Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4: 297-301
Edward Prados
4956 Sclzuyler Drive, Annandale, VA 22003, USA
-
0 0.25
-
0.5 0.75 1.0 N
Kilometres
t
i
1
I
Sira Bay
1
c
/
I
.. I Sira Island
,.7,)
Figure 1 . MaD of Aden with the location of Sira Bav. (All firmres bv the Author.)
there are very large mountains . . . It is the rendezvous were seeking to consolidate their hold over the
for all the ships which come from India Major and maritime trade of the Indian Ocean littoral
Minor, from Ethiopia and from Persia'. region. That Portugal failed in this attempt was
In 1513, the Portuguese Governor of India, due, in part, to that nation's inability to control
Alfonso de Albuquerque, mounted an ambi- Aden, and, by extension, the Red SedEgyptian
tious assault on Aden and its walls; the effort route to the Mediterranean (Prados, 1992).
was a complete failure. Subsequent Portuguese Aden's fortunes continued to fluctuate, with
attempts to capture the port also proved unsuc- a period of eclipse beginning in the 17th century
cessful. It was at this time that the Portuguese when the Red Sea port of Mocha-renowned
298
E. PRADOS: INVESTIGATION O F SIRA BAY
Y _I
(/
/
Js7
'J --)
7
\ -
---
Holkat Bay
1-
: \ k , f
)
' 2
i
z
__ -.-, _--1
0 1 2 3 4 5
Kilometres
for its coffee exports4isplaced Aden as a Crater alone boasted some level ground;
preeminent regional trading centre. The nevertheless, landfill activity has been extensive
Ottomans, who had successfully taken Aden in at this sub-centre. Initial observations made it
1538 and subsequently re-fortified it, relin- clear that within the last decade there have been
quished their hold over the port in order to huge reclamation activities. Today, Victorian
focus on their more prosperous Red Sea hold- seawalls lie behind both a major thoroughfare
ings (Little, 1968: 9). Aden had degenerated and an amusement park.
into a ramshackle fishing village when, in In addition to landfill activities, sediment
1839, the British captured and eventually deposition has affected and altered the extant,
fashioned it into a bustling city and a major submerged portion of Sira Bay. The rate of
port. sedimentation is difficult to predict, and, un-
doubtedly, it has changed over time (Duncan,
Topography and site formation processes 1994). Presently, tidal flats, which are exposed
The city of Aden is situated on a peninsula at low tide, characterize the coasts of Crater
moulded by volcanic activity. Aden was origi- and Khormaksar. While no perennial streams
nally an island; today it is joined to the main- or rivers empty into Sira Bay, infrequent but
land by an isthmus formed as the shallow violent rainstorms drive quantities of material
seabed between Aden and the mainland gradu- from Aden's mountainous backdrop into flood
ally silted up (Playfair, 1859 [1970]: 5 ; Serjeant, channels, known as sailas, that empty into the
1988: 163). On the Peninsula, steeply-sloping Bay. Currently, most of the Bay is so shallow
volcanic mountains lead directly into the sea; that it dries at low tide.
consequently flat land has consistently been a In 1839, it was possible to wade to Sira
scarce resource. The British built large portions Island (Kirkman, 1975). Subsequently, the
of the districts of Khormaksar, Ma'alla, and British built a causeway from the mainland to
Tawahi upon reclaimed land. Sira Island, which resulted in an accelerated
299
NAUTICAL ARCHAEOLOGY, 23.4
sedimentation rate in the Bay by deflecting British Engineers cleared the area without re-
the southerly waves that previously scoured it. gard to archaeology , . . Modern Aden is prac-
Today, this area is used as a soccer field at low tically entirely a British creation’ (1974: 210).
tide, suggesting that at least 0.5 m of sediment
has accumulated since then. The survey
It is probable that the tidal flats that cur- This survey was the first formal, underwater
rently characterize Sira Bay also existed in archaeological project to be conducted in
earlier eras. A wide expanse of tidal flats before Aden, or in Yemen itself. This resulted in
the old coastline would not have hindered difficulties, as the discipline is new to the
commerce at Aden, as it is the practice of dhow country. Officials were unsure of the proper
captains at Ma’alla to beach their vessels for jurisdictional placement of activities such as
off-loading, careening, and repairs. Even large SCUBA diving and underwater archaeology,
dhows have a shallow draft and nautical charts and were worried about the safety of these
show that the channel of Ma’alla’s dhow activities. Supporting facilities and equipment
harbour is dredged to only 2.7 m. Historical were non-existent.
sources indicate that Sira Bay’s mud flats have
existed for at least four hundred years. Cartographic reconstruction
It appears that Aden’s ancient (pre-7th cen- The survey was designed to be implemented by
tury AD) and Medieval (pre-16th century) means of a four-phase process: cartographic
maritime features do not lie underwater or reconstruction, visual searches, remote-sensing
below the seabed, but are covered by 5-10 m of searches, and intrusive investigation. The first
successive habitation levels and landfill. In phase, cartographic reconstruction, began with
1859, a British Officer, Capt. Playfair, noted a study of primary sources and charts, designed
ancient South Arabian inscriptions 6 m below to allow project members to define the param-
the level of the present town, in an era that eters of the search area. Following initial famil-
preceded modem landfill in Crater (1859 [19701: iarization, a map of shoreline change at Crater
13). At the same depth, Brian Doe, director of and Sira Bay was constructed depicting the
the Aden Department of Antiquities in the current shoreline in relation to the shorelines
1960s, unearthed four ancient column capitals of previous eras. As no up-to-date map was
(1974: 176-179). He also located the remains of available, the current shoreline was mapped
buildings 4-4-5 m underground in the area of with a transiting compass and a 30 m chain in
the Holkat Bay Road. December 1993. It was then digitally plotted
using AutoCAD (Release 12). A 1990 US
Earlier archaeological research Defense Mapping Agency nautical chart and a
Little terrestrial archaeological research work 1954 British chart were digitized as overlays on
has been conducted at Aden. R. B. Serjeant the map to provide recent, comparative data.
(1988) and Brian Doe (1965) identified Chinese Next, the Medieval shoreline was projected
ceramics found during surface surveys of in the following manner. An inspection of the
Holkat Bay and other areas around Crater. slope of Crater revealed a positive (upward)
Doe also conducted several test excavations slope leading to the remains of the sub-centre’s
that revealed the remains of buildings in the seawalls. On the Aden Peninsula, a positive
Holkat area. The Cisterns of Tawila, a Medi- slope leading to the sea is artificial, given the
eval system of water-catchment tanks for topographical characteristics of the landmass, a
Aden’s waterless Peninsula, have received some volcanic escarpment whose lava mountains
archaeological attention (Noms and Penhey, often plunge directly into the Indian Ocean.
1955). UNESCO environmental assessment Where natural beaches exist, they are limited in
specialists have studied the cisterns more re- extent, and descend (albeit far more moder-
cently, following damaging floods in early 1993. ately) to the sea. One of Crater’s few remaining
Buildings and streets occupy almost every Medieval structures, the Aden minaret (c.
square metre of land, and intensive construc- AD 1050), was observed to be directly behind
tion and development have destroyed archaeo- this positive gradient (Fig. 4). Additionally, an
logical information. According to Serjeant: ‘the aerial photograph revealed that building and
300
E. PRADOS: INVESTIGATION OF SIRA BAY
1414600
LEGEND
1414200 - Shoreline change
A 1993Survey
B 199wDMA chart
C 1964 U K chart
1413900 - D 1300/Rassuhdera shorellne
E 260 B C lSabaeao Bhorelme
Numbered featurea
1413800 - 1 Sira Mole 5 Sea walls
2 Sira fortress 6 Minaret
3 Potential Mole 7 Cisterns of
4 Merryland Tawila
1413300 -
1413000 - D
E
1412700 - .I 6‘
L
f
Metres
1412400 -
200 4oo---m 800 loo0
1000 100 300 600 700 400
- - - - - - I
1412100 -
i_Holkat Bay
0.1 0
Kilometres
1
1411800 1111
Figure 5. Shoreline change at Sira Bay. The causeway to Sira Island did not exist in the pre-Colonial era.
to the west, the observation post of Jebal in deeper water. No significant anomalies pro-
Mansour to the north, a fortification to the truded through the 1.5m overburden of the
south, and ships at sea to the east. The location
exposed tidal flats. Those cultural remains dis-
of the internal platform, flush with the main cernible on the surface proved to be of modem
windows, would have made it impracticable for origin.
the Muslim caller-of-prayer, the muezzin, to A diving search did disclose more infor-
perform his five-times-daily ritual. Notably, mation about the deeper, submerged portion
the minaret is not currently used for religious of the Bay. Activity during this phase of the
purposes, despite Aden’s dearth of minarets survey was directed primarily in the vicinity of
following twenty years of socialist rule. No a mole or breakwater, found at the extreme
formal study of the minaret was permitted, end of the harbour on the northern side
but through the cooperation of construction of Sira Island. The mole’s location makes it
workers repairing a fence, the interior of the extremely effective in blocking the swell gener-
structure was visited. Its brick construction, ated by the easterly waves of the north-east
octagonal siding, and decorative brick patterns monsoon. The proper positioning of such a
display Seljuq Turkish influence (Bloom, 1989: mole would have been crucial during Aden’s
157-158); it is likely that the tower dates to the
tenure as a world-class entrepbt. Capt.
1lth century AD. Regrettably, little effort hasHaines’ 1836 chart of Aden confirms the
been expended to conserve and restore this mole’s usefulness by depicting a fleet of vessels
unique, historic structure. anchored in the feature’s lee.
Underwater examination of the mole and
Visual searches its surroundings revealed that the feature once
This second phase of the project commenced in extended a further 25m and that the mole
January 1994 with walking searches of Sira Bay was not a natural formation (Fig. 6). A regu-
at low tide, and continued with diving searches lar, sloping, stone wall at its submerged end
302
E. PRADOS: INVESTIGATION OF SIRA BAY
which ends abruptly at the seabed confirmed sensor interference. Magnetometer tow lanes
its artificial nature and indicated that its were randomized, varying according to transit
builders were able to operate efficiently in availability on shore, but the team succeeded in
10 m of water. That the mole’s builders could its objective of intensively sampling what was
conduct work underwater has implications for probably the most active area of the Bay in
the survival of submerged cultural remains in the pre-Colonial era (Fig. 7). Several gaps in
a shallow bay fronting a heavily-populated magnetometer lane coverage were caused by
area. Although locals did not seem to know obstructions, such as fishing boats and nets
the age of Sira mole, pictorial sources show it located in the harbour. Unfortunately, the team
as early as the 16th century, and it is likely and local officials were not able to have the
that the mole dates to well before that period. obstructions removed prior to the conclusion of
Only modern surface material was located in the magnetometer search.
the diving search. Three distinct construction A traditional, Yemeni huri towed the mag-
layers underlying the breakwater’s modem netometer sensor at a relatively constant speed.
surface were briefly noted at a break in the The huri had a shallow draft, making it ideal
wall, but officials prevented the team from for surveying in the shallow bay. However,
recording and investigating this, the seaward, there were no enclosed spaces aboard the craft.
side of the mole. The lack of a protected cabin area precluded
the use of an EG & G Geometrics RS-232
Remote sensing searches communications cable that would have permit-
In the third phase of the project, a SCUBA ted automatic transferal of data from the
King underwater metal detector and an EG & magnetometer to the project’s notebook com-
G Geometrics G-866 proton precession mag- puter. Instead, thousands of magnetometer
netometer were utilized in detecting subsurface readings had to be input manually into the
metallic and magnetic anomalies. The metal computer. The magnetometer values were then
detector proved to be of limited value. The matched with their respective x-y coordinates,
seabed, dark in colour and rich in igneous, which were calculated by a team-designed
magnetic minerals such as magnetite, caused QBASIC locational control programme. Team
the metal detector to register almost continu- members plotted and investigated all significant
ally as it was walked along a preset grid. anomalies.
Greater success was obtained with the mag- The volcanic composition of the Aden pen-
netometer, as it was trawled during high tide at insula imposes limits on any magnetometer’s
least 1 m above the seabed, thereby reducing effectiveness. Small rocks, less than 10 cm in
303
NAUTICAL ARCHAEOLOGY, 23.4
““‘F:
1414200
100 0100
-
0.1 0
- - -
200
- -
300
I
Metrss
400
Kilometres
600 800 lo00
600 700 900
1
r
N
1413341.67
i -
-
-
- 1413341.67
1
-
1413183.33 - 1413183.33
-
-
-
- 1413025.00
-
-
- 1412866.67
-
-
-
- 1412708.33
-
-
1412550.00 L l l I I I 1 I I I
504500.00 504641.68 504783.33 504925.00 505066.67
Figure 8. Magnetic contour map of main portion of Sira Bay. 10-gamma contour interval.
of fifty-gamma anomalies (Fig. 7). No air-lift or rocks were magnetic and were responsible
dredging equipment was available, and team for generating the anomalies detected by the
members dug the pits using bare hands and magnetometer.
shovels. Excavation proved difficult as the The work was completed on 28 January
sediment was hard-packed, there was a 30cm 1994, following six weeks of preliminary analy-
depth of water above the surface of the hole, sis and actual survey. No significant anomalies
and surge caused the pits to silt-up as quickly as or cultural remains were detected during the
they could be dug. Excavation revealed the underwater portion of the survey of Sira Bay.
sediment to be of uniform colour and density. Team members were not, however, allowed to
In both sondages, small fragments of wood, less examine several areas where a greater potential
than 3 x 1 cm, were found. Conservation was for ancient sites exists. Internal security consid-
initiated on the wood fragments; however, it erations forbade additional investigation.
is more likely that these fragments are from
construction debris and run-off than from Conclusions
archaeological sites. Each sondage also yielded The survey team confirmed the location of
one igneous rock, always placed squarely at the Aden’s pre-Colonial harbour. Additionally, the
end of the probe. Examination with the metal site of an ancient and Medieval breakwater was
detector and magnetometer revealed that these identified. The team was not able to locate the
305
NAUTICAL ARCHAEOLOGY, 23.4
Figure 9. Magnetic anomaly map of Sira Bay. 10-gamma contour interval. Ortho-
graphic projection rotated 225 degrees clockwise for viewing purposes.
Highest peaks represent contemporary surface debris.
remains of any port facilities or shipwreck sites city as ballast. Fired brick is not a traditional
in the harbour. architectural material in Yemen, a country
The reason for the lack of observable port renowned for its stone and mud-brick
facilities is made clear by the cartographic architecture .
reconstruction: any extant remains of the Thus, it is unlikely that there are buried
ancient port would be located several hundred features or sites within the Bay itself. If any
metres inland from the current shore, and remain they are buried under sediment, and the
under perhaps 10 m of landfill. Shipwreck sites exact rate and depth of sediment accumulation
were not located for other equally valid in the Bay can only be accurately predicted with
reasons. Wood is an extremely scarce com- a coring programme. Sira Bay must have been
modity in Yemen. In timberless South Arabia, deeper in the past than it is currently, or the Bay
it would have been senseless to allow such a would have afforded no anchorage for ships
resource to deteriorate in a shallow harbour. waiting to unload their cargoes or seeking
Conversations with an elderly fisherman sug- shelter from the seasonally heavy monsoon
gested that builders had incorporated ships’ swells. In the project’s two sondages, team
beams into buildings in the area. In a similar members uncovered indigenous, volcanic rocks
fashion, the principal government and popula- at 1.25 to 1.5 m below present seabed level.
tion could have easily retrieved ships’ cargoes Probing through the sand overburden also
and ballasts. Observations of several older, revealed rocks and gravel clusters at a 1.5 m
dilapidated buildings revealed that they were depth. Areas of Sira Bay, then, were at least
constructed not out of indigenous rock, but 1.5 m deeper when it originally served as a
of fired brick, probably brought to the port harbour.
306
E. PRADOS: INVESTIGATION OF SIRA BAY
References
Aden Department of Antiquities, 1965, Bulletin Nuniher 5. Aden.
Aden Coliiny Development Plan: I960 -64, [ 19601. Aden.
Bloom, J., 1989. Minaret: S.vmhol of Islrrm. Oxford.
Bowen. R.. 1949. Arab Dhows of Eastern Arahia. Rehoboth, Massachusetts.
Breiner, S., 1973. Appliccrtions MunualJiv Portable Magnetometers. Sunnyvale, California.
De Albuquerque, A,, 1884 [rep. N.D.], The Commentaries of the Great Afonso Dalboyuerque. Translated by Walter
de Gray Birch. London.
Doe. B.. 1974. Ancient capitals from Aden. Arabiun Studies. 1: 1 7 6 9 .
Duncan. S. K.. 1994, An Environmental History of the Maple Leaf Site: 1862-1993. Greenville, North Carolina.
Kirkman, J. & Doe, B., 1975. The first days of British Aden: The diary of John Studdy Leigh. Arabian Studies. 2:
179-203.
Little, T.. 1968, South Arahia: Arena of Conflict. New York.
Miller, J. I., 1969, The Spice Trade e f t h e Roman Empire: 29 B.C. to A.D. 641. Oxford.
Moreland, W. H., 1939. The ships of the Arabian Sea about A.D. 1500, Part 11. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society
of Gri~atBritain and Ireland, 1939: 173-92.
Naval Intelligence Division, 1946, Western Arabia and the Red Sea. Oxford.
Norris. H. T. & Penhey, F. W. 1955, An Archaeological and Historical Survey of the Aden Tanks. Aden.
Periphrs Maris Erythrtrei. [ 19891. Translated by Lionel Casson. Princeton.
Playfair. Captain R. L., 1859 [rep. 19701, A History o/Arahia Fe1i.v or Yemen. Bombay.
Prados. E. F.. 1992. Aruhiu Felix: The Coming o / the Portuguese. Greenville, North Carolina.
Serjeant, R. B.. 1963. Thi, Porru~uesee f t h e South Arohian Cocrst. Oxford.
Serjeant. R . B., 1974. The Ports of Aden and Shihr. Rerueils Soriktk Jean Bodin, 32: 207-24.
Serjeant. R. B.. 1988. Early Islamic and Medieval trade and commerce in the Yemen. In Yemen; 3000 Yiwrs o / A r /
crnd Civilisrrtion in Amhicr Fc.1i.v. Innsbruck.
Varthema. Ludovico di.. N. D.. Trcrvels. Translated by John Winter Jones. London.
307