Professional Documents
Culture Documents
D. D. HoclnrHl
Departmentof Geology,Uniuersityof Ottawa
Ottawa,CanadaKl N 6N5
Abstract
403
404 HOGARTH: THE PYROCHLORE GROUP
SPECIES deflned
by A -atohs
kallpyrochl
vaz K,Sn,Ba,REE, one or more A-atons, other
Pb,Bi,u than Na or Ca, >202 rotal
A-atoms stannonicrollte
Kalipyrochlore (described but not named by Van Ceruranopyrochlore (Lin et al., 1973)is a cerian
W a m b e k e , 1 9 6 5 ,p . 9 - 1 5 ) pyrochlore. The nameshouldbe dropped.
Ba r i op y r o chl or e (name replaces pandaite, q.u.) Chalcolamprile(Flink, 1898; 1901) contains a
Yttropyrochlore (Kupriyanova, unpublished; de- "large number of microscopical inclusions"(Flink,
scribed as obruchevite by Kupriyanova et al., 1964, 1901,p. 163)and apparentlyrepresents an impure
anal.63) pyrochlore.The 10.86percentSiO, may be due to
Ceriopyrochlore (name replaces marignacite, 4.u.) impurities.The nameshouldbe dropped.
Plumbopyrochlore (Skorobogatova et al., 1966) Columbomicrolite (Yllliers, l94l) is an unnecessary
Uranpyrochlore(Holmquist, 1896; name replaces synonym of pyrochlore. The name should be
hatchettolite,q.u.) dropped.
Djalmaite (Guimardes,1939) is a synonymfor
Speciesof the microlite subgroup uranmicrolite. The nameshouldbe dropped.
Microlite (Shepard, 1835) Ellsworthite(Walker and Parsons,1923a)con-
Stannomicrolite(name replacessukulaite, 4.u.) forms to the new definition of uranpyrochlore. The
Bariomicrolite (name replaces rijkeboerite, q.u.) nameshouldbe dropped.
Plumbomicrolite(Hey, 1964,p. 1147;based on Sa- Endeiolite(Flink, l90l) is probablyan impurepy-
f i a n n i k o f fa n d V a n W a m b e k e , l 9 6 l ) rochlore. The few tiny analysed crystals "were
Bismutomicrolite (name replaces westgrenite, 4.u.) scraped"from aegirine. The I L48 percentweightloss
Uranmicrolite (Strunz, 1957; name replacesdjal- in HF and HrSOnwas assumedto be SiOr,essential
maite, q.u.) to the compositionof the mineral.The nameshould
be dropped.
Speciesof the betafite subgroup Fluochlore (Hermann,1850)is an earlysynonymof
Yttobetafte (Kalita, I 959) pyrochlore, not used by later writers. The name
Plumbobetafite (Ganzeev et al., 1969) shouldbe dropped.
Betafite (Lacroix, 19l2b) Haddamite(Shepard,1870) is assumedto be a
synonymof microlite,but analyses are lacking.The
Synonyms, doubtful and discredited names, and species nameshouldbe dropped.
not belonging to the pyrochlore group Hatchettolite(Smith, 1877) is a synonym of
The many synonyms and other names associated uranpyrochlore.The nameshouldbe dropped.
with the pyrochlore group are listed alphabetically Hydrochlore (Hermann,1850)is an earlysynonym
below, and discussedin light of the proposed no- of pyrochlore,not used by later writers. The name
menclature. shouldbe dropped.
Aluminobetafite (Kawai, 1960) may possibly be- Hydropyrochlore(lvanov et al., 1944)is probably
long to the pyrochlore group and betafite subgroup, an alteredmetamictpyrochlore.The nameshould be
with unusual gross substitution of Al and some Sn dropped.
and U. More data are needed. Koppite(Knop, 1875)is a poorly definedvarietyof
Azorpyruhite (Hubbard, 1886)probably belongsto pyrochlore.The type specimenis not available,but
the pyrochlore group, but as quantitative analysesare most specimensfrom the type locality arcpyrochlore
lacking, the mineral cannot be classifiedor renamed (seeVan Wambeke,1964,p.67 for analyses). Jakob's
at this time. analysis(Brandenberger, 1931)shows9.73 percent
Blomstrandile(Lindstrdm, 1874) has beenassumed Fe2O3,and contaminationis suspected. The name
to belong to the pyrochlore group. It is possibly shouldbe dropped.
uranpyrochlore, but adequate analyses are lacking, Marignacite(Weidmannand Lenher, 1907)is a
and new data are desirable. synonym of ceriopyrochlore.The name should be
Calciosamarskire(Ellsworth, 1928)has the compo- dropped.
sition of uranian yttropyrochlore, but the mineral is Mendelyeeuite or mendelejeuite (Vernadskii,1914;
metamict, and proof that it belongsto the pyrochlore 1923)is a synonymof betafite,the accepted analysis
group is lacking. Van Wambeke (1970) suggeststhat (seeChukhrovand Bonshtedt-Kupletskaya, 1967,p.
a somewhat similar metamict mineral from Zaire 175-l'76,anal. 9) conformingto the redefinitionof
may be yttrian uranpyrochlore with a high proportion this species, althoughthe proportion of uraniumis
of Fe3+in the B-positions.Further study seemsdesir- little abovethe necessary minimum.The nameshould
able before deciding the status of this mineral. be dropped.
HOGARTH: THE PYROCHLORE GROUP
Metasimpsonile (Simpson,1938,p. 88; Bowley, Samiresite (Lacroix, l9l2a) has the composition of
1939;Taylor, 1939,p. 93) is a synonymof miuolite. a plumbian uranpyrochlore (seeVan Wambeke, 1970,
The nameshouldbe dropped. p. 138). However, although this mineral is metamict,
Mumbite(Van Wambeke,1970)is a synonymof apparently with octahedral habit, it recrystallizeson
plumbomicrolite.The name should be dropped. heating (Gorzhevskaya et al., 1966; Gorzhevskaya
Neotantalite (Termier,1902)has long beenrecog- a n d S i d o r e n k o , l 9 7 l ) t o a p h a s e ," S " , r e l a t e d t o
nized as eithermicroliteor a closely-related mineral. synthetic UTarOro (Gasperin, 1965) and lesser
The originalanalysis(by Pisani)showedFe and Mn amounts of a pyrochlore phase.The name should be
as the principal l-atoms and the absenceof Ca. dropped.
Reexamination of Termier'stype materialby Gaspe- Scheteligite(Bjlrlykke, 1937)may possibly belong
in (1972\showedthe mineralto be metamictmicro- to the betafite subgroup, with complex substitution
lile with largedeficienciesin the l-ions, which may by Y, Mn, Sb, W, Bi, but more data are needed.
be filled by Ba, Pb, U, and Ca. Fe and Mn were Silicate-wiikite (Strunz, 1957)must be discredited,
presentas impurities.The nameshouldbe dropped. being a mixture; seewiikite.
Niobpyrochlore (Machatschki,1932)is an unneces- Stibiomicrolite(Quenseland Berggren, 1938)must
sary synonym for pyrochlore.The name should be be discredited, being a mixture of microlite, stibio-
dropped. tantalile, and stibnite(seeRos6n and Westgren,1938)
Niobtantalpyrochlore (Machatschki,1932),imply- Sukulaite (Vorma and Siivola, 1967) is a synonym
ing a compositionwith Nb ", Ta, must be renamed for stannomicrolite.The name should be dropped.
eitherpyrochloreor microlite,accordingto the analy- Tangenite(Gagarin and Cuomo, 1949)was a name
sis.The nameshouldbe dropped. presumptuously given to titanium-rich "betaftes"
Nuolaite(Lokka, 1928),a mixture of yttropyro- from Norway (Tangen quarry near Kragerl). Two of
chlore and other niobium oxide mineralsrelatesto the analysescorrespond ro betafte, and one to the
wiikite (q.u.),must be discreditedas a species. titanian equivalent of pyrochlore. Recently W. L.
Obrucheuite (Kalita, 1957)is a namelatershownto Griffin, of the Mineralogisk Museum, Oslo, has
have been given to two differentspecies(Gorzhevs- shown that the specimens analyzed were mixtures
kaya and Sidorenko,1969).One of these,brown (seetitanopyrochlore).The name is discredited.
obruchevite,after heatingto 700oC,crystallizedto Tantalbetafite(Kalita and Bykova, l96l) is a syn-
the samiresile^l phase(4.u.).The other, black ob- onym for betafite.The name should be dropped.
ruchevite,wassubsequently renamedyttropyrochlore Tantalohatchettolite(Villiers, l94l) is a synonym
(Kupriyanova, 1970, unpublished). The Soviet for uranmicrolite. The name should be dropped.
Union's Commissionof New Minerals(KNM) and Tantalo-obrucheuite (van der Veen, 1963), in-
MineralogicalTerminologyhave recommended the tended for the yttrium-rich member of the microlite
nameyttropyrochlorereplacethis type of obrucheuite. group, has not been found.
Pandaite(Jiiger et al., 1959) is a synonymfor Tantalpyrochlore (Machatschki, 1932) is a syn-
bariopyrochlore. The name should be dropped. onym of microlite. The name should be dropped.
Priazouite(Yurk, l94l1, 1956,p. 24), previously Titanbetafite (Ginzburg et al., 1960) is a synonym
regardedasan alteredpyrochlore(Dzhun,1963),has of betafite as redefined above. The name should be
beenshownto belongto the samarskilegroup (Gor- dropped.
zhevskayaand Sidorenko,1974)and must be ex- Titanmicrolite (Strunz, 1966, erroneously ascribed
cludedfrom the pyrochloregroup. to van der Veen, 1963),with Ti ) Ta > Nb, has not
Pyrochlore-microlite (Beuset al., 1962),implying a been found.
compositionwith Nb ^, Ta must be renamedeither Titano-obrucheuite(van der Veen, 1963) is a syn-
pyrochloreor microlite,accordingto the analysis. onym of yttrobetafite, and the name must be dis-
Pyrochlore-wiikile(Strunz,1957),beinga mixture, carded.
must be discredited;seewiikite, below. Titanopyrochlore (Machatschki, 1932) was named
Pyrrhite (Rose, 1839,p. 5621'1842,p. 383-385) as a hypothetical titanian equivalent of pyrochlore.
belongsto thepyrochloregroup,but cannotbe classi- O n e o f t h e a n a l y s e so f B j l r l y k k e ( 1 9 3 1 , a n a l . 3 ) , f r o m
fied becausethe type materialhas not beenanalyzed. the Tangen Quarry near Kragerf , Norway, conforms
The nameshouldbe dropped. to a dominantly calcian member of the betafite sub-
Rijkeboerite (van der Veen,1963)is a synonymfor group. W. L. Griffin (correspondence,April 1974)
bqriomicrolite.The name should be dropped. made a microprobe analysisof Bjlrlykke's specimen
HOGARTH: THE PYROCHLORE GROUP
lorozhd. Redk. Elem. Nauchn.-Issled.Inst. Mineral. Syrya, 10. Levinson,A. A, (1966)A systemof nomenclaturefor rare-earth
168p. (In Russian). minerals. Am. Mineral.,J1, 152-158.
Gorzhevskaya, S.A., G. P. LugovskoiandG. A. Sidorenko ( 1966) Lin, Teh-Sung, Wen-HsingHung and Tse-MinShih (1973)Cer-
Siberian samiresite. Geol. Mestorozhd. Redk. Elem. Vses. uranopyrochlore-a new variety of pyrochlore.Geochimica, l,
Nauchn.-Issled. Inst. Mineral.Syrya,30, 5l-71. (In Russian). 39-45.In Chinese).
- and G. A. Sidorenko(1969) The obrucheviteproblem. LindstrdmG. (1874)Blomstrandit, ett nytt uranmineralfrAnNohl.
TrudyMineral.Muz. Akad. r'r'aakSSSR, 19, 138-145.(In Rus- Geol.Fbren.Fbrh.,2. 162-164.
sian). Lokka, L. (1928)Uber Wiikite. Bull. Comm.gbol.Finlande,82,
(1971)The structuraltype samiresite. Roentgenogr. 68 p.
Mineral.Syrya,8, 49-62.(In Russian). Machatschki,F. (1932)Die Pyrochlor-Romeit-Gruppe. Chem
(1974) Productsof samarskitealteration.Trudy Erde.7. 56-76
Mineral.Muz. Akad. Nauk,SS.SR, 23,72-77. (In Russian). Palache,C., H. Bermanand C. Frondel (1944')Systemof Mineh
Guimardes, C. P. (1939)Djalmaita,um novo mineralradioactivo. alogyof ... Dana,Tthed.,Yol. l, John Wiley and Sons,New
AnnaesAcad. Brasil. Ci?ncias.I I . 347-350. York.
Hermann,R. (1850)Untersuchungen iiberdie ZusammensetzungParker,R. L. and M. Fleischer (1968)Geochemistry of niobium
der Tantalerze. J. Prakt. Chem..50.164-200. and tantalum.U.S. Geol.Sunt. Prof. Pap.,612.
Hey, M. H. (1964)Twenty-thirdlist of new mineral names.Min- Pudovkina.Z. V., L. S. Dubakina,S. I Levedevaand Yu. A.
eral. Mag., 33, 1125-1160. Pyatenko(1974)Study of Brazilianzirkelite.Zap. Vses.Min'
Hogarth, D. D. (1961)A study of pyrochloreand betafrte.Can. eral.Obshch,103,368-372. (In Russian).
Mineral..6.610-633. Quensel,P. and T. Berggren(1938)Mineralsof the Varutriisk
Holmquist,P. J. (1896)Synthetische Studieniiber die Perowskit- pegmatite.XI. The niobate-tantalate group.Geol Fbren.Fdrh.,
und Pyrochlormineralien. Bull. Upsala Uniu., Inst., Geol., 3, 60. 2t6-225
l8l-266. Ramsay,W. (1899)A third list of new mineral names.Mineral.
Hubbard,L. L. (1886)UeberAzor-Pyrrhiteund Zirkon von Laa- M a g . ,1 3 , 3 6 3 - 3 8 1 .
cherSeesowiePyrrhit und Azorit von San Miguel. Verh.Natur- Rose,G. (1839)Beschreibung einigerneuenMineraliendesUrals.
hist. Ver. preuss.Rheinland,Sitz.,43, 214-220. Pogg.Ann. Phys Chem.,48,551-572.
Hussak,E. andG. T. Prior(1895)Lewisiteandzirkelite,two new - (1842) Mineralogische-geognostische Reisenach dem Ural,
Brazilianminerals.Mineral. Mag., I I, 80-88. dem Altai und dem KaspischenMeere, Yol. 2 Verlag Sand-
Ivanov,A. A., I. B. Borovskiiand I. A. Yaroshch(1944)Pyro- erschenBuchhandlung, Berlin.
chlore from the VishnevyeMountains,Urals. Zap. Vses.Min- Ros6n,O. and A. Westgren-(1938) On the structureandcomposi-
eral. Obshch.,73, 56-58.(In Russianwith Englishsummary). tion of mineralsbelonging to the pyrochlore-atopite groupand
J?iger,E., E. Niggli and A. H. van der Veen(1959)A hydrated an X-ray analysisof disintegratedstibiomicrolite.Geol.Fdren.
barium-strontium pyrochlorein a biotiterock from PandaHill, Fbrh.,60, 226-235.
Tanganyika.Mineral. Mag., 32, 10-25. Safiannikoff.A. and L. Van Wambeke(1961)Sur une terme
Kalita,A. P. (1957)Compositionof obruchevite, a hydratedura- plombifdredu groupepyrochlore-micrclite.Bull Soc.fr. Min-
nium-yttrium variety of pyrochlore.Dokl. Akad. Nau&,SSSR, bral. Cristallogr.,84, 382-384.
ll7, l17-120.(In Russian). Shepard,C. U. (1835) Microlite, a new mineral species. Am. J.
- (1959)New data on somemineralsin the Alakurtti Vein Sci, 27, 361-362.
No. l. Trudy Instit. Mineral. Geokhim. Kristallokhim. Redk. - (1870)Unknown mineral(microlite?) in Haddamcolum-
Elem, 2, 164-l'12. (In Russian). bite.Am. J. sci.,50.93-94.
- a1d A. V. Bykova(1961)Tantalumbetafitefrom the La- Simpson,E. S. (1938)Annual Report of the ChemicalBranch.
doga pegmatites.Trudy Inst. Mineral. Geokhim.Kristallokhim. Rep.Dept Mines. l,V.Aust.for 1937,86-96.
Redk.Elemen.,7, 104-107 . (In Russian). Skorobogatova, N. V., G. A. Sidorenko,K. A. Dorofeevaand
Kawai, T. (1960)Chemicalstudieson mineralscontainingrare T. I. Stolyarova(1966) Plumbopyrochlore. Geol. Mestorozhd.
elementsfrom the Far East:No. 54.Betafitefrom former Kaijo, Redk. Elem. Vses.Nauchn.-lssled. Inst. Mineral. Syrya,30,
near Mukden, Manchuria. Nippon Kagaku Zasshi, 81, 84-95.(ln Russian).
1219-1220. (ln Japanese). Smith,J. L. (1977)Examination of the Americanminerals, No. 6.
Knop, A. (1875)Uber "Koppit" von Kaiserstuhl.NeuesJahrb. Am J. Sci.. 13.359-369.
Mineral.,50, 66-69. Strunz, H. (1957)Mineralogische Tabellen,3rd ed. Akademische
Knorring,O. Von and M. E. Mrose(1963)Westgrenite and way- Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig,
- (f 966) MineralogischeTabellen,4thed. AdademischeVer-
landite,two new bismuthmineralsfrom Uganda(abstr.).Geol.
Soc.Am. Spec.Pap.,73, 256-25'1. lagsgesellschaft, Leipzig.
Kupryanova,l. I., M. I. VolkovaandZ. I. Goroshchenko (1964) Taylor, L. E. R, (1939) X-ray studiesof simpsonite. J. Roy. Soc.
Rare earth mineralsin a molybdenitedepositin the European W Aust.,25,93-97.
U.S.S.R.TrudyMineral.Muz. Akad. Narl<SSSR, i,5,123-133. Termier, P. (1902)Sur la neotantalite,espicemin6ral nouvelle.
(ln Russian). Bull. Soc.fr. Minbral., 25, 34-38.
van der Veen, A. H. (1963) A study of pyrochlore.Nederlands
Lacroix,A. (l9l2a) Sur un groupede niobo-tantalites cubiques
(radioactifs)des pegmatitesde Vakinankaratra.Bull. Soc.fr. Geol.Mijnbouwkd.Gen. Verh.,Geol. Ser.,22, 188p.
Minbral., 35,84-92. Van Wambeke,L. (1964)G6ochimiemin6raledescarbonatites du
- (l9l2b) Quelques nouvelles observationssur lesmin€raux Kaiserstuhl.ln Les RochesAlcalinesel les Carbonatitesdu Kai-
uranifiresde la provincede I'Itasy,Madagascar.Bull. Soc.fr. serstuhl. EuratompublicationEUR 1827,d,le,65-91.
Minbral.. 35, 233-235. - (1965)A studyof someniobium-bearing mineralsof the
410 HOGARTH: THE PYROCHLORE GROUP