Professional Documents
Culture Documents
S INCE the people used electric power, the techniques of when they pass through forest and city, a large amount of trees
power transmission have progressed step by step with the and houses will fall and bulk power stations lack outgoing line
development of human civilizations. China is now building a corridors, too. Accordingly, enhancing the transmission
well-off society, and the strong power supply is one of the capability per unit corridor width under the long-distance
reliable guarantees to attain the economic advance objective. stable transmission is the aim of correlative studies.
The most obvious feature of the Chinese electric power HVDC and UHVDC are also large-capability and long-
industry is the extreme unbalance between the distribution of distance power transmission mode. But the DC is more adapt
primary energy resource and that of power load. China is a to transmit than distribute electric power. Multi-point HVDC
country with the vast territory. The exploitable capability of power transmission is quite expensive, and economical
hydropower is about 395 GW, and about two-thirds of the constraint limits its development. The Chinese “transmission
hydropower distributes in the southwest of China. With about of electric power from the western to the eastern region” will
1000 billion tons of coal resources reserved, about two-thirds make the transmission lines pass through the wide west and
central regions. With the develop-the-west strategy carried out
This work was supported by the Special Fund of the National Priority in China, more and more factories will transfer from east to
Basic Research of China (2004CB217906) centric and west regions, and more centric and west regions
Xuzheng Chai is with the Department of Electrical Engineering, State Key are developing. These regions would have huge electric power
Lab of Power Systems, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China (e-mail:
chaixz03@mails.tsinghua.edu.cn). demands in the future. Hence a large quantity of HVDC and
Xidong Liang is with the Department of Electrical Engineering, State Key UHVDC transmission systems applied to transmit electric
Lab of Power Systems, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China (e-mail: power from west to east in China isn’t the best choice.
lxd-dea@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn).
Rong Zeng is with the Department of Electrical Engineering, State Key Although the UHV AC and UHVDC power transmission
Lab of Power Systems, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China (e-mail: projects have been studied and designed [1, 2], integrating new
zengrong@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn).
technologies to solve the requirements of large-capability and Ping 500 kV TCSC system [8] (5% TCSC segment and 35%
long-distance power transmission in China still evoke many FSC segment) and Cheng-Bi 220 kV TCSC system [9] (50%
researchers’ great interests. TCSC) have been operating. Many SVC and STACOM have
The compact transmission lines have been designed and been applied in power transmission system. The main aim of
constructed with different towers and conductor them is keep voltage stability and Var balance. Although they
configurations in many countries, such as USA, Russia, Brazil, could offer damping for transient stability, the action isn’t
Italy, China etc. There are operating compact transmission very efficient.
lines even to thousands kilometers in some countries. The To the combination of compact transmission line and
Brazilian North-South interconnection, a single-circuit 500 kV FACTS technologies, whether it is a new mode or choice for
compact transmission line, 1020 km long, was energized in large-capability and long-distance power transmission? The
the beginning of 1999[3]. Based on the principle of AC power integrated effect will be preliminary studied in this paper. The
transmission, compact conductor configuration can utilize the possible main questions will be analyzed. Based on these
conductors fully, which makes the surge impedance loading investigations, the concept “flexible compact AC transmission
(SIL) increase significantly and the right-of-way decrease system” is propounded. Considering the long-distance
obviously. The proposed and tested high surge-impedance- transmission capability per unit corridor width, the flexible
loading compact transmission line even has the surge compact AC transmission system is a high efficient power
impedance loading of 1880 MW and the right-of-way width of transmission mode. It is applicable to EHV and UHV AC
18 meters [4] in Brazil. power transmission, and has a good developing and operating
China has made a point of designing and using the compact prospect.
transmission lines. Fig. 1 shows the Operating 500 kV single-
circuit compact transmission line and double-circuit compact II. CALCULATION AND SIMULATION OF TRANSMISSION SYSTEM
transmission lines on the same tower in china, which designed INTEGRATED COMPACT TRANSMISSION LINE WITH FACTS
and constructed by Chinese researchers and Power Grid TECHNOLOGIES
Corporations [5]. In China, the Operating 500 kV single-circuit The transmission capability of power transmission system
compact transmission line has the surge impedance loading of with combined compact transmission line and FACTS
1309.6 MW and the right-of-way width of 16 meters, and technologies is evaluated through the calculation and
double-circuit compact transmission lines has the surge simulation under steady-state stability and transient stability.
impedance loading of 2×1312.3 MW and the right-of-way
A. Transmission Capability under Steady State Stability
width of 31 meters [6, 7]. However, the right-of-way width of
500 kV conventional transmission line with horizontal three The power-carrying capability of the transmission system
phases conductors configuration is about 48 meters. The right- is generally evaluated by line loadability curve (St. Clair curve)
[10, 11]
of-way width is the horizontal distance of electric field , which expressed in per unit of surge impedance load,
intensity above 4kV/m on the ground up 1 m according to the SIL. In the calculation of line loadability curve, the thermal
Chinese national standard. rating of conductors, line voltage drop and steady state
stability are the actual restrictive conditions. The extensive
simulations and analyses have revealed that the thermal
limitation, line-voltage-drop limitation and steady-state-
stability limitation are the main controlling factors for
loadability of short, moderate and long lines respectively.
The conventional calculation method of power-carrying
capability (loadability expressed with actual value) curve
adopts the voltage drop between sending-end bus voltage and
receiving-end bus voltage [10, 11] or between sending-end
system equivalent voltage and receiving-end bus voltage [12] as
the line voltage drop criterion (5%). The voltage distributions
of actual operating AC transmission line are variable. When
the transmission line carries the load above SIL, the reactive
Fig. 1. Operating 500 kV single-circuit compact transmission line and double-
circuit compact transmission lines on the same tower in china power will be transmitted from both ends to the medial, and
some medial point will appear the maximum voltage. When
In order to improve the stability and transmission capability, the transmission line carries the load below SIL, the reactive
more and more FACTS devices (such as TCSC, SVC and power will be transmitted from the medial to both ends, and
STACOM ect.) have been installed in the power transmission the voltage of both ends will be higher than the other points in
systems in China. Owing to the excellent effect in improving the transmission line. In fact, the sending-end bus voltage and
transmission system stability and capacity, the TCSC receiving-end bus voltage have been prescribed concretely
(including FSC and TCSC ordinarily) has been used in large- according to relevant guide to power system voltage and
capability and long-distance power transmission. The Tian- reactive power techniques in China: When the transmission
3
line carries the load below SIL, the installed shunt reactors in transmission capability of 750 kV conventional transmission
both ends will keep the line voltage in the required level; line and integrated 500 kV compact transmission line with
When the transmission line carries the load above SIL, the 50% series compensation(concluding TCSC and FSC) is
generator excitation and reactive compensation equipments equivalent on the whole at the distance between 600 and 1000
will keep the line voltage in the required level. So according km; At the 1000 km transmission distance, the transmission
to the guide to power system voltage and reactive power capability per unit corridor width of integrated 500 kV
techniques in China, the sending-end bus voltage scopes compact transmission line with 50% series compensation is
within 100%~110% of rated voltage and receiving-end bus 116.9 MW/m, however, the transmission capability per unit
voltage scopes within 95%~105% of rated voltage are adopted corridor width of conventional 500 kV transmission line with
as the line voltage required level in the calculation of power- horizontal three phases conductors configuration is only 17.2
carrying capability curve. MW/m. According to the power-carrying capability curve, the
The mathematical model of AC transmission system is integrated compact transmission line with series compensation
shown in Fig. 2. technologies reveal great superiority in the transmission
capability per unit corridor width.
B. Transmission Capability under Transient Stability
The actual transmitted power of the operating power
transmission system depends on its transient stability. The
characteristics of terminal systems and transmission line with
Fig. 2. Mathematical model of AC transmission system
accessory equipments will make the transient stability of
In the calculation of power-carrying capability curve, power transmission systems widely different. It is necessary to
considering the main point-to-network transmission condition investigate the transmission capability of the integrated
in China, the sending-end and receiving-end short-circuit compact transmission line with FACTS technologies under
currents are set at 15 kA and 50 kA respectively. The sending- transient stability limitation.
end and receiving-end system equivalent voltage Es and Er are The energy function (lyapunov) method has been used to
specified as 1.05 and 1 per unit in the present case based on determine the transient stability margin to develop control
the case of load flow. The limitation criterion of sending-end strategies for improving transient stability. The analysis
bus voltage scopes and receiving-end bus voltage scopes are followed uses a structure preserving energy mode of a post-
100%~110% of rated voltage and 95%~105% of rated voltage fault power system, which retains the topology of the system.
respectively. In accordance with the steady state stability Consider a power transmission system with Ng generators, Nb
criterion of Transmission Line Reference Book 345 kV and buses (excluding generator internal buses), and Nl
Above by EPRI, the steady-state stability margin 30% is taken, transmission lines (including transient reactance branch of
corresponding phase angle difference δ = 44 ° across the generators), the energy function defined as [14] [15]:
system terminals. Full details are given in [13]. The Fig. 3 is Ng
power-carrying capability curve under the above condition. v =∑(12Miω%i2 −Pmiδ%i ) +
i=1
Nb Nl
vi0 vi0
i=1 l=1
where ω% i and δ%i are the angular speed and rotor angle of ith
generator with respect to the center of inertia (COI) reference
frame respectively. Mi and Pmi are the moment of inertia and
mechanical power input of ith generator respectively. Pli and
Qli are the real power load and active power load at ith bus
respectively. θ%i is the phase angle of voltage at ith bus. Qseries
is the reactive power loss in series branches. It is supposed
that the TCSCs are installed in lines between ith bus and jth
bus, and SVCs are installed in ith bus. TCSC is modeled as a
series combination of a fixed capacitance reactance X ijTCSC
0
,
TCSC , hence the applied series
and a controlled part X iju
Fig. 3. Power-carrying capability of different AC power transmission mode compensation capacitance reactance is X ijTCSC = X ijTCSC
0 + X iju
TCSC
.
The SVC is modeled as a parallel combination of fixed shunt
According to this figure, it could be summarized that: the
4
susceptance biSVC
0
and a controlled part biuSVC . Only fixed part performed with its parameters of sending-end and receiving-
of TCSC and SVC are operating before system fault. end system. The simulation uses the BPA software (Chinese
The introduction of FACTS equipments doesn’t alter the 3.0 version). The transmission capability of several EHV
original value of energy function (1) at the post-fault system. power transmission modes under transient steady stability
However, they will alter the trend and speed of energy limitation have been simulated and analyzed.
function change [16]. When TCSC and SVC change the Fig. 4 shows the test system. The transmission line is 1000
transmission line reactance and susceptance according to the km long between the sending-end bus B1-500 and the
control strategy, the real power and active power of any bus receiving-end bus B4-500, which is divided into three sections
will keep balance and sum to zero. The trend and speed of averagely.
energy function change is evaluated by the time derivative of
energy function:
Ng N N
& b & b V&
v& =∑(Miω&%i +Pgi −Pmi )δ%i +∑Piθ%i +∑Vii Qi + Fig. 4. Test system of a typical point-to-network power transmission
i=1 i=1 i=1 A three-phase fault occurs at bus B1-500 side of one of
Nb Nl transmission line between bus B1-500 and bus B2-500. The
∑b V − ∑ 12 (X
TCSC
1 SVC d 2 Xiju d 2 fault is cleared after 0.1 s by opening the faulted line. When
2 iu dt i TCSC TCSC V
dt series (2) the system comes into post-fault condition, the TCSC begins
Lij −Xij 0 )(XLij −Xij )
i=1 l=Ng +1 to operate in forced compensation state, and its capacitance
where X Lij is the reactance of power transmission line, reactance is twice of normal operation. The operating time in
forced compensation state is 25 circles (0.5 s). The controlled
% %
i j cos(θi −θ j ) = [ X Lij ITCSC −VTCSC ]
= Vi 2 +Vj2 − 2VV
2 2
and Vseries . part of SVC will be put into system according to the control
According to the energy balance of generator, real power law of BPA software, which is in accordance with the
balance and active power balance of any bus, the three items conclusion in this paper.
ahead in formula (2) are zero. And so: The table I is the simulation results. It is assumed that all
Nb Nl SC (include FSC and TCSC) are installed in the three-section
v& =∑ b V − ∑ 12 (X
TCSC
1 SVC d 2 Xiju d 2 transmission line averagely. TCSC is installed in faulted
2 iu dt i TCSC TCSC V
dt series (3) section and its parallel section, and FSC is installed in other
Lij −Xij0 )(XLij −Xij )
i=1 l=Ng +1 sections.
The energy function describes total energy of the post-fault
TABLE I
system, and the v& describes the rate of system energy TRANSIENT STABILITY TRANSFER CAPABILITY OF DIFFERENT AC POWER
function change. The system energy function must be a TRANSMISSION MODE
positive definite function. If the v& is negative, the system
energy will decrease continuously till the balance point of
system new steady. The formula (3) is deduced and gotten by
amending the process and conclusion of reference [17].
Therefore, the control law for TCSC:
TCSC
X iju = KTCSC dtd Vseries
2
, KTCSC > 0, X min
TCSC
< X ijTCSC < X max
TCSC
9999 MW respectively. Under the transient stability limitation, The Fig. 6 is the comparison of conductor configuration
the transmission capability per unit corridor width of and tower between Chinese 500 kV compact transmission line
integrated 500 kV compact transmission line with 33% FSC with invert-delta three phase conductors configuration
and 17%TCSC is 91.2 MW/m, however, the transmission (Chang-Fang line[22]) and conventional 500 kV transmission
capability per unit corridor width of conventional 500 kV line with horizontal three phase conductors configuration
transmission line with horizontal three phase conductors (No.2 Chang-An line[5]). According to the relative technical
configuration is only 13.75 MW/m. According to the report [22], some typical power frequency parameters of
preliminary analysis and simulation, the integrated compact compact and conventional transmission line are in table II.
transmission line with TCSC reveals great superiority in the
transmission capability per unit corridor width under transient TABLE II
SOME TYPICAL POWER FREQUENCY PARAMETERS OF COMPACT AND
stability, too. CONVENTIONAL TRANSMISSION LINE
and control theory. For the steady state stability, transient [8] Jiming Lin, Baoshu Peng, and Qiang Guo et al, "Tian-Ping TCSC in
China Southern Grid," International Electric Power for China, vol. 8,
stability and voltage stability of whole power transmission pp. 48-51, Oct. 2004.
system, all kinds of FACTS equipments, such as TCSC, [9] Jianbo Guo, Shouyuan Wu, and Guofu Li et al, "Study on domestic-
STACOM, SVC, SSSC etc, should be chose to exploit their manufactured demo project of 220kV TCSC for power transmission
from Cheng County to Bikou in Gansu province, " Power System
particular advantages.
Technology, vol.29, pp. 12-17, Oct. 2005.
B. Electromagnetic Transient Characteristics and Protective [10] S. N. Tiwari, A. S. Binsaroor, "An investigation into loadability
characteristics of EHV high phase order," IEEE Trans on Power Systems,
Scheme of Flexible Compact AC Transmission System vol. 10, pp. 1264-1270, Nov. 1995.
The parameters of compact transmission line are quite [11] J. J. LaForest, Transmission line reference book 345kV and above
(second edition) California: Electric Power Research Institute, 1982.
different from the conventional transmission line, and the [12] R. D. Dunlop, R. Gutman, P. P. Marchenko, "Analytical development of
electromagnetic transient characteristics also have its own loadability characteristics for EHV and UHV transmission line," IEEE Trans
particularity. When the FACTS devices are installed in the on Power Apparatus and System, vol. PAS-98, pp. 606-613, March.1979.
long-distance compact transmission line, the electromagnetic [13] Xuzheng Chai, Xidong Liang, Rong Zeng, "An improved calculation
method for Power-Transmitting Capability Curve of AC transmission
transient characteristics will be more complex. It is necessary line," Power System Technology (in Chinese), to be published.
to research the complex characteristics for the overvoltage [14] M. A. Pai, Energy Function Analysis for Power System Stability Boston:
protection and insulation coordination of power transmission Kluwer, 1989
[15] K. N. Shubhanga, A. M. Kulkarni, "Application of Structure Preserving
devices and FACTS devices. Energy Margin Sensitivity to Determine the Effectiveness of Shunt and
Series FACTS Devices,” IEEE Transaction on power system, vol.17, pp.
C. Relay Protection and Fault Location of Flexible Compact 730-738, Aug. 2002.
AC Transmission System [16] M. Ghandhari, G. Andersson, I. Hiskens, et al, "Control Lyapunov
When the compact transmission line and some FACTS functions for controllable series devices,” IEEE Transaction on power
system, vol.16, pp. 689-694, Nov. 2001.
equipments are adopted, the features of AC transmission [17] M. Noroozian, M. Ghandhari, G. Andersson, et al, "A robust control
system maybe are quite different from ordinary system. Some strategy for shunt and series reactive compensators to damp
relay protections and fault locations perhaps would be failed electromechanical oscillations,” IEEE Transaction on power delivery,
vol.16, pp. 812-817, Oct. 2001.
and wrong, especially when the FACTS equipments act. [18] M. H. Haque, "Improvement of first swing stability limit by utilizing full
benefit of shunt FACTS devices," IEEE Transaction on power system,
IV. CONCLUSION vol. 19, pp. 1894-1902, Nov. 2004.
[19] CEPRI. PSASP program basic data book Beijing: CEPRI, 2001. (In
Based on the preliminary investigation, this paper proposes Chinese).
a new large-capability and long-distance power transmission [20] R. de la Rosa, M. Ochoa, J. L. Bonilla, et al, “Contributions to lightning
mode: flexible compact transmission system. Calculation and research for transmission line compaction,” IEEE Transaction on power
delivery, vol.3, pp. 716-723, April. 1988.
simulation show its high efficiency. Some complex and new [21] T. J. F. Ordon, K. E. Lindsey, “Considerations in the design of three
questions only are presented in this paper, and the further phase compact transmission lines,” in Proc. 1995 IEEE Seventh
study should be aimed at these questions in concrete practical International Conference on Transmission and Distribution
Construction and Live Line Maintenance, pp.108-114
application. Considering the long-distance transmission
[22] Zuping Zhang, Gesong Chen, Jiming Lin, et al, "Study on the system
capability per unit corridor width, the flexible compact AC operation characteristics of 500 kV Chang-Fang compact transmission
transmission system has a good developing and operating line," CEPRI, and North China Electric Power Group Co., Tech.
prospect. Rep.X9714, April. 1997.