Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10
Distribution Feeder Analysis
269
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 270 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
V
I 5 = --------5- (10.1)
ZL 5
For this end node case, the line current I45 is equal to the load current I5.
Applying Kirchhoff’s voltage law (KVL), the voltage at Node 4 (V4) can be
determined:
V 4 = V 5 + Z 45 ⋅ I 45 (10.2)
The load current I4 can be determined, and then Kirchhoff’s current law
(KCL) applied to determine the line current I34:
I 34 = I 45 + I 4 (10.3)
Kirchhoff’s voltage law is applied to determine the node voltage V3. This
procedure is continued until a voltage (V1) has been computed at the source.
Z Z 23 3 Z 34 Z 45
1 12 2 4 5
+
I 12 I2 I 23 I3 I 34 I4 I 45 I5
VS
ZL 2 ZL 3 ZL 4 ZL 5
-
FIGURE 10.1
Linear ladder network.
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 271 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
The computed voltage V1 is compared to the specified voltage Vs. There will
be a difference between these two voltages. The ratio of the specified voltage
to the compute voltage can be determined as:
V
Ratio = ------s (10.4)
V1
Since the network is linear, all of the line and load currents and node voltages
in the network can be multiplied by the Ratio for the final solution to the
network.
S ∗
I n = ------n (10.5)
V n
The forward sweep will determine a computed source voltage V1. As in the
linear case, this first iteration will produce a voltage that is not equal to the
specified source voltage Vs. Because the network is nonlinear, multiplying
currents and voltages by the ratio of the specified voltage to the computed
voltage will not give the solution. The most direct modification to the ladder
network theory is to perform a backward sweep. The backward sweep com-
mences by using the specified source voltage and the line currents from the
forward sweep. Kirchhoff’s voltage law is used to compute the voltage at
Node 2 by:
V 2 = V s – Z 12 ⋅ I 12 (10.6)
Z Z 23 3 Z 34 Z 45
1 12 2 4 5
+
I 12 I2 I 23 I3 I 34 I4 I 45 I5
VS S2 S3 S4 S5
FIGURE 10.2
Nonlinear ladder network.
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 272 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
This procedure is repeated for each line segment until a new voltage is deter-
mined at Node 5. Using the new voltage at Node 5, a second forward sweep
is started that will lead to a new computed voltage at the source.
The forward and backward sweep process is continued until the difference
between the computed and specified voltage at the source is within a given
tolerance.
Example 10.1
A single-phase lateral is shown in Figure 10.3. The line impedance is
3000
Z 12 = ( 0.3 + j0.6 ) ⋅ ------------ = 0.1705 + j0.3409 Ω
5280
4000
Z 23 = ( 0.3 + j0.6 ) ⋅ ------------ = 0.2273 + j0.4545 Ω
5280
S 2 = 1500 + j750
( kW + jkvar )
S 3 = 900 + j500
3000’ 4000’
S2 S3
FIGURE 10.3
Single-phase lateral.
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 273 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
I 23 = I 3 = 143.0/ – 29.0 A
I 12 = I 23 + I 2 = 373.9/ – 27.3 A
V 1 = V 2 + Z 12 ⋅ I 12 = 7376.2/0.97 V
Error = V s – V 1 = 176.2 V
If the error is less than a specified tolerance, the solution has been achieved.
If the error is greater than the tolerance, the backward sweep begins. A typical
tolerance is 0.001 per unit, which on a 7200-V base is 7.2 V. Since the error
in this case is greater than the tolerance, the backward sweep begins by
setting the voltage at Node 1 to the specified source voltage:
V 1 = V s = 7200/ 0 V
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 274 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
Now the voltage at Node 2 is computed using this value of the Node 1
voltage and the computed line current in the forward sweep current:
V 3 = V 2 – Z ⋅ I 23 = 7026.0/ – 1.02 V
This completes the first iteration. At this point the forward sweep will be
repeated, only this time starting with the new voltage at Node 3 rather than
the initially assumed voltage.
1 Source Node
10 11
4
8
12
5
13
9 7
FIGURE 10.4
Typical distribution feeder.
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 275 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 276 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
• Line segments
• Transformers
• Voltage regulators
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 277 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
2
abc
3’
a
10 11
b b
4
c c
abc cba
8
4’ 12
c
5
a c
13
9 a
7
a
FIGURE 10.5
Unbalanced three-phase distribution feeder.
Node n Node m
Series Feeder
[Iabc] n Component [Iabc]m
[Vabc] [Vabc] m
n
FIGURE 10.6
Series feeder component.
Models for each of the series components have been developed in earlier
chapters. In all cases, models (three-phase, two-phase, and single-phase)
were in terms of generalized matrices. Figure 10.6 shows the general model
for each of the series components. The general equations defining the input
(Node n) and output (Node m) voltages and currents are given by:
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 278 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
The general equation relating the output (Node m) and input (Node n)
voltages are given by:
In Equations 10.7, 10.8, and 10.9 the voltages are line-to-neutral for a four-
wire wye feeder and equivalent line-to-neutral for a three-wire delta system.
For voltage regulators, the voltages are line-to-neutral for terminals that are
connected to a four-wire wye, and line-to-line when connected to a three-
wire delta.
• Spot loads
• Distributed loads
• Capacitor banks
Spot loads are located at a node and can be three-phase, two-phase, or single
phase, and connected in either a wye or a delta connection. The loads can
be modeled as constant complex power, constant current, constant imped-
ance, or a combination of the three.
Distributed loads are modeled in accordance with Figure 3.11. A distrib-
uted load is modeled when the loads on a line segment are uniformly
distributed along the length of the segment. As in the spot load, the distrib-
uted load can be three-phase, two-phase, or single-phase, and connected in
either a wye or delta. The loads can be modeled as constant complex power,
constant current, constant impedance or a combination of the three. Two
thirds of the load is connected at a dummy node located at the one-quarter
point of the line and the remaining one third of the load is connected at the
load end of the line segment.
Capacitor banks are located at a node and can be three-phase, two-phase,
or single-phase, and can be connected in a wye or delta. Capacitor banks are
modeled as constant admittances.
In Figure 10.5 the solid line segments represent overhead lines, while the
dashed lines represent underground lines. Note that the phasing is shown
for all of the line segments. In Chapter 4 the application of Carson’s equations
for computing the line impedances for overhead and underground lines was
presented. In that chapter it was pointed out that two-phase and single-phase
lines are represented by a three-by-three matrix with zeros set in the rows
and columns of the missing phases.
In Chapter 5 the method for the computation of the shunt capacitive
susceptance for overhead and underground lines was presented. Most of the
time the shunt capacitance of the line segment can be ignored, however, for
long underground line segments the shunt capacitance should be included.
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 279 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
Example 10.2
A very simple distribution feeder is shown in Figure 10.7. For the system in
Figure 10.7, the infinite bus voltages are balanced three-phase of 12.47 kV
line-to-line. The source line segment from Node 1 to Node 2 is a three-wire
delta 2000 ft. long and is constructed on the pole configuration of Figure 4.7.
The load line segment from Node 3 to Node 4 is 2500 ft. long and is also
constructed on the pole configuration of Figure 4.7, but is a four-wire wye.
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 280 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
Bus
FIGURE 10.7
Example 10.2 feeder.
Both line segments use 336,400 26/7 ACSR phase conductors, and the neutral
conductor on the four-wire wye line is 4/0 6/1 ACSR. Since the lines are short,
the shunt admittance will be neglected. The phase impedance matrices for
the two line segments are
Before starting the iterative solution, the generalized matrices for the three
series components must be defined.
1 0 0
[ a1 ] = [ d1 ] = [ U ] = 0 1 0
0 0 1
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 281 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
Equation 6.10:
Equation 6.17:
[ c1 ] = [ 0 ]
Equation 6.27:
1 0 0
–1
[ A1 ] = [ a1 ] = 0 1 0
0 0 1
Equation 6.28:
–1
[ B1 ] = [ a1 ] ⋅ [ b1 ]
LOAD LINE SEGMENT (using the same equations as for the source segment)
1 0 0
[ a2 ] = [ d2 ] = 0 1 0
0 0 1
[ c2 ] = [ 0 ]
1 0 0
[ A2 ] = 0 1 0
0 0 1
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 282 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
TRANSFORMER
The transformer impedance must be converted to actual values in ohms
referenced to the low-voltage windings.
2
2.4 ⋅ 1000
Z base = -------------------------- = 2.88 Ω
2000
Zt low = ( 0.01 + j0.06 ) ⋅ 2.88 = 0.0288 + j0.1728 Ω
0.0288 + j0.1728 0 0
[ Zt abc ] = 0 0.0288 + j0.1728 0 Ω
0 0 0.0288 + j0.1728
12.47
The turns ratio: n t = ------------- = 5.1958
2.4
12.47
The transformer ratio: a t = ------------------- = 2.9998
3 ⋅ 2.4
Equation 8.26:
–n 0 2 1 0 – 3.4639 – 1.7319
[ a t ] = --------t ⋅ 1 0 2 = – 1.7319 0 – 3.4639
3
2 1 0 – 3.4639 – 1.7319 0
Equation 8.30:
–n 0 2 ⋅ Zt Zt
[ b t ] = --------t ⋅ Zt 0 2 ⋅ Zt
3
2 ⋅ Zt Zt 0
Equation 8.45:
0 0 0
[ ct ] = 0 0 0
0 0 0
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 283 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
Equation 8.44:
1 –1 0 0.1925 – 0.1925 0
1
[ d t ] = ---- ⋅ 0 1 – 1 = 0 0.1925 – 0.1925
nt
–1 0 1 – 0.1925 0 0.1925
Equation 8.35:
1 0 –1 0.1925 0 – 0.1925
1
[ A t ] = ---- ⋅ – 1 1 0 = – 0.1925 0.1925 0
nt
0 –1 1 0 – 0.1925 0.1925
Equation 8.38:
0.0288 + j0.1728 0 0
[ B t ] = [ Zt abc ] = 0 0.0288 + j0.1728 0
0 0 0.0288 + j0.1728
12,470/30
[ ELL s ] = 12,470/−90 V
12,470/150
7199.6/0
[ ELN s ] = 7199.6/−120 V
7199.6/120
Set the line-to-neutral voltages at Node 4 equal to the nominal voltage shifted
by 30 degrees:
2400/−30
[ V4 ] = 2400/−150 V
2400/90
750/31.79
[ S4 ] = 1000/25.84 kVA
1250/18.19
www.engreferencebooks.com
0812_frame_C10.fm Page 284 Friday, July 20, 2001 3:57 PM
312.5/−61.8
S i ⋅ 1000 ∗
I4 i = --------------------- = 416.7/ – 175.8 A
V4 i
520.8/71.8
2470.9/ – 29.5
[ V3 ] = [ a 2 ] ⋅ [ V4 ] + [ b 2 ] ⋅ [ I4 ] = 2534.4/ – 148.4 V
2509.5/94.1
312.5/61.8
[ I3 ] = [ c 2 ] ⋅ [ V4 ] + [ d 2 ] ⋅ [ I4 ] = 416.7/ – 175.8 A
520.8/71.8
7956.4/3.3
[ V2 ] = [ a t ] ⋅ [ V3 ] + [ b t ] ⋅ [ I3 ] = 7344.5/ – 113.4 V
7643.0/120.5
118.2/ – 23.5
[ I2 ] = [ c t ] ⋅ [ V3 ] + [ d t ] ⋅ [ I3 ] = 150.3/ – 137.8 A
148.3/88.9
7985.9/3.4
[ V1 ] = [ a 1 ] ⋅ [ V 2 ] + [ b 1 ] ⋅ [ I2 ] = 7370.6/ – 113.2 V
7673.6/120.7
118.2/ – 23.5
[ I1 ] = [ c 1 ] ⋅ [ V2 ] + [ d 1 ] ⋅ [ I2 ] = 150.3/ – 137.8 A
148.3/88.9
www.engreferencebooks.com