 and control group was 415.6 57.6,
268.1 65.2 and 704.5 85.8, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference between native
tendon and group 1 for the amount elongation at failure (p > 0.05).
Conclusions: Regarding the results, we concluded that Endobutton-assisted modified Bunnell technique
provides stronger fixation than conventional techniques. It may allow early range of motion and can be
easily applied in minimally invasive and percutaneous methods particularly for cases with poor quality
tendon at the distal part of rupture.
Level of evidence: Level II, Biomechanical research study.
ß 2013 European Foot and Ankle Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1268-7731/$ – see front matter ß 2013 European Foot and Ankle Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fas.2013.06.012
262 [(Fig._1)TD$IG]
G. Huri et al. / Foot and Ankle Surgery 19 (2013) 261–266
Fig. 3. Endobutton-assisted modified Bunnell technique. (a) 3.2 mm suture passing pin (white arrows) was inserted through the calcaneus from proximally to distally (b) the
passing pin was advanced into the transcalcaneal tunnel and pulled out of calcaneus to carry the loop (asterisk) distally (c) the loop (asterisk) was carried to plantar site,
leaving the free limbs proximally (d) the sutures mounted on Endobutton were passed through the tunnel by the assistance of the loop (e) Final appearance of the specimen
repaired with Endobutton-assisted modified Bunnell technique.
[(Fig._4)TD$IG]
failure (N), stress at peak (MPa), percent elongation at failure, and
Young’s modulus (GPa) were compared using one-way ANOVA
followed by the Tukey HSD multiple comparison test (a = 0.05).
4. Results
Fig. 5. In the graphics all data are shown as mean with SD (CI: confidence interval).
5. Discussion Our results showed higher resistance to failure than the Krackow
technique and support the biomechanical feasibility for the clinical
While the ultimate failure force at the repair site after Krackow use of the Endobutton technique in acute ruptures.
suture technique was only 38% of the native tendon’s failure force, The Krackow method was chosen as a comparison group in this
Endobutton assisted suture technique provided two times more study because of its worldwide acceptance as a representative
failure resistance at the repair site than Krackow technique. method for tendon repairs. It is still a preferred technique as a
Even though the ultimate strength of repair obtained by the control in many biomechanical studies [34–39]. Although there
Endobutton technique is not equal with native tendon, it is more are various types of suture techniques used for tendon repairs
likely to resist rupture than the Krakow technique. When such as Kessler and Bunnell stitches, biomechanical superiority of
comparing human cadaveric data to ovine data, it has been Krackow suture technique for Achilles tendon repairs has been
shown that the load across the human Achilles tendon in neutral demonstrated in previous studies [40,41]. In a recent paper,
position is 370 N, and will increase to 400 N with passive ROM Maquirriain also recommended the Krackow method to reduce
[23]. Our average force to failure was 415 N using an ovine tendon lengthening during Achilles tendon repair [41], which is
model. This comparable result may support the clinical meaning has been shown to be essential for obtaining better outcomes [42].
of our technique. To our knowledge, this is the first study that The superior failure force of our technique may allow the
tests biomechanical properties and describes the operative opportunity for early rehabilitation with less gapping at the
technique of Endobutton assisted modified Bunnell technique repair site. The other advantage is its applicability in minimally
for Achilles tendon ruptures. invasive repair.
Endobutton techniques have been widely used for the Acute Achilles tendon rupture is most commonly managed with
treatment of several injuries such as acromioclavicular separation open surgical repair even with its relatively high rate of
[24,25], distal biceps brachii rupture [26,27], distal tibiofibular complications [17,42–45]. However in last decade, minimally
syndesmotic injury [28–30] and reconstruction of knee ligaments invasive treatment of Achilles tendon ruptures has become an
[31,32]. The use of an Endobutton has not been previously increasingly popular technique with orthopaedic surgeons
described for the treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures in [9,13,14,46,47]. Cretnik et al. published comparable functional
the literature. Fanter et al. demonstrated the safety of transcalca- outcomes of percutaneous suturing to open repair, with a
neal drilling during Endobutton use and also demonstrated good significantly lower rate of complications [17]. McClelland and
biomechanical results of Endobutton-assisted repairs combined Maffulli recommended percutaneous repair as a safe and reliable
with double-row suture anchor construct in the treatment of method in patients with lower demand because of its slightly
insertional Achilles tendinopathy in a laboratory setting [33]. higher incidence of re-rupture [48]. Subsequently Carmont and
There was no information about the biomechanical properties of Maffulli established a modified minimally invasive suture tech-
Endobutton assisted repairs without a secondary fixation device. nique with a lower complication and rerupture rates [16].
G. Huri et al. / Foot and Ankle Surgery 19 (2013) 261–266 265
However, Huffard et al. described disadvantages of percutaneous applied to techniques used in minimally invasive and percutane-
repairs including the difficulty of achieving appropriate tension at ous methods.
the repair site without visualizing the rupture ends [49]. To
address this issue, Doral et al. proposed endoscopically assisted Conflict of interest
percutaneous repair and reported satisfactory results without
rerupture [9]. In a recent study Henriquez et al. found no The authors have no conflict of interest.
difference between open and percutaneous repairs after mean of
18 months [50]. In a recent study Ortiz et al. compared the References
biomechanical properties of four different minimal invasive suture
[1] Olsson N, Nilsson-Helander K, Karlsson J, Eriksson BI, Thomee R, Faxen E, et al.
techniques for repair of the Achilles tendon ruptures in bovine Major functional deficits persist 2 years after acute Achilles tendon rupture.
model. They demonstrated the superiority of the modified triple- Knee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy Official Journal of the ESSKA
strand Dresden repair technique (mean load to failure 675 N) over 2011;19:1385.
[2] Leppilahti J, Forsman K, Puranen J, Orava S. Outcome and prognostic factors of
double-strand technique (mean load to failure 327.8 N) [22].
achilles rupture repair using a new scoring method. Clinical Orthopaedics and
However in case of the rupture with shredded distal part, we can Related Research 1998;152–61.
guess that, both of these repair techniques may not provide [3] Kearney RS, Costa ML. Current concepts in the rehabilitation of an acute
adequate purchase to maintain the resistance against distraction rupture of the tendo Achillis. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery British Volume
2012;94:28.
during early range of motion. The transosseous fixation of the [4] Maffulli N, Tallon C, Wong J, Lim KP, Bleakney R. Early weightbearing and ankle
endobutton technique may provide a stronger initial construct mobilization after open repair of acute midsubstance tears of the achilles
when the distal stump is compromised, but would need to be tendon. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2003;31:692.
[5] Yotsumoto T, Miyamoto W, Uchio Y. Novel approach to repair of acute achilles
studied further. Therefore, it is obvious that there is still no tendon rupture: early recovery without postoperative fixation or orthosis.
consensus about the best repair technique for Achilles tendon American Journal of Sports Medicine 2010;38:287.
rupture, which has a tenuous distal stump [41,51–54]. [6] Mortensen HM, Skov O, Jensen PE. Early motion of the ankle after operative
treatment of a rupture of the Achilles tendon. A prospective, randomized
The most common site for Achilles tendon rupture is 2–6 cm clinical and radiographic study. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery American
from the calcaneal insertion due to a smaller cross sectional area Volume 1999;81:983.
and a relatively poor blood supply compared to the rest of the [7] Speck M, Klaue K. Early full weightbearing and functional treatment after
surgical repair of acute achilles tendon rupture. American Journal of Sports
tendon [55,56]. In acute traumatic ruptures, it is frequently Medicine 1998;26:789.
difficult to achieve a firm and reliable grasp of the distal tendon [8] Mortensen NH, Saether J, Steinke MS, Staehr H, Mikkelsen SS. Separation of
stump because of either shredding or inadequate length. Our tendon ends after Achilles tendon repair: a prospective, randomized, multi-
center study. Orthopedics 1992;15:899.
described transosseous technique can considered providing
[9] Doral MN, Bozkurt M, Turhan E, Ayvaz M, Atay OA, Uzumcugil A, et al.
stronger fixation than primary suture repair based on our study Percutaneous suturing of the ruptured Achilles tendon with endoscopic con-
result. Moreover, quality of the distal tendon remnant is not as trol. Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery 2009;129:1093.
important as in the other techniques to provide a strong repair and [10] Doral MN. What is the effect of the early weight-bearing mobilisation without
using any support after endoscopy-assisted Achilles tendon repair? Knee
allow early range of motion. Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy 2013;21(6):1378–84.
There are some limitations of our study. First, our study uses [11] Lee SJ, Goldsmith S, Nicholas SJ, McHugh M, Kremenic I, Ben-Avi S. Optimizing
ovine tendon. The calcaneus in the ovine never touches the ground Achilles tendon repair: effect of epitendinous suture augmentation on the
strength of achilles tendon repairs. Foot & Ankle International/American
[57]. Therefore generalizing the results from animal studies to Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society [and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Society
humans is not always straightforward. The histology of the ovine 2008;29:427.
Achilles is different from the human Achilles and the rupture site [12] Mullaney MJ, McHugh MP, Tyler TF, Nicholas SJ, Lee SJ. Weakness in end-range
plantar flexion after Achilles tendon repair. American Journal of Sports Medi-
may also be in a different location [58–60]. Our model used a clean cine 2006;34:1120.
laceration as opposed to the ‘‘mop ends’’ typically seen in acute [13] Hrnack SA, Crates JM, Barber FA. Primary Achilles tendon repair with mini-
Achilles tendon ruptures. A surgical transection of the tendon dorsolateral incision technique and accelerated rehabilitation. Foot & Ankle
International 2012;33:848.
produces a more consistent stump to test across specimens. An [14] Ozkaya U, Parmaksizoglu AS, Kabukcuoglu Y, Sokucu S, Basilgan S. Open
inconsistent stump was anticipated to detract from our ability to minimally invasive Achilles tendon repair with early rehabilitation: functional
comment on the strength of the suture configuration alone and results of 25 consecutive patients. Injury 2009;40:669.
[15] Dobson MH, Nguyen C. Treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures. A meta-
introduce variability into the model, especially in the Krackow
analysis of randomized, controlled trials. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery
group. Another potential limitation of our technique is the possible American Volume 2006;88:1160 [author reply 1160].
need for a second operation to remove a symptomatic implant if it [16] Carmont MR, Maffulli N. Modified percutaneous repair of ruptured Achilles
is placed where the plantar fat pad is thin. This may lead to tendon. Knee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy Official Journal of the
ESSKA 2008;16:199.
increased total cost, both because of potential for reoperation and [17] Cretnik A, Kosanovic M, Smrkolj V. Percutaneous versus open repair of the
because of the cost of the implant itself. It may also be difficult to ruptured Achilles tendon: a comparative study. American Journal of Sports
tension the repair appropriately if this technique is attempted Medicine 2005;33:1369.
[18] Krackow KA, Thomas SC, Jones LC. A new stitch for ligament-tendon fixation.
through a less invasive approach. In regards to the testing model, Brief note. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery American Volume 1986;68:764.
cyclic loading measurements were not obtained in this study and [19] Watson TW, Jurist KA, Yang KH, Shen KL. The strength of Achilles tendon
may be useful when comparing the two constructs. Further human repair: an in vitro study of the biomechanical behavior in human cadaver
tendons. Foot & Ankle International/American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle
cadaveric and clinical studies are necessary to enhance our Society [and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Society 1995;16:191.
knowledge regarding this technique. [20] Brodie M, Vollenweider L, Murphy JL, Xu F, Lyman A, Lew WD, et al. Bio-
Strengths of the study include adequate power to detect a mechanical properties of Achilles tendon repair augmented with a bioadhe-
sive-coated scaffold. Biomedical Materials (Bristol England) 2011;6:015014.
difference among the study groups. All other variables were kept as
[21] Benthien RA, Aronow MS, Doran-Diaz V, Sullivan RJ, Naujoks R, Adams DJ.
consistent as possible, including age of the donor sheep, tendon Cyclic loading of Achilles tendon repairs: a comparison of polyester and
size, and a single surgeon performing the repairs. polyblend suture. Foot & Ankle International/American Orthopaedic Foot
and Ankle Society [and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Society 2006;27:512.
Based on our study results, using the Endobutton-assisted
[22] Ortiz C, Wagner E, Mococain P, Labarca G, Keller A, Del Buono A, et al.
modified Bunnell technique has three advantages. (1) It can Biomechanical comparison of four methods of repair of the Achilles tendon:
provide stronger fixation than conventional techniques even if a laboratory study with bovine tendons. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery
there is poor quality tendon at the distal part of rupture. (2) British Volume 2012;94:663.
[23] Orishimo KF, Burstein G, Mullaney MJ, Kremenic IJ, Nesse M, McHugh MP, et al.
Concerning its higher resistance force against rupture, our Effect of knee flexion angle on Achilles tendon force and ankle joint plantar-
technique can allow early range of motion. (3) It can be easily flexion moment during passive dorsiflexion. Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery
266 G. Huri et al. / Foot and Ankle Surgery 19 (2013) 261–266
Official Publication of the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons [40] Tang KL, Thermann H, Dai G, Chen GX, Guo L, Yang L. Arthroscopically assisted
2008;34:47. percutaneous repair of fresh closed achilles tendon rupture by Kessler’s suture.
[24] Beitzel K, Obopilwe E, Chowaniec DM, Nowak MD, Hanypsiak BT, Guerra JJ, et al. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2007;35:589.
Biomechanical properties of repairs for dislocated AC joints using suture button [41] Maquirriain J. Achilles tendon rupture: avoiding tendon lengthening during
systems with integrated tendon augmentation. Knee Surgery Sports Trauma- surgical repair and rehabilitation. Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine
tology Arthroscopy Official Journal of the ESSKA 2012;20:1931. 2011;84:289.
[25] Boileau P, Old J, Gastaud O, Brassart N, Roussanne Y. All-arthroscopic Weaver– [42] Kangas J, Pajala A, Ohtonen P, Leppilahti J. Achilles tendon elongation after
Dunn–Chuinard procedure with double-button fixation for chronic acromio- rupture repair: a randomized comparison of 2 postoperative regimens. Amer-
clavicular joint dislocation. Arthroscopy the Journal of Arthroscopic & Related ican Journal of Sports Medicine 2007;35:59.
Surgery Official Publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America [43] Bhandari M, Guyatt GH, Siddiqui F, Morrow F, Busse J, Leighton RK, et al.
and the International Arthroscopy Association 2010;26:149. Treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures: a systematic overview and
[26] Chavan PR, Duquin TR, Bisson LJ. Repair of the ruptured distal biceps tendon: a metaanalysis. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 2002;190–200.
systematic review. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2008;36:1618. [44] Strauss EJ, Ishak C, Jazrawi L, Sherman O, Rosen J. Operative treatment of acute
[27] Bain GI, Prem H, Heptinstall RJ, Verhellen R, Paix D. Repair of distal biceps Achilles tendon ruptures: an institutional review of clinical outcomes. Injury
tendon rupture: a new technique using the Endobutton. Journal of Shoulder 2007;38:832.
and Elbow Surgery/American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons [et al] 2000;9:120. [45] Worth N, Ghosh S, Maffulli N. Management of acute Achilles tendon ruptures
[28] Cottom JM, Hyer CF, Philbin TM, Berlet GC. Transosseous fixation of the distal in the United Kingdom. Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery (Hong Kong)
tibiofibular syndesmosis: comparison of an interosseous suture and endobut- 2007;15:311.
ton to traditional screw fixation in 50 cases. Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery [46] Khan RJ, Fick D, Keogh A, Crawford J, Brammar T, Parker M. Treatment of acute
Official Publication of the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons achilles tendon ruptures. A meta-analysis of randomized, controlled trials.
2009;48:620. Journal of Bone And Joint Surgery American Volume 2005;87:2202.
[29] Naqvi GA, Shafqat A, Awan N. Tightrope fixation of ankle syndesmosis injuries: [47] Mukundan C, El Husseiny M, Rayan F, Salim J, Budgen A. ‘‘Mini-open’’ repair of
clinical outcome, complications and technique modification. Injury 2012;43: acute tendo Achilles ruptures – the solution? Foot and ankle surgery official
838. journal of the European Society of Foot and Ankle Surgeons 2010;16:122.
[30] Schepers T. Acute distal tibiofibular syndesmosis injury: a systematic review [48] McClelland D, Maffulli N. Percutaneous repair of ruptured Achilles tendon.
of suture-button versus syndesmotic screw repair. International Orthopaedics Journal of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh 2002;47:613.
2012;36:1199. [49] Huffard B, O’Loughlin PF, Wright T, Deland J, Kennedy JG. Achilles tendon
[31] Miyatake S, Kondo E, Tohyama H, Kitamura N, Yasuda K. Biomechanical repair: Achillon system vs. Krackow suture: an anatomic in vitro biomechani-
evaluation of a novel application of a fixation device for bone-tendon-bone cal study. Clinical biomechanics (Bristol Avon) 2008;23:1158.
graft (EndoButton CL BTB) to soft-tissue grafts in anatomic double-bundle [50] Henriquez H, Munoz R, Carcuro G, Bastias C. Is percutaneous repair better than
anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Arthroscopy the Journal of Arthro- open repair in acute Achilles tendon rupture? Clinical Orthopaedics and
scopic & Related Surgery Official Publication of the Arthroscopy Association of Related Research 2012;470:998.
North America and the International Arthroscopy Association 2010;26:1226. [51] Chiodo CP, Glazebrook M, Bluman EM, Cohen BE, Femino JE, Giza E, et al.
[32] Noh JH, Yi SR, Song SJ, Kim SW, Kim W. Comparison between hamstring Diagnosis and treatment of acute Achilles tendon rupture. Journal of the
autograft and free tendon Achilles allograft: minimum 2-year follow-up after American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons 2010;18:503.
anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using EndoButton and Intrafix. Knee [52] Khan RJ, Fick D, Brammar TJ, Crawford J, Parker MJ. Interventions for treating
Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy Official Journal of the ESSKA acute Achilles tendon ruptures. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
2011;19:816. [Online] 2004;CD003674.
[33] Fanter NJ, Davis EW, Baker Jr CL. Fixation of the Achilles tendon insertion using [53] Chan AP, Chan YY, Fong DT, Wong PY, Lam HY, Lo CK, et al. Clinical and
suture button technology. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2012;40: biomechanical outcome of minimal invasive and open repair of the Achilles
2085. tendon. Sports Medicine Arthroscopy Rehabilitation Therapy & Technology
[34] Deramo DM, White KL, Parks BG, Hinton RY. Krackow locking stitch versus SMARTT 2011;3:32.
nonlocking premanufactured loop stitch for soft-tissue fixation: a biomechan- [54] Quagliarella L, Sasanelli N, Notarnicola A, Belgiovine G, Moretti L, Moretti B.
ical study. Arthroscopy the Journal of Arthroscopic & Related Surgery Official Comparative functional analysis of two different achilles tendon surgical
Publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the Interna- repairs. Foot & Ankle International/American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle
tional Arthroscopy Association 2008;24:599. Society [and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Society 2010;31:306.
[35] Heitman DE, Ng K, Crivello KM, Gallina J. Biomechanical comparison of the [55] Wren TA, Lindsey DP, Beaupre GS, Carter DR. Effects of creep and cyclic loading
Achillon tendon repair system and the Krackow locking loop technique. Foot & on the mechanical properties and failure of human Achilles tendons. Annals of
Ankle International/American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society [and] Swiss Biomedical Engineering 2003;31:710.
Foot and Ankle Society 2011;32:879. [56] Chen TM, Rozen WM, Pan WR, Ashton MW, Richardson MD, Taylor GI. The
[36] Hong Y, Hermida L, White KL, Parks BG, Camire LM, Guyton C. Core weave arterial anatomy of the Achilles tendon: anatomical study and clinical impli-
versus Krackow technique for Achilles tendon repair: a biomechanical study. cations. Clinical Anatomy 2009;22:377.
Foot & Ankle International/American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society [57] Lanyon LE. Analysis of surface bone strain in the calcaneus of sheep during
[and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Society 2010;31:1107. normal locomotion: strain analysis of the calcaneus. Journal of Biomechanics
[37] Krackow KA. The Krackow suture: how, when, and why. Orthopedics 1973;6:41.
2008;31:931. [58] Stone KR, Bowman HF, Boland A, Steadman JR. Ligament and tendon oxygen-
[38] Labib SA, Rolf R, Dacus R, Hutton WC. The ‘‘Giftbox’’ repair of the Achilles ation measurements using polarographic oxygen sensors. Arthroscopy the
tendon: a modification of the Krackow technique. Foot & Ankle International/ Journal of Arthroscopic & Related Surgery Official Publication of the Arthroscopy
American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society [and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association
Society 2009;30:410. 1987;3:187.
[39] White KL, Camire LM, Parks BG, Corey WS, Hinton RY. Krackow locking stitch [59] Bruns J, Kampen J, Kahrs J, Plitz W. Achilles tendon rupture: experimental
versus locking premanufactured loop stitch for soft-tissue fixation: a bio- results on spontaneous repair in a sheep-model. Knee Surgery Sports Trau-
mechanical study. Arthroscopy the Journal of Arthroscopic & Related Surgery matology Arthroscopy 2000;8:364.
Official Publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the [60] Virchenko O, Fahlgren A, Rundgren M, Aspenberg P. Early Achilles tendon
International Arthroscopy Association 2010;26:1662. healing in sheep. Archives of orthopaedic, trauma surgery; 2008;128:1001.