You are on page 1of 5

Neuron

NeuroView

Gut Microbe to Brain Signaling:


What Happens in Vagus.
€ lling,1 Timothy G. Dinan,1,2 and John F. Cryan1,3,*
Christine Fu
1APC Microbiome Ireland, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland
2Department of Psychiatry and Neurobehavioural Science, University College Cork, Ireland
3Department of Anatomy and Neuroscience, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland

*Correspondence: j.cryan@ucc.ie
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2019.02.008

The gut microbiota has emerged as a key player in health and disease. Here we discuss the vagus nerve,
which connects the visceral organs and the brain, as an important communication pathway for the gut micro-
biota to influence brain and behavior.

Visceral organs and the central nervous microbial communities, much attention species is therefore highly adapted to
system constantly communicate to pro- has been drawn to the one residing in the perform specific functions in defined
vide a sense of the body’s physiological GI tract, which is the largest and most environmental niches of the GI tract. As
condition and to adapt accordingly to diverse community of microorganisms. a whole, the gut microbiota produces
maintain homeostasis. One of the key The initial microbiota is acquired at birth an array of metabolites ranging from
players in this interoceptive feedback and develops alongside its host. Although sugars and short chain fatty acids to
loop is the gut-brain axis, the complex rather easily perturbed in these early neuroactive substances such as seroto-
bidirectional communication between critical years, the microbiota acquires in- nin or g-aminobutyric acid. These can
the gastrointestinal (GI) tract and the cen- ternal stability during the first years of serve as energy sources for the gut mi-
tral nervous system that involves endo- development. This process is regulated crobiota itself or the host, or can act on
crine, immune, and neural communica- by a combination of host genetics the host’s signaling pathways.
tion mechanisms, such as that through and environmental factors such as diet,
vagus nerve signaling. Although best stress, and exposure to other microbes Microbiota and Brain
studied in the context of food intake and or antibiotics. Hence, a well-functioning Some of the most convincing evidence
satiety, it is clear that this axis can play a microbiota is highly adapted to the host for the involvement of the microbiota in
role across many aspects of physiology and the host’s habitat and carries out host physiology and psychology emerged
and behavior. More recently the micro- metabolic and biochemical processes from germ-free rodents, which have been
biota (the trillions of microorganisms in that are important for the host’s function. deprived of any kind of microbe-host in-
and on our body) has been shown to be Although this description is broadly appli- teractions from birth. The lack of micro-
a key regulator of the gut-brain axis, and cable to a stable human gut microbiota, biota in these animals resulted in a variety
thus the microbiota-gut-brain axis has the presence and abundance of bacterial of altered physiological functions ranging
been proposed. However, the regulatory species can vary significantly between in- from gut sensory-motor functions and
mechanisms occurring are only now be- dividuals. This inter-individual difference gastric emptying to blood-brain barrier
ing unravelled. In this NeuroView, we is accounted for by the importance of integrity and immune functions. Further-
focus on one such pathway and describe the functions carried out by the micro- more, germ-free rodents showed drastic
how the gut microbiota may hijack vagus biota, rather than the individual species, alterations in brain physiology. Changes
nerve signaling as a means to alter brain thus allowing unique microbiota composi- in hippocampal levels of the neuro-
and behavior. tion without losing functionality. The adult transmitter serotonin, brain-derived neu-
microbiota is relatively stable but main- rotrophic factor (BDNF), and an altered
Microbiota tains a certain degree of flexibility to level of neurogenesis, as well as structural
The microbiota describes the consortium change in response to intrinsic and envi- changes to neurons in the amygdala, and
of different microbes, including bacteria, ronmental factors (Figure 1A; Bastiaans- variations in the level of myelination in
archaea, fungi, viruses, and parasites sen et al., 2019). the prefrontal cortex provide the physio-
that live on our skin, in our lungs, and in logical means to explain the differ-
the urogenital and GI tracts. Over the Habitat and Function ences in stress reactivity, anxiety-related,
preceding decades, the microbiota has It is important to stress that the gut mi- depressive-like, and social behaviors as
received increased attention for its crobiota is not uniform. Diversity and well as cognition observed in germ-free
involvement in various diseases ranging density of microorganisms increase animals (Figure 1B). While these studies
from obesity to cancer and has become along the GI tract according to nutri- indicated a relationship between the mi-
one of the most reviewed topics in tional, chemical, and immunological crobiota and brain and behavior, incon-
biomedical science. Within the different gradients (Figure 1C). Each individual trovertible evidence for this link came

998 Neuron 101, March 20, 2019 ª 2019 Elsevier Inc.


Neuron

NeuroView

Figure 1. The Microbiota-Gut-Brain Axis


(A) Factors influencing the composition of the gut microbiota. The initial microbiota is acquired at birth and is shaped by a variety of intrinsic and environmental
factors. Although microbiota stability peaks in adulthood, it maintains flexibility to adjust to environmental or dietary changes.
(B) Evidence for the influence of the gut microbiota on brain physiology has surfaced mostly from studying germ-free animals, which show alterations in various
aspects of neurophysiology.
(C) The microbiota-gut-brain axis encompasses different routes of communication that, depending on their location and function, can be hijacked by specific
species of the gut microbiota to influence brain and behavior. Gradients of pH, oxygen, antimicrobial peptides, and bile salts determine the density and diversity of
microbial species along the GI tract. Metabolites produced by the gut microbiota can either activate enteroendocrine cells to release gut hormones or be
absorbed across the epithelial cell layer to either be taken up by the bloodstream or to activate vagus nerve afferents to communicate with the brain. Different
types of vagal afferents can be found within the GI tract that transmits different signals to the brain. Thus, a combination of the location of the microbiota within the
GI tract and the chemicals produced is likely to determine where and how within the NTS the information is relayed, thereby provoking different behavioral
responses.

from a study where anxiety phenotypes gut microbiota of patients with depression well as social behavior (Bastiaanssen
could be transmitted between strains of exhibited increased levels of anxiety- et al., 2019).
animals solely through the transplantation related and depressive-like behavior.
of the gut microbiota (Bercik et al., 2011). Similarly, germ-free animals receiving Mechanisms of Microbiota-Gut-
To date, a variety of preclinical and clinical the gut microbiota from patients with Par- Brain Signaling
studies have linked the gut microbiota kinson’s disease or multiple sclerosis Despite this large body of evidence from
to health and disease. Drastic changes developed motor deficits accompanied rodent and human studies supporting
in the gut microbiota have been observed by neuroinflammation and autoimmune the influence of gut microbiota on physi-
in patients with autism spectrum dis- encephalomyelitis, respectively. Strik- ology and psychology, we do not yet fully
order, schizophrenia, major depression, ingly, germ-free mice or antibiotic-treated understand the mechanisms utilized by
Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s dis- transgenic mouse models of Alzheimer’s the gut microbiota to impact brain and
ease, and multiple sclerosis. Interestingly, disease do not develop plaques. Further- behavior.
when transferring the gut microbiota of more, preclinical studies demonstrated What we know is that constant commu-
patients with these diseases to suscepti- beneficial effects of the supplementation nication within the gut-brain axis regu-
ble germ-free animals, many of the symp- of specific bacterial strains (probiotics) lates specific aspects of homeostasis,
toms start to emerge which adds a causal or so-called prebiotics, which serve as partly through signals coming from the
element to the microbiota-gut-brain axis. an energy source for beneficial bacteria, gut microbiota. This exchange is bidi-
Germ-free animals that had received the on anxiety-related, depressive-like as rectional, thus, not only can the gut

Neuron 101, March 20, 2019 999


Neuron

NeuroView

microbiota influence the host by changing adult neurogenesis, stress reactivity, anx- the GI tract, widens the scope of signals
aspects of homeostasis, but the opposite iety- and fear-related behavior, as well as that can be transmitted by the vagus
is also true. cognition, which are indicative of brain nerve. Different types of mucosal endings
The gut-brain axis comprises different changes observed in psychiatric disease. have been described in the small intes-
routes of communication including endo- In contrast, vagus nerve stimulation, orig- tine: vagal villi and vagal crypt afferents.
crine, immune, or neural mechanisms, inally used for treating refractory epilepsy, Vagal villi afferents, as the name sug-
through which the gut microbiota is resulted in mood improvement of patients gests, terminate mostly in the apical part
capable of influencing the central nervous and is now approved as a method to treat of the villus in close proximity to the
system. The gut microbiota can stimulate patients with refractory depression. epithelial layer. Vagal crypt afferent end-
the release of gut peptides and hormones Studies have shown that these vagal- ings, on the other hand, encircle the
from enteroendocrine cells which are mediated effects are also influenced by luminal end of intestinal crypts. Although
taken up by the bloodstream to affect gut bacteria. Specific bacterial strains mucosal vagal afferents were thought to
centrally mediated events. Similarly, it in- have been demonstrated to utilize vagus be free neuronal terminals, a recent study
duces cytokine and chemokine release nerve signaling to communicate with the has demonstrated that at least a specific
that locally regulate bacterial concentra- brain and to alter behavior. For example, type of enteroendocrine cells are able to
tions, but these factors can also infiltrate administration of a subclinical dose of form glutamatergic synapses with what
the blood and lymphatic systems, ulti- the diarrhea-causing pathogen Campylo- are likely to be vagal villus afferents in
mately allowing them to have direct or in- bacter jejuni resulted in increased levels of the small intestine (Figure 1C). Similar
direct central effects. anxiety-related behavior and Fos immu- connections were also observed in the
noreactivity in cell bodies of vagal affer- distal colon between enteroendocrine
The Vagus Nerve ents as well as in the nucleus tractus sol- cells in the luminal part of the crypt and
Although the gut microbiota can commu- itarius (NTS), the main projection side of vagal afferents (Kaelberer et al., 2018).
nicate by endocrine and immune path- gut-related vagal afferents in the brain While muscular vagal afferents are
ways, perhaps the fastest and most (Goehler et al., 2005). In addition, the implicated in detecting stretch and
direct way for the microbiota to influence beneficial effects of Lactobacillus rham- tension, mucosal vagal afferents are
the brain is by hijacking vagus nerve nosus JB1 (L. rhamnosus JB1) on anxi- perfectly situated to detect chemicals
signaling. The vagus nerve, which is the ety-related and depressive-like behavior absorbed across the epithelial layer or
10th cranial nerve, links the viscera with are blocked following vagotomy (Bravo released by epithelial cells in response
the brain. It is a paired nerve that consists et al., 2011), as are the cognitive and elec- to luminal stimuli and to transmit this infor-
of sensory (afferent) and motor (efferent) trophysiological effects of a prebiotic mation within seconds. Electrophysiolog-
neurons. The vagus nerve tonically trans- which stimulates the production of bene- ical experiments have demonstrated that
mits information from the viscera to the ficial bacteria (Vazquez et al., 2016). vagal afferents respond to a variety of
brain and vice versa, and as part of the L. reuteri, which improves both social such stimuli including cytokines, nutri-
parasympathetic branch of the autonomic behavior in animal models of autism and ents, gut peptides, and hormones. There-
nervous system is involved in maintaining wound healing, both via oxytocin fore, the gut microbiota can alter vagus
corporeal homeostasis. The vagus nerve signaling, has been shown to be depen- nerve signaling by directly influencing
has been extensively studied for its dent on vagus nerve regulated pathways the concentration or by inducing the
involvement in hunger, satiety, and stress (Sgritta et al., 2019). release of either of these factors from en-
response but also for its major role in the To understand how specific bacteria teroendocrine or gastrointestinal immune
regulation of inflammation via neuronal within the gut microbiota utilize the vagus cells. Furthermore, some bacterial strains
motor efferents. nerve to communicate with the brain, we can produce neurotransmitters such as
Evidence for the involvement of gut need to understand where and how they serotonin that, when absorbed, can act
vagal neurons in mental health and can interact with the vagus nerve and directly on vagus nerve endings or
mood-related disorders surfaced as early when and how long they activate it to indirectly through activation of enteric
as the beginning of the 20th century when exert their effects on the brain. Finally, neurons.
gastrectomy (the partial or complete we need to be able to determine what cir- Information from the vagus nerve is
removal of the stomach) was applied to cuits are altered in the brain. relayed in the brainstem, where gut vagal
treat peptic ulcers. As a side effect, this afferents mostly synapse onto neurons in
resulted in the ablation of vagus nerve Where. the NTS. Gastrointestinal vagal afferents
activity from the stomach downward, Within the small and large intestine, in the NTS are topographically organized,
thereby preventing vagal communication vagal afferents end in the muscle layer with vagal afferents from the stomach
between the lower GI tract and the brain. as well as in the mucosa. In the muscle projecting to the medial and gelatinous nu-
Patients that underwent this treatment layer, vagal afferents form intraganglionic cleus and afferents from the intestines syn-
demonstrated increased occurrences of laminar endings and intramuscular arrays, apsing onto neurons in the medial and
psychiatric-related disorders. These find- while some vagal endings synapse onto commissural nucleus. Although glutamate
ings are supported by similar animal neurons from the enteric nervous system. is the main neurotransmitter, evidence
studies that ablated gut-related vagal The connection with the enteric nervous suggests that in addition to the topo-
communication, resulting in changes in system, which governs the function of logical organization, vagal afferents utilize

1000 Neuron 101, March 20, 2019


Neuron

NeuroView

different neurotransmitters depending on show alterations in cardiac vagal tone. to identify the parabrachial nucleus
their origin. For example, the neuropep- Although it is yet to be determined (PBN) as a relay structure for vagus nerve
tide cocaine and amphetamine-regulated whether changes in vagal tone in these signaling-dependent effects on reward
transcript, which is involved in satiety instances are cause or consequence, and avoidance behavior. Gut vagal affer-
signaling, is mainly expressed in afferents these observations highlight the link be- ents transmit information from the NTS
from the proximal GI tract. tween gut-related changes and the auto- to the PBN and from there to the substan-
Therefore, it is becoming clear that the nomic nervous system and suggest that tia nigra (SN) or the central nucleus of the
location of the microbiota within the GI the gut microbiota might be capable of amygdala (CeA). Activation of the PBN-
tract and the chemicals produced deter- influencing homeostasis by changing SN pathway results in the induction of
mine where and how within the NTS the the properties of vagus nerve signaling reward-related behavior whereas activa-
information is relayed. and related neuronal networks (Bonaz tion of the PBN-CeA pathway evokes
et al., 2016). avoidance behavior (Han et al., 2018). In
When. addition, a link between the NTS and the
When the equilibrium of the gut micro- What. hippocampus via the medial septum has
biota is altered with the supplementation Understanding the neural circuitry under- been demonstrated. This pathway pro-
of bacterial species, different incubation lying the effects of vagal stimulation on vides the means by which information
times seem to be needed to exert effects brain and behavior is a key goal for the coming from the vagus nerve can impact
on brain and behavior. Whereas an acute, field. Advances in optogenetic and che- hippocampal-dependent memory pro-
subclinical dose of pathogens can result mogenetic tools are transforming how cesses. Indeed, it was shown that lesion-
in brain effects and altered behavior we delineate the relative contribution of ing of the vagus nerve or subdiaphrag-
within hours, effects of probiotic strains these pathways to vagus-dependent be- matic deafferentation impaired episodic
(e.g., L. reuteri and L. rhamnosus) are haviors. However, most of our knowledge memory and altered BDNF concentra-
usually described after weeks of chronic to date has emerged from lesion and tions in the hippocampus of rats (Suarez
treatment. Nevertheless, electrophysio- pharmacological studies coupled with et al., 2018). Furthermore, vagus nerve
logical studies have shown that direct sophisticated anatomical tracing tech- stimulation is thought to at least in part
infusion of L. rhamnosus into the small in- niques. From the NTS, information is impact depression by acting on noradren-
testine increases the constitutive firing relayed to various forebrain regions and ergic neurons in the locus coeruleus (LC)
frequency of vagal afferents within mi- other brainstem nuclei, most of which which in turn can impact the serotonergic
nutes after luminal application (Perez- are also part of the central autonomic system in the dorsal raphe nucleus (DRN).
Burgos et al., 2013). network. Projections from the NTS to the The NTS-LC-DRN thereby provides
These observations raise the question forebrain that also receive information another neuronal pathway that could be
of whether bacterial species affecting from the GI tract have been identified by utilized by the gut microbiota to impact
the vagus nerve induce neurobiological tracing studies. These include, among brain and behavior. Finally, integration of
changes by simply activating the vagus others, the parabrachial nucleus, locus the NTS into the dorsal vagal complex,
nerve or by slowly altering the properties coeruleus, hypothalamus, amygdala, which is critical for interoceptive feed-
of vagus nerve signaling and related bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, ventral back, puts the NTS at a perfect relay
neuronal networks, or both. Changes to tegmental area (VTA), and medial septum hub for vagus nerve signaling to impact
excitability, synapse remodeling, or alter- which provide the means to influence physiology and psychology.
ation of the sensitivity for certain chemi- emotionality and motivation. In addition, Proof that gut bacteria utilize these
cals in response to microbiota-derived multi-synaptic projections ascending communication pathways has been un-
metabolites could therefore permanently from the NTS can transfer information covered in mouse models. Using opto-
affect vagus nerve signaling and in turn, from the vagus nerve to most likely any genetic tools, it was demonstrated that
result in changes to the vagal tone. Vagal given structure in the brain. Studies iden- L. reuteri utilizes the NTS-PVN-VTA
tone describes the strength of vagal tifying the specific neuronal networks pathway to alter social behavior in mouse
(parasympathetic) activation in the dy- involved in vagal gut-brain signaling and models of autism spectrum disorder.
namic interaction between the parasym- their effect on behavior have started to By activating the vagus nerve, L. reuteri
pathetic and sympathetic branches of emerge. increased oxytocin levels in the PVN
the autonomous nervous system. Cardiac The paraventricular nucleus (PVN) of thereby rescuing social interaction-
vagal tone, as measured by heart rate the hypothalamus is an important hub evoked long-term potentiation in dopami-
variability, is often used to measure the for relay signals emanating from the vagus nergic neurons in the VTA, which in turn
strength of parasympathetic activation. nerve. Its projections to the pituitary and results in the normalization of social
When homeostasis is challenged in such the VTA provide the means to directly in- behavior (Sgritta et al., 2019). In addition,
instances as stress, changes in cardiac fluence the hypothalamic-pituitary-adre- direct projections from the NTS to the
vagal tone can be observed. Interestingly, nal axis and the mesolimbic dopaminergic amygdala are likely to be involved in the
patients with Crohn’s disease or irritable system, respectively allowing the vagus effects of L. rhamnosus on anxiety-related
bowel syndrome, two diseases with nerve to interact with stress response behavior as administration decreased
malfunctioning gut-brain communication and reward circuitries. In addition, opto- GABAAa2 receptor subunit expression
and altered visceral interoception, also genetic tools have recently been used in the amygdala (Bravo et al., 2011).

Neuron 101, March 20, 2019 1001


Neuron

NeuroView

Furthermore, the effects on BDNF levels include, the details of species and Bonaz, B., Sinniger, V., and Pellissier, S.
(2016). Vagal tone: effects on sensitivity,
in the hippocampus following the coloni- habitat-specific communication required, motility, and inflammation. Neurogastroenterol.
zation of germ-free mice with gut bacteria to the identification of the neuronal net- Motil. 28, 455–462.
(Bercik et al., 2011) might be mediated by works within the brain that link the vagus
Bravo, J.A., Forsythe, P., Chew, M.V., Escaravage,
the multi-synaptic pathway between the nerve to a certain behavior. E., Savignac, H.M., Dinan, T.G., Bienenstock, J.,
NTS and the hippocampus as described Finally, it is important to stress that and Cryan, J.F. (2011). Ingestion of Lactobacillus
above. The same pathway could be there has never been a time where strain regulates emotional behavior and central
GABA receptor expression in a mouse via the va-
responsible for changes in GABA recep- the nervous system has existed without gus nerve. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108,
tor expression following L. rhamnosus microbial signals, and thus perhaps it is 16050–16055.
administration (Bravo et al., 2011). How- not surprising that the vagus is hardwired Goehler, L.E., Gaykema, R.P., Opitz, N.,
ever, many studies have also shown to intercept and conduct such signals Reddaway, R., Badr, N., and Lyte, M. (2005).
that the gut microbiota influences gene to moderate behavior. Although most Activation in vagal afferents and central autonomic
pathways: early responses to intestinal infection
expression in the cortex but the exact studies to date are in rodents, given the with Campylobacter jejuni. Brain Behav. Immun.
neuronal pathways by which these advances in bioelectronics in respect to 19, 334–344.
changes are mediated have yet to be vagus nerve stimulation, future studies in
Han, W., Tellez, L.A., Perkins, M.H., Perez, I.O., Qu,
determined. humans investigating the mechanisms of T., Ferreira, J., Ferreira, T.L., Quinn, D., Liu, Z.W.,
microbiota-vagus-brain interactions will Gao, X.B., et al. (2018). A neural circuit for gut-
induced reward. Cell 175, 665–678.e23.
Conclusion emerge. Although much has yet to be
Studies utilizing germ-free rodents or discovered, it is clear that in the context Kaelberer, M.M., Buchanan, K.L., Klein, M.E.,
administration of specific bacterial strains of microbiota at least what happens Barth, B.B., Montoya, M.M., Shen, X., and
Bohórquez, D.V. (2018). A gut-brain neural cir-
have provided ample evidence for the role in vagus doesn’t stay in vagus but af- cuit for nutrient sensory transduction. Science
of the gut microbiota in physiology and fects many aspects of emotionality and 361, 361.
psychology. Although most studies have neurobiology.
Perez-Burgos, A., Wang, B., Mao, Y.K., Mistry, B.,
focused on a specific behavioral readout McVey Neufeld, K.A., Bienenstock, J., and Kunze,
when investigating the effects of single ACKNOWLEDGMENT W. (2013). Psychoactive bacteria Lactobacillus
rhamnosus (JB-1) elicits rapid frequency facilitation
or multiple bacterial strains on brain and in vagal afferents. Am. J. Physiol. Gastrointest.
behavior, the effect of the gut microbiota We thank Dr. Kiran Sandhu for assistance in pre- Liver Physiol. 304, G211–G220.
paring the figure. We would like to acknowledge
is far more extensive when analyzed in all the wonderful scientists who we couldn’t refer- Sgritta, M., Dooling, S.W., Buffington, S.A., Momin,
the context of homeostasis. Thus, with ence due to reference number restrictions. This E.N., Francis, M.B., Britton, R.A., and Costa-
the ability to impact the vagus nerve and work was supported by the Science Foundation Mattioli, M. (2019). Mechanisms underlying micro-
Ireland (SFI) through the Irish Government’s bial-mediated changes in social behavior in mouse
vagus nerve-related functions, the gut mi- models of autism spectrum disorder. Neuron 101,
National Development Plan (Grant Nos. SFI/12/
crobiota offers the possibility to employ RC/2273). 246–259.e6.
the manipulation of the gut microbiota
Suarez, A.N., Hsu, T.M., Liu, C.M., Noble, E.E.,
as a non-invasive treatment option for REFERENCES Cortella, A.M., Nakamoto, E.M., Hahn, J.D., de
various conditions. Lartigue, G., and Kanoski, S.E. (2018). Gut vagal
However, we are only starting to under- Bastiaanssen, T.F.S., Cowan, C.S.M., Claesson, sensory signaling regulates hippocampus function
M.J., Dinan, T.G., and Cryan, J.F. (2019). Making through multi-order pathways. Nat. Commun.
stand the means by which the microbiota- sense of . the microbiome in psychiatry. Int. J. 9, 2181.
gut-brain axis operates. Various factors Neuropsychopharmacol. 22, 37–52.
Vazquez, E., Barranco, A., Ramirez, M., Gruart,
determine the means by which a single Bercik, P., Denou, E., Collins, J., Jackson, W., Lu, A., Delgado-Garcia, J.M., Jimenez, M.L., Buck,
bacterial species, or the gut microbiota J., Jury, J., Deng, Y., Blennerhassett, P., Macri, R., and Rueda, R. (2016). Dietary 20 -fucosyllac-
as a whole, can impact brain and J., McCoy, K.D., et al. (2011). The intestinal tose enhances operant conditioning and long-
microbiota affect central levels of brain-derived term potentiation via gut-brain communication
behavior, and a number of exiting ques- neurotropic factor and behavior in mice. through the vagus nerve in rodents. PLoS ONE
tions still need to be addressed. These Gastroenterology 141, 599–609, 609.e1–609.e3. 11, e0166070.

1002 Neuron 101, March 20, 2019

You might also like