Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/326618496
CITATIONS READS
0 17
5 authors, including:
Lin Wang
Southwest Jiaotong University
8 PUBLICATIONS 10 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Lin Wang on 03 August 2018.
A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Pigging operations of natural gas transmission pipelines for cleaning, swabbing and batching inhibition become
Natural gas pipeline a regular industry procedure, and that could help to maintain the integrity and optimum efficiency of the pi-
Pigging operations peline and safeguard both the environment and the assets of the pipeline owner. However, unreasonable controls
Fluid-structure interaction of pigging parameters including pressure, pig speed, period, etc. may induce harmful vibrations or even struc-
Vibration response
tural damage, especially for the aerial crossing segment. In this paper, a dynamic model capable of describing
Bifurcations
flow characteristics of accumulations driven by pigs and fluid-structure interactions involving fluid pressure,
centrifugal force and Coriolis force is established to investigate dynamic behaviors of an aerial crossing pipe
during pigging operations. The motion equation is solved using finite element method. Experimental results are
used to validate the motion equation of pipes conveying two-phase flow. A lot of numerical simulations of
dynamic responses under different boundary conditions and operating parameters are performed, and some
interesting and sometimes unexpected results are shown. Finally, the effects of boundary conditions and oper-
ating parameters on dynamic characteristics are discussed. This study is helpful for controlling harmful vibration
responses of natural gas pipeline under pigging operations and promoting the safety of pigging procedures.
1. Introduction crossing pipelines which are constructed when the pipeline route spans
rivers, roads, railways and other obstacles.
Natural gas transmission pipelines are vital energy artery for in- The instability phenomenon of pipes conveying fluid have received
dustrial development and the people's livelihood. In order to maintain considerable attention and hundreds of relative studies are reported
the product quality and the integrity and optimum efficiency of the over the past 40 years, and the instability behaviors of pipes subjected
transportation system and safeguard both the environment and the to single-phase flows is now reasonably well understood. However, the
assets of the pipeline owner, pigging operations are regularly im- dynamic behaviors of pipes conveying two-phase flow are difficult to
plemented for long-distance gas pipeline to clean any deposits inside, predict due to complex characteristics of gas-liquid two-phase flow
such as condensate, water, rust or other solid particles that are often [4,5] and fluid-structure interactions [6–8]. A number of studies were
produced with the natural gas [1]. performed to investigate the vibrations of tube bundles in two-phase
The high pressure gas from upstream drives pigs to push deposits cross-flow [9–13], and these work were largely related to nuclear steam
accumulating to form a liquid/solid plug during pigging operations. generators. Some studies on the vibration behavior of flexible cylinders
The deposits flowing through the pipeline can be considered as a two- subjected to external axial two-phase flow were undertaken from 1970s
phase flow phenomenon [2]. If the operating conditions involving plug for the development of nuclear fuels for boiling water reactors (BWR)
length which is related to yields of deposits and pigging periods, fluid [14–16]. Particularly, a few theoretical models were developed to in-
density depending on deposit species, pig speed and operating pressure vestigate internal multi-phase flow induced vibration problems. How-
are not controlled reasonably, the pigging operations would cause the ever, these models were established under certain conditions and ig-
risk of piping instability even damage [3], especially for the aerial nored some important factors (operating pressure, transitional velocity,
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: lincw_wang@qq.com (L. Wang).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpvp.2018.07.011
Received 9 April 2018; Received in revised form 15 July 2018; Accepted 24 July 2018
Available online 25 July 2018
0308-0161/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
Le Le
etc.), thus not available for analyzing the dynamic characteristics of
aerial-crossing pipeline under pigging operations [17–23]. Meanwhile, Ce = ∫ N TCSe Ndx + 2∫ N′T [MGe (x, t ) VGe (x, t )
0 0
a better understanding of dynamic behaviors of aerial-crossing pipe-
lines under pigging operations is generally required for pipe structural ⎤
+ MDe (x , t ) VDe (x , t ) ⎥ Ndx
stability and operation safety. (4)
⎦
In this work, a dynamic model capable of describing dynamics be-
haviors of an aerial crossing gas pipeline under pigging operations is Le Le
established, which includes a dynamic model for the fluid conveying Ke = ∫ BTEI Bdx + ∫ BT [P (x, t ) AF − TN (x, t )] Ndx
pipes and pigging model for flow characteristics during pigging op- 0 0
Le
erations. The dynamic model is adopted for the aerial crossing pipe T 2 2
performed to validate the dynamic model and solution methods in this Pe = ∫ [MGe (x, t ) + MDe (x, t ) + m] N Tdx
paper. And then the effects of operating conditions of pigging proce- 0 (6)
dures on dynamic characteristics are evaluated and analyzed. where N and B denote shape function and strain matrices. MGe , VGe , MDe
and VDe are functions in the local coordinate for mass-per-unit-length
and flow velocities of gas and liquid.
2. Modeling approach
2.2. Pigging model
2.1. Motion equation of pipes conveying two-phase flow
For describing major characteristics of pigging phenomenon as
Considering that the different phases have different densities and
shown in Fig. 1, plug zone driven by a pig is considered as a moving
flow velocities, each of the phases is considered to create its own
control volume, and its volume and velocity are almost constant in
Coriolis and centrifugal forces. In addition, the fluid pressure P (x , t ) ,
special pipe section. Ignoring the quality of the pig, the force balance on
axial tension of pipe TN (x , t ) , mass-per-unit-length of gas and dense
the plug formed of liquid/solid accumulations can be expressed as
phase MG (x , t ) and MD (x , t ) , gas and dense phase velocities VG (x , t ) and
VD (x , t ) , lateral displacement u (x , t ) are varying with time and position dVpig d 2
m plug = π ⎛ ⎞ ΔP − m plug g sinθ − Fd
(t is time and x is the coordinate along the centerline of the pipe). The dt ⎝2⎠ (7)
motion equation [24] for a pipe conveying two-phase flow is expressed
as follows: where Fd is drag force of the plug, g is gravitational acceleration,
ΔP = Pup − Pdown is differential pressure between upstream and down-
∂ 4u ∂ ⎡ ∂u stream of the plug, Pup and Pdown are the pressure of upstream and
EI + (P (x , t ) AF − TN (x , t )) ⎤ downstream.
∂x 4 ∂x ⎣ ∂x ⎦
∂ 2u The mass of the accumulation plug m plug is
+ [MG (x , t ) VG2 (x , t ) + MD (x , t ) VD2 (x , t )]
∂x 2 d 2
287
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
288
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
Fig. 3. Comparison of simulation and experimental results of dynamic response: (a) measure point D1, (b) measure point D2 and (c) measure point D3
(VSG = 1.39 m/s, VSL = 0.29 m/s).
transmission pipeline involve condensate, water, rust, foam debris and extreme values of vibration displacements under different parameters,
other solid particles. The types of accumulations depend on gas sources, and that can describe the vibration characteristics under different
pre-treatment process and operating conditions. To analyze dynamic conditions. As shown in Figs. 5 and 6, Dmax increases gradually with
behaviors of the aerial-crossing pipe with different deposits, dynamic fluid density increasing, but the Amax increase intensely after the fluid
behaviors with different fluid densities are simulated. density reaches 3000 kg/m3 and 1500 kg/m3 when the boundary con-
Fig. 4 presents dynamic responses of the midpoint on the pipe under ditions are Fix-Fix and Fix-Pin respectively. It indicates that higher fluid
pigging operations, and the important characteristics including the density is easier to induce the divergence of vibration amplitudes even
static equilibrium position (Dequ), maximum load deflection (maximum when fluid velocity is small, because the gravitational load, centrifugal
displacement during the plug passing, Dmax) and maximum vibration force and Coriolis force are increasing with fluid density. Therefore, the
amplitude (maximum vibration amplitude after the plug leaves, Amax) controls of the accumulation types and heavy component content in the
are marked. Fig. 5 and Fig. 6 present bifurcation diagrams for three pipe are essential for pigging operations.
positions. In the bifurcation diagrams, the data points represent the
Fig. 4. Dynamic response of the midpoint with different fluid densities, Vpig = 5.5 m/s, Lplug = 6.7 m and Pop = 3 MPa, boundary condition: (a) Fix-Fix; (b) Fix-Pin.
289
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
Fig. 5. Bifurcation diagrams for three positions of a system defined by Vpig = 5.5 m/s, Lplug = 6.7 m and Pop = 3 MPa as ρplug is varied, constraint condition: Fix-Fix,
(a) 1/4; (b) 1/2; (c) 3/4.
Fig. 6. Bifurcation diagrams for three positions of a system defined by Vpig = 5.5 m/s, Lplug = 6.7 m and Pop = 3 MPa as ρplug is varied, constraint condition: Fix-Pin,
(a) 1/4; (b) 1/2; (c) 3/4.
Fig. 7. Dynamic response of the midpoint with different pig speeds, ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Lplug = 6.7 m and Pop = 3 MPa, constraint condition: (a) Fix-Fix; (b) Fix-Pin.
4.2. Effects of pig speed on dynamic response 4.3. Effects of plug length on dynamic response
The effects of pig speed on the dynamic characteristics of aerial The plug length reflects the accumulation volume in the pipe.
crossing pipe are evaluated here. Fig. 7 presents time-domain responses Effects of plug length on the dynamic characteristics of aerial crossing
of the pipe midpoint with different pig speeds. With the pig speed in- pipe are evaluated here. Fig. 10 presents time-domain responses of the
creasing, the duration of plug flowing in aerial crossing pipe becomes pipe midpoint with different plug lengths. It is observed that the
shorter and the free-vibration amplitude after plug leaving varies. The maximum load deflection increases with the plug length increasing till
important characteristic parameters of dynamic behaviors under dif- the plug length reaches pipe length. Fig. 11 and Fig. 12 present the
ferent pig speeds can be drawn in Fig. 8 and Fig. 9, which present the extreme values of the displacements during the dynamic responses with
extreme values of the displacements during the dynamic responses. It is different plug lengths. Dmax increases with the plug length when the
observed that Amax increases intensely when the pig speed is higher plug length is less than the pipe length, and keeps constant when the
than 20 m/s and 15 m/s under two boundary conditions respectively. plug length is larger than the pipe length. Amax would be constant when
Amax would vary when the pig speed is increasing, and Amax would the plug length is respectively larger than 15 m and 30 m under dif-
diverge under different boundary conditions if the pig speed is larger ferent boundary conditions. It indicates that the effect of the accumu-
than 300 m/s and 250 m/s respectively. That can be explained that the lation volume on the vibration amplitude is limited.
fluid-structure interactions including the centrifugal force and Coriolis
force are increasing but the response time decreases with pig speed. It
indicates the control of pig speed is significantly crucial for the safety of 4.4. Effects of operating pressure on dynamic response
pigging operations.
Operating pressure (the upstream pressure of the pig) is significant
controlled parameter in pigging operations and affects the dynamic
290
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
291
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
Fig. 10. Dynamic response of the midpoint with different plug lengths, ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Vpig = 5.5 m/s and Pop = 3 MPa, constraint condition: (a) Fix-Fix; (b) Fix-
Pin.
Fig. 11. Bifurcation diagrams for three positions of a system defined by ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Vpig = 5.5 m/s and Pop = 3 MPa as Lplug is varied, constraint condition:
Fix-Fix, (a) 1/4; (b) 1/2; (c) 3/4.
Fig. 12. Bifurcation diagrams for three positions of a system defined by ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Vpig = 5.5 m/s and Pop = 3 MPa as Lplug is varied, constraint condition:
Fix-Pin, (a) 1/4; (b) 1/2; (c) 3/4.
Fig. 13. Dynamic response of the midpoint with different operating pressure, ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Vpig = 5.5 m/s and Lplug = 6.7 m, constraint condition: (a) Fix-Fix;
(b) Fix-Pin.
292
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
Fig. 14. Bifurcation diagrams for three positions of a system defined by ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Vpig = 5.5 m/s and Lplug = 6.7 m as Pop is varied, constraint condition:
Fix-Fix, (a) 1/4; (b) 1/2; (c) 3/4.
Fig. 15. Bifurcation diagrams for three positions of a system defined by ρplug = 1000 kg/m3, Vpig = 5.5 m/s and Lplug = 6.7 m as Pop is varied, constraint condition:
Fix-Pin, (a) 1/4; (b) 1/2; (c) 3/4.
respectively larger than 30 MPa and 15 MPa under different boundary express their gratitude to the support from the National Natural Science
conditions. It indicates that high operating pressure could induce the Fund (No. 11772273) and the National Natural Science Fund for
instability of the pipe during pigging operations. Distinguished Young Scholars (No. 51404290).
The dynamic behaviors and bifurcation characteristics of an aerial Supplementary data related to this article can be found at https://
crossing pipeline under pigging operations were investigated numeri- doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpvp.2018.07.011.
cally. The present theoretical model was extended to consider two-
phase flow characteristics and fluid-structure interactions, and vali- Nomenclature
dated with experimental results. The complicated dynamic behaviors
under different conditions were simulated, and the characteristics were AF Area of the flow channel cross section
analyzed. The typical conclusions are summarized as follows: Amax Maximum vibration amplitude after plug leaves
Cp Specific heat at constant pressure
(1) The dynamic responses of the system are the cumulative effects of Cm Mixture velocity coefficient
fluid-structure interactions and two-phase flow characteristics Cs Damping coefficient
during pigging operations. D, d Outer and inner diameters of pipe
(2) The fluid density and pig speed affect the centrifugal force, Coriolis Dequ, Dmax Equilibrium position and max load deflection
force and the rate of change of system properties, thus have sig- E, I Elastic modulus and moment of inertia
nificant influence on the maximum deflection and can excite in- Fd Drag force
tense vibration response after plug leaving. Boundary conditions g Gravitational acceleration
have significant influence on vibration characteristics. HLS Liquid holdup of liquid slug
(3) The effects of the accumulation volume on the vibration responses k Total heat transfer coefficient
are limited. However, higher levels of pig speed, fluid density or L plug Length of the plug
operating pressure are easier to induce large vibration amplitudes, Le Length of pipe element
and these parameters are crucial for the stability of the pipeline and m plug Mass of the plug
should be controlled reasonably during pigging operations. mg Gas mass flow
(4) The results can enrich our understanding on complicated dynamics MG , MD, m Gas, dense phase and pipe mass-per-unit-length
behaviors of natural gas pipelines during pigging operations and MGe , VGe , MDe VDe Gas, dense phase mass-per-unit-length and flow velo-
may promote the operation safety of natural gas pipelines. cities in local coordinate
P Local pressure of the fluid
Pc , Tc Critical pressure and temperature
Acknowledgements
P , T , Z Average pressure, temperature and compressibility factor in
pipeline
For the work described in this paper, the authors would like to
293
L. Wang et al. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping 165 (2018) 286–294
294