Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/336908934
CITATIONS READS
0 2,556
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sonal Pandey Tiwari on 05 June 2020.
Abstract Central India has a rich tradition of vernacular architecture. The paper
aims to study the transformation in vernacular architecture of the Baiga tribe. The
objective is to study the materials, construction techniques and the built forms. The
methodology includes a literature review and an analysis of case studies of vernacu-
lar architecture of the Baiga tribe. The discussion and findings reveal peoples’ aspi-
rations to be modern have altered their lifestyle. These socio-cultural conditions
have resulted in the different spatial organization of settlements; new building mate-
rials and construction techniques which have all impacted on the resultant built
forms. Conclusions include that lessons of vernacular architecture are of benefit if
they are integrated with contemporary practices through innovative and holistic
design approach. The suggestions need to be incorporated in the government poli-
cies so as to retain or conserve the unique characteristics of vernacular heritage.
10.1 Introduction
India is a land of diversity which can be broadly grouped into urban, rural and tribal
populations. People from rural and tribal areas are migrating to the cities in search
of jobs and better standards of living. Exposure to an urban lifestyle brings with it
aspirations to be modern. On the whole the modern lifestyle does not typically
match traditional ways of living. Therefore aspirations of modernity have resulted
in significant transformation of settlements, built forms and public spaces.
Pradhan Mantri Awas Yogana (PMAY)- Gramin (rural) is a rural housing pro-
gram based on the Government’s commitment to provide “Housing for All” via this
S. Patidar
Vinyas, Bhopal, India
B. Raghuwanshi (*) · S. Tiwari (*)
School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal, India
e-mail: brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in; sonal@spabhopal.ac.in
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
108 S. Patidar et al.
scheme by 2022. It aims at providing a pucca (permanent) house, with basic ameni-
ties, to all houseless community members as well as those households living in
kutcha (temporary) and dilapidated houses, with an interest subsidy of 6.5% on
housing loans [1].
Madhya Pradesh is a centrally located state in India. It has a rich biodiversity of
flora and fauna. The state is known for its forty-six tribes. The population of sched-
uled tribals (ST) is 21.1% of the state population (15.31 million out of 72.62 mil-
lion), according to the 2011 Census [2]. Some of the main tribes here are Baiga,
Gond, Bhil, Bharia, Saharia and Korku. Total population of Scheduled Tribes (ST)
8.6% (10, 42, 81,034) of the population of the country is seven-hundred and five [2].
Article 366 (25) says: “Scheduled Tribes means such tribes or tribal communities as
are deemed under Article 342 to be scheduled tribes for this constitution” [3]. These
tribes are indigenous and untouched by the waves of civilization and demon-
strate cultural evolution [4]. Tribal communities live in the forest and are isolated
from the cities. Typical characteristics of their built forms may be easily identified,
due to the strength of their customs and attitude, that they hardly accept things from
outside world. Thus some of the finest examples of vernacular architecture are still
present in the tribal areas [5]. Vernacular architecture reflects the environment, cul-
ture and historical context in which it exists. Vernacular forms are considered primi-
tive and unrefined forms in design, not commonly seen as architecture, yet these
primitive forms comprise a large percentage of the worlds built environment [6]. It
is people and place specific.
The Baiga tribe are of Dravidian origin. They are forest dwellers from Central India,
states of Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand. The name
Baiga means a sorcerer or medicine-man [7]. They have a vast knowledge of medic-
inal plants and folklore. To conserve this valuable traditional and cultural knowl-
edge involves a means of integrating it with modern life. These tribal communities
have stagnant population growth, low levels of literacy and access to high yield
agricultural technologies. This means they are quite impoverished. Seventy-five
such groups across eighteen States and one in Union Territory have been identified
and categorized as Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTGs) by Government
of India in 2006 [8]. Official recommendations were made in 2015 for growth and
development of these tribes, focussed on improvements to housing and habitat, and
conservation of culture. Each State and Union Territory are required to prepare a
“Conservation-cum-Development (CCD) Plan” for each Particularly Vulnerable
Tribal Group (PVTGs) of their state [8].
The dwellings of the Baiga are part of their habitat which continues to evolve
with the dynamic needs of the family. Today Baiga lifestyles have completely
changed, as a result their settlements have also continued to transform (Figs. 10.1
and 10.2). They traditionally practiced of transient forms of cultivation, whereby it
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 109
Fig. 10.1 Change in lifestyle: Baiga couple from 2005 to 2015. (Source: Author)
is an agricultural system in which plots of land are cultivated temporarily then aban-
doned to revert to their natural vegetation while the cultivator moves on to another
plot [9]. “Geza Rohen once described primitive man as ‘free, untrammelled and
truly self reliant’ in comparison with the member of more organized societies”. In
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
110 S. Patidar et al.
The paper aims to study the transformation in vernacular architecture of the Baiga
tribe of Central India. The objective is to study the materials, construction tech-
niques and built forms; and how some of these unique characteristics may be
retained or conserved.
10.4 Methodology
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 111
10.5.1 Settlement
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
112 S. Patidar et al.
The dwellings are usually rectangular in shape with the verandah (semi-covered
space) in the centre and rooms arranged around it. There is a small pigsty as well
as open space in the centre that divides the dwelling and the pigsty (Fig. 10.5a). The
built form fulfills basic needs. It is decorated with earthen colours and artwork pro-
viding an attractive aesthetic (Fig. 10.5b). As the family expanded, dwellings
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 113
Fig. 10.5a Baiga
dwelling, 2005. (Source:
Author)
became compact with the courtyard in the centre and rooms arranged around it. The
space segregation was achieved with partition walls which resulted into number of
rooms. The pigsty was attached to the backside of the dwelling (Fig. 10.5c).
Domestic animals like pigs, goats, dogs and hens were part of their lives which is
slowly disappearing.
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
114 S. Patidar et al.
Fig. 10.5c Side elevations Baiga dwelling, 2015, Typology 2. (Source: Author)
10.5.3 Foundation
10.5.4 Flooring
Flooring was typically rammed earth with a cow dung layer applied over the floor.
During festivals celebratory floral designs patterns were made and decorated with
natural colours for the floors. These have been replaced by industrial products such
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 115
10.5.5 Walls
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
116 S. Patidar et al.
10.5.6 Roofs
Roof coverings originally consisted of thatch tied/braced with bamboo or fine tim-
ber branches (Fig. 10.7a). Hand-made tiles were subsequently developed and had
evocative individuality in their uneven coverage as well as texture which brought
about a unique aesthetic quality (Fig. 10.7b). Wooden trusses supported these tiled
covered roofs. Factory-made moulded terracotta tiles eventually replaced the hand-
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 117
10.5.7 Doors
The dwellings originally had a single unprotected opening for the doorway.
Therefore at night, in order to protect themselves from wild animals, a woven mat-
ting was placed in front of the opening as a make shift obstruction (Fig. 10.8a).
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
118 S. Patidar et al.
Fig. 10.7b Hand-made
terracotta tiles. (Source:
Author)
Given there were no fixed doors in the original designs, the changing needs of pro-
tection of food stuffs and people meant doors were required specifically to store
grains. Therefore the timber shutter doors were introduced and could be bolted for
additional protection, whenever needed (Fig. 10.8b). A modified version consisted
of a battened and braced door (Fig. 10.8c). Plastic panel doors also replaced the
wooden doors and braced doors over time (Fig. 10.8d). Plastic doors were compro-
mised in terms of strength as well as aesthetics but are more cost effective.
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 119
10.5.8 Windows
The dwellings traditionally did not have windows. There is a gap between the walls
and roof which permits ventilation. However today windows are created with mod-
ern materials such as iron or aluminum grills (Fig. 10.9d).
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
120 S. Patidar et al.
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 121
10.5.9 Plaster
Plaster consisted of cow dung applied to wattle and daub, cob walls (Fig. 10.9a).
This gave uniformity to the wall base. Earthen colours such as yellow ochre, red and
white ochres bring a distinctive character to the built form (Fig. 10.9b). Lime plaster
replaced the cow dung which then transitioned to a cement plaster (Fig. 10.9c).
Arguably this choice of exterior render resulted in a more monotonous form of
dwelling (Fig. 10.9d). Flexibility in decoration was available in cow dung lay-
ered walls.
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
122 S. Patidar et al.
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 123
10.5.11 Ornamentation
Cow dung render did not equate to any ornamentation on the compound walls
(Fig. 10.9a). Naturally coloured mud render allowed for the making of creative
floral design, motifs and art forms which added to the aesthetic appearance of the
walls (Fig. 10.9b). The ornamentation was usually a female activity. Lime plaster
was the next iteration of the render, with the use of oil or acrylic paints for more
elaborate decorations (Figs. 10.9c and 10.9d). The integrity of these traditional arti-
facts is in their colourful contribution to the built environment.
Art is an intrinsic part of life of individual, community, habitat, and as a ritual in
this cultural context [10].
10.6 Discussion
Tribal culture is a living world heritage too precious to be lost. Tribal habitat embod-
ies principles living in balance and in harmony with the natural environment.
Models of sustainable development are therefore a process, a way of living.
This housing is a way of life, and not a model for mass production nor through
forms of legislation [10]. Pucca (permanent) houses constructed under Pradhan
Mantri Awas Yogana (PMAY)- Gramin (rural) with facilities similar to sanitary, gas
and electricity connections, potable water are changing the rural landscape at a very
fast pace [1]. The government is trying to replace kutcha (temporary) with pucca
(permanent) structures.
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
124 S. Patidar et al.
10.7 Findings
The new housing provided by Pradhan Mantri Awas Yogana- Gramin (rural) does
not address the social and the cultural needs of the people in the same ways as the
traditional dwellings. Sometimes unknowingly, these indigenous tribal groups have
become passive recipients to the transformation. Therefore the concept of transfor-
mation can be understood in terms of power relations. Tribes were self reliant,
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
10 Transformation in Vernacular Architecture of Baiga Tribe of Central India 125
10.8 Conclusion
Acknowledgement We are thankful to Ar. Shikha Patidar of her survey of Baiga Chak in 2005.
Study conducted in Keonchi in 2015 was a part of Vernacular studio of 3rd semester B.Arch
(2014–2019) at School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal. We are thankful to HOD Architecture
Dr Rachna Khare, studio coordinator Dr. Ram Sateesh and students for their drawings and photo-
graphs. We are thankful to Tribal Research Institute, Indira Gandhi Rashtriya Manav Sanghralya
(IGRMS) and Bharat Bhawan from Bhopal for sharing their research and publications. Lastly to
Mr. Abid Baig for drafting and composition. We are grateful to the people of Baiga Chak and
Keonchi for their love and cooperation.
References
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
126 S. Patidar et al.
7. Elvin, V.: The Baiga. Gyan Publishing House, New Delhi, India (2007).
8. Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India, Revised Scheme of “Development of
Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs)”. Homepage, https://tribal.nic.in/writeread-
data/Schemes/4-5NGORevisedScheme.pdf. Annex-I Names of the Particularly Vulnerable
Tribal Groups (PVTGs) - State / UT wise, List_of_Scheduled_Tribes_in_India, last accessed
2018/11/03
9. Shifting Cultivation, Homepage. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shifting_cultivation, last
accessed on 2019/01/30.
10. Souza, R.: Warli House and Habitat1. Congress of Traditional Sciences and Technologies of
India at IIT Powai, Bombay, 28 Nov-3 Dec1993.
11. Patel, S.: Housing for All by 2022 Assignment Delivered, Accountability Nil. Economic &
Political Weekly, 51 (10), 38–42, (2016).
12. Ramanujam, R.: Forest Rights in Baiga Chak, Madhya Pradesh. Economic & Political Weekly,
52 (25 & 26), 47–50, (2017).
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
Chapter 11
Meaning, Time, Communication:
Reflecting on the “Aceh Method”
and Vernacular
Julie Nichols and Darren Fong
Abstract The “Aceh Method” has been coined here to contemplate a form of rep-
resenting vernacular house typologies and to provide another “way of seeing”. Ways
of seeing and understanding vernacular knowledge centred on the production of
built form and their related socio-cultural conditions are revisited with this research
through a multimodal platform of the “Aceh Method”. This method was devised to
record, interpret and connect to the rich histories of vernacular architectural produc-
tion in Indonesia critiqued through analogue and digital means. Rather than digging
for additional remains of Acehnese architectural knowledge in the conventional
sense of writing history, this proposal contributes to ways of understanding past
built environments through a value analysis of immersive drawing and digital cap-
ture. In promoting a field of knowledge based on regional conditions, via onsite
cultural immersion with the subjects and artefacts, this research will disseminate to
the world value systems and technologies embedded in Acehnese vernacular heri-
tage. Tackling challenges of natural disasters in Aceh, the “Aceh Method’s” repre-
sentation techniques engaging socio-cultural conditions provides educational,
intellectual and practical tools to meet communities’ future built environment
aspirations.
J. Nichols (*)
School of Art, Architecture and Design, Vernacular Knowledge Research Group,
University of South Australia, Adelaide, SA, Australia
e-mail: Julie.nichols@unisa.edu.au
D. Fong
Vernacular Knowledge Research Group, University of South Australia,
Adelaide, SA, Australia
brishbhanlali@spabhopal.ac.in
View publication stats