You are on page 1of 12

ISSN: 1474-015X

Clinical Volume 1 Number 10


Spring 2008

Photodynamics
An International Newsletter for PDT and FD in Clinical Practice
In Dermatology

Editorial
It is Euro-PDT time again, with the 2008 Photodynamics will bring a report on the indication. Recent improvements in
meeting hosted by Professor Alejandro meeting in our next issue. remuneration may help to see PDT find its
Camps-Fresneda in Barcelona. The Euro- In this issue of Clinical Photodynamics, place as a useful therapy for actinically-
PDT Board has been busy pulling together we include reports from around the world challenged Americans. It is hoped that a
a programme that is fresh and innovative. on the place of PDT in dermatological wider licence for PDT use in the US might
The meeting will be the most practice. Given the considerable interest in follow, once practitioners gain greater
comprehensive event in the calendar on PDT at the recent World Congress in experience of this therapy and discover
the current use of PDT in dermatological October, we have invited experts to how it can find a useful place in our
applications. Professor Allan Oseroff, from comment on the current level of use of treatment armamentarium for NMSC.
the Roswell Park Cancer Institute in PDT in their region, where PDT is most We also carry a report on the posters from
Buffalo, NY, will offer one of the keynote used, what barriers exist to wider usage – the American Academy of Dermatology
lectures, ‘Learning the hard way – different and solutions, as well as inviting their AGM. If programme content is anything to
protocols with PDT in NMSC’, discussing vision of where they hope to see PDT in go by, PDT has a bright future – with
what we can conclude as optimal the next few years. We welcome workshops, forums and talks on its potential.
therapeutic parameters, given the variety correspondence – comments and personal There is certainly considerable off-label use
of protocols employed in delivering PDT views on this theme would be appreciated. of PDT in acne and photo-rejuvenation in
worldwide. The current status of the use of The USA, as the largest single the USA, with many impressive before-and-
PDT in emerging indications, including pharmaceutical market, remains a country after pictures! Clinical Photodynamics
acne, will be discussed, and techniques to where the provision of PDT is limited. is pleased to receive reports on readers’
minimise treatment-associated pain will be Currently, only the Levulan® formulation experience of PDT.
reviewed in an Experts Forum. For readers of ALA is marketed for AKs, although Colin Morton
unable to make the meeting, Clinical Metvix® (MAL) is FDA-approved in this Stirling, Scotland

PDT in Dermatology: Where Are We Now?


W
e asked a number of dermatological PDT specialists around the world to give us
a summary of the current use of PDT in their countries/regions and a prediction
of how this might change in the future. To make the replies more directly
comparable, we asked them to answer four main questions:
a. What is the current level of use of PDT in dermatological practice in
your region?
b. Where is PDT having its greatest impact in clinical practice and how
might other regions learn from your example?
c. What are the barriers to wider use? How might these be resolved?
d. Where do you hope to see PDT in routine use in the next few years?
If you would like to submit a similar report on the status of PDT in your own country/region,
please contact the editorial office at: eurocommunica@compuserve.com Continued on page 2

Editorial Board Also in this Issue


Dr Peter Foley Melbourne, Australia Prime Time PDT 10
Dr Sigrid Karrer Regensburg, Germany 2008 AGM of the American Academy
Dr Colin Morton Stirling, Scotland of Dermatology (AAD): Posters 11
Dr Colin Morton
Prof Ann-Marie Wennberg Göteborg, Sweden
Calendar of Events 2008-2009 12

OFFICIAL NEWSLETTER OF THE INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR PHOTODYNAMIC THERAPY


PDT in the United Kingdom
by: Dr Colin Morton therapies in the NHS remains challenging,
Consultant Dermatologist even when a strong evidence base exists.
Stirling, Scotland There remains a perception that the treat-
ment is complex to deliver and time-
consuming.
What is the current level of use of When topical PDT was first developed,
PDT in dermatological practice in the first generation of light sources used
your region? were inefficient and/or required the close
support of a medical physics technician. In
Topical PDT is now practised across the UK, addition, the topical photosensitisers, at
usually at regional level and predominantly that time unlicensed, required pharmacy
provided from teaching hospitals. A preparation, adding to the time required to
number of centres are very active, with deliver treatment.
waiting lists for treatment, but my The situation is now much improved, and
impression remains that PDT is still not Metvix® is approved in the UK for AK,
available to all patients who could benefit, Bowen’s disease, superficial and thin
with a number of UK cities being devoid of nodular BCC. No photosensitiser
a PDT service. The majority of centres use preparation is required and the current
the only licensed product for topical PDT in efficient red LED light sources deliver
the UK, Metvix® (Methyl Aminolevulinate treatment in under 10 minutes. PDT
[MAL]: Galderma), although some centres enthusiasts should be encouraged to advise
continue to use non-formulary their colleagues how straightforward the
aminolevulinic acid (ALA) products therapy now is to deliver, with multiple
employed before Metvix® gained its patients able to receive treatment in one
approval. therapy session.
The majority of topical PDT for skin moderate thickness lesions on the face and Pain is perceived as a significant drawback
applications is provided within the National scalp. Thin nodular BCC are treated with to PDT, but current protocols, especially
Health Service (NHS), where patients are caution, following careful lesion where smaller lesions are treated, often
not charged for therapy. PDT is also preparation and close follow-up. The use of require little pain management.
delivered by a number of dermatologists in PDT for non-licensed indications remains Nevertheless, several effective techniques,
private practice, with specific codes now limited. Gaining experience of PDT is key to such as cold-air analgesia, are emerging as
available for PDT by most insurers. The the recognition of where it is best used for methods for reducing discomfort, and I
office-based style of private practice does its current licensed indications. hope that we shall see a uniform delivery of
require the planning of PDT, often as a ‘day- PDT using protocols that can ensure the
case’ procedure in private rooms/hospital, What are the barriers to wider minimum possible discomfort to patients.
with a need to group patients in a single use? How might these be There remains a hesitancy by some col-
session for the most efficient delivery of resolved? leagues to include PDT in their treatment
treatment. The cost of PDT remains an armamentarium, probably for several
issue for private self-pay patients. Achieving funding for the delivery of new reasons. Some clinicians question the

Where is PDT having its


greatest impact in clinical
practice and how might other
regions learn from your
example?

Topical PDT has been used in a number of


centres in the UK for up to 12 years, giving
practitioners considerable experience in
identifying which patients and lesions can
derive the greatest benefit. Bowen’s disease
is a particularly good indication for PDT,
given its typical presentation on the lower
legs of elderly patients, a site recognised for
poor healing by conventional therapies.
The ability often to avoid surgery for large
superficial basal cell carcinoma (BCC) has
also seen the common use of PDT for this
indication.
The routine use of PDT for actinic
keratosis (AK) is less common, unless
patients have large numbers of thin and Fluorescence of two poorly defined BCCs before PDT.

2 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS Volume 1 Number 10


indications where the pathology is
superficial.
I hope that the recent updating of the 2002
PDT guidelines, endorsed by the British
Association of Dermatologists (BAD), and
currently at a draft consultation stage, will help
clarify its current place in practice. Certainly,
disease-specific guidelines produced by the
BAD on AK and Bowen’s disease make clear its
useful role, and updated guidelines for BCC
are also expected to confirm its benefits.

Where do you hope to see PDT


in routine use in the next few
years?

I wish to see easy access for UK patients to


PDT, to ensure that those who can benefit
most are able to receive it. Updated guidelines
should help pinpoint its optimal indications,
Patient receiving PDT for widespread actinic keratoses. and pain protocols should diminish concerns
regarding side-effects. Finally, I hope that
advantage of PDT over conventional therapy, worked against the therapy, suggesting its funding for research into particular
being concerned about the potential for use, for example, in recurrent BCC. Instead, presentations of acne and certain other new
recurrence, and are not yet persuaded by the clinicians should first become comfortable indications will see PDT take the next step in
good cosmesis conferred by PDT. The large with its use in other presentations perhaps development, becoming a general therapy
body of study data on PDT may have actually more appropriate for PDT – i.e. licensed option in dermatology practice. I

repeated 1-4 weeks later. The Aktilite® lamp is


PDT in Australia the most frequently used illumination source,
although other light sources, including
by: Dr Peter Foley Omnilux® lamps, Waldmann lamps, Pulsed
Consultant Dermatologist Dye Laser (PDL), and Intense Pulsed Light
Melbourne, Australia (IPL) are used in some centres.
Most PDT is performed in private (office-
What is the current level of use based) practice on a user-pays basis. The
of PDT in dermatological majority of practitioners offering PDT are
practice in your region? dermatologists, although some general
practitioners with an interest in skin cancer or
Topical PDT in Australia is only approved for cosmetic procedures do offer PDT.
the use of Metvix® (MAL) as the photosensit- The cost of PDT has to a certain extent
iser. Since the launch of MAL-PDT for the limited the uptake of the technique as, whilst
indications of AK and nodular and superficial Australians are happy to pay for cosmetic
BCC, we have also gained approval for procedures, they appear to have become
Bowen’s disease – or intraepidermal accustomed to low-cost healthcare. Although
carcinoma (IEC), as it is referred to in the PDT is not reimbursed by government bodies,
northern part of Australia. A number of some private insurers will cover the cost of the
centres spanning the country began using regulatory body governing procedures (Medi- cream. Patients covered by the Department of
MAL in 1999 with involvement in one of Photo- care Benefits Schedule, MBS) has deemed the Veteran’s Affairs (DVA) can have the cost of
Cure’s phase III studies utilising the major cost to be the topical agent and have MAL-PDT covered completely on a named-
Curelight®. Following the 310 and 308 BCC suggested reimbursement from the patient basis with written application, where
studies, there was a lull in proceedings as MAL Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS), who the medical practitioner can justify why other
was unavailable, having not at that time in turn have denied reimbursement on the therapies are not appropriate. A number of
received Therapeutic Goods Administration grounds that PDT is a procedure. public hospitals offer PDT through their
(TGA) approval. A number of centres exper- Most centres offering PDT only use Metvix®, dermatology departments. These patients are
imented for a period with extemporaneous as ALA is not TGA-approved, although it is treated without direct cost. However, despite
ALA and various light sources, including the quite legal for pharmacists to import the ALA these units being very active, the numbers are
Curelight® and the Omnilux® lamp. Since powder and formulate it as a solution or limited and waiting lists are extensive. The
approval has been granted for the proprietary ointment as required. This significantly majority of patients receiving PDT have AK,
product Metvix®, there has been a gradual reduces cost, but the ALA is considerably less BCC or Bowen’s disease, with a relatively small
uptake of this treatment modality across the stable and must be used quickly. MAL tends to proportion undergoing photodynamic photo-
nation. To date, no success has been achieved be applied for three hours, followed by 7-9 rejuvenation or having PDT for acne, rosacea
in gaining reimbursement status for PDT: the minutes illumination with 630nm red light, or other non-oncologic indications.

Spring 2008 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS 3


Where is PDT having its greatest lesions are a therapeutic nightmare in this minutes of illumination appear to fly past
impact in clinical practice and sunburnt land. rapidly and tolerably.
how might other regions learn Dermatologists in Australia are a relatively
from your example? What are the barriers to wider conservative bunch. Many have been reas-
use? How might these be sured by the five-year follow-up data, but there
Over the last 3-4 years, PDT has slowly gained resolved? remains a hard core of cynics, happy to use
acceptance as a mainstream treatment techniques such as cryotherapy and serial
modality, and registrars are expected to fully The most significant barrier to widespread use curettage and diathermy, with an absolute
understand and have gained experience with of PDT in Australia appears to be the cost. paucity of corroborative evidence, who disc-
the technique at the time of their Fellowship Apart from DVA patients covered under a ount PDT, as it is still in its infancy
examination. Exposure of registrars to PDT different reimbursement scheme, most ‘Downunder’.
during their training has enabled a new patients are out of pocket, relatively signific-
generation to gain insights into the technique antly, and baulk at the cost. Should Metvix Where do you hope to see PDT
in its proper perspective as a part of the cream or the PDT technique gain reimburse- in routine use in the next few
dermatologist’s armamentarium. ment status from the PBS or MBS, respectively, years?
To date, the greatest impact seems to have one would expect to see more widespread
been in elderly patients with Bowen’s disease employment of the technique. Over the next few years, one would hope PDT
on the legs, large superficial BCC and BCC in The perceived cost of topical will become more widely available in the
cosmetically sensitive areas, particularly young photosensitiser also limits availability in the public hospital system in Australia. This would
patients with facial lesions. With over 250,000 public system. The Aktilite® lamp is relatively result in equity of access. As the administrators
people (in a population of 21 million) having inexpensive for a hospital with a capital see the benefits in treating patients on an
at least one BCC treated by all techniques expenditure budget, but the recurrent cost of outpatient/day-case basis, with reduced need
annually, there is no shortage of clinical the cream limits numbers, even though having for inpatient care for large excisions, and
material. PDT available reduces skin cancer surgery reduced morbidity, introduction into more
The poor healing often seen on legs of waiting list times and means fewer patients centres should be seen.
patients with Bowen’s disease treated with needing inpatient care post-flap/graft. Hopefully, in the not-too-distant future,
other modalities (e.g. cryotherapy, serial One of the advantages of PDT over 5-FU for reimbursement status will be granted for both
curettage and diathermy, and 5-fluorouracil) Bowen’s disease or imiquimod for superficial the photosensitising pharmaceutical product
has been dramatically curtailed by using PDT. BCC, apart from the morbidity associated with and the technique itself. Reduced cost should
Likewise, BCC on the lower leg, where a graft the inflammatory response seen with these enhance uptake.
or flap would be required, has seen many agents, is the removal of the issue of Continued refinement in analgesic delivery
patients prepared to pay the cost involved to compliance. Unfortunately, some clinicians should remove one of the barriers to large
avoid the bed rest, immobilisation and limit- have failed to recognise this benefit. field treatment, allowing more zones of AKs to
ation of activities such surgery would entail. Pain can be a significant issue when large be treated, hopefully resulting in fewer skin
Large superficial BCCs are a popular indic- fields (bald scalps) or very sensitive sites (e.g. cancers developing.
ation. Although some lesions do not clear nose) are treated. Improved methods of Photosensitisers with even greater lesion
completely, or develop smaller occurrences, analgesia with cold air units (e.g. Cryo5) and specificity, enhanced tumour uptake and
the ensuing surgery is considerably easier (and inhalational agents (methoxyflurane) seem to penetration, and reduced pain would add to
without the problems associated with be helping with this issue. Unfortunately, some the attractiveness of the technique. Further
superficial radiotherapy fields). patient’s or practitioner’s first PDT experience research into non-oncological indications to
Widespread use for fields of AKs has not has been with large areas and inadequate maximise benefits and minimise discomfort
been seen due to the increased cost (cream analgesia, resulting in reluctance to treat will see greater interest, particularly for
use) and difficulty in achieving adequate smaller lesions on less sensitive areas. indications such as acne, where growing angst
analgesia. The recent introduction of The character of the nurse or technician with isotretinoin may result in reduced
Penthrox® (methoxyflurane) seems to be responsible for the illumination process is availability and new methods of treatment will
helping to overcome this. extremely important. An astute, outgoing, be required. Modification and maximisation of
Another area in which PDT seems to be garrulous nurse/technician distracting the protocols (e.g. fractionation of dose) should
having an impact is the transplant population, patient with conversation, sprayed cold water, see greater response rates and more
where extensive fields of actinically induced cold air, fans and music, often makes the 7-9 widespread acceptance. I

Are you receiving Clinical Photodynamics?


If this is not your personal copy Title: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Address for mailing: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
of Clinical Photodynamics and First Name/Initials: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................
you would like to receive Surname: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................
regular copies directly, free of Post held: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Country: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
charge, then please either copy Workplace: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Postal/Zip Code: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
and complete this form and post ................................ e-mail: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
it, in an envelope, to our
PLEASE RETURN THIS FORM TO: Eurocommunica Limited
Editorial Office or fax or e-mail Caxton House, 51 Barnham Road, Barnham, West Sussex PO22 0ER, UK
your details to us (see opposite). FAX: +44(0)1243 555043 E-MAIL: eurocommunica@compuserve.com

4 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS Volume 1 Number 10


PDT in Brazil photodamaged skin, combining short-contact
ALA and IPL, which is an off-label use of PDT.
I am greatly concerned about this, because I
by: Luis Torezan, MD have seen inexperienced physicians using PDT
Dermatologist, PDT group Hospital as the ‘ultimate’ modality for cosmetic
da Clinicas São Paulo- Brazil purposes. Using different ALA compounds
I-PDT member and concentrations combined with different
IPLs, they are offering something that is totally
What is the current level of use unrealistic, in my opinion. I think that PDT has
of PDT in dermatological to be provided for patients with the best
practice in your region? indications, following the steps of the
Guidelines for PDT in Dermatology. Its off-
Topical PDT has recently been introduced in label use has to be established and, in my
Brazil and Latin America, although I have experience, many physicians are uncon-
been using it in my clinical practice since cerned that PDT is an oncological treatment
1997. Metvix® (Galderma) was introduced in modality in its original definition.
2006 and Levulan Kerastick® (DUSA Pharma-
ceuticals) has just been released in our What are the barriers to wider
country. Although most dermatologists use use? How might these be
these two approved drugs, some centres resolved?
continue to use non-formulary ALA products.
The great majority of PDT use is provided by One of the main barriers remains the refusal
a few private hospitals and clinical private culture of sun tan and sun exposure in our of the insurance companies to cover the
practice (mainly dermatologists). Very few country is very well established. The possibility expenses. Proving that patients prone to
public institutions, mostly focused on oncol- of using a topical procedure with very little multiple NMSC, and also those with large
ogic diseases, also provide PDT, and patients side-effects, excellent cosmesis and high cure lesions, will benefit more with topical PDT is
are not charged for therapy. Because insur- rates has attracted many dermatologists who the main issue that I see.
ance does not cover this therapeutic modal- were not familiar with this therapy before. The Another problem is that many
ity, I think that PDT is still below its potential greatest indications are for multiple superficial dermatological surgeons prefer conventional
in our country. BCC, Bowen’s disease (which I consider the surgery to PDT, even for superficial and large
best indication) and very thin nodular BCC, lesions. Maybe the reason for this is based on
Where is PDT having its greatest especially for those patients who are not the incorrect widespread use of topical PDT
impact in clinical practice and suitable for surgery. Its use in AK is currently for photorejuvenation purposes. Why should
how might other regions learn limited to those patients with multiple lesions one rely on a drug that may be used for
from your example? and prone to field cancerisation, rather than NMSC and also for the improvement of
for single or a few AKs, because no insurance photodamaged skin? Fortunately, this concept
The greatest impact of topical PDT is on the covers the therapy expenses. is changing, although very slowly. If we keep in
treatment of large and multiple non- PDT has also had an impact on mind that PDT is an oncological therapy with
melanoma skin cancer (NMSC). These lesions photorejuvenation. Many dermatologists use great potential for other skin diseases, I think
are commonly seen in skin types I-III, and the PDT as a tool for the improvement of we will be able to convince the whole
dermatology community of its unique and
unquestionable benefits.
The current use of licensed products
(Metvix® and Levulan®), respecting the main
indications as well as the guidelines for PDT,
will provide the best results and, thus, lead to
a wider use of the modality in our country.
Pain is also perceived as a significant draw-
back to PDT, but current protocols may
diminish the discomfort, in combination with
skin-cooling techniques, such as fans.

Where do you hope to see PDT


in routine use in the next few
years?

I wish to see easy access for Brazilians to


PDT, ensuring that those who can benefit
most will be able to receive it. I hope that
PDT will definitely gain a place in every
dermatology community as a unique tool
for NMSC treatment and prevention of new
lesions. I think that PDT has an important
Photodiagnosis (PDD) of cancer. Left: before first PDT treatment. Right: before third PDT treatment. role in the treatment of field cancerisation.

Spring 2008 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS 5


This includes the treatment of visible and
non-visible AKs, covering large surface areas.
As a consequence of large-surface PDT, a
photochemoprevention effect will probably
be expected. I do not expect to see PDT for
photo-rejuvenation on a routine basis.
Instead, I wish to see it largely used for
severely photodamaged skin and multiple
AKs, which remains, in my opinion, the best
treatment choice for these patients. Also, I
hope that other skin diseases, such as acne,
will benefit from new protocols and
indications. Updated guidelines should help
the optimal indications, and pain-relieving
protocols should reduce concerns about
side-effects.
I
AK field treated with MAL-PDT. Left: pre-treatment. Right: post-treatment.

What are the barriers to wider


PDT in Canada use? How might these be
resolved?
by: Dr Robert Bissonnette Reimbursement for ALA and for the
Innovaderm Research procedure is the main limiting factor. Public
Montreal, Canada (provincial) insurance does not cover ALA.
Some private insurance companies will pay
What is the current level of use for ALA when it is used for the treatment of
of PDT in dermatological AK, but others will refuse to reimburse for
practice in your region? any indication, including AK. The fairly
extensive use of ALA-PDT for cosmetic
There are important provincial variations in purposes may in part explain the limited
PDT use and access in Canada. The service is coverage of private payers. The absence of a
not available in certain provinces, but derm- PDT code is also a limiting factor. Coding and
atologists performing PDT can be found in billing in Canada is established by each
most major Canadian cities. These dermatol- province. In Quebec, there is still no PDT
ogists mostly practice PDT as an office-based PDT with ALA has its greatest impact on code to use. Changes in billing and coding
procedure. They use ALA (Levulan®: DUSA patients with ill-defined, numerous AKs and could expand the use of PDT by Canadian
Pharmaceuticals) as this is currently the only who don’t accept the long downtime period dermatologists.
approved photosensitiser for use in derm- associated with the use of 5-fluorouracil (5- Another limiting factor is the availability of
atology in Canada. FU) or imiquimod. These patients have too the light source. Some physicians who do not
ALA is approved in combination with blue many lesions to be treated with liquid already have access to a light source to
light (Blu-U®: DUSA Pharmaceuticals) for the nitrogen or surgical modalities. They need a activate ALA have been hesitant to buy a
treatment of actinic keratoses (AK). However, treatment option that can eradicate numer- device specifically for the procedure.
many dermatologists use ALA in combination ous lesions, including sub-clinical ones. There
with other light sources, such as IPLs and red are a number of published studies showing Where do you hope to see PDT
LEDs, for the treatment of AK, as well as for that ALA or MAL-PDT can decrease the in routine use in the next few
other indications such as photoageing and appearance of new AKs, squamous cell years?
acne. carcinoma (SCC) or BCC in mouse models.
The current Canadian product monograph Evidence from clinical studies is emerging for If MAL is eventually approved in Canada, we
for ALA states that the solution should be a possible role for PDT in the prevention of will see more and more dermatologists using
applied on lesions only, followed by light AKs. Additional studies, looking at multiple PDT for the treatment of Bowen’s disease
exposure 14-17 hours after application. Very large surface PDT sessions as a preventive and BCC. A number of small studies have
few Canadian dermatologists are using PDT modality for BCC, AK and SCC in both shown very good efficacy of ALA- and MAL-
with such a long incubation time. Most immunocompetent and immunosuppressed PDT in the treatment of acne, and both are
physicians use a 45-minute to 2-hour patients, are needed to confirm these currently in phase II trials for the treatment of
incubation period before light exposure. findings and to define the best treatment acne vulgaris. These studies, as well as phase
With skin preparation (acetone wash or regimen for prevention. III studies, will determine the best
microdermabrasion), this is usually long enough ALA-PDT can also have a large impact on parameters for the treatment of acne. There
to get a good response when treating AK. certain patients with Bowen’s disease or are other photosensitisers currently under
BCCs. Even if ALA is not approved for study for the treatment of various
Where is PDT having its greatest Bowen’s disease or BCC, some dermatological conditions. The eventual
impact in clinical practice and dermatologists will use it off label in patients availability of more photosensitisers will
how might other regions learn who have failed with, or who have expand the use of PDT in dermatology in the
from your example? contraindications to, standard therapies. future. I

6 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS Volume 1 Number 10


PDT in China According to our own experience, we
believe that AK, Bowen’s disease and
superficial BCC are particularly good
by: Xiuli Wang1 and Zheng Huang2 indications for Chinese patients. Compared to
1 Shanghai Skin Diseases and STD these indications, nodular BCC and SCC
respond less to PDT. Mild and severe acne
Hospital, Shanghai, PR China
2 University of Colorado, Denver, also show good response to PDT. Urethral
condylomata acuminata respond well to PDT
USA
and show little side-effects and low
Email: xiuliwang2001@yahoo.com.cn recurrence. Our preliminary clinical study also
suggests that the combination of PDT with a
topical application of immunomodulators
What is the current level of use (e.g. imiquimod cream) might have a
of PDT in dermatological synergistic effect in treating some
practice in your region? dermatological conditions.

The use of PDT in dermatological practice What are the barriers to wider
started in mainland China in the early 1990s. use? How might these be
First, the combination of domestically made resolved?
haematoporphyrin derivatives (HpD) and
laser was used for the treatment of port As of 2007, there are at least 100 The use of PDT in dermatological practice is
wine stain (PWS) birthmarks. In the mid- dermatology or laser clinics nationwide still in its early stages in China. Like PDT in
1990s, the Wuhan University Hospital began using PDT in their practices. Typically, those other fields, it experiences its ‘highs and
to use topical ALA-PDT to treat non- clinics belong to city or university teaching lows’. The barriers include, but are not
melanoma skin cancers (e.g. BCC, SCC and hospitals. Big cities like Shanghai, Beijing, limited to, the few approved indications, the
Bowen’s disease). Soon after this, we Wuhan and Guangzhou are relatively more limited knowledge and acceptance by derm-
continued to study the usefulness of ALA- active. Although our protocols are similar to atologists and patients, limited availability of
PDT for the treatment of genital those reported by western colleagues, there photosensitising drugs and light sources, and
condylomata acuminate. are no national guidelines available for the relatively high cost of PDT treatment. The
Recently, a drug-grade ALA (Aila®: Shanghai dermatological PDT practice in China. longer waiting time in clinic and pain assoc-
Fudan-Zhangjiang Bio-Pharmaceutical Co. iated with ALA-PDT might discourage some
Ltd) has become available. The company’s patients and clinicians. More resources are
registration of ALA-PDT for the treatment of needed to strengthen basic and clinical
condylomata acuminate became the first research in order to optimise current proto-
dermatological PDT protocol approved by cols and make them more accessible to
the State FDA in 2007. The same company is patients and clinicians.
currently seeking the approval of ALA for Several local dermatology and laser clinics,
the treatment of acne vulgaris and haemato- A male Bowen’s disease patient – before and together with industrial companies, have
porphyrin monomethyl ether (HMME) for after six sessions of imiquimod + ALA-PDT. been engaged in organising PDT training
the treatment of PWS. courses and seminars for local clinicians who
Some local physicians have begun to use are interested in PDT. Although one of the
PDT as first-line therapy for treating PWS, AK motivations of such courses is to try to estab-
and urethral condylomata acuminate. Some lish standardised protocols, it is true that each
also use ALA-PDT to treat off-label individual might adapt his or her own (best)
indications such as skin cancer and acne PDT protocol. Nonetheless, because of the
vulgaris. Although Asian populations are A female PWS patient – before and after one large patient population, there is still room for
considered to have a lower incidence of AK, session of HMME-PDT (provided by Dr. Kaihua dermatological PDT to grow in China.
we and other local dermatologists have Yuan, Laser Plastic and Aesthetic Center, PLA
General Hospital of Guangzhou District).
begun to see more and more Chinese AK Where do you hope to see PDT
patients, so we expect to see an increased in routine use in the next few
use of ALA-PDT in China. Where is PDT having its greatest years?
impact in clinical practice and
how might other regions learn The coverage of PDT by regional Medical
from your example? Bureaux (a State medical insurance pro-
gramme) might be a key step towards
Chinese clinicians have successfully treated establishing dermatological PDT as a routine
several thousands of PWS patients, using therapy option in China. The approval of ALA
various PDT protocols before any of those for the treatment of acne vulgaris and HMME
protocols have been officially registered by for the treatment of PWS will certainly give
the State FDA. A recent study indicates that PDT a boost. Guidelines are needed to
PDT is as effective as conventional pulsed dye ensure the quality of PDT applications in
laser (PDL) and even better for certain types dermatological practice. Along with many off-
PDT experts visiting the Shanghai Skin and STD of PWS. We hope Chinese data and exper- label uses, dermatological PDT applications
Hospital (27 March, 2007). Xiuli Wang (middle) ience can convince western colleagues to might soon be expanded to photo-
and Zheng Huang (second from right). resume their interest in PWS PDT. rejuvenation and anti-infection. I

Spring 2008 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS 7


PDT in Sweden In our Department of Dermatology
(Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Göteborg),
we have solved the problem of pain during
by: Prof Ann-Marie Wennberg
PDT. A method using nerve blockage has
Consultant Dermatologist been developed at the clinic, where we pre-
Göteborg, Sweden treat all patients with this before they undergo
What is the current level of use PDT on the facial region. The issue will be
of PDT in dermatological addressed during Euro-PDT in Barcelona (6-8
practice in your region? March, 2008) by Dr. John Paoli.

PDT in Sweden started in the early 1990s as a What are the barriers to wider
method used for research purposes only. In use? How might these be
the Dermatology Department of Sahlgrenska resolved?
University Hospital, PDT was introduced into Where is PDT having its greatest
regular clinical practice in 1995. Apart from its impact in clinical practice and The barriers we see in the future are the
clinical use, PDT and the related field of how might other regions learn cost issues of PDT treatment. Most dermat-
fluorescence diagnostics are major areas of from your example? ological departments in Sweden must pay
research for the department. for the whole treatment and that includes
At the beginning of the 21st century, PDT Patients with numerous AKs and areas of field the cost of the cream. There is seldom a
became ever more popular all over the cancerisation are the main target of interest. reimbursement for expensive drugs. In our
country. Today, it is in daily use in clinical Large BCCs and BCCs on cosmetically sensitive country, the price of Metvix® went up by
practice in all University Dermatological areas are other types of indications, as well as 70% at the end of 2007. The departments
Clinics. It is also well established in the larger Bowen’s disease on sensitive areas and where must therefore cut down on other items or
regional hospitals, wherever there is a other methods are not as easily used. convince the hospital administration to
Dermatological Department, i.e. most major Since PDT is in the hands of reimburse in order to be able to continue
cities in the country. Some private doctors/nurses, the doctor in charge can be with MAL-PDT. This will be a major
practitioners also perform PDT. sure of a total patient compliance. PDT is also challenge.
In most centres, PDT is given as an a one- or two-shot treatment, so the patients
outpatient therapy. The patients arrive in the do not have to endure a long downtime Where do you hope to see PDT
morning for their cream application, which period. One other advantage for the patient is in routine use in the next few
may follow a differentiated curettage that inaccessible areas on the back can easily years?
procedure, depending on what type of lesion be treated.
is being treated. Most centres use Metvix® One important group of patients that are We see two areas where focus is required:
cream and the Aktilite® lamp as the steadily increasing are organ transplant 1. To be able to continue the good work with
illumination source. However, some centres recipients with large areas of AKs and in situ the indications we have today.
use ALA and either make their own ALA SCCs. These patients are a particular 2. The development of a good protocol for
cream or let the local pharmacist make the challenge to the dermatologist, who needs to the use of PDT in acne patients, as well as for
ALA. The licensed indications are for AKs, consider a number of different treatment organ transplant recipients with pre-
superficial and nodular BCCs and SCCs in situ modalities, and PDT can play an important malignant NMSC.
(Bowen’s disease). role in the future. I

PDT in Germany penetration into the skin. Recently, IPL has


also been used in order to reduce the pain
during irradiation.
by: Dr Sigrid Karrer In private practices, patients without PDT-
Consultant Dermatologist specific private insurance are often charged
University of Regensburg, Germany directly for this treatment, whereas other
routine treatments, such as curettage or cryo-
surgery, are reimbursed by their insurance
What is the current level of use companies. Thus, patients have to decide if
of PDT in dermatological they want to pay the extra money for this
practice in your region? special therapy that offers them a better
cosmetic result.
PDT using Metvix® (Galderma) in In clinical practice, PDT is usually
combination with red light is approved in performed on an outpatient basis. The
Germany for the treatment of AKs, BCCs and patients receive their drug application in the
Bowen’s disease. Since the approval of morning and return some hours later for
Metvix®, PDT for these tumours has become doctors also use non-approved illumination. When larger areas have to be
a routine practice, not only in many hospitals extratemporaneous formulations with ALA. treated, several sessions might be necessary
all over Germany, but also in a growing The most widely used light sources in to limit possible side-effects. In some patients
number of private dermatological practices. Germany are the Aktilite® lamp (LED) or the with many lesions, the whole area can be
Thus, PDT is available for most patients all Waldmann PDT 1200L lamp, both emitting treated in one session, using i.v. analgesia; the
over the country. In addition to Metvix®, the red light. The use of blue light is not patients then stay in the hospital for one
most widely used and approved drug, some recommended, due to the inferior depth of night.

8 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS Volume 1 Number 10


Where is PDT having its experiments were abandoned for many considered excellent indications for PDT,
greatest impact in clinical decades, until a renaissance of PDT other types of BCCs, such as nodular,
practice and how might other occurred about 20 years ago. Firstly, the infiltrating, morphoeic or pigmented BCCs,
regions learn from your mechanisms of action of PDT were studied should still be treated by surgery or Moh’s
example? in vitro and in vivo in a select few University surgery. In selected cases, where the
Hospitals, trying different topical and patient’s condition excludes surgery or
PDT has a long history in Germany. At the systemic photosensitisers and different where cosmesis is mandatory, PDT is also
beginning of the 20th century, a German light sources. Since the approval of used in non-superficial BCCs. For example,
medical student, Oscar Raab, discovered Metvix®, the use of PDT for non- melanoma nodular BCCs or BCCs on the face are
that acridine orange was lethal for skin cancer has rapidly grown, especially for treated by PDT.
paramecia in the presence of sunlight. At elderly people with widespread AKs and Besides the routine use for the licensed
that time, the term ‘photodynamic reaction’ field cancerisation of the face and scalp, for indications, some new and very promising off-
was coined by Hermann von Tappeiner, whom topical PDT is now considered as a label indications, such as human papilloma
director of the Institute of Pharmacology at first-line therapy. Also, due to the excellent virus-induced lesions (condylomata acumin-
the University of Munich. In 1903, Albert cosmetic results, patients with BCCs or ata, vulgar warts, plane warts), acne, facial
Jesionek in Munich treated conditions like Bowen’s disease often present to the rejuvenation, localised scleroderma, Leish-
skin cancer, lupus vulgaris and psoriasis dermatologist with the precise wish to be maniasis, etc., are also being investigated in
with topical photosensitisers, such as eosin treated with PDT. Whilst superficial BCCs some specialist hospitals, with the aim of
red or erythrosine. However, these on the trunk or Bowen’s disease are broadening the use of PDT in dermatology.

Figure 3: After occlusion, the area is also protected from light.

Figure 1: Patient with multiple AKs and field cancerisation on the scalp.
‘Lesion preparation’ of hyperkeratotic AKs prior to incubation with the
photosensitiser.

Figure 2: After application of the photosensitiser, lesions are first covered Figure 4: After 3 hours of incubation, the lesions are irradiated with red
with an occlusive dressing. light. For pain reduction, cooling is provided, using liquid nitrogen.

Spring 2008 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS 9


What are the barriers to wider right indication and to correctly perform the Where do you hope to see PDT
use? How might these be treatment (e.g. prior curettage, repeated in routine use in the next few
resolved? treatment, etc.). years?
Some doctors worry about the pain that
PDT is a therapeutic modality that requires can accompany the treatment. Indeed, when With growing clinical experience, well-
the dermatologist to have experience with treating larger areas, pain is often an issue. founded study data and International Guide-
the procedure, for best results. Thus, a However, this problem can be handled by an lines, PDT should become a universally
good way to resolve this potential barrier is adequate pain management protocol using available treatment modality for patients with
to inform and train doctors about the cooling devices or different kinds of oral, multiple AKs and field cancerisation, super-
procedures, indications and side-effects of local or intravenous analgesia. Thus, ‘pain- ficial BCCs and Bowen’s disease. In particular,
PDT. Special PDT training courses are being management’ should also be part of the the increasing number of immuno-
offered, in which theoretical questions are training courses offered for PDT. suppressed post-transplant patients with
considered and also demonstrations of Additionally, the costs of the treatment, multiple non-melanoma skin cancers will
actual patients receiving PDT are given. including the purchase of a lamp and of the benefit from PDT.
Some colleagues might have experienced relatively expensive drug Metvix®, is an issue As the development of PDT is continuously
recurrences after PDT of, for example, non- for the dermatologist willing to apply this advancing, it can be hoped that PDT for other
superficial BCCs, and thus have lost their therapy. Hopefully, a wider use of Metvix®- non-oncologic indications might become a
confidence in this therapy. Such frustration PDT will reduce the relative costs for the routine treatment in the near future, again
can be avoided when the doctors are photosensitiser in the near future. offering several advantages over standard
trained from the beginning to choose the therapies. I

Prime Time PDT


An international roundup of PDT-related
papers and publications
Enhancement of MAL-PDT by Iron Chelation with Evidence-Based Review of Lasers, Light Sources and
CP94 in Nodular BCC PDT in Acne
A Pye et al 2008 J Cancer Res Clin Oncol February 1 M Hædersdal et al 2008 J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol
(E-Pub ahead of print) January 23 (E-Pub ahead of print)
Treatment of nodular basal cell carcinoma (BCC) with The authors identified 16 randomised controlled trials and
topical PDT has been problematic, regularly resulting in 3 controlled trials for treatment of acne vulgaris, involving
recurrence. The combination of iron chelators with methyl a total of 587 patients. Treatments included PDT, infrared
aminolevulinate (MAL) reduces the bioconversion of lasers, broad-spectrum light sources, pulsed-dye lasers,
protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) to heme and so allows an intense pulsed light and one instance of a potassium titanyl
increased accumulation of PpIX in the target tissue. The phosphate laser. The most consistent outcomes were
authors examined the iron chelator CP94 in conjunction achieved with PDT (with up to 68% improvement using
with MAL, firstly in vitro in a number of human cell lines either ALA or MAL and red light). Only two trials compared
(including three dermatological cell types), with optical treatments with conventional therapies; the authors
fluorometrical measurement of PpIX accumulation, and called for more comparative studies and recommended that
then in an open, dose-escalating pilot study in patients with patients should be informed pre-operatively of the existing
nodular BCC, to determine the safety of this evidence for optical treatments.
pharmacological modification.
Large enhancements of PpIX accumulation were seen in
Violet Light PDT in Melanotic Melanoma
the cell cultures. In the clinical pilot study, CP94 plus MAL-
PDT was found to be feasible and safe. Moreover, greater L Ma et al 2007 J Environ Pathol Toxicol Oncol 26 165-172
reductions in tumour depth were seen in the MAL/CP94 co- Melanin absorbs light over the whole wavelength region used
incubated tumours. The addition of CP94 to MAL-PDT for PDT (400-750nm). Therefore, photobleaching of melanin
showed enhanced nodular BCC tumour clearance both offers a route to overcome this problem in using PDT to treat
clinically and histologically, even though the study was melanotic melanomas. Using reflectance spectroscopy to
small and intended only to assess the safety of CP94 measure depigmentation in nude mice and human skin, the
addition to the MAL photosensitising cream. The authors authors concluded that violet light MAL-PDT has the ability to
conclude that CP94 and MAL-PDT should be examined in a bleach melanin in these tumours and thus increase their
larger, controlled clinical trial. sensitivity to red light MAL-PDT given thereafter.

10 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS Volume 1 Number 10


American Academy of Dermatology
Annual General Meeting: Posters
1-5 February, 2008
San Antonio, USA
by: Dr Colin Morton
Stirling, Scotland

T
he latest annual general meeting
of the American Academy of
Dermatology (AAD) saw 10
posters presented which were specific
to PDT. The posters are now presented
in an electronic format, reducing the
health value of the AAD, when several
miles were traditionally trod in
pursuit of finding posters of interest
amongst the thousands on display. An
advantage, however, is that members
of the AAD can remotely access any of
The Alamo.
the posters via the AAD website during
this year at:
www.aad.org LKS); and 5-ALA HCl/alcohol solution red light. Total inflammatory lesion count
The posters are briefly summarised here. (Levulan Kerastick®). Fluorescence presented a median reduction of 37% and
intensities of PpIX increased in order of: 49% after the first and second treatment
POSTERS ALA hydrophilic < ALA lipophilic < ALA gel sessions. Three patients received three
w/o DMSO < ALA gel + DMSO < LKS. The sessions and showed a 71% reduction in
The results from two randomised, LKS formulation showed a significantly inflammatory lesions. No reduction in the
multicentre, vehicle-controlled studies earlier fluorescence induction of PpIX, number of non-inflammatory lesions was
evaluating the efficacy and safety of MAL- evident at two hours, as compared to the observed. The maximal pain score was 7
PDT for patients with 4-10 suitable actinic other formulations, and the intensity of (range 5-10), despite using a cool air device.
keratoses (thin or moderate thickness AK, PpIX was 10-fold higher after LKS At 6-month follow-up, three patients had
face and scalp) were reported together. application, in contrast to 5-ALA hydrophilic limited recurrence. Although blue light may
David Pariser (Chicago, USA) and Rolf- ointment. Although only a model, this study be useful for mild to moderate severity
Markus Szeimies (Regensburg, Germany) offers useful information, contrasting acne, red-light PDT might be required to
reported complete lesion responses with different formulations of ALA and observing impact significantly on moderate to severe
MAL-PDT to be superior in both studies that 40% DMSO did not enhance disease, with inevitable issues around
(86% and 83%) compared to response rates penetration of a 5-ALA gel. increased pain. More studies in this area are
with the vehicle cream placebo (52% and There is considerable interest in PDT in clearly required.
29%) after two treatments, seven days Brazil, with three posters detailing its Otavio Macedo also reported the use of
apart. The high placebo response noted is effects on acne and photo-rejuvenation. MAL-PDT in 10 patients with AK and mild to
probably explained by the preparatory Otavio Macedo and colleagues (São Paulo, severe facial photodamage. After 3-hour
curettage performed before cream Brazil) reported MAL-PDT for ten patients MAL application, red LED light (Aktilite CL
application. with mild-to-moderate inflammatory acne. 128) illuminated the treatment fields. After
Tim Maisch and colleagues Metvix® was applied on the whole face the first PDT session, all visible AKs had
(Regensburg, Germany) displayed a poster under occlusive dressing for one hour. The cleared. Clinical improvement of photo-
on ‘Protoporphyrin IX fluorescence face was illuminated with blue light (Clear ageing, mottled hyperpigmentation, fine
induction after application of different 5- Light®) for 20 minutes, with three lines, roughness and sallowness were seen
aminolevulinic acid formulations’. Using treatments, one month apart. Four weeks in all patients. There was also smoothing and
a new full thickness porcine skin model after the third treatment, a reduction in softening of perioral and periorbital rhytides.
(freshly excised porcine skin embedded in inflammatory and non-inflammatory lesions Jens Thiele and colleagues (Boston,
Hepes-agar), the skin sections were and also the fluorescence related to P. acnes USA) reported two organ transplant
incubated with five different 20% 5-ALA was observed. recipients, one with chronic radiation
formulations: 5-ALA + DMSO (5-ALA gel + In a separate poster, Beatriz Niwa (São dermatatis and one with erythroplasia of
40% DMSO [penetration enhancer]); 5-ALA Paulo, Brazil) reported the response of 10 Queryat (EQ), where the EQ cleared and
w/o DMSO (5-ALA gel without 40% DMSO); patients with moderate to severe acne to other treated skin sites showed a reduction
5-ALA lipophilic (5-ALA cream oil/water); 5- three MAL-PDT treatments at 4-week in the formation of new NMSC, using ALA-
ALA hydrophilic (5-ALA ointment water/oil, intervals, using 90-minute application and PDT and blue light.

Spring 2008 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS 11


Daniel Wasserman and colleagues ALA-PDT (30-60 minute application) in oily vehicle under occlusion for four hours,
(Boston, USA) reported the use of ALA-PDT patients with hidradenitis suppuritiva. Two which may have exacerbated the condition.
in five patients with basal cell naevus patients achieved 75% improvement, Sima Torabian and colleagues
syndrome with numerous basal cell sustained for at least nine months after (University of California-Davis, USA) used
carcinomas (BCC). There was clearance of three treatments at 2-week intervals. ALA-PDT in a patient with refractory
most treated lesions, despite using blue Improvement was less impressive for the Flegel’s Disease, a disorder of
light, although several lesions were injected two other cases. The authors point out that keratinisation. Improvement in appearance,
with ALA 1:1 with 1% lidocaine containing 10/14 patients, treated with PDT and with 80-90% reduction in visible lesions,
epinephrine. The authors also observed a reported in the literature, to date, achieved was achieved following six treatments with
striking decrease in the number of new BCC moderate to outstanding results. The four ALA-PDT (ALA for 60-90 minutes) using a
developing during follow-up of up to five who did not had treatment with ALA in an blue light.
years.
Eric S. Schweiger et al (Kansas City,
USA) presented one of two posters on the
use of ALA-PDT for hidradenitis suppuritiva.
His open-label study investigated PDT using
two blue light sources and an intense
pulsed light (IPL) for photo-activation.
Twelve subjects with active HS received PDT
once weekly for four weeks, with follow-up
visits four and 12 weeks later. For the nine
patients who completed the study, mean
lesion counts reduced by 50.8%, with a 27%
improvement in mean Dermatology Life
Quality Index scores. Blue light was better
tolerated than the IPL.
Erin C. DeVita and Amy Taub
(Lincolnshire, USA) also reported the
effective use of blue-light or IPL-delivered San Antonio Riverwalk.

Calendar of Events September 17-21, Paris, France


EADV 2008 – 17th Annual Congress of the European
Academy of Dermatology and Venereology
2008-2009 Contact: EADV 2008/MCI
Tel: +33 153 858 270 Fax: +33 153 858 283
March 6-8, Barcelona, Spain e-mail: info@eadvparis2008.com
EURO-PDT 8th Annual Congress URL: www.eadvparis2008.com
Contact: Claudia Zange, Department of Dermatology
University of Regensburg, Franz-Josef-Strauss-Allee 11 October 7-11, Brixen/Bressanone, Italy
93053 Regensburg, Germany 7th International Symposium on PDT and
Fax: +49 941 944 9662 Photodiagnosis in Clinical Practice
e-mail: claudia.zange@euro-pdt.org URL: www.euro-pdt.org Contact: Prof G Jori
Tel: +39 049 827 6333 Fax: +39 039 827 6344
March 27, London, UK e-mail: giulio.jori@unipd.it
Medical Dermatology or
Contact: Conference and Event Services Prof H Kostron
The British Association of Dermatologists, 4 Fitzroy Square Tel: +43 512 504 27278 Fax: +43 512 504 27460
London W1T 5HQ e-mail: herwig.kostron@uibk.ac.at
Tel: +44 (0)20 7391 6358 Fax: +44 (0)20 7388 0487 URL: www.bio.unipd.it/PDT2008
e-mail: conference@bad.org.uk
URL: www.bad.org.uk

May 15-17, Athens, Greece 2009


9th Congress of the European Society for Pediatric
Dermatology (ESPD) March 6-10, San Francisco, USA
Contact: Penelope Mitroyianni 67th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of
Tel: +30 2 107 257 693 Fax: +30 2 107 257 532 Dermatology (AAD)
e-mail: info@espd2008.com URL: www.espd2008.com Contact: AAD Secretariat
Tel: +1 202 842 3555 Fax: +1 202 842 4355
June 5-7, Athens, Greece
12th COSMODERM – Joint Meeting of ESCAD/Hellenic May 3-6, Tel Aviv, Israel
Society of Dermatology and Venereology 12th World Congress on Cancer of the Skin (WCCS)
Contact: Penelope Mitroyianni Contact: WCCS Meeting Organiser
Tel: +30 2 107 257 693 Fax: +30 2 107 257 532 Tel: +41 229 080 488 Fax: +41 227 322 850
e-mail: info@erasmus.gr e-mail: wccs2009@kenes.com

Published by Eurocommunica Publications, Caxton House, 51 Barnham Road, Barnham, West Sussex PO22 0ER, United Kingdom
Tel: +44 (0)1243 555041/2 Fax: +44 (0) 1243 555043 e-mail: eurocommunica@compuserve.com
The opinions contained in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Eurocommunica or the Editorial Board

12 CLINICAL PHOTODYNAMICS Volume 1 Number 10

You might also like