Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The antiepileptic drug valproic acid was studied in an open clinical trial as adjunct medication for 23 patients with
uncontrolled seizures of a g e o e M or partial type. Two-thirds of the patients experienced reduction in seizure
frequency ranging from 25 to 100%. Extensive testing revealed no evidence of serious systemic toxicity due to the
drug. Minor side effects (e.g., nausea, vomiting, or sedation) were usually transient.
Sodium valproate syrup and valproic acid in capsules gave equivalent mean low (23.3 &ml) and maximum (42.5
c18/ml)serum concentrations. The drug had a relatively short half-life of 8.7 hours, necessitating administration in
divided daily doses.
During initiation of valproate therapy there was evidence of a decline in total serum phenytoin concentration (16.5
to 10.2 pg/ml;p < 0.001)while the percentage of free pbenytoin increased (10.9to 20%). The quantity of unbound
phenytoin was relatively stable throughout. This observation was interpreted as a drug interaction: valproic acid
competed with phenytoin for access to plasma protein binding sites.
Manson RH,Cramer JA, Williamson PD, et al: Valproic acid in epilepsy: clinical and pharmacologicaleffects.
Ann Neurol3:20-25.1978
Valproic acid (dipropylacetic acid) is a promising an- seizures despite therapeutic serum concentrations of two or
tiepileptic drug only recently introduced into this three antiepileptic drugs, and had no evidence of progres-
country for clinical trial. Meunier and associates [ 141 sive medical or neurological disorder. As documented by
first reported the anticonvulsant properties of the case history, clinical observations, and, in many cases, elec-
drug in animals in 1963. Clinical trials by Carraz and troencephalogram and videotape recordings, the primary
seizure types were: 1 1 partial complex; 5 partial elementary;
co-workers [31 in France and later by investigators in
2 partial with secondary generalization; 2 generalized
other countries suggested both efficacy and freedom
tonic-clonic; and 3 generalized absence. Each patient served
from serious side-effects [2, 8, 12, 21, 221. Valproic as his own control based on documentation of seizure
acid seems to be most effective in the treatment of frequency for three months prior to the addition of val-
generalized seizures of absence type but is of some proate to the medication regimen.
value for all seizure types [91. In 2 patients absence attacks were quantitated by 24-hour
Valproic acid has a chemical formula unlike that of EEG and videotape monitoring before and during valproate
other antiepileptic drugs. It is a short-chain, branched therapy. All patients were hospitalized for one week during
fatty acid containing no nitrogen (Fig 1). The exact initiation of valproate therapy for observation of clinical
mechanism of action is unknown, but studies with efficacy, toxicity, and pharmacokinetics. Laboratory tests
animals suggest that the drug increases brain levels of administered prior to and during valproate therapy included
blood measurements of the following:alkaline phosphatase,
y-aminobutyric acid with a corresponding inhibition
serum glutamic-oxaloacetic transaminase, lactic dehydro-
of seizures [ 5 ] . genase, blood urea nitrogen, glucose, calcium, phophorus,
Although the present clinical study was undertaken sodium, potassium, chloride, bilirubin, total protein, albu-
to obtain further data concerning the efficacy and min, uric acid, creatinine, cholesterol, white blood cell and
toxicity of valproate, it was particularly designed red blood cell count, differential, hemoglobin, hematocrit,
to delineate pharmacological features including platelet and reticulocyte counts, and bleeding time.
bioavailability, half-life, and interaction with other an- Urinalysis plus 24-hour urine creatinine analysis were done.
tiepileptic drugs. Each patient also received audiological, ophthalmologic,
electrocardiographic, and electroencephalographic exam-
inations and a battery of neuropsychological tests [ 161 at
Materials a n d Methods baseline and at three- or six-month intervals. After the initial
Twenty-three adult patients participated in an open, three-month trial, 14 of 17 patients who benefited from
three-month clinical study; each gave informed consent. valproic acid agreed to participate in a long-term study.
The 20 men and 3 women were subject to uncontrolled The drug, supplied as Depakene by Abbott Laboratories
From the Epilepsy Center, Veterans AdministrationHospital, West Accepred for publication June 28, 1977.
Haven* Yale-New Haven Hospital* and the Of
Address reprint requests to Dr Manson, Epilepsy Center, Vererans
Neurology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT. Administration Hospital, Haven, CT 065 16,
unaltered rate of elimination indicates no self- Fig 2 . Elimination of valproir ucid from serum. Vafproate
induction of metabolism by valproate. u'as started on duy I at 300 mg per dose ( 3 doses per da.y),
T h e variation in valproic acid serum levels was de- increusing to 450 nig per dore o n day 3 and to 600 mfi per
fined for both formulations by obtaining blood sam- dose o n day 5 . Serial bloodsamples were obtained ufter the
ples serially to determine the maximum level achieved first dose of 600 rng of Vp-Na on day S and ufter six
mnnths of therapy. There is n o apparent difference in the
by each patient as well as the lowest level prior to the
rate of elimination of the drug between initiation of
next dose (approximately one half-life). Table 2 sum-
therapy or aber long-term therapy.
marizes the mean low and high valproic acid serum
concentrations with multiple daily dosing. The mean
valproic acid serum concentrations for all doses, both toin is illustrated in Figure 3. When Patient 6 was
syrup and capsule formulation, were 23.3 ? 8.0 pg started on valproate treatment at a low dosage, the
per milliliter 8 hours after the previous dose, with a total phenytoin level was 17.5 pg per milliliter with
maximum of 42.5 k 11.2 pg per milliliter. 8% free. After six months of Vp-Na treatment (2,400
mg/day), the patient was rehospitalized and the val-
Drug Interactioti proate was stopped. Mean total phenytoin levels were
During the first week of valproate therapy, many 14.6 f 1.4 p g p e r milliliter (N = 7) with 11.3 f 2.0%
patients exhibited a significant reduction in the serum free when the patient was not taking valproate and was
phenytoin level. For 2 1 patients, mean serum concen- receiving 400 mg of phenytoin and 160 mg of
tration of phenytoin before valproate was begun was phenobarbital daily. When valproate was restarted,
19.4 p g per milliliter, representing an average of three total phenytoin immediately declined to a mean of 8.5
o r four previous clinic visits each. The mean serum 2 1.0 pg per milliliter (N = 5) with a concurrent and
concentration declined to 14.6 pg per milliliter during sustained increase of free phenytoin to 18.5 t 2.7%
the fourth to seventh day after valproate was begun in (both,p < 0.001). The absolute concentration of free
the hospital (p < 0.001). An average of two or three phenytoin in plasma remained essentially unchanged
phenytoin serum levels at the lowest point during four whether the patient was on or off valproate therapy.
months showed a decline from 19.4 to 11.1 pg per The quantity of unbound phenytoin prior to and dur-
milliliter during valproate therapy ( p < 0.001). ing initiation of valproate (Fig 3) was 1.42 f 0.3 1 pg
T h e rapid fall of the phenytoin level in many pa- per milliliter (N = 6). When the valproate was
tients reflected displacement of phenytoin from stopped, free phenytoin was 1.63 k 0.19 p g per
plasma protein by valproic acid (Table 3). When val- milliliter (N = 7). It remained in a similar range, 1.55
proate was stopped, phenytoin returned to approxi- 2 0.20 pg per milliliter (N = 5), when the adminis-
mately 10% free, considered to be within the normal tration of valproate was resumed.
range [ 101. The reciprocal relationship between total Studies were done to see if the decrease in total
plasma phenytoin and the percentage of free pheny- phenytoin was secondary to altered metabolism re-
Dose of Dose of
Sodium Valproate Valproic Acid
Syrup (me) Capsule (mg)
Determination 300 450 600 250 500 All Doses
8 hr
pglml Vpa 16.3 22.2 26.5 21.1 28.5 23.3
SD 2.0 7.0 8.9 4.7 7.4 8.0
N 10 6 17 5 6 44
Max
pglrnl Vpa 33.0 43.9 48.7 30.9 47.7 42.5
SD 4.3 8.6 11.0 8.7 7.2 11.2
N 11 6 18 3 4 42
Mdkg 11.2 20.8 24.9 10.9 21.0 19.2
aSamples were obtained approximately 8 hours after the dose was administered and serially thereafter to determine the maximum level for
each patient. Some patients were tested on more than one dose.
lated to increased absolute phenytoin in serum when to normal (61.2% of dose) after two days of excess
displaced by valproic acid. While Patient 6 was under production (85.7% of dose). When valproate therapy
observation, 24-hour urine samples were collected for was stopped, mean H P P H levels in urine declined to
quantification of the principal phenytoin metabolite 182.5? 28.3mgperday(N = 2)fortwodays(45.6%
H P P H (Fig 4). The samples showed normal H P P H of dose) (p < 0.001).
output from 400 mg per day of phenytoin both prior The interaction of valproic acid and phenytoin is
to and during valproate therapy (mean, 244.7 19.5 * well demonstrated in Patient 6 (see Figs 3, 4). While
mg per day; N = 7) except when valproate was being the total plasma phenytoin levels declined, the plasma
started and stopped. Initiation of valproate therapy protein binding of phenytoin also decreased and the
brought an immediate, transient increase in H P P H metabolism of phenytoin (as reflected in urinary
production, which was repeated subsequently when H P P H quantity) transiently increased. At the same
valproate was restarted. The mean H P P H output rose time, bioavailable free phenytoin remained constant.
to 342.6 t 25.7 mg per day (N = 4) on these two In Patient 6, phenobarbital serum concentration was
occasions. Each time, urinary H P P H levels returned unchanged throughout, ranging from 22 to 26 p g per
milliliter whether the patient was on or off valproate.
In the whole group of patients no significant changes
Table 3. Protein Binding of Phenytoin in serum phenobarbital were seen.
following Valproate Administration a
.-.'.--.
I
b
IO- I -10
--"
5. 5
t
2 1 2 3 4 5 6-0s ~ ' 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 E 9 1 01 2 1 4 5 6
t START
VALP ROATE R:% f 0 AT E
RESTART
VALPROATE
syrup to capsule, the rate of absorption slowed while F i g 3. Phenytoin concentration was monitored daily
associated gastrointestinal upset diminished. W e during initiation of therapy and when ualproate treatment
found that allowing only one week to build to the uJaJstopped after six months to observe changes in
maintenance dose was too rapid for some patients; a pbenytoin bindin# in plasma. For Patient 6 (asfar the
other patient.f),valproate u i a ~administered slowly oz!erone
gradual increase in dose over two to three weeks is
week, the dose increasing from 900 to 2,400 mg per day.
suggested if patients begin to show toxicity. When When aalproate was started again after a period of ten
patients appeared drug toxic but levels of drugs other d a y ujithout i t , tQtalphenytOinconcentration declined
than valproate.were normal, the dose of valproate was significantly while the percentage of free phenytoin increased
reduced. This usually relieved the symptoms, indicat- (both.p < 0,0011. The concentration of unbound.free
ing that valproate can cause side-effects which are not phenytoin showed no statistically sigriijcant alteration
attributable to other medications. throughout.
Previous investigiuions of valproate [6, 81 have re-
ported alopecia. O n e patient in our group commented mean low premedication level and the mean
on hair loss during the initial month-long trial, but this maximum serum concentration was wide (23.3 to 42.5
could not be objectively verified. pg/ml) for both formulations, we found it valuable to
Extensive testing of hepatic, renal, and hernatopoi- determine the kinetic profile of drug absorption for
etic functions gave no evidence of any biochemical or each patient in order to be able to interpret blood
hematological abnormality. A decade of clinical use of levels obtained at varying times on clinic days. The
valproate indicates that it is an exceptionally safe an- serum levels that usually produce benefit without tox-
tiepileptic drug [181. icity (i.e., therapeutic level) reportedly range from
Because of the relatively short half-life of the drug, 67 to 82 pg per milliliter [ 131, 40 to 70 pg per millili-
ranging from 6 to 10.5 hours, multiple dosing is advis- ter [ I l l , 25 to 150 p g p e r milliliter [18], and 34 to 68
able to maintain relatively constant serum/brain val- pg per milliliter [171. Schobben et a1 [191 have
proic acid levels. Since the variation between the suggested a therapeutic range of 50 to 100 kg per
milliliter, which is higher than our experience.
Fig 4. Changes in urinaq HPPH concentration (in Even at highest doses, peak valproic acid concentra-
24-hour aliquots) associated with valproate therapy. tion infrequently approached this range in our pa-
Patient 6 received 400 mgper day ofphenytoin tients. Since the serum concentration varies depend-
throughout. Mean normal H P P H level is 244.7 t 19.5 ing on the interval between doses, the disparity may
nrg (in 24 hours) for this patient.
result from lack of uniformity in sample collection.
Results indicate good absorption with either syrup or
capsule administration of the drug. The capsule has
the advantages of slower absorption, gradual peaking
of plasma concentration, and greater acceptance by
patients.
In a previous report, Richens and Ahmad [17]
documented an average 27% elevation of phenobar-
bital in 7 patients receiving valproate, with n o consis-
tent rise in phenytoin concentration or half-life. Win-
dorfer, Sauer, and Gadeke [23] described elevation of
blood levels of phenytoin in 5 patients and elevation
of primidone in 7 when valproate therapy was started.