Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Chemistry of Taxol: David G. I. Kingston
The Chemistry of Taxol: David G. I. Kingston
DAVID G. I. KINGSTON
Department of Chemistry, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA 24061-0212,
U.S.A.
CONTENTS
1. Introduction and Scope 1
2. Isolation and Structure of Taxol 2
2.1. Historical background 2
2.2. Structure elucidation of t~ 2
2.3. Structures of related taxa 4
2.4. Sources of taxol and rela 4
2.5. NMR spectra of taxol 7
2.6. Mass
vlass spectrometry of taxol 9
2.7. X-ra
(-ray crystallography of taxol 9
2.8. Analysis of taxol 9
3. Chemistry of Taxol 10
3.1. H~Iydrolysis of taxol 10
Epimerization of taxol at C-7 11
kcylation of taxol 13
)xidation 14
3.5. Reduction 15
3.6. Reaction with electrophiles 15
3.7. Preparation of labeled taxols 17
4. Synthesis of Taxol 18
4.1. Syntheses from baccatin III 18
4.2. Approaches to total synthesis 21
5. Biosynthesis and Biotransformation of Taxol 24
5.1. Biosynthesis of taxol and related taxanes 24
5.2. Biotransformation of taxol 25
6. Structure-Activity Relationships of Taxol Derivatives 26
3accatin III analogs
Side chain modified analogs
~ng modified analogs
~nimal test data
ledgements
2es
1. I J . N I IR
~LO/ LD/ U
U LC~T
I IIUO
I .N A N D SCOPE
./'klNl./ ~L,L/I"I:~, This
I n I 8 revi
review IS pan oz a scnes mat ¢
The discovery of the novel diterpenoid* anticancer inhibitors of microtubule function, and t~
agent taxol in 1971 by M o n r o e Wall and his collab- eluded because its primary mechanism of a
orators (Wani et al., 1971) ranks in retrospect as one the microtubule level. Because of the impc
of the most significant discoveries ever made in taxol and because of the rapidly developing
the field of naturally occurring anticancer agents. this area of study, the discussion of taxol k,
extracts have been used as anticancer two parts. 1
uries, only a handful of plant-derived including it~
ts has been found to show clinically cations, pal
and taxol is clearly a member of this relationship
of the inter
tubules will
! D . G . I . KINGSTON
%**0 Ph
0
OAc
FIG. 1. Structures of taxinine and O-cinnamoyltaxicin-I triacetate.
relationships. Similarly, the many ap- taxane diterpenoids as summarized m a review artk
proaehes to the taxane ring system a are on Taxus alkaloids (Lythgoe, 1968). The derivati
not discussed in detail, in part because the total O-cinnamoyltaxicin-I triacetate (Fig. 1), obtain
synthesis of taxol has not yet been achieved. Various from the alkaloid taxine-I in T. baecata by Hofmal
partial syntheses of taxol and its analogs are, how- elimination and acetylation, is a typical example
e
ever, included. A full discussion of the taxane diter- Harrison a]
the structures elucidated by Lythgoe (Hal
penoids will be published elsewhere (Kingston et al., Lythgoe, 1966; Harrison et al., 1966).
1992b), and a discussion of synthetic approaches has The development of nuclear magnetic resonan
recently appeared (Swindell, 1991). spectroscopy as a powerful structural tool in t
1960s, together with the advent of X-ray crystallogr
phy on a routine basis, enabled work on taxa
N A N D S T R U C T U R E O F TAXOL ids to advance much more rapidly. In pe
diterpenoid
2. ISOLATION
ticular, Hadsall and his coworkers isolated nineto
2.1. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND different taxane
ta derivatives and reported them in
series of seven brief reports over the peri(
nmemorial it has been known that the
From time immemorial 1966-1975. Among these derivatives was the dit(
few, such as the English yew, Taxus
penoid baccatin-III, which although originally
~tain toxic constituents. In the middle
signed a different structure was finally assigned t
oi me nmeteenm th centur'
century a mixture ofoI toxic
toxin alkaloids
alKaloms
structure shown in Fig. 2 (Della Casa de Marcano
was isolated from T. baccata and given the name and Haisall, 1975). This and other work on the taxane
taxine (Lucas, 1856), but the solution of the structural diterpenoids until 1979 has been well reviewed by
problems posed by these complex compounds proved Miller (1980). The work on taxol itself until 1985 is
too challenging for the techniques of that day. It was summarized in an excellent review by Suffness and
early recognized, however, that the taxines had an Cordell (1985), and a review on Taxus alkaloids has
unusual skeletal structure, which is now known as the recently appeared (Bleehert and Gu6nard, 1990).
taxane skeleton. Other compounds containing this
skeleton were isolated from both T. baccata and the
" cuspidata, and the structures of some 2.2.
ounds were elucidated in the 1960s. As an on
acture of the diterpenoid taxinine of novelan
composition product of taxine, was collaborati(
63 (Kurono et al., 1963), and Lythgoe Wall and 17
kers published a series of ten papers of the wes
l structural assignments of several et al., 1971
RiO 0 P~ PhCONH
: 0
Ph~OCHs
PhCOO
The chemistry of taxol
o
\
°W °"
scheme they succeeded in isolating tk Live indicated an unusual lack of reactivity of the C-1
cytotoxic and antileukemic
nmeugeimc compound compounu taxo~ ~rom me the hydroxyl
nyuroxy~ gr group in baecatin III, and proved to be
bark in 0.02% yield. The structure of taxol was harbinger of o problems to come in the semisynthes
recognized to be ~e that of a taxane diterpenoid based of taxol.
on its 1H-NMRLspectrum, but the full solution of the Structura
Structurally, taxol is differentiated from most oth¢
structural problem lena re,
required the use of X-ray crystal- taxane diterpenoids by its ester side chain at C- 13 an
niques. Mild methanolysis of taxol by its oxetane ring D; it can be viewed as tk
yl ester and a tetraol. The ester was N-benzoyl-t//-phenylisoserine ester of baccatin II
~,lac.~t~ta~,~.~ o fy X-ray
f ~ .~-xu.v crystallography
~ tjoLgaxvba~lp.Aa J tas
* o the
L a I ~ yp-bro-
-oa~- The
x a a ~ conventional
conven
~ alv~axLI~aI~a planar
IJ1~ax~L representation
t~VL~o~xa*~*avax of
~ 1 Fig.
a A ~ . . 3 is
o ao i
IaA
mobenzoate derivative, and the tetraol was character- fact rather misleading, since taxol actually has a
ized as the bisiodoacetate (Fig. 2). These data, structure best described as an inverted cup shape, in
together with an analysis of the IH-NMR spectrum which the ester side chain lies across the opening of
of taxol, enabled Wall to assign the structure of taxol the cup. The representation of taxol shown in Fig. 4
as shown in Fig. 3. The numbering system shown for was obtained by using the Chem-3D Plus program,
taxol is that recommended by IUPAC (IUPAC, and clearly illustrates its three-dimensional shape.
Commission on the Nomenclature of Organic Chem- Because of the difficulty of representing taxol and
istry, 1978). It is interesting to note that Wall's other taxanes in two dimensions, two different rep-
only a bisiodoacetate from the tetraol resentations
used in this
o, , ,,~ . proposed b
showing the
groups accu
used by Ly'
.o~ \ / ""-d.~ ~ ° " popularadvanta
of
advantage, as pointed out by Lythgoe (1961
orientation of the 16- and 17-methyl gro
reverse of that expected. The 16-methyl grc
is fl with respect to the 19-methyl group as a
must be shown with a hatched bond, whi
/o~.-"'- methyl group is • but must be shown wit]
t3~
o o~ bond. Thes~
// . ~ , , ~ . designation
.-\-- Chemical
I N ~ system for
taxol is nar~
specifically
D. G. I. KINGSTON
AcO O OH AcO O OH
,P o.
L = 'o¢~
OH
.
r
OH = OAc
=. =
OH PhCOO
FIG. 7. Structure ~nnine (taxol B) and its ester side chain.
AcO OAc
1~Hydmxybaccatin I
RI=OAc R2=H
1~-Hydroxy-7a-deacetylbaccatin I
""o/~ RI=H R2=OH
AcO¢'I°~~ (
HO AcO
FIG. 8. Structures of baccatin I derivatives from T. ba
baccata and T. wallichiana.
~ho
RaCONH
,,," - H
H
HO PhCOO
Taxol (Taxol A) R~fH R2=Ac RpCsHs
Cephalomannine (Taxol B) R~=H R2=Ac Ra=CHsCH=C(CH~)
7-Xylosyl-10-deacetyltaxol R~=~-xylose R~H Rs=CHeHs
7-Xylosyl-
,ylosy 10-deacetyltaxol
y B R~=l~-xylose R2=H Rs=CHsCH=C(CHa)
Xylosyl-10-deacetyltaxol C R~=l~-xylose Rz=k
Xylosyltaxol R~=~-xylose R==,~
Xylosyltaxol B R~=13-xylose R2=,~
Xylosyltaxol C R~=13-xylose R==A
)-Deacetyltaxol R~=R==H
)-Deacetyltaxol B Rm=R2=H
)-(l~-Hydroxybutyryl)- R~=I-
10-deacetyltaxol
1U-(~-t-tyoroxyouIyryl)-
)-(13-Hydmxybutyryl)- r'hfn, n2=~,ns~ntun/~.,n2~,u
R,=I-
10-deacetyltaxol B Rs=CHsCH-C(CHs)
FIG. 9. Structures of taxol analogs.
of this compound, or for baccatin III and ]0-deacetyi lower yields. Thus in one such isolation 27
baccatin III, both of which can be converted into bark was expected to yield a total of about
~.l). Much of this work has not been taxol, or ab,
?roprietary reasons, but some trends of taxol fro
From the published work. is severely
1as initially obtained from T. brevifolia above requi
02% yield (Wani et al., 1971), and roughly thn
ale isolations have given somewhat T. brevifolia
D. G. I. KINGSTON
""" "
PhCOO
FIG. 10. Structures of baccatin III derivatives from T. baccata and T. wallichiana.
that T. brevifolia bark could never b( ma- it is known that other surveys have been carried o
nent solution to the supply problem
~roblem ot
ol taxol, since the but have not been publzshed
~ublished for
tor proprietary
proprletat reasoz
tree is slow growing and takes up to 200 years to thus Croomt reported on ornamental Taxus Tax= cultiv~
reach maturity; it has been estimated that there are as sustainable abundant plant materials ffor clinic
enough trees available to maintain a supply of taxol taxol studies, but provided no analytic~ ,tical data
only for the next 5-10 years.* support this claim. Of the three published studies,
s t
Taxol has also been detected or isolated in various first (Witherup et al., 1990) reported on the taxol a
other Taxus species. Wall's original 7ted 10-deacetylbaccatin III content of six Taxus speci~
that taxol had been isolated from 7" and The taxol content of both needles and stems w
T. baccata (Wani et al., 1971), but vere determined by HPLC, and the highest amount
given. Both tax<:ol and cephalomannine were isolated 0.01%) was found in T. X m e d i a cv. Hick
weight (0.0
~iana; a mixture of roots, stems, and
from T. wallichiana: needles, with
wi! comparable amounts in T. cuspidata (
;ed, and taxol was obtained with a
leaves were used. Capitata, T. canadensis, and T. brevifolia needh
0.001% yield (Miller
Miller et al., 1981). The trunk bark of Taxol content
cont~ of the stems was typically one half,
duced taxol with a 0.016% yield and
T. baccata produced less, that of
o the needles. The 10-deacetylbaccatin ]
0.0064% yield (S6nilh et al., 1984a). content of the stems and needles of the same plat
baccatin III and 10-deacetyl baccatin was also determined;
d in this case the highest yie
III can both be converted into taxol in high yield (0.02%) was found in T. baccata cv. Repandens
(Section 4.1), and thus the availability of these corn- needles, with other species yielding one half this
pounds is almost as important as that of taxol. amount or less.
Indeed, in view of the finding that the semisynthetic The second study (Vidensek et al., 1990) reported
taxol analog taxotere ~ (Fig. 12) is reported to have only on taxol content, but analyzed many more plant
an improved activity as compared with taxol (Man- samples, particularly of T. brevifolia. This study
gatal et al., 1989), baccatin III or its 10-deacetyl demonstrated that taxol content is highly variable,
derivative may ultimately prove to be more valuable even within the same species. Thus the 15 bark
than taxol, L[ of T. brevifolia ~ave a range of taxol content
samples
was originally isolated from heart- of 0.0001-4
ccata with an unreported yield (Chan 0.00003-0.(
td its correct structure was reported in the first grc
Lsa de Marcano and Halsall, 1975). It lia needles,
ated from the trunk bark of T. baccata the present
yield (S6nilh et al., 1984a), and from highest av,
and leaves of T. wallichiana in an seedlings a~
unspecified yield (Miller et al., 1981). Its 10-deacetyl amounts, although the latter datum is bas
derivative was obtained from T. baccata trunk bark two samples of undefined taxonomy.
with 0.02% yield (Chauvi6re et al., 1981), and also
from T. brevifolia bark in an unspecified yield n o
(Kingston et al., 1982).
The results of survevs for the occurrence of
~f three surveys / ~| J
,'acetylbaccatin III have appeared, and
PhCONH.
_ =
989) Presentation to the Division of Cancer
onal Cancer Institute, Board of Scientific Pa
zesda, MD, October 12. oH
The chemistry of taxol
.+, . . . . . . . . r . . . . . . . . . i . . . . . . . ~ . . . . . . . . . i . . . . . . . . . ,
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
ition causes a downfield shift of about 0.8 ppm manuscript (J. A. Beutler, G. N. Chmurny, B.
(Mellado et al. , 1984), and removal of the C-13 ester Hilton, S. Brobst,
] S. A. Look and K. M. Witheru
side chain causes ses the C-13 proton to move upfield submitted for
I publication) reports the assignment
almost 1.4 ppm; a; this latter assignment was used to ]3C-NMR spectrum of taxol by 2D methods; t
the ]3C-N/V
,'~l~'r';#"v (I,"~'rYIP, ,'~nn'~11(:
onfusion in the literature about the IaC-NMR~assignments of taxol are shown in Fig. ]
tion position of baccatin III (Magri et A recent manuscript reports the spectrum of tax
• . is worth notingv that the ~H-NMR obtained by a solid/liquid intermolecular transJ
spectrum of taxol is quite solvent dependent. Thus dynamic nuclear polarization technique (H. C. Dorn,
the C-20 protons appear as an AB quartet with some C. Tsiao, K. H. Tsai, G. Samaranayake and D. G. I.
additional coupling in CDC13, but as a broad singlet Kingston, submitted for publication). In this method
in CD3OD. dynamic nuclear polarization enhancement was gen-
The ~3C-NMR spectra of taxol (Magri, 1985) and erated at low field using nitroxides immobilized on
of baccatin III (Rojas et al., 1983) were originally silica gel in contact with the dissolved sample. The
7.49(m)
) ~ i 7"40(m)
2.23(S) 6.27(s)
7.74(dd,1.2,8.3) *,u e,~,~ 14 2
X 1.79(.,1.5) / %~
[I "]++"
The chemistry of taxol
O
71.2
OH
6~ / C H 3 22.6
~27.0
128.7
OH
07.0%~0 "~?0.'
16 0
ri2S.1
C
130.2
128.7
133.7
polarized sample le was then monitored with improved bisiodoacetate and p-bromobenzoate derivative
tion at high field. Because of the
spectral resolution (Fig. 2) determined during the original structm
experimental conditions
~nditions used, ]H-NMR signals with elucidation of taxol have never been published. Hov
relaxation times, such as the aro- ever, X-ray structures of baccatin V (Castellano an
;ns, showed dipolar dominated or Hodder, 1973)
19 and of taxotere (Fig. 16) (Gu~rittq
ncements, while signals with short Voegelein et al., 1990) have been published. T~
relaxation times showed only small enhancements, structure of taxotere (Fig. 16) clearly shows the
Interestingly, the C-10 acetate and the C-16, 17, and cup-like shape of the taxane skeleton of taxol and its
19 methyl groups showed larger enhancements than relationship to the C-13 side chain.
the C-4 acetate and the C-18 methyl group,
suggesting that the convex face of the taxol molecule
2.8. ANALYSISOF TAXOL
is the one that interacts with the silica surface.
The need to carry out extensive surveys of T a x u s
2.6. MASS SPECTROMETRYOF TAXOL species for their taxol content and to monitor taxol
discoverers of taxol reported a mol- in clinical sl
umably obtained under electron ioniz- analytical rr
ks) at m / z 853, but later workers only graphic me
it ion peaks under these conditions groups are
~81). The FAB mass spectrum oftaxol initial resull
et al., 1991~
olecular ions at M H +, M N a +, and
Most o f '
,,ment ions are observed corresponding
..... ' ....... "............................. " ....... " HPLC method was developed to separate t
to loss of the protonated C-13 side chain and to the
loss of acetic acid (Magri, 1985). cephalomannine, 10-deacetylcephalomanr
Recently, a detailed analysis of the FAB mass catin III, and 10-deacetylbaccatin I I I ,
spectrum of taxol has been carried out, using colli- et al., 1989). Both isocratic and gradient rev
sional activation to produce daughter ion spectra, but methods were tested, using cyano and phen
the= r~ltlt~ h~ve; ~n
so f:~r
far nnlv ]'~en
only been nublished
published in
in abstract
abstract silica gel columns.
arations, bu Both columns gave adeq
solvent and
and decrea
AY CRYSTALLOGRAPHYOF TAXOL
phase for t
no X-ray crystal structure of taxol has starting wit
and even the X-ray structures of the to MeOH:
10 D . G . I . KINGSTON
Ic
ay structure of taxotere.
discussed (Witherup
nerup et at.,
al., 1990).
~ v ) . Th
~ne analysis otf ~.
T. aoequateJy
adequately, and also separated several other co
brevifolia for taxol content previously noted was pounds from a T. brevifolia extract.
carried out usin sing Cl8 columns and M e O H : H : O ,
68 : 32 as the solvent,
lvent (Vidensek et al., 1990). A method
for analysis of taxol in T. chinensis has also been 3. CHEMISTRY O F TAXOL
i .1 i r~r
and Liu, 1989). Very recently another
3.1. HYDROLYSISOF TAXOL
separation of taxol and cephaloman-
published (Cardellina. 1991). This The first reactions carried out on taxol were hydt
method uses a cyanopropyl column with hexane: lytic in nature, as an aid to structure elucidation. As
iPrOH (2 : 1), and may be more amenable to prepara- previously noted, mild methanolysis of taxoi gave the
tive work than the reverse phase systems previously methyl ester of the side chain and a tetraol, which was
described, identified as 10-deacetylbaccatin III (Fig. 2) (Wani et
Analysis for taxol in biological fluids has also used al., 1971). Mild methanolysis of cephalomannine,
HPLC. After evaluating C8, cyanopropyl, and phenyl however, gave a mixture of six products, identified as
bonded phases, Riley and his coworkers (Rizzo et al., baccatin III (19%), 10-deacetylbaccatin III (19%),
1990) selected a Cs bonded phase column with a 10-deacetylcephalomannine (5%), baccatin V (17%),
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I ,
"- OH
PhCO0
the borohydride, and does not proceed if this yield some additional products in low yie deld, whic
group is acylated or converted to a silyl ether, were characterized as the 2,10-dideacyl derivatix
The reaction thus offers a pathway for the con- and the 2,4,10-trideacyl-13-de(triethylsilyl) derivatix
version of cephalomannine into taxol by conversion (Fig. 20). An alternate interpretation of these
the resul
baceatin III
to baccatin 1II and reacylation
reacvlation a,, as described in is that the neighboring
nei~hborin~ group
~rnun effect is not relevan
Section 4.1. but that access to the C-4 acetate is blocked by t~
Studies have also been carried out J ton bulky C-13 triethylsilyl group.
group on the selecuve selective deac,oeacylauon
dation ot ( t~accatm III, Ill,
with the conceept that reacylation might produce
3.2. EPIMERIZATIONOF TAXOLAT C-7
novel derivatives es with improved properties (Sama-
ranayake, 1990). ). Hydrogenation of baccatin III over The C-7 hydroxyl group of taxol is part of
Pt yields a bexah ahydro derivative by reduction of the fl-hydroxycycarbonyl system encompassing C-7, C-
the A 11 double bond is completely and C-9, anda as such is subject to epimerizatiol
uction under these conditions. Hydro- presumably via a retro-aldol/aldol mechanism (Fi
t y u t ; SLUO.leS w ~ere
r e tcarried
;ariletl oout
ut oon
n the
t i l e 7-triethylsilyl
/-trletnyl~llyl 21). Thus
LI). thUS !t r e a t m e n t
treatment oof cephalomannine
l c e p n a l o m a n n l n e vwith
~m ba~
oase
ether of this bexahydrobaccatin III, to avoid prob- yielded derivatives both of baccatin III and of 7-epi-
lems with epimerization at C-7 (see below, Section baccatin III, or baccatin V (Fig. 17) (Miller et al.,
3.2). Mild hydrolysis of 7-(triethylsilyl)-hexahydro- 1981), and 10-deacetyltaxol and 10-deacetylcephalo-
baccatin III with methanolic sodium methoxide at mannine were both partially converted to their
25°C yielded the 10-deacetyl derivative and the 4,10- 7-epi isomers on standing in aqueous methanol
dideacetyl derivative to about equal extents; there (McLaughlin et al., 1981). The driving force for the
was no indication at all of the formation of any epimerization may be in part due to the formation of
2-deacyl or 2,10-dideacyl product. Further hydrolysis a hydrogen bond between the 7-epi-hydroxyl group
of partially deacylated derivatives and the C-4
to 2-debenzoyl-4,10-dideacetyl-7-tri- gen bond is
in III (Fig. 19). (Castellano
ydrolysis of the tertiary C-4 acetoxy be an overx
of the secondary C-2 acyloxy group epimerizatic
ae due to a 'neighboring group' effect 1981), and il
droxyl group. This group is actually at equilibril
located relatively close to the C-4 acetate (Fig. 16), deacetyl derivatives appear to epimerize rr
and can thus act as a nucleophile to attack the readily than the corresponding acetylated d
C-4 acetoxy group intramolecularly. In support of The reason for this is not fully clear, but is
this hypothesis, treatment of 7,13-di(triethylsilyl)- associated with hydrogen bonding from
hexahydrobaccatin III under the same conditions as hydroxyl group to the C-9 carbonyl grot
used earlier gave only the 10-deacetyl derivative, associated activation of the C-9 carbonyl
l base for an extended time period did retro-aldol
RCONH
Bu4NBH4
o
12 D . G . I . KINGSTON
NaOMa
H MaOH H
o.~ po
J
J
.o "d
HO
n of taxol to 7-epi-taxol was observed The reason for this discrepancy is not known, but
when taxol was heated with the free radical initiator presumably associated with a trace impurity in one of
azobis(isobutyronitrile) (AIBN)(Huang et al., 1986). the batches of AIBN. 7-Epi-taxol has also been
The reaction proceeded cleanly and in high yield with isolated from T. brevifolia (Huang et al., 1986), and
the first batch of AIBN used, but later attempts to epimerization of taxol to 7-epi-taxol has been ob-
repeat this action have given poor or negative results, served in cell culture medium; baceatin III is also
AcO ,O OSIEI3
o~OO OSIE
13 NIOMa
aSI MaOH EtsSl
~/~ ~ Major
produ(:t
The chemistry of taxol
o-x -o ;;o'\
PhOOO
PhCOO PhCOO
FlG. 21. Mechanism of epimerization of baccatin III in hydroxylic solvents (SOH).
formed in small quantities under these conditions group with Zn/AcOH yielded an unprotected OX;
/11-----:
_ A t - - - - - _ J TT:-----~--_ srhoo\ "rl- . . . . . . . ~.
(Ringel and Horwitz, 1987). zolone (Magri and Kingston, 1988). The unprotecte
oxazolone was also prepared from taxol by treatmel
3.3. ACYLATIONOF TAXOL with carbonyldiimidazole (Deutsch et al., 1989).
In addition to acetylation of taxol, vanous
vari oth(
Taxol has three free hydroxyl groups, but the one 2'-acyltaxols have been prepared in attem Ipts to d
at C-1 is tertiary and thus inert to normal acylation velop water-soluble prodrugs of taxol. The T~ 2'-po
conditions. The 7-hydroxyl group is relatively ition is the preferred position for this appro )roach, sin(
crowded, so mild acetylation of taxol yields the acyl derivatives at this position are readily hhydrolyze
2'-acetate
9 preferentially. Acylation
' _ ~ r ~ t ~ t a nr@t'ar@nti*llv un
Arvl~tinn u nclar
m n r F .vionr . . . . . . . .
for- and could thus readily be converted to taxol in viv
. . . . . .
ous conditions leads to the 2',7-diac ,ery The fact that these derivatives are the easiest !
mild hydrolysis of this converts it t, :ate prepare is of course an added bonus.
(Mellado et el., 1984) (Fig. 22). The first derivatives of this type were prepared lc
A better way of preparing 7-acyltaxols is through Magri and Kingston (1988), who prepared 2'-su~
the use of more ~re selective protecting groups. The cinyltaxol aand 2'-(fl-alanyl)taxol formate (Fig. 24
chloroacetyl group oup has worked well in our hands for Very simila
similar types of derivatives were prepared t
this purpose, since ince it is readily removable from the Zalkow and and his collaborators (Deutsch et el., 1989
treatment with thioethanolamine or These ~se inves
investigators prepared 2'-succinyltaxol and 2
oist silica gel (Samaranayake, 1990). glutaryltaxc
dtaxol and their sodium, triethanolamm(
lloroethyloxycarbonyl derivative
i ne z,z,z-mcnioroemyioxycaroonyt aenvauve has
nas nium, and N-methylglucammonium salts. They also
also been used: it is selectively removable by treat- prepared the amide of 2'-glutaryltaxol and 3-(di-
ment with zinc and acetic acid (Chenu et el., 1987). methylamino)-l-propylamine, and attempted without
The 2,2,2-trichloroethyloxycarbonyl (troc)group success to prepare 2'-glycyltaxol and 2'-(phenyl-
also can function as an electrophilic center for intra- alanyl)taxol (Fig. 24). Various dimethylaminoacyl
molecular displacement. Thus treatment of 2',7- derivatives of taxol in both the 2'- and 7-positions
di(troc)taxol with the base 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]- have also been prepared by Stella and Mathew
undec-7-ene (DBU) yielded an oxazolone as the (1990).
single major product (Fig. 23). Treatment of this In
In recent
recent work Kingston and Zhao have nrenarad
dilute HCI during work-up also gave three new i
,1 oxazolone, while removal of the troc solubilizing
AaO. o OH
b
O ~ " ~ l Ao2OtPY PhCONH
AcO O OCOOCH=CCI
3 AcO O OCOOCH=(
Ph PhCON
CI3CCH2OCOO PhCOO ~O PhCOO
O I HCI
Zn/AcON J
J AcO O OCOOCH=CCI
3
AcO
Ph o
HN/ - vn = . . . .
'~O PhCOO
PhCOO
O
O
FIG. 23. af oxazolone derivatives of taxol.
AoO O
' i
OR
OH
PhCOO
iAC(
2'-succinyltaxol R=COCH
2'-(13-alanyl)taxolformate R=COCH:
2'-glutaryltaxol R-COCH
2'-glutarylamino amide derivative R=CO(CI-
The chemistry of taxol
~o
---I I/
o OH
V "
osmium tetroxide under catalytic condition,,
_] L o ~,- - - ,- ~ , . ~ in a very clean conversion to a diol (Fig. ~2!) . • ~LAI
was unaffected by these conditions, and could
cou] readil
be separated from the more polar diol byy simple
sin ttas
PhCONH O column chromatography. This process thus provid(
Ph" Y. ^"" 0 a simple and efficient method to separate ttaxol an
cephalomannine (Kingston et al., 1992a).
OR PhCOO
3.5. REDUCTION
2'-(triothylsilyl)taxol RfSiEt3 Taxol is very resistant to reduction reactions.~.Th~ ?
2'-(t-butyldimet hylsilyl)taxol R, hydrogenation of taxol under mild conditions leave
Fl(:;. 25. Silyl taxol derivati~ the compound unchanged, while more vigorous col
ditions
OltlOnS lead leao to the me reduction reOucuon of ot the
me phenyl
pne rin!
Treatment of 7-oxotaxol with 1,8-diazabicycloun- (Magri, 1985). The C-9 carbonyl group is is also
a resis
decene (DBU) in dichloromethane at 25°C or even by ant to reduction under various conditions, Slpecifical
including hydride reagents, such as sodium sodiun boroh2
chromatography on silica gel gave a ring-D seCO dride. Inspection of the structure of taxo taxol (Fig.,
product in quantitative yield. This ring-opened
product could be reduced to its dihydro derivative, shows that this group is in a very crowded
crowded envirot
. . . . . ~ _ _ J ~,~ ~'c___ _". . . . . . . VEt_ ~_ _J ~_~'__ _
~ne ment, and is thus inaccessible to reducing agents. 32
but this proved to be unstable and yi
red only reduction reaction that taxol undergoes readi
by the process of retro-Claisen conden
is the reductive cleavage of the C-13 ester side chai
by lactone formation (Fig. 27) (Magri
on, discussed in Section 3.1.
1986).
~halomannine differs from taxol in having a
Oxidation of taxol with activated manganese diox- Cephalon
~osed double bond, and this can readily be reduce
ide under mild basic conditions yielded 13-oxo- exposeddot
on catalytic ytic hydrogenation (D. G. I. Kingston an
resumably by hydrolysis of the C-13
baccatin III, presumably
C. A. Ivey, unpublished work). In all other respec
and oxidation of the liberated allylic
~halomannine is as unreactive towards reducir
) (Wani et al., 1971). In support of this cephalomar
agents as taxol.
cetylbaccatin III can be oxidized with
chromium trioxide in pyridine to its 13-oxo deriva-
tive; this reaction is reversible in that the 13-oxo 3.6. REACTION WITH ELECTROPHILF.~
derivative can be reduced stereoselectively to yield As already noted, taxol is very labile to basic
10-deacetylbaccatin III (Fig. 28) (S6nilh et al., 1984b). reagents, but is reasonably stable to acids, surviving
Oxidation ofcephalomannine could also be carried treatment with cold dilute sulfuric acid unchanged.
out with osmium tetroxide, since this compound has However, it does react with various Lewis acids under
an accessible double bond in the side chain. The more vigorous conditions.
separation of taxol and cephalomannine is a difficult Reaction of taxol with ZnBr 2 in MeOH at room
mg very careful chromatography, and temperature
ation is usually not possible in a single of 10-deace
, oxidation of cephalomannine with 30); the 7-et
CrO=/H*
,,oo,.._=
H
o
X ~
i i
PhCONH
...... itl V.r,
OH PhCOO OH PhCOO
CrOI/H*
AoO O O
o ,,.o. PhOONH
16 D . G . I . KINGSTON
,OH
PhCO0
OH PhCO0 OH
AcO
I Hz/Pt
O O
.h°O,, O
PhCONH 0
:
OH PhCO0 ~O'"r~O
OH PhCOO
FIG. 1 and reactions o f D-SCCOtaxo].
HO O OH HO O OH
CrO~'py ~
N
N"BH4
O
O
.
PhCOO PhCOO
that this isomer is the more stable form in the Treatment of either taxol or the Meerwein prod-
10-deacetyl series (Jitrangsri, 1986; Samaranayake uct with acetyl chloride yielded a second novel
et al., 1991). product, which was shown to have the structure
The reaction of taxol with zinc chloride has also indicated in Fig. 31. This product is presumably
been carried out by Potier and his collaborators formed either by a cationic mechanism or poss-
(Gu6ritte-Voegelein et al., 1987), but this reaction ibly by a concerted rearrangement in which hydro-
ve been done under more vzgorous gen abstr~
led to a ring-opened product similar is concerte
ed below, acetate fro~
found change accompanied the reac- 1991).
ith triethyloxonium tetrafluoroborate The rec(
agent). Reaction with this powerful chloride pr
der mild conditions, followed by an a taxol der
aqueous worK-up,
u yzelded
'ielded a mixture ot
of products
)roducts with contracted
contracted,A-ring (:Samaranayake et al., 19
one predominating. This product was shown to be the ment of 2',7-di(triethylsilyl) taxol with tr
20, O-secotaxol derivative 20-acetoxyl-4-deacetyl-5- fonyl chloride and triethylamine, followed
epi-20, O-secotaxoi (Fig. 31) by a combination of tection, yielded the 11(15---1)abeotaxol de
spectroscopic techniques and chemical conversion to Fig. 32. This compound possesses all the
its isopropylidene derivative (Samaranayake et al., groups of taxol except for the C-I hydro
but the skel
OAc 0 OH
OsO4
"NH O
The chemistry of taxol
HO O OH HO oO OH
PhCONH 0 ~ PhCONH 0
OH PhCOO OH PhCOO
hO0,, 0 / / PhCONH
Ph
OH
0""~ O'
PhCO0 OAc
OH Ph
Ok=
& °°~
PhCO0 OAc
OA©
20-Acetoxyl-4-deacetyl-5-epl-20,O.! Acetylohlorldeproduct
FIG. 31. Structures of l reagent and acetyl chloride reaction products.
bioactivity of this
Lhis important derivative will be dis- affinity labeled
labe derivative and a fluorescent labele
cussed in Section 6.3. derivative. The
' photoaffinity labeled derivative w~
prepared from 4-(l-azi-2,2,2-trifluoroethyl)benzo
EPARAT1ON qOF LABELED TAXOLS
3.7. PREPARATION Nassal, 1983) and taxol by protection of tax(
acid (Nassa
at the 2'-pc)osition with chloroacetyl chloride, acyh
l in Section 6.2 below, acylation of tion with ttthe azibenzoic acid at the 7-position, an
position does not change its tubulin- deprotectiol
protection (Samaranavake, 1990). The resultiv
assembly activity significantly. It has thus been poss- azibenzoyltaxol (Fig. 33) had an ICs0 comparable
ible to prepare various 7-acyl taxols with specific with that of taxol, indicating that it was an excellent
labels for biological studies on taxol, promoter of microtubule assembly and valuable for
The initial studies of taxol binding to microtubules photoaflinity labeling of tubulin; studies in this area
were carried out using a tritiated taxol prepared by a are in progress.
specially developed tritium exchange procedure The fluorescent labeled taxol was prepared by
with 3H20 o v e r rhodium on alumina (Parness and acylation of a 2'-protected taxol at the 7-position with
Horwitz, 1981). This procedure gave a mixture of five N-(Cbz)-/~-alanine, deprotection, and reaction of the
J I- . . . . . . . . . J . . . . . ".__.z . . . . z'..1 1-
;ver, and required careful chromatog- //-alanyl ar
ate the labeled taxol from the other resulting dt
)ducts. A simpler method of preparing same ICs0
taxol derivative was thus developed and also sh,
:etic anhydride to prepare 7-[3H- is thus a po
lenu et al., 1987). The labeled 7-acetyl- the biologic
C50 for stabilization of microtubules techniques q
a b o u t [Wlce m a tt oz
of [axol,
taxol aand is [thus
n o 15 useful as a pprobe
n u s useiul robe
for biological studies.
Since taxol binds reversibly to microtubules, there
4. SYNTHESIS OF TAXOL
has been interest in the preparation of labeled taxols
that could assist biological studies of this binding. At this time the total synthesis of taxol 11
Two such derivatives have been prepared: a photo- been achieved, but three different partial
1. Et~lSIClllm/dllzole Ph(
2. MsCI/NEt;
18 D.G.I. KINGSTON
suitably protected derivative of the side chain acid. prepare 10-deacetyltaxol from 10-deacetylbaccatin
However, the C-13 hydroxyl group of baccatin III is III.
very hindered, and may also be hydrogen bonded to One interesting and important finding from this
the C-4 acetoxy carbonyl group. Acylation at this approach is that N-t-butoxycarbonyl-10-deacetyl-
position is thus very difficult. As an example of this taxol, which was prepared from 10-deacetylbaccatin
hindrance, baccatin III is preferentially acetylated at III by a simple modification of the route described,
C-7 rather than C-13, and preparation of 13-acetyl- showed excellent in vivo anticancer activity (Colin
baccatin III required protection of the 7-position, et al., 1988). This compound has been named tax-
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
th excess acetic anhydride in the otere®, an,
lridine and 4-dimethylaminopyridine The seco
deprotection (Magri et al., 1986). developed t
on study of 10-deacetylbaccatin III tion with C
ut by Potier and his collaborators essentially
elein et al., 1986). Under mild con- baccatin II
20°C) the 7-acetate and 7,10-diacetate forcing co]
were formed in about equal amounts. Under more synthesized
,nthesized by Greene and his collaborat
vigorous conditions (48 hr, 60°C) the 7,10-diacetate et al., 1986) in a pathway built around
and 7,10,13-triacetate were formed in equal amounts, epoxidation reaction (Fig. 36). Epoxidati
while under the most vigorous conditions (24 hr, cinnamyl alcohol with t-butyl hydropero:
80°C) only the triacetate was formed. These results presence of titanium isopropoxide and (
suggest that the order of reactivity of the hydroxyl tartrate yielded the epoxide in 61% yield
eacetylbaccatin III is 7 > 10>>13. enantiomer
Lese results, Potier then developed a yielded the
is of taxol and various analogs from went regio
nd 10-deacetyl baccatin III. Initial trimethylsil
d conversion of 10-deacetylbaccatin was benzo,.
)c) derivative, acylation at C-13 with duction of
The chemistry of taxol
HO O OH 00~OCOOOH:OO~
AgCN,toluene
110 Q
.o cc~,c.~ocoo._~ ocooc.,cc~,
. ,,v -- un 1 . 0804 --':-,,z'--~~,.~'~r~
OH 0 3. Separation ~ I "~,
HO PhCOO PhCOO
1. CINaNR/AgNO:/OsO4
2. 7.n/AoOH
3. SelmrMIonof isomers
HO O OH
,2%
Ao o
NHR PhCOO OH PhCOO
R ,, SO2CsH4CHs or COOCaHs
FIG. 34. Synthesisof taxol side chain analogs.
et al., 1990). In this approach (Fig. 37) the readily pholine N-oxide (NMMO) and dihydroquinidine 4-
Lyl cinnamate was hydroxylated by chlorobenz(
)rocedure, using catalytic amounts of recrystallize
ide in the presence of N-methylmor- material in
~o o ocooc.,cc,~
"~*'~,1 hydr°xyemlnetl°n
O ~ ~ ButOOONH
,h .o PhCO0
,h OH
o. PhCO0
o
+ otherisomers [ (CHs)sSII
I
AoO O OH
• RuCI~,Halo4 0
ph~"~CH2OH ~ 2. CH2N2 ~--
(+)-DET p 1.12OH P OOCH3
1. MesSIN3
2. PhCOCI
PhCONH
: o N, o
II H2/Pd ph~ ~ L ~ O C I . I ~
ph" ~ ~ O C H s
i
OF
S
OCOPh
FIG. 36. Synthesis of the taxol side chain acid.
OsO4, NMMO, OH / - O\
1. TsCUEt3N
phff~,,/COOCH~ DQCB ~- COOCH:
2. K~COs =-
Ph P~ COOCH3
r
OH
F~C te route to the key epoxide.
~OCHs i CISIMlla,CHaOH
PhCONH N.I'Ii O
: O PhCOCI, NEts
ph " = " ~ ~ O C H i
ph. , ~ CHa i
:
6H OH
FIG. 38. Synthesis of the taxol side chain by Palomo et al. (1990).
taxol models by partial synthesis. The approach of 4.2. APPROACHESTO TOTAL SYNTHESIS
Swindell has already been alluded to: this approach
can be characterized as the synthesis, ha At this time no total synthesis of taxol has bee
modified side chain. reported, and only one total synthesis of a natural
Two groups have prepared analog,, 2tct occurring taxane has been accomplished. A detaile
side chain but a highly modified 'taxane' nucleus, treatment of
ol all the varied synthetic approaches to tt
)eAmicis (DeAmicis, 1988) prepared
Pirrung and DeAmicis taxane skeleton
skel that have been used by differet
racemic taxol side
ide chain from commercially available workers is beyond
1 the scope of this review; a fulh
racemic threo- rphenylserine and optically active side discussion of these approaches is contained in
chain by a moclification of the original Greene route, recent review
revie (Blechert and Gu6nard, 1990) and v~
ctive side chain was then coupled with also be forthcoming
for in a future review (Kingstc
diiodoalkanes in order to prepare et al., 1992).
199, In this section we will thus simp
esters (Fii
symmetrical diesters (Fig. 42). H<
However none ofo1- the describe the one synthesis
describ 'nthesis of
o1 the enantiomer ofor a
three diesters prepared showed any tubulin-assembly natural taxane that has been published to date, as an
activity, indication of the complexity of the task of the
Fillion (1990) has prepared a naphthalene carbo- synthesis of taxol.
lactone ester of the taxol sidechain (Fig. 43). Regret- The one taxane that has been synthesized is taxusin
tably no biological data was presented on this (Holton et al., 1988), or rather enantiotaxusin, since
ester, the natural product used as a starting material had
1. EI3SlCI, CsHsN \
2. CH3COCI, CsHsN ~--
PhCOO
PhCONH O
DPC, DMAP
Ph OH CsHsCHs
OCHCHs
I
OCHiCHs
AcO .o oN
)-q)..
T 1 -"°'"'°.oo..
..,,t.
~.2 D . G . I . KINGSTON
AcO. .O OCOOCH.aCCI
3 AcO O OH
Ph
.I)-.o 1.7-(troc)baccatln III
2. ZnlAoOH o
:.~o,,"~ :d%,:o
C13CCI'12OCH20 OH OCOPh
FIG. 40. Synthesis of taxol analol [1 et al. (1991) showing the postulated 5,6-dihydro-6-keto-
oxazine intermediate.
Ph
Aco..~ A~o.,,.,, .,"'Ph Aco,,.,,, ,,"'Ph
COCI
J iPr2NEt O~.~ CAN ~
I CH2C12 .N NH
,
OCHs
O ~ O H÷ ~--- PhCONHi
,~ ph ~
The chemistry of taxol
PhCONH
= O
)hCONH O O NHCOPh
Ph HO
OH OH
x. \(c.d" . o,
tBuLI -~ ~ ~ , ~ t-BuOOH
TllOIPr)4
O
O ~ BF'J'EtzO
1. LDA/TMSCI
~2. PhSeCI ~PDC
-3. H202 ~OMF
4. MeOH/K2CO2
HO
I 1. BrCH2CHBrOCHs
2. BusSnH, AIBN/PhNMe2
1. CH3COOOH
1. OMe 1.(CHs)aC(OCHs)2TsOH I~ 2. TI(OIPr)4
M"O × 2. But~aSlTf, pyrldlne
"L K.CO._ MmOH
O" 2. H aO O O 3. K2
~ Sml2, THF
1. L
X 1" FeCh' Ac20 X 2. mCPBA
2. NaOCH:, CHsOH 3. Bu4NF
~
O O ~,, O O .~ Ace OAc
~. I 3. T~40, pyrldlne 4. HCI ~ ~
~ 4. t-BueNa, THF 5. Ac20, pyrldlne
elm
Ac,O~
'O'rBS O
).4 D.G.I. KINGSTON
;tage whether the synthesis could be modified in an epoxide rings. These experiments do not
appropriate way. Thus, although it is likely that the hypothesis that the taxane skeleton l ; b I U I ] I I
9accatin III will ultimately yield to total synthesis, it from verticillene-type intermediates, since sinc( cycli2
i ss also quite unlikely that a commercially feasible tions of this type can be quite sensitive to the actt
sy;ynthetic route to taxol will be developed before the conditions. They do suggest, however, that tha the bi
end of this century. genetic sequence is much more subtle than l9reviou, r ....
S /
I
The chemistry of taxol
H H
HO " '"
been carded out. Acid hydrolysis of taxine Studies of the biotransformation of taxol are only
yields (3R)-dimethylamino-3-phenylpropionic acid just beginning to appear. Analysis of taxol in human
(Winterstein's acid) (Baxter et al., 1962), and biosyn- plasma obtained as part of clinical studies has been
thetic studies on this acid, which is related to the taxol carded out in three cases. In the first two cases
side chain, have been carried out by Leete and Bodem (Longnecker et al., 1987; Wiernik et al., 1987) no
(1966) and Haslam (Plattet aL, 1984). In T. baccata metabolites were detected. In the third case (Rizzo
phenylalanine serves as the best precursor of et al., 1990) a new peak eluting before taxol was
Winterstein's acid, and the bioconversion occurs detected in the plasma of a cancer patient by reverse
OH""
%o.
~.6 D . G . I . KINGSTON
. A
t, c .--
OR OR
AcO OR OR
AcO OR OR
AcO OI
Me2NH O
o
i il I "\
h ~ O , ,:, ' I %"~
' = or"
'/OH HO OCOR
=
HO - - OCOR N'~OH %ell 3
AoO O OH
PhCONH O
°
Ph : OH =
HO OCOPh
phase HPLC. This peak was not due to 7-epitaxol, in Fig. 50; other metabolites appeared also to be
since this elutes after taxol, and it was thus assumed hydroxylated taxols, but their precise structures were
to be due to a new and as yet unidentified metabolite not elucidated.
o f taxol. Treatment of taxol with cell culture media
in the presence or absence of cells does however
convert it in part to 7-epitaxol (Ringel and Horwitz, 6. S T R U C T U R E - A C T I V I T Y RELATIONSHIPS
1987). Thus taxol was approximately 50% converted c ~ T Ax,c~T r ~ i v AT T V ~
the cell culture medium of the J774-2
z2 hr, but the conversion is reversible Discussi(
was partially converted to taxol under taxol deriw
tions, many differ
of taxol in rat bile has been described the various
~t al. (1990). These workers found that that the nt
e injected taxol was recovered in urine, assays, evel
and no urinary metabolites were detected. On the depend on the exact conditions of the as
other hand, over 40% of the injected taxol was found major classes of assay have been used.
in rat bile, either unchanged or as one of the nine (1) Microtubule assembly assays. Th
metabolites detectable by HPLC. Baccatin III was the mechanism of action of taxol is as an
only metabolite that had lost the ester side chain; the agent. Unlike other plant-derived antirr
other metabolites all appeared to have intact side agents such as colchicine, podophyllotoxi
f these metabolites were identified as vinca alkal,
ed taxol derivatives V and VI shown taxol actua
The chemistry of taxol
OCOPh M
Compound R~ R2 R3 R,
1 Baccatin III OH OAc = O OH 52 1.3 1.7 x I,
2 10-Deacetylbaccatin III OH OH =O OH 46 1.0 4 x I(
3 7-Acetyl-10-deacetylbaccatin III OH OH =O OAc 82 0.9
4 7-Acetylbaccatin III OH OAc =O OAc 384
5 10-Deacetylbaccatin V OH OH =O ~t-OH 250 3.3
6 I 0-Deacetyl- 13-oxobaccatin III =O OH =O OH 350 5.3
7 10-Deacetvl-
yl- 1l l,
l. 12-dihvdro- 11-
12-dihydro- 11-
/-13-oxobaccatin III =O OH =O OH
~tylbaccatinIII OAc OAc =O OAc
VI OAc OAc fl-Ac OAc
yl-10-oxobaccatin Ill OH = 0 = 0 OH
xybaccatin I
~ybaccatin III
g". . . . :- ~....:- bTT.:---- *..'h~..l'.-- C.--~ ID[. . . . . . . . . . . . i ..... L--t
The chemistry of taxol
TABLE 3. Tubulin Assembly Activity of lO-Deacetyltaxol Derivatives with Modified Side Chains"
HO .0 OH
Bioactivity
".-,t'l Tubulin-
disassembly Cytotoxicity
a R4 PhCO0
inhibition P388
No. Rl R2 R3 R4 iC5o~, b EC~o~l
1 PhCONH H OH H 1.3
2 H PhCONH H OH 4
3 OH H CONH H l0
4 H OH H PhCONH 170
5e PhCONH H H OH 1.3
6d H PhCONH OH H 1.3
7 H H H H 17
8 H H OH H 4.5
9 H H H OH 3.5
I0 d H ButOCONH H H 2.3
11d ButOCONH H H H 4.1 12
12 TsNH H OH H 5
13 OH H "sNH H 15
14 ButOCONH H OH H 0.5 0.13
15 H ButOCC H OH 30 > 10
16 OH H IJU'UIJUN
)CONH 1"1 H 10 4
17 H OH H ButOCONH 160
18d ButOCONH H H OH 1.8
19d H ButOCONH OH H 4.3
20d NH 2 H H OH 30
21 d H NH2 OH H 30
(CH2)3CONH H OH H 1
CbH4CONH H OH H 5.5 >4
H R3 R2 H 23
25c OH H OH H 3
aData from Gurritte-Voegelein et al. (1991). blCs0 = concentration of drug leading to a 50*/, inhibition of the rate of
mammalian microtubule disassembly. IC50~ = ICso/IC~0(taxol). IC50 for taxol = 0.5/aM. Numbers larger than unity thus
correspond to less active analogs, cEC~0= concentration of drug leading to 50*/, inhibition in the amount of cell growth.
ECs0~'l= ECs0/ECs0(taxol). ECs0 for taxol = 0.27/~g/mL. dThe structures of each pair of erythro compounds may be
reversed. CThreo compounds: 2'R YS + 2'S,3'R.
et al., 1984), with at least one baccatin III derivative units o f / z g / m L , while the J774-2 d a t a are expressed
y 3) being m o r e active t h a n taxol in u n i t s o f p
.urn tubulin. The reason for this m a j o r can be sign
t k n o w n , b u t it is apparently not due and withou
actors such as the different conditions T h e tub~
ably o f the two tubulins. It is thus derived p r
the binding site o n Physarum micro- Gu~ritte-Vc
,~ t o l e r a n t t h a n the c o r r e s p o n d i n g site Voegelein
o n m a m m a l i a n tubulin. However However, baccatin
baccatln III 111 a n d its (Swmdell et al., 1991). The m a j o r conclu
(Swindell
derivatives were m u c h less cytotoxic t h a n taxol can be derived from a study o f these data,
towards Physarum or Plasmodium a m o e b a l cultures, n a t i o n with the scantier cytotoxicity d a t a
so either the baccatin derivatives are n o t available to eated below.
tubulin u n d e r these in vivo conditions or o t h e r factors (1) Some activity is retained even with s
are involved, t h a t are very different from t h a t o f taxol.
t r u n c a t e d si
activities wi
DE CHAIN MODIFIED ANALOGS
tubulin ass
tata o n taxols modified in the C-13 cytotoxicity
I is summarized in Tables 2-3. Table 322-fold.
Ltion o n t u b u l i n assembly or disassem- (2) The
30 D . G . I . KINGSTON
2-4-fold less active in the tubulin-assembly assay and from the 2'-hydroxyl group (compound 8
12-fold less active in the cytotoxicity assay. The 3'-butoxycarbamate group (compound 10 u1 tm).
2'-(t-butyldimethylsilyl) taxol derivative (Table 2, A comparison of cytotoxicity data with wit tubu
~ntry 4) is very much less cytotoxic than taxol, but'
entr assembly or disassembly activity is instructiveinstructi (Tab
this may be due to the steric bulk of the silyl group
this 2 and 3). The major conclusions to emerlge from
rather than the loss of the free hydroxyl group,
rather study of these data are that the activities of ( most
(3) The 3'-phenyl group appears to contribute to the analogs broadly parallel their tubulin-astubulin-asseml
~mbly
the overall activity of taxol. Although no close -disassembly activities. As an example, th the six s~
analogs were prepared, the lactic acid derivatives thetic analogs prepared by Swindell et al. ((195
(Table 2 compounds 10 and 11) are about one half (Table 2, entries 10-15) show the same trends in i t
as active as the corresponding phenyllactates (com- J774.2 cell culture assay as they do in the tubuli tul
pounds 12 and 13). The p-hydroxyp] tive assembly assay, although the magnitude of t
24 (Table 2) is slightly more activ ulin changes is larger in the cell culture assay. SimilaJ
disassembly inhibitor than taxol, but it is less cyto- four 10-deacetyltaxol analogs (Table 3, entries ent 14-1
toxic than taxol. 23) have cytotoxicities which broadly pallrallel th
(4) The 3'-N-benzoyl group can be replaced with tubulin-disassembly activities. The major excepti
other N-acyl groups with little loss of activity to this rule occurs in the case of 2'-acyl dderivativ
(cephalomannine, Table 2, entry 3) or with an in- which are hydrolyzed in vivo to the correspondi corr
crease in activity y ((Table 2, entry "y 19)
19). T-hydroxyl~ydroxyl comrcompound. Such derivatives are al not ve
(5) Removal of the 3'-N-benzoyl 1 s in potent tubulin disassembly inhibitors, but they
loss of activity (Table 2, entry 23). It n at quite cytotoxic (Table 2, entry 2). This cytotoxicity
this time whether a ccarboxamide
[ l e t :a ~Eoox~tmlue glI U L I p Lt:~ ~ L I ~ IhI l~i
~ is greatly
~ reduced if the T-hydroxyl group is convert
[ I ; ~ t l y 1~(.11
tivity,
essential for activit ' but the relatively good activity to a hydro ydrolytically stable group such as a t-but
of the desamino no derivatives 12 and 13 (Table 2) dimethylsil'. Lylsilyl ether (Table 2, entry 4), although
her groups could provide activity,
suggest that other noted earlier earlic it is possible that the steric bulk of tl
(6) The naturere of the polar groups at C-2' and C-3' group also has a negative effect on activity.
to a surprising extent without major These resultsre have been discussed in terms
Thus the 2',3'-diol (Table 3, entry 25) molecular modeling i of the taxol side chain (Swind
less active than taxol in the tubulin- et al. 1991 ). The major conclusion reached by the
disassembly assay, and compounds with the 2'- and authors is that the conformation of the side chain is
3'-groups interchanged can still show some (albeit not strongly influenced by the taxane skeleton, and
reduced) activity; this loss appears however to be they propose that the taxol recognition site on micro-
greater in cytotoxicity than in tubulin-disassembly tubules possesses a hydrophobic cleft designed to
activity (Table 2, entries 17 and 21). accept a side chain with its functionality preorganized
(7) The stereochemistry at C-2' makes an import- by stereochemistry and hydrogen bonding to re-
ant contribution to activity. In a model series this semble that of taxotere 8.
effect is more pronounced when there is an amide The fact that baccatin III analogs have the same
3' (Table 2, entries 14 and 15) than affinity as
ot (Table 2, entries 12 and 13). In the also been d
however, the effect is rather variable. These auth
-deacetyl series (Table 3) inversion at tubulin inv
o difference to tubulin disassembly followed b)
there is an N-benzoyl group present by specific
nd 6) but reduces activity by either
4-fold or 8-IOld when there is
d ' an N-t-BOC
/V-t-l~OCS group, 6.3. RING MODIFIEDANALOGS
depending on which of the structures shown as 18 and
19 has which activity. Data on taxol analogs modified on the !
(8) A major stereochemical effect is observed when system are shown in Table 4. The major c
the 2'- and 3'-groups are interchanged. The com- to emerge from these data are as follows
pound with the natural configuration (Table 2, entry (1) Acylation at C-7 (entries 8, 12)
aore active in the tubulin disassembly significantl,
one with the unnatural configuration of taxol.
(2) Atta(
ge in activity for certain modifications slightly inc
additive, at least in some cases. Thus activity (en
vity in going from compound 7 (Table (3) Rem
The chemistry of taxol
Cytotoxicity
Tubulin
disassembly J774.2 KB
No. Compound iCs0~l a ECsor~lb ECs0~I b Ref
1 Taxol 1.0 1.0 1.0 c,d,e,f
2 Cephalomannine 1.5 1.4 3.2 c,g,f
3. 10-Deacetyltaxol 1.3, 3.5 2.8 22 c,g,h,i
4 4-Deacetylcephalomannine 4.2 26 g,h
5 lO-Deacetyl-7-epitaxol 3.5 28 h,j
6 lO-Deacetyl-7-epicephalomanni 38 h
7 7-Epitaxol 3.0 1.5 3.0 j,k
8 7-Acetyltaxol 2.0 1.3 400 d,e,l,n
9 7-Xylosyltaxol 0.4 d
10 10-Deacetyl-7-xylosyltaxol 0.6 d
11 7-Xylosylcephalomannine 0.5 d
12 7-Glutaryltaxol 1 i
13 7,10-Diglutaryltaxotere 2 i
14 7,10-Diglycyltaxotere 1.2 i
15 7-(Phenylalanyl)taxotere 1 i
16 2',7-Diacetyltaxol 11.4 g
17 2',7-Diacetyl- 10-deacetyltaxol 2.8 g
18 2-Debenzoyl-2-(3-hydroxybenzc
. . . . . j - - ~- -.j . . . . . .,, . . . . . . j - / . . . . . . 1 41 n o
19 7-Oxotaxol > 103 m
20 2'-Acetyl-7-oxotaxol > 105 m
21 2',7-Dioxotaxol >106 m
22 10-Oxo- 10-deacetyltaxol > 103 k
23 Lactone (Fig. 27) > 105 m
24 20.O-secotaxol
~ecotaxol (Fig. 31) >21 > 105 m
chloride product (Fig. 31) > 105 m
-*l)abeotaxol (Fig. 32) 3 > 105 m
alCs0 = concentration of drug leading to a 50% inhibition of the rate of mammalian microtubule disassembly.
ICs0'°~= ICs0/ICso(taxol). IC50 for taxol = 0.5#M. Numbers larger than unity thus correspond to less active analogs.
bECso = concentration of drug leading to 50% inhibition in the amount of cell growth. ECs0~l= ECs0/ECso(taxol) in the
indicated cell line. ECs0 data for taxol: KB 1 x 10-5 ltg/mL; J774.2 9 x 10-2/~mol/L. ¢Chauvi6re et al. (1981). dLataste et
al. (1984). eMellado et al. (1984). fMiller et al. (1981). gParness et al. (1982). hMcLaughlin et al. (1981). iGu6ritte-Voegelein
et al. (1991). JRingel and Horwitz (1987). kHuang et aL (1986). IChenu et al. (1987). "Kingston et al. (1990). nln LI210
lymphocytic leukemia. °Monsarrat et al. (1990).
disassembly activity and cytotoxicity, so clearly there (8) Contraction of ring A does not reduce the
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
No.
F~iO. Compound Tumor* T/C (dose) b Re
1 Taxol P388 157(20) 149 (5) c
BI6 283(5) 254(25) c
MX-I CRa(15)-84(10) CR(6.7) e
LI210 131 (20) c
2 Cephalomannine P388 152-180(1-3.3) f
3 10-Deacetyltaxol P388 135 (16) g
4 10-Deacetyleephalomannine P388 130 (16) g
5 Taxotere ® P388 > 175 h
LI210 > 150 h
B16 > 150 h
6 2'-Acetyltaxol P388 140(20) 130(I0) i
7 7-Acetyltaxol P388 130(26) 127(13) i
8 2',7-Diacetyltaxol P388 104 (40) 100 (20) i
2'-Substituted taxols: 2'-substituent
9 CO(CH2)NH 3+ H C O 0 - P388 153(40) 140(40), 138(20) j
10 CO(CH2)2COOH P388 129 (44) 122 (22) j
11 CO(CH2)2COOH BI6 185(40) 154(20) 154(5) j
12 CO(CH2)COONa BI6 218(40) 201 (20) 154(2.5) j
13 CO(CH2)2COO - HN + (CH2CH2OF BI6 314 (27) 230 (7) j
14 CO(CH2)2COO-N-methylglucamm BI6 241 (50) 176 (25) 134 (12.5) j
15 CO(CHz)3COONa nl6 339(49) 192(12) 159(6) j
16 CO(CH2)3COO
~tSLR)- HN
HI~ +
~ (CH2CH2OI-
[L;H2t;I-12UH)3 Bi6 300(53) 291 (13) 207(7) j
17 CONH(CH2)3N(CH3)2HCI
CO(CH2)3CONH(CH2)3N(CH3)21 BI6 352(20) 352(10) 188(5)
18 COCH2N(CH3) 2 MX-I CR (20) CR (13)-53 (8.9)
19 COCH2CH2N(CH2CH3)2HC1 MX-I CR(18) CR(9) CR(4.5)
2',7-Disubstituted
)stituted taxols: substituent
20 CO(CH2)2COOH BI6 114(44) 105(22) 124(11) j
COONa BI6 166(44) 109(22) 149(11) j
,ted taxols: substituent
(CH3)2 MX-I CR (33) - 9 3 (16.5) 23 8.2) e
aTumor system used: P388 lymphocytic leukemia, LI210 lymphoid leukemia, BI6 melanoma, or MX-I mammary
xenograft, as indicated, bT/C values for P388, B16, and LI210 are expressed as median lifetime of test animals divided by
the median lifetime of control animals, times 100. T/C values for MX-1 are expressed as (change in treated tumor
weight/initial tumor weight) times 100 for tumors that regress. The dose (in mg/kg) is given in brackets. °Suffness and Cordell
(1985). dCR = complete remission. 'Stella and Mathew (1990). fMiller et al. (1981). mMcLaughlin et al. (1981). hLavelle et
al. (1989). iMagri and Kingston (1988). JDeutsch et al. (1989).
understand more fully those features o f the taxol and the functional groups of O-cinnamoyltaxicin-I.
molecule which are necessary for activity. J. chem. Soc. 2964-2971.
BEGL~, M.
Total syn!
L4. ANIMAL TEST DATA to the ta
4907-4924
e animal test data on taxol and its BLECXF.aT,S
nmarized in Table 5. The major point The Alkal
Lthese data is that some T-substituted pp. 195-23
CARDELLINA,
~etter activity in the B16 m e l a n o m a cephaloma
system than taxol. This is particularly true o f the CAS~LL^NO,E. E. and HODDER, O. J. R. (1973)
glutaryl amide derivative prepared by Deutsch et al. and molecular structure of the diterpenoid b~
(1989) (entry 17). Diacylation at C-2' and C-7 did not naturally occurring oxetan with a taxane sk~
give useful activity, however (entries 20, 21). Crystallogr. Sect. B 29:. 2566-2570.
C H A N , W . R . , H A L S A L L , T. G., H O R N B Y , G. IV
A . W . , SABEL, W . , BJAMER, K . , F E R G U S O N , G . a
Acknowledgements--I thank my coworkers who have SON, J. M. (1966) Taxa-4(16),ll-diene-5,,,
-L--~J __.:.t --__ . L . . . . .
-". . . . . . . .
the excitement ofr our
..... J~ . . . . .
studies tr .
on this . . .
tetraol, .
a . . . . . . .
~FIRISTEN,A. A., BLAND,J. and GImON, D. M. (1989) Cell HOLTON,R. A. (1984) Synthesis of the taxane tit
culture as a means to produce taxol. Proc. Am. Ass. J. Am. chem. Soc. 106: 5731-5732.
Cancer Res. 30: 566. HOLTON, R. A., JuG, R. R., KIM, H. B., WILLIAMS,WlLLLM A. I~
.7.OLIN, M., GLr~NARD, D., GUI~RITTE-VOEGELFAN,F. and HARUSAWA,S., LOWENTHAL,R. E. and Yogin, S. S (1988)
POTIE~, P. (1988) Preparation of taxol derivatives as synthesis of taxusin. J. Am. chem. Soc. 110:66558-656q
antitumor agents. Eur. Pat. Appl. EP253738 AI, 20 Jan., HUANG,C. H. O., KINGSTON, D. G. I., MAOm, MAGI N. F
1988. SAMARANAYAKE, G. and BoETrNER, F. E. (1! 1986) Ne
DAUBEN, W. G,, HUBBELL, J. P., OBERHANSLI, P. and taxanes from Taxus br~ifolia, 2. J. nat. Prod Prod. 4!
THIESSEN,W. E. (1979) Acid-catalyzed cyclization of cem- 665-669.
brene and isocembrol, d. org. Chem. 44: 669-673. IUPAC C o m I o N ON Tim NO~CLATUm~ OF ORGANI ORe
DEAMIcIS, C. V. (1988) Insertion reactions of oxacarbenes C'~mSTRY (1978) Nomenclature of Organic Chemis~ (Chem
generated photochemicaUy from eyclobutanones. Ph.D. .q~tion F:
Section I~. Natural
M~ttur:~l P r ~ u e t t rand
Products R,=latod Compo~
and Related ("n ~ound
Dissertation, Stanford University. Eur. Y. Biochem. 86: 1-8.
DELLA CASADE MARCANO,D. P. and HAI~ )75)JAZIRI,M., DIALLO, B. M., V,~at~LEN, M. H., VANH~
Structures of some taxane diterpenoi~ .III, LEN-FJ~ra£, R. J., ZHL~, A., BECU,A. G. and HOMES,
-IV -VI, and -VII and l-dehydroxybac~ ess- (1991) Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for
ing an oxetan ring. J. chem. Soe. Chem. Commun. detection and semi-quantitative determination of taxar
365-366. diterpenoids related to taxol in Taxus sp. and tisst
DENIS, J.-N., GREENE,A. E., SERRA,A. A. and L u g , M.-J. cultures. J. Pharm. Belg. 46: 93-99.
(1986) An efficient, enantioselective synthesis of the taxol JITRANGSRI,C. (1986) Approaches to the synthesis c
side chain. J. org. Chem. 51: 46-50. modified taxols. Ph.D. Dissertation, Virginia F Polytechn
DENIS, J.-N., GREENE, A. E., GUI~NARD, D., Institute and State University.
GU~RITTE-VOEGELEIN,F., MANGATAL,L. and POTIER, P. KINGSTON,D. G. I., HAWKINS, D. R. and OVB4GTON, Gel I
(1988) Highly efficient, practical appt aral (1982)New taxanes from Taxus brevifolia. J. nat. Pr~
taxol. J. Am. chem. Soc. I10:5917-591 45: 466470.
DENIS, J.-N., CORREA, A. and GREENE, An KINGSTON,D. G. I., SAM~L~NAYAK~,G. and IVEY, C. J
improved synthesis
hesls of
ot the taxol side
sloe ¢chain and ot RP (1990)The chemistry of taxol, a clinically useful ant
56976. J. org. Chem. SS: 1957-1959. cancer agent. J. nat. Prod. 53: 1-12.
DEUTSCH, H. M., GLINSKI, J. A., HERNANDEZ, M., KINGSTON, D G. I., GUNAT1LAKA,A. A. L. and IVEYC. /
r, D.
HAUGWITZ, R. D., NARAYANAN,V. L., SUFFNI/SS,M. and (1992a) Modified
M( taxols. 7. A method for the separatic
ZALKOW, L. H.• (1989) Synthesis of congeners and pro- of taxol and cephalomannine, jr. nat. Prod., in press.
drugs.
.o. . 3.. Water-soluble
. er-soluble
. prodrugs of taxol with potent KINGSTON, E D. G. I., MOLINERO, A. A. and RIMOLDI,
vity. J. reed. Chem. 32: 788-792. (1992b) The I"1 taxane diterpenoids. In: Progress in tl
GRIN,T., SUMIMOTO,M. and MORRISON,A. Chemistry •y of Organic Natural Products, HERZ,W., GlUS
11ol, a novel type of conifer diterpene. BACH, H., KmsY,] G. W. and TAMIVl,CH. (edS) Springe
Tetrahedron Len. 3879-3886. Vienna, in press.
ETTOUATI, L., AHOND, A., CONVERT, O., LAURENT, D., KURONO,M., NAKADAmA,Y., OmJMA, S., SASAKI, K. and
POUPAT, C. and POTmR, P. (1988) Plantes de Nouvelle- NAKAmsm, K. (1963) Taxinine. Tetrahedron Lett.
Caledonie. 114. Taxanes Isol6s des Feuilles d'Austrotaxus 2153-2160.
spicata compton (Taxac~es). Bull. Soc. chim. Fr. 749-755. LATASTE,H., Sl~ImLH,V., WRIGHT, M., GU~NARD,D. and
ETTOUAT1, L., AHOND, A., CONVERT,O., POUPAT, C. and PoTmt, P. (1984) Relationships between the structure of
POTIER, P. (1989) Plantes de NouveUe-Caledonie. 124. taxol and baccatine III derivatives and their in vitro action
Taxanes Isoles des 6corces de tronc d'Austrotaxus spicata on the disassembly of mammalian brain and Physarum
compton (Taxac6es). Bull. Soc. chim. Ft. 5: 687-694. amoebal microtubules. Proc. nam. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 81:
FILLION, H. (1990) 5-Hydroxy-l,8-naphthalene carbolac- 4090--4094.
tion by the taxol "side chain"• Pharmazie LAVELLE, F
GUtN~dtD,
HANSELL, G., PATEL, B. P. and SWINDELL, ties of RP5
Oxabicyclobutonium ions can intervene in Res. 30: 5(
and 3-oxetanyl solvolyses. J. Am. chem. L~TE, E. an
-3539. 3-dimethyl
LEIN, F., SI~NILH,V., DAVID, B., GUI~NARD, hedronLet
, P. (1986) Chemical studies of 10-deacetyl LONGNECKER
-Iemisynthesis of taxol derivatives. Tetra- T.-L., BRU
hedron 42: 4451-4460. D.S. and COLVIN, M. (1987) High-perform~
GUI~RITTE-VOEGELEIN, F., GLr~NARD, D. and POTmR, P. chromatographic assay for taxol in human !
(1987) Taxol and derivatives: a biogenetic hypothesis, urine and pharmacokinetics in a phase I tr
J. nat. Prod. 50: 9-18. Treat. Rep. 71: 53-59.
GU~RITTE-VOEGELEIN, F., GLrI~NARD, D., MANGATAL, L., LUCAS, H. (1856) Ueber ein in den Blatteru
POTIER, P., GUILHFM,J., CESAmO, M. and PAscAm3, C. baccata U enthaltenes Alkaloid (das Taxin). A
(1990) Structure of a synthetic taxol precursor: N-tert- 85: 145-149.
d- 10-dcacetyl-N-debenzoyltaxol. Acta LY'mGOE,B.
~6: 78!-784. Chemistry
LEIN, F., GUI~NARD, D., LAVELLE, F., R . H . F . (¢
"., MANGATAL,L. and POT~, P. (1991) MAGm,N. F
between the structure of taxol analogues Ph.D. Dis
nitotic activity. J. reed. Chem. 34: 992-998. State Univ
and LVTHOOE,B. (1966) Taxine. Part III. A MAGal, N. I
ore for the neutral frao-ment from O- taxnls. 2 (
;4 D . G . I . KINGSTON