Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TABLE OF CONTENT
1. GENERAL………………………………………………………………………………… 4
2. TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION……………………………………………………….. 6
3. RECOMMENDATION…………………………………………………………………… 8
Attachment – 1: Technical Bid Evaluation for Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO)
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION
FOR CARBON STEEL WELDED
BANGGAI AMMONIA FITTINGS (3RD MTO) Doc no : BAP-00-36-EB-0034-R
PLANT PROJECT Project No : 15-1802
Rev. No.: 0 Page 4 / 9
1. GENERAL
This Technical Bid Evaluation is based on Bid documents for Carbon Steel Welded Fittings
(3rd MTO) material with specification according and/or comply to document Purchasing
Specification for Fitting (Doc No.BAP-00-36-MR-0001-R).
This evaluation is for the bill of quantity below:
Description Definition
1.1 Vendor
The inquiry was issued to 6 vendors with the status below:
1. AMARSON VR
RFQ was sent to vendor on July 1, 2016.
Vendor quotation reference No.: ANNEXURE C-BAP-00-36-BQ-0034-R_0 CS
FITTING WELD, which was sent on July 12, 2016
2. MITRA GALPERTI
RFQ was sent to vendor on July 1, 2016.
Vendor quotation reference No.: OFFER 3rd MTO Fitting-R2 - BAP Project, which
was sent on July 25, 2016.
3. NEOTECH PIPES
RFQ was sent to vendor on July 1, 2016.
Vendor quotation reference No.: QUOTATION - 1094 BAP-00-36-BQ-0034-R_0 CS
FITTING WELD, which was sent on July 14, 2016.
4. RED ENERGY
RFQ was sent to vendor on July 1, 2016.
Vendor quotation reference No.: Z BAP-00-36-BQ-0034-R_0 CS FITTING WELD rev
01, which was sent on July 11, 2016.
5. TK CORP
RFQ was sent to vendor on July 1, 2016.
Vendor quotation reference No.: DSL160713AF - BAP-00-36-BQ-0034-R_0 CS
FITTING WELD, which was sent on July 13, 2016.
6. TOPSTEEL
RFQ was sent to vendor on July 22, 2016.
Vendor quotation reference No.: OFFER FIVE - BAP-00-36-BQ-0034-R_0 CS
FITTING WELD, which was sent on July 27, 2016.
- Material specification
- Type/Design of Fittings
- Wall thickness / Schedule
- End Connection
- Features
- AML (Approved Manufacture List)
- Inspection & Test Procedure
3. Design features and performance of materials (temperature & pressure range)
4. Proven experiences in comparable applications
5. Completeness of quotation and vendor response to request for supplementary information
6. Delivery time & schedule.
In addition, Vendor shall submit their interpretation for the conflict/discrepancy to get the
clarification from Contractor in writing.
2.1 AMARSON VR
Result:
Vendor quoted for all material Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO), and evaluation
have done for all items offered on vendor’s quotation document.
The evaluation result shown as specified on the table of Technical Bid Evaluation for
Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO) in Attachment 1.
According to the technical quotation review and evaluation, they were accepted and met
with the requirement for all offered items.
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION
FOR CARBON STEEL WELDED
BANGGAI AMMONIA FITTINGS (3RD MTO) Doc no : BAP-00-36-EB-0034-R
PLANT PROJECT Project No : 15-1802
Rev. No.: 0 Page 7 / 9
2.5 TK CORPS
Result:
Vendor quoted for all material Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO), and evaluation
have done for all items offered on vendor’s quotation document.
The evaluation result shown as specified on the table of Technical Bid Evaluation for
Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO) in Attachment 1.
According to the technical quotation review and evaluation, they were accepted and met
with the requirement only for all offered items.
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION
FOR CARBON STEEL WELDED
BANGGAI AMMONIA FITTINGS (3RD MTO) Doc no : BAP-00-36-EB-0034-R
PLANT PROJECT Project No : 15-1802
Rev. No.: 0 Page 8 / 9
2.6 TOPSTEEL
Result:
Vendor quoted for some material Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO), and evaluation
have done for all items offered on vendor’s quotation document.
The evaluation result shown as specified on the table of Technical Bid Evaluation for
Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO) in Attachment 1.
According to the technical quotation review and evaluation, they were accepted and met
with the requirement only for all quoted items.
3. RECOMMENDATION
Having meticulously reviewed and evaluated all Bidders proposals and response to
clarifications, CONTRACTOR concludes the following technically acceptable Bidders which
shown below
Attachment – 1: Technical Bid Evaluation for Carbon Steel Welded Fittings (3rd MTO)
Page 1 of 2
ATTACHMENT 1 - TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR CARBON STEEL WELDED FITTINGS - 3RD MTO
SIZE -L SIZE -S
NO CODE NO MATERIAL DESCRIPTION QTY ISBL QTY OSBL QTY UNIT AMARSON VR MITRA GALPERTI NEOTECH PIPES RED ENERGY TK CORP TOPSTEEL
(INCH) (INCH)
1 L6B10514 2"-XS 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 2 2 0 9 9 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
2 L6B10515 3"-STD 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 3 3 12 0 12 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
3 L6B10518 8"-STD 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 8 8 0 2 2 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
4 L6B10510 10"-STD 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 10 10 0 1 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
5 L6B10048 12"-SCH20 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 12 12 0 1 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
6 L6B10511 12"-STD 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 12 12 2 0 2 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
7 L6B10513 16"-STD 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 16 16 1 0 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
8 L6B10021 26"-STD 45 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 26 26 2 0 2 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 T/A
9 L6A10529 2"-XS 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 2 2 52 0 52 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
10 L6A10531 4"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 4 4 8 40 48 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
11 L6A10068 8"-SCH20 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 8 8 0 5 5 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
12 L6A10525 10"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 10 10 0 2 2 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
13 L6A10527 14"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 14 14 0 10 10 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
14 L6A10528 16"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 16 16 0 1 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
15 L6A10057 20"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 20 20 10 6 16 EA T/A T/A T/A T/A DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
16 L6A10058 24"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 24 24 15 0 15 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
17 L6A10023 30"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 30 30 0 1 1 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 T/A
18 L6A10535 30"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9, PWHT 30 30 2 0 2 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 N/Q DECLINE
19 L6A20019 30"-STD 90 ELBOW, A420-WPL6, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 30 30 0 4 4 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 N/Q DECLINE
20 L6A20080 30"-17.48mm 90 ELBOW, A420-WPL6, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9, PWHT 30 30 2 0 2 EA T/A DBA 2-Seam DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 N/Q DECLINE
21 L6A10027 38"-STD 90 ELBOW, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 38 38 0 4 4 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 N/Q DECLINE
22 L6A20028 48"-STD 90 ELBOW, A420-WPL6, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 48 48 0 7 7 EA T/A T/A DBA 2 Seam T/A T/A Portion 1 N/Q DECLINE
23 L6E11366 3"-STD*2"-XS CON. REDUCER, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 3 2 5 0 5 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
24 L6E11368 4"-STD*2"-XS CON. REDUCER, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 4 2 0 2 2 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 DBA M/C down one end from Sch 80/XS
25 L6E11369 4"-STD*3"-STD CON. REDUCER, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 4 3 15 9 24 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
27 L6F11923 8"-STD*4"-STD ECC. REDUCER, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 8 4 1 2 3 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
28 L6F11913 18"-STD*14"-STD ECC. REDUCER, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 18 14 0 1 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A T/A DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
29 L6F11914 20"-STD*12"-STD ECC. REDUCER, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 20 12 1 0 1 EA T/A T/A T/A T/A DBA SMLS, Portion 1 N/Q DECLINE
35 L6D11479 4"-STD*3"-STD RED. TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 4 3 3 9 12 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
Page 2 of 2
ATTACHMENT 1 - TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR CARBON STEEL WELDED FITTINGS - 3RD MTO
SIZE -L SIZE -S
NO CODE NO MATERIAL DESCRIPTION QTY ISBL QTY OSBL QTY UNIT AMARSON VR MITRA GALPERTI NEOTECH PIPES RED ENERGY TK CORP TOPSTEEL
(INCH) (INCH)
36 L6D11482 6"-STD*4"-STD RED. TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 6 4 1 1 2 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
37 L6D11484 8"-STD*6"-STD RED. TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 8 6 1 0 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
38 L6D11468 12"-STD*10"-STD RED. TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 12 10 0 1 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
39 L6C10441 2"*2"-XS TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 2 2 4 6 10 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
40 L6C10442 3"*3"-STD TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 3 3 0 1 1 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
41 L6C10443 4"*4"-STD TEE, A234-WPB, WELD, BW, ASME B16.9 4 4 0 8 8 EA DBA SMLS T/A T/A DBA SMLS DBA SMLS, Portion 1 T/A
TOTAL CARBON STEEL FITTING SMLS - 3rd MTO 156 137 293 EA
ITEM REQUIREMENT AMARSON VR MITRA GALPERTI NEOTECH PIPES RED ENERGY TK CORP TOPSTEEL
DELIVERY TERM FOB COUNTRY OF ORIGIN FOB INDIA FOB KOREA FOB INDIA FOB SINGAPORE EXW KOREA EXW SINGAPORE
AWAJI, BASSI LUIGI, BENKAN, CHERO, DEE, KEON SAE, MEGA, NIPPON JOINT, PETROL RACCORD, PHOCEENNE-GENOYER, SUMIKIN KIKOH, SK BEND, TECHNOFORGE, IML, VIAR, MEGA, LAME, JD, ULMA, HYSCO,
AWAJI, TK BEND, INTERFIT, SK BEND,
BRAND / MANUFACTURE / COUNTRY OF ORIGIN TECTUBI, TK BEND, TUBE PRODUCTS, IML, METALFAR, BOTHWELL, ASK, SBC BEND, VIAR, SCHULZ, BKL, BUHLMANN, CRANE, DAEKYUNG BEND, DELCORTE, DONGJIN, VR ASSOCIATES MEGA, AWAJI, TECHNOFORGE NEOTECH PIPES SEAH, HUSTEEL, KUMSOO, SK, TK, TCC, TK BEND
T BENKAN
ERNE, EZEFLOW, FORITEX, GAM RACCORDI, INTERFIT, ITM, KANZEN, TAYLOR FORGE, WFI SAMYOUNG, BKL, ASK
ACCEPTED WITH NOTE 2 ACCEPTED ACCEPTED WITH NOTE 2, 3 ACCEPTED WITH NOTE 2 ACCEPTED WITH NOTE 1 ACCEPTED WITH NOTE 2
RESULT
(FOR ALL ITEMS) (FOR ALL ITEMS) (EXCEPT FOR ITEMS NO.31-34) (FOR ALL ITEMS) (FOR ALL ITEMS) (FOR ALL QOUTED ITEM)
Note : 1. Delivery time shall be reduced to maximum 8 weeks for all items
2. If the Brand approved by Client
3. for information, this vendor is had bad performance in previous order 2nd MTO fittings packages which caused by poor quality