Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Declaration:
❑ I hold a copy of this assignment if the original is lost or damaged.
❑ I hereby certify that no part of this assignment or product has been copied from any
other student’s work or from any other source except where due acknowledgement
is made in the assignment.
❑ No part of the assignment/product has been written/produced for me by any other
person except where collaboration has been authorised by the subject lecturer/tutor
concerned
❑ I am aware that this work may be reproduced and submitted to plagiarism detection
software programs for the purpose of detecting possible plagiarism (which may
retain a copy on its database for future plagiarism checking)
Signature: ……………………………………………………………………….
Note: An examiner or lecturer/tutor has the right not to mark this assignment if
the above declaration has not been signed)
MAJOR PROJECT
Marshmallow Group
Trần Mỹ Duyên
Vũ Bảo Nam
Principles of Marketing
Introduction
Colgate History
engages in the production, distribution, supply of personal health care products and
toothpaste is considered as the most popular and best-selling product (Hung, 2009).
Since the establishment, Colgate has been acquired more than 7 companies around the
world and expanding business scale across 200 countries. Having joined in Vietnam’s
market in 1996, Colgate acquired DaLan - a well-known toothpaste brand at that time and
then immediately wiped out it to build up Colgate’s own marked toothpaste items (Anh,
2019).
Mission Statement
Since the mission of the company from the very first day of operation, Colgate is
committed to working with passion, dignifying the integrity, honesty, high ethics in any
situations.
Maslow Hierarchy
helps to make dental hygiene. Moreover, dentifrices also give consumers breath fresh in
order to avoid embarrassing and unintended incidents. Due to the values, Colgate
company brings to the consumers, in 2017, “Colgate Palmolive is included in the ten best
Body
After discussing Colgate's brand mission and how they deliver the value to
needs, we will now proceed to analyze how micro and macro factors affect the
Micro factors. Firstly, about micro factors, let’s begin with Company factors. Being
a subsidiary of Colgate-Palmolive, a very large and long-standing company with over 200
years of operation (Colgate Palmolive, n.d.) helps Colgate's Company factors including
top management, finance or operations are now relatively stable. Next, Supplier factor,
thanks to Colgate owning a factory right in Vietnam, they can take advantage of available
resources such as production materials and abundant labor resources in a very effective
way. Coming to the third micro factor - Marketing Intermediaries, there are many
reseller and distribution section; VMLY&R Vietnam in marketing service agencies; and a
lot of banks in the financial intermediaries section. Next is the customer factor, in Vietnam,
there are two main types: consumer market such as households, ordinary consumers;
reseller market includes wholesale channels like Metro, Co.op mart and retail channels
such as convenience stores and grocery stores. Finally, Competitor factors, Colgate is
competing with Close up or P/S in the same toothpaste market. At the same time, Colgate
also has to compete with substitute products such as mouthwash and chewing gum from
Macro factors. Next is macro factors affecting Colgate in Vietnam. The first factor
is Demographic, with the diversity of segments in Vietnam, Colgate has to launch more
than 15 product types to satisfy a lot of different customers (Colgate, 2019). Secondly,
about economic forces, with Vietnam’s market economy developing quite steadily and a
GDP of $ 3,000 a year (Hiếu, 2019), it is quite easy for the majority of people to buy
Colgate products The third is Natural Environment Factors, thanks to the favorable
geographical position and mild weather conditions in Vietnam, Colgate's raw material
supply is always guaranteed, in addition, the transportation and sale of products is quite
activities. Next is the technology factor, the rapid development of technology worldwide
has required Colgate to constantly change and adapt so that their production and
business activities take place optimally and not outdated. Lastly, Political and Legal factor,
in general, the politics in Vietnam is relatively stable and the government has created
many favorable conditions for foreign businesses like Colgate to develop. What Colgate
needs to do now is to comply with the law and solve and eliminate problems of counterfeit
products.
SWOT Table.
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats
● Growing apprehension on
chemicals
Note: Datas for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats from (Bhasin, 2019), (Ghoda,
STDP
Segmentation
- Depending on
purchasing decisions
of parents
-Love using
toothpaste with
different tastes
appearance
- Teeth Rural and urban - Age: 21-30 - Considering more Tend to try
Gum Rural and urban - Age: 31-40 - Looking for good- Potential
- High criteria of
quality and
ingredients.
- Using familiar
life
retired
Targeting. Colgate has been targeting to a range of customers, however, the age
from the twenty-one to forty is the group that this brand mostly focuses on due to the
outstanding demand and products affordability comparing to the other segments. At this
age, “people are at risk of facing many dental problems such as gingivitis that could lead
to periodontal at the older age” (Steven, 2019). Since the sense of personal as well as
home dental protection, the middle-aged consumer demand could be said to be quite high
that they seriously look for the high-quality criteria of ingredients. Especially, by reason of
busy life, instead of trying different brands of toothpaste, people in this age group are
likely to become loyal customers to the brand which offers them the value they are looking
able to attract the consumers by its own marketing differentiation. Owning a “whitening”
attribute with uses Hydrogen Peroxide whitening technology helps this product line to be
Positioning.
As can be seen in the positioning map, Colgate is considered one of the best-quality
established to organize medical research - has found out that Colgate toothpaste helps
“removing 22% plaque, tartar from teeth and gingivitis, 48% decline in bleeding gums and
5% decrease in tooth decay” (Wilson, L. 2016). For example, Colgate Total is the toothpaste
that is approved by both the United States Food and Drug Administration and the American
Dental Association (Verduin, P. 2015). Comparing to the other brand, Colgate quality is a bit
inferior to Sensodyne; in contrast, the price of Colgate toothpaste is still cheaper and
Next are the discussion and analysis of marketing mix, also known as 4Ps
including Product, Place, Price, and Promotion. Additionally, the marketing mix involves
a series of actions or strategies that the company uses to promote its brand or product in
convenience product when consumers can easily find and buy frequently, immediately.
In the analysis, the product will have 3 levels, namely Core customer value, Actual product
and Augmented product, by doing this Colgate can better understand the different levels
of need a customer has for a product (EPM, n,d.). First is the core customer value section,
which includes the most basic needs of consumers when choosing to buy products, thus
the core customer value that Colgate brings within their toothpaste products is to satisfy
the daily dental hygiene needs of customers. Secondly, about the actual product, usually
a product will have many features but there are few core values. Similarly, in Colgate
toothpaste products, there will be many actual products attached like the value of Colgate
brand name which lasts for more than 200 years (Colgate Palmolive, n.d.); many features
such as whitening, prevent tooth decay or fresh smell, etc; and many ways of packaging
products such as small sizes for travel to big sizes for a large family. The final level will
regimens, dental care centers and customer support hotlines printed right on the product
packaging. Moreover, there is also convenient for customers when they can easily find
and buy Colgate products. In addition to 3 levels of product, is the analysis and evaluation
of Colgate's branding strategy. Colgate is currently using line extension strategy which
means they will add new features to their existing products, rather than developing the
new products (Linton, n.d.). For instance, Colgate will launch Colgate Max Fresh green
tea product beside Colgate Max Fresh products existing on the market. Thereby, more
than 15 toothpaste products have been launched in Vietnam (Colgate, 2019) in order to
increase the product variety in here. By using this tactic, Colgate will have many great
advantages such as enhance the ability to meet the variety of customer needs, reduce
production costs, build more relationships with retailers and increase the distance with
their competitors (Marketing Study Guide, n.d.). In contrast, Colgate also faces some
dramatically risks such as confusing consumers and retailers; arises some invisible costs
like image dilution or production complexity; and the risk of increasing more competition
effective way of the distributional channel. The manufacturers would directly distribute the
merchandise to the wholesalers who then continue dispatch these products to the
retailers. And the retailers are the last to offer the items for the consumers. What is more,
according to the data we got from the survey (Appendix B), Colgate toothpaste is widely
grocery stores in rural areas. The wide distribution of Colgate toothpaste is one of the
contributory factors that attract more and more people to consume this product line.
Likewise, in an age of advanced technology, Colgate also gives the customers another
option of online shopping that people could look for Colgate toothpaste through reliable
websites such as Shopee or Lazada. Instead of wasting time going out for buying
products; nowadays, with a single click, people are able to purchase what they desire in
a faster and convenient way (Cornell, n.d). Consequently, by this strategy, Colgate has
advantages in reaching various customers and satisfy them. The robust distribution
system once again shows the popularity of Colgate all over the world in general and in
Vietnam in specific.
Price. The third factor that we analyze in Colgate marketing mix strategy is Price.
When Colgate approach in the Vietnam market in 1995, while equitized domestic
toothpaste companies, they also lowered their price to expeditiously attract a large
number of customers and fasten the process of gaining high market share. As a result,
they are now holding 25% of Vietnam toothpaste market, and is one of the two largest
nowadays in the Vietnam market. Research shows that the Colgate’s toothpaste price in
Vietnam is only ⅓ compared to other countries in Southeast Asia (Nhi & Minh, 2013).
international price of Colgate is quite high for most of Vietnamese, which might be
challenging for Colgate to maintain a high market share with such price, especially when
there are companies that are selling their products with competitive price like Unilever
Lan, Doreen).
Some other price strategies that are used by Colgate are quantity discounts and bundle
toothbrush and 5 lines of mouthwash (Colgate, 2019), Colgate can easily create bundles
that serve different segments at the same time like Family Package, Travel kit, Adult
Sensitive Bundle, etc. Selling in bundles enable Colgate to offer customers a better price,
sell more products and save budgets in distribution and packaging. Moreover, bundles
can be used as a place for selling extra-product, like introducing new products, or getting
rid of inventories.
Promotion. The last marketing mix tool is Promotion. To build good relationships
with customers, not only do companies need to create customer value by developing
good products, selling them with attractive price or making them available to target
customer, but they also have to promote the value to their clients by communicating it
clearly and persuasively (Kotler & Armstrong, 2014). The key value that Colgate delivers
to its customers is the happiness and self-confidence in bright smile. It was showed
consistently in the logo (a white smile on red background), the packaging, and also in
attached their products to the image of dentists giving advice on dental care. This can be
Sensitive. Furthermore, they also created a lasting impression in customers mind with the
raise purchase intention and customers credibility (Daneshvary & Schwer, 2000).
Another remarkable factor in their promotion mix is Colgate Oral Health Month campaign,
Hospital of Odonto-Stomatology, with the goal of raising public awareness of oral health
care. The "Dental Health Month" program takes place with a series of propaganda and
free dental check. These are considered CSR activities, which do not only raise brand
recognition, but also favorable publicity and a good corporate image (Epstein-Reeves,
2012).
The very first issue of Colgate is a misleading advertisement. Colgate was accused to
Derbyshire (2007), the Advertising Standards Authority (UK) claimed that the survey method
was not appropriate to lead to the conclusion that "More than 80% Of Dentists recommend
Colgate". The article has shown some illogical points in Colgate’s survey. First of all, this
survey was conducted by calling telephones to dental professionals, which is not reliable as
we could not confirm the identity of dentists. Next, the survey indicated that each dentist can
choose many different brands. However, the headline makes customers misunderstand that
80 percent of dentists recommend Colgate over other brands and only 20 percent of dentists
recommend other brands. The Colgate’s misleading headline was just one in numerous
cases of deceptive advertising, which has a lot of negative impacts on consumers and the
competitive market. It is obvious that providing consumers with false information is unethical
and illegal that may lead to consumers’ serious health problems. Furthermore, false ads can
advertised products from the market. Specifically, Colgate’s toothpaste products can create
a bias in consumers’ purchase intention as they sound more reliable; and as a result, the
unfair competitive advantage was created within Colgate might force other toothpaste
brands to leave if they cannot find a characteristic that has the same level of reliability.
In the first issue of Colgate, there are two cases that Colgate has to deal with. If Colgate
has clear evidence about the survey, it should public the specific data to prove that its slogan
is reliable. Otherwise, Colgate should quickly replace another slogan before all customers
misleading information. Next, the brand may release a campaign linked to CSR activities or
a much attractive worldwide advertising so as to build customer reliability. The second issue
of Colgate is about the promotion strategy: weak online marketing. In a study conducted
annually by Totally awesome, a pioneer in digital media for children, more than 75 percent
of children from 6 to 14 years old in 7 Asia Pacific countries chose the Internet instead of
television. In Vietnam, the percentage of children who prefer to access the Internet is up to
66% (Brands Vietnam, 2017). However, Colgate has hardly promoted advertisements on
Internet sites like Facebook, Youtube, or Instagram. Although Colgate has an official fan
page, it has not really caught the attention of many people. In details, while Colgate
Facebook fan page has around 100,000 likes, the competitive brand – Closeup – gains up
to 11,500,000 likes. The fact that Colgate has not exploited Internet sites is a remarkable
In the second issue, to basically solve this, Colgate needs to build stronger online
marketing strategies to reach its target customers. Some suggestions are promoting its
ads online websites or social networks, recruiting a young communications team who is
campaigns more efficient, Colgate should increase its coverage degree on the Internet
For example, it can pay for Chau Bui – a hot fashion KOLs on Youtube – to appear on
her review Youtube channel to promote for Colgate White Optic line.
The third issue is the counterfeit Colgate toothpaste. According to Huyen (2015),
Department of Science and Technology cooperated with the Ministry of Public Security
indications that these products contain diethylene glycol instead of fluoride, which may
As can be seen from the third issue – counterfeit toothpaste – it seems unable to
remove all the counterfeit toothpaste on the market. However, there are some ideas to
face it. Colgate has to sign contracts with both reliable offline and online distribution
channels such as supermarket, Tiki, Lazada,…to make sure that these distribution
channels only sell Colgate genuine products and avoid importing fake goods.
Furthermore, Colgate needs government policy and support to guarantee the brand’s
exclusive rights in order to eliminate counterfeit products on the market. Colgate also
needs the main help from customers who directly use the products. Besides providing
software or tips to identify the differences between real and fake toothpaste, Colgate has
to warn consumers about oral diseases by using low-quality toothpaste. For instance,
customers must not trust the 50 percent discount or buy 1 get 1 free campaign because
Conclusion
customer insights and effective marketing mix strategies. However, there are still a lot of
significant issues that Colgate needs to solve in order to develop stronger and take the
References
Anh, T. (2019). US based toothpaste firm suffers $11 million loss in Vietnam.The
11-million-loss-in-vietnam-1547287033518.htm
https://www.marketing91.com/swot-analysis-of-colgate-palmolive/
Brands Vietnam. (2017). Trẻ em Việt Nam ngày càng chuộng lên mạng hơn xem TV.
cang-chuong-len-mang-hon-xem-TV
Cawley, J., Avery, R., & Eisenberg, M. (2013). The Effect of Deceptive Advertising on
Consumption of the Advertised Good and its Substitutes: The Case of Over-the-
https://www.colgate.com.vn/products/toothpaste
us/about/history
business-planning-online-57259.html
Daneshvary, R., & Schwer, R. K. (2000). The association endorsement and consumers'
https://search.proquest.com/docview/220133936?accountid=63189
Derbyshire, D. (2007, January 17). Colgate gets the brush off for 'misleading' ads.
the-brush-off-for-misleading-ads.html
Phương, Đ. (2019). Ông chủ kem đánh răng Dạ Lan: Liên doanh với Colgate là sai lầm
chu-kem-danh-rang-da-lan-lien-doanh-voi-colgate-la-sai-lam-lon-nhat-doi-toi-
3912398.html
https://expertprogrammanagement.com/2018/04/three-product-levels-kotler/
companies-should-embrace-csr/#58176a013495
http://fernfortuniversity.com/term-papers/swot/1433/1351-colgate.php
Geller, M. (2007, June 14). Colgate warns of fake toothpaste in U.S. Retrieved from
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-colgate-fake/colgate-warns-of-fake-
toothpaste-in-u-s-idUSN1441921320070614
https://www.scribd.com/doc/77341765/Colgate-Toothpaste-SWOT Analysis
Hiếu, C. (2019). Thu nhập bình quân người Việt tăng lên 3.000 USD/năm theo cách
viet-tang-len-3000-usdnam-theo-cach-tinh-moi-1111830.html
https://english.thesaigontimes.vn/7493/Colgate-Palmolive-Vietnam-opens-
toothbrush-plant-in-Binh-Duong.html
Huyen, T. (2015). Xử lý hàng trăm vụ vi phạm quyền sở hữu trí tuệ. Retrieved from
http://cand.com.vn/Xa-hoi/Xu-ly-hang-tram-vu-vi-pham-quyen-so-huu-tri-tue-
352544/
Kotler, P., & Armstrong, G. (2014). Principles of Marketing. Pearson Education Limited -
https://yourbusiness.azcentral.com/product-line-extension-strategy-28398.html
from https://www.innismaggiore.com/index.php/blog/differentiation-is-why-we-
care-about-brands/
Marketing Study Guide. (n. d.). Benefits of a product line extension. Retrieved from
https://www.marketingstudyguide.com/benefits-product-line-extension/
MCDougall, A. (2015). Older consumers are generally more brand loyal while millennial
https://www.cosmeticsdesign-europe.com/Article/2015/08/27/Older-consumers-
are-generally-more-brand-loyal-while-millennials-seek-innovation
Money Matters. (n. d.). What are the risks involved in line extensions?. Retrieved from
https://accountlearning.com/what-are-the-risks-involved-in-line-extensions/
Nhi, L., & Minh, T. (2013). Thị trường kem đánh răng: 90 bóp 10. Doanh Nhân Sài Gòn.
rang-90-bop-10-1050788.html
https://www.statista.com/topics/3456/colgate-palmolive/
https://www.medicinenet.com/gum_disease/article.htm
Strauss, K. (2017). The 10 companies with the best CSR reputations in 2017. Forbes .
companies-with-the-best-csr-reputations-in-2017/#2e8871e6546b
The Economic Times. (n. d.). Definition of 'Marketing Mix'. Retrieved from
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/definition/marketing-mix
Verduin, P. (2014) Setting the record straight about Colgate Total toothpaste. Fox
straight-about-colgate-total-toothpaste
colgate-total-toothpaste/
Appendix B: Survey
[Translation]
- Grocery store
- Market
- Supermarket
- Convenience store