Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 3.
PARASITE DRAG or
ZERO LIFT DRAG
The objective of this chapter is to give you knowledge of the
aerodynamic causes of drag.
According to the JAA requirements you shall be able to describe:
List of Contents
Page Paragraph
3-2 3.1 Review of flow around a body.
3-10 3.2 Form drag.
3-14 3.3 Skin friction drag.
3-16 3.4 Interference drag.
3-17 3.5 Parasite drag as the sum of drag forces.
3.1
REVIEW OF FLOW AROUND A BODY.
This paragraph introduces drag, streamline and turbulent flow, lami-
nar and turbulent boundary layer, transition point and separation
point.
Introduction to drag.
Drag is the aeronautical term for the resistance experienced by all
bodies moving through the air. Drag is one of the components of the
total aerodynamic force. It is the component that is parallel to the
relative motion and counteracts the motion of the body forward into
the free stream direction, i.e. drag is always parallel to the free stream
and is opposite to the flight path.
Lift Total
Aerodynamic
Force
Free stream
Flight path
Drag
Fig. 3.1
Lift Total
Aerodynamic
Force
Free stream
Flight path
Thrust Drag
Fig. 3.2
The total drag is the sum of the various drag forces acting on the
aeroplane. In this lesson we will study a part of total drag called
parasite drag, or more correctly: zero lift drag, leaving the other part
known as lift induced drag for the next chapter 4, and wave drag for
chapter 19.
3 - 2
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
Point 1
Velocity 1
Point 2
Velocity
2
Fig. 3.3
Turbulent flow is a flow where the elements of air do not follow a steady
path. In turbulent flow, the fluid elements passing through a fixed
point will change both the magnitude and the direction of their
velocity V in the course of time.
Fig. 3.4
Boundary layer
Fig. 3.5
The region between the surface of the body, where the local speed is
zero, and the first point, where the local speed is equal to the speed
of the airflow, is called the boundary layer.
The boundary layer is the region where the speed of the air
decreases more and more until it is zero on the body surface.
The change in speed is due to the fact that the influence of the fluid
viscosity starts to make itself felt at a certain distance from the
surface. Normally the boundary layer is a very thin layer. In the
section shown, for example, its actual thickness is only about 2 to 10
millimeters. However, on the aft body of e.g. a long fuselage, it may be
~100 mm. Due to the viscosity effect, there is friction between the body
surface and the air.
Friction
Fig. 3.6
V
Laminar
boundary
layer
Fig. 3.7
The laminar boundary layer is, however, very unstable and small
disturbances such as rivets or even scratches on the surface will
trigger a tumbling motion resulting in a transition to a turbulent
boundary layer.
V V
Turbulent
Laminar boundary
boundary layer
layer
Transition area
Fig. 3.8
Notice that the turbulent boundary layer will be thicker than the
laminar one. A rough surface is not the only factor that may cause a
turbulent boundary layer. An increase in pressure that causes
dramatic changes in the layer's speed may also lead to a turbulent
boundary layer. In fact, the laminar boundary layer suddenly becomes
turbulent, at least beyond the maximum thickness of the profile, due
to the increase in pressure. The position on the surface (where this
transition occurs) is called the transition point, which is followed by
a transition area.
3 - 4
;;
Principles of Flight
Fig. 3.9
Lam
inar
Transition region
Transition
points
Turbulent
In the turbulent boundary layer, the speed, and thus the energy,
close to the surface is higher than that of the laminar flow. The
reason for this is turbulent mixing. Due to turbulent mixing, the low-
speed air particles close to the surface are brought out into the high-
speed flow where they increase their speed due to the collision with
particles at higher speed and vice versa.
Height Height
Boun- Boun-
dary dary
layer layer
Velocity Velocity
Laminar Turbulent
Transition point
Fig. 3.10
On most aircraft wings, the transition point is located near the leading
edge, but at some glider aircraft with so-called laminar wing sections
Fig. 3.11
Transition point
© TFHS and NAR
and with extreme smooth surfaces, the transition point may be located at
~50% of the chord.
The location of the transition point is not constant. It will change with
a change in pressure distribution, with the degree of friction from the
Reynolds number.
We have already mentioned that due to the compressibility effects
(called Mach effects) the flow and hence the pressure distribution is
changed at high speeds. This will cause a critical high-speed value,
However, there is also a critical low speed due to the viscosity of the
air.
At very low speeds the energy from the mass of air flowing over a
surface is too low compared to the friction of the surface and this will
effect the boundary layer. The factors that determine the flow char-
acteristics around a wing are the velocity V (cm/s), the wing chord c
(cm) and the kinematic viscosity of air (at sea level at 15oC it is 1/0,14
or ~7). The product of these is called Reynolds number (Re or R) after
the discoverer of this relationship. It is a non-dimensional parameter
of great importance. The number tells the ratio between the force of
the mass flow and force of the friction. So, the formula by which
we get the Re number, is at sea level Re = V ∞ c ∞ 7.
3 - 6
;;
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
CD
Re
Fig. 3.12 Re crit
;;
section, the canard will have less reduced performance.
The force of the mass flow and the force of the friction
have great impact on the boundary layer.
The behaviour of the boundary layer is very
much depending on the Reynolds number.
Separation point.
When the pressure difference along an airfoil is too great, the flow
velocity will be so low that the flow in the turbulent boundary layer will
start to separate from the airfoil at a point called the separation
point. Let us take a look at an airfoil in relative motion. We can see
that from point A to point B, the air accelerates due to the decreasing
static pressure. Crossing section B, the air starts to decelerate due to
the increasing static pressure and continues decelerating until point
C is reached.
B
A
C
A B
g
Increasin Decre
velocity
- as
velocit ing C
++ y
+
Motion
of the a
Fig. 3.13 ir
B
A
Separation point
C
A Reverse flow
Increasing B
++ velocity - Dec
r
velo easing C
city
++
Moti
on o
f the
air
Fig. 3.14
In the region preceding the separation point, the layer of air at zero speed
that is closest to the body will rapidly increase in thickness, and due to the
increase in pressure from B to C, this surface layer may start to flow
against the main flow, causing flow separation.
The flow separation causes a turbulent wake behind the body moving
through the air as we can see in the picture below. The earlier the flow
separation, the greater the turbulent wake.
p p
Wide
wake
Separation points
Narrow
wake
Fig. 3.15
The shape of the flow separation depends on the shape of the airfoil
and the conditions in the boundary layer. Thick profiles have early
separation and large wakes, while thin profiles have separation points
very close to the trailing edge and thus small wakes.
Separation point
Thin wake
Fig. 3.16
Fig. 3.17
3 - 8
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
However, the actual Re number also has an effect on the flow separation,
hence also the drag. This is illustrated by the example of a circular cylinder.
;;
The upper figure in the next illustration shows the case of a flow at low Re
number. The boundary layer is laminar, and early separation takes place,
giving a large dead air region and a high drag coefficient. At a higher Re
number, transition takes place at a point upstream of the separation
point. As a result, the turbulent boundary layer remains attached to the
surface until a point much further round is reached. The size of the dead
air region is much reduced, as shown in the lower figure, and so is the drag
coefficient. Consequently, at a higher speed the Re number is higher
resulting in the transition point moving forward reducing the dead air
region and hence also the drag coefficient.
Notice the difference between the transition point and the sepa-
ration point. Transition point Separation point
r
Lamina Turbu
lent
Separa
ted
Fig. 3.19
3.2
FORM DRAG.
This paragraph deals with form drag dependent upon airflow separa-
tion, and how to reduce form drag.
Fig. 3.20
Let us now consider what happens in the case of a real fluid. A cylinder
moving in a real fluid, in other words a fluid with a certain degree of
viscosity, behaves very differently. The fluid will follow the shape of the
cylinder only until separation occurs, then it breaks away.
In practice, the flow varies from the free stream velocity at the front
of the cylinder to the maximum value around the upper and lower
surfaces of it. Then the flow breaks away and, as a consequence, the
velocity of this flow does not reach that of the free stream behind the
cylinder.
Fig. 3.21
3 - 10
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
-
+ +
-
Fig. 3.22
-
+ -
-
Fig. 3.23
This means that the force acting on the aft part of the cylinder is no
longer balanced by the force acting on the front part. As a consequence,
there is a resultant force in the direction of the relative wind. This force
is a type of drag and is called FORM DRAG.
-
+ Form- drag
-
Fig. 3.24
If we only have one half of the cylinder, the separation point moves forwards
and the turbulent wake becomes greater. In this case the form drag
increases due to the increased difference in pressure between the front and
aft parts of the body.
-
+ - drag
Form
-
Fig. 3.25
The shape of the body determines the amount of form drag. The shape
of the forward surface of the body determines the velocity and, as a
consequence, the pressure distribution on the front part of the body.
The shape of the body also determines the position of the separation
point, the dimensions of the turbulent wake and, as a consequence,
the pressure distribution on the aft surface of the body.
-
+ - drag
Form
-
Fig. 3.26
Let us now consider a body with the same front area but with a pointed
fore-body. There will be a smoother speed transition from the front of
the body to the thickest part, but it creates a turbulent wake of almost
the same dimension.
-
+ - drag
Form
-
Fig. 3.27
3 - 12
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
If we now consider a body with the same front area and fore-body but
with a fairing at the aft part, we can see that we have a smooth
transition of fluid velocity from the front to the back of the body and
therefore also a smaller wake. This is the shape of an airfoil. The airfoil
experiences the smallest difference in pressure between the fore and
aft surfaces and, as a consequence, it produces the lowest value of
form drag.
-
+ Form -drag
-
Fig. 3.28
- Separation point
+ Form -drag
-
Separation point
-
+ F Drag
-
Fig. 3.29
You have seen that a given airfoil at a low angle of attack experiences
a given form drag due to the shape of its front and aft parts. You have
also seen that with an increase in the angle of attack, the separation
point moves forwards. As a consequence, the thickness of the
turbulent wake increases and so does the difference in pressure
between the front and aft parts of the airfoil. The form drag therefore
increases.
-
+ F Drag
-
-
Thicker wake
+ Form drag
Fig. 3.30 -
© TFHS and NAR 3 - 13
© TFHS and NAR
Fig. 3.31
Fairings reduce drag
What will the speed of the fluid be behind the body in comparison
with in front of the body when flow separation occurs?
3.3
SKIN FRICTION DRAG.
This paragraph deals with skin friction drag due to friction and how to
reduce it.
Using a very thin flat plate parallel to the relative motion we can
assume that there is no flow separation due to the form of the body.
The resistance experienced by the body in this situation is the skin
3 - 14
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
friction drag only. Skin friction drag depends upon surface roughness. The
rougher the surface, the greater the skin friction drag.
Fig. 3.32
A rough surface causes higher skin friction drag because the boundary
layer becomes almost immediately turbulent. As you know, the
turbulent boundary layer creates more friction and is thicker than the
laminar one.
Skin friction drag also depends upon the size of the body surface.
However, a larger surface gives a higher Reynolds number. Generally,
the higher the Reynolds number the greater the tendency to resist
separation, giving a corresponding lower skin friction coefficient Cf. In
addition, increased speed gives a higher Re-number, decreasing the
CD.
A larger surface area, and/or a higher speed,
increases the Re-number, giving a lower CD.
Friction drag
Fig. 3.33
Why does a rough surface create more drag than a smooth one?
3.4
INTERFERENCE DRAG.
This paragraph deals with interference drag and how to reduce it.
Interference of vortices.
We have now reached the last component of parasite drag namely,
interference drag. When we put together two bodies with different
shapes, for example a fuselage and a wing, the difference in local
airflow speed between the two surfaces causes differences in pressure,
which create vortices. These vortices create drag, which is called
interference drag.
Fig. 3.34
Fuselage
Wing
Fig. 3.35
3 - 16
Principles of Flight Parasite drag.
3.5
PARASITE DRAG AS THE SUM OF DRAGS.
This paragraph sums up the components of parasite drag and explains
its formula.
Sum of drags.
We have now analysed all the components of parasite drag: form drag, skin
friction drag and interference drag. Parasite drag, or zero lift drag, is the
sum of all of these.
PARASITE DRAG
-
Vortices Interference
Fig. 3.36
The coefficient of parasite drag CD0 expresses the capacity of the body
to create form drag, skin friction drag and interference drag. It is
therefore the sum of these drag coefficients. This coefficient is almost
independent of velocity and completely independent of the creation of
lift (CD = D/q∞S). However, to be precise, due to effects of Re-number,
it decreases somewhat if speed increases, and increases somewhat if
altitude is increased.
Do remember:
When doubling the speed, D0 will be four times greater.
Parasite drag
Zero lift drag
Do
4 Do
Do
V
Fig. 3.37 V 2V Airspeed
3 - 18