Professional Documents
Culture Documents
S
ince Shell developed their bitumen slip layer for piling, marketed under the name of
Bitumen Compound SL, large quantities have been used for piles and buried structures.
Whilst the product has been used primarily on piling where downdrag forces are likely to
develop, it has also been used on buried structures such as concrete culverts under earth
dams, where earth movement could create unacceptable stresses within them.
Despite the detailed and exhaustive tests carried out by Shell during the product development
programme, there still exist in the minds of some engineers nagging doubts as to whether
bitumen slip layers do all that is claimed for them. Bearing in mind the importance of secure
foundations, it is understandable that engineers should seek some independent reassurance on
such a fundamental matter.
Evidence of the effectiveness of this type of application is now available in Technical Note 109
issued by the Construction Industry Research and Information Association (CIRIA), a 56-page
report on the performance of the piled east bridge abutment at Newhaven, Sussex. The
programme of measurements was designed to provide a case history of the behaviour of a
typical foundation with particular reference to load distribution in the piles. It also investigates
the effects of downdrag on the piles caused by load shedding of the consolidated upper
deposits as a result of the embankment load.
Determining the effectiveness of the bitumen slip layer was not one of the primary objectives of
the project; but the results obtained from instrument readings showed that it could be expected
virtually to eliminate downdrag loadings.
When using an appropriate thickness of Bitumen Compound SL, downdrag will normally be
reduced by at least 90% so that even if negative skin friction assumes twice the proportions
anticipated, consequential loading transmitted to the pile will still remain well within the capacity
of the latter. its use, therefore, does in such circumstances constitute a valuable 'insurance
policy".
Page 1 of 12
BITUMEN COMPOUND SL
SLIP LAYER FOR BEARING PILES AND BURIED STRUCTURES
• It must not reduce the effective soil support needed Two grades are available - Standard and Tropical - coveri
to prevent buckling of a pile. most conditions except extreme heat and extreme cold.
After considerable research and trials, a compound was How effective is it?
developed which conformed sufficiently closely to the
range of requirements to be acceptable from both the A later section deals with calculation of loading
practical and technical points of view. transmitted through a layer of Bitumen Compound SL.
As a guild, however, the reduction of downdrag load
Shell showed their confidence in the compound by due to negative skin friction, or other soil movement,
incorporating it in the foundations of the new Shell
Page 2 of 12
when using an appropriate thickness would exceed
90%. However, in order to avoid complicated calculations for
every individual situation, a range of constants (K), which
Downdrag loadings on uncoated surfaces due to soil take into account the flow characteristics of the coating,
movement are difficult it not impossible to predict with have been calculated. These, when incorporated into the
accuracy, a these can in practice considerably exceed appropriate formula, enable a close approximation of the
the anticipated value. By using Bitumen Compound SL as downdrag, or other type of loading transmitted through a
a slip layer, the effect any excess loadings is largely coating of Bitumen Compound SL, to be obtained.
eliminated as the coating would transmit only a small In devising the formula, it has been assumed that there is
percentage of any extra load. In this way, its use 100% bond between the soil and the coating, and
constitutes a valuable "Insurance policy" against t between the coating and the surface to which it is
potentially serious effects of loadings beyond the design applied. This is the worst situation and anything less
limit of the piling. than 100% bond at both faces will result in a reduced
load transmission from the moving soil through the
Practical post-installation evidence of the effectiveness coating to the structure.
Bitumen Compound SL is contained in a report on the
instrumented performance of coated piles supporting a
road bridge abutment at Newhaven, Sussex. Details are
given in C.I.R.I.A. Technical Note No. 109, and a
summary of the relevant part is available from Shell on
request.
Uses
Page 3 of 12
DANGER OF UPTHRUST AND DOWNDRAG ON 6 4 0
PILING CAUSED BY SEASONAL SHRINKING AND
SWELLING OF CLAY NEAR TREE ROOT ZONE EXAMPLE OF CALCULATION
Formula
Using the Standard grade of Bitumen Compound SL on
Stress transmitted through a coating of Bitumen end-bearing piles in a region where the average soil
Compound SL temperature is 10'C, and where a rate of ground
settlement of 25Omm/ year is anticipated:
Anticipated rate of ground
= K x settlement or movement (mm/year) N/ml of • From Table A, K for 100C = 5.0
coating thickness (mm) surface area • A coating thickness of 6mm is assumed.
• The downdrag stress transmitted. Through the coating
To obtain the total load transmitted, the resultant figure is is therefore:
been multiplied by the surface area over which the soil
movement is expected. 5.0 x 250 = 208N/m2
6
Please note that although the settlement (or movement) If the surface area of the pile subject to soil movement
is expressed in terms of mm/year, this may not be the were say, 25m2, the total downdrag load on the coated pile
amount of settlement occurring over 12 months. If for would be 25x208 = 55.2kN
example most of the settlement were expected in the first
6 months, amounting to say 10Omm, this would be It is suggested that a factor of safety of 2 is used to take
entered in the formula as 20Omm/ year i.e. the rate of care of temperature and other variations, so in the above
settlement, expressed in terms of mm/year. example a total downdrag load of say 1OkN would
represent a safe working figure. This, in practical terms,
would be considered negligible.
VALUES FOR CONSTANT K
The downdrag load on uncoated piles is difficult to predict
These are related to the temperature of the coating, i.e. accurately, but in general the reduction in downdrag
the anticipated soil temperature. Soil temperatures in the loading by using an appropriate thickness of Bitumen
U.K. are generally of the order of 10'C. However the Compound SL would exceed 90%.
tables below provide K values for a range of soil
temperatures, applicable to the Standard and Tropical
grades of Bitumen Compound SL respectively.
Page 4 of 12
• Circular steel casings
3. The formula for calculating the anticipated rate of pile • Steel sheet piling
settlement under loading should be regarded as a and is usually applied on site.
guide to performance rather than an accurate
prediction. This is because: It cannot be used on continuous flight auger or similar in
situ piling unless some form of precoated liner can be
• Of necessity loading is carried out over a relatively installed in the shaft prior to concreting. Such a liner
short time and the relationship between load need only be substantial enough to support the coating
transmitted and the time during which it is until concreting has been completed.
transmitted, is not necessarily straight-line.
• Relatively small variations in coating temperature can In situ vertical surfaces
have a significant effect on load transmitted (see
Tables A and B). Although when performing in service Bitumen Compound SL has been successfully applied to
any total load variation from this cause is likely still to in situ vertical surfaces such as concrete walls and
be negligible, it can be wrongly interpreted when columns and on brick walls and piers (e.g. to isolate them
measuring actual values recorded during short-term from externally superimposed loadings).
loading tests. These cannot of course correspond to
the conditions to which the piling will be subjected in A practical technique has been established for this, which
service. consists of "casting' panels of Bitumen Compound SL on
• It is virtually impossible to ensure a precise and the kraft paper, then applying them while still warm to the
uniform coating thickness. As the load transmitted primed surfaces.
through the coating is directly proportional to its
thickness, any variations in uniformity and/or Installation through hard ground
thickness are likely to reflect in the test results.
In most cases, Bitumen Compound SL is required to be
Other structures installed through relatively soft, compressible soils, which
are the ones most likely to create negative skin friction.
Many other situations occur where relative movement In some cases however, the coated piling has to be
between soil and structure creates excessive loadings. installed through denser layers of sand/gravel due to the
In the majority of cases, these loadings can be virtually characteristics of the strata concerned.
eliminated by the use of a slip layer of Bitumen Firmly adhered Bitumen Compound SL provides a tough
Compound SL. Stress transmission calculations are abrasion-resistant coating under hammer-blow loading
made according to the formula previously indicated. times, and when driven through sand of medium density
should suffer little damage except at the leading edges.
The denser the sand or the harder the ground, the
greater is the possibility of damage to the coating and
Suitable piling systems where doubt exists, it is safer to drive test piles and/or
consider alternative methods of installing the piles. The
Bitumen Compound SL can be used with most piling latter might for example consist of preboring using a
systems either as they are, or with appropriate C.F.A. rig and injecting bentonite slurry instead of grout to
modifications. maintain the bore. The coated piles are then installed
through the slurry.
As a hot-melt compound which solidifies by cooling, it Whatever the conditions, however, where coated piles
has to be pre-applied before piling is installed. This can have to be driven, the most important requirement is that
be carried out on such piles as: the Bitumen Compound SL is firmly bonded to the pile
surface. It is always wise to test the adhesion before
• Precast concrete (including "shell' piles) driving the pile.
• H section steel piles
APPLICATION GUIDE
Area to be coated
Condition of surface to be coated
Normally, only that part of the pile upon which negative
friction is anticipated need be coated. CONCRETE
Those parts of a pile which rely primarily upon positive
friction for their bearing capacity should be left Concrete should have cured sufficiently to achieve its
untreated. A distance of about ten times the pile required strength.. Concrete piling should also be
diameter (or width) from the bottom should be left allowed to cure out of the moulds as long as possible
untreated to avoid adverse effects on the pile bearing prior to coating, to permit maximum dissipation of internal
capacity. This is not so important if piles are driven to set moisture. Excess moisture, if trapped, could adversely
on rock, i.e. are purely end-bearing. affect adhesion of the hot-applied Compound.
Page 5 of 12
Surfaces should be clean, dry and free from laitance prior molten Compound and stretched along each edge of the
to priming. top pile face to which it will bond when the Compound
cools. This will act as an edge shutter and the
STEEL Compound can then be poured in one pass up to the full
thickness.
Steel surfaces should be clean, dry and free from any When the coating is firm enough, the rope can be
poorly adhered coating, loose rust or millscale. removed and re-used for the other faces.
Some overspill is inevitable but this is usually largely
It is important that any surface (including primed eliminated after experience in pouring. Some contractors
surfaces) to which Bitumen Compound SL is applied lay siliconesurfaced paper under the piles to collect any
should be dry, as the presence of free moisture could spillage which can easily be removed uncontaminated,
impair adhesion. This includes frosted surfaces and re-used.
which may appear dry but become wet as the hot
Compound instantaneously melts the ice particles. When one face has been completed, piles are rotated
through 900 to treat the next face, repeating the process
When and how to prime for the reminder. Any bare areas at corners (possible if
using the rope shutter techniques) can be filled in
Bitumen Compound SL will bond tenaciously to most afterwards by pouring from a small can.
completely clean dry surfaces without a primer. in
practice, however, such a clinical condition is rarely Paper should be laid on the timber baulk supports to
achieved, so concrete and steel surfaces should always prevent coated faces sticking to the timber when piles are
be primed first with one exception: roated.
To prime steel or concrete surfaces, apply Shell Super • Pour into moulds larger than the pile to give the
Penetration Primer by brush or spray at about 0.2 required coating thickness.
litreS/M2 and allow to dry completely before over-coating. • Pour one face at a time, opposite faces first, then
The primer normally dries in several hours but it is filling remaining faces level, turning the pile for each
probably safer to allow it to dry overnight before applying application.
the Compound. A separate data sheet provides further • Pour and spread on each face. More than one pass
information on Shell Super Penetration Primer. may be needed to build up the required thickness.
Use lowest temperature possible to make Compound
Application of Bitumen Compound SL just spreadable,
Page 6 of 12
Compound. When the top half of the casing has been
coated to the required thickness and has cooled, it is General Information
rotated through 180' to coat the remaining section. The
rope shutter can be removed after coating the first half as HOT WEATHER
the latter will act as a dam for the second operation. In hot weather, coated piles may need to be kept in the
shade to prevent creep of the coating. If this is not
Other techniques such as rotating casings mechanically possible, the coating should be painted with Shell Alubit,
while applying the coating have been used, but it has a bituminous aluminium paint to reflect heat. If
generally been found that they are more costly in the end temperatures are such that, despite precautions,
than the simple pouring technique described. excessive creep of the coating occurs, piles can be
H-SECTION STEEL PILING sprayed with water and/or rotated periodically.
These are generally coated by pouring the faces in Piles should be driven as soon as possible after coating
sequence, using rope shuttering to provide the once the Compound has cooled to ambient temperature
dam/depth gauge. Piles are laid out horizontally and to avoid sagging during prolonged storage.
level on timber baulks as for square section piles.
COLD WEATHER
If they are laid out initially with the webs vertical, the Where weather conditions have resulted in the
pouring sequence would be: temperature of the Bitumen Compound SL coating being
reduced to approximately O'C or below, some cracking of
• Pour top of top flange and top of each lower half the coating may occur during driving. If this results in the
flange, using rope shutters at outside edges of all detachment of significant areas of coating, pre-warming
flanges. of piles about to be driven will normally prevent this.
• Rotate 90' and pour web to required thickness.
• Rotate 90' and pour top of top flange and each half of TRANSPORT
lower flange (using rope shutters). Where coated piles have to be transported, they should
• Rotate 90' and pour remaining face of web. be separated to prevent the coatings sticking together.
If piles are to be transported in hot weather, the coating
Flange edges will still be left largely bare but these can should be painted with Shell Alubit as a precaution
be coated subsequently by pouring from a small can. It against prolonged exposure to heat from the sun which
is not necessary to build up the full thickness on flange may result in excessive creep.
edges, but continuity of coating is desirable at these
points. MINOR DAMAGE
Minor damage to the coating (e.g. from slings or small
IN-SITU PILES scrapes), or localized surface irregularity has no
Application of a slip layer to cast in-situ piling can be significant effect on overall reduction of downdrag. If,
achieved by using a sleeve which forms a permanent however, the coating is completely removed over small
shutter for the appropriate length of pile. Such a sleeve areas it is advisable to fill these in to ensure continuity of
can be of light gauge steel, or fibreboard placed within an coating.
oversize hole or within an oversize casing which is
subsequently withdrawn. The sleeve is coated with SURFACE IRREGULARITY
Bitumen Compound SL before placing. Alternatively a Because of the nature of the Compound and methods of
heavier gauge steel sleeve is coated and driven or application some 'runs" or drips are bound to occur.
placed to the required depth. The pile is constructed Although they may mar an otherwise smooth-looking
within and below it, leaving the sleeve in place and surface, they have no adverse affect on the performance
obviating the need for a temporary casing. of the application.
Page 7 of 12
− Do not attempt to remove Compound from the
skin.
− Immerse the injured part under running cold
water.
− If the Compound completely encircles a finger
or limb, sprit the cold Compound to avoid a
tourniquet effect.
− Obtain medical advice without delay.
• In the case of fire use a dry powder, carbon dioxide
(CO2) or foam extinguisher, sand or earth. Never use
water.
Page 8 of 12
Page 9 of 12
Ref: A.I.M. Claessen, J.J Gelok
Bitumen slip layers for Bearing Piles
Shell Bitumen Review 35, July 1971
The shear in the bitumen layers was measured at regular intervals over a period of about four months after driving.
Figure above gives, for one of the test piles, the shear in the bitumen layer at about 8 mm from the concrete surface
and at different depths below the surface of the soil, as a function of time. In this figure the settlement of the surface is
also represented. From the measurements it appears that, after a short time, the shear of the bitumen layer proceeds
almost linearly with time, i.e. in the circumstances (long loading time) the bitumen practically behaves as a viscous
liquid.
The relationship between the shear in the bitumen layer and the distance to the pile surface is only by approximation a
linear one. In the trial on the KSLA site the shear rate at the surface of the 10-mm thick slip layer was found to be a
factor of about 1.3 greater than the date at 8 mm distance from the pile surface. Using the same factor the shear stress
was calculated at different depths along the slip layer of the pile previously mentioned. Calculating the total shear force
(negative friction) by integrating the shear stress over the total layer surface a value of about 3X104 N, i.e. about 3 tons,
was found.
Page 10 of 12
CONCLUSIONS
Theoretical studies and field trials have demonstrated that negative friction on bearing piles can be reduced to an
acceptable level if the piles are provided with a slip layer of a suitable grade of bitumen approx. 1 cm thick. Such a
bitumen layer can be applied fairly easily. The lower part of the pile, in general 4-6 m from the point, must remain
uncoated in order not to affect the point-bearing capacity of the pile adversely. By using piles provided with a bitumen
slip layer it is possible to reduce the number of piles required by 1 550% or even more, depending on the type of
foundation and the structure of the soil. The additional cost of the bitumen slip layers involved will amount to about
10% of the cost of constructing the pile foundation by conventional methods. Bitumen slip layers can be applied to
other foundation elements subject to negative friction such as shafts, abutments, and sheet piling. They can also be
applied to tunnels and other similar structures.
CONTAINER SIZES
Standard Grade 12.5kg Easy-strip cartons
Tropical Grade 142kg light gauge steel drums
Typical Specification for application of Bitumen Compound SL for Inclusion in a Bill of Quantities:
(b) Steel surfaces should be cleaned free of any loose rust and scale. Concrete must have cured sufficiently to
achieve its required strength and should be clean and free from laitance. Surfaces to be treated must be dry.
(c) (Where priming is required) A priming coat of Shell Super Penetration Primer is to be applied by brush or spray
at about 0.2 litres/m'. The priming coat must be dry before the Bitumen Compound SL is applied.
(d) The slip layer shall consist of Bitumen Compound SL manufactured by Shell Eastern Petroleum (Pte) Ltd. It
shall be heated gently at a temperature not exceeding 180'C until melted, without any localised overheating.
it shall be applied by pouring, or spreading by towel or squeegee, or by casting in moulds, or by a combination of these
methods, whichever is most appropriate to the circumstances. Rotation of circular piles may assist in even distribution.
More than one coat may be required to achieve the necessary thickness. Checks will be made by the Engineer on the
thickness of the completed coating which shall be a minimum of ___________ mm.
(e) Piles should be driven as soon as possible after the coating has cooled to ambient temperature to avoid
sagging during prolonged storage of coated piles.
If coating has to be carried out in wet or other weather conditions which may adversely affect adhesion of the slip layer
or primer, a weather-proof cover shall be erected over the appropriate length of the pile during coating.
Certain precautions may need to be taken for hot or cold weather working or transporting coated piles, and the
recommendations of Shell Eastern Petroleum (Pte) Ltd should be followed where appropriate.
Page 11 of 12
First large commercial application
Following the success of the field trials described in this article the first large-scale commercial contract using Bitumen
slip layers was awarded to the Dutch firm, N.V. Nederiandse Bouw - Maatschappij NBM at the beginning of 1 971 for
driving 2000 foundation piles for Shell Nederiand Chemie plants at Moerdijk. Each pile was treated with a 9-m long
bitumen slip layer, and up to 75 piles were treated per day. The first contract was completed in June and a further
contract for another 3000 piles treated with bitumen slip layers was then placed with NBM.
Page 12 of 12