Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transmission
In the present context, the
biggest challenge facing us
in realtime operation of the
National Grid is one on safe,
secure, reliable and optimal
economic operations... more
so in meeting stakeholders’
expectations.
Highlights of Achievements:
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
56
Table 1:
Transmission System Equipment Database as at
31 August 2008
Length/Capacity/
Types of Lines
No.
500 kV 638
Overhead Lines (circuit-km)
275 kV 7,565
Overhead Lines (circuit-km)
132 kV 10,609
Overhead Lines (circuit-km)
Total Overhead 18,812
Lines Length (circuit-km)
275 kV 51
Underground Cable (circuit-km)
132 kV 689
Underground Cable (circuit-km)
Total Underground 740
Cable Length (circuit-km) Divisional Goals
500 kV Transformer 10,500 MVA The Transmission Division is entrusted to manage and
operate the 500 kV, 275 kV and 132 kV Transmission
275 kV Transformer 29,193 MVA
Grid of Peninsular Malaysia, known as the National Grid.
132 kV Transformer 44,115 MVA The National Grid consists of approximately 18,812
circuit-km of overhead transmission lines, 740 circuit-km
Total Transformer Capacity 83,808 MVA of underground transmission cables and 386 substations
with transformation capacity of 83,808 MVA. During
500 kV Substation 7 the period under review, thirty-two (32) power stations,
275 kV Substation 69 made up of TNB power stations and Independent
Power Producers (IPPs), are connected to the grid with
132 kV Substation 310 19,723 MW installed capacity and a maximum electricity
Total Number of demand of 14,007 MW recorded on 21 May 2008.
386 (Please see Table 1)
TNB Substation
57
Operations Review – Transmission Division
Operational Summary
The Transmission Division had
taken initiatives to ensure and Olak Lempit Substations Minutes with a 15% reduction of
t h a t t r a n s m i s s i o n p ro j e c t s were completed in January transmission-initiated tripping as
are completed on time and 2008. The Lenggeng 500/275 kV compared to Financial Year 2007
within budget. These initiatives substation was commissioned in (Please see Graph 1).
include improving procurement the same month.
approach and practices, The upgrading of the National
project specifications and Bill In the Easter n region, the Load Despatch Center (NLDC)
of Quantities (BQ) as well as Kandis 275/132 kV substation project is in progress and
ensuring accurate project scoping was energised on 31 December scheduled for completion in
together with a stringent QA/ 2007. The project strengthens early 2009. The National Grid
QC process. the supply from the National will be equipped with a realtime
Grid to the state of Kelantan state-of-the-art SCADA/EMS
A total of forty (40) projects and acts as a prime substation system that helps facilitate in
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
58
a positively lower index in its “Headline KPI”, the
Graph 1: System Minutes. During the period under review, the
Transmission Tripping System Minutes stand at 6.56 minutes compared with
9.34 minutes last year. (Please see Graph 2) This is
500 the third consecutive year single-digit System Minutes
was recorded. Also for the third consecutive year the
464 Division has maintained Zero Major Disturbance.
0
FY’04 FY’05 FY’06 FY’07 FY’08
59
Operations Review – Transmission Division
60
Khlong Ngae
(HVDC link)
PERLIS O
A
CIMA SD
To
BKTR 300kV DC line 100km
TEWA BKHM
KGAR
KCMT KPLS
UMKA TPAU PLPS
CPNG
PAUH
ASTR
MGON
BMRH
CEND KNYR
GRIK
132 kV Cable
61
Dato’ Ir. Aishah binti
Dato’ Haji Abdul Rauf
Vice President
Distribution
We strive to improve the
technical efficiency of the
system network operations
and in resolving Power Quality
concerns with the aim of providing high quality power
supply to relevant customers.
Highlights of Achievements:
Distribution Division’s main achievements throughout Financial Year 2007/2008 are:
Completed 50% of the Remote Meter Reading (RMR) on schedule for 60,000 LV LPCs.
Commissioned the first wind-solar hybrid Renewable Energy plant at Pulau Perhentian, Terengganu
on 6 November 2007 in collaboration with TNB subsidiary, TNB Energy Services Sdn Bhd (TNB-ES).
The project was jointly funded by TNB/Akaun Amanah Industri Bekalan Elektrik (AAIBE)/Terengganu
State Government.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Commissioned the Metro Southern Regional Control Centre (MSRCC) on 22 August 2008 and
Northern Eastern Regional Control Centre (NERCC) on 20 August 2007.
Certification Of ISO 9001:2000 Surveillance Audit by SIRIM.
Distribution Losses has been reduced from 9.29% to 8.69%.
Certification of 5S Audit by MPC.
Collection of back billing on theft of electricity (TOE) amounting to RM43.70 million for the period
from September 2007 until August 2008.
Launching of E-Application for individual customer, contractors and developers on 28 August 2008
by the Deputy Minister of Energy, Water and Communications.
System Average Interruption Duration Index (SAIDI) has improved further to 78 minutes and Average
Collection Period (ACP) to 25 days.
Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) Score of 7.1, the first time TNB exceeds 7.0 the highest over the
last 10 years and a major improvement over the 6.8 figure achieved in the previous CSI survey.
62
To focus on its core business The Distribution Network cables comprising Low Voltage
activities of distribution network Operations component of (<1 kV), 6.6 kV, 11 kV, 22 kV
operations and electricity the Division plans, designs, and 33 kV cable systems. Both
retailing, Distribution, being the constructs, operates and the underground and overhead
biggest Division and face of maintains the system that systems totalling 548,981 km,
TNB to customers, fully supports delivers electricity supply to the help to strengthen the reliability
TNB mission and translates it as customers. Distribution Division of the distribution network.
follows: connects all the 6.9 million
customers from the National To ensure secure and reliable
of 357,267 km of underground
63
Operations Review – Distribution Division
Power Generation
Operational Improvements
For the initiative to improve Connect Supply on
Time, TNB Distribution has developed a new project
monitoring system called Distribution Project Monitoring
System (DPMS) to assist our project personnel to
manage and improve their project implementation in
Transmission meeting customer needs.
Network
TNB has expanded the use of Remote Meter Reading
(RMR) technology for Low Voltage Large Power
Customers (LV-LPC). Up to 31 August 2008, there
are 37,000 LV-LPC out of 60,000 LV-LPC that had
been installed with RMR. (All High Voltage & Medium
Voltage Large Power Customer (3,800) had been
equipped & monitored with RMR). RMR provides TNB
Transmission and the customer better understanding of the load
Main Intake profile or usage pattern in order for the customer to
manage their energy consumption more efficiently.
64
Distribution Division has
embarked on 5S programme
as part of its continuous quality
initiatives and has achieved some
major achievements throughout
the states. The Distribution
Division HQ received its 5S
certification on 24 July 2008 and
all states offices received their
5S certification by August 2008.
Summary Of Operations
Ordinary Power Customers
(OPCs) constitute the majority of
our almost 6.9 million customers
which are mainly Malaysian
households. Large Power
Customers (LPCs), while small in
Commercial Package which Quality Management And number, account for almost 80%
assist LPCs looking for financing of the total sales of electricity in
Initiatives
to mitigate PQ problems at their the country. LPCs are also further
factory site. Anugerah Kualiti Presiden (AKP) categorised into the commercial
The AKP assessment is conducted and industrial categories, with
Besides that, PQ Seminars are once every two years to inculcate the industrial customers being
being organised to continuously a ”Business Excellence” culture further classified into different
update our customers on the throughout the Division. The AKP industries. The direct undertaking
latest development on PQ. assessment, is modeled after the for the customers’ needs and
We have also launched a PQ Malcolm Baldridge framework to expectations fall within the
Guidebook which is distributed raise our quality standards and jurisdiction of Distribution
to PRIME Customers for their business performance. The Division Division.
re f e re n c e . P Q t r a i n i n g f o r has also initiated a ”Distribution
all LPCs, consultants and League Table” Award to promote Delighting customers is a key
contractors associations such internal benchmarking amongst its priority in TNB. Hence it is
as FMM, ACEM & TEEAM is 13 state operations. imperative for TNB to identify
also being planned. PQMS (PQ these needs and expectations
Monitoring System) meanwhile In the effort to improve employees’ through a structured and focused
identify real time power quality performance, the Division has also data and information gathering
incidents on the system and encouraged Work Improvement exercise. Feedbacks from
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
the information are accessible Team – Innovative Creative Circle customers are obtained through
by Distribution nationwide to (WIT-ICC) – programmes during a combination of a structured
allow for remedial action as and the 2007/2008 Financial Year. This Customer Satisfaction Index
when it is required. All these includes eight (8) sessions of WIT- (CSI) survey, feedback forms
initiatives to improve the quality ICC Management Presentations available at TNB retail outlets
of supply are in line with the which were organised at state – the Kedai Tenaga and survey
government agencies through level in the Division; one (1) WIT- done through TNB Careline
MIDA/MITI to attract more high ICC session for Management 15454 (Call Management
tech industries to Malaysia where Presentations was organised at Centre). CSI survey has been
PQ is a critical issue to some of Divisional level during which conducted for the past ten years
the manufacturing processes. 27 WIT-ICC with high potential by an international independent
for standardisation projects was company to provide feedback
presented. By the end of the on TNB’s service level and also
financial year, four (4) projects areas for improvement.
from last year’s Management
Presentations were approved for
standardisation throughout TNB.
65
Operations Review – Distribution Division
66
system will be expanded to The highest TNB management
other services/outlets. Front council Executive Management
liners were also put through Committee spearheaded by the
customer orientation training President/CEO meets regularly
and a Smile Campaign launched to ensure participation and
for Kedai Tenaga. commitment from all Divisions
and support services to our
Another initiative to enhance its customers. Further more, a t
services, TNB embarks on the 3 Distribution Division, department
Phase promotional scheme from heads and executives organise
1 June 2007 until 31 May 2008 regular meetings, cross
for all domestic and commercial functional initiatives, continuous
customers. In the promotional and close monitoring of
scheme, customers were given projects and implement service
50% discount on connection l e v e l a g re e m e n t s b e t w e e n
charges. The objective of the departments to obtain regular
Voice Recorder (IVR) and IP promotional scheme was to feedback on pertinent issues.
Telephony and CTI (integration encourage single phase users
of computer and the telephone) of electricity to upgrade their Serious attention is being given
with the latest state-of-the supply to a 3 Phase supply, to to minimise product defects
-art technology in managing facilitate the additional electrical and improve supply delivery
customer enquiry on electricity load in the home as well as to perfor mance through close
supply. ensure better reliability of supply. monitoring of manufacturers and
suppliers.
A FAQ booklet has also been Materials availability and quality
developed to assist frontliners is given high importance to TNB’s
and counter staff in responding infrastructure development. This
to customer enquiries in a proper has been identified as a key
and consistent manner. TNB initiative to boost TNB’s service
has also developed a customer delivery. TNB is committed in
information package for its new this effort to ensure on-time
customers to brief them about completion of all supply projects
TNB’s services and what to do if and longer lifespan of street
they require assistance. lighting through better quality
products.
TNB is always striving to
provide the highest quality
service to its customers. As
such, Kedai Tenaga centres are
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
equipped with a new QMatic
queue management system to
facilitate better tracking and
monitoring of counter services.
40 Kedai Tenaga have been
installed with the QMatic system
which optimises customer flow,
i m p ro v e s c u s t o m e r s e r v i c e
and creates a more relaxed
atmosphere for both customers
and staff. The system also
allows for better tracking of
performance such as customer
waiting time and transaction
time for each counter service.
For FY2008/2009, the QMatic
67
Operations Review – Distribution Division
68
continues to carry out operations and maintenance activities for the customers located in remote rural areas,
including those accessible only via river or sea routes. TNB is also responsible for the maintenance and
operations of 12 and 24-hour diesel stations in rural areas as well as offshore islands. TNB has also carried
out, among others, the installation of 25,000 streetlights in rural areas under the “Lampu Jalan Kampung”
project under the Ministry of Rural and Regional Development programme.
The following is the list of solar hybrid projects that have been completed by TNB for the last financial
year (2007/2008).
69
Emphasis on playing
its role as a “business
strategist” with the
vision to achieve
“financial excellence”
Dato’ Izzaddin Idris
Chief Financial Officer /
by optimising financial
Senior Vice President (Group Finance) processes, managing
operating costs,
Finance
driving business
performance and
mitigating risk.
During the year under review, the Division had also focused
on several key initiatives identified last year which included
the following:-
70
SUMMARY OF OPERATIONS
Financial Performance – FY2008 vs FY2007
By all standards, FY2007 was an exceptional year with several notable achievements with record profits
of RM4.1 billion, much improved technical performance, recoveries and value creation initiatives. Armed
with these successes as well as additional key drivers in place for a better performance, TNB prepared
itself for the challenges it had anticipated in FY2008, the main element being the expected higher cost
of generation.
FY2008 surpassed all expectations by any measure as the higher coal prices and IPP payments far
exceeded operational cost savings and demand growth recorded of 6.1%. While total Group revenue
increased by 10.4%, operating expenses increased by 22.5% resulting in EBITDA margin being squeezed
down to 29.5% compared to 37.6% reported in FY2007. The Group’s performance for the financial year
under review was also affected by the rapid weakening of the Ringgit against both the US Dollar and
Japanese Yen in the second half of the financial year.
The financial performance of the Group over the years is best illustrated by the following charts.
Gearing
Gearing ROA
ROA
80 80 7 7
6.3
6.3
68.6
68.6
70 70
64.9
64.9
6 6
58.1
58.1
60 60
5 5
4.6
4.6
49.9
49.9
46.9
46.9
50 50
4 4
%
%
%
%
3.3
3.3
40 40
3 3
2.6
2.6
30 30
2.2
2.2
2 2
20 20
10 10 1 1
0 0 0 0
FY’04
FY’04
FY’05
FY’04 FY’05
FY’06
FY’05 FY’06
FY’07
FY’06 FY’07
FY’08
FY’07 FY’08
FY’08 FY’04
FY’04
FY’05
FY’04 FY’05
FY’06
FY’05 FY’06
FY’07
FY’06 FY’07
FY’08
FY’07 FY’08
FY’08 Notes:-
1. Gearing is calculated as
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Interest
Interest
Coverage
Coverage Basic
Basic
EPSEPS total debt as a percentage
of total capital
8 8 100100
94.9
94.9
2. ROA is determined
as Group net profit
6.9
6.9
7 7
6.7
6.7
59.9
5 5
4.7
4.7
60 60 3. Interest coverage
4.4
4.4
52.5
52.5
sen
sen
3.8
3.8
4 4 interest expense
40 40
4. Basic EPS is computed
3 3 by taking total profit
30.2
30.2
attributable to equity
26.1
26.1
0 0 0 0
FY’04
FY’04
FY’05
FY’04 FY’05
FY’06
FY’05 FY’06
FY’07
FY’06 FY’07
FY’08
FY’07 FY’08
FY’08 FY’04
FY’04
FY’05
FY’04 FY’05
FY’06
FY’05 FY’06
FY’07
FY’06 FY’07
FY’08
FY’07 FY’08
FY’08
71
Operations Review – Group Finance Division
Key Initiatives in FY2008 business units (including each older e-platforms to Maybank2e.
power station (for the Generation net with the aim of maintaining
W ith continuing regulatory Division) and State (for the only one electronic payment
scrutiny, exceptionally difficult Distribution Division)) to measure processing system.
market conditions, and ongoing internal efficiencies, monitor
shareholders’ expectations, performance as well as identify During the year under review, an
the Group Finance Division areas for improvement. Traditional asset valuation was conducted on
has placed more emphasis on budget planning activities have the Group’s key operating assets
playing its role as a “business also been fine tuned with to ensure proper and adequate
strategist” with the vision to automated budgetary control insurance coverage. Whilst the
achieve “financial excellence” by mechanism to instill discipline exercise resulted in an increase
optimising financial processes, whilst time-control features will in asset valuation for assets to
managing operational costs, be introduced soon to monitor be insured, by 87% for TNB
driving business performance progress. This is also coupled and 79% for TNB Janamanjung
and mitigating risk. with the Investment Evaluation Sdn. Bhd., the total insurance
Framework for Budget Planning premium only increased by
Whilst several key drivers can be methodology. 15% as the rates for premium
ordinarily considered “business were reduced. The reduction in
as usual”, the measures and The ability for business units insurance rates was achieved
targets that had been set were to benchmark against best as a result of prudent insurance
aggressive so as to ensure practices and targets is a step renewal processes, lower loss
continuous improvement. towards improving efficiencies & ratio for most of the policies
productivity in order to realise the and improved risk management
Driving Business Performance vision of becoming one of the through creating awareness and
Group Finance Division leading corporations in the energy sharing of information/knowledge
continued to hone its skills and and related businesses globally. on risk management. Subsequent
applied the tools developed and to this exercise, similar asset
implemented to monitor the Advances in IT, in particular valuations were carried out for
performance of the business. internet technology, has rapidly major subsidiaries.
TNB’s 20-year cashflow-driven enabled business operations to
Dynamic Strategic Planning be conducted over the internet Debt Liability & Capital
Model developed in 2005 was and become new platform for Management
further enhanced with additional entities to interact. At TNB, The active management of the
features allowing complex tariff an earlier initiative to adopt debts and obligations continued
simulation, M&A analytics and Maybank2e.net has been now to provide the foundation of
c a s h re q u i re m e n t s c e n a r i o extended to third parties with TNB’s financial strength with
planning. The full implementation non Maybank accounts. It is the year-end ratios at arguably,
and rollout of the Divisional the intention to also migrate all a much improved position as
Accounts now enables the core payments and transactions on tabulated below.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Financial Year
Financial Ratios
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Debt Service Cover Ratio 2.0x 1.6x 1.4x 1.8x 2.5x 2.3x
Debt-Equity (Net of Cash) Ratio 2.11 1.94 1.69 1.19 0.78 0.68
72
The Division actively monitored the exchange rates, bond prices and Clearly, the debts maturing in
funding costs during the year and notwithstanding that there was no FY09 and FY10 will be met from
new funds raised, TNB applied its cash balances to prepay several the current cash balance as well
foreign currency loans denominated in Swiss Francs and Euro in June as from operations although the
and September 2008 respectively. possibility of refinancing these
with new borrowings, subject to
As at 31 August 2008, the debt maturity profile of TNB is as terms. The refinancing risk posed
depicted below:- in FY11 with debts of RM3.7
billion maturing will require TNB
Debt Maturity Profile as at 31 August 2008 to consider alternative strategies
such as prepayment and/or bond
RM USD Yen Others
buyback. This will also address
the perennial feature of TNB’s
4,000 loans where foreign currency
debt is in excess of 25% of the
3,500 total debt portfolio, clearly a
mismatch of the predominantly
3,000
Ringgit-denominated revenue
2,500
base.
RM million
Business Strategy TNB will focus on countries the current challenges in the
During the year, 3 key policies within ASEAN, the Middle EPC and financial markets, the
were reviewed and reformulated East, and the Indian bid is expected to close in mid-
to be aligned with TNB’s 20-Year subcontinent with limitations December 2008.
Strategic Plan and for improved driven by country ratings.
internal controls. The Treasury On the existing Shuaibah III
Emphasis is also given to the
Policy was updated with recent water desalination and power
operations and maintenance
developments in electronic project, the overall construction
aspect of each investment
banking functions, new policies is progressing well with
opportunity to grow the
for counterparties and enhanced commercial operations targeted
business of TNB Repair &
with better controls whilst the for mid-2009.
Maintenance Sdn Bhd.
Investor Relations Policy was
developed to identify specific Proactive Investor Relations
D u r i n g t h e y e a r, 2 M & A
owners, a structured approach in Investor Relations role in TNB
opportunities were evaluated
the communications strategy, as is a strategic management
and TNB was pre-qualified for
well as documenting the need to tool, providing a platform for
several greenfield projects in the
ensure a transparent, timely and regular communications between
Gulf Cooperation Council region.
fair dissemination of information/ the Group and the financial
Whilst the M&A opportunities
news to the investing community, community which includes its
would have provided TNB with
research analysts, rating agencies current and potential investors
an immediate inter national
and the public at large. as well as research analysts. The
footprint with the capability to
major focus rests in the consistent
further expand existing capacity
Of significance is the new communication and dissemination
as well as a window into a
Investment Policy & Strategy of accurate, reliable and timely
“pooling” industry in a developed
w h i c h s e t s o u t t h e b ro a d information to investors and
market, the valuations would
principles under which Business analysts which portrays the Group’s
have posed a strain on TNB’s
Development will identify, explore performance and prospects. The
future cashflow. TNB has also
an d s u ppo r t ne w bus in e s s IR communication channel is also
agreed to partner with the Saudi
opportunities both locally and a means of acquiring feedback
Binladin Group to bid for the
abroad. The foundation of the from the investment community
1700MW and 150,000 m3/day
policy and strategy is the 20- which is then channeled back
independent water and power
Year Strategic Plan but always to Management and Board of
plant project in the industrial
dependent on the financial Directors.
city of Yanbu in the Kingdom of
position of TNB. In brief:-
Saudi Arabia. Notwithstanding
TNB as a “technical investor”
will pursue “Greenfield” and
“Brownfield” generation
projects which meets the
investment threshold of the
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
74
As always, TNB invites the Outlook & The Way The ability to raise funds at
financial community and media Forward – FY2009 competitive rates in view of
to attend the announcement of the global financial turmoil
its quarterly financial results. On TNB’s Challenges affecting credit availability
average a total of 87 parties The Finance Division will continue and the expectation of
attended or “conferenced in” for on its journey “towards financial an economic slowdown
these quarterly presentations. excellence.” Given that the worldwide
economic and financial climate
in the near term is expected to To implement a transparent
As in previous years, TNB
remain volatile and that demand and objective electricity
participated in several investor
growth will be lower than the pricing mechanism for end-
c o n f e re n c e s a n d m e e t i n g s
year before, the ability to drive customers incorporating
arranged by leading investment
down costs remains a critical a fuel cost pass through
banks to provide an update on
factor for success. mechanism and rectify the
the company’s performance, and
imbalance in the “input-
address issues and concerns
Under this scenario, the role of output” value chain of the
raised by fund managers and
Group Finance for the ending 31 business
investors alike. Aside from
the conferences and meetings August 2009 will bring renewed
attended outside of TNB focus to the important aspects
premises, Management and IR of drivers of revenue and cost
frequently have fund managers as well as drivers to creating
and analysts requesting for value. Key challenges for FY2009
meetings at TNB offices. include the following:-
During the year under review, The need to further develop
TNB had approximately 120 strategic partnerships
meetings (excluding Quarterly with EPC contractors, key
announcement of financial consultants and business
results) with analysts and fund partners to enable TNB
managers at TNB. compete better under the
p re s e n t e n v i ro n m e n t t o
succeed in developing new
businesses internationally
Higher fuel prices will have
a knock-on effect on cost of
services and materials related
to asset development,
asset management and
maintenance [ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
75
Corporate
Dato’ Abdul Razak bin Abdul Majid
Affairs
Senior Vice President
Divisional Goals
The Corporate Affairs Division was established in January 2008, following a resolution on the need to
reorganise the corporate functions of TNB. It consists of five (5) departments, namely:-
1. Company Secretary;
2. Yayasan Tenaga Nasional;
3. Regulatory and Relations Management Department;
4. Legal Services Department; and
5. Corporate Communications Department
During the year under review, the Division has continuously assisted the TNB core businesses by providing
corporate secretarial and corporate advisory services; legal and litigation management, regulatory and
relations management, and valuable communications with internal and external stakeholders. In addition,
the Division continues to provide educational and welfare aid through Yayasan Tenaga Nasional (YTN).
The Division’s goal is to ensure attainment and compliance with best practices of corporate governance
through fostering of an open and collegial approach on business and corporate affairs and towards
enhancing relationships with TNB stakeholders, government agencies, non-governmental organisations
and customers at large.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
76
Operational Summary to policy making and other Revamping of “Livewire”,
fiduciary duties to the TNB TNB’s intranet system, for
i. Regulatory and Relations Group within the ambit of easier accessibility and
Management Department company laws, securities information sharing in TNB.
The Department focuses on law, Securities Commission
developing and enhancing Launching of a new TNB-wide
guidelines and Bursa Malaysia information sharing channel
c l o s e re l a t i o n s h i p s a n d listing requirements. Its other
linkages between TNB and called “TNB NewsTube” which
key function is to assist the emulates features similar to
the Regulators, Government Board of Directors in adopting
Agencies, individuals, corporate-wide broadcast.
corporate governance
organisations and associations principles and practices
that may exercise influence as essential elements to
over matters relating to TNB Human Resource
Company performance and Management
in particular and the power integrity. The Office is also
industry in general. responsible for administration Recognising that the workforce
matters related to registration is one of its most valuable
ii. Legal Services Department of public, as well as eligible assets in driving the success of
The Department provides employee shareholders. its operational objectives, the
Corporate legal & litigation Division placed great emphasis
advisory on operational v. Yayasan Tenaga Nasional in building the capacity of its
matters, as well as ensuring (YTN) human resource through training
compliance with Acts of Yayasan Tenaga Nasional programmes to suit the diverse
Parliament, especially the (YTN), established as a trust requirements of the various
Electricity Supply Act 1990, body for TNB, ensures that professional disciplines within
relevant rules, regulations the company’s corporate the Division.
and by-laws, as well as the social responsibility initiatives
Terms and Conditions of and efforts are continuously
Licencing for TNB and its met through scholarships and Customer Focus and
subsidiaries. loans to deserving students. Stakeholders Management
iii. Corporate Communications The Division is fully committed
Department to the Company’s SE 10/10
Operational Improvements Service Excellence initiative.
The Department is
responsible for managing In the year under review, the Various systems, activities and
stakeholders’ perceptions Corporate Affairs Division has programmes were undertaken
through effective internal and implemented various initiatives to raise the proficiency levels
external communications in to continuously enhance the consistent with the Corporate
media relations, community efficiency and effectiveness of Objectives on service excellence.
affairs and corporate its programmed activities. These These include the setting up of
responsibility, corporate include: the Pusat Aduan Korporat and
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
77
Group
Human
Dato’ Kamaruzzaman bin Jusoh
Resource
Vice President
Highlights of Achievements:
Succession/Talent Management
Current Talent pool strength stands at 288. There are 254 Key Leadership Positions (KLPs) and
potential successors have been nominated for 85% of these positions.
Talent Exchange Programme
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
The inaugural GLC Talent Exchange initiative amongst GLCs was launched in June 2008. Two top
talents (selected from the talent pool) from TNB have been assigned to Celcom Berhad and MBSB
(Malaysian Building Society Berhad) for one year. In return, TNB has accepted two talents, one each
from Malaysia Airports Holdings Berhad (MAHB) and MBSB.
Leadership Development Audit (LDA)
TNB’s company-wide adequacy in terms of framework, policy, processes and practices to meet its
leadership recruitment, development, readiness and retention requirements were audited by an
external consultant in April 2008. The overall results were commendable. Out of the 7 elements
audited, 5 were found to be of good practice while the other 2 were adequate.
Blue Book Implementation
TNB was rated as being amongst the top two GLCs in Blue Book Implementation by an external
consultant.
Specialist Career Path
This scheme had been in existence for 4 years. To date two Specialists and 24 Technical Experts
had been appointed. Two of them had received international recognition for their respective
achievement in Flashover Analysis Tool and Power Quality Guidebook.
78
Operational Summary The short term and long
term development plans and
In order to meet its current and placement in the Talent Review
future business needs, TNB has Process have been made a
to ensure that its leadership permanent agenda at the
pipeline is able to supply Management Breakout, TNB’s
capable and competent leaders. biannual management retreat.
Towards achieving this goal, the The Leadership Development
Group’s talent pool size had been Audit conducted by an external
increased to 288 candidates as consultant had rated TNB as
a result of continued focus on Ir. Sazali P. Abdul Karim
having a commendable standard Flashover Analysis Tool which
talent identification and their of talent management. is his brain child has been
development. More importantly patented and put in display
the search for potential talent The Specialist Career Path at World Intellectual Property
has delved deeper into the Scheme continues to create
Organization (WIPO)
lower level hierarchy of TNB opportunities for aspiring and
executives. In the mean time,
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
deserving candidates. To date
the Division continued to adopt the number of specialists and
formal development programmes technical experts has increased to
such as Progem (Programme for two and twenty four respectively.
General Managers) conducted This alternative career path for
by the National University of engineers has partly contributed
Singapore. to the retention of technical
excellence in TNB.
An exter nal consultant was Moving forward and in line INTERNAL AFFAIRS
commissioned by Khazanah with the Second Phase of
Nasional to conduct an audit on TNB’s 20 Year Strategic Action Highlights of Achievements:
the implementation of the Blue Plan to achieve geographical Establishment of Caught
Book guidelines on Intensifying business expansion, overseas Red-Handed Procedure.
Performance Management job assignments for selected Launching of the Whistle
based on the following 3 key candidates to enhance their Blowing Information System
elements: knowledge and broaden their (WBIS) and Toll Free Line.
Organisational Performance, exposure in the relevant fields
have been implemented. Five Introduced Customer Charter
Programs, policies and Systems for the IAD.
Benefits to Labour Force members of TNB’s workforce
were seconded to TNB Liberty
The audit had rated TNB as one Power Limited in Pakistan Divisional Goals
of the top practitioners among and six others to Shuaibah III
Independent Water and Power The IAD strives to be a
the GLCs. department of high
Project (Shuaibah), Saudi Arabia
under this initiative. professionalism and integrity in
CAPACITY BUILDING
disciplinary management not
One of the key attributes of a
As part of long term capacity only in TNB but among the
world-class organisation is its
building initiative, two engineers Government Linked Companies
concern for the standard of
were sent to the Korean Advanced (GLCs). The department’s major
professionalism in the workforce.
Institute of Science & Technology objective is to reduce the
Among the Division’s objectives,
and University of Michigan in number of cases of misconduct
therefore, is to ensure that TNB
preparation for nuclear power in TNB through education and
has a capable and professional
option eventualities. prevention programmes as well
work-force to meet, if not exceed
as providing excellent services.
customer expectations through
quality delivery. During the period
under review, 114 developmental Process Improvement
Operational Summary
and 1,110 mandatory technical To enhance efficiency in service
and non-technical training delivery to internal customers, T h e I A D i s re s p o n s i b l e i n
programmes were conducted for 86 procedures and 118 work managing, conducting and
executives and non-executives instructions relating to Human monitoring disciplinary actions
respectively. The programmes Resource Management had against the employees including
were designed to ensure that been declared for MS ISO formulating a Disciplinary
TNB employees are equipped 9000:2001 process compared Policy for TNB. Functionally,
with competencies that would to only 65 procedures and 82 the department reports to the
meet its business requirements work instructions in the previous Board of Directors’ Disciplinary
and raise organisational efficiency financial year. Committee while operationally it
and productivity. reports to Vice President (Human
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
80
Operational Improvements Key Performance Indicators
81
Highlights of Achievements:
Review of Division Business Plan and Top Management
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).
Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) initiatives in
TNB.
Major Strategic Issue Coordination; Gas Pricing and
Tariff, Cogeneration and Malaysian Electricity Supply
Industry (ESI) Structure.
Sealing power supply agreement with Sarawak
Zainab binti Abdullah Electricity Berhad (SEB).
Vice President Involvement with Sarawak – Peninsular Malaysia
(SARPEN) Interconnection.
Study on the Development of Nuclear Power
Generation.
Execution of Service Level Agreement for TNB thermal
Planning
power stations under the custody of Generation
Division.
Enhance
Business Customer/
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Expansion Stakeholder
Loyalty
GLOBAL LEADERSHIP
Get
Defend 2025
Our
Our House
Core Service
In
Excellence OVERSEAS INVESTMENT
Order Excel in:
2020
– All business areas
– Reputation as a
GEOGRAPHICAL EXPANSION Improve financial strong business
Position (SERVICES) 2015 position and human partner
For resource readiness of – Ability to continue to
Growth TNB create shareholder
SERVICE EXCELLENCE Expand works and
services related to the value
2010 Venture into
energy sector
power/energy related TNB acknowledged as
Improve Core investments in the amongst the most
To be amongst the Operations under T7 Creation of new
international arena admired companies
best performing Strategy revenue stream
companies in Malaysia leveraging on TNB’s globally
by 2007 Place TNB as the best knowledge and
performing company competencies in the
in Malaysia by 2007 energy business
and as the Regional
best by 2010
82
Divisional Goals The Strategic Planning The Division plays the role of
Department acts as the the secretariat for CDM projects
The Planning Division which secretariat for the biannual in TNB. Currently two generation
was operationalised in January management retreat known as projects are being pursued for
of 2008, comprises three the Management Breakout, which the deployment of CDM – i.e.
departments namely Strategic is a forum for the top leadership the Ulu Terengganu and Ulu
Planning Department, System of TNB to deliberate and resolve Jelai hydroelectric projects. In
Planning and Development strategic issues. The Division addition, several potential CDM
Department and Energy also conducted the Strategic projects were also identified
Procurement Department. The Planners Forum in 2008 with the in a study conducted with
Strategic Planning Department objective of creating a platform TNB Research. These included
was previously under the for a strategic discourse on rehabilitation of small hydros,
Group Finance Division, while strategies and implementation Small Renewable Energy Power
both the System Planning and thus contributing towards the Programme (SREP), Bio-mass
D e v e l o p m e n t , a n d E n e rg y alignment of corporate and Renewable Energy (RE) and the
Procurement Departments were division strategies and objectives. recycling of SF6 gases in TNB’s
formerly operating under the In addition, the forum also substations.
Transmission Division. served as a useful platform for
the dissemination of strategies Gas Pricing and Tariff
The Division’s key roles and and policy information. Adjustment
functions include formulating The Division was actively
and reviewing TNB’s long term involved in the recent tariff
strategic plan that will position Management of Strategic adjustment due to the
the organisation towards attaining Issues review of the gas price for
its desired future state, planning the power sector. The tariff
of the long-term power system Implementation of Clean
adjustment in July 2008
development to ensure safe, Development Mechanism
is strictly to recover the
reliable and economic power (CDM) Projects
additional fuel cost incurred
supply to meet the electricity TNB is fully supportive of
mainly due to the gas price
demand and supply needs of the the Government’s efforts
increase. However, the tariff
nation. In addition, the Division in placing the Clean
adjustment does not take
is also responsible for managing Development Mechanism
into consideration the recent
all activities related to energy (CDM) as an important
high increase in coal price.
procurement, operationalisation complementary mechanism to
and settlement of energy and facilitate the implementation
Cogeneration
capacity procured from power of sustainable energy projects
In support of the
producers and cross border (with emphasis on Renewable
G o v e r n m e n t ’s i n i t i a t i v e s
trading. Energy (RE) and Energy
towards efficient utilisation of
Efficiency (EE) projects),
energy resources, the Division
thus resulting in overall
has recently commissioned a
Formulation and improvement and protection
Cross-Divisional Task Group
Implementation of of the environment.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
to review the Cogeneration
Corporate Strategies policy with the view towards
The Clean Development
The Planning Division is actively encouraging efficient
Mechanism (CDM) is an
involved in the coordination and utlisation of energy in the
arrangement under the Kyoto
communication of the TNB 20- business sector. The Task
Protocol allowing developed
year Strategic Plan to facilitate Group has proposed several
countries with a Green House
an effective implementation of immediate term measures
Gas (GHG) reduction commitment
strategies and initiatives through- related to the scheme of
(known as Annex 1 countries)
out the Group. This includes the rates and conditions to
to invest in projects that reduce
coordination of all Divisions’ facilitate development of
CO 2 emissions in developing
5-year Business Plans mid-term Cogeneration.
countries (such as Malaysia) as
review to ensure alignment with an alternative to more expensive
TNB long term strategic direction. emission reductions in their own
Communication, coordination countries.
and implementation activities of
the 20-year Strategic Plan are
implemented in conjunction with
other relevant divisions.
83
Operations Review – Planning Division
Unplanned Outage Rate (UOR) 9.4% 6.1% 4.7% 2.2% < 3% 3.3%
With Sarawak Energy The Planning Division worked power sector could be facing
Berhad (SEB) hand-in-hand with the initial energy (fuel) supply security
Tenaga Nasional Berhad project developer and the and constraints due to the
(TNB) and Sarawak Energy appointed consultants depletion of indigenous gas
Berhad (SEB) signed a Head in the Technical System reserves and over reliance
Of Agreement on 7 May Study. The roles of the two on imported coal. It could
2008 for supply of power parties were to ensure high also face the prospects of
to Peninsular Malaysia from reliability and performance pressure in supply increase
hydro-electric, and, or coal of the interconnection based due to high and volatile
power plants in Sarawak. In on the criteria set out in energy prices. The fossil fuel
this agreement, apart from the Transmission System prices have been escalating
Bakun, SEB also agrees to Reliability Standards and due to increasing demand
supply 3,000 Megawatts of Malaysian Grid Code. The accentuated by the limited
electricity to TNB from 2017 study had produced a key and depleting supply. In
to 2020 and further 5000 report entitled “Basis for addition, the high usage of
MW from 2021 to 2030. Functional Performance fossil fuel for power generation
84
could pose environmental price (coal) and constraints in Excellence by 2010. TNB has
issue as a result of emission the international coal supply succeeded to achieve many
of greenhouse gas. For the chain (both the coal supply strategic objectives under this
sustainable development of sources and infrastructure) phase despite the impact of
the nation’s electricity and are posing major challenges many external challenges and
energy sector and to mitigate to Malaysia’s power sector. environmental pressures. To
the energy supply security align TNB with the current and
issue, nuclear power plant In order to ensure the sector’s future business environment,
should be seriously considered long term sustainability in the Plan will be reviewed and
as a viable alternative for the particular mitigation of the suitable strategies reassessed
future. TNB has been working energy supply security risk, for implementation during its
closely with other stakeholders the Planning Division is second phase (2011-2015)
and agencies in particular The entrusted to implement the which focuses on geographical
Malaysian Nuclear Agency following initiatives: business expansion.
(Nuclear Malaysia) on the – Harness hydro power in
nuclear option. Peninsular Malaysia and Addressing Major Strategic
Sarawak (Bakun etc) Risks
In this regard, the Division
Execution of Service Level – Promote the use will provide an active and
of Demand Side supporting role to address
Agreements (SLA’s) with
Management, Energy major strategic risks in
thermal power stations Efficiency, Renewable
operated by Generation particular the tariff review,
Energy and other non- fuel pass-through mechanism
Division fossil power sources. a n d p r i c i n g s t u d y, a n d
In our effort to ensure that all – Plan the development of Malaysian Electricity Supply
power generators operate under more efficient generating I n d u s t r y ( E S I ) s t r u c t u re
similar business environment, the plants. analysis to ensure the
Planning Division has developed successful implementation of
– Assist in preparatory
and implemented SLAs on all the Identification of Strategic
work for possible use
thermal power plants operated Risks and the Associated
of nuclear energy. The
by the Generation Division. All Risks Mitigation Plan.
project would demand
technical, commercial and legal
much efforts in the
terms of the Agreements are TNB Strategic Planners
formulation of policy,
adapted from the most recent Forum and Technical
identification of sites,
Power Purchase Agreement Planners Forum
conduct of pre-feasibility
(PPA). To date, six individual These biannual forums will
and feasibility studies,
SLAs had been duly signed. involve discussion of strategic
instituting the regulation,
and technical issues impacting
conduct manpower
TNB in the medium and long
planning.
Challenges and Prospects term by the Group’s strategic
– Work closely with or technical planners and
The power supply industry will stakeholders such as related executives. It also
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
be facing increasing challenges Ministry of Energy, Water serves as the platform for
attributable to volatile fuel and Communications and staff to be updated on
prices, energy supply security the Economic Planning major strategic and technical
issue, current global economic Unit (EPU), Prime Minister issues/initiatives as well as
downturn and deteriorating Department on national TNB policies.
financial condition. In this energy policy studies
regard the Planning Division for sustainable energy Hydro PPAs with TNBG
will undertake various initiatives development. The Planning Division
to mitigate the risks associated i s c u r re n t l y c o n d u c t i n g
with these challenges: Review of TNB 20 Year negotiations and development
Strategic Plan of SLAs for TNB Hydro power
Sustaining Long Term The Strategic Plan which was plants. These include Kenyir,
Energy Security developed in 2005 sets the Temenggor, Pergau and
Energy supply security strategic direction of TNB for Cameron Highlands hydro
due to depleting energy the period of 2006 -2025. The Power Stations.
resources (gas), high and first phase which commenced
volatile international energy in 2006 sets to achieve Service
85
Investment
Dato’ Nik Ibrahim
Management
bin Nik Mohamed Divisional Goals
Vice President The Investment Management Division manages an extensive
portfolio of equity investments of the Company and the Group
with the objective of ensuring positive value addition to TNB
Group as a whole. The Division is currently monitoring equity
investments in 68 subsidiaries and associate companies and
other long-term investments in core and non-core businesses
with a market value of approximately RM4.949 billion.
Operational Summary
The Division assumes the role of setting strategic direction
for the subsidiaries and streamlining their operations within
the Group. It also formulates long term and short term
investment strategies for the equity investments within the
Group. The Division also plays the leading role in overseeing
and monitoring the performances of the 68 companies
while administratively overseeing 10 subsidiaries involved
in such sectors as manufacturing, services and consultancy,
education, mining and utility. 83% of these companies are
locally registered.
86
As it moves forward to a new 3. Tenaga Switchgear Project Developer, Engineering
era, MTM is highly enthusiastic Sdn. Bhd. (TSG) P ro c u re m e n t C o n s t r u c t i o n ,
i n f u l f i l l i n g i t s v i s i o n “ To As a 60%-owned subsidiary, Operations and Maintenance of
Become A World Class Leader Tenaga Switchgear Sdn. Bhd. projects and Equity Owner. A
In Transformer Business Globally (TSG) had delivered a robust quality review of its functions
by 2020”. set of results as it continued has led to the restructuring of
to build on its consistent and its roles and responsibilities that
2. Tenaga Cable Industries well-executed strategy. During could better serve the needs of
Sdn. Bhd. (TCI) the period under review, TSG the Group and its customers in its
Tenaga Cable Industries Sdn. Bhd. charted total sales of RM52.17 capacity as the leading provider
(TCI) a 76%-owned subsidiary million which generated profit of District Cooling System in
of TNB had recorded a solid before tax of RM4.4 million, and major buildings in Malaysia.
performance in manufacturing return on investment (ROI) of 13
and distribution of power cables The company had succeeded in
percent.
such as XLPE Cables up to securing projects in Engineering
33 kV, Optical Ground Wires TSG’s success in its core business Procurement Construction with
(OPGW), low voltage general of assembling and manufacturing main focus in 30,000RT District
cables, aluminium conductors high voltage switchgears offers Cooling System in Abu Dhabi,
(ACSR), aluminium/aluminium customers a wide range of UAE, District Cooling System
alloy rods and sales of OPGW competitively priced products project at 1 Borneo Hypermall,
accessories. As a leader in and services. It had also Sabah, District Cooling System
cable manufacturing TCI sets differentiated itself from the project for IJN, Main Infrastructure
benchmark for cables quality competitors through its service Works Project Phase 1, UITM,
and prices. excellence. During the same Achi Jaya Plantations Gas Engine
period, TSG had successfully Project, and District Cooling
During the period under review, completed Turnkey 132 kV GIS System project at UITM Medical
TCI succeeded in reducing its projects such as PMU Shah Alam Training Centre, Sg. Buloh.
borrowing by 53.7% from RM54.5 West, TNB Central, PMU Melaka
million to RM25.2 million. As Amidst the increasingly
275 kV GIS, TNB Major Project,
a result, its Net Tangible Asset competitive global landscape in
SSU 33 kV MAHA, and SSU
(NTA) increased from RM0.72 to particular the competition from
33 kV MOX, TNBD Selangor and
RM0.84, Current Ratio (CR) from well-established local contracting
PMU 132 kV Kuantan, TNB East.
115 percent to 146 percent, and firms, TNEC had persevered in
It also completed the supply of
Gearing Ratio from 0.92 times pursuing its passions to reach
its products such as PMU TG
to 0.48 times. new heights of excellence by
Langsat, PMU Ulu Repah, PMU
open and aggressive marketing
The key features of TCI business Masjid Tanah, PMU Kuala Pilah,
for district cooling system
model required close monitoring PMU Putra Jaya and PMU KL
projects, for mulating new
of prices on the London Metal Pavilion. It is now setting its
project packaging strategy for
Exchange (LME). Its diligence eyes to penetrate overseas
competitiveness in tendering,
had paid off when it realised market. The 170 kV GCB and DS
expanding the district cooling
savings of RM0.65 million for project which is 80% completed
system business internationally
aluminum and RM0.79 million for has been developed to meet
and establish strategic
copper after having successfully the requirements of the
partnerships.
locked in on LME contract price Indonesian market.
or lower for the metals. TCI had Spurred on by the vision “To
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
services for the development, Choice in Malaysia by 2010 and the last three financial years has
operations and maintenance the Region by 2015”. increased, from RM77.4 million
of Renewable Energy related in financial year 2004/2005
projects such as wind and solar 6. TNB Fuel Services Sdn. (FY05) to RM82.6 million in
hybrid, biomass and mini hydro, Bhd. (TNBF) financial year 2006/2007 (FY07)
Power Quality Mitigation and As a purchaser and supplier of to RM98.3 million in financial
Monitoring, Energy Efficiency fuel, including coal for power year 2007/08 (FY08). The bulk of
Audit and Implementation and generation in Malaysia since the revenue is generated from
Air conditioning and Mechanical 1998, TNB Fuel Services Sdn. tuition fees.
Ventilation Systems services and Bhd. (TNBF), wholly-owned by
maintenance. TNB, continues to face new and Research is one of the key
greater challenges in the face agenda of UNITEN and this
TNBES had initiated a broad of volatile fuel market. TNBF is seen in the quality of its
strategy review to ensure that plays a key role in monitoring researchers as clearly worded in
its strategic intent and policies coal and freight markets. The its mission statement. UNITEN’s
remain relevant, building on Fuel Procurement Executive c o m m i t m e n t i n p ro m o t i n g
the opportunities presented by Committee and Coal Hedging research activities is evident
the changing environment and Committee, established to from the number of research
meeting the rising expectations study the fuel market have undertaken that continues to
of the various stakeholders. since extended its activities to increase year after year. UNITEN
cover other critical commodities has won 38 local awards and
TNBES is proud to have such as copper and aluminium 3 international awards and has
participated in Engineering, required by other subsidiaries. acquired Ministry of Science,
Procurement and Contracting Technology and Innovation
of 2MW Landfill Gas Power TNBF is optimistic that its vision (MOSTI) research grants
Station in Puchong, Selangor, “To Be a Reputable International amounting to over RM10 million.
Operations and Maintenance Fuel Trader and Fuel Services UNITEN has been placed in the
and Rehabilitation of TNB Mini Provider” would be fulfilled given 7th position, and is the highest
Hydro Stations, Renewable its track record and experience among the Private Higher
Energy (W ind/Solar Hybrid) in the field. Education Institutions (HEIs) to
power stations for supply of up receive the MOSTI Fund.
to 300kW per station at various 7. Universiti Tenaga Nasional
locations, Renewable Energy (UNITEN) As a pioneer among private
of mini hydro for Langkawi Since its inception in 1997, the universities in Malaysia and
Cable Car Middle Station for university has emerged as one is wholly-owned by TNB,
LADA, the islands off Mersing, of the most sought after higher UNITEN focuses on three niche
Johore, Orang Asli Settlements learning institutions in the country areas; engineering, information
in Peninsular Malaysia, Pulau in just 10 years. Favourable technology and business. Most of
P e r h e n t i a n ( w i n d / s o l a r ) o ff remarks have been constantly the programmes are accredited
Terengganu and Remote Areas received about UNITEN’s strategic by professional bodies such as
in Sabah for the Ministry of location, first-class infrastructure Institution of Mechanical Engineers
Rural and Regional Development and highly marketable graduates; (UK), Institution of Civil Engineers
and Pulau Kapas for Terengganu but what stands it in good stead (UK), Engineering Accreditation
State-owned PERMINT. is its corporate credo – vision Councils (EAC), Malaysia Institute
and mission statements – and of Accountants (MIA), Malaysia
It enjoyed a prestigious the undivided support of its staff
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
ICT Division
Highlights of Achievements:
90
Razali bin Awang
Chief Information Officer
Divisional Goals
The ICT Division continues to subscribe to four main
objectives towards supporting TNB’s overall vision and
mission namely to effectively govern and consolidate
the use of ICT in TNB, e-enabling critical business and
technical processes, providing reliable digital infrastructure
and network connectivity as well as maximising returns
from ICT infrastructures and expertise.
91
Operations Review – ICT Division
92
The Division had also contributed The Division had also undertaken At the same time, the Server
i t s e x p e r t i s e t o w a rd s t h e continuous upgrading of Utilisation Key Performance Index
development of the Online Vendor infrastructure to enhance the had indicated optimal utilisation
Registration (OVR) System. The resiliency, reliability and availability of ICT Division’s infrastructure by
efforts had been well-rewarded of the TNB telecommunication the Group.
when TNB was honored with the network as well as to provide for
“Best New Services” Award for its robust and reliable channels for
reputable IT applications such as teleprotection, telecontrol and Implementation of Process
OVR, eCIBS and MFFA during SCADA. Standardisation and
the 10th ASEAN Communication Improvement (PSI)
& Multimedia (ACM) Expo & The in-house development of
Forum 2007 in Kuala Lumpur. these systems coupled with The ICT Division heavily utilises
prudent project management the PSI platform to improve its
ICT also contributed in the discipline had enabled TNB to internal services. Through the PSI,
development of an online Whistle realise cost savings in the long the Division is able to study and
Blowing System together with term. propose system improvement in
Internal Affairs Department as line with its main objective of
part of TNB’s effort to improve Key Performance Indicators E-enabling critical business and
internal or external complaint technical processes for higher
channel related to employee The ICT Division’s Key Performance efficiency.
misconduct and power abuse. Indicators are evaluated based on
the four main thrusts formulated During the period under review,
The Division had implemented an to support TNB’s overall goals, the Division had undertaken a
internal Customer Management namely prudent spending and review of its operational process
System (CMS) that enabled online maximising value from ICT to simplify and better manage
request and tracking of ICT investments, improving customer its services. The new processes
incidents and change requests. efficiency through excellent and would include the application
This system was implemented in industry standard ICT products of the entire Plan, Do, Check
accordance with the principles and services delivery, operational and Act cycle in accordance
of IT Infrastructure Library (ITIL), excellence through e-processes with the IT Infrastructure Library
the industry best practice for IT and leveraging on human capital (ITIL) to ensure the effectiveness
Service Management. for continuous growth. of services delivered. Apart
from this, the Division has also
Several projects to improve Overall, the Division had managed implemented parts of the Control
in-house operations had been to reduce capital expenditure Objectives for Information and
instituted during the period through innovative project Related Technology (COBIT) to
under review. Enhancement of implementation which succeeded effectively govern ICT operations
the cbPMS had enabled TNB in meeting all deliverables while in its processes.
to monitor the Key Performance optimising cost.
Indicators and competencies of In the meantime, the Division had
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
all staff, thus contributing to In line with industry practice, reduced the number of processes
better performance management. the Division’s services to the from the initial 38 to 23 following
Other projects implemented were core divisions were measured by process consolidation in Project
the enterprise-wide Electronic the Telecommunication Network Implementation, Service Desk
Document Management System Availability and System Availability Escalation, Data Centre Monitoring
( E D M S ) t o m a n a g e T N B ’s indicators. In this respect, the and Customer Management
records and files and the TNB Division had succeeded not only systems. The reduction to the
Storage Virtualisation project in meeting the targets but had number of processes signifies
which involved consolidation surpassed the industry benchmark. lesser red tape and provides a
of various storage platforms to Its internal Customer Satisfaction more seamless and systematic
improve ERP performance that Index score had also shown process in delivery of ICT products
led to simplification of storage improvement. and services.
management as well as reduction
of total cost of ownership.
93
Operations Review – ICT Division
94
Awards and Accolades Moving forward, the MFFA solution will be included in
(Mobile Field Force Automation) the implementation scope to
ICT Chief Information Officer, project scope will be expanded optimise the functionality of
Encik Razali Awang has been to include Distribution Division the Corporate GIS project and
given recognition nationally as a teams located in other parts of sharing of information between
visionary and charismatic leader Peninsular Malaysia such as Johor various TNB applications.
by MIMOS as reported in the and Penang. This project will be
Business Today magazine. extended to the Transmission
Division in the near future.
95
Divisional Goals
TNB has restructured and strengthened
its procurement organisation and has
given the Procurement Division the
mandate to play a greater strategic role
in driving value creation and enhancing
procurement process transparency,
integrity and efficiency.
Procurement
enforcing compliance and promoting
national development priorities,
including the development of a more
competitive and resilient Bumiputra
enterprise community.
Procurement is a strategic
function that drives value creation Driven by its vision and mission, the
Procurement Division aspires to be
in supply chain for the Company the leader amongst regional utilities in
Supply Chain Management. It is also
committed to create value through
Highlights of Achievements: innovation and adoption of procurement
best practices.
Significant Value Creation in the Financial Year
amounting to RM118 million.
Continued and sturdy progress in the 2nd year of Operational Summary
Procurement Transformation Plan implementation. During the period under review,
Launching of the nationwide On-line Vendor Registration various activities and initiatives were
in October 2007. successfully carried out to address the
five key focus areas in the Procurement
Hosting of the “Anugerah Usahawan/Vendor Cemerlang”
Transformation Plan, i.e. the promotion
event in February 2008.
of use of local content and ensuring
Launching of the TNB Product Quality Assurance Policy Bumiputra equity shares; realising value
and Procedures in July 2008.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
96
Operational Improvements divisional tender evaluations. Partnership with
The enhancement of the Stakeholders
e-Bidding system is on-going to
Eight e-Bidding sessions for meet current and future Heads of ASEAN Power
products and services were requirements. Utilities/Authorities (HAPUA)
successfully conducted with The HAPUA Procurement
more than RM15 million Procurement Appraisal Circle was established in
savings being realised. The Division continues its February 2007 to serve as a
efforts in enhancing process platform for ASEAN member
On-line Vendor Registration integrity and transparency by countries to share best
(OVR) conducting 44 procurement practices, provide alternative
OVR was implemented in appraisals on selected sources of information for
October 2007 to replace the stations throughout Malaysia. market intelligence and price
manual vendor registration The objective is to ensure benchmarks via the HAPUA
system. The objective is the adequacy, compliance Procurement Portal and create
to shorten the vendor and effectiveness of opportunities for collaborative
registration process and procurement process, policy procurement activities
improve efficiency. There and procedures. and benchmarking for
has been an increase in the performance improvements.
number of renewals and TNB had successfully hosted
new registration of vendors the 2nd HAPUA Procurement
Human Resource Capacity
following the implementation Circle meeting in March
Development
OVR. As the system is shared 2008 which was attended by
with other divisions through The Division is structured around representatives from eight
the intranet, it has enabled 4 key departments namely ASEAN countries. Amongst
the verification of vendor Sourcing Controller, Strategic others, the meeting resolved
status by the divisions during Supplier Management, Best that the HAPUA Procurement
Practice and Policies and Shared Circle must continue to exist
Purchasing. Staffs with diversified as a platform for HAPUA
skills and disciplines are members to interact in the
continuously being developed to sharing of information and
support the enhanced strategic procurement best practices.
function of procurement. A benchmarking visit to PT
PLN (Persero), Indonesia
was conducted to share
and compare procurement
best practices adopted
by TNB’s counterpart in
Jakarta. The visit was
also part of procurement
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
97
Operations Review – Procurement Division
98
local products. An awareness Marketing & Promotional Awards and Accolades
programme has been planned Programmes The Procurement Division was
to disseminate the Policy to all
The Strategic Supplier entrusted to contribute to the
regions in FY2009.
Management Department of the “Quality Assurance of External
Division had jointly participated in Suppliers” criteria which is one of
local and international marketing the criteria in the Prime Minister’s
Excellence Award for
and promotional programmes Industry Excellence Award 2007
Entrepreneurs/Vendors (AKIPM). The assignment was
with the vendors. Participation
Since the introduction of the in these programmes helps based on the Division’s close
E n t re p re n e u r D e v e l o p m e n t the vendors leverage on TNB relationship with TNB Group-
Programme in 1993, TNB through brand name to penetrate the wide suppliers. The Division
the Procurement Division has local and overseas markets. The ensures the quality of TNB
been consistently nurturing and Division had participated in, products and services through
developing its entrepreneurs among others, the Ministry of its consistent quality assurance
thus paving the way for them Entrepreneur and Cooperative efforts which encompasses
to emerge as global players. Development (MECD) EXPO supplier selection, supplier
T h e E n t re p re n e u r s / Ve n d o r s held in May 2008 at the Putra certification and recognition.
Excellence Award was introduced World Trade Centre (PWTC)
for the first time in February and the international marketing
2008 to serve as testimony to mission to Cambodia & Vietnam Division Challenges
TNB’s success in implementing in July 2008.
The escalating price of raw
the Entrepreneur Development
materials including the cost of
Programme. Salutary Avenue
fuel has a direct impact on TNB’s
Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. was
procurement operational costs.
the winner of the Entrepreneurs/
Value creation initiatives including
Vendors Excellence Award 2008
the adoption of procurement
for their consistent achievements
best practices particularly the
i n t h e l o c a l , re g i o n a l a n d
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
international markets. The event
is crucial in order to sustain
was held at One World Hotel,
TNB’s profitability.
Kuala Lumpur.
99
Corporate
Services
Md. Jailani bin Abas
Senior General Manager
The Corporate Services Division
provides support services to TNB
Group in areas it specialises in i.e.
logistics, properties, security and
intelligence services.
Highlights of Achievements:
Among the highlights of achievement of Departments and Units under the Division are:
Security Services & Intelligence Department (SSID)
Formation of National Taskforce on metal theft with relevant enforcement agencies to combat
intrusion and theft at TNB installations with participation from GTD.
Formation of SSID National Control Room.
Effective 1 May 2008, SSID enforced rigid KPI and penalty in the contract with private security
companies. The Department also took the initiative to provide training to private security
personnel as stipulated in the same contract.
Conducted Cyber Crisis Drill in coordination with EWRM, Cyber Security & National Security
Council.
Held dialogue session with Malaysian Indian Metal Traders & Recyclers Association (MIMTA).
Investigation & Intelligence Unit’s success include uncovering syndicated crime involving TNB
personnel against TNB assets, syndicates involved in theft of transformers, electricity, TNB fuse
link, cables and padlocks at installations. Four members of the syndicate involved in theft of
padlocks at installations were arrested. Also uncovered was a syndicate involved in forgery of
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
100
Divisional Goals It aims to achieve operational management, management
excellence by reducing breach and land procurement. The
Following a major restructuring of security to prevent losses to Department’s mission is achieve
in early 2008, the Corporate TNB. SSID aspires to be among excellence in the management of
Services Division’s functions and the leading security services property, products and services.
responsibilities have been scaled provider in the region by 2010.
down to cover four main areas The Logistic Services Department
namely logistics, properties, The Department has three provides cost-effective logistic
security and intelligence operational units namely services to customers and to seek
as well as support services Operation, Planning & Crisis new services that could add value
including human resource and
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Management and Investigation to the Group. The Department’s
administration, finance and & Intelligence Units. SSID’s objective is to manage total
planning and performance. The main focus is to safeguard logistics requirements to meet
Division’s core operational focus TNB’s key installations from customer expectation.
is to be the leading division damage, vandalism and theft.
in supporting TNB’s vision and Its personnel are stationed at For the period under review, the
mission and provides excellent various critical locations such as Department had provided cost-
support services within TNB. power stations, substations and efficient and effective logistic
regional warehouse and offices services with high customer
throughout Peninsular Malaysia. satisfaction. These included
Operational Summary freight, fleet and generator set
The Security Services & The Property Services services to support TNB’s core
Intelligence Department (SSID) Department provides property businesses. Major assignments
is one of the important support support services to the core handled during the period
services providing and delivering businesses of TNB by enhancing included vehicle repair and
effective & efficient core security the Group’s assets values through maintenance, vehicles inspection
services to TNB to ensure excellent discipline in planning b y P U S PA K O M , s u p p l y o f
uninterrupted power supply. a n d d e v e l o p m e n t , p ro j e c t generator sets, repair of feeder
101
Operations Review – Corporate Services Division
The Property Services Indicators are grouped under audited during Internal Quality
Department is responsible for four main categories as follows: Audit (IQA). No non-compliance
the management of TNB mega was discovered except for minor
projects such as TNB Tower and Financial observations for improvements
other TNB buildings. E ff e c t i v e O P E X B u d g e t (OFIs). Three procedures for
Management (exclusive fleet management would be
During the period under review, uncontrollable project registered.
major projects undertaken by the requirement & expenses).
Logistics Services Department Effective CAPEX Budget The Division‘s Internal Quality
included the following: Management (exclusive Audit was conducted on 27 June
Major refurbishment of six uncontrollable project to 8 July 2008. It plans to review
(6) units of 500 kW mobile requirement & expenses). its Action Plans on SIRIM NCR
generator sets. and OFI by mid September 2008.
Customers The ISO concepts, process and
Built skid tanks for Generator
procedure will be disseminated
set operating bases at Gong Internal Customer Service
to staff the Division in the next
Badak, Malim Nawar, Muadzam Score.
Financial Year.
Shah and Chain Ferry.
102
Human Resource Quality Management and The Division also managed
Management Initiatives various categories of vendors
comprising among others panel
Apart from recruiting qualified The Division had conducted workshops, panel transporters,
and competent personnel, various quality management and panel Multimodal Transport
the Division has placed great initiatives which included: Operators (MTOs), Petronas,
emphasis on continuous capacity T hough there was AKP CELCOM, private security
building of its human resource. assessment during the period agencies, building contractors,
As at end August 2008, the under review, activities under general vendors for supply of
Corporate Services Division has AKP were implemented as materials.
a staff strength of about 1500 planned.
with many areas of specialisation.
To enhance their skills and 26 WIT teams were actively
Challenges and Prospects
competencies, the number of involved in formulating ways
training days attended by staff, to improve quality of products A s T N B - o w n e d a s s e t s a re
in particular the executives, and services to customers. gazetted as National Critical
has been included as one of Team members are drawn from Infrastructure, Security Services
their KPIs. Suitable internal and the same units as projects are & Intelligence Department
external training programmes designed to improve processes (SSID) needs to be proactive in
would continued to be of their respective units. ensuring the proper protection
identified and proposed to the The 5S activities conducted for the assets. Among initiatives
management. had considerably improved taken included the formulation
the office work environment of strategies and mechanisms
Currently more than 90% of that promote vigilance as well as
Customer Focus the staff Had taken part in 5S building networking with various
programmes through weekly security agencies.
The Corporate Services Division observations, monthly meetings
identifies its customer needs and and quarterly audit. The fight against sabotage
expectations through the Annual and threats of terrorism
Risks were monitored from TNB
Customer Satisfaction Index require comprehensive and
Risk Information System (TRIS)
(CSI). Each year all departments multifaceted strategies. Raising
to maintain strong internal
under the Division are required awareness and educating TNB
control with the objective to
to distribute questionnaires to staff of the threats, undertaking
minimise, if not eliminate, the
their customers. The final analysis strict compliance measures,
impact and likelihood of the
of the results of the survey will adopting and implementing
Division/Departments failing
be reported by the Performance necessary legislation and the
to achieve their objectives
& Planning Department. The effective sharing of information
and to reduce uncertainty of
scores and findings will serve and intelligence at bilateral,
undesirable events occurring.
as the basis for all departments multilateral levels multilateral and
will take appropriate corrective regional levels are among some
measures which include: of the pertinent initiatives.
Stakeholder/Relationship
Identifing areas for
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
improvement.
Management Among the main challenges
The Division had established faced by the Property Services
Organising formal and informal
good rapport and networking Department is the appropriate
meetings with customers to
with many stakeholders directly outsourcing of its roles
understand their needs and
related to its daily operations. a n d f u n c t i o n s i n p ro p e r t y
expectations and problems
Among these are the Ministry management in particular
encountered with the services
of Finance (MOF), the Malaysian property maintenance services
offered.
Industrial Development and project management.
Meeting customer needs is set
Authority (MIDA), the Royal
as one of the KPIs of staff.
Customs Department, the
Develop and implement Ministry of Domestic Trade &
Customer Relationship Consumer Affairs, the Ministry of
Management Plan. International Trade and Industry,
the Road Transport Department,
the Royal Malaysian Police and
PUSPAKOM.
103
Sabah Electricity
Sdn Bhd
Highlights of Achievements:
The sales of electricity in the financial year amounted to RM854
million compared to previous years sales of RM807 million
showing a favourable increase of 5.8%. Total units sold for the
year amounted to kWh3,384.74 million compared to kWh3,221.34
in FY2006, an increase of 5.07%.
The total reported operating expenses for the financial year amounted
to RM977.96 million compared to RM909.22 million reported in
FY2007 (net of subsidy). The Company receives significant amounts
of diesel and medium fuel oil subsidies from the Government of
Malaysia and is presented net of Energy Costs.
Total operating expenditure exceeded total income (revenue
plus other operating income) resulting in an operating loss of
RM16.44 million compared to an operating loss of RM3.24
million in FY2007. Total finance costs and foreign exchange
losses for the financial year of RM65.03 million in FY2008
(RM59.50 million in FY2007) resulted in a net loss after finance
costs of RM81.47 million (RM62.75 million in FY2007).
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
104
Human Resources Division Generation Division and gas plants as a cost saving
strategy. Among initiatives to
With a manpower strength of During the period under review, be implemented to achieve this
2,289 staff, SESB continues to the total installed capacity for the objective were Trash diverter II
develop the competency and Generation Division was 871.3 project at SJ Tenom Pangi and
capability of its employees as MW (SESB 435.8 MW and IPP replacement of Lateral Exhaust
part of key strategy to enhance 435.5 MW) and the maximum Ducting and Damper Door at
the productivity and efficiency of demand throughout the state SJ Patau-Patau. Graph 1 shows
the company. was 646.9 MW. the generation fuel mix as at
end August 2008. Generation
During the period under review, Total cost per unit (CPU) generated from gas fuel accounted for 52%
the Division had conducted for all SESB power stations (i.e. of the total energy, followed by
various workshops and training major, minor, rural and mini MFO at 21% and hydro at 13%.
sessions including GTD technical hydro stations) and IPP plants for
courses, Mini MBA, Kepner Tregoe FY2007/2008 was 16.4sen/kWh During the period under review,
Problem Solving and Decision- while the CPU for SESB’s major the Sepanggar Bay Power
Making, SEMS, 5S Practice, stations only and IPP plants was Corporation Phase 2 (34 MW) (an
PSI (Process Standardisation & 16.1sen/kWh. The overall unit IPP project) and the Powertron
Improvement), Shared Values, and generated and total expenditure Phase 2 (70 MW) project were
other soft-skills programmes. incurred were 4,176 GWh and completed in July and August
RM681 million respectively of 2008 respectively. The East-
Some 75% of its executive and which minor and rural stations West Interconnection project
33% non-executives had availed accounted for only 1.71% of the which was completed in July
themselves to the training. SESB total unit generated and 0.53% 2007 had enabled energy from
continued its collaboration with of the total expenditure. the West Coast to be exported
Institut Latihan Perindustrian to the East Coast and thus
Kota Kinabalu (ILPKK) in the As a strategy to reduce overall reducing unit generated from
recruitment of non-executive generation costs, the Division the expensive diesel-operated
technical staff through the Skim had focused on the SESB major Gas Turbine operation at Tawau
Latihan Perantis Ketukangan. stations, all IPPs and mini hydro and Sandakan.
SESB adopted Kirk Patrick’s plants. It had also optimised
four levels of training evaluation. power generation from hydro
Reward and Recognition initiatives
were introduced with 30 incentive
schemes. For FY2007/2008, the
AKP score for HRM was 80%
points. The achievement in
AKP will be the prime mover Graph 1
for SESB to move forward to Generation Fuel Mixed as at 31 August 2008
achieve service excellence by
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
year 2012.
Diesel
(Sutra) IPP
3%
Hydro SESB
13%
Diesel
SESB
Biomass 8%
(THS) IPP MFO IPP
2% 21%
PML IPP
0.10%
105
Operations Review – Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd
Transmission Division Table 1 below showed the Delivery The Division had implemented
Point Unreliability Index (DPUI) a total of 21 projects for
The key mandate for the and System Average Interruption maintenance and system
Transmission Division is to Frequency Index (SAIFI) achieved improvement. The following
ensure supply reliability and by the Transmission Division seven projects were completed
quality. In its endeavour to fulfil during FY2007/2008. while 14 more are in various
this responsibility, the Division stages of implementation.
has formulated the following As indicated in Table 1, there was
objectives: Replacement of neutral
a mark difference between “Total earthing resistor (NER) at
To c a r r y o u t p l a n n i n g , Achievement” and “Achievement Karamunsing Sub-Station
operation, maintenance and without Major Incident”. A major and UMS 66 kV Sub-Station
system improvement works incident is defined as a load completed on 1 December
of the transmission system loss of 50 MW and above. The 2007.
throughout Sabah and segregation between the two
Federal Territory of Labuan. Installation of three-pole
scenarios is necessary for the
132 kV & 66 kV SF6 gas
To operate the Sabah Grid in purpose of continuous monitoring
circuit breaker at the 66 kV
the most efficient manner. on the effectiveness of the routine
Sub-Stations in Tenom Town,
and preventive maintenance
To t r a n s m i t a d e q u a t e Penampang, Kota Kinabalu,
performances.
power supply efficiently and and Inanam completed on
economically with minimum 4 April 2008.
Three major incidents that
interruptions. 132 kV transmission line
led to the large disparity in
achievement during the period rentice clearing for year 2008
The supply reliability of from Sandakan to Segaliud
under review were:
transmission lines contributes to Sub-Station 13 May 2008.
the overall image of SESB as Total blackout on the East
transmission lines and substations Coast due to tripping of both 132 kV transmission line
are the linkages between supply 275 kV Kolopis – Segaliud rentice clearing for year
source and distribution system. lines with a total load loss of 2008 from Sempor na to
124 MW on 30 September Kalumpang Sub-Station
SESB Transmission Division 2007. completed on 13 May 2008.
underwent restructuring during VT faulted at Karamunsing 132 kV transmission line
the period under review Sub-Station with total load loss rentice clearing for year 2008
resulting in the creation of of 308 MW on 6 November from Tawau to Kalumpang
two new departments - the 2007. Sub-Station on 13 May 2008.
Energy Procurement Unit (EPU) Tower collapsed of 132 kV Procurement and training
and Operation Planning (OP). along Kayu Madang – UMS of 132/275 kV Emergency
The EPU is responsible for lines due to theft on tower Restoration System (ERS)
monitoring the Independent members with a total load Tower completed 13 June
Power Producers (IPP), while OP loss 459.3 MW on 21 April 2008.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Table 1
Key Achievement
Performance
Targets and Objectives Target
Indicators/ W/O Major
Total
Measures Incident
106
Installation of polymeric
132 kV transmission line
arresters (TLA) on the
Graph 2
132 kV transmission line
from Sandakan to Segaliud
System Average Interruption Index (SAIDI)
Sub-Station completed on for FY2005-2008
23 July 2008. 3,000
2,645 2,583
2,500
Distribution Division
U n d e r t h e S E S B ’s 2 0 Ye a r 2,000 1,850
As indicated in Graph 2
the Distribution Division had
succeeded in reducing SAIDI by
700 mins while Overall SAIDI for
SESB is shown in Graph 3.
107
Operations Review – Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd
40
20
0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
ACP (days)
108
Major Projects Division
Under the 9 Malaysia Plan, the Federal Government had allocated RM600 million to implement 23 projects
to strengthen electricity supply mainly the transmission and distribution system in Sabah as follows:-
3 Additional 132/11 kV; 1 x 20/30 Project start: May 2008 The SCADA portion will
MVA Transformer at Lahad Datu Progress: 8% be tested once the data
PMU freezing is lifted
6 132 kV Kota Kinabalu Outer Ring Project start: March 2008 On-going
Phase 2 from the new Kepayan Progress: 10%
PMU to the new Lok Kawi PMU
7 Proposed 132 kV Alam Mesra Project start: August 2007 On-going. First PMU to use
PMU; 2 x 800mm2 XLPE cu, Progress: 90% the Compact Air Insulated
132 kV from UMS PMU System (CAIS)
10 33 kV Underground cable from Cable laying had been Circuits will be transferred
PMU Kepayan to PPU KKIA & completed and initially to the new 33 kV swithgears
MAB Kota Kinabalu energised at 11 kV at the Kepayan PMU in
stages. The PPU building
progress is 75%
11 33 kV Underground Cable from Cable route had been On-going. Cabling work
PMU Kepayan & PMU Minintod changed due to the progress is 60%. The PPU
to PPU Star City, Kota Kinabalu requirement of the authorities building had commenced in
October 2008.
109
Operations Review – Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd
12 33 kV Underground Cable from Cable laying had been Full completion dependent
PMU Sepangar to TLDM Base, completed and initially on the Unggun 132/33 kV
Teluk Sepanggar, Kota Kinabalu energised at 11 kV on PMU project. Tender for the
20 May 2008 PPU Building at the TLDM
Base had been analysed for
award.
13 33 kV Underground cable from Cable route had been On-going. Cabling work
SJ Patau-Patau to PPU W.P. changed due to the progress is 20%
Labuan requirement of the authorities
Besides these projects undertaken by SESB, the Major Project Division is also monitoring and coordinating
the implementation of several generation projects carried out by the Independent Power Producers and
Small Renewal Energy Programme (SREP) as follows:
2 Ranhill Powertron (RPSB) 190 MW Overall Progress is 99% Steam Turbine Generator
Combined Cycle Block 1 & 2 (STG)23 achieved Initial
Operation Date (IOD)
on 23 August 2008
and performance tests
commenced on 22
September 2008
110
Organisation Development ISO Lead Auditors and another 9 November 2007; thus enabling
Division 64 staff members were trained as a structured implementation
ISO Auditors to facilitate Internal of quality initiatives and
Process Standardisation and Quality Audit exercise and PSI staff participation and hence
Improvement (PSI) implementation programme in promoting team work. The
SESB launched the PSI SESB. SESB’s Quality Manual Quality Council headed by the
programme on 27 November and 9 General Procedures had Managing Director, oversees the
2007. SESB’s Quality Manual, been submitted to SIRIM for planning, execution, corrective
9 General Procedures, 175 Level adequacy audit in preparation for action and review of all quality
2 procedures and 216 work ISO 9001:2000 compliance audit initiatives through regular Quality
instructions were developed targeted for September 2008. Council meetings. Each quality
through a joint effort of the initiative is headed by a Project
management team and selected S E S B M a n a g e m e n t Te a m Champion who promotes, plans,
key personnel of the Company. approved the Quality Framework coordinates and reviews progress
34 staff members were trained as as depicted in Figure M1 below on of the quality initiative.
Figure M1
Quality Framework
ISO
MCM SEMS AKP AUDIT GRR BM
SESB
Quality Council
Quality
WIT Secretariat CFT EWRM BMWA
Quality Secretariat
HQ
WG1 SC1 WC7 WC1
111
Operations Review – Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd
to enable them to facilitate respective work place. 118 its target of 90% following the
WIT projects. staff members were trained installation of the kiosks.
as SEMS auditors. The joint
concerted efforts of the Another major improvement is
SEMS Project Champion the replacement of 9.6kbps and
and Station Facilitators had 128kbps data-communication
resulted in the reduction of lines with streamyx 1.5Mbps
number of stations having at eleven SESB branch offices.
‘zero STAR’ rating from 4 to Beside improving the response
0 , and increased the number time, the Company was able
of stations having ‘2 STAR’ to realised an annual saving of
rating from 9 to 20. RM185,000 from the reduced
line rental charges.
112
Vegetation and Maintenance The Company fully subscribes Prospects
Management System developed to the concept of giving back
in-house was implemented t o t h e s o c i e t y. H e n c e t h e A comprehensive Power Plan
in March 2008. This system theme for SESB’s Corporate for SESB covering the three
facilitates better management of Social Responsibility is ”Caring core businesses of Generation,
the clearing of vegetation along For Future Development” Transmission and Distribution has
distribution power line network which focus on education, been drawn up to year 2025.
as part of the effort to reduce health, environment and rural
SAIDI. electrification. The forecast demand growth of
electricity is at 7.7% per annum
For FY2007/2008, SESB has up to year 2010. To support the
growing demand as well as to
Other Initiatives allocated RM50,000.00 for its
corporate social responsibility improve the reliability of supply,
Corporate Social Responsibility p ro g r a m m e s w h i c h c o v e r s various generation, transmission
As one of the largest GLC in Sabah contributions to charitable and distribution projects will be
SESB is mindful of the fact that cause and community welfare implemented.
its success is not only measured services including among
by the company’s performance others, donations to Thalesemia SESB has set a target of 90%
but also the extent to which it Association. electrification by 2010 to enable
has contributed to the well being more people in the state having
of the community, humanity, access to electricity in an effort
society and environment. Various to contribute towards the social
activities, functions and events and economic development of
had been organised to promote Sabah.
goodwill with the government and
community as well as to enhance
SESB’s corporate image.
113
Corporate Information
Board Of Directors
Tan Sri Leo Moggie Dato’ Puteh Rukiah Tan Sri Dato’ Lau Yin Pin
(Non-Independent binti Abd Majid @ Lau Yen Beng
Non-Executive Chairman) (Non-Independent (Senior Independent
Non-Executive Director) Non-Executive Director)
Dato’ Sri Che Khalib
bin Mohamad Noh Dato’ Mohammad Zainal Tan Sri Dato’ Hari Narayanan a/l
(President/Chief Executive Officer) bin Shaari Govindasamy
(Non-Independent (Non-Independent (Independent
Executive Director) Non-Executive Director) Non-Executive Director)
114
Dato’ Fuad bin Jaafar Datuk Zalekha binti Hassan
(Independent (Alternate Director to Dato’ Puteh
Non-Executive Director) Rukiah binti Abd Majid)
(Non-Independent
Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Siti Norma Non-Executive Director)
binti Yaakob (Resigned w.e.f. 28 January 2008)
(Independent
Non-Executive Director) Datuk Mohd Zaid bin Ibrahim
(Appointed w.e.f. (Non-Independent
12 September 2008) Non-Executive Director)
(Resigned w.e.f. 18 March 2008)
External Auditor
Messrs PricewaterhouseCoopers
(No. AF: 1146)
Level 10, 1 Sentral
Jalan Travers
Kuala Lumpur Sentral
P. O. Box 10192
50700 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
115
Group Corporate Structure
As at 9 October 2008
TNB ENGINEERING CORPORATION SDN. BHD. (100%) TNEC CONSTRUCTION SDN. BHD. (100%)
TNB COAL INTERNATIONAL LIMITED. (100%) NORTHERN UTILITY RESOURCES SDN. BHD.
(20%)
SABAH ELECTRICITY SDN. BHD. (75%)
ORION MISSION SDN. BHD. (100%) LAHAD DATU HOLDINGS SDN. BHD. (100%)
116
Associate /
Investment Companies
JIMAH ENERGY VENTURES HOLDING
SDN. BHD. (20%)
Trust Foundation
YAYASAN TENAGA NASIONAL
117
Organisational Structure
As at 9 October 2008
Company Secretary
President /
Chief Executive Officer
Senior Vice President
(Operations & Technical)
Vice President
Planning Division
Vice President
Human Resource Division
Vice President
Investment Management Division
118
Calendar Of Corporate Events
October 2007
broadcasted to all 25 TNB TNB – PERKEM
stations nationwide via Collaboration 25 October 2007
video conferencing. A ceremony was held to
mark the exchange of the FY2007 4th Quarter
Results Announcement
October 2007
Document of Collaboration
between TNB and PERKEM TNB announced its 4th
(Association of Malay quarter unaudited financial
Electrical and Mechanical results for FY2007.
Contractors). It was part
of the initiatives under the
TNB Bumiputera Vendor
Development Programme.
8 October 2007
119
Calendar Of Corporate Events
January 2008
T7 Final Review Session Ma’al Hijrah Celebrations
TNB conducted a Final TNB participated in the
Review Session to mark Ma’al Hijrah 1429H national
the successful completion level celebrations.
of its T7 Strategy by the
close of FY2007. T7 laid the
foundations for TNB to be
21 January 2008
among the best companies 2nd Surveillance Audit
in Malaysia by inculcating SIRIM QAS International
goal-oriented culture. Sdn. Bhd. conducted
the “Second Surveillance
Signing Ceremony of Audit” on TNB’s Process
December 2007
Agreement for TNB Standardisation and
REMACO & TurboCare SpA Improvement (PSI) to
TNB Repair and 13 December 2007 enhance customer service
Maintenance Sdn Bhd Annual General Meeting excellence.
(TNB REMACO) forged an TNB held its Annual
alliance with multinational
General Meeting for year
TurboCare SpA Group which
2007 during which thirteen
provided it with full access
resolutions were passed.
to technology and skill via
technology transfer. An
agreement to formalise the
arrangement was signed on
2 November 2007.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
120
15 April 2008
Visit by Yunan Power Grid
18 March 2008 Corporation (YPGC)
March 2008 The Yunan Power Grid
MoU between Felda &
Corporation (YPGC) visited
JPower
TNB Headquarters as
TNB signed a
part of its study tour to
Memorandum of
familiarise itself with the
Understanding with FELDA
regulatory regime governing
Palm Industries Sdn Bhd
the energy sector.
and Japan’s J-Power to
develop a biomass power
19 April 2008
April 2008
plant at Jengka, Pahang.
Long Service Award
TNB honoured 913 staff for
their long service at a Loyal
18 February 2008 Service Award Ceremony for
the Central Region.
February 2008
19 April 2008
121
Calendar Of Corporate Events
June 2008
of the Staff Union attended Eco Power to enable the
the National Level Workers latter to develop a 2 MW The BrandLaureate Societe
Day celebration organised power plant at Batu Pahat, Awards 2008
by the Ministry of Human Johor. TNB won The BrandLaureate
Resources at Stadium Putra Societe Award 2008 for
Bukit Jalil.
17 June 2008 excellence in Corporate
Social Responsibility.
27 May 2008 Electric Asia ’08
Expo & Forum
AKIPM for TNB
TNB emerged as the winner TNB showcased the
of The Prime Minister’s region’s premier electrical
Industry Excellence Award and power industry event
for 2007. It also won The named Electric Asia ’08
Quality Management Expo & Forum at the Kuala
Excellence Award Lumpur Convention Centre.
June 2008
122
29 July 2008 14 August 2008
August 2008
July 2008
31 August 2008
August 2008
28 August 2008
Merdeka Parade 2008
E-Application
TNB participated in the
TNB introduced online
Private Sector Category of
application for electricity
the Merdeka Parade ’08
supply by consumers. Using
held at Dataran Merdeka
web-based technology,
in conjuction with the
the system provides fast,
51st National Merdeka
convenient and easy
Celebrations.
monitoring of electricity
supply applications.
28 August 2008
123
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
124
Media Highlights
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
125
Statement Of Corporate Governance
A review of of the roles and functions The composition of the Board is further
in the President/CEO’s office to ensure strengthen with the appointment of
greater focus on strategic issues and Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Siti Norma Yaakob
to streamline our business activities who brought with her distinguished
w a s a p p ro v e d b y t h e B o a rd i n credentials as a former member of
December 2007. Three new Divisions the Malaysian judiciary. She is known
namely Corporate Affairs, Planning and as a person of high esteem and an
Procurement were established following acclaimed professional in her own right.
the review. The revised organisation Her knowledge and experience would
structure is indicated on page 118 of serve the Board well in assessing and
the Annual Report. evaluating legal perspectives before
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
126
and Risk Management Framework. An Investor Relations Policy was put in (A) THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Compliance with the LOA would promote place to ensure a transparent and timely
The Board is determined and
greater managerial discipline internally disclosure of the Company development,
committed with its responsibility in
as clear processes and procedures with to the stakeholders. This policy is
governing, guiding and monitoring
proper check and control are put in place intended to provide guiding principles for
the direction of the Company with the
that would in turn provide the confidence TNB in its quest to ensure that investor
eventual objective of enhancing long
in decisions made. relations functions, activities and efforts
term sustainable value creation aligned
are effective, timely and informative.
with the interests of shareholders, while
In line with the Company Long Term It also aims to build continuous, long-
taking into account the interests of other
Strategic Plan to expand its business term relationships and credibility with
stakeholders. The Board is committed
venture internationally to sustain growth, shareholders and potential investors
to ensure good corporate governance
a Policy and Strategy Document for based on trust, transparency and a
practices are well applied inline with
Investment was approved by the Board. greater understanding of the Company
the principal responsibilities outlined in
The policy provides the guideline on the and its businesses.
the Code and operates within a set of
focus area, country risks and the expected
governance as set out below:-
yield on the investment made. Compliance of these internal policies
and strategies will ensure due diligent
Composition of the Board
The Board also approved a Treasury and care are reinforced in the interest
The Board of Directors of TNB consists
Policy designed to take into consideration of the Company and its stakeholders.
of nine (9) members comprising one
the best, updated prudent practices This culture would in turn bring about
(1) Non-Executive Chair man, one
and to a certain extent practical good performance which is a strong
(1) Executive Director and seven (7)
necessity to suit the current market indicator for current and better long term
Non-Executive Directors. The diverse
volatility affecting treasury activities of performance and risk management by
background of members drawn from
the Company. The policy takes into the Company.
such varied fields as finance, law,
consideration the requirements of the
engineering, management and public
new accounting standard applicable to To further strengthen the application of
administration provide considerable
the financial instruments. The Treasury the existing Whistle Blowing activities in
depth and wisdom of knowledge,
Policy is structured with the following the Company, a toll free 1-800-888-862
expertise and experience to the Board
sub-policies namely: Whistle Blowing Implementation System
of TNB. A brief profile of each Director
Credit Risk Policy was officially launched on 14 August 2008.
is set out on pages 154 to 159 of this
Liquidating Risk Policy Alternatively, feedback and complaints
Annual Report.
Interest Rate Risk Policy from the public can also be channelled
Foreign Exchange Risk Policy, to http//wbis.hq.tnb.com.my.
Process of Appointment to the Board
Investment Policy, Appointment to the Board of TNB is
Permitted Instrument, In the period under review, the Company
made either by the Special Shareholder
Monitoring Policy of TNB Retirement has won recognition and accolades from
pursuant to Article 5(2) of the Company’s
various organisations and professional
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
127
Statement Of Corporate Governance
A diagram outlining the main Committees involved in the decision making process is set out below:-
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Board Nomination & Board Finance & Group Risk Management Fuel Procurement
Remuneration Committee Investment Committee Committee Executive Committee
128
The composition of the Board Committees and the attendance of Members at the The key terms of reference of the Board
meetings of the Board Committees are listed as follows:- Committees are as follows:-
Tan Sri Dato’ Hari Narayanan a/l Govindasamy 16/17 Board Tender Committee
To ensure the implementation of
Dato’ Haji Zainal Abidin bin Putih 15/17 and compliance with the TNB
Procurement Policy and Procedures
and will make the necessary
Board Tender Committee recommendations (if any) to the
Directors Meeting Attendance Board. The Committee shall ensure
TNB practices Best Value with
Dato’ Puteh Rukiah binti Abd Majid 13/13 integrity and accountability;
Dato’ Mohammad Zainal bin Shaari 11/13 To ensure TNB complies with the
applicable laws, regulations, rules
Tan Sri Dato’ Lau Yin Pin @ Lau Yen Beng 13/13
and guidelines to achieve Best
Dato’ Fuad bin Jaafar 13/13 Business Practices in its procurement
of equipment, materials, works or
services;
Board Nomination and Remuneration Committee The Board Tender Committee meets
Directors Meeting Attendance at least once a month;
129
Statement Of Corporate Governance
Board Finance and Investment Committee All Directors have the right and duty to
To establish a framework of policies from which the Committee shall make its make further enquiries when necessary.
recommendation to the Board in relation to the management of the Company’s In most instances, Senior Management
financial and investment activities. of the Company as well as external
advisors are invited to be in attendance
The Board Finance and Investment Committee meets as and when required and at Board Meetings to provide insight
at least twice a year. and to furnish clarification on issues that
may be raised by the Board. Whether
as a full board or in their individual
The Board Meetings capacities, Directors are also at liberty
to take independent professional advice
The Board meetings are scheduled in advance and during the Financial Year ended 31
on any matter connected with the
August 2008, fifteen (15) Board Meetings were convened to deliberate and consider
discharge of their responsibilities as they
a variety of significant matters including review on business plan, budget, quarterly
may deem necessary and appropriate.
financial results, risk assessment, key performance indicators of the Senior Management,
debt restructuring and other corporate proposals such as foreign investment exercise,
The Board is also notified of any
overall performance of the Company and the subsidiary companies as well as other
disclosures/announcements made to
related business matters that require their deliberation and due approval.
Bursa Malaysia.
Minutes of proceedings and resolutions passed at each Board and Board Committees
Meetings are kept in the statutory register at the registered office of the Company.
In the event of potential conflict of interest, the Director in such position will make Board Effectiveness
declaration to that effect as soon as practicable. The Director concerned will then The present composition, size, modus
abstain from any decision-making process in which he/she has interest in. operandi, strength of relationship
with the Management and functional
Attendance Details of Board Members Board Committees contribute to an
effective Board. This is also in line
Directors Meeting Attendance
with the principle and best practices
Tan Sri Leo Moggie (Chairman) 15/15 of the Malaysian Code of Corporate
Governance (revised 2007). Apart from
Dato’ Sri Che Khalib bin Mohamad Noh 15/15 the convening of Board Meeting on
Dato’ Puteh Rukiah binti Abd Majid 14/15 a frequent basis, deliberation and
discussion at a Board Meeting is
Dato’ Mohammad Zainal bin Shaari 12/15 conducted in a comprehensive and in
depth manner before arriving at any
Tan Sri Dato’ Lau Yin Pin @ Lau Yen Beng 15/15
decision, as recommended by the
Tan Sri Dato’ Hari Narayanan a/l Govindasamy 15/15 Management.
Dato’ Zainal Abidin bin Putih 15/15 The internal Board and Management
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
131
Statement Of Corporate Governance
(b) The remuneration package of Non-Executive Directors comprises of the following elements:-
(i) Fees
The Directors are paid fixed monthly fees and meeting allowance for each Board and Board Committee meeting
attended during the year. Such fees are tabled to the shareholders of the Company for approval.
(ii) Benefits-in-kind
Other benefits in the form of coverage on electricity bills and reimbursement are made available as appropriate.
Executive Directors
Dato’ Sri Che Khalib bin Mohamad Noh (i) 600,000.00 — — 354,000.00 *97,344.00 1,170,864.00
(ii) 119,520.00
719,520.00
Non-Executive Directors
Tan Sri Leo Moggie — 132,000.00 34,000.00 — 22,097.40 188,097.40
Dato’ Puteh Rukiah binti Abd Majid — 76,000.00 31,200.00 — 10,000.00 117,200.00
Dato’ Mohammad Zainal bin Shaari — **73,000.00 **44,175.00 — 35,821.18 152,996.18
Tan Sri Dato’ Lau Yin Pin — 76,000.00 51,050.00 — 4,212.80 131,262.80
@ Lau Yen Beng
Tan Sri Dato’ Hari Narayanan a/l — 76,000.00 36,700.00 — 14,775.78 127,475.78
Govindasamy
Dato’ Zainal Abidin bin Putih — 76,000.00 38,750.00 — 13,879.20 128,629.20
Dato’ Fuad bin Jaafar — 71,096.00 30,600.00 — 17,602.94 119,298.94
Datuk Zalekha binti Hassan (Alternate — — 500.00 — 6,738.41 7,238.41
Director, resigned w.e.f. 28 Jan 2008)
Datuk Mohd Zaid bin Ibrahim — 48,742.00 13,850.00 — 34,048.33 96,640.33
(resigned w.e.f. 18 March 2008)
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
* This sum consists of RM42,000.00 for car allowance and RM55,344.00 for flexible benefits
** Paid directly to Khazanah Nasional Berhad
(B) SHAREHOLDERS
TNB is committed to maintain a constructive relationship with its shareholders, pursuing its on-going commitment to sustain
the highest standards of corporate governance practices throughout the Group with full appreciation of its impact on long-term
corporate performance and optimal shareholder value.
132
Whilst various channels of During the year under review, the unit I n t h e F i n a n c i a l Ye a r, T N B h a d
communication are optimised to had organised and participated in approximately 68 meetings with equity
provide shareholders and investors with various local and international events research analysts, fund managers and
a balanced and comprehensive view which include:- investors who had requested to meet
of the Group’s performance and the up with company officials (excluding
Conferences and forums organized
issues faced by the Group in light of investors that were seen at conferences,
by research houses including CLSA,
the challenging environment, the role road shows and quarterly financial
Credit Suisse First Boston, JP Morgan,
of investor relations is entrenched as results presentations).
Morgan Stanley and Deutsche Bank.
the communications platform between
In the Financial Year TNB attended 5
the Group and the investor at large.
of these conferences/forums.
In this regard, the Investor Relations Constructive Use of the Annual
& Management Reporting Unit Announcement of quarterly financial General Meeting
(“IRMU”), a dedicated unit under the results to the financial community
Finance Division has been entrusted and the media. During these The Annual General Meeting (AGM) is
with the responsibility of coordinating events, teleconferencing facility was the principal avenue for shareholders to
and responding to all queries and arranged to enable the investment communicate and engage in dialogue
information raised by shareholders, communities at major financial with the Board and Management of
research analysts and investors. An centers worldwide to listen as well TNB. The highlights of the Company
equal level of importance is placed as participate in the briefings. On technical and financial performance
on the need for investor relations to average, some 87 participants from which is made via visual presentation is
channel the views of the investment the financial community and the made by the Chairman and President/
community back to Management and media attended or took part in the Chief Executive Officer at the AGM.
the Board of Directors. teleconferencing during the quarterly The turnout of shareholders at general
presentations in the Financial Year. meetings of TNB has always been
The Annual Investor Relations high. A total of 3835 shareholders and
Programme which serves to provide The Invest Malaysia exhibition proxies attended the Seventeenth AGM
the Management opportunities and organised by Bursa Malaysia. held in 2007.
platforms to interact with investors, One-on-one and group meetings with
analysts as well as the media. The Constructive dialogue between the Board
equity and fixed income investors
events and activities scheduled in the and the shareholders are encouraged
and analysts. These meetings have
Programme include:- whereby at the AGM, shareholders are
proven to be the most effective
given the opportunity to raise question
Quarterly results announcement medium to enhance investors’
on issues pertaining to the Company’s
Analyst briefing/conference call understanding and perception of
Financial and Operational performance.
Full year results announcement the Group. In the Financial Year,
The shareholders can exercise their voting
Analyst briefing/conference call TNB attended a meeting to meet
rights and the meeting is convened in
Dividend payment the local fund managers organised
strict compliance with the laws and
Preparation and release of Annual by CIMB.
procedures of general meeting. Separate
Report Aside from the conferences and resolutions are proposed for separate
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Annual General Meeting meetings attended outside of motions and the Chairman will declare
Site visits TNB premises, Management and the outcome of each resolution after
Investor Day/Domestic road-shows IR frequently played host to local proposal and secondment are done by
International road-shows and international fund managers the shareholders. Each item of ordinary
Major international broker conferences and investors who requested for and special business in the notice of the
meetings at TNB offices. During general meeting would be accompanied
The programme is reviewed and updated the year under review, TNB held by a full explanation of the effects of the
periodically as and when invitations for approximately 120 of such meetings proposed resolution. Shareholders are also
IR events are received. (excluding Quarterly announcement given the opportunity to put forward their
of financial results). questions on the proposed resolutions and
on the Group’s operations. The Chairman
will provide sufficient time for shareholders’
questions on matters pertaining to the
Company’s performance and would seek
to explain to the shareholders with regard
to their concern.
133
Statement Of Corporate Governance
Immediately after the AGM, the (C) ACCOUNTABILITY AND AUDIT Internal Control
Chairman and the President/Chief
Executive Officer will address all issues Financial Reporting The Board acknowledges that they are
raised by the press and analysts through responsible for maintaining a sound
The Directors are responsible for ensuring system of internal control to safeguard
a press conference and an analyst that financial statements are drawn up
briefing during which all stakeholders shareholders’ investment and the
in accordance with the requirements of company’s assets as required by the
are provided with the latest update on the Companies Act 1965 and in line
the Company. Code. TNB adheres to Bursa Malaysia
with approved accounting standards in guidelines on the Statement on Internal
Malaysia so as to present an objective Control: Guidance for Directors of Public
and understandable assessment of the Listed Companies, as guidance for
Continuing Disclosure of Material Group’s financial position and prospects. compliance with these requirements.
Information TNB publishes quarterly financial reports
so that its shareholders can monitor the On 28 August and 16 October 2008,
TNB firmly observed the continuing
Company’s financial position regularly. the Board Audit Committee met with
disclosure obligation imposed upon a
In this Annual Report, an assessment is the External Auditors without the
listed issuer by Bursa Malaysia. The
provided in the Directors’ Report of the presence of the Executive Director
Company has in place Corporate
Audited Financial Statements. and the Management to discuss on
Disclosure Policy and Procedures since
1994, which provides for adoption of the adequacy of the system of internal
On behalf of the Board, the Board control to ensure efficient and effective
Best Practices in Corporate Disclosure
Audit Committee (BAC) scrutinises the operation and compliance with statutory
laid down by Bursa Malaysia in July
financial, statutory compliance aspects re q u i re m e n t s a n d t h e C o m p a n y
2004. As required under the said
of the Audited Financial Statements guideline, policies and procedures.
Best Practice, the Company Secretary
and Companies policies and procedures
is identified as “Corporate Disclosure
prior to full deliberation at the Board Information on the Group’s internal
Manager” within the context of the
level. The Board ensures the integrity control is presented in the Statement of
aforementioned Best Practice.
of the Company’s financial reporting Internal Control, pursuant to paragraph
and fully recognise that accountability 15.27(b) of the Bursa Malaysia Listing
Timely and accurate disclosure is made
in financial disclosure form an integral Requirements is set out in pages 142
on all the material information and
part of good corporate governance to 144.
throughout the Financial Year under
practices.
review, the material information and
the material development thereof
on acquisition, disposal, divestment, RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT IN
Relationship with the Auditors
issuance of notes, proposed financing RESPECT OF THE FINANCIAL
facility, conversion of bonds, related The Board has, through the BAC, YEAR UNDER REVIEW
party transaction, employee share established a formal, transparent and (Pursuant to paragraph 15.27(a) of the
option scheme, notice of book closure, appropriate relationship with the Group’s Bursa Malaysia Listing Requirements)
change in boardroom are among the Auditors, both external and internal. A
material information released to Bursa
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
report by the Board Audit Committee The Board is fully accountable to ensure
Malaysia via Bursa Malaysia Link. is provided in page 145 and its Terms that the financial statements are prepared
of Reference is provided on pages 148 in accordance with the Companies Act
to 151. 1965 and the applicable approved
Confidentiality of Information accounting standards set by Malaysian
The Board Audit Committee meets Accounting Standards Board so as to
In the conduct of briefings or
regularly with the external and internal present a true and fair view, balanced
presentations, the Company takes care to
auditors to discuss and review the audit and understandable assessment of the
ensure that any information regarded as
plan, quarterly financial results, annual Group’s financial position and prospects.
undisclosed material information about
financial statements, their audit findings In this Annual Report, an assessment is
the company and its operations will not
and made recommendations for the provided in the Directors’ Report of the
be given to any single shareholder or
Boards approval. Audited Accounts.
shareholder group.
The new ordinary shares issued during the financial year ranked pari passu in all respects with the existing ordinary shares
of the Company.
The Company has been granted an exemption by the Companies Commission of Malaysia via a letter dated 18 September
2008 from having to disclose in this Report the name of the persons to whom options have been granted during the
year and details of their holdings pursuant to section 169(11) of the Companies Act, 1965 except for information on
employees who were granted options representing 450,000 ordinary shares and above. Details are as set out in page
177 of the Directors Report.
(5) Sanctions/Penalties
There were no sanctions and/or penalties imposed on the Company and its subsidiaries, Directors or Management by the
relevant regulatory bodies during the Financial Year ended 31 August 2008. [ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
* PKR 1 = RM0.04587
135
Statement Of Corporate Governance
Persons
Connected Aggregate Value
to Major (RM) of the
Transacting Shareholder Interested Nature of Transaction during
Company in (Related Parties Major Recurrent the validity of the
TNB Group Involved) Shareholder Nature of Relationship Transactions Mandate
Bangsar Energy Telekom Khazanah Khazanah Nasional Berhad Capacity and 10,848,501.00
System Sdn. Malaysia Berhad Nasional being a Major Shareholder Energy Services
Bhd. Berhad of TNB has 41.78% interest
in Telekom Malaysia
Berhad, making the latter
person connected to the
Major Shareholder.
136
SHAREHOLDERS’ MANDATE FOR RRPT OF REVENUE OR TRADING NATURE
Persons
Connected to a Aggregate Value
Director/Major (RM) of the
Transacting Shareholder Interested Nature of Transaction during
Company in (Related Parties Major Recurrent the validity of the
TNB Group Involved) Shareholder Nature of Relationship Transactions Mandate
TNB Messrs. Zaid Datuk Mohd Datuk Mohd Zaid bin Provision of 647,758.19
Ibrahim & Co. Zaid bin Ibrahim being a Director Legal and
Ibrahim of TNB who is also the Consultancy
Chairman and Majority Services
Shareholder of Messrs. Zaid
Ibrahim & Co., making the
latter person connected to
a Director.
Note: The abovementioned transactions does not equal or exceed the applicable prescribed threshold pursuant to Paragraph 2.1 of Practice Note 12/2001
of the Listing Requirements.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
The Board is pleased to report to shareholders that the Company has applied the principles of corporate governance and is
in compliance with Part 1 of the Code. Further to that, the Board remains committed to attain the highest possible standard
of corporate governance through continuous adoption of best practices as recommended in Part 2 of the Code.
Signed on behalf of the Board of Directors in accordance with their resolution dated 16 October 2008.
1. Overview
Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) recognises that the management of principal 2.1 Risk Management Policy
risks plays an important and integral part of the Group’s daily operations The TNB EWRM Policy formulated
and the effective identification and management of such risks will positively in 2004 was reviewed during the
affect the achievement of the Group’s business and strategic objectives. The year to enhance the effectiveness
on-going implementation of an Enterprise-Wide Risk Management (EWRM) of the framework. The second
framework which was introduced since 2003 would ensure that the major areas edition was published in October
of risks are identified, managed and controlled or mitigated effectively. 2007. Further improvements were
subsequently made in the following
The EWRM framework provides for a uniform application of risk management areas:
across the Group through standardised risk management processes and
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
138
Figure 1
Enterprise Wide Risk Management (EWRM) Framework
2.2 Risk Management Structure
The EWRM requires that a risk itoring and review
Mon
management structure be embedded
in the framework to ensure that roles,
responsibilities and accountabilities Risk Policy and
for managing risk are clearly Guidelines
defined and communicated. The
risk management structure (Figure 2)
comprises various levels of authority Group Wide Risk Risk Treatment
in the Group namely the Board of Assessment Process Options
Directors, Board Audit Committee
(BAC), Group Risk Management Business review
Committee (GRMC) chaired by the
President/Chief Executive Officer,
Risk Identification
Group Risk Management Working
Committee (GRMWC) chaired by
Controls TNB Risk
the Chief Financial Officer/Senior – Terminate
Information Mitigation
Vice President (Finance), Enterprise- – Reduce
System plans
Wide Risk Management (EWRM) Risk rating (TRIS) – Accept
Department, Group Internal Audit – Pass on
(GIA) and TNB Operating Divisions.
Risk treatment
139
Enterprise Wide Risk Management
3. Major Initiatives/Achievements
3.1 Risk Assessment Process
The Group Wide Risk Assessment (GWRA) Process was reviewed and streamlined to standardise the risk management
methodology in the Group. It focuses on identification, assessment, control and monitoring of risks. The EWRM
Department was also involved in conducting due diligence for TNB major projects and overseas ventures in
collaboration with external risk advisors.
Ongoing activities to mitigate legal risks involved assessment of TNB contract management and the standardisation of
major contracts as well as establishing a TNB Confidentiality Policy. In addition, audits on fraud policy and ethics were
included in the audit plan for the year under review and a fraud database is being compiled. In the case of risk of
accidents, data collation and reconciliation of statistics and insurance details are ongoing and road shows are organised
to educate TNB staff with regards to this risk and the necessary mitigating action that need to be taken.
Two Risk Management Forums were organised as a platform to communicate decisions made by the GRMWC, GRMC
and BAC to the Risk Managers, Risk Coordinators and senior management. During the forums, risk management
issues identified in the course of risk-based audits conducted by the Group Internal Audit were highlighted. Also
discussed was the success of using the EWRM framework to turnaround the performance of a subsidiary.
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
As part of continuous improvement to the system, further enhancements to TRIS had been identified and developed.
In addition, regular training on TRIS were conducted throughout the year for newly appointed Risk Managers, Risk
Coordinators and Risk Owners or as refresher courses for those already in service.
140
3.7 Project Risk Assessment Process
The preliminary methodology for a Project Risk Assessment Process was approved by GRMWC and GRMC. The
process serves as a risk assessment tool to identify, analyse and manage risks associated with a project throughout
its lifecycle. Further enhancement to the methodology and the development of a project risk assessment system is
planned for the next financial year.
In addition, the CERP document for System-Related Emergencies was printed and distributed to the relevant personnel
within TNB. Awareness training sessions were carried out across the Group in collaboration with the System Operations
Department of the Transmission Division to enhance the understanding of the various elements of the CERP, to ensure
preparedness for any emergency situation and to give emphasis on the necessary collaboration between the core
divisions.
The CERP Steering Committee had reviewed the TNB CERP document for Non-System Related emergencies such as
floods and pandemics. The document is scheduled for approval and implementation in the next financial year.
As a company that provides essential services crucial to national security, TNB continues to collaborate with external
parties and various government agencies in particular the National Security Council, the Chief Government Security
Officer, the Prime Minister’s Department and the Ministry of Health. TNB had also participated in the various drills on
pandemic and cyber threats organised by the relevant government agencies.
Central to the success of risk management is the ability to successfully embed risk management culture and processes
within the Group. Risk management initiatives within TNB will continue to be strengthened to ensure that TNB is able
to respond effectively to the continuing changing business environment while achieving its objectives to protect and
enhance stakeholders’ value.
141
Statement Of Internal Control
Board Responsibility
The Board of Directors (Board) is responsible for Tenaga Nasional
Berhad’s Group (the Group) system of internal control. The system
is designed to meet the Group’s business objectives and safeguard
shareholders’ investments, the interest of customers, regulators and
employees, and the Group’s assets. The internal control system covers
the areas of risk management, finance, operations, management
information systems and compliance with the relevant laws and
regulations. The system provides a reasonable but not an absolute
assurance against material misstatement, loss or fraud.
The Board has established a framework on the operating entities to provide Launching of a Whistle Blowing
for identifying, evaluating and assurance on the adequacy and hotline to complement the existing
managing the significant risks faced effectiveness of the system in mitigating Whistle Blowing Procedures to
by the Group. The framework and risk and controlling the risks faced by the provide a more convenient feedback
management processes are reviewed at Group. The processes in place enable mechanism, thus encouraging higher
regular intervals by the Board and is the system to be refined and enhanced transparency and improvement in
in accordance with the Statement on to meet the challenges and needs the governance process.
Internal control: Guidance for Directors of the Group. During the year, the
Roadshows on the Group’s Code
of Public Listed Companies. following initiatives were undertaken to
of Ethics and the importance of
enhance risk management processes in
integrity. The Anti Corruption
the Group:
Agency (ACA) was invited to speak
Risk Management Revision of the Procurement Policies to employees on the importance of
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
An Enterprise Wide Risk Management & Procedures and EWRM Policies & cultivating, instilling and maintaining
(EWRM) System has been approved Procedures to improve procurement integrity and good ethical practices
by the Board and implemented by the and risk management processes, throughout the organisation.
Group to identify, assess, treat, report and enhance accountability and
Development and implementation of
and monitor strategic and operational responsibility.
a training module on the effects of
risks faced by the Group. The Board
Development and implementation fraud, the laws and enforcement on
Audit Committee (BAC) reviews the
of a risk management module as fraud, and fraud prevention in the
effectiveness of the system and the
part of a training programme to organisation for new management
reports arising from risk management
increase employees’ risk awareness trainees.
activities undertaken during the year.
and assist them to identify, assess,
The BAC is assisted by the Group Fraud and Ethics Review, comprising
treat and monitor risks within their
Risk Management Committee, Chief a Fraud and Ethics Survey, Fraud
scope of work.
Risk Officer, EWRM Department and Data Analysis and review of the
operations staff in the risk management Development and approval of the system for managing fraud.
processes. Review of the EWRM systems Anti Fraud Policy.
Implementation of Project Risk
is undertaken by Group Internal Audit
Assessment for projects worth
RM100 million and above.
142
Control Structures Organisation Structure by the Group are:
The Board has established control The Board has implemented a Enterprise Resource Management
structures and is committed to evaluate, divisional structure for the Group. Clear System (ERMS)
enhance and maintain them to ensure lines of authority, responsibility and e-Customer Information & Billing
effective strategic and operational accountability have been established System (e-CIBS)
control over the Group’s business to enable the Group’s vision, mission, Enterprise Human Resource
operations. The following key internal strategies and operational objectives Management System (EHRMS)
control structures are in place to assist to be achieved. The divisional structure Supervisory Control and Data
the Board to maintain a proper control enhances the ability of each division to Acquisition System (SCADA)
environment: focus on their assigned core or support Remote Metering System (RMR)
functions within the Group. Electronic Banking Facilities
Board and Management Committees Tenaga Risk Information System
In its efforts to promote corporate The Board also reviews and refines the (TRIS)
governance, transparency and effectiveness of the Group’s organisation Electronic Document Management
accountability, the Board has set up and control structures to enhance the System (EDMS)
Board and Management Committees Group’s ability to achieve their strategic Distribution Network Information
to assist them to accomplish the vision, and operational objectives and manage Management (DNIM)
mission, strategies and objectives set challenges in its operating environment.
for the Group. The Committees oversee During the year, three new Divisions
the areas assigned to them under their were formed, being the Corporate Group Policies & Procedures
Terms of Reference. The Committees Affairs, Planning and Group Procurement
The Board has approved policies and
play an important role to direct, Divisions. The regulatory relations, legal,
procedures to govern the financial and
monitor and ensure that the plans and corporate communications and company
operational functions, and ethics of the
operations are in accordance with the secretarial functions were consolidated
Group. The objectives of the policies and
Group’s approved long term and short into the Corporate Affairs Division. The
procedures are to ensure that ethics, and
term business plans, and the policies of planning function for power systems,
internal control principles and mechanisms
the Group. The Committees are: energy procurement and strategies were
are embedded in operations. This enables
grouped in the Planning Division. The
the Group to respond quickly to evolving
Board Committees procurement function was upgraded
risks and immediately report on any
Audit Committee from a department to a division to
significant control failure. The policies
Tender Committee oversee the strategic procurement
and procedures are also reviewed on a
Disciplinary Committee matters of the Group. The formation
regular basis to ensure its relevance and
Nomination & Remuneration of the Divisions was to strengthen the
effectiveness. Amongst others, the policies
Committee functions as well as enhance strategic
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Special Engagement Against Strategies identified in the Strategic affecting the Group. BAC meetings are
Losses Team & Revenue Plan, 5 Year Business Plans, Annual held regularly to deliberate audit findings,
Maximisation Unit Operation Plans and KPIs are reviewed, management response, corrective actions,
approved and monitored by the Board and monitoring of actions taken by
Both the above entities assist the Group and management. Revisions are made management for areas with significant or
in the detection and curbing of theft of based on changes in business and high risks. GIA scope of coverage includes
electricity as well as improve billing operating environments. Feedback from generation, transmission, distribution,
and collection where theft has been the Board during breakout sessions with projects, procurement, engineering,
identified. them is used to develop the Five Year finance, human resources, corporate
and Annual Operating Plans. services, information and communication
technology, investment in subsidiaries,
MONITORING & REVIEW The Five Year Business Plan and Annual risk management and compliance.
Operating Plan also contain the budget
Board Interactions With of the Group, to enable the Group GIA has an independent status in
Management via Breakout to direct its resources towards the the Group and reports functionally to
Sessions achievement of its financial objectives. the Board through the Board Audit
The Board interacts actively with The budget is monitored at regular Committee. GIA annual audit plans,
management during breakout sessions intervals by management to ensure budgets, competency and resources are
to discuss and review the plans, effective budget utilisation. reviewed and approved by the Board
strategies, performance and risks faced Audit Committee. This is to enable
by the Group. During the year, two review on the adequacy of coverage,
Board Breakout sessions were held. Financial and Operational Review resources available and coverage of
These sessions provide a monitoring significant and high risk areas. The review
The Board Audit Committee (BAC) also helps to confirm the audits that are
and review mechanism to enhance reviews the Group’s quarterly financial
the Board’s effectiveness and enables to be co-sourced and outsourced to
performance together with management, facilitate transfer of knowledge from
management to seek mandates to and these are subsequently reported to
address the risks faced in its internal consultants and coverage by external
the Board. The quarterly reviews enable party in areas where technical skills are
and external environment. An inaugural the BAC to deliberate and assess the
Board Audit Committee Breakout not available in GIA.
Group’s financial results and operational
session with Senior Management was performance. Monthly management
also held during the year to promote accounts which serve as a monitoring
awareness and importance of improving Conclusion
tool, are also circulated to the Board
and maintaining strong internal controls and key management staff to provide For the financial year under review,
in the Group. information on key financial results, some weaknesses in internal control
operational performance indicators, were detected. However, after due
budget comparisons to enable them and careful inquiry and based on the
Business Planning & Budgeting to monitor and contribute towards information and assurance provided,
improving performance. the Board is satisfied that there were
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
144
Board Audit Committee Report
Reference which is they attended during the financial year were as follows:
Non-Executive
3. Dato’ Zainal Abidin bin Putih Yes 15/17
Director
145
Board Audit Committee Report
146
Group Internal Audit The reports issued provide independent
and objective assessment of the
The internal audit function of the Group following:
is carried out by the GIA Department.
GIA is independent and reports directly Existence, effectiveness and
to the BAC. adequacy of the internal control
systems to manage operations and
GIA provides independent, objective safeguard the Group’s assets.
assurance on areas of operations
Adequacy and effectiveness of the risk
reviewed, and advice on best practices
management operations, governance
that will improve and add value to the
and compliance functions to manage
Group.
and anticipate potential risks over
key business processes.
A systematic and disciplined approach
is adopted to evaluate adequacy and
The internal audit reports arising from the
effectiveness of the risk management,
assignments were issued to management
financial, operational, compliance and
for their response, corrective actions
governance processes. Internal audit
and provision of deadlines to complete
activities are aligned to the strategic
the relevant preventive and corrective
plan/objectives of the company. A
actions. The reports were subsequently
risk-based methodology is adopted
tabled to the BAC for their deliberation.
to ensure that the relevant controls
Management staff was present during
addressing risks are reviewed regularly.
the deliberation of the reports to ensure
that they undertake the responsibility of
During the financial year, a total of 68
carrying out preventive and corrective
reports covering 158 assignments were
actions on the weaknesses reported.
issued. The areas of coverage includes
generation, transmission, distribution,
procurement, engineering, projects,
finance, corporate governance, fraud
& ethics, human resource, logistics,
information and communication
technology, investments in subsidiaries
TAN SRI DATO’ LAU YIN PIN @
and risk management.
LAU YEN BENG
Chairman
Board Audit Committee
Tenaga Nasional Berhad
(Senior Independent
[ Tenaga Nasional Berhad ] [ Annual Report 2008 ]
Non-Executive Director)
147
Terms Of Reference Of The Board Audit Committee
6.6 approve the appointment of the Head of Internal 7.2.3 To deliberate on the key risk issues
Audit; highlighted by Group Risk Management
Committee in their reports to BAC.
6.7 engage independent advisers and to secure the
attendance of outsiders with relevant experience 7.3 Internal Control
and expertise if it considers this necessary; and 7.3.1 To assess the quality and effectiveness of
the systems of internal control and the
6.8 to review the adequacy of the structure and Terms
efficiency of the Group’s operations.
of Reference of the Board Committees, including
the BAC. 7.3.2 To review the findings on internal control in
the Group by internal and external auditors.
7.3.3 To review and approve the Statement on
Internal Control for the Annual Report
as required under Bursa Malaysia Listing
Requirements.
149
Terms Of Reference Of The Board Audit Committee
150
8.4 No business shall be transacted at any meeting 9.4 The minutes of each meeting shall be entered into
of the Committee unless a quorum is present. the minutes book kept at the registered office of
The quorum for each meeting shall be three (3) the Company under the custody of the Company
members. Secretary. The minutes shall be available for
inspection by the members of the Board, external
8.5 The Chairman of the Committee shall chair
auditors, internal auditors, and other persons
the Committee meetings and in his absence,
deemed appropriate by the Company Secretary.
the members present shall elect one amongst
themselves to be the Chairman of the meeting.
8.6 In appropriate circumstances, the Committee may 10. Disclosure
deal with matters by way of circular reports and 10.1 The Committee shall assist the Board in making
resolution in lieu of convening a formal meeting. disclosures concerning the activities of the
8.7 Officers of the Group or others as necessary Committee, in the Report of the Board Audit
may be invited to attend meetings where the Committee, to be issued in the Annual Report.
Committee considers their presence necessary. 10.2 The Board requires all Directors to submit a
8.8 All recommendations of the Committee shall be Disclosure of Interest to avoid any conflict
submitted to the Board for approval. between their personal interests and the interests
of the Company. In the event of a conflict, either
8.9 A Committee member shall excuse himself/ perceived or actual, this Disclosure of Interest shall
herself from the meeting during discussions or be submitted to the Chairman of the Committee
deliberations of any matter which gives rise to an with a copy to the Company Secretary.
actual or perceived conflict of interest situation
for the member. Where this causes insufficient
Directors to make up a quorum, the Committee 11. Revision Of The Terms Of Reference
has the right to appoint another Director(s), which
11.1 Any revision or amendment to the Terms of
meets the membership criteria.
Reference, as proposed by the Committee or any
8.10 The Committee, through its Chairman, shall report third party, shall be presented to the Board for its
to the Board after each meeting. approval.
8.11 Subject to the provisions of this Terms of Reference 11.2 Upon the Board’s approval, the said revision
and Memorandum and Articles of Association or amendment shall form part of this Terms of
of TNB, the Committee shall establish its own Reference and this Terms of Reference shall be
procedures for meetings. considered duly revised or amended.
151