Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Polymer Testing
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/polytest
Material Characterisation
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Two types of commercially applied Ethylene/Vinyl Acetate Copolymers (EVA) for encap-
Received 9 November 2010 sulation of photovoltaic modules were investigated by the thermal analysis methods of
Accepted 21 December 2010 Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) and Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) in the
temperature range from 150 C to 200 C. Glass transition, crystal melting and cross-
Keywords: linking were analyzed. The aims of the investigations were to gain more information for
EVA
incoming goods control and to get information about the whole temperature dependent
Thermal analysis
material properties in the investigated temperature range, starting at very low tempera-
DSC
DMA tures up to the crosslinking temperature region.
Glass transition Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Crystal melting
Cross-linking
0142-9418/$ – see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.polymertesting.2010.12.003
W. Stark, M. Jaunich / Polymer Testing 30 (2011) 236–242 237
concerning the cross-linking reaction can be gained from the experiment from 60 to 180 C, an endothermic peak close
exothermic process. to 100 C was found.
The state of knowledge is summarised by the following
information:
1.3. DSC-measurements in the temperature range of cross-
linking reaction
1.1. DSC-measurements starting at temperatures considerably
below room temperature
For cross-linking of EVA, peroxide is added as curing
agent. At temperatures above 160 C the peroxide decom-
Vogel and Heinze [10] published DSC results from
poses. Free peroxide radicals abstract mainly the hydrogen
23 C to 227 C. For non cross-linked material two peaks,
located at the tertiary carbon of the acetate group of the
one close to 50 C and one close to 70 C, and an exothermic
vinyl acetate (VAc) co-monomers [10,16]. Often dicumyl
double peak in the range from 140 C to 200 C are seen. For
peroxide (DCP) is used - Bianchi et al. [19]. The DSC heating
a cross-linked sample only a broad endothermic shoulder
rates were varied from 2.5 K/min to 40 K/min. For rates of
without a peak in the range 20 C–50 C followed by
10 K/min and higher an analysable exothermic peak in the
a distinct peak near 65 C appears. The exothermic peak is
range 150 C–200 C was seen.
missing.
Summarizing the DSC literature data, one can state that
Varghese et al. [11] showed a DSC curve from 80 C to
for EVA no results starting at very low and reaching up to
250 C. There is an endothermic step from about 40 C
crosslinking temperatures were found. Typical endo-
to 10 C passing into a first peak at about 50 C, which is
thermic peaks caused by crystal melting are found whereby
followed by a second peak close to 85 C.
often two endothermic peaks appear: first peak around
Khonakdar et al. [12] published DSC curves for EVA
40 C–60 C, second peak at 70–90 C. Sometimes, a broad
copolymers and also for pure EVA in the range 75 C to
endothermic shoulder starting from 40 C is observed.
175 C. A peak near 85 C was found. For the blends,
Cross-linking appears in the range 140 C–200 C. The
reduced crystallinity of the cross-linked material was
measurement of cross-linked material in a second run
reported.
shows changes in the endothermic peak shape. These
changes are discussed as a consequence of the change in
1.2. DSC-measurements starting at or close to room
molecular structure by cross-linking.
temperature
Shi et al. [13] have reported on DSC results in the range 1.4. DMA-measurements
0 C–140 C. A so called L-peak (lower temperature) and
a H-peak were found which are attributed to the primary The DMA results of Dikobe and Luyt [18] measured at
and secondary crystallization. Depending on the VAc 1 Hz between 80 and þ80 C show a distinct decrease in
content and the thermal treatment, the L-peak is in the storage modulus in the 20 C region. A second decrease
range 40 C–60 C, the H-peak 80 C–90 C. Using WAXD it appeared close to 40 C. The tand curves gave a first peak in
was found that many crystals became bigger and more the region 10 to 0 C, associated with the glass transition,
perfect by thermal ageing. and a second peak near 60 C.
Marcilla et al. [14] published DSC results in a tempera- Varghese et al. [11] measured at 50 Hz. They found
ture range starting from 37 C to 157 C showing two a decrease of storage modulus from about 30 to 0 C
endothermic peaks - a lower one near 47 C, a higher one accompanied by a tand peak at about 10 C. From tand
near 70 C. maxima, a glass transition temperature of 12 C for
Agroui et al. [15] investigated two EVA types designated uncross-linked and 10.4 C for cross-linked material were
slow and fast cure. DSC was measured from 40 C to 155 C. given.
Two endothermic peaks were seen, a more pronounced one Storage modulus, loss modulus and tand curves
at 50 C and more a shoulder near 70 C. measured at 10 Hz were published by John et al. [20]. A
Reyes-Labarta et al. [16] measured mixtures of PE with sharp decrease in storage modulus at about 40 C and
EVA and also pure EVA. DSC results for EVA from 27 C to a second decrease at about 40 C were reported. The loss
227 C showed two endothermic peaks – one near 50 C modulus had a first peak in the region of 130 C and
and another about 70 C. An exothermic peak in the range a second close to 25 C. Tand showed maxima at about
175–215 C appeared. After cross-linking, the lower peak 130 C, 20 C and 50 C. The change in material prop-
had vanished. This was interpreted by the reduction in erties in the temperature region around 40 to 0 C was
structural regularity by the created cross-links. brought about in connection with the glass transition.
Moly et al. [17] used DSC and WAXS. DSC performed in Tand maxima at 140 and 25 C and a distinct
the range 40 C–160 C showed a broad shoulder from 40 C decrease in loss modulus from 40 C were found also by
finished by a peak at 80 C. During cooling, a peak at 50 C Khondakar et al. [21]. The increase of tand between 75 and
followed by a wide shoulder was seen. For blends, a 95 C was explained by Koshy et al. [22] as melting of
decrease in crystallinity by cross-linking was found which crystalline segments.
was explained by some hindrance to the ordered arrange- To summarize the DMA measurements, a first relaxation
ment of the polymer chains. process appears in the 120 C range, followed with
Dikobe and Luyt [18] investigated EVA-PP blends, and increasing temperature by a glass transition in the range
also both polymers separately, by DSC and DMA. In a DSC 40 to 0 C. An additional decrease of storage modulus in
238 W. Stark, M. Jaunich / Polymer Testing 30 (2011) 236–242
2. Experimental
2.1. Material
a compression mould.
E00 ¼ jE jsind
00
2.2. Thermal analysis E – storage modulus
2.2.1. Dynamic mechanical analysis The loss factor tand is calculated from:
In DMA, a sinusoidal mechanical excitation of the
sample is executed whereby force, elongation and the E00
tand ¼
phase shift between them are measured as a function of E0
temperature. The complex modulus E* is calculated from Characteristic changes of moduli E0 and E00 and tand
the measured data and the geometry: caused by thermally activated molecular movements begin
at definite temperatures.
l3 F
Edual cantilever ¼ A DMA 242C, Netzsch, Germany, was used for the
16 b h3 A investigations with a dual cantilever holder and a sample
l – sample length, length of 5 mm. The heating rate was 1 K/min and the
b – sample width, amplitude 40 mm. During a single measurement run cycling
h – sample thickness, between the 5 frequencies – 0.33; 1; 3.33; 10 and 33.3 Hz –
F – force, was carried out automatically.
A – deflection.
2.2.2. Differential scanning calorimetry
With the phase shift, the complex E* can be split into DSC evaluates the change of temperature difference
two components: between a sample crucible and a reference crucible during
non-isothermal or isothermal conditions. The difference is
E0 ¼ jE jcosd used to calculate the heat flow into or out of the sample. It
0
E – storage modulus can detect melting, evaporation, glass transition and also
Fig. 1. DMA – storage modulus as function of temperature, material 1. Fig. 3. DMA – tand as function of temperature, material 1.
W. Stark, M. Jaunich / Polymer Testing 30 (2011) 236–242 239
Table 1
Material 1 - Loss modulus peak temperature of the glass transition for
different frequencies.
00
Frequency, Hz E peak temperature, C
0.33 32.1
1 30.4
3.33 28.4
10 27.2
33.33 25.0
3.1.1. DMA
f ¼ A e RT
The DMA results are presented first because they will be Ea – apparent activation energy,
embraced in the discussion of the DSC results. The DMA R – gas constant.
was measured for cross-linked samples only. The cross- The correlation between ln(f) and 1/T is shown in Fig. 4.
linking conditions were: 30 min at 160 C using a heated A linear relation was found. From the slope of the straight
compression mould. For better comparability, the results of line, an apparent activation energy can be calculated. The
the storage and loss modulus are shown in a normalized activation energy found was 328 kJ/mol, a value in the
manner, where the values at 150 C were set to unity. range typical for a glass transition [27]. The temperature
The results for material 1 are given in Figs. 1–3. A small range of the glass transition is in accordance with pub-
decrease in storage modulus together with a loss modulus lished data in [11,18,20].
and tan d peak in the range of 140 C can be explained by The next step in storage modulus between 40 and 60 C
the secondary relaxation caused by side group or end group was not accompanied by a peak in loss modulus. This will
motion or backbone “crank-shift” type motions typical for be discussed together with the DSC data later.
many polymers [25].
The storage modulus curve shows a distinct decrease 3.1.2. DSC
from 40 C. This change is accompanied by a peak in loss A basic raw material sample was measured in a 1st run
modulus and tand. There is a pronounced correlation from 150 to 200 C. The measurement was rerun with the
between frequency and location of the peak. For the loss now cured sample. The results for the 1st and 2nd runs are
modulus, the values are shown in Table 1. given in Fig. 5.
At the beginning of the DSC measurement, the typical
thermal imbalance between the crucibles must be adjusted
Fig. 7. DSC – heat flow results for the temperature program from Fig. 6, Fig. 9. DMA – loss modulus as function of temperature, material 2.
material 1.
Fig. 8. DMA – storage modulus as function of temperature, material 2. Fig. 10. DMA – tand as function of temperature, material 2.
W. Stark, M. Jaunich / Polymer Testing 30 (2011) 236–242 241
Table 2
Material 2 - Loss modulus peak temperature of the glass transition for
different frequencies.
00
Frequency, Hz E peak temperature, C
0.33 31.7
1 29.9
3.33 28.2
10 26.7
33.33 24.6
4. Conclusions
and DSC and the combination of the measurement of the [10] J. Vogel, C. Heinze, Reactive processing of polyethylene and Poly
(ethylene-co-vinyl acetate), Angewandte Makromolekulare Chemie
original material with measurements of the material ther-
207 (1993) 157–171.
mally treated by the measurement to 100 C and cured [11] H. Varghese, T. Johnson, S.S. Bhagawan, S. Joseph, S. Thomas, G.
during the preceding measurement to 200 C go beyond Groeninckx, Dynamic mechanical behavior of acrylonitrile buta-
previously published data. diene rubber/poly(ethylene-co-vinyl acetate) blends, Journal of
Polymer Science Part B-Polymer Physics 40 (15) (2002) 1556–1570.
Both materials show very similar characteristic behav- [12] H.A. Khonakdar, S.H. Jafari, A. Haghighi-Asl, U. Wagenknecht, L.
iour as a function of temperature which can be concluded Haeussler, U. Reuter, Thermal and mechanical properties of
as follows: uncrosslinked and chemically crosslinked polyethylene/ethylene
vinyl acetate copolymer blends, Journal of Applied Polymer Science
103 (5) (2007) 3261–3270.
– A glass transition appears in the range 40 to 20 C, [13] X.M. Shi, J. Zhang, D.R. Li, S.J. Chen, Effect of damp-heat aging on the
– The glass transition is not shifted perceptibly by cross- structures and properties of ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers with
different vinyl acetate contents, Journal of Applied Polymer Science
linking, 12 (4) (2009) 2358–2365.
– For original, non thermally treated material two crys- [14] A. Marcilla, J.A. Reyes-Labarta, F.J. Sempere, DSC kinetic study of the
talline melting processes indicated by two endothermic transitions involved in the thermal treatment of polymers. Meth-
odological considerations, Polymer 42 (12) (2001) 5343–5350.
peaks exist, [15] K. Agroui, A. Maallemi, M. Boumaour, G. Collins, M. Salama, Thermal
– Crystal melting is accompanied by a dip in storage stability of slow and fast cure EVA encapsulant material for
modulus, photovoltaic module manufacturing process, Solar Energy Materials
and Solar Cells 90 (15) (2006) 2509–2514.
– For material heated to 100 C, cooled down and heated [16] J.A. Reyes-Labarta, M.M. Olaya, A. Marcilla, DSC and TGA study of the
once more the endothermic double peak has changed transitions involved in the thermal treatment of binary mixtures of
into a broad endothermic shoulder followed by only PE and EVA copolymer with a crosslinking agent, Polymer 47 (24)
(2006) 8194–8202.
one pronounced endothermic peak, [17] K.A. Moly, H.J. Radusch, R. Androsh, S.S. Bhagawan, S. Thomas,
– Cross-linking appears in the temperature region from Nonisothermal crystallisation, melting behavior and wide angle
140 to 180 C, X-ray scattering investigations on linear low density polyethylene
(LLDPE)/ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) blends: effects of compatibi-
– After heating to 200 C including cross-linking the
lisation and dynamic crosslinking, European Polymer Journal 41 (6)
remaining endothermic peak shifted to lower temper- (2005) 1410.
ature giving a hint that this process also has changed [18] D.G. Dikobe, A.S. Luyt, Morphology and properties of polypropylene/
crystal perfection. ethylene vinyl acetate copolymer/wood powder blend composites,
Express Polymer Letters 3 (3) (2009) 190–199.
[19] O. Bianchi, R.V.B. Oliveira, R. Fiorio, J.D.N. Martins, A.J. Zattera, L.B.
Knowledge of the characteristic DMA and DSC curve Canto, Assessment of Avrami, Ozawa and Avrami-Ozawa equations
for determination of EVA crosslinking kinetics from DSC measure-
progressions is of high interest for good incoming control of
ments, Polymer Testing 27 (6) (2008) 722–729 OK.
basic raw material. [20] B. John, K.T. Varughese, Z. Oommen, P. Poetschke, S. Thomas,
Dynamic mechanical behavior of high-density polyethylene/
ethylene vinyl acetate copolymer blends: the effects of the blend
References ratio, reactive compatibilization, and dynamic vulcanization, Journal
of Applied Polymer Science 87 (13) (2003) 2083–2099.
[1] A. El Amrani, A. Mahrane, F.Y. Moussa, Y. Boukennous, Solar module [21] H.A. Khonakdar, U. Wagenknecht, S.H. Jafari, R. Hassler, H. Eslami,
fabrication, International Journal of Photoenergy (2007) Article Dynamic mechanical properties and morphology of polyethylene/
Number: 27610. ethylene vinyl acetate copolymer blends, Advances in Polymer
[2] T. Carlsson, P. Konttinen, U. Malm, P. Lund, Absorption and Technology 23 (4) (2004) 307–315.
desorption of water in glass/ethylene-vinyl-acetate/glass laminates, [22] A.T. Koshy, B. Kuriakose, S. Thomas, S. Varghese, Viscoelastic proper-
Polymer Testing 25 (5) (2006) 615–622. ties of silica-filled natural rubber and ethylene-vinyl acetate copol-
[3] G. Oreski, G.M. Wallner, Evaluation of the aging behavior of ethylene ymer blend, Polymer-Plastics Technology and Engineering 33 (2)
copolymer films for solar applications under accelerated weathering (1994) 149–159.
conditions, Solar Energy 83 (7) (2009) 1040–1047. [23] SOLAR EVAÒ RC02B: http://eu.mitsuichem.com/.
[4] S.I.A. Ayutthaya, J. Wootthikanokkhan, Investigation of the photo- [24] ETIMEXÒ VISTASOLARÒ: http://www.etimex-solar.com/.
degradation behaviors of an ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymer solar [25] Handbook of thermal analysis and calorimetry. in: S.Z.D. Cheng (Ed.),
cell encapsulant and effects of antioxidants on the photostability of Applications to Polymers and Plastics, vol. 3. Elsevier, 2002.
the material, Journal of Applied Polymer Science 107 (6) (2008) [26] J.D. Menczel, R. Bruce Prime, Thermal Analysis of Polymers,
3853–3863. Fundamentals and Applications. John Wiley & Sons, 2009.
[5] K. Agroui, A. Belghachi, G. Collins, J. Farenc, Quality control of EVA [27] S. Vyazovkin, N. Sbirrazzuoli, I. Dranca1, Variation in activation
encapsulant in photovoltaic module process and outdoor exposure, energy of the glass transition for polymers of different dynamic
Desalination 209 (1–3) (2007) 1–9. fragility, Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics 207 (13) (2006)
[6] B. Lee, J.Z. Liu, B. Sun, C.Y. Shen, G.C. Dai, Thermally conductive and 1126–1130.
electrically insulating EVA composite encapsulants for solar photo- [28] G.F. Shan, W. Yang, X.G. Tang, M.B. Yang, B.H. Xie, Q. Fu, Y.W. Mai,
voltaic (PV) cell, Express Polymer Letters 2 (5) (2008) 357–363. Multiple melting behaviour of annealed crystalline polymers,
[7] K.H. Illers, H. Hendus, Schmelzpunkt und Kristallitgröße von aus Polymer Testing 29 (2) (2010) 273–280.
Schmelze und Lösung kristallisiertem Polyäthylen, Die Makromo- [29] H.Y. Cai, P. Li, G. Sui, Y.H. Yu, G. Li, X.P. Yang, S. Ryu, Curing
lekulare Chemie 113 (1967) 1–22. kinetics study of epoxy resin/flexible amine toughness systems by
[8] A. Frick, C. Stern, DSC-Prüfung in der Anwendung. Hanser Wirt- dynamic and isothermal DSC, Thermochimica Acta 473 (1–2)
schaft, 2006. (2008) 101–105.
[9] G.W. Ehrenstein, G. Riedel, P. Trawiel, Thermal Analysis of Plastics: [30] G. Tripathi, D. Srivastava, Cure kinetics of ternary blends of epoxy
Theory and Practice. Hanser Gardner Publications, 2004, ISBN:13: resins studied by nonisothermal DSC data, Journal of Applied
9781569903629. Polymer Science 112 (5) (2009) 3119–3126.