Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PDT 5ALA
PDT 5ALA
Photodynamics
An International Newsletter for PDT and FD in Clinical Practice
In Dermatology
Editorial
It is Euro-PDT time again, with the 2008 Photodynamics will bring a report on the indication. Recent improvements in
meeting hosted by Professor Alejandro meeting in our next issue. remuneration may help to see PDT find its
Camps-Fresneda in Barcelona. The Euro- In this issue of Clinical Photodynamics, place as a useful therapy for actinically-
PDT Board has been busy pulling together we include reports from around the world challenged Americans. It is hoped that a
a programme that is fresh and innovative. on the place of PDT in dermatological wider licence for PDT use in the US might
The meeting will be the most practice. Given the considerable interest in follow, once practitioners gain greater
comprehensive event in the calendar on PDT at the recent World Congress in experience of this therapy and discover
the current use of PDT in dermatological October, we have invited experts to how it can find a useful place in our
applications. Professor Allan Oseroff, from comment on the current level of use of treatment armamentarium for NMSC.
the Roswell Park Cancer Institute in PDT in their region, where PDT is most We also carry a report on the posters from
Buffalo, NY, will offer one of the keynote used, what barriers exist to wider usage – the American Academy of Dermatology
lectures, ‘Learning the hard way – different and solutions, as well as inviting their AGM. If programme content is anything to
protocols with PDT in NMSC’, discussing vision of where they hope to see PDT in go by, PDT has a bright future – with
what we can conclude as optimal the next few years. We welcome workshops, forums and talks on its potential.
therapeutic parameters, given the variety correspondence – comments and personal There is certainly considerable off-label use
of protocols employed in delivering PDT views on this theme would be appreciated. of PDT in acne and photo-rejuvenation in
worldwide. The current status of the use of The USA, as the largest single the USA, with many impressive before-and-
PDT in emerging indications, including pharmaceutical market, remains a country after pictures! Clinical Photodynamics
acne, will be discussed, and techniques to where the provision of PDT is limited. is pleased to receive reports on readers’
minimise treatment-associated pain will be Currently, only the Levulan® formulation experience of PDT.
reviewed in an Experts Forum. For readers of ALA is marketed for AKs, although Colin Morton
unable to make the meeting, Clinical Metvix® (MAL) is FDA-approved in this Stirling, Scotland
The use of PDT in dermatological practice What are the barriers to wider
started in mainland China in the early 1990s. use? How might these be
First, the combination of domestically made resolved?
haematoporphyrin derivatives (HpD) and
laser was used for the treatment of port As of 2007, there are at least 100 The use of PDT in dermatological practice is
wine stain (PWS) birthmarks. In the mid- dermatology or laser clinics nationwide still in its early stages in China. Like PDT in
1990s, the Wuhan University Hospital began using PDT in their practices. Typically, those other fields, it experiences its ‘highs and
to use topical ALA-PDT to treat non- clinics belong to city or university teaching lows’. The barriers include, but are not
melanoma skin cancers (e.g. BCC, SCC and hospitals. Big cities like Shanghai, Beijing, limited to, the few approved indications, the
Bowen’s disease). Soon after this, we Wuhan and Guangzhou are relatively more limited knowledge and acceptance by derm-
continued to study the usefulness of ALA- active. Although our protocols are similar to atologists and patients, limited availability of
PDT for the treatment of genital those reported by western colleagues, there photosensitising drugs and light sources, and
condylomata acuminate. are no national guidelines available for the relatively high cost of PDT treatment. The
Recently, a drug-grade ALA (Aila®: Shanghai dermatological PDT practice in China. longer waiting time in clinic and pain assoc-
Fudan-Zhangjiang Bio-Pharmaceutical Co. iated with ALA-PDT might discourage some
Ltd) has become available. The company’s patients and clinicians. More resources are
registration of ALA-PDT for the treatment of needed to strengthen basic and clinical
condylomata acuminate became the first research in order to optimise current proto-
dermatological PDT protocol approved by cols and make them more accessible to
the State FDA in 2007. The same company is patients and clinicians.
currently seeking the approval of ALA for Several local dermatology and laser clinics,
the treatment of acne vulgaris and haemato- A male Bowen’s disease patient – before and together with industrial companies, have
porphyrin monomethyl ether (HMME) for after six sessions of imiquimod + ALA-PDT. been engaged in organising PDT training
the treatment of PWS. courses and seminars for local clinicians who
Some local physicians have begun to use are interested in PDT. Although one of the
PDT as first-line therapy for treating PWS, AK motivations of such courses is to try to estab-
and urethral condylomata acuminate. Some lish standardised protocols, it is true that each
also use ALA-PDT to treat off-label individual might adapt his or her own (best)
indications such as skin cancer and acne PDT protocol. Nonetheless, because of the
vulgaris. Although Asian populations are A female PWS patient – before and after one large patient population, there is still room for
considered to have a lower incidence of AK, session of HMME-PDT (provided by Dr. Kaihua dermatological PDT to grow in China.
we and other local dermatologists have Yuan, Laser Plastic and Aesthetic Center, PLA
General Hospital of Guangzhou District).
begun to see more and more Chinese AK Where do you hope to see PDT
patients, so we expect to see an increased in routine use in the next few
use of ALA-PDT in China. Where is PDT having its greatest years?
impact in clinical practice and
how might other regions learn The coverage of PDT by regional Medical
from your example? Bureaux (a State medical insurance pro-
gramme) might be a key step towards
Chinese clinicians have successfully treated establishing dermatological PDT as a routine
several thousands of PWS patients, using therapy option in China. The approval of ALA
various PDT protocols before any of those for the treatment of acne vulgaris and HMME
protocols have been officially registered by for the treatment of PWS will certainly give
the State FDA. A recent study indicates that PDT a boost. Guidelines are needed to
PDT is as effective as conventional pulsed dye ensure the quality of PDT applications in
laser (PDL) and even better for certain types dermatological practice. Along with many off-
PDT experts visiting the Shanghai Skin and STD of PWS. We hope Chinese data and exper- label uses, dermatological PDT applications
Hospital (27 March, 2007). Xiuli Wang (middle) ience can convince western colleagues to might soon be expanded to photo-
and Zheng Huang (second from right). resume their interest in PWS PDT. rejuvenation and anti-infection. I
PDT in Sweden started in the early 1990s as a What are the barriers to wider
method used for research purposes only. In use? How might these be
the Dermatology Department of Sahlgrenska resolved?
University Hospital, PDT was introduced into Where is PDT having its greatest
regular clinical practice in 1995. Apart from its impact in clinical practice and The barriers we see in the future are the
clinical use, PDT and the related field of how might other regions learn cost issues of PDT treatment. Most dermat-
fluorescence diagnostics are major areas of from your example? ological departments in Sweden must pay
research for the department. for the whole treatment and that includes
At the beginning of the 21st century, PDT Patients with numerous AKs and areas of field the cost of the cream. There is seldom a
became ever more popular all over the cancerisation are the main target of interest. reimbursement for expensive drugs. In our
country. Today, it is in daily use in clinical Large BCCs and BCCs on cosmetically sensitive country, the price of Metvix® went up by
practice in all University Dermatological areas are other types of indications, as well as 70% at the end of 2007. The departments
Clinics. It is also well established in the larger Bowen’s disease on sensitive areas and where must therefore cut down on other items or
regional hospitals, wherever there is a other methods are not as easily used. convince the hospital administration to
Dermatological Department, i.e. most major Since PDT is in the hands of reimburse in order to be able to continue
cities in the country. Some private doctors/nurses, the doctor in charge can be with MAL-PDT. This will be a major
practitioners also perform PDT. sure of a total patient compliance. PDT is also challenge.
In most centres, PDT is given as an a one- or two-shot treatment, so the patients
outpatient therapy. The patients arrive in the do not have to endure a long downtime Where do you hope to see PDT
morning for their cream application, which period. One other advantage for the patient is in routine use in the next few
may follow a differentiated curettage that inaccessible areas on the back can easily years?
procedure, depending on what type of lesion be treated.
is being treated. Most centres use Metvix® One important group of patients that are We see two areas where focus is required:
cream and the Aktilite® lamp as the steadily increasing are organ transplant 1. To be able to continue the good work with
illumination source. However, some centres recipients with large areas of AKs and in situ the indications we have today.
use ALA and either make their own ALA SCCs. These patients are a particular 2. The development of a good protocol for
cream or let the local pharmacist make the challenge to the dermatologist, who needs to the use of PDT in acne patients, as well as for
ALA. The licensed indications are for AKs, consider a number of different treatment organ transplant recipients with pre-
superficial and nodular BCCs and SCCs in situ modalities, and PDT can play an important malignant NMSC.
(Bowen’s disease). role in the future. I
Figure 1: Patient with multiple AKs and field cancerisation on the scalp.
‘Lesion preparation’ of hyperkeratotic AKs prior to incubation with the
photosensitiser.
Figure 2: After application of the photosensitiser, lesions are first covered Figure 4: After 3 hours of incubation, the lesions are irradiated with red
with an occlusive dressing. light. For pain reduction, cooling is provided, using liquid nitrogen.
T
he latest annual general meeting
of the American Academy of
Dermatology (AAD) saw 10
posters presented which were specific
to PDT. The posters are now presented
in an electronic format, reducing the
health value of the AAD, when several
miles were traditionally trod in
pursuit of finding posters of interest
amongst the thousands on display. An
advantage, however, is that members
of the AAD can remotely access any of
The Alamo.
the posters via the AAD website during
this year at:
www.aad.org LKS); and 5-ALA HCl/alcohol solution red light. Total inflammatory lesion count
The posters are briefly summarised here. (Levulan Kerastick®). Fluorescence presented a median reduction of 37% and
intensities of PpIX increased in order of: 49% after the first and second treatment
POSTERS ALA hydrophilic < ALA lipophilic < ALA gel sessions. Three patients received three
w/o DMSO < ALA gel + DMSO < LKS. The sessions and showed a 71% reduction in
The results from two randomised, LKS formulation showed a significantly inflammatory lesions. No reduction in the
multicentre, vehicle-controlled studies earlier fluorescence induction of PpIX, number of non-inflammatory lesions was
evaluating the efficacy and safety of MAL- evident at two hours, as compared to the observed. The maximal pain score was 7
PDT for patients with 4-10 suitable actinic other formulations, and the intensity of (range 5-10), despite using a cool air device.
keratoses (thin or moderate thickness AK, PpIX was 10-fold higher after LKS At 6-month follow-up, three patients had
face and scalp) were reported together. application, in contrast to 5-ALA hydrophilic limited recurrence. Although blue light may
David Pariser (Chicago, USA) and Rolf- ointment. Although only a model, this study be useful for mild to moderate severity
Markus Szeimies (Regensburg, Germany) offers useful information, contrasting acne, red-light PDT might be required to
reported complete lesion responses with different formulations of ALA and observing impact significantly on moderate to severe
MAL-PDT to be superior in both studies that 40% DMSO did not enhance disease, with inevitable issues around
(86% and 83%) compared to response rates penetration of a 5-ALA gel. increased pain. More studies in this area are
with the vehicle cream placebo (52% and There is considerable interest in PDT in clearly required.
29%) after two treatments, seven days Brazil, with three posters detailing its Otavio Macedo also reported the use of
apart. The high placebo response noted is effects on acne and photo-rejuvenation. MAL-PDT in 10 patients with AK and mild to
probably explained by the preparatory Otavio Macedo and colleagues (São Paulo, severe facial photodamage. After 3-hour
curettage performed before cream Brazil) reported MAL-PDT for ten patients MAL application, red LED light (Aktilite CL
application. with mild-to-moderate inflammatory acne. 128) illuminated the treatment fields. After
Tim Maisch and colleagues Metvix® was applied on the whole face the first PDT session, all visible AKs had
(Regensburg, Germany) displayed a poster under occlusive dressing for one hour. The cleared. Clinical improvement of photo-
on ‘Protoporphyrin IX fluorescence face was illuminated with blue light (Clear ageing, mottled hyperpigmentation, fine
induction after application of different 5- Light®) for 20 minutes, with three lines, roughness and sallowness were seen
aminolevulinic acid formulations’. Using treatments, one month apart. Four weeks in all patients. There was also smoothing and
a new full thickness porcine skin model after the third treatment, a reduction in softening of perioral and periorbital rhytides.
(freshly excised porcine skin embedded in inflammatory and non-inflammatory lesions Jens Thiele and colleagues (Boston,
Hepes-agar), the skin sections were and also the fluorescence related to P. acnes USA) reported two organ transplant
incubated with five different 20% 5-ALA was observed. recipients, one with chronic radiation
formulations: 5-ALA + DMSO (5-ALA gel + In a separate poster, Beatriz Niwa (São dermatatis and one with erythroplasia of
40% DMSO [penetration enhancer]); 5-ALA Paulo, Brazil) reported the response of 10 Queryat (EQ), where the EQ cleared and
w/o DMSO (5-ALA gel without 40% DMSO); patients with moderate to severe acne to other treated skin sites showed a reduction
5-ALA lipophilic (5-ALA cream oil/water); 5- three MAL-PDT treatments at 4-week in the formation of new NMSC, using ALA-
ALA hydrophilic (5-ALA ointment water/oil, intervals, using 90-minute application and PDT and blue light.
Published by Eurocommunica Publications, Caxton House, 51 Barnham Road, Barnham, West Sussex PO22 0ER, United Kingdom
Tel: +44 (0)1243 555041/2 Fax: +44 (0) 1243 555043 e-mail: eurocommunica@compuserve.com
The opinions contained in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Eurocommunica or the Editorial Board