Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Maxwell’s Equations
r · E = 4pr, (2.1)
1 4p
r⇥B ∂t E = J, (2.2)
c c
r · B = 0, (2.3)
1
r ⇥ E + ∂t B = 0. (2.4)
c
It is known fact that for E and B given in terms of electromagnetic poten-
tials the sourceless Maxwell’s equations (2.3) and (2.4) have the form
of identities. The vector potential A is a vector field such that magnetic
field is obtained as B := r ⇥ A. The equation (2.3) is an identity,1 1
Independently on particular form of A.
r · (r ⇥ A) ⌘ 0, because it contains antisymmetric combinations of
symmetric second-order partial derivatives. The Faraday’s law (2.4) can
be cast in the form ✓ ◆
1
r ⇥ E + ∂t A = 0.
c
This equation reduces to identity when expression E + 1c ∂t A is propor-
tional to the gradient of certain function j(t, x). In order to establish the
correspondence with electrostatic potential we choose the minus sign in
54 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
E ! Ei , B ! Bi , A ! Ai .
1 ∂
∂0 : =
c ∂t
The set of derivatives of any function f ( x0 , x) i.e. (∂0 f , ∂1 f , ∂2 f , ∂3 f )
transform as covariant components of a four-vector i.e.
∂0µ f = Lµ n ∂n f .
Taking into account that function f is arbitrary we can write the last
formula in the form ∂0µ = Lµ n ∂n .
We shall assume that the sequence of four elements j and A1 , A2 , A3
transform as contravariant components of a four-vector. Thus, we
denote
A µ ! ( A0 , A i ) where A0 ⌘ j.
In order to justify this assumption we note that Maxwell’s equations
imply that the electromagnetic potentials must obey equations
4p 4p i
(∂20 r2 ) j = (cr), (∂20 r2 ) A i = J (2.9)
c c
where the Lorenz gauge condition4 ∂t j + ∂i Ai = 0 has been imposed.5 4
Ludvig Valentin Lorenz 1829 - 1891. In
Since the d’Alembert operator ∂20 r2 is Lorentz invariant and the literature frequently confused with
Hendrik Antoon Lorentz.
the components (cr, J i ) ! J µ transform as contravariant components 5
If the original potentials j0 and A0i give
of the four-current then the sequence ( j, Ai ) must also transform as ∂t j0 + ∂i A0i = f (t, xi ) then the function
c(t, xi ) which is a solution of equation
contravariant components of a four vector. Note, that the Lorenz (∂20 r2 )c(t, xi ) = f (t, xi ) allows to ob-
condition is invariant under Lorentz transformations when A0µ = tain new set of potentials j and Ai that al-
µ
L n An . ready satisfy the Lorenz condition. Note
that Lorenz condition do not fixes the po-
The covariant components Aµ ! ( A0 , Ai ) can be obtained from tentials completely. New potentials has
contravariant ones by contraction with components of the metric tensor still gauge freedom given by functions c
which are solutions of the wave equation
Aµ = hµn An . Note, that expression Ai appears in two different contexts. (∂20 r2 )c(t, xi ) = 0.
where
Fµn := ∂µ An ∂n Aµ . (2.12)
In order get the second relation (2.13) we contract both sides of (2.11)
with the Levi-Civita symbol. It gives
1 1 1
eabi Bi = eabi eijk Fjk = (daj dbk dak dbj ) Fjk = (F Fba ) = Fab .
2 2 2 ab
Covariant components of the electromagnetic field tensor can be identi-
fied with the following matrix
0 1
0 E1 E2 E3
B E1 0 B3 B2 C
B C
Fµn ! B C, (2.14)
@ E2 B3 0 B1 A
E3 B2 B1 0
which gives
4p i
J.∂µ F µi =
c
Thanks to tensor approach Gauss’s law and Ampere-Maxwell’s can
be wrapped up together in a single, frame-independent law First pair of Maxwell’s equations
4p n
∂µ F µn = J . (2.16)
c
Gauss’ law for magnetic field and Faraday’s law form the second pair
of Maxwell’s equations. They can be wrapped up together in a single
law Second pair of Maxwell’s equa-
tions
∂a Fbg + ∂ b Fga + ∂g Fab = 0. (2.18)
or equivalently as
∂[a Fbg] = 0
where [. . .] stands for anti-symmetrization of any group of indices.
In the case of three indices it reads
1
∂[a Fbg] := ∂a Fbg + ∂ b Fga + ∂g Fab ∂ b Fag ∂a Fgb ∂g Fba .
3!
The expression (2.18) is known as Bianchi identities in electromag-
netism. Indeed, for Fµn given in terms of four-potential Aµ the
expression (2.18) vanishes identically.
58 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
8 Permutation symbol
< +1 for even permutation of 0123,
>
µnab
eµnab ⌘ e := 1 for odd permutation of 0123, (2.19)
>
: 0 for repetition of indices
{ x µ } ! { x 0µ } (2.20)
where there appears a symbol e0µnab with indices that label new coordi-
nates on the rhs of (2.22). Any permutation of two rows changes the
sign of the determinant (2.22). Thus we can write
∂x r ∂x s ∂x g ∂x d
Jersgd = e0µnab . (2.23)
∂x 0µ ∂x 0n ∂x 0a ∂x 0 b
maxwell’s equations 59
∂x 0k ∂x 0l ∂x 0w ∂x 0c
Contracting the equation (2.23) with ∂x r ∂x s ∂x g ∂x d one gets Transformation formula of the
Levi-Civita symbol eµnab
∂x 0k ∂x 0l ∂x 0w ∂x 0c
Jersgd = e0klwc . (2.24)
∂x r ∂x s ∂x g ∂x d
The presence of Jacobian determinant spoils the tensor law of transfor-
mation.10 Similarly, taking arbitrary permutation of columns in (2.21) 10
Such objects are called relative tensors of
and dividing by J we get weight W = +1.
0 ∂x a ∂x b
gµn ( x0 ) = g (x) (2.26)
∂x 0µ ∂x 0n ab
where x 0 on the lhs is a function of x i.e. x 0 = x 0 ( x ). The formula (2.26)
can be cast in the matrix form
g 0 ( x 0 ) = J 2 g ( x ). (2.28)
where
g( x ) := det( ĝ( x )), g0 ( x 0 ) := det( ĝ0 ( x 0 )).
The signature11 of the quadratic form cannot be changed by transforma- 11
Numbers of positive and negative ele-
tion of coordinates hence the sign of the determinant must be consistent ments when the form has its canonical
form.
with the sign of determinant of metrics in any frame. In particular, we
know that in Cartesian basis det(ĥ ) = 1 so g( x ) < 0 and g0 ( x 0 ) < 0.
Multiplying (2.28) by 1 and taking the square root of its both sides
we get q q
g0 ( x 0 ) = sgn( J ) J g ( x ). (2.29)
Next, dividing the lhs (rhs) of equation (2.24) by the lhs (rhs) of (2.29)
one gets expression
1 1 ∂x 0k ∂x 0l ∂x 0w ∂x 0c
p e0klwc = sign( J ) p ersgd
g0 g ∂x r ∂x s ∂x g ∂x d
1
#µnab ( x ) := p eµnab . (2.30)
g( x )
Thus
q
# rsgd ( x ) := g( x )ersgd . (2.31)
#µnab ( x )# µnab ( x ) = 4!
⇤ µn 1 µnab
F := # Fab (2.33)
2
1 µnab
and it has the form ⇤ F µn = 2e Fab in Cartesian coordinates.
It gives
⇤ 01 1 0123 1 0132
F = e F23 e F32 = e0123 F23 = F23 = B1 ,
2 2
⇤ 02 1 0231 1 0213
F = e F31 e F13 = e0231 F31 = F31 = B2 ,
2 2
⇤ 03 1 0312 1 0321
F = e F12 e F21 = e0312 F12 = F12 = B3 ,
2 2
maxwell’s equations 61
and similarly
⇤ 12 1 1230 1 1203
F = e F30 e F03 = e0123 F03 = F03 = E3 ,
2 2
⇤ 23 1 2310 1 2301
F = e F10 e F01 = e0123 F01 = F01 = E1 ,
2 2
⇤ 31 1 3120 1 3102
F = e F20 e F02 = e0123 F02 = F02 = E2 .
2 2
The contravariant components of the dual tensor can be arranged in
the form of matrix
0 1
0 B1 B2 B3
B C
B 1 3 2 C
⇤ µn
B B 0 E E C
F !B B
C.
C (2.34)
B B 2 E 3 0 1
E C
@ A
B3 E2 E1 0
Finally, the second pair of Maxwell’s equation reads Alternative form of second pair
of Maxwell’s equations
∂µ ⇤ F µn = 0 (2.36)
4p n b
( L 1 ) µ L a Lnb ∂r F ab
r µ
L bJ = 0
| {z } c
r
da
A set of all such linear forms (covectors) at any point p form a vector
space provided that Linear space of covectors
1 1 1 1
(w 1 + w 2 )(v) := w 1 (v) + w 2 (v), (2.41)
1 1
( a w )(v) := a w (v). (2.42)
This space, denoted by T⇤ ( p), is dual to T( p) and it is called tangent Cotangent space
space of covectors or cotangent space. Components of one-forms are de-
noted by wa and they are defined as sequences of numbers representing
values of one-form on basis vectors {ea }a=0,...,3 at the point p i.e., Components of one-form
1
w a : = w (ea ).
In the space of one-forms one can define the dual basis which consists
on one-forms {e b } b=0,...,3 that act on the basis vectors ea 2 T( p) giving
b
e b (ea ) := da . (2.43)
1
Elements of dual basis {ea }a=0,...3 and components of one-forms w
transform in the following way
∂x 0a ∂x b
e0a = ( p)e b , wa0 = ( p)w b . (2.44)
∂x b ∂x 0a
64 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
1 ∂f
w := ( p ) e a 2 T⇤ ( p ). (2.46)
∂x a
Such association does not depend on the reference frame. Moreover,
it is invertible – with any sequence of numbers it can be associated a Invertibility
sequence of derivatives ∂a f | p . Since p is fixed the sequence of deriva-
tives is a numerical sequence. The simplest function which allows to
associate a sequence of numbers with a sequence of partial derivatives
at p has the form
f ( x 0 , · · · , x 3 ) = wa x a
where wa is a sequence of numbers. It gives
b
∂a f | p = w b da = wa .
∂fa
ea = ( p)e b (2.47)
∂x b
where { f a }a=0,...,3 is a sequence of functions. Each function f a defines
one covector ea . Components b of this covector in the basis that the
maxwell’s equations 65
f a ( x0 , · · · , x3 ) := x a .
ea = dx a .
We stress that dx a in this expression have the meaning of linear forms Differentials dx a as linear forms
that act on elements of the space T( p) according to
Hence
1
w (v) = wa dx a (v) = wa va .
1
w = wa ( x0 , . . . , x3 )dx a . (2.48)
where {va } are components of certain vector v in vector basis {ea }a=0,...,3 .
This mapping defines the function wv( p) : T( p) 7! R which is given
by Function p ! wv( p) 2 R
1
wv( p) := w (v) = wa va . (2.50)
Linear two-form is a function which associates a real number with Linear two-form
a pair of vectors from T( p)
2
w: (v1 , v2 ) ! R.
• it is anti-symmetric Skew-symmetry
2 2
w (v1 , v2 ) = w (v2 , v1 ). (2.52)
1 1
With each pair of one-forms w 1 , w 2 there can be associated a two- External product of one-forms as
1 1
form w 1 ^ w 2 which acts on vectors v1 , v2 according to a prototype of two-form
1 1 1 1
(w 1 ^ w 2 )(v1 , v2 ) := eij w 1 (vi )w 2 (v j )
2 3
1 1
w ( v ) w ( v
2 1 5)
⌘ det 4 1 1 1 1
. (2.55)
w 1 (v2 ) w 2 (v2 )
1 1 1
The form w 1 ^ w 2 is obtained as external product of covectors w 1 and
1
w 2 . Each one-form maps vectors from T(p) on real numbers and these
numbers are arranged in anti-symmetric expression. It follows from
determinant properties that
1 1 1 1
w1 ^ w2 = w2 ^ w1 (2.56)
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
(w 1 + w 2 ) ^ w 3 = w1 ^ w3 + w2 ^ w3 . (2.57)
2 1
w= w dx a ^ dx b . (2.58)
2 ab
2 1
w (v1 , v2 ) = w (dx a ^ dx b )(v1 , v2 )
2 ab
1
= wab eij dx a (vi )dx b (v j )
2 " #
1 dx a (v1 ) dx b (v1 )
⌘ wab det
2 dx a (v2 ) dx b (v2 )
" b
#
1 v1a v1
= wab det b (2.59)
2 v2a v2
µ µ
where dx a (vi ) = dx a (vi eµ ) = vi dµa = via . The coefficients of this
form are values which it takes on each pair of vectors from the set
{ea }a=0,...,3 ,
" b
#
2 1 dµa dµ
wµn := w (eµ , en ) = wab det . (2.60)
2 dna
b
dn
k
Linear differential k-form w, where 0 k N ⌘ 4, is a covariant Linear differential k-form
tensor of rank (0k ) given by
k 1
w= wa ...a dx a1 ^ . . . ^ dx ak (2.61)
k! 1 k
dx a1 ^ . . . ^ dx ak
k
Components of w are given by values which this form takes on each
k-th element sequence of vectors {ea } i.e.
k
wa1 ...ak = w (ea1 , . . . , eak ). (2.63)
68 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
p (0, 1, . . . , N 1) = a1 , a2 , . . . , a N 1
Its contravariant components #a1 ...a N are given by expression Contravariant components of the
q Levi -Civita pseudotensor
#a1 ...a N := ga1 b1 . . . ga N b N | g| eb1 ...b N
q
1
= | g|ea1 ...a N
g
sgn( g) a1 ...a N
= p e
| g|
where
q
1
⇤
w b1 ...b N := | g| w a1 ...ak ea1 ...ak b1 ...b N (2.65)
k
k! k
Physical examples
The four-current one-form is a differential form with components J µ i.e. Electric current one-form
J := Jµ dx µ . (2.66)
and so
⇤
J = J 0 dx1 ^ dx2 ^ dx3 J 1 dx0 ^ dx2 ^ dx3
J 2 dx0 ^ dx3 ^ dx1 J 3 dx0 ^ dx1 ^ dx2 . (2.68)
Similarly, Maxwell’s form is a two-form dual to Faraday’s form. It Dual two-form of the electromag-
reads netic field
⇤ 1⇤
F := F dx a ^ dx b , (2.71)
2 ab
where
⇤ 1 µn
F ab = F # µnab . (2.72)
2
They have their explicit form
0 1
0 B1 B2 B3
B B1 0 E3 E2 C
⇤ B C
Fab ! B 2 C. (2.73)
@ B E3 0 E1 A
B3 E2 E1 0
70 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
Exterior derivative
We have seen that with a differential of certain function f : O ! R there
can be associated differential one-form in the region O of Minkowski
spacetime. Since the function f can be interpreted as zero-form then
differential of function associates one-form with each zero-form.
The exterior derivative (exterior differential) is a generalization of this Exterior differential
operation for an arbitrary k form. This operation associates (k + 1)–
form of class C r 1 with k–form of class C r :
✓ ◆
k 1
dw = d wa1 ...ak dx a1 ^ . . . ^ dx ak
k!
1
= dwa1 ...ak ^ dx a1 ^ . . . ^ dx ak
k!
1
= ∂a0 wa1 ...ak dx a0 ^ dx a1 ^ . . . ^ dx ak . (2.75)
k!
The exterior derivative has the following properties Properties of exterior differentia-
tion
k k k k
d(w 1 + w 2 ) = dw 1 + dw 2 , (2.76)
k l k l kk l
d(w ^ w ) = dw ^ w + ( 1) w ^ dw, (2.77)
k
ddw = 0 for any form, (2.78)
0
dw = ∂a w dx a . (2.79)
k
A differential form w is called closed if Closed form
k
dw = 0. (2.80)
k
A differential form w is called exact if Exact form
k k 1
w=d s . (2.81)
k 1
Each exact form is closed because dd s ⌘ 0. The inverse statement
holds only in regions contractible to a point.
k
Poincaré Lemma. Let O ⇢ A be a region contractible to a point and w, Poincaré Lemma
where k = 1, 2, · · · , be an arbitrary closed differential k form defined in O
k k 1 k k 1
i.e. dw = 0. There exists a form s such that w = d s .
maxwell’s equations 71
0
w = w, (2.82)
1
w = w1 dx1 + w2 dx2 + w3 dx3 , (2.83)
2
w = w12 dx1 ^ dx2 + w23 dx2 ^ dx3 + w31 dx3 ^ dx1 . (2.84)
k
One can associate components of forms w, k = 0, 1, 2 with components Relation with gradient, curl and
of some vector fields. In such a case the differential forms obtained divergence
by exterior derivatives of given forms have components which can be
identified with components of well-known operations: gradient, curl
and divergence.
This field correspond with the electric field of infinitely long uniformly
charged lines where l0 stands for linear density of electric charge. The
second field has the form Magnetic field of infinitely long
conducting wire
2I0 f̂ 2I y x
H= = 0 x̂ + 2 ŷ
c r c x 2 + y2 x + y2
1 1 1 1
It follows that both forms e and h are closed Both e and h are closed
1
de = 0 , r ⇥ E = 0, (2.90)
1
dh = 0 , r ⇥ H = 0 in E2 \{0, 0}. (2.91)
The second integral does not vanish. It means that the integral between
two points depends on the integration path that connects these points.
1
Hence, the differential form h is not exact (it cannot be represented by
1
the exterior derivative of some zero-form). The form h is not definite at
r = 0 (vector f̂ is not definite at the origin) what requires exclusion of
this point from domain of the form. Consequently, the form is definite
in the region which is not contractible to a point i.e. there is no satisfied
1
the assumption of Poincaré Lemma. On the other hand, the form e is
exact and it reads
q
1
e = d 2l0 ln x2 + y2 + const .
maxwell’s equations 73
Volume form
The form
4
w = w0123 dx0 ^ dx1 ^ dx2 ^ dx3
4
is a 4-form in Minkowski spacetime. It is closed, dw = 0, because its
degree is equal to number of spacetime dimmensions. The example of
4
4-form is volume form w which is given by Volume form
1p
vol = ⇤1 = g eµnab dx µ ^ dx n ^ dx a ^ dx b . (2.94)
4!
d⇤ J = 0, (2.100)
where
d⇤ J = dJ 0 ^ dx1 ^ dx2 ^ dx3 dJ 1 ^ dx0 ^ dx2 ^ dx3
dJ 2 ^ dx0 ^ dx3 ^ dx1 dJ 3 ^ dx0 ^ dx1 ^ dx2
= (∂µ J µ ) dx0 ^ dx1 ^ dx2 ^ dx3 . (2.101)
k 1
w= wa ...a ( x0 , . . . , x3 ) dx a1 ^ . . . ^ dx ak , (2.105)
k! 1 k
given in some region O , the integral of this form over some regular
surface sector P is defined as follows Definition of the integral of
k form
76 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
Z Z
k k
w := w (v1 , . . . , vk )dt1 . . . dtk , (2.106)
P D
k
where w (v1 , . . . , vk ) is the value of the form on vectors
∂x a
v j := ea ( p ), a = 0, 1, 2, 3, j = 1, . . . , k. (2.107)
∂t j
Since
b b b a a ∂x ai
dx ai (v j ) = dx ai (v j eb ) = v j dx ai (eb ) = v j dbi = v j i = (2.108)
∂t j
are partial derivatives, then applying (2.62) one gets in (2.106) the
determinant of partial derivatives. This determinant is just the Jacobian
of transformation x a = x a (t1 , . . . , tk ) i.e.
a
∂x i ∂ ( x a1 . . . x a k )
det ⌘ i, j = 1, 2, . . . , k. (2.109)
∂t j ∂ ( t1 . . . t k )
Thus the integral (2.106) reads Integral of k form
Z Z
k 1 ∂ ( x a1 . . . x a k ) 1
w := wa1 ...ak dt . . . dtk . (2.110)
P D k! ∂ ( t1 . . . t k )
k
When the integral of the form w splits into a finite or countable number Splitting the integral into inte-
of integrals over orientable surfaces Pi which have no common points, grals over distinct orientable sur-
k faces
then the integral of the form w over hypersurface P is a sum of integrals
over Pi
Z Z
k k
P
w := Â Pi
w. (2.111)
i
Let us consider an oriented hypersurface ∂P that consists on regular Induced orientation at the border
sectors ∂P1 , . . . , ∂P M . The hypersurface ∂P = F(∂D) is the image of
faces Si , i = 1, . . . , M of the polyhedron D in the space of parameters
{t1 , . . . tk } i.e.
∂ D = S1 [ S2 [ . . . [ S M .
The orientation introduced on D allows to introduce invariantly the
orientation on ∂P . This is so-called induced orientation. One can choose
outward unit vector n of the polyhedron D . It is perpendicular to Si at
any point p localised in its interior. The orientation on Si is determined
by the basis f1 , . . . , fk 1 , and chosen in such a way that n, f1 , . . . , fk 1
has orientation compatible with the orientation of R k .
where
1 ∂( xµ xn xa x b ) 1 2 3 4
d4 W : = # µnab dt dt dt dt (2.113)
4! ∂ ( t1 t2 t3 t4 )
Stokes Theorem
k 1
Given (k 1)–form w of class C 1 on P [ ∂P the integral of this form over Stokes theorem for differential
∂P is equal to the integral of its exterior derivative over P forms
Z Z
k 1 k 1
w = dw. (2.114)
∂P P
H ! ( w1 , w2 , w3 )
(i.e. Hi ⌘ wi ), then Stokes theorem for differential forms takes the form
of familiar Stokes theorem for vector fields
Z Z I Z
1 1
w= dw , H · dx = r ⇥ H · dS,
∂S S C S
If one associates components of a certain vector field D with compo- Components of strength vectors
nents of this two-form, correspond with component of
one-forms
D ! (w23 , w31 , w12 ),
1
(E, H) $ w
then the exterior derivative of this form corresponds with divergence of
this vector field r · D. In such a case the Stokes theorem for differential whereas components of induc-
forms results in the Gauss theorem for vector fields tions correspond with compo-
Z
2
Z
2
I Z nents of two-forms
w= dw , D · dS = r · D dV.
∂V V S V 2
(D, B) $ w
The electric dislocation vector is an example of such a vector field.
and
I
e (∂P ) := + 1
F ⇤ µn 2
F d Sµn .
2 ∂P
80 lecture notes on classical electrodynamics
Example
Let us consider purely spatial surface P in the form of cube with side a
and the center located at the origin of reference frame. We choose the
following parametrization
x0 = const, x 1 = t1 , x 2 = t2 , x 3 = t3 .
∂( x1 x2 ) 1 2
dS03 = # 0312 dt dt = dt1 dt2 .
∂ ( t1 t2 )