Professional Documents
Culture Documents
H. Shoukry 2014
H. Shoukry 2014
h i g h l i g h t s
The production of nano-structured industrial waste minerals by ball milling has been investigated.
The ball milling is beneficial for particle size reduction of waste minerals from micro to nano level.
The ball milling result in significant modification in particles morphologies.
The nanostructured minerals improve the mechanical, physical and structural properties of mortar.
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This work investigates the high-energy ball-milling process in order to develop ultra fine nanostructured
Received 8 September 2014 mineral admixtures. Three types of waste byproduct minerals including; spent catalyst (S.C), copper slag
Received in revised form 26 September (BFS) and cement kiln dust (CKD) were milled for 2 and 4 h in high energy planetary ball mill and then
2014
calcined at 750 °C. The prepared materials were characterized for their particle size/morphology by field
Accepted 3 October 2014
Available online 25 October 2014
emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM). X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used for crystallinity stud-
ies and phase analysis. Upon milling, nanostructured particles were obtained with dimensions less than
100 nm. The milling process led to modification of particles morphology and surface texture. XRD pat-
Keywords:
Ball milling
terns indicated that nanostructured materials are found to be more amorphous as compared with the
Surface area fresh (as received) materials. The aim of this study was also directed to investigate the effect of the pre-
Cement mortar pared nanostructured materials on compressive strength and capillary water absorption (sorptivity) of
Compressive strength mortars. For this purpose, blended mortar samples were prepared with partial replacement of cement
Water absorption by different amounts 5%, 10%, 15% and 20% of nanostructured S.C, BFS and CKD. The compressive strength
Microstructure and sorptivity tests were performed at 28 days of curing; the phase composition/decomposition was
studied by (XRD) and microstructure was investigated by (FESEM). Results showed that compressive
strength of nanostructured blended mortar is greater than that of plain mortar, an enhancement of about
33% was observed. The capillary water absorption generally decreases with increasing replacements of
cement by nanostructured materials. A decrease of about 44% was observed at 20% of nanostructured
CKD. The microstructure of blended mortar appeared quite dense and compact with great modifica-
tion/improving for interfacial transition zone (ITZ) between cement paste and aggregate.
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction properties and workability) are, for instance, governed by the par-
ticle size distribution (PSD), but also their properties in hardened
In the construction industry, cement an energy intensive mate- state, such as strength and durability, are affected by the mix grad-
rial, can partially be replaced with mineral admixtures as supple- ing and resulting particle packing [1]. One way to further improve
mentary material in producing cement and concrete composites the packing is to increase the solid size range, e.g. by including par-
for conserving cement, utilizing waste materials, saving the envi- ticles with sizes below 300 nm.
ronment, reducing CO2 emission and improving their performance. Various methods have been implemented to improve cement
The properties of cement mortars and concrete in fresh state (flow paste and concrete properties in the past. The addition of supple-
mentary materials into cement and concrete has been considered
by various researchers all over the world for improving the
⇑ Corresponding author. strength and durability of cement paste, mortar and concrete.
E-mail address: hamadashoukry@yahoo.com (H. Shoukry). These include various supplementary cementing materials, includ-
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2014.10.004
0950-0618/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
K. Al-Jabri, H. Shoukry / Construction and Building Materials 73 (2014) 636–644 637
Seat
Water
a
Fig. 3 shows the morphology and size of the ball milled spent
catalyst as compared with the starting fresh material. The grains
of the as received spent catalyst showed relatively large homoge-
neity in particle size with an average diameter less than 100 lm 100 nm
It was observed also that the SEM analysis was not capable of inter-particle fusion caused due to the high surface energy resulted
detecting a single particle even at higher magnifications while from the mechanical activation/ball milling process.
agglomerates of particles were detected. This is because of the Fig. 4a shows the SEM micrograph of the as received copper
slag. As can be seen, the particles have heterogeneous morpholo-
gies and appear like fractured pieces with distinct and sharp edges.
The average grain size is in the range of 200 lm. SEM micrograph
a
100 µm
1 µm
b
b
1 µm
100 nm
c
c
1 µm
100 nm
(a): Fresh BFS, (b): After 2 hrs milling (a): Fresh CKD, (b): After 2 hrs milling
(c): After 4 hrs milling (c): After 4 hrs milling
Fig. 4. SEM photomicrographs of the starting/fresh and ball milled copper slag Fig. 5. SEM photomicrographs of the starting/fresh and milled cement kiln dust
(BFS). (CKD).
640 K. Al-Jabri, H. Shoukry / Construction and Building Materials 73 (2014) 636–644
of the particles milled for 2 h is shown in Fig. 4b. It indicates the Fig. 5 that the grain size of the as received CKD is in the range of
ultrafine characteristics of the ball milled particles and suggests 10 lm. The grains appeared as a collection/agglomeration of parti-
that the milling process leads to modification of particles morphol- cles with non uniform shapes. After milling the particles had dis-
ogy where the particles appear finer with ill-defined edges which persed and instead more fine particles with great modification in
suggest some amorphous characteristics. Increasing the milling morphology have been determined. Semi spherical clusters were
time actually resulted in decreasing the particle size and increasing identified with dimension less than 400 nm. Increasing the milling
the homogeneity. time to 4 h resulted in minimizing the particle to a large extent
The nano-structured slag particles were achieved due to the ball with the appearance of nano-structured particles with dimension
mill material as seen from Fig. 4b and c. Semi spherical particles in range of 100 nm. At larger magnification it was observed that
were identified. Also the texture of slag has changed from glassy even after milling for 4 h, the particles of CKD were crystalline; this
smooth to irregular and rough surfaces. The outer glassy finish of is shown in Fig. 4c and is further confirmed by XRD analysis.
the fresh slag may have been eroded during ball milling and the
inner crystalline core may have been exposed after ball milling 4.2. Crystallinity and phase analysis (XRD analysis)
for 4 h. The increased surface roughness supports the higher sur-
face energy of ball milled particles. The increased surface rough- The mineralogical phase composition of the spent catalyst, cop-
ness gives the particles great importance when used as partial per slag and cement kiln dust were determined using powder X-
replacement of cement in mortar and concrete industry. Since, ray diffractometry (XRD). Fig. 6 shows the XRD patterns of these
the rough particles will achieve good bonding within the cement minerals after thermo-mechanical activation (milling for 4 h fol-
matrix; this in turn will contribute to the enhancement in mechan- lowed by calcination at 750 °C) as compared with the as received
ical strength and result in improving the microstructure. (fresh) samples.
Fig. 5 shows the morphology and size of the ball milled CKD as The XRD pattern of S.C presented in Fig. 6a showed a broad dif-
compared with the starting fresh material. It can be seen from fuse halo at 2h angle of about 23° which confirms the presence of
Intensity, CPS
2 Theta, °
(a): S.C (b): BFS (c): CKD
Fig. 6. XRD patterns of the starting/fresh and ball milled minerals.
K. Al-Jabri, H. Shoukry / Construction and Building Materials 73 (2014) 636–644 641
amorphous content. The broad diffraction peak at 2h of 23 is typi- Increasing surface area of particles will result in increasing the
cal silica characteristic and is attributed to the absence of an number of surface atoms of particles, which in turn form unsatu-
ordered crystalline structure [22]. The observed sharp peaks repre- rated bonds so that are unstable and tend to react faster i.e. they
senting the few crystalline mineral phases present in the material are highly active. The extreme fineness and the huge surface area
and correspond to a hydrogen aluminum silicate like faujasite, of the nanostructured S.C, BFS and CKD make them very effective
quartz, and kaolinite. BFS was found to be mainly composed of vit- pozzolanic materials and their application in cement and concrete
rified (amorphous) alumina-silicate in addition to a small amount structures will enhance the mechanical strength and improve the
of crystalline minerals, such as quartz, mullite, mica etc. after microstructure.
thermo-mechanical activation, significant peak broadening was
occurred. The peak broadening was caused by the structural disor- 4.4. Compressive strength
der introduced during milling and indicates the higher degree of
amorphisation. BFS was totally converted to amorphous material Fig. 8 shows the variation of compressive strength of cement
with the disappearance of the crystalline phases. The X-ray diffrac- mortar blended with different amounts of nano structured (S.C –
togram of CKD indicating that this mineral is a crystalline material BFS – CKD) at 28 days of curing.
even after thermo-mechanical activation (see Fig. 6c). It is evident that, for the mortar blended with nanostructured
XRD tests were performed to verify that the particle size reduc- (S.C and BFS), the compressive strength increases with increasing
tion alone was not the sole factor in determining if thermo- nano structured materials replacement ratio up to 15% by about
mechanical activation has been occurred. The amount of crystal- 20% and 14% respectively, this is a significant enhancement in
line and amorphous phases in the materials might also change the compressive strength. The reasons for the increase in compres-
due to the milling process. The results showed that for both (S.C sive strength may be due to the high amorphous silica content,
and CKD), the baseline of the XRD curves was approximately the ultra fineness and specific surface area of the nanostructured (S.C
same, but the intensity of peaks in the XRD curves was varied and BFS). Basically, the nanostructured materials enhance the
due to the milling process. The decreased crystalline phases of strength of hardened cement mortar by two mechanisms. The first
the tested materials could be considered as an indication for the mechanism is the packing effect as filler into interstitial spaces
increased reactivity. It was observed that the crystalline peaks of inside the skeleton of hardened microstructure of mortar and thus
all milled materials were lowered when compared to the as increasing its density as well as the strength. The second mecha-
received materials. It can be concluded that the materials having nism is the pozzolanic effect. The thermo-mechanical treatment
the lowest crystalline peaks are the most highly reactive and these of S.C and BFS produced anhydrous alumino-silicate (Al2SiO5)
materials can be applied as partial replacement of cement to which is mainly amorphous material and behaves as a highly reac-
improve the mechanical strength of mortar. Since these minerals tive artificial pozzolan. The reaction of alumino-silicate with free
contain amorphous active silica and alumina, so they are able to lime liberated during cement hydration was led to additional bond
promote the hydration of cement and participate in pozzolanic strength and solid volume; resulting in higher strength of hard-
reaction i.e. chemically convert the lime (calcium hydroxide) liber- ened cement pastes. The pozzolanic reaction between the calcium
ated during cement hydration into calcium silicate hydrate (CSH)
which is the strength responsible phase. S.C. BFS CKD
40
38
4.3. Specific surface area (SSA)
36
34
The specific surface area of the as received and milled materials
as a function of milling time is shown in Fig. 7. As expected, SSA 32
increases with milling time for the three studied waste materials. 30
S.C showed the greatest enhancement of SSA. After 4 h of milling, 28
the rates of increase in SSA for S.C, BFS and CKD (as compared with 26
the as received materials) were about 425%, 419% and 397% respec-
Compressive strength, MPa
24
tively. The significant increase in SSA is attributed to the reduction
22
of grain size due to milling process.
20
0 5 10 15 20
22000
18000
16000
SSA (m2/kg)
14000
12000
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
0 2 4
Milling time (hours) Replacement ratio (%)
Fig. 7. Variations of specific surface area for S.C, BFS and CKD as a function of the Fig. 8. Compressive strength of nanostructured blended mortar at 28 days of
milling time. curing.
642 K. Al-Jabri, H. Shoukry / Construction and Building Materials 73 (2014) 636–644
S.C BFS CKD of cement, can be both physical and chemical [23].
Capillary absorption coefficient mg.cm .sec
1.9
Calcium carbonate influences the hydration of C3S. Limestone
-2
1.8 accelerates and enhances the rate of formation of C-S-H and CH.
1.7 Probably it offers nucleation sites for growth. Calcium carbonate,
also, can form a complex, calcium carbosilicate hydrate, with the
1.6
hydrated products of C3S. During cement hydration, C3A and cal-
1.5 cium sulfate react to form AFt (Aluminate–Ferrite-Trisubstituted
1.4
or Ettringite). Sulfate depletion typically occurs before the C3A
consumption is complete, resulting in the conversion of AFt to
1.3 AFm (Aluminate–Ferrite-Monosubstituted, Monosulfoaluminate,
1.2 or Monosulfate). The presence of calcium carbonate, however,
alters these reactions. First, AFt formation is accelerated in the
1.1
presence of calcium carbonate [24]. Second, the conversion of AFt
1 to AFm is delayed or prevented due to the reaction between C3A
0% 5% 10% 15% 20%
and calcium carbonate to form calciumcarboaluminate.
Replacement ratio ( % )
The formation of calciumcarboaluminate occurs as some of the
Fig. 9. Capillary water absorption of plain and nano structured blended mortar sulfates are replaced by carbonate ions during C3A hydration. As a
with different replacement ratios at 28 days of curing. result, the limestone or CKD can be used for partial substitution of
the gypsum to control the early hydration of C3A.
The quartz (contained in CKD) is inert. The partial replacement
hydroxide and amorphous silica is capable to form supplementary of OPC with CKD may have an impact on cement properties due to
calcium-silicate-hydrate similar in composition and structure to the presence of unreactive raw materials within CKD. Quartz has
those obtained from Portland cement hydration. Nanostructured physical effects on CKD-PC blends due to nucleation and filler
materials can raise the hydrate reaction of cement and produce effects.
more hydration products, which can be observed from the SEM The slow decrease of compressive strength with increasing
pictures. replacements; may be due to agglomeration of nanostructured
Obviously, increasing the replacement ratio over 15% results in particles around cement grains which lead to retard cement hydra-
decreasing the compressive strength to values which are still larger tion. Also, it may be due to the defects generated in dispersion of
than plain mortar (in case of S.C) and less than the plain mortar (in nano particles that causes weak zones.
case of BFS).
In case of nano structured CKD, It is clear that the compressive 4.5. Capillary water absorption (sorptivity)
strength increases with increasing replacement ratio up to 10%. An
enhancement of about 33% relative to plain mortar was observed. The effect of nanostructured (S.C – BFS – CKD) on the capillary
CKD can consist of up to 50% calcium carbonate/limestone (CaCO3), water absorption of cement mortar as a function of the replace-
up to 30% quartz and clays and dehydrated clays. The effects of the ment ratio is shown in Fig. 9. As seen, the water absorption coeffi-
a b
Cement paste
Cement paste
CH crystal
Sand
Sand
c d
(a): Plain (b): Mortar – 15% S.C (c): Mortar – 15% BFS (d): Mortar – 10% CKD
Fig. 10. SEM micrographs for plain and nanostructured modified mortar.
K. Al-Jabri, H. Shoukry / Construction and Building Materials 73 (2014) 636–644 643
cient decreases with increasing the amount of nanostructured structure of the hardened cement mortar containing
materials. A decrease of about 28%, 39% and 44% was observed at nanostructured S.C, BFS and CKD appeared quite dense and com-
20% replacements of nanostructured S.C, BFS and CKD respectively, pact with less voids. Furthermore, large crystals of CH are disap-
this is attributed to the improvement of microstructure. Due to its peared. It may be assumed that, the strengthening effect of nano
ultra fine size, nano particles fill the voids between cement grains particles would be further enhanced in mortar because the nano
and in the interface between aggregate and cement paste; this particles improve not only the cement paste but also the interfacial
resulted in a compact structure and led to the reduction of water transition zone between cement paste and aggregate, which result
mobility inside skeleton. In addition the pozzolanic reaction with in a good bonding and this will enhance the mechanical perfor-
free calcium hydroxide (CH) resulted in the creation of more CSH mance of nanostructured blended cement mortar [27].
which fill the internal capillary pores and make the structure more The nano particles have considerably modified the interfacial
uniform and dense as will be seen from SEM micrographs. Densifi- transition zone and increased the bond between the cement paste
cation of cement matrix results in the immobilization of water and aggregate due to the physical packing effect. Also the pozzola-
inside the bulk paste [25]. The durability of cement and concrete nic activity of the nanostructured waste minerals resulted in the
structures is closely related to the water absorption so the reduc- creation of additional calcium silicate hydrate which gets depos-
tion of water absorption will extend life time of cement based ited in interfacial transition zone.
products and hence durability [26].
4.7. X-ray diffraction
4.6. Microstructure characteristics
Fig. 11 shows the XRD patterns obtained for the plain and nano-
Fig. 10 Shows the SEM micrographs of both plain and nano- structured blended mortar after 28 days of curing. Obviously, the
structured blended mortar at 28 days of curing. SEM analysis was main compounds detected from XRD diffractograms are calcium sil-
performed on the mixes with promising mechanical performance. icate hydrate (C-S-H), calcium hydroxide (CH) and calcium sulfoalu-
The microstructure of the plain mortar displayed a micro gap minate/Ettringite (E) along with Quartz (Q). The intensities of the
between the cement paste and aggregate which is due to the col- peaks representing the hydration products (CSH and CH) in the
lection of CH crystals in the interfacial transition zone. This in turn nano CKD blended mortar are higher than those of plain mortar;
result in a weak bonding and reduces the mechanical strength of this indicates that the nano CKD particles resulted in the accelera-
cement mortar. tion of hydration process and produced more hydrates at the same
Replacement of Portland cement by ultrafine nanostructured time of hydration. Due to the high active silica content of both (S.C
particles was found to influence hydration behavior and led to dif- and BFS); these materials resulted in the consumption of CH phase
ferences in the microstructure of the hardened mortars. The micro- by pozzolanic reaction. The reduction of CH by reaction with the
pozzolana can result in greatly enhanced durability and strength.
CH Q CH
Q The main conclusions that were drawn from the current study
can be summarized as follow:
CH
E E
The high energy planetary ball milling is a beneficial tool for
particle size reduction of spent catalyst, copper slag and cement
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 kiln dust particles from micro to nano level.
Mortar - 15% Nano BFS
The ball milling technique leads to a considerable modification
in particles morphologies.
The replacement of cement by the nanostructured S.C, BFS and
CKD can be considered as helpful in enhancing the compressive
strength of cement mortar and reducing the capillary water
absorption.
Replacement of cement with 20% nanostructured CKD led to a
Intensity
5 10 15
Acknowledgements
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Plain mortar
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 References
2 Theta,°
[1] Hüsken G, Brouwers HJH. A new mix design concept for earth-moist concrete:
Fig. 11. XRD patterns for plain and nanostructured mortar at 28 days of curing. a theoretical and experimental study. Cem Concr Res 2008;38:1246–59.
644 K. Al-Jabri, H. Shoukry / Construction and Building Materials 73 (2014) 636–644
[2] Al-Jabri KS. The use of industrial waste materials and by-products in cement [14] Schmidt M, Amrhein K, Braun T, Glotzbach C, Kamaruddin S, Tanzer R.
production. In: Lackner M, editor. High temperature processes in chemical Nanotechnological improvement of structural materials – impact on material
engineering, May. Vienna: ProcessEng Engineering GmbH; 2010 [chapter 9]. performance and structural design. Cem Concr Compos 2013;36:3–7.
[3] Neville AM. Properties of concrete. 4th ed. England: ELBS with Addison Wesley [15] Meng T, Yu Y, Qian X, Zhan S, Qian K. Effect of nano-TiO2 on the mechanical
Longman; 1996. properties of cement mortar. Contr Build Mater 2012;29:241–5.
[4] Lea’s OI. Chemistry of cement and concrete. 4th ed. London: Arnold; 1998. [16] Chen J, Kou S-c, Poon S-c. Hydration an properties of nono-TiO2 blended
[5] Ge Z, Gao Z. Application of nanotechnology and nanomaterials in construction. cement composites. Cem Concr Compos 2012;34:642–9.
In: Proceedings of the first international conference on construction in [17] Tobon J, Paya J, Borrachero M, Restrepo O. Mineralogical evolution of Portland
developing countries (ICCID), Pakistan; 2008. p. 235–40. cement blended with silica nanoparticles and its effect on mechanical
[6] Sobolev K, Shah SP. Nanotechnology of concrete: recent developments and strength. Contr Build Mater 2012;36:736–42.
future perspectives. SP-254. Detroit: American Concrete Institute; 2008. [18] Said A, Zeidan M, Bassuoni M, Tian Y. Properties of concrete incorporating
[7] Bittnar Z, Bartos PMJ, Nemecek J, Smilauer V, Zeman J, editors. Nanotechnology nano-silica. Contr Build Mater 2012;36:838–44.
in construction: proceedings of the NICOM3 (3rd international symposium on [19] Zhang M-h, Li H. Pore structure and chloride permeability of concrete
nanotechnology in construction), Prague, Czech Republic, Springer-Verlag, containing nano-particles for pavement. Contr Build Mater 2011;25:608–16.
Berlin Heidelberg; 2009. [20] ASTM C109M-07, Standard test method for compressive strength of hydraulic
[8] Scrivener KL. Nanotechnology and cementitious materials. In: Bittnar Z, Bartos cement mortars; 2007.
PMJ, Nemecek J, Smilauer V, Zeman J, editors. Nanotechnology in construction: [21] Bozkurt Nusret, Yazicioglu Salih. Strength and capillary water absorption of
proceedings of the NICOM3 (3rd international symposium on nanotechnology lightweight concrete under different curing condition. Indian J Eng Mater Sci
in construction), Prague, Czech Republic, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg; 2010;17:145–51.
2009. p. 37–42. [22] Byung WJ, Kim CH, Tae GH, Park JB. Characteristics of cement mortar with
[9] Raki L, Beaudoin JJ, Alizadeh R. Nanotechnology applications for sustainable nano-SiO2 particles. Const Build Mater 2007;21:1351–5.
cement-based products. In: Bittnar Z, Bartos PMJ, Nemecek J, Smilauer V, [23] Marku J. The characterization and the utilization of cement kiln dust (CKD) as
Zeman J, editors, Nanotechnology in construction: proceedings of the NICOM3 partial replacement of Portland cement in mortar and concrete production.
(3rd international symposium on nanotechnology in construction), Prague, Zastita Mater 2012;53:broj 4.
Czech Republic, Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg; 2009. p. 120–4. [24] Marku J, Vaso K. The influence of Trietanolamine (TEA) on characteristics of
[10] Sanchez F, Sobolev K. Nanotechnology in concrete – a review. Constr Build fresh and hardened mortars containing limestone powder. Nat Montenegrina
Mater 2010;24:2060–71. (J Sci Popular Sci), Podgorica 2010;9(3):867–81.
[11] Lee J, Mahendra S, Alvarez PJJ. Nanomaterials in the construction industry: a [25] Ramachandran VS. Thermal analysis of cement components hydrated in the
review of their applications and environmental health and safety presence of calcium carbonate. Thermochim Acta 1988;127:385–94.
considerations. ACS Nano 2010;4:3580–90. [26] Bensted J. Some hydration investigations involving Portland cement – effect of
[12] Pacheco-Torgal F, Jalali S. Nanotechnology: advantages and drawbacks in the calcium carbonate substitution of gypsum. World Cem Technol
field of construction and building materials. Contr Build Mater 1980;11(8):395–406.
2011;25:582–90. [27] Liao K, Chang P, Peng Y, Yang C. A study on characteristics of interfacial
[13] Jayapalan AR, Lee BY, Kurtis KE. Can nanotechnology be ‘green’? comparing transition zone in concrete. Cem Concr Res 2004;34:977.
efficacy of nano and microparticles in cenemtitious materials. Cem Concr
Compos 2013;36:16–24.