Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTERNATIONAL
SATELLITES
INTERNATIONAL
JOSEPH N. PELTON
JOHN HOWKINS
Associate Editor
Janet Greco
S
M
TOCKTON
P R E S S
©Macmillan Publishers Limited, 1987
Softcover reprint of the hardcover 1st edition 1987 978-0-333-39499-1
All rights reserved. No part of the publication
may be reproduced or transmitted, in any form
or by any means, without permission.
Satellites International
Includes index.
1. Artificial satellites in telecommunication. 2. Artificial satellites in telecommunication- Directories. I.
Pelton, Joseph N. II. Hawkins, John, 1945- . III. Greco, Janet
TK5104.S376 1987 621.38'0422 87-6507
ISBN 978-0-935859-07-2 (Stockton Press)
Pelton, Joseph N.
Satellites International.
1. Artificial Satellites
I. Title II. Hawkins, John
629.47 TL796
SECTION I
SECTION II
Intelsat 119
Intersputnik 128
Inmarsat 130
EDITORS' FOREWORD
Satellites International represents an ambitious undertaking. Richard Butler, Secretary General of the International Tele-
It is an attempt to compile within a single reference source the communication Union; Dean Burch, Director General of
world's most complete, most authoritative and most systema- Intelsat; Albert 'Bud' Wheelan, President of the Hughes
tic treatment of satellites. This volume covers not only Aircraft Company Space and Communications Group; Oliver
communications satellites, but all types of applications satel- Robinson, Executive Director of the International Press
lites from all over the world. The best way to achieve this Telecommunications Council, and many, many more.
objective was obvious. We had to go to the world's leading Another challenge in the preparation of Satellites Interna-
experts, wherever they were - in Europe, in Japan, in tional was to have two editors an ocean apart and contributors
Canada, in the United States and around the world- and then from several continents. Nevertheless, by using express mail
to persuade them to collaborate on this ambitious effort. and especially satellite telephone calls, telexes and facsimile,
Surprisingly, they all agreed. this project was not only started but also finished in a little
The list of contributors is long and impressive. It includes over one year.
SECTION I
1 A USER-FRIENDLV INTRODUCTION TO SATELLITES
This section presents a basic overview of how satellites work. Starting with natural satellites and
the gravitational physics that govern their operation, one learns here about the nuts and bolts of
both natural and artificial satellites. Leaving aside highly technical jargon, satellites are explained
in layman's terms. In short, if you want to know more about why satellites are important, then this
is the place to start.
Mention satellites, rockets and space, and most people start Earth's surface. The Moon's velocity, about 3,600 kilometers
visualizing exotic and complex astra-technologies complete per hour (2,250 mph), allows it to make one revolution about
with space-helmeted super heroes like Buck Rogers, Flash every 27 days - thus completing one rotation and one
Gordon, or at the very least, the more sedate Dr Who. To revolution around the Earth in a lunar month. The angular
most people, the technology seems extremely difficult to momentum of the Moon creates a centrifugal force that
understand. It isn't easy, but it's not impossible to learn. equalizes the centripetal force of the Earth's gravity, keeping
Satellites and the key related technologies can be understood the orbit stable. Like a whirling pail at the end of a rope that
without a Ph.D in electronic engineering or astrophysics. keeps a perfect circle - the Moon is compelled to circle the
First, we'll start with the basics and work our way up from Earth.
there. We'll start with what are satellites? Why do we need The force of the Earth's gravity diminishes as one moves
them? What can satellites do that terrestrial communications away from Earth, thus the tug of gravity is much less than one
and sensing systems cannot do? Why are they placed into percent of the force that would apply if the Moon lay directly
different types of orbit? What are their strong points and on the Earth's surface. The Moon, of course, tugs back on the
weak points? Earth's surface. This is why we have daily tides- as the Moon
Armed with this basic knowledge, you should be well- 'pushes' and 'pulls' the oceans' waters. Billions of years ago
equipped to learn a great deal more about the critical role when the Moon was much closer to Earth, the Moon's pull
that satellites play in a $17 trillion global electronic economy, was much greater and thus 30-metre (100 foot) high tidal
and why satellites are truly instrumental in our complex and waves were commonplace.
increasingly international world. The Moon also happens to rotate on its axis one time as it
Satellites today bring us accurate weather forecasts, they makes one revolution around the Earth. This is why we never
help us spot crop disease, trace and rescue crashed pilots, see the far side of the Moon. (As a quibble to accuracy, we do
provide medical service, educate millions of students in over time manage to see around 6 to 7 percent of the far side
remote villages and link together world leaders during times since there is some wobble in the Moon's axis in addition to
of strategic crises. These amazing satellites also allow stock perturbations in the Moon's orbit. These perturbations occur
markets to trade freely around the world, and allow global because the Earth is not a perfect sphere and because the
television shows like the Olympic Games to reach two billion Sun's gravity is also part of the complex formula that governs
people. It seems incredible that only two decades ago Jive the Moon's orbit. Nevertheless, 93 percent of the Moon's far
transoceanic television broadcasts were not even possible. surface is permanently facing away from Earth.
Today, nearly half of the world's population can be linked But enough about the Moon. What about artificial or
together live via satellite at any time of the day or night. man-made satellites?
The basic physics that applies to natural satellites also
applies to artificial ones as well. Launch a satellite fast
WHAT IS A SA TEL LITE? enough and high enough and it will go into orbit in a manner
similar to the Moon. It takes more power and more speed to
There are only two basic types of satellites - natural and launch a satellite into a higher orbit than a low one. The
artificial (or man-made). Natural satellites in our solar system rotational speed of the Earth, which is at its maximum at the
are numerous. Although Earth has only one natural satellite, equator, helps achieve its orbital speed. This is why launch
Jupiter and Saturn have over 25 between them. With new centres tend to be located as near as possible to 0 degrees
exploratory satellite missions going to the outer limits of our latitude in places like Kourou, French Guiana or Cape
solar system, the number of known natural satellites is likely Canaveral, Florida.
to keep increasing. The recent Uranus 'fly-by' encounter, for Although we may think of outer space and satellites as a
example, conducted by NASA's Voyager 2 in 1985, enor- new thing, the idea of orbiting a man-made object around the
mously increased what we know about the Solar System. Earth is hardly a new idea. The first astronaut, according to
But let's start with the most familiar natural satellite that Chinese legend, was a twelfth-century tinkerer and fireworks
we all know quite well, our Moon. expert. His idea was to mount a gross of rockets affixed to a 12
This ancient satellite has revolved around the Earth for by 12 grid and ride his fiery steed into immortality in an
billions of years and is now in a relatively stable circular orbit incendiary blaze of glory. And Sir Isaac Newton puzzled not
roughly 385,000 kilometers (240,000 miles) away from the only about gravity, but orbital mechanics too. Sir Isaac's own
1
Satellites International
illustration of how a cannon aimed at the right angle and updated information from space and a network of such
armed with enough brute explosive power shows how he satellites can instantaneously pin-point locations anywhere in
envisioned a projectile being placed into orbit. the Earth's surface or in the atmosphere where aeroplanes
Design and mechanical considerations apart, they both had fly.
basically the right idea. Much about space applications, past, present and future,
Today, we have high-speed electronic computers that derives from literature that foretold actual events by many
calculate precise orbits to guide our rockets into space. Our years, and sometimes many centuries, ahead of the technol-
staged rockets allow us to lift large masses of equipment into ogy. Edward Everett Hale, a nineteenth-century American
orbit with great efficiency, compared with the single rocket, author, described the orbital logic explained above in his
which must be returned intact to the Earth's surface. Without book, The Brick Moon. In it, a large brick moon inhabited by
this staging process, which allows one rocket to be placed on over 30 men, three women and palm trees was used for
top of another, man would still be trying to reach the moon, navigation, much as the US Navy's Navstar system is used
rather than be able to say that he'd been there and back in today. Communication with the Earth consisted of choreog-
1969. raphed manoeuvres whereby the crew jumped up and down
Once vou decide to launch a satellite into orbit, there are to create Morse Code signals. Hale's nineteenth-century ideas
lots of things to consider. For instance, what is the satellite's about space must seem bizarre today, or at least quaint.
mission, and what orbit is best suited to the task? There are Nevertheless, Edward Everett Hale's tale of the brick moon
many different types of orbits. Some are good for navigation, is not simply a historical curiosity, as we have seen, it
others for communications, yet others for Earth sensing. As a preceded later developments.
general rule of thumb, as the orbit gets higher, more money The third major type of orbit is a single, very precise orbit
and power are needed for a successful launch. Because of known as the geosynchronous or geostationary orbit (also
this, there is a tendency to use a low Earth orbit (sometimes know as GSO). This is sometimes also known as the Clarke
referred to as LEO) if it can do the job. Unfortunately, some orbit, after Arthur C. Clarke who discovered it. Again, the
of the most useful orbits for important applications like idea is a simple one. For most planetary bodies there is a
communications require orbits far away from the Earth's single magic orbit that meets these two conditions: a stable
surface. circular orbit and an orbital speed that exactly matches the
speed of rotation of the planetary body. For the Earth, this
means a satellite in an orbit that is 35,786 kilometres above
WHAT ORBITS ARE BEST? the Earth's surface (or 42,165 kilometres from the Earth's
centre) which also maintains an orbital velocity of 3,075
Generally speaking, there are four types of orbits \Yhich metres per second. This precise orbit allows a satellite to
might be appropriately used today for satellite applications, complete one revolution around the Earth every 24 hours.
even though there are exceptions to this rule. These four There are several reasons why one might wish that the
orbits are : geostationary or Clarke orbit was closer to the Earth's
• low Earth orbit (typically 500 kilometres or less than 300 surface. For communications there would be less delay
miles); associated with sending the signal to the satellite and back.
• medium Eearth orbit (typically 500 kilometres or 7,000 to Furthermore, if the orbit was closer to Earth you would be
8,000 miles above Earth); able to use less power to overcome 'path loss' associated with
• geosynchronous or geostationary Earth orbit (exactly targetting your transmission to a point out in space about
35,786.3 kilometres/22,238 miles); one-tenth of the way to the Moon. But the laws of physics are
• and super-synchronous orbits (sometimes known as cislu- not to be denied. The careful balance of gravity, orbital
nar orbits) which represent orbital locations 'above' the velocity, and rotational speed of a planet produce only one
geosynchronous orbit and 'below' the lunar orbit. such orbit for any planetary body. The Moon, for instance,
Of course, in space, terms like above or below are rather has its lunarstationary orbit; Mars and Venus likewise have
meaningless and phrases like 'in' and 'out' from Earth convey theirs. Phoebus, one of the two tiny natural satellites of Mars,
much more meaning. has a stationary orbital speed that could be achieved using a
Low Earth orbits, because they are the easiest and least baseball and a bat. Someday, we may find useful applications
expensive to achieve, are used most. The US Space Shuttle for the stationary orbits of other planets, asteriods or natural
(the official name is Space Transportation System, or STS) is satellites associated with communications or sending mined
capable of launching a satellite directly into a low Earth orbit, materials back to Earth.
or it can capture a satellite in this orbit and return it to the The advantages of having a satellite fixed in a stationary
Earth for repair. The possible applications and scientific uses orbit with respect to the Earth's surface occured to visionary
of this orbit include reconnaissance, weightlessness or thinkers long ago. An Austrian scientist and writer named
vacuum experiments, material processing and space manufac- Potocnik, who wrote under the name Hermann Noordung,
turing activities, localized weather and resource imaging, and first proposed the idea in Problems in Space Travel, pttblished
many others. in 1928. Noordung suggested that the geostationary orbit
The next class of orbits are considerably further out in might serve as a good location for a manned space station.
space and thus allow a much broader view of what is Even earlier, the Russian rocket theorist Konstantin Tsiol-
happening to Earth on a planetary scale. Medium orbit kovsky noted that a geostationary orbit existed for Earth but
satellites are typically launched into a polar orbit so that when failed to note its practical benefits.
a satellite passes over the Earth, it can be programmed to stay The first person to present a systematic proposal for
in the sun's illumination, which is important for remote creating a global communications satellite network for
sensing and weather monitoring. This type of orbit, which television and telecommunications which utilized the geosta-
allows one pass about every 90 minutes, is also particularly tionary orbit was Arthur C. Clarke, the British (now Sri
well-suited for navigational purposes. The logic of this type of Lankan) scientist and science fiction writer who first pre-
orbit and its efficiency for serving the entire world is relatively sented his ideas in Wireless World in 19~5. In many ways,
clear. Satellites in these types of orbits can quickly provide Arthur C. Clarke is today considered the father of the
2
A User-Friendly Introduction to Satellites
3
2 TRENDS IN SATELLITE COMMUNICATIONS
Albert Wheelan, President, Space and Communications Group and Executive Vice President, Hughes
Aircraft Company and Barry Miller, Senior Public Relations Executive, Hughes Aircraft Company
The rate of development of satellite communications over the last 20 years has been swift and
spectacular. International communications has increased by a factor of nearly one hundred in two
decades, largely as a result of satellites. Nearly 170 countries use domestic satellite television,
radio, telephone, and/or data services. Costs have fallen, satellite lifetimes have expanded and
technological innovations have come quickly. To appreciate how far satellites have come and
where they are going, we asked two executives of the aerospace organization that designed and
built most of the communications satellites in the world today to tell us their views.
INTRODUCTION
Recent years have witnessed dramatic changes in telecom- at the leading edge of space technology. Intelsat was the first
munications. These are nowhere more apparent than in the to use synchronous spacecraft for commercial service (Intel-
communications satellite sector. The sudden change from a sat I), the first to use channelized repeaters (Intelsat IV), the
regulated monopoly to a competitive structure in American first to exploit spatial re-use of frequencies (Intelsat IV-A),
telephone service has set a new direction for the US and the first to combine spatial and polarization frequency re-use
possibly for international services. Regional satellite systems (Intelsat V) and the first to sponsor international satellite
have appeared to complicate the role of Intelsat. National switched time division multiple access (TDMA) (Intelsat VI).
satellite systems have continued to grow and have moved into Through its spacecraft programmes, Intelsat has become the
the 11114 GHz band of frequencies. Direct broadcast of world's most important sponsor of communications satellite
television signals to the home by satellite has emerged, technology.
become confused, and is changing in response to new Intelsat expects that its traffic will increase from the present
technology. The space shuttle and Ariane rocket launchers 90,000 equivalent half-circuits to 500,000 by the end of the
have provided important new routes to space, although the century. The growth will occur almost equally in the three
current status of the space shuttle remains in question. New ocean basin service areas. Full-time television carriage is
spacecraft/launcher ideas have emerged for powerful new expected to increase from 16 to 35 dedicated transponders in
systems. Policy and technical innovation will continue and the next ten years. In a major departure, Intelsat began
may significantly change the character of satellite com- selling transponders in 1986 for domestic service in addition
munications systems before the end of this decade. to its long standing practice of leasing capacity for such
service. The organization expects the number of transponders
leased or sold for domestic service to double in the next five
INTELSAT years from the present figure of 50. With this outlook and the
remarkable accomplishments of the last 20 years, it is difficult
Intelsat is the telecommunications cooperative established by to see Intelsat as anything other than a resounding success.
treaty to provide international communications service by And yet it is entering a period of considerable uncertainty.
satellite. Today it owns and operates 15 spacecraft in There are two threats, both related to deregulation of the
geosynchronous orbit, representing an investment of over $3 telecommunications industry in the US. The first is posed by
billion. Besides handling two-thirds of all overseas telephone cables. Since the costs of submarine cables go into the rate
and data communications, it provides virtually all live base of the carriers but the costs of satellites do not, it would
overseas television. The ownership and use of Intelsat have been natural for the carriers to place their traffic in
facilities is widely shared among the members. Intelsat cables, not satellites. The Federal Communications Commis-
membership has grown to 114 nations, and 170 users access sion (FCC) anticipated this eventuality and directed that the
nearly 1,000 antennas to utilize the space segment for traffic be divided evenly. That restriction is now lapsing at the
domestic and international purposes. The group's traditional very time that Intelsat's traffic growth rate has declined. Nine
greater than 20 percent annual traffic growth has slowed to percent per year is still good growth but it reflects significant
about 11 percent. Yet throughout this period its communica- economic deceleration. Moreover, Intelsat is compelled by its
tion charges have decreased on 13 occasions despite a hefty founding treaty to serve the world at common prices, so as to
rise in the world wide cost of living index. average profitable business traffic with the costs of providing
Intelsat has continued to support the development of inefficient services to developing countries. This rate averag-
communications satellite technology in a major way. Because ing was a matter of international policy, thoroughly under-
of the consortium's unique service demands and traffic stood by all parties who joined Intelsat. By contrast, cables
growth, Intelsat spacecraft have consistently been developed serve only the high density routes. This economic advantage
5
Satellites International
is independent of the technology used: microwave or optical terns. Whatever one's position on the matter, it is clear that
fibre cables. the US has dramatically reversed its single system policy
Intelsat could easily compete with cables by abandoning position. The world of telecommunications does not deal
rate averaging or by building two-beam satellites that would easily with sudden policy shifts - either domestically or
connect only Europe and America . To be specific, a internationally.
Delta-class satellite with two reflectors would form two spot Intelsat is thus entering a period of significant challenge. It
beams- one directed to Europe and one to the eastern US. responded first by arguing on a policy level with its largest
Such a satellite has been discussed for at least a decade and owner, the US, which holds 23 percent of the Intelsat share.
would probably undercut cable costs. In doing so, however, it This appeal was largely in vain . It has now turned to its
would destroy everything Intelsat is trying to preserve: rate greater strength: its technical and economic momentum.
averaging over the entire world. It is an uncomfortable With those assets, Intelsat is beginning to compete vigorously
dilemma, especially since the cable owners are not so with the new satellite entrants. It is also taking steps to
constrained. Many cable owners who are also members of compete effectively with cables. the outcome of these
Intelsat must make difficult choices when they cast their votes contests will not be clear for several years . In the meantime,
at Intelsat meetings. there will be considerable turbulence in the international
This leads to the second threat facing Intelsat. In the arena , just as there is in the US.
present climate of deregulation, a number of enterprizing Intelsat already faces competition from new regional
American firms asked the FCC for permission to provide satellite systems. These systems pose a problem for Intelsat,
services across the Atlantic using aerial cable satellites. They which is charged with providing international service through
would serve primarily business interests, although some a single integrated system. Starting in 1977, the Indonesian
would provide a public message service. All claim that such national system has provided satellite capacity to its neigh-
satellites would do Intelsat no economic harm. But those who bours on a transponder lease basis. This system also supports
understand the economics know better. These proposals are some communications between countries in southeast Asia
for cream-skimming systems, which would serve only the that might have been carried by Intelsat. However, the
lucrative high capacity business routes. With policy absolute magnitude of the traffic loss was unimportant. For
encouragement from the White House, the FCC has now instance, it was substantially less harmful than the transfer of
approved these new applications subject to technical and the Hawaii/continental US west coast traffic from Intelsat to
economic coordination with Intelsat. Comstar in July 1976.
This is a strange turn of events, It was the US which The next challenge from a regional system occurred when
invented, championed and supported the establishment of a the Arab League decided to proceed with the Arabsat system
single international satellite system. Now, the US proposes to in 1980. Arab nations argued that the traffic to be carried
challenge Intelsat by authorizing competitive satellite sys- among the 21 Arab countries (Figure 1) would not have gone
6
Trends in Satellite Communications
on Intelsat anyway, since these nations planned to build no other way for these vehicles to communicate. Satellites
terrestrial microwave networks to handle the traffic if their provide an important new capability for mobile users because
satellite system proposal was turned down. Faced with the of the broad access or geographic coverage available from
significant economic and political influence of the Arab synchronous orbit. Satellite mobile service was first demons-
nations, Intelsat accepted the new system, which was laun- trated experimentally by Syncom II in 1963 and subsequently
ched in February 1985. At this time only modest traffic is on with the A TS series. The US Department of Defense
the Arabsat system, and little traffic has migrated from the furnished narrowband UHF service to military users with
Intelsat system. Tacsat in 1969. This continued with Comsat's Marisat, the
The same issue was re-enacted by the 26 European Navy/Air Force Fleetsatcom and the Hughes Leasat prog-
countries which formed Eutelsat. two of the Eutelsat ECS ramme. However, civilian carriers were slow to provide such
satellites are now in orbit. The Eutelsat system, with the service.
coverage shown in Figure 1, provides an alternative to the It was Comsat which took the pioneering step by adding
well developed terrestrial system that connects the member L band (1.5 GHz) radio capability to the Marisat spacecraft,
nations. It may also supply new services, such as high speed thereby delivering three-ocean maritime service from 1976
digital transmission of business data and television distribu- onward. The Marisat spacecraft were joined by the Marecs A
tion. In coordinating the system, Eutelsat noted that Intelsat satellite in 1981, Marecs B2 in late 1984, and leased service on
does not now carry intra-European traffic. The existing Intelsat V satellites in 1983.
terrestrial network could continue to do the job, so Intelsat The International Maritime Satellite Organization (Inmar-
would lose nothing that it might have had. The coordination sat) has emerged as the international cooperative supplier of
of Eutelsat with Intelsat has been difficult and limited to a maritime voice and data service to ships at sea, as the result of
five-year period. many years of preparation by the International Maritime
A similar question was raised for traffic between Canada, Organization. Like Intelsat, its ownership is related to
the US and Mexico. Intelsat, at the time of the original member use. It is a young organization and is growing
coordination, had no satellites properly positioned to supply rapidly. It now provides high quality telephone and data
such a service. Despite Intelsat's wish to provide for such service to 4,000 ships and off shore drilling rigs equipped with
traffic in later years, the telephone authorities pointed out suitable terminals. Inmarsar- recently initiated the develop-
that the north/south traffic was flowing nicely on the ment of a new generation space segment with much higher
terrestrial network and could easily continue without satellite capacity than present systems. The next few years will be a
augmentation. Satellite interconnections have now been period of significant growth and evolution for Inmarsat.
negotiated bilaterally by satellite operators in the three During the same period, limited progress has been made on
countries. supplying a public message service to aircraft in flight. There
What is difficult here is that the original philosophy of is no satellite service to civilian aircraft although Inmarsat is
Intelsat did not adequately address the issue of satellite about to initiate a pilot project for such service and A ring, a
connections between contiguous countries. The basic plan- US company which has long been in the aeronautical radio
ning was for long transoceanic routes. The problem of business has announced plans for their own aeronautical
adjacent country connection is thus left to Intelsat to satellite service by placing 'packages' on other satellites. It
negotiate with its member nations on a case-by-case basis. In expects this activity could lead to trial operations in the late
doing so, some members appear simultaneously as breakaway 1980s or early 1990s.
petitioners and as Intelsat shareholders in the debates that The third class of mobile satellite service is for land or
ensue. surface vehicles. Because user equipment will probably be
Certain aspects of Intelsat intersystem coordination proce- omnidirectional, all users will see all satellites operating on
dures for separate international systems are now much clearer their side of the Earth, unless the satellites can form narrow
with the successful determination by the Intelsat Assembly of beams at UHF to divide the coverage area. This means that
Parties in April, 1987, that the Pan am sat System did not there may be only one or two suitable orbit positions in each
constitute 'significant economic harm' to Intelsat. Since this hemisphere. These must be shared cooperatively among the
finding only affected about 20% of the satellites' capacity this nations seeking to establish mobile service. This possibility is
precedent is still indicative of future actions by Intelsat being developed jointly by the US and Canada. Two
member countries. important questions face such a service: 1) how it will relate
The fundamental position of Intelsat is extraordinarily to the terrestrial cellular radio system serving the same class
strong. It is uniquely successful as an international commer- of users?, and 2) whether it can become a viable commercial
cial venture, returning to all of its shareholders a handsome activity or must remain a government subsidized service? Our
return on their investments each year. It has a reliable impression is that there is a valid need for satellite service. It
redundant system in place. It has a strong and growing should supplement cellular radio and probably use the
business base. Its communications satellites are the most adjacent bands at 850 MHz. We believe that the initial service
advanced now flying; those in development are even better. It should be established with modest channel capacity and small
is a going business, with an established procedure for spacecraft.
collecting revenues, calling for capital contributions, buying
satellites and launchers and distributing earnings. With this
enormous power it can move in many directions- if it does so NATIONAL SYSTEMS
carefully. The next few years will prove decisive for Intelsat.
National systems which provide domestic telecommunica-
tions service by satellite have proliferated and expanded
MOBILE SERVICES rapidly. Table 1 lists the number of satellites in domestic
service in late 1979, those active in January 1986 and those
Telecommunications service to mobile users - ships, aero- projected for end 1989. In constructing this summary, it was
planes and surface vehicles- has always been one of the most difficult to differentiate between experimental programmes
important uses of the radio spectrum, simply because there is and those in operational service. The forecast for 1988 was
7
Satellites International
especially difficult, because some nations and organizations began similar C-band (6/4 GHz) service earlier with Anik A.
discuss plans for building domestic systems without actually AT&T introduced signal sideband amplitude modulation
committing the large amounts of capital needed. However, (AM) in its Telstar system. Exploiting the unusual linearity of
the number of nations that lease transponder capacity from the solid state power amplifiers carried on its new Telstar 3
Intelsat affords a good indication of serious intent. Brazil, spacecraft, AT&T has shown it can carry 6,000 half-circuits
Mexico, Australia, the Federal Republic of Germany, France on each 36 MHz C-band transponder, in contrast to the
and India all leased Intelsat capacity before proceeding with maximum (single carrier) capability of 1,000 half-circuits in
their own space programmes. Twenty-six nations now lease the same transponder using frequency modulation.
the equivalent of nearly 40 full transponders from Intelsat for An unexpected but significant policy development for
domestic service. national systems occured in the US at the start of the 1980s.
Table 1 National Communications Satellites In the traditional ownership pattern, a few large communica-
(geostationary satellites only) tions carriers owned spacecraft and leased services on a tariff
basis. A number of major users became concerned about this
October October January End approach when Satcom III failed to achieve orbit in 1979 and
1979 1983 1986 1989 there was a sudden shortage of transmission capacity for
Argentina 2 video programming. The concern was aggravated by the
Australia 2 3 uncertainty of future satellite access and tariff charges.
Brazil 1 2 Hughes proposed that users be allowed to buy and own
Canada 4 5 6 5 individual transponders. For users who did not need the
France 2 2 capacity of an entire satellite, this had several benefits. Users
Germany, FR 2 could control their own transmission capacity and accurately
India 1 1 2 anticipate its cost. They could also enjoy the tax benefits of
Indonesia 2 3 2 2 ownership. This condominium approach to satellite service
Ireland 2 has broadened the participation of American firms in satellite
Italy 1 communications and is stimulating new applications.
Japan 2 2 4 The industrial firms responsible for building the current
Luxembourg 1 generation of national and regional communications satellites
Mexico 2 2 are summarized in Table 2. It is a very competitive field in
Nigeria 2* which price is usually the deciding factor. Two US firms have
Pakistan 2* shared most of the spacecraft sales so far: Hughes and RCA.
Thailand 2*
UK 2*
USA 8 21 28 38 DIRECT BROADCAST SATELLITES
USSR 3 8 11 15
The initial direction for direct broadcast satellites was set in
Total 17 40 57 91
1977, at the special World Administrative Radio Conference
(W ARC) convened by the International Telecommunication
*Firm decisions have not been finalized.
Union (ITU). It established transmission standards and
The significance of Table 1 is not in its detail, but its trend. allocated orbit and frequency combinations for all nations in
The number of national systems is accelerating because they Europe, Africa and the Far East. Primarily at the request of
are an economical way to build long-distance networks the US, allotments for the western hemisphere were delayed
rapidly, both in developing nations and in accessible regions until a special conference was held in 1983. A great deal
ot advanced natiOns. In countries with existing terrestrial happened technologically in those intervening six years, and
systems satellites provide a simple way to establish new this is reflected by the differing standards established by the
services with separate nationwide networks. two conferences. The same technical progress probably
Two trends have characterized the evolution of national accounts for the difference of views between Canada and the
systems in this decade. The first is the start of Ku-band US. It certainly explains the continuing confusion within the
service: Canada, Australia, Europe, Mexico and the US have American DBS community. In short, we are in a period of
established Ku-band services at 11 and 14 GHz. Satellite extraordinary change in a field that was considered settled in
Business Systems (SBS) now operates four Ku-band 1977.
spacecraft and Telesat Canada is using two Anik C satellites The impetus for this change was the dramatic improvement
with another in orbital storage. GTE and RCA are also in ground station performance. In 1977, it was thought that a
deploying Ku-band systems. These users have found that the receiver/noise figure of 6 dB was achievable. Proceeding on
increased attentuation experienced at Ku-band is offset by that assumption and conservative estimates of system losses,
the ease of locating earth stations in urban areas. Other it seemed that equivalent isotropic radiated power (EIRP)
Ku-band systems are being planned by Luxembourg, Ireland, levels of 63 to 65 dBW would be required to provide
the Federal Republic of Germany, Japan and several recent satisfactory television reception. With antennas that cover
FCC licensees. average-size countries or the time zones of larger countries,
The second major trend in domestic systems is the this logic led to a judgement that travelling wave tube
introduction of new modulation techniques. The initial amplifiers (TWT A) of 230 watts or more would be required
national systems all used frequency modulation (FM). for each television channel. The Federal Republic of Ger-
Indonesia's Palapa system pioneered demand assignment many and France embarked on the development of such
service on one transponder in 1976 and is now preparing to tubes. They also began a joint programme to build direct
enlarge that capability. A major change was introduced by broadcast satellites using this technology, which resulted in
SBS which inaugurated full TDMA service in early 1981. This the French TDF-1 and the West German TV-Sat program-
TDMA system provides high quality voice and data service to mes. Japan's BS-1 experimental system, which flew in 1978,
some 107 sophisticated stations in the US. Telesat Canada was based on 100-watt tubes.
8
Trends in Satellite Communications
Since that initial judgement was made, several things have was Comsat's disclosure in November 1984 that it would
changed. First, the DBS receiver/noise figure has improved to abandon its DBS programme, after almost completing its two
3 dB and may drop to 2.5 dB in the next few years. The spacecraft and making significant progress payments for
second change resulted from a more realistic evaluatton ot launch services. In the end, this represents a financial
system losses, reflecting video transmission experiments investment of $100 to $200 million for Comsat. Meanwhile,
made with the Communications Technology Satellite. That the FCC has given q~nstruction permits to nine additional US
spacecraft carried both 200-watt and 20-watt amplifiers. DBS applicants (including RCA's re-submission), however,
Surprisingly, the Canadians and NASA found that the none appear to be moving with any haste to implement
20-watt channel provided high quality DBS service. Telesat service. Comsat meanwhile has tried to sell its two DBS
Canada implemented operational 20-watt Ku-band video satellites in Europe.
service on the Anik B spacecraft in 1980 and is continuing Aside from technical considerations, there is a troubling
that service on Anik C. When Australia was establishing its question about the programme content DBS operators will
satellite standards for outback television distribution, Canada offer. American television networks spend $600 million to
positioned the CTS over Australia for several months. The $800 million each year to programme a single television
Australians got the same high quality and built their DBS channel. Current experience of American cable operators
service around 30-watt TWTAs. suggests that the public's appetite for multiple channels is
As 1983 began, DBS plans in the US were in a state of limited. The basic question is whether DBS operators can
confusion. Eight organizations, CBS, Comsat, DBS Corpora- deliver programming of satisfactory quality and find sufficient
tion, Graphic Scanning, RCA, US Satellite Broadcasting, consumer acceptance for their systems.
Western Union and Video Satellite System, applied to the Most of the high power DBS spacecraft are quite different
FCC for permission to operate such systems and were granted from the spacecraft that provide point-to-point service. This
provisional construction permission in November 1982. The is shown by the plot of satellite weight versus power in Figure
FCC insisted that the applicants begin construction by June 2. All the point-to-point satellites, from Early Bird to Intelsat
1984 or give up their grants. As that data approached, DBS VI, lie roughly along a straight line. Adding channels to a
and Western Union abandoned their applications, and RCA communications satellite with an established ground network
asked to be considered in a later round. Having argued adds weight and power in equal measure. The DBS emphasis
vigorously for many orbital slots at the special 1983 WARC, so far is on satellite power. Weight is secondary, as long as the
the FCC was forced to soften its standard of progress. Of the heavy batteries needed to carry the service through eclipse
original eight, only Comsat was building satellites while two are not supplied. A DBS spacecraft based on the 1977
others continued on a very thin expenditure basis. New WARC is a high power, on-off, lightweight, small capacity
applications were invited. The crowning blow in this long saga satellite.
9
Satellites International
provide many channels. The satellites that offer this service
will use 40-watt tubes and be indistinguishable from the
Fixed service satellites
Ku-band spacecraft that will provide point-to-point and
on-premises communication service. If we are right, we will
have come full circle, first trying desperately to distinguish
2000 DBS satellites, and finally blending them into established
designs and business arrangements.
SPACECRAFT
Manufacturer
British
Aerospace/
RCA Hughes Matra
Satellite Satcom Series 4000 HS 376 HS 393 ECS
Total weight (kg) 600 750 540 to 661 1090 610 to 680
Total power (Watts) 1000- 1375 2260 900- 1118 2250 1100
First launch October 82 November 85 November 80 November 87 June 83
Lifetime (years) 10 10 7- 10 10- 12 7
10
Trends in Satellite Communications
BAe/MATRA
ECS
RCA
SATCOM
Hughes
HS376
t
Figure 3. Scale comparison of three current domestic spacecraft.
solid rocket motor for apogee impulse and nickel cadmium rounded by an equipment platform . Two co-rotating momen-
batteries. It uses monopropellant hydrazine for orbit adjust- tum wht:els provide attitude control. The ECS employs a
ment. Operators and purchasers of the HS 376 are shown in solid rocket motor for apogee impulse and 16 thrusters for
Table 5. stationkeeping. The users of the BAe/Matra spacecraft are
The British Aerospace (BAe )/Matra ECS programme shown in Table 6.
began in 1977 with the Orbital Test Satellite (OTS) prog- The Arabsat three-axis spacecraft being constructed by
ramme sponsored by the European Space Agency (ESA}. Aerospatiale (SNIAS) is sized to fly on Ariane and has a mass
The same basic vehicle was later adapted to provide L-band of 1,134 kilogrammes in synchronous orbit. It uses a solid apogee
service in the Marecs programme. Telecom I is another OTS rocket and 12 thrusters for orbit control. Its solar panels
derivative developed for French national service. The ECS provide 1.3 kilowatts of prime power and its energy wtll be
for Eutelsat is an OTS derivative with two three-panel stored in nickel cadmium batteries for eclipse operation. So
sun-tracking solar array wings. Power is increased in subse- far, it has found only one custome r.
quent ECS derivatives by adding panels to the wings. This The Indian satellite built by Ford is a very special body
generic spacecraft has grown in mass from 443 kilogrammes to stablized spacecraft that provides point-to-point communica-
680 kilogrammes and in power from 750 watts to 1,300 watts. tion, direct broadcast and weather monitoring services- all in
The satellite bus is a cylindrical central thrust cone sur- one satellite. Because of this specialization, it has found no
Number of First
Owner Name spacecraft Payload Channels flight
Satellite Business Systems SBS 5 K-band 10- 14 November 1980
Telesat Canada Anik C 3 K-band 16 November 1982
Western Union Westar 4 C-band 24 February 1982
Indonesia Palapa B 3 C-band 24 June 1983
Brazil 1 SBTS 2 C-band 24 February 1985
Mexico Morelos 2 C-band/K-band 18/6 June 1985
Australia Aussat 3 K-band 15 August 1985
Telesat Canada 1 Anik D 2 C-band 24 August 1982
Hughes Communications Galaxy 3 C-band 24 June 1983
AT&T Telstar 3 3 C-band 24 July 1983
Total number of spacecraft 30
1 HS 376 is built under license by Spar Canada for these customers.
11
Satellites International
other market , although parts of its design have been applied Satellite Television Corporation , is apparently based on a
to Arabsat and to a new generation of US geosynchronous liquid perigee stage to place the spacecraft in transfer orbit
meteorological satellites. after its ejection from the shuttle . RCA is also using the new
Pam D2 as the perigee stage for its upgraded spacecraft. This
Future Domestic Systems gives it about 50 percent more payload than the Advanced
Satcom spacecraft. The first two K-band spacecraft in this
A new generation of spacecraft is now being developed for new series were launched in 1985 and early 1986. The
the national and regional market by RCA, BAe/Matra and satellites have on-orbit mass of 1,025 kilogrammes and a
Hughes . Full details of their designs have not yet been design life of ten years .
publicly revealed, but the following information is available. The British Aerospace/Matra team is also upgrading the
The third generation Hughes satellite - the HS 393 - is a basic ECS spacecraft for greater payload capability. The
spinning vehicle designed to fill the gap between the HS 376 Eurostar is being designed for launch by Ariane 4 or by the
currently being mass produced for domestic service and the space shuttle with a Pam D2 . Its initial application will be as
large Intelsat VI. This is designed to fly on the space shuttle the next generation of Inmarsat maritime satellites, starting in
with a 25 percent load factor , or, in half of the Ariane 4. On mid-1988 . Inmarsat will have a mass at separation from the
the space shuttle, it will use integral propulsion with a STS/Pam D of 1,269 kilogrammes and from Ariane 4 of 1,160
Minuteman III solid rocket motor for perigee boost. It will kilogrammes.
use nickel hydrogen batteries and a hi-propellant system for Ford announced a new satellite design, known as Supersat ,
apogee impulse and on-orbit stationkeeping. The HS 393 will in 1983. Supersat is a body stabilized spacecraft that is
weigh 1,361 kilogrammes and generate 2,800 watts of prime optimized for launch via the space shuttle. It uses a liquid
power at the beginning of life in geosynchronous orbit. Three hi-propellant system for perigee impulse, the initial design of
customers have ordered HS 393s for service starting in late which was done jointly by Ford and Aerojet. The same
1987. hi-propellant motors will be used for apogee impulse , after
RCA 's full direct broadcast version in contrast to the some tankage is staged in transfer orbit. With varied
interim weight and power configuration RCA built for propellant loading , the spacecraft offers a considerable range
12
Trends in Satellite Communications
of payload weight capability. At the lower end of the scale, it Table 7 Comparison of lntelsat Spacecraft
provides the capability of Intelsat V; 950 kilogrammes and 1.6
kilowatts. At the upper end of its capability it weighs 1,528
kilogrammes and produces as much as eight kilowatts of Intelsat V Intelsat VA Intelsat VI
prime power (in the configuration proposed for a US Manufacturer Ford Ford Hughes
domestic hybrid system). The spacecraft's centralized digital
processor system will combine telemetry and control func- Atlantic capacity (half 25,000 30,000 80,000
tions, attitude control computation and power management circuits)
from a single unit. Number being built 9 6 5
First flight 1980 1985 1987
lntelsat spacecraft Bandwidth (MHz) 2,321 2,570 3,262
Initial mass in orbit (kg) 950 950 2,243
Two important new Intelsat vehicles have emerged in the last Total power (Watts, 1,354 1,354 2,300
few years. The Ford Intelsat V spacecraft first flew in 1980, EOL 1)
and all but one of the subsequent flights in the 15-satellite Lifetime (years) 7 7 10
VIVA series have been successful. Intelsat contracted Ford to Launcher Atlas Atlas STSor
upgrade the basic spacecraft to the Intelsat VA configuration, Centaur or Centaur or Ariane4
which exploits the increased lifting capability of the Atlas Ariane 1 Ariane 2
Centaur and Ariane. (Initial plans to fly the Intelsat V series 1 End of life.
on the shuttle were abandoned because the Pam A horizontal
launch configuration and the spacecraft modifications needed services for the space shuttle and for unmanned low altitude
for shuttle launch were too costly.) Communications payloads spacecraft. The first TDRSS was launched in April1983. The
were added to the Intelsat V and VA series to provide L-band second was destroyed in the explosion of the Challenger
maritime and K-band spot beam international business shuttle on 28 January 1986. Its initial in-orbit weight is
service, and increases in the global C-band service. The essentially the same as Intelsat VI. Because NASA elected to
15-spacecraft Intelsat V and VA series is summarized briefly launch it with the shuttle and the IUS stage, it has proven to
in Table 7, (and the entire Intelsat family is compared in be a very expensive system. The difference in launch costs for
Figure 4). these large new spacecraft is shown in Figure 6, which plots
Intelsat VI is the largest communications satellite prog- 1986 launch costs in 1982 US dollars. TDRSS and Intelsat VI
ramme ever undertaken. The development, engineering and will have about the same initial weight in orbit. However, the
production of the first five spacecraft is covered by a $700 combination of a long payload and the enormous cost of the
million contract. It is the largest and most complex spacecraft IUS stage (assumed here to be only $60 million) produces an
yet built for commercial service. When launched by the space $89 million difference in launch costs between the two.
shuttle, it would use integral propulsion and provide its own Olympus is a general purpose, body stabilized spacecraft
perigee impulse with a large solid rocket motor, although whose development by British Aerospace is sponsored by the
delays in the shuttle programme now make this unlikely. ESA. It is designed to carry a wide variety of communications
When it flies on Ariane 4, it will not need this motor, since payloads within its weight and power boundaries. The first
Ariane will place its 3,720 kilogrammes directly into transfer application, called L-Sat, is planned for both point-to-point
orbit. For both types of launch, the apogee impulse will be services and direct broadcast applications. It is designed to fly
generated by two hi-propellant thrusters. The same hi- on Ariane 3 and 4, with first launch scheduled for mid-1987,
propellant system will later feed small thrusters for orbital but can also ride on the shuttle with an IUS.
adjustment. Intelsat VI will use nickel hydrogen batteries and By contrast, Leasat is a shuttle-only vehicle designed
will be the first Intelsat spacecraft to employ RF beacon specifically to minimize launch costs. The 4.27-metre dia-
tracking for precise attitude control (better than 0.1 degree meter cylindrical spacecraft just fits within the 4.57 metre
even during orbit manoeuvres). It has a satellite switched inside diameter of the shuttle bay. With its solid perigee
TDMA and a completely reconfigurable antenna for the motor it weighs 6,818 kilogrammes and occupies 25 percent of
three ocean basin operating areas. The antenna provides the shuttle bay. The UHF payload provides service to the US
sixfold frequency re-use by polarization and spatial diversity. Navy, although the large deck offers great design flexibility
Considerable growth capability was built into Intelsat VI for for other antenna combinations. The spacecraft employs
the evolving communications needs of international users. integral propulsion and the Frisbee ejection technique.
With extra fuel loading this satellite can have a 14-year Leasat has two significant economic advantages. Its shuttle
operational lifetime. user charge is low because it occupies a minimum length in
the orbiter bay corresponding to its payload weight.
New large spacecraft Secondly, the user need not pay for a separate perigee stage.
Four of the five Leasat satellites have been successfully
In addition to Intelsat VI, three other large spacecraft are orbited and three of these are providing UHF communica-
being developed which will supply worldwide service from tions service.
geosynchronous orbit: 1) the TRW Tracking and Data Relay
Satellite (TDRSS), 2) the British Aerospace Olympus Spinning versus body stabilized
spacecraft, and 3) the Hughes Leasat. They each use the
increases in payload and volume capability provided by the A few satellites issues seem to have resolved themselves. Late
space shuttle and later versions of Ariane. Their characteris- in the 1970s, earnest debates were still heard about the
tics are summarized in Table 8 and Figure 5, where they are relative merits of body stabilized and spinning satellites. That
compared with Intelsat VI. The economics of each is closely debate has been largely ended by the configuration choices
tied to the trend in launch vehicles. that sophisticated owner/operators have made. Body stabil-
The TDRSS spacecraft is a body stabilized vehicle whose ized and spinning spacecraft have divided the national
multiple antennas provide two-way communication and data markets almost evenly. Intelsat went from spinners to body
13
Satellites International
stabilized and then back to spinners. American naval service choice, which he makes based on experience. The rhetoric of
has gone from spinners to body stabilized and back to the past is now seen for what is probably was: an attempt to
spinners. What these market decisions show is what thought- differentiate the satellite products of companies which wished
ful people have know for a decade: most satellite tasks can be to enter the field.
done with either technology. It is primarily the builder's
14
Trends in Satellite Communications
15
Satellites International
ing at 20 and 30 GHz (Ka-band) has been apparent for a meantime, the basic components such as low noise HEMT
decade. People were first attracted by the large bandwidth field effect transmitters for receiving at 30 G Hz and TWTs
allocation. With the small wavelength, they could also and solid state devices for transmitting at 20 GHz are being
imagine forming multiple beams and using this band over and developed in government supported programmes.
over. What was not known was the extent of signal
attenuation in the atmosphere. Fortunately, Bell Telephone
Laboratories installed 20 and 30 GHz beacons on the Beam changing in orbit
Comstar satellites. With their own ground stations and a
collaborative data collection effort around the US, Bell The technical possibility of modifying a satellite's coverage
mapped out the seasonal, diurnal and geographic statistics of pattern after launch is now becoming an exciting reality. Such
signal attenuation over a five-year period. 1 This significant set modification can provide significant flexibility for domestic
of experiments cast the new band into a rather different light. satellites that must be built to operate at any position in a
Hell found that propagation was interrupted by rain too often wide orbital arc. With three years required to build satellites
to permit transmission that was up to AT&T telephone and a late regulatory decision on location, antenna tuning
standards (99.99 percent). With a 15 dB margin it might be represents a major attraction compared with simply averag-
possible to achieve a one-way availability of 99.90 percent. ing, and thus degrading, a satellite's beam to operate equally
However, the data show clearly that even adding an well over a wide arc.
additional 20 dB margin would not yield 99.99 percent (see Intelsat must have spacecraft which can operate inter-
Figure 8). Furthermore, the worst fades occur in the changeably in its three ocean basins, in which the earth
afternoon during the peak east coast to west coast traffic. The station complexes and coverage requirements are quite
initial hope had been to avoid rain outages by using different. Modest beam changing capabilities were included
diversified reception with two or three separated stations. in the C-band satellites developed a decade ago. Intelsat
However, the measurements showed that rain cells are too IV-A and Intelsat V both have feed horns and therefore
extensive to permit this solution. special coverage patterns that can be switched in or out by
ground command.
The technology on Intelsat VI is spectacular by compari-
son. An array of 143 horns is used for the transmit antenna
and a similar number for the receive antenna. Each horn is
i excited with the appropriate phase/amplitude distribution for
the three operating regions. Ground commands can mechani-
~) 10-2
aiCI) 100 .§ ~ cally activate whichever feed distribution network is desired
o;o and thereby produce the antenna pattern appropriate to each
~a 50 :::~.C
c - operating ocean basin.
~·~ CI)"O
.Q c
lii~ Beam modification can also be done by completely
~i CDCI)
Eo electronic means. The possibility of a phased array in which
U..c i=1il the beam can be instantly reformed on command is becoming
~ 10-3
3:
a reality. With the advent of solid state power amplifiers, the
.5 potential of placing any transponder into any beam is not far
away. The operational opportunity for adjusting a satellite's
coverage and capacity to match rapidly changing traffic
requirements or interference problems is thus becoming
10 20 30 possible.
Rain attenuation, dB
16
Trends in Satellite Communications
Development of silicon carbide transistors offers substan- privatized by the US Government), several new US start up
tial performance improvements for millimeter wave power firms and even the USSR's Proton. Both the shuttle and Ariane
generation. Five-watt devices at 40 GHz are expected, which were committed to operational service in 1982. The American
will make possible 10-watt power amplifiers at 40 GHz with 20 space shuttle first flew into low Earth orbit in 1981, and had
percent efficiency. This technology is expected to mature in been a model of reliability on that and each succeeding flight,
the 1990s. until the Challenger tragedy. After four test flights, it ejected
Another important step has been linearizing the output two communications satellites, one Canadian and one Amer-
amplifiers. Techniques have been developed for improving ican, during its first operational mission in November 1982. It
the linearity of both solid state and TWTAs. Linearity has flown 19 times since then, placing 22 additional commer-
improvement provides greater communications capacity and cial communications satellites plus TDRSS into low Earth
is critical to modulation techniques like single sideband orbit. It also demonstrated the unique utility of human
amplitude modulation, which depends critically on linearity participation in space delivery by recovering. two errant
in the carrier-to-intermodulation ratio over the communica- satellites and restarting a third. At this writing the shuttle's
tion bandwidth. future schedule, launch rate and the continuing role it will
play in commercial launchings are unclear, but most commer-
cial requirements are being shifted to other vehicles because
Signal Demodulation and Processing of their low priority vis-a-vis government missions.
It was anticipated that the shuttle would be very reliable
The first TDMA system is now operating. In the SBS system, because of the safety demands imposed for the sake of the
the receive and transmit beams both see the entire coverage astronauts. 3 This was reflected in low premiums for launch
area. Any TDMA signal that goes up to the spacecraft is insurance in 1983: four to seven percent for the shuttle versus
repeated and can be heard by any receiving station. Now five to eight percent for Delta and 10 to 14 percent for Ariane.
consider what would happen if the coverage areas were Two years later insurance rates for the shuttle and Ariane had
divided into two or more zones served by individual beams. A risen substantially as an expression of a sharp increase in
TDMA signal transmitted up in one beam could only go down casualty claims. The gap between the two has narrowed,
in another if there were some means in the satellite to reflecting Ariane's rising success rate. Today, rates are well
recognize its intended destination and route it to the above 20% and will not return to lower levels in the near
transmitters feeding that other beam. If there are thousands- future.
or millions - of individual signals coming up, the satellite is The shuttle pricing policy announced in 1977 offered
presented with the tremendous task of reading and routing attractive rates for the first three years of operation. The
individual messages at the clock rate of the TDMA system. pricing policy for the second three-year period began in
Intelsat VI will be able to recognize signal destination and October 1985. This progression is shown in Figure 9 for a
process signals appropriately for routing and retransmission. typical domestic satellite, together with the price history for
Its satellite switched TDMA unit is a six by ten matrix of PIN launching such a spacecraft with the Delta and Ariane. This
diodes driven by a digital logic unit. It will route individual comparison indicates a continuing, albeit diminishing price
TDMA signal components from the six uplink beams to the advantage for the shuttle. A competitive price competition
appropriate ten downlink beams at a clock rate of 944 KHz. between the shuttle and Ariane late in 1985 substantiated this
Satellite switching of digital signals will improve rapidly. assessment. Critics on either side of the Atlantic complain
The next step is to demodulate upcoming signals to digital that the Ariane/shuttle differential is more a reflection of
form using high speed analog-to-digital circuits, then process government support than it is a fundamental disparity in
them for subsequent retransmission in a digital processor. launch economics. Whatever the truth, satellite launch costs
When this on-board digital sorting and distribution of signals took their first drop in two decades. Unfortunately the trend
is combined with a rapidly scanning antenna beam, the result was quickly reversed after the Challenge disaster.
can be a system solution of extraordinary capacity. 2 The three American expendable launch vehicles: Delta,
The prospect of on-board signal processing is made Atlas Centaur and Titan may all be commercialized by the US
possible by the rapid development of analog-to-digital con- Government after years of delay. All have established
version circuitry and compact digital processors. This will be enviable records of reliability. In the face of the shuttle's
an exciting area of satellite technology in the next decade and
clearly holds enormous potential for space telecommunica- 50
tions. This is one of the key elements of the ACT
experimental programme.
40
DELTA 3920/PAM
:::i!
LAUNCH VEHICLES ~
1if 30
0
The price of launch vehicles thus far has represented about u
J:
half the cost of establishing a communications satellite u
...J
20
satellite communications (unlike government-sponsored
programmes to visit the planets or survey the Earth), 10
increasing attention has been focused on the cost of launch
services.
For all practical purposes, there are only two launch 0~--~--~----~--~----~--~----~--~
1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989
vehicles suitable for commercial flights- the space shuttle and
Ariane although there are increasingly a number of options Launch date
becoming available, such as the Chinese Long March 2 and 3,
the Titan III C, Atlas Centaur and Delta (all of which may be Figure 9. Launch cost progression for Delta class satellites.
17
Satellites International
operational success and aggressive pricing, however, expend- Centaur. IUS exemplifies the classic problem of trying to do
able vehicles suffered a precipitous decline in orders. This all jobs with a single machine.
rapidly drove up unit prices, as fixed costs were spread over The economic alternative to standard upper stages is
fewer and fewer flights. The result was that the production integral propulsion. The concept is to incorporate a solid or
facilities for two of the three were phased out in 1983. liquid rocket motor into the spacecraft design to provide the
In early 1983 NASA offered to commercialize Delta, Titan perigee impulse - just as communications satellites have
and Atlas Centaur by allowing private ventures to use always provided their own apogee kick motors. This techni-
government tooling and launch facilities at reasonable rates. que exploits the precision of the shuttle guidance system to
Several firms explored this opportunity. However, a bid for establish the correct initial orientation at spacecraft separa-
Intelsat VI launch services submitted by Titan backers was tion. This attitude is preserved gyroscopically by spinning out
not cost competitive with the shuttle and Ariane 4. But in the of the shuttle bay until a safe separation distance is achieved
wake of the Challenger disaster and the several years' delay for perigee rocket motor firing. The leverage of this approach
associated with an STS launch Intelsat has signed options for is three fold. First, it uses the satellite's own guidance system,
two Titan III C launches with Martin Marrietta despite the rather than investing in redundant inertial platforms as IUS
high costs. does. Secondly, users buy only the combination of rocket
The Ariane rocket is the major alternative to the shuttle. It motors needed to place the specific satellite in orbit- instead
first flew almost coincidentally with the shuttle. It became of the total capability required for all other users of the stage.
fully operational in June 1983. It has flown 16 times, This minimum investment in integral propulsion contrasts
experiencing three failures, two of them early in the prog- with the high common denominator implicit in standard
ramme. It presents a possible alternative way into space when upper stages. The third virtue is the elimination of a separate
the shuttle is grounded or becomes overcommitted. A second development organization and the network of interface
launch pad was built at Kourou, French Guiana, and this requirements that must be established between the standard
increased confidence in the Ariane alternative. The rocket is upper stage and every potential user.
also being upgraded to the Ariane 4 configuration, which The economic advantages of integral propulsion are over-
could place 4,200 kilogrammes in transfer orbit. whelming in the telecommunications sector, where price
To preserve the benefits of price competition and oper- competition with alternate means of transmission is central to
ational convenience, it was specified that Intelsat VI be decision making. Integral propulsion is being used for Intelsat
launchable either by the space shuttle or Ariane 4. However, VI and was the decisive price difference in selecting the
there is an important distinction between Ariane and the developer. It seems to be the chosen path for many third
shuttle. Ariane puts a satellite into elliptic transfer orbit, from generation domestic satellites now being developed.
which it rises to synchronous altitude. In contrast, the shuttle
places a satellite into low Earth circular orbit at 160 nautical
miles. Shuttle launching therefore requires either an addi- CONCLUSION
tional stage to push the satellite into transfer orbit, or, that
the satellite carry adequate propulsion capability to do the Satellite communications have made significant progress in
job itself. the past few years. Even greater strides will be made in the
Two standard upper stages have been developed to place years ahead as the number and capacity of new satellites
shuttle payloads into transfer orbit. The Pam D is a increase. However, a variety of economic, technical and
commercial venture that provides perigee impulse for Delta regulatory issues cloud this otherwise optimistic picture. How
class payloads with a solid rocket motor. It has worked we cope with these question will influence the long-term role
perfectly 30 times. However, two of these stages malfunc- satellites play in worldwide telecommunications.
tioned in February 1984 on a shuttle flight, leaving the Westar
VI and Palapa B2 satellites stranded in low Earth orbit. The
spacecraft were subsequently recovered by a shuttle crew, REFERENCES
returned and refurbished to meet the needs of new custom-
ers. So Pam D appears to be a successful enterprise. Scores of 1. 'Results from the 19 and 28 GHz Comstar Satellite
Pam D/Pam D2 stages have been ordered, roughly 60 percent Propagation Experiments at Crawford Hill', a paper by
for commercial satellites. Most Pam Ds will be used on the Donald C. Cox and Hamilton W. Arnold, in Proceedings of
shuttle to life payloads into high orbits. The remainder were the IEEE, Volume 70, no. 5, May 1982.
final stages for Delta.
The second standard upper stage is the inertial upper stage 2. Bell Laboratories first proposed such a system, using a
(IUS). This was developed by the US Air Force for its own synchronized flying spot beam and TDMA modulation
needs and those of NASA. It provides both the perigee and techniques. See 'Scanning Spot Beam Satellite System', by
apogee velocity impulses with two solid rocket motors Douglas 0. Reudink and Yu S. Yeh, in.Bell System Technical
controlled by three redundant guidance systems and can place Journal, Volume 56, no. 8, October 1977.
2,273 kilogrammes in geosynchronous orbit. IUS had two
problems: one transient, the other systemic. During its first 3. 'The Economics of Telecommunications in the Century of
operational use in April 1983, it failed to place TDRSS into the Satellite', by Albert D. Wheel on, in the proceedings of
its intended synchronous orbit. This was caused by a second the World Telecommunication Forum, ITU, Geneva, 20
stage motor nozzle failure, which was corrected with time and September 1979.
money. The systemic problem is its cost. The original basis
for proceeding with IUS was that it would cost several million
dollars per shot. That price has now grown to over a hundred
million and is still rising. There are nd commercial users and
there will be none. Even some Air Force programmes have
abandoned IUS for cost reasons, and NASA has switched its
spacecraft to a new high .energy upper stage based on
18
3 THE BASICS OF SATELLITE TECHNOLOGY
Wilbur Pritchard, Chairman of the Board, Direct Broadcast Satellite Corporation; Chairman of the Board,
Satellite Systems Engineering; Founding Chairman of the Board, Society of Satellite Professionals; IEEE
Fellow, AIAA Fellow
To understand how satellites work to provide communication services is not difficult. That is, it is
not difficult if you are provided with clear explanations, with an absence of technicalities and a few
understandable analogies. Among the world's best qualified teachers of the basics of satellite
technology is a man who has designed satellites, headed several aerospace corporations, founded
the International Society of Satellite Professionals, and is one of the key leaders of the direct
broadcast satellite industries and the cellular radio industry. This explanation, in part, first
appeared in a book published by Prentice-Hall under the title of Satellite Communication System
Engineering. It was so clear and concise, we asked Prentice-Hall for the right to edit and revise the
text for Satellites International. We thank Wilbur Pritchard and Prentice-Hall for granting this
request.
In the previous chapters, the basics of satellite communica- larger and more focused achieves greater directivity. In this
tions from an overview perspective were covered. But how do manner the antenna attains higher performance and higher
communication satellites actually work and what do earth gain. Gain is measured on a logarithmic scale in de~ibels. In
stations really do?; in particular, how is an end-to-end the case of parabolic earth station antennas, the gain is
satellite link established and operated? That is the very ques- proportionate to the square of the antenna diameter,
tion to be taken up here. adjusted by the 'efficiency' of the feed and reflector system.
19
Satellites International
detection of the signal carried by the carrier wave. That is, the overall carrier-to-noise ratio can never be any
larger than the smallest of the three individual components.
Radio frequency: The frequencies that radio waves can be Two basic elements are required to establish a satellite link.
transmitted for satellite communications generally fall The first is the satellite repeater, or transponder, and the
between 200 MegaHertz (MHz) and 300 GigaHertz (GHz). second is a satellite earth station. The following paragraphs
Specific frequencies are assigned for satellite communications briefly introduce the characteristics of each.
by procedures defined by the International Telecommunica-
tion Union. The most common frequency bands are C-band
(6 and 4 GHz); Ku-band (14 and 12/11 GHz); and L-band Satellite transponders
(1.5 GHz). Other bands, however, are used at higher and
lower frequencies. From a communication standpoint, a satellite may be
considered as a distant microwave repeater which receives
Modulation: In sending a signal on a carrier wave the process uplink transmissions and provides filtering, amplification,
of varying the phase, frequency or amplitude of the wave is processing and frequency translation to the downlink band
known as modulation. The process of receiving the carrier for retransmission. This kind of transponder is a quasi-linear
wave and recovering the signal from it is known as demodula- repeater amplifier: the uplink and downlink bands are
tion. separated in frequency to prevent oscillation within the
satellite amplifier while permitting simultaneous transmission
Transponder: Transponders are the active electronics in a and reception at different frequencies. Moreover, the lower
satellite that receives a carrier wave, filters it, translates it frequency band is normally used on the downlink to exploit
into the downlink frequency, amplifies it and transmits it back the lower atmospheric losses (sometimes called path loss),
to Earth. The amplifying tube in the transponder is known as thereby minimizing satellite power amplifier requirements.
a travelling wave tube. Increasingly, lower powered satellites Thus, in communication satellite operation today 6 GHz
are now using solid state amplifiers rather than travelling uplinks are paired with 4 GHz downlinks. Likewise, 14 GHz
wave tubes. uplinks are paired with 12 GHz downlinks. The 6 and 4 GHz
band, or C-band, frequencies have the advantages of adequ-
With these definitions in mind, it is possible to understand ate bandwidth, negligible fading, low rain loss (for earth
how a satellite link is created. station elevation angles above five degrees) and the availabil-
The channel carrying capacity of a satellite radio frequency ity of affordable and reliable microwave devices.
(RF) link (typically expressed in terms of voice channels per Unfortunately, the available orbital locations and thus the
transponder) is directly related to the overall available carrie!- number of times the available spectrum can be reused are
to-noise ratio (C/N). Exclusive of interference, three baste being consumed quickly. The frequency coordination and
elements are considered in designing this RF link. The first is spectral utilization problems have become severe. Therefore,
the uplink, representing the channel from the transmitting the trend toward using higher frequencies, which began in the
earth station to the satellite. The quality of this link is usually 1920s, continues. The Ku-band at 14 and 12 GHz has become
expressed in terms of the uplink carrier-to-noise ratio, or popular in recent satellite design in developed countries (like
(C/N)u. This ratio depends on the power of the transmitting the US, Japan and Europe) as the device technology has
earth station, the gain of the transmitting antenna, the gain of developed. Although Ku-band has the advantage of ame-
the receiving antenna and the system noise temperature. The liorating the interference problem, a substantial fading
power of the transmitter on the ground depends on the size of margin must be provided to accommodate the severe rain
the power amplifier employed. The gains of both the loss. Despite this, Ku-band is rapidly taking its place along
transmitting and receiving antennas are directly related to with C-band for satellite communications. Given these
their sizes and efficiencies. The system noise temperature is trends, interest in the Ka-band (at 30 GHz/20 GHz) is now
composed of the receiver temperature, the noise due to losses growing as well with two such systems filed for in the US and
between the antenna and the receiver system, and the other satellite systems, in Japan and Europe, under testing.
antenna noise. Satellite transponder amplifiers must provide relatively
The second component in the RF link is the downlink. The high gains (in the range 80 to 100 dB) while maintaining
corresponding figure of merit is called the downlink carrier- relatively low noise operation. (This 'gain' is the same as its
to-noise ratio (C/N)d. As with the uplink, (C/N)d depends on amplification of the transponders. It should not be confused
the power of the transmitter, the transmitting and receiving with antenna gain, a measure of the antenna's ability to
antenna gains and the receiving system noise temperature. 'capture' radiated energy in a particular direction.) The
The third component to be considered in the RF link design is high-gain requirements typically require multiple-stage low-
the electronic system found in the satellite transponder noise amplification. The first stages in modern transponder
which, in addition to amplifying the uplink noise, produces amplifier chains are provided by solid state amplifiers. These
undesirable noiselike signals that are normally measured by devices require careful design to minimize noise and intermo-
an equivalent carrier-to-noise ratio which we shall call (C/N)i. dulation effects. Filters must also employ careful design
Several impairments, primarily intermodulation (or cross practices to minimize interference from adjacent channels, as
modulation effects) are included in the overall (C/N)i well as other factors. Frequency translation from the uplink
component. Interference from other sate~lites and terr~strial to the downlink band causes the uplink noise to be amplified
systems can also be collectively charactenzed by a car~ter-to by the multiple-stage amplifier chain. Final stages of ampli-
interference ratio. If one assumes that the thermal nmse and fication in the transponder are typically provided by
all the noiselike impairments are low level and additive, they travelling-wave tube amplifiers. It is in this high power output
can easily be combined to yield a composite carrier to noise amplifier stage that most of the impairments that affect
ratio ( C/N)t. (C/N)i are generated. In multiple carrier operation, intermo-
The overall carrier-to-noise ratio available in the link is a dulation is usually the dominant impairment. Other factors,
combination of the three elements [(C/N)u, (C/N)i, (C/N)d], such as amplitude modulation-to-phase modulation (AM-to-
and they combine in the same way as do resistors in parallel. PM) conversion, must also be considered. AM-to-PM results
20
The Basics of Satellite Technology
from amplitude variations that produce unintentional phase figuration is shown in Figure 2. Earth stations are available in
modulation at the output of the travelling wave tube. The a wide variety of size, function, sophistication and cost. They
AM-to-PM causes amplitude ripple in the passband of the are categorized by function, by the size of the antenna, by the
channelizing filters to reproduce spurious PM signals in its figure of movement and by the level of radiated power.
output. Antenna diameters range in size from as small as 0. 7 metres
Adjacent channel and adjacent satellite interference must for direct broadcast receive only applications to as large as 30
also be included in an overall consideration of impairments. metres in diameter for large international gateway stations.
Therefore, the designer, in addition to considering thermal With the new Intelsat standard, international stations are
noise effects, must consider a wide range of linear and today only 14 to 17 metres in diameter and domestic stations
nonlinear impairments. These impairments are related to seldom are larger than 10 to 11 metres. These larger stations
both the design of the satellite hardware components and the require tracking systems to maintain the pointing of the
design operating points in the RF link. It is interesting to note antennas at the satellite.
that such impairments are often less serious in terrestrial An earth station consists of an antenna subsystem, a power
systems, including earth stations, where primary power and a amplifier subsystem, a low-noise receiver subsystem, and a
wide range of hardware are readily available. In a satellite, ground communications equipment subsystem (GCE). Many
however, the limitations of spacecraft mass and power in stations are equipped with' separate uninterruptable power
orbit force systems engineers to balance the available power supply systems and control, test and monitoring facilities,
against the acceptable distortion due to nonlinear impair- sometimes called telemetry, tracking, and command systems
ments. (TT &C). Small stations usually do not require tracking
Virtually all satellite transponders used to date have been systems because of the large beamwidth of the antenna
of the type described here. In the future, more sophisticated compared to the narrow range in which satellite station
trasnsponder designs employing regenerating repeaters will keeping is maintained.
surely be used for digital transmission. In a regenerating The performance of an earth station is specified by its
transponder the digital signal is demodulated and a new equivalent isotropic radiated power (EIRP) and its gain-to-
output signal is generated within the transponder itself. This system noise temperature ratio (G/T). EIRP is the product of
approach has the distinct advantage of separating the uplink the power output of the high power amplifier at the antenna,
and the downlink into two independent paths. and the gain of the transmitting antenna. The receiving
system sensitivity is specified by G/T, which is the ratio of the
receive gain of the antennas to the system noise temperature.
Earth stations The antenna gain is proportional to the square of the
diameter and is dependent on the efficiency of the feed/
The second basic element in a satellite link is an earth reflector system. The system noise temperature is composed
terminal. A block diagram of a typical earth station con- of three components: the noise of the receiver, the noise due
r----------------------------~
I I
I I
.-----1 High-power I Up- IF
amplifier I converters Modulator Baseband MUX
I )
I /
L ________ - - - - - - - - - - - ____ J
BeamW/G Polarization
and
tracking
Feed servo
r-- -----------------------
I
I
'
l
Low-noise I Down- IF I
receiver converters Baseband MUX
I
I
I I
L - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ___ J
Commercial
power input
AZand EL Antenna
drive tracking
motors servo
Diesel acpower
generator to station
loads
Telemetry tracking
and de power
command system to station
loads
Figure 2. 'JYpical earth station configuration, showing the transmission and reception paths ofasignal. The upper path (from right to
left) is the transmitting path, from the signal origination to the dish. The lower path (from left to right) shows the signal being received.
Abbreviations are: WIG, wavelength; IF, intermediate frequency; AZ, azimuth; EL, elevation; MUX, multiplex; UPS,
uninterruptible power supply.
21
Satellites International
to losses between the antenna feed system and the receiver, transponder. It is the most common method in use because it
and the antenna noise. Although the performance of an earth was a natural extensim~ of the frequency division multiplex
station is typically limited by thermal noise, it can also be (FDM) systems that were in use for many years in terrestrial
plagued with some of the same difficulties caused by carrier systems. In FDMA, each uplink RF carrier occupies a
nonlinear impairments in a satellite transponder. In general, defined frequency slot and is assigned a specific bandwidth in
the larger the station, the more affordable high power levels a multicarrier repeater. The receiving station selects the
and equipment become, the fewer system compromises must desired carrier by RF filtering. In FDMA, multiple access is
be made. The system designer must account for impairments achieved through frequency planning.
such as intermodulation distortion in the high power amplifier The second basic type used in commercial satellite com-
located in earth stations as well as in the satellite transponder. munications is time division multiple access (TDMA).
However, the difficulties presented to the designer in the TDMA employs a single carrier which is time shared among
earth station are less restrictive than those in the satellite many users. It operates in burst mode, such that the
transponder. transmission bursts from all stations arrive at the satellite
transponder consecutively. The bursts are contiguously inter-
leaved without overlapping in time. Each earth station
THE TERRESTRIAL LINK receives all bursts from all stations (including its own) and
selects those destined for its users. Utilizing time shared
The second part of the end-to-end satellite communications single carrier TDMA provides some distinct advantages over
problem is embedded in the terrestrial link between the FDMA. In particular, a single carrier TDMA approach
satellite earth station and the user environment. This part avoids the intermodulation distortion that must be accommo-
deals more specifically with the baseband signal (i.e., the signal dated in multiple carrier FDMA systems.
after demodulation). To provide adequate satellite service to A third kind of multiple access system, known as code
a user, the service requirements must be well defined in terms division multiple access (CDMA), is one in which all uplink
of quality. Quality of service, specified in terms of parameters signals occupy the same frequency band at the same time.
such as link availability (grade of service), bit error rate, Each has its own pseudorandom code chosen from a set,
transmission rate, and signal-to-noise ratio, may then be which is used to separate the desired signal from the other
translated into a required carrier-to-noise ratio (C/N)r in the signals. The other signals are considered the same way as
RF link. The required (C/N)r is then compared with the interference or even jamming. This system has been used
available carrier-to-noise ratio (C/N)a to determine the primarily in military applications for security purposes but is
overall capacity of the link. In designing systems to meet now being used for data distribution to microterminals.
required quality and grades of service, several fundamental Commercial applications of CDMA (or spread spectrum, as it
baseband processing elements must be considered. is sometimes called) are thus beginning to emerge for lower
The first level of processing is source coding and/or speed data communications networking for speeds up to 56
modulation, wherein a source signal (voice, data or imagery) kilobits per second.
is coded in digital form or processed in analog form to
prepare it for terrestrial transmission and multiplexing. In
analog transmission it is common to use amplitude modula- COMMUNICATIONS NETWORKS AND SERVICES
tion (AM) and frequency modulation (FM). For digital
transmission, pulse code modulation (PCM) is used most A telecommunications system must service several types of
often. networks to achieve full interconnectivity among users. The
Following individual source coding, the next processing shortest networks consist of buses used to distribute informa-
level is multiplexing. For analog transmission, channels are tion from PBXs or distributed computer systems operating
combined using frequency division multiplex (FDM), which within a building or a small campus environment. Such
employs frequency separated carriers, each of which networks are typically less than 0.1 kilometre in maximum
accommodates one channel. In digital transmission, multiple communications distance and are normally serviced through
channels are combined into higher level digital signals using wire pairs, or other short distance techniques, such as
time division multiplexing (TDM), which employs separate line-of-sight optical or infrared systems.
time slots, each carrying the information from one channel. In the next level of the network hierarchy are local
The next level of processing is channel coding, which may networks extending over distances from 0.1 kilometre to
be used to improve the quality of digital transmission by about 10 kilometres. ·Examples of such networks are those
adding redundancy to the transmitted information to reduce servicing large campuses or small cities. These networks are
the overall error rate. Finally, RF modulation is used to potentially implemented using one of several technologies,
modulate either single or multiple channel signals onto radio such as optical fibres, coaxial cable systems and multipoint
frequency carriers high enough for transmission on the digital radio distribution (sometimes referred to as digital
satellite link. Analog transmission typically uses FM termination service, or DTS). Still larger networks,.such as
(although AM is also used occasionally), and digital transmis- regional networks, extend from one kilometre to several
sion usually employs some form of phase shift keying (PSK). hundred kilometres. These include systems serving large
Note that either FM or AM may be used twice in the cities or compact multistate areas. Long-haul networks with
composite source satellite transmission. mean distances greater than 100 kilometres are the most cost
The final level in signal processing is 'multiple access'. To effective applications for fixed service satellite transmission.
exploit the satellite's geometric advantage, we must design Although most satellite networking applications cover dis-
systems that permit more than one earth station pair to utilize tances greater than 1,000 kilometres, shorter distances are
a transponder simultaneously. Multiple access techniques becoming economically feasible.
have been used extensively in satellite communications. For Created and encouraged by the continued development of
commercial applications, two types have beem employed digital technology, many new telecommunication services
most often. The first is frequency division multiple access have emerged in recent years. Still heading the list is
(FDMA), which employs multiple carriers within the same traditional telephone service, accounting· for approximately
22
The Basics of Satellite Technology
80 percent of the value of telecommunication services COMPARISON OF TRANSMISSION
currently in place. Although telephone service has had a long TECHNOLOGIES
evolutionary history, spanning more than one hundred years,
the last decade has produced a revolution because of Many new technologies are emerging during the 1980s.
deregulatory actions taken in the US, Japan and the UK. The Table 1 summarizes the five most popular: satellites, digital
divestiture of the Bell System in the US, and the emergence microwave radio, optical fibres/coaxial cables, local distribu-
of digital technology will undoubtedly have enormous impact tion radio and wire pairs. Each of them will expand greatly in
on the future for satellite communications and its use for the coming years. Historically, as each new technique was
voice service. introduced, those associated with its creation were often so
New video services have also emerged from the digital zealous in promoting it that the inexperienced were misled
revolution. Once these services were limited to full-motion into thinking that it would dominate the telecommunications
broadcast quality video. New services have been developed to field. This has not often been the case. Each technique tends
create revolutionary communication systems, such as video to apply best under a particular set of circumstances, and as
teleconferencing for business applications. New transmission telecommunications expand, each finds its proper place in the
systems have evolved for communicating image signals at overall communications framework.
data rates and bandwidths far less than normally required for Table 1 lists each technology and illustrates those applica-
broadcast quality video. Facsimile and graphics systems are tions for which it performs best. Also noted are the primary
also developing rapidly as new tools to communicate image issues or problems associated with that particular technology.
information while saving on the cost of travel. Nevertheless Satellite transmission, for example, applies best in long-haul
video conferencing is still a developing service not likely to applications for medium to wideband transmission. Because
achieve its potential until the 1990s. of its geometric advantage, it is suited for multipoint-to-
Perhaps the fastest growing area is that of data communica- multipoint (multiple access), multipoint-to-point (data
tion services. Seeded by the financial community and large gathering), or point-to-multipoint (broadcast) applications.
corporations seeking to manage their businesses better, new In these services its inherent advantage over terrestrial tech-
data communication services have emerged. Database access niques is formidable.
and data transfer through widely dispersed processing sys- One of the early uncertainties in satellite technology was
tems, transactional service for retail operations, inventory the effect of the long time delay to geosynchronous orbit. The
management systems, network management, remote access combination of delay and echo can be distressing on a
and electronic mail are just a few examples of new services. A telephone conversation and the delay alone can reduce the
wide range of data rates is required to support these various 'through point' when data are transmitted, although it
services. For discussion purposes, we classify data services in certainly must be considered in any satellite communications
terms of speed, roughly in accordance with the bandwidth systems design, proven solutions to the problems exist. Error
capabilities of the transmission media. correction algorithms must be tailored to satellite transmis-
sions. The unique geometric advantage of a satellite
in geosynchronous orbit makes it possible to service
Speed range Data rate complex, fully interconnected mesh networks with in-
Low speed (narrowband) < 1200 bits per second dividual nodes widely seperated on the Earth's surface.
Medium speed (voiceband) 1.2 to 64 kilobits per second Note that with N links, the geometric advantage of
High speed (wideband) 64 kilobits per second to the satellite position allows [N(N-1)/2] links of inter-
3 megabits per second connection without introducing switching. This means if there
are 50 earth stations in a network, 1,225 direct pathways
Table 1
Local distribution radio Local/regional Medium to high speed Point-to-point Transmission path
Point-to- geometry
multipoint
Wire pairs Local Low to medium speed Point-to-point Construction cost (cable
duct availability)
23
Satellites International
are possible via satellite [e.g., 50(49)/2= 1 ,225]. Note also that Earth station growth, in sheer numbers, is even more
communications between any two nodes in such a network is dramatic. The estimated value of the annual earth station
independent of the distance between them. This distance marketplace by the end of the decade is well over
insensitivity is a distinct characteristic of satellite systems $300,000,000. There are multiple market segments employing
which applies within the coverage area of a particular RF large numbers of earth stations. These markets include
beam. One should be careful not to interpret distance common carriers, large businesses, government and televi-
insensitivity within a particular beam as meaning that the cost sion distribution. The continued long-term growth is concen-
of a satellite link is independent of the size of the total trated in large business communications government and
geographic area covered by the beam. As coverage area common carriers. It should be noted that small home
increases, more satellite power is needed to produce the same terminals for direct broadcast and mobile satellite applica-
EIRP on the ground and thus higher costs are incurred. tions may ultimately number in the millions.
Digital microwave radio, evolving at the same time, fits
well in local or regional network applications and is applic-
able to wideband transmission in point-to-point applications. FURTHER READING
Typically, the issue for the systems engineer is to transmit the
desired information and accommodate the network Communications Act of 1934, as amended, latest edition
geometry, while coordinating frequency and power levels so (stock number 0400-0264), Superintendent of Public Docu-
as to share the spectrum with other systems. ments, United States Government Printing Office, Washing-
Optical fibre and coaxial cable systems, now rapidly ton, DC 20402.
developing, are also applicable to wideband transmission. 'Determination of Coordination Area', CCIR Report 382-3,
Point-to-point and in some cases point-to-multipoint network CCIR Green Books, Volume IX, International Telecom-
applications are possible. The salient issue is the cost of munication Union, Geneva, Switzerland.
construction of the network. Regardless of the cost of the Edelson, Burton I. 'Global Satellite Communications', Scien-
optical fibre itself, the cost of the cable ducts (or just the cost tific American, Volume 236, no. 2, February 1977.
of installing the fibre in existing ducts) can make a network IEEE Transactions on Communications: Special Issue on
too expensive compared to other methods. However, the Satellite Communications, October 1979.
installed cost of fibre links is dropping rapidly, thus now
providing strong competition for satellite communications in
high traffic density point-to-point applications.
The technology for local distribution radio has been
developing for many years and is now emerging rapidly
because it allows the instantaneous set-up of digital services
between a central site and a local network node. Data rates
and services from low speed (1,200 bits per second) to high
speed (1.544 megabits per second) are easily set up covering
network distances of approximately 5 to 15 miles. Transmis-
sion path geometry, as in the case of any radio system, is the
critical item.
Twisted wire pairs are one of the greatest natural com-
munications resources for local distribution existing in the
world today. Narrowband and medium band information and
correspondingly low and mediumdata rates are possible on
the wire pairs that have been installed by telephone com-
panies over the past one hundred years. The use of wire pairs
is limited to point-to-point applications and the critical issue is
installation cost, often re'l,~ted to the availability of pathways
for cable installation. We can expect that the pathways for
existing local telephone systems will be used in the future to
accommodate coaxial cables and optical fibres where twisted
pairs are now used.
24
4 WORLD TELECOMMUNICATIONS LEADERS
The history of satellites is a tale not only of outstanding technological achievement but also of
remarkable international co-operation. Here the leaders of four of the major international bodies
which have orchestrated and advanced this co-operation outline the development and objectives of
their own organizations. Dean Burch, Director General of Intelsat, describes the scale of Intelsat's
success and its strategy for continuing innovation and expansion. The Director General of
Inmarsat, Olof Lundberg, writes about past and future improvements made in maritime and
aeronautical communications through Inmarsat's utilization of the space segment. The success of
Eutelsat both as a provider of telecommunications services and as a catalyst for the European
space industry are described by the Secretary General of Eutelsat, Andrea Caruso. Richard
Butler, Secretary General of the International Telecommunication Union, explains the structure
and work of the Union in the field of regulation, standardization and development of
telecommunications in general, and space communications in particular.
The Intelsat global cooperative, formed in 1964, has a 20-year local communication development is achieved in the next
record of outstanding success. This success can be measured decade. In terms of communications impact on a worldwide
in many ways, such as the growth of the traffic on the system basis. few activities or events in recent times are of
which has grown an incredible 500 times - from 150 voice comparable scope.
channels at year-end 1965 to over 75,000 equivalent voice But major innovations with global impact are not new to
channels today. Intelsat began the global communications Intelsat. In 1982 there was no such thing as a full-time
satellite revolution with Early Bird, our first satellite, in 1965. international satellite TV distribution system. No more!
This satellite, with 240 telephone circuits, more than doubled Starting with a US-to-Australia system on the Pacific Ocean
the capacity available for transatlantic telecommunications satellite, the phenomenon of a full-time international net-
services in its day. work for satellite distribution has caught on quickly in the last
Early Bird is now dwarfed by the capabilities of today's three years. Today, there are 12 full-time international video
satellites. In 1987, Intelsat will launch the Intelsat VI satellite networks in operation or scheduled for operation, in which a
that will have the capacity to send simultaneously either growing number of countries around the world participate.
40,000 voice circuits or, in an all-video mode, over 200 Intelsat's performance in terms of providing reliable
television channels - or an incredible three billion bits of international and domestic satellite services, has constantly
information per second. That is sufficient digital capacity to improved, despite declining utilization charges. Satellite
send the Encyclopaedia Britannica (including colour facsimile reliability ratings are much higher than 99.9 percent. Intelsat
of the illustrations) from New York to London once every thus exemplifies. on a day-in, day-out basis, how the nations
three seconds. of the world- large and small, developed and developing-
Today, incredible telecommunication feats are being can effectively cooperate together with outstanding success.
achieved by lntelsat as a matter of routine. Each year lntelsat Intelsat's market-oriented strategies ensure that it Will
facilitates tens of millions of airline bookings around the continue to provide state-of-the-art telecommunications
world. Trillions of dollars in electronic fund transfers flow services to all parts of the globe. through this decade and
through the Intelsat global satellite network annually. During beyond.
1986, Intelsat relayed about one billion telephone conversa-
tions carried along some 1,800 different international earth
station-to-earth station pathways. In all, Intelsat now serves INTELSA T'S FIVE-POINT STRATEGY
170 countries and territories around the world.
Intelsat's near achievement of a global electronic village is Intelsat's innovative plans for the 1980s and 1990s have, as
dramatically shown by the fact that for global television their essence. five essential points.
spectacles, like the Olympics and the World Cup soccer
matches, global satellite audiences exceed over a billion New Services and Tariffs
people. Indeed, with the 1986 World Cup Soccer Finals in
Mexico and the Republic of Korea's Olympic Games in 1988, Since 1984, Intelsat has introduced more than 300 new
global video audiences may well reach two billion. It is for services. The characteristics of these new services and tariffs
these reasons that Intelsat is sometimes called the 'tomorrow involve lower costs, various levels of protected services.
organization'. greater flexibility in long-term lease capacities (from one to
Intelsat was formed for the purpose of creating an seven-year periods), new digital and video services. the
international telecommunications satellite network available introduction of new services that effectively utilize small and
to all countries of the world on a non-discriminatory and lower cost earth stations, advanced new services for sophisti-
globally averaged basis. In fact, it has achieved this objective cated business users. on the one hand, and thin route rural
and much more. Today, Intelsat also provides international and remote services to developing countries on the other, and
maritime mobile services to its sister organization, Inmarsat. greater flexibility for smaller users. such as new types of
It provides domestic (or internal) long-distance and rural part-time services and off-peak rates. Almost all of these
telecommunications in nearly 30 nations around the globe. innovations, particularly those offering services where small
The list of domestic service leases now ranges alphabetically earth terminals can be utilized, bring Intelsat closer to the
from Algeria to Zaire. With the recent innovation of planned customer. Intelsat has thus tried very hard to anticipate
domestic services (whereby capacity can be leased on a customer market-place demand.
non-preemptible basis or even sold for $3 to $5 million per In this respect Intelsat has made its biggest effort to
transponder) the prospects are good that the number of introduce new digital services that are cost effective. Its new
countries relying on Intelsat for internal communications will digital tariffs that entered into effect in April 1987. define a
double by 1990. With up to 170 transponders available to sell charge for only 'digital bearer' channels. This means that up
or lease for planned domestic services, this new Intelsat to five 'derived' channels can be realized from this single
policy could have a major impact on the rapidity with which 'bearer' channel. In effect Intelsat signatories who invest in
25
Satellites International
low rate encoding equipment and digital speech interpola- can be transmitted at data rates ranging between 15 megabits
tion equipment can obtain their new digital services at a per second and 68 megabits per second. The development of
fraction of the previous cost. more advanced and lower cost digital coding and decoding
In addition to these new commercially structured services equipment (or codecs) for video application suggests that
Intelsat has also initiated Project SHARE in association with studio-quality satellite transmissions should be achieved
the IIC. Project SHARE provides free satellite services for within the next five years in the range of 15 to 20 megabits per
education and health purposes. So far some 70 countries have second. Intelsat has already tested a 15 megabit digital
participated in this programme, including the People's compression television system under the Intelsat research and
Republic of China. which has initiated a national satellite- development programme on live satellite demonstrations.
distributed educational system. This system gives promise of allowing up to five television
channels to be derived from a single Intelsat transponder.
Small Earth Station Design Similar breakthroughs at lower data rates should be achieved
in the video conferencing service areas, particularly on
Among the more important of Intelsat's new service offerings dedicated corporate networks. This means that highly effec-
are the Intelsat Business Service (IBS), the Intelnet data tive motion video conferencing may be provided in the range
service to micro terminals, the Vista low-density telephony of, say, 512 to 768 kilobits per second and, perhaps within the
service, and new analog and digital television service. In all of next five years, at substantially lower rates as well.
these new services, the key ingredient is the introduction of All of these advanced techniques. largely of a digital
much smaller and lower-cost earth terminals. With IBS. a nature, will in effect allow Intelsat's global satellite charges to
3.5-metre earth station can be used on the customer's continue to decrease in future years. lntelsat is also exploring,
premises to interconnect directly into the global system. With on a parallel basis. more efficient operating techniques to
Intelnet. microterminals as small as 75 centimetres in derive higher fill factors in the lntelsat space segment, in
diameter can be used to receive data at 19.2 kilo bits per order that lntelsat-satellites will, in the future, more closely
second. Intelnet thus can be used to support such diverse approximate the fill factors achieved in terrestrial and
operations as electronic mail, remote printing of electronic submarine cable transmission systems. This, too, will help
newspapers, and news and financial distribution services. Intelsat achieve highly cost-competitive communications ser-
Because each microterminal, complete with encoding and vice capabilities for the 1980s and 1990s.
decoding equipment and microprocessors, costs only about
$2,500, they open a broad range of opportunities for Advanced Technologies
broadcast and large network operations that were never
before possible with satellite communications. VISTA earth The Intelsat VI satellite today represents the largest and most
terminals, for thin route and rural communications, some 4.5 sophisticated commercial communications satellite either in
metres in diameter. can and soon will be bringing satellite orbit or in production. This satellite has 50 transponders and
communications to remote parts of Africa, South America, operates in several frequency bands with a variety of
Asia and the South Pacific. Indeed, it is Intelsat's special duty modulation techniques. Perhaps most significant is the fact
and obligation to promote the cause of communication that Intelsat VI can be optimized to operate in the satellite-
development that distinguishes Intelsat in a substantive and switched TDMA mode, utilizing two 6x10 matrices for
important way from US entrepreneurs who are promoting dynamic switching and beam interconnection. The optimized
private transoceanic satellite systems. mode of operation allows Intelsat VI to transmit some three
Finally, Intelsat has redefined its earth station perform- billion bits of information per second; and provide services
ance characteristics to allow significant reductions in the cost ranging from low, medium and high power (including a
of building Intelsat standard earth stations. This will stimu- high-powered 44 DBW spot beam). Special new features,
late dJstnbutiOn ot earth statiOn networks w1th many smaller such as a domestic beam configuration to provide higher
antennas serving as multiple gateways into the Intelsat powered services optimized for domestic and/or regional
network. leases or for transoceanic 'cable buster' service have been
undertaken on two Intelsat VI satellites.
Advanced Modulation and Operating Techniques If the possible lifetime extension of lntelsat VI is taken into
consideration, as well as the low Intelsat option prices for
Intelsat is planning to implement a number of advanced additional purchases, then the cost efficiency of Intelsat's
modulation and operating techniques that should allow space segment looks very impressive. These spacecraft (in
significant increases in the amount of communications capac- terms of transponder performance per year in orbit) if not the
ity that can be derived from the Intelsat space segment in most cost effective communications facilities available any
future years. place in the world, are certainly very close to it. regardless of
In particular, Intelsat will implement (in the late 1980s and whether you are talking of domestic, regional or international
early 1990s) voice processing techniques - initially, at 32 service. For the future, Intelsat is looking at new capabilities,
kilobits per second data rates for telephone services and such as on-board processing techniques and electronic scan-
ultimately, at 16 kilobits per second. This innovation alone ning or hopping beam technology, that will allow Intelsat to
will allow Intelsat to double and then quadruple the capacity push ahead even further the frontiers of communications
of the Intelsat space segment. satellite technology to create not only highly cost-effective
Intelsat will also be implementing a special 'cable in the space segment capacity, but also the ability to operate with
sky' type of service (initially for the restoration of optical simplified TDMA terminals, whose cost may drop below
fibre systems) to transmit 140 megabits of data per second $100,000 per terminal. Receive-only services will become
through a single wideband Intelsat transponder. This, in available at very low costs indeed.
effect, means that eight such transponders will be able to
duplicate the entire capacity of the T AT-8 transatlantic Greater Reliability
optical fibre cable system.
Intelsat has also introduced a digital video service which Intelsat is also exploring procedures to ensure the increased
26
World Telecommunications Leaders
27
48 INMARSAT ON THE MOVE
Inmarsat came into being in July 1979, and began operations Inmarsat amended its Convention in October 1985 to give
in February 1982. Its purpose, as amended in October 1985, is it the institutional competence to provide aeronautical
'to make provision for the space segment necessary for services from 1988. The amendments followed discussions
improving maritime communications and, as practicable, with the aeronautical community and a recommendation
aeronautical communications, thereby assisting in improving from the international conference held in 1975-76 that led to
communications for distress and safety of life, communica- the organization's establishment, that Inmarsat study the use
tions for air traffic services, the efficiency and management of of multi-purpose satellites to provide both maritime and
ships and aircraft, maritime and aeronautical public corres- aeronautical communications.
pondence services and radiodetermination capabilities.' Trials and demonstrations of aeronautical communications
Forty-four states have adhered to the Inmarsat Convention via satellite have already begun and contracts are being
and have designated signatories, typically national telecom- awarded for further prototype equipment development.
munications administrations, to sign the Operating Agree- Inmarsat is working on standards for a high gain aircraft earth
ment. The organization is financed by contributions from its station (AES), capable of telephony and message traffic, as
signatories which are to be repaid with compensation set at 14 well as a low gain AES, used for low speed data traffic.
per cent. Initially, lnmarsat expects to provide aeronautical satellite
Inmarsat provides mobile satellite communications to the service for public correspondence (passenger communica-
maritime and offshore industries of more than 70 countries. tions), company communications and subsequently, for air
(All countries are entitled to join the organization and ships traffic control.
from all nations are able to use the system whether or not Inmarsat mobile satellite services will be provided in the
their country of registry is a member.) About 5,000 ships and following frequency bands from 1988:
other users are equipped with ship earth stations. Maritime mobile satellite service:
Currently, Inmarsat leases satellite capacity on geostation- 1,530-1,544 MHz (receive), 1,626.5-1,645.5 MHz
ary satellites positioned over the Atlantic, Indian and Pacific (transmit)
Ocean regions, providing global coverage, except for the Mobile satellite distress and safety:
polar regions beyond the 75 degree latitudes. These are the 1,544-1,545 MHz (receive), 1,645.5-1,646.5 MHz
Marisat satellites, the Marecs satellites and the maritime (transmit)
subsystems on certain Intelsat V satellites. In April 1985, it Aeronautical mobile satellite service- (AMSS) (R):
awarded a $150 million contract to an international consor- 1,545-1,546 ,MHz (receive), 1,646.5-1,647.5 MHz
tium led by British Aeorospace for construction of three (transmit)
satellites, with options on up to six more, to be launched from Inmarsat studies indicate that it will need all of the
1988. The satellites, part of Inmarsat's second generation maritime mobile satellite service spectrum - and more - by
system, will be needed to provide additional capacity for the the turn of the century. Equally, its preliminary estimates for
growing number of maritime and other users and to provide aeronautical public correspondence indicate a need for about
new services. 17 MHz in the same time frame. Currently the AMSS (R)
Services currently provided via the Inmarsat system are: band, which stretches from 1545-1559 MHz (downlink) and
telephone, facsimile and low/medium speed data over tele- 1645.5-1660.5 MHz (uplink), is restricted to safety-related
phone channels, telex, leased circuits for voice and high speed communications, such as air traffic control and some com-
data, high speed and very high speed data communications pany communications. The World Administrative Radio
and group calls (broadcast calls made by authorized shore- Conference (W ARC) for the mobile services, held in 1987, is
based users to selected ships). expected to review the allocations for mobile communica-
Currently, Inmarsat has type approved only one ship earth tions, including the AMSS (R) band.
station (SES) standard. The Standard A SES has a parabolic There is some demand for reallocation or sharing of the
antenna with a diameter between 85 and 125 em. About a band in North America by those organizations hoping to
dozen manufacturers around the world produce Standard A provide mobile satellite services in Canada and the US.
ship earth stations at competitive prices around $25,000. Studies undertaken by aeronautical agencies, including the
Inmarsat is developing other ship earth station standards. US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the Air Trans-
Standard B will be a digital version of Standard A, with 20 port Association and Aeronautical Radio Inc., as well as the
kHz channel 'spacing compared to the 50 kHz now used by International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), show that
Standard A. It will come into use from about 1989. Standard all of the AMSS (R) band will be needed by aerO"nautical
C will be a much smaller terminal, with an omnidirectional agencies by the year 2010 and that additional spectrum for
antenna and 5 kHz channel spacing, to be used for low speed aeronautical public correspondence will be needed.
data (600 bits per second) and telex services by smaller boats Inmarsat has drawn to the attention of its signatories and
such as fishing boats, yachts and lifeboats. It is expected to parties to the spectrum requirements for maritime and aero-
cost about $4,000 to $5,000 when it comes on the market in nautical satellite communications and is hopeful that neither
1988.
29
Satellites International
erosion nor reallocation of spectrum will occur. Inmarsat has
said that the aeronautical community, like the maritime
community, needs spectrum for global coverage, universal
standards and a common set of operating procedures.
In addition to maritime and aeronautical communications,
Inmarsat provides access to its system for certain land mobile
applications. For example, it has adopted a policy whereby it
can make access available for emergency relief operations on
land, where natural disasters such as earthquakes, droughts
or floods have disrupted existing communications or where
adequate communications do not exist. In such cases, a
mobile earth station can be used to re-establish a link with the
outside world via Inmarsat. Similarly, the Director General is
authorized to approve, on a case-by-case basis, the use of
mobile earth stations for land mobile communications where
no suitable alternative exists.
Use of the Inmarsat system is growing rapidly. As
mentioned earlier, there are 5,000 ship earth stations. This
figure will grow to about 11,000 by 1990 and to 17,000 by
1995. These numbers do not include aircraft or other mobile
earth stations, nor the impact which the Future Global
Maritime Distress and Safety System (FGMDSS) may
have.
The FGMDSS, to be introduced by the International
Maritime Organization from 1990, will replace the current
distress and safety arrangements with a new approach.
Whereas current arrangements rely essentially on ship-to-ship
assistance in the event of danger or distress, the future system
provides for vessels to alert the shore for coordination of
appropriate rescue arrangements. The FGMDSS will impact
all ships over 300 tonnes. Ships will be required to carry radio
equipment according to their area of operation. In Area A3,
which is within the Inmarsat coverage area, the ship will have
the choice of fitting either a ship earth station or high
frequency transmit-receive equipment with digital selective
calling. The FGMDSS, which will figure prominently in the
deliberations of WARC 1988, will probably lead to a
dramatic increase in the number of ship earth stations and the
amount of traffic through the Inmarsat system.
As a commercial but not-for-profit system, Inmarsat has
already earned a sufficient surplus of revenues over expendi-
tures. As a result, it was able to announce a reduction of up to
15 percent in its space segment charges for all services as ot
1 January 1986.
In addition to new standards and services, Inmarsat expects
to introduce spot beam service in the 1990s. Initially, this may
come with Inmarsat 2A, modified satellites in its second
generation system, with one or two steerable spot beams in
addition to the global beam coverage. Spot beam coverage
will enable higher power in the satellite to be delivered to
smaller, cheaper mobile terminals and may also lead to lower
communications charges. Although the Inmarsat 2 and 2A
satellites essentially use tested and proven technology, the
third generation Inmarsat satellites, scheduled for introduc-
tion in the late 1990s, will be advanced technology satellites,
delivering spot beam service around the world to a wide range
of mobile terminals, across the seas, in the air and on land.
30
4C THE EUROPEAN TELECOMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE
ORGANIZATION
31
40 THE INTERNATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATION UNION
AND SPACE COMMUNICATIONS
INTRODUCTION
the Radio Regulations. It is the latter regulations which
The role of the International Telecommunication Union is particularly apply, in so far as the regulation of satellite
essentially to harmonize the actions of nations for the communications is concerned. They are reviewed and revised
world-wide development of telecommunications - a role in by World Administrative Radio Conferences which are
which it has a distinguished record of over 120 years. convened by the Union when this is considered necessary.
The Union was established in 1865 in Paris and is the doyen The work of Administrative Conferences and the perma-
of intergovernmental organizations. Known at the time of its nent organs of the Union has over the years made significant
establishment as the International Telegraph Union, it contributions in realizing one of the basic objectives of the
changed its name in 1932 when it assumed additional Union, enunciated in the Convention, namely to:
responsibilities embracing telephony and radiocommunica- coordinate efforts with a view to harmonizing the
tions. The new name it took is the name that it bears today- developement of telecommunication facilities, notably
the International Telecommunication Union. those using space techniques, with a view to full advantage
In 1947 the Union entered into an agreement with the being taken of their possibilities.
United Nations through which it became the UN specialized
agency responsible for telecommunications.
Today, the Union has a membership of 162 countries and is ADMINISTRATIVE CONFERENCES
responsible for the regulation, standardization and promotion
of development of telecommunications of all kinds. The first World Administrative Radio Conference (WARC)
which, among other things, looked at the question of satellite
communications was the one held in 1959. It was soon
STRUCTURE followed by an extraordinary and specialized WARC in 1963
for space radiocommunications. The latter Conference
The Union has a multi-tiered structure which in a way marked the transition from regulatory provisions for research
corresponds to the diversity of demands that were progres- purpose to those applicable to the everyday reality of space
sively placed on it. This structure comprises Plenipotentiary telecommunications. Among other things, it made frequency
and Administrative Conferences, an Administrative Council allocations, and established procedures for the co-ordination
and four permanent organs, namely, the General Secretariat, of satellite networks with one another as well as between
two International Consultative Committees, one for Radio space communication systems and terrestrial systems with
and the other for Telegraphy and Telephony and the which some sharing of spectrum space is involved.
International Frequency Registration Board. Progress was rapid in the following years leading to major
The Plenipotentiary Conference, as the supreme organ of and specialized service reviews in 1971 by a WARC for space
the ITU, meets periodically (normally once in every five telecommunications - a conference which was almost of a
years) and reviews and updates the International Telecom- general character in that it reviewed all services in the
munication Convention, the Union's basic instrument. The perspective of space options and extended in a very large
Conference revised one the of the Articles of the Interna- measure the Radio Frequency Allocation Table. For the first
tional Telecommunication Convention at its meetings of time frequency bands were allocated to the Broadcasting
Malaga-Torremolinos (1973) and Nairobi (1982), to recog- Satellite Service, for use under certain specific conditions,
nize the fundamental importance of the geostationary which included the establishment of plans. Then came the
satellite orbit (along with the radio frequency spectrum) as a 1977 W ARC for the planning of the Broadcasting-Satellite
limited national resource. The relevant text currently appear- Service. which established a Plan for the service in the 12
ing in Article 33 of the Convention reads: GHz band for Regions 1 and 3* along with arrangements for
In using frequency bands for space radio services Members Region 2 pending a subsequent conference, the 1983 Region
shall bear in mind that radio frequencies and the geosta- 2 Broadcasting-Satellite Service Conference. Between 1977
tionary satellite orbit are limited natural resources and and 1983, there had been the major WARC 1979 with its
that they must be used efficiently and economically, in almost total review of the radio spectrum allocations and
conformity with the provisions of the Radio Regulations, co-ordination and planning arrangements, including refine-
so that countries or groups of countries may have ments to the 12 GHz band allocations which paved the way
equitable access to both, taking into account the special for the practical planning of the 1983 Region 2 Conference.
needs of the developing countries and the geographical In the two decades between 1959 and 1979, many technolo-
situation of particular countries. gical improvements had taken place which resulted in the
The Convention has international treaty force and is cost/benefit ratio of satellite communications becoming
supplemented by the Administrative Regulations, which, favourable even for domestic communications where the
besides the Telegraph and Telephone Regulations, include distances to be spanned were far less than those involved in
33
Satellites International
Figure 2.
140" 120" 100° 40" 60" SO" 100" 120" 140° 160" ISO• 160"
20°
ISO" 1eo• 1•0• 120" 100• so• •o• 20" 20° 40" eo• so• 100" 120" 140" 1&0° ISO•
34
World Telecommunications Leaders
intercontinental systems. Thus satellite systems were tending Each CCI holds a Plenary Assembly every four years. The
to extend their usefulness from those providing global Plenary Assembly draws up a list of technical or operational
coverage to those with regional, sub-regional and domestic questions. the study of which would lead to improvements in
coverage. international radio communication or international telegra-
Because of these trends. the 1979 Conference took many phy and telephony. These questions are appropriately distri-
important decisions. Of these. two need to be mentioned. buted amongst a number of Study Groups. composed of
Firstly. the spectrum space allocated for providing conven- experts from different countries. The Study Groups draw up
tional point-to-point telecommunication services via satellite. Recommendations which are submitted to an ensuing Plenary
or the Fixed Satellite Service as it is called. was expanded. Assembly for adoption. CCIR and CCITT Recommendations
Secondly, while making a number of improvements in the though not always having the same binding force as the
regulatory provisions applicable to satellite communications. Administrative Regulations are almost universally followed
it decided that a future W ARC be convened 'to guarantee in as they represent the collective wisdom of operating adminis-
practice for all countries equitable access to the geostation- trations and companies. manufacturers and designers of
ary-satellite orbit and the frequency bands allocated to space equipment throughout the world.
services'. This Orbit Conference was to be held in two
sessions. Of these. the first session was held in 1985 and the The Radio Consultative Committee
second will be held in 19S8. The CCIR is the permanent organ of the ITU. responsible
The 19S5 First Session of the Orbit Conference - 0 RB (I) under the International Telecommunication Convention · ...
- established Final Acts (providing for the incorporation of to study technical and operating questions relating specifically
the Region 2 Broadcasting Satellite Service Plan into the to radiocommunications without limit of frequency range and
Radio Regulations) as well as a Report to the Second Session to issue recommendations on them ... · In this connection
which includes planning principles and method as well as the work of the CCIR includes:
procedural guidelines. • the provision of relevant technical bases for use by various
The Final Acts brought to fruition the objectives foreseen Administrative Radio Conferences as well as others
at the Plenipotentiary Conference of Malaga-Torremolinos in concerned with the efficient utilization of the radio-
1973. namely. the establishment of a definitive World frequency spectrum and geostationary-satellite orbit:
Agreement for the Broadcasting Satellite Service in the 12 • the recommendation of performance standards for space
GHz band. communication systems and technical arrangements that
A critical issue and challenge facing ORB (1) was how to assure their effective and compatible interworking in
find an acceptable way of guaranteeing in practice to all international telecommunications.
countries equitable access to the geostationary-satellite orbit In order to respond more effectively to a growing number
and the frequency bands allocated to the space radiocommu- of various technical questions concerning space services.
nication services. whilst reconciling that objective with the including questions of sharing the radio-frequency spectrum
efficient and economic use of these natural resources. and geostationary orbit, the Xllth CCIR Plenary Assembly
The adoption for the fixed satellite service of a novel and (New Delhi. 1970) created a new structure for the Study
dual approach. with allotment planning for certain bands and Groups. Indeed. among the eleven Study Groups of the
planning through improved procedures for certain other CCIR. seven are directly involved in studies of questions
bands, once again highlighted the pragmatic way in which the related to space communications. These are:
ITU could come to grips with issues that needed to be settled Study Group 2 - Space research and radioastronomy
in negotiations between its Members. ORB( I) also contri- Study Group 4 - Fixed-satellite service
buted, among other things. to the evolution of new technical Study Group 5 - Propagation in non-ionized media
criteria as well as the simplification of procedures associated Study Group 7 - Standard frequencies and time signals
with all space services. Study Group 8 - Mobile services
The First Session undoubtedly took an histone step Study Group 10- Broadcasting service (sound)
towards satisfying objectives for equitable access to the Study Group 11 - Broadcasting service (television)
geostationary-satellite orbit and the appropriate planning In the brief space of this contribution it would not be
mechanisms for radiocommunication services utilizing it. possible even to mention all the studies of the CCIR in the
Currently the intersessional work is being carried out both by field of space communications. Nevertheless it could be
the Members of the Union and by the permanent organs. indicated that the questions studied or being studied include
which will be brought to fruition at the Second Session of the the following: frequency utilization and orbit sharing aspects.
Conference scheduled to take place in 1988. such as interference assessment and control, antenna discri-
mination. cross polarization. and frequency interleaving:
propagation factors like attenuation and depolarization by
PERMANENT ORGANS OF THE UNION rain; system characteristics covering a wide variety of satellite
services such as the fixed-satellite service, the broadcasting-
satellite service, the earth-exploration satellite service. the
The Consultative Committees meteorological-satellite service and the mobile-satellite ser-
VIces.
The ITU has two Consultative Committees : the International Special mention should also be made of the studies
Radio Consultative Committee (abbreviated CCIR from its undertaken by the CCIR in the preparation of two hand-
French title) and the International Telegraph and Telephone books: one on Satellite Broadcasting Systems and the other
Consultative Committee (abbreviated CCITT from its French on Satellite Communications.
title). The CCis deal with technical and operational questions
in their respective fields of competence. All Member coun- The Telegraph and Telephone Consultative Committee
tries of the Union can participate in their work. as well as The duties of the CCITT are 'to study and issue recommenda-
recognized private operating agencies, scientific and indust- tions on technical, operating and tariff questions relating to
rial organizations, and international organizations. telecommunication services. other than technical or operating
35
Satellites International
questions relating specifically to radiocommunication.' • to effect, in accordance with the Radio Regulations, an
Within the framework of its mandate, the CCilT studies orderly recording of the positions assigned by countries to
the use of telecommunication and where necessary, the geostationary satellites, with a view to ensuring formal
signalling associated with these various types of information. international recognition thereof;
A number of Study Groups are concerned with this work, in • to furnish advice to Members with a view to the equitable,
areas such as telegraph and data services, telephone transmis- effective and economical use of the geostationary satellite
sion, telephone switching, telephone signalling and opera- orbit, taking into account the needs of Members requiring
tion, interconnection of maritime satellite communications assistance, the specific needs of developing countries, as
services with terrestrial telephone and telex networks etc. In well as the special geographical situation of particular
particular, the following Study Groups are involved: countries;
• to perform any additional duties, concerned with the
Study Group I - Definition and operational aspects assignment and utilization of frequencies and with the
of telegraph and telematic services equitable utilization of the geostationary satellite orbit, in
(facsimile, teletex, videotex, preparation for or in pursuance of the decision of such a
etc.) conference.
Study Group II - Telephone operation and quality In this regard, the IFRB applies the relevant co-ordination,
of service notification and registration procedures prescribed in the
Study Group XII - Telephone transmission perform- Radio Regulations. As part of this process, the IFRB
ance and local telephone networks received, in 1985 for example, information relating to more
Study Group XV - Transmission systems than 70 new satellite networks which it published, under the
Study Group XVIII - Digital networks advance publication procedure. Similarly, in the same year,
the IFRB published the necessary information concerning the
Insofar as space communications are concerned, the work request for co-ordination of space services assignments
of the CCITT basically involves studies leading to the relating to some 80 geostationary-satellite networks. Assist-
formation of appropriate recommendations for the use and ance was also provided on request to certain Administrations
integration of satellite circuits (with their relatively long (250 in the co-ordination of frequency assignments to stations in
millisecond) propagation times) in telecommunication net- various satellite services.
works. The subjects of such studies have included, for The IFRB also prepares reports for and participates in
instance, characteristics of echo suppressors and cancellors, world and regional administrative conferences on space
digital sp~ech interpolation, effects of long propagation times radiocommunications. These reports include information on:
on signalling systems, the use of circuits derived from • the application of the relevant regulatory provisions;
telecommunication satellites for the provision of maritime • any difficulties which may be reported to it by Administra-
mobile services and measures to be adopted for the use of tions in gaining access to suitable orbital locations and
satellite circuits for data transmission and telegraphy. Study frequencies;
Group XVIII has a pivotal role in the process of defining the • any difficulties encountered by the Board itself in applying
new Integrated Services Digital Network (ISDN). the relevant provisions along with an indication of the
solutions adopted.
Joint CCI activities Furthermore, for conferences in which planning is
Close collaboration exists between the CCis. In this regard, involved, the IFRB undertakes the necessary preparatory
mention should be made of the World Plan Committee and work for the computer aided development of plans based on
the four Regional Plan Committees (Africa, Latin America, requirements submitted by Administrations.
Asia and Oceania, Europe and the Mediterranean Basin), Finally, mention should be made of the list of space
which are joint CCITT/CCIR Committees. They are radiocommunication stations and radio astronomy stations
responsible for developing a General Plan for the Interna- maintained by the IFRB, which is published periodically.
tional Telecommunication Network to facilitate the co-
ordinated development of international telecommunication
services. The General Secretariat
There are also Special Autonomous Groups of the CCis
which work together as may be necessary on the preparation The main duties of the General Secretariat, of relevance to
of handbooks on subjects of particular interest, especially to space communications, besides providing administrative and
developing countries. One such subject relates to the econo- secretarial support to Conferences, are:
mic and technical impact of implementing a regional satellite • the planning and management of technical co-operation
network. programmes for the development of satellite communica-
tions;
The International Frequency Registration Board (IFRB) • the exchange, co-ordination and publication of general
information regarding satellite communications.
The IFRB's main task is to decide whether radio frequencies
which countries assign to their radio stations (and which they Technical Cooperation
notify to the Board) are in accordance with the Radio The General Secretariat provides assistance and technical
Regulations and would not cause harmful interference to co-operation for developing countries, in general with the
other stations. If the Board's finding in a particular case is financial support of the UNDP or other similar programmes
favourable, the frequency is recorded in the Master Interna- or funds. In order to facilitate the use of satellites by these
tional Frequency Register it maintains, thereby securing countries for their intercontinental, regional, sub-regional
formal international recognition for the assignment. and domestic communications, the ITU provides:
The essential duties of the International Frequency Reg- • services in regard to professional training which includes
istration Board (IFRB) in regard to space communications the provision of experts for courses, seminars and confer-
are: ences;
36
World Telecommunications Leaders
• support for individual satellite projects, i.e. expert assist- agencies such as UNESCO, ICAO, IMO and WMO, as well
ance in the analysis and appraisal of plans and specifica- as intergovernmental regional organizations having an
tions involving satellite communication services as well as interest in space communications. It also collaborates with
the evaluation of offers of supply of satellite communica- other international organizations like Intelsat. Intersputnik,
tion equipment from manufacturers including, as may be Inmarsat, Cos par and IAF. Such co-operation involves
necessary, supervision of the installation work; participation in the examination of questions of common
• development of general specifications, for example, of the concern and exchange of information of mutual interest. In
kind formulated for a GLObal approach to the provision of particular it participates in the work of the United Nations
DOMestic telecommunication service in the rural and Committee on the peaceful uses of outer space and its
remote areas of the developing world (GLODOM) in Scientific and Technical and Legal Sub-Committees.
which appropriate satellite technology (integrated with low As a part of its information exchange activities, the Union
capacity terrestrial systems in national networks) would be publishes each year an annual report on telecommunication
a significant element. and the peaceful uses of outer space.
It would not be possible in the space of this article to cover Furthermore, the Union's monthly Telecommunication
even on an illustrative basis the various types of technical Journal carries lists of satellites launched as well as articles
co-operation projects undertaken or being undertaken by the and information on space communications and space techni-
General Secretariat. Nevertheless, a brief explanation of a ques. The June 1985 issue of the Journal was devoted to space
current regional project may serve to give an idea of the matters and dealt with the role of the ITU in space
nature of the work involved. The project in question relates communications.
to an African regional satellite communication system which Finally, mention should be made of a Table of Satellites
is based on and flows from a decision taken by African (successfully launched during the period 1977-1984) which
governments to combine several projects involving satellite was published as a supplement to the July 1985 issue of the
communications. This decision was influenced by a pre- Journal. This table complements the first Table of Artificial
feasibility study carried out on appropriate modern telecom- Satellites covering the period 1957-1976 published as a
munication technology for integrated rural development in supplement to the February 1977 issue of the Journal.
Africa.
Preliminary work leading up to the feasibility study for this
project is currently under way. In response to a Resolution CONCLUSION
adopted by the Ministers concerned the Union is working as
the lead agency in an inter-agency Co-ordinating Committee It may be seen that over the years the Union has served to
which includes several African regional organizations. provide an appropriate regulatory framework, as well as the
The Committee has adopted a strategy for financing the necessary technical standards, to promote the timely develop-
study to select an optimal mix of terrestrial and satellite based ment and use of space communications. Through its technical
facilities which would best serve the telecommunication co-operation and information exchange activities, the Union
requirements of the African continent. The study would has also served as a catalyst and provided all possible support
cover all possible options including common user sharing of to this development process.
facilities. The conditions for implementing the project have The ITU will, in accordance with the mandate given to it by
been laid down and efforts are being made to mobilize the its 160 member countries, continue to carry forward its
necessary funds to start the feasibility study as soon as regulatory, standardization, planning, development and co-
possible. ordination work in the realm of space communications.
This project will no doubt benefit from one of the studies Only a brief overview of the salient features of the Union's
that the General Secretariat had carried out some time ago in work, in this rapidly developing field, could be presented
regard to the possible new applications of satellite com- here. Readers who wish to have more detailed information on
munications. the Union's work are advised to consult the relevant ITU
This earlier study concerned the use of high power publications, some of which have been referred to in this
satellites, or transponders of satellites, for domestic rural and contribution.
remote-area communications. The system recommended by
the study was one that would be available to developing
countries to provide intra-country connections over which
thin-route communications could be established. With a * For the purposes of Administrative Conferences, the world
satellite designed for high sensitivity, transfer-gain and is divided into three regions: Region 1 covers Europe
power, with a steerable-spot or area beams, it would be (including the whole of the territory of the USSR) and Africa;
possible to use ground stations with 3m and less antennae and Region 2 covers the Americas and Region 3 covers Asia and
fully solid-state equipment including power supplies suitable Australasia.
for operation in unelectrified rural areas.
For many developing countries a judicious blend of satellite
communication-technology with traditional terrestrial solu-
tions now appears to offer a unique opportunity for rapid
expansion of their national networks in directions they prefer
and to reach remote and rural areas sooner than would be
otherwise possible. Finally, as a result of the Maitland
Commission and its formally adopted report an independent
Center for Telecommunications Development has been
established in Geneva.
Exchange of information
The Union maintains close co-operation with UN specialized
37
5 EARTH STATION ANTENNAS
Kunishi Nosaka, Deputy Director, Kokusai Denshin Denwa Co. (KDD), Research and Development
Laboratories; former chairman, lntelsat Committee on Technical Matters; and Matsuichi Yamada, Manager,
Kokusai Denshin Denwa Co. (KDD), Radio Transmission Laboratory
The world of satellite communications, with the advent of advanced digital communications, is
marked by innovation. Earth station technology today is far more complex than it has ever been.
To design an earth station network one must consider the right radio frequency band, whether the
satellite signal is cross or circularly polarized, whether the applications require a small, medium or
large antenna, and whether analog or digital transmission is appropriate. This chapter explains in
detail the evolution of satellite earth station technology. It also explains why, in the 1990s, the
technology is moving towards smaller antennas, higher frequencies and more digital modulation
techniques.
INTRODUCTION
A satellite communication system integrates a satellite and an Technological innovations have opened up many new
earth station. Technically, it is analogous to a terrestrial opportunities for satellite communication applications in the
microwave relay system. Both systems send signals from a areas of regional and domestic public telecommunication,
transmitting site to a relay station in the middle, where the maritime communication, broadcasting, dedicated business
signals are then amplified and relayed to a remote receiving service, etc. Consequently, many different types of earth
site. The main feature of the satellite system is that the stations have emerged to fit specific applications. A particu-
terrestrial repeater in the middle is replaced by a satellite in larly remarkable development is that of small earth stations
space which circles around the Earth at varying altitudes from with dish sizes ranging from less than 3 to 10 metres in
more than several hundred kilometres to several tens of diameter for two-way communications and even several tens
thousands of kilometres above the ground. of centimetres for receiving signals. These small antennas are
Typically, communications satellites are placed in geosyn- exploiting the development of high power radiation from
chronous orbit, located 22,300 miles out in space. The satellites. Smaller earth stations are cheaper and have thus
propagation loss between earth stations and satellites in stimulated the application of satellites for mobile uses and the
geosynchronous orbit is very large, of the order of 200 dB (or home reception of broadcasts, etc, which require the econo-
1 x 10- 20 ). The performance of a satellite, measured in terms mical implementation of many earth stations. Today, even
of antenna gain and transmit power of its repeaters (or private industries are capable of constructing their own
transponders), are constrained by several factors such as the independent networks more economically in some countries.
limitations on the weight and size of the satellite. Thus, in The following sections describe the technical elements to
general, an earth station needs to transmit a high power signal be taken into account in designing earth stations, and analyse
to a satellite and be able to pick up a very weak signal from a the various types of earth stations that have been developed
satellite. from the early 1960s to the present for diversified applica-
An earth station is composed of an antenna with a tions.
transmitting system and receiving system. Although most
people are usually attracted by the view of a large dish-type
antenna looking up to the sky, earth station antennas now THE FIRST EARTH STATIONS IN THE EARLY
come in different shapes and many sizes, usually ranging from 1960s
3 to 30 metres in diameter. The technical characteristics of
earth stations can primarily be classified by 1) operating In satellite communication. radio signals propagate through
transmit/receive frequencies (eg, 6/4 GHz), 2) antenna free space, the ionosphere and the atmosphere. At frequen-
performance (or gain, which is explained later) and 3) cies below about 100 MHz, they suffer from attenuation
transmit power. effects due to reflection or absorption by the ionosphere.
The first commercial use of a satellite communication Furthermore, at frequencies below 1 GHz, cosmic noise from
system was the transoceanic public telecommunication ser- the Milky Way increases along with the wavelength. At
vice begun by lntelsat in 1964. The earth stations at that time frequencies above 10 GHz, oxygen, water vapour. "rain and
had antenna sizes of about 30 metres in diameter at the cloud in the atmosphere absorb and scatter radio waves
operating frequency band of 6/4 GHz. These were prototypes substantially.
of the Standard A station. Since then, satellite technologies Thus in the early 1960s engineers selected the frequency
have experienced significant advances and transponder capa- bands between and 1 and 10 GHz, called the radio window.
bilities have been improved both in power and bandwidth. For example, the uplink/downlink frequency bands for the
39
Satellites International
Telstar satellite launched in 1962 and the Early Bird in 1965
were 6/4 GHz , and those for Relay in 1962 and Syncom in
1963 were 2/4 GHz and 7/2 GHz respectively.
The most famous earth station in this experimental period
is the Andover earth station built by AT&T in the US in 1962.
It was used successfully for communication tests by Telstar
and later for commercial use for Early Bird. The antenna had
a horn reflector and operated at the 6/4 GHz band with an
aperture of 18 metres by 18 metres. It weighed 380 tons and
was covered by an 18-storey radome . Satellites launched in
the early 1960s were mostly non-synchronous satellites which
circled the Earth every two to four hours ; the ground antenna
thus had to be fully steerable in order to track the satellite's
movement. Since the horn reflector antennas had remarkably
low sidelobe characteristics in the off-axis from the main
beam, very little thermal noise is picked up from the ground.
This feature gives excellent low noise performance for signal
reception.
The Andover earth station was also equipped with a
MASER receiver (microwave amplifier by stimulated emis-
sion of radiation). It was cooled by liquid helium to operate as
an extremely low noise receiver. For sending signals into
space, a high power klystron transmitter of several kilowatts
was used. On the other hand , despite these technical
advantages, the horn-reflector antennas had several dis-
advantages, including its big mechanical construction and
high cost. This type of design was thus not favoured for
commercial use.
In the UK, a large parabolic antenna with a 26 metre
diameter was constructed at Goonhilly in 1962. A deep dish
was used to suppress thermal noise from the ground and a low
noise receiver (LNR) was placed near the primary horn in
front of the main dish to minimize feeder loss. But because of
its moderate performance and the inconvenient location of
the transmit/receive equipment, this type of antenna is now Figure I. Ibaraki earth station.
used only for small, low cost stations.
In Japan, an experimental 6/4 GHz earth station was built
in Ibaraki, about 100 kilometres north of Tokyo, in 1963. This earth station. This figure of merit is usually called the
earth station adopted the Cassegrain type antenna covered gain-to-noise (G/T) ratio (dB/K). Gain is expressed in
with a radome (although the radome was found to be decibels (dB) and thermal noise in degrees Kelvin (K). A
unnecessary and removed). Figure 1 shows the 22 metre larger G/T indicates a higher receive antenna gain with low
antenna of Ibaraki earth station. This earth station operated sidelobe characteristics and a lower receiver noise figure . For
with a 3 kilowatt high power klystron amplifier and a 6 degree example, the G/T of an Intelsat standard A station is 35.7
Kelvin low noise MASER receiver cooled by liquid helium . dB/K, while a small Inte\sat Business Service station such as
The Cassegrain-type antenna has the advantage of a short an E-1 has a G/T of 25 dB/K
wave guide that runs from the primary horn to the transmit/ The larger the diameter of an antenna, the higher the gain
receive equipment. This antenna design was later adapted as (G). The contribution to thermal noise (T) includes I) cosmic
the primary design of earth stations around the world. noise from the sky, 2) thermal noise in the atmosphere, 3)
ground noise picked up by the side\obes of the antenna and 4)
thermal noise originating in the receiver. The cosmic noise is
THE BASICS OF EARTH STATION DESIGN of the order of several Kelvin degrees and can be largely
neglected. The thermal noise originating from the absorption
The Gain to Noise Temperature Ratio of gases in the atmosphere becomes notable in the higher
frequency region over 10 GHz. The ground noise contribu-
The quality of the satellite link is expressed by the signal to tion can be substantial particularly at a low elevation angle
noise (S/N) power ratio at the receiving terminal. For and near urban areas. The receiver noise and the effects of
instance, if the transmit power of the satellite remains rainfall, which are the more significant elements, will be
constant, then the S/N ratio improves (i.e., gives a better addressed later. Figure 2 shows the typical characteristics of
reception quality) and the receive antenna gain is increased. total system noise temperatur_e versus elevation angle in the
The S/N ratio decreases as the noise power level at the clear sky for a 4 GHz antenna of 30 metres in diameter.
receiving earth station rises . The noise power is usually
expressed as the noise temperature. For example, a receiver Selection of Frequencies and Polarization
at temperature T (in degrees Kelvin) can be expressed in
terms of its thermal noise power hy the following: kT Table 1 shows the radio frequency allocations from the 1979
Watt/Hertz (where k is Boltzmann constant). This ratio of World Administrative Radio Conference (WARC 1979).
antenna gain (in decibels) to system noise power temperature These allocations include the fixed satellite service, the
T (in degrees Kelvin) expresses the basic performance of an mobile satellite service (maritime and aeronautical) and the
40
Earth Station Antennas
used for domestic and business satellite communication
systems.
A mechanically despun antenna on-board the satellite
which could focus its radiation beam to the Earth regardless
of the satellite's spinning, had not yet been developed by the
early 1960s. Instead, satellite antennas like the slotted array
or biconical antenna were used in this period. These antennas
could only radiate a linearly polarized radio signal at the 6/4
GHz band. Because the polarization plane at 6/4 GHz is
afffected by Faraday rotation in the ionosphere, earth
stations must compensate for this effect by using a polariza-
tion tracking device. A mechanically despun antenna was
developed for the Intelsat III series and the use of circular
polarization became possible. The international satellite
7 10 50 70 communication systems in the 6/4 GHz band use circular
Antenna elevation angle (deg.) polarization, while many domestic satellite systems use linear
polarization.
Figure2. In the higher frequency bands over 10 GHz, the effect of
Faraday rotation in the ionosphere is very small and most
satellite communication systems in these higher frequency
Table 1 Frequency allocations for satellite communications bands use linear polarization because of its simple ground
(WARC 1979) equipment. When more channel capacity is needed in a
satellite design, a frequent technique is to use orthogonal
Space to earth (downlink) Earth to space (uplink)
polarizations (linear or circular) in order to share the same
Fixed satellite service frequency band and accommodate more transponders.
2.500MHz-2.655MHz (Region 2)
2,500MHz-2,535MHz (Region 3) Propagation effects
2,655MHz-2,690MHz (Region 2,
Region 3) Rain attenuation
3.400MHz -4.200MHz 5,725MHz-5.850MHz (Region I) When radio waves travel through rain in the vicinity of an
4,500MHz -4.800MHz 5.850MHz-7 ,075MHz earth station, the signals are attentuated by absorption and
7.250MHz -7,750MHz 7, 9(XlMHz-8.400MHz
scattering. Figure 3 shows the amount of typical rain
10.7GHz -ll.7GHz 12.75GHz-13.25GHz
12.5GHz -12.75GHz (Region I 14.0GHz -14.8GHz
attentuation in C and Ku-bands in the temperate rain zone.
Region 3) 17.3GHz -18.1Ghz At frequencies over 10 GHz, rain attenuation is more
ll.7GHz-12.3Ghz (Region 2) 27.0GHz -27.5GHz (Region 2 significant. At sites with a substantially heavy rainfall, and if
17.7GHz-2l.2GHz Region 3) the elevation angle is unfavourably low, the transmission
27.5GHz-3l.OGHz
Maritime mobile satellite
1,530MHz-1.544MHz 1,626.5MHz-1,645MHz
Aeronautical mobile satellite
1,545MHz-1.559MHz 1,646.5MHz-1,660.5MHz
Mobile satellite
1,544MHz-1.545MHz 1,645.5MHz-1,646.5MHz
19.7GHz- 2l.2GHz 29.5GHz- 3l.OGHz
Broadcasting satellite
2,500MHz-2,690MHz iD
~
11.7GHz- 12.5GHz(Region I) c:
0
12.IGHz- 12.7GHz (Region 2) 'al
ll.7GHz- 12.2GHz (Region 3) :::l
c:
22.5GHz- 23.0GHz (Region 2, Region 3)
~
c:
·a;
broadcast satellite service. For the fixed satellite service, the a:
use of the 6/4 GHz band has been very popular since the 1960s
because of the favourable conditions of rain attenuation.
However, increased traffic demands and the desire to move
antennnas into cities where lower frequencies are now in use,
has brought attention to the frequency bands over 10 GHz.
the adoption of such higher frequencies requires system
designs that compensate for the propagation effects of the
atmosphere, ionosphere and rainfall attenuation effects. Satel- 50 100
lite antennas in the Ku (14/11 GHz) and Ka (30/20 GHz
bands are typically designed to have a large gain with limited Rain rate (mm/h)
beam coverages. This helps to compensate for atmospheric (8: Elevation angle)
and rainfall attenuation and also allows the use of smaller
earth stations. These higher frequency bands are now widely Figure3.
41
Satellites International
quality at these higher frequency bands may occasionally observed at locations near the geomagnetic equator and at
become very poor and unacceptable. In such situations. high latitudes when the level of solar activity is very high. For
spreading the earth stations over several different sites at a example. the signal variation at 4 GHz can be as much as 6 to
distance of more than 10 to 30 kilometers can improve system 8 dB.
availability.
Rainfall also contributes to the increase of thermal noise Polarization rotation in the ionosphere
received by earth station antennas. particularly at higher When a linearly polarized signal passes through the ionos-
frequency bands. The G/T figure of the earth station is thus phere. a rotation of the polarized plane can be observed. Its
significantly affected by precipitation. effect is inversely proportional to the square of the frequency.
This is called the Faraday rotation and may occasionally reach
a peak value as high as 9 degrees at 4 GHz. 4 degrees at 6
Rain depolarization GHz and 1 degree at 12 GHz. Therefore an earth station with
When a satellite is not re-using its frequencies by orthogonal linearly polarized signals needs to track or periodically adjust
polarization. the required level of cross-polarization discri- the polarization angle of receiving signals to compensate for
mination for satellite antennas and earth station antennas is the Faraday effect.
less stringent. In such cases. an axial ratio of 3 dB (or
cross-polarization discrimination (XPD) of 15 dB) is very Coordination with Other Systems
common. However. when frequency re-use by orthogonal
polarization is adopted. the antenna's axial ratio must be Most of the frequency bands allocated by the International
improved so that a co-polar signal can be separated from the Telecommunication Union to the fixed satellite service are
cross-polar signal. The axial ratio of 0.75 to 0.5 dB (XPD of shared with terrestrial radio relay systems. The ITU's CCIR
about 30 dB) is typical for earth station antennas and recommends that interference to satellite communications
satellites now in use. Heavy rainfall near the earth station from terrestrial radio networks should be kept within 10
increases the interference level of cross-polarization for both percent of the total noise budget. It is also important to keep
the uplink and downlink signals. particularly at earth stations interference from adjacent satellite communication systems
with low elevation angles. within a tolerable level. To achieve these objectives. the
ITU's Radio Regulations provide coordination procedures
Scintillation for adjacent systems. Every new system must follow this
When signals pass through the ionosphere. a rapid amplitude procedure. working through the appropriate administration
variation is created by the ionosphere's irregularity. particu- of each country and the ITU's International Frequency
larly at frequencies below 10 GHz. These effects can be Registration Board.
Az rotation
centre
Horn
Figure 4. Side elevation of various kinds of dish antenna. The arrows show the path of a transmitting signal.
42
Earth Station Antennas
CONFIGURATION OF EARTH STATIONS AND because of its asymmetrical structure, although it may be used
THEIR TECHNOLOGIES on a limited steerable basis. The Torus antenna is another
type of offset antenna. The Torus reflector, with the circular
There are many types of earth stations: giant earth stations shape along the direction of the equatorial arc and the
with 30 metre dishes can carry the traffic of thousands of parabolic shape along the orthogonal direction, is fixed on the
telephone channels, while a very small micro-terminal with a ground. Its radiation beam can be steered in the limited range
60 centimetre dish can be used to receive low speed data by a movable feed horn. Multibeam radiation by the Torus
signals. The most common earth station configuration is antenna is also possible by the use of multiple feed horns.
generally made of up 1) an antenna for the transmission and These antennas' performance is not as good as that of other
reception of radio signals, 2) a high power amplifier for offset antennas but they are less expensive due to the fixed
transmission, 3) a low noise receiver for reception and 4) reflector. They are therefore suitable for temporary installa-
communication systems which include a frequency converter, tions or experimental purposes. Also, this design allows for a
modulator/demodulator (modem) and the baseband signal single antenna to track more than one satellite using the one
processors. Earth stations for public telecommunication are fixed reflector and several tracking feed systems aimed at
usually connected by mean' of terrestrial systems to central different satellites.
switching centres in cities, even though direct access to
corporate PABXs (private automatic branch exchanges) are Tracking
now becoming more common even for public traffic. Even in the geostationary orbit a satellite moves about one or
more degrees in azimuth and elevation angles as looked at
Antenna subsystems from an earth station. This requires the provision of an
auto-tracking capability with an accuracy of less than one-
Types of antennas tenth of the halfpower beam width of the radiation pattern.
Most of the current earth stations (from large Intelsat earth Tracking accuracy of less than 0.01 degrees can be achieved in
stations down to the small micro-terminals) use reflective- the Intelsat standard A earth station by the use of a higher
type antennas because they provide a good performance at a mode tracking system. When the half-power beam width of
reasonable cost. There are four types of reflector antennas the antenna is relatively large compared to the movement of a
currently used for commercial applications: 1) parabolic, 2) satellite, a different kind of step track system is enough to
Cassegrain (standard or modified), 3) beam wave guide-fed perform this task. These drive the antenna in a trial and error
Cassegrain and 4) the new offset type, of parabolic, Casseg- manner at regular intervals to maximize the received signals.
rain or Gregorian design (see Figure 4). Because of its simplicity and low cost, the step track system is
The parabolic antenna is simple and less expensive, but its widely used in the small and medium size earth stations such
efficiency is not very high. In addition. the sidelobe character- as Intelsat standard B and Inmarsat ship terminals. The third
istics of this type of antenna are relatively poor because the method is the program tracking system where the antenna is
supporting struts for the feed-horn are in front of the main moved according to predicted data on the satellite ·s position
dish. It is used mainly as an antenna for small and economical and movement: this method is used in Intelsat standard A
terminals. antennas.
The standard Cassegrain antenna with dual reflectors was
developed because of its better efficiency and performance Antenna performance
and smaller sidelobe. It was often used to a significant degree Gain: The gain of the antenna is a measure of its energy
in the beginning of satellite communications but is now used concentration to or from a satellite and is given by the
chiefly as an economical antenna for medium size earth following equation:
stations such as the lntelsat standard B ( 11-metre antenna).
The horn reflector Cassegrain antenna is sometimes called a
"modified Cassegrain antenna'. This type of antenna was very G =lJ
popular during the early period of the Intelsat standard A
earth station because it had several advantages. One of these (where D is the aperture diameter of the main reflector. 'A is
was that the low noise receiver could be installed in a radio the wavelength and Yl is the aperture efficiency).
equipment room behind the main reflector which rotates only
in the azimuth direction; the high power amplifier could then Sidelobe: The unwanted spill over of radiation patterns in
be installed on the ground level by the use of a rotary joint to off-axis angles from the main beam is called a sidelobe.
achieve interconnection. Maximum suppression of the sidelobes is essential to reduce
The beam wave guide-fed Cassegrain antenna was the antenna noise of the earth station. This is particularly
developed to offer the convenience of easier maintenance and important for low elevation angle operation. In addition to
operation. In this design the high power amplifier and low the problem of the antennas' efficiency. side lobes can be the
noise receiver could be installed on the ground, eliminating source of interference to and from other systems. both
problems associated with antenna rotation. The overall satellite or terrestrial. The CCIR has determined the refer-
performance proved excellent and this type of antenna is now ence pattern of antenna sidelobes as 32-25 log dBi for any off-
widely used by the Intelsat standard A earth station. axis direction greater than one degree. A further improve-
The offset antennas of the parabolic, Cassegrain and ment of 3 dB is recommended as a design objective.
Gregorian types are the most recent developments. No
obstacles, such as a feed horn, are placed in the path of the Cross polarization: A good polarization purity of the order of
radio signals and thus the antenna gives an excellent sidelobe 30 dB (XPD) is necessary at an earth station which accesses a
performance. The use of such an offset antenna with low satellite with dual polarization.
sidelobe is especially desirable for smaller earth stations, A Cassegrain antenna typically has a symmetric reflector
since they are vulnerable to interference from other systems configuration working with a good corrugated horn feed and
because of their broad beam characteristics. Such an offset a polarizer with a 0.3 dB axial ratio. Such a configuration can
antenna may not be suitable for fully steerable systems demonstrate the necessary polarization purity. This type of
43
Satellites International
antenna is now widely used in the lntelsat system. the maritime system and by the single channel Vista terminals
The offset parabolic antennas normally do not have a good for thin route communications in the Intelsat system.
polarization purity because of their asymmetric reflector The following table shows examples of typical electrical
configuration. Special types of offset antenna such as Casseg- performance of HPA.
rain or Gregorian, however, are able to provide satisfactory
performances by reflector shaping. Table 3 Typical performances of high power amplifiers
Low noise receiver
Type Frequency Output power Bandwidth Application
The low noise receiver is the front-end receiver connected to TWT 6 GHz 10 KW 500 MHz lntclsat A
the receiving antenna and its noise temperature is a key factor Klystron 6 GHz 3 KW 40 MHz lnmarsat shore
station
which contributes to the value of earth station Gff. Two basic TWT 14 GHz 250 w 250 MHz IBS
types of LNR are available at present, the rarametric SSPA 1.6 GHz 60W 10 MHz lnmarsat ship
amplifier and the solid state gallium arsenide (G,_As) field terminal
effect transistor (FET) amplifier. The parametric amplifier is
a degenerative amplifier usually with a varactor diode. The 4 Communication equipment
GHz LNR has a low noise temperature of about 40 degrees
Kelvin. This type of amplifier is widely used in large earth Earth stations transit and receive radio signals with various
stations. The noise temperature of parametric amplifiers used types of modulation (e.g., FM PSK), which carry telephone,
in 11 GHz and 20 GHz are relatively high (i.e., over 100 TV and data. An important feature of satellite communica-
degrees Kelvin). This is considered acceptable because of the tions is multiple access - the ability to interconnect many
high sky noise temperature in these high frequency regions. earth stations directly through one satellite. There are three
multiple access methods: frequency division multiple access
Table 2 Typical performance of LNR (FDMA), time division multiple access (TDMA) and code
division multiple access (CDMA). The choice of modulation
and access is determined by the available satellite power, and
Noise
Amp temperature Bandwidth Cooling Application
the requirements for bandwidth and traffic.
Each earth station operator installs communication equip-
4 GHz PA 40°K 500 MHz Thermo- lntclsat A
electric
ment to fit the selected transmission method. It will consist of
4 GHz PA 60°K 500 MHz None Medium station baseband processors, a modem, TDMA synchronizer or
II GHz PA 100°K 750 MHz None Intclsat C frequency converter and carrier combiner/dividers, etc. On
4 GHz FET 55°K 500 MHz Thermo- lntelsat B the transmit chain, output carriers of the communication
electric
II GHz FET l70°K 750 MHz None IBS
equipment are sent to the HPA. On the receive side, output
1.5 GHz FET 90°K 45 MHz None lnmarsat ship carriers of the communication equipment are sent to the high
terminal power amplifier. On the receive side, output carriers from the
low noise receiver are fed to the communication equipment.
The GaAs FET amplifier is a new solid state device, The staff of a large earth station must maintain and operate
developed as a simplifier and less expensive LNR with a many facilities located in separate areas. They must also
relatively low noise figure. Many small and medium size earth monitor the operation conditions of many carriers for
stations have now adopted this device as an LNR, but transmission and reception. To carry out these tasks, most
operation is limited to low power and low capacity operation. large earth stations have a control and monitoring console.
The following table shows typical performances of LNRs.
The use of different types of high power amplifiers used for Experiences and technical developments in the past quarter
transmitters depends on the requirement of the transmit century have generated many satellite communication sys-
carriers of the earth stations. Three types of HP A are now tems.
available with various output powers and bandwidths. In 1965, Intelsat started its service in the Atlantic Ocean
Travelling wave tubes (TWT) are wide band amplifiers that region with Early Bird, which carried only 240 telephone
can cover a bandwidth of about 500 MHz that is available in circuits between five earth stations. Now, Intelsat is carrying
the 6 and 14 GHz bands and suitable for multi-carriers that about 45,000 telephone circuits on anetwork of Intelsat V and
can cover a bandwidth of about 500 MHz that is available in VA satellites and about 500 participating earth stations in 170
the 6 and 14 GHz bands and suitable for multi-carrier countries and territories.
transmission. The maximum level of output power now Inmarsat started its maritime mobile service in 1982 and
available in the market is about 10 kilowatts. now has a network of maritime satellites (the maritime
Klystron is an alternative amplifier with a narrow pass- communications subsystems, or MCS, on the Intelsat V
band which is usually used for a single carrier transmission. satellites and the Marecs satellites) which offer a global
Therefore, the power combined with multiple Klystron service with about 15 shore earth stations and some 5,000 ship
amplifiers is a second choice for multiple carrier transmission. terminals.
The Klystron amplifier is more efficient and has the merit of a Several regional groups of countries, united by culture,
longer lifetime, simpler maintenance and lower cost than a economy or by politics, have organized regional satellite
TWT. systems. These systems include Eutelsat (Europe), Palapa
Solid state power amplifiers (SSPA) have a relatively small (south east Asia), Arabsat (for the Arab world) and
output power but a high level of efficiency. They are Intersputnik (largely for Soviet bloc countries). These sys-
relatively small and cheap, and are becoming very popular as tems are offering their services with many earth stations in
an HP A for small earth stations such as required by ships for their respective service areas.
44
Earth Station Antennas
In the US, the Federal Communications Commission Table 5 Example of performance of lntelsat standard A
adopted an 'Open Sky Policy' in 1972 and allowed the entry earth station
of private satellite systems. This decision stimulated opportu-
nities for many diversified businesses. Today, there are 30 Type of antenna Beam wave guide fed
satellites in operation for US domestic communications with Cassegrain
thousands of earth stations and over a million TV receive- Type of mount Elevation-over-azimuth,
only antennas. The deployment of satellite systems for wheel-and-track
business services has triggered the construction of many small Autotracking method Monopulse tracking using
earth stations. higher mode
Diameter (metres) 34
lntelsat Earth Stations Frequency 4GHz 6GHz
GIT (clear sky) 42.1dB
Using a combination of Intelsat V and VA satellites deployed (at EL=5 deg)
in the three ocean regions- the Atlantic, Indian and Pacific- Gain* 61.9dB 65.6dB
Intelsat offers many services. The most important function of Noise temperature* 48 K
Intelsat is that it operates the global public telecommunica- (at EL=5 deg)
tion network for voice/data and TV transmission. To facilitate High power amplifier 12 KW TWT/3KW Klystron
each country's construction of their own earth stations and Low noise receiver 50K FET with thermo-
yet maintain their compatibility with other stations, Intelsat electric cooling
has specified the technical performance characteristics of 14
different standards including a variation of earth standards 'Including feed subsystem.
A,B,C,D,E,F,G and Z. Intelsat is endeavouring to respond
to other types of service requirement and anticipate new the likelihood of less expensive space segment charges. The
market trends. The Intelsat Business Service (IBS) was guided beam fed antenna with shaped reflectors is the most
introduced in 1983 to provide integrated business services by common type of antenna for the standard A station. The
which industry can transmit voice, data and other digital following table shows an example of the standard A earth
signals such as for video conferencing, computer data station characteristics.
transfer, etc, directly from the customers' office. Intelsat has
now specified the standard E and F earth stations for this new Standard B
service and will allow these smaller dishes for public The standard B station with a medium size antenna of about
telecommunication services. Intelsat has introduced another II metres at 6/4 GHz was developed as an economical earth
new type of digital data broadcasting/collection network station with a G/T of 31.7 dB/K.
called Intelnet I and II, which uses micro-terminals with A typical antenna type for the standard B station is the
antenna diameters as small as 0.6 metres. Intelsat's Vista Cassegrain antenna with shaped reflectors and mostly driven
service will provide minimal communication facilities for by the step tracking system. Occasionally, the tracking range
rural or remote communities via the small 4.5 metre low cost of antenna is limited within a minimum drive of azimuth and
earth station known as standard D. The table below elevation angles to reduce cost.
summarizes the main data of Intelsat standard earth stations.
Standard C
Table 4 lntelsat standard earth stations The standard C earth station was introduced as an earth
station to access the 14/11 GHz spot beam transponder of the
Frequency Size of Intelsat V satellite and to carry the trunk traffic of voice
Standard (GHz) antenna (m) Services circuits. Because 14111 GHz signals are affected substantially
by rainfall, the antenna size differs very much from 13 metres
A 6/4 30 1 Public voice/
on up, depending on the rain climate and operational
data,TV
elevation angle of the station sites. To define the G/T
B 6/4 13 Public voice/
requirement for the standard C station at the II GHz region,
data,TV
the predictive rain rate in a year can be taken into account as
c 14/11 13~20 Public voice/
follows:
data,TV
D 6/4 4.5~13 Vista
14/11,12 GIT = 39 + L 1 for all but 10 % of the time,
E 3.5~8.5 IBS
4.5~ 10
GIT = 32.5 + L 2 for 0.017 % of the time,
F 6/4 IBS
1 The specifications for the Intelsat Standard A station were reduced, effective
where L 1 and L2 are the predictive rain attenuation factors
March 19X6. to bring down the cost of future earth station construction and
higher power satellites within the lntclsat system.
relative to clear sky conditions exceeded for no more than 10
percent and 0.017% of the time respectively.
The guided beam fed Cassegrain antenna with a shaped
Standard A reflector is the most common design for the standard C
The standard A earth station has been widely used since 1965. station. The other feature of standard C stations is the use of
For years it was typically known as a large antenna of about linear polarized radio signals and a polarization adjustment
30 metres in diamter with a G/T of 40.7 dB/K for the 6/4 GHz device.
operation. Today, standards have been reduced to a G/T of For the economical construction of earth stations which
35.7 dB, and a 15 to 18 diameter antenna. Though the initial have the requirement of dual frequency operation of 14111
investment is higher than that for other smaller standard GHz and 6/4 GHz, an antenna with dual feed systems in those
stations, the satellite capacity can be utilized more efficiently. two frequency bands is now available and an earth station
Therefore, for earth stations with sizeable traffic require- design which satisfies both of the standard A and C
ments, Intelsat recommends the standard A earth station and specifications has already been constructed.
45
Satellites International
Standard E and F at 6/4 and 14111 GHz is currently the prime motivation to use
New digital transmission services for business applications, these higher frequencies. Earth stations for domestic systems
that can be offered directly to users by means of small earth usually have a high elevation angle, the main reflector can be
stations at or near the customer's premises, have become placed in nearly horizontal plane, an offset Cassegrain
attractive in the last few years to large commercial users. antenna with a 11.5 metre antenna could be installed on a
Intelsat has specified three types of standard E earth stations rooftop and even under strong winds would not be adversely
in the 14/11 and 14/12 GHz bands to provide its Intelsat affected.
Business Service (IBS). The standard E-1 (G/T= 25 dB/K) A limited steerable antenna is attractive because of its low
has a small antenna of 3.5 metres and is suitable for roof top cost, and a beam steerable antenna such as Torus is also used
installations. The standard E-2 has the figure of GT=29 occasionally in domestic satellite applications.
dB/K. The standard E-3 (G/T=34 dB/K) has a medium size Transportable earth stations which can be conveyed by a
antenna of about 8 metres and is intended as an urban helicopter or a truck, are also very popular to set up satellite
gateway" station to serve a group of IBS users. All these communication links on a temporary basis, for example, in
standard E stations transmit and receive integrated digital disaster situations.
signals of 64 kbit/s to 6.3 Mbit/s. Since IBS earth stations have Recently, data collection and distribution services have
small antennas, and are mostly installed in densely populated attracted attention. The basic network structure for this type
areas close to business districts, it is important to protect the is the communication link between a medium size 'hub'
signals against interference from adjacent terrestrial networks station and many micro terminals. often over several
sharing the same frequency bands. The offset antenna with thousand. The micro terminal is a very small and economical
low sidelobe characteristics is most suitable as a rooftop earth station with an antenna as small as 60 centimetres. For
antenna in this kind of environment. The New York Teleport example, Equatorial Communication Inc. provides a data
site was selected in a suburban area to provide many antennas distribution service from the central hub earth staion with an
for international and domestic business services, so that the 11 metre antenna to thousands ofreceive only microterminals
site is protected from any radio interference. located at customers' sites in the US. Financial and news
The standard F earth stations with antenna diameters of 5 services are the largest users of this data distribution service.
metres (F-1), 7 metres (F-2) and 9 metres (F-3) in the 6/4 GHz This very small antenna is susceptible to interference from
band were also specified to provide IBS service. Perhaps other systems because of its broad beam. The selection of a
more significantly Intelsat has also specified for intermediate special transmission method, to compensate for these
data rate carriers that the F-2, F-3 as well as the E-2 and E-3 interfering conditions (or high noise levels) is necessary.
earth stations can now be used for public switched service. Spread spectrum techniques is the main approach which has
been successfully used for this purpose.
Standard 0
The stand?rd D earth station is appropriate for rural and Ship Terminals for the Maritime Mobile Satellite
remote communities presently having inadequate or no System
services.
The basic network is provided by a link between the The maritime satellite system provides a communication link
standard D-1 station with a small antenna of 4.5 metres in between shore earth stations and the ship terminals in oceans.
diameter and the standard D-2 station with about a 10 metre The basic configuration of a shore station is almost the same
antenna. The standard D-1 carries only one or more voice as an Intelsat standard B station, except that its frequency
circuits. To be more economical it has less stringent charac- bands cover both the 6/4 GHz and 1.6/1.5 GHz bands. The
teristics for cross polarization purity and sidelobe characteris- remarkable features of the ship terminals are that the
tics. terminal must be small and light enough to be installed on
ships and, even more demanding, the antenna must be
steered to access a satellite under rolling and pitching
EARTH STATIONS FOR DOMESTIC SATELLITE conditions of a ship at sea.
COMMUNICATIONS Inmarsat has specified the technical characteristics of the
1.6/1.5 GHz ship earth stations as having a G/T of -4 dB/K.
There are many domestic satellite systems such as Satcom, This terminal consists of two separate systems, one above
Galaxy, Westar and SBS (USA), Anik (Canada), Telecom deck and one below. The above deck unit has an antenna of
(France), Insat (India), Palapa (Indonesia), CS (Japan). The about 1 metre in diameter, integrated with a solid state high
basic configuration of their earth stations does not differ power amplifier of about 50 W and a field effect transistor/
greatly from the Intelsat earth station standards. But domes- low noise receiver antenna, usually designed as a simple
tic systems generally have rather small service areas and parabola with a cross-dipole feed. Its mounting deck is
consequently a high satellite radiated power; they also stabilized regardless of the ships' course and movement by
anticipate access by a much larger number of earth stations. means of an x-y axis controlling device. The above deck
Consequently the earth stations are smaller. Sometimes a system is covered by a hard radome to protect it against wind,
dish the size of an Intelsat standard B station is adapted, but rain and snow. The below deck system consists of the
the tendency is to move towards smaller antennas in the range communication equipment. This includes the frequency
of 3 to 8 metres particularly for business uses and remote area selection equipment for the transmit/receive carriers, the
services. modem and the telephone/telex. Today, about 5,000 ship
Most domestic systems use the 6/4 GHz band, especially in terminals are offering voice, telex and data services to ships at
developing countries. This is exclusively the case in the 21 sea. Some terminals are also installed on oil rig platforms,
developing countries which purchase or lease capacity from although Intelsat provides such offshore service as well.
Intelsat for domestic services. The 14/11 GHz band is
generally used for business services applications. The use of Receive-only terminals for DBS
30/20 GHz is now observed only in Japan and the US. The
difficulty of frequency coordination with terrestrial networks Many high power satellite systems for direct broadcasting by
46
Earth Station Antennas
satellite (DBS) are now being deployed, such as TV-Sat in
Germany, TDFl in France, and the lower powered Aussat in
Australia. In Japan the BS-2 system started its DBS service in
1984. To provide an effective and economical service, DBS
receiving terminals must be very cheap and easy to operate.
The ITU's 1977 WARC on the Broadcasting Service adopted
a standard DBS receiving terminal for six 12 GHz circularly
polarized beams with antenna of 0. 7 to 1.6 metres in diameter
and a low noise receiver of no more than a 3 dB noise figure
(G/T = 6 dB).
Many DBS receiving terminals (consisting of an antenna
and adapter for connection with a home TV set) are available
in the market for $500 to $1,000. The most popular types of
antenna are front-fed or offset parabola. The latter has a
higher efficiency and is more effectively protected against
snow on the dish because of its mechanical configuration. To
reduce cost, the reflectors are usually made in fibre rein-
forced plastic or pressed aluminium. The signals are then
processed in the adapter for frequency selection, and con-
verted from the frequency modulation of DBS to the
amplitude modulation of terrestrial broadcasting systems.
47
6 THE ECONOMICS OF SATELLITE COMMUNICATIONS
The economics of satellite communications have many unusual aspects. It costs no more to
transmit via satellite a television signal to one. one hundred. one thousand or even a million
receivers. Satellites are also able to interconnect locations thousands of kilometres apart on a
distance insensitive basis; in other words. satellite telecommunications links in general cost the
same over short and very long-range distances. As a result, they are particularly well
suited for certain applications which terrestrial telecommunications, like microwave relay, coaxial
and optical fibre cable are not.
The applications where costs of service and technological advantage go to communications
satellites include: direct broadcast television or large scale television/radio distribution: long
distance overseas telecommunications services where large numbers of countries need to be
interconnected; mobile communications for aircraft. ships and land vehicles on long distance
journeys (i.e., non intraurban communications); data distribution services (e.g., news, electromc
publishing, etc); and rural and remote communications services.
The economics of satellite communications are also affected by rapid technological innovations
and by economies of scale in their operation. All of these factors are explored in this chapter by a
leading economic expert. Dr Marcellus Snow. who has published five books on the economics of
satellite communications.
In 1965. Intelsat began commercial service with a single systems must provide wires. cables or other physical conduits
Atlantic satellite having a capacity of 240 voice circuits - between all terminal points. These conduits must be installed.
enough to accommodate 240 telephone conversations. or one whether on poles. underground or on the sea bed. Repeaters
television transmission. simultaneously. It charged $32.000 are also necessary over longer routes.
for a one year lease for one-half of the capacity required for a Even line-of-sight radio frequency transmission is not
two-way telephone conversation. Twenty years later, the independent of distance. although it is less distance-sensitive
same capacity could be leased for $4.680. In 1987, Intelsat than wire technologies. Microwave systems. for example.
was using fifth generation satellites capable of carrying 15.000 require periodic repeater towers because of the Earth's
telephone conversations, and was preparing for the 1989 curvature. Only high frequency radio, an obsolescent tech-
launch of Intelsat VI spacecraft capable of accommodating nology with highly unreliable transmission properties, is
30,000 such conversations and three television transmissions relatively distance-insensitive among terrestrial communica-
at the same time. A similar record of more recent vintage has tions technologies.
been achieved by other commercial applications of satellite Another cost component of technologies such as cables is
technology. notably in the domestic communications and the expensive hierarchical switching required to achieve
remote sensing systems of the US and certain other countries interconnectivity. This is particularly so with the advent of
and regions. digital switching and other switching innovations that require
This chapter will examine the economic aspects of the very large investments in research and development. pri-
dramatic. technology-induced decrease in satellite com- marily because of the software necessary for each new
munications costs over the past two decades. Since Intelsat is generation.
the premier supplier of international commercial satellite Besides distance, the cost of terrestrial modes of com-
facilities, Intelsat's costs, tariff policies and regulatory acti- munication also increases with difficulties imposed by terrain
vites will figure prominently in this discussion of satellite and climate that intervene between sending and receiving
economics. Reference will also be made to economic charac- points. A country characterized by lofty mountain ranges.
teristics of other satellites and satellite systems. numerous islands or an inhospitable and inaccessible hinter-
land. for example. would find any terrestrial system costly
even for shorter distances. although distance would add its
ECONOMICALLY RELEVANT TECHNICAL own independent contribution to costs as well.
PROPERTIES OF SA TEL LITES Satellite technology. by contrast. is inherently insensitive to
the distance of transmission. at least within the coverage zone
The most important difference between space-based com- of a satellite. For a global beam from geosynchronous orbit,
munications systems and terrestrial ones concerns the rela- this is roughly one-third of the Earth's surface excluding the
tionship of cost with transmission distance. For all terrestrial polar regions. The satellite itself is the only 'repeater' apart
systems. total cost varies directly with distance, although from the earth stations with which it operates.
various fixed costs make this relationship proportional. Cost These cost properties imply that the economic advantage of
is particularly sensitive to distance in wire-based transmission satellites over terrestrial transmission modes is most pro-
systems that do not use the radio frequency spectrum. Such nounced when long distances. difficult terrain, severe climate
49
Satellites International
and sparse population are involved. Terrestrial technologic' minimization would 'uggest. of cour-.e. that Intelsat own and
may have a co~t edge in compact areas where flat terrain and operate the earth segment a~ well. consisting primarily of
equable climates favour dense settlement and heavy traffic earth stations and terrestrial links to the national telecom-
flows. The configuration of actual national and international munications networks of it~ member countries. Due to the
telecommunications networh. however. is usually a complex widely varying ways in which each Intelsat member organizes,
mixture of both technologies. and the isolation of one or the operates and regulate~ its domestic and international tele-
other in a comparative cost study i' not particularly realistic communications services. however. the earth segment is not
or insightful. part of Intelsat. Over the years. space segment cosh have
In addition to the quantitative advantage that satellites can fallen much more rapidly than earth segment cosh, making
provide because of their insensitivity to distance. they also Intelsat's charges a decreasing and on occas10n almost
exhibit qualitative properties that are superior to terrestrial insignificant part of total system costs.
modes. Over two decades, for example. until the recent Most other commercial satellite systems combine both the
advent of optical fibre technology. satellites were the only space and earth segments. This facilitates system optimization
means of transmitting televi,ion signals acros~ oceans because from an engineering standpoint and has certain implications
of the large capacity required. In addition. various broadcast for costs and cost recovery by me am. of a pricing structure.
and mobile radio services have requirements and properties Another fundamental distinction with important economic
that lend themselves uniquely to satellites. Finally, for implications is that between geosynchronous and non-
various technical reasons satellites are superior for both geosynchronous satellites. A stationary orbit is ideal for
communications and navigational purposes with aeroplanes telecommunications and minimizes the cost of earth stations.
and ships at sea. Inmarsat. the global maritime satellite Remote sensing satellites. of course. are of greatest value
organization. was created to provide world wide communica- close to the earth but must be tracked and monitored by more
tions and navigation services for ocean vessels. Although expensive gear. Finally. scientific satellites have a wide
analogous satellite-based technology for aircraft has existed variety of special requirement~. such as polar orbits.
for many years, a number of economic and political factors A final overall aspect of satellite costs is the pervasive
have prevented the establishment of a global navigation and economic distinction between static and dynamic effects. In
communications service for civil aviation. the static time frame, technology is frozen. Cost savings then
come from two main sources: average costs that decline as the
level of output increases (economies of scale), and cost
COSTS advantages accruing to multi-product firms that enjoy the cost
complementarities of joint production (economics of scope).
Table 1 gives a rough idea of the evolution of Intelsat's traffic. Economies of scale are the best-known static source of cost
net investment. and revenues during its first two decades of savings in large communications and other public utility
operation. Because Intelsat's Operating Agreement struc- entities. Economies of scope have been identified in much
tures it as an economic cooperative of owners and users. total more recent research that will be dealt with later in this
revenues in any year are a dependable proxy for total costs, chapter.
including capital depreciation, interest, and operation and
maintenance.
Table 1 furnishes ample evidence of the rapid and sustained PRICING STRATEGIES AND ECONOMIC REGULATION
decrease in Intelsat's per-circuit costs since 1965. By any
measure, such costs have fallen by a full order of magnitude While the relationship of cost to output combines economic
or more during the past 20 years of operation, even when with physical variables, the relationship of cost to prices is a
measured in nominal dollar~. The real rate of decline, taking purely economic one, involving no engineering or production
into account the considerable rate of international inflation data.
since the mid-1960s, would of course be considerably greater, The simplest market model. that of perfect competition,
perhaps by seven or eight percent annually. involves abstractions from reality that are not yet even
Three points bear particular mention with respect to these approximately correct for most communications firms,
costs. First. they are essentially independent of route or including satellite providers. In perfect competition, there are
distance within the coverage zone of a given satellite, a large number of small firms, none of which has the power to
typically that of an ocean region- Atlantic, Pacific or Indian. set prices. The interaction of supply and demand determines
Second. Intelsat's costs are only those of the space segment. price and output levels simultaneously and autonomously. All
These consist of the most of the satellites themselves, firms are assumed to have the same technology and informa-
including their design. development, launch, insurance and tion base, meaning that they have the same cost and
in-orbit station keeping. Overall system optimization and cost production functions.
50
The Economics of Satellite Communications
To minimize the costs of production, each firm produces fair to say that the public utility approach, at least in theory,
output at the level of minimum average cost, i.e. that point at has stressed efficiency while the main emphasis of the PTTs
which the benefits of economies of scale are greatest. At that has been on distributional considerations.
output leveL average cost is also equal to marginal cost, The technological advances of the past two decades.
which is the cost of producing the last or most recent unit. particularly in telecommunications and satellites, have intro-
Economic theory has demonstrated that under a wide variety duced strains in both regulatory approaches. The public
of conditions. the welfare of society is maximized if produc- utility tradition has been criticized for regulatory 'lag·,
tion occurs at the output level for which price equals marginal meaning that delays in legislative and administrative decisions
cost. Price then exactly covers the costs of production. and in their implementation have retarded the desired effects
including what in an accounting sense would be considered of regulation. typically in favour of the service providers. In
profit, namely a return to invested capital at the market rate. addition. the theoretical case has been made by Harvey
'Excess' profits above this return. such as are often earned by Averch and Leland Johnson for the point of view that rate of
unregulated monopolists. are not available. return regulation induces public utilities to engage in a mode
There are two primary reasons why the assumptions of of production that is inappropriately capital intensive. Like-
perfect competition are seldom applicable to the setting of wise, PTT operation of communications systems and other
most public utility enterprises. including those in the com- public utilities has, it is argued, been insufficiently swift in
munications industry. First, there is usually one large. accommodating user demands. particularly those from the
dominant firm rather than a number of small ones. A second business community. for introduction of a broad variety of
and not unrelated factor is that the dominant firm generally new telecommunication services. The PTTs have also been
enjoys economies of scale that extend well into and beyond criticized for neglecting criteria of production and tariff
the levels of market demand that would be generated by efficiency in favour of politically dictated production. innova-
conceivable pricing structures. For ease of exposition we tion, and pricing practices that many regard as contrary to the
simplify this model to that of a single monopoly firm enjoying best interests of society as a whole.
economies of scale - that is. average costs that decline as Since the early 1970s, two refinements in the theory of
output increases - for a single output and for indefinitely economic regulation and pricing have emerged that are
large levels of that output. particularly relevant to communications satellites systems and
Such a firm obviously has the market power to set prices at to telecommunications generally. These are: 1) the theory of
whatever level it wants. while consumers will buy output in pricing based on ability to pay (elasticity of demand): and 2)
amounts predicted by a demand function relating aggregate advances in industrial organization theory under the rubric of
demand to price. Economic theory shows that excess profit- sustainability of monopoly and contestability theory, which
that above and bevond a market rate of return in invested make use of cost and production functions that allow for the
capital- can be ge~erated by such a monopolist, and that it is more realistic case of multiple outputs. Each will now be
maximized when the monopolist charges a price that is equal briefly summarized and applied to cases involving satellite
to marginal revenue, i.e., the revenue generated by the sale communications.
of the most recent unit of output. In doing so the monpolist Although models of price discrimination have long been
harms the interests of consumers by creating a contrived familiar in micro economic theory, the reintroduction by
scarcity of output: less is produced than would be optimally William Baumol and David Bradford of seminal work by
desirable, and a higher price is charged than is needed to Frank Ramsey and Marcel Boiteux was instrumental in
cover production costs. This abuse of market power is the focusing attention on the potential of elasticity-based tariffs
basis of the received theory of economic regulation. It is to optimize pricing policy under the regulatory and technolo-
particularly applicable to the type of oversight of privately gical constraints usually encountered by public utilities.
owned public utilities exercized in the US by regulatory Specifically. a public utility with economies of scale faces the
bodies such as the Federal Communications Commission following problem: although economic welfare suggests that
(FCC). it is optimal for price to equal marginal cost, marginal cost
Such boards are charged with preventing the abuses of pricing in the presence of economies of scale cannot generate
market power that would ensue from unregulated monopoly. enough revenue to cover total costs, since the cost of the last
In its most straightforward version, the economic theorv of unit produced- marginal cost- is lower, given economies of
regulation holds~ that monopolies would be constrained to scale, than the cost of each of the previous units produced.
produce output at a level for which more would be produced So-called 'Ramsey pricing' addresses this problem by propos-
at a lower price, such that total costs are just covered. This ing a 'second best' solution: one separates users into
can be accomplished in a number of ways, including direct subgroups on the basis of varying price elasticities of demand
price regulation: rate-of-return regulation positing and (ability to pay). and each subgroup then pays a price equal to
admissible rate base on which return may be earned; marginal cost plus a premium inversely proportional to its
restriction of entry by competitors: and requirements for price elasticity of demand, where the factor of proportionality
universal or subsidized categories of service. is set at a value just sufficient to capture total operating costs.
Regulatory theory, and the regulatory practices that it In this manner, user groups with higher ability to pay (lower
informs, have been common in the US and Canada for price elasticity of demand) pay more, while those with a lower
decades. where most public utilities, including communica- ability to pay (higher price elasticity of demand) pay less. 1
tions systems, are privately owned and operated but publicly What are the uses of Ramsey-like pricing mechanisms for
regulated. Other countries. particularly those of continental satellite communications and for telecommunications gener-
Europe, have a stronger tradition of state-owned monopolies ally?
that provide basic services such as communications. energy By Article V( d) of its intergovernmental agreement,
and transportation. In such countries, the complex and often Intelsat is obliged to charge for its services on the basis of
adversarial model of regulation is replaced by ministerial average cost. This would appear to preclude it from any overt
oversight. ownership and operation based on more openly or conscious form of elasticity-based pricing, such as charging
political criteria, such as the perceived distributional effects differential rates for the same type of service in its three
and equity implications of various pricing alternatives. It is ocean regions. By contrast, pricing in the US domestic
51
Satellites International
satellite market is now almost completely deregulated, and potential domestic transponder leasee - whether a developed
excess capacity is providing incentives for demand-based or a developing country - more price sensitive than interna-
pricing favourable to most users. Similar pressures can be tional users, other things being equal.
expected to arise in other regional and domestic systems to
the extent that excess demand encounters an environment of
deregulation. SATELLITE ECONOMICS AND
Since 1973, Intelsat has practiced a type of pricing that can TELECOMMUNJCA TIONS DEREGULP.. TION
be construed as being based on ability to pay, although it has
certainly not involved explicit application of the Ramsey Readers need no rehearsal here of the widespread deregula-
inverse-elasticity rule. This tariff policy is Intelsat's leasing of tion of telecommunications, national and international, since
whole, half and quarter transponders for domestic use to its the early 1970s. The confines of this chapter make it
member countries. The origin of this policy is instructive with impossible to treat these developments with any generality;
respect to the conflict between pricing policy based on on the other hand, it is difficult to discuss examples of
average costs and that based on ability to pay. communications without dealing with the broader deregula-
Excess capacity over and above the need for system tory matrix in which they are embedded. Two topics appear
redundancy posed a problem for Intelsat in the early 1970s. suited for review here as case studies: the deregulation of the
Addressing the problem of 'marketing' these spare channels American domestic satellite market in the 1970s and the
while not violating lntelsat's statutory commitment to aver- issues of separate systems in competition with Intelsat which
age-cost pricing, its Finance Subcommittee stated: is more current and still partially unresolved.
As early as the mid-1960s, when Intelsat had just com-
'Circumstances [might] arise ... in which an incremental menced operation, the FCC began to receive applications
cost approach might be thought justified in the interests of from firms and non-profit entities to design, launch, own and
earning revenue from otherwise idle capacity. But it would operate communications satellite systems for domestic use.
be very important to avoid creating serious anomalies by As these requests accumulated, various policy options were
comparison with other Intelsat tariff offerings. If, for considered. The President's Task Force on Communications
example, transponders were made available to meet Policy (1968) reviewed alternative market structures for
special requests it would be unreasonable to deny signator- domestic satellites and concluded, in its final report, that a
ies already using the space segment the opportunity to single provider of domestic satellite service should be
make similar application, and if the rate were a favourable authorized by Congress in lieu of competition. This was
one it would enable signatories with large voice circuit congruent with the intent of the Communications Satellite
requirements to economize, at the expense of Intelsat Act of 1962, which had chartered the Communications
revenues, in their space segment charges.' Satellite Corporation as the single provider of international
satellite communications (via its membership in Intelsat) for
In 1973, at the instance of a request by Algeria to lease a the US. A year later, however, a new administration was in
transponder for domestic use, the Finance Subcommittee the White House, and the recommendations of the Presi-
stated that 'most' of its representatives: dent's Task Force were not heeded. Instead, the White
House issued a pro-competitive statement in 1970 that in
· ... agreed that it would be in the interest of Intelsat to many ways is a prescient anticipation of policy issues and
establish ... a new type of space segment utilization for terminology that would arise later in the decade. 2
domestic services, using spare capacity at a reduced Translated into policy initiatives as the FCC's Open Skies
cnarge. lt seemed reasonable ... to expect that by this Programme this pro-competitive stance has guided and
means traffic could be attracted to, or retained by, the shaped the market structure of domestic satellite service in
Intelsat system on a scale which would improve the the US since the early 1970s. Few would argue, in retrospect,
financial position of Intelsat as a whole and effect a that this incremental, market-based, competition-driven
reduction in the space segment cost for each user in the approach has not been in the overall interests of American
whole system.' industry and consumers alike. Other countries, notably
Japan, Australia and the UK, have also relied significantly on
Intelsat's Board of Governors decided in 1973 to establish market forces for the gradual introduction of domestic
leasing of transponders for domestic traffic (subject to satellite services. Some countries, to be sure, decided early on
interruption of service to accommodate emergency needs of that satellite communications were to be based primarily on
regular international traffic) as a separate tariff category, with government initiative outside of the influence of market
the price set at $1 million per year per transponder (now forces. These include Canada, which preceded the US by
reduced to $800,000). Since then approximately 35 different several years in offering domestic satellite service; Indonesia,
countries have availed themselves of domestic transponder whose Palapa system is now leasing transponders to neigh-
service. bouring countries as well; and France and the Federal
There are two senses in which Intelsars transponder Republic of Germany. The fact that several domestic
leasing can be interpreted as a kind of inverse elasticity communications satellite systems can co-exist and earn
pricing, i.e., a policy based on price sensitivity or ability to pay. money in the US market is a rather conclusive affirmation of
First, the majority of users (though by no means all) are the lack of natural monopoly conditions in that market
developing countries that can be considered more price asserted as long ago as 1970 by the White House and the
sensitive than wealthier users, other things equal. Second and FCC.
perhaps more important, Intelsat's intergovernmental agree- We now turn to the issue of separate systems in potential
ment discourages the establishment of separate public inter- competition with Intelsat. The Reagan administration has
national satellite systems that would cause 'significant econo- expressed conditional approval of some forms of competition
mic harm' to Intelsat, whereas no such stricture is applied to for separate systems established by American entrepreneurs,
domestic systems. Thus, the alternative of establishing a and the FCC followed suit in August 1985, by approving the
separate domestic system could be expected to make each applications of three private operators subject to the restric-
52
The Economics of Satellite Communications
tion that their services not interconnect with the national more encouraging policy toward the use of small, inexpen-
telephone systems of Intelsat member countries. What are sive, low power earth stations with the Intelsat space
the economic principles that underlie this ongoing conflict segment. It is difficult, however. to establish a cause and
regarding competing international satellite systems? effect relationship between the presence of latent competition
The basic public policy issue in terms of the cost and pricing and the behaviour of the incumbent firm and thereby to
concepts already established is whether Intelsat is a natural corroborate the contestability hypothesis.
monopoly and, if it is. whether its monopoly is sustainable or One final note deserves mention before we leave the
unsustainable. Natural monopoly is a property of the cost separate systems example. The tacit assumption until now has
function (technology) and thereby amenable to econometric been that competition would consist of the construction of
detection when the cost function is estimated. Despite the entirely separate satellite systems and networks - that new
war of words on both sides of the issue, empirical research physical facilities would be emplaced in orbit and on the
into this area is still in its infancy. 4 Three logical possibilities ground. A less severe type of competition, and one toward
present themselves. First, Intelsat might not possess natural which lntelsat has shown itself somewhat amenable, is what
monopoly - in words, it might be unable to offer a given has been called service competition, namely the resale or
combination of services as cheaply as two or more firms in wholesaling for third party use of circuits provided by Intelsat
concert (Intelsat presumably being one of those firms). In through a separate entrepreneur or retailer. This certainly has
that case. competition should be allowed so as to provide its precedent in the leased-line and value added services of
users with the lower-cost option of multi-firm output. Second, telecommunications firms using terrestrial or domestic satel-
Intelsat might have a natural monopoly that is sustainable, lite facilities. Once again, however. a satisfactorily rigorous
namely invulnerable to profitable entry by separate systems. comparison of service competition with facilities competition
In that case. entry would not pose a threat to Intelsat, since would require econometric cost estimation on a scale not yet
any competitors would lose money and presumably exist. To undertaken by the parties involved.
be sure. accounting and legal safeguards would be necessary
here to prevent below-cost (predatory) pricing on the part of
potential entrants with the means of sustaining short-term Conclusion: a systems setting
losses to establish a long-term market foothold. Third,
Intelsat might have a natural monopoly that is unsustainable, Let us synthesize our observations to this point within a
meaning that competitors could profitably enter and remain, systems framework. To emphasize the need for such a
even though the combination of their output and that of perspective. consider the 'chicken and egg' problem- that of
Intelsat against entry in the interest of users' welfare, and the bi-directional or circular causality in the satellite facilities
clearest description of the 'significant economic harm' to planning process. To estimate the need for facilities, one must
Intelsat referred to in Article XIV( d) of the inteigovernmen- know demand. To estimate demand, one must know price.
tal agreement.' To estimate price, one must know cost. And to estimate cost,
As noted earlier, a natural monopoly using strict Ramsey one must know the need for facilities. Certainly it is
pricing is sustainable against entry under a broad range of suboptimal to concentrate on some of these relationships to
conditions. This implies that any change in the direction of the exclusion of others. For example, demand for facilities is
elasticity-sensitive pricing from average-cost pricing would, often assumed to grow autonomously at a certain annual rate,
other things being equal, improve the chances of 'sustaining' with no sensitivity to alternative pricing structures.
natural monopoly against competition. Intelsat, however, Figure 1 indicates these relationships. Where one enters
appears to have this option available to it because of its this circle is immaterial from the standpoint of modern
obligation in Article V(d) of the intergovernmental agree- econometric techniques involving the estimation of systems of
ment, previously noted, to use globally averged pricing. 6 One simultaneous equations. Let us begin with capacity, the most
problem posed by globally averaged pricing is that some 'physical' of the variables enumerated. Costs are determined
services are priced below cost and others are priced above by capacity via the cost function, and we have noted that a
cost. This in turn provides 'cream' to 'skim' and is the basis of multi-product cost function is appropriate and presently
Intelsat's complaints of cream-skimming by potential entrants within the state of the art of economic science. In addition,
r
on the North Atlantic and other high-traffic routes on which several econometric and accounting based cost reconstruc-
Intelsat presumably recoups profits that finance thinner
traffic routes. including most of those to, from and between Demand
developing countries. function
The concept of economics of scope. or cost complementar-
ities in the production process, is also illustrated by the
separate systems issue. Natural monopolies are not generally Prio~
met head-on by competitors offering the same approximate
product mix, but rather by those specializing in particular
services. 7
We now turn to contestability of market structure, namely
the ability. noted above, of latent competition in an environ-
ment of low sunk costs and low-cost market entry and exist to
_L:
induce certain types of socially desirable behaviour on the
part of the incumbent firm. Some have argued that the threat
of entry by separate systems has encouraged Intelsat to Costs Facilities
provide more specialized services under more convenient
terms and conditions. Specialized offerings recently intro-
duced by Intelsat include the Vista service for developing
-------------
Cost
function
countries and the Intelsat Business System (IBS) for business-
oriented users. In addition, there has been a progressively Figure 1.
53
Satellites International
tions of Intelsat have been reviewed. Costs are recovered by 7. Suppose that Intelsat produces x units of voice traffic y
means of a tariff policy or pricing structure. Pricing policies units of data traffic and z units of video traffic at a cost
that we have noted include elasticity sensitive pricing, C(x,y,z). a firm with the same cost function producing only
globally averaged pricing. and marginal cost pricing. Prices, x units of voice traffic would sustain cost C(x,O,O,); likewise,
in turn, determine demand by means of the demand function. firms specializing in data and video alone would sustain costs
Price elasticity of demand. which must be known if elasticity C(O,y,O) and C(O,O,z) respectively. If Intelsat has sufficiently
sensitive pricing is to be used, emerges from this relationship. strong economies of scope (synergy, complementarity of
Finally. demand is related to capacity in the facilities planning production), then it can produce output combination (x,y,z)
process. which is perhaps the most information and indeter- more cheaply than can its three specialized competitors in
minate of the four relationships illustrated. Nevertheless. a concert:
rigorous cost-minimizing model of facilities planning relating
demand, capacity, costs. depreciation. price and the discount C(x,y,z) < C(x,O.O) + C(O,y.O) + C(O.O.z).
rate was summarized earlier in this chapter.
The relationships in Figure 1 are certainly not all-inclusive. Of course. if Intelsat has natural monopoly properties for this
Reciprocal effects with the economy at large. among other output combination. then this cost relationship afforded by
phenomena, have been distracted from. Demand, for exam- economies of scope follows as a special case. The most
ple, will certainly be affected by the overall levels of income common type of entry against a monopolist is often that of a
and employment, and the cost function will be sensitive to the small, specialized firm hoping that its advantages from
prices of production inputs. Nonetheless. Figure I. as does economies of scale in individual product lines will overcome
this chapter in general. gives an idea of the perspective and whatever economies of scope are enjoyed by the incumbent.
possibilities of economic science in discussing satellite com-
munications. It seems fair to conclude that the state of the art
has not yet been widely applied. Such an application appears FURTHER READING
quite desirable to illuminate the types of policy questions that
have emerged in the past and that are likely to arise in the Harvey Averch and Leland L. Johnson, 'Behaviour of the
future. Firm under Regulatory Constraint'. in American Economic
Review, Volume 52. no. 5, December 1962. pp. 1,052-69.
54
The Economics of Satellite Communications
55
7 PUBLIC POLICY ISSUES IN SATELLITE
COMMUNICATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING
Thomas L. McPhail, Director and Professor, Department of Communications Studies, University of Calgary;
author of Electronic Colonialism
As space applications have grown in number and sophistication over the last 20 years, the legal.
regulatory and public policy issues have grown and multiplied. Who owns the geosynchronous
orbital arc and how should access be regulated? Is remote sensing of other countries' resources
legal, and what ethical use should be made of such information once acquired? To what extent
does national sovereignty allow a country to control broadcasting within its own territory and thus
allow it to forbid direct broadcast satellite transmissions considered objectionable by the
government? These are some of the important policy issues that Canadian scholar Thomas L.
McPhail addresses in this chapter.
In the latter half of the twentieth century, after the start of the ACCESS TO THE GEOSTATIONARY ORBIT
space age, the international community recognized that the
existing body of international laws and treaties dealing with The less developed countries (LDCs) of the world are
earthly authority could not adequately address the problems particularly concerned about the allocation of the Fixed
posed by space activities. Satellite Service 'parking spots' in the geostationary orbit.
In order to develop a new international order, the United (The Fixed Satellite Service is distinct from the Broadcasting
Nations created the Committee On Peaceful Uses of Outer Satellite Service in that the former is non-broadcasting. FSS
Space (COPUOS) to develop and codify the law of outer involves two-way transmission of radio signals between
space. Since that time, several treaties have been formulated. satellites and fixed ground stations. Its signals are not
The first agreement was the Treaty on Principles Gov- intended for general reception by the public.)
erning the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Some planning of the geostationary orbit is necessary
Outer Space, Including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies because present technology cannot accommodate an unli-
(Outer Space Treaty). This instrument, signed in 1967, mited number of satellites. Approximately 3,000 satellites can
created a general framework for all future activities in outer be put into all of the bands allocated to the Fixed Satellite
space. It declared space as the common province of Service at the present time. Only 200 to 300 satellites can be
mankind, 1 that outer space is not subject to appropriation by put into the 6/4 GHz band (the C-band) which is considered
any state, that the exploration of space should be for the to be the most effective one for LDCs.
benefit of all of mankind, and that space activities should be A few LDCs, most notably Brazil, Indonesia and India,
conducted in accordance with international law. The agree- have already launched satellites. However, most LDCs do
ment also provides that nations should not interfere with the not yet have the technology to launch satellites of their own.
space activity of other nations; that operations that could These countries are concerned that by the time they do have
interfere with the activity of other states should be peacefully the technological capacity, all of the orbital slots in the
resolved through international consultations; and that laun- geostationary orbit may be gone. (Or, that if there are some
ching states should notify the UN and the international remaining, it will be more costly for an LDC to launch a
scientific community of the nature, location and results of satellite since new satellites must not interfere with satellites
space activity to the extent possible. that are already in the geostationary orbit; avoiding this can
The 1967 Outer Space Treaty set forth general provisions be expensive.)
for international activities in outer space. Subsequently As a result, the LDCs could like to have orbital slots in the
drafted treaties enunciated new principles for activities in GSO allotted to them on an 'a priori' basis (also known as
outer space and refined the broad guidelines set forth in the 'planning' or 'rationing'). The LDC's position is in sharp
Outer Space Treaty. contrast to the ITU's current 'first come, first served' (or
Despite the protection afforded by these treaties, there are engineering) policy favoured by the developed countries. The
still gaps in the law of outer space, particularly with regard to developed countries consider a priori planning to be_wasteful
international use of the geostationary satellite orbit, remote since it would tie up some parking spots that might never be
sensing of Earth resources by satellites and direct satellite used.
broadcasting of television signals. This chapter will analyse The 'first come, first served' policy of the ITU came under
the legal questions raised by these three issues, discuss recent attack in the 1970s. At the Malaga-Torremolinos Plenipo-
proposals under consideration in the international community tentiary Conference in 1973, the ITU adopted Article 33,
and recommend solutions that may foster beneficial use of which recognized the spectral/orbit resource as a limited
these outer space resources. natural resource that all nations were entitled to share
57
Satellites International
equitably and use efficiently. Though this article recognized Until a definition of outer space is developed. or until
the right of all nations to use the geostationary orbit, the 'first allocation of the GSO occurs. this issue is likely to continue to
come, first served' policy was left in effect because the only arise.
nations that could efficiently use the orbit were the ones that The issue that must be addressed is the question of
possessed the financial and technical capability to launch and sovereignty over the geostationary orbit. The geostationary
maintain communications satellites. orbit does not depend on Earth's gravity. Natural forces
In 1977, a World Administrative Radio Conference was constantly perturb the flight of geostationary satellites and
convened by the ITU to draw up regulations for direct without their on-board station keeping mechanisms these
broadcasting satellites. The conference adopted an allotment satellites would drift off into space. Furthermore, any linking
plan for two of the ITU's three regions based on an a priori of these satllites to the Earth results from the gravitational
planning principle whereby orbital positions were assigned to field of the entire planet, not the gravity within the borders of
nations in those regions regardless of need. Since these a single country.
changes only applied to the broadcast satellites using the 12114 The UN's resolutions recognizing state sovereignty over
GHz band and not to the overwhelming number of com- natural resourcces were intended to protect depletable raw
munications satellites using the 4/6 GHz band, the first come, materials that, historically, have been exploited. However.
first served policy was largely still in effect. the developing nations have attempted to link the concept of
In the US, the FCC established for domestic satellite users permanent sovereignty over limited natural resources to the
a 'multiple entry policy' in 1972 which was intended to make geostationary orbit through Article 33 of the ITU. Though
efficient use of the spectral/orbital resource while fostering the spectral/orbital resource is limited. its limitation is based
the rapid development of a competitive market. This 'open upon how well technology permits efficient use of the
skies' policy imposed virtually no restraint on applicants. As a resource. It cannot be completely consumed as can Earth-
result, the demand for service has outstripped the capacity of based natural resources. International custom also seems to
the orbital arc serving the US. Consequently, the commis- strike down the argument that the geostationary orbit is not a
sion's policy was attacked by both existing carriers and new part of outer space on the grounds the outer space begins at
entrants. However, the FCC has not changed is policy, and is the perigee of any satellite orbiting the Earth. The claim of
relying on technological improvements to meet future needs. sovereignty over the geostationary orbit also violates the
non-appropriation provision of the Outer Space Treaty.
58
Public Policy Issues and Satellites
force a gradual redistribution of the advantages of GSO orbits resources but also over information about those resources.
from developed to developing nations. Barring any major These resolutions are not binding, however, and even if they
change in their voting pattern. this redistributuion will were, it does not appear that the concept of sovereignty over
continue to influence the future legal trend of ITU policy natural resources extends to information about those
formulation. resources.
Aside from legal objections, there are also practical
considerations against adoption of a priori consent regime.
REMOTE SENSING The proposal is unenforceable and would seriously jeopardize
remote sensing technology. because the satellites cannot be
Remote sensing is 'the acquisition of information about the turned on and off and their 'footprints' cannot be shaped to
Earth's surface by the use of sensors placed on orbiting the contours of political boundaries.
spacecraft'. Currently. remote sensing is done only by the The proposal for strict controls over the disposition of
developed countries. primarily the US. Although it can yield information is based on the same questionable extension of
great benefits, many developing nations are concerned that the concept of sovereignty over information as a natural
the information collected may be used to their detriment. resource. Strict controls would also seem to have enforceabil-
They also feel that the existing international law cannot ity problems and would seem to violate the provision of the
adequately protect them from misuse of this technology. Outer Space Treaty calling for wide disclosure of the results
Much of the discomfort over the sufficiency of international of space activity.
law stems from the fact the the Outer Space Treaty does not The concern of most nations is that they will be placed at a
contain any specific references to remote sensing. The treaty disadvantage if they do not have access to the information.
can be viewed as imposing some limitations on remote Another approach would be to guarantee priority access to all
sensing because it is an activity carried out in space. Thus, sensed states along with an unrestricted right to technical
remote sensing should be conducted for the benefit and in the assistance for analysis of the data. By placing fewer restric-
interest of all countries and in accordance with international tions on the activity. the technology could be fully developed
law. The treaty also requires nations operating in space to to assure the optimum flow of benefits. Furthermore, a policy
inform the Secretary General of the ITU of the results of such of wide dissemination would promote international coopera-
activity to the greatest extent feasible. However. the extent tion and would be consistent with the spirit and letter of the
and provisions of this treaty are too vague to act as legal Outer Space Treaty.
directives binding nations that operate remote sensing satel- In the Remote Sensing Text, 4 remote sensing includes
lites. As a result of the concern over remote sensing satellites, observation of the 'natural resources of the Earth and its
the UN General Assembly, in 1971, authorized COPUOS to environment'. The word ·environment' is interpreted to
establish a working group on remote sensing to formulate a include human activity. Those nations concerned about
set of rules governing operation of remote sensing systems. 2 protecting military information have raised a debate over the
This legal subcommittee has drafted a set of 17 principles that present definition. They prefer to drop the word ·environ-
would act as voluntary guidelines.-' Although the subcommit- ment' from the definition and restrict remote sensing activi-
tee reached a consensus on many of the principles in the ties to natural resources.
draft, the provisions are largely mere reiterations of the ideas
set forth in the Outer Space Treaty. A wide division remains
on principles related to the right of countries to gather and DIRECT BROADCAST SATELLITES
disseminate information obtained by remote sensing tech-
nology. Direct broadcast satellites (DBS) operate within the Broad-
casting Satellite Service. They are called DBS because they
Issues broadcast directly to homes. DBS can only operate efficiently
in the geostationary orbit. However, unlike the problem of
When remote sensing is conducted in outer space. the activity allocating space in the GSO for Fixed Satellite Service (for
is beyond the territorial sovereignty of the sensed state and is non-broadcast purposes), there has been no such problem in
governed by international law. Apparently, there is no rule or allocating GSO space for DBS. The 1977 WARC on
principle of international law that prohibits a nation from Broadcast Satellites adopted assigned positions in the GSO
observing activity within another nation from beyond that for Region 1 (Europe, Africa, the USSR and Mongolia) and
country's territory. Because there is no rule prohibiting the Region 3 (Australasia). A Region 2 (the Americas) confer-
activity. remote sensing is presently considered legal and the ence was held in the summer of 1983 and it also adopted a
sensed countries have no say as to whether or not their priori assignments of the GSO over the western hemisphere,
territory will be subject to remote sensing by another country. albeit on a more extensive and flexible basis.
The LDCs are also concerned about the possibility of What is at issue with DBS is that broadcasts of information
companies or countries profiting from information about are made without deference to national borders. The dispute
them which they themselves do not have (as a result of the arising from this fact has been summarized as follows: 'While
information being too costly or not being made available to there is no consensus that transmissions broadcast from the
the LDC governments at all). They are worried that decisions satellites of one country to ground stations located in another
concerning their country's development will be made outside country violate any of the various telecommunication agree-
of their country. ments, a specific provision of the Radio Regulations provides
A substantial number of nations perceive the existing legal that "[in] devising the characteristics of a [broadcasting
regime as inadequate, and they have attempted to establish a satellite], all technical means available shall be used to
restrictive framework based on prior consent and strict reduce, to the maximum extent practicable, the radiation
controls over dissemination. The main foundation for this over the territory of other countries." The US maintains that
proposal has been that the concept of permanent sovereignty this is merely a technical requirement, but many countries
over natural resources, as embodied in several General view it as a prohibition against the use of the BSS to broadcast
Assembly resolutions, gives a state control not only over its to a foreign country without that country's consent.'
59
Satellites International
Many nations fear that DBS could be used to transmit claimed right to receive that transmission. This is not to say
propaganda or culturally offensive programming into their that prior consent is itself a principle of international law. The
territory, and that they will be unable to intercept because UNESCO Declaration did not establish prior consent as a
DBS will be able to bypass that country's retransmission principle of international law because that document did not
stations. As a result, the UN General Assembly authorized have the binding effect of a treaty. Although there is some
the COPUOS to establish a working group to study DBS. The authority that ITU Paragraph 428A imposes some limits on
committee has drafted a set of principles on the use of DBS, transmissions between countries, the effect of the regulation
but delegates have reached agreement on only six of the is at best uncertain.
provisions. For the past ten years, the DBS working group
has been unable to forge a consensus on the key issues of Conflict resolution
prior consent of the receiving state and programming content. Once DBS becomes widespread there are bound to be
It does not appear that any progress will occur in the near conflicts on these matters. How can these conflicts be
future because the debate has split along ideological lines. resolved? The Principles Governing Direct Satellite Broad-
casting, a draft treaty adopted as a United Nations General
Issues Assembly Resolution in 1982, states that any conflict should
be resolved via consultation between the parties and, failing
Individual rights vs. state rights that, via 'established procedures'. However, these procedures
The US and others believe that all individuals should have the may prove inadequate. If so, new conflict resolution proce-
right to receive any information they want to receive dures will have to be developed to deal with these issues in
including broadcasts from other countries. The USSR and the future.
many other developing countries argue that the interests of
the state are paramount and that individuals should not be
permitted to receive broadcasts if it is not in the interest of the REFERENCES
state for them to do so. The disagreement is based on
fundamental ideological differences that exist between 1. Since this treaty was ratified, the concept of the Common
societies, and the major space powers are at opposite ends in Heritage of Mankind has emerged.
this argument. 2. Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space
(COPUOS), 'Text of Draft Principles on Remote Sens-
Concern over content ing', reprinted in Report on the Twenty-First Session,
The LDCs are worried that broadcasts from other countries Annex/, 1981.
will contain propaganda, may arouse political tensions, and 3. Ibid.
would promote a culture and lifestyle inconsistent with their 4. Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space, 'Princi-
own. ples Governing the Use by States of Artificial Earth
A compromise solution appeared in 1973 when the Satellites for International Direct Television Broadcast-
UNESCO issued its Declaration of Guiding Principles on the ing, reprinted in Report on the Twentieth Session, Annex
Use of Satellite Broadcasting for the Free Flow of Informa- 11, 1981.
tion, the Spread of Education and Greater Cultural 5. Ibid.
Exchange. The declaration listed four types of programming 6. Ibid.
that would require varying degrees of prior consent. The four
categories were news, cultural, educational and commercial
advertising. The negotiating text that emerged from the DBS
legal committee also addressed programming content. 5
60
8 THE ITU AND SATELLITE COMMUNICATIONS
The International Telecommunications Union is the most important specialized agency of the
United Nations to address the field of telecommunications, including satellite communications.
Other UN agencies play some role, such as UNESCO, the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of
Outer Space, the International Maritime Organization, the International Civil Aviation
Organization, the UN Development Programme, the World Bank, the Intergovernmental Bureau
of Informatics, plus several others. But the ITU is considered to be the 'lead' agency. The ITU's
main constituent parts, the CCIR, CCITT and IFRB, are responsible for setting basic standards,
creating a framework for new digital services, authorizing orbital locations and frequency use for
satellites and providing technical cooperation and assistance for developing countries. Since
communications is so universal, it is not surprising that the ITU is the largest intergovernmental
organization, in terms of membership, in the world. In this chapter, George Codding, who has
studied the ITU for over 30 years, writes about how this organization works to regulate the
provision of communications satellites on a global basis. He explores in detail the general points
that Thomas McPhail analyzed in the preceding chapter.
The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) is the 1947. In 1865, the ITU's predecessor, the International
principal international organization involved in establishing Telegraph Union, was founded in Paris in order to help bring
technical rules and regulations for the proper use of satellites about an efficient European telegraph system. In 1936, the
for communication purposes. 1 As we will see, this task has International Telegraph Union, which by that time had
devolved on the ITU as a result of the ITU's overall become almost universal in membership and had expanded its
responsibility for the efficient operation of the world's mandate to include communication by telephone, merged
international telecommunication network and more specifi- with a group of administrations involved in the regulation of
cally, its responsibilities for the proper utilization of the radio radio communications to become the International Telecom-
frequency spectrum. An understanding of the nature and the munication Union. The third date, 1947, is the year that the
extent of this involvement is essential for all who are using Atlantic City ITU conferences thoroughly reorganized both
communication satellites and who plan to use them in the the ITU's structure and functions and brought it into
future. relationship with the United Nations. 4
After a quick look at the structure and functions of this The present-day structure of the ITU is made up of eight
unique organization, this chapter will investigate the rights major components: the plenipotentiary conference, world
vesting mechanism for terrestrial radio communications, on administrative conferences, regional administrative confer-
which the satellite communications rights vesting mechanism ences, the Administrative Council and the four permanent
is based. It will also trace the history of ITU involvement in organs. The plenipotentiary conference is the supreme organ
satellite communications from the 1959 Geneva ITU Admi- of the ITU with power to amend the International Telecom-
nistrative Radio Conference up to and including the recently munication Convention, the ITU's basic treaty. The plenipo-
concluded 1985 Space W ARC for the planning of the tentiary meets in principle every five years, and all members
geostationary satellite fixed services. A focus will be on some of the ITU have the right to be represented. As is the case in
of the more contentious problems that face the ITU in this all ITU conferences, each member countr<' has one vote and
arena, including the advantages and disadvantages of formal decisions are made by a simple majority.· The plenipotenti-
'a priori' planning as compared to the older 'first come, first ary conference also determines the general policies of the
served' method of obtaining rights to the use of certain union, establishes the basis for its budget, elects the ITU's
geostationary orbits and related radio frequency bands. 2 principal officials, and designates the states that are to send
Before proceeding, it might be helpful to note that representatives on the Administrative Council. 6
telecommunication, according to the ITU definition, World administrative conferences have the authority to
includes: revise the ITU's radio, telegraph and telephone regulations
and to consider 'any other question of a worldwide character
'any transmission, emission or reception of signs, signals, within the competence of the conference'. Regional adminis-
writing, images and sounds or intelligence of any nature by trative conferences are supposed to deal only with specific
wire, radio, optical or other electromagnetic systems . .J telecommunication questions of a regional nature'. 7
The Administrative Council meets annually at the head-
quarters of the ITU in Geneva, Switzerland, and is made up
BACKGROUND of the representatives of 41 countries selected by the
plenipotentiary conference 'with due regard to the need for
There are three major dates in the life of the ITU, the oldest equitable distribution of the seats on the Council among all
of the world's international organizations: 1865, 1936 and the regions of the world'. The ITU Convention gives the
61
Satellites International
council four major duties: I) ensure the efficient coordination protected from harmful interference from other users is
of the work of the union and exercise effective financial almost as old as radiocommunication itself. The first interna-
control over its permanent organs; 2) facilitate the imple- tional conference on radio held in Berlin in 1903 addressed
mentation by member countries of the provisions of the the obligation not to interfere and the requirement to give
convention, the radio, telegraph and telephone regulations notice of the frequencies being used. The Final Protocol of
and the decisions of ITU conferences; 3) determine the that conference, which was signed by six of the eight
union's policy of technical assistance; 4) promote interna- participating states, contained a provision which provided
tional cooperation for the provision of technical cooperation that :
to the developing countries by every means at its disposal. .. x
and also to carry out any other duties assigned to it by a 'Wireless telegraph stations should operate, as far as
plenipotentiary conference. The Administrative Council may possible, in such a manner as not to interfere with the
also resolve questions not covered by the convention that working of other stations.' 12 .
cannot wait to be settled at the next conference if it can obtain
the agreement of a majority of members. The problem of determining which station should yield to
The first of the ITU's permanent organs is the General another in cases of harmful interference was solved for the
Secretariat under the direction of a Secretary General and a ITU in an almost offhand manner. The same conference, in
Deputy Secretary General elected by the plenipotentiary an attempt to encourage intercommunication in the new
conference. The Secretary General is required to ensure maritime radio service, also included a provision in the Final
economic use of the union's resources and 'is responsible to Protocol which provided that:
the Administrative Council for all administrative and finan-
cial aspects of the Union's activities.'~ The General Secretar- 'The Contracting Parties shall publish all technical in-
iat, which has about 500 employees, is responsible for the formation of a nature to facilitate and accelerate com-
preparation of conferences, publishing research and admi- munications between coast stations and ships at sea.' 13
nistering the ITU's technical assistance programme.
The ITU also has an International Frequency Registration Another component was addressed three years later when the
Board (IFRB), an International Radio Consultative Commit- second Berlin Radiotelegraph Conference included a provi-
tee (CCIR), and an International Telegraph and Telephone sion in the Radio Regulations calling on the Berne Bureau of
Consultative Committee (CCITT), each of which has its own the International Telegraph Union to draw up a list of radio
specialized secretariat. 111 stations, including the frequencies used by those stations. The
The IFRB is made up of five individuals elected by the 'Frequency List of Radioelectricity Stations', which became
plenipotentiary conference. It is responsible for the orderly known as the Berne List, was made available to all interested
recording and registration of radio frequency assignments and parties.
positions assigned by registration of radio frequency assign- Administrations quickly began to use the Berne List as a
ments and positions assigned by countries to geostationary guide to selecting frequencies for new radio stations; and it
satellites, providing advice to member countries as to the soon became accepted practice that newer stations would not
most efficient use of radio frequencies and the geostationary interfere with those already registered. In cases of disputes,
satellite orbit, and assisting in the preparation for conferences harmful interference-free operation was the right of the radio
dealing with radio matters. station which was the first to be registered on the list.
The CCIR studies technical and operating questions The only major change in the first come, first served
relating to radio communications and issues recommenda- procedure occurred when the ITU created the IFRB and gave
tions concerning them. Any member of the ITU has the right it the task of overseeing the ITU's list of frequencies, the
to be a member of the CCIR and be involved in its activities name of which was changed to the Master International
as do private operating agencies that have obtained the Frequency Register, and the registration in that list of
sponsorship of an appropriate administration. The CCIR is frequencies notified to it by admi,,istrations.
made up of a Plenary Assembly which meets every four years. As it now stands, the first come, first served approach
The CCITT is similar to the CCIR, except that it also studies obliges administrations to notify the IFRB of any frequency
tariff questions and has a small laboratory at its disposal. 11 assignment in the specified radio services if: 1) it is capable of
causing harmful interference to any service of another
THE TERRESTRIAL RIGHTS VESTING administration; 2) if the frequency is to be used for
MECHANISM international communication; or 3) if the administration
desired 'to obtain international recognition of the use of the
There are basically two different types of satellite com- frequency'. 14 It should be noted that administrations are free
munication rights vesting mechanisms. The first one is based to use any other frequency in any manner that they desire.
on prior usage and has become known as the 'first come, first The IFRB examines each notification for its conformity with
served' approach; and the second, based on one or more the ITU convention and the Radio Regulations and decides
specific allotments to ITU member administrations contained whether it will cause harmful interference to the service
in a formal treaty, has become known as the a priori method. rendered by a station whose frequency has already been
Both systems are, with certain variations, derived directly recorded in the Master International Frequency Register. If
from the rights vesting mechanisms developed by the ITU for the findings of the board ar~ satisfactory, it will enter the
certain types of terrestrial radio communication. This section frequency in the Master Register. The date of that registra-
will be devoted to an account of the terrestrial system. Its tion determines the rights of that station against any other
application to satellite communication, with certain modifica- station. 15
tions, will be the subject of the following sections.
The 'a priori' approach
The first come, first served approach
The increased use of radio communication over the years and
The concept that a user of a radio frequency could be the resulting crowding of certain portions of the radio
62
The ITU and Satellite Communications
frequency spectrum led some to explore a more structured conference during the latter part of 1963 to examine the
approach to rights vesting. At a series of meetings shortly technical progress that had occurred in the use of radio
after World War L for instance, the US put forward a series communication for space research and, in the light of this
of proposals to its wartime allies to take all usable frequencies examination, decide whether to allocate frequency bands for
and redistribute them to all of the countries of the world on that purpose and consider new provisions for the Radio
an equitable basis. The recipients would have the right to use Regulations concerning the identification and control of radio
their allotment in any way they desired without harmful emission from space vehicles. IY
interference from the stations of other administrations. 16 The In response to the recommendation of the 1959 conference,
political climate changed, however, and nothing became of the ITU held an Extraordinary Administrative Radio Confer-
the US initiative. ence in Geneva in 1963 to investigate the frequency needs for
The situation finally became acute in Europe in the 1920s. satellite communications Without too much difficulty, the
The reception of broadcasting signals throughout Europe had conference designated an additional portion of the Frequency
become increasingly diffficult due to interference between the Allocation Table for the use of satellite communications on
stations of different countries. At the suggestion of the BBC, an exclusive as well as a shared basis.
an International Broadcasting Union (UIR) was created and Of special importance was the decision of the conference
given the task of finding a solution to the interference that these frequencies would be subject to the same notifica-
problem. The UIR's solution was to make an inventory of tion and recording process employed by the ITU for most
existing and projected usage and allot the available frequen- types of terrestrial radio communication, thus extending the
cies to each participating country according to a pre-arranged first come, first served principle to satellite communications.
formula. 17 In the beginning, the allotment plans that were While the decision itself was made without any great
produced were informal and non-binding, although they were opposition, a general discussion did occur over its possible
accepted and applied by most of the European broadcasting future implications. Several delegations expressed the opin-
administrations. However, the third such plan, the Prague ion that if something additional were not done, satellite
Plan, was incorporated by reference into the frequency communication might well become the monopoly of the
management provisions of the 1927 International Radiotele- richer nations. 20 Nothing was done directly to alleviate these
graph Convention and thus became binding on the parties to concerns, but when considering a separate but related matter,
it. the conference did adopt a recommendation to the effect that
With the creation of the ITU in 1934, The European all members of the ITU had a 'right to an equitable and
broadcasting allotment plans for the European braodcasting rational use of frequency bands allocated for space com-
service became part of the ITU's Radio Regulations. From munications' and that the use of the frequency spectrum for
1936 on, therefore, two different rights vesting schemes space communication should 'be subject to international
existed under the auspices of the ITU, the first come, first agreements based on principles of justice and equity permit-
served formula, whereby the right to use a frequency free ting the use and sharing of allocated frequency bands in the
from harmful interference was based on the date of its mutual interest of all nations'. 21
recording in the Master International Frequency Register;
and the a priori formula whereby the right to use a radio The New Regulatory Regime
frequency free from harmful interference was based on the
existence of an allotment of that frequency contained in a The 1971 Space WARC 22 was an important conference for
formal, binding treaty. 1x satellite communication in that it extended the scope of the
ITU's regulatory regime to include the geostationary satellite
orbit in addition to the frequencies used, and it made a frontal
THE ITU BECOMES INVOLVED IN SPACE attack on the concept that adminstrations should obtain any
permanent rights to any particular geostationary orbital
The ITU became involved in satellite communications only a positions or associated radio frequencies.
few years after it was demonstrated that messages could be After expanding the portions of the Frequency Allocation
sent to satellites and retransmitted to a predetermined Table devoted to satellite communication and identifying
location on the Earth. At first this involvement was of a several different space communications services on the basis
superficial nature owing to the newness of satellite com- of recent development, the conference entered into a
munication and the ITU's heavy responsibilities in other discussion of the frequency notification and registration
areas of radio communication. Soon, however, the regulation procedures for space communication. The delegates con-
of space communication was to become a major preoccupa- cluded that the procedures that had been used by the ITU in
tion of the ITU and its member administrations. the past for terrestrial radio communication and adapted to
the early satellite communication systems would not be
Preliminary steps adequate for systems involving geostationary satellites. As a
result, the 1971 conference introduced a new modified
The Ordinary Administrative Radio Conference of 1959, the procedure for geostationary satellite communication systems.
first general ITU radio conference to be held after the The new procedure consists of an advanced publication
launching of Sputnik 1, took due note of the claims that were process, a final coordination procedure and the recording of
being made about this exciting new method of communica- the system in the Master Frequency RegisterY
tion. Although delegates to the 1959 conference did not feel The advanced publication process requires that any admi-
that they had the expertise necessary to take any substantive nistration planning a satellite communication system notify
action, they did make two important decisions that would the IFRB of that fact, along with information concerning the
substantially affect the future of satellite communication. system's principal characteristics- including orbital position
The first was the designation of a few frequency bands in the case of geostationary satellite communications systems
between 136 MHz and 31.8 GHz to be used for space-related - between five and two years in advance of bringing that
research activities on a shared basis with other radio users. service into operation. This information is then made
The second was to recommend that the ITU hold a special available by the IFRB to the other members of the ITU. If
63
Satellites International
another administration ascertains that the new system might discussions in the UN and UNESCO on the same subject,
cause unacceptable interference with one of its existing or there was widespread concern that many countries would be
planned satellite systems, it sends all pertinent information to deprived of this valuable new service. Even under the
the notifying administration with a copy to the IFRB, within amended notification and registration procedures, the
four months of receiving the information about the new developing countries feared that the more technically adv-
system. All of the adminstrations involved are requested to anced countries might broadcast television programmes
attempt to work out any differences they might have, directly into the homes of the people of these countries
including, if necessary, making changes in orbital positions without their permission. This situation could occur deliberatly
and the frequencies to be used. The board keeps members of or as a result of spillover from a legitimate broadcast.
the ITU informed of the progress of the negotiations and The 1971 conference was no more successful than the UN
provides assistance to the parties if so requested. and UNESCO had been concerning the overall problem of
The Radio Regulations also provide a coordination proce- the limits that should be established to direct broadcasting of
dure to take place just prior to notifying the board of the television programmes to other countries by satellite. It did,
requirements of a new system for recording in the Master however, defer to those who argued in favour of prior consent
Register. Under this procedure, the administration that when it added a provision to the Radio Regulations requiring
intends to start a new geostationary satellite communication administrations implementing a new domestic service to use
system is required to coordinate with any other administra- all technical means available 'to reduce, to the maximum
tion concerned that their system might be affected. Detailed extent practicable, the radiation over the territory of other
information is exchanged with the help of the IFRB, and the countries unless an a~reement has been previously reached
administrations are requested to work out their differences. If with such countries'.L
the administrations are not successful, the IFRB automati- The most important action of the conference for the future
cally becomes involved in the process. This may include a of direct broadcasting by satellite was the decision to request
request from the board to the administration to resolve their the next ITU plenipotentiary to schedule a conference
differences, or, an assessment by the board itself of the actual expressly for the purpose of creating a comprehensive plan
amount of interference, if any, that the new system might for the broadcasting service at 12 GHz. A resolution to this
cause. As in the case of the advanced notification procedure, effect, which was primarily the work of the French and British
however, the resolution of the conflict rests entirely on the delegations, was passed over the objection of the US by one
good will of the administrations involved. hundred votes to one. Although the resolution did not specify
The final phase is the notification of the new system to the that an a priori allotment plan was required, with the
board for registration in the Master International Frequency probable exception of the US, the feeling in 1971 was that an
Register. As in the case of terrestrial radio services, the a priori plan would be the logical end result of that
notices are examined by the IFRB for conformity with the conference. As explained by DuCharme and others:
ITU Convention, the Radio Regulations, and the probability
of causing harmful interference to the satellite communica- The highly political overtones and the social and cultural
tion services of other administrations. If the notification impact of direct broadcasting satellites (DBS) together
receives a favourable finding from the board, it is entered into with the question of radiation spillover (intentional or
the Master Register as of the date of notification. Once otherwise) in the territory of other countries, were factors
registered, it receives 'international recognition' and is which prompted the planning of DBS. It was believed that
protected from interference from satellite systems that are the a priori planning and assignment of radio channels,
notified to the board at a later date. orbit positions and associated coverage areas to individual
A number of the delegations to the conference expressed countries would significantly alleviate the spillover prob-
concern that this system would also work to the disadvantage lems. Moreover, a priori planning would ensure that
of latecomers because there was no obligation on the part of orbit/spectrum resources would be available to meet the
an administration that has registered a system to make any needs of all countries'. 26
changes that might be necessary to permit another adminis-
tration to have its own interference-free system. Further, The Debate Continues
there was even the possibility that all of the desirable
frequencies and geostationary orbital positions might be The 1973 ITU Plenipotentiary conference went over much of
occupied by the time that some administrations could the same ground that had been covered in1971, but in the end
introduce their own systems. Some of the same delegations decided to hold the conference that had been requested and
felt that the only way the rights of all could be protected set the date for 1977. In the end, the 1973 plenipotentiary
would be to adopt an a priori plan. came down on the side of those who found serious flaws in the
In an attempt to meet some of the concerns of these older first come, first served system when it added a new
delegations, the conference adopted a non-binding resolution paragraph to the lead article of the Special Provisions for
and recommendation which announced that 'all countries Radio contained in the ITU's International Telecommunica-
have equal rights in the use of both the radio frequencies tion Convention. This article, as partially modified by the
allocated to various space radiocommunication services and following ITU plenipotentiary reads:
the geostationary satellite orbit for these services' and that
'registration with the ITU of frequency assignments for space 'In using frequency bands for space radio services Mem-
radiocommunication services and their use should not create bers shall bear in mind that radio frequencies and the
an obstacle to the establishment of space systems by other geostationary satellite orbit are limited natural resources
countries'. 24 and that they must be used efficiently and economically, in
Different concerns were expressed by the developing conformity with the provisions of the Radio Regulations,
countries in a separate but related discussion. By 1971 it had so that countries or groups of countries may have
become clear that the technology would soon permit televi- equitable access to both, taking into account the special
sion programmes to be broadcast directly to a home equipped needs of developing countries and the geographical
with the appropriate receiver. As had occurred during prior situation of particular countries . .n
64
The ITU and Satellite Communications
A long and sometimes acrimonious debate also took place Region 1). The plans for Regions 1 and 3 include a large
at the World Administrative Radio Conference held in number of technical parameters dealing with link design
Geneva in 1979 to revise the ITU's Radio Regulations over earth station and space station hardware and deployment;
the relative merits of two approaches to rights vesting. any major modifications to these parameters must be with the
Delegates from the developing countries argued that the first agreement of all affected administrations. According to
come, first served arrangement was unfair to the vast Article 16, the plan is intended to meet the requirements of
majority because of the necessity of late entrants into satellite the broadcasting satellite service in the two regions for 15
communication to adapt their systems to those already in years from the date of its entry into force (1 January 1979),
existence. The delegate of India indicated that his country and is significant because it marks the first time that rights to
had already encountered considerable difficulty in obtaining the use of the geostationary orbit and related frequencies
the necessary space resources for an Indian domestic satellite depend not on the date of notification of a system or even the
system under the rules adopted by the 1971 space conference. use of a system, but also on whether the system conforms to
The proponents of the status quo, especially the US, argued the plan. The plan can be revised only by an ITU administra-
that the a priori approach was wasteful because it would tive radio conference called for that purpose.-' 1
unduly restrict the development of satellite technology, and
new uses of satellite technology that would have the effect of
providing more rather than less space resources for the use of The 1983 Satellite Broadcasting Conference
newcomers. 2H
The 1979 W ARC did not resolve the dispute, but did pass a The countries of Region 2 met in Geneva in 1983 to draw up
resolution recognizing that the geostationary satellite orbit their own a priori allotment plan for the frequency bands 11.7
and the radio frequency spectrum ar(' 'limited natural to 12.2 GHz. Delegations from 25 countries were in attend-
resources' and calling for the convening of a two-part world ance and the conference lasted from 13 June to 17 July. With
space conference 'to guarantee in practice for all countries the wisdom gained from technology changes in the ensuing six
equitable access to the geostationary satellite orbit and the years and the help of computer modelling techniques, the
frequency bands allocated to space services ... ,zy technical parameters for satellite broadcasting in the plan
produced for Region 2 are a great deal more refined than
those of the 1977 plan. The space in the orbital arc between
ORGANIZING THE SA TEL LITE BROADCASTING broadcast satellites was considerably narrowed for instance.
SERVICE The final plan allotted 48 geostationary orbital positions and
2,114 frequency channels to the countries in Region 2, the
The broadcasting satellite service in the 12 GHz band was largest single share of eight orbital slots and 256 frequency
organized by means of a formal a priori allotment plan at the channels going to the US.
World Broadcasting Satellite Administrative Radio Confer- The plan was also generally more flexible than the Region 1
ence held in Geneva in 1977 and the Regional Administrative and 3 plans. Under certain circumstances, for instance, a
Radio Conference for the Planning of the Broadcasting system which does not adversely affect another administra-
Satellite Service in Region 2 held in Geneva in 1983. This was tion maybe initiated even if it varies from the characteristics
the first major step away from the traditional rights vesting established in the plan. Further, in certain cases a system that
system for satellite communications. does adversely affect the operation of another administra-
tion's system may be used on an interim basis. If it does cause
increased interference, however, the consent of the other
The 1977 Broadcasting Satellite WARC administration is required. 32
In addition to its flexibility, the Region 2 plan is notable for
Almost all of the delegations that arrived in Geneva in 1977 the fact that it attempts to meet the space requirements of
for the World Broadcasting Satellite Administrative Radio administration on a regional basis for the first time. If
Conference, the conference convened by the 1973 ITU successful, this could provide an additional method for
Plenipotentiary on the recommendation of the 1971 Space overcoming controversies in future satellite communication
WARC, were prepared from the outset to plan the future of conferences.
the broadcasting satellite service by means of a formal a priori All of the countries that participated in the 1983 Region 2
allotment plan, with the notable exception of the US. The US conference seem to have been satisfied with the results. Even
argued, as it had before, against a formal a priori allotment the US, which had fought hard but unsuccessfully against a
plan because such a plan would tend to inhibit the develop- priori planning for the satellite broadcasting service, reacted
ment of satellite broadcasting technologies and procedures. favourably. In his report to the Secretary of State, the head of
The US favoured a more flexible plan that would allow other the US delegation stated his opinion that the plan would take
delegates to share in the development of satellite communica- care of all of the 'reasonable' requirements of the countries in
tion in a manner that could make enough additional space the Americas 'well into the next century'. Further:
resources available for all countries that would need them.
When its arguments fell on deaf ears, the American delega- 'The US objectives - to come home with adequate
tion changed tactics and succeeded at least in convincing its orbital/spectrum resource and procedural flexibility to
delegates from countries in Region 2 to postpone the drafting meet the existing and future requirements of the broad-
of any allotment plan for that region until 1983. 30 casting satellite service - were fully achieved at RARC 83
After this decision was made, the remaining delegations (Geneva). The eight orbital positions obtained- each with
had little difficulty in drawing up an a priori allotment plan 500 MHz providing 32 channels - and the built-in
for Regions 1 and 3. Thirty-four geostationary orbital flexibility of the regulatory procedures give US operators
positions were identified in the arc between 37 degrees west assurance that they may go forward with confidence to
and 170 degrees east in which each administration was provide direct broadcasting satellite service to the Amer-
allotted geostationary orbital positions and frequency bands ican public. oJJ
(11.7 to 12.5 GHz for Region 3 and 11.7 to 12.2 GHz for
65
Satellites International
This, then, was the situation just prior to calling the 9. The intersatellite service
two-phase conference for 1985 and 1988 to plan all other 10. The amateur satellite service
satellite communication that had been recommended by the 11. The radio-astronomy satellite service
1979 WARC and approved by the 1982 ITU Plenipotentiary. 12. The standard frequency and time-signal satellite service.
66
The ITU and Satellite Communications
was given the title Final Acts and was approved by the The 1985 Space W ARC also directed the ITU to carry out a
conference as a whole without any major oppm,ition.'K number of studies in the intersessional period to help the 1988
The other, more important conference objectives proved to session attain its goal of creating an allotment plan for the
be more difficult to achieve. Even before the conference fixed satellite services. The IFRB, for instance, was given the
there had been indications that a conflict might occur awesome task of developing a software package for the use of
between the partisans of the two major approaches to the second session in the preparation of the final fixed service
planning. Many of the developing countries had made it clear geostationary satellite allotment plan and of carrying out
at the 1979 W ARC that they would fight for an a priori plan appropriate planning exercises with that software in advance
in those portions of the radio frequency spectrum where there of the second session. In addition, the IFRB is asked to
was any possibility of a shortage. review the procedures for converting an allotment from
On the other side. some pre-conference statements gave notification to assignment in the proposed plan and to
the impression that they might be taking a 'hard line' develop guidelines for improved regulatory procedures for
approach to the subject and refuse to be associated with any a the parts of the fixed satellite bands which will not be covered
priori plan whatsoever. 'Y That impression was softened by the allotment plan. The CCIR was asked to carry out more
somewhat when the same countries submitted proposals to than a dozen highly technical studies. including one on the
the conference which accepted the possibility that a plan development of new criteria for the sharing of frequency
might be acceptable if it were confined to the most intensively bands by the fixed satellite service with other satellite
used bands, if it were not too detailed. and if it was not a part services. In addition. the CCIR was instructed to make a
of a formal treaty instrument.~ 11 study of the technical character of the fixed satellite service in
The conference officials were so worried about the possibil- the frequency band 20/30 GHz and to make a report to the
ity of an outright cla~h between the two factions that they next session to enable it to decide whether it should
decided to attack the crucial issue of exactly what services recommend that a future conference establish a plan.
should be planned and what planning method should be Intersessional activities also involve the General Secretariat
adopted immediately. but to first review and discuss, one by and the Administrative Council. The conference adopted a
one, each of the planning approaches and planning principles budget of 900,000 Swiss francs (approximately $500.000) to
that had been forwarded to the conference by the CPM. It cover these activities during the calendar year 1986. ~ 3
was hoped that in the meantime the two sides could come to
terms on some sort of a common approach. As it turned out.
after more than four weeks the conference was still discussing The 1988 Space WARC
planning approaches and planning principles; and it took the
creation of a special Chairman's Task Force, numerous It should be kept well in mind that the decisions of the 1985
plenary assembly meetings. and many late nights before a Space W ARC are not absolutely binding on the second
solution to the major issues could be reached. Some of the session which has been scheduled to take place in Geneva in
more important decisions were, in fact. taken after the 1988. Theoretically, that conference could ignore everything
scheduled end of the conference when so many delegations that the 1985 conference did and strike out completely on its
had already left Geneva that it was no longer possible to find own. It is extremely doubtful, however, that this will be the
a quorum necessary for a valid vote. case. The momentum that has been established by the CPM
In the end, the 1985 Space WARC decided that the fixed and the first session will, in all probability. establish limits
service should be planned and that this planning should beyond which the 1988 session will not go. It seems doubtful.
include an allotment plan, limited to geostationary satellite for example, that the second session would decide that it wa~
systems providing domestic services 'that would permit each not appropriate to draw up an a priori allotment plan for the
administration to satisfy requirements for national services fixed satellite service and thus incur the wrath of the
from at least one orbital position, within a predetermined arc developing countries, which are the vast majority of the
and predetermined bands·. The plan is to be established in members of the ITU. It also seems clear that the 1988
the band 4.500 to 4,800 MHz and in a 300 MHz segment to be conference would not dare decide to create rigid a priori
selected from the 6,425 to 7,075 MHz band. It is also to be allotment plans for other geostationary satellite communica-
established in the bands 10.70 to 10.95 GHz. 11.20 to 11.45 tion systems and thus drive the US and other like-minded
GHz and 12.75 to 13.25 GHz. The plan is to last for a period countries out of the conference.
of at least ten years. The conference also agreed that the next It is possible. however, that the results of the intersessional
session should adopt "improved procedures' in ten additional studies and the results of the evaluations of the decisions of
fixed satellite service bands to J;rovide for any additional the 1985 conference by individual countries or groups of
requirements that might surface. 1 countries may lead to requests for a revision of some of those
A great deal of discussion also occurred at the conference decisions or for new approaches to certain of the problems
over the status in any future plans of the common user that arose at that conference.-~~ It would be unfortunate if
organizations such as lntelsat. Some delegations argued that these requests should result in a reopening of the fruitless
since these organizations already provided domestic satellite debates over the proper method of rights vesting or a wasteful
communication services for a number of countries and might repetition of the work of the first session and of the CPM
be the only way that the communication needs of many before it. Consequently any proposals to change the technical
additional developing countries could be met, they should be parameters or the planning principles adopted in 1985 that
accorded a preferential status in any plan that was adopted. A may, and perhaps should, be advocated will have to be
number of other delegations, led by the US. argued that since couched in terms that are understandable and which make the
only administrations can have a legal status in an allotment benefits clear to all concerned. To do otherwise could result
plan, the multi-user organizations would have to depend on in consequences that will not be good for any of the members
member administrations for their space resource needs. A of the ITU.
compromise was finally reached whereby the common user Because of the seriousness of the issues involved, and
organizations would have an 'equal status' with administra- because it can make decisions that will be binding on
tions as concerns access to the necessary space resources. 42 administrations, it is obvious that the results of this confer-
67
Satellites International
ence will have a tremendous impact on the future of long and useful future.
communication by means of geostationary satellites and
telecommunication in general. The results, if approved by a
majority of the delegations, will become a part of the ITU's REFERENCES
Radio Regulations after ratification by the countries
involved. Perhaps just as importantly, it could have a I. While the ITU is mainly concerned with maintaining the
profound impact on the future validity of the ITU itself to efficiency of satellite communications, both the United
continue to provide a forum for the countries of the world to Nations and UNESCO are involved to a certain extent with
work out their telecommunication problems. the content of the information that is carried by communica-
tion satellites. (The UN is also involved in issues dealing with
the placement of objects in space.)
CONCLUSION 2. Portions of this chapter are an adaptation of the author's
contribution to Donna A. Demac, George A. Codding Jr,
The International Telecommunication Union has been Heather E. Hudson and Ram S. Jakhu, Equity in Orbit: The
closely linked to artificial satellites almost from the begin- I985 Space WARC, International Institute of Communica-
ning. This link was initially forged because radio was tions (IIC), London, I985.
necessary for their proper utilization, sending commands to 3. See International Telecommunication Convention,
them from Earth. It became even stronger when administra- Nairobi, I982, ITU, Geneva, I983, Annex 2, paragraph 2015.
tions began using satellites to relay radio traffic from one point 4. See George A. Codding Jr and Anthony M. Rutkowski,
on Earth to another. Effective use of radio communication, The International Telecommunication Union in a Changing
whether by satellite or by terrestrial means, demands World, Artech House, Dedham, MA, 1982, Chapter One.
cooperative efforts. The ITU was the logical choice as the For additional information on the older history of the ITU see
locus for this effort because of its long history of successful the author's International Telecommunication Union, E.J.
involvement in the effective regulation of terrestrial radio Brill, Leiden, 1952 (reprinted in 1972 by Arno Press).
communications, its longevity, and the fact that it had 5. The only exception to the simple majority vote involves
virtually all of the countries of the world as its members. the admittance of new members to the ITU. If the applicant is
When the use of satellite communication systems were still not already a member of the United Nations it must receive
the province of a few countries, it was possible for the ITU to the approval of two-thirds of the ITU's membership.
treat them in a manner similar to the way it treated terrestrial 6. For the details of the ITU's structure, see the Interna-
communication systems. Space was found for them in the tional Telecommunication Convention, Nairobi, 1982, Arti-
frequency .. allocation table and the rights vesting system that cles 5 through 12.
had been employed for many years for terrestrial communica- 7. Ibid., Article 7.
tions when these were extended to include satellite com- 8. Ibid., Article 8, 4. (4).
munication systems. Geostationary orbital positions were 9. Ibid., Article 9, I. (3).
added to that system when geostationary satellite com- 10. In 1984, the IFRB had 137 in its secretariat, the CCITT
munication came into being. 43, and the CCIR 26. See ITU, Report on the activities of the
The rapid expansion of the use of geostationary satellite International Telecommunication Union in I984, Geneva,
radio communication by developed countries combined with 1985, p.125.
an increased appreciation on the part of the developing 11. The work of the ITU is financed mainly by contribu-
countries of possible benefits and dangers, leading to the tions from the member countries. The amount that each
decision to treat satellite communications separately from member contributes depends on the contributory class that it
terrestrial communications and to approach problems from a chooses, ranging from a high of 40 units down to a minimum
different perspective. The fear of possible shortages in both of 118 unit.
frequency bands and orbital positions then led to the decision 12. As quoted in Codding The International Telecom-
of the 1977 Satellite Broadcasting Conference to abandon munication Union, p. 86.
almost all of the traditional first come, first served rights 13. Ibid.
vesting system and provide for an a priori allotment plan for 14. See Radio Regulations, Edition of 1982, ITU, Geneva,
Regions 1 and 3 and the 1983 regional space conference did 1982, Article I2, paragraph I, (1) c.
the same for Region 2. It seems likely that because of what 15. In the case of an unfavourable finding, there are a
happened in Geneva in 1985, the 1988 Space WARC will do number of provisional and appellate procedures which could
the same for at least some of the key frequency bands of the result in an eventual entry of that notification in the Master
geostationary satellite fixed service, the other major geosta- Register with full or secondary rights.
tionary satellite service which a large number of countries will 16. See Codding and Rutkowski, pp. 262-265.
be using in the forseeable future. What will be done at other 17. The first plan, the Geneva Plan, allotted frequencies to
future ITU conferences, however, will depend on a number European broadcasting stations on the basis of : I) existing
of factors such as advances in satellite communications, services; 2) size of country; 3) population density; and 4)
applications of other telecommunications technologies, and economic development. See Codding and Rutkowski, pp.
the international political climate. 267-68.
So far the ITU has been able to meet the needs of the users, 18. Other regions followed the lead of the Europeans and
and future users, of satellite communication as it did in the allotment plans were created for a number of additional
past for the users of terrestrial radio communication. As we terrestrial radio services, including both aeronautical and
have seen, however, it has not been an easy task. It has maritime mobile, but an attempt to do the same for all other
demanded a great deal of goodwill on the part of all frequencies that make them likely to cause international
concerned and the expenditure of a great deal of time and harmful interference was unsuccessful. Such a plan was
money. And if the delegates to future conferences can do as suggested by the United States at the ITU's first post-war
well, the connection between the International Telecom- conference held in Atlantic City in 1947, but for a number of
munication Union and satellite communications will have a reasons, inlcuding international politics, it did not become a
68
The ITU and Satellite Communications
reality. See Codding and Rutkowski, pp. 31-35. 1985).
19. See Radio Regulations, ITU, Geneva, 1959, Article 5 41. It should be noted that a quorum was not present when
and Recommendation No. 36. the conference accepted the provisions setting the duration of
20. See E.D. Ducharme. R.R. Bowen and M.J.R Irwin, the plan at ten years, requiring existing systems to make
'The Genesis of the 198511987 ITU World Administrative adjustments to accommodate new systems, and describing the
Radio Conference on the Use of the Geostationary Satellite meaning of the principle of 'guarantee of access'. See
Orbit and the Planning of Space Services Utilizing It', in Addendum to Report to the Second Session of the Confer-
Annals of Space Law, Volume VII, 1982, p. 265. ence, Document 324 (Rev. 1), 15 September 1985 and
21. As quoted in Milton S. Smith III, 'Space WARC 1985- Corrigendum 1.
Legal Issues and Implications', LL.M. thesis submitted to the 42. Ibid.
Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research at the Institute of 43. See Report to the Second Session of the Conference.
Air and Space Law, McGill University, 1984. For an account of the accomplishments of the 1985 Space
22. The official title being the World Administrative Radio WARC, see R.E. Butler, ·opening Statement', a speech
Conference for Space Communications, Geneva, 1971. delivered at the Annen berg School Program, 25 October 1985
23. For details of the procedure, see Radio Regulations, and D. Withers, 'Equitable Access to Satellite Communica-
Edition of 1982, Articles 11 and 13. tion', in Electronics and Wireless World, December 1985, pp.
24. See Final Acts of the World Administrative Radio 65, 66, 75.
Conference for Space Communications, ITU. Geneva, 1971, 44. The US delegation made a declaration to the effect
Resolution Spa 2-1 and Recommendation Spa 2-1. that the US did not feel it was appropriate to use as much
25. See Radio Regulations, Edition of 1982, Article 30, space for the allotment plan as was proposed. Nevertheless,
Section II. after the conference the head of the US delegation was willing
26. DuCharme, Bowen and Irwin, p. 267. to say that under the circumstances the US came out of the
27. International Telecommunication Convention, conference 'very well'. See 'Briefing by Dean Burch, US
Nairobi, 1982, ITU, Geneva, 1982, Article 33 (2). Representative to the World Administrative Radio Confer-
28. See Anthony M. Rutkowski's account of the discus- ence (WARC) on Space Communications at the State
sions in 'Six Ad-Hoc Two: The Third World Speaks its Mind', Department', a mimeograph distributed at the Second Circle
in Satellite Communications, Volume 4, March 1981, p.23. Congressional Study Group, Center for Strategic and Inter-
29. See Radio Regulations, Edition of 1982, Resolution national Studies, Georgetown University, 4 October 1985.
No.3.
30. For frequency management purposes, the ITU divides
the world into three regions: Region I includes Europe,
Africa and the USSR; Region 2, the Western hemisphere;
and Region 3, Asia and Australasia.
31. See Final Acts of the World Administrative Radio
Conference for the Planning of the Broadcasting Satellite
Service in Frequency Bands 11.7 to 12.2 GHz (in Regions 2
and 3) and 11.7 to 12.5 (in Region 1), ITU, Geneva, 1977.
32. See Milton S. Smith III. pp. 128-29.
33. See Report of the United States Delegation to the ITU
Region 2 Administrative Radio Conference on the Broad-
casting Satellite Service, Geneva, Switzerland, 13 June to 17
July 1983, US Department of State, Washington, DC, 1983,
p. 2 (mimeo). Nevertheless, the US did make reservations to
the plan concerning polarization in its downlink and feeder-
link channel assignment and the coverage area power flux
density, p. 67.
34. See Radio Regulations, Edition of 1982, Resolution
No.3.
35. Ibid.
36. See Report of the CCIR Conference Preparatory
Meeting (CPM) for the WARC ORB (1) Joint Meeting,
Study Groups 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11, Geneva, 25 June to
20 July 1984, Part III, ITU, CCIR, Administrative Supple-
ment, Document B/180-F/E/S, 19 July 1984, pp. 1-26.
37. The ITU has used various acronyms for this conference
including ORB WARC (1), WARC-ORB (1), or WARC
ORB-85. In this discussion we will use the term '1985 Space
WARC'.
38. See World Administrative Radio Conference on the
Use of the Geostationary-Satellite Orbit and the Planning of
Space Services Utilizing It, First Session, Geneva, 1985, Final
Acts, WARC ORB-85, ITU, Geneva, 1985.
39. See, for instance, Third Notice of Inquiry [in General
Document No. 80-741], US Federal Communication Com-
mission, FCC 83-452 (adopted 6 October 1983), p. 15.
40. See 1985 Space WARC Document 18-E (13 June 1985),
Document 30-E (27 June 1985) and Document 31-E (1 July
69
9 SATELLITE COMMUNICATIONS AND DEVELOPMENT
The last few years have been critical ones in terms of satellite communications and development.
Highlights include the launch and initial operation of Brazilsat, the More los Satellite System of
Mexico and the Arabsat System. There has also been the effective use of Inmarsat terminals for
certain rural and remote telecommunications services. Another landmark has been the completion
of the Maitland Commission report on communications development. This report, called The
Missing Link, led to the establishment of the new Centre for Telecommunications Development,
and a call for billions more dollars to be invested in rural telecommunications.
As of December 1985 Intelsat has offered domestic services capacity for sale or by protected lease
on a planned basis. Equally important has been the offer of Vista and Intel net thin route service.
purchase plan for low cost rural earth stations, the establishment of the Intelsat Development
Fund, and especially Project SHARE (Satellites for Health and Rural Education) under which
much has been done. For instance, under Project SHARE, a national Chinese tele-education
course was established for a half million students- and a Canada/ Africa telemedicine link is now
saving lives in Kenya and Uganda. In all, 70 countries have now participated in dozens of Project
SHARE activities.
This chapter outlines how communications can be effectively applied in rural and remote areas for
development. Taking up this task are two of the world's leading professors in communications
development, Heather Hudson and Meheroo Jussawalla. who will provide an overview of what is
happening around the world and explain why communications development is important.
71
Satellites International
producers and shippers can result in reduced spoilage and allowing all sites to share a common circuit or channel, a
higher prices for produce; feature particularly useful for administration and teaching.
72
Satellite Communications and Development
Systems optimized for large numbers of small users would Despite the tangible and intangible benefits of satellite
be particularly attractive for the South Pacific and sub- communications, actual investment in telecommunications
Saharan Africa. Pacstar, a joint venture of Papua New infrastructure has remained small. Approximately 0.3 percent
Guinea and US commercial interests, is a proposed system of GOP is expended on telecommunications by non-OPEC
which will include C-band coverage of the South Pacific and developing countries. This is no indication, however, of the
Ku-band coverage of major Pacific rim centres. Aussat 3 will demand for telecommunications in urban and rural areas.
provide Ku-band coverage of the South Pacific and New Even where services are available, they are generally clus-
Zealand. The ITU is currently carrying out a feasibility study tered in metropolitan centres emphasizing the dichotomy in
for a regional satellite system for sub-Saharan Africa under the development investments of LDCs.
the name Rascom. One of the major reasons is that telecommunication
An inexpensive communication satellite is being developed infrastructures face major financial constraints and are not
to transmit technical information in the form of computer planned as primary investments. While technological deter-
data to scattered groups and individuals throughout the Third minism is part of the process of growth, the costs must be
World. Called Pacsat, the satellite will be based in low Earth affordable for low income countries either to generate from
orbit and will communicate digitally with ground stations. domestic revenues or to borrow from international organiza-
Pacsat is a joint effort of two non-profit organizations: tions and banks. The need for greater investment in Third
Volunteers in Technical Assistance (VITA) based in Arling- World telecommunications has been emphasized by the
ton, Virginia and the Radio Amateur Satellite Corporation in ITU's Maitland Commission report (1985) which highlights
Silver Springs, Maryland. Pacsat will be deployed in a polar the disparities in access to telecommunications infrastructure.
orbit which puts it within range of any spot on Earth once
every 24 hours. The earth stations will serve as nodes in a low
cost global electronic mail system. The purpose of the system THREE ERAS OF DEVELOPMENT
is to provide agricultural and other developmental informa-
tion. A Swedish project called Mailstat uses a similar In 1945, Arthur Clarke envisioned delivery of television
approach to Pascat. across oceans and continents via satellite. By the 1960s,
satellites had caught the fancy of educators who were
captivated by the potential of the technology as the ultimate
SA TEL LITE USE BY DEVELOPING COUNTRIES magic multiplier, able to transmit television to receiving sites
throughout a nation or continent. They overlooked the
Communications technology has so revolutionized global institutional environment into which the technology would be
interdependence that it is now possible for developing introduced - an environment that seemed to offer little
countries to examine the options offered to them by off the incentive for an application that threatened teachers and the
shelf equipment, calculate its opportunity costs, and weigh autonomy of educational institutions. The educators and
them against tangible and intangible benefits to their societies communicators paid little attention to the interactive capabili-
before making any investment. Technological choice has ties of satellites, namely for telephone services, data transmis-
become rationalized in an environment of access to informa- sion and teleconferencing.
tion. Although satellites went into international commercial
Once a country has determined its telecommunications service in the mid-1960s, for our purposes this first phase of
requirements, based on its development goals and plans, it developmental applicatons or the 'Era of Conjecture' can be
must consider which technology or mix of technologies is said to extend from Arthur Clarke's article in 1945 until the
most appropriate for meeting these goals. Countries with early 1970s.
limited rural infrastructure, significant land area, and/or The 'Era of Experiments' may be considered to extend
difficult terrain - mountains, jungle or scattered islands, etc. from about 1971 to 1977. During this period, there were
- may find satellite technology particularly appropriate. numerous experiments and demonstrations of satellite
Smaller countries and those with more extensive infrastruc- applications for education and training, health services,
ture may find that satellite technology is attractive only for community development and cultural exchanges. These
sharing of service with other countries in the region. projects were conducted on the US Applications Technology
Regardless of geographical size, poorer countries may find Satellite series (ATS 1 and ATS 6, and to a lesser extent ATS
satellites an attractive solution to their communication 3), and the joint US-Canadian Communications Technology
problems only if the capital cost of the system can be shared Satellite (CTS or Hermes). These experiments took place
among a number of nations- for example, through a regional primarily in the US and Canada, but also included the Indian
system or through lease or purchase of capacity on an Satellite Instructional Television Experiment (SITE) which
international system such as Intelsat. used A TS 6 in India in 1975 and demonstrations in Africa and
Capital costs include the satellite and spare (to be launched Asia on the French-German experimental Symphonie satel-
in case of failure of the in-orbit satellite), launch, insurance lites.
and terrestrial facilities (for tracking, telemetry and control The 'Era of Services' may be said to have commenced in
and for telecommunicatons). Recent catastrophic failures of the latter 1970s. The late 1970s and the early 1980s can be
launches and satellites have dramatically increased insurance characterized by several developments which have pushed
costs from premiums representing 7% of the programme satellite applications out of the realm of experiments and
costs to a sum of over 20%. It remains to be seen whether demonstrations, and into the early phases of operational
these are short-term phenomena. Planners must recognize service. The developments include:
that the total cost ot the terrestrial facilities is likely to exceed
the cost of the satellite if the system is to be fully utilized. - the launching of the first domestic satellite owned by a
Failure to invest in earth stations and local infrastructure such developing country (Indonesia, in 1976);
as local telephone plan, exchanges and rebroadcasting trans-
mitters will result in under utilization of the space segment - the installation of the first rural satellite networks. In
investment. Alaska, beginning in 1976, more than one hundred small
73
Satellites International
earth stations were installed in villages for telephone and later rammes in the Eskimo language (Inuktitut) which are
broadcasting; similar facilities were installed in northern distributed over the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation's
Canada; Northern Television Service on the Anik D satellite. The
programmes are produced by the native people themselves in
-the use of Intelsat satellites for domestic communications by several northern production centres, and up linked from
many developing countries (20 developing countries by the Frobisher Bay on Baffin Island.
end of 1985); Indian people in northern Canada have created a satellite
radio network to provide information to remote villagers in
-procurement by several developing countries of domestic or their own languages. The Wawatay Native Communications
regional satellite systems, e.g., Indonesia's regional Palapa B, Society produces ten hours of news and public affairs
India's Insat, Arabsat, Brasilsat and Morelos (Mexico). programming per week in the Cree and Ojibway languages.
The programmes are fed to community radio stations in the
villages using an audio sub-carrier of a transponder on Anik C
used by TV Ontario for educational television. Several
DEVELOPMENT APPLICA T/ONS OF SA TEL LITES similar projects are being implemented by native communica-
tions organizations across the Canadian north with funding
Alaska support from the federal government.
74
Satellite Communications and Development
ATS 1 finally failed in 1985, 19 years after it was launched. classroom, so that there were ten BKS classrooms. In
Some sites were able to switch to ATS 3. USP in 1986, under addition, the Bogor Agricultural Institute is connected to the
Intelsat's Project SHARE, was able to switch to a free system, so that faculty from this agricultural graduate
semi-operational service. Nearly every South Pacific country research institution can teach over the satellite system to the
and territory now has an Intelsat 8 earth station which USP BKS institutions.
will convert to a fully operational service in 1988. The South The project's goal is to use satellite communications to
Pacific may also implement thin route communications using improve educational quality by fostering distance teaching,
Intelnet service and Aussat 3 may offer operational facilities. curriculum development, faculty upgrading and exchange of
administrative and research information. Because of their
India location, hundreds or even thousands of miles away from the
centres of excellence near Jakarta, the Eastern Island
India was the first developing country to experiment with University campuses tend to be cut off from the mainstream
domestic applications of a satellite for development. In 1975, of agricultural development and education. These distances
India carried out the Satellite Instructional Satellite Experi- also make travel inconvenient and expensive for faculty and
ment. The SITE project used NASA's A TS 6 satellite to administrators. As a result. faculty members, or ·dosen', with
deliver educational programming to more than 2,500 villages. special expertise frequently travelled to various campuses to
SITE proved that India could manufacture its own technol- present concentrated short courses in their subject matter.
ogy, including televison sets and small earth stations with This arrangement was disruptive not only to the professor's
chicken wire antennas, and that it could manage the normal class schedule, but also to the class schedules of
installation and operation of equipment and production of students who would drop their regular classes to attend the
daily instructional programming. The project evaluation also 'flying dosen's' course. Also, because of poor communica-
provided valuable insights into the relevance of the content, tions, the administrators on the BKS campuses felt it
viewer reactions and the potential impact of educational necessary to meet in person with their counterparts to
television programmes on village development. This led to coordinate the administrative matters.
follow-on experiments in 1981 when India's own Apple Thus, Sisdiksat aims to expand educational opportunity to
satellite was launched by the European Space Agency. students in the Eastern Islands by fostering closer com-
India began operational domestic satellite services in 1983 munication and interchange among the 11 BKS universities
with the In sat I 8 satellite. In sat distributes television to and teacher training institutions; to upgrade their course
towns and villages throughout the country. It is also used for offerings by capitalizing on faculty strength (regardless of
trunk telephony, and plans to provide thin route telephone where the faculty are located); to upgrade existing faculty and
and telex service to remote and hilly areas. The experience provide additional training to tutors; to exchange information
gained from SITE will be used to produce rural development among university faculty and staff; and access the resources of
programming that will be distributed to villages via Insat. the Jakarta area. An innovation that developed during the
project was the use of the satellite network by the new Open
Indonesia University of Indonesia. This 'university without walls' has
used the satellite facilities to train more than one hundred
Indonesia was the first developing country to procure its own tutors.
domestic communication satellite system. Operated by
Perumtel, the Palapa system went into operation in 1976, The West Indies
providing television, telephone and telex services. At pre-
sent, the system is being used by other Asian countries, first Another AID sponsored project under the Rural Satellite
by Thailand and now by Singapore, Malaysia and the Programme is the University of the West Indies Distance
Philippines. The second generation Palapa 8 I was launched Teaching Experiment (UWIDITE). The participating sites
in 1983. More than 40 small earth stations (less than five are part of the University of the West Indies, a regional
metres in diameter) now constitute the domestic system. university in the Caribbean. The main office of UWIDITE is
The Agency for International Development (AID) laun- located on the Mona campus of the University of the West
ched the Rural Satellite Programme (RSP) to assess whether Indies in Kingston, Jamaica.
satellite communication can contribute cost effectively to Teleconferencing enables the university to use the special-
rural development and to transfer a broad range of com- ized faculties at each of its three main campuses to fullest
munications technologies to developing nations. The prog- advantage. All three main campuses have strengths in some
ramme encouraged the use of existing satellites to provide areas, although each offers different courses. The UWIDITE
thin route communications, telephone, audio teleconferenc- system allows teaching to emanate from locations with
ing and graphics. to support rural development activities. particularly strong faculty, and it increases cost -effectiveness
In Indonesia, the RSP uses the Palapa satellite to link 11 by enabling a course to be taught once to many students
agriculturally-oriented campuses known as the Eastern rather than repeated several times.
Islands University Group (known by its Indonesian initials, One of the major purposes of the satellite linkage in the
BKS); the campuses were linked with one another and with UWIDITE proejct is to assist students in their home
locations in Jakarta and Bogor, further to the west. The countries to obtain a univer~ity education. The university has
project, known by its Indonesian acronym, Sisdiksat, includes a system of 'Challenge Examinations' through which high
interactive audio teleconferencing, facsimile and audiog- school graduates on islands away from the main campuses
raphic capabilities. (located in Jamaica, Barbados and Trinidad) can qualify for
The BKS campuses are located on islands spread over university matriculation. Challenge students can prepare for
1,600 miles of ocean. The main project office is at Hasanud- the examination by using study materials at extramural
din University in Ujung Pandang on the island of Sulawesi. extension centres on their home islands. Participating
The 11 BKS campuses include eight universities (one with extramural centres are located in Dominica, St Lucia and
two campuses) and two teacher training institutions. One of Antigua. Many non-Challenge courses have also been offered
the former and one of the latter shared a distance teaching through UWIDITE. These courses tend to be aimed at more
75
Satellites International
advanced students, including some graduate students and supply its clinics or an education ministry that cannot pay its
in-service training students such as nurses and teachers. In teachers is not going to be able to take full advantage of
1986 the UWIDITE network was interlinked under Project satellite facilities.
SHARE with the Memorial Hospital Nova Scotia for medical
training and diagnosis. This test proved successful for Essential Complementary Infrastructure
Telemedicine applications.
Satellite communications cannot foster development in isola-
Peru tion. There must be adequate infrastructure in the form of
transportation to move goods to market and to deliver the
In Peru, an AID sponsored project began operation in supplies ordered by telephone or telex. There must be a
November 1983, in San Martin, a department on the eastern power source to run the communications equipment. And
side of the Andes with very limited infrastructure. Thin route even more basic essentials such as clean water and adequate
satellite earth stations link three communities, using domestic shelter must be available for developmental improvements to
capacity leased from Intelsat. Four additional villages are be sustained.
served via VHF links from one earth station. The system
provides an audio conferencing network and community Project Design
telephones.
The project is being carried out by Entel Peru, which has To be effective, the project itself must be well-designed and
established planning and evaluation groups to work with planned. It must build on experience already gained in the
communities and agencies on how to utilize the capacity. The sector, and must have adequate resources for implementa-
goal is to use telecommunications as a catalyst for rural tion. The goals of the satellite project must relate to the goals
development to extend expertise, improve administration and and priorities of the ministry or agency. Even a very
provide linkages among businesses, farmers, markets and successful pilot project may not be continued or supported if
suppliers. it does not contribute to meeting the goals of the ministry, or
Early evaluation results indicate that, despite technical if it is perceived to be draining resources from other priority
problems, both the audio conferencing service and the public activities.
telephones had heavy use. However, integrating these uses Too often, software planning starts long after hardware
into ongoing rural development activities has required con- plans for the satellite have been finalized and the satellite is
siderable time and effort now that expansion of this network already under construction. Applications are then delayed
is underway. due to insufficient lead time before the satellite launch, or are
rushed so that the results are unsatisfactory. Applications of
communications technology require sufficient time to assess
CRITICAL FACTORS the needs, develop software, train personnel and carry out
field trials before final implementation.
As more countries introduce developmental applications of The degree of heterogeneity of the target population will
their own domestic and regional satellites, and as the costs of influence the project design and the design of the communica-
domestic use of Intelsat decline, we may expect to see many tions delivery system. For example, to serve several language
more developmental benefits from satellite communications. groups, multiple audio tracks may be required for television
India, for example, is adapting its experience with SITE in programmes. A decentralized approach using several chan-
the mid 1970s to operational educational services using its nels for different regions of the country may be required.
Insat system. Brazil and Mexico both have extensive experi- Although users will not have experience with satellites,
ence in using radio and television for education, which could they may have relevant experience with other technologies
be valuable in designing educational services to be delivered that will help them prepare for satellite services. For
by their domestic satellites. However, the availability of the example, teachers who have used radio and television in the
technology does not guarantee that it will be used effectively classroom will be able to plan for satellite-delivered broad-
for developmental purposes. In order to project the impact of casting. Health workers and administrators who have used
satellite services on development, it is necessary to consider a two-way radio will adapt easily to satellite teleconferencing.
number of factors. Portable video can be used both to produce television
programmes and to explain the new services that will be
Economic Status available by satellite.
The ministry or agency which is to carry out the project must More and more developing countries are investing in satellite
have sufficient resources in funds and personnel to develop technology. Indonesia has been joined by India, Brazil and
and implement the activity. A health ministry that cannot Mexico as owners of their own domestic satellites. The
76
Satellite Communications and Develpment
77
10 FUTURE REGIONAL SATELLITE SYSTEMS: THE CASE
OF THE CARIBBEAN
Donna Demac, Interactive Telecommunications Program, New York University; and Aggrey Brown,
Director, Caribbean Institute of Mass Communication
Several regional satellite systems have now come into existence: Entelsat, Arabsat, and Palapa.
These have been discussed in other chapters and documented in the reference section that follows.
There are, however, various plans for new regional satellite projects that deserve attention. The
major initiatives at this point involve the Caribbean (Carisat), the Andean countries of South
America (Project Candar, which will start on Intelsat capacity~. and Africa which has already gone
through several studies involving the ITU Glodon project or Afrosat, the French/UK AFSAT
study and most recently the new ITU RASCOM study. New regional systems will, of course, be
reported upon as they come into being in future editions of Satellites International. The following
section reports on the planning process being followed in the Caribbean. In many ways it is parallel
to ongoing planning in the Andean countries and in sub-Sahara Africa.
In 1987, Caribbean nations are planning a feasibility study for combined. The average population of the remammg 11
the establishment of a regional satellite system that will be Caricom countries is 175,000. the size of a small town in the
carried out in cooperation with the ITU's Centre for us.
Telecommunications Development. Though interest in a
regional satellite has existed for nearly a decade, the rapid
expansion of foreign-owned telecommunications systems in CARIBBEAN MEDIA
the 1980s has increased interest in the satellite option as a
means of strengthening regional integration. Typical of ex-colonial regimes, Caribbean governments have
The utili;;:ation of space is now driven by international only recently begun to address systematically their needs in
competition and joint ventures which are responding to a the fields of broadcasting and telecommunications. Most
variety of economic challenges and opportunities. Many years Caricom countries achieved political independence less than
of research and experimentation in space have led to growing 25 years ago. In most places, the structures relevant to
appreciation of the value of satellite communication for other communications that were inherited from colonial masters
sectors, including agriculture. transportation. trade and continue to confuse rather than clarify the government's
education. role.'
In the Caribbean. plans for the expanded use of satellite For example. though private ownership of broadcasting
technology. by ownership or leasing. stem from current and cable television stations exists in a number of countries,
efforts to establish policies for the future in such areas as virtually all of the eastern Caribbean countries follow the
intraregional transportation. commerce and rural develop- British tradition of public ownership of broadcasting facili-
ment. Improvement in telecommunications facilities and ties. But government ownership does not confer the same
training is also a necessary step towards creating a business control over programme content and advertising as exists in
climate that will address the serious problems of unemploy- more industrialized countries.
ment which exist in most Caribbean countries. National media objectives in the region are severely
constrained by very practical market considerations. It is
generally far less expensive to import a dozen hours of foreign
THE CARIBBEAN REGION programming than to produce a single programme with local
talent. With the advent of satellite broadcasting. there is
The Caribbean is a complex region consisting of 14 scattered today even greater concern for the cultural integrity of the
islands and continental countries varying in size. language. region. Already, in most countries, over 70 percent of all
resources, forms of government and culture. Each country televised material originates from outside the region.
has its own social, religious and political history. Relevant to A quote from the August 1986 issue of South magazine
efforts to create regional media. five major languages are underscores the point:
spoken in the Caribbean and a variety of dialects.
There are also dramatic differences in terms of geographic 'The percentages of foreign programming.
size and population density. Jamaica. which is just a little mainly from the US. tell their own story. In the
smaller in size than Connecticut. is 25.5 times the size of Bahamas there is now 100 per cent foreign
Barbados; Guyana is 19.5 times the size of Jamaica, which domination of television. In Antigua and Bar-
makes it almost 500 times the size of Barbados. In terms of buda. the state-owned ABS TV station shows 60
population, Jamaica has more people (2.5 million) than all per cent US programming. with the other 40 per
the other English speaking countries of the Caribbean cent mainly made up of government information
79
Satellites International
programmes. In Trinidad and Tobago, 76 per apparent the inferiority of telephone serv1ce within the
cent is foreign dominated. In Dominica, to region.
counter the heavy bias, the government insisted The average penetration rate of telephones in the region is
on one hour a day of local programming on all 9.8 per 100 persons.
eight TV channels received but lack of funds and
staff have prevented full utilization of the daily Table 1: Caribbean telephone penetration
slot. Member State Number of telephones per 100 persons
And it is not only the disproportionate amount
of foreign TV which is damaging. The violence Antigua and Barbuda 7.2
which forms part of so many US programmes is Barbados 25.0
regularly dug up to offer explanation for Belize 4.4
increased local crime and violence. The swamp- Bahamas 29.0
ing of the Caribbean by alien US values and Dominica 3.7
lifestyles has shaken the foundations of local Grenada 5.4
culture and identity.' Jamaica 5.4
St Christopher (Kitts)/Nevis 5.3
The Caribbean is said to have privileged access to foreign St Lucia 6.4
media and telecommunications due to its proximity to North Montserrat 15.4
America. Yet as this quote indicates, such bounty also St Vincent 5.3
endangers steps being taken towards national and regional Trinidad and Tobago 9.0
sovereignty. Satellites, in particular, may render a country Guyana 3.4
mute by overwhelming local messages with foreign informa-
tion. This conundrum has been described by William Demas, Estimated total population 5 million
President of the Caribbean Development Bank as 'independ-
ence begetting dependence'. 2 Concern regarding the over- Estimated total number of telephones 490,416
whelming impact of foreign-owned media is a primary factor
in consideration of a regional satellite. Estimated penetration rate 9.8 per 100 persons
However, it should be noted that though the Caribbean
satellite option best symbolizes the drive for regional coop- Source: ITU Yearbook of Statistics, 1972, 1981; UNDP
eration, there are other near-term proposals of more immedi- Statistical Yearbook.
ate significance.
The head of the Caribbean Broadcasting Union has At a 1986 meeting of Caribbean transportation ministers,
recommended an expansion of ground station capability this low rate of penetration was largely attributed to two
across the region. Wider reception would benefit telephone factors. First, the dependence of most governments on
service, distance teaching and provide incentives for more foreign owners to expand and manage telecommunications
regional programming for radio and television. 3 facilities was seen as an obstacle to improved regional
With regard to ways to obtain additional funds for local interconnection and the acquisition of indigenous manage-
media, proposals have been discussed involving license fees ment expertise. Following independence, several ofthe larger
for cable television, pay-per-view schemes, as well as various Caribbean countries either acquired interest in or became full
economic incentives for foreign companies willing to contri- owners of their telecommunication entities. In the majority of
bute to national or regional production ventures. these countries, however, all telecommunication services,
In some instances, governments have been challenged to including telephone, telex, facsimile and computer data, are
develop policies in response to the introduction of media controlled by Cable and Wireless or other foreign companies.
systems by private entrepreneurs. In Belize, for example, Additionally, antiquated and nonexistent telephone ser-
which until recently had no television system of its own, vices were seen as an unfortunate consequence of the
entrepreneurs installed 20-foot diameter satellite dishes and separate ownership of internal and external facilities. In many
are delivering programmes to cable subscribers. Not able to Caribbean countries, the government owns the telephone
stop such activity, short of extreme measures, the govern- company that provides national service but only has a
ment has instead brought the new media owners within the minority share in the external carrier company. At a time
state's purview by requiring private operators to obtain a when export strategies are driving innovation in the telecom-
license for a modest fee. 4 munications sector, this separation prevents much of a
Another subject of very keen interest involves efforts by country's population from benefiting from improvements in
the US to make its copyright law applicable to Caribbean the external network.
countries. Provisions in the Caribbean Basin Recovery Act of Various options exist for strengthening regional telecom-
1983 conditioned certain economic benefits on compliance. munications. Each one presents more complex challenges
This has led to continuing debate over the appropriateness of related to the size of the capital expenditures involved and
such conditions and the best way for Caribbean countries to institutional reform. A Caribbean satellite offers the most
address the legal issues raised by the spillover of satellite dramatic prospects for improving services for entire popula-
signals emanating from the US. 5 tions and for expanding service between countries in the
region. Yet this option cannot be achieved economically in
the near-term and, for that reason alone, must be considered
CARIBBEAN TELECOMMUNICATIONS alongside other less expensive and ambitious alternatives.
One way to improve basic telecommunications would be to
As travellers to the region quickly realize, the absence or increase use of the Intelsat Atlantic Ocean satellites. Stan-
unpredictability of basic telephone communication places the dard earth stations in nine Caribbean countries already access
Caribbean squarely in the developing world. The upgrade of these satellites. Intelsat presently has plans to put additional
international phone circuits in the 1980s makes even more satellites and earth stations into service. However, as of late
80
Future Regional Satellite Systems
1986, only 10 percent of Intelsat circuits linked Caribbean Institutional Arrangements
countries; the rest carried traffic between countries in the
region and nations in the Western hemisphere and Europe. Efforts to strengthen regional telecommunications involve
The new Intelsat Caribnet service is intended to respond to the contributions of numerous governmental and private
this need. organizations. Included here are the Caribbean Community
Secretariat (Caricom) which plays a central role in coordinat-
Foreign-Owned Systems ing regional economic policies, including telecommunica-
tions; the Caribbean Association of National Telecom-
The proximity of Caribbean countries to the US and the munications Organizations (CANTO) which facilitates tech-
dominance of English as a common language, make the nological integration; the Caribbean Publishers and Broad-
region a prime choice for investment by US telecommunica- casters Association (CPBA), an influential private sector
tions and data corporations. At the time of writing, plans by organization; the Caribbean Broadcasting Union and the
outside companies (most of whom own portions of interna- Caribbean News Agency (CANA).
tional cables) to build sophisticated telecommunications Regional governments also have recognized the need for
systems in the Caribbean, are moving forward at a rapid pace. training in mass communication. In 1974, Caribbean govern-
As of 1987, the Federal Communications Commission has ments recognized the need for well-trained and technically
authorized over 100 domestic satellites to provide trans border competent personnel and established the Caribbean Institute
services to the Caribbean. The majority of these provide of Mass Communication (Carimac) as a department of the
broadcasting and data transmission. In addition, AT&T has Faculty of Arts and General Studies at the University of the
received authorization to install a TransCaribbean fibre optic West Indies (UWI) campus in Jamaica. Recently, Carimac's
cable that will extend from the US to the Dominican curriculum and research agenda has also included Caribbean
Republic, Jamaica and Colombia. This cable is expected to be telecommunications.
in service by 1990.
The list of pending telecommunications networks also The Caribbean and the ITU
includes plans by several British and European firms. Most of
these projects will create private networks- some viewing the Some of the Caribbean nations are playing a more active role
Caribbean as only a small piece of a global network- leaving in meetings of the International Telecommunication Union.
unresolved the problems relating to intraregional com- A great deal of attention has been paid to the recommenda-
munication. This is likely to increase political pressure on tions of the report of the Independent Commission for World
Caribbean governments for communication policies respon- Wide Telecommunications Development entitled The Mis-
sive to public needs. sing Link and to developments regarding geostationary
orbital allotments. At the World Conference on Telecom-
munications Development in Arusha, Tanzania in 1985, held
REGIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS PLANNING shortly before the 1985 Space W ARC on geostationary orbit
IN A GLOBAL CONTEXT allotments, delegations from Barbados, Belize, Jamaica and
Trindad and Tobago called for attention to the special needs
Interest in a Caribbean satellite almost certainly has resulted of small island states and fragmented sub-regions.
from broader economic and political developments affecting
the region. Caribbean telecommunictions officials are con- Plans for a Caribbean Satellite
cerned about the impact of deregulation and privatization in
the industrialized world. Of concern at the present time is the The ITU has served as a catalyst for a Caribbean satellite and
possibility that Intelsat's prices will increase due to private for regional telecommunication planning in general. Though
competition for international and domestic satellite transmis- interest in a regional satellite had existed in several quarters
sion. since the 1970s, actual planning for a 'Carisat' emerged in
While such major policy changes defy predictions, they connection with the 1983 ITU Regional Administration
compel attention to their possible impact on the distribution Radio Conference for the Americas. The conference distri-
of wealth and technical resources. Deregulation and competi- buted orbital positions and frequency bands for direct
tion in the telecommunications market have brought about broadcast satellites.
the introduction of new technologies and the attendant Caribbean delegates, realizing that most member countries
development of new products and services in the consumer could not justify having their own satellites also secured a slot
market. In some of the industrialized countries, video discs for a regional satellite. Shortly after this, a report on the
and digital stereo are available for consumer purchase. conference, including preliminary ideas for a Caribbean
Video-conferencing, the exchange of data among banks and satellite, was prepared for the Caribbean Broadcasting
other multi-national enterprises, as well as remote printing of Union. In this report, the 'Caribbean beam' was envisioned
newspapers and magazines via satellite, are established as a shared satellite with 16 transponders capable of providing
features of the business enterprise. reception over a vast area, encompassing Bermuda in the
Yet it has become apparent that not all nations can North Atlantic to Suriname and Guyana in South America;
participate on an equal footing in this telecommunications Barbados in the east to Belize in Central America.
explosion. While certain countries are operating on the Variations in the political status and satellite requirements
second and later generations of communication satellites, the of the various countries were reflected in the specifications
developing countries have yet to take full advantage of the for dedicated national up-links for the independent countries
opportunities inherent in the earlier ones. For this reason, and service to and from the non-independent territorjes. The
policies which promote competition and sale of the most report emphasized the flexibility of the network and the
sophisticated technologies may not serve the interests of the possibility of accommodating changes in political status and
developing nations. Moreover, local ownership of telecom- national requirements as they arose.
munications facilities becomes a more attractive alternative as Further elaboration of this idea was then provided in a
the ability to influence foreign-owned systems diminishes. CBU document recommending a detailed study of the
81
Satellites International
83
11 COMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE SERVICES
The best communications satellites in the world are useless without users. Improving a satellite's
lifetime, or its irradiated power, or its stabilization system are all interesting and desirable
developments, but the end user has only a few very basic concerns. Will the satellite work and
reliably so? Will the capacity needed to provide the service be available on time? Will the satellite
provide high quality service on a consistent basis? To many users, the transmission mode is a
matter of indifference. You could use a satellite, or a microwave relay, or a coaxial cable, or a pair
of twisted wires; all would be quite acceptable as long as they worked. Even a pair of tin cans
connected by a wire would be acceptable if the service came through on time. Fortunately satellites
work much better than tin cans, and in fact are the first media capable of providing global ISDN
quality digital communications to business users and public switched networks.
Because the perspective of the service user is different, this section is devoted to the user
community which defines what it is that communications satellites must acutally do. Included here
are the views of the international press community, the video conference user groups and
broadcasters.
11A Video and Audio Conferencing Networks Louis A. Bransford and Suzanne G.
Douglas
11 B Telecommunications Satellites and the Press Today Oliver Robinson and Louis A. Bransford
85
11 A VIDEO AND AUDIO CONFERENCING NETWORK S
Louis A. Bransford, President, and Suzanne G. Douglas, Public Service Satellite Consortium
The telecommunications industry has undergone dramatic Audio conferencing, using standard phone lines, may
changes in the last five years, driven by social, economic and ultimately prevail as the most flexible, most convenient, and
political forces. The changes had tremendous impact on the least expensive method of sharing information among three
corporate world, government and the public service sector. or more locations. Plain old telephone service is an often
For many organizations the changes call for new services, new overlooked and usually underutilized option. It is estimated
products and better ways of delivering services. Telecon- that 40 to 50 million meetings are held daily in the OECD
ferencing is one of those services. Both private business and countries and that 50 to 60 percent of those meetings could be
the public service sector is increasingly finding that telecon- handled by voice communications alone. Historically,
ferencing can meet many of its needs for information however, relatively few meetings have been conducted
exchange and transfer. Teletravel can he more than ten times electronically. Numerous excuses have been made, not the
more effective than actual busines~ travel to a meeting or least of which are outmoded prejudices based on bad
conference. Not only is teleconferencing displacing certain experiences with old technology. Archaic speakerphones,
travel and personal visits for routine business, teleconferenc- poor signal quality, time wasted while waiting, and that
ing enables new services, like distance teaching and tele- uncomfortable feeling some people have conducting business
marketing, to evolve. by phone head the litany of complaints.
There are four types of teleconferencing techniques now That picture is slowly changing. The evolution of bridge
available: full motion video conferencing; audiographic (or technology, high quality speakerphones, and the concomitant
slow scan) teleconferencing; audio conferencing and compu- training programmes available through telecommunications
ter conferencing. Full motion video conferencing, by far the consultants has helped sway public response toward the use of
most complex and expensive option, requires full video audio and audiographic technologies for a variety of uses.
origination capabilities at each of the participating sites. Research indicates that 85 percent of teleconferencing activi-
However, the most common video conferencing arrangement ties are audio rather than video. Audio conferencing's
typically uses a configuration involving a one-way video, flexibility and convenience in concert with judicious planning
two-way audio connection from the origination site to one or can realize effective, efficient, and productive alternatives to
more receiving sites. Usually, the vi~ual programe is transmit- the traditional meeting without the requirements and costs
ted via satellite, with return voice interaction carried over associated with video or audiographic teleconferencing.
standard telephone lines. In the past two years, the alterna- Dozens of universities around the world use audio con-
tive to point-to-point full motion video conferencing using ferencing for curriculum delivery, while thousands of
digital compression techniques has seen rapid development. businesses use audio conferencing for tele-meetings. Some
These networks typically use 1.544 megabits per second companies, such as Arco Oil, J.C. Penney and others, have
(mbps) speeds in the US and Japan and 2.044 mbps in dedicated full time teleconferencing networks. Both universi-
Europe, although more sophisticated new coding equipment ties and businesses make extensive use of audio-visual aids,
allows speeds as low as 56 kilohits per second. Dedicated including transparencies, tapes and slides. But with straight
receive-only networks are providing another option for users audio conferencing these must be sent in advance and no
with ongoing teleconferencing requirements. interactive video image is possible.
Audio conferencing involves linking two or more indi- In teleconferencing situations when audio only is not
viduals or groups at dispersed sites typically using telephone adequate and full motion video is not justified for reasons of
lines for voice communications. For convenience and to cost or programme requirements, audiographic technology is
ensure uniform voice quality, many audio conference users frequently used. Audiographics offer both written and
now employ audio conferencing bridge services. graphic communications and are generally used in conjuntion
An audiographic conference is simply an audio conference with an audio conference.
which is augmented by the use of such visual technologies as Defined broadly, audiographics include freeze frame/slow
freeze frame or slow scan television, facsimile, computer scan television, facsimile, telewriters, electronic blackboards
graphics, electronic blackboards, or remotely controlled and electronic text. All of these technologies work in more or
projection equipment, all of which can be transmitted over a less the same way. A visual image is converted to digital form,
standard telephone line. Satellite service enhances audio transmitted over a standard telephone line, and recqnverted
graphic transmission capability in terms of capacity, speed at the receiving end into a u~eable format. Taping and storing
and quality. for later use can be accomplished in either an audio or video
Computer conferencing denotes a telecommunications format with most audiographic systems.
mode that allows dispersed individuals to be connected Audiographic conferencing offers several advantages. Its
through a computer network, using computer keyboards to use, first of all, is predicated on standard telephone lines.
send data and message communications. This flexibility allows users to originate and distribute graphic
87
Satellites International
information to and from virtually any location. Phone line video signal, the advent of a digitally compressed video
charges, usually for two lines per site (one for video and one technique has resulted in video signals which use less than ten
for audio transmission), and audio conferencing bridge percent of a single transponder. Although digital video is not
charges are essentially the only transmission costs in audiog- completely smooth in its simulation of full motion, it is
raphic conferencing. The ability to transmit a variety of adequate for most educational and training purposes.
written, graphic and other print information economically Popular digital video rates range from 1.544 mbps (T-1 line
and conveniently has made the audiographic alternative an rate) in the US to 2.044 mbps in Europe down to the more
attractive one for a wide range of users in both business and economical 56 kilobits per second (kbps) codecs offered by
social services. Since these systems are most extensive in the certain high tech suppliers. Most US cities have 56 kbps
US examples are largely derived from American experiences. service and with ISDN coming soon, 64 kbps services should
A number of US universities have implemented audiog- be available throughout most of Europe and Japan within two
raphic systems as part of their efforts to reach students to three years.
outside the typical campus. The University of Wisconsin Despite these examples of applications, ambitious projec-
Extension (UWEX) Educational Telephone Network (ETN) tions for satellite teleconferencing services have never been
is a dedicated, four-wire audio teleconferencing network that realized. Particularly in the area of teleconferencing, the
provides UWEX with exclusive use of a system that offers explosion largely fizzled. The satellite teleconferencing indus-
higher quality and more reliable service than regular tele- try has grown, and from all indications, will continue to
phone lines. In addition to ETN's 200-site audio network, the expand, but on a moderate scale.
Statewide Extension Education Network (SEEN) consists of An Air Transport Association report issued during the first
an additional 23 sites equipped with dual networks - one part of the decade predicted that by 1985 teleconferencing
carries audio messages and one is used for slow scan/freeze would divert one percent of the airlines business travel
frame transmission. These networks offer state residents a revenue and two percent of postal revenue. This hasn't
combination of non-credit professional and continuing educa- happened. In fact, financial reports indicate that both travel
tion courses, public service programming, credit courses and and mail services have increased not only in terms of revenue,
administrative services. Altogether, electronically-delivered but also in utilization.
instruction through this network is provided to more than A few years ago, teleconferencing promoters estimated
36,000 participants each year. that as much as 30 percent or more of today's conventional
The US Department of Agriculture's Soil Conservation meetings would be replaced by teleconferencing by the end of
Service has equipped 20 sites with electronic blackboards and the decade, growing to 50 percent by the turn of the century.
two-way audio capability. Two additional sites have audio In retrospect, cost and time savings projections were both
and computer equipment, and another two have audio and overestimated and misleading. Certain types of repetitive
slow scan capability. Thirty-three other sites have audio meetings have been displaced, but there's no empirical
equipment. This interactive capability is used for teletraining evidence that teleconferencing is replacing conventional
courses on soil conservation, and for administrative and meetings in general. Those organizations that have acquired
technical teleconferences. In France, over one hundred sites dedicated facilities are, of course, exceptions but the total
have been equipped for audiographic teleconferencing in number of public or social service organizations that have
addition to 40 sites for video conferencing. Through Eutelsat, dedicated facilities are very few. Consequently, the real
both video conferencing and audiographic services are growth manifested in the teleconferencing industry has been
available throughout Europe today. interpreted in less positive terms because market projections
Full motion video conferencing, although experiencing did not meet the initial expectations.
some success in the private sector, has not achieved compara- Teleconferencing presents a viable alternative to tradi-
ble use in the public service sector. This dichotomy is tional means of delivering programmes and services, but
primarily due to cost and availability factors. arguments justifying its use in the past two years are based
Full motion video conferencing is available on an ad hoc less on cost reduction and more on revenue generating
basis for approximately $1,000 per hour for a two node potential. Much less attention is paid to the technology, with
network. A typical teleconferencing site includes a three applications and programming coming to the fore. Value-
camera set up with graphics and taping facilities. AT&T, after added benefits of going through the teleconferencing process
experimenting with such an arrangement has phased out its continue to accrue. Teleconferencing allows an organization
Picturephone meeting Service. Other full motion video to utilize staff more efficiently, involve key people who
conferencing networks are marketing excess time on an ad ordinarily would not be able to travel, plan more systemati-
hoc basis but with a relatively modest return on their cally and replicate programme materials easily.
investment. The most successful full motion video conferenc- Teleconferencing planners have now adopted much more
ing services have been full time dedicated corporate net- realistic goals. The advent of dedicated networks in concert
works. with expanded telecommunications capability will surely
Direct broadcast satellite (DBS) services will use more accelerate the incorporation of teleconferencing into business
powerful Ku-band satellites and small earth stations. These as usual, but this expansion will be tempered by a more
have the potential for dramatically increasing the use of one- pragmatic view of teleconferencing's strengths and weak-
way video conferencing by offering new subscriber services nesses. The user community, both corporate and non-profit,
and increasing satellite capacity. The prospect of acquiring has a better understanding of how and where teleconferenc-
earth stations less than one meter in diameter for $800 or less ing can best contribute. The realization that certain informa-
will attract not only large business, but small users and tion is not amenable to electronic delivery, and the fact that
non-profit organizations. For users of one-way video con- travel is often a perceived perquisite not willingly relin-
ferencing on a regular basis, dedicated networks have proven quished, will contribute to more down-to-earth planning. A
a viable means of establishing an ongoing delivery system. great awareness of the real costs and revenue potential in
A recently developed alternative to full motion video uses teleconferencing will clarify much of the current thinking
digital compression technology. Rather than use an entire regarding the value, utilization and ultimate adoption and
satellite transponder to transmit a broadcast quality analog integration of teleconferencing on a regular basis.
88
Communications Satellite Services
This process of technology adoption is the culmination of a
number of steps along the way. These steps include aware-
ness. understanding. acceptance and utilization. leading to
adoption. In less than a decade satellite teleconferencing has
moved from the awareness stage to one of understanding and
acceptance. However. effective utilization is necessary to
guarantee the adoption of this technology. Teleconferencing
is moving toward this final stage. but to date it has not been
utilized nor integrated effectively. By capitalizing on the
knowledge and experience of the computer industry.
however. these stumbling blocks are slowly being overcome.
Ad hoc teleconferencing. much of it experimental in nature.
has set the stage and the next decade will represent the true
benchmark for the teleconferencing industry. It may not be as
pervasive as some early predictions estimated. but its
presence will be an undeniable factor in both the corporate
and the non-profit worlds.
89
11 B TELECOMMUNICATIONS SATELLITES AND THE
PRESS TODAY
Oliver Robinson, Executive Director, International Press Telecommunications; and Louis A. Bransford,
President, Public Service Satellite Consortium
Most people hate change as much as they welcome variety. beside the cost of the satellite itself and its launch.
Change is thus resented most by those with a vested interest Satellites might have been designed exclusively for the
in the status quo such as people whose livelihood may be media, for what the media want is a tool for disseminating
threatened by technological innovation or governments to information to the largest number of people. When a
whom change is almost impossible to reconcile with the telephone subscriber calls his family, clients or business
exigencies of economic planning or historical regulations. colleagues, his conversation is of little value unless it is
The satellite is a symbol of change. It offers almost two-way. But with the media the requirement is differrent.
unlimited opportunities for the exchange of information Broadcasters want to reach as many viewers as possible, not
between peoples, businessmen, scientists and all those who vice versa. The press wants to distribute its various informa-
strive to make the world a better place. It is a unique tool for tion services to subscribers by the thousand, be they
defining the role and influence of the written press in today's newspapers, broadcasting organizations, business houses and
electronic world. ultimately the reader. Newspapers also want to send their
The press- the oldest of the media- is a popular vehicle for pages to remote printing plants for regional or even foreign
disseminating news and views. It preceded sound broadcast- editions. In fact the media's main requirement is for a
ing by several generations and television by even more. multi-destinational one-way telecommunications service
Yet it survives, and in most cases, prospers despite the which may traverse oceans, continents or even both.
closure of evening newspapers largely uncompetitive in price The potential of satellites for press distribution, however,
and stolid in content beside the glossiness of dinnertime has been severely constrained. The press has been given
television. Television provides the headlines to a story. But almost unrestricted access to the telecommunications satellite
there are people whose appetite for information is whetted by in only one country - the US- although recently, restrictions
the two or three minute TV introduction, which is all that have been removed in Canada. Privately-owned American
television can spare for an earthquake, a hi-jack, a political or satellite carriers have been happy for news agencies and
economic crisis or some other news event. Many who want to newspapers to publish in several cities, to buy or lease
know more about the story turn to the newspaper for the transponders and to own their own terminals. This 'space
fuller story- to read at their leisure - and not at a pace some freedom' together with the dramatic increases in the charges
newscaster may dictate. Some people buy newspapers for renting terrestrial (or microwave) facilities, began the
because they provide a wealth of specialist information such space race for the US press. Now, it has become a little less
as stock exchange prices which are not readily available as yet than a stampede, with the development of a new technology
in a more convenient and cheaper form. People buy them used in astronomy and perfected in military applications.
because they are more transportable than a TV set. They buy The new technology is known as 'spread spectrum'.
them because they are scurrilous, or at least opinionated, Because of the modulation technique that it uses, it is more
because of their crosswords, their 'do-it-yourself' columns, sensitive to bandwidth than noise and can work in a
their astrologies and their political proclivities. They buy remarkably high noise level environment. Spread spectrum
them as an antidote to boredom. Yet most people think of the permits the use of small transportable 0.6-metre diameter
press and the newspaper as synonymous: they aren't. Some receive-only dishes. These dishes, together with a micro-
members of the public have heard of news agencies like AFP, processor and printer cost no more than $2,500 and weigh a
AP, ANSA, DPA, EFE and Reuters 1, but the majority modest 16 kilogrammes. They provide highly reliable digital
remains largely ignorant of their functions and of their role in communication of up to 19.2 kilobits per second. Thousands
the dissemination of information, whether general or special- of these dishes have been installed by broadcasting stations
ized, to thousands of newspapers and business subscribers. and publishing houses throughout North America for the
News agencies and some publishing houses have been reception of news agency services upon which they depend
quick to realize the impact of new technology upon their for both news programmes and newspaper content. There is
conventional products, and in this tornado of change the scarcely a commodity more perishable than news and the
satellite plays a star role. Its great advantage over other small receive-only dish has preserved its freshness at a price
means of telecommunications is that it is virtually distance that is modest compared with the use of terrestrial circuits
independent in terms of cost. Investment in a transoceanic provided by telecommunications administrations or privately-
cable connecting no more than two terminals will be not quite owned carriers.
proportional to its length, but the cost of a satellite serving a This 'freedom of the skies' in the US has also led to the
multitude of earth stations in a variety of countries, is a publication of individual newpapers at plants all over the
constant except for the number and size of stations needed to country. The Wall Street Journal, with a circulation limited at
transmit or receive a signal, and these can be insignificant first to the financial community in and around New York
91
Satellites International
City, is now printed in 22 plants throughout the US. The Wall provide a quality telecommunications service to all comers at
Street Journal has purchased satellite capacity and uses its all hours. They explain how satellites can go astray and have a
own 11-metre ground stations for both transmission and limited life span, how they are likely to be more vulnerable
reception. The demand for financial information keeps than terrestrial networks in times of war. For this reason
growing. In societies where there are more and more telecommunications administrations have some argument in
stockholders people want to read about the ups and downs of favour of tariff policies which fail to distinguish between
currencies, shares and commodity prices, etc. They also want spatial and terrestrial communication, at least for conven-
informed opinion about the likely drift of this market sector tional telecommunication services such as the telephone,
or another. USA Today is also a satellite flag bearer. This telex and data networks. Yet despite this the satellite has had
publication aims to be America's first national newspaper and a marked effect upon some intercontinental tariffs and in
the breadth of its state-by-state coverage keeps the itinerant particular, between London and New York, the main
businessman or tourist aware of events back home. The overseas telecommunications artery of the world. Here rates
prestigious New York Times is another entrant into the have dropped by as much as 60 percent during the last few
multi-point satellite printing business, although on a some- years despite inflation.
what less ambitious scale. But has even this sort of tariff decrease been sufficient?
To news agencies whose function it is to collect and Intelsat now provides a two-way voice grade circuit between
disseminate information, whether in textual or photographic two countries for just under $800 a month. If business or the
form, telecommunications costs represent a conspicuous item press leases this same channel from its telecommunications
in their budgets. Anything which can contain or reduce administration, the retail price which includes earth station
telecommunications costs is not only of benefit to the agency charges and terrestrial links will be 7, 10 or even 15 times
itself but to its newspaper and commercial subscribers, and higher. Administrations may say that they have expensive
ultimately, to the newspaper reader too. Newspapers that satellite ground stations to buy, staff wages to pay, parts and
want to publish at a variety of sites cannot realize their equipment to maintain and eventually replace, but their
ambitions without telecommunications facilities that are mark-up still seems excessive. The problem of high tariffs can
reliable and tariffs which are equitable. In the US their be measured by comparing the rates for service provided by
dreams have come true, but elsewhere at least the economic satellite carriers within the US by Intelsat's international rates
freedom of the press is still hampered. and those between the US and countries abroad where the
Frustrations abound, particularly in the developing coun- telecommunications service is provided by PTT's. For
tries. Many established their own government sponsored example:
news agencies shortly after independence, for the enlighten-
ment of their people and the creation of a spirit of national Voice grade circuits
identity and consciousness. The agency's budget often USA to:
reflected the poverty of the country, sometimes less than
$100,000 a year. No agency can survive without news from UK $ 7,046 per month
USSR 16,245 ,
the outside world, and in particular, from countries which
Australia 11,391,
have shared to some greater or lesser extent, the same
Japan 11,279,
heritage or in future, some converging destiny.
Chile 15,092 ,
Yet these news agencies can scarcely receive or send
Zaire 15,807 ,
information across their own frontiers because of the very
high tariffs imposed by their own telecommunications admi-
nistrations for telex, telephone or leased circuits, whether lntelsat
provided by land line or radio. Even when satellites are used International two-way
the price can be prohibitive. One African administration will voice circuit $ 780 per month
charge a customer $2,500 for renting a single 50 words per
minute teleprinter circuit from the capital city to New York US domestic
for ten days while a portable receive-only dish with a capacity New York to:
of 19.2 kilobits sells for the same price. Dallas $ 1,092.50 per month
What's wrong? Unfortunately, governments so proud of San Francisco 1,177.50 , ,
their news agencies and anxious for their success are also Los Angeles 1,177.50,
patrons of their telecommunications administrations. These Houston 965.00 ,
administrations may be their governments' principal source of Atlanta 965.00,
revenue and valuable foreign exchange. If satellite com- Miami 965.00,
munication could be as accessible to the press in, say, Africa
and Latin America as it is in the US, the literate would be Few administrations will tell you what they make on the
better informed. If this is what governments want, then there international satellite calls but will tell you how they lose on
must be realistic pricing of telecommunications services for innumerable terrestrial roundabouts like the provision of
the media, not only in the developing, but also in the telephone service to remote areas. Such services to remote
developed world. areas and subsidies that help this to occur are important, but
Satellite communications poses a challenge to telecom- the press is a social service too. The freedom to communicate
munications administrations because it allows direct intercon- in today's world of telecommunications is thus threatened by
nections rather than routing through third party countries. excessive transmission tariffs. This threat is particularly so
The satellite not only threatens their traditional way of doing with regard to the new spread spectrum technology which
business, but it delivers enormous savings in the cost of Intelsat calls Intelnet, which is so well adapted to interna-
telecommunication. These administrations are committed to tional news distribution.
investing in expensive terrestrial networks, including the Governments and their telecommunications administra-
Integrated Services Digital Network (ISDN). They argue that tions cannot stare into a satellite mirror forever, fixed in
this investment is necessary because it is their responsibility to indecision. Policies for communication and telecommunica-
92
Communications Satellite Services
tion - and these are interdependent and indivisible - are as It is not a sin to ask for the moon. Yet, except for tides, the
essential to the fabric of society as policies for health, satellite is infinitely more useful.
education and defence. Governments have the responsibility
to create conditions most favourable to the collection and
dissemination of information, but seldom, if ever, face this
daunting challenge. REFERENCE
In the meantime, international or foreign editions of
newspapers are starting to proliferate, but only because of the 1. AFP, Agence France Presse (Paris); AP, Associated Press
telecommunications tariffs they can afford. Asahi Shimbun of (New York); ANSA, Agenzia Nazionale Stampa Associata
Tokyo started printing in London on 1 January 1986 to bring (Rome); DPA, Deutsche Press Agentur (Hamburg); EFE,
the sizeable Japanese population in Europe closer to their Agencia EFE (Madrid); Reuters, (London).
home country. The International Herald Tribune, the father
of international page facsimile printing, is now printing in
south east Asia and has plans for a Miami edition in the
forseeable future. The Financial Times of London also prints
in Frankfurt and New York. The Economist and the weekly
Guardian print via satellite in New York, while a number of
American dailies want to use satellite for European editions.
Papers in Arabic and Chinese are now printed in London.
The press is aboard the satellite bandwagon even if it is in low
gear.
It is undoubtedly true that Intelsat has been largely
responsible for stimulating the press and other industries to
use satellites for specialist applications. In as little as six
months Intelsat introduced more than 200 service offerings in
1984. Most of its signatories however, have offered no more
than five or ten of these new services to the public.
Market research can play a key role in increasing man's
understanding of the benefits of satellite communication, and
it is unfortunate that more is not being done in this respect.
Satellites mean employment, not only in their construction
and launching, but for those who can use them profitably. If a
newspaper can publish a foreign edition, be it a country or
continent away, using an inexpensive and reliable satellite
link, it can mean jobs for more journalists, more advertising
and distribution personnel, more maintenance staff and more
telecommunications engineers. Satellites must not be seen as
a challenge to the orthodoxy of the telecommunications
establishment but as the ubiquitous servant of most of
mankind.
Yet there are portents that telecommunications administra-
tions are beginning to come to terms with satellite com-
munication - but with varying degrees of enthusiasm. The
French PTT recently authorized the establishment of a press
carrier, funded jointly by its fully-owned subsidiary, France
Cable, and the French news agency, Agence France Presse.
The new carrier will disseminate news to small dishes
throughout western Europe over the ECS and Telecom 1
satellites. Furthermore, the International Press Telecom-
munications Council, which was set up in 1965 to safeguard
and promote the telecommunications interests of the world's
press, has recently submitted a series of contributions to the
CCITT. This committee, whose voting members are res-
tricted to representatives of telecommunications administra-
tions, have been giving a more than sympathetic ear to the
claims of the press for access to satellite communication so
that it may serve its readers better. Perhaps this may be due
to the clarity and vigour with which newspapers and news
agencies have been able to define their requirements, not
only technically, but in social and economic terms.
What is it that the press wants? In brief: unrestricted access
to satellites for both transmission and reception; the ability to
purchase satellite capacity or to lease band-width (from full
transponders to voice grade circuits on a full or part-time
basis for both point to multi-point and two-way services);
freedom to own transmit and receiver stations; the right to
purchase or lease satellite capacity at affordable rates.
93
11C SATELLITES AND TELEVISION
BROADCASTING
Among the many inventions and new technologies of the 20th would remain stationary above the same spot and
century, some have achieved their full potential only when would be within optical range of nearly half the
paired together. One example is radio broadcasting and the Earth's surface. Three repeater stations, 120 degrees
subsequent invention of the transistor; another is television apart in the correct orbit would give television and
broadcasting, which started in 1936, and the arrival 21 years microwave coverage to the entire planet'.
later in 1957 of the communications satellite in space. His prescience has been quoted many times over the
The technologies of television and satellites have since following years, providing Dr Clarke with the satisfaction
been combined to create the most powerful medium for the denied to many prophets in their own lifetime.
distribution of information, education and entertainment Events since the launch of Sputnik have taken place at such
known to mankind. In the space of 30 years, the global an accelerated pace of change and development that the
potential for satellite-transmitted television programming words in this chapter may well be outdated before they are
expanded to a point where two billion people, in every read! If it is often bewildering to newer generations, how
continent of the world, were estimated to have watched the must it seem to those from earlier generations like Mr
same event at the same time. The event was the World Cup Botham senior, who grew up in a horse-drawn age, before
Soccer Final from Mexico City in 1986. popular newspapers, before electricity, before radio and
The speed of development over a relatively brief number of before television? If television has shaped and influenced
years can be measured by comparing that astonishing figure lifestyles and social expectations in the second half of the 20th
with equally impressive figures from earlier years: one-half century, then the use of satellites has been one of the most
billion people watched the Apollo moon landing and man's significant contributory factors. And there is still more than a
first steps on the moon in 1969; the Olympic Games in 1984 decade of development to come before the century gives way
reached an estimated audience of 1.5 billion. Major news to the new vistas of the year 2000 and beyond. The following
events such as the Mexican earthquake in 1985, the Reagan- pages will review some of the steps along the way since
Gorbachev summit in 1986, and the Ethiopian famine Sputnik, consider some of the effects and consequences, and
pictures in 1985, reached equally large audiences by means of attempt to look into the future uses of satellite systems for
satellite distribution. broadcasting.
A less dramatic, more intimate example of the use of Television broadcasting made its first use of an interna-
satellite communications encapsulated the extraordinary time tional satellite in 1962, using the Telstar satellite which was
scale in which these developments have occurred. orbiting the Earth once every 157 minutes. This was the first
On Christmas Day 1986, the English sports personality Ian satellite designed for experimental television transmission (as
Botham - in Australia on a cricket tour - took part in a live well as multi-channel telephony). It was constructed by the
television programme which linked him in Melbourne with American Telephone and Telegraph Company (AT&T), and
his grandfather in Leeds, in the north of England. launched by NASA on 10 July 1962, to work with the British
The programme, transmitted by the BBC and by Channel Post Office earth station at Goonhilly Down, and with the
10 Australia, showed the two Bothams on a split screen, French PTT earth station at Pleumeur-Bodou.
exchanging Christmas greetings as though they were in the A week after the launch, executives of AT&T and the
same house; but one was in cold, rain-swept Yorkshire, British Post Office set up an experiemental link and saw
England, and the other 13,000 miles away in warm, sunny pictures of each other as they exchanged greetings at their
Melbourne. The technological achievements of satellite respective earth stations. At about the same time, there was a
broadcasting which made this possible are now taken for more ambitious exchange between the US and France and
granted in most countries - but their brief exchange illus- some pictures derived from the satellite feed were broadcast
trated how the world has changed in their lifetime. on French television. However, the 'official' debut of
Mr Botham senior was one hundred years old - and when television by satellite came on 23 July 1962 - with a
he was born in 1886, Queen Victoria was on the throne of programme transmitted from the US to the members of the
England, the American Civil War was barely over, Australia European Broadcasting Union (EBU); followed by a prog-
was still being explored and colonized, and Thomas Edison ramme in the opposite direction to viewers of the US
was still developing the telegraph and experimenting with networks.
uses of electricity. Ian Botham was 31 - and when he was In Earth orbit, Telstar was 'visible' to the US and
born in 1955, the use of outer space was still in the laboratory European earth stations for just 18 minutes, and special
stage and the Russians were edging towards the historic day programmes were on the air in 27 European countries to wait
in 1957 when the first Sputnik was launched into orbit, for the first transmission shortly after 8.00 pm CET. Richard
bringing closer to reality the predictions of Arthur C. Clarke, Dimbleby, the legendary BBC commentator, hosted the
who wrote in 1945: Europe-wide programme and introduced the first pictures as
'An "artificial satellite" at the correct distance from the the satellite came over the horizon. Fred Friendly of CBS
earth would make one revolution every 24 hours: ie, it appeared in the studio and took viewers on a US tour, in
95
Satellites International
which all three networks- CBS, NBC and ABC- took part. initiatives. From the original 12 countries whose representa-
There were sequences from New York and California, from tives met in Washington in October 1964, the membership
Cape Canaveral and the Mormon Tabernacle Choir at Mount had grown to 114 by the end of 1987.
Rushmore, from the Rio Grande and from the Canadian In that first year, there were five earth stations providing 75
border. telephone circuits across the Atlantic Ocean. Television
As the pictures eventually faded from view, Europe transmission was possible only by surrending voice circuits.
celebrated a new step in history and Telstar continued its way By the end of 1986, fifteen operational satellites over the
around the globe. About 2Yz hours later, the satellite was three oceanic regions were operating in conjunction with 680
over the Atlantic Ocean again and just before 11:00 pm CET, major earth stations, and countless small receive-only anten-
there was another 18-minute transmission showing American nas, linking together 165 countries, territories and dependen-
viewers a panorama of Europe: industry in Germany, opera cies around the globe. ·
from Rome, the first edition of the next day's newspapers in How has all this hardware in space been utilized by the
Paris, the Ceremony of the Keys at the Tower of London, and television broadcasters of the world?
another new invention, the hovercraft, on the south coast of Live international transmissions of space-shots, moon
England. landings, Royal Weddings, Olympic Games and World Cup
So it all began, and from that day in 1962, for TV audiences Soccer were among the subjects which enabled television
in North America and Europe, the use of Atlantic satellites production and distribution techniques to evolve, technical
for special occasions gradually developed. Once the uncer- and creative improvements to be made, which utilized the
tainties of the low-orbiting Telstar had been succeeded by potential of this new medium.
geostationary satellites in the 22,300-mile orbit (as predicted Sporting events gained audiences of many millions to enjoy
by Arthur C. Clarke) the continents were linked with growing the big occasions- and provide massive exposure for sponsors
frequency as TV executives began to persuade their col- and advertisers, too. But it is in the area of news coverage and
leagues to recognize the value of the impact achieved - even reporting that those same global audiences have been most
at the relatively high costs of satellite transmissions in the profoundly affected.
1960s. In the 1960s, television viewers in Europe saw the racial
Syncom-11 and Relay were the satellites which provided the confrontations in Arkansas, Alabama and Chicago in their
mid-Atlantic link for some notable pioneering work in 1963. stark reality, almost as they happened, conveying the depth
One occasion which bridged the generations was the of the problem in a way which was not possible by radio or
ceremony in Washington DC in April 1963 at which Sir newspapers. Those long, hot summers led to changes of
Winston Churchill was made an hononary US citizen. Presi- attitudes and policies in the US, and one may ask whether the
dent Kennedy presided over the ceremony in the rose garden changes were, perhaps, more radical or more comprehensive,
of the White House, describing Sir Winston as 'the most because the eyes of the world were watching, via satellite?
honoured and honorable man to walk the stage of human Then Vietnam, which sometimes seemed to be the first war
history at this time'. The honour was ac~epted by Sir to be fought on the screens in the living rooms of American
Winston's son, Randolph Churchill. Sir Winston and Lady families- as well as those in the rest of the world. Analysis of
Churchill watched the ceremony in their London home - he the way in which the conflict eventually came to an end leaves
was by then too elderly to make the transatlantic journey. But little doubt about the influence of the television coverage on
he was able to share in the historic occasion by satellite - and public opinion, and of public opinion on the decision-makers.
so, too, were millions of admirers of Churchill on both sides It was graphic reporting and pictures, month after month,
of the Atlantic. made even more telling by the immediacy of satellite
Seven months later, on 22 November 1963, the same transmission across the Pacific Ocean, which in turn limited
satellite link was used to bring to the rest of the world the any opportunity for censorship or official controls over what
unbelievable, unforgettable news coverage from Dallas of the was being seen.
assassination of President Kennedy. It is the first occasion on More recently, by contrast, the British encounter with the
which the links between New York and London were Argentine forces in the Falkland Islands was in a remote
established within a matter of a few hours instead of being island in the South Atlantic where it was possible, even in
planned days in advance. 1982, for control to be maintained over the news coverage for
The film coverage of the presidential motorcade, the several weeks. Now, only five years later, it is doubtful
moment of the shooting and the scenes which followed at the whether any Western country could successfully keep such
hospital and elsewhere were transmitted from NBC New distance between its war-like efforts and the attentions of the
York via satellite to be recorded and shown to British world's TV cameras; changes in public attitudes and improve-
audiences more quickly than any previous news story from ments in technology are the main reasons - and Intelsat's
the US. Simultaneously, the London-based international TV satellites are there to provide the links.
news agencies were distributing copies of the same pictures by Iceland was a less remote island and the situation there was
air to broadcasters in other parts of the world- where again, not a hazardous war zone but a summit conference in the
the coverage was seen by viewers a day earlier than would autumn of 1986. The news coverage of that event was a clear
have been possible before the transatlantic satellite. indication of changes which had taken place in a few, short
In the months and years that followed, more and more years. With only two or three days notice no fewer than
special events were transmitted in the same way - occasions eleven transportable earth stations were flown in to enable
like the NASA space launches, and sporting occasions like broadcasters to transmit television coverage by satellite to the
the Olympic Games and World Cup; and major news stories US, the USSR, Japan and many other countries, using seven
could be moved from North America to Europe or vice versa, different satellites.
with more and more immediacy. This instantaneous global network enabled correspondents
The role of Intelsat became central to the growth of global to report in many languages as this potentially crucial meeting
television transmissions. The organization was created in of world leaders unfolded. It also provided an unprecedented
1964, recognizing that satellite communications should be a world audience for the political positioning by the President
matter for an international forum rather than for national of the United States, the Chairman of the Praesidium of the
96
Communications Satellite Services
USSR and their spokesmen as they sought to characterize the hundred transmissions every day. If the same growth rate
outcome of the meetings. were to be experienced over the next ten years, there would
This political exploitation is one by-product of the expan- be little room for anything else on the world's TV screens but
sion of satellite communications for television broadcasting. satellite transmitted programmes!
Another is the disappearance of the opportunity for politi- And that is only part of the story. By the end of 1986, 14
cians and leaders to ponder for hours, even days, on a major broadcasting organizations had leased full-time transponders
event before presenting their views in a considered, possibly on Intelsat satellites providing them with the potential for 24
sanitized, form. Now, their own people, and probably most of hours use, every day of the year. This is also a rapidly growing
the world, would have seen the reality of an event as quickly area, which all adds up to a massive volume of TV traffic
as a prime minister or president can be informed through already crossing the oceans of the world every day. It is not
diplomatic channels. just Intelsat and the major broadcasters who make this
A classic example was the Shtila Camp massacre in happen. For much of the daily flow of news coverage around
Lebanon in 1985, when TV camera crews found their way to the world, the key players are the two international TV news
the bloody scene soon after the marauding troops had agencies, Visnews and Worldwide Television News (WTN)-
departed. Within two hours, the coverage was transmitted by both London-based companies. Their camera crews cover
satellite from a Syrian earth station (the nearest facility news event in every corner of the world and supply a daily
operational at the time) and received in London. By the end service to more then 400 broadcasters in every country where
of the same day, the pictures were distributed around the TV exists. They compete, in the field and in the marketplace,
world and were seen by viewers in US, Europe, Japan, and are among the heaviest users of satellites to reach their
Australia- and, no doubt, in Eastern Europe and the Middle clients with pictures of 'today's news today'.
East, too. A national broadcaster may book satellite time for a major
The massacre was identified as the work of the Israeli- news story of importance to that particular country, covered
backed Christian militia. The victims were Palestinians, who by their own correspondent and cameraman, if they happen
have few friends around the world. In Lebanon, the to have those resources available in the right place at the right
Christians were the enemies of the Moslems. Against such a time. The agencies have their cameras in constant use, in
complex political background, the issue might have easily upwards of 50 different locations every day to provide the
become submerged in United Nations debate and it would regular, daily service of news coverage upon which broadcas-
have been months before the full facts emerged. By then ters depend in order to compile their TV news bulletins.
fresh news would have displaced the story from the headlines. The use of international satellites for this purpose was
But on this occasion, the television pictures provided ample pioneered by Visnews in 1975, with a daily ten-minute
testimony of the facts and governments were put under transmission of news from London to a group of broadcasters
immense pressure to condemn the incident. The first and in Australia- who until then, had received their TV newsfilm
categoric reactions came from the US and the USSR. Both from the rest of the world two or three days after the event.
condemned the massacre unequivocally and the rest of the That daily transmission was later shared by Japan and other
world quickly followed their lead. The Israeli cabinet came Asian countries. In the following years, the number of daily
close to resigning and world politics had been influenced not newsfeeds by Visnews to various groups of broadcasters
just by the news coverage of a single, vivid event, but by the around the world grew to a total of eight with a combined
speed with which people the world over became aware of it, transmission time of nearly four hours a day, by the end of
almost simultaneously. 1986. Meanwhile, WTN, developing the same pattern of
Those who question, with some justification, the influence multi-destination news transmissions, has another three daily
of satellite-delivered television news coverage, should also newsfeeds.
take into consideration that in the months and years that All this is the international dimension of satellite news and
followed there were no further such occurrences. programme distribution. In addition, there is now a major
In a very different context, it was the television coverage of domestic satellite industry in the US, providing coast-to-coast
the Ethiopian famine in 1985 which touched the conscience of links for the networks, for independent stations and for cable
millions of people worldwide, and which in turn galvanized services. Canada has its own domestic system; so too, does
governments into action in a meaningful way. That unforgett- Japan, India, Indonesia, Australia; and in Europe, there is
able coverage of the refuge camps, once it emerged in the growing Eutelsat system which provides services for
London, was distributed worldwide by satellite so that the broadcasters as well as other telecommunications needs; and
impact was total and simultaneous, leading to the massive in the Middle East, Arabsat provides similar services.
success of the 'Live Aid' initiative. This again was possible Intelsat's services are not exclusively international. In 1987
only by international satellite interconnections, and the nearly 40 countries had purchased or leased transponders
spontaneous response which it created is now history. from the organization to provide domestic telecommunica-
The growth in the use of satellites for the international tions services - among them Argentina, China, Germany,
transmission of news and special events, including big Israel, Norway, Peru, UK and Zaire. Many of these countries
sporting occasions, has been spectacular during the 1970s and use some of the capacity for international TV distribution.
1980s. It is not so long ago that broadcasters superim- The totality of satellite facilities, still expanding both in
posed a caption: 'BY SATELLITE' over material received in numbers and in the power and flexibility of the hardware in
this way - partly as kudos, partly to explain any quality orbit, adds up to a massive new resource for the flow of
difference in the pictures or sound. Now, few broadcasters information around the world. And the use of that resource
consider the caption necessary, for either reason. Indeed, the for television is the way in which most people are aware of the
repetition would become distracting. existence of satellites.
Consider these Intelsat statistics. The use of the system by The largest global audience for a television transmission is
broadcasters for what is called 'occasional TV service'- which thought to have been the two billion who saw the World Cup
can be booked for any period from ten minutes upwards- has Soccer final in 1986- a statistic which underlines the power
increased from 12,000 hours in 1976 to over 60,000 in 1986. and potential of the combined technologies of television and
During 1986, there were an average of more than one satellites.
97
Satellites International
A trend has been clearly established in the direction of the existing national state broadcasters and networks, who
more international communications, but this inevitably raises have dominated world broadcasting for so long, but also for
questions about who provides the television programmes, and the new, emerging entrepreneurial broadcasters and prog-
who controls the airwaves? This is a technical question as well ramme distributors who have seen satellites as the route to
as a political one: technical because the availability of new, international broadcast markets.
frequencies for broadcasting cannot be left to chance and Satellites also provide the potential for direct transmission
there are existing international regulating bodies (notably the to the home. Although DBS- direct broadcast by satellite-
International Telecommunication Union) who grapple with has been slow to achieve the expectations of its early
the complexities of this issue at their periodic meetings. advocates, there is little doubt that it will become a new and
The political question is harder to reconcile, partly because important factor during the early 1990s - initially in Europe
of widely differing ideologies and attitudes towards broad- and Japan.
casting freedoms; but also because of the varying stages of The possibilities of DBS have already been exploited in
development in the broadcasting and communications sys- many countries where those with the resources to buy and
tems between one country and another; and the priority install backyard receivers costing a few thousand dollars can
which each nation attaches to this area. receive a wide range of existing television programmes from
It is probably true that attitudes would be rather different if domestic and international satellites. The next stage, genuine
all countries had reached the same stage of technological and DBS, will arrive with new high-powered satellites, transmit-
economic development, with equal capabilities for transmit- ting new programme channels direct to small roof-top
ting television programmes to the rest of the world and for receivers costing only a few hundred dollars. Those preparing
receiving them. That is clearly an unattainable hypothesis, to finance such enterprises are aware that once the novelty
but the basic inequalities are the root cause of many of the value has faded, their future will depend on the sustained
problems which exist and will continue to exist, because it is quality of their programming, in competition with existing
the ability to influence the hearts and minds of peoples which and other new forms of counter-attraction - including the
television possesses, more powerfully than guns or butter, home video player.
military power or economic aid. In Britain, the commercial company planning to launch a
Against this background, where does the future lie for three-channel DBS service in 1990, is proposing to devote
satellites and broadcasting? First, the existing uses of an one channel to the theme of 'see it now'. By accessing all the
international satellite system such as Intelsat for the transmis- existing and prospective international satellite systems they
sion of television pictures will continue to grow rapidly. This plan to bring to their viewers the strong appeal of live
will be encouraged by the continuing reduction of costs, television, whether it is a news conference in Washington, a
resulting from more powerful satellites in space working with sports event in Australia or a fashion show in Paris.
smaller. cheaper and more flexible earth stations on the This concept poses an enormous challenge, in terms of
ground. This technological trend will in turn enable broadcas- technology, programme rights and presentation techniques -
ters to bring news and other special events from any part of but it is 'state of the art' television, utilizing the satellite
the world to their domestic audiences with the same ease that systems of the world to the full in an exciting and imaginative
is possible in 1986 within the US by using the domestic way which will no doubt be done by other organizations in
satellite system. other parts of the world too. But is it the ultimate use of
Equally important, the reduction in cost will enable those satellite technology for broadcasting? It is certainly difficult
broadcasters in smaller countries, including the developing to conceive an idea which goes beyond the prospect of live
countries, to use the benefits of satellite transmission more events, as they happen anywhere in the world, delivered
and more frequently. direct to the home television screen by satellite via a rooftop
Cost reductions will come as the result of smaller earth dish. But no doubt someone will!
stations, which themselves cost only a fraction of the
investment necessary through the 1970s and most of the 1980s
to build and operate the huge 30-metre Standard A earth
stations. Also, the smaller earth stations can be located at or
close to the broadcaster's premises - subject to national
regulations - thus removing the high cost of long terrestrial
links between remote earth station sites and city centres.
Another economy will come from improved use of the
transmission bandwidth, enabling two or even four television
signals to be carried by a transponder which at present carries
only one signal. Work is going on with analogue and digital
signal compression techniques which suggest that this new
development will be available for widespread use during the
1990s. Indeed, one analogue version was used by the
Japanese broadcasters with reasonable success in 1984 and
another has been pioneered by an Australian broadcaster
using the Pacific Ocean satellite link.
Yet another stimulus to more efficient and cost-effective
satellite transmission will come as the result of competition.
The prospect, as much as the actual emergence of commercial
competitors to Intelsat, will ensure that the organization is
competitive in the highly visible television marketplace. The
arrival of international and domestic fibre optic cable links
will also have its effect on the pricing of competing systems.
All of this should be good news for broadcasters - not only
98
12 THE 'OTHER' APPLICATIONS SATELLITES
Satellites for communications purposes evolved after much importance to the military organizations of the world,
early scientific and technological research. It became clear because they provided images containing data of great
early on that the high vantage point provided by satellites in strategic and military value.
Earth orbit was immensely valuable for other practical The early images from the hand-held Hasselblad cameras
purposes in addition to acting as a communication relay. Of in the American programme revealed amazing detail even at
course, the Earth can be seen very well from space, but the that time. This prompted the scientific and technological
potential value of this new tool was not recognized until after community to develop methods of separating the data
the images taken by the astronauts with automatic photogra- contained within the image and combine it with techniques
phy equipment in the late 1950s and early 1960s were already developed for analyzing aerial photographs and other
examined. remote sensing data. Techniques such as false colour analysis
Two applications of great importance emerged. First, - whereby different parts of the image would be assigned
looking up at satellites in the sky provided a new way to various colours to represent different parameters (vegetation,
locate one's own position on Earth. The precise positioning of environmental pollution, or geological structures, etc.)
satellites in orbit can assist our own navigation on the Earth's became an established tool
surface and within its atmosphere. Second, the high vantage Moreover, by choosing an orbit with a plane close to that of
point of satellites provided a big picture of the planet, the North and South Pole, a 'sun synchronous' orbit could be
allowing Earth observation for both civil and military achieved. In this orbit, the plane is precessed just enough to
purposes. ensure that as the satellite orbits, the Earth's rotation beneath
Historically, it is worth noting that the full significance of it on each subsequent pass is slightly displaced longitudinally,
using space platforms as observation posts in the sky became thus providing total coverage of the world which can be
apparent from some of the early photographs from space. repeated every X days, depending on the choice of orbit.
The early astronauts, including those on the American Orbit inclination could be chosen to assure the frequency of
one-man Mercury mission, the two-man Gemini programme overpassing a particular point on Earth with the same light
and the Russian Soyez manned space flight, collected large angle (synoptic coverage). But if an operational system were
quantities of photographic evidence which, on analysis, required to provide cover at a certain repetition frequency
revealed that the macro-scale effect of looking down from over a given point, then the number of satellites which would
space. from altitudes of several hundred miles, could add need to be placed into such a pattern could also be
greatly to man's knowledge of the Earth. The ability to have a determined. Naturally. if the orbit were chosen so that its
consistent set of data within the large field of view made plane was fully coincident with the North and South Poles,
possible by a single pass of a satellite was of immense then a different pattern would be achieved without the same
importance, because it revealed new views of the Earth that repetitive light conditions. This became appropriate for radar
were not even attainable from high altitude aircraft. satellites which did not need to rely on light illumination.
From this point on, the full potential of Earth observation Although typically, an orbit of a few hundred miles altitude
from space began to be realized. From it spawned the takes llf2 hours, the precise choice of altitude can significantly
immensely important programmes for meteorological vary the general pattern described. Flexibility therefore exists
observation of the environment and natural resources on land to provide global coverage, depending on the choice of
and in the oceans. Clearly, such activities were of immense satellite and the orbit height. However, with the introduction
99
Satellites International
in later years of radar, rather than the early visual and been obtained. Much of this pioneering work was done by the
infra-red bands of the electromagnetic spectrum, light condi- National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration
tions became less important and the pattern of coverage (NOAA) in the US, but many of the meteorological
chosen for a given system varied again. organizations of the world were very much involved in the
It should not be presumed that the only orbit for Earth planning work. Amongst them, the British Meteorological
observation is that in the polar plane. From the very early Office has had a leading role in developing weather models
days, some of the vital meteorological data was obtained from and improving weather forecasting techniques, as well as
cameras and other sensors located on satellites placed into disseminating the data gathered. The USSR also made an
geostationary orbit. The overview of nearly one half of the important contribution to the early collaborative work
globe's surface made possible by the 22,300 mile altitude of between East and West in the meteorological field. At the
the geostationary orbit, enabled daily temporal changes to be present time, Japan, Russia and Europe have all combined to
observed, as well as daily and annual observations of weather provide satellites which furnish operational coverage (as will
conditions and other characteristics. be described later).
For both experimental and operational purposes, a pattern Clearly, military interest is a crucial feature in the field of
developed for satellites to be placed in orbits which varied in Earth observation, since by increasing the power of the
height from a few hundred miles in the polar or near polar optical systems, or the resolution of the radar within the
planes, up to the 22,300-mile high geostationary orbit. But spacecraft, fine details of features on Earth can be obtained
this is not the end of the story. For the last seven or eight which are of critical importance to national security. At the
years the Netherlands, in combination with Indonesia, have early days of its development, the relatively poor resolution
been carefully exploring the possibility of an Earth observa- of 90 metres was possible, but this progressively improved to
tion satellite placed into an orbit of a few hundred miles 10 to 30 metres in recent years. All of this is of great interest
altitude above the plane of the equator. Such an orbit would in terms of strategic value, but it was not nearly sufficient to
provide regular coverage, every 1 V2 hours or so, of territory meet the stringent demands of the military. Therefore,
within typically + or -20 degrees of the equatorial plane. This defence reconnaissance satellites were developed in the early
is an important area of the world. It is also an area heavily 1970s and even then reached a spatial resolution capability of
covered by cloud (in the cases of land masses with tropical a fraction of one metre.
forests) although in other cases there are vast arid areas and The military reconnaissance satellites (as they were called)
here, clear atmospheric conditions exist. In general, however, were of dramatic value. It was important that these satellites
the Tropical Equatorial Resources Satellite (TERS) may add achieve the highest resolution possible. Techniques began to
yet a further dimension to the general observation of the be developed to ensure that image quality should not be lost
world beneath. in the electronic transmission of data down from orbit via the
What of the sensors? When one takes into account the fact telemetry links to the ground.
that the first sensors were simple hand-held cameras, it can be In the early operational Russian and American satellites,
seen how far this technique has advanced. Today's devices the film which was exposed through the high quality optical
range from multi-spectral scanners which can choose fre- systems was contained in a capsule. This was separated from
quency bands in the visible, the near infra-red and the far the main spacecraft after some days in orbit (typically seven).
infra-red spectrum (the latter providing opportunities for Then, small retro-rockets fired in the capsule, which
daylight and nighttime visibility of the Earth below). decreased its velocity, lowered its orbit, and made re-entry
However, these frequencies do not penetrate cloud and are possible. The capsules were then recovered on the ground (or
therefore limited in terms of observing characteristics snatched during parachute descent in the case of the US) thus
beneath cloud free zones. Even so, most of the demonstrated ensuring that the fine grain resolution of the film was not
capability for potential operational use so far has arisen from down-graded. The recovery of such capsules has been
the clever analysis of data obtained from these sensors during augmented in recent years by the electronic transmission of
gaps in the cloud. data, which can now be achieved at extremely high quality.
Of equal importance already, but of potentially greater All in all, it can be seen that the combined military and civil
importance in the future, are satellites that use radar interest in the developments of Earth observation systems has
techniques. Radar penetrates cloud and provides guaranteed been of major importance.
coverage of the land or sea in any weather condition. At this Finally a word on navigational satellites. In the 1960s the
time, however, the techniques for obtaining data from such US Navy required a system to assist nuclear powered
radar sensors are less advanced than the multi-spectral submarines to identify where they were as precisely as
sensors in the visible and infra-red fields. But rapid advances possible, so that they could target their nuclear ballistic
are being made and in the next five to ten years advanced missiles accurately. As a result, the Transit satellite system
radar systems will be operational. There is no doubt that in was devised. The Transit system established a pattern of
the long-term, radar type sensors will provide the mainstay of satellites in low polar orbits to transmit data which, on
guaranteed operational coverage. However, the technology analysis from the ground, permitted high positional accuracy
will undoubtedly be augmented by a variety of other sensors, of the receiving stations' location to be determined. As will be
since it is an apparent fact of technological life that seldom seen later, the quality of the information, even in the early
does one technique totally displace another, but rather years, was extraordinarily good, and the cost of the ground
augments capability. equipment remarkably low compared to what might be
A few general words on the meteorological scene: as thought. Once the system was established, it was recognized
already noted, the meteorologists were the first to benefit that this achievement had vital civil applications, particularly
from operational Earth observation systems. In the early to shipping. It was also immensely important for terrestrial
1960s the cameras and other sensors which had been placed in and aircraft location.
experimental satellites, encouraged the meteorological The US agreed that civil users would be entitled to use the
authorities of the world to stimulate the development of ground stations that received the data from the satellite, and
special projects and coordinate their programmes in such a be applicable for civil oriented purposes. Thus, the Transit
way that for some years now integrated global coverage has navigational system was extended for use throughout the
100
The 'Other' Applications Satellites
world by ships and other users enabling them to locate their two pre-operational satellites, Meteosat 1 and 2, the first of
positions with considerable accuracy. which was launched in 1977. These two satellites provide
Today. Transit is being replaced by the Global Positioning excellent information, principally by a radiometer which
System (GPS) of the US Navstar satellite programme. With provides a visible wavelength resolution of 2.5 kilometres and
GPS in its highest capability read-out mode, an accuracy of 16 infra-red resolution of 5 kilometres. The radiometers operate
metres in each horizontal plane, and also in the vertical plane, in invisible, infra-red and water vapour parts of the spectrum.
can be established against precise world coordinates. It serves Eumetsat ordered three operational Meteosats to be
to show that already, in the last two decades, satellites have launched by Ariane in 1987, 1988 and 1990. Intermediate
been used to replace the stars. Yet their system has become capability to assist the world's operational system will use a
the most precise method known to mankind to locate himself Meteosat engineering model P2 for launch by the Ariane 4
on or above the surface of our globe. vehicle to replace the gaps left by the GOES failure (see
below).
Meteosat varies in fundamental details to the TIROS-N
EARTH OBSERVATION SATELLITES system described above, in that it is in the geostationary orbit
and located on the Greenwich Meridian at zero degrees. It
Meteorological thus provides major coverage of the globe. It is a spin-
stabilized satellite of a mass at launch of 700 kilogrammes and
As explained in the introductory remarks above, within the a design life of three years and should still have, at the end of
earth observation category of spacecraft the first operational life, an electrical power of 0.2 kilowatts. The budget cost of
systems were those that provided information on meteorolo- the three operational Meteosats (plus parts for a spare) in
gical conditions. The range of sensors has expanded consider- 1984 money was $180 million dollars.
ably from the early days and they now provide wide ranging
data for research into meteorological activities as well as the GOES
provision of data for forecasting. In order to indicate the In a similar orbit to Meteosat are the Geostationary Oper-
nature of the satellites now used globally, various current ational Environmental Satellites (GOES). operated by the
operational satellite systems will be described, since an NOAA in conjunction with the TIROS-N craft in the polar
international range of spacecraft now exists for this important orbit. The operational system comprised three satellites, but
activity. the series has been plagued by sensors which have failed on
various occasions: GOES 4 in November 1982 and GOES 5 in
NOAA July 1984. The GOES 1 is still operational but providing only
For many years the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric visible wavelength cover and so GOES 1, together with
Administration (NOAA) has been responsible for the provi- GOES 6, 7 and 8 are the only satellites currently available.
sion of weather services. It inherited NASA's early work in The payload comprises a visible and infra-red spinscan
experimental satellites and now a variety of satellites are in radiometer and atmospheric sounders (VAS). The satellites
place. Essentially the operational network comprises two are spin-stabilized. It has a 0.3 kilowatt end-of-life power
craft on intersecting orbits. The payloads comprise an from an initial launch weight of 840 kilogrammes and a design
advanced high resolution radiometer and the TIROS oper- life of five years.
ational vertical sounder, solar backscatter ultra-violet spectral
radiometer. In addition, later spacecraft such as NOAA 9 and GMS-3
10 carry equipment for the Earth Radiation Budget Experi- The Japanese have made a contribution of importance to this
ment (ERBE) operating in conjunction with the Earth category. GMS-3 (also known as Himawari 3) is the third in
Radiation Budget Satellite (ERBS) which was deployed by the Japanese series of geostationary meteorological satellites.
the shuttle. From NOAA 8 onwards, the satellites also carry a The first GMS was brought out of retirement in 1984 when its
406 MHz Sarsat search-and-rescue transponder for locating replacement, GMS-2, suffered a scanning mirror malfunc-
and relaying ship and aircraft distress beacons. tion. GMS was moved back to its parking place at 160 degrees
The orbit of the Television/Infra-red Observation Satellite east after the launch of GMS-3 in August 1984. The payload
(TIROS-N) is 870 kilometres high and sun-synchronous. The has a visible infra-red spin scan radiometer and the satellites
inclination is 98.86 degrees to the equatorial plane. (The are owned by NASDA (the Japanese national space agency).
mechanics of this has been described above.) The satellites They are established in the geostationary orbit and are
are stabilized in three axes and have an end-of-life electrical spin-stabilized with an end-of-life power of three kilowatts
power generation capability of 0.45 kilowatts. The launch against a weight at launch of 680 kilogrammes. They have a
weight was 1. 712 kilogrammes and the cost, for example, of design life of five years. The radiometer provides 1.25
NOAA 9, was $43.5 million. kilometre, visible resolution and five kilometre infra-red
The high resolution radiometer operates at visible near resolution. GMS-3 also carries a solar particle monitor.
infra-red and far infra-red wavelengths to measure surface Together. these satellites are valuable in assisting the world
temperatures, cloud cover and vegetation. The vertical community in this import aspect of meteorology.
sounder system comprises infra-red, microwave and stratos-
pheric sounders, together producing a vertical temperature Earth and Ocean Observation
profile. The solar backscatter radiometer determines ozone
distribution in the atmosphere. The ERBE equipment Important as the meteorological satellites have become, the
comprises a medium to wide field-of-view non-scanning mainstream development of Earth observation now and in
radiometer and a narrow angle scanning radiometer. the future will be to observe land and sea mass·es with
increasing detail of spectral and spatial resolutions.
Meteosat The presence of tools such as Earth observation from
Europe has estabished an international meteorological orga- satellites is of such growing strength, that it is likely to have
nization Eumetsat, to operate the Meteosat geostationary an immensely beneficial impact on our communities in the
weather satellites. The European Space Agency (ESA) built future - both to developed and developing societies. The
101
Satellites International
macroscale of observation and its cost effectiveness ERS-1 satellite. and also by Japan, with its MOS I satellite,
(described already in the general introduction), manifests and by Canada, which is initiating the development of
itself extremely well when one looks to the problems of the Radarsat to be launched early in the next decade. Indeed,
under-developed parts of the world where important adv- within the next ten years, there will be many sources of data
ances need to be made in agriculture, irrigation and water available from operating satellites, each with a variety of
management, land utilization, marine management and so sensors that in combination cover a full spectrum from simple
on. The list of potential users of data derived from such visible cover to complex radar systems.
satellite observation is impressive, it ranges from the obvious It is now appropriate to describe in more detail some of the
to the less obvious applications such as archeology, sociology, key satellites which are indicative of the Earth observation
urban planning and others. scene. Landsat (which was originally called the 'Earth
The benefit of Earth observation should always be mea- Resource Technology Satellite· in the NASA programme)
sured in the integrated use of the spacecraft; any one sector has launched five models. Currently two Landsats are
alone is unlikely to support and justify the major research and operational, Landsat 4 and 5. Landsat 4 has lost two of its
development costs associated with the spacecraft and its four solar panel outputs and the X-band transmitter for its
implementaiton into an operational system. Indeed, until thematic mapper has failed. However, in total, the Landsat
recently, the world did not have an operational system series has been of exceptionally high importance in the
because the US Landsat satellites, important as they were, development of the whole technique of Earth observation.
constituted a pre-operational system. The commercialization The payload ot the current Landsats compnses a multi-
of EOSA T (which is a private company combining a leading spectral scanner and a thematic mapper; whereas the spatial
aerospace and photographic organization in the US), and the resolution (in other words the size of the picture element) was
immensely successful launch in the beginning of 1986 of the 90 metres in the early Landsat of the 1970s, currently the
French SPOT system, designed for operational use, now gives thematic mapper gives a spatial resolution of 30 metres. They
the guaranteed regular coverage of an operational service. have (until commercialization) been operated by NOAA,
The application of data derived from such spacecraft falls who took over from NASA. Now the private organization
into two distinct categories - one which could be called EOSAT, which is a joint venture between Hughes and RCA,
humanitarian use, the other, commercial use. 'Humanitarian is organizing to take over the programme. Two further
use' covers such aspects as information on the location of Landsats in 1988 and 1991 are tentatively scheduled to be
icebergs, the sea's state, conditions of ice flows, levels of launched within the operational period of the switch from
pollution, forest fires and so on. The commercial use comes public sector ownership to privatization. The orbit in which
particularly from locating mineral deposits, monitoring the Landsat has been placed is sun-synchronous, 705 kilometres
status and extent of agricultural crop growth, water manage- high at a 98 degree angle to the equator, which leads to a
ment and so on. It is important to note that the provision of 16-day repeat cycle (in terms of the precise synoptic coverage
data in the humanitarian category (as with meteorological with the same sunlight levels and angles, etc.). Landsat 4 was
data) represents information on which the world is becoming launched in July 1982 by the expendable US Delta rocket and
increasingly reliant. These different services assist security Landsat was launched in March 1984, also by a Delta. Earth
and generally improve the environment. There will, there- observation satellites require high precision in pointing and
fore, always be the need for substantial funds to be made therefore use three-axis stabilization. The electrical power
available either by individual governments or through for- generation at the end of life is 0.8 kilowatts and the weight at
mally constituted international organizations (such as the launch was 1,940 kilogrammes. The nominal design life is
UN) in order for this dissemination of data to continue. The three years.
same does not apply to commercial data. In the Western The multi-spectral scanner operates in four visible and
world we have already reached the point where the on-going infra-red spectral bands. The thematic mapper operates in
provision of this data is going to be on a commercial basis. seven narrower bands from blue/green to thermal infra-red
There have, of course, been problems along the way in with a 30-metre resolution. Image transmission is either direct
achieving even this early commercial status. For example, an or via NASA's Tracking and Data Relay Satellite (TDRS);
initiative was taken by the German manufacturer, MBB, in Landsat makes use of the new NA VST AR global positioning
conjunction with an American bank, to operate the SPAS system for its knowledge of its precise three-axis coordinates
observation pallette flown out of the shuttle. Unfortunately it at any one time.
appeared that the legal conditions imposed via NASA In 1978 an experimental radar satellite called Seasat was
regarding the dissemination of data so obtained, were launched and it had a synthetic aperture radar payload.
unacceptable to the commerical entrepreneurs who withdrew Seasat provided excellent images with resolution of approx-
from this project. There are many hurdles to be overcome, imately 50 metres. It also had an ability to determine wave
therefore, to ensure that the business environment is satisfac- height to an accuracy of one metre or better. The satellite
tory with regard to the protection of data. If a private lasted one hundred days before it failed but during that time it
organization is investing its own money to acquire that data produced an enormous quantity of very important and
there will undoubtedly be continuing legislative and regula- reassuring data on the practicality and importance of develop-
tory battles in the future as the world community begins to ing radar satellites for the future.
use, ever more extensively, such information. One of the most significant achievements for observation
There is also now a proliferation of countries who are satellites in the visible and infra-red part of the spectrum has
building satellites to obtain data regarding the Earth's been the successful launch in 1986 of the French SPOT
environment beneath. The US, USSR and France have satellite (Satellite Probatoire d'Observation de Ia Terre),
already been mentioned but already these countries have which is owned by CNES of France. SPOT 2 is scheduled for
been joined by China (who has now launched and recovered launch in 1988.
elements from seven Earth observation satellites), India and Authorization has now been granted by the French
the UK (through the small and experimental Surrey Uni- government for two further SPOTs to be developed and
versity satellites, UOSAT 1 and 2). These countries are being launched in later years. Compared with Landsat's 30-metre
joined by Europe, with the important development of the resolution thematic mapper, SPOT offers a 20-metre resolu-
102
The 'Other' Applications Satellites
tion colour image and panchromatic resolution, even better, synchronous near-polar orbit 780 kilometres high with a
at 10 metres. It also has two high resolution Vidacom cameras three-day repeat cycle and is primely designed for ocean
which make stereoscopic imaging possible. It also uses surveillance. It is planned as the forerunner for a series of
mirrors for precision beam steering. As a result it can be operational spacecraft to be launched in the 1990s, although it
programmed to acquire an image of a particular area on may well be that the Polar Platform, which is gaining
successive cycles. This provides an immensely important increasing interest by Europe and the UK in particular, as a
advantage over a fixed beam system, in that it can provide a major part of the European contribution to the Columbus
more cost effective cover of the world beneath. The high element of the International US Space Station, may incorpo-
resolution multi-spectral sensors are already producing excel- rate sensors and missions which may lead to later develop-
lent results on a satellite which has a mass at launch of I, 750 ment of the ERS-1 unmanned satellite.
kilogrammes and a power at the start of life of 1.2 kilowatts: it The primary role of the ERS-1 will be to provide global
also has three-axis attitude stabilization and a minimum wind and wave information to users within three hours
design life of two years. maximum of overpass but the ERS-1 will also provide land
The interesting feature of the SPOT system is that the observation by synthetic aperture radar and generally assist in
French government has created a special marketing organiza- the development of algorithms and techniques for an oper-
tion called SPOT Image, which has now successfully signed ational system. ERS-1 is due to be launched by Ariane in
up franchises in many of the countries of the world that can 1989; it will have three-axis 'tabilization to high accuracy with
benefit from SPOT data. SPOT Image is based in Toulouse a power of 2.6 kilowatts (necessary for the power-demanding
and the data is already being made commercially available. role of the radar) and a designed launch weight of 2,160
SPOT could also serve as the basis of a proposed Samso kilogrammes. It has a two-year minimum operational life and
military reconnaissance satellite. This is likely to be a a projected cost of $400 million. It is interesting that ERS-1
Franco-German joint venture although details are still being uses the SPOT spacecraft bus, even though the sensors are
finalized. Without question, however, the SPOT system has quite different. The SAR sensor will operate in three modes:
enormously stimulated the confidence of the world user- image, wind scatterometer and wave. The radar-altimeter will
community that a monopoly position will not be maintained measure wave height, wind speed, ice type topography and
by the US. Indeed there will be multiple sources of data boundaries and will be calibrated by retro-reflector from
available in later years for those who are becoming ground ranging stations. The Along-Track Sensor is a three
increasingly dependent on such data. wavelength infra-red radiometer able to measure sea surface
Further development at this time is under way with the and cloud top temperatures. When one has combined with
MOS-1, Japan's experimental Marine Observation Satellite. this the microwave sounder, which is able to measure total
This is planned as the forerunner for an operational system in atmospheric water vapour content and rainfall, then it can be
the 1990s. MOS-1 will concentrate on observing the sea seen that the data which can be available from ERS-1 is of
surface and the atmosphere but will also examine the great importance and represents a powerful combined instru-
techniques required for land observation. Japan plans an mentation system.
Earth resources satellite JERS-1 to be launched around 1990. Radarsat is due to launch in the early 1990s and has
MOS-1 will also carry an experimental data collection system characteristics rather similar in many ways to ERS-1 and is a
transponder, as a forerunner of the TDRS type tracking and project involving extensive collaboration also between the US
data relay satellite. and the UK.
MOS-1 has a payload comprising a multi-spectral, electro- The Chinese Earth observation programme clearly has
nic self-scanning radiometer, a visible and thermal infra-red major military implications, since the capsules which have
radiometer and a microwave scanning radiometer. It is being been re-entered from space follow the similar technique to
developed by NASDA and it will be launched in a sun- that successfully operated by the US for many years- namely,
synchronous orbit. The inclination of the orbit is at 99.1 the recovery of film maintaining the high resolution capability
degree to the equator and the altitude at 909 kilometres, which can be lost by electronic transmission from orbit to
which means it provides a 17-day repeat cycle for the same Earth.
conditions for a given point on Earth. The satellite will be The Indian programme similarly is ambitious and looks to
three-axis stabilized with a launch weight of 750 kilogrammes provide enhanced Earth observation capability which will be
and a design life of two years. A multi-spectral radiometer of considerable importance to the Indian space programme.
will determine the sea surface colour with spatial resolution of TERS is a potential venture between Indonesia and the
50 metres. Visible and thermal radiometers will measure sea Netherlands initially, but with the opportunity to involve a
surface temperatures and the microwave radiometer will wider number of countries in the equatorial band as joint
measure atmospheric water vapour content. sponsors and users of the system.
Europe is becoming increasingly active in the field of Earth Finally, an elaboration on a comment made above regard-
observation and, in the last few years, the European Space ing the polar platform work being initiated in the UK as a
Agency has taken a major decision to develop the ERS 1 potential part of the space station. Importance is attached to
advanced Earth resource satellite. The Marconi Company the wide variety of instrumentation associated with remote
(UK) has the lead in the industrial team developing the sensing and which could be carried on the platform. The
payload which is a C-band synthetic aperture active micro- phase-B activity which defines more precisely the nature and
wave instrument. It also will carry a radar altimeter capable the role of the space station is still underway at the time of
of determining sea surface conditions and wave height on a writing this book and therefore no final information can be
relativity basis to an accuracy of ten centimetres. It has a given, but the point is made here that the remote sensing
novel Along-Track Scanning Radiometer initiated by the utilization is an extremely important part of the space station
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory of the SERC in Britain and programme as foreseen at this time.
also has a microwave sounder. The satellite is being
developed within the framework of the European Space MILITARY RECONNAISSANCE
Agency's programme. It will be Europe's first Earth
resources satellite, and will be established in a sun- No attempt is made in this section to go into the same detail
103
Satellites International
as that covered in the essentially civil programmes above, for bridges, or for urban or rural redevelopment. Surveying
the obvious reason that there is a very high security activities also relate to networks across countries. They are
implication in the provision and operation of such military also concerned with massive pipelines for the transportation
systems. These reputedly can give spatial resolution to the of oil and natural gas in many different parts of the world.
order of one foot or better, which clearly provides a vast So far, with comparatively few exceptions, the implications
quantity of data of extremely high importance in strategic and of satellite navigational systems have been insignificant to this
tactical military operations. Not surprisingly, the advanced sector of the community. Not necessarily so in the future.
work of the US and the USSR in the satellites which have Essentially, a survey team has a fundamental requirement to
been launched operationally since the early 1970s is highly establish the relationship of all of the appropriate features of
confidential, but the principles of operation are clearly similar either natural terrain or an artificial structure, to a datum
to those which have been mentioned above on the civil point on Earth. Generally this starts with determining a fixed
systems. Operationally, a radar system particularly for reference point in relation to the macrostructure of the
marine observation would be expected to have accompanying country, region or town, then moving from that point to
high power level requirements which, it is reported, has led to determine, by use of theodilites, etc., the relative position of
the USSR satellites used for marine observation being each continuing datum point. The act of transferring the
equipped with small nuclear reactors in order to generate reference points to the next in sequence is a time-consuming
these high levels of power. process when multiplied by large numbers of functions which
Generally speaking, the inclusion of the military recon- clearly a district survey, for example, demands. From that
naissance satellites must be seen as a vital element within the point onwards, the collation of measured points into a pattern
military thinking and operational capability of the Eastern and the transformation of these data into appropriate formats
and Western blocs and provides now (and indeed has done for use by construction engineers is also a complex and
for many years) an opportunity to observe with precision expensive process. Some of these features have been referred
what is happening in other areas of the world not easily to in relation to Earth observation techniques, but the central
monitored by aircraft or other means. There are many who principle of the process is the precise three-dimensional
consider that the Open Skies policy, initiated over ten years determination of position. This is precisely what navigational
ago, which ensures that agreements can be easily monitored satellites permit to be accomplished by means that will
by the use of space systems, is a major contributor to become progressively inexpensive and increasingly accurate.
continuing world peace on a global scale and it can be seen, A point will be reached in the next few years where a more
therefore, that the technology applications in the military continuous, semi-automatic or even automatic process may
reconnaissance field are indeed most important. well be achieved by the use of satellites, whereby a measuring
point can be surveyed and the data obtained by reference to
the advanced capabilities of future navigational satellite
NAVIGATION systems. Without proceeding further with this train of
thought at present, so far as the precise nature of the system is
In the early 1960s, the US Navy called for the development of concerned, it can clearly be seen that the advent of improved
a satellite system named Transit which consisted of a series of navigational satellite systems could have immense bearing on
satellites orbiting in relatively low polar orbits around the the industrial implications and commercial opportunities in
world and continously transmitting signals which could be the future regarding non-aerospace activities such as the
picked up by antennas located on nuclear-powered sub- whole surveying field.
marines. In summary, the field of navigational satellites has fewer
By means of relatively straightforward triangulation sub-divisions than in communications systems, yet the
techniques, the crew could determine with considerable financial implications are really very interesting. The range of
accuracy the location of the ship. A few years later it was possible operations are very broad. We have many primary
announced that such a system would be made avilable for use and secondary applications to watch as the use of satellites for
by the world merchant shipping industry. Since that time navigational purposes expands in the 1990s.
many thousands of ships of all sizes have been equipped with
on-board, omni-directional terminals to permit such posi-
tional measurements to be established. In addition to
shipping, many offshore oil installations have made use of the
service. Indeed, by the early 1980s, the situation had been
reached whereby the use of such a satellite terminal permitted
the user to determine where he was on the surface of the
world with greater accuracy and repeatability than any other
system in use by man. Navigational systems by satellite have
progressed far.
A new US global system of 18 orbiting satellites called
Navstar now provides a much more enhanced capability than
the earlier Transit systems. It brings with it many interesting
implications: clearly one of these is that ships and aircraft can
benefit from the advent of such satellite navigational and
positioning data.
However, other new operations will become possible. One
of these is the technique of surveying. The need for surveys in
the construction industry and many service industries is
worldwide. Surveys are needed to identify precisely the
nature of terrain, and as far as possible the geological
composition of the land for the purpose of creating dams or
104
13 SATELLITES FOR THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
In the last 25 years of satellite applications, some remarkable achievements have been attained.
International telecommunications have increased more than one hundred times in volume,
international television has not only become possible, but routine. Close to half the world's
population will witness the 1988 Summer Olympics live via Intelsat. We now expect to see a global
weather map on our evening news and a satellite-based forecast of the weather for a week ahead.
Communications via satellite to ships at sea, to jet aircraft in the skies and to vehicles on the
ground are already possible. Also well-established are satellite systems for Earth resource sensing,
navigation, geodetic measurements; and in the military sector, photo reconnaissance and
electronic surveillance have been operational for some time. Yet these activities would have been
science fiction only a quarter of a century ago. But time does not stand still, and the next quarter
century will likely bring even more changes and innovations. The list of possibilities is long and
impressive: solar power systems in space, satellite relays to personal hand-held communicators,
satellite clusters to cram more equipment into geosynchronous (Clarke) orbit, intersatellite relays
and much more that will be described in the following section. One thing is clear- the sky is no
longer the limit.
COMMUNICATION SATELLITES
105
Satellites International
other as the multiple satellites 'rotated' around a single Because of the likely future requirements for geosynchro-
nodal point on the geosynchronous orbital arc. The satellite nous coverage, with immediate update on weather conditions
clusters sometimes are referred to as being deployed into and the difficulty of doing it from the 'saturated' Clarke orbit,
'Halo orbits'. new concepts (such as tethered satellites or meteorological
The design of communications satellites of the 21st century satellites maintained in 'fixed point low-earth' orbit through
will be quite different. Phased-array antennas may likely be ground-based power sources) could also be explored. The
used to create very high-powered beams with low sidelobes. first applications of such technologies will, however, more
This would allow the possibility of many-fold frequency likely come in the communication satellite field.
reuses. It is also likely that new power sources and high
efficiency ion engines would be developed for deployment of
satellites from low-Earth orbit to Clarke orbit and to maintain EARTH RESOURCES SENSING SATELLITES
structures in space for multi-year lifetimes.
Because satellites in geosynchronous orbit will be long- Earth resource sensing satellites will likely be driven by
lived and have changing operational missions, it is likely that several factors. First, it is likely that ocean sensing will
there will be robotic or service modules that will be available increase in economic and scientific importance in the 21st
to move around the geosynchronous orbit to perform repairs, century. Greater emphasis will likely be placed on sensing not
as well as maintenance, supply and mission retrofits. There only the Earth's surface and the ocean's surface, but also we
will also likely be a service 'tug' operating from low-earth may well see the use of side-looking radar and other
orbit to geosynchronous orbit and back, largely to support the techniques to obtain submarine data and information, parti-
upgrades and maintenance of satellites in Clarke orbit as cularly for continental shelf areas.
performed by the service module. Secondly, it is likely that much higher resolution (say 1 sq.
Although there are some who have suggested that optical metre per pixel) may evolve as fifth and sixth-generation
fibre cables will make satellites obsolete, this seems unlikely. computers prove capable of processing the tremendously high
The network flexibility of satellites can never be matched by data levels these high-resolution Earth resource satellites will
optical fibres. Glass is cheap, but air and vacuum are cheaper. produce. The high data rates required in order to relay earth
Multinational corporations will likely use satellites to create resource sensing data from space to Earth will, in fact,
intracorporate digital networks, including, data, electronic tremendously increase by a factor of more than one hundred
mail, facsimile, telephony, audio-conferencing, and video- times- maybe even a thousand. This will require allocation of
conferencing. Equally important will be the broadband much broader bands of radio frequencies to handle such wide
applications that will include not only television, but also band data relays. The high resolution images produced by
high-definition television, three-dimensional television, and multi-spectral sensors and cameras will also likely create
perhaps other new communication services not yet invented increased controversy about the proper use of such data.
or conceived. There are already concerns with resolution of only 40-metre
By the middle of the 21st century, virtually all countries square per pixel in the SPOT satellites. There remains
(developed and developing) will be using the much higher concern that this information could be misused, not only for
efficiency digital modulation techniques for virtually all their industrial espionage purposes, but also for military recon-
telecommunications and broadcast requirements. The effi- naissance and surveillance purposes as well.
ciencies that the digital modulation techniques bring through
voice encoding and video-compression will help produce
dramatic new economies. Digital techniques, plus satellite NEW SATELLITE AND NEW SERVICE CONCEPTS
technology breakthroughs, should help bring the price of
telecommunication services down to less than 10 percent of The evolution of communication satellites, weather satellites,
their current levels. New high-value communication services, Earth resource and reconnaissance satellites can be predicted
(such as three-dimensional television, and multiple-rastered with an apparent high degree of reliability. But it is much
television) would probably not become economic without more difficult is to envision the totally unknown and the
such dramatic breakthroughs in new satellite technology, and undiscovered. Certainly man is just beginning to understand
in digital communications techniques. the possible uses of our planet. It would seem likely that we
will see in the 21st century the design, launch and operation
of satellites to monitor all of the important environmental
METEOROLOGICAL SA TEL LITES conditions over the entire planet. Such a system could help to
save our planet from the ravages of industrial pollution. This
Meteorological satellites, like communications satellites, will system could monitor acid rain, oil spills, the changes of the
also radically change by the 21st century. In large measure, albedo of the ice caps in the polar regions, depletion of the
this may be driven by complex new computer models that will ozone layer, builds up of sulphur dioxide and carbon dioxide,
allow accurate weather forecasting on a global basis for dessertification, deforestation, damage to the mountainous
extended periods of weeks at a time. These complex highlands areas, rates of urbanization, and changes in the
computer models will demand far more information on total amount of land that is in vegetation. Such an environ-
meteorological conditions. Masses of information, in the mental satellite system would be technically possible by the
form of space imaging data, will be required with frequent 21st century and may also prove economically essential, as
updates. This suggests either more satellites of greater suggested by the devastation of the world's great forests in the
sophistication in low-Earth orbit or, perhaps more likely, the 1980s.
development of meteorological satellites that can operate in Another use of satellites also looms over the horizon - the
geosynchronous orbit but with sufficient resolution and so-called Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI). This complex
accuracy in their sensing devices to produce highly precise defense system, sometimes known as 'Star Wars', would
information. This will allow observation of weather condi- require the development of a vast array of technology in the
tions on a micro-level, as well as on a macro basis, as the various fields of satellite communications, particle beam
needs of the computer model and changing weather dictates. weaponry, computerized targetting and control, and many
106
Satellites for the Twenty-First Century
other areas. If it goes ahead, this multi-billion dollar necessary and appropriate. The future of military uses of
expenditure would be a great technological gamble that may space and, in particular, of the Strategic Defense Initiative of
never succeed, but undoubtedly would serve as a great source the US, remains both a puzzle and a concern to those engaged
of new science and technology. in the peaceful uses of outer space. But continued prolifera-
Another possibility is the deployment of equipment in tion and competitive deployment of satellite systems may
space to allow low-cost but effective radio broadcasts to become overly wasteful of the limited radio frequency
hand-held receivers. Depending on the frequency, it might be resource of the geosynchronous orbital arc. Accordingly,
possible to broadcast from space via such a simple design as a consolidated institutional solutions, such as Intelsat, Inmar-
couple of wires 5 to 10 kilometres long. These wires could act sat, and Intersputnik, may be found to be the best solution for
as the antenna system. delivery of at least some international and domestic space
It has even been suggested that a form of 'space elevator' services to Earth. Other systems, however, will likely
could be created. This would require a giant satellite in continue as private competitive ventures. One thing is clear,
Clarke orbit to lower a tapered cable to the earth's surface, the 21st century stands filled with excitement, challenge and a
and then be anchored there. Such a space elevator would great deal of hope!
allow equipment to be raised and lowered along the cable into
geosynchronous orbit. This system, if it ever should become
feasible, would lower the cost of launching by more than 100
times.
We can also imagine the development of cost-effective
phased-array antennas that can be built right into the roofs of
houses and buildings and could conform to almost any
surface, including the roof of a car, truck, aeroplane or ship.
Mobile communications and position locating via satellite
could thus be an important part of the story.
Moving a little closer to the present, Intelsat has been
wrestling with the subject of how to provide low-cost and
affordable communications to rural and remote locations.
Recently, a manufacturer in Silicon Valley has offered to test
a low-rate encoding voice-message service that will allow
communications, or at least a voice-message link, to be
established to earth stations for less than $10,000. The
combination of such innovative microterminals, low-rate
encoding, and rural communications seem made for each
other. But in time, we may find unexpected applications
beyond rural communications, such as to support oil drilling
operations, geological surveys, weather forecasting, environ-
mental monitoring, etc. Such applications may be unexpected
beneficiaries of new rural communications technologies and
the innovative new uses that they make possible.
It is hard not to look to the future with some enthusiasm,
not to be awed with some sense of wonder at how truly
remarkable our new technologies are and what tremendous
potential they offer for education, for health, for business, for
scientific exploration and humanitarian purposes. These
technologies are also serving to allow our fragile world to
grow more closely together to make our economies more
inter-related and to share our breakthroughs and innovative
uses with one another.
This is not to suggest, however, that the future is
straightforward and that progress will come easily and
without some considerable opportunity for problems and
rancour to occur. International and political problems will
likely serve as larger obstacles to success than technological
difficulties. Despite these potential problems we will still see
in the 21st century a great diversity of applications, including
global direct broadcast satellite, sophisticated Earth resource
and environmental sensing satellites, satellite clusters and
other new applications. The institutional framework within
which international and national satellite services are pro-
vided has grown more complex and challenging from an
institutional policy and even an economic standpoint.
We have seen the proliferation of communications satel-
lites, to the extent that there are now more than 150 such satel-
lites in Clark orbit, with prospects of more than 300 to be
launched by the start of the 21st century. Diversification,
specialization and forward-looking developments in the
communication and application satellite field has been
107
SECTION II
1. SATELLITE MANUFACTURERS AND SYSTEMS
GENERAL
This section lists the major statellite manufacturers with weight, the satellite has to guarantee service for a certain time
information on their spacecraft families and systems. For and maintain its orbital position.
addresses, see the A-Z of countries {Chapter 7). The platform of a communications satellite includes:
Satellite construction has become more complicated over • the energy pack which collects solar energy by cells on the
the years due to technological innovations and a tendency outside of the satellite, or on fixed panels;
towards specialisation. As a result, the manufacturers work- • the power generation and distribution system which
ing directly on one satellite can number six or seven, from as. converts the solar energy into electrical power and
many countries. Some operators deliberately seek an interna- distributes this power to other components of the satellite,
tional balance for political reasons. In recent years, the US including the on-board batteries;
manufacturers' share of the market has been challenged by • the stabilisation subsystem which ensures that the satellite
European companies, while in the late 1980s the Japanese remains in a fixed position relative to its orbit and that the
may be more active. antennas remain pointed at the service area of the system;
Usually one company, the prime contractor, is responsible • the thrust subsystem which is responsible for keeping the
for the time schedule and cost control of each project. The satellite in the correct orbital position: it consists of
prime contractor then subcontracts manufacturers for the on-board propulsion jets and their fuel supplies;
construction of specific parts of the satellite system. For • the temperature control system which radiates the excess
example, Intelsat ordered its VI series of satellites from heat produced by the payload to the exterior of the
Hughes Aircraft of the US. Sub-contracts went to British spacecraft.
Aerospace (UK) , NEC (Japan), Selenia Spazio (Italy), Spar There are two basic stabilisation concepts used in current
Aerospace Ltd/Comdev (Canada) , MBB (Germany FR), satellite platform design: spin stabilised and three-axis stabil-
Thomson-CSF (France) and AEG Telefunken (Germany ised.
FR). The five satellites in this Intelsat-VI series (more may be Spin stabilised platforms rotate at a speed of 60 revolutions
commissioned later) constitute the largest and most valuable per minute around an axis and give the satellite gyroscopic
contract for communications satellites. stability around that axis. The solar cells are fixed to the
outside of the spacecraft which is typically cylindrical.
INTELSAT- VI The three-axis technology gives the satellite stability by
using small jets along each axis of its body. Inside the
Prime contractor Hughes Aircraft Company satellite, momentum wheels provide stability in the satellite's
position towards the Earth .
Subcontractors: Telemetry and command antennas
(Selenia)
C-band multiple beam antennas (British
A erospace)
K-band spot beam antenna (British
Aerospace)
Earth coverage antennas (Selenia)
Communications equipment:
C-band receivers (Thomson-CSF
and Spar)
K-band receivers (Thomson-CSF
and NEC)
Travelling wave tube amplifiers (Thom-
son CSF)
Thermal radiator {MBB)
Spinning structure (British Aerospace)
Digital electronics {Spar)
Solar cell arrays (MBB)
Forward panel solar cells {AEG Tele-
funken)
111
Satellites International
Aerospatiale (France)
The payload of a satellite includes: The Space and Communications Division of British Aeros-
• the antennas which receive the signals from Earth and pace (UK) (BAe) is a manufacturer and designer of satellites
retransmit them; the shape of an antenna is determined by for telecommunications, direct broadcast television and
the geographical area to be served, together with the specialised business services. It has been the prime contractor
stength of the signal; for several major projects including OTS and ECS (and UK
• the transponders, which change the frequency of the military satellites). It has developed Olympus, which is part
received signals, amplify them and retransmit them back to of the advanced programme of the ESA and will be launched
Earth; in 1987/8 to provide advanced communication and DBS
• the telemetry, tracking and command system (TT&C) television services. BAe has also developed the Eurostar
which receives commands from Earth and transmits Platform for DBS and has proposed its use for a UK DBS
information about the satellite back to the command system (initially in 1984, as Unisat). BAe is also the prime
centre. contractor for the Marecs (maritime) satellites and Inmarsat
Manufacturers often form consortia to bid for specific II series. It is a subcontractor to Hughes in the Intelsat-VI
contracts. The consortia may be formed purely to ensure the programme. Other British Aerospace activities include the
optimum technical mix of expertise and components, manufacture of the solar arrays for the NASA space telescope
although political considerations may be a factor. Mem- and microprocessor modules for other spacecraft. It is a
bership of a consortium may be based on an agreement to partner with Matra (France) and Selenia Spazio (Italy) in a
exchange information or simply on a long experience of joint company called Satcom International.
collaboration. The companies listed in the two groups below
frequently work together, but the inclusion of a company in a Some examples of BAe spacecraft include:
particular list does not imply any commitment, and some
companies (eg, AEG/ANT) work within either group. • ECS - the European Communications Satellites are being
built for the European Space Agency (ESA) by a
Consortia: European consortium led by British Aersopace as prime
contractor. Five satellites have been ordered. The first
1. British Aerospace (UK) ECS was launched in 1983, the second in 1984. ECS
Hughes Aircraft Company (US) satellites provide Europe with a regional space-based
Selenia (Italy) communications system.
NEC (Japan) • Eurostar- a medium scale, multi-role civilian commercial
Fokker (Netherlands) satellite extending the OTS/ECS series. Eurostar satellites
Matra (France) will be built under British Aerospace prime-contractorship
and will offer a variety of worldwide communications
2. Aeritalia (Italy) services.
Aerospatiale (France) • Giotto- a scientific satellite launched in 1985 to intercept
Ford Aerospace (US) Halley's Comet in 1986. It was built for the ESA with
Marconi (UK) British Aerospace as the prime contractor.
MBB (FRG) • Marecs - The maritime Marecs satellites are part of the
Mitsubishi (Japan) Inmarsat system and were built by a consortium under the
AEG/ANT (FRG) prime-contractorship of British Aerospace. They provide a
Alcatel/Thomson Espace (France) global communication system for the merchant shipping
and off-shore industry. It is the maritime version of the
ECS.
MAJOR MANUFACTURERS • Olympus-1- the first of a family of high-power, multi-role
communications satellites with direct broadcast facilities.
This section lists the major companies that work as prime The first spacecraft, built for ESA, is scheduled for launch
contractors, and the major subcontractors. in 1987.
112
Satellite Manufacturers and Systems
Ford Aerospace and Communications Corporation Hughes has also constructed the Geostationary Operational
(US) Environmental Satellites (GOES) for the National Oceanic
and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), and the GMS
Ford Aerospace is one of the top three US manufacturers satellite series, both of which scan nearly two-thirds of the
(the others being Hughes and RCA). In recent years its major Earth's atmosphere and help predict storms and other
output has been as prime contractor of the Intelsat-V series, weather conditions.
of which 15 satellites have now been ordered. Ford has The founder of Hughes Aircraft Company was Howard
worked for ten years with the Mitsubishi Electrical Company Hughes. He signed the company over to the Howard Hughes
(Melco) on the Japanese CS satellites. Other imporant Medical Institute before he died. The Institute claimed tax
subcontracts are for components of the French Telecom-! exemption, but a US court decided that Hughes was not
satellites and Arabsat. The multi-functional satellites pro- sufficiently actively engaged in medical research to qualify for
duced by Ford include the Indian lnsat programme and the the tax breaks. It finally sold the Hughes Aircraft Company
NOAA series of weather satellites. In the future Ford hopes to General Motors for $5 billion in 1984.
to sell the technology it is developing to construct direct Hughes is responsible for the successful HS 376 series of
broadcasting satellites. satellites. The HS 376 is a multi-purpose satellite which is
adaptable to a wide variety of requirements including voice,
video and facsimile services in both the C-band and K-band
Hughes Aircraft Company (US) frequencies, or a combination of the two. The HS 376 can
also be used for DBS.
Hughes is the world's largest satellite manufacturer. About Customers for the HS 376 include AT&T (Telstar),
60% of the commercial satellites launched in the past 25 years Australia (Aussat), Indonesia (Palapa), Mexico (Morelos),
were built by Hughes Aircraft Company. In 1963, Hughes US (SBS) and Western Union (Westar). The HS 376 is also
built the first geostationary satellite, Syncom, and has since used by the Hughes-operated Galaxy system, which serves
constructed several of the most successful series of satellites. the business community, cable programmers and broadcas-
Hughes built the Intelsat I, II and IV series. They are also the ters in the US. The Anik-C and Anik-D satellites for
prime contractor for the Intelsat-VI series (see page 26). Canada, and the SBTS satellite for Brazil were also con-
113
Satellites International
114
Satellite Manufacturers and Systems
structed on the same design, but were built under licence by etc. NEC is the prime contractor for the Broadcasting
Spar Aerospace (Canada). Satellite (BS-3), the Geostationary Meteorological Satellite
The HS 376 is 216 centimetres in diameter. With the (GMS) and the Marine Observation Satellite (MOS-1) for the
antenna and the telescoping cylindrical solar panel in their National Space Development Agency of Japan. For BS-3,
stowed positions, the spacecraft is 282 centimetres in height. NEC made the spacecraft, mission and TT&C systems, while
In its in-orbit configuration it is 660 centimetres, or nearly RCA made the major bus subsystem.
two stories tall. A spin table in the base of the cradle spins the For GMS, NEC made the spacecraft and TT&C equipment
satellite to 50 rpm. Four springs deploy the satellite, which is while Hughes made the other subsystems. For MOS-1, NEC
ideally suited to launch from the space shuttle. made the spacecraft systems and major subsystems while
several other manufacturers participated in the other sub-
The other satellites produced by Hughes include: systems.
HS 393 - a domestic satellite with a wide body configura- NEC also made transponders for Intelsat IV, IV-A and VI
tion that can accommodate varied communications require- spacecraft, and the TT &C transponders for Inmarsat-2.
ments. It can provide 16 high power channels (up to 50 dBW)
or 48 low power channels for standard telecommunications RCA(US)
needs. The HS 393 is 3.6 metres in diameter. Stowed for
launch, the satellite is only 3.4 metres high. Its fully deployed RCA is one of the largest US manufacturers. RCA Astra-
in orbit height is 10 metres. It can be launched from either the Electronics was formed in 1958, a few months after Sputnik
space shuttle or the expendable Ariane 4 rocket. was launched. The new company used RCA's expertise in
HS 394- a high power 4 kilowatt class spacecraft capable of radio to develop SCORE (1958), the first voice message from
DBS, mobile communications and conventional transmission space. Its early satellites included Echo and Relay I and II.
in multiple frequencies. Its design combines the technologies The main breakthrough came with Satcom I and II in the mid
of spin stabilised satellites and body stabilised (three-axis) 1970s which serviced the emerging US cable industry. Later
satellites. satellites include G-Star, ASCI and II, Americom, BS-3,
HS 399 - is primarily a low cost option for customers Panansat and the Astra satellite for SES, Luxembourg. The
implementing a first generation system with limited com- TIROS, ESSA. ITOS and NOAA type of spacecraft were
munications capacity. The 12-transponder satellite is designed and built by RCA Astra-Electronics under the
designed to use the space shuttle at a post-1985launch cost of technical coordination of NASA's Goddard Space Flight
under $10 million. Center. Astro has also been commissioned by NASA to build
the Advanced Communications Technology Satellite (ACTS)
Matra (France) that will carry out key experiments in satellite signal
processing and switching. ACTS is scheduled for launch in
Matra is a prime contractor responsible for the first French 1989/90. It will experiment with several electronics and
domestic telecommunications satellites, Telecom-lA and communications systems designed to provide greater capaci-
Telecom-1B. As a sub contractor, it works with British ties and more flexible networking: i. Baseband processing;
Aerospace and Selenia Spazio in the Satcom International ii. Multiple Beam Antenna; iii. Microwave Matrix Switch;
consortium. The company also manages the French observa- iv. Time-Division Multiple Access (TDMA); v. Advanced
tion satellite programme, SPOT. receiving transmitters.
MBB specialises in both research and development and Selenia Spazio, established in 1983, is the only Italian
manufacturing. As a key member (with Aerospatiale) of the company devoted solely to space activities. Selenia Spazio's
Eurosatellite consortium, it was responsible for TV-SAT and stock capital is controlled by Selenia (60% ), while Aeritalia
TDF satellite, as well as Tele-X. It is also the prime (24%) and ltaltel (15%) are minority shareholders. The
contractor for Kopernicus. A subsidiary company, ERNO, activities of Selenia Spazio are devoted to all space systems
manufactures on-board data handling systems. power systems with particular regard to telecommunications and other
and ground equipment. ERNO has been associated with applications systems, like meteorology and remote sensing,
MBB in TV-SAT/TDF/Tele-X and Kopernicus. and cover both spaceborne and ground systems. Satellite
projects in which Selenia is currently engaged include:
Mitsubishi (Melco) (Japan) Arabsat, European Remote Sensing (ERS), Intelsat VI,
L-Sat, Meteosat and GOES. Past projects include ECS,
Mitsubishi Electrical Company (Me leo) is the prime contrac- Meteosat, Sirio 1, Intelsat IV, Vand VA, ESRO IV, Exosat,
tor for the Japanese space agency, N ASD A, for the construc- OTS and Insat. It is a member of the Satcom International
tion of the national CS communications satellite system. The consortium.
first satellite of this system, CS-1 was launched in 1977, and
was developed in cooperation with Ford Aerospace (US). SPAR Aerospace (Canada)
Nippon Electric Corporation (NEC) (Japan) Spar is the leading Canadian aerospace company. Its first
prime contract was the Anik D-1 satellite, launched in 1982.
NEC is a major manufacturer of a wide range of electronic The Anik A, C and D satellites were built on a Hughes
equipment and notable for its company slogan of C & C: design, the HS 376, under licence to Spar/Comdev Corpora-
Computers and Communications. Its satellite manufacturing tion. The partnership was also the prime contractor for the
capability includes on-board satellite communications equip- SBTS satellites for Brazil, which were also based on the HS
ment such as K-band receivers, solid state power amplifiers, 376 design.
115
Satellites International
NEC-built spacecraft family
Application Satellites/Subsystem Supply
ORBIT
Satellite Main mi>sion Weight Shape Perigee Inclination Launch vehicle Launch date
(kg) Apogee Angle
Engineering Test Confirming 638 elliptical 25km 28.SO N-II-1 II Feb. 1981
Satellite IV performance of 36,000km
(KIKU-3) N-Il rocket;
measuring
satellite launch
environment;
skills in ground
handling
techniques for
applications type
satellite
Engineering Test Preliminary 385 near circular 68km 4SO N-1-7 3 Sept. 1982
Satellite III experiments in 1,230km
(KIKU-4) 3-axis attitude
control; solar
paddle
deployment and
active thermal
control, etc;
functional tests
for on board
equipment
116
2. MAIN LAUNCH VEHICLES
1. Launch costs depend on the nature of the payload and are negotiable; these costs are only a guide.
2. Capable of launching 2,000 tonne payload into low orbit.
3. Capable of launching 1,400 tonne payload into low orbit.
4. Upper stage only.
* In development.
117
3. GLOBAL SATELLITE SYSTEMS
INTELSAT
119
Satellites lntcrnationar
Disposition of total revenues. Launch date May 1975
Launcher NASA
Millions$ Design life (years) 7 (exceeded)
411
Number of channels 12
400r--------------------------------------+ TWTA power (watts) 6
Antenna coverage Indian Ocean
Operating expenses f:tt~=:J /TV region 1
350 Depreciation ~ f------------~~41:; Status Spare
Compensation for • Primary use
use of capital Lease services
IVA (Fl)
.,
(I)
Type FSS
.,c>
:::J
250
Orbital position 3l 0 W
e! Launch date September 1975
iii
§ 200 Launcher NASA
0 Design life (years) 7(exceeded)
c
.g Number of channels 20
'iii TWTA power (watts) 4 at 6; 16 at 5
8.
(I)
150 Antenna coverage Atlantic Ocean
i5 /TV region 1
Status Spare
Primary use Telephony
Lease services 3 Radiodiffusion Television
Marocaine (Morocco)
7 libya (PAL)
50
10 Argentina
10 Argentina Television
Colour, Channel7 , Buenos
Year
0
1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 Aires
120
Global Satellite Systems
121
Satellites International
NK =Not Known
VA (FlO)
Type FSS
Orbital position 24SW 4. Earth Stations
Launch date March 1985
Launcher NK Intelsat currently authorizes three standards for international
Design life (years) 7 services through its satellites. Standard A, with 30-metre or
Number of channels 44 larger dish antenna, can be rotated one degree per second
TWTA power (watts) 4.5/8.5/5.10 and can track- to a fraction of a degree- a satellite stationed
Antenna coverage Atlantic Ocean in geostationary orbit. Due to technical improvements, the
ITUregion 1 specification for Standard A earth stations was reduced to 15
Status Primary path from 18 metres in 1986. Standard A operates in the C-band
Primary use Telephony Standard B earth stations measure between 10 to 13 metres in
Lease services 12 Major international news diameter and operate in the C-band. Many countries have
feeds also installed Standard C stations, with antennas measuring
74 World Net 13 to 20 metres in diameter for Ku-band operations with
Intelsat V.
In addition to these main 'gateway' standards, Intelsat
VA (Fll) authorizes various D. E and F standards. Standards Dl and
Type FSS D2 are used for the Vista low density telephony service
Orbital position 27SW (international and domestic) and operate in the C-band.
Launch date NK Standards E1, E2 and E3 are used for the Intelsat Interna-
122
Global Satellite Systems
tiona! Business Service (IBS) and operate in both the C and lntelsat Business Service
Ku-bands. Standards Fl, F2 and F3 are also used f0r IBS but IBS is an integrated digital service designed to carry the full
they operate in the C-band only. The antenna diameter for range of telecommunications services, including voice, fac-
the D. E and F standards range from 3.5 to 12 metres. simile, data applications and video teleconferencing. It
Two other standards should also be mentioned. Standard Z permits small and medium sized antennas to be located near
is authorized for earth stations to be used for leased domestic end-user premises and in major cities, providing direct access
services. This standard provides specific guidelines on tech- and minimizing dependence on terrestrial switched networks.
nical performance requirements: however. certain para-
meters can be chosen by the earth station owner. subject to Intelnet
Intelsafs review. Standard Z operates in both the C and The Intelnet service, started in 1984. is used for data
Ku-bands and the dish diameter ranges from 4.5 to 18.3 transmission to very small earth stations or 'microterminals'.
metres. Standard G is recently authorized for accessing the Intelnet can be used, for example. to broadcast financial news
space segment for specialized international services that are to a great number of receive-only stations.
not covered by the other station standards. Standard G
operates in both C and Ku-bands: the dish diameter ranges Vista
from .8 to 12 metres. Vista provides telecommunications services such as voice and
Intelsat operates eight ground stations for tracking. tele- low speed data to rural and remote communities. The service
metry. command and monitoring (TTC&M). These stations can provide both domestic and international links. The new
are at the sites of Standard A earth stations and use their Vista and Intel net services can have widespread application in
antennas. the developing world. The key to these services is the
The eight TTC&M stations are operated for Intelsat at introduction of small low cost earth terminals that can
Tangua. Brazil: Zamengoe. Cameroon: Pleumeur Boudou. support thin route requirements.
France; Jatiluhur. Indonesia: Fucino. Italy; Yamaguchi.
Japan; Paumalu. Hawaii. US; Andover. Maine. US.
The signatories of these countries are contracted to provide 6. Countries operating lntelsat Transponder leases
TTC&M services to Intelsat until 1989. In-orbit tests are as of 31 December 1985
conducted from the facilities located in Italy and Japan.
123
Satellites International
Regular:
1. SPAIN#! ISG ISZ Atlantic 504 53 bi 28 Jan 76 2S Jan 76 27 Mar76 N/A
2. SPAIN #2 ISG ISH Atlantic 504 24 bi 16 MarS3 17JanS3 4 Feb S3 N/A
3. USA-FRANCE* ISG ISG Atlantic 504 37 a 27 MarS5 12 Mar S5 3 Oct S5 2 Oct S7"
Preemptible:
4. ALGERIA 36G 36H Indian 501 13 bii 16 Jan 75 4 Oct 74 17 Feb 75 31 Mar90 1
5.NORWAY#I ISG ISH Atlantic 502 22 bi !Oct75 14 Oct 74 31 Dec 75 30 Dec90"'
6. NIGERIA #I 36G 36H Indian 501 14 bii 16Jul75 15 Jul 75 31 Dec 75 30 Dec S5 5
7. NIGERIA #2 36G 36H Indian 501 15 bii 5 Apr 77 I Feb 76 15 Oct 76 14 Oct S6"
S. SUDAN 36G 36H Atlantic 414 7 bii 27 May 76 15 Jan 77 15 Feb 77 14FebS7 7
9. NIGERIA #3 36G 36H Indian 501 12 bii 27 May 76 I Apr 77 I Apr 77 31 Mar S7"
10. ZAIRE 36G 36H Atlantic 414 9 bii9 5Mar75 S Feb 7S 15 Dec 7S 14 DecSS "'
11. PERU #I 9H 9H Atlantic 511 12 bii 21 Sep 7S 27 Nov 7S 15 Dec 7S 14 DecSS 11
12. MEXICO #lA 36S 72H Atlantic 503 II bii IS Mar Sl S Dec Sl 9 Dec Sl S DecS6 '"
13. MEXICO #IB 36S 72H Atlantic 503 12 bii IS Mar Sl S Dec Sl II Mar S2 10 MarS7 '"
14. CHILE #2 ISG ISG Atlantic 503 37 bii 17 Dec Sl 27 Jan S2 I AprS2 31 MarS7
15. MEXICO #IC 36S 72H Atlantic 503 14 bii IS MarS! S Dec Sl 24 Apr S2 23 Apr S7 '"
16. COLOMBIA #4 ISG ISH Atlantic 511 II bii 10 Jun 81 29 Dec Sl 12 Jun S2 I I Jun S7
17. COLOMBIA #5 ISH ISH Atlantic 511 15 bii l7DecSJ 16 Jun S2 15JulS2 14 JulS7
18. PERU #3 36H 36H Atlantic 51 I II bii IS MarS! 30 JulS2 I Aug S2 31JulS7
19. PORTUGAL #I 54G 54G Atlantic 502 37.36 bi 17 Dec81 7 Oct S2 S Nov S2 7 Nov 87
20. USA/AUSTRALIA ISG ISH Pacific 413 3 a 23 Jun S2 18 May S2 20 Nov S2 19 Nov S7
#I
21. USA/DIEGO 36G 36G Atlantic 502 38 a 23 Jun S2 17 May S2 21 Dec82 20 Dec S7
GARCIA/ICELAND/
PORTUGAL!
GERMANY (GFR)/
ITALY
22. DENMARK #2 ISG 18G Atlantic 503 35 bii 16 SepS2 15 Dec82 I Jan S3 31 Dec S7
23. USA/AUSTRALIA ISG ISH Pacific 413 3 a 15 Dec82 15 Nov S2 I AprS3 31 MarSS
#2/JAPAN
24. UK/USA #I (CBS) ISG ISZ Atlantic 502 54/44 a 15 Dec S2 18 Nov S2 I May S3 30 Apr88
25. UK/USA #3 (ABC) ISG ISZ Atlantic 502 54/44 a 16 Mar83 25 Feb S3 I May 83 30 Apr8S
26. USA/UK #2 ISG 18G Atlantic 502 36 a 16 MarS3 22 Dec S2 I Sep S3 31 Aug SS"
(Visnews)
27. USA/KOREA 36G 36H Pacific 413 II a 15 Dec S2 IS Nov S2 24 Sep S3 23 Sep SS
/PHILLIPPINES
28. CHILE #3 ISG ISG Atlantic 503 37 bii 23 Mar84 I Feb S4 S Feb S4 7 Feb S9 13
29. USA/JAPAN #I ISG ISH Pacific 413 9 a 23 Jun S3 20 Jun S3 I AprS4 31 Mar8S'"'
30. PERU #2 9H 9H Atlantic 511 12 bii 20AprS2 30 JulS2 27 Aug S4 26 AugS9
31. MALAYSIA #2 36H 36H Indian 501 22 bi 17 Dec Sl 9 Sep S2 I SepS4 31 Aug S9
32. UNITED 9G 9Z Atlantic 511 53 a 15 Sep S3 16 Aug S4 S Sep 84 31 Dec S9
NATIONS
33. GERMANY. FR 216S 216S Indian 512 61.63.69 bi 15 Sep S3 14 Sep S3 27 DecS4 26 DecS9
34. COLOMBIA #06 9H 9H Atlantic 511 15 bii 23 Jun S3 15 Jun S3 I Jun S5 31May90
35. USA/UK #4 72H/S 72H/S Atlantic 51 I 13173 a (19 Apr S5) 14 Mar S5 I OctS5 30 Sep 92
36. CHINA #2 72H 72H Indian 501 23 bii (15 Jul85) 20 Jun S5 I Nov S5 31 Oct 90
37. SAUDIA ARABIA 54H 54H Atlantic 414 1,5 c 28 Sep 77 J60ct 77 I Jan 7S 31 Dec S7 15
#2
38. SAUDIA ARABIA ISH ISH Atlantic 414 5 c S Feb7S 8 Feb 78 I Mar 7S 29 Feb S8"'
#3
39. OMAN #2 36G 36G Indian 501 36 c 2S Sep 77 10 Nov 7S 15 Nov 7S 14 May S6 17
40. NIGER 36G 36H Atlantic 414 3 c II Dec80 1S Feb 81 I Apr81 31 Mar91 1"
41. MOROCCO 36G 36H Atlantic 411 3 c 25 Jun SO 12 Mar82 30 Mar S2 29 MarS7
42. ARGENTINA 54G 54G Atlantic 511 36, 38 c 17 Sep Sl 26 Oct81 28 AprS2 27 AprS7
43. THAILAND #I 9H 9H Indian 501 24 c 10 Jun S1 10 May S2 10 May S2 9 May S7
44. VENEZUELA 36H 36H Atlantic 511 12 c 17 Sep Sl 19 Aug S2 2 Sep S2 I Sep S7
45. LIBYA 36H 36H Atlantic 411 7 c 17 Sep Sl 28 Oct S2 I Nov S2 31 Oct S7
46. INDIA #3 36H 36H Indian 501 21 c 16 Sep S2 1 Nov S2 5 Nov S2 4 Nov S7 1"
47. INDIA #4 27H 27H Indian 501 21 c 16 Sep S2 I Nov S2 I Feb S3 3JJanS8'"
48. UK#IA 72S 72S Atlantic 511 63 c 16 MarS3 17 Mar S3 29 Mar S4 2S Mar 89
49. UK#IB 36S 36S Atlantic 511 61 c 16 Mar S3 17 Mar S3 31 Aug S4 30 Aug S9
50. ITALY #I 72H/Z 72H Atlantic 502 23 c 23 Jun 83 15JunS5 I Jun S5 31 May90
124
Global Satellite Systems
International TV Leases
(future use inquiries received as of 31 December 1985)
125
Satellites International
Domestic Leases
(future use inquiries received as of 31 December 1985)
Members of lntelsat
Date of '(c
Country Organization Joining Share
126
Global Satellite Systems
Denmark Generaldirectoratct for Post-Og Telegrafvae>enet 13 June 1974 0.3R4163
Dominican Compania Dominicana de Telefonos. C.Por A 20August 1971 0.050000
Republic
Ecudor Im.tituto Ecuatoriano de Telecomunicaciones (I ETEL) 9 November 1973 0.350R31
Egypt Government of the Arab Republic of Egypt 20 October 1971 0.690000
El Salvador Admini>tracion Nacional de Telecomunicaciones (ANTEL) 19 January 1977 0.050000
Ethiopia Provisional Military Government of Socialist Ethiopia 20 August 1971 O.OR9209
Fiji Fiji International Telecommunications Ltd (FINTEL) 4 May 197R 0.050000
Finland General Directorate of Po>ts and Telecommunications 15 December 1971 0.092176
France Government of France 27 March 1972 5.642236
Gabon Telecommunications Internationales Gabonaises (TIG) 20 April 1972 0.050000
Germany, GFR Bundesministerium fur das Post und Femmeldewesen 12 January 1972 0.050000
Ghana Ministry of Transport and Communications 12 December 1973 0.050000
Greece Hellenic Telecommunications Organization S.A. (OTE) 20 August 1971 0.813135
Guatemala Empresa Guatemalteca de Telecomunicaciones (GUA TEL) II October 1979 0.050000
Guinea Government of the People's Revolutionary Republic of Guinea 14 July 19RO 0.050000
Haiti Telecommunications D'Haiti S.A. 3 October 1974 0.16R004
Honduras Empresa Hondurena de Telecomunicaciones (HONDUTEL) 6 May 19RO 0.050000
Iceland Government of Iceland 14 February 1972 O.IROOOO
India Overseas Communications Service Ministry of Communications 23 December 1971 0.49R730
Indonesia Government of the Republic of Indonesia 20 August 1971 0.49R731
Iran Telecommunication Company of Iran 25 August 1971 0.937963
Iraq Government of the Republic of Iraq 6 August 1973 0.405501
Ireland Irish Telecommunications Board 27 August 19R4 0.1331R2
Israel The Israel Telecommunication Corp. Ltd (BELZEQ) 12 April 19R4 0.557462
Italy Telespazio 20 August 1971 2.14R906
Ivory Coast Government of the Republic of Ivory Coast 20 August 1971 0.264921
Jamaica Jamaica International Telecommunications Ltd (JAMINTEL) 14 December 1972 0.3R2145
Japan Kokusai Denshin Denwa Co, Ltd (KDD) 20 August 1971 3.330332
Jordan Government of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan 20 August 1971 0.29R781
Kenya Kenya Posts and Telecommunications Corporation 16 June 19R3 0.374390
Korea Korea Telecommunication Authority 3 September 19R2 0.720R52
Kuwait Ministry of Communications R March 1973 0.9R9464
Lebanon Government of Lebanon 20 August 1971 O.OR6501
Libya Government of the Libyan Arab Republic 9 June 1975 0.149600
Liechtenstein Government of the Principality of Liechtenstein 20 August 1971 0.050000
Luxembourg Government of Luxembourg 2R September 1971 0.050000
Madagascar Societe des Telecommunications Internationales de Ia Republique Malgache 9 February 1973 0.050000
(STIMAD)
Malawi Department of Posts and Telecommunications 16 July 19R4 0.050000
Malaysia Telecommunications Department 22 February 1972 0.6R28Rl
Mali Telecommunications Internationales de Mali (TIM) 6 July 1976 O.OR6374
Mauritania Government of the Islamic Republic of Mauritania 20 August 1971 0.050000
Mauritius 2 September 19R6 0.059969
Mexico Government of Mexico 4 November 1971 l.RJRJR4
Monaco Government of the Principality of Monaco I May 1972 0.05000
Morocco Government of Morocco 20 August 1971 0.257424
Netherlands Government of the Kingdom of the Netherlands 13 October 1971 1.12ROOR
New Zealand Postmaster General 5 January 1972 0.4025R4
Nicaragua Compania Nicaraguense de Telecomunicaciones por Satelite 12 November 1971 0.050000
Niger Government of the Republic of Niger 14 April 19RO 0.050000
Nigeria Nigerian External Telecommunications Ltd 17 November 1975 1.230R44
Norway Norwegian Telecommunications Administration (Teledirektoratet) 20 August 1971 0.3R2246
Oman Sultanate of Oman 3 January 1975 0.509R37
Pakistan Government of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan 20 August 1971 0.393000
Panama Intercontinental de Communicaciones Por Satelite S.A. (INTERCOMSA) 29 May 1975 0.050000
Papua New Guinea Post and Telecommunication Corporation 24 March 19R3 0.050000
Paraguay Administration Nacional de Telecomunicaciones (ANTELCO) IR July 1977 0.116067
Peru Empresa Nacional de Tclecomunicaciones (ENTEL PERU) 20 August 1971 0.74R993
Philippines Philippine Communications Satellite Corporation (PHILCOMSA T) 10 October 1973 0.644R42
Portugal Companhia Portuguesa Radio Marconi 20 August 1971 0.6R249R
Qatar Government of the State of Qatar 2 February 1976 0.324020
Rwanda Ministere des Postes et des Communications 2 September 19R6 0.050000
Saudi Arabia Government of Saudi Arabia 24 August 1972 3.106999
Senegal Government of the Republic of Senegal 20 August 1971 0.050000
Singapore Telecommunication Authority of Singapore 20 February 1973 1.400000
Somalia Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications 27 March 19RJ 0.050000
South Africa Department of Posts and Telecommunications 20 August 1971 1.271510
Spain Compania Telefonica Nacional de Espana 20 August 1971 1.962657
Sri Lanka Government of Sri Lanka 7 February 1973 0.050000
Sudan Government of the Democratic Republic of the Sudan 20 August 1971 0.2RR474
Sweden Swedish Telecommunications Administration 19May1972 0.664R7R
Switzerland Direction Generale de L'Entreprise des Postes Telephones et Telegraphes 20 August 1971 1.234140
Suisses
Syria Government of the Syrian Arab Republic 20 August 1971 0.122415
127
Satellites International
Tanzania Tanzania Posts and Telecommunications Corporation 9 March 1978 0.098839
Thailand Government of Thailand 20 August 1971 0.424225
Togo 2 September 1986 0.050000
Trinidad and Trinidad and Tobago External Telecommunications Co. Ltd (TEXTEL) 20 August 1971 0.050000
Tobago
Tunisia Administration for Post Telegraph and Telephone 20 August 1971 0.050000
Turkey Government of Turkey 10 September 1971 0.227404
Uganda Ministry of Power. Posts and Telecommunications 11 September 1980 0.050000
United Arab Ministry of Communications 12 May 1976 1.736693
Emirates
United Kingdom British Telecommunications PLC 18 September 1984 13.068645
United States Communications Satellite Corporation 20 August 1971 22.462815
Uruguay Administracion Nacional de Telecommunicaciones 7 December 1982 0.050000
Vatican City State Government of the Vatican City State 20August 1971 0.050000
Venezuela Compania Anonima Nacional Telefonos de Venezuela 20 August 1971 1.149790
Vietnam Direction Generate des Postes et Telecommunications 29 October 1979 0.050000
Yemen Arab Government of Yemen Arab Republic 20 August 1971 0.219888
Republic
Yugoslavia Community of the Yugoslav Posts, Telegraphs and Telephones 20 August 1971 0.217580
Zaire Office National des Postes et Telecommunications de Zaire (ONPTZ) 20 August 1971 0.286292
Zambia Government of the Republic of Zambia 1 November 1972 0.098744
128
Global Satellite Systems
Statsionar 4
Type FSS 4. Earth stations
Orbital position ww
Launch date June 1983 The system operates 18 earth stations in 17 countries.
Launcher USSR They are equipped with 12-metre or 25-metre antennae.
Mission life (years) 3
Number of channels 2
TWTA power (watts) 5 at 15; 1 at 40 5. Services
Antenna coverage Atlantic Ocean
ITU region 1 Intersputnik provides a full range of communications ser-
Status Intersputnik/ vices: voice, vision, data, etc.
USSR domestic
Primary use TV/Telephony
Services 1 I Programma TV Moscow; Auxili- Users and Members: lntersputnik
ary Service for Radio Mayak
2 OIRT news feeds
3 Telephony channel with radio,
voice and data traffic Country Organization Member
5 Wideband digital service of
6 Multiple digital carriers Inter-
sputnik
Afghanistan Ministry of Communications Yes
Algeria Ministere des Postes et No
Statsionar 13 Telecommunications
Type FSS Angola Ministerio dos Transportes e No
Orbital position 80° E Comunicacoes
Launch date 1984 Bulgaria Ministry of Posts and Yes
Launcher USSR Telecommunications
Mission life (years) 3 Cuba Ministerio de Comunicaciones Yes
129
Satellites International
Czechoslovakia Federal Ministry of Posts and Yes capacity in orbit over the world's three major ocean regions,
Telecommunications it provides global service for about 3,300 ships, oil rigs, etc. In
Ethiopia Provisional Military No the near future, Jnmarsat hopes to extend its services further
Government of Socialist into the field of mobile satellite communications, in particular
Ethiopia aeronautical mobile satellite services.
German Ministerrat der Deutschen Yes Inmarsat has forty-three member countries. It also offers
Democratic Demokratischen Republik services to non-member countries.
Republic Ministerium fur Post und
Fernmeldewesen 2. Constitution and Finance
Hungary Ministry of Communications Yes
and Posts The organization consists of three parts:
Iraq The President of Posts, No 1. The Assembly meets once every two years to review the
Telegraphs and Telephones long-term policy and objectives of the organization. The
State Organization assembly is composed of representatives of all the signatories.
Kampuchea No The assembly expresses its views and recommendations to the
Korea, North Ministry of Communications Yes Council. Each member country has one vote.
Laos Ministre des Postes et Yes 2. The Council meets three times a year and is comparable to
Telecommunications a corporate board of directors. It consists of representatives
Libya Directorate General of Posts No of the 18 signatories with the largest investment shares and
and Telecommunications four signatory representatives elected by the Assembly on the
Mozambique Ministero dos Transportes e No principle of geographical representation (taking into account
Comunicacoes the interests of developing countries). The Council, having
Nicaragua Direccion General de No due regard to the views and recommendations of the
Telecomunicaciones y Correos Assembly, is responsible for providing the necessary space
(TELCOR) segment in the most economic and efficient manner. Signa-
Poland Ministerstwoj Lacznosci Yes tories in the Council have a voting power equivalent to their
Romania Ministry of Transport and Yes investment share. The Council is assisted by an Advisory
Telecommunications Committee on Technical and Operational Matters
Sri Lanka Department of No (ACTOM).
Communications 3. The Directorate carries out the day-to-day activities of the
USSR Ministry of Yes organization from its London headquarters. The Director
Telecommunications General is the chief executive officer and legal representative
Vietnam Direction generale des postes Yes of Inmarsat. He is responsible to and under the direction of
et telecommunications the Council. The Director General is appointed by the
Yemen, People's Yemen Telecommunicaions Yes Council for a term of six years, subject to confirmation by the
Democratic Corporation Parties.
Republic of
Procurement
The procurement policy is set out by the Council. Procure-
ment of goods and services required by lnmarsat shall be
INMARSAT effected by the award of contracts, based on responses to
open international tender.
International Maritime Satellite Organization
40 Melton Street, London NWJ 2EQ, England
Telephone: (1) 387 9089 Telex: 297201 INMSAT G Capital requirements and investment shares
Fax: 44 1 387 2115 Inmarsat is required to operate on a sound economic and
Contact: Olaf Lundberg, Director General financial basis having regard to accepted commercial princi-
ples. Its capital requirements are financed by contributions
1. History from signatories in proportion to their investment shares.
These in turn are intended to reflect their utilization of the
In 1973, the International Maritime Organization (then space segment. The minimum initial investment share is .05
known as IMOC), a London-based specialized agency of the percent, and the present capital ceiling is $300 million.
UN, convened a series of conferences to consider establishing
an international maritime satellite system. The last of these Revenue
conferences, held on 3 September 1976, adopted a 'Conven- Revenue is earned from telecommunications entities for their
tion on the International Maritime Satellite Organization use of the space segment. The charges levied by Inmarsat are
(Inmarsat)'. The organization came into being in July 1979, based on the satellite power and bandwidth used as well as
when the Inmarsat Convention was signed together with the market factors.
'Operating Agreement on the International Maritime Satel-
lite Organization (Inmarsat)'. Inmarsat became operational 3. Spacecraft
in February 1982.
Inmarsat is an international cooperative organization, Maritime satellite communications as pioneered in 1976 by
patterned on Intelsat. It provides satellite communications Comsat General (US) with a system of three geosynchronous
facilities to the world's shipping and offshore industries. It is Marisat satellites giving global coverage. When Inmarsat
funded by its member countries through their respective became operational in February 1982, it leased transponders
signatories. Inmarsat, like Intelsat, is commercially-oriented, on these Marisat satellites. To meet the fast growing demand
earning revenues from the sale of its services. With satellite for its services, Inmarsat now leases capacity on Marecs-A
130
Global Satellite Systems
which is funded by Inmarsat, 2) the coast earth stations Kuwait; Odessa, USSR; Pleumeur Bodou, France; Tangue,
(CES), and 3) the ship earth stations (SES). This section will Brazil; Santa Paula, California; Ibaraki, Japan; Singapore;
cover both CES and SES. Nakhodka, USSR; Yamaguchi, Japan; Eik, Norway; Ther-
1. Inmarsat coast earth stations provide the link between the mopylae, Greece.
satellites and the telecommunication networks ashore. They 2. The ship earth stations are the satellite communications
are owned and operated by the signatories, who are also terminals which are purchased or leased by individual ship
responsible for the landline connections to the public owners/operators from manufacturers and suppliers of ship
switched telephone and telex networks. A typical coast earth radio equipment. They are typically .85 to 2-metre parabolic
station consists of a parabolic antenna about 11 to 14 metres antennas housed in a fibreglass 'radome' and mounted on a
in diameter, which is used for transmission to the satellite at 6 stabilized platform which enables the antennas to track the
GHz and for reception at 4 GHz (C-band). The same antenna satellite despite ship movement. While the Standard A ship
or another dedicated antenna may be used for L-band earth station (see Lundberg, page 29) will remain the
transmission (1.6 GHz) and reception (1.5 GHz) or network workhorse of maritime satellite communications for the
control signals. foreseeable future, other standards are being considered for
Inmarsat coast earth stations are located at: Goonhilly, UK; the late 1980s, designed to take advantage of new transmis-
Southbury, Connecticut; Fucino, Italy; Umm al-Aish, sions techniques. New facilities being considered include
132
Global Satellite Systems
access through a PABX as in an office or hotel, automatic (Japan) respectively. Each NCS regulates the distribution of
transfer of data from computer to computer and improved available telephone channels to ships and coast earth stations.
distress and safety capabilities now under study by IMO and Telex channels are directly assigned to ships by individual
others. coast earth stations.
In addition to the space segment and the different types of
earth station, each of the three main ocean regions has its 5. Services
own Network Coordination Station (NCS), for which Inmar-
sat has let contracts with Comsat (US) and Kokusai Denshin Inmarsat provides telephone, telex (the most popular service)
Denwa (KDD) of Japan. The Atlantic region NCS, operated and data communications at up to 1.5 megabits per second.
by Com sat, is at Southbury, Connecticut. Those for the Interactive services include videotex, navigational/weather
Indian and Pacific regions are at Yamaguchi and Ibaraki information and search and rescue (SAR).
133
4. REGIONAL SATELLITE SYSTEMS
The Agreement for the Establishment of the Arab Space Arabsat (F2)
Communications Organizations was made in Cairo on 14 Type
April 1976. It was signed by 22 Arab countries and entered Orbital position 26°E
into force in February 1977. Under the terms of the charter, Launch date May 1985
Arabsat is to provide for and promote an Arab satellite Launcher NASA
network for the purpose of serving communications and Design life (years) 7
information as well as any services requested by the mem- Number of channels 25
bers. TWTA power (watts) 8.5/50
Antenna coverage Arab League Nations
Arabsat has three main bodies: 1TU region 1
1. The General Assembly is composed of the ministers of Status Main
communications of all the Arab member states. It is the Primary use TV/Telephony/
legislative body of the organization and convenes once a year Data
to outline general policy.
2. The Board of Directors is composed of representatives of
nine member states. The five highest shareholders are Transponders
permanent members of the Board; the other four members Each spacecraft has 25 C-band transponders and one CIS-
are elected every two years from the other Arabsat members. band transponder. Each C-band transponder will be able to
The board meets four times a year and is responsible for carry one TV channel, 1,100 SCPC/FM telephony channels or
providing, using and developing the space segment as well as approximately 550 FDM/DM/FDMA telephony channels.
implementing the .General Assembly's recommendations. The CIS-band transponder will carry one community TV
3. The Executive Body is made up of various administrative channel. The Earth-to-space transmissions for all services will
and technical branches and is headed by the Director be in the 5,925-6,425 MHz C-band. The space-to-Earth
General. Its function is to carry out policy decisions of the transmissions will be in the 3700-4200 MHz C-band. C-band
General Assembly and Board of Directors. The Director will be used for all services except community TV, which will
General is elected for a three-year term. be in the 2500-2690 MHz S-band. For TV, frequency
The organization's initial capital was $100 million divided modulation will be used. Arabsat will use the 2,500 MHz band
into 1,000 shares, although it has been increased several for community TV. With the high power flux density
times. Shares are tied to usage after two year's operation. specified for this band, it will be possible to receive TV signals
In 1985 more than 50% of the shares were announced to be at remote locations and rural areas by a cheap S-band earth
in the hands of Saudi Arabia (35%) and Kuwait (18% ). The station (TYRO). These stations can be operated by batteries
third largest shareholder is Libya (8% ). and also by solar energy converters. The cost of each station
including the monitor will not be more than $3,000. This will
3. Spacecraft allow educational TV programmes to be set up in all the
Arabsat member states and is one of the unique features of
The space segment consists of two satellites built by Aerospa- the Arabsat system.
tiale with Ford as sub-contractor. Arabsat-1 was launched on
8 February 1985 and Arabsat-2 (in-orbit spare) on 18 June 4. Earth Stations
1985 at 26° E and 19° E respectively. A third satellite remains
on the ground as a spare. The satellites are expected to The construction and operation of the earth stations in the
operate for at least seven years. system is the responsibility of the individual administrations.
135
Satellites International
Arabsat has specifications for two types of earth stations: 1) and objectives. It deals, in particular, with all questions
C-band stations for telephony, miscellaneous services and concerning relations with outside bodies, the procurement of
regional TV, with 11-metre antennas; and S-band stations for satellites and staff matters.
community TV with antennas of 4 to 6 metres. 2. The European Communications Satellite Council is the
A primary TTC&M earth station has been built in Riyadh, principal organ for the ECS space segment. It is composed of
Saudi Arabia. When completed, it will include Ku-band, representatives of each member administration. Its function
C-band and S-band facilities. Two antenna systems will be is to develop a reliable space segment adapted to the needs of
provided for simultaneous communications with each in-orbit members. It also makes traffic forecasts, defines the condi-
spacecraft. Other earth stations are being built in Djibouti, tions for accessing the ECS space segment and determines
Oman, Kuwait, Mauritania and the Arabic Emirates. earth station standards. In addition, the Council approves the
budget and regulates charges for the ECS space segment.
3. The General Secretariat is the permanent executive organ
Arabsat Members
and is headed by the Secretary General. It is responsible for
Algeria the management of the entire organization and, in particular,
Bahrain of the ECS space segment.
Djibouti Financial participation is based on usage, following the
Egypt Intelsat model. The system of payments for users of the
Iraq Eutelsat space segment is based on PTT practices, rather than
Jordan market forces. There are thus considerable disparities
Kuwait between the rates paid by European programmer providers
Libya on ECS (F1).
Mauritania The basic space segment charge is 1.8 million European
Morocco Currency Units (ECU's) per transponder per year, for a
Oman pre-emptible lease. In addition, Eutelsat requires the pay-
Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) ment of a downlink charge of 200,000 ECUS for each
Qatar country, other than the country of origin of the signal, where
Saudi Arabia there is official reception of the signal, up to a maximum of 1
Somalia million ECUS. Neither of these rates is expected to change
Sudan for the next three years.
Eutelsat leases the transponders on both satellites to
Syria
Tunisia national administrations which then lease them to program-
Yemen Arab Republic ming companies at rates which reflect Eutelsat's basic rates,
Yemen (PDR) an uplink charge and often a profit margin.
United Arab Emirates
3. Spacecraft
EUTELSAT Eutelsat's space segment began with the Orbital Test Satellite
(OTS) which was developed by the European Space Agency
European Telecommunications Satellite Organization (ESA) and launched in 1978. The OTS was used by Eutelsat
Tour Maine-Montparnasse, 75755 Paris Cedex 15, France for an extensive programme of telecommunications experi-
Telephone: 33 (1) 538 47 47 Telex: 203823 EUSAT F ments. It came to an end on 31 December 1983.
Contact: Andrea Caruso, Secretary General Eutelsat's space segment consists now of two satellites, F1
and F2, known as European Communication Satellites (ECS)
1. History or Eutelsat. The first, launched on 16 June 1983, is mainly
used for delivering TV services. F2 was launched in 1984. F3
Eutelsat was the first regional satellite system in the world. It was to be launched in September 1985 but the launch failed.
was set up to ensure the establishment, operation and F4 is scheduled for launch in 1987/8 but launches have been
maintenance of the space segment of the European telecom- held up by the problems of Ariane and the Shuttle. A second
munications satellite system. The organization was created in generation satellite, the Eutelsat-II series, is planned for the
provisional form on 30 June 1977 by the 17 members of the 1990s. Eutelsat also leases capacity on Telecom 1. The
European Conference of Postal and Telecommunications Eutelsat-I satellites are in a geostationary orbit at l0°E and
Administrations (CEPT). 13°E. Eutelsat-II satellites will be at 30°E and 36°E.
On 14 May 1982 an intergovernmental conference in Paris
at which twenty-six European countries were represented
adopted a Convention establishing the definitive organiza- THE EUTELSAT SYSTEM
tion. Twenty-four countries signed the Convention and it
entered into force in August, 1985, allowing Eutelsat to join Name ECS (Fl)
the ranks of Intelsat and Inmarsat. Today Eutelsat comprises Type FSS
26 member countries. Orbital position 13°E
Launch date June 1983
2. Constitution and Finance Launcher Ariane
Design life (years) 7
Eutelsat's objective is to provide its members with the space Number of channels 12
segment capacity necessary for meeting their telecommunica- TWTA power (watts) 20
tions services requirements. Antenna coverage Europe
The organization consists of three parts: ITU region 1
1. The Assembly of Signatory Parties defines general policy Status Spare
136
Regional Satellite Systems
Primary use TV About 180 earth stations, not standardized, are operating as
Lease services 1 Radio Televisione Italiana receive-only stations for TV signals. By the middle of 19S6
(RAI), Italy the number of standard earth stations was 18.
2 SAT-1, Germany
3 Olympus, Holland 5. Services
4 TV5, France New World
Channel Worldnet The services provided by the Eutelsat space segment are as
6 Sky Channel, UK (S) follows: telephony and telegraphy; television distribution;
7 Teleclub, Switzerland satellite multi-service system (SMS) for business telecom-
9 Film Net, Belgium (S) munications, providing high speed data transmissions, audio
10 3-SAT, Germany, FR and videoconferencing, remote printing of newspapers, facsi-
12 Music Box mile, interconnection of computers, etc. (2,400 bit/s to 2
Mbit/s).
137
5. APPLICATIONS SATELLITES
The Global Atmospheric Research Programme The first weather satellite was the TIROS (Television
(GARP) Infra-Red Observation Satellite), built by RCA. as were its
successors for 20 years, and launched by the United States on
This project took place from I December 1978 to 30 1 April 1960. TIROS I weighed 2fl3 pounds (128 kilogram-
November 1979. Its aim was to improve the knowledge of mes) and had a cartwheel configuration - 22 inches (0.56
global processes that produce changes in weather and metres) in height. 42 inches (1.07 metres) in diameter -
climate. and included observations and measurements by rolling along in orbit like a wheel. Two 0.5 inches ( 1.27
ships, balloons, aircraft. polar-orbiting satellites and five centimetres) vidicon TV cameras were mounted 180° apart in
geostationary satellites. All 147 members of the WMO the rim. It operated successfully for nearly three months.
contributed to GARP - the largest cooperative space effort TIROS showed the feasibility of using satellites for weather
ever conducted. observation, and the system soon grew to a pre-operational
satellite programme. Another nine TIROS satellites were
Spacecraft launched in the period from 1960 to 1965.
In the early 1960s NASA initiated a scientific satellite
1 Geostationary Meteorological Satellite (GMS or Hima- programme called Nimbus. Satellites were launched in this
wari). Japan at 140°E programme between 1964 and 1978. The system was
1 Meteosat (European Space Agency) at oo developed to test advanced instruments for the operational
3 Geostationary Meteorological Satellites (GOES), USA at TIROS satellite system and its successors. It also intended to
75°W, 135°W and 60°E. be a research system for remote sensing and data collection.
Meteorological satellites carry cameras or sensors to generate In 1966 NASA launched its first Applications Test Satel-
images of the earth's surface that can be used to make lite, ATS-1, a geostationary satellite equipped with cameras
weather forecasts and study the climatic changes. and transmitters. The satellite transmitted a picture of the
Satellites in the geostationary orbit provide a global view of western hemisphere every 20 minutes.
weather systems. Low-orbiting satellites. usually in a sun- In February 1966 TIROS became an operational system
synchronous orbit, provide additional details. under the name TOS (TIROS Operational System). The new
139
Satellites International
system provided routine daily worldwide observations with- time to plant and to cut), data about the oceans indicating
out interruption. It used ESSA satellites (Environmental where fish are likely to be present. a variety of information
Science Service Administration). Nine ESSA satellites were assisting in forecasts of weather and climate: wave heights,
launched between 1966 and 1969. Larger cameras were used which are a crucial factor in ocean transportation: and
to increase the quality of the cloud cover pictures. The first of information about the likelihood of mineral oils and other
a new generation of satellites was launched on 23 January geological resources.
1970, the ITOS-1 satellite, or Improved TIROS Operational Specialist sensing satellites have been developed by the US
Satellite. The ITOS/NOAA satellites operated in sun- and by France. Several other countries have used telecom-
synchronous orbit with an orientation system which pointed munication satellites to provide some capacity for remote
sensors at the earth, giving full meteorological coverage of sensing. The ESA's Spacelab also carried out experiments in
land and oceans. ITOS-1 weighed 690 pounds (313 kilo- remote sensing.
grammes) was 49 inches (1.24 metres) in height and had a Remote sensing originally depended on balloons and
width of 40 x 40 inches (1.02 x 1.02 metres). Its array span was aircraft. It was not until the first Landsat was launched in
14 feet (4.3 metres). It carried two automatic picture trans- 1972, producing images with resolutions down to 80 metres,
mission TVs and two advanced l-inch (2.54 centimetres) that the potential of using satellites was realized. As well as
Vidicon camera systems. the US, the sole operators of Landsat. other countries moved
A second satellite in this series was launched in December to set up their own receiving stations. Canada was the first,
1970 under the name of NOAA-1, following the name of the then Brazil and Italy.
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the
successor of ESSA. Between 1970 and 1976 four more
satellites were put into orbit: NOAA 2, 3, 4 and 5. NAVIGATION
The development of operational polar-orbiting environ-
mental satellites continued and a third generation emerged. The first dedicated navigation satellite system was the Transit
The new satellites were equipped with a very accurate system system, made for the US Navy. This series of satellites
for mapping sea-surface temperatures and had the capability orbited at approximately 1.600 kilometres in polar orbit. The
to identify snow and sea-ice. The series started off with the satellites transmitted continuous signals which could be
launch of the TIROS-N on 13 October 1978 and continued picked up by antennas on nuclear-powered submarines so
with NOAA-6 to NOAA-9launched between 1978 and 1984. that the crew could determine the location of a ship with
A pre-operational geosychronous system was developed by considerable accuracv.
NASA in the early 1970s. The first Synchronous Meteorolo- The current US N;{vy navigation satellite system consists of
gical Satellite (SMS-1) was designed by NASA and built by nine Navstar satellites, launched between 1978 and 1984. It
the Ford Corporation. It was equipped with a 40-centimetre may be replaced by a new navigation system called the Global
telescope for visible and infra-red scanning. SMS also Positioning System which gives a very accurate performance
gathered data from remote weather stations. SMS-2 was for both position location and navigation. The US may allow
launched in February 1975 and the first operational version a other countries to access this sytem.
few months later in the same year. The operational system The Inmarsat convention also gives provisions for the
was called Geostationary Operational Environmental Satel- development of an international navigation satellite system.
lite (GOES). Six GOES satellites were launched up to 1984 to Inmarsat has initiated studies to determine the technical and
provide data from geosynchronous orbit. economic feasibility of such a system.
The navigation satellite system operated by the USSR
USSR consists of Tsikada satellites which service ships, oil rigs and
floating military bases.
The USSR's first experiments with weather satellites were
carried out with the regular Cosmos satellites. From 1969 to
1980 a series of 30 dedicated Meteor-1 satellites was launched SEARCH AND RESCUE
followed by 11 Meteor-2 satellites from 1975 to 1984.
The Meteor satellites scan the Earth from pole to pole and Two satellite systems are equipped with devices to aid the
store data for transmission on command to 50 receiving search and rescue of ships, aircraft, etc., in distress. When a
stations. ship is in danger, or an aircraft crashes, it Emergency
Locator Transmitor (EL T) is automatically activated and
transmits signals on a reserved frequency. The signals are
REMOTE SENSING monitored by the nearest satellite and retransmitted to the
earth. As the satellite moves towards and then away from the
Remote sensing is the acquisition of information about an accident, its measurements of the Doppler effect of the ELT's
object or surface from a distance. Satellites can provide signals allow the accident's precise location to be known to
photographs and images about the Earth's surface and what within about 20 kilometres. There are two such systems in
lies above or immediately below it. The satellite's sensors can operation, operated respectively by the USSR and a group of
pick up both optical and infra-red signals and by knowing, for other countries which agreed in 1980 to provide a com-
instance, the temperature of the signals being emitted it is plementary service.
possible to deduce the state of crops and of large areas of The Satellite Aided Search and Rescue (SARSA T) system
water. By passing over the same piece of land at regular was initiated by Canada, France and the US, who were later
intervals a satellite can produce a series of images to show joined by Brazil, Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden and
sequential changes, SEASAT (1978) for instance, covered the UK. It is operated by the US, and uses capacity on the US
95% of the world's oceans every 36 hours, taking more NOAA-E weather satellite launched in 1983. It now uses
information in a single day than had been possible in decades. NOAA-8 and NOAA-9, both of which are equipped with
This information is regularly used to deduce information special repeaters. There are receive-only stations in Canada,
about the state of the Earth and of crops (indicating the best France and the US.
140
Applications Satellites
The USSR Space System for Vessels and Aircraft in Receive stations have been set up in Moscow. Archangel and
Distress (COSPAS) was set up by the USSR in 1982. It Vladivostok.
consists of three satellites: Cosmos 1383, 1447 and 1574.
141
6. INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS A-Z
ABU CITEL
Asia-Pacific Broadcasting Union Conferencia Interamericana de Telecomunicaciones
PO Box 1164 Jalan Pantai Bharu, Kuala Lumpur 22-07, Torre Central de Telecommunicaciones, Eje Central Lazaro
Malaysia Cardenas 567, 0320-Mexico DF
Telephone: (3) 44 35 92 Telex: 32237 ABU Telephone: (5) 534 16 91 Telex: 1773980 DAITME/170956
SQPAME
AIR
Asociacion Interamericana de Radiodifusion
Calle Yi, no. 1264. Montevideo. CITEL
Uruguay Conferencia Interamericana de Telecomunicaciones
Telephone: (2) 90 44 56 Telex: 834 AIR UY 1889, F Street NW OAS, Washington DC 20006. USA
Telephone: (202) 789 3194 Telex: ITT 440392 OAS UI
APT RCA 248381 OAS UR
Asia-Pacific Telecommunity
5, Chaengwattana Road, Bangkok 5, Thailand Comite International Radio Maritime
Telephone: 2 233 3434 Telex: 84198 APTELBK TH General Secretariat: Pier Head House, Narrow Street,
London El4 8DQ. UK
ARABSAT Telephone: (01) 790 66 04 Telex: 8956139 COMSUP G
Arab Satellite Communications Organization
PO Box 1038 Riyadh. Saudi Arabia Conseil International des Unions Scientifiques
Telephone: (1) 464 66 66 Telex: 201300 ARBSAT SJ 51, Boulevard de Montmorency. F 75016 Paris. France
Telephone: (1) 4525 03 29 Telex: 630553F ICSU
ASBU
Arab States Broadcasting Union General Secretariat
COSPAR
17, rue El-Mansoura. BP 65. Al-Menzah IV, Tunis, Tunisia Committee on Space Research Secretariat
Telephone: (1) 23 S8 18 Telex: 13398 TN 51, Boulevard de Montmorency, F 75016 Paris, France
Telephone: (1) 4525 06 79 Telex: 630553F ICSU COSPAR
ASETA
Asociacion de Empresas Estatales de Telecomunicaciones del
Acuerdo EBU
Sub-regional Andino. San Ignacio no. 969 y Jonas Guerrero. European Broadcasting Union
Casilla postal 6042. Quito. Ecuador Head Office: Ancienne Route 17. Case postale 193, CH 1211
Telephone: (2) 54 98 55 Telex: 2S60 Geneva 20, Switzerland
Telephone: (22) 9S 77 66 Telex: 289193 UER CH
Association Internationale de Signalisation Maritime
13, rue Yvon Villarceau, F 75116 Paris. France
Telephone: (l) 500 38 60 Telex: 610480F IALASM EBU Technical Centre
32, Avenue Albert-Lancaster, B 1180 Brussels, Belgium
ATU Telephone: (2) 374 58 30 Telex: 21230 A EBUER B, 21939
Arab Telecommunication Union B EBUER B
PO Box 2S015, Baghdad. Iraq
Telephone: ( 1) 555 0638 Telex: 2007 A TU IK
ESA
CEPT European Space Agency
Conference Europeene des Administrations des Postes et des S-10, rue Mario-Nikis, F 7573S Paris Cedex 15. France
Telecommunications Telephone: (1) 4567 55 78 Telex: 202746 ESA
Direction generale des postes et des telegraphes. DK-1530,
Copenhagen V, Denmark EUTELSAT
Telephone: I 15 66 10 Telex: 911 1845 CEPTDK TTX DK European Telecommunications Satellite Organization
Fax: 45 114 50 26 Tour Maine-Montparnasse, 33 Avenue du Maine, F 75755
Paris Cedex 15. France
Conference Europeenne des Administrations des Postes et Telephone: (1) 538 47 47 Telex: 203823 EUSAT
des Telecommunications
Office de liaison de Ia CEPT. Seilerstrasse 22, Gulfvision
Case postale 1283, CH-3001. Berne, Switzerland PO Box 6802. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Telephone: 31 62 20 79 Telex: 911089 CEPT CH Telephone: 402 08 06 Telex: 20211S GULFTV SJ
Fax: 31 62 20 78 Fax: (1) 403 2912
143
Satellites International
IAAB ISO
Inter-American Association of Broadcasters International Standards Organization
Calle 11, no. 1264, Montevideo, Uruguay 1 rue de Varembe. CH 1211 Geneva 20, Switzerland
Telephone: (2) 90 44 56 Telex: 843 AIR UY Telephone: (022) 34 12 40 Telex: 23887 ISOCH
IAF NANBA
International Astronautical Federation North American National Broadcasters Association
250, rue Saint-Jacques, F 75005 Paris, France 1500 Bronson Avenue, Ottawa, Ontario K1G 315, Canada
Telephone: (1) 4633 78 42 Telephone: (613) 731 3111 Telex: 05 34260
IBI OIRT
Intergovermental Bureau for Informatics Organisation Internationale de Radiodiffusion et Television
PO Box 10253, 23 viale Civilta del Lavoro, I-00144 Rome, Technical Centre, Skokansk, 16956 Prague 6,
Italy Czechoslovakia
Telephone: (6) 591 60 41 Telex: 612065 I IBINF Telephone: (02) 34 21 639 Telex: 122444/122371
ICC OTI
International Chamber of Commerce Organizacion de Ia Television Ibero-Americana
38, cours Albert 1cr. F 75008 Paris, France Varsovia 44, piso 40, Mexico
Telephone: (1) 4261 85 97 Telex: 650770 INCOMERC Paris Telephone: (5) 533 1286 Telex: 177 1140/177 7526
IIC PATU
International Institute of Communications Union panafricaine des telecommunications
Tavistock House South, Tavistock Square, Boite postale 8634, Kinshasa 1, Zaire
London WC1H 9LF, UK Telephone: 22 175 Telex: 21049 ZR
Telephone: (01) 388 0671 Telex: 24578
Fax: (01) 380 0623 SITA
Societe Internationale de Telecommunications
INMARSAT Aeronautiques
International Maritime Satellite Direction generale, 112, avenue Charles-de-Gaulle,
Organization F 92522 Neuilly-sur-Seine, France
40 Melton Street, London NW1 2EO, UK Telephone: (1) 4758 13 22
Telephone: (01) 387 90 89 Telex: 264604 INMSAT G
SWIFT
INTELSAT Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial
International Telecommunications Satellite Organization Telecommunication
3400, International Drive N .W, 81, Avenue Ernest Solway,
Washington. DC 20008, USA B 1310 La Hulpe, Belgium
Telephone: (202) 944 03 33 Telex: (via WUT) 892707 Telephone: (02) 219 42 90 Telex: 26532 SWIBRU
(via WUT) 64290
UAI
INTERSPUTNIK Union Astronomique Internationale
International Organization of Space Communications 61 avenue de I'Observatoire, F 75014 Paris, France
2 Smolensky 1/4, Moscow 121099, USSR Telephone: (l) 325 83 58
Telephone: (95) 244 03 33 Telex: 411288 DISK SU
UNESCO
INTUG United Nations Educational, Scientific
International Telecommunications Users Group and Cultural Organization
26 Elmfield Road, Bromley, Kent, UK 7 Place de Fontenoy, 75700 Paris, France
Telephone: (09) 634 40 00 Telephone: (1) 4568
IPTC URSI
International Press Telecommunications Council Union Radio-Scientifique Internationale
Studio House, Hen and Chickens Court, 184 Fleet Street, 32 avenue Albert Lancaster, B 1180 Brussels, Belgium
London EC4A 2DU, UK Telephone: (02) 374 13 08
Telephone: (01) 405 26 08
URTNA
ITU Union des Radiodiffusions et Televisions Nationales
International Telecommunication Union d'Afrique
Place des Nations, CH 1211 Geneva 20, Switzerland 101, rue Carnot, Boite postale 3237, Dakar, Senegal
Telephone: (022) 34 60 21 Telex: 23000 Telephone: 21 16 25 Telex: 650 URTNA SG
144
SECTION Ill
Albania
AFGHANISTAN
Broadcasting
ALBANIA
Broadcasting
Radiotelevisione Shqiptar
Rruga Ismail Qemali, Tirane
Telephone: 3239
147
Algeria
ALGERIA
Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications There are no national facilities. Algeria uses Intelsat,
4 Boulevard Salah Bouakouir, Algiers Intersputnik, Inmarsat and Arabsat. Thin-route telephony
Telephone: 611220 Telex: 52020 GENTEL ALGER; 52022 and receive-only TV services are provided via 1 V2 transpon-
SECGEN ALGER ders leased from Intelsat on a pre-eruptible basis. A domestic
satellite system with 19 permanent and one transportable
earth station is planned.
Broadcasting
Earth Station Facilities
Radiodiffusion Television Algerienne
21 Boulevard des Martyrs, Algiers Antenna Date
Telephone: 602350 Telex: 52042 RT A ALGER System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Lakhdaria-1 A IP 25 June 1975
Intelsat Lakhdaria-3 A AP 13 January 1977
Membership of International Organizations Domsat: 15 earth stations, 11m antenna, provide access for
the domestic satellite system, via Intelsat.
Arabsat: one main earth station with an 11-12m diameter
Organization Date of Membership %Share antenna.
ITU 1963 0.2544529 Inmarsat: one coastal earth station with an 11-13m diameter
Intelsat 1973 0.362102 antenna.
Arabsat 1976 0.9 Eutelsat/Eurovision: A transmit/receive earth station, 10-15m
Inmarsat 1979 0.05 diameter antenna, may be built.
ANGOLA
148
Argentina
Broadcasting
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Antigua Broadcasting Service Intelsat StJohn's B A2 12 December 1984
PO Box 1280, StJohn's
Telephone: (46) 20012 Telex: 2090 TELCO AK
ARGENTINA
The Secretary of State for Communications controls telecom-
Government Departments munications via two monopolies (see below, Encotel and
Entel), and regulates public and private broadcasting.
Secretaria de Comunicaciones
Direccion General de Asuntos Internacionales Telecommunications
4° Pi so, Corrientes 132, Oficina 71, 1000 Buenos Aires
Telephone: 33 94 51 Telex: 21706
Empresa Nacional de Correos y Telegrafos (Encotel)
Sarmiento 151, Oficina 309, 1000 Buenos Aires
Secretaria de Comunicaciones Telephone: (1) 3113748 Telex: 22045 Fax: (1) 312 5060
Sarmiento 189, 1041 Buenos Aires
Telephone: (1) 392 0367 Encotel operates all telegraphy services.
149
Ascension Island
Empresa Nacional de Telecomunicaciones (Entel)
Rivadavia 622, 2° Piso, 1002 Buenos Aires Space Segment
Telephone: 49 97 87 Telex: 18511 ENTSI AR
Fax: (1) 311 4385
Uses Intelsat and Inmarsat. Domestic and national services
are provided via Intelsat transponder leases. However, the
Entel is the national telecommunications organization
government plans to replace the country's current Intelsat
responsible for the operation and development of the
transponder leasing with a domestic system called Argentsat
telecommunications networks.
(or Nahuel). In April 1985, it filed with the ITU for two
positions in the geosynchronous orbit, at 80°W and 85°~,
both of which were granted. The system will provide
Broadcasting inter-urban and rural telephony services, national and
regional TV distribution and data transmission. Current plans
envisage a high-power (320-360 watts) system. It IS not
Direccion Nacional del Servicio Oficial de Radiodifusion expected to be in service before 1990.
Ayacucho 1156, 1112 Buenos Aires
Telephone: (1) 821 1120 Telex: 21250 RADIODIF AR
Existing
Space
Antenna Date
Comision Nacional de Investigaciones Espaciales System Location type Coverage operational
Dorrego 4010, 1425 Buenos Aires Intelsat Balcarce-1 A AP 15 September 1969
Telephone: 772 5474 or 771 5258 Telex: 17511 LANBA AR Intelsat Balcarce-2 A A2 17 March 1972
Intelsat Bosque
Alegre A AI 16 September 1982
(Cordoba)
Membership of International Organizations The Inmarsat coastal earth station has an 11-13m diameter
Atlantic Ocean region antenna.
Organization Date of Membership % Share
ITU 1889 0.7633587
Planned
Intelsat 1973 1.152640
38 earth stations are currently being installed to use the 1Y2
Inmarsat 1979 0.14750
transponders leased from Intelsat. Twenty-one additional
Cite!
earth stations will be built to complete the national system.
ASCENSION ISLAND
Government Department Membership of International Organizations
The Council Acsension Island is not a member of the ITU nor Intelsat
Jamestown, St Helena
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Cable & Wireless pic
Jamestown, St Helena
Telephone: 247 6222
Earth Station Facilities
150
Australia
AUSTRALIA
national system. About 80% of the Australian population
Government Department lives in the narrow eastern and south-eastern coastal parts of
Australia. But about 300,000 Australians live in rural regions
outside the coverage area of the national broadcasting
Department of Transport and Communications stations and conventional telecommunications distribution
PO Box 34, Belconnen, ACT 2616 points and a further 1 million have been unable to receive
Telephone: (62) 641177 Telex: 62025 SECCOM AA satisfactory signals from the ABC's radio and television
Fax: (62) 644 000 services. All of this has changed with the introduction of the
Aussat system in 1985-86.
Telecommunications
Domestic System
Overseas Telecommunications Commission
PO Box 7000, Sydney, NSW 2001 A domestic lease on Intelsat has been used to distribute ABC
Telephone: (2) 230 5000 Telex: 20591 OTCOM AA programmes as well as telephony, etc. However, a domestic
Fax: (2) 230 5617 system is now operational.
The Aussat system is owned and operated by Aussat
Australian Telecommunications Commission Proprietary Ltd, which was established on 6 November 1981
Communications House, 199 William Street, Melbourne, as a wholly-owned government body and is now owned 75%
Victoria 3001 by the Australian government and 25% by Telecom
Telephone: (3) 606 5511 Telex: 30146 TELECOM AA Australia.
The Aussat system was built by Hughes. It consists of two
satellites, Aussat I and 2. An in-orbit spare completes the
system.
Broadcasting
The Aussat system provides the following services:
• Homestead and Community Broadcasting Satellite Service
Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) (HCBSS) is the prime purpose. Four 30-watt transponders
Box 487, Sydney, NSW 200 I on each satellite operate in four contiguous spot beams
Telephone: (2) 339 0211 Telex: 26889 covering all Australia. The HACBSS will broadcast ABC
radio and television programmes direct to all those people
beyond the reach of the terrestrial networks (300,000) or
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal located in places of difficult or partial reception
153 Walker Street, N. Sydney, NSW 2060 (1,000,000). The HACBSS was set up by the Australian
Telephone: 922 2900 Telex: ABTEE 26683 government and is run by the Australian Broadcasting
Corporation. The HACBSS will be transmitted from the
state capital of each region- Sydney (Southeast); Darwin
Satellite Operators (Central); Brisbane (Northeast); Perth (Western).
• Remote Commercial Television Service (RCTS) is a
commercial version of HCBSS. Four new licences have
Aussat Pty Ltd been granted to commercial companies (one in each
MLC Centre, 19 Martin Place, Sydney 2000 region).
Telephone: 238 7800 Telex: 26921 AUSSAT AA • long-distance telephony;
• telecommunications and broadcasting services for Papua
New Guinea;
Membership of International Organizations • business communications services like teleconferencing
and high speed digital transmission;
• programme feeds for the Australian Broadcasting Cor-
Organization Date of Membership %Share poration (five 12-watt transponders); .
ITU 1978 4.5801526 • programme feeds (encrypted) for the commercial tele-
lntelsat 1973 3.159546 vision networks (seven 12-watt transponders);
Inmarsat 1979 1.31243 • distance education by the Special Broadcasting Service
(SBS) (two transponders);
• aeronautical, marine and land-based transport com-
munications for the Department of Transport.
Space Segment Although Aussat was conceived as a national satellite it has
always had a regional orientation. A Memorandum of
Understanding was agreed with Papua New Guinea in 1982,
Australia uses both Intelsat and Inmarsat. Aussat is the whereby PNG could access the system directly and lease
151
Austria
capacity. The Aussat board also agreed in 1985 to modify communities may form cooperatives to purchase and install
Aussat 3 so that it could provide better coverage of the south TYRO earth station antenna with diameters of 2.4-3m. The
west Pacific, including New Zealand. signals will then be distributed to individual homes by coaxial
cable or via low-power TV transmitters.
Aussat
AUSTRIA
152
Bahrain
BAHAMAS
BAHRAIN
153
Bangladesh
Planned
Space Segment One land-based mobile earth station is being built for
maritime communications via Inmarsat.
Uses Intelsat, Inmarsat and Arabsat.
Existing
Amenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Ras Abn Jarjur-1 A A2 14July1969
Intelsat Ras Abn Jarjur-2 A 1P 9 February 1980
Arabsat Ras Abn Jarjur 11-12m Arabsat1986
BANGLADESH
Government Departments Membership of International Organizations
Ministry of Posts, Telegraphs and Telephones Organization Date of Joining o/c Share
Bangladesh Secretariat, Dhaka 2 ITU 1973 0.0318066
Intelsat 1976 0.104614
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting
Bangladesh Secretariat, Dhaka 2
Space Segment
Uses Intelsat.
Telecommunications
Earth Station Facilities
Telegraph and Telephone Board of Bangladesh
Central Office, Telejogajog Bhaban 36/1 Mymensing Road,
Dhakar 27 Existing
Telephone: (2) 316 444 Telex: 642020 BTTB BJ
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Betbunia A IP 24 April1975
Broadcasting Intelsat Talibabad B IP 30 December 1981
154
Belgium
BARBADOS
BELGIUM
Kabinet van de Gemeenschap- Minister van Kultur Belgische Radio en Televisie (BRT)
Jozef II Straat 30, B-1040 Brussels Omroepcentrum, A Reyerslaan 52, B-1040 Brussels
Telephone: (2) 219 02 37 Telephone: 737 3111 Telex: 22486
155
Belize
Radiodiffusion Television Beige de Ia Communaute Culturelle
Fran"aise (RTBF) Space Segment
Boulevard Auguste Reyers 52, B-1040 Brussels
Telephone: 737 2111 Telex: 21010 RTBF JTV BRU
Uses Intelsat, Entelsat & Inmarsat.
Space
BELIZE
Government Departments Membership of International Organizations
Broadcasting
Radio Belize
PO Box 89, Belize City
Telephone: (02) 72468
156
Bermuda
BENIN
Uses Intelsat.
Broadcasting
Earth Station Facilities
Office de Radiodiffusion et Television du Benin
BP 366, Cotonou
Telephone: 312041 Telex: ORTB 5132 Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Abomey-Calavi A AP 13 June 1984
BERMUDA
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Department of Telecommunications
·Court Street and Front Street, Hamilton
Telephone: (29) 5 5151 Telex: 3633 RADIO BA
Earth Station Facilities
The Bermuda Telephone Co. Ltd.
PO Box 1021, Cedar Avenue, Hamilton 5 Antenna Date
Telephone: (29) 5 1001 Telex: 3201 System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat NN (IBS) B AS June 1986
Cable & Wireless pic Intelsat Devonshire- I B Al 21 November 1978
Church Street West, Hamilton 5 lntelsat Devenshire-2 A A2 24 Aprill984
Telephone: (29) 5 4777 Telex: 3222
Broadcasting
157
Bhutan
BHUTAN
Ministry of Communications and Tourism Bhutan has no existing satellite communications facilities and
Department of Posts and Telegraphs, has no plans to install any.
Royal Government of Bhutan,
Tashichho Dzong, Thimpu
Telephone: 2296
Broadcasting
BOLIVIA
Telecommunications
Antenna Date
Empresa Nacional de Television Boliviana System Location type Coverage operational
Casilla 900, La Paz Intelsat Tiwanacu A AP 19 December 1978
Telephone: (2) 32 32 92 Telex: 2312 TV BOL
158
Brazil
BOTSWANA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
BRAZIL
<;6es, which is the holding company for both Em bra tel and the
Government Department state telephone companies. It was authorized in 1982 to
contract, install and operate Brasilsat. The Departamento de
Comunicacoes Domesticas via Sate lite (SAT) coordinates the
Ministerio das Comunica~oes
operation of all the earth stations.
Esplanada dos Ministerios, Bloco R, 6° andar, 70-044 Brasilia
Telephone: (61) 223 4992 Telex: 611994 MNCO BR;
611456 MNCO BR
Broadcasting
Departamento Nacional de Telecomunica~oes (Dentel)
Ministerio das Comunica<;6es
Telephone: Esplanada dos Ministerio, 7000 Brasilia DF Associacao Brasileria de Emissoras de Radio e Televisao
(ABERT)
Rue Barao do Flamengo 32, 4° andar, 20000 Rio de Janeiro
TVGiobo
Telecommunications rua Lopes Quintas 303
20000 Rio de Janeiro
Telephone: (21) 294 7732 Telex: 2122795 TVGB BR
Empn:sa Brasiliera de Telecomunica~oes (Embratel)
Avenida Presidente Vargas 1012, 150 Andar, 20 071 Rio de
Janeiro
Telephone: (21) 2832149 Telex: 2168182,2121810 EBTL Space
BR
Embratel is the state owned company set up in 1965 that Instituto de Pesquisas Espaciais (INPE)
operates and develops Brazil's telecommunications and tele- CP 15, 12200 Sao Jose dos Campos
vision networks. It reports to the Ministerio das Comunica- INPE is the Brazilian space research centre.
159
Brazil
EIRP 34dBW
Membership of International Organizations TWTA power (watts) 9.6
Antenna coverage South America
/TV Region 2
Organization Date of Joining %Share Status main
ITU 1877 0.7633587 Primary use Telephony/TV
Intelsat 1973 3.041419 Lease services I H Rede Globo TV
Inmarsat 1979 0.84965
5H Bandeirantes TV
CITEL
ISH Embratel:
occasional video feeds
18V Embratel:
occasional video feeds
Space Segment 24V Embratel:
occasional video feeds
160
Bulgaria
BRUNEI DARUSSALAM
Government Department Space Segment
BULGARIA
Government Department Membership of International Organizations
161
Burkina Faso
BURKINA FASO
Telecommunications
Space Segment
BURMA
162
Cameroon
BURUNDI
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Direction Generale des Transports, des Postes et
Telecommunications
BP 2390, Bujumbura Uses Intelsat.
Telephone: 22 5422
CAMEROON
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Organization of International Telecommunications
BP 1517, Yaounde
Telephone: 23 40 65 Telex: INTELCAM 8320 KN Uses Intelsat. No national system at present. However, there
are plans by Comsat General on behalf of the ministry to
lease some Intelsat transponder capacity to interlink with
Direction des Telecommunications Standard Z stations.
Yaounde
Telephone: 22 35 50 Telex: MINPOSTEL 8285KN
163
Canada
CANADA
Telesat Canada
Department of Communications 333 River Road, Ottawa, Ontario KIL SB9
Journal North Building, 300 Slater Street, Ottawa, Ontario Telephone: (613) 746 5920 Telex: 05341S4
KIAOCS
Telephone: (613) 922 0220 Telex: 053 3342 COMTEL OTT
Spar Aerospace Ltd
Fax: (613) 592 1231 6303 Airport Road, Suite 403 Mississauga, Ontario L4V IRS
Telephone: (4I6) 67S 9750 Telex: 06968923
Telecommunications
Spar Aerospace Ltd
Satellite and Aerospace Systems Division, 31025
TransCanada Highway, St Anne de Bellevue, Quebec H9X
CRTC IRS
IOO Metcalfe Street, Ottawa, Ontario KIA ONZ Telephone: (5I4) 475 2150 Telex: 05822792
Telephone: (613) 997 0313 Telex: 0534253
David Florida Laboratory
Telecom Canada Communications Research Centre, Department of
410 Laurier Avenue West, Room 1140, Box 2I40, Station D, Communications, PO Box 11490 Station H, Ottawa, Ontario
Ottawa, Ontario, KIP 6H5 K2HSS2
Telephone: (613) 560 3340 Telex: 053 4934 TCTS ADMIN
OTT ComdevLtd
I55 Sheldon Drive, Cambridge, Ontario
Teleglobe Canada Telephone: (519) 6222300 Telex: 610 366 3164
6SO Sherbrooke Street West, Montreal, Quebec H3A 2S4
Telephone: (5I4) 2S9 7272 Telex: 9IOO TGLOBE CA
Fax: (5I4) 2S9 70S3
Space Segment
CNCP Telecommunications
3300 Bloor Street West, Suite I200, West Tower, Toronto, With a population of 25 million spread across such vast
Ontario MSX 2W9 territories, Canada has long recognized the potential benefits
Telephone: (4I6) 232 6229 Telex: 06969695 CNCPFA TOR of space technology. Four early research satellites were
launched in 1962, I965, I969 and I971: the Alouette and ISIS
satellites. Canada has continued to pioneer satellite services.
In I972, Canada became the first country to operate a
Broadcasting domestic telecommunications system with a satellite in
geostationary orbit. The satellite was named Anik, the
Eskimo word for brother. Additional services and channel
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation capacity were provided with the launches of Anik-A2 (I973),
1500 Bronson Avenue, PO Box S47S, Ottawa, Ontario KIG and Anik-A3 (I975).
315 Later, Canada and the US combined their expertise to
Telephone: (613) 7241200 Telex: 062I7796 design and develop the Communications Technology Satel-
lite, Hermes. At the time of its launch in I976, Hermes was
CTV the world's most powerful satellite and the first to operate in
42 Charles Street East, Toronto, Ontario M4Y IT A the 14/I2 GHz frequency bands. The use of these bands
Telephone: (4I6) 92S 6000 Telex: 02267S allowed the use of smaller (2-3 metre diameter) and less
expensive ground stations.
The research begun with Hermes continued with Anik-B,
launched in 197S. This hybrid satellite both in the 6/4 GHz
Membership of International Organizations frequency bands, like Anik-A, and the 14/I2 GHz bands, like
Hermes. The Department of Communications (DOC) spon-
sored a number of pilot projects with the Hermes and Anik-B
Organization Date of Joining %Share
satellites including:
ITU I 90S 4.5SOI526
• Communications services at 6/4 GHz: TV, radio, two-way
lntelsat I973 2.3IS574
voice (FM/FDMA, FM/SCPC and PM/TDMA), telecon-
Inmarsat 1979 4.37929
ferencing, facsimile and data.
I64
Canada
165
Cape Verde
Telesat
Earth Station Facilities
In 1986 Telesat signed a contract with Spar for two powerful Antenna Date
Ku-bond satellites, El and E2, to be launched in 1990. System Location type Cmwage operational
Intelsat Des Laurentides A Al 11 August 1979
Intelsat Lake Cowichan-1 A pp 24 August 1972
Intelsat Lake Cowichan-2 A pp I May 1984
M-SAT Intelsat Mill Village I A A2 24 October 1966
lntelsat Mill Village 2 A AP 29 October 1969
Intelsat Mill Village 3 N AS 30 January 1981
The Canadian government announced in March 1985 its Intelsat Mill Village 4 A A2 20 June 1984
support of a commercial mobile communications satellite Inmarsat - CES
CAPE VERDE
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Empresa dos Correios e Telecomunica~;oes
Caixa Postal220, Praia
Telephone: 613126 Telex: 87 PUBLICO CV Uses Intelsat.
166
Central African Republic
CAYMAN ISLANDS
Via UK.
Executive Council.
George Town, Grand Cayman
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Cable & Wireless (West Indies) Ltd
Fort Street (PO Box 293), Grand Cayman
Telephone: 2 611 Earth Station Facilities
Antenna Date
Broadcasting System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Grand Cayman B A2 21 August 1980
Radio Cayman
PO Box 1110, George Town, Grand Cayman
Telephone: 97799
Broadcasting
Radiodiffusion-Television Centrafricaine
BP 940 Bangui
Telephone: 2355
167
Chad
CHAD
Broadcasting
CHILE
Compania de Telefonos de Chile
Government Department San Martin 50, Santiago
Telephone: (2) 86616 Telex: 240955 CTCH CL
Ministerio de Tran~portes y Telecomunicaciones
Amumltegui 139, Santiago ITT Comunicaciones Mundiales SA
Telephone: (2) 69 131 Telex: 34 1156 Huerfanos 1546, Casilla 3767, Santiago
Telephone: (2) 71 30 05 Telex: 440629 ITTCZ
168
China
Subsecretaria de Telecomunicaciones Entel has an Intelsat transponder lease, and also uses
Amunategui 139, Santiago. Inmarsat.
Postal Address: Clasificador 120, Correa 21. Santiago
Telephone: 726503 Telex: 40200
Earth Station Facilities
Membership of International Organizations
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Organization Date of Joining %Share Intelsat Longovilo-1 A AP 22July1968
ITU 1908 0.2544529 Intelsat Longovilo-2 A A2 7 October 1977
Intelsat 1973 0.578405
Inmarsat 1981 0.05
Cite!
CHINA
169
Colombia
STW-2
Type FSS
Orbital positian 103°E
Launch date February 1986
Launcher
Design life (years) 3
Number of channels: C-band 2
TWTA power (watts) 4.4
Antenna coverage China
ITU region 3
Status Experimental
Primary use Communications experiments
COLOMBIA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Empresa National de Telecomunicaciones (Telecom)
Calle 23 No 13-49, Bogota DE
Telephone: (1) 420660 Telex: 44280 ENTP CO Uses Intelsat.
Colombia does not have a national system. However,
Telecom has leased three Intelsat transponders. Plans for a
Departamento Administrativo de Aeronautica Civil national system have been abandoned and the Condor system
Aeropuerto elDorado, Bogota DE for the Andean countries is a priority.
Telephone: 669200 Telex: 44844, 44620 DAAC CO
Antenna Date
Instituto Nacional de Radio y Television System Location type Coverage operational
Avenida elDorado, Bogota DE Intelsat Choconta-1 A AI 17March 1970
Telephone: 446782 Telex: 44311 INRA CO Intelsat Choconta-2 A AP 9 June 1981
170
Cook Islands
CONGO
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Office of International Telecommunications (Intelco)
Brazzaville
Telephone: 81 16 86
Earth Station Facilities .
COOK ISLANDS
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Cable & Wireless pic
PO Box 47, Avarua, Rarotonga
Telephone: 6822 26171 Earth Station Facilities
171
Costa Rica
COSTA RICA
Antenna Date
Radiografica Costarricense SA (Racsa)
Apartado 54, San Jose System Location type Coverage operational
Telephone: 33 55 55 Telex: 1015 RACSADIV CR Intelsat Tarbaca A A1 24 November 1981
Broadcasting
CUBA
Radio Corporation of Cuba
Government Department Apartado 1130, Havana
Telephone: 68211 Telex: 511185
Ministerio de Comunicaciones
Plaza de Ia Revolucion •Jose Marti', Havana 6 Western Union Telegraph Company
Telephone: 74980 Telex: 51945 CCO MINSTRO Osibpo 351, Havana
Telephone: 69901 Telex: 571140
Telecommunications
Broadcasting
172
Czechoslovakia
Organization Date of Joining o/c Share Uses Intelsat. No domestic system at present. The govern-
ITU 1918 0.1272264 ment has plans for its own system, and has registered a launch
lntersputnik 1972 $13.000plus date of 1989. No details are available at this time.
additional
contribution
based on Earth Station Facilities
utilization of
space segment
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Caribe B A1 14 August 1979
CYPRUS
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Cyprus Telecommunications Authority
121 Prodromos Avenue, PO Box 4929, Nicosia
Telephone: (021) 77 111 Telex: 3288 CYTA ADM CY Uses Intelsat.
CZECHOSLOVA KIA
Ceskoslovenska Televize
Gorkeho nam. 29-30, CS-11150 Prague I
Telephone: (2) 2201 54 Telex: 121800 TVPG C
173
Denmark
DENMARK
Telecommunications
Membership of International Organizations
Generaldirektoratet for Post-Og Telegrafrvaesenet
Tientgensgade 37, DK-1530 Copenh_agen Organization Date of Joining '7c Share
Telephone: (1) 156610 Telex: 22323 ITU 1866 1.2722646
Fax: (1) 156610 ext. 3028 Intelsat 1974 0.384163
Inmarsat 1979 1.66142
Eutelsat 1984 3.27016
Telecommunications Direktoratet
Anker Heegards Gade 4, DK-1503 Copenhagen
Telephone: (1) 11 33 77 Telex: 27277 TELDIR DK
Space Segment
Central Telecommunications Services
Farvergade 17, DK-1007 Copenhagen
Telephone: (1) 11 66 05 Telex: 22999 TELCOM DK Uses Intelsat. No domestic system, although Denmark has
leased capacity on both Intelsat and Eutelsat satellites.
Det Store Nordiske Telegraf-Selskab
Kongens Nytbrv 28, DK-1050 Copenhagen
Telephone: (1) 12 00 88 Telex: 22371 GNTC Earth Station Facilities
174
Egypt
DIEGO GARCIA
Space Segment
Uses Intelsat.
DJIBOUTI
EGYPT
175
El Salvador
ELSALVADOR
EQUATORIAL GUINEA
176
Falkland Islands
ETHIOPIA
FALKLAND ISLANDS
General Post Office The Falkland Islands are not a member of the ITU or
Port Stanley Intelsat.
Telephone: 135
177
Fiji
FIJI
Telecommunications
Space Segment
FINLAND
178
France
Organization Date of Joining '/r Share Finland uses the Nordic earth station at Tanum. Sweden.
ITU 1920 1.2722646
Intelsat 1973 0.092776
Inmarsat 1979 0.14750
Eutelsat 1985 2.7211\1
Space Segment
FRANCE
Canal Plus
Government Department 78 rue Olivier de Serres. 75015 Paris
Telephone: (1) 4533 7474 Telex: 201141
Ministere des Postes et Telecommunications
20 avenue de Segur, 75700 Paris Cedex FR3- Societe Nationale France Regions 3
Telephone: (1) 4566 2222 Telex: 250310 GENTEL 5 avenue du Recteur Poincare, 75782 Paris Cedex 16
Fax: (1) 4654 5379 Telephone: (1) 4230 2424 Telex: 200082
Radio France
Telecommunications 116 avenue du President J.F. Kennedy, 75786 Paris Cedex 16
Telephone: (1) 4524 2424 Telex: 200002
Direction Generate des Telecommunications (DGT)
20 avenue de Segur, 75700, Paris • Television Fran~>aise 1
15-19 rue Cognacq-Jay, 75330 Paris Cedex 07
Telephone: (1) 4555 3555 Telex: 260003
Service des affairs internationales (SAl)
38-40 rue du General-Leclerc, F 92131 Issy les Moulineaux
Telephone: 566 22 22 Telex: GENTE X 200773 F Telediffusion de France (TdF)
Fax: (1) 4538 7068 21-27 rue Barbes, BP No 518, F 92542 Montrouge
Telephone: 6571115 Telex: DIR TDF 250738 F
Fax: (1) 4654 3201
Centre National d'Etudes des Telecommunications
38-40 rue du General Leclerc, 92131 Issy les Moulineaux
Telephone: ( 1) 4638 4444 Telex: 250317
Secretariat d'Etat aux techniques de Ia communication Satellite and Launch Vehicle Manufacturers
35 rue St Dominique, 75700 Paris
Telephone: ( 1) 4550 3250
Aerospatiale
37 blvd de Montmorency, 75781 Paris Cedex 16
France Cables et Radio (FCR) Telephone: (1) 45244321 Telex: 620059
124 rue Reamur, F-75091 Paris
Telephone: 4221 7171 Telex: FCR X 220731
Aerospatiale
Space and Ballistics Division, BP 96, 78133 Les Mureaux.
Paris Cedex 16
Broadcasting Telephone: (3) 4750123 Telex: 698850 F
179
France
Alcatel Thomson Espace not only in Europe but in many other countries including
Industrial Plant, 26 avenue JF Champollion, Z1 Thibaud, China and India. It was operational from 1967-72.
PO Box 1187, 31037 Toulouse France has launched the Telecom series of satellites as
Telephone: (61) 41 5777 successors to the Symphonie series. The Telecom system is
Manufacturer of satellite payloads and subsystems. the only national satellite communications system in Europe.
(Eutelsat and Intelsat provide the vast majority of telecom-
Arianespace munications capacity required by the European PTTs.)
1 rue Soljenitsyne, 91000 Evry There are currently two Telecom satellites in orbit,
Telephone: 6087 6000 Telex: 692392 ARESP F Telecom-I and Telecom-II. They were launched in 1984 and
Operators of the Ariane launch system. 1985, respectively. Telecom-II, the last of the series, is
expected to be launched in 1987/8.
Crouzet The satellites are used for: occasional transmission of TV
25 rue Jules Vedrines, 26027 Valence Cedex signals; TDMA (time division multiple access) business
Telephone: (75) 79 85 11 Telex: 345807 communications as part of Eutelsat's Satellite Multi-Service;
Fax: 55 22 50 French military communications.
Matra Telecom I
Space Branch, 10 avenue Kleber, 75116 Paris Type FSS
Telephone: (1) 450152 20 Telex: 613039 MATFIN F Orbital position 8°W
Fax: (1) 4501 82 42 Launch date August 1984
Launcher Ariane
Matra Design life (years) 7
Headquarters, 4 rue de Presbourg, 75116 Paris Number of channels C-band: 4
Telephone: (1) 4723 5404 Telex: 698077 Ku-band: 6
Fax: (1) 4501 82 42 TWTA power (watts) C-band: 8.5
Matra satellites include Eutelsat 1 - F1-F3 and Telecom Ku-band: 20
1A-1B. Matra manages the SPOT observation satellite Antenna coverage C-band: Atlantic Ocean Region
programme. Consortia: Satcom International. Ku-band: France
ITU region 1
ThomsonCSF
Status Main
Division Tubes Electroniques, 38 rue Vauthier, BP 305,
Primary use Telephony
921302 Boulogne Bilancourt
Services 1 Agence d'Images TV
Telephone: (1) 4604 8175 Telex: 204780 TCSF F
Francaise
2 Occasional video
Space Research 3 Occasional video
5 Worldnet
Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales 6 Canal J
2 Place Maurice Quentin. 75001 Paris NB: 4 of the 6 K-band
Telephone: 4508 75 00 transponders have been
CNES is the national space research centre. leased by Eutelsat for SMS.
180
Gabon
will have four TV channels transmitting at about 230 watts in
the 12 GHz band. French Guiana
There are also plans for a national Videosat system
providing specialized telecommunications services at 1-3 GHz
and 12 GHZ. Two satellites will be placed at 32° east and
Antenna Date
37.5° west, and used for telephony and video. However, the System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Tron Biran-1 A AP 6 May 1974
plans are not confirmed.
Intelsat Tron Biran-2 B AS 4 October 1984
France was the major partner in the consortium set up by
the European Space Agency to develop the Ariane rocket.
French interests have the major share in Arianespace, the
company that operates the launcher. Martinique
Antenna Date
Earth Station Facilities System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Trois Islets A AP 21 January 1972
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
New Caledonia
Intelsat Bercenav-en-Othe I A AP 13 March 1978
Intelsat Bercena~-en-Othe 2 A II 19 July 1980
Intelsat Bercena~-en-Othe 3 C AP I September 1981 Antenna Date
Intelsat Bercenay-en-Othe 4 A II 24 March 1983 System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Pleumer-Bodou-1 A AS 28June 1965 Intelsat L'Ile Non A pp 21 July 1976
Intelsat Pleumer-Bodou-2 A AS 3 November 1969
Intelsat Pleumer-Bodou-3 A AI 22 January 1974
Intelsat Pleumer-Bodou-4 A IP 24 May 1976
Intelsat Pleumer-Bodou-6 A A2 16 January 1984 Polynesia
Intelsat Pleumer-Bodou-7 A AI 15 January 1985
lntelsat Rambouillet-1 c AI 15 January 1985
Antenna Date
The French administration also operates several earth stations in the French System Location type Coverage operational
overseas territories. Intelsat Papenoo B pp 2 May 1978
GABON
Radio Television Gabonaise
Government Department BP 150, Libreville
Antenna Date
Broadcasting System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Franceville A AP December 1987
Radiodiffusion Television Gabonaise Intelsat N'Koltang-1 A AP 14 June 1973
BP 10150, Libreville, and BP 776 Franceville Intelsat N'Koltang-2 B Al 7 May 1981
181
Gambia
GAMBIA
Broadcasting
GERMANY (DDR)
182
Germany (FRG)
GERMANY (FRG)
Radio Bremen
Government Department & Telecommunications Heinrich Hertz Strasse 13, D 2800 Bremen 33
Telephone: (0421) 23841 Telex: 245181 RB D
Deutsche Forschungs und Versuchsanstalt fur Luft und Sender Freies Berlin (SFB)
Raumfahrt (DFVLR) Masurenallee 8-14, 1000 Berlin 19
E. V. Linder Hoe her, 5000 Cologne 90 Telephone: (030) 3081 Telex: 182813 SFB D
Telephone: (2203) 60 11 Telex: 8874410
Suddeutscher Rundfunk (SDR)
Fernmeldetechnisches Zentralamt (ZMT) Neckarstrasse 230, Postfach 837, D 7000 Stuttgart 1
Am Kavalleriesand 3, D-6100 Darmstadt Telephone: (0711) 2881 Telex: 723456 SDRS D
Telephone: (6151) 831 Telex: 419511 FTZ D
Sudwestfunk (SWF)
Fax: (6151) 834791 Hans Bredow Strasse, Postfach 820, D 7570 Baden Baden
Telephone: (07221) 2761 Telex: 0787810 SWF D
Broadcasting
183
Ghana
GHANA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Posts and Telecommunications Corporation
Accra
Uses Intelsat.
Telephone: 22000 Telex: 2010 ENG HQ ACCRA
184
Grenada
GREECE
Government Department Membership of International Organizations
GRENADA
Government Department Broadcasting
Space Segment
Uses lntelsat.
Telecommunications
Earth Station Facilities
Cable & Wireless (West Indies)
Mercury House, The Carenage, St. George's An Intelsat standard N station, linking with the Atlantic
Telephone: 2200 Telex: WB 411 satellite, was opened at Des on 17 February 1986.
185
Guatemala
GUATEMALA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
GUINEA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Direction Generate des Telecommunications
Conakry Uses Intelsat.
Telephone: (4) 412 05 Telex: 607
186
Guyana
GUINEA BISSAU
Secretario de Estado dos Correios e Telecomunica~oes International satellite circuits are currently provided through
CP 200, Bissau Senegal or the Republic of Guinea. There is a HF radio link
Telephone: 212 914 Telex: 240 PUBLICO BL with the Cape Verde Republic.
GUYANA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Guyana Telecommunications Corporation
PO Box 10628, Georgetown Uses Intelsat.
Telephone: 0279 Telex: 2208 GTC COM GY; 2216
GYTELCOGY
Earth Station Facilities
Broadcasting
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Guyana Broadcasting Corporation Al 26 January 1979
Intelsat Georgetown-! B
PO Box 10760, Georgetown
Telephone: (02) 6923115
187
Haiti
HAITI
Telecommunications
Space Segment
HONDURAS
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Empresa Hondurena de Telecomunicaciones (Hondutel)
Apartado Postal1794, Tegucigalpa DC Uses Intelsat.
Telephone: 222000 Telex: 1220 HONDUTEL HT
188
Hungary
HONG KONG
Via UK.
Telecommunications
HUNGARY
Magyar Radio
Telecommunications VIII Brody Sandor utca 5-7, Budapest 1800
Telephone: 338300 Telex: 225362 MRHIR H; 225188
MARAD H
Posta Kosponti Taviro Hivatel (Central Posts and Telegraph
Office)
V. Varoshaz utca 18, PF 1 1364, Budapest
Telephone: (01) 180 050
189
Iceland
ICELAND
Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications Iceland uses Intelsat and leases some lntelsat capacity.
PO Box 270. 121 Reykjavik
Telephone: (91) 26000 Telex: 2000 GENTEL IS
Earth Station Facilities
Broadcasting
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Rikisutvarpid-Sjonvarp (Icelandic State Broadcasting Service) Intelsat Skyggnir-1 A AP 25 September 1980
Laugaugavegur 176, Reykjavik
INDIA
190
India
Space lnsat JB
Manufacturer Ford Aerospace
Orbital position 74° E
INSAT Launch date September 1983
Department of Space, Government of India, New Delhi 52, Launcher NASA
1/Bajh Design life (years) 7
Number of channels C-band 12
S-band 2
Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) TWTA power (watts) C-band: 4.5
Ahmedabad 380 053 S-band: 50
Telephone: 443296 EIRP: C-band 32dBW
S-band 42dBW
Antenna coverage Indian Subcontinent
Membership of International Organizations ITUregion 3
Status Main
Primary use Telephony,
Organization Date of Joining '7c Share Direct Broadcasting
ITU 1869 2.5445292 Services S-band:
Intelsat 1973 1.()6 Doordarshan
Inmarsat 1979 0.51869
Since 1979, India has used an Intelsat ocean transponder for
part of its domestic telecommunication links. The system uses
two main stations in New Delhi and Madras and five remote
Space Segment stations in Port Blair, Nicobar, Kavaratti, Leh and Aizwal. In
1982, following the failure of Insat-1A, two full Intelsat
transponders were leased until Insat-1B became fully oper-
The first Indian satellite was the experimental Aryabhata ationaL One transponder on Statsionar-6 was leased for TV
(named after a fourth century astronomer) which the USSR distribution for the same reason.
launched on 19 April 1975. After several experiments the
satellite stopped functioning.
Later, India used two foreign satellites to carry out
experiments in domestic services. The Franco-German Sym- Earth Station Facilities
phonie satellite was used to conduct experiments with fixed,
mobile and emergency earth stations. A more important
experiment, the Satellite Instructional Television Experiment Antenna Date
(SITE), was provided by NASA's Application Technology·
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Ahmed A I1 27 December 1976
Satellite (ATS-6) repositioned above the Indian Ocean. With
Intelsat Vikram-1 A 1P 21 February 1971
2,400 television sets in as many Indian villages, SITE
Intelsat Vikram-2 A I1 June 1988
programmes were broadcast on educational and general
Inmarsat Belepur CES I 1985
matters.
191
Indonesia
INDONESIA
Republic announced its decision to develop and operate a
Government Department communications satellite system. The Hughes Aircraft Com-
pany was commissioned to design and construct the
spacecraft (two HS 3330 satellites) and two base stations on
Ministry of Communications the island of Java, one at Jakarta and one at Surabaya.
Directorate General of Posts and Telecommunications, Jalan Another four earth stations were built by ITT and Ford
Kebon Sirih 37, Jakarta Aeronautics. On 8 July 1976, NASA launched the first
Telephone: (21) 346000 Telex: 44407 POSTEL IA Indonesian satellite, Palapa-A1, and the system was officially
opened on 16 August 1976. A2 was launched on 10 March
1977. The system was used solely for domestic television and
Telecommunications telephone traffic until23 June 1978 when a lease contract was
signed between Indonesia and the Philippines for Domsat-
phil, the Philippine Satellite Telecommunications Company,
Perum Telekomunikasi (Perumtel) to use Palapa for domestic purposes in the Philippines. Later
Jalan Cisanggarung 2, Bandung Thailand and Malaysia signed similar agreements.
Telephone: 59100 Telex: 28200 DIRUTTEL BD At the extraordinary meeting of the fourth Assembly of
and Parties of Intelsat, held in Manila on 2-3 April 1979, it was
J alan Kebon Sirih 37, Jakarta agreed that Palapa's second generation, the Palapa-B series,
Telephone: (21) 345083 could be used as a regional system (the second such system,
Telex: 4407 POSTEL IIA after Eutelsat). The satellite system remains wholly-owned by
the Indonesian government and operated on its behalf by
Perumtel. So far, four member countries of the Association
Broadcasting of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) have entered into
agreements with Permute! to lease some capacity. They are:
Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand and Singapore.
Radio Republik Indonesia The Palapa-B satellites, also built by the Hughes Corpora-
Jalan Merdeka Barat 4-5, Jakarta tion, are nearly twice as powerful as the first generation,
Telephone: (21) 377 508 (both of which have been retired). Capacity has doubled to 24
transponders. Palapa-Bl was successfully launched in June
1983. Palapa-B2 was launched on 6 February 1984 but a
Televisi Republik Indonesia
failure in one of the rockets caused it to remain in a useless
Pusat Senayan, Jakarta
orbit. A replacement B2P was launched successfully in March
Telephone: 582 160
1987.
PALAPA-A PALAPA-B
Membership of International Organizations
Manufacturer Hughes Hughes
Orbital position 83° E, 77o E 108° E, ll8° E
Organization Date of Joining %Share Launch date 1976, 1977 1983, (1984), 1987
ITU 1949 0.2544529 Launch vehicle Delta STS
Intelsat 1973 0.498731 Design life (years) 7 8
A SEAN 1967 Frequency bands 3.7/4.2 GHz 3.7/4.2 GHz
Transponders 12 24
Power 5 watts 10 watts
EIRP 32 (Indonesia) 34 (Indonesia)
Space 27 (ASEAN) 32 (ASEAN)
Space Segment
192
Iran
Sub total 8 12
ASEAN:
Philippines 1 V2 3V2
Thailand 3
Malaysia 1 V2
Occasional
ASEAN TV
IRAN
Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications Uses Intelsat and Inmarsat. Transponder capacity is leased
Directorate General of Telecommunications, Dr Shariati from Intelsat for domestic telecommunications and television
Avenue PO Box 931, 16314 Teheran distribution. TCI is planning a national satellite system
Telephone: 84 36 12 Telex: 212444 PTT IR (ZOHREH) and has registered orbital slots at 26°, 34°, 47°
and 41 o East. TC1 has also agreed to purchase two transpon-
ders on an Intelsat satellite at 60° east.
Telecommunications
193
Iraq
IRAQ
IRELAND
Government Departments Broadcasting
Department of Communications
Kildare Street, Dublin 2 Satellite Companies
Telephone: (1) 71 8211 Telex: 25323 PTHQEI
Atlantic Satellites
15 Kildare Street, Dublin 2
Telecommunications Telephone: (1) 606900 Telex: 90696 PDF EI
Telecom Eireann
St Stephens Green, Dublin 2
Telephone: (1) 714444 Telex: 91119 TEHQ EI
194
Israel
Space Segment
ISRAEL
Ministry of Communications Uses Intelsat for occasional use and has also purchased two
Directorate General. 91999 Jerusalem Intelsat transponders. There are plans for a national satellite
Telephone: 230222 Telex: 26381 GENTEL IL system (AMS) consisting of two spacecraft providing services
at 3.4/3.95 GHz. 11112 GHz and 20/60 GHz. They will be
colocated at 15° East.
Telecommunications
195
Italy
ITALY
Broadcasting
196
Jamaica
IVORY COAST
Telecommunications
Earth Station Facilities
Societe de Telecommunications Internationale de Ia Cote
d'lvoire (lntelci) Antenna Date
BP 1838, Abidjan OL System Location type Coverage operational
Telephone: 32 49 85 Telex: 23790 INTELCI ABIDJAN lntelsat Abidjan-1 A A1 10 August 1972
Intelsat Abidjan-2 A AP 5 November 1980
Office National des Telecommunications (ONT)
01 Bolte Postale 1838, Abidjan 01, Abidjan 17
Telephone: 34 60 00 Telex: 23790 ONT ABIDJAN
Broadcasting
JAMAICA
Government Departments
Ministry of Public Utilities, Communications and Transport The Jamaica Telephone Co Ltd
47 Half Way Tree Road, PO Box 21, Kingston 5
Telecommunications Services, Post Office Headquarters, PO
Telephone: (809) 926 9700 Telex: 2184 TELCO JA
Box 7000, Kingston
Telephone: (809) 922 2400 Telex: 2133 POTELSKN JA
Post Office Broadcasting
Telecommunications Services
PO Box 700, Kingston
Telephone: (809) 922 9430 Telex: 2133 POTELSKN JA Jamaica Broadcasting Corporation
5 South Odean Avenue, PO Box 100, Kingston 10
Telecommunications Telephone: (809) 926 5620
197
Japan
Space Segment
Uses Intelsat.
JAPAN
NTV (Nippon Television)
Government Department 14 Nibancho, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 102
Telephone: (3) 263 6008 Telex: 24723 Fax: (3) 265 2111
Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications
No 3-2 Kasumigaseki 1-chome, Chiyoda ku, Tokyo 100 TV Tokyo (Channe112)
Telephone: (3) 504 4757 Telex: J 29100 4-3-12 Toranomon, Minato-ku, Tokyo 105
Telephone: (3) 432 1212 Telex: 4321280 Fax: (3) 432 1407
198
Japan
BS-2A (Yuri)
Space Segment Orbital position 110° E
Launch date January 1984
Launcher NASDA
Japan's space programme began when a meteorological Design life (years) 5
satellite was launched on 14 July 1977 by NASA. Later that Number of channels: C-band 3
year the first communications satellite was launched, the Ku-band -
CS-1A or ·sakura'. CS-lA and CS-18 were experimental Antenna coverage: C-band All Japan
satellites with a design life of three years. An experimental
Ku-band 3
broadcasting satellite, 8SE, was launched in 1978. /TV region Main
In 1983 the next generation of two CS- spacecraft wa; Status Television
launched to provide an operational service. Their main Primary use NHK TV, Tokyo
function is to provide telecommunications to Japan's many Services Various communications
remote islands. When the CS-2 series ends in 1987/8.
NASDA plans to continue with CS-3, also consisting of two
spacecraft. CS-3A and CS-38 are planned to be launched in BS-2B (Yuri)
1988. Orbital position 110° E
In 1984, Japan launched its (and the world's) first oper- Launch date February 1986
ational direct broadcast satellite. 8S-2A or Yuri (after the Launcher NASDA
Japanese word for 'lily'). The satellite has three transponders, Design life (years) 5
two of which failed soon after launch. A second Yuri (8528) Number of channels: C-band 3
was launched in February 1986 and has worked much better. Ku-band -
Japan has several applications satellites: GMS-3 (launched Antenna coverage: C-band All Japan
1984) for meteorology; EXOS-C (launched 1984) for space Ku-band 3
research; and MOS-1 (launched 1986) for marine observa- /TV region Main
tion. Status Television
When Japan's telecommunications sector was opened to Primary use NHK TV, Tokyo
competition in April 1985. it became possible for private Services Various communications
entities to launch and operate communications satellites. The
Japanese Satellite Communications Corporation (JSC) a joint
venture of C. Itoh, Mitsui and Hughes, received approval
from the Ministry of Telecommunications to offer basic Earth Station Facilities
communications services over a private system. The launches
are scheduled for December 1987 and April 1988.
Japan has its own launch facilities which are operated by
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
NASDA at Tanegashina.
Intelsat Ibaraki I A PS 26 March 1968
Intelsat Ibaraki 2 A PS 21 September 1971
CS-2A (Sakura-2A)
Intelsat Ibaraki 3 A PP 15 December 1983
Orbital position 132° E
Intelsat Okinawa 8 PS 1986
Launch date February 1983
Intelsat Yamaguchi 2 A IP 6 October 1980
Launcher NASDA
Intelsat Yamaguchi 3 A II 14 February 1985
Design life (years) 3
Inmarsat Yamaguchi CES
Number of channels: C-band 2
Inmarsat Ibaraki CES
Ku-band 6
Antenna coverage: C-band All Japan
Ku-band Main island
/TV region 3
Status NK
Primary use Telephony
Services Various communications
CS-2B (Sakura-2B)
Orbital position 136° E
Launch date August 1983
Launcher NASDA
Design life (years) 3
Number of channels: C-band 2
Ku-band 6
Antenna coverage: C-band All Japan
Ku-band Main island
/TV region 3
Status NK
Primary use Telephony
Services Various communications
199
Jordan
JORDAN
Government Department Membership of International Organizations
Broadcasting
Earth Station Facilities
KAMPUCHEA
Broadcasting None.
200
Kiribati
KENYA
Uses Intelsat.
Telecommunications
Voice of Kenya
PO Box 30456, Harry Thuku Road, Nairobi
Telephone: 334567 Telex: 22244
KIRIBATI
Antenna Date
Broadcasting System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Bairiki B PP 27 May 1985
Intelsat Christmas Island B PP 10 January 1981
Radio Kiribati
PO Box 78, Bairiki, Tarawa
201
Korea, PDR
KOREA,PDR
KOREA
202
Kuwait
Space Segment
KUWAIT
203
Laos
LAOS
Government Department and Telecommunications Space Segment
LEBANON
Government Department and Telecommunications Space Segment
Ministere de l'lnformation
Beirut Lebanon has two Intelsat Standard A stations at Arbaniyeh
but both were damaged on 7 May 1983 and are not in service.
There are separate stations for Arabsat, Eutelsat and the UN.
Membership of International Organizations
204
Liberia
LESOTHO
Telecommunications
Space Segment
LIBERIA
Broadcasting Antenna
System Location type Coverage
Intelsat Sinkor B A1
Liberian Broadcasting Corporation
Inmarsat Sinkor CES AOR
PO Box 594, Monrovia
205
Libya
LIBYA
LIECHTENSTEIN
Regierung des Furstentums Liechteinstein, FL 9490 Vaduz Organization Date of Joining o/c Share
66317 ITU 1963 0.1272264
Telephone: 77855 IPRDZ FL Intelsat 1973 0.05
Eutelsat 1983 0.05
206
Macao
LUXEMBOURG
Government Department Membership of International Organizations
Telecommunications
Space Segment
MACAO
Government Department Telecommunications
207
Madagascar
via Portugal.
MADAGASCAR
Telecommunications
Space Segment
MALAWI
208
Maldives
MALAYSIA
Antenna Date
Radio Television Malaysia (RTM)
System Location type Coverage operational
Department of Broadcasting, Angkasapuri, Kuala Lumpur
Intelsat Kuantan A PP 16 March 1970
2210
lntelsat Melaka A 1P 28 August 1980
Telephone: (3) 44 5333 Telex: 31383 (TV); 30283 (radio) Palapa Kuantan
Palapa Kota Kinabula
Britarafon Sdn Bhd
c/o PO Box 10233, Kuala Lumpur 01 02
Telephone: (3) 248 2470 Telex: MA 31167
MALDIVES
209
Mali
MALI
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Societe de Telecommunications Internationales du Mali (TIM)
BP 273, Bamako
Telephone: 2259 33
Earth Station Facilities
Antenna Date
Broadcasting System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Sullymanbougoul 1 B A1 15 December 1976
Intelsat Sullymanbougoul 2 B AP 19 September 1977
Radiodiffusion Nationale du Mali
Intelsat Sullymanbougoul 3 A A1 1986
BP 171, Bamako
MALTA
210
Mauritania
Malta Broadcasting Authority Malta has no facilities at present and does not use Intelsat or
Attard Buildings, National Road, Blata I Bajda Eutelsat. However, an Intelsat Standard B station is being
built to access the Atlantic path.
Xandir Malta
PO Box 82, Gwardamanga
Telephone: 25051 Telex: (406) 1443 XANDIR MW
MAURITANIA
211
Mauritius
MAURITIUS
Government Department~ Space Segment
MEXICO
Departamento de Informacion y Estadistica
Government Department Guanajuato No 125, 7° piso, Mexico 7
Telecommunications
Organization Date of Joining %Share
ITU 1908 0.2544529
Telefonos de Mexico SA Intelsat 1973 1.818184
Parque Via 198, Mexico 5, DF Cite!
Telephone: 1771233 TELME Telex: 1771233
Broadcasting
212
Monaco
Morelos-2 (SMS)
Space Segment Manufacturer Hughes (376)
Orbital position 116SW
Launch date November 1985
Mexico has its own national space system (Morelos) and also Launcher NASA
uses Intelsat. Until Morelos became operational in 1986, Frequency band 4/6 GHz, 12/14 GHz
Mexico leased capacity on both Intelsat and Westar. Number of channels C-band 12
The Morelos system (named after a hero of Mexican Ku-band 4
independence) consists of two satellites, one operational and TWTA power (Watts) C-band 7
one in-orbit spare. Additional spacecraft are planned. A key Ku-band 20
feature of the system is the large number of earth stations (up ITU region 2
to 6,000). Status In-orbit space
Primary use Telephony
Morelos-1 (SMS)
Manufacturer Hughes (376)
Orbital position 113SW
Launch date June 1985 Earth Station Facilities
Launcher NASA
Design life (years) 10
Frequency band 4/6 GHz; 12/14 GHz Antenna Date
Number of channels C-band 12 System Location type Coverage operational
Ku-band 4 Intelsat El Triunfo A PP June 1986
TWTA power (Watts) C-band 7 Intelsat Industrial B AS 15 May 1986
Ku-band 20 Hermosillo
Antenna coverage Central America Intelsat Iztapalapa-5 B AS 15 May 1986
ITU region 2 Intelsat Tulancingo-1 A Al 13 January 1969
Status Main Intelsat Tulancingo-2 A AP 9 January 1981
Primary use Telephony/TV
Services 12 XEW-TV, Mexico City
14 XHITM-TV, Mexico
City
22 XHDF-TV, Mexico City
24 XETV, Tijuana/San
Diego
MONACO
213
Mongolia
MONGOLI A
Broadcasting
Space Segment
Ulan Bator Radio
State Committee for Information, PO Box 365, Ulan Bator Uses Intersputnik.
MOROCCO
Government Departments Membership of International Organizations
214
Nauru
MOZAMBIQUE
Telecomunica.;oes de Mo.;ambique Uses an Intelsat lease for domestic service and occasional
CP 25, Maputo international use.
Telephone: 27590 Telex: 6509 DGTDM MO
NAURU
215
Nepal
NEPAL
Government Departments Membership of International Organizations
Telecommunications
Earth Station Facilities
Nepal Telecommunications Corporation
Singh a Durbar, Kathmandu Antenna Date
Telephone: 215444 Telex: NP 201 TELCOM System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Sagarmatha B IP 13 October 1982
Broadcasting
Radio Nepal
PO Box 634, Singha Durbar, Kathmandu
Telephone: 410732
NETHERLANDS
Direction des Lignes a Grande Distance et des Liaisons
Government Department Radioelectriques
Berkenweg, 3818 Ia Amersfoort
Telephone: 69 91 11 Telex: 79467 DKRUS NL
Ministerie van Welzijn Volksgezondheid en Cultuur (Ministry
of Welfare, Public Health and Culture)
Steevoordelaan 3/10, 2284 EH Rijswijk Radio Holland BV
Telephone: (70) 94 92 33 Telex: 316880 Jan Rebelstraat 20, 1007 AB Amsterdam Osdorp
Telephone: 101972 Telex: 13166 RHOL NL
Telecommunications
Space
Department of Posts, Telegraphs and Telephones (PTT)
BP 30000, 2500 GA The Hague Netherlands Agency for Aerospace Programmes (NIVR)
Telephone: (70) 43 43 43 Fax: (70) 43 32 93 PO Box 35, Kluyverweg 1, 2600 AA Delft
Telephone: (15) 78 80 25 Telex: 3890
Staatsbedrijf der Posterijan, Telegraphic en Telefonic (PTT)
PTT Centrale Directie, Headquarters, Kortenaerkade 12,
2518 AX The Hague
Telephone: (70) 75 91 11 Telex: 31111
216
New Zealand
Nederlands Omroep Stichting (NOS) Uses Intelsat, Inmarsat and Eutelsat. There are no plans for a
PO Box 10, 1200 JB Hilversum national system.
Telephone: (35) 77 91 11 or 28 11 10 Telex: 43479,43189
NOSAZNL
Earth Station Facilities
Stichting Radio Netherland
Wereldomroep, PO Box 222, 1200 JG Hilversum
Telephone: 16151 Telex: 43336 WOMR NL Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Burum-1 A AP 7 August
Membership of International Organizations Intelsat Burum-2 A A1 23 June 1978
Intelsat Burum-3 A IP 3 October 1984
Intelsat Burum-4 A II 8 January 1985
Organization Date of Joining %Share Inmarsat CES
ITU 1866 2.5445292 Eutelsat
Intelsat 1973 1.128008
Inmarsat 1979 2.56013
Eutelsat 1985 5.45359
NEW ZEALAND
217
Nicaragua
NICARAGUA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Empresa Nicaraguense de Telecomunicaciones (Enitel)
Apartado postel2664, Managua
Uses Intelsat and Intersputnik.
Telephone: 51812 Telex: 1458
Antenna Date
Direccion de Medios de Comunicacion
System Location type Coverage operational
Apartado 209, Managua
Intelsat Managua A A1 28 November 1972
Telephone: 24823
Intersputnik Managua
Satellite Operator
Nicatelsat
Compafifa Nicaraguense de Telecomunicaciones por Sate lite
( CNTS), Apart ado de Correos 4567, Managua
Telephone: (2) 25737 Telex: 2448
NIGER
218
Norway
Uses Intelsat for leased capacity (domestic) and occasional Antenna Date
use (international). System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Gondel B 1P 19 September 1977
Intelsat Karma A Al 28 October 1981
NIGERIA
NORWAY
219
Oman
Norsk Rikskringkasting (NRK) For Intelsat, Norway uses the joint Nordic station in Sweden
Bjornstjerns, Bjornsons Plass 1, Oslo 3 for international traffic and its own station at Eik for the
Telephone: (2) 46 98 60 Telex: 76820 RRUTL N Norsat service.
Fax: (2) 457176; (2) 457177 For Inmarsat, it has used the joint Nordic coast earth
station (CES) at Eik in Norway since February 1982. It
operated in the Atlantic Ocean region until February 1983. In
Membership of International Organizations accordance with a joint agreement with the UK, the Eik CES
then handled traffic in the Indian Ocean region while
Goonhilly (UK) carried the Atlantic Ocean region traffic.
Organization Date of Joining %Share There is also an agreement with Telecom Singapore for the
ITU 1866 1.2722646 use of their CES in the Pacific Ocean region. This tripartite
Intelsat 1973 0.382246 agreement makes it possible to offer customers global
Inmarsat 1979 14.24488 coverage at reasonable charges.
Eutelsat 1984 2.50247 For Eutelsat (F-2), Norway is building ground stations in
Nittedal and Stavanger.
Space Segment
OMAN
Government Departments Membership of International Organizations
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat, including a leased transponder, Inmarsat and
Arabsat.
General Telecommunications Organisation
PO Box 3789, Muscat
Telephone: 69 78 82 Telex: 3400 GENTEL MB Earth Station Facilities
220
Panama
PAKISTAN
Ministry of Communications Uses Intelsat and Inmarsat. There are plans for a national
Telegraph and Telephone Department, Islamabad satellite system, with two spacecraft at 38°E and 4l E 0
PANAMA
Broadcasting
Earth Station Facilities
Asociacion Panamena de Radiodifusion
Apartado 7387, Panama Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Direccion Nacional de Medios de Comunicacion Social Intelsat U tibe-1 A A2 7 September 1968
Apartado 3422, Panama 1 Intelsat Utibe-2 A AP 20 April1981
221
Papua New Guinea
PARAGUAY
222
Philippines
PERU
Telecommunications
Space Segment
PHILIPPINES
Globe Mackay Cable and Radio Corporation
Government Department ITT Building, United Nations Avenue, PO Box 770, Manila
RP 2801, Ermita Metro Manila
Ministry of Transport and Communications
Telephone: (2) 506081 Telex: ITT 40005 PM GM CR
Corner of Panay Avenue and Scout Reyes Streete, Quezon
City National Telecommunications Commission
Telephone: (2) 981160 Telex: 63912 NTC PN David Gutierrez Building, Scout Reyes Corner, Panay Ave,
Quezon City 3008
Telephone: (2) 98 11 60
223
Poland
POLAND
Telecommunications
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Glowny Urzad Telekomunikacji Intelsat Psary A AP 6 October 1982
Barbary 2, 00686 Warsaw Intersputnik Psary
Telephone: (22) 2123 74 Telex: 813598 Inmarsat CES
Broadcasting
224
Portugal
PORTUGAL
Broadcasting
Radiodifusao Portuguesa E P
A venida Duarte Pacheco 5, 1000 Lisbon
Telephone: (1) 65 40 41 Telex: 12538 RDP P
225
Qatar
QATAR
ROMANIA
Telecommunications
226
Rwanda
Space Segment
RWANDA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Antenna Date
Radiodiffusion de Ia Republique Rwandaise System Location type Coverage operational
PB 83, Kigali Intelsat Kicukiro B lP 18 March 1982
Telephone: 5665 Telex: ORINFOR 557
227
St Lucia
STLUCIA
SAN MARINO
Direzione Generale Poste e Telecomunicazione Uses Intelsat and Eutelsat via Telespazio (Italy).
San Marino
Telephone: 541 991 349
Earth Station Facilities
Membership of International Organizations
None. Uses Telespazio (Italy.)
228
Saudi Arabia
Antenna Date
Broadcasting
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat San Marcal B AP 21 October 1980
Radio Nacional de Sao Tome et Principe
Avenida Marginal12 de Julho, CP 44, Sao Tome
Telephone: 212 22875 Telex: 217 RADIO ST
SAUDI ARABIA
Ministry of Posts, Telegraphs and Telephones Arab Satellite Communications Organization (ASCO)
Riyadh PO Box 1038, Riyadh
Telephone: (1) 40 21550 Telex: 201220 PTT SJ Telephone: 4646666 Telex: 201300 ARABSAT
Fax: (1) 476 6752
229
Senegal
SENEGAL
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Broadcasting
SEYCHELLES
230
Singapore
SIERRA LEONE
Telecommunications
Earth Station Facilities
Sierra Leone External Telecommunications Ltd
PO Box 80, Freetown Antenna Date
Telephone: 22804 System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Wilberforce-! A Al December 1987
Intelsat Wilberforce-2 B A1 10 August 1979
Broadcasting
SINGAPORE
231
Solomon Islands
SOLOMON ISLANDS
SOMALIA
Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications The Director General of Posts and Telecommunications
Mogadishu Mogadishu
Telephone: 29005 Telex: 754 MINPOSTEL SM Telephone: 24 001 Telex: 754
232
South Africa
SOUTH AFRICA
233
Spain
SPAIN
Government Departments Televisio de Cataluya (TV3)
Diagonal652, Barcelona
Telephone: (3) 205 02 64
Ministerio de Transportes, Turismo y Comunicaciones
Gabinete de Ordenacion de las Telecomunicaciones, Calle de Sociedad Espanola de Radiodifusion (SER)
Alcala 54, Madrid 14 Gran Via 32, 28013 Madrid
Telephone: (1) 2313300 Telex: 44100 JNTE
Fax: (1) 733 3684
Membership of International Organizations
Secretaria General de Comunicaciones
28070 Madrid
Telephone: (1) 221 65 00 Organization Date of Joining %Share
ITU 1866 0.7633587
Intelsat 1973 1.962657
Inmarsat 1979 1.30846
Telecommunications Eutelsat 1985 4.62608
Broadcasting
Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Radiotelevision Espanola Intelsat Aguimes A A1 3 April1971
Paseo de Ia Castellana 118, Madrid 25046 Intelsat Buitrago-1 A A1 11 January 1968
Telephone: (1) 4116646 Telex: 47092 Intelsat Buitrago-2 A 1P 13 April1970
Intelsat Buitrago-3 A AP 31 August 1973
Intelsat Buitrago-5 A A2 15 April 1982
Radiotelevision Espanola Intelsat Rota B A 1 October 1986
Prado del Rey, Madrid 24 Intelsat Torre jon B A 1 September 1986
Telephone: (1) 218 6529 Telex: 27366 Intelsat Zaragoza B A 1 November 1986
Inmarsat CES AOR
Euskal Telebista Eutelsat Guadalajara
Durango (Vizcaya)
Telephone: (4) 681 6600 Telex: 319023
Television de Galicia SA
San Marcos AP 707, Santiago de Compostela (Ia Cornua)
Telephone: (81) 56 5141 Telex: 86297
234
Sudan
SRI LANKA
SUDAN
Ministry of Transport and Communications Broadcasting Service of the Democratic Republic of the Sudan
Khartoum PO Box 572, Omdurman
Telephone: 72 168
235
Suriname
Uses Intelsat and Arabsat. The PTT leases an Intelsat Antenna Date
transponder for domestic service, called Sudosat. System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Umm Haraz-1 A AP 21 November 1974
Intelsat Umm Haraz-2 B Al 25 August 1985
SURINAME
SWAZILAND
236
Sweden
SWEDEN
Government Departments Satellite Manufacturers
Ministry of Communications
Ericsson Radio Systems AB
Vasagatan 8-10,5-103 33 Stockholm
Box 1001, S 43120 Molndal
Telephone: (8) 763 1000 Telex: 17328
Telephone: (31) 67 1000 Telex: 20905 ERICRA S
Fax: (31) 87 66 39
Ministry of Education Satellites: TV SAT, TD F, ECS
Box 10333, Stockholm
Telephone: (8) 7631895 Telex: 13285 MINEDUC S
Saab Space AB
Box 13045, S 40251 Goteborg
Telecommunications Telephone: (31) 37 00 00 Telex: 21652 SAABRA S
Fax: (31) 21 08 00
Satellites: TV SAT, TDF-1
Swedish Telecommunications Administration (Televerket)
S 12386 Farsta
Telephone: (8) 713 1000 Telex: 14970 Swedish Space Corporation
Fax: (8) 713 3333 Tritonvagen 27 S 171, Soina 54
Telephone: 898 0200 Telex: 17128 SPACECO
Svensk Marin Radio, AB Satellite: Tele-X
Andreegatan 21, S 41463 Goteborg
Telephone: 1241 50 Telex: 21452 SMRADIO S
LuxorAB
Box 901, S 59129 Motala
Broadcasting Telephone: 14128000 Telex: 5578 LUXOR S (141) 57120
Sveriges Radio
Membership of International Organizations
S-105 10 Stockholm
Telephone: (8) 784 0000 Telex: 10000
Fax: (8) 784 1500 Organization Date of Joining %Share
ITU 1866 2.5445292
Sveriges Television AB Intelsat 1973 0.664878
Oxenstiernsgatan 20, S 10510 Stockholm Inmarsat 1979 0.65244
Telephone: 784 0000 Telex: 10000 SRCENT S Eutelsat 1984 5.45359
Sveriges National Radio
Oxenstiernsgatan 20, S 10510 Stockholm
Telephone: (8) 784 0000 Telex: 10000 Space Segment
Fax: (8) 784 1500
Sveriges Local Radio AB Uses Intelsat, Inmarsat and Eutelsat. The Swedish govern-
S-10127 Stockholm ment has been an active supporter of plans for a Nordic
Telephone: (8) 22 98 00 Telex: 11850 satellite system and is now instrumental in the Tele-X project
Fax: (8) 52 1813 in which the Swedish Board for Space Activities has the
controlling share in partnership with Norway and Finland.
Tele-X is a multipurpose satellite with the emphasis on two
Space channels of high-power television distribution at 12 GHz.
237
Switzerland
SWITZERLAND
Direction Generale de l'Entreprise des Postes, Telephones et Uses Intelsat and Eutelsat. Plans for a private DBS system,
Telegraphes called Telsat, have been abandoned.
Viktoriastrasse 21, CH 3030
Telephone: (31) 62 1111 Telex: 32011 PTI CH
Fax: (31) 62 60 39
Earth Station Facilities
Radio Suisse SA
Case Postale 31,3000 Berne 14 Antenna Date
Telephone: 659111 Telex: 32192 System Location type Coverage operational
Fax: (31) 65 94 01 Intelsat Leuk-1 A 1P 9 January 1974
Intelsat Leuk-2 A AP 29 January 1980
lntelsat Leuk-3 A AI 5 February 1984
Broadcasting Eutelsat 1985
SYRIA
Syrian Telecommunications Establishment Directorate Directorate General of Syrian Broadcasting and Television
General Place des Ommanyades, Damascus
Saadallah Jabiri Street, Damascus Telephone: 211200 Telex: 411233 GENRAD
Telephone: 21 9000 Telex: 411015 GENTEL
238
Thailand
Space Segment
TANZANIA
THAILAND
239
Togo
Bangkok Broadcasting & TV Co Ltd Uses Intelsat (with a leased quarter transponder for domestic
998-1 Phaholyothin Road, Box 4-56, Bangkok service) and Palapa ( P/4 transponders). There are plans for a
Telephone: 2781255 Telex: 82730 domestic satellite system, called Ramsat, for the 1990s.
TOGO
Ministere de !'Equipment des Mines et des Postes et Organization Date of Joining %Share
Telecommunications ITU 1961 0.0636132
Lome
Telephone: 213801 Telex: 5245 POSTEL TO
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Secretariat General des Postes et Telecommunications
Lome
Telephone: 214401 Earth Station Facilities
Antenna Date
Broadcasting System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Cacavelli A AP 31 May 1978
Radiodiffusion-Television Togolaise
BP 434, 3286 Lome
Telephone: 215357
240
Trinidad and Tobago
TONGA
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Tongo Telecommunications Commission (TTC)
PO Box 46, NukuAlofa
. Telephone: 21 257
Earth Station Facilities
Cable & Wireless
NukuAlofa Antenna Date
System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Nuku'alofa B PP 18 June 1978
Broadcasting
Radio Trinidad
Telecommunications llB Maraval Road, Port of Spain
Telephone: 21151 Telex: BROADCAST 3239 WG
Trinidad and Tobago Telephone Co. Ltd.
PO Box 917, 54 Frederick Street, Port of Spain Trinidad and Tobago Television Co Ltd
Telephone: 34211 Television House, Maraval Road, Port of Spain
Telephone: (809) 62 24 141
Trinidad and Tobago External Telecommunications Company
(Textel)
PO Box 3, Port of Spain
Telephone: 53852 Telex: 9002, 9003 TEXTEL WG
241
Tunisia
Space Segment
Uses Intelsat.
TUNISIA
TURKEY
242
Uganda
Space Segment
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
General Post Office
Grand Turk
Telex: 212 TUR CAICOS TQ Earth Station Facilities
UGANDA
Uganda Television
PO Box 4260, Kampala
243
United Arab Emirates
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Emirates Telecommunications Corporation Ltd
Head Office, PO Box 3838, Abu Dhabi
Telephone: (2) 28 3333 Telex: 22135 ETCHO EM Uses lntelsat, lnmarsat and Arabsat.
UNITED KINGDOM
244
United Kingdom
Cable & Wireless pic
Mercury House, 110-124 Theobalds Road, London WClX Space Segment
8RX
Telephone: (l) 242 4433 Telex: 23181 CANDW G
The UK uses Intelsat, Inmarsat and Eutelsat. Until recently,
British Telecom had a monopoly of all national and interna-
Mercury Communications Ltd tional services. However, in 1982 full licences to operate both
90 Long Acre, London WC2E 9NP international and domestic services were given to British
Telephone: (1) 838 2449 Telecom (BTl} and Mercury Communications, and both
organizations maintain a number of ground stations.
The UK (in the pre-1982 form of the British Telecom-
Broadcasting munications monopoly) has generally preferred to develop
communications satellite services through global and regional
bodies rather than on a national basis. As a result, there are
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) no national satellites and no national telecommunications
Broadcasting House, London W1A 1AA satellites in the fixed service are likely for some time. There
Telephone: (1) 580 4468 Telex: 265781 BBC HQ G are plans to launch a high power direct broadcast satellite
system. However, the IBA has licensed a private company,
British Satellite Broadcasting (BSB) to provide three chan-
Independent Broadcasting Authority (IBA) nels of direct broadcast television. The satellite, supplied by
70 Brompton Road, London SW3 lEY Hughes, is scheduled to be launched in 1989. Meanwhile, BTl
Telephone: (1) 584 7011 Telex: 24345 IBALON G has several leased transponders on Intelsat and Eutelsat, as
well as on SES's Astra (Luxembourg).
Space
Earth Station Facilities
British National Space Centre (BNSC)
Millbank Tower, Millbank, London SW14QU Antenna Date
Telephone: (1) 2113000 System Location type Coverage operational
Intelsat Goonhilly 1 A AS 28 June 1965
Intelsat Goonhilly 2 A Al 26 November 1968
Satellite Manufacturers Intelsat Goonhilly 3 A 11 6 August 1972
Intelsat Goon hilly 4 c AP 4March 1983
Intelsat Goonhilly 6A A AP 10 October 1985
British Aerospace
Space and Communications Division, Argyle Way,
Intelsat Goonhilly 6C c AP 1986
Intelsat Goonhilly 7 B AS 15 September 1983
Stevenage, Herts SG1 2AS Intelsat Madley 1 A IP 19 November 1978
Telephone: 438 3134 56 Telex: 82130 Intelsat Madley2 A A2 27 March 1980
Satellites: Olympus, Marecs, ECS, Intelsat VI, Skynet IV. Intelsat Madley3 A IS 4 September 1981
Intelsat Madley 5 c Al 19 September 1984
Ferranti Electronics Ltd Intelsat Thameside 1 c Al 1986
Microwave Division, Microwave House, First Avenue, Intelsat Thameside 3 c AP 7 August 1984
Poynton Industrial Estate, Cheshire SK12 lNE Intelsat Whitehill! c 11 23 May 1985
Telephone: (625) 871611 Telex: 666786 FERPOY G Intelsat Whitehill2 B 11 1986
Intelsat Whitehill3 B A2 1 September 1986
Eutelsat Thameside
Marconi Defence Systems Ltd Eutelsat Thameside
The Grove, Stanmore, Middlesex Inmarsat
Telephone: (1} 954 2311 Telex: 22616
245
United States of America
246
United States of America
247
United States of America
American Satellite Company (ASC) GTE Satellite Corporation
1801 Research Boulevard, Rockville, Maryland 20850 One Stamford Forum, Stamford, Connecticut 06904
Telephone: (301) 251 8300 Telephone: (203) 965 2000
Ford Aerospace Satellite Services Corporation TRW Space and Technology Group
1140 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 201, Washington DC One Space Park, Redondo Beach, California 90278
20036 Telephone: (213) 535 0856
Telephone: (202) 785 4000
248
United States of America
AMSAT
Organization Date of Joining %Share
ITU 1908 7.63 The American Satellite Company (AMSAT) is developing a
Intelsat 1971 22.46 system to provide leased line and private services. ASC-1 was
Inmarsat 1979 28.91 launched in 1985 and ASC-2 is due to be launched in 1989.
ASC-1
Space Segment Orbital position 128°W
Launch date August 1985
Launcher NASA
The US is the world's largest user of satellite services both Design life (years) 8.5
domestically and internationally. It has a large number of Number of channels C-band 18
domestic systems, all privately-owned. It is also a significant Ku-band 6
user of Intelsat and Inmarsat. In addition, US companies are 1WTA power (watts) C-band 8.5-16.2
active in satellite communications in other countries as Ku-band 16.2
suppliers and operators. Antenna coverage us
The US launched its first satellite in 1958, four months after ITUregion 2
Sputnik. Since then it has developed a wide range of Primary use telecommunications
launchers and spacecraft, and the associated electronics for
all kinds of techniques and applications. Key events have AT&T COMMUNICATIONS (AT&T)
been the Satellite Communications Act (1962) and the White
House declaration in 1972 of an 'open skies' policy to AT&T owns and operates the Telstar system to supplement
encourage an entrepreneurial approach to domestic systems its extensive terrestrial communications network. In addition,
(subject to FCC authorization). This approach has resulted in AT&T lease two Com star satellites owned and operated by
a large number of companies offering competitive channel Com sat.
capacity. The Telstar space segment is composed of three satellites:
In addition, several US companies are seeking to set up Telstars 301, 302 and 303. The system is used for the
trans-Atlantic and regional systems that would compete with following services:
Intelsat (and with undersea cables). Among the main • long-distance telephony, data and facsimile transmission;
contenders are lSI and Orion in the Atlantic region, and • leased television network feeds to affiliate television
Panamsat in Central America. Orion would be at 37.5° West stations;
and 47° west. lSI would be at 46° west and 58° west. • occasional news and sports feeds.
Panamsat's single RCA satellite would be at 45° west.
Most civilian US satellites carry telephony and/or video
(see list below). However, there are several other systems. Telstar 301
Orbital position 96°W
Launch date 1983
US Domestic Satellite System Operators Launcher NASA
Design life (years) 10
Number of channels 24
Company Name of system 1WTApower (watts) 8.5
American Satellite Company ASC Antenna coverage us
AT&T Comstar; Telstar ITU region 2
Comsat Comstar; STC Status main
Cygnus Satellite Corporation Cygnus Primary use TV
(subsidiary ofM/ACom) Lease services 1H CBS feeds
Federal Express Fedex or ExpresS tar 2H ABC feeds
Ford Aerospace Ford sat 3H Occasional video feeds
GTE Spacenet; G-Star 4V CBS feeds
NASA TDRS 4H Telephony
Hughes Galaxy 5V World communications
Martin Marietta MMC feeds; radio
(Communications Systems) 5H ABC feeds
RCA American Satcom; Aurora 6V ABC feeds
Communications (including 6H ABC feeds
RCA Alascom Services) 7V Hughes TV Network
MCI SBS 9V Occasional video feeds
US Satellite Broadcasting USSB 9H Occasional video feeds
Western Union We star lOY Occasional vide6 feeds
lOH Occasional video feeds
12V Wold communications
feeds
249
United States of America
11 V Telephony
Telstar 302 llH Telephony
Orbital position 86°W ·owned hy Com>at and lca>ed hy AT&T
Launch date September 1984
Launcher NASA Comstar D4*
Design life (years) 10 Orbital position 76°W
Number of channels 24 Launch date 1981
TWTA power (watts) 8.5 Launcher NASA
Antenna coverage us Design life (years) 7
!TV region 2 Number of channels 24
Status main TWTA power (watts) 5 or 5.5
Primary use Telephony/TV Antenna coverage us
Lease services 5H ABC feeds !TV region 2
6V CBS feeds Status main
8H Occasional video feeds Primary use Telephony
9V CBS feeds Lease services 2V Telephony
lOY Occasional video feeds 2H Telephony
lOH Occasional video feeds 4V Telephony
11 V Occasional video feeds 8V Telephony
8H Telephony
Telstar 303 9H Country Music Television
Orbital position 125°W lOY American Extasy
Launch date June 1985 lOH US Satellite Corp
Launcher NASA lOY The Playboy Channel
Design life (years) 10 llH Telephony
Number of channels 24 11 V KTVT (Dallas)
TWTA power (watts) 8.5 12H Telephony
Antenna coverage us 12V Telephony
/TV region 2 *Owned hy Com,at and lca>ed hy AT&T
Status main
Primary use Telephony/TV
GTE
COMSAT GTE Satellite Communications (GTE) owns and operates a
satellite network which currently consists of five satellites:
The Comsat General Corporation (Comsat) is the US Space nets I, II and III and G-Stars A 1 and A2.
signatory to Intelsat. Comsat owns and operates a domestic This space segment is used for the following purposes:
satellite communications system composed of five satellites. • Sprint Digital Satellite Network, GTE's long-distance
Three of the five were launched in 1976 and have been leased telephony service;
since then by Inmarsat. The other two satellites, Comstars D3 • occasional use booked on an hourly basis by customers;
and D4, are leased by AT&T. • occasional news and sports feeds;
Comsat has received permission from the FCC to own and • the relay of cable television services to cable networks;
operate a Ku-band satellite system. This system would consist • general communications services.
of two satellites with 40 watts of TWT A power per channel.
Comsat may acquire its own satellites, or re-use other
satellites (eg, SB-5). Spacenet I
Orbital position 120°W
Launch date June 1984
Comstar D3* Launcher Ariane
Orbital position 127°W Design life (years) 10
Launch date June 1983 Number of channels C-hand 18
Launcher NASA K-band 6
Design life (years) 7 (exceeded) TWTA power (watts) C-hand 8.5
Number of channels 24 K-band 16
TWTA power (watts) 5 or 5.5 Antenna coverage N. America, Alaska and Hawaii
Antenna coverage us /TV region 2
!TV region 2 Status main
Status main Primary use Telephony/TV
Primary use Telephony Lease services 2H Bonneville Communications
Lease services 2V Telephony 5H Occasional video feeds
2H Telephony 6H Hospital Satellite Network
3H Telephony 7H Occasional video feeds
4V Telephony 8H American Christian TV
7V Telephony Service
7H Telephony llH Baptist
8V Telephony Telecommunications
8H Telephony Network (BTN)
9V Telephony 14VSCPC
250
United States of America
16V Spanish International operate two Ku-band satellites with TWT A power of 50 watts
Network feeds per channel (there will be 16 channels).
20H SCPC In the long term, Hughes has applied for permission to
22H SCPC operate two Ka-band satellites with 32 channels of 20 watts
23H SCPC each. These satellites would be available in 1988 and 1989.
Spacenet II Galaxy I
Orbital position 69°W Type FSS
Launch date November 1984 Orbital position 134°W
Launcher Ariane Launch date June 1983
Design life (years) 10 Launcher NASA
Number of channels C-hand 18 Design life (years) 9
K-band 6 Number of channels 24
TWTA power (watts) C-hand 8.5 TWTA power (watts) 9
K-band 16 Antenna coverage North America
Antenna coverage us /TV region 2
Caribbean Status main
ITU region 2 Primary use TV
Status main Lease services 1 The Nashville Network
Primary use Telephony 2 2 WGN (Chicago); radio
Lease services 20H Florida News Network 2 The Disney Channel (East)
3 Showtime (East)
G-Star AI 3 SIN
Orbital position 13°W 4 Cable News Network
Launch date May 1985 4 CNN Headline News
Launcher Ariane 5 ESPN
Design life (years) 10 5 The Movie Channel (East)
Number of channels 16 6 CBN Cable Network
TWTA power (watts) 14 at 20; 2 at 27 6 Home Team Sports
Antenna coverage N. America, Hawaii, Alaska 7 C-SPAN
!TV region 2 7 The Movie Channel (West)
Status main 8 WOR-TV Superstation; radio
Primary use Telephony 9 PTL Satellite
Lease services Not known 9 WTBS Superstation
10 Cinemax (East)
10 Gala Vision
G-Star A2 11 The Discovery Channel
Orbital position l05°W 12 Home Box Office (East)
Launch date March 1986 12 The Disney Channel (West)
Launcher Ariane
Design life (years) 10 Galaxy II
Number of channels 16 Type FSS
TWTA power (watts) 14 at 20; 2 at 27 Orbital position 74°W
Antenna coverage N. America, Hawaii, Alaska Launch date September 1983
ITU region 2 Launcher NASA
Status mam Design life (years) 9
Primary use Telephony Number of channels 24
Lease services Not known TWTA power (watts) 9
Antenna coverage 48 US States
/TV region 2
Hughes Galaxy Communications Status main
Primary use Telephony
Hughes Galaxy Communications has been a US common Lease services 8 News & sports feeds
carrier since 1983. It operates three satellites, Galaxy I, II and 9 News & sports feeds
III, which offer virtually total coverage of the US. 19 channels are inactive
Galaxy I is a famous satellite for several reasons:
• 18 of its 24 transponders were sold to the highest bidders in
1983 (the other six are leased on a pre-emptible basis); Galaxy Ill
• Galaxy I regroups most of the successful US cable Type FSS
networks, which has proved a key marketing point to cable Orbital position 93.SOW
operators and home TYRO installations. Launch date September 1984
Galaxy II is primarily used for telephony and other Launcher NASA
communications services for private telecommunications Design life (years) 9
companies like MCI and Equatorial communications Inc. Number of channels 24
Hughes Galaxy Communications plans to launch Galaxy TWTA power (watts) 9
IV. Its transponders will also be available for sale. Antenna coverage us
Hughes has also been granted permission by the FCC to /TV region 2
251
United States of America
Status main
Satcom F4
Primary use Telephony
Orbital position 83°W
Lease services 4 News & sports feeds
Launch date January 1982
I2 News & sports feeds
Launcher NASA
IS channels are inactive
Design life (years) 10
Number of channels 24
TWTA power (watts) 6 at 8.5; IS at 5.5
RCA
Antenna coverage North America
RCA American Communications Inc. was formed by RCA /TV region 2
Communications in I976 to own and operate RCA's domestic Status main
telecommunications system. Earlier RCA had leased chan- Primary use Cable TV
nels on Anik F2 (Canada). Lease services 1 News & Sports feeds
RCA curently operates five Satcom series satellites: Sat- 2 Bravo
corns F3R, F4, FIR, F2R and Satcom F5 (aka Aurora 1). 4 Nickelodeon
Sat corns F3R and F4 cary a large number of cable television 5 ABC feeds
services, while Satcom FIR is mostly used for video feeds and 6 Madison Square Garden
Satcom F2R is devoted to telephony. Satcom F5 provides 7 National Christian
telecommunications services to Alaska. Network; Prime of Life
RCA launched two Ku-band Satcom in late I985 and I986. Network; radio
The Satcom K-series is designed to offer I6 transponders with 9 Sports Vision
47-watt tubes per satellite. 10 American Movie Classics
RCA is planning to launch Satcom F6 and Satcom F7 in 11 Home Sports
I988 and I989, respectively. RCA hopes to offer interna- Entertainment
tional television trasmission across the Atlantic with Satcom 12 The Playboy Channel
F6. 14 Occasional video feeds
16 The Silent Network
Satcom F3R 17 Trinity Broadcasting Net,
Orbital position 13I W
0
radio
Launch date November I98I 19 WPIX-NY Superstation
Launcher NASA 20 NBC Contract Channel
Design life (years) 10 21 Occasional video feeds
Number of channels 24 22 ABC feeds
TWTA power (watts) 6 at 8.5; IS at 5.5 23 Odyssey Music
Antenna coverage North America and Hawaii
/TV region 2
Satcom-Kl
Status main
Primary use Cable TV
Orbital position sse
Launch date November I985
Lease services I Nickelodeon
Launcher NASA Shuttle
2 The PTL Network; radio
Design life (years) 10
4 Financial News Network;
Number of channels 16
Cable Sports Network
6 SPN; radio
Antenna coverage us
/TV region 2
7 ESPNfeeds
Status Operational
8 CBN; radio
Primary use Video distribution
9 USA Cable Network
IO Showtime (West)
I1 MTV Satcom-K2
I3 Home Box Office (West) Orbital position 8I0
252
United States of America
Antenna coverage North America and Hawaii Status mam
/TV region 2 Primary use Telephony
Status main Lease services 1V Wideband digital service
Primary use TV 2H Telephony
Lease services 1 ONTV (West) (S) 3V Telephony
3 Wide band digital service 4H SCPC
6 Occasional video feeds 5V Telephony
8 NBCfeeds 6H Occasional video feeds
9 Occasional video feeds 7V Telephony
11 Occasional video feeds 8H SCPC
12 Netcom International 9V SCPC
15 Yonkers Horse Racing 10H Telephony
19 Wideband digital service 11 V RCA Americom
20 American Forces Radio & 12H SCPC
Television Service; AFRTS 14H Telephony
Radio 15V SCPC
22 Netcom International 16H Telephony
23 Wide band digital service 17V Telephony
24 Radio Televisione Italiana 19V Occasional video feeds
feeds 20H Learn/ Alaska TV
Network
Occasional video feeds
Satcom F2R 22H Telephony
Orbital position now 23V RCA Americom
Launch date 1983 24V Alaska Satellite TV
Launcher NASA project
Design life (years) 10
Number of channels 24
TWTApower (watts) 8 Satellite Business Systems (SBS)
Antenna coverage North America
ITU region 2 SBS was the first US satellite operator to operate Ku-band
Status main satellites. It was authorized by the FCC in February 1977 and
Primary use Telephony became operational in 1981.
Lease services 1V 6 SCPC Channels SBS currently operates four Hughes-built SBS series
2H Wide band digital service satellites: SBS I, II, III and IV. The space segment is used
3V Telephony for:
4H Telephony • time division multiple access {TDMA) business com-
5V Telephony munications services;
6H Wide band digital service • high-speed telephony to customers linked by SBS-operated
7V Telephony earth stations;
9H Telephony • television network feeds and occasional news and sports
10H 14 SCPC Channels feeds;
11 V Telephony • Videolink, an interactive video teleconferencing service.
12H Telephony SBS plans to launch an enhanced version of its SBS satellite
14H Voice of America (SBS V) some time in 1986 or 1987. SBS has also been
15V 17 SCPC Channels authorized by the FCC to launch SBS VI by 1987 or 1988.
16H 13 SCPC Channels SBS VI will offer four times the communications capacity as
17V Telephony the first four SBS spacecraft and three times that of SBS V.
18H Wide band digital Each of the 19 transponders will have a TWT A power of 41
19V Telephony watts.
20H American Forces Radio
and Television Service; SBS I
AFRTS Radio Orbital position 99oW
21 V Telephony Launch date November 1980
22H Telephony Launcher NASA
23V Telephony Design life (years) 7
24V Wide band digital service Number of channels 10
TWTA power (watts) 20
Antenna coverage North America
Satcom FS (Aurora I) /TV region 2
Orbital position 143°W Status main
Launch date October 1982 Primary use TDMA Service
Launcher NASA Lease services 2H TDMA Business Service
Design life (years) 10 5H TDMA Business Service
Number of channels 24 6H TDMA Business Service
TWTApower (watts) 8.5 7H Preemptible leased
Antenna coverage Alaska, Hawaii, US transponder
/TV region 2
253
United States of America
Westar Ill
SBS IV Orbital position 91°W
Orbital position 101°W Launch date August 1979
Launch date August 1984 Launcher NASA
Launcher NASA Design life (years) 7
Design life (years) 9 Number of channels 12
Number of channels 10 TWTA power (watts) 5
TWTA power (watts) 5 at 20; 5 at 40 Antenna coverage us
Antenna coverage North America ITUregion 2
ITU region 2 Status main
Status Spare for system Primary use TV
Primary use Lease service 1 Radio
Lease services 2 Radio
3 CNN news feeds
4 Radio
5 American Satellite Corp
(ASC)
254
United States of America
255
Union of Soviet Socialist Republic
256
Union of Soviet Socialist Republic
The Statsionar System Antenna coverage Indian/Pacific
Gorizont 7 (Statsionar-11) (ocean region)
Type FSS /TV region 3
Orbital position 11°W Status Main
Launch date 1983 Primary use TV/Radio/Telephony
Launcher USSR Services 6 II Programma TV,
Design life (years) 5 Moscow; Radio Mayak
Number of channels 6 7 Empty
TWTA power (watts) 5 at 15; 1 at 40 8 Telephony
Antenna coverage Atlantic 9 Inactive
(ocean region) 10 I Programma TV, Moscow;
lTV region 1 Soviet Radio
Status Spare for Gorizont-12 11 Inactive
Primary use
Services
Gorizont-9 (Statsionar-5)
Type FSS
Gorizont-6 (Statsionar-7) Orbital position 53°E
Type FSS Launch date 1984
Orbital position 140°E Launcher USSR
Launch date 1982 Design life (years) 3
Launcher USSR Number of channels 6
Design life (years) 3 (exceeded) TWTA power (watts) 5 at 15; 1 at 40
Number of channels 6 Antenna coverage Indian/Pacific
TWTA power (watts) 5 at 15; 1 at 40 (ocean region)
Antenna coverage Pacific /TV region 3
(ocean region) Status Intersputnik
/TV region 3 Pacific Ocean region
Status Main Primary use Telephony
Primary use Telephony/TV Services 6 I Programma TV, Moscow;
Services 6 II Programma TV, RadioMayak
Moscow; Radio Mayak 7 Wide band digital
8 Telephony & data 8 Telephony
10 I Programma TV, Moscow; 9 Wide band digital service
Soviet Radio 10 II Programma TV,
Moscow; Soviet Radio
11 Wide band digital
Gorizont-7 (Statsionar-4)
Type FSS
Orbital position ww Ruduga-7 (Statsionar-8)
Launch date June 1983 Type FSS
Launcher USSR Orbital position 25°W
Design life (years) 3 Launch date 1980
Number of channels 6 Launcher USSR
TWTA power (watts) 5 at 15; 1 at 40 Design life (years) NK
Antenna coverage Atlantic Number of channels NK
(ocean region) TWTA power (watts) NK
/TV region 1 Antenna coverage Atlantic
Status Intersputnik (ocean region)
Primary use TV lTV region 1
Services 6 I Programma TV, Moscow; Status NK
Radio Mayak Primary use Telephony
7 OIRTfeeds Services NK
8 Intersputnik radio, voice
and data
Raduga-17 (Statsionar-2)
9 Intersputnik TV unilaterals
Type FSS
10 Wide band digital service
Orbital position 35°E
11 Narrowband digital service
Launch date 1985
Launcher USSR
Design life (years) NK
Gorizont-8 (Statsionar-6) Number of channels NK
Type FSS TWTA power (watts) NK
Orbital position 900E Antenna coverage Northern Indian Ocean
Launch date 1983 (ocean region) region
Launcher USSR /TV region 1
Design life (years) 3 Status NK
Number of channels 6 Primary use Telephony
TWTA power (watts) 5 at 15; 1 at 40 Services NK
257
Uruguay
Raduga-13 (Statsionar-9)
Type
Earth Station Facilities
FSS
Orbital position 45°E
Launch date 1983 There are numerous earth stations for the Moskva and Ekran
Launcher USSR networks, including 5,000 TYROs. The Intersputnik system
Design life (years) NK has two earth stations at Dubna (Atlantic Region) and
Number of channels NK Vladimir (Pacific Region). Inmarsat is accessed through the
TWTA power (watts) NK Centre for International Maritime Satellite Communications
Antenna coverage Indian at Odessa. Another station, to be known as CIMSC-2, is
(ocean region) being built at Odessa.
/TV region 3
Status NK
Primary use Telephony
Services NK
Raduga-14 ( Statsionar-3)
Type FSS
Orbital position 85°E
Launch date NK
Launcher USSR
Design life (years) NK
Number of channels NK
TWTA power (watts) NK
Antenna coverage NK
(ocean region)
/TV region 3
Status NK
Primary use Telephony
Services NK
NK=Not Known
URUGUAY
Telecommunications
Space Segment
Administracion Nacional de Telecommunications (Antel)
Casilla de Correa 1477, Montevideo
Uses lntelsat.
Telephone: 28 1441 Telex: 398850 ANTEL UY
Antenna Date
Associacon Nacional de Broadcasters Uruguayos (Andebu) type Coverage operational
System Location
Calle Yi 1264, Montevideo A1 18 December 1980
Intelsat Manga 1 B
Telephone: 900053 A Al 15 April1985
Intelsat Manga2
258
Vatican City
VANUATU
None.
VATICAN CITY
Radio Vaticana
00120 Vatican City, Rome Via Italy.
Telephone: (6) 6982 Telex: 504 2023 SCVRADIO VA
259
Venezuela
VENEZUELA
Government Department Membership of International Organizations
Venezola de Television
Apartado 3979, Caracas
Telephone: 2399811
VIETNAM
Government Department Broadcasting
260
Yemen Arab Republic
WESTERN SAMOA
Telecommunications
Uses Intelsat.
Radio Sana'a
Telecommunications Ministry of Information, Sana'a
261
Yemen, People's Democratic Republic of
Space Segment
Uses Intelsat.
262
Zaire
YUGOSLAVIA
Nikolas Testa Tvornica Telekomunikacijskih Uredaja
Government Department Moskovska 45, Zagreb 41000
Telephone: (041) 565222
Ministry of Yugoslav Posts, Telegraphs and Telephones
Palmoticeva 2, 11001 Belgrade
Telephone: (11) 338921 Telex: 11421 YU GENTEL Membership of International Organizations
Fax: (11) 33 24 14
Organization Date of Joining %Share
ITU 1866 0.2544529
Telecommunications Intelsat 1973 0.217580
Eutelsat 1983 0.95712
Savezna Uprava 2a Radio Veze (SURV)- Federal Directorate
of Radiocommunications
Terazije 411111, 11000 Belgrade Space Segment
Telephone: (11) 34 60 41
Iskra Ljubljana
Trg Revolucije 3, 61000 Ljubljana
Telephone: (061) 213213
ZAIRE
263
Zambia
ZAMBIA
Telecommunications
Space Segment
ZIMBABWE
264
Zimbabwe
265