You are on page 1of 6

Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, April 2020, Vol. 11, No.

04  361

Effect of Sensory Motor Integration Technique on


Motor Dysfunction in Guillain-Barre Syndrome.

Sanket R. Thorat1, G. Varadhrajulu2, Suraj B. Kanase3


1
Intern, 2Dean, 3Associate Professor, Department of Neurosciences, Faculty of Physiotherapy,
Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed to be University, Karad, Maharashtra, India

Abstract
Background: Guillian-Barre syndrome (GBS) is an autoimmune disorder that affects motor as well as
sensory nerves. There is rapidly progressing muscle weakness typically pyramidal in distribution. Autonomic
nervous system is also involved in this condition. The recovery is slow thus physical therapy along with
medical management plays an important role. Sensory motor integration is a relationship between various
sensory inputs to produce desired motor response.

Objectives: Objectives of the study were to determine the effect of Sensory Motor Integration Technique On
Motor Dysfunction in GBS and to reduce the recovery time.

Material and Method: In this experimental study, 28 subjects with GBS were assessed with GBS disability
scale and subjects were given Sensory Motor Integration Technique along with medical treatment and other
therapies.

Results: Statistical analysis was done of GBS disability scalein 28 subjects in which it was seen that post
treatment there was very significant effect of Sensory Integration Technique. (p value- 0.002)

Conclusion: The current study concluded that there is a significant effect ofSensory Motor Integration
Technique On Motor Dysfunction in Guillain-Barre Syndrome. There was significant decrease in disability
in GBS patients after the intervention thus Alternate Hypothesis accepted.

Keywords:  GBS, Sensory Motor Integration, Physical Therapy, GBS disability scale, Disability.

Introduction paralysis and death.3 Acute inflammatory demyelinating


polyradiculoneuropathy (AIDP) is the most common
Guillian-Barre syndrome (GBS) is an autoimmune
type of GBS which primarily causes demyelination
disorder which involves peripheral nervous system and
with varing degrees of secondary axonal damage. Acute
is acute in onset.1 GBS is rapidly progressing motor
motor axonal neuropathy (AMAN) is the next most
disorder associated with absent reflexes.2 GBS varies in
common type of GBS which is primary considered
severity and in its severest form, could lead to respiratory
as axonal disorder affecting just the motor nerves and
causing motor symptoms.4 Axonal variants that involve
both sensory and motor symptoms are not seen much.4

It has shown that, with age, incidence of GBS could


Corresponding Author:
be more frequent and it is predominantly most common
Dr. Suraj B. Kanase
in males but some literature suggest that it is common in
Faculty of Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical
females.2,5
Sciences Deemed to be University, Karad, Maharashtra,
India GBS is caused due to a viral or an bacterial infection,
e-mail: drsurajkanase7@rediffmail.com may be precipitated by a vaccination, could be caused
362  Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, April 2020, Vol. 11, No. 04
after a major surgery due to several reasons or caused Sensory integration (SI) is the ability to organize
by prolonged use of several drugs such as zimelidine.5 sensory information to make an adaptive response.10
Studies have shown that Campylobacter jejuni, Epstein Sensory input from the environment and from the
Bar virus, Mycoplasma pneumonia and Cytomegalovirus body provides information to the brain. The brain then
are the most frequent causative factors.2,5 organizes, integrates, synthesizes and processes this
information to obtain appropriate response to stimuli.
The onset of the disease starts with sensory symptoms The processing of information allows individuals to
in the distal extremities followed by rapidly progressive receive sensory inputs and respond automatically,
distal weakness that spreads proximally.2 The weakness efficiently and comfortably to it.10
seen GBS is typically pyramidal in distribution, for
example, ankle dorsiflexion and knee and hip flexion are There exists a relationship between motor responses,
often severely affected and the weakness in the arms is sensory input and normal sensorimotor development
usually more severe in shoulder abduction and elbow which will be helpful for providing a treatment approach
extension.2 Sensory symptoms commonly seen although in GBS patients.
minor and include loss of vibration and proprioception.
Symptoms such as areflexia, myalgia, sphincter It has been noted that sensory system has facilitatory
disturbances and autonomic disturbances are commonly or inhibitory influences on the motor systems. Motor
seen in GBS.5 system needs inputs from various sensory systems.
Research shows that, sensory integration techniques
GBS is a monophasic disease. The neuropathy stimulates cutaneous sensations, proprioceptors, visual
typically begins 7–10 days after any triggering infection component to produce the desired motor response.
with weakness reaching its most severity in 4 weeks
followed by a plateau phase and then followed by a Aim and Objectives:
recovery phase. 60% of patients are able to walk unaided Aim: To find the effect of Sensory Motor Integration
by 12 months and the some patients are have various Technique On Motor Dysfunction in Guillain-Barre
degrees of residual symptoms.6 Mortality rate in GBS is Syndrome.
between 5 and 10 percent and the major causes of death
include infection, emboli and autonomic instability.2,7 Objectives:

GBS is medically managed by plasmaphereis, • To determine Effect of Sensory Motor Integration


steroid therapy and IgG 5 but supportive management has Technique On Motor Dysfunction in Guillain-Barre
been more effective in improving mortality in patients Syndrome.
with GBS with good ICU care and modern method of • To reduce the recovery time and make patient
ventilation. Passive movement of the extremities and ambulatory while studying the effect of sensory
active physiotherapy including chest physiotherapy motor integration technique along with other
once the initial acute stage commences, is seen to therapies given.
very beneficial.2 Since much of the damage to nerves
occurs early in the course of the disease it may be more Materials and Methodology
effective to look at treatments capable of improving • Type of study- Experimental study
nerve regrowth and regeneration with medical drugs as
well as newer physiotherapy management approaches. • Study Design-Pre-test and post test
Increased knowledge of GBS and its pathophysiology • Place of Study-Krishna hospital, Karad
may form a base for new, targeted and personalized
treatments that hopefully will improve the outcome for • Sample formula – n= 4 X SD2/(X€)2
the patients.8 • Sample size- supposed to be 30

Katz defines sensory integration as “an innate • Sampling Method-Consecutive sampling


neurobiological process in which the brain integrates • Study duration- 6 months
and interprets sensory stimuli in the environment”9
Materials Required:
• GBS disability scale.
Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, April 2020, Vol. 11, No. 04  363
Selection Criteria: • Exercise session were given for 30-45 minwith rest
intervals for 4 days/week for a duration of 8-10
Inclusion Criteria:
weeks.
• Both Male and Female
• Sensory Motor Integration techniques were given
• Have neurological impairment secondary to GBS to these patients which included vestibular based
• Unable to ambulate more than 200 feet without activities including swiss ball and wobble board
assistive devices exercises along with assisstance, proprioception
exercises that included weight bearing with the help
• Able and willing to comply with the protocol of closed kinematic chain exercises such as mini
Exclusion Criteria: squats by holding the bar with assisstance and wall
pushups, stretching of major muscle groups was
• Recent of History of seizures also done, tactile stimulaton included prehension by
• Evidence of upper motor neuron involvement holding objects with different surface designs such
as soft ball and asking the patient to feel the pressure
• Any medical condition, including psychiatric
and use of ADL table, co ordination activities
disease, which would interfere with the interpretation
included throwing the ball, catching the ball, hitting
of the study monitors.
the ball, etc and cobmination of all these exercises
• Clinically diagnosed diabetic neuropathic were given to the patient along with visual and
individuals. auditory cues.
Outcome measures: Gullian Barre Syndrome • After the intended duration of treatment the efficacy
Disability scale of the treatment protocol in both the groups were
compared.
Procedure: Individuals with GBS were selected
on basis of inclusion and exclusion criteria. Informed • Post test assessment was taken after 4 weeks by
consent was taken from the patients. Subjects were using GBS disability scale.
assessed before starting with the protocol. Subjects will • Pre-test and Post-test, the data collection sheets
be explained about the procedure of the study. were filled and assessed.
• Subjects were selected through consecutive • Statistical analysis was done using appropriate
sampling. biostatistical tools.
• Pre test assessement was taken using GBS disability
scale.

Findings:

Table 1: Age Distribution

Study Variables N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation


Age (in Years) 28 18 40 29.71 6.26

Interpretation: Table 1 represent quantitative Table 2: Gender Wise Distribution of Study


study variables distribution among study population. Population.
Here minimum age of participants was 18 years and
maximum age of was 40 years, also average age of Gender Frequency Percent
29.71±6.26. M 15 54%
F 13 46%
Total 28 100%
364  Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, April 2020, Vol. 11, No. 04
Interpretation: Out of 28(100%) study participants 15(54%) were males and 13(46%) were females. [Seen in
Table 2]

Table 3: Gullian Barre Syndrome Disability scale

Sr.No. Parameter Pre-test Post-test t value p value Inference


1. GBS Disability Scale 3.10±1.13 2.07±1.27 3.213 <0.002 Very Significant

Result living. Sensory symptoms commonly seen include loss


of vibration and proprioception which play an important
Within the group statistical analysis (Table 3) shows
role in coordination and activation of neuromuscular
that there was significant decrease in GBS diability after
system. Symptoms such as areflexia, myalgia, sphincter
the intervention. The mean pre intervention was 3.10 ±
disturbances and autonomic disturbances were also seen
1.13 which significantly decreased to 2.07± 1.27 post
in severe cases of GBS.5
intervention.
Winer JB also suggests that 60% of patients are able
Discussion to walk unaided by 12 months and the some patients
This study was conducted to study the effect are have various degrees of residual symptoms.6 The
of Sensory Motor Integration Technique on Motor objective of this study was to enhance the recovery with
Dysfunction In Guillain-Barre Syndrome. Guillian-Barre less time and make patient ambulatory with sensory
syndrome (GBS) is an rapidly progressing autoimmune motor integration along with other therapies employed.
motor disorder which is acute in onset and which involves
Ayres studied the relationship between motor
involvement of peripheral nervous system. GBS varies
responses, sensory input and normal sensorimotor
in its severity, there are patients with mild to moderate
development. She defined sensory integration (SI) as
residual symptoms and in its severest form, it could
the ability to organize sensory information to make an
lead to respiratory paralysis and death.3 Griffin JW et al.
adaptive response. Sensory integration (SI) is a term
suggests that there are various types of GBS including
that states combination of various sensory inputs to
acute motor axonal neuropathy (AMAN) which is one
get the desired motor response.5 Katz defines sensory
of the most common type of GBS-primary considered
integration as “an innate neurobiological process in
as axonal disorder affecting just the motor nerves and
which the brain integrates and interprets sensory stimuli
causing motor symptoms.4 The treatment approaches
in the environment”9
used in this study will be more beneficial to such patients.
However the incidence of GBS is 1 in 100,000, thus due The main aim of this study was to see the effectiveness
to the limitations faced this study focuses on GBS as of sensory motor integration technique on motor
a broad terminology and includes patients diagnosed dysfunction in Guillain-Barre Syndrome. Objectives of
with GBS as a diagnosis. The causative factors of GBS the study were to determine the effect of sensory motor
in these patients were not known but some presented a integration technique on motor dysfunction in guillain-
history of previous infection. barre syndrome and to reduce the recovery time and
make patient ambulatory with sensory motor integration
The onset of the disease starts with sensory
technique along with other therapies already given.
symptoms in the distal extremities followed by rapidly
progressive distal weakness that spreads proximally. 30 individuals were selected over a period of 6
Winer JB states that the weakness seen GBS is typically months and they participated in the study out of which
pyramidal in distribution. Ankle dorsiflexion and knee all individuals fulfilled the selection criteria but 28
and hip flexion are often severely affected and the individuals continued their participation in the study
weakness in the arms is usually more severe in shoulder for 8 weeks. Subjects were screened by Gullian Barre
abduction and elbow extension. This in turn affect the Syndrome disability scale pre-test. Out of 28 individuals
balance, posture and gait in these patients leading to 15 were males and 13 were females. Male predominance
no or less motor control required for activities of daily was seen. A study titled “Population incidence of
Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, April 2020, Vol. 11, No. 04  365
Guillain-Barré syndrome: a systematic review and meta- than pre-intervention. Patients were able to do activities
analysis, ” by J. J. Sejvar et al. supports this difference of daily living well due to the therapies employed.
noted, by suggesting that GBS is more common in male
population.11 Conclusion
Treatment included vestibular based activities This study found out that there is a significant effect
which were carried out with movable surfaces like of Sensory Motor Integration Technique On Motor
swiss ball or tilt board activities to stimulate the patient Dysfunction In Guillain-Barre Syndrome. There was
affected with GBS and improve their righting reactions, significant decrease in disability in GBS patients after
equilibrium and autonomic responses. These exercises the intervention.
helped in improving balance, postural control, muscle Conflict of Interest: There is no conflict of interest
tone and co activation of different muscle groups. They concerning the content of the study.
also promoted self control and security with movement.5
Also tactile based activities helped to facilitate body Source of Funding: This study was funded by
image awareness and included deep or light pressure Krishna institute of medical sciences deemed to be
input and self controlled tactile stimulation by university karad.
prehension exercises and use of objects with various
surface modifications. Various weight bearing activities Ethical Clearance: The study was approved by the
such as CKC exercises which included mini squats and institutional ethics committee of KIMSDU.
wall pushups followed by stretching of major muscle
groups stimulated proprioception and improved co
References
activation of muscle groups and body perception. Co- 1. Ted M. Burns, M D.Guillain Barre Syndrome.
ordination activities included kicking the ball, catching Semin Neurol 2008; 28:152-167.
ball, hitting a ball with a plastic bat and writing etc which 2. Winer JB. An update in guillain-barré syndrome.
incorporated timing of responses, pairing of vision with Autoimmune Dis. 2014; 2014:793024.
motor outcomes as well as muscle activation patterns doi:10.1155/2014/793024.
also improved. All sensory integration techniques were
3. Haymaker WKJ, The Landry-Guillain-Barré
combined and incorporated and the desired results were
syndrome: a clinicopathologicic report of fifty fatal
obtained.5 Task related training plays an important role
cases and a critique of the literature. Medicine.
in improving lower limb control which in turn enhances
1949; 28:59–141.
walking performances12.
4. Griffin JW, Li CY, Ho TW, et al. Guillain-Barré
The treatment sessions were carried out for 4 days syndrome in northern China: The spectrum of
per week for 8 weeks. Post 8 weeks Gullian Barre neuropathological changes in clinically defined
Syndrome disability scale was again assessed among cases. Brain,1995;118(3):577–595.
the subjects. Outcome measures showed significant 5. Glady Samuel Raj. Common Approaches in
difference among disability status. This was confirmed Neurorehabilitation In: Glady Samuel Raj. Glady
using statistical analysis by using ‘Paired t- test’ for Samuel Raj, 1st edn. New Delhi:Jaypee Brothers
within group comparison. Medical Publishers; 2006;296-98.
Within the group comparison, the Gullian Barre 6. Winer JB, Hughes RAC, Osmond C. A prospective
Syndrome disability status pre treatment was 3.10±1.13 study of acute idiopathic neuropathy, I. Clinical
which changed to 2.07±1.27 (P value <0.0002)considered features and their prognostic value. Journal
very significant which showed small but significant of Neurology Neurosurgery & Psychiatry,
improvement in GBS patients. According to mean GBS 1988;51(5):605–612.
disability score, pre intervention the patients were able 7. Souayah N, Nasar A, Suri MFK, Qureshi AI.
to walk 10 meters across in an open space with help or National trends in hospital outcomes among patients
assistance and after the treatment session which patients with Guillain-é syndrome requiring mechanical
were able to walk 10 meters or more without assistance ventilation. Journal of Clinical Neuromuscular
in less period of time. Myalgia was also considerably Disease. 2008;10(1):24–28.
reduced and General Health of individuals was better 8. Doets, Alex Y, Jacobs, Bart C, van Doorn, Pieter
366  Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, April 2020, Vol. 11, No. 04
A. Advances in management of Guillain–Barré Front Pediatr.30 Mar 2017;(5):57doi:10.3389/
syndrome. Current Opinion in Neurology: October fped.2017.00,057.
2018;31(5) :541–550. 11. J. J. Sejvar, A. L. Baughman, M. Wise and O. W.
9. Young SN, Furgal K, Effectiveness and Implication Morgan, “Population incidence of Guillain-Barré
of Sensory Integration Therapy on School syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis,”
Performance of Children with Learning Disabilities. Neuroepidemiology, 2011;36 (2):123–133.
Int J Neurorehabilitation .29 Feb 2016;3:198. 12. Suraj Bhimarao Kanase G. Varadharajulu, Effect
10. Jorquera-Cabrera S, Romero-Ayuso D, Rodriguez- of Task Related Training versus Conventional
Gil G, Triviño-Juárez JM. Assessment of Sensory Training on Walking Performances in Post Stroke
Processing Characteristics in Children between Patients. International Journal of Science and
3 and 11 Years Old: A Systematic Review. Research (IJSR), Volume 3 Issue 11, November
2014.

You might also like