Professional Documents
Culture Documents
on Three Continents
Drahoslav Hulínek
Dominik Bonatz
Milan Kováč (eds.)
ISBN: 978 – 80 – 89704 – 01 – 9 Bratislava 2015
Archaeology on Three Continents 2006 – 2011
157
Miloš Gregor, Milan Kováč, Branislav Kovár
Fig. 1 Crystalo-
clasts of calcite
and lithoclasts
of intrasparitic
or micritic lime-
stone. Photo:
Project SAHI –
Uaxactun.
tegrating device Eltinor IV (Department of Geology and -fine class ceramics. The structure of matrix also differs
Paleontology, Faculty of Natural Sciences, Comenius between the subgroups. The chaotic structure of matrix is
University in Bratislava). characteristic for the C1 subgroup, whereas the matrix in
subgroup C2 is mainly fluidal.
CARBONATE GROUP
Based on the mineralogical and petrographic compo-
sition of temper and matrix of analyzed fragments, two Division according to ceramic type, with
main petrographic groups were distinguished. The first indicated ad mixture of volcanic ash:
group, consisting of 24 out of 40 sherds is marked as UA-
X/C (Uaxactun / Carbonates) and its composition con- TEPEU
tains subangular to angular crystaloclasts of calcite, and Total amount of Tinaja Rojo: 5
lithoclasts of intrasparitic or micritic limestone (Fig. 1). Tinaja Rojo with volcanic ash: 4
Occasional crystaloclasts of euhedral to anhedral quartz Total amount of Cambio sin engobe: 5
or chalcedony, and lithoclasts of silicites were also iden- Cambio sin engobe with volcanic ash: 3
tified (Fig 3). The matrix is characterized by an isotro- Total amount of Maquina Café: 2
pic optical character and in the X-ray diffraction record Maquina Café with volcanic ash: 2
quartz and calcite were identified. The diffraction peaks
that would correspond to clay minerals (illite, kaolinite) TZAKOL
were not observed. According to the modified Wentworth Total amount of Aguila Naranja: 8
granulometric classification (Ionescu and Ghergari, 2002) Aguila Naranja with volcanic ash: 6
the samples from UAX/C can be divided in to two sub-
groups that differ in their matrix: temper ratio. In the sub-
group C1 temper clearly prevails over the matrix, where CHICANEL
as in the subgroup C2 temper occurs more sporadically Total amount of Laguna verde inciso: 1
(Fig 2). This is also reflected in the modified Wentworth Laguna verde inciso with volcanic ash: 1
granulometric classification where the samples from sub-
group UAX/C1 belong to the class of coarse ceramics Tab. 2 Division according to ceramic type, with indicated ad
and the samples from subgroup UAX/C2 to the semi- mixture of volcanic ash
158
Volcanic Ash in Ancient Maya Ceramics. Mineralogical and petrographical characterization
of Maya ceramics from Uaxactún, Guatemala.
Fig. 2 Fragment
of potery – sub-
group C2. Photo:
Project SAHI –
Uaxactun.
159
Miloš Gregor, Milan Kováč, Branislav Kovár
Fig. 3 Crys-
taloclasts of
fast euhedral
quartz. Photo:
Project SAHI
– Uaxactun.
composition of the matrix and temper, using optical (Maggetti, 1982; Riccardi et al., 1999; Cultorne et al.,
microscopy and X-ray diffraction analysis. The resul- 2001; Ionescu and Ghergari, 2002, Reedy, 2008). The
ting data were then compared with published work presence of thermally unalterd calcite in the group UA-
dealing with the identification of firing temperature X/C corresponds to temperatures that did not exceed
Fig. 4 Volcanic
glass in sample.
Photo: Project
SAHI – Uaxac-
tun.
160
Volcanic Ash in Ancient Maya Ceramics. Mineralogical and petrographical characterization
of Maya ceramics from Uaxactún, Guatemala.
Fig. 5 Fragments
of amphiboles.
Photo: Project
SAHI – Uaxactun.
800 °C. The absence of diffraction peaks of clay mi- matrix was composed from illite, then its optical cha-
nerals, might, besides temperature, to some extent also racter would correspond to temperatures exceeding 800
reflect the original composition of clay-rich raw materi- °C. However, no diffraction peaks corresponding to il-
al. If the material contained illit, one of the most com- lite were observed in the X-ray diffraction record, and
mon clay minerals, it would be possible to observe the the matrix also shows no signs of melting, which would
diffraction peaks of this mineral also in ceramics fired correspond to temperatures over 1000 °C. It is therefo-
at temperatures over 900 °C. The absence of diffraction re likely that the clay-rich raw material was composed
peaks of clay minerals at the maximum firing tempera- mainly of kaolinite. Based on the changes observed in
ture up to 800 °C may correspond with the presence of the matrix and temper, the firing temperature of cera-
kaolinite in the original composition of clayish material. mics from the group UAX/VA was higher than 800 °C.
Within the temperature range 500-600 °C, the kaolinite
is transformed to metakaolinite, which is amorphous. POTTERY MAKING PROCESS
The process of transformation of kaolinite to metaka- The forming techniques were derived from the ob-
olinite is observable as a gradual diminishing of the served structure and the data were compared with ex-
diffraction intensities of kaolinite, until their disappea- perimental work and published data (Shepard, 1957;
rance at a temperature of 600 °C. The isotropic optical Velde and Druc, 1999; Ionescu et al., 2007, Reedy,
character of the matrix and the absence of diffraction 2008). All analyzed matrix structures are characteristic
peaks of clay minerals may, therefore, suggest that the for the ceramics-forming technique by modeling. A high
original material was composed mainly of kaolinite. In proportion of temper and chaotic structure in the sub-
this respect, the firing temperature of the UAX / C can group UAX/C1 and UAX/VA could correspond to the
be determined as being within the range of 600-800 °C. technique by pressing the prepared material on a form.
The firing temperature for the group UAX/VA is sig- The vessels are made of more than two pieces. The flui-
nificantly higher than for the UAX/C group. As in the dal structure of the matrix and a smaller proportion of
previous case, no diffraction peaks corresponding to temper in subgroup UAX/C2 probably corresponds to
clay minerals were observed. This could be due either the hand building method, where the gradual drawing
to the higher firing temperature, or to the composition of up and shaping of the walls is used. This structure also
the clay material. Thermally altered calcite corresponds corresponds to the so-called paddle and anvil technique.
to temperatures having been higher than 800 °C. If the For a more precise identification of the modeling tech-
161
Miloš Gregor, Milan Kováč, Branislav Kovár
Fig. 6 Thermally
altered calcite.
Photo: Project
SAHI – Uaxac-
tun.
nique, a detailed study of macroscopic features on the formations can only be found in a considerable distance
surface, or within the ceramic, would be necessary. Only from the site. Uaxactún is at least 300km from every
their combination with microscopic features, would, possible source of volcanic ash, and more like 400-500
however, finally allow the refinement of individual for- km along some likely pedestrian routes. Therefore, this
ming techniques. group of ceramics may represent either the import of
The potential sources of temper and clay material, ceramic vases or ash from volcanic areas. Alternative-
from which the pottery was made, were derived based ly, it could indicate the use of deposits from volcanic
on the mineralogical and petrographic composition of ash carried by air over long distances. The volcanoes
the matrix and ceramics. The results were compared El Chichón and Cerro Quemado are mainly indicated as
with the geological situation in the wider surroundings the source of volcanic ash in the Petén area; Acatenan-
of the site, as well as with previously published data (Jo- go, Tajumulco or Pacaya volcano (or Volcano the Agua)
nes, 1986, Lyeden et al., 1993, Hardy, 2006; Ford and in the lake Amatitlan may also be alternative candidates
Spera, 2007). The group UAX/C, characterized by the (Ford and Rose 1995, 159).
presence of carbonates used as temper, and raw material According to Ford and Spera (2007), ceramics tem-
rich in kaolinite, was probably made from local materi- pered with volcanic ash are characteristic of the Late
al sources, as the wider area around the site is built up Classic period. Our study indicates practically the same
mostly by Mesozoic carbonate rocks. This assumption, proportion also during the Early Classic. Volcanic ash
however, can only be proven by a more detailed petro- in the Uaxactún area probably originates from volcanic
graphic study of material taken directly from the site. eruptions in the west or the south. Ash was indeed trans-
ported in the form of large ash clouds over long distan-
ORIGIN OF VOLCANIC ASH ces, as evidenced by layers of ash in the sediment cores
The use of volcanic ash as temper in Maya pottery has from Lake Petén Itzá (Leyden et al., 1993). If these ash
long been demonstrated (Shepard, 1939, 1942); analyses fallouts were indeed the source, they had to be used to-
and discussions about specifics, however, continue with pically- immediately after deposition, as the analyzed
intensity. The presence of volcanic material in the group fragments of volcanic glass and pumice do not show any
UAX/VA therefore is not surprising, but represents a signs of weathering (!). Volcanic ash was subsequently
specific problem. The wider surroundings of the site are mixed with the clayey material derived from the wider
composed of carbonate rocks, and the nearest volcanic surroundings of Uaxactún. Ceramics with added volca-
162
Volcanic Ash in Ancient Maya Ceramics. Mineralogical and petrographical characterization
of Maya ceramics from Uaxactún, Guatemala.
nic ash were fired at higher temperatures than normal ceramics containing volcanic ash, has been known from
ceramics (tempered with carbonate rocks), providing the pre-Mamom phase (Sunahara et al 2006). Our ana-
better utility characteristics. lysis has brought further evidence of the Preclassic use
Jones (1986) considers volcanic material to be an im- of volcanic ash in ceramics, although it is clear that in
port, brought to lowland environment through existing Uaxactún, this was a less widespread phenomenon du-
obsidian trade routes. Volcanic ash is very light, even ring the Preclassic.
at large volumes, therefore it can be easily transported
over longer distances. The hypothesis is also supported CONCLUSIONS
by Hardy (2006). Volcanic ash-tempering was a com- We believe that the idea that volcanic ash used in ce-
mon practice in the Central Lowlands, its use already ramics came from natural deposits created by ash fallout
begun during the Preclassic period (Hardy, 2006). The is not sustainable for several reasons. The frequency of
evidence of extensive long distance trade, resulting in the use of volcanic ash during the Early and the Late
Group G Group A
Total amount: 7 Total amount: 1
Number containing volcanic ash admixture: 4 Number containing volcanic ash admixture: 1
period / total amount/with volcanic ash period / total amount/ with volcanich ash
Tepeu / 5 / 3 Tepeu / 1 / 1
Chicanel / 2 / 1
Group C Tz´ibatnah
Total amount: 7 Total amount: 3
Number containing volcanic ash admixture: 3 Number containing volcanic ash admixture: 2
period / total amount /with volcanic ash period / total amount/ with volcanic ash
Tzakol / 5 / 3 Tepeu / 3 / 2
Tepeu / 2 / 0
Group F North
Total amount: 4
Number containing volcanic ash admixture: 1
period / total amount /with volcanic ash
Chicanel / 2 / 0
Tepeu / 2 / 1
163
164
Sample UAX5D2-1/001 UAX5B/002 UAX5X10-3/003 UAX5D2-1/004 UAX5A3-2a/005 SB1E-2/006 UAX5D-1C4/007 UAX5D1-2b/008 UAX5X1-1/009 M010
Petrographic group UAX/C2 UAX/C2 UAX/C1 UAX/C1 UAX/C1 UAX/C2 UAX/C2 UAX/C2 UAX/C1 UAX/VA2
Colour of matrix dark brown brownish brownish reddish red-brown dark brown brownish dark brown dark brown dark brown
Optical character of matrix anisotropic anisotropic isotropic anisotropic isotropic anisotropic anisotropic anisotropic anisotropic anisotropic
Structure of matrix fluidal fluidal chaotic chaotic chaotic orientated chaotic fluidal weakly orientated weakly orientated
Granulometric composition medium medium coarse coarse coarse medium medium medium coarse coarse
Quartz + + + + + + + + + +
Chalcedony – – – – – – – – – –
Plagioclase – – – – – – – – – +
Calcite + + + + + + + + – –
Hematite – – – + + – – – – +
Amphibole – – – – – – – – – +
Limestone + + + + + + + + + –
Silicit – – – – – + – – – –
Volcanic rocks – – – – – – – – – +
Pedogenic nodules – – – + – – – – – –
Sample EE-011 UAX-4E1-1/012 UAX-4X1-2/013 UAX-3XA1-9/014 UAX3A15-5/015 UAX3A1/016 UAX3A-92/017 UAX2C2-4/018 UAX2C5-2/019 UAX2C2-3/020
Petrographic group UAX/C1 UAX/C1 UAX/C1 UAX/C2 UAX/C2 UAX/C1 UAX/VA1 UAX/C1 UAX/VA2 UAX/C2
Colour of matrix dark brown dark brown dark black dark brown light brown dark brown dark brown dark brown dark brown light brown
Optical character of matrix anisotropic isotropic isotropic anisotropic anisotropic isotropic isotropic isotropic isotropic anisotropic
Structure of matrix weakly orientated weakly orientated chaotic weakly orientated chaotic weakly orientated weakly orientated chaotic weakly orientated orientated
Granulometric composition coarse coarse coarse medium medium coarse coarse coarse medium medium
Quartz + + + + + + + – + +
Chalcedony + + – – – – – – + –
Plagioclase – – – – – – + – – –
Calcite + + + + + + – + + +
Hematite – – – – + – + – – –
Amphibole – – – – – – + – – –
Limestone + + + + + + – + – +
Volcanic rocks – – – – – – + – + –
Pedogenic nodules – – – – – – – – – –
Sample UAX1B3-3/021 UAX1B8-3/022 UAX1B3-3/023
Miloš Gregor, Milan Kováč, Branislav Kovár
165
Miloš Gregor, Milan Kováč, Branislav Kovár
Classic was so high that it could not be dependent on Belize, suggests the import of ceramics rather than that
the chance fall of volcanic material onto the site or the of ash (Sunahara et al. 2006). The samples of analyzed
region. The original idea of the need to find evidence ceramics from Uaxactun, for example Aguila Naranja
for constant volcanic activity, which would have en- in Tzakol, or Tinaja Rojo in the Tepeu period, do not
compassed the Petén lowlands during the Late Classic confirm this hypothesis because they represent local
period (Ford and Rose 1995), to which period the cera- types, suggesting that the ceramics were not imported.
mic analyses supposedly corresponded, should be also We should therefore focus on the hypothesis of volcanic
abandoned because of the growing body of evidence of ash import. It would seem that a material used as often
practically the same intensity of use of volcanic ash in as volcanic ash had to be an essential trading commodi-
the Early Classic. ty. However, the continuous supply of large quantities at
Obando et al. (2011, 116) argue that in Chinikiha in such long distances is not easily imaginable, especially
Chiapas, carbonates as temper were, from a chronologi- if the only means of transport were people themselves.
cal point of view, gradually substituted with siliciclas- The facts, however, speak clearly; volcanic ash as a long
tics including those with volcanic glass, reflecting chan- distance trade article had to far exceed all others, both in
ges in technology and mentality. Such development, terms of quantity and the frequency of deliveries.
however, cannot be confirmed for Uaxactún. The pro-
portion of volcanic ash as temper in ceramics during the RESUME
Early Classic and the Late Classic period is, according An attempt has been made in the present work to esti-
to the findings from Uaxactún, almost equal. This may mate the mineralogical and petrographical composition
reflect a certain technological stability and, in contrast to of Mayan pottery fragments excavated from the Ua-
other regions, for example outstanding relationships be- xactun archaeological site in Guatemala. Firing conditi-
tween this area and other Early Classic settlements with ons as well as the modeling techniques could be inferred
volcanic activity. That it might not have been such an from the estimated mineralogical and petrographical
exceptional phenomenon is indicated by similar results composition. The possible sources of raw materials have
from the study from Calakmul (Dominguez et al. 1998). been only proposed and further investigation is needed
Nevertheless, there probably can be no doubt that the in order to solve the problem of possible sources of tem-
rapid increase in trade in raw materials, including ash, per and clayish material.
was a general phenomenon of the Late Classic period Forty most representative samples were studied with
(Simmons and Brem 1979). This is also indicated by the help of optical microscopy and X-ray diffraction analy-
results of our analyses from the site of Tz‘ibatnah, 70 ses using Bruker D-8 Advance operating at 40 kV and 40
km distant, in Northern Petén. mA using CuKα radiation at scan speed of 0.02°2θ/1s in
Based on our analysis, we therefore have to consider range of 4-84 °2θ. Besides the mineralogical and pet-
a relatively constant use of volcanic ash in Uaxactun’s rographical composition also the granulometric compo-
ceramics during the entire Classic period. An assumpti- sition was estimated by using the Eltinor IV counting
on that volcanic ash fallout was the source, however, device with 1000 points per thin section. Two main pe-
would rely on there having been constant volcanic acti- trographic groups were distinguished according to es-
vity within Uaxactun’s proximity during a period of timated mineralogical and petrographical composition.
aproximatelly 700 years, which is geologically very un- The first group UAX/C (Uaxactun/Carbonate) contains
likely. Fluctuations in use exist, but they are not large, only subangular to angular crystaloclasts of calcite and
and could be caused by a number of factors, including lithoclasts of intrasparitic or micritic limestone (Fig. 1).
the diversification of local workshops and local traditi- Occasionally also crystaloclasts of fast euhedral to an-
ons. For example, Jones (1986) documented only limited hedral quartz and silicites were identified (Fig. 3). The
use of volcanic ash in Northern Belize, where tempering matrix is isotropic and the PXRD analyses show only the
of ceramics with carbonate material was more popular. presence of calcite and quartz. The diffraction peaks of
Unequal representation might be also caused by inter- clay minerals (e.g. illite, kaolinite) are completely missi-
ruptions in long-distance trade during certain periods of ng. According to modified Wentworth`s granulometric
time, due to political and economic reasons. Important- classification (Ionescu and Ghergari, 2002) the samples
ly, our study rules out the use of deposits from specific from UAX/C can be divided in to two subgroups that di-
ash fallouts in the geological history of the area, as the ffer in the matrix: temper ratio. The temper in subgroup
volcanic elements in analyzed samples do not show any C1 is clearly prevailing over the matrix, whereas in the
signs of erosion. Therefore, only the hypothesis of long subgroup C2 the temper occurs only sporadically. This
distance trade with ceramics or volcanic ash remains. can be observed also in modified Wentworth`s granu-
Sunahara, analyzing the situation in nearby Western lometric classification where the fragments from sub-
166
Volcanic Ash in Ancient Maya Ceramics. Mineralogical and petrographical characterization
of Maya ceramics from Uaxactún, Guatemala.
group UAX/C1 belong to the field of coarse ceramics UAX/C probably come from the vicinity of the site, as
and fragments from subgroup UAX/C2 belong to the the area is built up by Mesozoic carbonate rocks. Detai-
field of coarse to semi-fine ceramics (Fig. 2). Also the led mineralogical study of surrounding rocks and clays
structure of matrix is different in estimated subgroups. can improve the data on potential raw material sources.
Chaotic structure of matrix is characteristic for the C1 The presence of fresh unaltered volcanic ash in com-
subgroup, whereas the matrix in subgroup C2 is mainly position of petrographic group UAX/VA represents a
fluidal. The second group UAX/VA (Uaxactan/Volca- specific problem. According to the geological situation
nic Ash) contains angular fragments of fresh, unaltered of the nearest surrounding, the investigated area is com-
volcanic glass, plagioclases and amphiboles (Fig. 4, posed of mainly Mesozoic carbonate rocks. The nearest
5). Occasionally also lithoclasts of glassy pumices and volcanic formations can be found over 300 km away.
partially thermally altered calcite were observed (Fig. Therefore the ceramics tempered with volcanic ash can
6). The matrix is clearly isotropic and its structure is represent either import from that region or specific type
mainly chaotic. The PXRD analyses show presence of of ware.
plagioclases, amphiboles and broad hump situated at 20 We believe that the idea that volcanic ash used in ce-
- 30 °2θ refers to the presence of amorphous phase – ramics came from natural deposits created by ash fallout
volcanic glass (Fig. 4). The diffraction peaks of any clay is not sustainable for several reasons. The frequency of
minerals were not observed. the use of volcanic ash during the Early and the Late
The firing conditions were inferred from the chan- Classic was so high that it could not be dependent on
ges observed in mineralogical composition of matrix the chance fall of volcanic material onto the site or the
and temper. Presence of thermally untouched calcite region. The original idea of the need to find evidence
in petrographic groups UAX/C refers to temperatures for constant volcanic activity, which would have en-
not higher then 800 °C. The absence of any diffraction compassed the Petén lowlands during the Late Classic
peaks of clay minerals can possibly refers the original period (Ford and Rose 1995), to which period the cera-
composition of clayish material. If the clayish materials mic analyses supposedly corresponded, should be also
consist from illite, the peaks of this mineral would be abandoned because of the growing body of evidence of
observed in ceramics fragments fired over 900 °C. Ab- practically the same intensity of use of volcanic ash in
sence of illite peaks could possible reflects the presence the Early Classic.
of kaolinite in the original composition of clayish mate- Importantly, our study rules out the use of deposits from
rial. At 500 – 600 °C the kaolinite is transformed to me- specific ash fallouts in the geological history of the area,
takaolinite, what is easily observable as diminishing and as the volcanic elements do not show any signs of erosion.
disappearance of kaolinite diffraction peaks. Also the Therefore, only the hypothesis of long distance trade with
isotropic matrix can possibly refer to the presence of ka- ceramics or more probably with volcanic ash remains.
olinite in original clayish material. Therefore we suggest
that the ceramics from subgroup C were fired at 600 –
800 °C. The firing temperature for ceramics fragments NOTES
from petrographic group UAX/VA is markedly higher. 1 Original version of these analyses was (together with the
Presence of glassy isotropic matrix and thermally al- co-author Silvia Alvarado) presented in Spanish at the XXI
tered or partially altered calcite refer to temperatures Simposio de Investigaciones Arqueológicas en Guatemal,
ranging from 800 – 900 °C. All analyzed structures are 2012 under the title „Nuevos hallazgos de mineralogia y pet-
characteristic for modeling. High amount of temper and rografia de la cerámica de Uaxactun”.
chaotic structure of the matrix in subgroup UAX/C1 and 2 The research concerned was carried out within the pro-
UAX/VA possibly refers to pressing the prepared ma- ject reg.-no. 2/0189/12 and 2/0156/14 of the VEGA Grant
terial on a form. The vessels are made from more than agency,
two parts. Fluidal structure of matrix in subgroup UAX/
C2 could result from drawing or pinching technique or BIBLIOGRAPHY
paddle and anvil technique. For better identification of
modeling technique detailed study of the macroscopic CULTRONE/RODRIGUEZ-NAVARRO/SEBASTIAN/CAZALLA/
and microscopic features have to be performed. DE LA TORRE 2001 –
The possible sources of temper and clayish material G. Cultrone/C. Rodriguez-Navarro/E. Sebastian/O.
were derived from the mineralogical and petrographical Cazalla/M. J. De La Torre, Carbonate and silicate phase
composition of analyzed fragments. Carbonates (cal- reactions during ceramic firing. European Journal of Mi-
cite, intrasparitic and micritic limestones) and clayish neralogy 13 p. 621-634.
material rich on kaolinite present in distinguished group
167
Miloš Gregor, Milan Kováč, Branislav Kovár
168
Volcanic Ash in Ancient Maya Ceramics. Mineralogical and petrographical characterization
of Maya ceramics from Uaxactún, Guatemala.
SUNAHARA/JOËLLE/PAUL/JAIME 2006 –
K. Sunahara/Ch. Joëlle/H. Paul/A. Jaime, Petro-
graphic Analysis of Cunil Phase Ancient Maya Po-
ttery from Western Belize. Presentado en 71st annu-
al meeting of the Society for American Archaeology,
San Juan, Puerto Rico – Maya Archaeology in Be-
lize. En http://rom.academia.edu/KaySunahara/
Papers/600593/. 5. July 2012.
VELDE/DRUC 1999 –
V. Velde/C. I. Druc, Archaeological Ceramic Materi-
als. Springer – Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, p. 297.
169
CONTENT
INTRODUCTION 5
DRAHOSLAV HULÍNEK
195
SECTION C. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH IN CENTRAL
NORTH-EASTERN PETÉN, GUATEMALA 121
CONTENT 195
ABBREVIATIONS 199
INDEX 201
196